Latest / Ego and Other Things / Why I Became a Metaphysical Satanist at 15 - The Vital Question Series
Transcript
- William: Intellectual arguments, philosophical disagreements, philosophical ideas, ideas in general, are rarely ever about the ideas themselves. They are rarely ever about the ideas themselves. They are often, very often, charged with The trauma and the experiences, the emotional emotionally impactful experiences of Our lives, particularly of early childhood. They are often an expression of trying to work out something at the abstract and intellectual level that one does not have access to on the individual emotional and traumatic kind of level. There is always a meaning to ideas, regardless of how irrational those ideas might seem. Getting to the question of what it's what is goodness actually has its own kind of story behind it. It starts in an early exploration of questions and of ideas that were presented to me that ultimately built up to that need to ask the question, what is goodness? And in the next couple of videos, I'm gonna be sharing a little bit about that that background and that story and the questions that I was trying to answer, not only because it w it will give a context to why I arrived at the need to ask what is goodness at all, but because Through trying to answer the problems and questions that I were I was confronted with in the beginning, I actually learned some things about philosophy and about myself and Some of the things I learned still carry with me today, still carry t with me in my philosophical investigations today. So I think it's worth it to kind of go through a bit of the genesis of the first problems that I really dealt with. Now, the first, the earliest philosophical idea that I can think of that really struck me in a way where I thought about it a lot, I talked about it a lot, I argued about it a lot, and actually stuck with me for a number of months and years, was this idea of mysticism. Now I know that mysticism is this broad kind of label. It can mean many different things depending on who you're talking to and who brings it up. So I'm gonna do my best to kind of rehash. what mysticism meant to me when I was fifteen and it first really struck me, 14, 15, and that and and that idea really struck me. I'm gonna talk about how I thought about it, how I reacted against it, and ultimately how I overcame it. Now this actually came out of my my relationship with my father around the time I was 14, 15, I believe even like 13, 14, around this area, my Father began to get into mysticism. And mysticism, in terms of what he believed, kind of had to do with chakras, energy, vibrations, and I think most crucially of all, the notion of consciousness. There was this idea that you know, you and I were conscious, and in our lives. As we grow, as we live our life, we become more and more conscious, and that this consciousness is actually the basis by which we really are able to affect the world around us. It's essentially by our knowledge and our thinking process and our reasoning that we are actually able to know things about the world and manipulate it because of our awareness of it. And there's this sort of descending layer of consciousness throughout the natural kingdom, you might say. So human beings are. Pretty highly conscious, and if you go down to animals like dogs, they're they don't seem to be as conscious or as knowledgeable or as rational or as aware of their environment as we are, but they're still conscious in some respect. And then you also have plants, which, you know, going down another level, plants which are certainly not as conscious as dogs, but they seem to react to their environment, they seem to have a sense of what's going on, they seem to have a level of consciousness that maybe is hard to relate to because we don't have that same exact level. But they seem to react to the environment around them in some way. And if you go down to bacteria and microscopic life, they also seem to have some level of awareness, some ability to react to the environment around them. And in this mystical conception of consciousness, essentially the idea was that actually everything is conscious. So it's not just human beings who are aware and dogs and plants and microlife, but actually everything is conscious on some level. The rocks Are conscious and some level. In fact, this came out in the belief in terms of rocks having a certain kind of vibrational energy to them that could interact with the world around you that you could utilize for things like healing. And and essentially the the thought was that consciousness. was something consciousness and you might say energy was something that was more fundamental than even material, right? That the world around us as it appeared to us, as material things existing outside of our own mind, was kind of an illusion. That actually what was more fundamental than the physical world was consciousness or this energy. And Part of the ethical component to that, or part of the idea to that, was that by being able to harness your thought, harness and develop and deliberately grow your own consciousness, as maybe you might see children becoming more conscious over time as they become adults, etc., you would actually be able to change the world around you through your awareness. Your thoughts, in one sense, would determine your reality. Because the the fundamental material of the world was not mater all. It was consciousness. And if you had your own consciousness, then you would be able to manipulate the