Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / 5 Classroom Management Strategies that Actually Work
Transcript
- Ilana: Teachers, what if I told you this could be the school year you stopped feeling like you were just trying to survive? You are going to go back to work and keep that teacher magic again. You're going to be able to make it through an entire lesson and deliver focused, continuous instruction to engaged students. And your students are going to be closing those gaps. You know what I mean? doing that good work, handing it in. some of you are already wondering how you're going to make it through another year in underfunded, under-resourced school without completely burning out. I'm giving you five classroom management strategies that you can actually implement tomorrow that are very possible, very reasonable, and very effective. And of course, they don't teach you these things in university. And I say that as a teacher who has been teaching for 16 years at many different schools with many different needs. I'm going to show you those five core features of every classroom that is going to run smoothly and allow you to reclaim that teacher magic and enjoy teaching again. So let's get into it. The first strategy, so simple. Teach the behavior you expect. Teachers tell students to be respectful all the time, to be responsible, to be ready, be ready for learning. But the problem with that is those aren't behaviors, they're expectations. What does be ready actually mean? And sure, a funny thing would be what's ready for PE class isn't the same as what's ready for math, but also... What they've been taught is means to be ready at home is going to be completely different to every other student in the classroom and to your own expectations. So you need to know what be ready means for you and then you need to teach it to them. Do the students come in at the start of the day and do a warm up every time the students come in? Do they do 30 minutes of reading? You know, do they get their materials first? Do they know what to do if they finish? early. Super important for that. Do they know what a quiet transition actually looks like? Do they know how to get up from their chair, tuck it in, do what the transition requires them to do quietly? You have to teach that. If you haven't taught it, if you haven't modeled it and practiced it, then you are asking your students to guess. and how good are they at guessing, then you're surprised when they get it wrong. I had a colleague who was so frustrated because their students took too long to settle in. You know, they were chatting, they were talking about what happened yesterday or last night or what they watched, you know, overnight or a video game they played or you know, towards the end of the year, it was those weird butter sticks like everyone was talking about them, you know, pick it, you can understand it. Then when they finally did settle down and they sat down, they didn't have what they needed. So they got up again and it was this huge production. Even though she did the right thing, she started the day with every the same lesson, right? The same curriculum she was teaching. And it was just, really, really hard for her to deal with all of it. But she kept telling them. You need, get what you need and sit down. Get what you need and sit down. Get the materials and sit down. And then boom, she realized that they didn't know what they needed. She had never put that whole thing in motion. So her and I made a poster for the front of the door. I'm a huge believer in poster. If you've been here long enough, you know, I think you should have a poster on the front door that tells your students what they need to do when they get in. So then you open the door, they can see the poster, they see you, they greet you, they walk in. Part of that routine, that visual schedule, if you will. So I made the poster, they could see it when they walked in, and my colleague would say, get what you need, it's on the door, you have three minutes. And that is really important. So it's great, she had the visual, she orally told them what they needed. and she gave them a time frame so it wasn't open-ended. So she taught the routine she needed and yes, it takes time. It absolutely takes time and it takes a lot of repetition but then you click it away and students start doing it naturally. So sometimes the behavior problem isn't that students are refusing to follow the expectation. It's that you never made the expectation concrete. Teach it, model it, practice it, and yes, even with teenagers. Okay, classroom management strategy number two coming in hot. Predictability is a behavior strategy. Okay, so this one, teachers often underestimate, make your classroom predictable. Students should know what happens when I walk in, what happens when the teacher starts talking, what happens when I need help, what happens when the act. ends. The more predictable your classroom is, the less energy students have to spend figuring out what's happening next and what then is expected of them. And that matters because uncertainty creates friction and a consistent routine with a visual agenda, clear transition signals, That is all the building blocks that students need to be able to spend less of their mental energy figuring out what's around them and what they like being scared for what's going to happen next and what they're going to need to do and more mental energy on the lesson that you're delivering on the material that they're learning. Advanced notice when something in your routine is changing is really important. students like the routines. Some students need them more than others, but they do benefit all students. So having those clear routines is really important. But if you know that there's a special assembly coming up, if you know there's a fire drill, whatever is happening that's gonna disrupt the routine, make sure the students know and make sure you know which