Latest / Stories of Change: Helping You Navigate What's Next / What to Say When Someone You Love Is Dying: The Good Goodbye with Dr. Maureen Keeley
Transcript
- 0:00Judy Oskam: Welcome to Stories of Change and Creativity.
- 0:03Judy Oskam: I'm Judy Oskam.
- 0:04Judy Oskam: This episode is about saying goodbye.
- 0:08Judy Oskam: The conversations we have when someone close to us is dying, and we know our time together is limited.
- 0:17Judy Oskam: If you're like me, I've had moments where I wished I'd said something a little differently, or I wish I'd said something sooner.
- 0:26Judy Oskam: In these moments, I've felt really unsure.
- 0:29Judy Oskam: And back when my dad was uh nearing the end several years ago, I reached out to my colleague, Dr.
- 0:38Judy Oskam: Maureen Keeley.
- 0:40Judy Oskam: She's a professor of interpersonal communication at Texas State University.
- 0:45Judy Oskam: Her research focuses on the final conversations we have with a loved one or someone we know nearing the end of life.
- 0:54Judy Oskam: Dr.
- 0:55Judy Oskam: Keeley, along with Dr.
- 0:57Judy Oskam: Julie Yingling, wrote the book The Good Goodbye, the Transformative Power of Conversation at the End of Life.
- 1:06Judy Oskam: And trust me, this book and their research can help you learn how to show up, know what to say, and how to live with fewer regrets afterwards.
- 1:18Judy Oskam: If you're caring for an aging parent, like I am with my brother, or someone nearing the end of life, this episode will give you a research-based lens for creating a good goodbye.
- 1:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: I'm Dr.
- 1:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: Maureen Keeley.
- 1:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: I'm a professor at Texas State University.
- 1:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: I've been here 31 years.
- 1:41Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I have been I'm a professor of interpersonal communication, which means I teach about communication relationships.
- 1:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I teach nonverbal and family and relational calm, and I even teach an end-of-life graduate course and communication end of life.
- 1:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, I've been doing this whole body of research for over two decades.
- 2:00Judy Oskam: Well, and you started that because you saw a gap, right?
- 2:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: I started because my mother was dying 20 years ago, 27 years ago.
- 2:10Judy Oskam: Wow.
- 2:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um she was very private and quiet, and none of us knew if we were doing it right because these conversations that happen at the end of life, what I call final conversations, are done in private and they should be done in private.
- 2:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: But we don't have any models.
- 2:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: We didn't know what to say, what do people talk about?
- 2:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: I I'm one of six children.
- 2:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: I'm the youngest by five minutes.
- 2:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: I've six six of us, I have an identical twin.
- 2:35Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 2:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: Four minutes, I have an identical twin.
- 2:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: And one of my older brothers said, Hey Maureen, Mom, said anything to you profound?
- 2:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I go, What do you mean, Chris?
- 2:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: He goes, I'm waiting to hear her life secrets or her advice that will change my life.
- 2:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he goes, I just want this profound conversation.
- 2:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I went, Oh, Chris, do you know mom loves you?
- 2:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 2:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: So, do you know mom's proud of you?
- 2:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: He said, Absolutely.
- 2:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: I said, Can you imagine you're dying, you're scared, you're in pain.
- 3:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: If you had to have a profound conversation for every person who walked through that door, you'd lock that door and not let anybody in because there's just one more thing that you have to do that you don't want to do.
- 3:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: Right.
- 3:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I went looking and there was one tiny little pamphlet, and I mean like the size of a three, you know, double three by five card.
- 3:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it was 10 pages long, and all it said was communication's good, but the dying needs you talk to them.
- 3:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: I'm going, I for a fact know that not all communication between people in relationships is good.
- 3:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 3:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it didn't tell us what people talked about.
- 3:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it said, do it because the dying needed it.
- 3:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I agree.
- 3:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, I think that there's an altruistic side to it.
- 3:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: But I kept thinking about it and I went looking, you know, for more.
- 3:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: And there were books from people who are dying, what they wanted to say.
- 3:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: There were books between medical professionals and the dying, and what those conversations were, some doctors, nurses, chaplains even, social workers, a few, but nothing in the family.
- 4:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: Well, we're the ones who spend all the time with them.
- 4:06Judy Oskam: And we're there when it happens.
- 4:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: We're there when it happens.
- 4:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: We are the caregiver for the majority, whether that is days, weeks, months, over a year, two years.
- 4:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so I just decided I had a job to do.
- 4:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: And honestly, I thought it was crazy.
- 4:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Who's going to talk to me about their most private conversations?
- 4:25Dr. Maureen Keeley: And yet they did.
- 4:27Judy Oskam: And they did.
- 4:28Judy Oskam: And I'm telling you, your first book, Final Conversations.
- 4:31Judy Oskam: That really helped me out in 2017 when my dad was dying.
- 4:36Judy Oskam: And I remember you and I, you you met me on campus and gave me the book.
- 4:41Judy Oskam: And that really was special to me.
- 4:43Judy Oskam: But in the middle of the night, I'm researching and searching, Googling all of your articles and sending them to my brother, right?
- 4:52Judy Oskam: Because we were the two caregivers with my mom.
- 4:55Judy Oskam: My mom was is still around and she's 94.
- 4:59Judy Oskam: So that was so impactful to read about that.
- 5:03Judy Oskam: Of course, we were at the very end there, but it really had some good um strategies for what to do.
- 5:10Judy Oskam: And I didn't, no one had ever told me those things.
- 5:13Judy Oskam: Why is it that some of that is unspoken?
- 5:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, because we live in a society that says don't talk about death and dying.
- 5:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 5:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because it's almost magical thinking.
- 5:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: If I if I talk to my mom about dying, then I'm going to make her die faster.
- 5:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or I'm going to make her give up hope.
- 5:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or I'm going to invite in some sort of evil entity to come take her faster.
- 5:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: And in lots of cultures, that's true.
- 5:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: Some cultures they talk about it more.
- 5:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: Other cultures they talk about it less than we do, which is shocking to me.
- 5:44Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um and so and so we're just, we don't know what to say, and we're afraid to say the wrong thing.
- 5:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: So instead, we won't say anything.
- 5:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or we avoid showing up.
- 5:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: I know people who have just avoided going until somebody forced them at the last minute to go because you know their loved one needed to see them.
- 6:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: But the whole point of Final Conversations, and that first book came out in 2007, and the new book that just came out in 2025, The Good Goodbye, is about the fact that yes, we're doing it for the person we love.
