Latest / Raising Men / Q&A: Heart-Level Connection Strategies for Dads and Sons
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome back to Raising Men.
- 0:03I'm your host, Shawn Dawson.
- 0:05You know, I started this journey with kind of a single uncomfortable truth.
- 0:13Our sons aren't just watching us, they're becoming us.
- 0:18That is generally the theme of today's Q &A session.
- 0:22We've got two questions.
- 0:24One is from a dad who feels like his old school playbook is out of date.
- 0:31And the other is about a phenomenon we've all probably seen.
- 0:35A kid who is just soulful and an emotional genius at home, but turns into a silent statue the moment he hits the playground.
- 0:48Now, as always, we're going to dive into the collective wisdom of the incredible guests that we've had on this show, from therapists and...
- 0:58psychologists to green berets and tech leaders to see how we can update our operating systems and help our boys navigate a world that often asks them to hide who they really
- 1:12are.
- 1:14Our first question comes from a listener who identifies as an older dad.
- 1:21That uh hits home with me, I'll tell you that.
- 1:25He writes, I feel like the world
- 1:27is moving too fast for my old school advice.
- 1:32I was raised in a strict suck it up household, but that doesn't seem to work on my son.
- 1:38My efforts to toughen him up seem to make him even more fragile.
- 1:42Am I thinking about this the right way?
- 1:45So I hear the humility in that question.
- 1:49And by the way, I feel this greatly as well.
- 1:52I kind of had a similar experience to you growing up.
- 1:57We often fall into the trap of parenting on autopilot, just doing what feels right.
- 2:05And a lot of the times, what feels right are the grooves that have been worn into our brain based on how we were brought up.
- 2:13So we essentially repeat the patterns that we inherited.
- 2:18But as my guest, Damien Gomes, who builds AI systems for a living, he put it really well.
- 2:25He says, we're not...
- 2:27building an automation, we're helping our sons find their own operating systems for life.
- 2:34And one of the core metaphors that I like to use on this show is the two brain metaphor.
- 2:40I often talk about the Conan the barbarian brain and the Sherlock Holmes brain.
- 2:46Now, the Conan brain is the amygdala.
- 2:50It's survival driven, it's reactive, and it's kind of limited to
- 2:57just emotional responses, mostly being one acceptable male emotion, which is anger.
- 3:05The Sherlock brain is the prefrontal cortex.
- 3:09It's the logical side, it's observant, it responds to things as opposed to reacts to things, and it's capable of empathy.
- 3:19Dr.
- 3:20Gloria Vanderhorst pointed out that while the Conan model was
- 3:26once adapted for survival, it is often maladaptive in the modern world.
- 3:34And so if we only teach our sons to be aggressive and brave while cutting off fear, we make intimate relationships much more difficult, maybe impossible for them later in life.
- 3:49So updating your OS means moving from a system
- 3:55of control to a system of connection.
- 4:00Updating your operating system doesn't mean throwing away your values.
- 4:04It means redefining what these things look like, like strength.
- 4:09Christopher Veal, a Marine veteran, shared that true manhood isn't about the armor or the walls we build.
- 4:18And he argues that vulnerability is actually a form of leadership.
- 4:22That when you admit mistakes or show emotion,
- 4:25You're not weakening your position.
- 4:27You're building a drawbridge of trust for your son.
- 4:33Simon Rinne, who grew up in that suck it up culture of the 80s and 90s like I did, emphasized that the playbook is changing.
- 4:42He suggests that mindfulness, bringing the subconscious to the conscious, is the ultimate upgrade.
- 4:50It allows us to pause between a child's behavior
- 4:55and our reaction allows us to consider that reaction and try to get the best outcome, meaning the outcome that is most aligned with our deeper values.
- 5:07As Eli Weinstein noted in his work on his transition from dude to dad, we have to unlearn the silence of past generations to build new patterns of emotional strength.
- 5:21Now, dad,
- 5:23Your old school values of hard work and protection and provisions, they're still vital.
- 5:31They're really, really, really good, especially in this kind of modern world where the values are kind of crumbling or the institutions that used to instill those values are
- 5:43crumbling.
- 5:45But the update you should think about is emotional literacy.
- 5:50uh Johnny Miller.
- 5:51taught us that our nervous system is the upstream lens through which we experience our family.
- 6:00So if you can regulate yourself before you relate to them, you're already running the most advanced software that you probably can.
- 6:11Our second question is, my kid is emotionally brilliant at home.
- 6:18He's kind, he's expressive, and he's deep.
- 6:22But the second we're around other people or at school, he shuts down.
- 6:27How do we help him navigate this?
- 6:30Now, Dr.
- 6:31Gloria Vanderhorst had some good insights on this too, I think.
- 6:34She talked about something that she calls the masculine ritual of safety.
- 6:41And it goes to kind of a central hypothesis that I'm working on right now, which is that a lot of the things that
- 6:51I think we believe that men don't do, right?
- 6:56Men aren't expressive.
- 6:58Men don't wanna talk about things.
- 7:00Men wanna kinda be on their own and all of that.