students need a private check-in as well to make sure they understand that that's happening and to see if you need to adjust anything. That along with clear expectations, chef's kiss for a really well. behaved, managed classroom. And I know this sounds boring. You know, this isn't a, this isn't like get this Pinterest poster, have this Instagram thing in your classroom. No, but these are the things that students need to take their mental load off of what's going on around them and constantly checking to you and what you are teaching. Boring is what you want. When students know the routine, you don't have to spend five minutes or more. negotiating it with them because it happens every day. And here's a story for you. Before I used to start class by saying, okay, everyone get settled. We're going to start with and almost immediately the questions would start. What are we doing? Are we working with partners? Do I need my Chromebook? Can I get something from my locker? Are we handing this in? Which always drives me insane. Anyways, just these like relentless questions and then the chaos of the students getting up. like half of the class is throwing questions at me. The other half of class just decides to get up anyways and starts meandering around and then I'm like why are you up? Like I needed a pencil. I didn't say you needed a pencil for this. Where this is Q &A where I'm handing out you know, the whiteboards and the whiteboard markers, you don't need a pencil. well, I don't, I, but I don't have a pencil for later today, right? And because I hadn't created the systems in place, students felt like they could just get up and, get the things that they needed because they weren't sure what was happening. So these students are getting up, they're talking with their friends, everything's happening all at the same time. And by the time I actually start the lesson, I'd already spent 15 minutes. getting everyone organized and talking too loudly, because I'm trying to talk over everybody, just exhausting myself with it all, right? Like I was just exhausted by the time I actually started the lesson, which hurts, I think, all the time, but especially when you're teaching something that you love, really stings a little bit more, at least for me. So obviously I knew something had to change. It's not the students' fault, right? We might want to blame the students, but I knew it wasn't their fault, so I had to change one thing. And that was making the beginning of class predictable. And I am a person who likes to put things everywhere. I really like to see it, to say it, to know it, right? So I had a short agenda on the board when the students walked in. The first task was always in the same place on the whiteboard. First task, whatever it was. Students knew where to put their things. They knew what they needed and what to do while they waited for me to. be again, really building those independent blocks up for them. It took time. We went over it again and again for a week. I had a signal that we all agreed on so I could get everyone's attention when I needed it. And I had, I do believe, an early finishing work for students who need it when an activity is ending so that students would know what was happening next. And I really try to make sure it's not busy work. I really do try to make sure it's work where I can see deeper thinking for them. So it's really, I find it very important. And of course, the surprising thing didn't happen. I didn't have to talk as much after about two weeks. And it's not necessarily that students were better motivated or anything like that, but they stopped having to guess what was happening, right? Sure, it's easier, like when one student gets up, it's easier for more students to get up. But if you create the classroom where students aren't just randomly getting up because they know that what's happening doesn't require a pencil, a pencil sharpener, all those things, well then they understand that they're sitting at their desks and waiting for your instructions or doing their work. So it was really interesting because those same students who used to ask, what are we doing? I mean, they just started walking in and getting ready, right? And that is that beautiful power of predictability. You don't want to make your classroom more rigid. You just want to remove that unnecessary uncertainty so students can spend their time and really their energy learning instead of figuring out the system that you've kept inside of your head. Once the students know the routine, you don't have to negotiate with where they're supposed to go or what they're supposed to be doing. And all of sudden that barrier to learning, it got lowered, right? Okay, classroom management strategy number three, correct the behavior without creating a bigger behavior problem. Super tricky, right? And so, it's the one strategy that can really change the tone of your classroom. when you can stop matching the intensity of the behavior, right? So, you know, the student keeps calling out. It's not that you need to stop that lesson and launch into a lecture about respect. You don't need to argue with students or, have those like power struggles with students at all. You just wanna correct the behavior without creating anything bigger, keeping it brief. calm, very specific, whenever possible, private, right? All right, so one of your students is constantly interrupting, yelling out, trying to give you the answers, everything like that, right? And so sometimes what ends up happening as a teacher would be like, seriously? How many times do I have to tell you to stop interrupting? You know better. You're being disrespectful and you're disrupting everyone else. Right? Like, so that's kind of a big reaction. And what if we could just say, please wait until I call on you. You know, if it continues, hold that thought or I'll come back to you. You know, I know some teachers like to say, it's my turn to speak. I'll let