Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Beyond the Battery: Two Radical Motor Designs Are Quietly Rewriting the Future of EVs
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the deep Dive. OK.
- 0:13So whenever we talk about electric vehicles, right, it
- 0:15feels like 99% of the conversation is batteries?
- 0:18Always batteries range, charging speed, capacity.
- 0:21Exactly how big, how far, how fast?
- 0:24But today, we're going to deliberately ignore the battery
- 0:28for a bit. We're diving into something
- 0:30else, maybe the unsung hero that's really pushing EVs
- 0:35forward into a second generation, the electric motor
- 0:38itself. Really is the unsung hero gets
- 0:40overlooked constantly. So our mission today really is
- 0:43to unpack how some pretty radical innovations in motor
- 0:46design are promising these huge, almost unbelievable jumps in
- 0:50power efficiency and maybe down the line, affordability too.
- 0:54Yeah, absolutely. We're looking at two really
- 0:56disruptive designs, kind of opposites in a way.
- 0:58There's the axial flux motor that's all about extreme power
- 1:01density. Power in a small package.
- 1:03And then there's the dual rotor motor, which is engineered
- 1:05completely differently, focusing on just raw efficiency.
- 1:08And this is such a critical area for you listening because you
- 1:11know, for years, like you said, it was all battery capacity that
- 1:14dictated everything, right? But now we're seeing real
- 1:17technological differences in the motor itself, and that's
- 1:21becoming the next big fight, the next competitive battlefield for
- 1:24car makers. So the battery stores the juice.
- 1:27But the motor delivers the performance and trust me, that
- 1:29performance is about to get a serious shake up.
- 1:32We've got some genuinely wild numbers here, specific metrics
- 1:36that just change what you think a motor can weigh, what it can
- 1:39do. OK, let's unpack this and maybe
- 1:42start with something that's, well, surprisingly old.
- 1:45Yeah, almost 200 years old. Conceptually, we're starting
- 1:48with the axial flux motor and specifically the breakthroughs
- 1:52made famous by a UK company called Yesa.
- 1:55You might have heard Mercedes actually acquired them recently.
- 1:57Right. Why SA?
- 1:59And yet most source has pointed this out too.
- 2:01The basic idea goes back to the 1820s, which sounds fascinating
- 2:05historically, but it makes you wonder.
- 2:06Why now? Exactly, If the concept's been
- 2:08around that long, why is it only now showing up in like super
- 2:12high performance cars? Well, it was viable in concept,
- 2:15but putting it into practice, that was the hard part.
- 2:18It really comes down to the motors geometry, which is sort
- 2:20of key to understanding all of this.
- 2:22So most E VS driving around today, your Tesla, your Leaf,
- 2:26whatever, they use what's called a radial flux motor.
- 2:29Imagine, like a coffee can, a cylinder.
- 2:32Right, this sort of barrel shaped motor you picture long
- 2:35and round. Exactly, and the magnetic fields
- 2:38flow radially outwards from the center towards the end of the
- 2:42can. No axial flux, totally different
- 2:45shape. Instead of a cylinder, think
- 2:47flat like a pancake or maybe a disc spinning.
- 2:50A pancake motor got it right. And the magnetic flux, the force
- 2:54it travels parallel to the motors axle, the axis of
- 2:57rotation, hence the name axial. OK.
- 2:59So flat versus round? Why was the flat 1 so hard to
- 3:02build back then? It just needed an incredible
- 3:04precision. The alignment has to be perfect
- 3:07and managing the heat in that flat shape is really tricky.
- 3:1019th century engineering just, well, it wasn't up to it.
- 3:13So Yasa's work, this revival, it's purely a modern thing then,
- 3:17driven by new tech. Precisely.
- 3:19It only really became feasible economically and structurally
- 3:23because of huge leaps in computational modeling, letting
- 3:26engineers simulate and perfect the design before building
- 3:29anything. Computers.
- 3:31Plus brand new magnetic materials that are way more
- 3:34powerful and super precise automated manufacturing.
- 3:37It just makes it a viable and really powerful alternative to
- 3:41those radial motors because fundamentally it's so much
- 3:45smaller for the same power output.
- 3:46And critically, this isn't just like lab stuff, right?
