Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Steve Greenfield on Profitability, Tariffs, and AI in Auto Retail
Transcript
- 0:06Announcer: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:11Jim Fitzpatrick: Hey everyone, Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Welcome into another edition of Inside Automotive right here at CBTnews.com.
- 0:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Innovation in the auto industry shows no signs of slowing down, as many of you know.
- 0:20Jim Fitzpatrick: Few people have a better pulse on these trends than our next guest.
- 0:25Jim Fitzpatrick: You know him well.
- 0:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Joining us in the studio is Mr.
- 0:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Steve Greenfield, CEO and founder of Automotive Ventures and host of the Future of Automotive right here at the CBT Automotive Network.
- 0:35Jim Fitzpatrick: We're so happy to have him in the studio.
- 0:36Jim Fitzpatrick: This guy's all over the world.
- 0:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Steve's constantly on the move meeting with innovators across the globe.
- 0:41Jim Fitzpatrick: He's here to share what's hot, what's not, what we should be focused on, some maybe some new innovations out there that we need to keep an eye on as well.
- 0:49Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Steve, what a pleasure to have you in the studio.
- 0:51Steve Greenfield: This is always great.
- 0:52Steve Greenfield: Always great to be here.
- 0:53Steve Greenfield: So thank you for having me.
- 0:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, we appreciate all of the content that you give to our viewers over probably the last five or six years now, right?
- 0:59Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean it's been it's been fantastic.
- 1:00Jim Fitzpatrick: So we appreciate it, and I know they appreciate it.
- 1:03Jim Fitzpatrick: So let's kind of jump right in here from your perspective, and as I mentioned, you're all over the globe.
- 1:07Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, you're you're an international guy now, right?
- 1:09Jim Fitzpatrick: So uh and you've got your hands, as I said, on the pulse of all things.
- 1:13Jim Fitzpatrick: How would you describe the overall state of automotive retail today?
- 1:17Steve Greenfield: Yeah, well, it's been resilient, right?
- 1:18Steve Greenfield: I mean, I think you look at the beginning of the year, a lot of people were concerned with the tariffs, so the SAAR would get a big hit.
- 1:24Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 1:24Steve Greenfield: And for whatever reason, consumers continue to buy.
- 1:26Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 1:26Steve Greenfield: I think a lot of that is because of the convenience and the the um the opportunity that dealers provide.
- 1:33Steve Greenfield: You think of dealers?
- 1:34Steve Greenfield: Dealers will sell.
- 1:35Steve Greenfield: You give them cars, they will sell cars.
- 1:37Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, right.
- 1:38Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 1:38Steve Greenfield: And the the production has continued, yeah, and dealers have been able to sell.
- 1:41Steve Greenfield: I think tariffs have largely affect the OEMs so far.
- 1:44Steve Greenfield: They've absorbed the losses, they haven't passed them through to the dealer, right?
- 1:48Steve Greenfield: And only a few of them have really uh represented that in a higher MSRP.
- 1:51Steve Greenfield: Sure.
- 1:52Steve Greenfield: What happens next year?
- 1:52Steve Greenfield: I don't know, but I cut up with Jonathan Smoke from Cox Automotive yesterday.
- 1:56Steve Greenfield: He feels yes next year is gonna be a good year as well.
- 1:58Steve Greenfield: Okay, you know, solid, not a record-breaking year from a SAARS standpoint, but pretty resilient.
- 2:02Steve Greenfield: And there is an upside as well next year, depending on the economy.
- 2:05Steve Greenfield: So I think that um it's been good for dealers.
- 2:07Steve Greenfield: Yeah, you know, they continue to be profitable, not as profitable as 2022.
- 2:10Jim Fitzpatrick: No, no, no.
- 2:11Jim Fitzpatrick: But that was a high water market-
- 2:12Steve Greenfield: But more profitable than pre-COVID still.
- 2:14Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 2:14Steve Greenfield: And they figure out ways to run their operations with less cost, which is great.
- 2:18Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 2:18Steve Greenfield: Cost discipline has been contained through.
- 2:21Steve Greenfield: And I think that um luckily enough, the consumer keeps buying cars and servicing their cars.
- 2:25Steve Greenfield: So for the time being, we've got to really keep a close eye on consumer confidence, but for the time being, things are good in dealer land.
- 2:30Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 2:31Jim Fitzpatrick: And I think since COVID, would you agree that dealers are like, hey, if we don't hit 17 and a half million SAAR or chase 18 million, you know, one day or whatever, is not that doesn't matter to us.
- 2:41Jim Fitzpatrick: It's all about now how much money we can make out of our dealership.
- 2:44Jim Fitzpatrick: And if it's on less cars and we hold stronger gross profits, then so be it, right?
- 2:49Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 2:49Steve Greenfield: I mean, Kevin Tynan, who you know quite well, is now over at Presidio, he he really articulates this better than I've seen any any other analyst.
- 2:56Steve Greenfield: And the fact that with MSRP inflation, now that the average new car is 50 grand, when you multiply that by 16 million, the actual value of cars that we're selling is much more than it was ever in the past.
- 3:07Steve Greenfield: True.
- 3:08Steve Greenfield: So while we fixate on SAAR, but remember SAAR was at a $30,000 car.
- 3:13Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 3:13Steve Greenfield: Right pre-COVID.
- 3:14Steve Greenfield: Now we're at a $50,000 car.
- 3:15Steve Greenfield: Multiply that by $16 million or whatever we're running at.
- 3:18Steve Greenfield: And actually the value of cars, which means dealers' opportunity to get gross margin off that value of cars is higher.
