Latest / Rusty's Garage / The Motorsport Brief | James Allen on the Red Bull rebuild & Oscar’s summer musings.
Transcript
- 0:02A listener production.
- 0:04Welcome to the Motorsport Brief, a mid-season F1 report.
- 0:08Is the biggest story of the year so far over or is there more to come?
- 0:15Hi everyone, Rusty here back in the garage.
- 0:17In the wake of Christian Horner's shock sacking from Red Bull Racing, the drive to survive producers must be frothing.
- 0:24Some have wondered if this has been coming for a while.
- 0:27Will it be enough to keep Max Verstappen?
- 0:29And can the team get back to the kind of dizzy heights of the Vettel era and add to what Max has achieved this decade?
- 0:36Shortly to former F1 lead commentator James Allen, who's
- 0:40Feature ep you can find in our library, what it was like working alongside the legendary Murray Walker back in the day, and a whole lot more.
- 0:49He's very articulate, James, as you'll hear.
- 0:51It's a great story.
- 0:52For something completely different, check out our recent feature releases with Aussie sprint car legend Brooke Tattnall, growing up with his famous racing father, George, getting a break in the US and how tough that was.
- 1:06being his own identity, plus the next gen. That's right, the third generation Tattnall chasing the Speedway dream.
- 1:14You might also like to hear from the new promoter of the Australian Rally Championship, Adrian Coppin, growing up around events, setting up bunting in the backyard as a youngster.
- 1:24Sorry, mate, that is a true story.
- 1:25To his own domestic and international drives, bringing future WRC stars down under to compete, working in key operational roles at Rally Australia, Motorsport Australia and SRO in this part of the world, plus his plans for the future of the ARC.
- 1:43Now to our guest for this ep of the shorty.
- 1:45James Allen and I worked together for years on the 10 coverage of the Australian Grand Prix at Albert Park.
- 1:51He is incredibly well respected in the F1 paddock.
- 1:55These days, he's the president of Autosport Business and F1 at the Motorsport Network.
- 2:01They are go-to trusted news sites for anything on the sport.
- 2:06He also hosts the excellent James Allen on F1 Pod, which you can check out when you're finished with this episode.
- 2:13Hello, mate.
- 2:13Thank you very much for coming back on.
- 2:15Rusty, it's great to see you.
- 2:17Now that the week has sort of passed, that the dust is kind of settling a little bit, are we any clearer on why Christian was shown the door?
- 2:25I mean, intense political pressure perhaps from Team Verstappen.
- 2:28Was it purely the drop in performance, the prospect of losing Max if it triggered an escape clause?
- 2:34What do you reckon?
- 2:35Yeah.
- 2:35Well, it's a very good question.
- 2:37And obviously, in terms of actual announcements and formal kind of acknowledgements, there is nothing.
- 2:43My understanding from conversations is that it's a combination of all of those things.
- 2:51The performance clearly is the first and foremost thing in Formula One.
- 2:55Over 20 years, Christian had built a world-class outfit.
- 2:59in Milton Keynes, which is about an hour north of London.
- 3:02They'd also recently expanded into building engines as well, which is always a bit of an Achilles heel of Red Bull over the years.
- 3:08They were always reliant on if they didn't have a works engine, it made them vulnerable to competition against Ferrari and Mercedes.
- 3:15So they took the bullet, made the massive investment in the engine division.
- 3:18That's a little bit behind, as you would expect, when we're talking about the 2026 engines.
- 3:23But more importantly,
- 3:25the current car and the current DNA of Red Bull racing is on the wrong track.
- 3:30And that's evidenced by the fact that, you know, poor old Liam Lawson had a really rough ride at the beginning of the year.
- 3:37Only lasted a couple of races, got replaced by Yuki Tsunoda.
- 3:42yuki sunoda exactly and um and he's he's only managed to score seven points in that second car so if both drivers at red bull racing were performing as yuki is um then they would be at the bottom of the constructors championship which is not where red bull racing should be max verstappen's an extraterrestrial as you well know and is pulling out performances from that car that are incredible and what happened was
- 4:0612 months ago or 18 months ago when Christian ran into some difficulties with an employee who made some claims of inappropriate behavior towards him and there was an internal investigation, two internal investigations within Red Bull, he was exonerated at the time.
