Latest / Deep Dive / The Competence Curse: How Being the Best Employee Can Destroy Your Career
Transcript
- 0:00So what if being incredibly competent at your job like being
- 0:05the person everyone relies on, the one who always delivers?
- 0:08What if that is actually the most dangerous thing you can do
- 0:10for your career? Oh wow.
- 0:12I mean, it's a terrifying thought, mostly because it
- 0:15completely up ends. You know, the basic social
- 0:18contract we're all taught from day one.
- 0:20Right the whole work hard, do a good job and you'll be rewarded
- 0:23thing. Exactly.
- 0:24Just flips that entirely on its head, yeah.
- 0:26It really does. Well, welcome to the deep dive.
- 0:28Today we are unpacking the total breakdown of that exact
- 0:32psychological contract of hard work.
- 0:34We're going to explore how modern ambition has essentially
- 0:37been well weaponized. Yeah, and to do this, we're
- 0:40pulling together a really compelling stack of sources.
- 0:42We are. We've got a recent highly
- 0:44debated Sky News Australia interview with Rizlan Kogan.
- 0:48He's the CEO of kogan.com, and we're combining that with some
- 0:52really raw audio pieces on modern corporate pressure
- 0:55cookers and the hidden traps of workplace competence.
- 1:00Before we really get into the weeds here though, I do want to
- 1:02set a quick ground rule for our decision.
- 1:04For sure, good call. Because we are going to be
- 1:05touching on some pretty intense shifts in national political
- 1:09polling, immigration policy, tax structures, all of that today.
- 1:14And just to be absolutely clear, we are not taking a political
- 1:17stance here. Right.
- 1:18No endorsements of any viewpoints, left or right.
- 1:21Strictly acting as your guides through the data.
- 1:24We just want to break down the underlying mechanics of what's
- 1:26happening and understand how these workplace pressures are
- 1:29translating into, well, massive societal shifts.
- 1:32Exactly. We're just here to figure out
- 1:34how the engine works and the road map for today.
- 1:37It takes us from a tragic failure inside a university HR
- 1:40department right into a generational clash over the
- 1:43definition of the word hustle. And then, finally, to the
- 1:46explosion of all these pressures at the national ballot box.
- 1:49Right. So let's start with the human
- 1:51cost, because to understand the macroeconomics of all this, we
- 1:54really have to look at the reality on the ground.
- 1:56We we need to talk about Brian Stronach.
- 1:59Yeah, Brian's story is the well, it's the devastating anchor for
- 2:03this entire phenomenon. It really is.
- 2:05He was a 61 year old HR advisor at the University of New
- 2:08England, and if you look at how his colleagues and his family
- 2:11described him, he was just the quintessential reliable worker.
- 2:15Like the ultimate company man. Exactly.
- 2:17Unassuming, deeply smart, incredibly dedicated, he was the
- 2:22guy quietly holding the Fort while everyone else took the
- 2:25credit, you know? But then this massive structural
- 2:29shift happens. The university brings in a new
- 2:31vice chancellor, Bridget Haywood, and she initiates this
- 2:34$20 million restructuring, which is huge, right?
- 2:37And that translates to 200 redundancies. 200 people are
- 2:41suddenly just gone. Now, common sense tells you that
- 2:45if you cut 200 people, you should probably also be cutting
- 2:47the work those 200 people did. Right.
- 2:49But that never happens, does it? Never.
- 2:51No. The daily operational
- 2:52requirements of a massive institution, they don't just
- 2:55evaporate because some executive updated a spreadsheet.
- 2:58The work remains. Yeah.
- 3:00And what happens in these modern restructures is that the excess
- 3:03load is just silently, systematically dumped onto the
- 3:07survivors. Right, people like Brian.
- 3:09Exactly. He suddenly finds himself
- 3:12absorbing the responsibilities of two, sometimes three,
- 3:15different roles. He was working until 1:00 AM
- 3:18just to keep the basic administrative lights on.
- 3:22I was thinking about this dynamic and I keep coming back
- 3:24to this idea of like the competence curse.
- 3:27No, the competence curse I like. That yeah, it's like, OK, think
- 3:30of it like you become the load bearing wall in a house that is
- 3:34actively crumbling. OK, Management sees that you can
- 3:37hold the weight, so they never promote you and they certainly
- 3:39never relieve you. They just keep piling more and
- 3:42more of the roof onto your shoulders until you fracture.
- 3:45Because hiring new people to replace the ones they fired is
- 3:48expensive. Exactly.
- 3:50But exploiting your ingrained sense of duty?
- 3:54That doesn't cost them a single cent.