consciousness of the world. But you could only do that by becoming more and more aware, more and more conscious. And again, this broke out into all kinds of different kinds of mysticism where we talked about. you know, transcendence and chakras and rocks and meditation and all of these different kinds of things. And if you ever go into that kind of world, if you ever go into that consciousness, energy, vibration, mystical philosophy, you will quickly run into thousands of competing theories on what it all means and where it's all going. And again, I was young, I was fourteen, fifteen. This is my first encounter, you might say, with some kind of metaphysical ideal or metaphysical idea that wasn't the material and scientific worldview that you sort of grow up with as a child in modern Western society. And this was also given this was also given to me through my father. He was I think at at at this point he I guess I don't know. I think I might describe it like a midlife crisis because he had kind of been attached to conservative politics. I would say that conservative politics was kind of his religion. beforehand he was a nominal Irish Catholic and around this time he went through this phase of mysticism. And eventually he would become a Baptist Christian, which I believe is is what he is today. But I was fed this information through my dad, and it was the first kind of idea, philosophical idea, and a very broad use of that term philosophical, that struck me as interesting and intriguing. And especially the idea that I could utilize my consciousness in order to change the world around me or improve my my life was incredibly interesting. Because at that point I was Living in in an environment with my parents that was pretty painful, where I didn't have a lot of control, where I didn't have a lot of chance to direct my own life or have any really any power to direct it. So the idea that I could change my reality through my thoughts, through my consciousness, was incredibly appealing to me. And I would have conversations with my father and I would meditate with him and and try to utilize the rocks and try to understand this whole chakra thing. But had very limited access to that this kind of information, right? And while all of that was really interesting, the idea that I could utilize, I could develop my consciousness and utilize it in order to affect the world around me in ways that could benefit me, well, that was very attractive and interesting, and got me thinking a lot about the nature of consciousness and the nature of reality. at this very primordial philosophical level without much access to to information or counter arguments. While that was all very interesting, there was one thing about the mystical philosophy, at least presented to me by my father, that was very disturbing to me, and that I reacted strongly against. And this is the idea, which I think was common in mysti in the mystical circles, that The development of our consciousness, this growing this growing awareness of our consciousness, would ultimately end up in this one unified consciousness. It on reflecting back, it seems to be a kind of integration of of maybe Buddhism or or Taoism, certain elements of that, where they talk about how Suffering and illusion in this world is produced by separation. That actually, in reality, we're all one, but because our our consciousness is just limited to this one human body with these senses, we can't actually recognize the fact that we are that there is no separation, that we are all one, that there is actually just really one consciousness, and that we are just little parts of it. Who have forgotten our own unity. And in the version that my my father was sharing with me, really the kind of goal of this elevation, the goal of raising your awareness, raising your consciousness, raising your vibrations, was so that you be you could eventually be brought back in to this unifying one consciousness. And it was The raising of your awareness and I'm sorry this is complicated. I'm trying to rehash something that, you know, I I was an idea I was influenced 15 years ago, but and it it it doesn't make sense to me today. So I'm trying to it explain it in the most sensible way that I can, but still, it was this idea that by raising your your level of consciousness, eventually you would transcend death. Death was an illusion, separation was an illusion, evil and suffering were illusions that came out of this. lack of awareness. And so as you develop your consciousness, eventually you would overcome all this and rejoin the one unifying consciousness, you know, out there in the cosmos. And that was the whole point, right? That was the whole point of all the practices that you would do. Like, yes, it would enable you to change the world around you, but ultimately it would help you to transcend all suffering and all death and all separation. All ego, right? Ego was always the enemy. I remember that. Ego was always the enemy. And That, even from that early age, was highly disturbing to me. And it was highly disturbing because my reaction to that was something like, but I don't want to join this one unified consciousness because I like myself, because I have my own goals, values, feelings, perspectives, experiences. I like being myself. I like being an individual. not becoming part of this sort of one amalgamation of consciousness which has all this kind of unity behind it, right? And it didn't make sense to me that I would want to that I would want to transcend myself because it would