Latest / FE exam in the car / STUDY DISCUSSES EGG WHITE PROTEIN VS EGG YOLKS AND MORE
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Celebrity exercise and diet Secrets. We discuss how celebrities stay in shape
- 0:07and more so, let's get started. Welcome back everybody. Today. We
- 0:32got a great guest, Kevin Paulson. He's got a master's of Science and
- 0:35Human Movement at the University of Actually he didn't get at the University of Illinois.
- 0:40He's getting his PhD at the University of Illinois or Vanish and pain.
- 0:45We're going to find out a lot about nutrition with him today, especially about
- 0:48eggs. That's right, eggs. He did a great study on egg yolks
- 0:53and egg white specie if those really matter. You've heard a lot of things
- 0:56about egg yolks over the years, so is it true there's an impact you
- 0:59a build muscle. We're gonna find out all that and a whole lot more
- 1:03so. Before we get started, you know what to do, Share,
- 1:04subscribe, hit that I like button. You know we like it. It's
- 1:07not waste any more time on the show, mister Paulson. Welcome sir.
- 1:11I thank you Carlas for having me on. Thank you for being here.
- 1:14This is a topic that's always interested, especially for people who are a die
- 1:17hard workout. So even if you're not working out a lot or you haven't
- 1:21been around a lot, It doesn't matter, folks, you can still benefits.
- 1:23Maybe you'll get there. But the egg argument, we've heard this argument
- 1:27for for a little while. Now, that's what I really was interested about
- 1:30your study because you had the egg yolks and egg whites and that separation.
- 1:34So tell us little about what motivated you to do that study, right,
- 1:38So, yeah, this is this is a study that was performed by a
- 1:42researcher called Stay from Them Bleed. He was he was the main the main
- 1:48researcher on it within our lob with Professor Nick Bird. So it's been a
- 1:56couple of years ago now that that study got published and the time when they
- 2:00when they started conducting it. It usually takes a couple of years with these
- 2:02studies to uh to finish up. The idea was that the amount of protein
- 2:10and mainly UH, the the amino acid content of that protein. So the
- 2:15amino acids are the building blocks of protein, as you know, that is
- 2:19what would dictate the the muscle protein synthetic response, So the capacity of the
- 2:24muscle to renew its its proteins and and and incorporate extra proteins. So with
- 2:34that in mind, they thought to test that hypothesis with the study. So
- 2:38what Stefan looked at was basically and young healthy men. So they recruited ten
- 2:46healthy young men and they sought to compare the effects of whole eggs versus egg
- 2:52whites on muscle protein synthesis, and the idea being that both groups would provide
- 3:00the participants with an equal amount of protein, so eighteen grams of protein in
- 3:04this case, and fairly similar amino acid profiles as for example, one amino
- 3:12acid that is plays a big role in stimulating muscle putin synthesis is themino acid
- 3:17leucine, and both both groups contained about one point six grams of the leucine.
- 3:23So that was kind of the idea of when going into the studies to
- 3:29test that hypothesis. So yeah, I'll explain what they did in the study
- 3:34exactly. So what's stay Fund had to participants do was they had to come
- 3:39in on two separate occasions. On the first occasion, they would consume either
- 3:45the whole eggs or the egg whites, and then on the next occasion,
- 3:47typically there's a weekend between these these types of the experiments they would eat the
- 3:53other option. So it's what we call a randomized crossover design to really pinpoint
- 4:00what the effect is of each investigated nutrient. Then on each of those days,
- 4:06those Christmas came in fasted, well rested, they typically don't exercise a
- 4:11couple of days before, and then he'd have them perform a heavy stimulus of
- 4:17resistance exercise. So in this case we used a leg extension and leg press
- 4:24fairly heavy, after which they consumed the whole egg or the egg whites.
- 4:30Ask you a quick question, Yeah, in regards to the participants of male
- 4:33female, was there an age range, was there a fitness level or anything
- 4:36like that you looked for. So, yeah, and for this study he
- 4:39used ten men. They were they were all resistance trained. The reason they
- 4:46used men at the time is because well, men have sometimes the hormonal fluctuations
- 4:53they can affect muscle protein synthesis. So from a like historic men have been
- 5:00most studied with our muscle metalloism studies. Fortunately, that's that's changing now.