- 7:04Those things aren't true.
- 7:06But what is true is that men don't feel safe doing those things and so they don't happen.
- 7:14Dr.
- 7:15VandeHearst explained that unlike women who...
- 7:19often dive directly into emotional sharing, men and boys often require a ritual or some kind of process or posturing before they can feel safe.
- 7:33They feel the need to establish their status or toughness in the room before they can bring their real worries into the light.
- 7:43So your son, when he's coming in and not
- 7:48engaging the way he is when he's feeling safe at home, he's got a survival mechanism reading a room that he perceives as potentially judgmental and he doesn't want to step out
- 8:03of line.
- 8:04In fact, research shared by Dr.
- 8:07Vanderhorst suggests that infant boys are actually born with a broader range of emotional expression than girls are.
- 8:17Because society and oftentimes even well-meaning caregivers, including us, unintentionally discourage intense reactions in boys.
- 8:31And so our boys learn to narrow the room and limit their expressions for safety.
- 8:38And that is kind of extinguishing their fire.
- 8:42So when we see our boys shutting down,
- 8:45our instinct might be to push them to be ourselves, almost shaming them into not being so shy.
- 8:57And we have to be careful not to do that.
- 9:00We need to not shame them for their protective shell.
- 9:05I have a theory that shame is never a good idea.
- 9:11And I'm not sure whether that's 100 % true.
- 9:15But certainly in our relationships with our kids, I think it's really overused.
- 9:21Paul Kix used a beautiful metaphor here, I think, which he called it the Brooklyn Bridge.
- 9:28He explained that vulnerability is like the tensile strength of a bridge.
- 9:33It's the ability to flex and sway under pressure without breaking.
- 9:39If a bridge is too rigid, it becomes brittle and it snaps.
- 9:45Ken Mossman, who works on dismantling the lone wolf myth, points out that boys often equate vulnerability with weakness because that's what they see modeled from us.
- 9:58If they see us hiding our cards in public or not being willing to be vulnerable, they're gonna do the same.
- 10:07So, how do we help them bridge the gap between their private brilliance and their public persona?
- 10:13How do we do it in the moment?
- 10:17The first uh nugget that I might see comes from Dr.
- 10:20Michelle Watson Canfield.
- 10:23And that's about connection before correction.
- 10:26We talked about, in that episode, we talked about the castle metaphor.
- 10:30Heart level connection is what opens the drawbridge into the inner walls of the castle.
- 10:37So if you try to correct his public posturing without that connection,
- 10:43He'll just pull the bridge up tighter.
- 10:44So, you know, get down to his level, look him in the eye and say, man, it seems like you're feeling pretty shy right now.
- 10:51That's understandable.
- 10:52I feel shy often as well.
- 10:54What do you think we could do to feel more outgoing or safe or like you are at home?
- 11:00Like remember when you sang that song in front of your aunts and uncles or whatever.
- 11:05You can also model the redo.
- 11:06If you find yourself posturing, maybe you were aggressive in traffic or you...
- 11:11You shut down during a social gathering and started browsing your phone or something like that.
- 11:17Talk to him about it later.
- 11:19Simon Rinne and Ryan North both emphasize the power of the repair.
- 11:24It's such a powerful thing.
- 11:25Say, hey, I noticed I was acting out a bit.
- 11:29And I was acting tough earlier, but I was feeling nervous.
- 11:33And this is how I dealt with that.
- 11:35If he sees you struggling with those same sorts of things, he'll be able to address that later.
- 11:40And you also need to think about addressing the root need.
- 11:42Dr.
- 11:43Van Der Hor suggests that many of the behavioral masks are actually a cry for belonging.
- 11:52He's acting a certain way in public.
- 11:54He's likely trying to figure out where he fits.
- 11:58So maybe we can help him reframe his internal emotional brilliance as the secret strength rather than something that he's afraid to show people.
- 12:11But as we wrap up this Q &A, I want to leave you with one operating principle that has come up time and time again over a lot of episodes.
- 12:21It comes from many of our guests.
- 12:24But Michelle Watson Canfield said it really, really clearly.
- 12:28She says, never underestimate the power of your presence.
- 12:33You don't have to have the perfect updated OS today.
- 12:37You don't have to know exactly what to do.
- 12:40to stop the posturing, you just have to be willing to show up and be present.
- 12:47And that doesn't just mean physical presence, that means intellectual and emotional presence as well.
- 12:53Fatherhood isn't a destination, it's a constant process.
- 12:57It's about trying and failing and having the courage to try again.
- 13:02Remember my principle that excellence is failure.
- 13:08If you wanna dive deeper into any of these concepts, I highly recommend checking out the full episodes with any of the people that we mentioned here.
- 13:16You can find links to all of that and links to their work in the show notes and other resources at Raising.Men.
- 13:28Until next time, keep it up, man.
- 13:31Keep doing the work, face what you're avoiding, stay curious, and remember that the man
- 13:38that you are is the man that he will be.
- 13:42I'm Shawn Dawson.
- 13:43This is Raising Men, and you are a great parent.