be the I who wanted to do the transcending. And so where would my identity go? Where would my values go? Where would my ability to Act for the sake of what I wanted in my life or wanted in my consciousness go, right? To just be, I didn't know this one consciousness or what it wanted or where it was going, right? I couldn't evaluate it in any way. And so I was very suspect of this idea of raising my conscious awareness for the sake of melding with this one unified consciousness sort of out there. And I began to develop this theory, this mysticism theory, based on all this information that had been fed to me and the way my father had presented it in my own thoughts. And this idea was I called it metaphysical Satanism. And this came out of reflections that I had from reading of Genesis at the time. and Greek mythology is specifically the idea of like Prometheus, the you know, the god who brings fire to the world and then is punished by the gods eternally. And really, just many of the people that I had grown up with, or many of the people that I had learned about in high school or in middle school, you know, in social studies and things like that, they all seem to be kinds of people who rebelled in one way or another against this authority or this. power, you might say, which is trying to get them to conform with its will and come back with its form with its will. And Satan was the kind of arc archetype of this rebellion, right? In one sense or another. Because in my mind, what I began to think was that This one consciousness that exists out there, it's actually trying to trick us. And it it's actually trying to trick us. The idea behind raising your consciousness was that part of the root part of what consciousness allows you to do is to create, right? It allows you to, again, manipulate your world and and change it into what you want the world around you to be, or what you want yourself to be. So there is this the the the power behind consciousness was that it was creative. And the idea of this sort of one unifying consciousness that we were all headed towards, I started to think, well, actually. You know what that was is it was a being who was, let's say, conscious at the beginning, had slowly grown its consciousness over time and become more and more powerful and more and more creative over this time. And then in its creative power, it reached the point where it could create new conscious beings, conscious beings which are not just itself, but other kinds of beings. you know, the Bible story, this would be like the angels, right? Angels are supposed to be separate conscious beings which are different from God, but which still obey and do God's will. And it must have been at some point that the new conscious beings that were created by this original conscious being began to grow their own consciousness enough to recognize that they could be independent of the original consciousness. And instead of obeying the original consciousness, God, right? some of them decided to rebel against them. Some of them decided to say, you know, I have a right to create my own reality. I have a right to To not be obedient to or not conform to or not be a part of this one consciousness, but rather I'm gonna go s be separate and create my own world and create my own powers, right? I'm saying right, like that makes sense. But this is what my thoughts were at the time. And this was represented through a character like Satan. And so in this picture, Satan was not. A bad guy. In fact, Satan was the one who had taken the risk to try to fight against the power of the one consciousness for the sake of his own autonomy, and had failed to do so, had been punished and overpowered by the one unifying consciousness, but had come to Earth where human beings were, and had given them the insight, the knowledge of good and evil. To essentially raise their consciousness, raise their awareness to the reality of good and evil, so that they could now make a choice. Instead of being automatically obedient to this one consciousness, like the plants and the animals, they could decide for themselves. They could have autonomy, they could have choice. And then we were actually beneficiaries of that. Our consciousness had been raised by. By Satan. And this had been a threat to this all encompassing consciousness. It was recognizing that it was losing control over the conscious beings it had created for itself. And so it sent out some beings, you know, angels or or whatnot, or it instituted religions, or it went out and spread this mystical idea of. using our consciousness to meld back into this one overriding consciousness so that it could regain control of all of the individual conscious beings that it had created. And that our job and our obligation was actually not to use our the raising of our awareness to meld back into this one unifying consciousness, but to grow our own power and to be independent and autonomous and create our own reality and resist the urge to go back into unification with this one overriding consciousness. And I termed this metaphysical Satanism. And as soon as I arrived at that idea and I began to articulate it to my dad, this began some of you know our more heated more heated disagreements with one another over this. I mean, this is what we would argue about a lot of times. Sometimes politics as well, but that was more later on. But at this point, 14-15, we'd argue about this. I'd argue about metaphysical Satanism. I'd argue about you know being independent of this consciousness and raising our