- 5:08So in a lot of our studies right now, we have a lot of
- 5:11females incorporated as well, included as well. Yeah, so you included ten
- 5:17resistance strength men I think they all came from a local powerlifting gym, so
- 5:21they were well trained, which is also very important because the muscle our,
- 5:28muscle poortein synthetic response tends to change a little bit as we get more trained.
- 5:33Question did you see that? Were you checking to see if they if
- 5:36they were on any pds at all, or did you know? So,
- 5:43yeah, we have, we have medical history questionnaires and and pds. You
- 5:47know, if somebody would somebody would supplement with something like the stosterone, that
- 5:54would be if they reported, they're immediately excluded. So we tell them and
- 5:59if they were, would you know, not tell us. We would immediately
- 6:01see that since that really jacks up those muscle putin synthetic rates, so it
- 6:06would be immediately apparent. But they were, they were well trained. So
- 6:13let's see. So after the exercise, about they consumed the whole egg or
- 6:18the egg whites depending on the trial, and then we took repeated blood,
- 6:24breath and muscle samples afterwards. So with this we could measure a couple of
- 6:29things, the main outcome being muscle protein synthesis as well as lucine oxidation to
- 6:34get a measure of how much protein we're oxidizing see and interestingly what he what
- 6:42he found in that study was that the whole eggs, despite having a similar
- 6:46protein content and any similar amino acid profile, the whole egg stimulate the muscle
- 6:51protein synthesis to a larger extent than the egg whites. And at the same
- 6:58time, the amount of lucine oxidation was it the same, So they wasted,
- 7:02wasted, the oxidized the same amount of protein, except for the muscle
- 7:09protein synthesis rates was higher and the whole So that was really interesting. It
- 7:13was counter to the to the hypothesis at the time, and it kind of
- 7:16kind of initiated this this whole food question, So is does does eating protein
- 7:26within its whole food matrix? Does that effect the the anabolic the anabolic effect
- 7:33that that the food ingestion has on our bustle. So yeah, since then
- 7:38we've been heavily focusing on that with some new studies. Well, yeah,
- 7:42that was that's that's what's safe from doing. That's cool it is because I
- 7:46know we've had the egg argument now for several decades. M It's kind of
- 7:51it's interestingcause there's so many books now that I've read about statins and and egg
- 7:57yolks and causing cholesterol more of a correct, a relational thing, it seems
- 8:01like. And maybe if the person susceptible and all this other stuff, so
- 8:03the egg has been getting hammered. Yeah, it's true, And yeah,
- 8:09maybe unsubstantiated to a certain extent. I know that there's some epidemiological studies that
- 8:16that show that the correlation between cholesterol and cardiovascular risk is not as clear as
- 8:22it was originally thought. There have been studies done where people consumed eggs over
- 8:26a longer period of time and they didn't see any any any effects on on
- 8:31any cardiovascular parameters. But yeah, and I think with as with every food,
- 8:39the entire diet should be taken into context, right, just like just
- 8:43like with this this whole food question, we'd like to take a more holistic
- 8:48approach to our diet and and not not necessarily focus on this this single food
- 8:54is the cause of all your cartive vascular risk, you know. So,
- 8:58yeah, that's an interesting comics. I know, as I talked to geneticists,
- 9:03as I talk to nutritionists, I'm really sorrying to see and maybe I'm
- 9:09just behind. It doesn't surprise me. But even in the world of neuroscience,
- 9:11there's so much more about the interaction going on the dynamics of all these
- 9:16things. As you just mentioned, mac micronutrients are going to play a role.
- 9:20Certain levels of aminos genetic influences such as how many receptors you have for
- 9:26certain things, and enzymes and things of that nature can all play a role
- 9:30in all this. It gets really complicated really fast. Let me ask you
- 9:35this in regards to the eggs, how were they made with the hardboiled eggs?