- 4:22But you'll remember that there was a cache of material that was released, never verified or anything like that, but it did create a very...
- 4:29and toxic environment around the team.
- 4:32And Max Verstappen's father, Joss, said, if Christian Horner stays, this team will explode.
- 4:37It will fall apart.
- 4:38Subsequent to that, Adrian Newey, the great genius designer, left the team.
- 4:42Jonathan Wheatley, who was like the sergeant major, the disciplinarian that managed that team,
- 4:48He left and he's now doing great things at the Sauber outfit.
- 4:51A guy called Will Courtney, who was one of the key people on the pit wall that calls the race strategy during the races, that's won them so many races.
- 4:58He's left, gone to McLaren.
- 5:00So there was a brain drain happening.
- 5:02And then the big, as you said in your question, $10 million question was what was going to happen with Max Verstappen?
- 5:07Was he going to be the next one in this talent drain out of Red Bull Racing?
- 5:11Yeah.
- 5:12There was a disagreement, an argument after the Silverstone Grand Prix, where Verstappen had a difficult afternoon against the McLarens, between Jos Verstappen and Christian.
- 5:23And then 48 hours later, Christian was relieved of his operational duties, announced it to the team the following day and exited the building.
- 5:30He's still on the payroll at Red Bull Racing.
- 5:33but I think it's a combination of performance, the atmosphere within the team, what they call in team sports losing the locker room or losing the dressing room as a manager, and also the issues with Verstappen.
- 5:48And I guess the question then, Rusty, is does it make it more or less likely that Max will stay now that this has happened?
- 5:53This is sort of one of the things I want to come to.
- 5:55Firstly, Laurent Mechies comes in from Racing Bulls.
- 5:58He's got a great CV, as you know, form with that race team at the moment.
- 6:03Are the ingredients going to be right for him to put some sort of rebuild together?
- 6:09And how hard is that mission?
- 6:11Yeah.
- 6:11Well, I mean, I know Laurent very well.
- 6:13He's a good friend and he's been through the various different areas of the sport.
- 6:18You know, he had a spell at the FIA where he was working on the race operations side.
- 6:23He was an engineer at Toro Rosso, as it was then called, now Racing Bulls.
- 6:28He was also the sporting director at Ferrari and then came back to be the boss at Racing Bulls prior to this promotion to Rebel Racing.
- 6:36Very competent guy, engineering background, but a good manager.
- 6:40But if you think about it, he's not just taking on a team principal role, he's taking on the CEO role as well, which means he's also got to get the Red Bull powertrains, the engine division, going in the right direction.
- 6:50Those engines are going to be badged forward next season in Formula One with a major rule change.
- 6:55So that's an awful lot for someone to take on their plate and...
- 7:00He knows the setup, which is why I don't think he probably had too much choice in this.
- 7:03I think it was a you're doing this rather than would you like to do this.
- 7:07Had to uproot his family and move them from Italy to England, which is right in the middle of the year as a major undertaking.
- 7:17Very capable guy.
- 7:19But he's obviously going to have to get everyone sort of singing on the same hymn sheet.
- 7:23And again, the crucial element of that is, does Max Verstappen stay around?
- 7:28Can they continue to count on him as they go into the 2026 season?
- 7:32Or is he...
- 7:36Is he going to jump ship and perhaps go to Mercedes, which Toto Wolff is trying very, very hard to organise?
- 7:42And I think that everybody's hanging out to wait and see what Max's decision is.
- 7:47And if you weigh it up from his point of view, on the one hand, you could say with a major rule change like this, where the engines and the chassis are changing for next year, you're better off sticking with the people you know.
- 7:59and then in his case have a look at the competitive landscape during 2026 last time we had a big rule change like this rusty you'll remember red bull were on the right side of it in 2022 and max was dominant before that 2014 mercedes were on the right side of it and lewis hamilton was dominant nika rosberg and matt and the red bull racing really suffered at that point
- 8:22So he'll look and say, is it going to be Mercedes?
