Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Dark Knight / Sazerac Rye
Transcript
- 0:00Robots radio presents. In 2008, director, Christopher
- 0:05Nolan and star Christian Bale gave the world, an eerily
- 0:08thrilling superhero movie that transcends the genre in 2019, we
- 0:13kick off season 2 with an absolute classic of awry.
- 0:17The movie is The Dark Knight. The whiskey is Sazerac rye and
- 0:21we'll review them both. This is the film and whiskey
- 0:25podcast. Welcome to the season two
- 0:46premiere of the film. And whiskey podcast the show,
- 0:48where each week, we review a classic movie and a glass of
- 0:51whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G.
- 0:53And this week, we are looking at the 2008 film.
- 0:57The Dark Knight Brad. Welcome to season 2, man.
- 1:00It is so good to be back in the studio again.
- 1:03Have you enjoyed your time off since we recorded our season 1
- 1:06finale? Oh my gosh, dude.
- 1:07I can't tell you the amount of Adventures I've been on.
- 1:10I've been in Germany and China and Cancun.
- 1:14It's just been epic. Well, I've always felt like this
- 1:16podcast was holding you back. So I'm glad you're finally
- 1:19living a fulfilling life in your off time.
- 1:22Well, now that we're making all this money off of the podcast, I
- 1:25have the extra income to, you know, go do realize my dreams.
- 1:29Absolutely. Well, hey man, we had to drag
- 1:31you back in at some point and we are back.
- 1:33Back for the beginning of season 2, talking about honestly, one
- 1:37of the Cornerstone films of our young lives. 2008's The Dark
- 1:41Knight and Brad. I don't think this is one of
- 1:43those movies where I'm going to even have to ask you, if you've
- 1:46seen it before, because I feel like if you're under a certain
- 1:49age, everyone in America saw this movie, this was a cultural
- 1:53phenomenon and it has become one of the defining films of a
- 1:57generation. Yeah.
- 1:58In a lot of different ways, The Dark Knight really transformed.
- 2:03Of people's lives during that era as far as like their
- 2:06understanding of movies that you, that just because it's a
- 2:10superhero movie doesn't mean that it has to be us of a
- 2:13certain type. Yeah.
- 2:15Like I'm sure like I think back on the superhero movies before
- 2:18this and you even look at the 90s Batman movies and they were
- 2:21cheesy and Jack Nicholson is Hamming.
- 2:24It up. And you know, you have that era
- 2:27and then you have the newer are aware.
- 2:28The Spider-Man's were coming out with Tobey Maguire which fun
- 2:32fact. I actually really Like those
- 2:34Spider-Man. Oh, I do too, I do too even the
- 2:36first movie in this Trilogy, you know, the Dark Knight trilogy
- 2:40Batman Begins. It still had the classic
- 2:43Christopher Nolan, kind of twists and surprises but I would
- 2:45say it, followed the superhero. Genre more closely this movie
- 2:50took Cinema to a whole new level.
- 2:53Yeah, this really did change the game when it came to superhero
- 2:56films and Brad. You're right.
- 2:57I mean, I think what we've seen over the years is an evolution
- 3:00in how filmmakers envisioned Superhero tails, you know I
- 3:06think back to like 1978 Superman the movie with Christopher
- 3:09Reeve. I think that's a phenomenal
- 3:11movie and you get to the late 1980s and you know superheroes
- 3:14had pretty much fallen out of fashion again until Tim Burton
- 3:17takes on Batman and I look back on Tim Burton's Batman.
- 3:20And I've actually never really been a fan of it but I find that
- 3:23people of a certain age people from a certain generation we're
- 3:26really transformed and changed by what that movie did and at
- 3:29the time that was considered a really kind of gritty dark take
- 3:33on it. Because Burton went for these
- 3:34sort of Gothic, expressionistic things in that film.
- 3:37But when you get to the Dark Knight and I hate to use the
- 3:40word grounded, I hate to use the word gritty or realistic because
- 3:43we're going to use it. We're going to overuse it
- 3:44talking about this movie. But what Christopher Nolan did
- 3:48with the Dark Knight is he took, you know, the Batman mythology
- 3:52and he applied it to what is essentially a real-life crime
- 3:57tail. Like, this movie strikes, me
- 3:59more as almost like a crime move, but what you would call
- 4:02like a crime film, Like Michael Mann's heat or something like
- 4:05that. Then it does a superhero movie.
- 4:07Does that make sense? Yeah, it feels in a lot of ways
- 4:09like this could be an episode of The Wire.
- 4:12You know what I mean? Yeah, for sure.
- 4:13I remember as I was watching it this time, I guess I had
- 4:17forgotten how much they make Gotham feel like New York City.
- 4:23Like there is no semblance of this being a superhero comic
- 4:27book movie like even compared to the Marvel movies, which I would
- 4:31say do a pretty good job of setting.
- 4:33Being superheroes in the real world.
- 4:35At least when they're on earth like compared to those even this
- 4:39doesn't feel like a superhero movie and granted.
- 4:41You can talk about how Batman doesn't technically have super
- 4:44powers. He's just really smart and
- 4:46really wealthy in the end. This feels like a real life
- 4:49crime drama. Yeah, it really does.