- 3:24Steve Greenfield: The OEMs are actually calculated.
- 3:26Steve Greenfield: OEMs are less fixated on number of cars and more on total revenue.
- 3:30Steve Greenfield: Right.
- 3:30Steve Greenfield: That's what Wall Street wants.
- 3:31Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 3:31Steve Greenfield: And how much margin you can make off that revenue.
- 3:33Steve Greenfield: So I think you know, we are fixated so much on SAAR, and that isn't necessarily the way.
- 3:37Steve Greenfield: And Kevin was the one that really opened my eyes to that.
- 3:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it's a good point.
- 3:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, that's a good point.
- 3:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it really is, no question about it.
- 3:42Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, you got a front row seat on all these emerging technologies, obviously, with with your with your company.
- 3:49Jim Fitzpatrick: You're looking at these companies, you're investing in some of them around the world, and and uh what what what's new in the way of innovations and some of the trends that you see out there?
- 3:57Jim Fitzpatrick: And what what what are the ones that you're keeping your eye on?
- 3:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Or maybe investing in.
- 4:00Steve Greenfield: Yeah, sure.
- 4:01Steve Greenfield: So so uh as you see in the press, everything is all AI all the time.
- 4:04Steve Greenfield: I I do worry that you know dealers are already getting numb to that.
- 4:08Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 4:08Steve Greenfield: And you know, everyone's got some AI widget for their selling.
- 4:11Steve Greenfield: By NADA, every single booth is gonna have something AI related.
- 4:14Steve Greenfield: And dealers aren't gonna be able to discern between them, right?
- 4:17Steve Greenfield: So but I think it is interesting.
- 4:19Steve Greenfield: There are some interesting use cases.
- 4:20Steve Greenfield: I think the most powerful one we've seen out of the gate is just phone answering.
- 4:24Steve Greenfield: Yeah, there's a number of these companies out there, dealers can literally never miss a call again during working hours and after hours.
- 4:30Steve Greenfield: And the dealers I've talked to said these are well worth the money they're paying because now it's my first line of defense.
- 4:36Steve Greenfield: And a younger generation of folks, not us, but a younger generation, are now used to not getting a human on the call anyway.
- 4:42Steve Greenfield: They might prefer not talking to a human.
- 4:45Steve Greenfield: I want to get through to Delta and talk to someone, but a lot of younger people I don't think do.
- 4:49Steve Greenfield: And you know, AI now is getting smart enough to take the in-bound calls.
- 4:52Steve Greenfield: What gets me really excited will be phase two of that, where where they can mine the CRM.
- 4:57Steve Greenfield: And like, you know, I've got a BMW out here in the parking lot.
- 5:00Steve Greenfield: Uh last time I was in for service was two years ago, I hate to say that, and they rolled me up for a $3,000 job.
- 5:06Steve Greenfield: How many times do you think that BMW dealership in Atlanta?
- 5:09Steve Greenfield: I won't name the one.
- 5:10Steve Greenfield: Right, right.
- 5:10Steve Greenfield: There's only a couple has contacted me.
- 5:13Steve Greenfield: Hey Steve, um, I'm a little concerned.
- 5:15Steve Greenfield: I haven't seen you come back in for that $3,000 job.
- 5:18Steve Greenfield: We'd love to have you back in.
- 5:19Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 5:20Steve Greenfield: In two years, not once.
- 5:20Steve Greenfield: Not one, not once.
- 5:21Steve Greenfield: Not once.
- 5:22Steve Greenfield: Wow.
- 5:22Steve Greenfield: And this is a sophisticated owner, I can tell you.
- 5:24Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 5:25Steve Greenfield: Um, but you know, I so I think there's all kinds of opportunities.
- 5:27Steve Greenfield: AI should be harvesting, mining the CRM, finding opportunities like that, right, and um plucking them out and then figuring out how I want to engage text, email, phone calls, whatever it is.
- 5:38Steve Greenfield: And they make it really easy for me to say, yeah, I want to get that $3,000 job done.
- 5:43Jim Fitzpatrick: Of course.
- 5:43Steve Greenfield: Um some dealers do a good job of this, but I think that um we are on the cusp now of unlocking all kinds of better consumer experiences and more revenue and profit for dealers off of just like very simple applications of AI.
- 5:55Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, that's right.
- 5:56Jim Fitzpatrick: And even with companies that are that consider themselves progressive and advanced companies that have got, you know, call centers that are size of a football field to handle all of their different calls coming in, AI still blows that away.
- 6:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 6:08Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, the the the the biggest call center in the world can't handle what AI does 24-7 around the clock, whether they're receiving phone calls to set appointments, or out outgo, you know, outbound calls as well, right?
- 6:20Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 6:20Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, there's just you just can't do it.
- 6:22Steve Greenfield: You can't do it.
- 6:22Steve Greenfield: I mean, you know, if you took the best salespeople on the face of the earth, you've probably met them.
- 6:27Steve Greenfield: These people sell like 40, 50 cars a month fairly consistently.
- 6:30Steve Greenfield: And like when I've seen these interviews with these people, it's just that they have a really big Rolodex and they're very thoughtful.
- 6:36Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 6:37Steve Greenfield: You know, they they they reach out to you on your birthday.
- 6:39Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 6:40Steve Greenfield: And they say, Jim, how is life going?
- 6:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 6:41Steve Greenfield: How are your kids doing?
- 6:42Steve Greenfield: They they know your wife's name, they know your kid's name, etc.
- 6:45Steve Greenfield: And they're just very thoughtful, building long-term value with you.
- 6:48Steve Greenfield: So you you would never think of buying a car from anyone else.
