Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Top 100 Used Dealers, Tesla Delays Affordability, Sam’s Club Scan and Go
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning, Monday, April 21st. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay. Daly is Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:06Today, we're talking about the top 100 used car dealers, Tesla delaying its affordable car, and Sam's Club getting rid of cashiers along with the old furniture. See you bye In a renovation at Sam's Club.
- 0:19And the whole thing. That- Sam's Club's trying... they're cutting- They're trying to be Costco, but they ain't got dollar hot dogs. You know what I'm saying? Oh, no.
- 0:26[laughs] I mean, that- I know it's kind of the opposite of Costco, uh, in my mind. It is the opposite of Costco. I mean, have you ever been to a BJ's? No, but we have one, and my wife went, and she was like, "Meh."
- 0:38Like, is it- Not great... yeah. Is it like Costco is Target, Sam's Club is Walmart, and BJ's is like Dollar General? Like, how does that work? I, I mean, no, no. I would, I would go- It's the other way around... Publix-
- 0:52Well, no Like- Publix is a grocery store... oh, Publix is... Yeah, it's a grocery store. It's a wa- it's gotta be a warehouse store. It's been a long time, but BJ's I feel like was one of the OGs.
- 0:58No, I've heard that BJ's is, is higher than Sam's Club- Mm... these days. Well, we don't have a Sam's Club anymore in Syracuse 'cause it did close, and now it's a mini storage. So- [laughs]...
- 1:08maybe that'll tell you something. B- That- BJ's is still- Hey, can we talk about how many storage units are in the US? Uh- That's gotta be a thing Oh, we had a little convers- Goodness... yeah, we have mini ones.
- 1:16They're attached to our houses, called garage, where we keep the crap we don't want to- That's all you need, people All right That's all you need All right. We are live- Tell them how it is...
- 1:23we're l- uh, okay, like a day more than three weeks away from ASOTU CON- Ah... 2025. It's gonna be- Ugh... unbelievable.
- 1:30Watching the tickets come in, watching the social media posts of people posting their license plates that they're going to be there.
- 1:35We got some other things brewing, like I heard there's a little pickleball event brewing. Um- What? Yeah. Yeah, I didn't even tell you about that. Come on now. Uh, yeah, there's a little pickleball thing a- brewing.
- 1:44Um, but if you go to asotucon.com right now and click on Agenda, and then Detailed Agenda by Stage, you're gonna see a whole flurry of topics that you need to know about, or you wanna know about- Right...
- 1:56because there are areas, all different areas, to improve your business, to handle the situations as it's coming at you, whether it's tariffs or people issues.
- 2:05You know, we've been talking a lot how people issues are gonna affect your bottom line much more than a tariff will. Um, and that's legit. We're talking people. Yep.
- 2:12We're talking, uh, sales, acquisitions, health insurance. We got a panel on health insurance costs and how you can take care of your people better there. All kinds of stuff.
- 2:20Uh, Kyle, you and I decided we were gonna pick one session today to talk about- One thing... that we are interested in. And naturally, I was like, "I wanna pick this one. Which one is yours?"
- 2:29And you're like, "Well, that was gonna be it." So- [laughs] That was gonna be it. So, uh, the- What are you excited about? I'm, I'm excited about day one, Studio One. This is 2:30 to 3:00.
- 2:38SEO to GEO, which is generative engine optimation- optimization, with Nick Iskowitz and John Sukal- uh, Sukawati.
- 2:47This is, what's happening right now is that when you're searching, even if you're searching on Google, or if you're- Doesn't matter...
- 2:52a lot of people move into ChatGPT or searching some level of AI tool, it is what is generated in the answer. Where is it getting the information that is giving you that first answer and response?
- 3:04Even if you're still using Google, what do you need to do to your content and your website to make sure you show up in that, not the traditional route where you just wanna show up in the first page of search results that's actually becoming a little outdated.
- 3:16So cutting edge technology, cutting edge conversation. I'm gonna give you... Actually, I'm not gonna talk about mine, because this was an interesting thing.
- 3:22I think this is, like, we're already getting into the news here today. But last week, GPT announced that the, that all of your history is available to GPT. And then they announced o3. Oh, the memory- Check this out...
- 3:40the memory of- The memory... everything you put in- Full memory... it can remember it- Right... and reference in future conversations you have with it.
- 3:46When you think about GEO, it's actually audience segmentation at its finest, and I posted on LinkedIn today about- Mm... how we are basically creating our e- own echo chamber, but this is the adverse to that. Somewhat,
- 3:59uh, uh, if you go to o3 and ask it a question, instead of like, "What are restaurants near me?" You say, "What are restaurants near me that I would like?" Ooh.
