Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Investigating Art Crime" with Lynda Albertson
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Investigating
- 0:07Art Crime. In our first stage talk of the year,
- 0:10we introduced a new topic to the Bellingcat Discord
- 0:12server, art crime, sparking an ongoing conversation
- 0:15on how we research thefts, heists, frauds, illicit
- 0:19art markets, cultural heritage looting, art smuggling
- 0:22networks, and restitution claims using open sources.
- 0:26Want to be part of this conversation? Join our
- 0:29Discord server and search for the Artcrime channel.
- 0:32But for now, listen in as we lay the foundations
- 0:34of this topic. This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte
- 0:37Ma, on Thursday the 16th of January 2025 in the
- 0:40VeliCat Discord server. Welcome back to the Bell
- 0:57and Cat stage talk series and happy new year.
- 1:00This is the first talk in 2025, can you believe
- 1:03it? And this week we're joined by Linda Albertson
- 1:07discussing a new focus topic for Bell and Cat,
- 1:10art crime. Linda is the CEO of the Association
- 1:13for Research into Crimes Against Art, a civil
- 1:16society organization that focuses on providing
- 1:19an improved intelligence picture which can help
- 1:22law enforcement and public prosecutors to better
- 1:24understand the mechanisms behind crime activities
- 1:27related to trafficking of cultural goods, both
- 1:30offline and online, criminal modus operandi,
- 1:33and the possible nexus with terrorist financing.
- 1:35She also spearheads ARCA's transnational crime
- 1:38mapping project, which provides targeted analysis
- 1:41and cross -border intelligence to law enforcement
- 1:43agencies and public prosecutors, and oversees
- 1:47ARCA's 220 -hour PG search program, which trains
- 1:51people in OSINT techniques, provenance research,
- 1:55and pretty much everything else related to analyzing
- 1:57art and antiquities crime. So we have a lot to
- 2:02talk about in this next hour. As we talk, please
- 2:06put your questions in the chat, which is in the
- 2:08top right -hand side of your screen, and I'll
- 2:10make sure to ask them as we move into the Q &A
- 2:13section. Please note that if you do not want
- 2:16me to mention your Discord name, please pop that
- 2:19within your question and I'll make sure to not
- 2:22name you on the audio recording. Okay, here we
- 2:26go, Linda. Please take it away. Okay. Thank you,
- 2:31Charlie, for setting this up, and also I'd like
- 2:33to thank George, who reached out to me just before
- 2:36Christmas to invite me to come and give a talk
- 2:40with you all. I've been following Bellingcat's
- 2:43work since about 2015. I think we were both looking
- 2:47at specific sites that were the subject of iconoclasm
- 2:52in Syria. And it was interesting to see how there
- 2:55were some parallels in the organization. But
- 2:57this is the first time I've had a chance to meet
- 2:59with you all. And I'm really looking forward
- 3:01to kind of helping you guys see a little bit
- 3:04about how my world works and then hopefully also
- 3:07learning things from you all about things that
- 3:10you may be doing that might be of use if it's
- 3:13applied to the work that we do. So I thought
- 3:16I would start this particular podcast today.
- 3:20by giving some examples of how OSINT can be a
- 3:24game changer as it relates to looking at documenting
- 3:29and analyzing what we see in the way of criminal
- 3:34activity in the art market. So starting all the
- 3:37way from the criminal themselves that initiates
- 3:41the act. So that could be a forger or that could
- 3:44be someone that's plundering a tomb in in Italy
- 3:49or perhaps looting territory up in Bulgaria,
- 3:54wherever it is, from the very initial criminal
- 3:56all the way through the various supply chain
- 3:59pieces that actually facilitate those types of
- 4:03activities going through to the good faith buyer,
- 4:06which is ultimately at the end of the marketplace,
- 4:09so to speak. So I want to start this talk by
- 4:12going over some examples, some current examples.
- 4:16that will help you look at how we are interpreting
- 4:18how the market is moving today, but also looking
- 4:22at some of our historic examples because those
- 4:26are also quite useful because our particular
- 4:30prime skill set area, the area where criminals
- 4:33operate, it's a slower boil than say, for example,
- 4:37if you're harvesting cocaine and then you're
- 4:39shipping it overseas and you want to get it out
- 4:41to the market as quickly as possible. And antiquities
- 4:45theft is often more along the lines of, you know,
- 4:48sitting in the tree waiting for the deer to come
- 4:50by and being very, very quiet and hoping nobody
- 4:53notices that you're observing things until eventually
- 4:56that perfect opportunity arrives to like make
- 4:59your case, so to speak. So sometimes our cases
- 5:01can be very, very slow, which people like me
- 5:04like because I like the puzzles that it gives
- 5:06me time to work on. But sometimes for other people
- 5:09that are more like need that instant gratification,
- 5:11that aha moment, sometimes our crime is not quite
- 5:14that particular jolt of energy. But I thought
- 5:19I would start by giving you an example by opening
- 5:22a video of a type of social media or Soxcent
- 5:27that we would get from either our own investigations
- 5:31or sometimes people like yourselves that would
- 5:32come to us and say, hey, I found this image online
- 5:35or this video online through social media of
- 5:38a different website. or through, you know, a
- 5:40telegram channel or wherever somebody might have
- 5:43approached you even privately by email and sent
- 5:45you information about an object that's up for
- 5:47sale. We get those kinds of requests from people
- 5:50all the time and the first thing we have to do
- 5:52is kind of look at the object itself that's in
- 5:55these photographs and determine if that object
- 5:58is a forgery. And today, for example, we will
- 6:02see some pretty extravagant methods used by forgers
- 6:08that will create new objects and then pass them
- 6:11off as old by putting them up in very theatrical
- 6:14scenarios. So the first thing we do when we get
- 6:17a video such as this one that I'm going to open
- 6:19up right now is kind of look at the objects itself.
- 6:22So what you see here are some mummy cartonnage
- 6:25or trappings. This would sit over the top of
- 6:29the body inside the coffin, which would then
- 6:31sit inside of a sarcophagus. So what you see
- 6:34here are objects that are coming from Egypt.
- 6:37They're very, very specific. You can see quite
- 6:41a lot of detail in some places, although it's
- 6:44not quite clear on this video. You'll see hieroglyphics
- 6:46as well. You also see a little tiny piece of
- 6:50paper on the image on the left -hand side, which
- 6:53is what we refer to as a proof of life. A lot
- 6:56of times in these transactions, because digital
- 7:00technology and digital photographs and videos
- 7:03are so commonplace, intermediaries will pass
- 7:07their videos along, then someone else might find
- 7:09a buyer and then say like, hey, I want a percentage
- 7:12of this sale in the process. So the person that
- 7:16is trying to purchase this type of material will
- 7:19sometimes... ask for a proof of life because
- 7:21they want to deal directly with the finder, the
- 7:25looter themselves, and not three intermediaries
- 7:28in between where they're having to uplift the
- 7:30price of the object. So this is a typical type
- 7:32of video that we might receive. If it's a topology
- 7:36of art that I know well, then I can analyze it
- 7:39and look at it and say, hmm, I think this is
- 7:41authentic. Or if it's, in this case, a piece
- 7:44from Egypt, I would usually run it by one of
- 7:47our analysts that is an expert on Egyptian art,
- 7:50someone that can read hieroglyphics, someone
- 7:53that can tell by the painting styles perhaps
- 7:55which part of Egypt these particular objects
- 7:58came from. In this particular case, I've seen
- 8:01enough looted coffins, mummy coffins from Egypt
- 8:06that I'm pretty good at being able to tell if
- 8:09what I'm looking at is authentic or not. When
- 8:11it comes to statuary, I'm less... proficient.