- 4:52And I think the movie has a lot going for it because it goes in
- 4:54that direction. And you know what, we see in the
- 4:57Years After the Dark Knight is that all sorts of different
- 5:00franchises tried the Dark Knight approach.
- 5:02Whether it be with In the superhero genre or whether it be
- 5:06something like, you know, James Bond which reboot rebooted a few
- 5:09years after this with Casino Royale, everyone tried to take
- 5:12the more realistic less heightened version of a story
- 5:17and apply it in a gritty way. And the Dark Knight is directly
- 5:20responsible for that. Yeah, I think what you saw there
- 5:23was that people were over the, the stylized version of
- 5:29superheroes that you had seen in a lot of ways, and they wanted
- 5:32that Gritty realistic type of movie and in the dark night, you
- 5:38really get that almost to Perfection.
- 5:41Well, I don't think we should go any further at this point though
- 5:43without busting out our favorite segment on this show.
- 5:47Brad explains the part of the show, where Brad tells us
- 5:50exactly what this movie was about.
- 5:52So Brad, can you succinctly some up for us?
- 5:55The film. The Dark Knight.
- 5:56Hey, you want to see a magic trick?
- 6:00What was that your Joker? What?
- 6:04What's that smell? That was more of my like it was
- 6:07a poor. Poor attempt at the Joker.
- 6:10All right. Cool.
- 6:11You're off to a good start. But long story short, there's
- 6:14this dude named Bruce Wayne and he's also Batman and Batman is
- 6:21cleaning up the city of Gotham, which used to be really, really
- 6:25crappy and crime-ridden and he's doing such a good job of it that
- 6:29he's about to shut down like three different mobs.
- 6:33And all their rackets. And so they decide to release
- 6:37this madman named The Joker on to the city of Gotham in order
- 6:43to get rid of the Batman. And the Joker comes up with this
- 6:46plan, where he's going to start murdering citizens of Gotham day
- 6:51by day until the Batman reveals himself, and who he is.
- 6:55And so, the rest of the movie is this, like we said earlier, it's
- 7:00a crime drama. They're trying to figure out who
- 7:02the Joker is. They're trying to figure out
- 7:04what his motivations are. Why is he doing the things that
- 7:06he is doing? And through that?
- 7:10You get a fantastic Adventure that's just gripping from the
- 7:14very opening scene. Well, hey, that was actually a
- 7:18really good summation Brad. Nice job sir, boom.
- 7:22So the Dark Knight comes out in 2008 directed by Christopher
- 7:25Nolan. We've already touched on this,
- 7:26Nolan has become one of Hollywood's biggest directors.
- 7:29I mean so much so that a he kind of gets his way with whatever he
- 7:32wants. Now he can make Movie about
- 7:34anything and it's just financed. And The Dark Knight is a huge
- 7:38piece in that puzzle because before he came onto the Batman
- 7:41series, Christopher Nolan was a really critically regarded
- 7:46director, who was doing some interesting things.
- 7:47He really dealt with movies that had a lot to do with the human
- 7:51psyche, and some Dark Twisted stuff in that his most famous
- 7:54movie before. This was a Memento, made
- 7:57Memento, he made a remake of a Swedish movie called insomnia.
- 8:00And then Warner Brothers, picks him up, to make Batman Begins.
- 8:03After Batman Begins, he makes the prestige which is a lot of
- 8:06people's favorite Christopher Nolan movie and he follows it up
- 8:09with this sequel. The Dark Knight.
- 8:11So Brad. How familiar are you with
- 8:14Christopher? Nolan's sort of filmography, did
- 8:16you, have you seen a lot of his earlier films before the dark
- 8:19know? Honestly, I've seen a lot of
- 8:20Christopher Nolan from Batman Begins on.
- 8:23I don't know if I've ever seen anything from before that.
- 8:26Like, I've seen Inception and The Prestige and all three of
- 8:29the Batman and you know, a few of his other new Her films.
- 8:33But no, I don't think I've ever seen Memento or insomnia.
- 8:35One of the things that I love that Christopher Nolan does kind
- 8:38of has a signature. Now, is that the climax of his
- 8:40movies? He intercuts between two or
- 8:43three story lines, back and forth to build suspense, and you
- 8:46get that again in this movie, at the end of the film, you're
- 8:49watching, you know, these two fairies full of people, one full
- 8:53of convicts, one full of citizens that the Joker has
- 8:56rigged with explosives, and he's given each very icky to blow up
- 9:01the other fairy Joker's trying to introduce a new Turkey into
- 9:03Gotham and prove that people are not as principled as Batman
- 9:08would like to believe and intercut with that, you've also
- 9:11got what's going on with Batman. Try to find the Joker in this
- 9:15skyscraper. That's under construction.
- 9:17And you see this pattern happening again and again, in
- 9:20Christopher Nolan's movies, it's especially prevalent in
- 9:23Inception, where you essentially have four different storylines
- 9:26going on at the same time and they all come to a head.
- 9:28And I think it's just this really interesting pattern.