- 3:49This is proven tech. It's already in some seriously
- 3:53demanding cars. Oh yeah, we're talking hyper
- 3:55cars, the Koenigsegrigera, the Ferrari SF90 Striadale.
- 3:58They use YASA axial flux motors. That real world use proves it's
- 4:03tough enough. It works and the strategic move
- 4:05here is massive. Mercedes didn't just partner
- 4:08with Rios so they bought them in 2021, right?
- 4:10I. Remember that.
- 4:10They bought them specifically to lock down this axial flux tech
- 4:14for their future high performance cars, their AMG
- 4:16lineup. It's a huge bet that power
- 4:18density making things smaller and lighter but more powerful is
- 4:21the future for performance EVs. OK, this is where it gets really
- 4:25interesting for me. The actual numbers.
- 4:28Let's talk about the physical reality of Yass's latest
- 4:31prototype. This stuff kind of blows my
- 4:33mind. Yeah, when you look at the
- 4:35specs, it does make you rethink what's possible with, you know,
- 4:38heavy engineering components. So we are talking about a motor
- 4:41that weighs just 12.7 kilograms tiny.
- 4:44Like seriously, that's less than a checked bag on a plane,
- 4:48probably less than a packed carry on for a lot of people.
- 4:51And yet Desana Dyno recorded a peak power, OK, short term peak,
- 4:57but still 750 kilowatts. Which is what, over 1000
- 5:01horsepower? Over 1000 horsepower from
- 5:03something you could practically pick up and carry.
- 5:05And getting that kind of power from such a small light unit,
- 5:09that leads us right to the killer metric here, power
- 5:12density. Yeah.
- 5:12Tell us about that the power to weight ratio.
- 5:14It's just staggering. They hit 59 kilowatts per
- 5:17kilogram. 59 kilowatts per kilogram.
- 5:19Now I get. This.
- 5:20That's a 40% jump over Yass's own previous record, which was
- 5:23already impressive. But the really big deal what's
- 5:27that it's triple the power density of the best conventional
- 5:31radial flux motors you can get right now Triple.
- 5:33Triple the power for every pound or kilo of motor, that's that's
- 5:38disruptive. That is a massive leap, and the
- 5:40implications aren't just about going faster in a straight line,
- 5:42are they? Not at all.
- 5:44Because the motor is so compact, so much lighter and smaller, it
- 5:47completely changes how you package the car.
- 5:49How so? Mercedes can put it right near
- 5:51the axle, much closer than a bulky radial motor.
- 5:55This drastically improves weight distribution, which means better
- 5:58handling, better dynamics through corners.
- 6:00It changes the whole feel of the car, not just the zero to 60
- 6:04time. OK, but cramming, you know, 1000
- 6:07horsepower or potential into something the size of a pancake,
- 6:09yeah, that's got to create some serious engineering headaches,
- 6:12right? Like heat?
- 6:14Oh absolutely. That's the real magic Yassa had
- 6:16to solve. When you shrink the motors
- 6:19physical size, you also shrink its thermal mass.
- 6:22There's just less metal there to soak up the heat.
- 6:24So getting rid of that heat, managing it effectively at such
- 6:27high power densities, that's the biggest challenge and that's why
- 6:30we have to talk about peak power versus continuous power.
- 6:34OK, I explain that difference. Why does the continuous number
- 6:37matter more for like everyday driving or even track driving?
- 6:42Right. So peak power, that's for the
- 6:44brochure. It's that amazing.
- 6:46Like 2 second burst for a launch control start, or maybe the
- 6:49absolute maximum it can hit momentarily.
- 6:51The headline number. Exactly.
- 6:53Continuous power though, that's what you can actually use.
- 6:56Can it hold, say, 80 miles an hour going up a long hill for 5
- 7:00minutes without overheating, without the car needing to cut
- 7:03power back to protect itself? OK.
- 7:06That's the real world capability.
- 7:08For mass market cars, even performance cars you drive
- 7:11regularly, continuous power is the true measure of how good the
- 7:14system is. So what are they estimating for
- 7:16sustained power on this prototype?
- 7:17Yasasa figures the continuous power is somewhere in the range
- 7:20of 350 to 400 kilowatts. Still huge numbers for that size
- 7:24and weight. Absolutely huge.