- 4:12It takes you and puts you in a deeper autom- a- audience segment. Like, oh, I like steak and, uh, and mushrooms. Okay.
- 4:19So now the, the targeting to get me actually requires the depth of your content to be much more structured instead of just, like, being a restaurant. It's like, no, a restaurant for people that like- People like this...
- 4:36steak and mushrooms. It sounds like- Phew. Come on... it sounds like brand at its finest. It is. And that's why the people who have been doing the grind of the brand work and building out not like- They're gonna win...
- 4:45not like garbage throwaway content, like, you know, random stuff that might get traffic but not relevant traffic, but things that talk about who you are. Posting on social media has to do with this.
- 4:54Um, I just asked GPT what restaurants are near me that you think I'd like. Um, let's see what it comes up with. It's searching the web right now. Um, I, [laughs] I think I know what it's probably gonna say- [laughs]...
- 5:06and what it's not gonna say. It's like, "You seem to like burgers." It's just gonna- McDonald's would be good... no, I think it's just gonna, I think it's just gonna generate an image of a pizza. [laughs] Okay.
- 5:18That's amazing. Let's see. It's got Noble Cell- Cellar, which is a small, like kind of really hip, new fine dining concept thing. Okay. Nice. A place called Eden, where I've never been to. It's farm-to-table.
- 5:28Pasta Abilities, which is pasta. Dinosaur Bar-becue. I mean, it's not that good. It di- it's not that good. It didn't do that good. Everybody wants to... Yeah. I don't, uh, granted, I don't talk about my food a lot.
- 5:39I mean- No, yeah, yeah, yeah... like I could see why it picked this stuff based on what I talk about, like business and like- For sure... the entrepreneurship and like, it...
- 5:49I, I don't know if it knows, I guess it knows how old I am, maybe. Maybe not. I think it thinks I'm a little younger than I am. [laughs] That's nice of it. What places can I go to before 8:30, right? Yeah, right.
- 5:59And be at home in bed by 9:00. Also that. Also that. [laughs] I think, I think there's news to talk about today. But all that- Let's talk about it...
- 6:04all that to say, we are unpacking the things that are gonna give you insights that when you get to your dealership or you can call or text or take pictures of the slides and disperse them to your teams, guess what?
- 6:14Your business is actually gonna get better. That's right. That's what ASOTU CON is all about. Absolutely.
- 6:18And doing that with people who are also wanna see you succeed, and the people who you can ask, "What are you doing about this?" And that's really where the growth comes. So go to asotucon.com, get your tickets.
- 6:27Bring a team member or two, and if you need any help to do that, just DM me or Kyle. We'll make sure you can get there- That's right... as fast as possible, as easy as possible.
- 6:37The automotive top- automotive news top 100 US used car dealership groups list is out. The big takeaway isn't just who's up or down, but how they are adapting to survive.
- 6:48As competition at auctions grows fiercer, retailers are shifting hard into alternative sourcing strategies. By the way, we're gonna talk about a lot of those at ASOTU CON. [laughs] Yep. Uh, here are the top three.
- 6:59Lithia sold 411,000 used vehicles. Uh, AutoNation was number two. Penske was number three. So Lithia, AutoNation, Penske.
- 7:08However, if we did include used ca- car retailers Carvana and CarMax, CarMax would've been number one at 770,000. Carvana would've been number two at 416,000. So Carvana... I mean, CarMax 770, Carvana 416, Lithia 411.
- 7:25Granted, they don't sell new cars. They don't- Right... you know, it's a different thing, but I- we just thought- For sure... it'd be relevant to put that in there.
- 7:29Krause Auto Group posted the biggest leap on the list, jumping 25 spots. They've been working- Come on... to number 67 with a 39%, uh, sales increase. Holman, our friends there, up 24 spots.
- 7:41DARCARS up 20 spots, and Swickard Auto Group up 17 spots. Also made significant moves with strategies ranging from better internal competition, hmm, interesting, to expanded certification and F&I offerings.
- 7:56Van Horn Auto Group, based, based in Plymouth, Wisconsin, cracked the top 100 for the first time at number 69. They came in smoking. Wow.
- 8:03Roughly half of its monthly used purchases come from auctions, so interesting there. Here's, uh, a quote from, uh, Brian- But only half. But only half.
- 8:12The rest are so- are sourced through services They got 'em somewhere else. Only 50% of their inventory is auctions. Yeah. That's a strong move- Right, and then-... at a, at a dealership of that size...
- 8:20and they slipped on to number 69, um, on the list. Uh, who is it? Brian Weiland, used car director of Van Horn, said, "We've had to readapt because it's not just the easy to go to...
- 8:31It's not just that easy to go to the auction and get 100 cars." You can't do that- No... easy anymore. So, um- It's not...