- 9:31You see, and I don't recall if If that actually happens in
- 9:34Batman Begins I think that the Dark Knight might be the first
- 9:37time we see Christopher Nolan employ this like signature
- 9:41cutting technique that he does. Yeah, like you said, Inception
- 9:44is probably where it's at its best where you have all those
- 9:47stories being interwoven and he's just flashing back and
- 9:50forth between the two of them so quickly but you're right.
- 9:53I think this might be the first time that he did that, and that
- 9:56like it really is a phenomenal way to keep people on the edge
- 10:00of their seats. So no one also co-wrote this
- 10:02movie. His brother Jonathan, which he
- 10:05tends to do on most of his films, but aside from his
- 10:08excellent Direction and his excellent script.
- 10:11What really blows me away about this movie is the cast.
- 10:13I mean, just from top to bottom. The people you find in this
- 10:16movie starting at the top with Christian Bale is bad man.
- 10:19Heath Ledger as the Joker Morgan Freeman, Gary Oldman, Maggie,
- 10:22Gyllenhaal and Aaron Eckhart. And those are just the main
- 10:25players, you know, and I didn't even mention Michael Caine as
- 10:28Alfred. So you know, front from top to
- 10:30bottom. This cast is just absolutely
- 10:33Stacked. Yeah, the further you get along
- 10:35in this movie, you like it almost becomes normal to just
- 10:39see, great actors giving out great performances.
- 10:43Honestly, when I was watching this movie, I just thought to
- 10:45myself halfway through, I'm like, man.
- 10:47Yes, you know, we're going to talk about and people always
- 10:50talk about Heath Ledger as the Joker but the rest of this cast
- 10:54turns in some wonderful performances.
- 10:57Well that leads us into our next topic here.
- 10:59Brad at which is the cast and I guess I want to ask you.
- 11:02Who do you want Start with because we, I think we should
- 11:05just go through the cast and give our thoughts on each
- 11:06person. Yeah, let's let's start small
- 11:10and and big that's not good. Okay.
- 11:12So let's start with Aaron, Eckhart as Two-Face.
- 11:15So Aaron Eckhart plays a character, you know, if you're
- 11:18big into comic books, as I was not growing up, then, you know,
- 11:21the backstory of the character to face you know his real name
- 11:24is Harvey Dent in this film. He is the district attorney of
- 11:29Gotham, who is considered to be a time and time again they call
- 11:32him Gotham's. White Knight, he is the hero
- 11:35that Gotham needs, you know to Rally behind.
- 11:38He has this image of this squeaky clean public servant who
- 11:41is crusading for justice and by the end of the film, The Joker's
- 11:46sort of maneuvering and his machinations and all that has
- 11:50led Harvey Dent to be horribly disfigured.
- 11:53He's lost the love of his life and he becomes the villain to
- 11:56face to show you that it's full of people.
- 12:03Pretty to believe in good until their Spirit breaks, completely
- 12:09until they get a good. Look at the real Harvey Dent and
- 12:14all the heroic things. He's done.
- 12:18You didn't think I'd risk losing the battle for Gotham soul in a
- 12:23fistfight with you. You need an Ace in the Hole.
- 12:31Mine's Harvey. What did you do?
- 12:35I took Gotham's White Knight and I brought him down to our level
- 12:42it wasn't hard see Madness. As you know is like gravity.
- 12:48All it takes is a little push. So yeah.
- 12:52Brad what do you think about Eckhart in this movie?
- 12:55Honestly if you put Christian Bale and Heath Ledger is the
- 12:58main two performances and then you took all the other actors.
- 13:03You named as all like supporting actors.
- 13:05I might say that Aaron Eckhart has the best supporting
- 13:08performance out of anybody in this film.
- 13:11Oh, that's really interesting to me.
- 13:12And this, I'm actually really happy that we're going to have
- 13:14something to disagree on because I think we both love this movie,
- 13:17but I kind of find Aaron eckhart's performance.
- 13:20I don't know if I would call it the worst necessarily, but I
- 13:23think it's the, it's probably the cam piaced of all of them.
- 13:26Like, it, really? Yeah, to me, it's the one that I
- 13:29think would fit in a regular superhero.
- 13:31Movie more than Other performance.
- 13:34It's the least grounded. I think you know, he definitely
- 13:37choose the scenery his CGI face definitely helps with that, but
- 13:41he seems a little bit broad. He seems a little bit
- 13:44over-the-top for me and it might just be because I don't think
- 13:46Eckhart is like that great of an actor to begin with and he's up
- 13:50against these sort of like Titans of acting.
- 13:52But yeah, for me, I liked what he did.
- 13:54I didn't think he was bad necessarily, but if I had to put
- 13:57my finger on one person in this cast, that I think I could have
- 14:01may be swapped out for someone else.
- 14:03I think for me will be Eckhart. Wow, that actually surprises me.
- 14:07And for people listening that might not know what campy means.
- 14:11Define, a campy performance. Oh gosh.
- 14:14That's that's a little bit hard to do.
- 14:16You know when I think of of camp like a campy movie, I think of
- 14:19like Rocky Horror Picture Show, I think of like a
- 14:21tongue-in-cheek, almost like winking at the camera and
- 14:24eckhart's not going that far overboard where he's like, you
- 14:28know, staring down the barrel of the camera.