- 7:26Sustaining that level of output from something so small, it's
- 7:29deeply impressive. It proves it's not just a drag
- 7:32strip special. It can handle real high speed
- 7:34driving track use. Their chief of new technology,
- 7:38Simon Audling, he put it really well.
- 7:40He said basically this is real hardware in real life delivering
- 7:44real data, and it's performing beautifully.
- 7:46Real world results, that kind of power density, you know it's
- 7:50going to rewrite the rules for high performance EVs.
- 7:53But hang on, if it's that much better, why isn't Mercedes just
- 7:58sticking these in every single car they make right now?
- 8:01Why is it still sort of AMG only tech for now?
- 8:03What's the catch? It comes back to that precision.
- 8:05We talked about complexity and cost.
- 8:08Axial flux motors, just because of that flat geometry, they tend
- 8:11to need more individual parts, and the tolerances for
- 8:14manufacturing are incredibly tight.
- 8:16Even a tiny misalignment can cause vibrations or big
- 8:18efficiency losses. So harder to build consistently
- 8:21at scale. Exactly.
- 8:23The payoff in power density is enormous, no question.
- 8:26But the manufacturing complexity and the cost that comes with it
- 8:30means for now it makes most sense in those high margin
- 8:34performance focused vehicles where buyers will pay the
- 8:37premium. OK, that makes total sense.
- 8:39So Yasa is chasing raw power, planting the flag at the top of
- 8:43the performance mountain. But like you said, for most
- 8:45drivers, maybe 99% of us, the killer app isn't hitting sixty
- 8:50in two seconds, it's stretching how far you go on a charge,
- 8:54making those battery dollars count.
- 8:55Precisely. Which brings us nicely to the
- 8:57other side of this innovation coin.
- 8:59Right, while he also focuses on power, there's this other German
- 9:02startup, Deep Drive, and they're attacking the EV problem from
- 9:06the complete opposite direction, aren't they?
- 9:08Yeah, their whole game is maximizing efficiency
- 9:10specifically for the mass market getting more miles out of the
- 9:14same battery. How are they doing that?
- 9:15They've got this patented dual rotor motor design.
- 9:18How is that different from the radial Cam or the axial pancake?
- 9:22OK, so it's actually a really clever twist on the radial flux
- 9:26idea. Normally in a radial motor you
- 9:28have the rotor spinning in the middle inside a fixed outer
- 9:32casing called the stator. Right, the standard setup.
- 9:34Deep Dr. flips it, they put the stator the fixed part in the
- 9:37middle, and then they have two rotors spinning around the
- 9:40outside of it simultaneously. Whoa, OK, Two spinning rotors on
- 9:44the outside. What's the advantage of doing
- 9:46that? By using that dual rotor setup,
- 9:48they can really optimize how the magnetic fields line up and
- 9:51interact. It lets them generate the
- 9:53maximum amount of turning force, the torque, while absolutely
- 9:57minimizing the energy that gets wasted as heat or electrical
- 10:00resistance. Basically, they're squeezing
- 10:03every last bit of useful work out of the electricity coming
- 10:06from the battery. Making the most of every
- 10:07electron. And what's the headline claim?
- 10:10What's the result of that improved efficiency?
- 10:12They're claiming their motors are 20% more efficient than the
- 10:15current generation of electric motors that are widely used
- 10:18today. 20% Now that number might not sound as flashy as 1000
- 10:22horsepower, but in the real world?
- 10:24It's huge. That's the real.
- 10:26So what factor here? For you, the listener, a 20%
- 10:30boost in motor efficiency translates directly into about
- 10:3320% more driving range from the exact same battery.
- 10:36So you don't necessarily need a bigger, heavier, more expensive
- 10:39battery pack to go further. Exactly, you just need a
- 10:41smarter, more efficient motor and that ability to boost range
- 10:45without adding battery cost or weight.
- 10:47That is absolutely critical if we want EVs to be adopted by
- 10:50everyone. And there's another benefit too,
- 10:52right? Something about materials?
- 10:54Yeah, a really important second very benefit because their
- 10:57magnetic field design is so optimized in this dual rotor
- 11:00setup, they actually need significantly fewer rare earth
- 11:03magnets and less copy wind and wire to build the motor.
- 11:07Less expensive, hard to get materials.