- 6:51Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 6:51Steve Greenfield: And you're gonna go back to you know, Bob or whoever it is who's your salesperson.
- 6:55Steve Greenfield: Um we could AI should be able to uniquely replicate that.
- 6:59Steve Greenfield: You know, take those algorithms, whatever those activities are that are in the heads of the best people, best best salesperson, best FI manager, best fix ops person, best technician, and then distill that down to their essence, replicate them, and now every dealer's the the the the tide will rise, all ships, right?
- 7:17Steve Greenfield: Every dealer should be a great operator because we're gonna be able to complement humans, even if they're new employees, with the best practices in America of the best operating dealers.
- 7:27Steve Greenfield: And this is really, I think, the unlock for AI.
- 7:30Steve Greenfield: We have to see that.
- 7:31Steve Greenfield: But I think when when that happens, there'll be plenty of companies for folks like me to invest in, sure.
- 7:35Steve Greenfield: And all kinds of benefits for dealers overall, to just like augment their employees with best practices, real-time best practices, kind of like guardrails that will keep them out of trouble, but make sure they're on the straight and narrow at all times to just be doing the best things to generate more revenue and profit.
- 7:51Steve Greenfield: So I I think that we are very close to seeing this kind of unlock for dealers.
- 7:56Jim Fitzpatrick: And there we should say too that there's some dealers, I mean, there's some vendors out there, uh, as you know, you know, you go for for these dealers that are visiting NADA in just a few months where they say they have AI.
- 8:07Jim Fitzpatrick: They're still kind of working on the AI.
- 8:10Jim Fitzpatrick: You know what I mean?
- 8:11Jim Fitzpatrick: I've heard from dealers that say, ah, this company sold me uh not a bill of goods per se, but they said we have AI, this is what we'll do, and at the end of the day, it ain't working that way, right?
- 8:20Jim Fitzpatrick: But they got you in to say we got AI.
- 8:22Jim Fitzpatrick: We got AI.
- 8:22Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 8:23Jim Fitzpatrick: Check the box.
- 8:24Steve Greenfield: Do you do you see some of that out there where you're like, what I would recommend for if I'm a dealer, NADA is now in two months or three months, whatever it is.
- 8:30Steve Greenfield: I'd say, look, start with what your business objectives are.
- 8:33Steve Greenfield: Okay, right?
- 8:34Steve Greenfield: Because it is gonna be you you will you will get numb walking that floor with a lot of people pitching you a lot of stuff, and you won't be able to know what's real, what isn't real.
- 8:41Steve Greenfield: But you know, if I want to um have uh increase productivity for my salespeople.
- 8:46Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 8:46Steve Greenfield: My salespeople sell 10 cars a month, and next year I want them to sell 12 cars a month, right?
- 8:51Steve Greenfield: Then that's a challenge for a vendor.
- 8:53Steve Greenfield: You say, how do you help me hit my business objectives?
- 8:56Steve Greenfield: If I want to increase my fixed operation absorption overall next calendar year, these are things where I would have a strategy, come to NADA with the strategy, talk to probably your existing vendors and challenge them, but then any vendor that's pitching some crazy AI thing, align it back to what your business objectives are for next year.
- 9:14Steve Greenfield: Because I think it is going to be tantalizing for a dealer to say, oh, I'm gonna go try this, I'm gonna go try this.
- 9:18Steve Greenfield: I know, I know.
- 9:19Steve Greenfield: And rather than chasing shiny objects, reconciling it back to what they want to accomplish next year, what improvements in the business do they want to make, I think will be a good lens through which they can challenge their existing vendors and look at new vendors and not get enamored with some new AI widget that may or may not provide value aligned with where you want the ship to go.
- 9:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Right, right.
- 9:38Jim Fitzpatrick: So that's great advice, yeah, there's no question about it.
- 9:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Because there's, as I said, there's so many companies out there that are ringing the AI bell, and it as some of you have even sat here and said, we weren't quite ready yet, but we're ready now, okay?
- 9:51Jim Fitzpatrick: But they sold some packages to dealers, and I think they were maybe using the dealers a little bit of a guinea pig out there, right?
- 9:58Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, yeah.
- 9:58Jim Fitzpatrick: But um, so in terms of uh 2026, as because it's right around the corner, um, another good year in the business from your perspective, from all things that you're watching and and and the people that you're speaking to, we should have another good year.
- 10:13Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I think so.
- 10:13Steve Greenfield: I mean, we talk about dealers overall.
- 10:15Steve Greenfield: Well, I think the consumer demand will still be there, right?
- 10:17Steve Greenfield: We'll see what happens with consumer confidence overall, but for the time being, it seems like the current administration has their fingers on the pulse of consumer confidence overall.
- 10:25Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 10:26Steve Greenfield: I think dealers have proven themselves.
- 10:27Steve Greenfield: Like I've been in the industry for 25 years.
- 10:29Steve Greenfield: It's amazing.
- 10:30Steve Greenfield: Every single year, they're profitable.
- 10:33Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 10:33Steve Greenfield: Um, they can they can uh reallocate resources and their people into the departments depending on, you know, I get squeezed on new car, I can go to used car.
- 10:39Steve Greenfield: I get squeezed on a new car and go to F&I, I can go into fixed operations, etc.
- 10:43Steve Greenfield: Dealers have been proven to be very resilient and innovative in terms of allocating resources around.
- 10:48Steve Greenfield: I think that fixed ops is gonna continue to be a more important area.
- 10:52Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 10:52Steve Greenfield: I think of dealers like there are controllables and uncontrollables.