- 14:30But I do think that Eckhart in this Movie and Jeff Bridges in
- 14:34Iron Man are like, Cut From the Same Cloth.
- 14:37It's a little bit more over the top than I think this movie asks
- 14:40for. So he's not pulling a Walter
- 14:42Huston and winking at the camera.
- 14:44Literally he's not going that far.
- 14:46Yeah, yeah that's interesting to me.
- 14:49I did not think he was over the top and partially because you
- 14:53know, like we talked about earlier, this movie really comes
- 14:55across like a crime drama. And I'm so used to shows like
- 14:59the wire or NCIS or Are you know, other types of Crime TV
- 15:05shows having characters that act like this that are you know, in
- 15:09pursuit of justice and I'll never demand anything but the
- 15:13best for my people but I'll even Devan demand better for myself.
- 15:16And yeah, I've never stopped working like that.
- 15:19Type of character is so ingrained in the crime drama,
- 15:23genre that to me, Aaron Eckhart was like perfect for that role.
- 15:27I thought he performed very admirably, you know, I think
- 15:30it's actually a really good point because he really does
- 15:32remind Made me almost less of like a movie style of acting and
- 15:36more of like a I'm on Law and Order type acting.
- 15:39Yeah. And and in a lot of ways, I do
- 15:41think you're right. It really works for the
- 15:43character because of what Nolan does with the character.
- 15:46He takes this, like you know, this Lennie Briscoe type
- 15:50character that we're all used to seeing and he turns it on his
- 15:53head when he becomes a villain, right?
- 15:56And I think that the reason he shows so much Zeal and
- 16:00enthusiasm at the start of the movie, Is to emphasize how far
- 16:05he falls when he's ready to kill Gordon son at the end of the
- 16:10movie. Yeah.
- 16:11And that's a scene that I want to get to eventually because for
- 16:13me that's one of the best scenes in the whole film.
- 16:15But because you mentioned his name, I think maybe we should
- 16:17segue into some of the other people in the cast.
- 16:19And for me, the best supporting performer in this whole film is
- 16:23Gary Oldman as Commissioner Gordon and it's because, you
- 16:26know, Gary Oldman has now won an Oscar, he was a guy that was an
- 16:30unsung hero in Hollywood for years and years.
- 16:32We've seen him in in so many different kinds of roles.
- 16:35Whether it was in, you know, the professional or as Sirius Black
- 16:39in Harry Potter and he really under plays things here.
- 16:43We've seen him in enough roles where he's screaming and a
- 16:45lunatic and things like that. For me old man, just knocks it
- 16:48out of the park because he I think he understands that he's
- 16:51in a movie where there's a man dressed up in a cape like a bat
- 16:55standing next to him and you know in the wrong hands with the
- 16:59wrong actors, this whole scenario could be ridiculous and
- 17:02Gary Oldman really just kind of grounds everything.
- 17:06And in a lot of ways, I feel like we're in his shoes, you
- 17:09know, he's not a superhero. He's not a super villain.
- 17:11He's just a guy that's in over his head and really trying to
- 17:14help in any way that he can. And so, for me, he was kind of
- 17:18like my into the movie as an audience member.
- 17:21Yeah. And a lot of ways, if you want
- 17:23to picture yourself as somebody in this film, he's the easiest
- 17:27person to stand in for in general the average American
- 17:30citizen wants to do a good job for their Over hood for their,
- 17:34you know, community and they want to keep people safe.
- 17:37They want to help out and and Gary Oldman does that perfectly
- 17:41in this movie. And I would agree with you that
- 17:43if it wasn't Aaron. Eckhart for me, Gary Oldman is
- 17:47very close for me as his performance was so, so well
- 17:51done. All right.
- 17:52What did you think about Maggie Gyllenhaal in the role of
- 17:55Rachel? Now, in the first film Batman
- 17:57Begins, this character was played by Katie Holmes.
- 18:00She was replaced for this film with Maggie Gyllenhaal.
- 18:02I think that was the Right choice because I think Maggie
- 18:04Gyllenhaal is just a way better actor than Katie Holmes but for
- 18:07the amount of time that we had her on screen.
- 18:10What did you think of Maggie Gyllenhaal?
- 18:11I thought she was okay. Okay, I wasn't Blown Away by her
- 18:14performance. There's a few lines that were
- 18:17delivered and just like a way over dramatic fashion that I
- 18:21wasn't a huge fan of. Yeah.
- 18:22But I mean overall like she's she's pretty good.
- 18:25I'd probably give her like a bee. - I don't really think she
- 18:27had that much to work with here either.
- 18:29You know, she heard character is probably the most under written,
- 18:32which is really sad. Add because she's one of only a
- 18:34few characters that carried over from the first movie and I guess
- 18:38we'll get into what happens to her here.
- 18:39But one of the big twists of this film is that she's killed
- 18:43halfway through the film by The Joker.
