Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Rethink Engineering: Kaihan Krippendorff on Strategy, AI, and the Fourth Option
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Engineering Influence Podcast from ACEC. We're here at our 2025
- 0:12Fall Conference in San Diego.
- 0:14If you can hear the noise behind us, it's because our first general session just let out.
- 0:18And to kick off that general session, we are joined by a very good speaker on
- 0:24the topic that we have focused on this year's event, which is thinking differently,
- 0:29especially in the age of technology,
- 0:31rapid evolution of technology, AI, and the like, Kayan Krippendorf.
- 0:36He is a McKinsey alum. He is also the host of the OutThinkers podcast.
- 0:41He's the author of OutThinking the Competition. He has brought his ideas framework
- 0:46to companies large and small across the world to kind of change the way they're thinking,
- 0:51to look ahead, and to create what he calls the fourth option to kind of re-evaluate
- 0:57and re-energize the way you're thinking and trying to plan for the future and
- 1:01very pleased to have him as our guest on the program, Kayan.
- 1:04Welcome. Thank you. And yeah, this is great. You know, you had a,
- 1:09you had probably the biggest audience that we've had in a while.
- 1:12Yeah. Congratulations on that. Thank you. So much energy. Yeah, it was good.
- 1:15I mean, you know, you, you started off by saying that you're a mechanical engineer
- 1:19by education. Your son, Makar is.
- 1:22He's supposed to be a civil engineer. Civil engineer. He's decided that. Fantastic.
- 1:26So let's go into a little bit about, you know, just for those who weren't in
- 1:30the room, kind of how you approach strategy and kind of looking ahead and trying to figure out.
- 1:37How you can stay ahead of rapid, you know, the change has already happened.
- 1:41It's rapid, but what's your framework for doing that?
- 1:45Well, so it's basically says that we need to come up with different ideas when rules change, right?
- 1:51And the way you come up with ideas, there are certain like natural ways that
- 1:54people end up doing the same thing. Yeah. We like doing the same thing.
- 1:58And there are five reasons, and you can address them by these five things.
- 2:01Imagining a different future, dissecting the problem
- 2:04and focusing on a different leverage point expanding our option
- 2:07set so we have many more options analyzing and choosing
- 2:10those options avoiding doing what's been done before and then
- 2:13selling is building buy-in and support from
- 2:16those we need support from for the new status yeah and that's the
- 2:18that's the basis for the ideas framework right there and you used a couple of
- 2:23good examples in your presentation i think the one that is most relatable is
- 2:28apple yep and the rise of mp3s but not just the rise of mp3s but the way that
- 2:35Apple realized that it wasn't a question of what the content was,
- 2:38but it was more distribution and how people are going to get it.
- 2:41If you want to delve into that a little bit about how they saw that.
- 2:44Yeah. And there's an important concept called the job to be done,
- 2:46which is what do our customers actually really, really hire us for?
- 2:49And we often confuse that. And so in this case, music companies started thinking
- 2:54as of what people really wanted was really high fidelity music.
- 2:58But really what we want, why do we want to listen to music? For me,
- 3:01it's like to control my state. I want to be in a certain mood.
- 3:03I want to wake up and be energized or whatever.
- 3:07And having a high quality soundtrack isn't so important,
- 3:10but being able to have a lot of selection so apple saw that mp3
- 3:13players was an alt becoming an alternative way to deliver on
- 3:17the job to be done and what that means is that the what
- 3:20what what you want to out deliver on is different i want
- 3:23to don't want to i don't care what the quality of music is i want
- 3:25to kind of get you a thousand songs in your pocket and then
- 3:28that changes what capabilities you need you need distribution
- 3:32capabilities not production capabilities but the main thing
- 3:34that we talked about was that underneath all that is a mindset
- 3:38the new game requires a new mindset just like athletes
- 3:41when they learn a new approach to playing a game they have
- 3:44to go through this practice to build in their intuition the
- 3:47right choices and that's been baked in it seems to apple's dna from steve jobs
- 3:53early on right it's it's kind of think differently it's that you're not trying
- 3:57to hit the market demand it's the whole idea as well the market's going to want
- 4:01it when we bring it out yes it's not anticipating demand but driving it yes
- 4:05let me follow up on that Apple question,
- 4:07it's, it's kind of tied in a little bit to AI because there's always that talk
- 4:11that Apple's missed the boat on AI that for some reason, everybody else is moving forward,
- 4:16pushing, and they're saying, well, AI is, is, is, is not as fully fleshed out
- 4:21in Apple's operating systems or products.
- 4:24Where do you see that? Do you think that they're just waiting and just trying
- 4:27to kind of figure out where to go with it and realize that everybody else is too early to the game?