- 10:55Steve Greenfield: What I can't control is if my OEM makes good product that consumers want.
- 10:59Steve Greenfield: What I can't control is how much front-end gross the OEM is gonna permit me to have.
- 11:04Steve Greenfield: The things I can control is which used cars I stock.
- 11:06Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 11:07Steve Greenfield: Uh I can control how much I invest in my F&I managers to attach more products and drive more back end PVR.
- 11:14Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:14Steve Greenfield: I can I can um definitely focus on how sophisticated my fixed operations are, selling more parts, selling more service overall.
- 11:21Steve Greenfield: So I think dealers just have to really look at their entire operation through what can I control?
- 11:26Steve Greenfield: What levers can I pull to grow?
- 11:28Steve Greenfield: Where should I not worry, not lose any sleep, um, and um focus on those areas where they can grow and then work with their vendors to say, look, I need to energize more absorption or fixed ops revenue, profitability.
- 11:42Steve Greenfield: Um, how can you help me?
- 11:43Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 11:44Steve Greenfield: And if the answer is like we can't help, then maybe it's time to look at another vendor.
- 11:47Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:47Steve Greenfield: But you need to really be crisp around the things you can control and where you can get the most advantage for the least amount of effort.
- 11:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure, for sure.
- 11:55Jim Fitzpatrick: And for those dealers that are out there, you know, I've heard I've spoken to some of them where they, you know, that some of these vendors, man, they'll have you sign up for a one-year contract that you can't get out of, right?
- 12:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Only to find out that they didn't quite have the technology that they presented themselves as, you know.
- 12:09Jim Fitzpatrick: So be careful of that too, dealers, that uh, you know, you don't sign in.
- 12:14Steve Greenfield: I think m most vendors now, thankfully, are like month to month.
- 12:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 12:17Steve Greenfield: And and realize they have to prove their value every month or they don't re-up.
- 12:21Jim Fitzpatrick: For sure.
- 12:21Steve Greenfield: Uh but yeah, I mean I I I would echo exactly what you said.
- 12:23Steve Greenfield: Uh when you start talking about a year or longer, you gotta really question what you're getting into.
- 12:27Jim Fitzpatrick: I know.
- 12:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Even though it's uh might be appealing to go, well, if you sign a 24-month contract, will you really bring that monthly rate down a year in and all of a sudden guess what?
- 12:34Jim Fitzpatrick: You just sign up for two years with the wrong vendor, you know, because they don't have what you what you thought.
- 12:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, so let's talk about used cars since you you mentioned that.
- 12:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Um that is a sticky field right now.
- 12:43Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, with the price of used cars, and then the every dealer is challenged in the acquisition of these cars, everyone's buying cars out of the service lane, which seems to be a successful way to go, buying them off the road.
- 12:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, any thoughts on on the used car business?
- 12:57Steve Greenfield: No, just that I mean you know car Carvana wants to get to now to three three million cars sold a year.
- 13:02Steve Greenfield: That's a longer term goal.
- 13:03Steve Greenfield: They've been very successful buying cars off the street.
- 13:06Steve Greenfield: CarMax is the same as well.
- 13:07Steve Greenfield: So I think dealers need to up their game, right?
- 13:09Steve Greenfield: It used to be that if you built a good centralized buying center you know in your local area, you could have at it, right?
- 13:16Steve Greenfield: And you could pick off the cherries and pull in really good cars off the street.
- 13:19Steve Greenfield: Now I think that everyone, the competition's increasing.
- 13:22Steve Greenfield: So dealers need to um increase their game themselves, hire great people, um, look to their vendors at where they can help, but they need to figure out how they can continue to get a good source of vehicles.
- 13:33Steve Greenfield: I think a lot of dealers are fatigued about the auctions with fees, right?
- 13:36Steve Greenfield: I hear that a lot.
- 13:36Steve Greenfield: I guess that's primarily what's driven Carvana and CarMax to get independent.
- 13:40Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 13:40Steve Greenfield: Say, look, we're just gonna like build our own competency with buying cars directly off the street.
- 13:44Steve Greenfield: They've been very successful, but I think studying those experiences of a dealer, like go through and sell a car to Carvana, sell a car to CarMax and see what they do.
- 13:54Steve Greenfield: Um I think and then replicate the those elements that you think are really good and sticky with the consumer.
- 13:59Steve Greenfield: But um I think that the the challenge, the beautiful thing about America, there's a lot of competition.
- 14:04Steve Greenfield: Yeah, the bad thing about America, there's a lot of competition.
- 14:06Steve Greenfield: I think every year it's gonna get you know more and more intense.
- 14:09Steve Greenfield: You get these really big players that have unlimited budgets and they have really good customer experience.
- 14:14Steve Greenfield: And you know, I talk to people in Uber rides around the world or whatever, and you talk to them, they're like, Yeah, I just sold my car to Carvana.
- 14:20Steve Greenfield: And when you ask them, how was it?
- 14:21Steve Greenfield: Like my dentist, actually, here not too long ago.
- 14:24Steve Greenfield: I did too.
- 14:24Steve Greenfield: She's like, she's like, you know, very sophisticated.
- 14:27Steve Greenfield: I've been with her for 20 years.
- 14:28Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 14:28Steve Greenfield: And she said, I recently bought a car from Carvana.
- 14:30Steve Greenfield: I said, Well, what'd you buy?
- 14:31Steve Greenfield: She said, I bought like a two-year-old Mercedes.
- 14:33Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 14:33Steve Greenfield: I said, Well, how was the experience?