- 8:37and just, I think it's worth mentioning, of this list, so many of them are already going to be represented and have people at ASOTU CON.
- 8:45So if you wanna get better at used car business, we're talking, um, number 98, Holler Classic, CMA at 87, Russ Darrow, uh, Krause Group, Rohrman, RML Automotive, Orsman, Walser, Holman, are all gonna be on the floor walking around- Wow...
- 8:58and talking at ASOTU CON. Can't miss that. No. Let's go. Used cars is a big deal right now. I mean, used cars is a huge deal. We've got, like, four or five conversations.
- 9:07We got podcast conversations and stuff on the main stage all about used cars, all about sourcing, acquisition, retailing, reconditioning, um, even moving through, uh, the fixed op side of the business and figuring out how to do that.
- 9:20Uh, you know, when, especially when we have the prospect of potentially shrinking new car inventories, you gotta get your used cars up, um, to figure out how to kinda con- still compete. And here's what I think.
- 9:31I still don't understand why we don't have a public or a mid to large size group starting to think about how you actually beat a CarMax or a Carvana at scale.
- 9:42I, I just think, like, someone's gotta be poised to figure that out, and, and, and we gotta do it in the, on the franchise retail side. There's no reason why we can't. Got a comment from LinkedIn.
- 9:52"How do you guys see the Tesla continuing to drop used sale prices? How do we see that, and how long is it gonna happen?" So glad you asked. Oh. Because- That's a bit... Yeah... 'cause speaking of Tesla. Stop. Segway.
- 10:03Time. [upbeat music] Maybe before we go into this, we answer that question. Go ahead, Kyle. What were you gonna say? Well, no, yeah. If, if you've watched specifically on their used cars, right?
- 10:13And, um, Jimmy Douglas has been talking about this a little bit, you know, uh, owner of Plugg, how they have been taking their certified used cars and continually drop prices to try and incentivize demand. Yeah.
- 10:27Um, it, it is interesting, and, like, that's a, that, that's definitely a point of, like, watch out if you're buying these used EVs.
- 10:34Look at market, uh, market trends right now, and you might wanna be in Plugg even if you're not buying them often just to understand where the pricing is because there is a difference in the regular used car market.
- 10:46I, I... We talked to someone last week where they were going to the auction and, and CarMax and Carvana were seeing vehicles bring $3,000 to $5,000 over MRR. Mm-hmm.
- 10:57And so you've got this, like, different market where EVs are bringing less and starting to price down, and the market is generally going up over the last week and a half.
- 11:06So just watch out when you're looking at the, the price of cars. He- dude, I literally had this conversation with my friend on Sunday, right? It's Easter Sunday.
- 11:12You're at church, and, you know, you're the car guy, so they always ask you. That's right. "Hey, my wife would trade in her, um..." Can't remember if it was an Equinox or a RAV4 or whatever it is.
- 11:20I was like, "He's looking for the cheapest option." I said, "Honestly, the cheapest option right now is to trade in that used car, which is worth more than it typically would be." Going up in value.
- 11:28And then, and then, like, a used Tesla is probably gonna be the cheapest trade out, you know? It's just- Yep... it is right now. It really is. So we gotta get it from a dealer. [laughs] Gotta get it from a dealer.
- 11:43There's plenty of them. I know. That's what I'm saying, like, and they're cheap. Cheaper than usual. Well, speaking of Tesla- Yeah... their long-anticipated push into affordable EV territory hit a speed bump.
- 11:53The automakers delayed the launch of their stripped-down Model Y, code name E41, intended to bolster warning signs and broaden its customer base. That's what they were trying to do.
- 12:03But the production of this model is now expected in late 2025 or early '26- Wow... missing the targets. They said they were gonna be jumping in on this, like, I think first half of this year.
- 12:13They plan to build 250,000 units of the model in the US in 2026 once production is fully ramped. The E41's designed to cost 20% less to produce than the refreshed Model Y, which currently starts at 49,000.
- 12:26The delay underscores mounting pressure from aging models back to the used car conversation. They're holding all this inventory. Um, and obviously one of the big challenges, Elon Musk's political activity.
- 12:35They're also preparing a no-frills version of the Model 3 as part of, of a broader pivot toward budget-friendly offerings after shelving their promised $25,000 EV platform to prioritize robotaxi development instead.
- 12:48I mean, Lord knows what they're gonna do next. Look, and they, they absolutely should prioritize robotaxi. They're seeing success. You're, even Waymo is seeing success here.
- 12:58Why not go after something that you think is gonna be the future of the industry, especially when you see, you know, uh- Well, they can own the re-... other manufacturers. Yeah, and they can own- Yeah...
- 13:07the revenue verticals. They, on, on, on all the verticals. Um, I still think, you know, 35, $39,000 Model Y would be super attractive, um, and a $25,000 Model 3 would be super attractive.
