Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04We're going to pick up where we left off with
- 0:06the US Government's brief in response to Glenn Maxwell's attempt
- 0:10at an appeal number four, the sexual abuse of Virginia Roberts.
- 0:15Beginning in or about the summer of two thousand, Maxwell
- 0:18and Epstein entered into a new phase of their scheme
- 0:21to sexually abuse teenage girls. That summer, Maxwell recruited a
- 0:26seventeen year old girl named Virginia Roberts from the parking
- 0:29lot of Omar A Lago to provide Epstein with massages.
- 0:32Over the next several months, Virginia was paid to provide
- 0:35Epstein with sexualized massages at his pom Beach residents in
- 0:39exchange for one hundreds of dollars in cash for each massage.
- 0:43Virginia also traveled with Epstein and Maxwell to other locations,
- 0:47including New York and the Virgin Islands on Epstein's private plane.
- 0:52Virginia brought other teenage girls to Epstein's pom Beach house.
- 0:56One of those girls was fourteen year old girl named Carolyn,
- 0:59who virgin Ninya introduced to Maxwell and Epstein at the
- 1:02Palm Beach Villa in two thousand and one five The
- 1:06Sexual Abuse of Carolyn. Carolyn met Maxwell the very first
- 1:11time she went to Epstein's house, and she interacted with
- 1:14Maxwell multiple times thereafter. On Carolyn's first visit to the house,
- 1:19Maxwell greeted Virginia, who introduced Carolyn to Maxwell. Maxwell then
- 1:23told Virginia, you can bring her upstairs and show her
- 1:26what to do. After Virginia showed Carolyn how to perform
- 1:29sexual massages on Epstein. Thereafter, Carolyn performed over one hundred
- 1:34page sexualized massages for Epstein when she was between fourteen
- 1:38and eighteen years old. The vast majority involved the same
- 1:42course of abuse, through which Epstein masturbated, touched Carolyn's breasts
- 1:46and buttocks, and directed Carolyn to touch his nipples. Epstein
- 1:51also attempted to touch Carolyn's vagina with a vibrator, brought
- 1:54other females into the room to engage in oral sex
- 1:57with Carolyn, and rpe Carolyn by pay petrating her vagina
- 2:01with his penis. At first, Maxwell personally scheduled Carolyn's appointments
- 2:06with Epstein, including all phone calls from New York, and
- 2:09sometimes sent a car to pick Carolyn up because she
- 2:12was too young to drive. Maxwell also engaged Carolyn in
- 2:16conversations during which Carolyn revealed that she had previously been
- 2:20sexually abused by a relative, that her parents were separated,
- 2:24and that her mother struggled with addiction. Maxwell invited Carolyn
- 2:28to travel with Maxwell and Epstein, but Carolyn responded that
- 2:31because she was only fourteen years old, she would not
- 2:34be able to get permission to travel. Carolyn was paid
- 2:37several hundred dollars in one hundred dollars bills after each massage,
- 2:41and Carolyn also received gifts of lingerie from Epstein and
- 2:45Maxwell's shipped from Manhattan to her home in Florida. Usually
- 2:49the money was laid out on the table or by
- 2:51the sink in the bathroom, but Maxwell personally paid Carolyn
- 2:55after a few massages. Maxwell saw Carolyn fully nude in
- 2:59the massage room on approximately three occasions, when Carolyn had
- 3:02already undressed in preparation for the massage, but before Epstein
- 3:06entered the room. On one such occasion, when Carolyn was
- 3:10fourteen years old, Maxwell told Carolyn that she had a
- 3:13nice body and touched Carolyn's breast. At some point, Epstein
- 3:17asked Carolyn if she had any young friends that she
- 3:20could bring four massages. Carolyn ended up bringing multiple girls
- 3:24to Epstein for sexualized massages, including multiple miners. When Carolyn
- 3:29brought girls to massage Epstein, both the girl and Carolyn
- 3:32would be paid hundreds of dollars in cash. Number six
- 3:36sexual abuse of Melissa. One of the minor girls Carolyn
- 3:39brought to provide paid sexualized massages to Epstein was a
- 3:43sixteen year old girl named Melissa. Melissa went to Epstein's
- 3:47residence to provide Epstein with massages on multiple occasions when