- 18:45And the first time I saw this movie, I mean, obviously, that
- 18:48was not something I was expecting and it really is such
- 18:51an effective kill because after that point you have no idea
- 18:55who's safe and who's not. And I think that Maggie
- 18:58Gyllenhaal's last scene, you know, where she's tied up in
- 19:01this abandoned sort of way. House surrounded by these oil
- 19:04drums and she's talking through a phone that's been rigged to
- 19:09Harvey Dent her boyfriend. I think that scene is so
- 19:11powerful and she really plays it well and because of how
- 19:15committed she is I think that scene has even more of an
- 19:17emotional impact. Yeah.
- 19:18You know what you're right. I don't know if I've been giving
- 19:21her enough credit for that final scene because I will agree.
- 19:23That's probably one of the most powerful scenes of the movie
- 19:26that really gives the film The Emotional weight.
- 19:30It needs for the final fight between Batman and Joker.
- 19:34So, okay, we've gone through three of our supporting
- 19:36characters. I guess the other two that we
- 19:38should at least briefly mention would be Michael.
- 19:40Caine as Alfred, and Morgan Freeman as Lucius Fox.
- 19:45So let's talk about Morgan Freeman first.
- 19:47Because if I'm being 100% honest here, you know, we've just
- 19:49watched Morgan Freeman a few weeks back in the Shawshank
- 19:52Redemption, which is probably my favorite Morgan Freeman
- 19:55performance. This is another character for me
- 19:58that I think is under written and in a lot of ways, I kind of
- 20:02wonder why. Morgan Freeman needed to be in
- 20:04this movie. He's great because he's always
- 20:06great. But this character has very
- 20:08little bearing on what happens in the film.
- 20:11And it seemed like it could have been played by like, literally
- 20:13anybody and it wouldn't have really made the movie, any
- 20:16better or worse. Yeah, I mean, when you think
- 20:18about it, like Simon Pegg as Benji in the Mission Impossible
- 20:22movies is great, like Simon Pegg is a supporting actor, you know?
- 20:27Yes he has a few movies where he's the lead but in general,
- 20:30he's not going to be Tom Cruise. You know, as Ethan Hunt, he's
- 20:34going to be Simon Pegg as Benji. The support guy who gives him
- 20:38Cool Tech stuff, right? And so in my mind, I'm like, do
- 20:41you really want to put Morgan Freeman as the Support Tech guy?
- 20:47You know, the Q to the James Bond, right?
- 20:50It just feels weird to me. Also a Morgan, Freeman's a great
- 20:54actor, but I'm still not 100% convinced that he knows how to
- 20:57like turn on a computer virtually have him to have him
- 21:00as like your Tech genius. I'm like, hmm.
- 21:03Not 100% bought into this. Yeah.
- 21:05But at the same time I'm like, I guess if you're able to convince
- 21:09an actor of that caliber and you know, just weight and gravity
- 21:13that Morgan Freeman has to play a tech guy.
- 21:16That's just a supporting actor, like go for it.
- 21:19I guess. Absolutely, well, that takes us
- 21:22to the last of our supporting characters, which would be
- 21:24Michael Caine as Alfred and honestly, there's not enough
- 21:28great things. I can say about Michael Caine as
- 21:30Alfred. It's a role that in a lot of
- 21:31ways, I feel like he was born to play.
- 21:33To play. When you get to the third film,
- 21:34in this franchise, The Dark Knight Rises, they really
- 21:37finally, give Alfred some emotional payoff.
- 21:40And Michael, Caine has probably the best scenes in that whole
- 21:43film. I don't think they give him
- 21:44quite as much to do here, but he still feels very vital to
- 21:48everything that's happening. And he really does provide a lot
- 21:51of the underlying philosophy of what you see on the screen.
- 21:56His story about, you know, the the Bandit the jewel thief in
- 21:59Burma, you know, is a microcosm for what Batman is.
- 22:03Spear Ian seeing and Alfred really isn't a lot of ways, the
- 22:05heart and soul of this movie, a long time ago, I was in Burma my
- 22:10friends and I were working for the local government that were
- 22:14trying to buy the Loyalty of tribal leaders by bribing them
- 22:17with precious stones. But their Caravans have been
- 22:20raided in a forest not for Franken by banding.
- 22:23So we went looking for the stunts.
- 22:27But in six months we never met anyone who traded with him.
- 22:32One day, I saw a child playing the Ruby sighs the Tangerine,
- 22:39the bandits have been throwing them away so I still bought
- 22:45because he thought it was good sport because some men aren't
- 22:48looking for anything, logical like money.
- 22:51They can't be bought bullied reasoned or negotiated with some
- 22:56men. Men just want to watch the world
- 22:58burn, you know, you just thought about what's actually his story
- 23:02about the jewel thief and and in Burma is a serious version of
- 23:07Christopher Walken and the gold watch.
- 23:12Oh man, why should I want to see The Dark Night with Christopher
- 23:15Walken as Alfred? That's how pretty.
- 23:19So what did you think of Michael Caine in the movie?
- 23:21I just want to know. Is there anybody else in
- 23:24Hollywood? That you would rather Have is
- 23:27your like real life Grandpa than Michael Caine.
- 23:30No, absolutely not like he is hands-down perfect.
- 23:33And like you said, the role of Alfred is absolutely perfect.