- 3:56That is a perfect way to visualize it, and what's so
- 3:59insidious is that it's rarely just the sheer volume of work
- 4:02that breaks people. It's the psychological
- 4:04environment that wraps around. It.
- 4:05Oh, absolutely. Like while Brian was visibly
- 4:08drowning under the workload of three people, his supervisors
- 4:11were constantly moving the goal posts.
- 4:14He was dealing with management condescendingly calling him big
- 4:17fella while totally dismissing his requests for support.
- 4:21God, that's just gross. And the trigger, the specific
- 4:25event that pushed him into a crisis, It's almost hard to
- 4:28comprehend because it was so minor.
- 4:31It was an impossibly small administrative oversight.
- 4:34He forgot to record a Zoom meeting about a routine staff
- 4:37complaint. Which I mean, anyone could do
- 4:39that, right? But this wasn't a mistake he
- 4:42made that week. It was an oversight from six
- 4:44months prior. Six months wait.
- 4:45Really. Yes, half a year ago.
- 4:47Literally anyone could make that mistake on a Tuesday afternoon,
- 4:51let alone someone managing the workload of an entire gutted
- 4:54department. But because of this hyper
- 4:55punitive environment, he just spiraled into an absolute panic.
- 4:59He genuinely believed he was going to be held personally
- 5:02liable and sued over this missing recording.
- 5:04So he tries to pull the ripcord, he attempts to resign just to
- 5:08save his own health, and then HR pulls a move that that is
- 5:11frankly shocking. They refused his resignation.
- 5:14How does an employer even do that?
- 5:16You can't just force someone to keep working.
- 5:18Well, they use bureaucratic delay tactics, right?
- 5:20Yeah. Instead of just accepting his
- 5:22notice and letting him leave, they dragged out the process.
- 5:25Unbelievable. Questioning the terms,
- 5:28scheduling unnecessary review meetings, just keeping him
- 5:31psychologically trapped in the maze.
- 5:33So he finally goes to his own doctor, gets prescribed
- 5:37antidepressants and receives A2 week sick leave certificate just
- 5:41to physically get out of the building.
- 5:43Right. But tragically, very shortly
- 5:46after receiving that certificate, Brian took his own
- 5:48life. It is absolutely harrowing and
- 5:51the aftermath really exposes the structural failures here.
- 5:54His family spent 4 grueling years fighting for some kind of
- 5:57accountability. Yeah, Safe Work NSW, the actual
- 6:00government regulatory body. They investigated the university
- 6:03for two full years and walked away with 0 prosecutions.
- 6:06Zero, which meant the family had to completely bypass the
- 6:09standard regulators and take the fight to the Personal Injury
- 6:12Commission. And they finally secured an
- 6:14$849,300 settlement. Which is massive.
- 6:19It is, and through that legal pressure they forced the
- 6:23University of New England to formally admit liability for his
- 6:26death. It established a massive legal
- 6:29precedent, but obviously the cost to his family is
- 6:33incalculable. Yeah, completely.
- 6:35And this is where we really have to zoom out, because the reality
- 6:38we're untacking today is that Brian's story isn't just a rogue
- 6:41incident in one badly managed department, is it?
- 6:44Not at all. This environment is an
- 6:46engineered feature of modern white collar work.
- 6:49Yeah, Professor Maureen Dollard recently conducted a landmark
- 6:52study on this exact issue. She surveyed 11,000 staff
- 6:56members across 42 Australian universities.
- 7:00Wow. And the metrics are staggering.
- 7:01Right. Oh, they're terrible. 80% of
- 7:03staff reported suffering from substantial emotional
- 7:06exhaustion. 80. Percent and seven out of 10
- 7:08explicitly stated that their management prioritizes
- 7:11productivity over psychological health.
- 7:13Which is wild because universities are traditionally
- 7:15marketed as these. You know, progressive Ivy
- 7:18covered sanctuaries of learning. Right, but the data shows
- 7:21they're effectively 3 times worse than the average workplace
- 7:24for psychological hazards. And that toxicity, it isn't just
- 7:28an accident of middle management.
- 7:29It goes all the way to the top. Look at the highly publicized
- 7:33ordeal of Doctor Liz Allen at the Australian National
- 7:36University. Oh yes, she faced relentless
- 7:39bullying, was falsely accused of leaking internal information.
- 7:44And during one confrontation, she was physically blocked from
- 7:47leaving a room by the chancellor, who happened to be
- 7:49Julie Bishop, the former foreign minister.
- 7:52Right. And to add this completely
- 7:53bizarre layer of gaslighting to the situation, Bishop reportedly
- 7:57offered her a hug. Well, actively blocking her
- 8:00exit. I mean, you can't make this up.