- 3:51she was under the age of eighteen. When Melissa and
- 3:54Carolyn went to the Palm Beach house, they remained in
- 3:57the home for about an hour and then returned with
- 4:00hundreds of dollars in cash. B the defense case, verdict
- 4:04and sentencing, Maxwell called nine witnesses in her defense case,
- 4:09including former employees and dissociates, as well as an expert
- 4:13on memory. On December twenty ninth, twenty twenty one, the
- 4:17jury found Maxwell guilty of counts one, three, five, four,
- 4:21and six. On April first, twenty twenty two, Judge Nathan
- 4:25denied Maxwell's motion for a new trial pursue it to
- 4:29fed R Rule of Criminal Procedure thirty three, based on
- 4:32a juris provision of inaccurate information during jury selection, as
- 4:37discussed in greater detail in point three. On April twenty ninth,
- 4:40twenty twenty two, Judge Nathan denied all but one of
- 4:43Maxwell's remaining post trial motions. Judge Nathan found that the
- 4:47three conspiracy counts, Count one, three, and five were multiplicitis,
- 4:53and that she therefore would enter judgment on count three
- 4:56alone among the conspiracy counts. On June twenty ninth, TI
- 5:00twenty twenty two, Judge Nathan sentenced Maxwell to sixty months
- 5:03imprisonment on count three, one hundred and twenty months imprisonment
- 5:07on Count four, and two hundred and forty months imprisonment
- 5:10on Count six, all to run concurrently, to be followed
- 5:14by five years supervise release, and imposed a seven hundred
- 5:17and fifty thousand dollars fine and a three hundred dollars
- 5:20mandatory special assessment. Argument point one, the District Court correctly
- 5:26concluded that Jeffrey Epstein's non prosecution agreement does not bar
- 5:30Maxwell's prosecution. In the Southern District of New York in
- 5:34two thousand and seven, the US Attorney's Office for the
- 5:37Southern District of Florida entered into a non prosecution agreement
- 5:40with Jeffrey Epstein. Maxwell argues that this agreement, which neither
- 5:44she nor the U. S Attorney's Office for the SDNY signed,
- 5:48nevertheless bars her prosecution in the Southern District of New
- 5:52York in this case, and she twice sought dismissal of
- 5:55the charges in the indictment on that ground. The District
- 5:58Court denied the motion to dismiss, correctly recognizing that Maxwell's
- 6:03argument is precluded by the text of the agreement and
- 6:06the court's long standing precedent. Accordingly, this court should affirm
- 6:10the denial of the motion to dismiss the relevant facts.
- 6:15In two thousand and five, the Palm Beach Police Department
- 6:18in Florida opened an investigation into Epstein on the complaint
- 6:21of the parents of a fourteen year old girl. The
- 6:24Palm Beach Police ultimately brought the investigation to the Federal
- 6:28Bureau of Investigation in West Palm Beach, which it turned
- 6:31opened an investigation with the US Attorney's Office for the
- 6:35Southern District of Florida. That investigation culminated in a draft
- 6:39sixty page indictment proposing to charge Apstein for the sexual
- 6:43abuse of multiple victims. In two thousand and seven, the
- 6:47USAO SDFL and Epstein entered into a non prosecution agreement.
- 6:52The agreement was signed on the authority of R. Alexandra Acosta,
- 6:56United States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida. Under
- 6:59the terms of the NPA, Epstein agreed to plead guilty
- 7:03in appending Florida State case and to receive a sentence
- 7:06of at least eighteen months imprisonment and twelve months community control.
- 7:11He also consented to jurisdiction in the Southern District of
- 7:14Florida for civil suits involving victims specified by the USAO SDFL,
- 7:20among other terms. In exchange, USAO SDFL agreed to defer
- 7:25prosecution in the district once Epstein completed. As half of
- 7:29the bargain, the NPA provided that no prosecution for the
- 7:33offenses then under investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation
- 7:38and the US Attorney's Office will be instituted in this district.