- 23:38For Michael, Caine, he embodies that role so perfectly that I
- 23:42don't even think of him. As Michael Caine, like half the
- 23:45time when I see him in real life, I'm like, oh that's Alfred
- 23:48like right, he's Batman's butler and in a lot of ways.
- 23:51Like that's okay. Michael Caine has given us so
- 23:55many different phenomenal. Romances throughout the years
- 23:58but this performance is Alfred it, it really brings Humanity to
- 24:02Batman because without Alfred in this movie, all you have is a
- 24:06rich spoiled billionaire who thinks that he can be a
- 24:09vigilante but because of Alfred, you get the humanity and and it
- 24:14would help if you've seen Batman Begins because I think, I think
- 24:17Michael Caine gives a phenomenal performance in that movie as
- 24:20well, you know, to kind of ground Bruce Wayne and his
- 24:24childhood. But No man.
- 24:27He brings so much Humanity to Batman's character that you
- 24:30desperately need and that leaves us with, you know, the to lead
- 24:34performance as in the movie, which we would call Christian
- 24:36Bale, as Batman and Heath Ledger as the Joker, you know,
- 24:39honestly, I don't really know how much we need to talk about
- 24:41Christian Bale's Batman. People have gone back and forth
- 24:43on it. The voice is weird.
- 24:45The voice is Gravely. I get it.
- 24:47I still think Christian Bale's phenomenal in this movie, but at
- 24:50the end of the day, we all know, this is Heath, Ledger's film.
- 24:54And when I watched it this time, And Brad, I don't know if you've
- 24:57seen the movie, but a lot of people have I was really struck
- 25:00by the parallels to The Silence of the Lambs and how they deal
- 25:04with the character of Hannibal Lecter in that movie, this movie
- 25:07has that same sort of like foreboding sense of dread
- 25:11throughout. I really didn't know what the
- 25:13Joker was going to do next and I think Nolan was really praying
- 25:16on our fears of terrorist attacks with the joker but it
- 25:21reminded me of how afraid I was all the time about Hannibal
- 25:24Lecter when I was watching The Silence of the Lambs.
- 25:26Hams and in the same way, you know, Hannibal lecter's only on
- 25:30screen for like 20 minutes in that movie and Heath, Ledger's
- 25:33probably only on screen for about 20-25 minutes in the Dark
- 25:36Knight, but his presence is in every single scene and I think
- 25:40for me that's the mark of a just a true classic performance
- 25:44because you're thinking about the Joker at every turn.
- 25:47Yeah, you're never quite sure when he's going to pop up next
- 25:51and they do a great job in this movie from the very beginning of
- 25:55slow. Slowly introducing hints of the
- 25:58Joker into the movie. You know the judge is at the, at
- 26:01the hearing the opening, hearing for all the criminals that they
- 26:04booked with this sting and she's flipping through her files and
- 26:08there's a joker playing card in the fire.
- 26:11You know what I mean? And so from the very start, you
- 26:14get these little hints and images of like, who the Joker is
- 26:17and what he's going to do, the opening scene of the movie is so
- 26:21spectacular. I'm surprised we haven't talked
- 26:23about it yet because honestly this might be one of the best
- 26:25opening. Of any movie ever.
- 26:27Oh, it's such a great opening sequence.
- 26:29And again, you know, I talked a little bit about how it reminded
- 26:31me of Michael Mann's movie Heat, it's set up as this really
- 26:36gritty on the street, Heist crime movie and it never really
- 26:40Strays from that path. It's not like they just hacked a
- 26:43heist on to the beginning of this film.
- 26:45Like, that's the vibe that Nolan wants you to have throughout the
- 26:49movie and that opening, it sets up everything you need to know
- 26:52about crime in Gotham about who the Joker is about.
- 26:56How little regard for human life, he has and and kind of
- 26:59what his Twisted mentality looks like in practice.
- 27:02Yeah. And the cool thing is from the
- 27:04very start, you kind of get this picture of the Joker that he's
- 27:07always in control. Yep.
- 27:09That he always knows everything that's happening and that, you
- 27:12know, in a lot of ways. And and the thing I love about
- 27:14this is that the comic book nerd in me that grew up in the 90s
- 27:18watching, you know, the classic Batman cartoon.
- 27:21The Joker is a character who puts on this facade, Of
- 27:27carelessness and chaos, and Anarchy and he promotes a
- 27:32philosophy of Anarchy. But in reality, he is one of the
- 27:35most controlling person villains that you can have knows exactly
- 27:40how he wants things to go. He knows exactly what buttons to
- 27:43push to get people to do the things that he wants them to do.
- 27:46He's completely meticulous in the way he plans, everything out
- 27:49and that's one of the things I love about Nolan script is that
- 27:53it allows the Joker to contradict him.
- 27:56Self knowing that it's not a plot hole but it actually
- 27:59increases the sort of Mystique behind the Joker.
- 28:03You know, one of the best things about his character in this
- 28:04movie, is that at two different points in the movie, he tells
- 28:08two different stories about his origin, about how he got his
- 28:11scars and they're completely different stories.