- 8:25Is it going to be Aston Martin with Adrian Newey designing the car and works Honda engines exclusively?
- 8:30Is that the direction to go in?
- 8:32So he can buy himself some time to make the right decision rather than having to jump now with a leap of faith that you believe one of them or the other might be the one to go for.
- 8:41On the other hand, he might look at Red Bull and say, this team's in turmoil.
- 8:45I need to get out of here as quickly as possible.
- 8:47My hunch is...
- 8:48The racing intelligence would be stay where you are for a year and then move at the end of 26.
- 8:56My kids, I try to tell them, James, all the time to go to trusted places like a motorsport.com or an autosport and so on, somewhere where there's credibility.
- 9:04But they've come to me with things like –
- 9:05flight plans on social media of Max Verstappen's plane and tracking Toto Wolff's boat and so on.
- 9:12And, you know, trying to understand if this will be the end of the story or if Max would stay or jump.
- 9:20I'm glad you've shed a bit of light on that.
- 9:22Can we come back to Christian just briefly?
- 9:27I mean, he's got a lot of IP from his time at Red Bull.
- 9:31Could you – and I know there's a contract to work out and probably a sizable severance and maybe even gardening leave.
- 9:37Could you see him, you know, going to a Cadillac or staying in the pit lane?
- 9:41What do you think there?
- 9:42Yeah.
- 9:43I think Christian, his pride will be hurt by this.
- 9:47And I think he'll probably want to prove that he is as good as he's always said he was to the owners of Red Bull Racing that's kept him in post for 20 years.
- 9:57And his track record speaks for itself.
- 9:59Eight drivers' championships, six constructors' championships.
- 10:02I think it's 124 race victories.
- 10:04and over 250 podiums.
- 10:06So he's a very, very successful, probably one of the most successful team principals in F1 history, and he's only just turned 51.
- 10:13So there's a lot more to come from Christian Horner if he wants another big job.
- 10:18He's a very wealthy man already.
- 10:19He might want to go and do something else.
- 10:21But if he does want to stay in Formula 1,
- 10:23my hunch would be that he would want a piece of the action.
- 10:27Like Toto Wolff is a shareholder at Mercedes, like Adrian Newey is a shareholder at Aston Martin, I don't think he will want to be anybody's employee anymore.
- 10:36There were some suggestions that Ferrari were trying to get hold of him.
- 10:39Obviously, that's a big job, an exciting job, to return Ferrari to greatness, but there wouldn't be any shareholding attached to that, and you'd have to move the family to Italy and all the rest of it.
- 10:48John Elkin, the chairman of Ferrari, has already said that's not likely to happen.
- 10:53And I don't think that is the direction of travel.
- 10:55I think he's more likely to turn up either at a team like Alpine, perhaps try and buy the team with some wealthy kind of Middle Eastern or American backers.
- 11:06perhaps be involved in a startup like, you know, of a new team coming into the sport.
- 11:11He'd be very credible if he presented a 12th team proposal with backers.
- 11:15But I think he'd be more likely to want to start from an existing base like an Alpine, if he could, or a Haas or whatever, to try and buy a team that's there and then take it from there.
- 11:25If he wants the challenge.
- 11:26I think his wife is very supportive of him having a big career in England.
- 11:30Formula One and wanting to continue with all of that so we will see and just coming back to your kids and their social media tracking There's been a lot about this actually Because the boats in Sardinia and all this kind of thing but the slightly more kind of prosaically of course the reality is that Max Verstappen and Toto Wolff live a matter of a few hundred meters away from each other in Monaco and if they wanted to meet they literally just have to walk around to each other's house knock on the door and sit there and
- 11:58in the back of the house so no one's looking and have a conversation they don't need to go uh all the way to italy or track on their jets or any of that stuff so uh that's the nature of it they're both they're both monaco residents so it's it's easier for and they talk a lot right they're always talking max's dad is always talking to toto and max's manager raymond vermoulin is always talking to him as well this is a fantastic chat we might get james just to hold there for a moment a quick break back with more on rusty's garage right after this
- 12:27You're listening to the Motorsport Brief, our short cast, as we kind of do a report at the midpoint of the 2024 F1 season.