- 6:13Dr. Maureen Keeley: But here's a surprise for everybody.
- 6:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: It's for us.
- 6:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: When our loved one dies, you you either believe that they're going to heaven and they're fine, they're looking down at us, they're happy, or if you don't have a belief, then you think that they're worm food and they don't know anymore.
- 6:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 6:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: We remember the conversations, we carry them with us for the rest of our lives.
- 6:33Judy Oskam: I love that.
- 6:34Judy Oskam: Well, and you you, as a communication expert, you know the power of conversation and the power of connection.
- 6:42Judy Oskam: And I think that in in in your book, uh, which is The Good Goodbye, you and your your co-author, Julie Yingling.
- 6:50Judy Oskam: Dr.
- 6:50Judy Oskam: Yingling.
- 6:50Judy Oskam: Dr.
- 6:51Judy Oskam: Yingling, on the back cover it says, Death is the one thing we cannot control.
- 6:56Judy Oskam: We will all face the death of a loved one, and many, if not most people in our culture will be hesitant and unprepared to say goodbye.
- 7:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: When we have someone we love who's dying, we're totally out of control.
- 7:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: We often have very little decisions to make.
- 7:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: Our loved one has some decisions to make if they're willing to.
- 7:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um if they're able to.
- 7:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 7:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Of course, there could be fights in the family about what to do.
- 7:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: So if we have these conversations beforehand with our loved one, we can avoid those fights and hard feelings later on.
- 7:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: And uh it is just the only thing we can control.
- 7:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: So let's embrace it and understand there's not a perfect final conversation.
- 7:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: You may later on reflect back and go, that was perfect, but don't go into a conversation expecting perfection because that's too much pressure for all of us.
- 7:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: And and I've been teaching, you know, over three decades verbal and nonverbal communication.
- 7:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: So sometimes it is simply the nonverbal.
- 7:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: So showing up and spending time with them, holding their hand, making them their favorite cup of tea.
- 8:00Judy Oskam: Right.
- 8:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: But it's that time and sometimes in the silence where the conversations pop out of nowhere.
- 8:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: My mom would wake up in the middle of the night every night, the last few months, especially the last few weeks of her life.
- 8:13Dr. Maureen Keeley: And in those quiet moments after she'd wake up, sometimes from a nightmare, and she was processing something that happened in her life that she had to process.
- 8:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, there'd be this quiet, and then an easy conversation would start that came out of the blue.
- 8:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: And if I wasn't there at three o'clock in the morning, I wouldn't have had that opportunity.
- 8:30Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 8:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so I just want to encourage everyone to go and be with them as much as possible.
- 8:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: Is it easy to watch someone you love die?
- 8:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: No.
- 8:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: They are shrinking, they're in pain, they're afraid.
- 8:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: But it's also beautiful in the moments that you never expect.
- 8:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I was one of my mom's caregivers.
- 8:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: We I come from a large time, we would take turns.
- 8:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: My two sisters are nurses, they knew how to do everything.
- 8:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: Sure.
- 8:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: I was not a nurse.
- 8:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I remember my dad telling me once, Maureen, I love the way you lift your mother.
- 9:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I go, What do you mean?
- 9:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: He goes, Well, your sisters lift her like a nurse.
- 9:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: You lift her like a hug.
- 9:06Judy Oskam: Oh, I'm not sure.
- 9:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because we would I would use my whole body to lift her, and then we would just look at each other and smile and hug.
- 9:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, so I get all these extra hugs I never would have imagined.
- 9:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: And if my dad hadn't worded it that way, I would not have realized it was something special.
- 9:21Judy Oskam: Right.
- 9:21Judy Oskam: Right.
- 9:21Judy Oskam: Right.
- 9:22Judy Oskam: Well, and and you know, you're right about it's not just the profound major conversations.
- 9:29Judy Oskam: It's you call it the everyday, right?
- 9:31Judy Oskam: It's it's it's the everyday conversations.
- 9:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, there are six themes that we found that people commonly talk about, and everyday talk and routine interactions are one of them.
- 9:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it was probably one of the more shocking finds.
- 9:44Dr. Maureen Keeley: And and these themes emerged, and they were absolutely right.
- 9:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because what if you think about your relationships right now with your husband, with your children, it is the good morning kiss, it is what's your day gonna look like, sharing a cup of coffee, it is at the end of the day coming together, and and it's in it's those moments we're gonna miss the most because that's what kept us going every day.
- 10:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: That is what built our relationships every day and kept them healthy.
- 10:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so um, you know, I've interviewed children and adults, we've interviewed well, we've interviewed well over 150 people, adults and children, and we've surveyed well over 500 people.
- 10:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um they would like the kids were talking about how important it was that daddy, who was dying of cancer, still read them their nighttime story.
- 10:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: Routine.
- 10:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: Routine.
- 10:37Judy Oskam: Right, right.
- 10:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or, you know, they set up a tent in the backyard because to go camping a lot, but he wasn't up for that.
- 10:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: So they'd set up the tent, you know, and one little one little boy asked, he was scared because he didn't know who's gonna pull his teeth, because his daddy was the the person who pulled the teeth.
- 10:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so his mom said, I'll do it.
- 10:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then the older brother said, Or I'll do it.
- 10:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: Who do you want to do it?
- 10:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: So giving the child some control over that.
- 11:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yes.
- 11:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: But they want to know that their life will go on that because little ones don't really understand.
- 11:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: They know something's changing and there there's chaos around them, so they want that structure.
- 11:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, but we also want that kind of structure.
- 11:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: And and I had one guy who uh had to be in his late 40s when his mother was dying, or maybe 50, and he just set up a video recorder.
- 11:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he said, we just sat on the couch and we were telling stories and looking at pictures, and mom was telling us who was who.
- 11:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: He said, and I realized life is these everyday moments.
- 11:32Judy Oskam: Yeah, I love that.
- 11:33Judy Oskam: I love that.
- 11:34Judy Oskam: So, in order for us, you know, and and the listeners to really understand, it's not something out of their control, it's something that they can do.
- 11:42Judy Oskam: It's just the basic everyday.
- 11:45Judy Oskam: Talk a little bit about the research and how you how you talk to the people, what you ask them.
- 11:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: Okay, so this research over the past four years is based on four major um research studies.
- 11:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: And the very first one was interviewing um adults and interviewing them from the age 18 to I think the oldest was 80 or 85 years old.
- 12:09Dr. Maureen Keeley: And some of the conversations had happened only three weeks prior, and others had happened 20 years prior.