- 8:02It pushed Doctor Allen to the absolute block.
- 8:04It eventually took a formal Senate inquiry led by David
- 8:07Pocock to expose the dysfunction and force Bishop, along with
- 8:10five council members, to resign. Yeah, analysts often describe
- 8:14these modern corporate and academic environments as adult
- 8:17daycares where workplace psychopaths just thrive.
- 8:21Adult daycare. And the truly alarming part is
- 8:24how companies actively select for this dynamic.
- 8:26They heavily utilize psychometric tests during the
- 8:29hiring process. Right.
- 8:30Those weird personality quizzes you have to take before an
- 8:33interview. I've always hated those.
- 8:34Exactly. But they aren't looking for the
- 8:36most balanced, healthy, well-rounded individual.
- 8:41They're looking for specific psychological vulnerabilities.
- 8:44Wait, really? They want you to be vulnerable.
- 8:46Yes, they want candidates who index high unconscientiousness,
- 8:51meaning they work extremely hard, but also high on
- 8:55neuroticism. Meaning they have a deep
- 8:57internal fear of failure. Precisely.
- 9:00If an employer can hire someone whose entire self worth is tied
- 9:03to their professional output, that employee will overwork
- 9:07themselves without management ever having to explicitly ask.
- 9:10OK, let me pause you there because I want to challenge how
- 9:13some of these HR mechanisms actually function in the real
- 9:16world. Think about performance
- 9:17improvement plans or Pi PS. Or the dreaded PAP.
- 9:20Right corporate HR. Our departments always market
- 9:23Pips as the supportive, collaborative tool to help a
- 9:26struggling employee get back on track.
- 9:28Sure, on paper. But if management is actively
- 9:30looking for vulnerable people to just ring dry, how do Pips fit
- 9:34into that? Are companies actually trying to
- 9:36improve performance, or is this just a cynical legal trap?
- 9:40It is largely a legal and financial mechanism.
- 9:43Think about it. If a company simply wants to
- 9:45downsize, doing a round of standard layoffs is expensive.
- 9:49Yeah, they have to pay severance.
- 9:51Right severance and it can trigger regulatory or union
- 9:54scrutiny. But if they place an employee on
- 9:57APIP, they can set key performance indicators that look
- 10:00objective on paper but are mathematically impossible to
- 10:04achieve in the given time frame. So.
- 10:05They engineer a failure. Precisely when the employee
- 10:08inevitably fails to meet those impossible metrics, the company
- 10:12now has a documented paper trail of quote UN quote incompetence
- 10:16so they can fire the person for cause, avoiding severance
- 10:19payouts and protecting themselves from wrongful
- 10:21termination suits. Or even better for the company's
- 10:24bottom line, the sheer stress of the PIP forces the employee to
- 10:28self select out and quit just to save their own sanity.
- 10:31Exactly, It's an intentional degradation of mental health to
- 10:35protect a budget line item. And we see major consulting
- 10:38firms operating on this exact model, deliberately burning
- 10:42through fresh graduates in two or three years before replacing
- 10:45them. But here's the structural
- 10:47problem with that model. If you're intentionally burning
- 10:50through your workforce that fast and actively pushing your
- 10:54established workers out through weaponized pips, you
- 10:57mathematically require a limitless, cheap supply of
- 11:00replacement labor. Which brings us to the
- 11:03demographic and cultural shift. This insatiable corporate hunger
- 11:07for fresh labor has sparked a massive generational debate over
- 11:10what it actually means means to hustle.
- 11:13Right, we have two very distinct playbooks clashing here.
- 11:16Let's look at the 1980s migrant playbook first.
- 11:19In that Sky News interview, Rizlan Kogan talks about his
- 11:22parents arriving from Belarus in 1989.
- 11:24Yeah, landing with $90.00 in their pockets.
- 11:26Exactly, and his core point is that they came seeking a system
- 11:29where raw hard work and calculated risk taking were
- 11:32fairly rewarded. They weren't looking to run
- 11:34scams or get on welfare. They operated from a mindset of
- 11:37deep scarcity. And that era had a very specific
- 11:41blueprint for success. The older generation of migrants
- 11:45and really the working class of that time generally, they built
- 11:48their lives by taking on multiple physical jobs.
- 11:52They treated debt like a disease to be avoided at all costs.
- 11:55They built wealth slowly, strictly on merit and delayed
- 11:59gratification. There are countless stories from
- 12:02that era of people working three jobs to buy a $375,000 asset
- 12:07outright in cash by the time they were 35.