- 4:34Three quick things to say. First of all, Apple doesn't view itself as a technology
- 4:38company. It views it as a customer company.
- 4:40When they changed, they really started scaling when they took the name Apple
- 4:43Computer and changed it to Apple.
- 4:45So that's the first thing is knowing who they are. And so as such,
- 4:47I think they follow customers carefully and they're going to follow the customers
- 4:51as they ask for the AI. The third thing I would say is they have a long pattern of being seconds.
- 4:57We think it was innovative, but they didn't develop the first MP3 player.
- 5:00They didn't develop the first smartphone.
- 5:02They didn't develop the first tablet. They wait, wait.
- 5:06Then when they see the market coming, then they come in better.
- 5:09Yeah. So it's a good indicator of exactly where we are right now and where they are.
- 5:15Let's apply that a little bit to the engineering industry because you made a
- 5:18good point early in the presentation that, you know, there's certain things
- 5:21in the work that will not change. It's grounded in physics.
- 5:24You have things that are immutable. You're not going to be able to do that.
- 5:27But when it comes to the business side of things, norms, regulations,
- 5:30all that changes. Right?
- 5:32So for an engineering firm leader, for a CEO who's trying to figure out five,
- 5:3810 years down the line, what are my opportunities here?
- 5:42Especially with technology growing, a greater demand in the marketplace for
- 5:46digital delivery, right?
- 5:47It's not just the bridge now, it's the data surrounding the bridge, right?
- 5:52In your experience, how should a leader take advantage of this opportunity to
- 5:58kind of set the framework, to do the right strategic planning,
- 6:00to position themselves appropriately for it?
- 6:03Yeah. I mean, in the talk, we covered like five different areas on five different
- 6:07areas. In the talk, we talked about these five different areas.
- 6:09But I think of all of them, I think that the best starting point is to imagine
- 6:16that we are not an engineering company we are a something company yeah it happens
- 6:21to be doing what we're doing through engineering and we take that mindset which
- 6:25is a little bit more like the apple mindset.
- 6:27Is what is the job what is it what are
- 6:30customers really trying to do they don't want a bridge right they
- 6:33want less traffic yeah they want the city
- 6:36to grow so we are a help cities grow
- 6:39and create manageable lifestyles for their citizens company
- 6:43yeah we happen to do that through engineering and
- 6:47then you could think about how would that kind of company approach this
- 6:49challenge and what you'll see is that there'll be other technologies or
- 6:53approaches or expertises that you would bring into the
- 6:56solution that right now you're not thinking are
- 6:59within the scope of what you do because you're defining yourself in
- 7:02a certain way that's an interesting idea i and and way of thinking we always
- 7:07talk at least in our world on on more of the constant marketing side of saying
- 7:11that you know the firms need to talk more about results and impact and less
- 7:16on the technical aspects of it, right?
- 7:19It's a question of, yes, what is the end result of like the San Diego pure water
- 7:25that we talked about, the mayor talked about earlier?
- 7:2850% of the water is going to be reused and recycled for the city of San Diego,
- 7:32you're, you're fixing a massive issue.
- 7:35So you're, uh, you're, you know, you're helping the world become a little bit
- 7:38more sustainable. You do that through engineering.
- 7:41And, and that's, it's a shift in mindset. That's right. That really separates companies.
- 7:48Yeah. I think that's one of the shifts in mindset is what business am I really in? Yeah. Right.
- 7:52Another shift that I think goes along with that and naturally is what I call
- 7:55coordinate the undeproredated because it's unlikely that you are going to provide all of the solutions,
- 8:01to the water problem and so what you do and it also relates to another shift
- 8:05in mindset about be good so you combine those two if we can create this movement
- 8:11around sustainable water consumption,
- 8:15in san diego and then we can say we can coordinate all the other stakeholders
- 8:20then we can start being part of a collective solution.
- 8:24John Deere is a company that's doing that really well. They created this movement
- 8:28of precision farming and they know they can't do the drones.
- 8:31They know they can't do all of the connectivity.
- 8:34So, you know, they have a partnership with Elon Musk's satellite business and
- 8:39with all these other ecosystem partners. And it comes from,
- 8:43getting behind the shared. Yeah. And by using that, you can position yourself
- 8:47to be either the linchpin, the coordinator for other companies to come together,
- 8:52which creates opportunities for partnering and actually increases your opportunities. Yes.
- 8:58One of the things that I don't think you address in your presentation directly
- 9:03was the idea of the entrepreneur within corporations and firms.
- 9:09Explain that a little bit and how important that could be for an engineering
- 9:13firm to try to move into this area of thinking. Yeah, I think it's really important.
