Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 64
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, true crime cases five four three two one one one one one
- 0:22one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. Death lies in the creation of the nine one one system. Sometime
- 0:45after midnight on March thirteenth, nineteen sixty four, a woman by the name
- 0:50of Katherine Genevese, or Kitty to those closest to her, had been working
- 0:55at her job as a bar manager in Queens, New York. Beknownst to
- 1:00her, someone had been following her. Kitty wouldn't make it home that night,
- 1:04and the story that played out afterward would change all of our lives forever.
- 1:10The twenty eight year old woman had come into her own the eldest child
- 1:15of an Italian American family. She had grown up in Park Slope. She
- 1:19was known to be a confident and happy girl growing up, and despite her
- 1:23mother and the rest of her family moving to Connecticut when she was just a
- 1:26teenager, Kitty opted to stay behind and live with a grandparents. In nineteen
- 1:33sixty three, Kitty moved in with a woman by the name of Mary Zylanko.
- 1:38Although the two were roommates. They were also dating something at this time,
- 1:44which was not widely accepted. The two of them kept their relationship a
- 1:48closely guarded secret, and those living around them were completely unaware. In the
- 1:53early morning that March in nineteen sixty four, Winston Mosley had been following Kitty
- 2:00sometime after she had left work. He hadn't targeted her specifically. It was
- 2:05this pure chance that she had been in the area at the time. After
- 2:09she parked a little ways from her apartment building, he rushed toward her,
- 2:13brandishing a hunting knife. She ran towards the front entrance of her building,
- 2:19desperate to reach the major streets nearby. Mosley was faster, though, overtaking
- 2:23the fleeing Kitty and stabbing her twice in the back with his weapon. Despite
- 2:29her injury, Kitty managed to yell, getting the attention of Robert Moser,
- 2:34a neighbor, who demanded of Mosley to leave her alone. The now public
- 2:38form causes her attacker to flee, and Kitty limps in the direction of the
- 2:44rear entrance. The attack, however, wasn't over. After ten minutes,
- 2:50Mosley returns to the scene and finds Kitty lying in a hallway after a locked
- 2:53door kept her from getting all the way into the building. Despite her serious
- 2:59condition, she attempts to fight off his attack, but is stabbed multiple times
- 3:05as Kitty lay on the ground bleeding out. Mostly rapes her and steals a
- 3:08total of forty nine dollars before leaving her to die in the arms of a
- 3:13friend that had come when she heard Kitty screaming during the second assault. He
- 3:17takes six days before police finally catch Winston in the midst of a burglary.
- 3:23After his arrest, police begin to learn more about their assailant. He is
- 3:28a resident of Queens, New York, and is married with three children.
- 3:32Despite the horrid nature of his crimes, police are surprised to learn that the
- 3:37man has no criminal record. While in custody, however, he admits to
- 3:43committing thirty to forty burglaries in three sexual assaults and murders. During his confession,
- 3:50he informed police that he chose to attack women because they were easier marks
- 3:54and they rarely fought back. By the time he was done mapping out exactly
- 3:59what he'd done to Kitty, there was no doubt that the police had their
- 4:03man. The trial itself was a mere formality and was over in three days.
- 4:09The confession was enough to establish Winston's guilt, and nobody, not even
- 4:14the defend argued the point. The jury delivered a guilty verdict after only seven
- 4:19hours of deliberation. Four days after the verdict was read, Mostly was sentenced
- 4:25to death, although it would later be commuted to a life sentence, because
- 4:30it was deemed the defense should have been allowed to argue he'd been medically insane.
- 4:35How this story played out in the papers didn't fit with the facts.
- 4:39However. The mess began when the chief of police, a man named Michael
- 4:44Murphy, was eating lunch with A. M rosenthal, An, editor of
- 4:48the New York Times. Their conversation eventually came to the topic of Kitty's murder.
- 4:55The chief claimed that during the attack, thirty eight people sat by and
- 5:00did nothing while Kitty was assaulted for thirty minutes. After the lunch meeting,
- 5:05a reporter was assigned to follow the story from the perspective that the chief of
- 5:10police had stated. The end result was a huge influx of misinformation reported as
- 5:15fact. The article stated that during three separate attacks, the thirty eight witnesses
- 5:20had simply done nothing in the expectation that someone else would be the one to
- 5:27act. A number of false studies were even undertaken because of the country's outrage
- 5:31towards the events that took place that night. They claimed that nearly forty individuals
- 5:36suffered what they deemed the bystander effect. Like most cases, the truth was
- 5:43a much simpler thing. Kitty did not suffer three attacks, but two,
- 5:47and they weren't ongoing for thirty minutes. It is known that Winston left her
- 5:51approximately ten minutes before returning. The statement that thirty eight people stood by while
- 5:58she was stabbed and then raped was also an outright lie. Not a single
- 6:02person witnessed the entire thing, and two people in fact did call the police,
- 6:08even if the authorities had arrived sooner. The first time Winston stabbed Kitty,
- 6:13he punctured her lung, an injury that was going to be fatal even
- 6:16if the second attack had never occurred. The reason for the facade was even
- 6:21simpler. During this time in history, racial tensions were at their peak.
- 6:27Mosley was a black man who detacked Kitty, a white woman. Many who
- 6:30knew the truth of the situation feared the white population of the city might riot
- 6:35against the black population. To make the claim, albeit falsely, that thirty
- 6:41eight people stood by while a woman was raped and stabbed to death gave people
- 6:45another scapegoat. The story of Winston Mosley doesn't end with his incarceration, however,
- 6:51After spending almost four years behind bars, he escaped custody after he steals
- 6:57a transport officer's gun while being taken back to prison from a local hospital where
- 7:01he was treated for self inflicted wounds. He hold up in a nearby house
- 7:06for three days until the owners of the home stopped by and found him.
- 7:12Moseley then tied up the husband and raped his wife during the hour plus he
- 7:16held them hostage. Four days later, he forces his way into another house
- 7:21and takes a mother and daughter hostage before surrendering two hours later. For his
- 7:28escape in the crimes he committed afterward, he was given two additional fifteen year
- 7:31sentences. During his incarceration, he went to the parole board eighteen different times
- 7:38and was denied. During his earrings, he showed little empathy for what he'd
- 7:44done to Kitty and his other victims. He would elaborate by stating that because
- 7:47of his fame, he was more of a victim than those he hurt,
- 7:51since his victimization continued on indefinitely. Despite this terrible tragedy, one could say
- 7:59something than good came about it because of it. At the point in time
- 8:03when Kitty died, if you needed to call the police in an emergency,
- 8:07you had to dial an operator and request a specific police station to be connected
- 8:11to. By the end of nineteen sixty four, someone could call the operator
- 8:16and when asking for the police, they would be connected immediately. Another advancement
- 8:22would come less than five years later, when the nine one one system became
- 8:26operational. Winston Moseley died in March twenty sixteen from heart failure.