- 12:09Which sounds like absolute mythology to anyone trying to
- 12:12buy a house today. Doesn't it?
- 12:13But then you contrast that 1980s blueprint with the new era
- 12:17playbook people arriving and entering the workforce from the
- 12:202010's onwards. They aren't arriving to work
- 12:22factory lines. They have global corporate
- 12:24experience. Yeah, they prioritize aggressive
- 12:27networking and navigating complex office politics.
- 12:30And most importantly, their relationship with debt is
- 12:32completely inverted. Yes, the new strategy relies
- 12:36heavily on massive leverage. Instead of saving cash for 20
- 12:39years, the new playbook is to borrow heavily, acquire multiple
- 12:42properties and then charge market rate rents to their own
- 12:45newly arrived peers to service the debt.
- 12:48It feels like watching someone who painstakingly beat a video
- 12:52game on the hardest difficulty setting, only to see a new
- 12:55player walk in, enter a cheat code, and skip straight to the
- 12:59final boss. That's a really good way to put
- 13:00it. The older generation looks at
- 13:02the massive debt in the aggressive office politics and
- 13:05feels like they're decades of genuine grueling sacrifice are
- 13:09being invalidated. But on the flip side, the new
- 13:12generation looks at the old three job cash only grind and
- 13:15just sees stubborn, unnecessary suffering.
- 13:19I mean, why grind your physical health into dust when you can
- 13:22leverage a bank loan and network your way to the top?
- 13:24Exactly. But we also have to recognize
- 13:26that the macroeconomic environment itself has
- 13:28completely changed. The older generation could save
- 13:31cash because assets were cheaper relative to wages and interest
- 13:35rates actually rewarded savers. Today, relying purely on savings
- 13:40will leave you permanently locked out of the housing
- 13:42market. You'll never catch up.
- 13:44Right. The new generation is highly
- 13:46leveraged because the modern financial system practically
- 13:49demands leverage to build wealth.
- 13:51They aren't necessarily cheating.
- 13:53They're playing a fundamentally different game.
- 13:55But the friction happens when employers take this new, highly
- 13:59leveraged, desperate energy and weaponize it against the rest of
- 14:03the workforce. That is the squeeze on the
- 14:04ground. Employers look at newer arrivals
- 14:07who might be carrying massive debt or who are highly dependent
- 14:11on employer sponsored visas and they see a workforce willing to
- 14:14accept longer hours for significantly lower pay and.
- 14:18Management brands this desperation as hunger and
- 14:21ambition. Exactly.
- 14:23And what happens when an established worker, someone who
- 14:25has been in the industry for 20 years who knows their worth,
- 14:28refuses to accept that new lower standard management slaps a
- 14:32label on them? Suddenly drawing a boundary
- 14:34makes you complacent or entitled.
- 14:36Employers frame it as a character flaw, but established
- 14:40workers aren't slacking off. They are trying to maintain the
- 14:43baseline dignity of their profession.
- 14:46Yeah, they're refusing to participate in a race to the
- 14:49bottom. They earned their labor rights
- 14:51and their wage expectations through decades of collective
- 14:55and individual effort. So if you're listening to this
- 14:58right now and you've recently felt like your workload is
- 15:01doubling every year but your paycheck barely moves, this is
- 15:04the exact mechanism driving that feeling.
- 15:06You weren't imagining it, no. Love at all?
- 15:08You are being forced to compete in a system that explicitly
- 15:11rewards a willingness to be exploded over quiet, steady
- 15:14competence. The entire architecture of the
- 15:17modern workplace has been redesigned to squeeze more
- 15:19output from fewer people. And when you squeeze people that
- 15:22tightly at work, when their wages stagnate, their stress
- 15:26skyrockets, and their local communities are transformed by
- 15:29hyperleveraged property markets that price them out of their own
- 15:32neighborhoods, that pressure cannot be contained within the
- 15:35walls of an office. Right, it has to go somewhere.
- 15:37It inevitably boils over into the broader macro economy and
- 15:41straight into national politics. We are seeing that explosion
- 15:43happen in real time. Let's look at the data from the
- 15:46Institute of Public Affairs from late 2020. 578% of people now
- 15:51classify housing as a full blown national crisis.
- 15:55And 71% of the entire population wants a complete pause on
- 15:59migration until local infrastructure can catch up to
- 16:02the demand. What is really telling is that
- 16:05this isn't just an older generational sentiment. 74% of
- 16:0918 to 24 year olds agree with that pause.
- 16:12That's huge. And 77% of respondents believe
- 16:15the current rate of population growth is actively dividing the
- 16:18country. That economic anger is creating
- 16:21an absolute earthquake at the ballot box.