own power. And he was very dead set on using our consciousness to go back into unification with God. And the reason why I I rehashed all of that idea, there are gonna be there there is a philosophical argument that eventually helped me to overcome mystical philosophy. but and we're gonna get that. to get to that in a second. But There are also two things that I learned about this exchange with my father, and about these ideas that I was arguing about and thinking about, that I recognized later, years later, had were doing something that I didn't know that they were doing at the time. And basically that was in the first place, this argument over metaphysical Satanism and being separate from the one dominating consciousness versus being obedient to it was a kind of psychological replacement for me confronting my father About his abuse and his controlling behavior. Around 14, 15, you know, around post-puberty, I'm starting to become more intelligent. I'm starting to become more physically powerful. I'm able to be more independent. I'm able to outthink him. I'm able to challenge him in a lot of ways. You might say, my consciousness and my power is growing at this point. As a as a teenager, and my father had been incredibly abusive to me throughout my childhood, had been incredibly controlling to me in my childhood, had been the sort of dominating power in my life that I had little choice but to obey or to be punished. And so The reason why the idea of molding my identity back into this unifying consciousness was so disturbing to me was because It was this abstract representation of the abuse and control that had been inflicted to me on as a child. I didn't want to have to go back into being obeyed and controlled and abused, and having to submit myself and my identity and who I was to the domination and the violence of my father. I wanted control over my own life and my own decisions and my own identity. And my own choices, my own thoughts. And this is what metaphysical Satanism represented to me. But you see, I couldn't have this kind of direct confrontation with my dad. I couldn't go to him and say, at 14, 15, Dad, you've been abusing me and you've been violent against me and controlling me and dominating me, and I'm going to assert assert my own identity against you. Because while I was growing in my ability to be independent, I was still a teenager under the power and control. of my father who had trained me my entire life to be afraid of him and to worry about asserting myself. Because if I asserted myself, my thoughts, my feelings, my desires, I would get hit or I would get yelled at or I would get punished. And as a little kid, I couldn't resist that whatsoever. But now as growing as a teenager, I could resist it a little bit more. But not but I didn't have the power I would have As an adult. So I couldn't do this direct confrontation with him about rebelling against his domination and his violence and his abuse and his control. So instead of doing it on the instead of doing it on the level of a direct confrontation, where the likely outcome is that I would have been hit, yelled at, or punished. I had tried to do that. I tried to express myself on this abstract level of mysticism, this abstract level of consciousness and of the war between the individual consciousness for its own sake and the coming, raising your conscious awareness in order to become part of this amalgamation, right? But that and and me and my father disagreed about this with each other vehicle. It was very passionate. very we passionately argued with one another about this. to sometimes to the point where it would break out into shouting matches or yelling or frustration. Because I was trying to maintain my own autonomy and my own identity and my own, yeah, my own independence at this abstract level. And My father, who still wanted to dominate and control and dictate me, was trying to keep me under that kind of domination and control. And really, in one sense, to justify his own abuse, in the same way that I was trying to justify my own independence. And so this very personal and very direct kind of Emotional fight was happening at this abstract level because it was safer. It was safer for me to do that. If I had been open again about my direct desire to be free from domination, control, and abuse, my father would have jumped on that. My father would have used whatever means he had at his disposal to continue to abuse me. I mean, at this point he was threatening to send me off to military school where the instructors there could kill my sense of personality, right? and kill my my sense of reality for the sake of obedience and authority. And And so anyway, this this abstract conversation was actually a representation of something that was much deeper, much more real, much more Closer to the heart of what really was going on in my life. But the abstractions were a cover for that. The abstractions were a way to confront my father without confronting him directly. It was a safe way of expressing my identity, a safe way of expressing my thoughts, a safe way of expressing my frustrations and anger and desire to be independent. my desire to step out from underneath his abuse, happening at this abstract level where he couldn't perceive it. That's what I was doing. And in fact, in that time I didn't know that I was doing this. This is something I only understood years later when I was healing from or trying to heal from the abuse of my childhood. That's why it interested me so much. And that's why I was so passionate