- 8:14So oftentimes those will reach out to other people
- 8:16in our network that are experts. So if any of
- 8:19you that are a part of Bellingcat are, you know,
- 8:22an art historian, an Egyptologist, an archaeologist,
- 8:25please do let me know because there are times
- 8:27that material comes up that we just don't have
- 8:30enough experience in. Like I can't tell you necessarily
- 8:33the difference between, you know, certain dynasties
- 8:37of China that is coming from China. So it's very
- 8:41difficult when you're looking at porcelains,
- 8:43for example, to know what's authentic and what's
- 8:46a reproduction. So you really do need some kind
- 8:48of inherent expertise. But we will end up with
- 8:51photos like this. And the first thing that we
- 8:54have to do is think about it. Do we want to say
- 8:57something right away? Do we want to make a large
- 8:59announcement? You know, oh, these types of things
- 9:01shouldn't be sold on Facebook. Well, the fact
- 9:05that they are sold in these social media settings
- 9:07allows us to capture the information. And if
- 9:10we capture the information, hopefully when those
- 9:13types of objects come back up for sale in a nice
- 9:16gallery in London or a nice gallery in New York
- 9:19City, we can then match it to a looter's photo,
- 9:22which allows us the opportunity to kind of cross
- 9:26compare notes. So like if we have documentation
- 9:29that is being circulated with that particular
- 9:32object that's saying, you know, that it came
- 9:34from a family collection from the 1920s, but
- 9:37yet we have a brand new looter photo, like the
- 9:40ones that you see here, then we can kind of counter
- 9:43that and we can start to look at is that documentation
- 9:46that's traveling with the object authentic or
- 9:49a forgery in and of itself. And sometimes that's
- 9:51one of the very things that we need in some countries
- 9:54to prove that something is stolen is that there's
- 9:58either a falsification or a fraud attempt going
- 10:01on with the documentation itself, or that we
- 10:04can prove by looter videos that have time stamps
- 10:07specifically that this object was probably still
- 10:10in country. So this is where your metadata that
- 10:12sometimes you see when you're looking at photos,
- 10:15if it hasn't been stripped off completely, can
- 10:17sometimes be very, very helpful. If the object
- 10:19is geolocated to still be in Egypt in 2012, then
- 10:24we know that that is after the date of the Egyptian
- 10:27cultural property law that went into effect.
- 10:30So it helps us to know that this perhaps may
- 10:33have been the result of either the Arab Spring,
- 10:36because we see a lot of conflict antiquities,
- 10:38but we also see a lot of post -conflict work.
- 10:41In fact, during the COVID lockdown, we saw a
- 10:44lot of images like these where multiple mummy
- 10:48coffins or carton nudge pieces would be in one
- 10:51room stored together because with the borders
- 10:53closed and so many countries kind of on a mandatory
- 10:56lockdown, there was a kind of influx of too many
- 11:01objects that were being found and not enough
- 11:03exportation of those objects from the source
- 11:06country onto an intermediary country. Then what
- 11:09do we do with images like this? Like I said,
- 11:12you know, we collect them, we document them in
- 11:14specific ways so that we can find them later.
- 11:18We don't just have one giant database that says,
- 11:21you know, mummy cartilage, because if we did
- 11:23that, we'd never be able to find which image
- 11:26represents the object in question. But then what
- 11:30we do is we look for similar matches. And if
- 11:32you see this image that I have below here, which
- 11:35looks very much like the second Cartilage piece
- 11:40here, the one to the right, you can see that
- 11:43this particular object was eventually seized
- 11:46in Belgium from a fine art fair. Again, looking
- 11:51at the paperwork, the paperwork doesn't match
- 11:53with the object itself, and it did match with
- 11:56other photos that were part of different trafficking
- 12:00groups. So sometimes these can take years. And
- 12:04in fact, this particular video is dated to 2021.
- 12:08And then this subsequent seizure was quite a
- 12:11few years later. So it's an interesting way of
- 12:15finding, documenting, looking for patterns, and
- 12:18then moving forward from there to hopefully build
- 12:21cases in whatever jurisdiction that that particular
- 12:24object then kind of pops up into. Now I'm going
- 12:29to go back just a little bit backwards in time
- 12:32because I want to show you why these cases can
- 12:35be really slow in one sense but very fruitful
- 12:39in others. So what you see here are a series
- 12:43of Polaroid images with numbers on them. So 152,
- 12:47153, 154 of what looks to be an object freshly
- 12:53looted and kind of dirty. You can see it's Sitting
- 12:55in the boot of a car, there's a bunch of newspapers
- 12:59underneath it. You can see that it's fragmented
- 13:01into different pieces. What makes looking at
- 13:07digital photographs interesting, I find the same
- 13:10level of interest in Polaroid photographs because
- 13:13they, again, will help date an object, even though
- 13:17they don't have metadata in the traditional sense
- 13:19that we would have with digital technologies.
- 13:21So when you see this type of photograph, you
- 13:24automatically understand that this type of picture
- 13:29could only have been taken after 1972. 1972 being
- 13:33the year that these types of cameras became available
- 13:36in Europe, since this is a European piece. In
- 13:39fact, this is a piece from Italy. So it helps
- 13:42us to know that in 1972, this object was freshly
- 13:46looted in the trunk of somebody's car. Now, if
- 13:50you've come across these pictures because maybe
- 13:52you stop a trafficker or someone that's related
- 13:56to traffickers, like Pasquale Camera, for example,
- 14:00fell asleep at the wheel of his car when he crashed,
- 14:02he had Polaroid images inside the glove compartment
- 14:05of his car, and those helped to kind of like...
- 14:08paved the road for a bigger investigation that
- 14:11then resulted in thousands of Polaroid images
- 14:14being found in what is now known as the Giacomo
- 14:17Medici archive and the second archive, which
- 14:20is the John Franco Bacchina archive. Now, the
- 14:23reason these types of photographic techniques
- 14:27were used by traffickers in the past was because
- 14:31they didn't have to take a roll of film to be
- 14:34developed at a you know, a photographic shop,
- 14:37which is what we used to have to do back when
- 14:39I was a young lass. So you didn't have to worry
- 14:43about perhaps the, you know, photography lab
- 14:45technician, you know, going to the police and
- 14:48saying, hey, these pictures are a little bit
- 14:50suspect and you might want to like be here when
- 14:53this guy comes to pick up his developed film.
- 14:56So by having this kind of instantaneous photo,
- 14:59It allowed the dealers to instantly take a picture
- 15:03of something very, very quickly, drop it in the
- 15:05mailbox and send it off to perhaps a dealer in
- 15:07Switzerland or another dealer in Rome or wherever
- 15:10the particular dealer was at any given point
- 15:13in time. This particular object, as you can see
- 15:17below, after it was restored, went from Italy,
- 15:21was handled by a very important dealer from Rome
- 15:26in Cerveterre. It was also handled by a London
- 15:29dealer and his Greek partner for a while and
- 15:32then it was sold to an American millionaire and
- 15:34eventually donated to the John Paul Getty Museum.