- 9:18When we talk about the innovators, we often admire entrepreneurs,
- 9:21you know, who go to the West Coast in their garage.
- 9:24But what my research shows, if we look at the real transformative technology
- 9:28or innovations like the internet, stents, DNA sequencing, mobile phones,
- 9:3470% of those were developed by entrepreneurs, employees inside established jobs.
- 9:38So who is going to invent the next thing? 70% chance it's going to be someone
- 9:42in your firm. not the entrepreneur that's independent.
- 9:46And so we have this massive brain strength, this repository of intelligence
- 9:54that I really think we're wasting.
- 9:56Another piece of research that I just released on Monday showed that when you
- 9:59find a market need or a customer need and you broadly let it be known inside
- 10:04your company and the ecosystem, on that.
- 10:08On average, there's a 71.4% chance that the solution already exists in your house.
- 10:15So there's huge potential in tapping and activating that interaction.
- 10:19You know, there are certain firms that thrive on that and are open culturally
- 10:25to allow those voices to be heard or at least feel comfortable in going outside of the lane.
- 10:33Yes. And then, of course, there are others that are not.
- 10:35I mean, that's a differentiator there.
- 10:38From a CEO standpoint and from a product line manager standpoint,
- 10:43what is the best way to create that system that encourages those entrepreneurs to be heard?
- 10:50I think the number one thing is to appreciate that the probability of success
- 10:55with an entrepreneurial idea is low.
- 10:57Yeah. A 10% chance is good.
- 11:00Steve, Jeff Bezos has this great quote. If you have a one in 10 chance,
- 11:05so long. No, you're fine.
- 11:08Jeff Bezos has a great quote. If you have a one in 10 chance of a hundred times
- 11:12payoff, you got to take that bet every time.
- 11:15But you have to be ready to lose nine times out of 10.
- 11:19So if we can introduce this idea that it's okay to lose nine times out of 10,
- 11:24we will invite more ideas.
- 11:26And what happens is someone proposes an idea and it doesn't work out or it's
- 11:31not adopted and they never hear why.
- 11:33And then they stop sharing ideas. What we need to
- 11:36do is say great this idea we looked at it we're not going to do it but thank
- 11:40you yeah your idea added to those 10 ideas which allowed us to get that one
- 11:45idea yeah and we want to hear we want more or that one idea actually gives the
- 11:48foundation for the different idea which then grows out of something else and
- 11:52instead of having somebody leave the firm and have that idea as the kernel of their business.
- 11:56Have that part of yours yes absolutely and it's
- 11:59so much better for them to do it if your firm can
- 12:02be the platform in which if they can achieve their idea
- 12:05more rapidly because you have scale you have the sales force you have
- 12:08engineers you have systems it can
- 12:11be so much more fun to innovate on that kind
- 12:13of platform than to go and try to google because no
- 12:17matter even if you're a straight good old civil structural
- 12:20kind of you've been doing bridges for 100 years there's still
- 12:24a lot of room for innovation there's still a lot of ways to think
- 12:27about yourself as as a transportation or
- 12:30modality company you're bringing people from point a to point b break
- 12:34the thinking that you just do bridges and and
- 12:37have those ideas yeah and the ideas don't really have to be big yeah let's look
- 12:41at ikea for example transformed yeah um a furniture retailer with a flat pack
- 12:47box what was a flat pack there was one guy designer he was building something
- 12:51in his house a chair a table he He couldn't get it into the back of his car
- 12:55when he was driving to work.
- 12:56So he took the legs off. Yeah.
- 13:00And when he got there, he said, why don't we just sell all of our furniture?
- 13:03It's not expensive. It's not risky. They could test out and it transformed.
- 13:07So there are small ideas can have profound impacts.
- 13:13There's a lot to go into. I would really encourage everybody out there to check
- 13:17out Al Thinker's podcast and to check out Kayan's book, Al Thinking the Competition.
- 13:23For anybody out there who wants to get more information to me,
- 13:25I know you have a slide deck you're going to make available to the conference
- 13:27attendees, but where should people go to learn a little bit more and dig into some of your research?
- 13:32LinkedIn is probably the best way to connect with me and learn from you. Awesome.
- 13:35We'll put a link in the show notes to Kyan's LinkedIn, and I really appreciate
- 13:39you to take time out of the morning to follow up with a podcast after a presentation.
- 13:43It's never the easiest thing. No, I was a thrill to be here. Fantastic.
- 13:48And with this energy and with this intelligence that's in the room,
- 13:50thank you for having me. Absolutely.
- 13:52Fantastic. And again, this has been Engineering Influence Podcast from the American
- 13:56Council of Engineering Companies. We'll see you next time.