- 7:42The NPA also provided that if Epstein complied with the agreement,
- 7:47the United States also agrees that it will not institute
- 7:50any criminal charges against any potential co conspirators of Epstein,
- 7:54including but not limited to, four named individuals, none of
- 7:58whom was Maxwell. Indeed, Maxwell was neither a party to
- 8:02the agreement nor involved in negotiating its terms. This provision
- 8:06appears to have been added with little discussion or consideration
- 8:10by the prosecutors. The NPA continues that upon execution of
- 8:14this agreement and the plea agreement with the State's Attorney's Office,
- 8:17the federal grand jury investigation will be suspended. The agreement
- 8:23was executed on September twenty fourth, two thousand and seven,
- 8:26and Epstein pled guilty in state court on June thirtieth,
- 8:29two thousand and eight. In twenty nineteen, the Department of
- 8:32Justice Office of Professional Responsibility conducted an investigation into the
- 8:37negotiation surrounding the NPA and issued a two hundred and
- 8:41ninety page report containing detailed factual findings. After the U. S.
- 8:46Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York charged
- 8:49Maxwell in this case in the Southern District of New York,
- 8:52she twice moved to dismiss the charges on the grounds
- 8:55that they were barred by the NPA. The District Court
- 8:58denied the motions can ccline acuding that the NPA does
- 9:01not bind the USAO SDN y B applicable law. The
- 9:07Court is long held that a plea agreement binds only
- 9:10the office of the United States Attorney for the district
- 9:13in which the plea is entered, unless it affirmatively appears
- 9:16that the agreement contemplates a broader restriction. United States versus
- 9:20Anneb seven to seventy one, F Dot two, D six
- 9:23seventy six seventy two, Second Circuit, nineteen eighty five, accord eg.
- 9:28United States versus Prisco three ninety one f. Appendix nine
- 9:32to twenty nine, twenty one, Second Circuit twenty ten. United
- 9:36States versus Salame one fifty two F three d eighty
- 9:40eight one, twenty Second Circuit. Nineteen ninety eight. The requisite
- 9:44affirmative appearance may be established by an express statement in
- 9:47the plea agreement, or it may be inferred from the
- 9:50negotiations between the defendant and the prosecutor, as well as
- 9:54from the statements at the plea colloquy. United States versus
- 9:58Russo eight oh one fIF dot two D six twenty
- 10:01four six, twenty six, Second Circuit nineteen eighty six. This
- 10:06Court reviews de novo both the denial of emotion to
- 10:10dismiss an indictment and the interpretation of a plea agreement.
- 10:14United States versus Montague, sixty seven f. Fourth five, twenty five,
- 10:19twenty seven, Second Circuit, twenty twenty three. United States versus Padia,
- 10:23one eighty six F Dot three d one thirty six,
- 10:26one thirty nine, Second Circuit, nineteen ninety nine. This Court reviews,
- 10:31for abuse of discretion, a district court's denial of an
- 10:35evidentiary hearing before ruling on a motion to dismiss. United
- 10:39States versus Walters nine ten F. Dot three d eleven,
- 10:43twenty two, twenty eight, Second Circuit, twenty eighteen. United States
- 10:48versus Greenberg, eight thirty five F. Dot three d two
- 10:51ninety five, three oh five, Second Circuit, twenty sixteen. See discussion.
- 10:58The District Court correctly rejected Maxwell's argument that the NPA
- 11:02bars this prosecution. Maxwell has no right to invoke the
- 11:05protections of the NPA because she is neither a party
- 11:08two nor a third party beneficiary of the agreement. But
- 11:12even if Maxwell had standing under the NPA, it would
- 11:16not bar this prosecution because it was plainly intended to
- 11:19bind only the us AO SDFL. Thus, Judge Nathan rightly
- 11:24concluded that, under long standing second circuit precedent, the NPA
- 11:29does not bind us AO SDNY. Accordingly, this Court should
- 11:33affirm the denial of Maxwell's motions to dismiss. All Right,
- 11:37we're going to wrap up this episode here and in
- 11:39the next episode, we're gonna pick up where we left off.
- 11:43And that's with Maxwell is not entitled to enforce the NPA.
- 11:48All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 11:50be found in the description box.