- 14:34Steve Greenfield: She said, It was amazing.
- 14:36Steve Greenfield: And this is a dentist, a sophisticated.
- 14:37Steve Greenfield: She said, She said, I went to the vending machine and I put in the coin and it went and retrieved my car and brought it.
- 14:44Steve Greenfield: And when the this is what she said, literally.
- 14:46Steve Greenfield: She said, when the car came down, it spun around and there was a halo over top of my car.
- 14:50Jim Fitzpatrick: Wow.
- 14:51Steve Greenfield: And she said, I still have that coin at home.
- 14:52Steve Greenfield: Oh my gosh.
- 14:53Steve Greenfield: I'm thinking to myself, like, there is something to this.
- 14:56Steve Greenfield: Like, it was the experience of buying more than the car.
- 14:59Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 14:59Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 15:00Steve Greenfield: That that and so I mean, we have a lot to learn, I think, from these companies that are intensely focused on the consumer experience.
- 15:06Steve Greenfield: And how does a dealer build their own version of that?
- 15:08Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 15:09Steve Greenfield: Right?
- 15:09Steve Greenfield: And not just simply make it a transaction where like get more out the door.
- 15:12Steve Greenfield: Because these these people, like, I I am I guarantee you she will buy her next car from Carvana.
- 15:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, I've heard that from a number of people.
- 15:18Jim Fitzpatrick: That's crazy.
- 15:19Jim Fitzpatrick: A number of uh family members uh have purchased from Carvana.
- 15:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Sorry about that dealers, but a number of family members have, and they said the same thing.
- 15:26Jim Fitzpatrick: My our next car will definitely be through Carvana, not because of the car, because you can buy that car anywhere, but because of the overall experience.
- 15:33Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh so I think we do have a lot to learn.
- 15:35Jim Fitzpatrick: I, sorry to tell you, sold my car to Carvana.
- 15:38Jim Fitzpatrick: And but before that, I said, well, listen, I'm in the industry.
- 15:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Let me call around to it's a BMW, let me call around to some BMW dealerships and see if they want to buy, you know, my car.
- 15:47Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh it was in mint condition, it was a 645 BMW and or 650 BMW, and uh great condition, low miles, the whole deal.
- 15:55Jim Fitzpatrick: Everybody wanted me to bring it by the store to take a look at it.
- 15:58Jim Fitzpatrick: Before they give you a price.
- 15:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Before they give me a price.
- 16:00Jim Fitzpatrick: They gave me a range, give you a price.
- 16:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, we gotta but we gotta see it.
- 16:04Jim Fitzpatrick: I'm busy here in the studio.
- 16:05Jim Fitzpatrick: I'm like, let me just let me see what I can do with Carvana.
- 16:08Jim Fitzpatrick: Took a picture of the license plate, right?
- 16:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Sent it over.
- 16:10Jim Fitzpatrick: They're like, oh yeah, boom, here's here's the price.
- 16:12Jim Fitzpatrick: If it's what you say, here's the price, and we'll come out and pick it up.
- 16:16Jim Fitzpatrick: The guy came up with the flatbed truck.
- 16:18Jim Fitzpatrick: Here's your check, Mr.
- 16:19Jim Fitzpatrick: Fitzpatrick.
- 16:20Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you very much, and off goes the car.
- 16:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Exact number that they told me online without ever seeing the car was what the check was made out for.
- 16:28Steve Greenfield: Yep.
- 16:29Jim Fitzpatrick: And I mean, you you can't beat that.
- 16:30Jim Fitzpatrick: You can't beat that.
- 16:31Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, and and this is what franchise dealers are up against.
- 16:34Jim Fitzpatrick: Right, you know?
- 16:35Steve Greenfield: And this is how Carvana buys whatever they're buying, 700,000 cars a year or something off the street.
- 16:40Steve Greenfield: Incredible.
- 16:40Steve Greenfield: And it's only gonna grow, right?
- 16:42Steve Greenfield: So that's what dealers are gonna feel, like that's what you're competing with.
- 16:45Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 16:45Steve Greenfield: That kind of convenient experience, transparent and convenient experience.
- 16:48Steve Greenfield: And dealers might fight it because they want you to come in.
- 16:51Steve Greenfield: They didn't want to give you the.
- 16:52Steve Greenfield: They lost you.
- 16:54Steve Greenfield: No, but they lost you.
- 16:55Steve Greenfield: And I think that this is exactly you need to be mystery shopping, not only the other dealers in your marketplace, but these big marketplaces just to understand what is state of the art and what are consumers, how are consumers processing these experiences now?
- 17:06Steve Greenfield: Because that's your competition.
- 17:07Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 17:08Jim Fitzpatrick: And you had a great idea there to for dealers to actually sell a car to Carvana, as many dealer friends of mine have purchased a car from Tesla to see how it goes, how it drives, but more overall, what was the experience like?
- 17:19Jim Fitzpatrick: You know what I mean?
- 17:20Jim Fitzpatrick: And um uh it it it to see firsthand what is it that is so appealing to consumers that they're gonna buy a car online and take delivery of it at $100,000 or whatever the price is.
- 17:31Jim Fitzpatrick: And a lot of dealers have said, wow, they were really amazed with how that whole process went down.
- 17:36Jim Fitzpatrick: You know?
- 17:36Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, not the whole, it wasn't a perfect situation in every case, but it was an eye-opener for many dealers.
- 17:42Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I've never heard I've heard of dealers mystery shopping and selling cars to Carvana to their credit.
- 17:46Steve Greenfield: I've never heard of them recording, like video recording the entire process.