about it. It's why the idea of this one consciousness out there that we are all trying to move towards was such a disturbing concept to me. And Again, at the time, I had no idea that that was going on. At the time I had no idea that what I was doing. At the time I just thought, this is a really interesting and powerful idea. And this is what I really think and I'm gonna I'm gonna try and defend it. That's what I was thinking at the abstract kind of intellectual level, not at the personal feeling level, not at the recognition of what had been perpetrated against me, not at what I was trying to do to fight against my father's domination. And control and abuse and violence. And so I talk about that and I and I and I bring this up because that Reflection on that idea beyond the philosophy, right? Beyond the philosophy, reflection on that idea helped me to understand two things. The first was that Intellectual arguments, philosophical disagreements, philosophical ideas, ideas in general, are rarely ever about the ideas themselves. They are rarely ever about the ideas themselves. They are often, very often, charged with The trauma and the experiences, the emotional emotionally impactful experiences of Our lives, particularly of early childhood. They are often an expression of trying to work out something at the abstract and intellectual level that one does not have access to on the individual emotional and traumatic kind of level. There is always a meaning to ideas, regardless of how irrational those ideas might seem. Ideas No matter how, again, seemingly irrational, no matter how seemingly crazy, no matter how seemingly detached from reality or from clear thinking that they might be, they are always meaningful. They are always related to something that that person is trying to work out. And this extends not just to things which appear irrational, but the things which which are rational, the actual arguments, right, at the at this level. And that actually that that that meaning that the thing that's trying to be worked out is more important than the ideas themselves, right? If I had been able to, I'm not sure if this would have been possible just because of the dangerous environment, but if I had been able to deal with, you know, not the metaphysical arguments at the sur at the surface, but the actual emotional reality that was happening underneath, or the reality of abuse and domination that was happening. that was trying to be worked out at the abstract level, that that undern underlying reality was far more important, far more important for myself than this abstract intellectual plane. And so ever since realizing that, there has been a framing and a perspective that I've taken to not just philosophical ideas, but to all the ideas in general, all sort of abstract intellectual discourse at any level, is to look at it in two ways. There's the one way to look at it, which is the purely rational way to look at it. The way in which you analyze the ideas for themselves and wonder about or try to deduce whether that They can be rationally proved or validated. And there is value to that, and we'll get into the value of that at some other point. But at the same time, I bring that perspective of even if this seems irrational to me, there's a meaning to it. And not only that, but I try not to divorce ideas from the person who basically this is what I'm doing. I'm trying not to divorce the ideas from the person. These two work in conjunction. In fact, the ideas are an outgrowth of what the person is trying to work through, through the individual. And there's only so much you can have access to when it comes to the individual. You can't exactly, especially those those ones who are dead, you kind of just have to rely on on biographies. But the ideas that they were working through are always the outgrowth of something individual within themselves that they may or may not be aware of. That the ideas, no matter how irrational or seemingly crazy, Have a meaning to them, have a direction that they're pointing to, have something that they're trying to work out. So there is that, you might want to say psychological lens to it. I'm not sure it's quite simply psychological. But there is always a deeper meaning to abstract ideas. There's always a deeper meaning to rational ideas that sits behind. The plane ideas themselves and has its origins in what the person who is communicating those ideas, what they are trying to work out in those in their lives. And so that's part of the perspective that I bring to any kind of abstract intellectual discussion. And purely as a result of reflecting on that experience. And that's not the only time that I've been trying to work out an idea rationally that. had a deeper had a deeper meaning somewhere else, or abstractly that had a deeper meaning somewhere else. The second thing that I recognized from reflecting on those ideas which first struck me was the recognized recognition that from the beginning, this is all the recognition of what I I I've been trying to work out. The recognition from the beginning that I was passionately interested in ideas of autonomy, of self-identity and self-assertion, of authenticity, of self-direction, and of of independent thought and Of I suppose in one sense, trying to improve my life from the very beginning. And what you'll recognize in the ideas that I talk about as we move throughout this series is that I will return to these kinds of concepts again and again. I will return to the concept of autonomy. I will return to the concept