- 15:38So you can see that there are several passes
- 15:41in these processes for these types of objects
- 15:45to finally make their way into a museum where
- 15:48the museum is just seeing it as a wonderful donation
- 15:51by one of their constituents. The family that
- 15:54donated this particular piece in fact donated
- 15:56hundreds of pieces to the John Paul Getty Museum
- 15:58This one has since gone back because we do have
- 16:01access to this particular Polaroid through long
- 16:04-term investigations the reason I brought up
- 16:07an older investigation in this conversation with
- 16:11you is because I wanted you to kind of understand
- 16:15that just because you find something that may
- 16:18not necessarily be overtly rewarding today doesn't
- 16:23mean that it won't bear fruit sometimes a decade
- 16:26later, or in the case of the Medici archives
- 16:28and the Gianfranco Bacchina archives, we still
- 16:31see people, the Carabinieri officers and other
- 16:34analysts that analyze these photographs, are
- 16:38finding these pieces as they recirculate into
- 16:40the art market today. Perhaps they were bought
- 16:43When these two dealers were very, very active,
- 16:46they went into a private collection. Maybe that
- 16:48person has now passed away and his children are,
- 16:51you know, consigning the pieces to galleries.
- 16:54So they reappear periodically and have been bearing
- 16:57fruit for now 40 years. So this type of imagery,
- 17:02when it can be captured, when it can be analyzed
- 17:04and interpreted, is quite useful on a lot of
- 17:08different levels. So just like digital photographs
- 17:11which have now replaced Polaroids, they're used
- 17:14because they're instantaneous, they're used because
- 17:17even the dirty broken pieces kind of stand in
- 17:22a voyeuristic way as representing something that's
- 17:26fresh, something that no one's ever seen before
- 17:29and that is in fact authentic. You will see in
- 17:32some countries people staging not authentic material.
- 17:36in settings that make it look like they actually
- 17:39were looted objects to try and entice people
- 17:42to buy things. And those types of dealers oftentimes
- 17:45will feed what they're selling to kind of interpret
- 17:49who they're selling to. Are they selling to a
- 17:52novice? If they're selling to a novice, then
- 17:54they'll send replicas. If they're selling to
- 17:56somebody that's more seasoned or an expert that
- 17:59knows the material culture that they're trying
- 18:01to sell, then they'll save the real pieces. for
- 18:05their conversations with these other people and
- 18:07also ask for a different markup perhaps. So this
- 18:10is just a way to show how early techniques in
- 18:14analyzing something can then bear fruit and give
- 18:17you opportunities to help law enforcement if
- 18:20you're ever past this type of a particular photo.
- 18:25Sometimes the objects themselves will even give
- 18:28you some examples of like how to trace a particular
- 18:32object. So I'm again using Egypt. I'm heavily
- 18:35focusing on Egypt simply because for the most
- 18:38part that's a type of art that most people have
- 18:41been exposed through their own schooling and
- 18:43education, even if they don't know each type
- 18:45of object. So what you see here are a group of
- 18:48what are called Ushoptis. Now Ushoptis were left
- 18:52in tombs Along with the sarcophagus along with
- 18:56the dead and offerings for the dead and each
- 19:00Burial had a certain number of these you shopped
- 19:03ease. Okay, so they were put in place To represent
- 19:07a worker in the afterlife for every day of the
- 19:10year. So they were 365 in a perfect world sometimes
- 19:14that didn't always happen 365 workers one for
- 19:17every day of the year and then a certain number
- 19:19of overseers that overseed the littler U -Shop
- 19:23D workers. And what they tell us and why they're
- 19:27interesting for like looking at and examining
- 19:31trafficking patterns is as you can see from a
- 19:34lot of these, they have hieroglyphics that are
- 19:36painted on the front of them. And those hieroglyphics
- 19:39will talk about the person that is deceased.
- 19:43They'll give their name. They'll give their title.
- 19:46Sometimes they will have incantations that are
- 19:49written on them as well. And they would be pretty
- 19:52much identical, other than they're written out
- 19:54by hand, for all of 365 of those people, you
- 19:59know, the little tiny Ushoptis. So why is that
- 20:01helpful to us? And we see this in lots of different
- 20:04types of art. If you have 365 objects that are
- 20:08all the same, and the looter runs off and he
- 20:11leaves the tomb that he's broken into open, and
- 20:14the authorities go back and find, let's say,
- 20:16one or two of these Ushoptis left behind, then
- 20:20when all of a sudden a rash of this particular
- 20:24authentic eusopti comes on the market, it gives
- 20:26us something to analyze. If all the eusoptis
- 20:29are coming from the same individual, that's suspect
- 20:32in and of itself, because we usually don't see
- 20:35one collector that will collect 12 of the same
- 20:38objects. Usually a collector will like one of
- 20:40each, like you see here in the Louvre Museum.
- 20:43They're different eusoptis from a lot of different
- 20:45burials. So that can sometimes help narrow down
- 20:49where in the supply chain the particular person
- 20:52that is selling the object might be. If they
- 20:54have five or six or seven of these, maybe he's
- 20:57closer to the original source country looter
- 21:00than say, for example, the showroom gallery that's
- 21:03in London that has one of these particular objects.
- 21:06But it's a way for us to track things by looking
- 21:10at the specific type of art. We also see that
- 21:12with Etruscan material. Etruscan material can
- 21:15be very specific to particular regions. Apulian
- 21:18vases have a very particular style. So we can
- 21:21look at them and say, OK, those come from southern
- 21:24Italy. So it's a methodology that needs people
- 21:28to say, ah, this is being sold. And it also needs
- 21:31a helping hand by people that are familiar with
- 21:35the type of art that is being sold. Also need
- 21:39familiarity with looking at the names of people.
- 21:41What are the problematic names that the dealers
- 21:43that have perhaps had seizures in the past? And
- 21:48sometimes that can be more difficult to determine
- 21:52as an external person to law enforcement. So
- 21:56a lot of times, because these are ongoing investigations,
- 21:59even when there is a criminal proceedings going
- 22:01on for privacy reasons, the person where the
- 22:05objects are seized from will be named specifically.
- 22:09buy their initials. So that doesn't help an organization
- 22:13like ARCA that wants to kind of track is this
- 22:15the first time this particular dealer has had
- 22:17a problem or is it the tenth time this particular
- 22:20dealer has a problem. The first time you can
- 22:22say okay well perhaps he wasn't careful or she
- 22:25wasn't careful and you know they trusted the
- 22:28person that sold them the object but when it's
- 22:29the fifth sixth or seventh time their name has
- 22:31come up in relation to something that is stolen,
- 22:34then you start to think, okay, well maybe there's
- 22:37something a little bit more here that we should
- 22:38explore. Maybe we should look at all of the pieces
- 22:41that this particular individual is looking at
- 22:44and kind of explore which ones might be suspect
- 22:46and which ones might be perfectly legitimate.
- 22:49So your Shabtis are a good example of how we
- 22:51can explore those. This is another example. Sometimes
- 22:55you'll see them with the boxes that they would
- 22:57have been in the more prestigious burials. Other
- 23:00times they would just be scattered in a tomb.
- 23:02If they're scattered in the tomb, those are often
- 23:04the ones that sometimes are left behind, or sometimes
- 23:07they are even picked up very early on by the
- 23:10traditional looters from 2 ,000 years ago. So
- 23:13people have been looting tombs in Egypt, unfortunately,
- 23:16for a very long time. the person that is breaking
- 23:19into a tomb today is not going to say, oh, well,
- 23:21there's only 256 of these here, not 365, so maybe
- 23:26I should leave them alone. They're aware that
- 23:28sometimes looters in the past have left things
- 23:31behind, and they just take as many as they can.