- 12:35Lots of races to come.
- 12:37A close fight in the title between Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri.
- 12:41And whilst the beginning of the podcast has focused on Christian Horner and his departure from Red Bull Racing, we will talk a bit about Oscar's form and his chances in this second half.
- 12:52Back to the convo now.
- 12:54You and I were on the grid in Abu Dhabi back in 2010 for the title decider.
- 12:58It seems like yesterday we were doing that broadcast.
- 13:00Red Bull, I remember, had the music blaring in the garage.
- 13:03They came, James.
- 13:04They disrupted.
- 13:05They conquered.
- 13:06And very impressively with some of the stats that you rolled off before.
- 13:10Can you see them feeling it all, given the passing of Dietrich Matisic in the past 18 months, two years?
- 13:17Can you see them feeling like they have ticked?
- 13:19the formula one box and maybe you know feeling like they've done what they needed to do in formula one or will they be hungrier than ever to prove the doubt is wrong here i mean to me it's very hard to imagine the sport without a red bull now isn't it well we've got two haven't we because they've got two teams racing bulls and the junior team and red bull racing racing bulls of course where liam lawson is is at the moment um i think the
- 13:43Well, a couple of things.
- 13:44Firstly, the team was set up and the whole vision was that of Dietrich Matteschitz, who was the guy that ran Red Bull.
- 13:50He died a few years ago, as you say, and a lot of the problems that have happened that we've been talking about here stem from his death because he was kind of a strong man figure who held the whole thing together.
- 14:00And what he said went.
- 14:02And without without him there, everybody's kind of fighting like rats in a sack for supremacy.
- 14:07So that's a big part of what's led us to this to this situation with Red Bull and with Christian Horner.
- 14:13So, but at the same time, the whole notion of speed and excitement and adrenaline and extreme sport is, which Formula One definitely is, is part of Red Bull's DNA.
- 14:23So, you know, why would they take themselves out of, you know, especially at the moment, Formula One is booming like I've never seen it before in my 35 year career, even when Senna and Prost were at it and in their prime, you know.
- 14:35It was nothing like as big a deal as it is today.
- 14:39So this isn't the moment to quit Formula One.
- 14:41There's still a lot more growth to come.
- 14:43And also the valuations of the team.
- 14:44You know, these are business people at heart.
- 14:46Yes, they want to sell energy drinks, and that is their business.
- 14:49But the value of their two teams combined is probably somewhere in the region of $5 to $6 billion US.
- 14:58Currently, and there's every reason to believe...
- 15:01because that's doubled in the last couple of years, there's every reason to believe that could double again in the next two to five years.
- 15:07So, you know, they could be sitting on two assets there that in a few years from now will be worth $10 billion.
- 15:14I sound like Austin Powers here, don't I?
- 15:16$10 billion.
- 15:20But that's a lot of money, Rusty.
- 15:21That would see you and I comfortably in retirement and utes and fishing trips, wouldn't it?
- 15:26It certainly would.
- 15:2720 years is a long time in this brutal business, James.
- 15:30Even outside of motorsport, it's rare to hear someone say now that they've been with a company or been in that role like Christian for two decades.
- 15:38Maybe it was just time beyond the scandal, the tension and everything else that's transpired there.
- 15:46Can I come to, at this point, if you don't mind, a bit of Oscar Piastri chat?
- 15:52I said recently, park the patriotism.
- 15:54We cannot discount Lando Norris.
- 15:56He is energised by Monaco, the Silverstone win as well.
- 15:59He trails Oscar by eight points now on the ladder.
- 16:04Can McLaren keep letting these two race?
- 16:07We love that they do, but surely this back half of the season is going to get interesting.
- 16:11Yeah, I think so.
- 16:12I mean, it was, what was it, July last year, where things got a little bit tasty between Oscar and Lando in, um, in Hungary and there was some team orders there.
- 16:22And, uh, and then there were a few other examples, uh, as the season went on and they weren't even really fighting for a driver's title at that point.