- 16:23If you look at the tracking polls from Roy Morgan and News
- 16:25poll in mid 2026, something historically unprecedented has
- 16:29happened. The.
- 16:30One Nation numbers. Yeah, the populist right wing
- 16:33One Nation party is leading the primary vote at 29.5%.
- 16:37They've overtaken both the traditional major parties.
- 16:39Labour is sitting at 26% and the Coalition is down to 17.5%.
- 16:44It's wild. And furthermore, immigration and
- 16:47population growth has overtaken the economy and climate change
- 16:51to become the absolute top voting issue for nearly 1/4 of
- 16:54the electorate. It is a massive realignment of
- 16:57the political landscape. But I want to ask you about the
- 16:59root cause of this realignment, because it's very easy for
- 17:02pundits to look at those polls numbers and claim that the
- 17:04population is simply experiencing A spontaneous
- 17:07ideological shift. But when we synthesize
- 17:11everything we've talked about today, from the broken corporate
- 17:14HR practices to the localized wage suppression, is this really
- 17:18an ideological shift? Or is this just a massive
- 17:21structural panic from a workforce watching their actual
- 17:25standard of living decline? When we look at the data
- 17:27surrounding these debates, the synthesis points heavily towards
- 17:30structural panic. Voters aren't suddenly waking up
- 17:33with entirely new core philosophies, they're reacting
- 17:36to the collapse of that psychological contract we
- 17:38discussed at the start of the show.
- 17:39The unwritten rule was always if you were competent.
- 17:43If you work hard, you will be secure.
- 17:45And now competence gets you a fatal workload, and hard work
- 17:49barely pays the rent. Exactly.
- 17:51People feel fundamentally dispossessed.
- 17:54They are watching their per capita GDP drop.
- 17:56They're locked out of housing in the cities they grew up in,
- 17:58while simultaneously being told by corporate management that
- 18:01they just aren't hungry enough. It's madding.
- 18:03So they're pulling the emergency brake at the ballot box because
- 18:06they are demanding relief from a system that is squeezing them
- 18:10from every conceivable angle. So let's trace the full arc of
- 18:13what we've unpacked today. We started with a devastating
- 18:17localized consequences of the competence curse, how a highly
- 18:21reliable, deeply dedicated university worker was pushed to
- 18:25the absolute brink by a bureaucratic machine that
- 18:28prioritized budget restructures over human life.
- 18:31And from there, we examined how that machine operates on a macro
- 18:34level, using psychometric testing to find vulnerable
- 18:37workers and weaponizing performance improvement plans to
- 18:40legally maneuver around labor protections.
- 18:42Then we looked at the generational clash over debt
- 18:44leverage and the very definition of hard work, and how
- 18:47corporations exploit the desperation of newer arrivals to
- 18:50drive down wages and label established workers as entitled.
- 18:54And finally, we connected those workplace pressures directly to
- 18:58the current historic political upheaval, because the micro
- 19:01tragedy inside the HR department and the macro rebellion at the
- 19:04ballot box are ultimately symptoms of the exact same
- 19:07broken economic engine. Which leaves me with a final
- 19:10thought. It's not explicitly stated in
- 19:13the research, but it feels like the natural, almost inevitable
- 19:17conclusion to everything we've discussed today.
- 19:19OK. What is it?
- 19:20Well, if being highly competent at your job is a curse that
- 19:24simply earns you the workload of three people until you break,
- 19:28and if institutional loyalty is eventually rewarded with a
- 19:31mathematically impossible PIP, what does the future of
- 19:35day-to-day survival in the modern workplace actually look
- 19:38like? That is the defining question
- 19:40for the modern workforce right now.
- 19:42Are we entering an era where strategic incompetence becomes
- 19:45the norm? Strategic incompetence.
- 19:47I like that, right? We're purposefully performing
- 19:49just adequately enough to fly under the radar.
- 19:52Never volunteering for extra tasks and deliberately hiding
- 19:55your true capacity is no longer seen as laziness, but rather as
- 20:00the ultimate survival tactic. Wow.
- 20:02If being the load bearing wall eventually gets you crushed,
- 20:06maybe the absolute smartest thing you can do for your career
- 20:11and your life is to pretend you don't know how to hold up the
- 20:14ceiling. It forces us to completely
- 20:16redefine what a successful career actually looks like.
- 20:19It really does. Well, thank you for joining us
- 20:21on this deep dive. Keep asking the tough questions,
- 20:23keep looking closely at the structures around you, and we'll
- 20:26catch you next time.