- 23:34So this is where I'm going to kind of close up
- 23:38my talk by just adding one more thing, and then
- 23:41we'll open the floor for some questions. OSINT
- 23:45crowdsourcing benefits can help in a lot of ways
- 23:48in our field, as long as the people that are
- 23:51doing it kind of take that very discreet, watchful
- 23:56waiting approach. Making big noises and saying,
- 23:59you know, I'm going to publish this in the New
- 24:01York Times. Look, I saw this, you know, recently
- 24:04looted object from Syria from Palmyra. Look,
- 24:08it's beautiful. We'll only send that underground
- 24:10for about 40 years. The lifetime of the person
- 24:14that will buy something illegitimate and then
- 24:17that person passes away and then the next person
- 24:19comes along doesn't realize it's quite so sketchy
- 24:21so sometimes It takes people to look at things
- 24:26in a kind of long -term approach most of the
- 24:30time law enforcement are busy chasing the You
- 24:34know, I don't want to say low -hanging fruit,
- 24:36but the ones that can bear the most fruit at
- 24:39one time. So they'll be looking at bigger cases.
- 24:42They won't necessarily start with just one looted
- 24:45object, even though they know absolutely it fits
- 24:48the pattern of what a looted object is. What
- 24:51they're looking to do is find a way to stymie
- 24:53the complete network that's involved. And sometimes
- 24:56that means watching and waiting. It seems like
- 25:00people aren't necessarily responding to something,
- 25:03but they actually are. Sometimes they're looking
- 25:05at where the object turns up. and what the laws
- 25:08in that particular country allow for. Some countries
- 25:11have a shorter statute of limitations than others,
- 25:14so sometimes they'll wait till objects move to
- 25:17another jurisdiction where it's more likely that
- 25:21that object can be seized and then restituted.
- 25:24But the having people like yourselves people
- 25:27that are interested in looking at art looking
- 25:30for the detail of things is quite useful to us
- 25:34because we that you know multiplies the number
- 25:37of eyeballs that are looking in a lot of different
- 25:40areas and Sometimes you will see how the the
- 25:44criminality changes overtime you know for a while
- 25:48syria and iraq we're getting a whole lot of attention
- 25:51so we didn't see a lot of material coming out
- 25:54online in open forums that would come from these
- 25:56particular area areas but we did see was an uptick
- 26:00of art that was being stolen perhaps from nepal
- 26:03and from india because there was not the the
- 26:06hyper focus on terrorism and could these pieces
- 26:09be tied to financing organized crime or terrorism
- 26:12so. The market itself in illicit material changes
- 26:16over time, and observers that are looking at
- 26:18things longitudinally can see that and can help
- 26:21us with that. It also helps us when we can collaborate
- 26:26with experts that we know on the other end of
- 26:29the equation. So when you see something that's
- 26:31super important, sometimes... We already have
- 26:34connections with the very people that can write
- 26:36the documentation from one country to the next
- 26:38to help that process go a little bit smoother.
- 26:43Or to just tell you, this is great, but we're
- 26:46going to hold on this for a while, because either
- 26:48they're already aware of it, it's already been
- 26:50seen, and it's under observation with law enforcement,
- 26:53or because it needs a longer life cycle of things
- 26:57to look at. And I think with that, I'll... turn
- 27:01off the share screen function and I will go back
- 27:04to Charlie and let her see what kind of questions
- 27:08we have in the audience. Thank you so much, Linda,
- 27:11for that fascinating talk. It's wonderful to
- 27:15kind of see those examples that you shared as
- 27:17well. I also put the links to those examples
- 27:19in the chat for anybody who wants to look back
- 27:21at them in more detail. I'll also include them
- 27:24in the description of the podcast episode as
- 27:27well. Please make sure that you're putting in
- 27:30your questions in the chat. We've had a few come
- 27:32through already, but please pop them in there
- 27:35and I'll ask them in a second. Linda, I wanted
- 27:38to start off with this question because it's
- 27:41something that I ask a lot of people who do these
- 27:44stage talks and for you, it seems to be not just
- 27:46work, but a passion and it's something that we're
- 27:50passionate about here at Bellingcat as well,
- 27:52hence why we're interested in speaking to you.
- 27:54So I wanted to understand what first sparked
- 27:57your interest in this area and what kind of got
- 28:00you into art crime and what, in case it inspires
- 28:04others to get involved, basically. A lot of people
- 28:09that work with ARCA have different kind of backgrounds.
- 28:11I would say that the bulk, probably about 70
- 28:14% of our analysts come with an art historical
- 28:18background. I'm not one of those. Instead, my
- 28:22background is in the criminal justice system.
- 28:25I have a degree in psychology. I'm interested
- 28:28in what makes crime happen from the lowest level
- 28:33criminal through, you know, like what's happening
- 28:36in that individual's life that makes them turn
- 28:38to crime in the first place. So I enjoy that
- 28:42aspect of it. What brought me to art as a criminal
- 28:46kind of like niche in this particular market
- 28:50was just a great passion for the cultures of
- 28:53the past and how ultimately we're all tied together
- 28:56to one another. And it's that, you know, the
- 29:00remains that we have of the past that we can
- 29:02use to kind of identify us as people. Hopefully,
- 29:06like... you know, 2000 years from now, everybody's
- 29:08going to see our little tablets like this, and
- 29:10they're going to wonder what these are and why
- 29:12they were so important to us and why we were
- 29:14fixated on them. But it does say a lot about
- 29:17the community itself, how they lived, what they
- 29:21revered, these kinds of things. So I would say
- 29:24that's kind of what got me into it. First opportunity
- 29:27was just having colleagues that were sleeping
- 29:30at an excavation when they found a major statue
- 29:33in Rome, a statue of Marcius, a very rare statue
- 29:36that's now in the Capitoline Museums, where they
- 29:40had to sleep at the excavation overnight because
- 29:42the statue was too big to move at night and they
- 29:44were afraid that people would come in overnight
- 29:46and actually, you know, nick it and run with
- 29:49it. So, you know, even in a country in the western
- 29:53part of Europe that has got an enormously well
- 29:57-trained police departments such as the Kid of
- 29:59Neonity still have issues with art and antiquities
- 30:01crime. And that was quite interesting to me.
- 30:06Really interesting. I think Curious Cat's question
- 30:08actually falls nicely after what you've just
- 30:11said. They've asked what skills slash needs are
- 30:15highest to help with your group? I wouldn't say
- 30:20any one is higher than the other. I mean, For
- 30:24example, we have some people that don't have
- 30:26a problem whatsoever to look at every single
- 30:30Egyptian object or every single Greek object
- 30:33in every single museum of the world. And that's
- 30:37a very long and tedious process. It requires
- 30:39somebody to really be invested in doing searches
- 30:43to figure out which museums hold which material
- 30:45and then which of those pieces could be problematic.
- 30:50That takes somebody that is very detailed oriented,
- 30:54but also very passionate about the material itself.