you know when it's yours. Right? Same expectation, completely different interaction. one raises the temperature, first one really kind of like adds that oxygen to the fire, while the other one holds the boundary of like, we don't act like this in class, without turning the behavior into a performance. And think that's really the key. Being trauma-informed doesn't mean being permissive. You can hold high expectations and correct behavior and maintain a clear boundary without turning every correction into a confrontation. There's this one time I was teaching in middle school and I was co-teaching with this fabulous teacher. I love this teacher, she's fantastic. And I was teaching about critical thinking with the lens of digital literacy. Very ambitious, I know. And the class had students who would just call out all of the time, huge executive functioning challenges in that classroom, which is actually why she asked me to co-teach with her. And I was like, I can't wait. So exciting. So, you know, anytime she was teaching before we did this together, there was constant side conversations, interruptions, comments. Things would always escalate always escalate And then you know you kind of like okay like I'm gonna ignore this behavior right so like you try to ignore it But it would always end up being too much, and then you'd be like stop interrupting it would happen again Be like seriously like we just we just talked about this you just I just asked you to stop interrupting You're doing it again, then their eyes roll then you know that you get super frustrated with that and before you know it, 10 minutes of that lesson is gone, never to be seen again, and the bell is about to ring because more time was spent adjusting that behavior than actually teaching the lesson. So I remember, you know, with all of that information, like being in that classroom and when I was creating this unit for co-teaching for digital literacy, I just remember thinking, okay, I cannot continue to spend more energy arguing about the behavior than the behavior itself actually deserves. So, which means that the problem... even though it might seem like the problem is the behavior, the problem really was the interaction right after the behavior. And I knew I needed to change my approach. So the next time I taught that class, I talked about the expectations I had for the class. I asked them, after each expectation, why they thought it was important and if they agreed with it. You know, we had some discussions. I wrote expectation, like I didn't call it expectations we all agree on, but I put a title on the board and I wrote everything down on the board as long as it was agreed upon and then I started the lesson. And I will say this, at the beginning of every lesson on that unit, I did the same thing. What did we, I had it written down, but I asked them what did we agree on? They'd call it out, I'd write out anything that they forgot. I'd be like, do we still agree with this? Do we understand with this? Do we know what this looks like while I'm teaching? Right? And it was great because then I would start the lesson and when students talked, as of course they will, I would use my whiteboard marker that I never let go of and I would point to where the expectation was on the whiteboard and I would keep the lesson going. I would just go tap, tap as I was talking and as soon as we stopped talking, it was great. And like other students would be like, no, don't do that. Right? And it's not, I think it's really important because the goal isn't to be in charge. Right? Like you are in charge. You're the teacher. You don't need to prove it. The goal is to get the classroom back on track and you can hold the boundary and maintain those high expectations and you can still choose not to turn every correction into a confrontation. Being calm isn't being permissive. It's being firm and it's being very confident in the fact that you know you're a teacher and you know you don't need to escalate anything. Hey. I'm not even going to repeat, hey, we already talked about this. I'm just going to tap, tap, tap. You're going to know what I'm talking about. Behavior's going to stop, and I'm going to keep going. I'm not even going to disrupt my lesson for it. And that is very powerful. And I still, it's one of my favorite units that I've ever taught because I really put in that work and it went so well. And I still talk to people about it because I loved it so much. So it worked really well. So it will work well for you. OK. Classroom management strategy number four, build a relationship and keep the standard. So I think, know, good classroom management, you don't need to be in control. It doesn't need to be rigid. And you do not need to lower your expectations for these students at all. Okay. Sometimes teachers will hear that build relationships and think, so I need to just let everything go. No. Not at all. Remember connection, it's not about permissiveness. It is one of the most powerful strategies to be able to communicate to a student that you care enough about them to hold them accountable. To set the high expectations and to be there to help them achieve those high expectations. And you don't need to know what is happening in a student's life to be able to say, see you're having a difficult day and the expectation is that you are still communicating respectfully. You can give a student another chance without eliminating the expectations. You can show grace without removing boundaries. I had this student where everything was a comment. every little thing he saw as an invitation to speak. And he had an opinion about everything. And he held contradictory opinions, as most people who talk too much And when I asked the class to get started, there was a comment when I gave instructions, there was a joke. And if I dared to correct something for this student, there was an argument. And at first, I found myself bracing, know, bracing for the next