- 12:15Judy Oskam: Wow.
- 12:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: And believe it or not, that interview that happened 20 years prior was more profound and more memorable than the three-week one.
- 12:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because the three-week interview, she was still processing the death and hadn't had time.
- 12:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: The grief, you mean her grief.
- 12:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: The actual watching her mother dying, and her grief was mixed in it, but it was watching, oh, my mom died, my mom died.
- 12:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: But when you get past that phase of it, then you start remembering the conversations, and then you're remembering, oh, this happened, or she said this, and something that didn't seem like that important at the moment may seem really profound.
- 12:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: Occasionally, something happens in that moment, and like like the guy who was 80 years old, he knew that conversation was important.
- 12:56Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 12:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he said he knew it that moment, and he knew that he was the most loved because she's the only one he told that story to.
- 13:02Judy Oskam: Oh, wow.
- 13:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: It was it was funny.
- 13:03Judy Oskam: Oh wow.
- 13:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and so in interviewing these adults, we identified five themes.
- 13:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: And the five themes were love, thank goodness that was the theme.
- 13:12Judy Oskam: Sure.
- 13:13Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um identity, and identity is um how we kind of know who we are.
- 13:19Dr. Maureen Keeley: As we're growing up and throughout our lives, people reflect who we are and they say messages to us, or they like you're a daughter or a son.
- 13:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: Your daughter, your son, or you're so strong.
- 13:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, you're so beautiful.
- 13:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: Why do you keep putting yourself down?
- 13:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: You need to believe, have more confidence in yourself and go look in that mirror.
- 13:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: Look how beautiful you are.
- 13:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: I don't want you ever do anything to your body that would change how beautiful you are, your nature, natural beauty.
- 13:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or I had this one um mother tell me, her son, he was dying at 19.
- 13:47Dr. Maureen Keeley: And Gloria, rest in peace.
- 13:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: She just died a few days ago.
- 13:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh no.
- 13:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: But her son told her, Mom, you need to go back to school.
- 13:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: Very traditional Hispanic family.
- 13:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: None of them had ever gone to college.
- 13:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he said, You need to go to school for both of us because I can't go.
- 14:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: And you're so good with kids, and you need to be their protector.
- 14:05Dr. Maureen Keeley: So go to school and get a degree where you can do that.
- 14:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: She went back to school and got a degree in as a social worker.
- 14:12Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 14:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: Changed her life.
- 14:14Judy Oskam: Changed your life.
- 14:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then how many lives did she change by going from being a secretary, which is what she was, administrative assistant, at Texas State.
- 14:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh my gosh, that's great.
- 14:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: To to doing that.
- 14:24Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 14:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, so those are identity messages telling us kind of, you know, most of them are compliments and talking about strengths.
- 14:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: Occasionally it's a tough relative giving a hard message.
- 14:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: Sure.
- 14:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: Uh, and and moving on.
- 14:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: So the third um theme was spiritual or religious messages.
- 14:41Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so if it's religious, it would be, oh, we said the Lord's Prayer together, or um, he told me he believed in an ever an everlasting life and Jesus Christ, and you know, um, or I'll meet you at Heaven's Gate.
- 14:55Judy Oskam: Right.
- 14:55Judy Oskam: Right.
- 14:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or spiritual messages is like the message where the mother who was dying told this man, who was 80 years old, that her husband, who was his father, had come to her 10 years prior and he had died, and he walked through a door that used to be there, but they'd closed up because it was two doors into this bedroom, and lifted her off the bed and hugged her and said, I'm allowed to come this one time to tell you how much I love you.
- 15:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it's beautiful here, and I will be here when it's your time to come to me.
- 15:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then he laid her back down.
- 15:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she she said, I knew I felt him, I knew it was true.
- 15:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: Sure.
- 15:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so the son, who was very religious but not spiritual, said, I changed that moment and I became spiritual in addition to being religious.
- 15:41Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 15:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: So that was beautiful.
- 15:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: I had another woman who um a a chosen mother was dying, and this woman's husband, um, he was dying, not Ruth.
- 15:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um, she had rushed, they weren't supposed to be there that weekend.
- 15:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: They had gone out to visit them out of as a surprise, and he ended up getting hit by a horse, and which eventually would kill him.
- 16:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: He got hit in the head.
- 16:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: Wow.
- 16:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: But she finally went out to the waiting room and laid, he looked, she laid on a like a lounge, you know, a recliner chair to close her eyes, and she saw this light come down the hallway and rest on her heart, and she just knew it was him, and she said, CJ, I promise I'll look after Ruth.
- 16:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: I she'll be fine, she'll be taken care of for just a few minutes.
- 16:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: She said, You're safe, you can go.
- 16:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then she saw the light rise above her, the orb, go out the window.
- 16:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: And at that moment, she heard um blue, a blue uh code.
- 16:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, yeah.
- 16:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, it died.
- 16:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: He coded.
- 16:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: He coded.
- 16:38Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 16:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so she was somebody who used to sell like tractors and and those kinds of things, like real farming equipment.
- 16:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: She went back to school, got a counseling degree, and eventually became a minister and um was a specialist at end of life.
- 16:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: She became she said, I'm I'm supposed to be a midwife at death, and that's what I do now.
- 16:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: Wow.
- 16:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: Changed her life.
- 16:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: Wow.
- 16:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 16:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: So then the fourth one was everyday talk.
- 17:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: And the fifth one, um, this is a really important one.
- 17:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, it's called in the ch in the book, it's called Healing Damage Relationships.
- 17:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, academically, we called it difficult um relationship talk.
- 17:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I knew that, I mean, most of the stories I was getting were from people who, oh, we had a great relationship.
- 17:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: I love my mom.
- 17:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: I love my husband, you know.
- 17:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: But we all know that some of us have really challenging relationships, and maybe you're estranged.
- 17:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so I had some of those people come talk to me.
- 17:30Judy Oskam: Wow.
- 17:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: And they told me really powerful conversations, really powerful conversations about how um, you know, their mother just didn't love them, was just kind of cruel and um or another mother was an alcoholic, you know, and so they had these really hard conversations, and did they didn't fix everything by participating, but it started the healing journey and one healing for them, right?
- 17:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: Healing for them, for them, yes.
- 17:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: And actually, probably also for the dying.
- 17:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, probably so because they the dying wanted them to show up, and some people just can't, and I understand that sometimes you need to have your boundaries, and you you can heal those relationships other ways after the person has died.