- 13:20Um, but yeah, Tesla, Tesla, it's weird because Tesla's in trouble, but at the same time they have all US manufacturing capacity, and so- Yeah... they will be n- they will not have to be impacted by tariffs.
- 13:32So it may be, like, a really quick switch if pricing, you know, drives up in tariff-impacted vehicles.
- 13:38I think that same LinkedIn user, sorry w- your name is not coming through on, on, on the stream here, "I wanna produ- purchase a, a S Plaid Tesla. How long do I wait to pull the trigger before price- pricing increases?"
- 13:50I don't think we can tell you that. [laughs] I wouldn't, I wouldn't have a clue, but we'll find out. We, we probably know some people. Ask Jimmy Douglas. Jimmy Douglas. [laughs] Literally search him on LinkedIn.
- 14:00Jimmy Douglas- @JimmyDouglas... Alex Lawrence- Alex... John Foley. John Foley. Those are your guys. The- those are definitely your guys. Speaking of your guys. [upbeat music] Ah. Segway. If you like cashiers,
- 14:11say goodbye. Sam's Club is betting on the future of checkout by putting it into customers' hands and phones. As a part of a major remodel of all 600 locations- Whoa...
- 14:21the retailer is ditching both traditional and self-checkout lanes in favor of fully app-powered experience. Every single store will adopt the Scan and Go app, eliminating traditional checkout entirely.
- 14:35AI tech will verify the purchases, removing the need for receipt checks at exits, that little fancy, you know, uh, o- you know, check one, check one thing off.
- 14:43[laughs] One-third, this is qui- crazy, one-third of members already use the app, with usage up 50% over three years, meaning they have a really driven adoption there.
- 14:54Digitally engaged customers shop three times as frequently as those th- uh, that are not, and spend, get this, three times as much. Whoa. EVP Diana Marshall said, "Connection is at the heart of every shopping journey.
- 15:07Experience will be a key differentiator to Sam's Club going forward"- All right... in a quote that makes no sense to me. Well- But okay. I, I, yeah, [laughs] experience, of the app experience.
- 15:16Brian Ortega chiming in on the livestream, "The app is great." That was my next question because, like, for an app, first of all- It is. It's strong... your, first of all- I've used it...
- 15:24your Wi-Fi has to be great, number one. Yeah. Right?
- 15:27You have great Wi-Fi, you have a strong app, because there's a part of having the app open, like, im- I've never shopped with an app, so I'm just total, I'm probably the best, like, naysayer right here.
- 15:39But, like, I wanna have my phone available for other things, but I guess if I don't have to check out, it's a really fair trade-off. What do you do? You go through and you scan it with your app?
- 15:47You just scan it as you put it in your, in your, in your basket, right? And so there's none of that, like, double in and out, and you just, as soon as you scan it, and then you walk out. You're done. Yeah.
- 15:57I mean, that's- Pays on the app. You're good. That's, that's pretty amazing. I mean, I, I love hearing Brian Benstock has this bit where he talks about grocery shopping.
- 16:04It's like you go around, you, you put all the stuff in your cart, and then you get there, you take it all out of your cart, and then it goes down the belt, and then you put it all back in your cart [laughs] and you go to the car.
- 16:12And then you take it back out of your cart one more time- Right... before you- And then you take it out of your cart and put it in your trunk... it's, it's a mess. It's a straight mess. Yeah.
- 16:17So, like, look, and they say their, their, their user base is, you know, Gen Z is starting to make up a big, big, uh, swath- For sure... of their user base.
- 16:24And so it's, it's [sighs] I mean, there's so many implications to this. Over 600 stores, how many cashiers do they have? A lot. [laughs] Right? And what it...
- 16:33I think there's a, there's a really great opportunity to deploy some people throughout the store to literally make the experience better.
- 16:39Like, if you don't have to pay cashiers, wouldn't it be amazing to have someone that's helping you load your bags into your car? Man. Right? A little crew, some RFS. Go full Publix on them. It's on.
- 16:49I think that would make a major difference, and you just look out for the, like, the folks who might have trouble, some older folks, um, some moms with kids, you know what I mean, doing the thing.
- 16:56I'll tell you what, that would, that would definitely make some people- Call your boys 'cause we got some consulting hours we can put in. Let's go. Call it up. Call it up. You know? [laughs] We're down.
- 17:05We love stuff like that. Whatever it is, it is Monday.
- 17:07We know you have a lot to do, but you should really go over to asodacot.com, look at a few sessions, figure out the ones that are gonna make you, uh, the more, more successful, and then go there and be with us in three weeks.
- 17:18We'll see you tomorrow.
- 17:18[upbeat music]