- 9:39Scrambled egg what did you guys know? They were scrambled? So both
- 9:41the egg whites and the whole eggs were scrambled. It's important to note because
- 9:50the cooking technique does alter or affect the digestibility of the protein. In this
- 9:58case, it's a randomized crossover the design. Like I said, so so
- 10:01each participant is ingesting both the whole eggs as well as the egg whites,
- 10:05sort of having both interventions. So in that case you compare them within the
- 10:11within the subject, so that's an equal comparison. But yeah, like I
- 10:16said, there's this ways to cook food more gradually to prevent that as a
- 10:22loss. For example, when we look at meat consumption, which is a
- 10:26very high quality protein. We know that grilling tends to be a little less
- 10:33good than than for example, cooking food or sewed cooking seed. Cooking is
- 10:39a really good method of preserving those uh, preserving these proteins. So yeah,
- 10:46that's that's a very important question. Yeah, do you know if that
- 10:48if cooking also alters the protein synth it does the body digest it differently and
- 10:56synthesized protein different cook They make a difference if it was scrambled compareed a hard
- 11:00boilder. Yeah. So, like I said, the bio the bioavailability of
- 11:07those amino acids, so how much of which amino acid is appearing within the
- 11:11blood That definitely affects muscle protein synthesis. So these different cooking methods, they
- 11:18affect how how much of these amino acids are appearing in the within the blood
- 11:22stream. So that definitely does affect muscle protein synthesis. Yeah problem, Yeah,
- 11:28yeah it does. Although with a lot of these high quality protein sources
- 11:33and a lot of people tend to eat you know, a lot, a
- 11:37lot of the a lot of the protein, so you'll still have sufficient amounts
- 11:41the maximumly stimulate muscle protin synthesis. The amount, The amount matters to what
- 11:48I'm trying to get that. Yeah, I was going to ask you that.
- 11:50And the muscle protein synthesis, we hear all kinds of numbers point zero
- 11:52seven point zero nine point nine one point zero per gram for kilogram. Way,
- 12:00what's your take on that? Have you've have you seen any numbers on
- 12:03that lately? Yeah, So the current r d A in the U S
- 12:07and in Europe as well is set at point eight grams per kilogram of body
- 12:13weight per day. So the rd A, so that's recommended dietary allowance,
- 12:20was originally set to prevent deficiencies. I know the rd A is getting a
- 12:24lot of scrutiny right now for being too low. It's not not providing people
- 12:30with enough enough protein, which I'll get get get to in a bit.
- 12:35I guess it's fair, But I think it's important to note that the rd
- 12:39A has been made originally or was put in place originally to prevent deficiencies,
- 12:43and it's very it's done a good job at that. Really. The only
- 12:48thing is if we're talking about maximizing muscle protein sentences and hypertrophy, or if
- 12:54you look at populations like like trained populations or older populations, clinical populations.
- 13:01It seems like that RDA might be getting a little too low. There's been
- 13:07some some some reviews on this work that recommended much higher protein amounts. For
- 13:13example stup Phillips, he's a very prominent professor from Canada. He's done a
- 13:20couple of reviews on this and what they see is that for resistance trained individuals
- 13:26or at least trained individuals, and it depends a bit what type of training
- 13:28it is. Resistance training and durance training, we see a range of around
- 13:33one point six to two point two grams per quila per day to be optimal
- 13:39and supporting muscle mass gain. So that's more than double double d r d
- 13:45A. But yeah, like I said that, Also, it also depends
- 13:50on what types of food are you eating, right, like I just said,
- 13:52with this whole egg and egg white study, and now we're seeing some
- 13:56differential effects between eating whole foods versus eating these proteins in isolation. And then
- 14:03as well, the type of training that you're doing matters a lot. As
- 14:09we perform resistance training, we need more proteins to support all that muscle mass.