- 17:49Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 17:50Steve Greenfield: And then sitting back in their sales meeting and playing it back.
- 17:52Steve Greenfield: And then doing a play-by-play, like the NFL really, right?
- 17:55Steve Greenfield: Pause.
- 17:56Steve Greenfield: What are we hearing here?
- 17:57Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 17:58Steve Greenfield: What elements of this should we we mimic?
- 17:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 18:00Steve Greenfield: And what elements are we like, okay, we're never gonna do that.
- 18:02Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 18:02Steve Greenfield: But let's be very deliberate with what our strategy is overall.
- 18:05Steve Greenfield: And I think that uh that that needs to be done.
- 18:07Steve Greenfield: Yeah because this is the competition.
- 18:08Jim Fitzpatrick: I uh whether we like it or not.
- 18:10Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 18:10Jim Fitzpatrick: And in fact, it was funny because I said to this one particular dealer, I said, Well, do you guys have a flatbed car uh truck that you can come out and pick the vehicle up?
- 18:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Because otherwise I've got to have uh you know a car behind me, my wife's gotta drop me off, whatever the case might be.
- 18:22Jim Fitzpatrick: And they said, Oh no, no, no, you gotta you gotta drop the vehicle off.
- 18:25Jim Fitzpatrick: We don't we don't have a a truck that's gonna that's gonna do that.
- 18:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, now I gotta take my wife's schedule and have her follow me out to the dealership.
- 18:31Jim Fitzpatrick: And as you know, in Atlanta, that's a two, three hour deal in Atlanta, right?
- 18:34Jim Fitzpatrick: In in traffic.
- 18:35Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh, but Carvana was like, nope, we'll come right out, don't worry about it, we'll be there at two o'clock.
- 18:40Jim Fitzpatrick: And sure enough, two o'clock came and the truck was sitting out there and and uh gave him the title and the key, and they were off in like 15 minutes.
- 18:46Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, it was it was really, really something to see.
- 18:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, so um so in terms of investments and opportunities, I know that's something that you live in every single day.
- 18:55Jim Fitzpatrick: What uh what's new, what's hot, what are what are dealers looking at right now?
- 18:59Jim Fitzpatrick: What are you what talk to us about maybe some of the big wins that you've got.
- 19:02Steve Greenfield: Yeah, yeah.
- 19:02Steve Greenfield: So um, you know, I I'm really intrigued with this fact that uh 60% of a dealer's cost structure is human capital.
- 19:09Steve Greenfield: I think AI is uniquely positioned to make all of your employees more effective, right?
- 19:14Steve Greenfield: Increase more.
- 19:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Maybe less head capital.
- 19:16Steve Greenfield: Well, I think over time, that's definitely it.
- 19:18Steve Greenfield: Like you know, I think that the the second phase of this is gonna be as people leave, right?
- 19:22Steve Greenfield: Whether they quit or retire, right.
- 19:24Steve Greenfield: You might be like, oh, I don't need to replace Sally or whoever or whoever it is, it's in the back office.
- 19:28Steve Greenfield: But I think um right now I would be encouraging your employees to experiment with this and try to drive productivity.
- 19:34Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I know for me right now, I mean, I use Chat GPT fairly frequently.
- 19:38Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I mean, I don't know if you're using it too, but like just small little tweaks, right, that might you make your life easier.
- 19:43Steve Greenfield: And things that used to take three hours now can make take five minutes.
- 19:47Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 19:48Steve Greenfield: And it's amazing to me.
- 19:48Steve Greenfield: Like, okay, well, I'll just give them three hours of my life back.
- 19:51Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 19:51Steve Greenfield: And I think the same thing with your employees, like, you know, just being making sure they have a little bit of education around these tools and then giving them a little bit of empowerment just to stretch the boundaries a little bit, see how they might make their own lives easier.
- 20:04Steve Greenfield: The good thing about humans is we're all lazy.
- 20:06Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 20:07Steve Greenfield: And we like to make our lives easier.
- 20:09Steve Greenfield: And if you give me, if you give me a tool that will make my life easier, I'm likely to use it.
- 20:13Steve Greenfield: I'm gonna like it and at work that drives more productivity.
- 20:15Steve Greenfield: But to your point, then I do think that that's 60% of a dealer's cost structure.
- 20:20Steve Greenfield: Five years from now, that's gonna be less.
- 20:22Steve Greenfield: That might be 50% or 40%.
- 20:24Steve Greenfield: All of that saving is gonna flow through to a dealer's bottom line.
- 20:27Steve Greenfield: I believe in the future dealers are gonna be more productive because of AI, more profitable, and worth more because of AI, because we'll be operating bigger businesses with fewer humans, which can be scary, can be scary, but that that that's really the hope that I have overall.
- 20:43Steve Greenfield: Um, you know, one of the best examples we have, well, the best company we've invested in by far is WarrCloud.
- 20:47Steve Greenfield: Okay.
- 20:48Steve Greenfield: You know, Jim Roche.
- 20:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Incredible, incredible guy, incredible company. Not a doubt-
- 20:53Steve Greenfield: I'm on the board of that company.
- 20:55Steve Greenfield: We invested five years ago.
- 20:56Steve Greenfield: It was our first investment, our best investment.
- 20:58Jim Fitzpatrick: And tell tell the audience what WarrCloud does.
- 20:59Jim Fitzpatrick: What the solution is-
- 21:02Steve Greenfield: It simply automates warranty claims back to the OEM.
- 21:03Steve Greenfield: Yep.
- 21:04Steve Greenfield: So typically a dealer either outsources that or has a clerk who manages that process.