interaction and not looking forward to teaching my favorite lessons because of that constant natter and pushback. But I also recognized that I couldn't continue and complete a full year like that. So I took a breath. That's my strategy. I really like grounding with my breath. I don't know what your strategy is. If you don't know what it is either, it's a good time to figure that out. If you do know what it is, awesome. I'm glad you found something that works for you because that can be really hard to do. So I took a breath and I realized that I needed to make a connection with this student. I'm getting annoyed by all the nattering and the pushback and everything, but had I actually put in any effort to connecting with that student? I hadn't, right? Especially because like, me, bracing before I like, had any interactions it doesn't make me want to build a relationship, but I'm the adult. the next day, instead of immediately correcting him or instead of like rolling my eyes, you know, where no one can see, of course, I stopped and asked him about the stickers on his water bottle. I know my daughter likes talking about the stickers on her water bottle. I thought, let's try this one. And it ended up being something he was really interested in. They were stickers from manga and he got really animated talking to me about it. And I asked him some, you know. follow-up questions like that were about what he was saying. it wasn't a big conversation or a profound breakthrough, but we talked, for a minute and a half. And after that, I made a point in checking in with him each lesson, small little comments, questions about his interests. And I didn't expect this, but this ended up helping me because my nervous system immediately calmed down. And I realized that it's because up until then I had associated every interaction with a student as negative and now I was creating all these positive interactions with the student. Nothing dramatic changed overnight. But after time, there was change. I could correct him. We could have inside jokes. One day when he started talking and I was giving a lesson, I just looked at him and I was like, I really need you to listen right now. And I need everyone to listen right now, to me. And he looked at me and was like, all right. And I realized that, okay, sure, the relationship's not gonna make the behavior disappear. Of course not, you know? That's not how it works. It did mean that when I addressed the behavior, I had a connection with the student and the results could change, The correction started landing differently and students don't need teachers who have no expectations of them, but they want teachers who can communicate, hey, I see you, I believe you can do this, I'm not gonna give up on you. And I realized that I had communicated that to that student and so we got there in the end, which was pretty fun. It's nice to be able to like flip those relationships around, you know? all right. Classroom strategy number five. Don't turn every behavior into an incident. And you know, not all behaviors do need your full attention. Is a student talking? Can you just stand near them and maybe they'll stop talking? If someone's distracted, can you do eye contact? Have a visual cue or like a sound cue to get them back on track? If a student is getting off task, can you quietly redirect them? If someone needs a choice, maybe just give it to them. know, sometimes people can't go from a clean slate and that's fine. Sometimes a pause is enough. Silence is deafening. There's a reason that that is a saying. Sometimes a look is enough or simply walking towards a student can change their behavior. You're also teaching your students like when you see something mildly annoying, should focus on it, we don't want students to focus on that. We do not like it. You don't want students to focus on that. You don't like it when students come at you with every single little problem. Don't come at them with every single little problem. Remember a student who loved to tap the pencil on the desk? I get it. I'm a pen clicker. I totally understand. wasn't necessarily loud enough to stop the lesson, but as soon as I noticed it, I couldn't unhear it. And a few students would always start to look over. Some students started doing it themselves. So it kind of was turning into a little bit of a thing. And of course, my first instinct was, can you please stop tapping? We've... Talk about this, right? But I knew where that could go and I didn't want to turn it into a scene And this was math. We needed to get through this. I needed the students to pay attention because the ones who started tapping it really needed that help. And I did not want like a distraction to become the main focus. So I walked over while I continued teaching. and I just gently put my hand on the student's desk. gave them eye contact when they glanced up at me, I looked at the pencil and they put it down all while I kept teaching, No announcement, no lecture, no loss of momentum, which was really what I was going for. And it worked, I could have stopped the lesson, called the student out, waited for them to respond, turn it into a big thing, but I chose the least intrusive thing I could think of at the time to get the job done. You're not ignoring the behavior when you do that, you're creating a classroom where students know what is expected, what will happen next, and that boundaries exist for everyone. You're tapping your pencil. I'm going to gently remind you not to do that, right? That is creating a classroom where students know what happens next. It's not just, I know that PE happens. you know, Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 11.45, no, it's knowing that, when this happens, the teacher will be there to calmly reset what's happening, And when you get those things right, you do spend a lot less time managing behavior and a lot more time actually teaching. Thanks for joining me. I'll see you next time.