- 18:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: But if you can start the healing by going in, because I had one person said, you know, I had been so mad for so many years, but I'm watching this woman shrink in front of me.
- 18:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: She's physically shrinking because that's what happens at the end of life.
- 18:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, and she was in pain and she was scared, and you know, people die the way they lived.
- 18:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: So if they were kind of crotchety or grumpy, they're gonna be that way at the end of life too.
- 18:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: But then she also started thinking about all the ways that this woman had been a good person, just not a great mom.
- 18:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, she was really good every time somebody got sick or died, the church, she'd be first person making food, and you know, and she was a great, wonderful grandmother to her two sons.
- 18:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: She was a single mom, this woman was a single mom.
- 18:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: And this grandmother watched them when she had to work.
- 18:48Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it was just for whatever reason, she could not be a good mother to her, but she was a great one grandmother.
- 18:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so that helped the healing process.
- 18:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she said, if I hadn't done that, I was carrying so much anger that I never could have moved on.
- 18:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: And and I did.
- 19:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: So, and there was only about 20% of the people we talked to who had those kind of relationships, but every single one of those 20% said that was the only conversation they needed.
- 19:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: The rest were not important to them.
- 19:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: They said wow, that was it.
- 19:13Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then we um did another study down the road, um study three, so I've skipped two, I'll come back to two in a minute, but we found a sixth theme.
- 19:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because when I was doing interviews, which was the first study, you have to let the conversations and the themes emerge.
- 19:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: I can't do leading questions.
- 19:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: I can't say, because I knew all the research said people want to talk about what they want, you know, their their final wishes, or what kind of treatment or care they want, why a living will is really important.
- 19:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, what I do with the house, or, you know, lots of to do things.
- 19:47Dr. Maureen Keeley: And not one single person I interviewed talked about it.
- 19:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: But when we asked about it in a survey, because the survey is a quantitative study, and I can ask all sorts of questions based on research from other academics in other Studies.
- 20:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: So, like all the studies about dying, they said that was one of the most important conversations.
- 20:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: One of the most, you know, but for the people who are memorable, yeah, yeah, that's a to-do list.
- 20:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: But what's memorable is you tell me you love me.
- 20:10Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 20:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: What's memorable is that hug, those hugs we had every day.
- 20:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know.
- 20:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: So it it did emerge.
- 20:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: We have a sixth theme that I did not know for a while.
- 20:19Dr. Maureen Keeley: I thought was there, but I couldn't prove it until we did the quantitative study.
- 20:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: And that one, um, we called it academically instrumental death talk.
- 20:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: And in the book, we call it taking care of the business of death and dying.
- 20:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, so the whole idea is yes, what are their final wishes?
- 20:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: Do they have a living will?
- 20:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, do they want what what do they want for the memorial service?
- 20:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: Do they want a memorial service?
- 20:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, I had some people, um, their spouses, if they did all the bills, told them, here are all the passwords, here are when you have to pay the bills, you know, or here's who you call when the hot water heater goes out, you know.
- 20:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I even had some people tell me that they found notes from their loved ones after the person died because they had left them all these notes about how to do things.
- 21:01Judy Oskam: Yes, yeah, I love that.
- 21:02Judy Oskam: And so that's important too.
- 21:03Judy Oskam: It is important, it is important.
- 21:05Judy Oskam: Well, and as far as the research then, was there anything that surprised you that really you found surprising that you didn't know from your firsthand experience and your experience as a as a uh you know communication expert and a scholar?
- 21:19Judy Oskam: Is there anything that surprised you?
- 21:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, it all surprised me.
- 21:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 21:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because when I was looking for answers, but you lived through it though.
- 21:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: But I didn't have any answers, and I didn't I didn't know how to organize it or to make sense of it.
- 21:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: Got it.
- 21:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: I just when my mom died, I realized I can breathe, and I didn't think I'd be able to breathe.
- 21:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: I was really close with my mother and I didn't know if I had done it right or if I'd done it well.
- 21:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: I have a PhD in interpersonal communication, and if I don't know if I'm doing it right, what what did anyone else know?
- 21:48Dr. Maureen Keeley: But after I did that first study, I go, Oh my gosh, my dad read my first book, and my dad's not a big reader.
- 21:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: My dad died about three years ago, and he said, Maureen, we did this right.
- 21:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: He goes, Look, we we had all these conversations.
- 22:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, he goes, I didn't know.
- 22:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: So you don't know what you don't know until you know it.
- 22:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: Exactly.
- 22:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or you find out what you didn't know.
- 22:08Judy Oskam: Exactly.
- 22:09Judy Oskam: Um the everyday talk surprised me.
- 22:12Judy Oskam: Yeah, I that really surprised me too because I I kind of missed the boat on some of my earlier final conversation stuff with my dad.
- 22:21Judy Oskam: I I wished I had done things differently there, and I think he probably would have too.
- 22:26Judy Oskam: But the everyday talk is interesting.
- 22:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: You have new meaning for it, don't you now?
- 22:32Judy Oskam: A new frame.
- 22:33Judy Oskam: Now I have a new frame of reference.
- 22:35Judy Oskam: And for the listeners to understand that everyday talk, for you to operationalize that and really understand how vital it is, it's everything from just would you like coffee or can we sit down and have a chat before we watch our Netflix series or something.
- 22:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: Or watching your favorite sports team or the politics and get into a discussion about politics if you enjoy that.
- 22:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: I don't encourage that one.
- 23:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: But you know, and it and it's it's it's it's what first it helps create the relationship, but it's what maintains relationships.
- 23:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: It's and it's oh, telling stories and jokes and laughing at the same show or watching your favorite movie again.
- 23:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, it's it can be anything that's everyday to you.
- 23:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: I had um uh this one young man who a friend was dying, and they're they were like family to him, and she loved going out on the water.
- 23:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: So he would take her out on the boat as long as she could.
- 23:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, and they would just drive around the lake, and he said, We talked about everything and nothing, and it was all so important, and none of it was important in that moment.
- 23:37Judy Oskam: And that's a good point.
- 23:38Judy Oskam: Everything but nothing.
- 23:39Judy Oskam: You're really talking about things that you might not think are so impactful, but they really do.
- 23:44Dr. Maureen Keeley: What can I define final conversations for people?
- 23:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, please.
- 23:47Dr. Maureen Keeley: So it sounds like it's a common term now, and maybe it is.
- 23:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, no one had talked about it.
- 23:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: Everyone, if you ever heard the word final conversation, they thought it was the last message they had.