- 30:57Other people are very good at reverse image searching,
- 31:00and sometimes that can help us find the missing
- 31:02gaps. Oftentimes in the art market, they will
- 31:06not list in the provenance of an object. Another
- 31:10dealer so if I'm a dealer and I'm selling a work
- 31:13of art I'm not going to give you the name of
- 31:16the dealer perhaps that I bought the object from
- 31:18and part of that is to protect your client stream
- 31:20because you don't want the Client to go to that
- 31:23other dealer around you and part of it is sometimes
- 31:25because the person below them that they purchased
- 31:27from is kind of problematic And they don't want
- 31:30to advertise that necessarily. But sometimes
- 31:33because the objects can be very specific in size
- 31:36and shape, someone that's good at technology
- 31:39or reverse imaging might be able to find out
- 31:41where that piece has been in the past. So that's
- 31:44quite helpful. The questions are filling up now.
- 31:50Sarah asks, what's the best process to get results
- 31:53and the art restituted? Keeping in mind the concerns
- 31:57about making too much noise. E .G. What's guidance
- 32:00for server members who want to do this, keeping
- 32:03in mind it's a public server? The best thing
- 32:08to do because it is a public server and because
- 32:11oftentimes, especially with Discord, you guys
- 32:14are using your own screen names. I myself am
- 32:17using Saturn because I like wine quite a bit.
- 32:21So when you're using a pseudonym, I'm probably
- 32:23not going to give you a very strong roadmap necessarily
- 32:26to tell me you know, this is the tricks of the
- 32:29trade, because I don't know who you are. And
- 32:31oftentimes in public forums, we do have suspect
- 32:34people sitting in on these types of talks, because
- 32:38they can learn from us. They learn what law enforcement
- 32:41is already onto or researchers like ourselves
- 32:44are already onto. So the best thing to do is
- 32:46to open a direct channel with people that have
- 32:48been doing this before. That doesn't mean that
- 32:51you can't work independently, quietly on your
- 32:55own. I'm happy for you to do that. In fact, that's
- 32:58a wonderful thing and we can even tell you where
- 33:00we have some gaps, but sometimes knowing what
- 33:03your interest is, where you have acuity will
- 33:08help us to be able to tell you where we think
- 33:10there's enough stuff out there to be interesting
- 33:12to you that will lend a hand. Now to the question
- 33:16of being careful, you know, there are a lot of
- 33:21legal ways for one country to ask for the restitution
- 33:25of a work of art. It's a bit easier when it's
- 33:27in a museum because it's not in transit. It can
- 33:31sit there on the back burner for two or three,
- 33:34five, six, ten years before an action request
- 33:38is made. In some cases, it depends on what the
- 33:41legal... Once it's made public, for example,
- 33:44then the clock starts ticking in some cases of
- 33:47having to have a response. But if it's something
- 33:50that's in some small museum that no one has noticed
- 33:52before or hasn't been publicized in any real
- 33:55way or in any publication, it can still sit there
- 33:58and we can work on the pieces that are in movement
- 34:01from one place to the other. It is important,
- 34:06though, to kind of bear in mind that just because
- 34:08you identify something that is even if it's a
- 34:12perfect match, a perfect identical match, I know
- 34:15this was stolen in XYZ museum, is to interface
- 34:19with people that have good rapport with law enforcement
- 34:21already. And that's not to steal the thunder
- 34:25of the people that are involved. If people want
- 34:27their name out there, we're happy to say so -and
- 34:29-so found this particular object, they flagged
- 34:32it up to us, now we're taking it to you guys.
- 34:35But a lot of times, You're flagging something
- 34:38up that maybe some of these law enforcement people
- 34:40are aware of they're just watchful waiting So
- 34:44it's easy to get disgruntled or to feel that
- 34:48you know, law enforcement is not necessarily
- 34:51giving credit and sometimes even researchers
- 34:54that have been doing this for years get highly
- 34:56annoyed that, you know, there'll be this big
- 34:58pomp and circumstance restitution ceremony where
- 35:01the public prosecutors will be named and the
- 35:04law enforcement officers will be named and the
- 35:06people that, you know, kind of scratched the
- 35:09surface and opened that door to where the problem
- 35:11was. Sometimes they're not named. Sometimes that's
- 35:14by choice. I'm one of those people. I'm not a
- 35:16big fan of having my name on court documents.
- 35:19And I don't need a little pin on my desk to tell
- 35:22me that what I do is important. But for some
- 35:24people, they do have to justify their time. And
- 35:27they do want that credit. And that's OK as well.
- 35:30It's just a matter of kind of communicating that
- 35:33on the front end so that we can kind of let you
- 35:36know if those expectations with the type of art
- 35:39you're identifying are going to bear fruit or
- 35:41not. And on communication, obviously the art
- 35:46world operates on carefully cultivated relationships
- 35:49and trust networks, which can be seemingly opposite
- 35:53to transparent OSINT methodology. How can open
- 35:56source investigators navigate this contradiction
- 35:58to effectively contribute to art crime investigations?
- 36:01without compromising ongoing work? Is it just
- 36:04communication is key and giving a heads up to
- 36:07organisations that you are looking into this?
- 36:10Or is it okay to work in isolation in some parts?
- 36:12I think it is okay to work in isolation if you've
- 36:15got experience in that particular topology of
- 36:18art. So especially if you're an archaeologist
- 36:20or an art historian, you know, you understand
- 36:23Bauhaus paintings, or you are very interested
- 36:25in World War II era claims, you know, Holocaust
- 36:28era losses, or the Ukrainian losses from the
- 36:30two museums. They're more than just two, but
- 36:33the two principal museums where a lot of the
- 36:35paintings were taken. You know, if you've got
- 36:38a passion in an area, you're going to work in
- 36:39it a lot harder. So there's not this need to
- 36:45have somebody right looking over your shoulder.
- 36:47And you may want to eventually publish a report,
- 36:52an academic article, or even a newspaper article,
- 36:56hopefully somewhere down the road. The one thing
- 36:59we say about like, you know, talking with agencies
- 37:01like ours or there are others out there is to
- 37:04learn from our mistakes. In 2009, when ARCA was
- 37:08formed, you know, we went racing up to the door
- 37:10of the police and saying, we can help you, we're
- 37:12experts. And they looked at us like we had, you
- 37:15know, a unicorn horn growing out of our head.
- 37:17Like, what the heck are you talking about? We
- 37:18can't share anything with you. You know, we're
- 37:21a confidential Intel -based organization and
- 37:24you're an outsider. We don't know who you are
- 37:26from Adam. So sometimes it does take some time
- 37:29to, like, establish the trust involved to where
- 37:34they'll deal with you one -on -one. Until then,
- 37:37having somebody like our association that already
- 37:40has that trust level built up, we can kind of
- 37:42help you make sure that you are building the
- 37:45profile you need to be accepted, if you want
- 37:48to work directly with law enforcement. Some people
- 37:50don't. Some people are not comfortable with that
- 37:53at all. You also need to think about which law
- 37:57enforcement you're working with. When you're
- 37:59looking at the video that I showed at the beginning
- 38:03of my talk, if the volume was turned up, you
- 38:06can hear children. and the background of that
- 38:09particular video. So you can tell that that particular
- 38:12object at that point in time was probably inside
- 38:15someone's home. So if you take an object and
- 38:20you notify certain authorities in certain countries,
- 38:25are you taking the sole breadwinner out of that
- 38:28family home and leaving a mother with children?