- 11:09Right, which is great for manufacturing costs, helps bring
- 11:12down the sticker price of the car eventually and it's also
- 11:15really positive for sustainability, reducing our
- 11:17reliance on mining those finite resources.
- 11:20So Deep Drive is aiming to make EVs potentially cheaper to build
- 11:23lighter and go further, while Yas is making them smaller,
- 11:27lighter, and much much faster. OK.
- 11:30But the ultimate test for any cool tech obviously is getting
- 11:33it into actual cars people buy. We know YASA Tech is in
- 11:36$1,000,000 hyper cars, but how soon are we, the listeners,
- 11:41likely to see either of these innovations, these superpower
- 11:44dents, or the Super efficient in a car we might actually consider
- 11:47buying? Well, the good news is the
- 11:49transition is literally starting right now, just on slightly
- 11:52different tracks. OK, Yasa's axial flux motor,
- 11:55it's arriving basically as we speak.
- 11:57Mercedes started integrating that tech into their upcoming AM
- 12:00Gea platform late in 2024. The AMG Electric platform.
- 12:04Exactly. That's the crucial step, moving
- 12:06it from those ultra exclusive hyper cars into serious these
- 12:09production performance models. Still high end yes, but actual
- 12:12production cars, not one offs. OK, so coming soon to a high end
- 12:16Mercedes showroom. Yeah.
- 12:17What about deep drive, the efficiency focus, the potential
- 12:20cost savings for maybe a more mainstream car?
- 12:23They're a bit further out, but not by much.
- 12:26They're targeting series production starting around
- 12:28202740. 27 OK. And they're already in deep
- 12:31talks with several major car manufacturers, which tells you
- 12:35the industry is desperate to crack that cost and range
- 12:38problem for mass market EVs. Carmakers are actively chasing
- 12:41both these revolutionary paths at the same time.
- 12:44Right. So if we sort of bring this all
- 12:46together, we've got these two almost parallel revolutionary
- 12:50tracks defining the next wave of electric motors.
- 12:53Yeah, shaping the next generation of EVs.
- 12:56You've got YASA Laser focused on power density, packing insane
- 13:00horsepower into tiny spaces for ultimate performance.
- 13:04Better handling. Performance Frontier.
- 13:05And then you have deep drive engineering these hyper
- 13:08efficient motors using fewer materials, promising more range
- 13:11from the same battery, potentially lowering costs.
- 13:14Aiming squarely at the mainstream driver.
- 13:16Solving the practicality puzzle. It really feels like they're
- 13:19complementary solutions tackling different size of the electric
- 13:22car challenge. They absolutely are.
- 13:24YASA is solving the dream car problem, maximizing what's
- 13:29possible when cost is less of an object.
- 13:31Deep Drive is solving the everyday car problem, minimizing
- 13:34cost, maximizing range and usability for the average
- 13:37family. And it shows that motor
- 13:39technology itself, not just the battery, is where a lot of the
- 13:42key innovation is happening now. Totally.
- 13:45We're moving beyond just stuffing bigger batteries in
- 13:47technological differentiation in the motor that's defining the
- 13:50second act of the EV revolution. So as these really radical new
- 13:55motors start moving from, you know, the test labs and the race
- 13:58tracks onto actual factory production lines, yeah, it does
- 14:01leave us with a pretty interesting final thought for
- 14:03you to go on. Which of these breakthroughs,
- 14:07the pure raw power density that grabs all the headlines like YS
- 14:10is tech, or the maximum efficiency and potential cost
- 14:13reduction from something like Deep Drive?
- 14:16Which one will ultimately do more to redefine the electric
- 14:19car for the vast majority of drivers around the world?
- 14:22Power or efficiency? That's the big question, isn't
- 14:25it? What really moves the needle for
- 14:26most people? Something to think about.
- 14:30Well, we really appreciate you joining us today, taking the
- 14:32time to dive deep into this. It's fascinating stuff.
- 14:35The motor tech, hopefully we explained it clearly, took our
- 14:37time with it. Yeah, thanks for tuning in while
- 14:39we unpacked all that. We really hope this breakdown
- 14:42helps you understand what's coming next in EV innovation.
- 14:45It's an exciting time. Definitely is.
- 14:47OK, we'll catch you on the next deep dive.