- 14:15At the same time, as we get more trained, we also become
- 14:18more efficient. As muscle damage occurs, more of that protein gets funneled into
- 14:24actually synthesizing the contractile proteins. For endurance training athletes, they might actually require
- 14:30a little more. That's mainly because their protein oxidation goes up, so as
- 14:35they like, the longer the distance becomes, the more protein that will be
- 14:41utilizing for fuel, which is not a desirable effect, but that does increase
- 14:46the protein requirement. And then, like I just said, as we as
- 14:52we age, we get a little less sensitive to anabolic stimulus stimuli. There's
- 14:58a phenomenon called sarcopenia, which is the age related loss of muscle mass,
- 15:05which I actually worked with a bit more my previous lab and netherlens. But
- 15:11that's that's becoming a big problem within our society since that also leads to loss
- 15:16of muscle strength and increased falls, loss of independence. And we definitely see
- 15:20that that that that population also requires higher protein amounts. And then other clinical
- 15:28populations we see perhaps high requirements might be needed. For example, and obese
- 15:37individuals, they seem to be less less sensitive people on human analysis burn victims.
- 15:45And then yeah, so these these protein requirements can vary quite a bit.
- 15:50I guess I have a couple more questions, and again I appreciate the
- 15:52time. I know. I interviewed a gentleman yesterday day, the day before.
- 15:58I forgot his name. Uh doctor was a doctor shoot, but I'll
- 16:03have to look it up later either way. He works at the Rodale Institute,
- 16:08and they were looking at organic foods and things of that nature, and
- 16:11he was talking about how the soil can impact the micronutrient levels of a lot
- 16:15of vegetables, doesn't matter, do you think for eggs? Have you seen
- 16:19anything in regards to that, how the chickens are through caged compared to being
- 16:23open exposed to certain types of chemicals, anything of that nature. Did you
- 16:27see anything on that? Yeah? So I so, yeah. My expertise
- 16:33is a muscle metabolism, so this is definitely not something that we focus on.
- 16:37But I do know that the type of food that the animals need definitely
- 16:41impact the content of the meat of the animal. So we know, for
- 16:51example, that the grass fed animals tend to have a bit higher I think
- 16:55I think it's omega three content. How it affects the protein content, I
- 17:00don't know exactly, but yeah, what they eat definitely impacts the the quality
- 17:07of the meat. And we see this. This is really interesting within our
- 17:11field. We we study humans, but we're able to and am I the
- 17:18previous professor, I worked for a lichtant Loan and the Netherlands. He does
- 17:22a lot with this. What what they're what they're able to do is is
- 17:26to basically intrinsically label these these amino acids. So you use stable isotopes for
- 17:32that, and it's a way to label these amino acids. And then when
- 17:37they get ingested later with with sensitive analytical equipment, we can we can see
- 17:45those compounds back. So so then when they when they collect muscle bib sees,
- 17:52they can then see how how much of or how many of those isotopes
- 17:56are found back within the muscle. And what he saw is that you you
- 18:00essentially become what you eat and those proteins that were within the food. And
- 18:04he does a lot with milk, so his proteins that were within the milk.
- 18:08He sees those exact labeled proteins back within the muscle within a span of
- 18:15about five hours is a time usion measure. So yeah, that definitely impacts.
- 18:21That's wild. Yeah, it is. Let me ask you this,
- 18:23I guess everybody's probably going to be wondering. You know, in the fitness
- 18:27world, obviously you see a lot about wave protein and cassine and all this
- 18:32other stuff. There are some products that actually use album in right from the
- 18:36eggs that kind of protein. Do you do you know anything of their it?