- 38:32without any income source. So it's a Murphy's
- 38:36choice, what is it? Sophie's choice, decision,
- 38:40not Murphy's law, but Sophie's choice, of where
- 38:43you're doing the most harm and where you're doing
- 38:45the most good. ARCA tends to look more at the
- 38:50end of the supply chain versus the beginning
- 38:52of the supply chain. Because if you can eliminate
- 38:54the people that are purchasing those pieces,
- 38:57the... The source looters, the impoverished people
- 39:01will turn to other means for support. Sometimes
- 39:04good, sometimes not so good. But the fact is
- 39:08that at the end of the day, we don't want someone
- 39:11sitting in jail for 45 years because they stole
- 39:15something. We don't want a hand cut off because
- 39:18they stole something. We don't want the death
- 39:20penalty because they stole something. But what
- 39:23we do want is to break the supply chain to where
- 39:26people are deterred from this type of activity
- 39:29when it comes to antiquities. Painting thefts
- 39:32is a different story that tends to be more, you
- 39:35know, the more traditional art markets, art money
- 39:39laundering through art tends to be more the contemporary
- 39:42market at the moment. But all of that can change
- 39:44depending on where law enforcement is looking.
- 39:48If they start looking too much in one area, the
- 39:50market adapts quickly. Just while we're speaking
- 39:54about the supply chain and the people behind
- 39:57this kind of crime, my colleague Peter has asked,
- 40:01is it more common for criminals in this trade
- 40:03to specialize in antiquities slash art, or are
- 40:07they more often larger organized crime groups
- 40:09involved in many criminal markets? It varies.
- 40:13I would say First of all, let's look at the word
- 40:17organized crime. If you're looking at organized
- 40:19crime as a team of seven people from a looter
- 40:22to a middleman to a courier to a low -level dealer,
- 40:25there's a lot of that level of organized crime.
- 40:29There is also organized crime on a much more
- 40:32scary level. So like groups like the clans from
- 40:36Naples that were dealing in heavy amounts of
- 40:39cocaine based in Dubai, for example, dealt in
- 40:43stolen paintings. Two very, very important Van
- 40:47Gogh paintings that were restituted a few years
- 40:49ago were with Raffaele Imperiali, which was one
- 40:51of the principal Italian Cumorah clan conduits
- 40:58for cocaine coming from basically all over Europe,
- 41:03but predominantly coming through Spain. We see
- 41:05that also in the Netherlands. We see paintings
- 41:07disappear in the Netherlands that are tied to
- 41:10different drug trafficking organization. So there
- 41:14is that connection with larger organized crime,
- 41:17but it is less often and it's usually used as
- 41:22a negotiating tool. Sometimes hoping for lower
- 41:25sentences, they don't always get them. But oftentimes
- 41:29it's either for that or to be used as collateral,
- 41:31for example, you know, to like hold like, I'm
- 41:34going to give you my stolen painting to hang
- 41:36on to for a while until I pay you for you know,
- 41:39the cocaine that I just got for me once I sell
- 41:41it someplace else. So, you know, we do see specific
- 41:46types of organized crime using vanity pieces
- 41:49as a kind of negotiative tool because they know
- 41:53sooner or later the clock is ticking on them
- 41:55being discovered. John P. Murphys asked, I'm
- 41:58curious whether there's been any evidence of
- 42:01Gentive AI impacting the store and our market.
- 42:04Are dealers having to go to greater lengths to
- 42:06prove authenticity? than when photographs could
- 42:09be more trusted. I think we are starting to see
- 42:13AIUs to some level to look at the brushstrokes
- 42:17of artists in 2D paintings quite a bit. I wouldn't
- 42:20say that it has been well adopted by the art
- 42:23market. A lot of people still firmly base their
- 42:27decisions on connoisseurship. So they want it
- 42:30to be authenticated by a human being that has
- 42:33already been authenticating that particular type
- 42:35of art. you know, for the last 30 years in order
- 42:38to then say, okay, we're going to put a high
- 42:40value price tag on something. Will the technology
- 42:43evolve to allow for that? Perhaps. A lot of it
- 42:48just depends on how accurate that is. And there's
- 42:51not yet been what I would say any collaborative
- 42:55blind studies, like, you know, letting the AI
- 42:58analyze you know, large groups of objects. There
- 43:02are some actual academic projects that are taking
- 43:04one particular artist's group of paintings and
- 43:07then scanning all of them and then saying, yes,
- 43:09he can identify that particular artist's hands,
- 43:12so to speak. But they're not then matching that
- 43:15with the connoisseurship of someone that perhaps
- 43:18is already a da Vinci expert to say like, all
- 43:21right, now what did he say on each of those paintings
- 43:23and seeing how accurate the machines are to the
- 43:26humans. So that's something that will evolve
- 43:28over time, I'm sure, but it's not really there
- 43:31yet. In terms of like, you know, writing Python
- 43:35scripts to go out and look for things that are
- 43:37more antiquities focused, that gets a bit more
- 43:40complicated because just like those Ushoptis
- 43:42that I showed you on the last page share that
- 43:45I showed you, you know, those are also made into
- 43:48magnets and, you know, recreated in souk so you
- 43:52can buy them as little... you know, like one
- 43:54-off items that you would get when you're on
- 43:56vacation, when you're visiting Egypt, in the
- 43:58same way you can buy papyrus, fresh new papyrus.
- 44:01It's written, you know, been painted with your
- 44:02name and hieroglyphics or whatever. So a Python
- 44:06script is not going to be able to determine what
- 44:08is a suke item and what is an authentic item.
- 44:10And then you're just making more work for the
- 44:12actual analyst, who's then going fake, fake,
- 44:16fake, fake, fake, real, fake, fake, fake, fake,
- 44:19fake, fake, fake, real. So. There's only a limited
- 44:22amount of use that that kind of technology, it'll
- 44:25make great data lakes, but I'm not convinced
- 44:28and we've been doing this since 2009. I've yet
- 44:31to see a Python script help me more than just
- 44:34real human eyeballs. Isn't that true? Also an
- 44:38open source as well. I think it's fascinating
- 44:40actually to see how the Polaroids were useful
- 44:44in tracking down stolen art. A lot of our researchers
- 44:47have actually worked in validating and geolocating
- 44:51old Polaroids. I'll pop a few links in the chat
- 44:54of that kind of work. But how often do you come
- 44:58across these types of Polaroids arising now from
- 45:02historic cases? And how do you go about validating
- 45:05that they are really real Polaroid images of
- 45:09stolen off? You mean if they've been scanned
- 45:13and then they're being sent digitally? Exactly,
- 45:15yes. I would say, for the most part, they are
- 45:18not being used any longer because they no longer
- 45:21need to put things in the mail. The whole basis
- 45:25for utilizing these types of Polaroids was because
- 45:28they could drop them in a flat envelope, in a
- 45:30regular envelope, and mail them to whatever museum
- 45:34that they wanted. Because there's two types of
- 45:36Polaroids. Number one, there's the one that's
- 45:39looted and dirty and broken in bits and sitting
- 45:41in the back of somebody's car or on somebody's
- 45:43kitchen table next to their... a cup of espresso.
- 45:48Then there's the first round of let me take a
- 45:51beautiful staged look, a photograph in the gallery
- 45:55itself with good lighting. Those types of photos,
- 45:58for example, are not necessarily the smoking
- 46:00gun that you would want because you can't even
- 46:03prove that the dealer had that object. You just
- 46:06proved that he had a photograph of that object.