- 28:13And the signal to the audience is, wow, these are both probably
- 28:16dies, but he knows exactly, which story to tell in which
- 28:20situation, you know, the one about having a beautiful wife is
- 28:23the one that he tells to Harvey Dent's girlfriend, he knows how
- 28:26to get. Get under people's skin.
- 28:28So I had a wife. Beautiful, I thank you.
- 28:33Who tells me? I worry too much hotels me.
- 28:37I own a smile more he'll Gamble's and gets in deep the
- 28:43Sharks one day they carve her face.
- 28:48We have no life. A surgeries can't take it.
- 28:52I just want to see her smile. Again, I just want her to know
- 28:56that. I don't care about the scars.
- 28:59So I stick a razor in my mouth and do this.
- 29:05Myself and you know what? She can't stand the sight of me
- 29:11and it just makes him an even more.
- 29:14Sort of skin crawling. Lee creepy villain.
- 29:17Yeah that I think that's probably the best description of
- 29:20Heath. Ledger's Joker is skin.
- 29:23Crawling Lee creepy? I mean he just gets underneath
- 29:27you know your soul and just resides there and he just pushes
- 29:31all the buttons of gross - and fear.
- 29:35Here and you know, the video he releases where he has the fake
- 29:38Batman and he's like interviewing him in a meat
- 29:41locker. Yeah.
- 29:42Oh my gosh. I remember when I was like I
- 29:45don't know I would have been 17 or 18 watching this movie for
- 29:48the very first time in theaters. Like I just remember my skin.
- 29:53Just just pitching with how like with how fear-inducing that
- 29:58little video was well and I think that gets to a really good
- 30:01point Brad and we'll touch on this after the break but I
- 30:03really struggle a lot. With the violence in this movie.
- 30:06This is a PG-13 movie, that many people even today, would argue
- 30:09should have been rated R. And I think the fact that the
- 30:12violence is generally, bloodless still shouldn't take away from
- 30:15the fact that the violence in this film is different than the
- 30:19violence. You see in a Marvel movie, you
- 30:21know, in those movies of people shooting lasers at each other
- 30:24and things like that, and yes, people die.
- 30:26But the violence in this movie is so brutal.
- 30:29And so dark, and it just leaves in a lot of ways.
- 30:33It leaves me wondering like Like how did a twelve-year-old get in
- 30:36to see this movie in 2008? You know what I mean?
- 30:39Yeah. I look at this kind of movie and
- 30:42I think that the violence is brutally psychological and
- 30:46that's what makes it so scary is that you don't necessarily need
- 30:49lots of blood. But like when he slams that
- 30:52dudes head down onto the pencil, the pencil makes it disappear
- 30:55like that is just absolutely terrifying.
- 31:00Yeah like and it but the thing is at the end of the day it's
- 31:03effective because A word that I never hear people use with this
- 31:07movie is Scary, but if I'm being honest, this was a scary movie
- 31:11for me because the Joker is such a well drawn out character and
- 31:15he's so unpredictable that. By the time, we got to the third
- 31:18Act of this film. I was genuinely afraid of what
- 31:21was going to happen next. And I said this earlier but I
- 31:24think Christopher Nolan was really praying on our fears as
- 31:28an American audience in the wake of 9/11 and if we're being
- 31:33honest about the Joker and he's called this in Film.
- 31:35He's a terrorist, he's committing acts of Terror and so
- 31:38we don't know what's going to happen.
- 31:39Is he going to blow up these Bridges and tunnels like he's,
- 31:42you know, promising to from the very beginning of the film, we
- 31:45see people getting shot and killed in which is something we
- 31:47don't typically see in superhero movies and like you said The
- 31:51Pencil Trick there's just so many things that kind of
- 31:53undermine our expectations of what we're going to see in a
- 31:56superhero movie. That by the time, Rachel is
- 31:59blown up in a building. And then you see in the in the
- 32:02police department, when the Joker has Early.
- 32:05Sown an explosive device into a man's chest.
- 32:09That reminded me of a movie like David Fincher's, seven.
- 32:12Like this was really, really dark brutal stuff that you can
- 32:16would not see in a PG-13 movie and I still don't know how I
- 32:20feel about it being rated PG-13, but I can say that the violence
- 32:24was effective 100%. It was so effective in
- 32:28communicating. The fear that gripped Gotham
- 32:33City over the The emergence of the Joker.
- 32:36Yeah, so there's more things I want to talk about with the
- 32:39Joker and his plot to, you know, destroy Batman and so on and so
- 32:43forth. But in the end, I think we need
- 32:46to drink some whiskey. To continue talking about this
- 32:48movie. Bob, why don't we get into this
- 32:50Sazerac Rye? Alright, so today we are
- 32:57checking out Sazerac Rye. This is also known in the
- 33:01industry as babies as Sazerac rise, really historic name.
- 33:05If you ever heard of the cocktail a Sazerac, that's where
- 33:08this is, supposedly gets its name from Sazerac is currently
- 33:11being produced by Buffalo Trace. It's called babies as because
- 33:15this is the six-year version. Buffalo Trace.
- 33:17Every year releases a collection called their antique collection,
- 33:20which is five different kinds of whiskey that will retail for
- 33:23hundreds and hundreds of dollars and there is a Sazerac.