- 23:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: If it's the last message, you're not getting a whole lot of talking because people's bodies break down and most of it's non-verbal at that end.
- 24:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: How I defined final conversations for all four studies was any and every conversation that you have from the moment of a terminal diagnosis or old age, and you can see the person deteriorating to the moment they died.
- 24:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: And the sooner you start the conversations and the more frequent you have these conversations, the more you'll have to hang on to in the memories of them.
- 24:25Dr. Maureen Keeley: And if you wait until the last day, last hours, they may be unconscious.
- 24:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so it'll be a one-way conversation.
- 24:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: I still think they're important, and I think that they still hear it and it will make you feel better than if you hadn't had it.
- 24:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: And you know, I used to I used to say, I just want to die fast, you know, and in my sleep, I don't want to know I'm gonna die, and I don't want to know my loved one's gonna die.
- 24:48Dr. Maureen Keeley: I don't say that anymore because the biggest regret I've heard from people are who don't have a chance to have a good goodbye.
- 24:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: And they find out their loved ones died and they go, I didn't get to say goodbye.
- 24:58Judy Oskam: Ah, okay.
- 24:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so here's your chance to say goodbye.
- 25:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: Here's a chance to say anything or everything you ever might want to say because it pops up.
- 25:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: So there's no regrets.
- 25:09Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so when my mom died, I was exhausted because I had a baby I was taking care of, that baby's now 28.
- 25:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, you know, and I had, you know, working full time was going back and forth between my teaching at the university and flying home to Arizona to take care of my mom during any breaks.
- 25:25Dr. Maureen Keeley: Was I didn't have any regrets.
- 25:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: There's nothing left to say to her.
- 25:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, and sometimes you just repeat yourself, which is great.
- 25:34Judy Oskam: Oh yeah.
- 25:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: To say I love you a million times, great.
- 25:36Judy Oskam: Exactly.
- 25:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: But no regrets.
- 25:37Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 25:37Judy Oskam: Well, and you you you and your co-author mentioned that in the book.
- 25:41Judy Oskam: You talk about say I love you as many times as you can, just say it.
- 25:45Judy Oskam: Even if they might not you don't think they're gonna hear it, right?
- 25:49Judy Oskam: Hearing it is our last ones to go.
- 25:51Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 25:52Judy Oskam: Well, and that's I learned a lot about that from your research, the the death process.
- 25:59Judy Oskam: I mean, I really had never been around someone when they were dying.
- 26:03Judy Oskam: So I really learned a lot about that to really combine with some of the conversation, but we we really implemented some of the the um oral information, you know, really uh because we turned on the music that my dad loved.
- 26:19Judy Oskam: He loved a Norwegian singer.
- 26:22Judy Oskam: So we turned the music on, we talked to him, we told him it's okay, you're you're okay, we got it, we'll take care of mom, don't worry.
- 26:29Judy Oskam: We really used a lot, and I'm assuming he heard us.
- 26:33Judy Oskam: I I know he heard us, but I really learned a lot from that first book, and I am learning a lot from this book as well because I'm right in the middle of this with my mom.
- 26:43Judy Oskam: She's 94.
- 26:44Judy Oskam: And um, she's we're going for a hundred, but you never know.
- 26:50Judy Oskam: But you never know.
- 26:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: So again, I really found that the everyday uh what's been the reaction uh the first book um won three National Book of the Year awards.
- 27:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and our publisher, who was an independent publisher, small publisher, believed in sending books out for awards.
- 27:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: That was wonderful.
- 27:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um and I've had so many people who read the book and said the both books, but said, I never would have known how to do this or I would have been too afraid to do this without reading this.
- 27:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because this book is written in an everyday voice.
- 27:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Exactly.
- 27:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: And you're a nerd because you also looked up the academic article.
- 27:23Judy Oskam: I did, I did.
- 27:24Judy Oskam: But I also went back to the other book and I it really helped me.
- 27:28Judy Oskam: And this is written, everybody can benefit from this book.
- 27:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: Well, this book is different than oh, can I give a quick tip?
- 27:34Judy Oskam: Yeah, yeah, please.
- 27:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: Play the music.
- 27:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: My mother loved music, so we had music on, her favorite music, you know, at a low level so it wasn't disturbing to her.
- 27:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she also loved candlelight.
- 27:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: So we had candlelight music.
- 27:44Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, candlelights, candles on?
- 27:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, we put one on the oxygen tank with a sign on the door saying, no smoking, please.
- 27:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I had an uncle who was there with his wife, my aunt, who was her sister, helping take care.
- 27:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he was going around trying to talk to my brothers who are firefighters, my sisters who are nurses, and I was like, Yeah, mom loves candlelight.
- 28:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: Mom loves candlelight.
- 28:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: He finally went up to one of them who finally listened to him and said, I said, Is it good to have a candle on the oxygen tank?
- 28:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: And we all went, No, oh my God, we could have blown us all up.
- 28:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: So don't put candlelight.
- 28:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: That's right.
- 28:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: Do the fake ones now.
- 28:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: They have a fake ones.
- 28:19Judy Oskam: They have really good, good fake ones now.
- 28:20Judy Oskam: That's true.
- 28:21Judy Oskam: That was true.
- 28:22Judy Oskam: That's true.
- 28:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: But but this book, um, this second book that just came out in June, is really the culmination of twenty over 20 years of research.
- 28:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: And not only does it highlight all six themes, um, and they're more succinct, they're tighter chapters, um, because our publisher Hay House wanted it only so many words.
- 28:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: We cut 40,000 words out of this book.
- 28:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh my gosh.
- 28:45Judy Oskam: Wow.
- 28:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: It's almost another book.
- 28:47Judy Oskam: Sure.
- 28:47Dr. Maureen Keeley: But um, we also talk about what are the advantages and benefits of having these final conversations.
- 28:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: We talk about the challenges um of these final conversations.
- 28:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: We talk about culture.
- 28:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: We didn't, I didn't I didn't find out about culture until the third or fourth study, yeah, um, which was a quantitative study.
- 29:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um so that was important.
- 29:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it's not specific about any one culture, it's more generalized about differences in culture.
- 29:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, there's a chapter in here called Beyond Words that's nonverbal.
- 29:15Judy Oskam: I I love that chapter because it really gives you some ideas for what you could do that would really make a big impact.
- 29:23Judy Oskam: Yeah, you know, and visually as well, you know.
- 29:26Judy Oskam: I think there's I just know that I just know, you know, in my situation, just a hug and really makes a difference.