- 21:08Steve Greenfield: You put in WarrCloud, um, that clerk can go off and do something else.
- 21:13Steve Greenfield: Um we replace the clerk, uh, dealers get paid faster.
- 21:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Yep.
- 21:17Steve Greenfield: Um and so it's a cash flow, a positive cash flow issue.
- 21:20Steve Greenfield: Um, they also get paid more.
- 21:21Steve Greenfield: Because what we found for across all the dealers, we have about 800 dealers on WarrCloud now.
- 21:26Steve Greenfield: Um, you know, on average, dealers make 15% more per RO.
- 21:30Jim Fitzpatrick: Whoa.
- 21:30Steve Greenfield: Because there are reimbursements that that clerk may not be aware of.
- 21:34Steve Greenfield: Right because it knows which boxes to check and how to submit.
- 21:40Steve Greenfield: Wow.
- 21:40Steve Greenfield: So dealers can take out the cost of the clerk, get paid faster, and get more revenue per RO.
- 21:46Steve Greenfield: It's really a no-brainer value proposition for those dealers that have adopted.
- 21:50Steve Greenfield: So um and Jim Roche, as you've met at the most.
- 21:52Steve Greenfield: He's like, I just wish we had more entrepreneurs like him.
- 21:54Steve Greenfield: I mean, he's just like an unbelievable entrepreneur, super steady hand.
- 21:58Steve Greenfield: Yep.
- 21:59Jim Fitzpatrick: And by the way, he's had other successes in the auto space.
- 22:02Jim Fitzpatrick: So he needs to be.
- 22:03Steve Greenfield: He's written two books on fixed ops.
- 22:04Steve Greenfield: I mean, he knows fix ops so well.
- 22:06Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 22:06Steve Greenfield: He's a subject matter expert, and I just think the world of him.
- 22:09Steve Greenfield: So I mean we're very appreciative for Jim and what he's built, and it'll be a great outcome for that.
- 22:14Jim Fitzpatrick: And then that's that's a textbook case of like you said, where it's gonna be one of those areas that it can replace a human uh uh that you're paying for, you know what I mean, at the rate of forty, fifty, sixty, eighty thousand dollars a year.
- 22:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Those rates just keep going up.
- 22:27Jim Fitzpatrick: It's incredible.
- 22:28Jim Fitzpatrick: We've got to be paying people to join the organization.
- 22:31Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh but these are real huge savings.
- 22:33Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh the number of the dealers that I will talk to on air will say, well, AI is great, and you know, it's not gonna replace people, but it will give them a great tool, but I know it's gonna replace it.
- 22:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:45Jim Fitzpatrick: This has got to do that.
- 22:46Jim Fitzpatrick: It will, right?
- 22:47Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, and I'm not gonna hold them to it because obviously their staff is listening, like, oh, I better look for a job.
- 22:52Jim Fitzpatrick: But at the end of the day, the this has to, you know, bring down the headcount, bring down the human expense, and uh and it will, and it's doing it now.
- 23:02Steve Greenfield: Yeah, it will.
- 23:02Steve Greenfield: And yeah, the learning experience from WarrCloud is how many roles at a dealership?
- 23:05Steve Greenfield: I mean, you've run stores, I've never run stores, but I've walked around enough centralized accounting offices, and you talk to these people and say, what do you do?
- 23:12Steve Greenfield: Well, I reconcile bank statements at the end of the day, week, or month, or I reconcile part statements and have a 50-page part statement in PDF that I have to open the bank account and reconcile all the stuff.
- 23:23Steve Greenfield: And this is just, yeah, exactly right.
- 23:25Steve Greenfield: We'll we will be able to automate all those roles to free those people up to do higher value things, right?
- 23:30Steve Greenfield: But I do think over time dealers will say, Yeah, that's interesting.
- 23:33Steve Greenfield: I'm I'm actually running my operation with far fewer people, right?
- 23:36Steve Greenfield: Operating better with fewer errors, that's right, more efficiently and faster, and I'm more profitable.
- 23:42Steve Greenfield: That's right.
- 23:42Steve Greenfield: And that's a beautiful world for our dealers.
- 23:44Steve Greenfield: And I think that uh you know AI will uniquely unlock more profitability for dealers, and I want to find vendors that are gonna help dealers on that journey.
- 23:52Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, that's right, no question about it.
- 23:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Um will WarrCloud be out at NADA?
- 23:55Steve Greenfield: Yes, they will.
- 23:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Awesome.
- 23:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Check them out.
- 23:58Jim Fitzpatrick: If you're out there dealers, it's gonna be a big show.
- 24:00Steve Greenfield: And I hear you have a bigger booth at NADA.
- 24:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Boy, we are right in the middle of it all.
- 24:05Jim Fitzpatrick: I thank my friends over at NADA.
- 24:08Jim Fitzpatrick: We've got great positioning.
- 24:09Jim Fitzpatrick: Um we'll we'll I think we already have some 30 interviews lined up for the CBT stage, and uh it's always a big event for us because we are at the same time.
- 24:17Steve Greenfield: So, Jim, if I'm a vendor out there and I'm listening and I want to get on stage, how do I get on stage before?
- 24:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Come on, sell me, sell me.
- 24:22Jim Fitzpatrick: All our sales department.
- 24:23Jim Fitzpatrick: But it's really we it's amazing because we offer this package every year.
- 24:27Jim Fitzpatrick: We have now for you know probably 10 years.
- 24:30Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh, but so it's really we've priced it right.
- 24:32Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, you get an interview before NADA to drive traffic to your booth, and then we you get an interview at NADA that goes out immediately to all the social media outlets and on our website and everything else.