- 46:09So you have to kind of... put different pieces
- 46:12together. When they're very useful is when there
- 46:15is a seizure or when there's an oops moment,
- 46:17like, you know, a trafficker dies and he happens
- 46:19to have stuff in a car accident and people go,
- 46:22ah, that's wonderful. What was nice about these
- 46:26two particular archives, which by the way are
- 46:28still closed, they're not available to the public,
- 46:31specifically because Once people know that are
- 46:35in the market that that there's an object on
- 46:37that particular list They will sell it quietly
- 46:40and discreetly they won't sell it on the open
- 46:42market. So by keeping these You know thousands
- 46:45of photographs that they still have and that
- 46:47they're still using Quiet and again, that's what
- 46:50I'm saying when I talk about discretion It will
- 46:53allow them to hopefully wait for it to bubble
- 46:56up to the market because the art that is sold
- 46:59that is illicit impersonates art that is licit.
- 47:03That's different than cocaine. If somebody takes
- 47:05out a block of powder, you know what they're
- 47:09doing is kind of sketchy, and that they're probably
- 47:12going to do it in a place where there aren't
- 47:15prying eyes. But the people that buy art, legitimate
- 47:19and illegitimate, do it in fancy auction houses.
- 47:23They do it in prestigious galleries. And they
- 47:26do it to bring it into their home, to display
- 47:29it where it's going to be seen a lot. So there's
- 47:31a lot of time that goes into the laundering process.
- 47:35But just like we have the photographs from the
- 47:39Polaroids, we have big examples of cases that
- 47:42start with one Polaroid. So the Michael Steinhardt
- 47:45case, this billionaire in New York, started with
- 47:48one matching Polaroid photo, which gave the district
- 47:51attorney's office in New York the opportunity
- 47:53to go into Steinhardt's house and then photograph
- 47:56his collection. by photographing his collection
- 47:59when they were seizing the objects that they
- 48:01had matching Polaroids for. They then resulted
- 48:04in more than 200 objects that they were able
- 48:06to identify as being tied to, you know, illicit
- 48:10trafficking in one country or another, and also
- 48:12to the other dealers that this collector was
- 48:15actively having conversations with about. material
- 48:18that was freshly looted so it was able to they
- 48:21were able to take his emails and go through them
- 48:23as well and say like ah this one this one this
- 48:25one we're having direct conversations with a
- 48:28trafficker and they're having conversations about
- 48:29an object that's trafficked so digital technology
- 48:34sometimes it's good to wait until you can go
- 48:37in and you know look through these types of records
- 48:40but a lot of that requires you to really have
- 48:42a pretty good case that a judge is going to accept
- 48:45before they'll actually give you a search warrant
- 48:48to go and look at somebody's house. It can't
- 48:52be a hunch. It has to be pretty much a home run.
- 48:56Talking about previous cases, Thomas has asked,
- 48:59are there any particular databases of lost art
- 49:02that are old enough that working through them
- 49:04might yield more immediate results in the method
- 49:07of building a database and waiting, particularly
- 49:09ones where mass reverse image searching could
- 49:12yield new information? There are a few open data
- 49:19systems that are out there. So for example, the
- 49:23Interpol works of art database is open to the
- 49:26public. It is dependent on the countries that
- 49:29are part of Interpol putting their information
- 49:31into the system. Okay, and that means it has
- 49:34to have a photograph, it has to have dimensions,
- 49:36it has to have a description. So you will have
- 49:39some countries, like Italy for example, that
- 49:41already have very robust data systems of their
- 49:44own. it's not so hard for them to decide which
- 49:47items they want to share with the Interpol database.
- 49:51And it will usually oftentimes be the cold cases,
- 49:54the ones that no one is really, you know, jazzed
- 49:57up about looking for. So that is a place to start
- 50:00if you wanted to see those objects. Oftentimes
- 50:02though, by the time they're a cold case, you're
- 50:04looking at a black and white photo. So it becomes
- 50:06a little bit more difficult. to do a reverse
- 50:10image unless you can extract out, especially
- 50:12if you're talking about a three -dimensional
- 50:14object. But there should be enough clues once
- 50:17you know what type of art it is that you can
- 50:19do word searches and look for things in that
- 50:21particular way. Or if it's got an artist's name
- 50:24and it's a painting, perhaps, looking through
- 50:27some of the artistic databases. Some of those
- 50:30are for fees. But sometimes just doing a random
- 50:34search every little bit, if it's a specific artist
- 50:36that you're interested in following, you can
- 50:39find pieces like that. So I would say that is
- 50:42a start. There are two groups, one's called India
- 50:45Pride Project and another's called Lost Arts
- 50:47of Nepal. And they're using a lot of images that
- 50:49were taken, again, in the 1970s from the Pondicherry
- 50:53Institute to match with temples that they know
- 50:56have had their art stolen. and removed because
- 50:59those 70s photos show the object in situ. So
- 51:03then when they find the object in a specific
- 51:04museum or in a specific gallery being sold, they
- 51:08can prove that it was stolen from XYZ Temple.
- 51:10And that's quite useful as well. So a lot of
- 51:14academic databases on types of art will sometimes
- 51:17give you very fruitful examples of material,
- 51:20but you still have to know if it was stolen or
- 51:22not. That's great. Thank you so much. I think
- 51:25the majority of This server will be on that stolen
- 51:30works of art database for Interpol very shortly.
- 51:35Just drop the link in the chat. We actually had
- 51:37a question earlier on the Nepal one that you
- 51:40mentioned. Laurence, who's a new person to the
- 51:44Discord, so welcome Laurence, said, when you
- 51:47have a suspicion that a small private museum
- 51:50is exhibiting art from Nepal, which might be
- 51:52taken away, stolen from the country years ago,
- 51:55what are the best ways to investigate? besides
- 51:57asking Lost Arts of Nepal? Well, first of all,
- 52:03Lost Arts of Nepal are actually really good because
- 52:05they've already divided up these photographic
- 52:08images and data systems up into the topology
- 52:11of art, so they can be quite fast. They are active
- 52:16on Facebook even, so sometimes you can just drop
- 52:18information into them. Sometimes they're more
- 52:21about just identifying it and making the piece
- 52:23toxic, because that's about all that they can
- 52:26do in some of these cases because oftentimes
- 52:28the statute of limitations has expired. But it
- 52:32is good to work with the groups that are specifically
- 52:34working with specific types of art. They can
- 52:37alert the helpful hand, and they always look
- 52:41for volunteers as well, to, you know... Kind
- 52:44of guide you in the right direction or say like
- 52:46this dealers more interesting than that dealer
- 52:48is or this particular type of art is more Commonly
- 52:52found in this particular setting. There are people
- 52:55like Tess Davis with Antiquities Coalition is
- 52:58another wonderful group Tess Was probably one
- 53:01of the first people from North America that was
- 53:04talking about looted art from Khmer. So mainly
- 53:07in Cambodia, but also in parts of Thailand where
- 53:10the Khmer public statuary is from and you know,
- 53:16she went out all the way to Cambodia up to Coquere
- 53:19and Found like the actual ankles of the statues
- 53:22in question, you know and match them up in this
- 53:24way Angela Chu is another excellent researcher
- 53:27in London. She's doing great work as well. There
- 53:29are people you can turn to or you can ask me
- 53:32and I can say for this type of art go to speak
- 53:34with this person or that person. We're not trying
- 53:37to like just grab all of the thunder that's in
- 53:39the minds and hearts of Bellingcat people. We're
- 53:43about really and truly building capacity but
- 53:46without using that overly used word that doesn't
- 53:49do anything. You know, I'm the first one that
- 53:52will tell you I am not an expert on Chinese porcelain.