- 29:34Judy Oskam: And it's just it's just really timely for me.
- 29:38Judy Oskam: So I really appreciate it.
- 29:40Dr. Maureen Keeley: Well, and spending that time, you're busy, Judy.
- 29:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, I know.
- 29:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I know, but because you understand this, you're making the time to go be with her.
- 29:47Judy Oskam: I'm I'm gonna do it better.
- 29:49Judy Oskam: Yeah, I'm gonna do it better because I I'm like you.
- 29:51Judy Oskam: And you know, my brother and I have both said we don't we don't want to have any regrets.
- 29:55Judy Oskam: We want to leave it all on the table, you know, leave it all on the field.
- 29:58Judy Oskam: We want to do everything we can to make her life, you know, recognize and let her exit with dignity.
- 30:07Judy Oskam: Um peace, but it also comes back to us.
- 30:12Judy Oskam: Talk a little bit more about that because how did that help you individually?
- 30:17Judy Oskam: Because you were very busy too.
- 30:19Judy Oskam: You were going through the same thing I'm going through right now.
- 30:21Judy Oskam: But with a baby, but with a baby, with a baby, and a and a husband.
- 30:25Judy Oskam: And a husband, yes.
- 30:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Well, we talked about that um in chapter 10.
- 30:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: We talked about so what are the benefits?
- 30:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: What did I get out of it?
- 30:32Judy Oskam: Yeah, yeah.
- 30:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: Acceptance that that this is going to happen and I can't do anything to control it.
- 30:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: And when you see somebody you love deteriorating and it's hard, yeah.
- 30:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: But you see them accepting that they're going to die and they're okay with it, and they're actually as it they get closer, they get more at peace with it.
- 30:48Dr. Maureen Keeley: Not all, but most people get more at peace with it.
- 30:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: And if my mom could accept her death, then I could why shouldn't we?
- 30:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: And why and why would I want to watch her in pain any longer than she had already been?
- 30:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, for sure.
- 30:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: So acceptance, for sure, closure, nothing left in said, but closure takes time.
- 31:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, because you think you've you've closed it, and then a window opens, and there's something else you want to say.
- 31:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 31:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: So closure.
- 31:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um coping.
- 31:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: I learned how to cope.
- 31:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, I learned how to become more vulnerable.
- 31:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: I n was a witness to my mother's strength and to her peace at the end of life.
- 31:20Judy Oskam: I love that.
- 31:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, I saw that she didn't have any regrets either.
- 31:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: And we helped her heal some wounds so that she was able to pass over . .
- 32:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: By the way, don't preach at them.
- 32:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: This was an invited talk.
- 32:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: You cannot preach your belief system at your loved one.
- 32:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, sometimes my sisters and I would have this side conversation, um, and my mom would listen.
- 32:24Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she'd be in the room.
- 32:25Dr. Maureen Keeley: She'd be in the room, and she wanted to hear it.
- 32:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: She wanted us to talk about it.
- 32:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, she just didn't want us preaching at her, and we did not.
- 32:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and then what I didn't find out to the very the fourth study was personal growth.
- 32:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: How important, what what can how am I growing from this experience?
- 32:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: But you do.
- 32:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yes, you do.
- 32:44Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so one, it you see how you can relate to others and help them.
- 32:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: You find out maybe there's new possibilities for you to do, like that mother who went back to school.
- 32:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 32:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: Others changed careers, um, some um had no idea their own personal strength until they saw what they went through with their loved one who was dying, or because that person they loved told them about their personal strength and then they noticed in other parts of their life.
- 33:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, some had a s a spiritual change, um, or maybe a renewed faith in their religion, or just a larger grasp of spiritual beliefs systems.
- 33:21Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 33:22Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and then they also walked away from the experience with an appreciation for life.
- 33:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: That life is short and what do I want to do with my life now?
- 33:32Judy Oskam: I love that.
- 33:33Judy Oskam: I love that because I think when when you lose somebody, you do relish what you have, you know.
- 33:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: I I thought I would find out that grief was eased.
- 33:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: I did not find that answer in the in the surveys.
- 33:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I don't know if I asked the question wrong.
- 33:48Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, because from my personal experience, I still had grief.
- 33:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: Grief is grief.
- 33:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: You love someone who dies, you're gonna feel that grief.
- 33:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: But mine didn't last as deep or as long as I thought it would.
- 34:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um but I didn't ask that question.
- 34:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: But I did realize that grief is grief.
- 34:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: When you love somebody, any amount of conversation is gonna take away that grief.
- 34:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: You're still gonna have it.
- 34:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: Sure.
- 34:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: It may change what it would have looked like, but you don't know now because you've had the final conversation.
- 34:12Judy Oskam: Yeah, I love that.
- 34:13Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, those kinds of things.
- 34:14Judy Oskam: Um what else?
- 34:16Judy Oskam: Well, and you guys also uh talk about the spiritual part of this, and that and did you hear about some of that in your study from your uh participants about signs, and I'm fascinated by that.
- 34:30Judy Oskam: Talk about that if you will.
- 34:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: Well, it came up a number of different ways.
- 34:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: One, it came up with the first study in and adults telling us about those experiences.
- 34:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: And some of those adults were children when they lost someone, and that made me want to do the second study, which was talking to children from five to seventeen.
- 34:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: And some of them, you could hear them parroting their parents' beliefs.
- 34:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: Oh, my father said he's going to go prepare a home in heaven for us.
- 34:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, another one, a little girl was dying from cancer, and she got in a fight with her brother, and they were arguing about what the streets of heaven, what the what the roads look like.
- 35:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she thought he thought they were covered in gold, and she said, no, they're ruby, ruby red like my slippers.
- 35:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: She was a dancer.
- 35:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then so they, you know, they talked about their own with what their own beliefs, and that comforted both of them.
- 35:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um and so we heard lots of beautiful stories like that.
- 35:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: But then um, oh actually, I did a fifth study.
- 35:24Judy Oskam: Oh I did a fifth study.
- 35:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Of course you did, but it was a smaller one.
- 35:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: But this was the one that talks about um the chapter that talks about the conversations continue.
- 35:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I had so many people in the first study talk about this, but I was I was a tenured associate professor and I wanted to be a full professor.
- 35:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I thought it sounded a little woo-woo.
- 35:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: I love the woo-woo.
- 35:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: Bring it.
- 35:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: So I didn't want to talk about it in the first book, and I didn't, I hadn't we hadn't set it up to so that I could really do it.