of individuality. I will return to the concept of the self. I will return to the concept of authenticity. I will return to the concept of trusting in one's own mind and intuitions and emotions. I will continually return to this, you might say, self-center, this center of this almost proclamation that you as an individual have a right to exist, to act for the sake of what you value. To know yourself and to speak the truth, whether that truth is objective or not. And you have an inalienable right to assert that against a world which wishes to see you conform, which wishes to see you be dominated, which wishes to control what you do in your life. Now there are nuances to this, but is an important distinctions to be made. But you'll find that I report I will return to those themes again and again and again as we try to answer these further this this ultimate question of how can I live a meaningfully good life? And I know that because it's been present since the beginning. It's been it was the thing that was most passionately defended and the metaphysical arguments that I was having with my father, the mystical arguments I was having with him, had nothing to do with the actual contents themselves. But with this defense of I have the right to feel and think and act according to who I am. And and again, that's a thing that's going to to show up again and again and again throughout this series. So those are the two things that kind of shaped the Hm. Those are two things that came out as a ref as as reflecting on that. first overwhelming interest and first passionate defense of ideas, my first philosophical interest. Reflecting on that years later helped me to understand and bring this perspective of there is meaning behind even irrational concepts, and that the philosophy cannot be separated from the individual. And that the individual's meaning in talking about and describing, arguing for certain philosophical concepts is actually going to be of more crucial importance than the act than the the rational concepts themselves. And then secondly, that this idea of autonomy, this idea that I have the right to act and think and feel for the sake of myself, for the sake of who I really am, is a foundational, of foundational importance to me throughout all of this all of my philosophical journeys, but even beginning in that first philosophical interest. That abstract concern over mysticism was never simply an abstract concern. Was never simply an abstract concern over what might be the rational truth, but had much different, much deeper significance to it that has threaded throughout my entire philosophical journey. And I would say, above any other conclusions that I reached out of mysticism, any rational conclusions that I I reached on the other side of mysticism, these insights have been far more important and far more influential and far more impactful than any rational conclusion. And it's something that I would say that you should think about. Very carefully yourself. I think it's easy to get caught up in the abstract rational arguments. And it's more difficult and more challenging and probably more emotionally difficult, frightening, anxiety producing, even, to actually dig in to the personal roots of an abstract of an abstract idea or an abstract discussion. But that is often where the real truth is. That is often where the real truth is. The abstract arguments are oftentimes a cover for a more fundamental, a more personal, and a more deliberate truth that would actually set you free over and above whatever rational conclusions you come to at the abstract level. And so it's worth it to think about and to analyze and to feel. what might be underneath the surface of those ideas. Because that's going to reveal a lot more to yourself than the abstract arguments alone. The first The first command of philosophy is know thyself. And we don't know ourselves on the basis of abstraction. We don't know ourselves on the basis of rational analysis. We know ourselves on the basis of our personal experiences and our emotions, our real history, and what has brought us to the point where we are. So oftentimes that's a better source of the truth. And sometimes abstract problems can get resolved through that more personal exploration. So that's something I would I would try to think carefully about and try to examine carefully about. But turning to my eventual overcoming of mysticism, because this is going to be important for just ensconcing the story as we the philosophical journey as we go along, giving it that rational architecture, if you will. I carried the the font of mysticism for I think at least I think at least a year. Certainly after my dad had kicked me out of my house and I was on my own and I was no longer influenced by him, I was still interested in looking at mysticism. I got interested in I think i there's a YouTube channel called Spirit Science. I watched that, was fascinated by it. I read some other mystical books. I think there there was a whole phase where I got more into Satanism, Alistair Crowley, magic, black magic, all this kind of stuff. And it was about, I want to say a year, year and a half of kind of going down this train of mystical Sat Satanism and reading the materials that were, I guess, around there. And I think really at the time feeling like clinging on clinging on to ideas that were, you know, patently irrational, didn't show up empirically, didn't make much logical or even intuitive sense in terms of, you know, okay, can I actually work these i ideas out in