- 53:55I will tell you that I'm pretty good with Etruscan
- 53:57material, Greek and Roman material. to some extent,
- 54:01depends, more so Libya -based material in that
- 54:06particular instance, in India, because I'm very
- 54:09passionate about the Buddhist sculptures that
- 54:12have been taken from that particular country.
- 54:14In one case, one of the pieces that went back
- 54:16from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office,
- 54:18one of his analysts and myself looked at 65 temples.
- 54:24with Apsara statues to find hopefully which was
- 54:28the statue that this one particular statue had
- 54:30been removed from, which temple structure it
- 54:32was. So there are people that will like literally
- 54:35go through page after page because it becomes
- 54:38that like treasure hunt. You know, you feel like
- 54:40you're getting closer and even if you don't find
- 54:43it right away, you'll remember what you looked
- 54:45at from before and that will help in the next
- 54:47piece of that type of, you know, style of art
- 54:49comes up again. We've only got a few more minutes
- 54:55for questions, one or two questions left. Thomas
- 54:58asked earlier, as we're just talking about regions,
- 55:01what is the most in need region for this kind
- 55:05of investigation in terms of looted art? Is there
- 55:08any particular regions that would be worth focusing
- 55:11on particularly for tracking looted art? And
- 55:14are there any useful organizations that you could
- 55:17pinpoint people to in those particular regions?
- 55:21I would say in a lot of the post -conflict countries,
- 55:25they have their hands full on basically just
- 55:27rebuilding in a lot of cases. So art is not quite
- 55:30as high a priority. Or if it is, there are lots
- 55:35of dollars being thrown at these particular areas
- 55:39to try and help things along for the most part.
- 55:42But there are other areas that are completely
- 55:43ignored. Yemen, for example, everyone was all
- 55:46hot and heavy about helping out because we thought
- 55:49ISIS was We, I say, you know, the world, when
- 55:53I say we, was making millions of dollars off
- 55:56of art. That was another kind of like false flag
- 55:59that was out in the newspapers because it sounded
- 56:02big and scary and it got everybody's attention
- 56:04and then people were looking at art from those
- 56:06two areas. But Yemen was completely annoyed and
- 56:11ignored. Same with Sudan. Sudan is in a major
- 56:15crisis right now and Sudan has some of the most
- 56:18beautiful ancient Egyptian art. And no one is
- 56:21talking about, you know, the looting that's going
- 56:23on in that particular country. So there are plenty
- 56:26of places, but by the same token, North American
- 56:29and indigenous populations are having their material
- 56:32stolen. Peru is having their material stolen.
- 56:35Columbia is having their material stolen. So
- 56:37sometimes... where the opportunity is at a given
- 56:41moment is why that particular type of art becomes
- 56:44popular. Used to be that Etruscan vases and Apulian
- 56:48vases had million -dollar price tags, but when
- 56:51we dismantled these larger groups, people started
- 56:54to be a little concerned about buying that particular
- 56:57type of art, and they switched to other types
- 56:59of art. And that's when you saw, you know, the
- 57:01Asian market pick up the slack, so to speak,
- 57:03and people started having like, you know, more
- 57:05Buddhist or Hindu art in their homes. So it's
- 57:08going to change. My main suggestion would be
- 57:12pick something that you yourself are passionate
- 57:14about because if you're not, it's going to be
- 57:18too tedious. It's like going to be like filling
- 57:20out boxes of things. So look to what makes you
- 57:24happy. Really good advice. I would just point
- 57:26people's attention to the Caucasus Heritage Watch
- 57:30talks that we had. The stage talks in the last
- 57:33year, they touched on monitoring damage to cultural
- 57:37heritage and also art sites within the Caucasus
- 57:41region, which is also underlucked. So please
- 57:44have a look at that. Last question, and it's
- 57:47been coming in lots of different ways. Lots of
- 57:50people have been asking how they can receive
- 57:53training within this space. Is there any training
- 57:57that ARCA could do and is there any training
- 58:00that you recommend people take to advance in
- 58:03this phase and help as best they can with their
- 58:06open source skills? There are several different
- 58:10types of training programs that are available
- 58:12for a virtual environment that are a maximum
- 58:15one week duration for the most part that are
- 58:18offered by various agencies. Sotheby's, we'll
- 58:22talk about it from an art market perspective,
- 58:24different organizations will have little trainings,
- 58:27oftentimes specifically for groups of people
- 58:30like just archaeologists or just people working
- 58:32on World War II era claims. We tend to take a
- 58:35more multidisciplinary approach, which is why
- 58:38we have a very big, intensive, long program.
- 58:42It requires you to be on site with us, but that's
- 58:45a way for us to eyeball you to make sure that
- 58:47you know what you're doing and that you're well
- 58:50-trained and that you can go back and actually
- 58:52work effectively within this particular area
- 58:55and help solve some problems. And we have really
- 58:57interesting people that come and take the program.
- 58:59Last year, we had an officer from Toronto Police
- 59:03Department, his first officer for Toronto Police.
- 59:06And now it looks like they're going to start
- 59:08to look at forming a Canadian, our crime unit
- 59:13on a lot of different regional police departments
- 59:16within Canada because there's a problem of forgery
- 59:19in Canada, for example. So having, you know,
- 59:22a more in -depth training will allow you to be
- 59:24a bit more nimble, do a bit more, represent yourself
- 59:27better, have those relationships one -on -one
- 59:32with law enforcement that, you know, we've worked
- 59:34for years to kind of establish. We do this international
- 59:39art crime conference that's part of our long
- 59:41program as well. This is our 15th year of doing
- 59:44it. It brings 150 people together working in
- 59:47this field, face to face in one place, in a little
- 59:49tiny place with pizza and wine. So it's not a
- 59:53bad summer. Climate change is real. You got to
- 59:55like to sweat. But we do the courses in OSINT.
- 59:59We do courses in art law and how those two kind
- 1:00:01of interconnect with each other. We do illicit
- 1:00:04trafficking. We do museum risk management. So
- 1:00:06we look at museum security and how to red team
- 1:00:08a museum. So I'm biased, obviously. I think our
- 1:00:13training is pretty special. We were the first
- 1:00:15to have this kind of in -depth training. And
- 1:00:17so far we are the only one to have a training
- 1:00:20that's as intensive as ours. So if you want to
- 1:00:23learn more about it, feel free to hit me up.
- 1:00:27Amazing. I think you've got some ex -students
- 1:00:29in the audience as well. So welcome and thank
- 1:00:32you for listening. So that's it. Thank you so
- 1:00:36much, Linda, for your time today. fascinating
- 1:00:40to talk to you and I think we will probably need
- 1:00:43a whole other stage talk in a couple of months
- 1:00:46time when people really dig into this particular
- 1:00:49subject. If you are interested in getting involved,
- 1:00:53please do check out art crime in just in the
- 1:00:57Discord server. It's a fantastic channel and
- 1:00:59Linda and many other folks who've been here today
- 1:01:02are active within there and speaking about this
- 1:01:04topic and how you can get involved. So please
- 1:01:07do check that out. Check out Arca's training.
- 1:01:09And again, thank you so much Linda for your time.
- 1:01:13Thank you, Charlie. Thank you. Thank you everyone
- 1:01:15who came in today. Thank you. Thank you, everybody.
- 1:01:20Thank you for listening to the stage talk. If
- 1:01:22you'd like to catch a stage tour live where you
- 1:01:25can ask the guest questions, join the Bellingcat
- 1:01:28Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 1:01:35Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 1:01:38Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.