- 35:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: But this one, I did a specific study just asking people have you had any experiences where you feel like your loved one is reaching across and sending you a sign or talking to you?
- 36:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: And wow, I got some great stories from those.
- 36:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: And some were um typical signs you hear, um, butterflies or um red jays or bluebirds, or you know, what or um dragonflies.
- 36:19Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um are just finding uh angel's feather, you know, or for others it's a penny.
- 36:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 36:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um one mother, her her little boy died.
- 36:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she said, you know, they were just so grief stricken.
- 36:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um, they started finding signs from him.
- 36:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: Like one day she went looking in a in a high cabinet to to get something to to mix, you know, a special dessert or something.
- 36:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um and she saw a card in there, and so she pulls it out.
- 36:51Dr. Maureen Keeley: It was a card in his handwriting.
- 36:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: She had never seen it before, saying, Mommy, I love you.
- 36:58Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 36:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 36:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then that same mother talked about how her husband went um out to fix their mailbox or something.
- 37:06Dr. Maureen Keeley: It was broken.
- 37:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so he's having to dig it up and he's cursing and he's frustrated.
- 37:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: He goes, I wish I had another hand.
- 37:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then um he looks down and sees those little army men, it's missing a hand.
- 37:18Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 37:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then he finds the hand and he started laughing.
- 37:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: He said, 'cause and his son loved these toys.
- 37:22Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 37:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Never played near the mailbox with these toys.
- 37:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: And there was that.
- 37:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: So she kept finding all these signs.
- 37:29Dr. Maureen Keeley: Some people would walk into a room and they often smell um the cigar that their grandfather smoked, or the the favorite flower that uh their mother loved and the perfume she would wear.
- 37:41Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, some have got messages in dreams.
- 37:44Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 37:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: So um Colleen was in the middle of a dream, and all of a sudden her mom was there.
- 37:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she said, Mom, what are you doing here in this dream?
- 37:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: You're not supposed to be here.
- 37:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: She said, No, I'm not, but I could finally get to you.
- 38:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: I've been trying to get to you.
- 38:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: I just need you to know I love you, and I will always be here when you need me.
- 38:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: So and then the mom was gone.
- 38:10Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 38:11Judy Oskam: Oh my god.
- 38:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: You know, and I had lots of people talk about their dreams too.
- 38:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: It was and and they said, But it wasn't a dream.
- 38:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: They said, I know somebody's gonna say it was just a dream, it was not a dream.
- 38:19Dr. Maureen Keeley: I felt their presence.
- 38:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: One woman um had moved into her grandmother's grandparents' house and they were remodeling.
- 38:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so all you could smell was paint and fresh paint, and you know, they'd gotten rid of all the old stuff.
- 38:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then she woke up in the middle of the night one night and she said, It's she smelled like the old house.
- 38:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she sees her grandparents standing at the foot of the bed, and they're just smiling at her and shaking their head, yes.
- 38:42Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then they were gone, and then the smell was gone.
- 38:45Dr. Maureen Keeley: And she said she thinks it was just them coming to give their approval of how happy they were that she was living there with her new family in the house.
- 38:51Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh, I love that.
- 38:53Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 38:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: So if that doesn't, if those kinds of experiences don't expand your spirituality, I don't know what way.
- 38:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: I know, I know.
- 38:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: But also how comforting.
- 39:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: Exactly.
- 39:01Dr. Maureen Keeley: In my office at here at the university, you know, I have a doorstop.
- 39:05Dr. Maureen Keeley: And almost every time I'm in my office, um, all of a sudden the door moves the doorstop about two feet.
- 39:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: And I just laugh.
- 39:16Dr. Maureen Keeley: I go, hi, mom, thanks for visiting.
- 39:18Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because I think that's my mother.
- 39:19Dr. Maureen Keeley: Exactly.
- 39:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: And well, I I won't know the answer about that till I get to heaven, but that's right.
- 39:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: But I believe it so for me, it's my reality.
- 39:26Judy Oskam: Exactly.
- 39:26Judy Oskam: Well, and my mom, her favorite thing is butterflies.
- 39:30Judy Oskam: And I know whether she did that strategically to plant that in my head, that everywhere I see butterflies, I know it's gonna be her.
- 39:38Judy Oskam: Yes.
- 39:38Judy Oskam: And so we she has butterfly pictures all over the house, and there's they're everywhere, and that's sort of her thing.
- 39:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: I hope you keep your favorite one and put it in your house.
- 39:48Judy Oskam: I know, I think I will.
- 39:49Judy Oskam: Well, there's so many I could choose from, but I think that's what a smart as a mother to plant that idea.
- 39:53Judy Oskam: To plant that idea.
- 39:54Judy Oskam: Whether she did that on purpose or not, but I just think it's there are ways that.
- 39:59Judy Oskam: We can kind of use this information, and this is all research-based.
- 40:03Judy Oskam: It also research-based.
- 40:04Judy Oskam: But then also trust your intuition, there's a knowing.
- 40:06Judy Oskam: Exactly.
- 40:07Dr. Maureen Keeley: So there's a woman in the book named Susu, and her husband died of very quickly of lung cancer, like within four weeks of being diagnosed, and it should have been more like two, but he was on, he was intimated about 10 days.
- 40:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: Anyway, um, right as they're about to to unplug him, right?
- 40:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Because he's b fully breathing on the machine, not him.
- 40:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: And his brother leans down and said, Brother, you need to show me a sign so that I know what to look for.
- 40:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: So come back to me.
- 40:35Dr. Maureen Keeley: So that same day, they go back to the house.
- 40:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: And supposedly the dying can stick around for a few days if they want to to kind of get their you know balance.
- 40:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and he's out back, and this butterfly lands on his beer can.
- 40:52unknown: Oh my god.
- 40:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: And stays there for like a minute or two minutes and doesn't leave.
- 40:56Dr. Maureen Keeley: And he's laughing.
- 40:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: The brother goes, Ah, brother, I never thought you'd be a butterfly, but okay, thank you.
- 41:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then that same butterfly, the door opens, flies into the house, and lands on the fan, and it goes round and round and round.
- 41:09Dr. Maureen Keeley: And they're watching this butterfly in the house.
- 41:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: Butterflies don't fly into houses.
- 41:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then came back and flew on his wife's hand.
- 41:15Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 41:15Dr. Maureen Keeley: And stayed on her hand for about a minute.
- 41:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then the door opened again and the butterfly flew out.
- 41:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: And this same woman and her grown sons um talk about this time they were driving somewhere, either to her family or his family in either east or west Texas.