- 16:28It was, uh, Verstappen was a bit too far away.
- 16:31It's now a two horse race.
- 16:33There's no question.
- 16:34We're at the halfway stage in the championship, 12 rounds down, 12 to go.
- 16:38Um,
- 16:39And I would have said, if we'd had this conversation in the middle of June, that the momentum was definitely with Oscar Piastri and that Lando, psychologically, I think, was struggling a bit.
- 16:50I think the last two rounds in Austria and Silverstone, the manner of the victories, have reset things.
- 16:56Piastri made two mistakes in Silverstone, one in qualifying and another one in the race, where although he claims that he was just doing the same thing as he'd always done behind the safety car with his braking patterns...
- 17:08The reality is he left the door open for Verstappen to make that look worse than perhaps it was and get him a penalty, which, again, was probably more severe than it should have been.
- 17:19The net-net is he didn't win the British Grand Prix, which he should have done, and Lando Norris won it...
- 17:25And because Oscar was faster than him really throughout that.
- 17:28I was there, I was watching it trackside and Oscar definitely had the faster car that day and was the faster man, but he didn't win the race.
- 17:36And he'll have to go away and think about that because now with only eight point gap and 12 rounds to go, it's going to be a case of ebbs and flows.
- 17:43It's absolutely essential that both drivers finish every race.
- 17:47That's fundamental because if you drop points,
- 17:50If you don't score any points, as Norris didn't in Canada, you lose a lot of ground.
- 17:54And I don't know if you're aware of this, Rusty, but Oscar is now on the third longest points running streak in Formula One history.
- 18:01He scored points in 29 consecutive races.
- 18:05which goes back to the 2023 season.
- 18:08So there's only Verstappen and Hamilton have managed a longer streak than, even Schumacher didn't manage it, right?
- 18:1329 consecutive point finishes.
- 18:15So that's a big part of why Oscar is where he is, his consistency, bringing the car home and usually at the front.
- 18:22So he needs to rediscover that groove.
- 18:26If you'd asked me in June who my money was on for the world championship, I would have said Oscar.
- 18:30But I think this mental reset of Norris shows a different side of him, shows a depth to the competitor that perhaps we weren't sure was there.
- 18:40He's not against Max Verstappen, where you would say that Norris might crumble when he's up against Max sometimes.
- 18:46He's up against his teammate, which makes things more intimate and more difficult and creates more tension within the team.
- 18:52But equally, I think it's easier for Norris to take on Piastri than it would be to take on Verstappen in a similar situation.
- 18:59So I would not want to predict which of those two is going to be world champion.
- 19:03But there is no doubt that we are going to have a new Formula One world champion come December.
- 19:09Now, you have to get to the office, so you've been very good with your time.
- 19:12Rapid-fire questions to finish, if that's okay.
- 19:15Biggest surprise of the season so far for you?
- 19:17Got to be the Hulk at Silverstone, doesn't it?
- 19:19Yeah, a long time coming.
- 19:21What, 240-odd Grands Prixs without getting on the podium?
- 19:24Le Mans winner, of course, and certainly a driver who should have had a podium before now.
- 19:29I think, no, I don't think so.
- 19:30I think the biggest surprise of the season for me has been Hadjar in the Racing Bulls car.
- 19:34The rookies are actually, those two, him and...
- 19:38He's performing very, very well in qualifying, but also Behrman is six for six in qualifying against his more experienced teammate Ocon.
- 19:45I think the rookies are doing quite a good job.
- 19:47Antonelli, a little bit less so, but he's got, what, 42, 43 percent of the points of Russell.
- 19:51So he needs to step that up in the second half.
- 19:54But yeah, I think I think my surprise of the season is probably Hadjar.
- 19:58I think he's really caught my eye.
- 19:59That wasn't a very quick answer.
- 20:00Sorry.
- 20:00No, that's a that's a great shout, though, and a very good point.
- 20:02Can Lewis Hamilton win a Grand Prix, not a sprint, before the end of 2025?
- 20:06Yes or no?
- 20:07What do you reckon?