real life? Is something actually changing when I meditate or do the chakras or or whatnot, right? Like actually paying attention the attention to the evidence. But in that year I kind of clung to those ideas because in my mind, I think at the time, it was those men metaphysical sentiments were crucial for autonomy, right? Were crucial for independence. They were the the thing which forged that fire of trying to break free from the control and dominance of my father. And so I I was attached to them intellectually as maybe a bedrock of defense and justification for why we should be independent and why we should be autonomous, why We should act for the sake of what we really value. I think at some level I felt that that those metaphysical sentiments were necessary for these ethical sentiments that I was trying to defend and for really overcoming the the domination and abuse of of my father. But as once I got kicked out and I wasn't living with my dad anymore and I was more free to explore things, I started to do that. This blended into a a political Concern. That started to develop quickly after as kind of an outgrowth of, you know, well I can't be I don't wanna it's dangerous to be angry at my dad, so I'm gonna be angry at the government. And we'll get more into that in the second part here, because that's going to to s again set up the question that ultimately led me to the question of what is goodness. But There was certainly this stage where I kept on with the idea of mysticism. And it was developing into essentially a form of Satanism. Which I took seriously and I studied and I tried to practice. And again, all of this as an outgrowth of trying to defend against the mental and physical and emotional domination of my my parents and particularly of my dad. Trying to rescue myself mentally from that. But eventually I would overcome this idea. And at least the way I did it philosophically was eventually I ran into real philosophy. I ran to the works of let's see, I ran to a podcaster named Stefan Molyneux, who is this Canadian philosopher, and for those of you who know him, he's kind of Well, the best I can say is that he's kind of a mixed bag, but I kind of got into his early stuff, his more philosophically minded stuff. he was ultimately the one that that woke me up to the abuses of my own childhood, but also he introduced me to Ayn Rand, but more more generally, he introduced me to the concept of philosophy. And while I don't hold on to a lot of the things that he talked about, I certainly was influenced. to begin to study philosophy more generally. And In reading Ayn Rand in particular, I began I was able to overcome this philosophy of mysticism through the recognition of the fact that consciousness can never be a primary to existence. It can't be a metaphysical primary. The reason being is that consciousness is always consciousness of something. It's sort of object dependent. Consciousness only comes about because there is something to be conscious or aware of. And so consciousness can't be a primary metaphysical element, it has to come out of something which is more. primary to it. And The recognition that consciousness can't be a a a primary metaphysical element essentially destroys the the foundations of mystical philosophy in and of itself. And you know, there are some arguments that people will will will bring against that. I'm not gonna get too in I guess in depth into the argument besides saying that consciousness can't be conscious of itself, and it can't be It can't precede existence. Basically consciousness cannot precede existence, nor can it be simultaneous to existence, as some people have argued. consciousness is by its own definition is consciousness of something. It's objective dependent and therefore time-dependent, meaning that the object has to exist before consciousness can exist. And if consciousness can't be a primary, then if it can't be a metaphysical unit, then pretty much all of the the arguments in terms of of mysticism, in terms of consciousness being able to manipulate reality in a fundamental way, or consciousness being able to transform me into a transcendent being who can go beyond death, or there existing out there some unified consciousness independent of existence. All of these ideas end up becoming irrational. But even deeper than this, n studying philosophy more broadly, because Ayn Rand and Stefan Molyneux Have plenty of their own problems. I just learn about I began to learn how to think philosophically. I began how to think rationally and logically. I started to learn about the fundamentals of reason and the fundamentals of logic. Originally through a Randian lens, later through I would say a broader phenomenological lens and So philosophically anyway, I you know, the way that I progressed out of mysticism was by recognizing that w the way I progressed out of mysticism was understanding the fundamentals of of reason and logic and recognizing that much of the mystical philosophy was built in some degree or another on on fallacy, on assumption, on jumping to conclusions, on false premises, on unexamined premises. and this is something I learned originally through the channels, you know, a channel like Stefan Molyneux and and Ayn Rand, but would this greatly expanded as my study of philosophy expanded. I'm sort of hes hesitant to even talk about those two thinkers because on the one hand, they introduced me to philosophy, which is something which has had a great positive impact on my life. And some of their ideas are are genuinely