- 41:30Dr. Maureen Keeley: They get swarmed by a swarm of butterflies.
- 41:32Dr. Maureen Keeley: The car swarmed them.
- 41:34Dr. Maureen Keeley: And they go, Well, I guess dad's on the road with us.
- 41:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 41:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then left.
- 41:38Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, it wasn't dangerous, but it was butterflies all the time.
- 41:41Judy Oskam: Butterflies.
- 41:42Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 41:43Judy Oskam: Oh my gosh.
- 41:44Judy Oskam: Dr.
- 41:44Judy Oskam: Keeley, this is such fascinating work.
- 41:46Judy Oskam: Uh, any last-minute tips you would give to uh readers and listeners?
- 41:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yes.
- 41:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: A couple.
- 41:54Dr. Maureen Keeley: One is please tell your children sooner.
- 41:56unknown: Yes.
- 41:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: I understand if they're little, little, yeah, um, but they are watching how quiet the house has gotten.
- 42:04Dr. Maureen Keeley: They know that the routine is disturbed, they know there's hushes and secrets going on.
- 42:09Dr. Maureen Keeley: So do you need to tell them and use- Be open.
- 42:11Dr. Maureen Keeley: Be open and use real words.
- 42:12Dr. Maureen Keeley: Don't say mommy's gone to sleep.
- 42:14Dr. Maureen Keeley: Then they're gonna think mommy's gonna wake up and they're not.
- 42:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: So say mommy has died, and explain what that means.
- 42:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: And teenagers absolutely know what's going on, but from five up, they need to know what's going on.
- 42:25Dr. Maureen Keeley: So please be honest.
- 42:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: There's a couple chapters in here, one's called Out of the Mouth of Babes, and they give you all the things.
- 42:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: So it's it's how to talk to those who are dying, and they're also giving advice to those who are dying, how to talk to the children.
- 42:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, children were they're brilliant.
- 42:39Dr. Maureen Keeley: And then um, we also talked about um I think it's important to realize it's not easy.
- 42:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: We're I'm not trying to sugarcoat this.
- 42:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: It will be hard.
- 42:49Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah, some of the hardest things you can do.
- 42:51Judy Oskam: Yes.
- 42:52Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um and it's hard because there's obstacles to having good final conversations.
- 42:57Dr. Maureen Keeley: So, like, you need to have some privacy.
- 42:59Dr. Maureen Keeley: So every person deserves one-on-one time with them.
- 43:02Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, sometimes there's you think there's topics to be avoided because they're taboo in your family.
- 43:08Dr. Maureen Keeley: That's up to you to decide.
- 43:10Judy Oskam: Yeah.
- 43:10Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um sometimes you suppress emotions because we don't cry in this family, or I'm not gonna cry in front of my mom because then it'll make her cry or make her feel worse.
- 43:17Dr. Maureen Keeley: It's okay to cry.
- 43:20Dr. Maureen Keeley: And it's okay to laugh.
- 43:21Dr. Maureen Keeley: It's okay to show emotions.
- 43:23Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um try to give yourself as much time, which means showing up as much as you can.
- 43:27Dr. Maureen Keeley: If you can't show up, then do make the FaceTime or the phone call.
- 43:31Dr. Maureen Keeley: That was better than nothing at all.
- 43:33Dr. Maureen Keeley: Understand the health areas is going to slow things down.
- 43:36Dr. Maureen Keeley: So, like my father had dementia.
- 43:37Dr. Maureen Keeley: And so I made sure I had these conversations way earlier when he still could understand them.
- 43:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: Yeah.
- 43:43Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and not wait until they no longer could connect with you.
- 43:46Dr. Maureen Keeley: Um, and then sometimes we all all have our own individual hangups.
- 43:50Dr. Maureen Keeley: And our very last chapter just talks about how you can do it too.
- 43:53Dr. Maureen Keeley: I mean, you're talking to two communication professors.
- 43:55Dr. Maureen Keeley: We've been doing this a combined 65 years.
- 43:57Judy Oskam: Yeah, right.
- 43:58Dr. Maureen Keeley: I'm an expert in interpersonal communication.
- 44:00Dr. Maureen Keeley: She was an expert in communication across the lifespan.
- 44:03Dr. Maureen Keeley: And um, so we have kind of a to-do list of how to help you.
- 44:08Judy Oskam: It's a great book.
- 44:08Judy Oskam: And simple.
- 44:09Judy Oskam: It's simple, it's doable.
- 44:11Judy Oskam: It, I wish I'd had this in 2017, but I had your other book, so that was helpful.
- 44:16Judy Oskam: So I think this is such a great resource, such a great tool.
- 44:19Judy Oskam: Thank you for joining me today.
- 44:21Judy Oskam: Such important information.
- 44:22Judy Oskam: Thank you so much.
- 44:23Judy Oskam: I'm gonna do a TED talk on this in February.
- 44:25Judy Oskam: Oh, that's right.
- 44:25Judy Oskam: I love that.
- 44:26Judy Oskam: I'll be there.
- 44:26Dr. Maureen Keeley: Uh happy gonna be there.
- 44:28Dr. Maureen Keeley: Thank you for having me, and thank you for believing in my research all these years.
- 44:31Judy Oskam: And oh well.
- 44:32Judy Oskam: And I'm glad it's helped you.
- 44:33Judy Oskam: Super helpful.
- 44:34Judy Oskam: And again, I know it can help so many others.
- 44:36Judy Oskam: Thank you.
- 44:37Judy Oskam: Thank you.
- 44:38Judy Oskam: And thank you for joining us.
- 44:40Judy Oskam: Dr.
- 44:40Judy Oskam: Keeley made it clear there isn't a perfect final conversation, and there doesn't have to be.
- 44:47Judy Oskam: What matters is showing up in whatever ways you can.
- 44:51Judy Oskam: Sometimes that looks like meaningful words, sometimes it's just being in the room.
- 44:57Judy Oskam: One of my biggest takeaways is that these moments aren't only for the person who is dying, they're also for the people who remain.
- 45:06Judy Oskam: We carry these conversations with us.
- 45:09Judy Oskam: And maybe the more we make space, the better for both parties.
- 45:13Judy Oskam: Well, thank you for listening to Stories of Change and Creativity.
- 45:17Judy Oskam: If you found this episode helpful, please share it with someone who may need it and consider leaving a review.
- 45:24Judy Oskam: It truly helps more listeners find the show.
- 45:27Judy Oskam: Thanks for listening.