- 20:08Yes, he can.
- 20:10Yes, he can.
- 20:11It's a struggle, but Ferrari, I don't think they'll be doing too many more upgrades.
- 20:16They did lack a bit of pace, but they're not far off.
- 20:19They just need to execute better.
- 20:21Okay.
- 20:21An underachiever or achievers so far?
- 20:26Well, Red Bull, massively underachievers.
- 20:29An overachiever.
- 20:31Russell's done pretty well, got his victories, had five podiums.
- 20:34He's been right up at the front in a not fantastic Mercedes.
- 20:38He'd be an overachiever, I would say.
- 20:41Yeah.
- 20:42And Williams.
- 20:43Williams are much more competitive first half of the season than most people thought they would be.
- 20:47That's good.
- 20:48Can Fred Vassour weather what seems like a bit of a storm and stay at the helm of Ferrari, do you think?
- 20:54Well, there's two questions there.
- 20:55Can he stay at the helm of Ferrari short term?
- 20:58And then can he stay at the helm of Ferrari beyond the end of his current contract, which expires at the end of this year?
- 21:04I don't think they'll sack him before the end of the year, but I don't think they'll retain him next year.
- 21:08So I don't think Fred will be leading Ferrari in 2026.
- 21:12Okay.
- 21:13Wow.
- 21:13That's a big one.
- 21:14I would have thought stability would be a bit of a key there.
- 21:17Finally, we get nervous to ask this, and you've just said it's enormously hard to even contemplate.
- 21:23Could Oscar be the first Aussie to clinch that driver's crown, the first since Alan Jones did back in 1980?
- 21:31Yeah, absolutely.
- 21:32I mean, I think he's been the favourite for the last few months.
- 21:35He's been leading this world championship now for most of the season.
- 21:39He's got used to it.
- 21:40He knows what it feels like.
- 21:42He's got the best car.
- 21:44He just has to be...
- 21:47not just consistent, but just be as smart as he was earlier on and try and give Norris as many hard days as possible and knock him off balance.
- 21:56I think it's a bit like Rosberg-Hamilton.
- 21:58Rosberg won in 2016 because he managed to get under Hamilton's skin and he managed to knock him off his stride.
- 22:05And that's what Oscar needs to do to Norris, I think.
- 22:07And then if he does that, I think he'll be the world champion.
- 22:09Some nice parallels drawn with Alain Prost in recent times.
- 22:14So hopefully he channels more of that in the back end of this season.
- 22:17Action resumes at Spa at the Belgian Grand Prix at the end of July.
- 22:20James, we owe you a beer and more.
- 22:23Thank you very much for coming back on The Garage.
- 22:25It's always great to see you, Rusty.
- 22:27And interesting you mentioned Prost there.
- 22:28If people haven't seen it, I really recommend the Prost documentary series.
- 22:32It really does lift the lid on what was an incredible rivalry between him and Senna, but from Prost's point of view, which is a story that's not really been shared very much.
- 22:40So check that out wherever you can find it.
- 22:43Geez, good.
- 22:43I am indebted to James Allen for coming back on.
- 22:46Make sure you visit motorsport.com for all the latest news or autosport while you're at it and check out his podcast too.
- 22:53Just a little reminder that nominations for the 2026 Australian Motorsport Hall of Fame will close on Thursday, the 31st of July, 2025.
- 23:04So not many weeks left to go at the time we record here that closure foreclosed.
- 23:09finishes just before midnight Australian Eastern Standard Time.
- 23:13So if you know a competitor, maybe someone in the industry that you feel is worthy of being inducted into the Australian Motorsport Hall of Fame, you can go to any of the member bodies that are a part of that.
- 23:26They have shared the link details, or you can also go to Australian Motorsport Hall of Fame, all one word, .com.au, click on About,
- 23:36go to nominate and fill in the details.
- 23:38There is a little bit of work to do there, but over to you and we'll be announcing the latest inductees as we've done in recent years in the build-up to the Australian Formula One Grand Prix next March.
- 23:49That's it for today.
- 23:50We'll catch you next time.
- 23:51Bye for now.