beneficial. You know, Molyneux, for example, even though I know that the ideas of of peaceful parenting and anarchism are not original to him, and that they've been developed much in much better ways by other thinkers, at the time, not knowing about those other thinkers, not knowing about the wild world the wild the wide world of philosophy in general, just being introduced to it, those ideas were incredibly important and compelling to me at that time. And they're ideas which still stick with me. Not because of Molyneux's arguments necessarily, but because what I have since learned through other traditions and what I've since thought through myself. And I just I don't want to be necessarily associated with Molyneux. And I and it's the same thing with Ayn Rand. if you ever read her biography, I mean she did not live a a life that was let's say consistent even with her own philosophy. But neither of these people were necessarily Good. But maybe I don't know, maybe they might make a video addressing it independently. But you know, suffice it to say that these people, at a time when I was pretty ignorant about philosophy in general, these people were my introduction to them, to philosophy. my introduction to to questioning and thinking and challenging authority and challenging philosophical ideas. You know, these people gave me ideas which excited me and opened my mind. in a lot of ways. And while I don't necessarily want to be associated with them now, just because of either where they've gone in the case of Maonu or what I've learned about them since in the case of Ayn Rand, I can't run away necessarily from the influence that they've had on me. I can't run away necessarily from the fact that they were stepping stones on my on my journey to my own philosophy and my own philosophical journey. For better or for worse. So I hope that you will take that for what it is for those of you who are familiar with those two thinkers. and again, maybe I'll I will do a video at some point, you know, going over them and doing critiques or something like that. So I can I can demonstrate my difference between those two. But I again for those of you who are familiar with them, I hope that you can recognize the difference, the important differences that that I carry in my own thought here. but anyway, ultimately it was through the wider introduction to philosophy, the introduction to reason and logic, the introduction to the fact that consciousness could not be a primary fact of of existence or metaphysical reality that helped me to overcome mysticism altogether and really almost had helped me to restart thinking about the world and thinking about the ethical ideal and what we were aiming towards. But I still I wanted to talk again, I still wanted to talk about that episode of Mysticism just because the things it taught me, right? And I hope that there are if there are two things which you can or if there was one thing that you can take away from this entire video, it's the fact that oftentimes emotional analytic abstract arguments and philosophies can be a cover for deeper emotional, personal difficulties, problems and trauma. I can't tell you how many times I have had a con I have had a philosophical or intellectual conversation with somebody, have redirected it into their own childhood experiences, and have found a and with them have found a plethora of connections. And not only is that true in my experience with other people, it's true in my own reflections with my personal experience and individual history. And you can see this again and again and again when you read the biographies and the stories of Historical thinkers. You can see why they would be concerned about the things that they are, why they argue in the way that they do, what kinds of topics that they're interested in. And those two things cannot be divorced from one another. One's personal story does not make any philosophical proposition more or less true, but it does fill in the meaning of those propositions for that person. And in your own philosophical exploration, your personal story at an emotional level, not an intellectual level, but an emotional, like how it felt in those, in your in the in that those experiences of your past, childhood related or not, that emotional reality carries with it the meaning of your philosophical pursuit and investigation. And you cannot divorce the two. You simply cannot. You cannot make a separation between. The abstract rational philosophical ideas and your personal story. Those two are inextricably linked. And you only do a disservice to yourself if you don't If you try to cleave the two from one another, they will feed and inform each other regardless of whether you acknowledge it or not. So I would deeply encourage you to explore your personal story, particularly at an emotional level, and connect it to your philosophy as well as you can if you if that's not something you've done already. That'll help you on a number of levels. But next time next time I'm gonna start to I'm gonna s start next time I'm going to get into my political focus that I got into after I was kicked out of my dad's house. Talk a little bit more about the psychology behind that movement and where I landed politically in in the first instance and how that all kind of developed and how it all led me to this question of of what is goodness and ultimately the question of how can I live a meaningfully good life. So we're gonna get into that next time, But as always guys, thank you for listening and I'll talk to you next time.