- 18:40Does it actually alter it so much that is not as effective as it
- 18:42still good at that point the amount of albumen within the food. I always
- 18:48originally thought that albumin proteins combined to it. I know that Dan Moore did
- 18:55a bit of a of a study on what happens with albumin protein synthesis after
- 18:59ingesting multiple doses, and the idea was that protein gets a coupled to albumen
- 19:04in an effort to save it from our oxidation. I'm not too certain about
- 19:08actually ingesting albumin itself. Way is definitely a very high quality protein source,
- 19:18perhaps the highest quality that we know of right now, as it leads to
- 19:23very high muscle protein synthetic responses when compared to other nutrient sources. I think
- 19:30that this is mainly to do with its essential amino acids composition, mainly the
- 19:34amino acid leucine, which seems to very seems to be very potent and triggering
- 19:40muscle protein synthesis. But yeah, like I said, whenever you eat whole
- 19:45foods, they contain the entire spectrum of these amino acids, right, just
- 19:49like wave protein does contains this entire spectrum of amino acids. So if you
- 19:56get sufficient within that food and sufficient amount of those amino acids than that food,
- 20:00it's not necessarily the supplement with that on the side as well, although
- 20:06although there's a lot of there, there have been a lot of successful studies
- 20:11that that supplemented losing itself when the protein dose was suboptimal, and then it
- 20:17definitely helps and increasing muscle putain synthesis. And again, this is this is
- 20:21very this is very cool. Especially in the older population that I was just
- 20:25talking about. They have and they have difficulties with these anabolic stimuli, and
- 20:32a lot of them also have issues with appetite going down. They don't need
- 20:37as much anymore as they used to, and then these types of supplementation protocols
- 20:42might be it might be a strategy to try and improve that muscle and synthetic
- 20:47response. Interesting. I guess my last question, I don't know if you're
- 20:51a Rocky fan or not. M h. Actually, yeah, actually I
- 20:56used to be. I used to be boxer when I was younger. Watch.
- 21:00Yeah, well, you know, I've heard it's been kind of I
- 21:03don't know, I don't know if it's just bed docs or what was going
- 21:06on, but I know the whole the raw egg concept just down in the
- 21:08raw eggs. Remember him doing that in the movies? Oh yeah, yeah,
- 21:11and there's still people actually cracking it in and put it in their shakes.
- 21:15Yeah. Yeah. So I got into boxing because my dad used to
- 21:18be used to be a good boxer back home. And obviously back then we
- 21:22didn't have that much. Science wasn't as popular, and they didn't have the
- 21:27internet, so they couldn't look I need to step up. I remember him
- 21:30telling me stories of, you know, in the morning before his for his
- 21:33morning morning roadwork, head down, a couple eggs just out of the glass.
- 21:38Yeah. I did the same thing. Is there any issue with that?
- 21:42Have you seen anything in that study? I guess my last question for
- 21:45you. So, yeah, there have been some studies done that showed that,
- 21:49like I said, the cooking method matters, and it seems that after
- 21:52cooking the eggs, more of those amino acids are the bio availabilities higher,
- 22:00so you've seen more of those aminuo acids appear in the blood after cooking it.
- 22:06I know that Luke Flane, the professor I just mentioned in the Netherlands,
- 22:11he is at the moment conducting a study on this, so there should
- 22:15be some cool work on that coming out soon and seeing how that affects muscle
- 22:19putain synthesis directly, which I coul guess some of us are so low and
- 22:22on here to talk about that. Oh yeah right, yeah, I wonder
- 22:27that's a good question. I don't know. Well, thank you so much,
- 22:30Kevin for taking the time to be with to be with us. Yeah,
- 22:34I'm very happy to be on. Thank you so much for inviting me.
- 22:37And what can we get more information about the work you're doing. I
- 22:40know you're getting ready to get your PhD wrapped up here in a few months.
- 22:44Yeah. I haven't been too active on social media. I plan to
- 22:48in the future after I finish my PhD. So yeah, you can you
- 22:52can find me on Twitter and hopefully in the future I'll be a little more
- 22:56more active on that, just under my full name, Kevin Pollison. If
- 22:59you'd like to see more from what comes out of my lab our Professor Nick
- 23:03Bird. You can find him under at Nicholas Byrd on Twitter and he keeps
- 23:11his Twitter well updated with all the studies that we run at the moment.
- 23:14Oh, excellent again, folks. It's Kevin Poulinson is p A U,
- 23:17l U S S E and Kevin Poulison University of Illinois or Vanish and PAIGNS.
- 23:22A lot of work being done over there. Thank you very much Kevin
- 23:26again for doing this. We truly appreciate it. Thank you folks for joining
- 23:30us as well. Hope you got some more insight on the egg debate.
- 23:33If we try to get more answers on this, remember what to do,
- 23:37Share, subscribe, hit that I like button. Stay healthy out there, folks,