- 24:42Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh, and it's amazing because we'll make the announcement that we're now taking orders and it sells out very quickly for everybody that's already done it.
- 24:50Jim Fitzpatrick: They're like, this is a deal.
- 24:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it's a no-brainer.
- 24:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Especially if you don't have a great location at NADA.
- 24:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it helps to drive traffic over to your over to your website.
- 24:59Jim Fitzpatrick: So ask thanks for asking me about that.
- 25:01Steve Greenfield: No, of course, and I look forward to you.
- 25:02Steve Greenfield: You and I always catch up out there.
- 25:03Steve Greenfield: Oh, absolutely.
- 25:04Steve Greenfield: Absolutely, absolutely.
- 25:05Steve Greenfield: And seeing the bigger booth this year.
- 25:08Jim Fitzpatrick: Little bit bigger footprint in it in right in the middle.
- 25:10Jim Fitzpatrick: We're right next to Cox Automotive, right across from uh the the pavilion for NADA.
- 25:16Steve Greenfield: Primo Real Estate now, right?
- 25:17Steve Greenfield: Wow.
- 25:18Steve Greenfield: They must like you.
- 25:19Jim Fitzpatrick: I'm telling you.
- 25:19Jim Fitzpatrick: 13 years later, you got finally.
- 25:22Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right, that's right.
- 25:23Jim Fitzpatrick: No, but again, thank you so much for all of the great content that you provided uh to us and our viewers.
- 25:28Jim Fitzpatrick: They get so much out of it.
- 25:30Jim Fitzpatrick: We're so happy about all your successes with your companies.
- 25:32Jim Fitzpatrick: And I mean, you nailed it.
- 25:33Jim Fitzpatrick: You said, wait a minute, these these dealers are making money, but at the same time, they're also they're they're the guinea pig for all of these great technologies that are out there.
- 25:43Jim Fitzpatrick: And I know a number of dealers have said, well, how do we get in on that?
- 25:45Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, these companies are getting sold for hundreds of millions of dollars, and you've got dealers that go, well, wait a second, we were a big part of that that company's success.
- 25:53Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, we were we were kind of the the the beta for for in many cases, and uh you've been able to successfully bring those those parties together, you know, to say
- 26:02Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I mean i it's it's not really a secret, but more than half of our investors across our three funds are dealer principles.
- 26:08Steve Greenfield: And I know they don't think that I'm the best investor in the world, but what they do get, we're now seeing 300 companies a month.
- 26:13Steve Greenfield: Wow.
- 26:14Steve Greenfield: They get visibility in those companies.
- 26:15Steve Greenfield: That's great, and we always have space for direct investment from dealers.
- 26:18Steve Greenfield: So I can't number name the number of dealers that have invested alongside us.
- 26:23Steve Greenfield: When we invest, we do all the work, we we kick the tires, we do the diligence, et cetera.
- 26:27Steve Greenfield: We we get confidence that we want to invest, right, and then there's space left for dealers to invest alongside.
- 26:31Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 26:32Steve Greenfield: So I think it's been great.
- 26:33Steve Greenfield: I think that um, you know, the more that dealers are directing their our own money and investing in these solutions, the better.
- 26:38Steve Greenfield: Right.
- 26:38Steve Greenfield: Um and uh yeah, I'm excited to be on this journey, and I'm very honored to be trusted with so many of these dealers' money.
- 26:44Steve Greenfield: Yeah.
- 26:44Steve Greenfield: Um and uh it's been a great learning experience for me.
- 26:47Steve Greenfield: I've I've learned a lot from our dealer pressure.
- 26:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Oh, I bet, I bet.
- 26:50Jim Fitzpatrick: And it comes at a good time because a lot of dealers, if they're not buying other dealerships, they're coming off of you know, pretty good five years.
- 26:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Last five years have been very good, and they want to deploy that capital, and if it could be in a technology that they're currently using among all of their stores, and uh it it's a no-brainer, right?
- 27:05Steve Greenfield: Yeah, I I get enough guys that have their wealth manager, Goldman Sachs or whatever, like, hey, I'm in some like healthcare or biotech fund.
- 27:12Steve Greenfield: You're in the car business.
- 27:13Steve Greenfield: I have no idea what these things are.
- 27:15Steve Greenfield: I get these reports, and I've I can't even read these reports.
- 27:17Steve Greenfield: The stuff that we invest in, they understand.
- 27:19Steve Greenfield: Yeah, they can influence, they can take them to their 20 groups, and they can spread the gospel.
- 27:24Steve Greenfield: I think that you know it's been a good fit.
- 27:25Steve Greenfield: It's been a really good fit.
- 27:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Oh, no question about it.
- 27:27Jim Fitzpatrick: No question.
- 27:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, congratulations on all your success.
- 27:29Jim Fitzpatrick: We appreciate you and uh love what you're doing for us.
- 27:32Jim Fitzpatrick: So thank you.
- 27:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh uh it's it's just been great.
- 27:34Jim Fitzpatrick: So Steve Greenfield, CEO and founder of Automotive Ventures, all the information on the screen right here.
- 27:39Jim Fitzpatrick: If you got a little jingle and you want to get in on some of these great deals that Steve's put together, like WarrCloud, give him a call.
- 27:45Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, you're not gonna be uh sorry.
- 27:47Jim Fitzpatrick: In fact, count me in on you should cut me in because here you go just for giving you the little fire school finance.
- 27:53Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 27:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks so much.
- 27:55Steve Greenfield: Thanks, Jim.
- 27:56Announcer: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.