- 33:26That collection, that's 18, years old.
- 33:29But this is called baby-sized. People love to pick it up as an
- 33:32alternative to the really expensive, kind it flies off
- 33:35shelves, in the state of Ohio, it only cost $25 but you will be
- 33:39lucky to find it anywhere. And in many states you're going
- 33:41to have to pay double that price.
- 33:43At least to get your hands on a bottle of babies as Brad if you
- 33:47ever heard of this brand before. Yeah, I have heard a Sazerac cry
- 33:50and I'm actually really excited to try this because I, you know,
- 33:53I've heard the legend of how fast it flies off shelves.
- 33:56Elves. So I'm excited.
- 33:57We got our hands on some. Yeah me too.
- 33:59This was actually donated by one of the professors at the
- 34:01University. I work with so dr.
- 34:03Riemer thank you very much for this bottle of Sazerac Rye.
- 34:07Brad we've poured it out. What do you think of the nose on
- 34:10this bad boy? Honestly, it has a really
- 34:12Pleasant knows. There's nothing offensive about
- 34:14it. You get that little hint to Rye,
- 34:16it's not crazy strong. I'd be curious to hear the mash
- 34:20bill on this because I don't feel like it's a very high R I
- 34:25know and it's 90 proof. I think we should say that.
- 34:28You know, Brad used the word inoffensive to describe the
- 34:31nose. I think that's a good word.
- 34:32I also think I would probably call it like unremarkable.
- 34:35There's nothing on this that really stands out to me as
- 34:37unique. It just kind of smells like a
- 34:39standard Rye. What I am picking up though is
- 34:42that it has a lot of bourbon sort of character to it, which I
- 34:45think is what you're getting at Brad.
- 34:47It doesn't seem like a really high why Mash bill.
- 34:50There's a lot of oak on this and then I'm getting some of that
- 34:53classic bourbon vanilla and then kind of on the back end of, you
- 34:58know, inhaling it. You get that pepper and spice
- 35:01that you get both from Bourbon. And from Rye, it has a really
- 35:04spicy smell to me. But other than that, I don't
- 35:07know that it really stands out. Yeah, I'm gonna give it a seven
- 35:10on the nose. Its pleasant.
- 35:12It's nice. It doesn't it doesn't hit you
- 35:14too hard. I like it.
- 35:16Yeah. I'm gonna give it a seven as
- 35:17well. So why don't we go ahead and
- 35:19give it a sip? Yeah.
- 35:23That's not bad. It's a little bit watery.
- 35:26Yeah, it has the flavors you're looking for but they're not like
- 35:31crazy strong. So there wasn't really much
- 35:33going on here like on the front of my tongue on the front of my
- 35:36palate. The, when I first sipped it,
- 35:38you're right, it's very watery, it's pretty thin.
- 35:41There's not much going on in the taste and in fact, the only
- 35:43things I really picked up where those kind of like saltier
- 35:45saline notes. I was kind of bummed out by the
- 35:48fact that it tasted like that. And then I went to swallow it
- 35:51and right there on the end of the East into the Finish is
- 35:54where you really get a lot of those spicy peppery notes that
- 35:58you picked up on the nose. So, this is, this is a hard one
- 36:01for me. I think, I like the Finish more
- 36:03than I like the taste. And I only give the the taste
- 36:06about a five. I was about to say, I'm just
- 36:08going to go ahead and score, the tastes and finish together.
- 36:11Uh-huh. I would probably give it a 5 on
- 36:13taste and a 6 on finish. Yeah, I think I would do a five
- 36:16and a seven. So, so far, we're pretty much
- 36:19spot on each other's estimate here, in what we think.
- 36:23Of this rye bread. What would you give the overall
- 36:25balance? I'll give it a six and a half.
- 36:27I think that the nose gives me more than the taste and the
- 36:32Finish does. But overall it's pretty
- 36:34well-balanced. I mean the the term inoffensive
- 36:38stands all the way through. I mean even now a few seconds
- 36:40after having drank it, it's still sitting on my palette.
- 36:43It's a nice pleasant taste. But it's nothing strong.
- 36:47Yeah. The Finish lingers and it's a
- 36:49really robust finish, but yeah, it's unreal.
- 36:53Kabul and I'm kind of bummed because I've heard so much about
- 36:56how quickly this flies off shelves.
- 36:57It's not a bad ride by any stretch of the imagination and I
- 37:01would be happy to have it on my shelf, but certainly not at, you
- 37:04know, anything more than retail. So, for overall balance, I think
- 37:08I'm just going to go ahead and give it a 7.
- 37:10All right? So that brings us out to our
- 37:13final category, which is value. Now we've said in the state of
- 37:16Ohio, this is 25 bucks. But Brad, what do you think
- 37:20about it? Yeah, honestly $25 is a good
- 37:22value. You for a whiskey like this,
- 37:24it's a good Pleasant whiskey. I could see people who want to
- 37:28introduce their friends to a rye whiskey, giving them something
- 37:32like this, we talked about Bulleit Rye, a few weeks or
- 37:36maybe a month or two ago. And I would probably put this in
- 37:39a similar category you know bullet probably costs about
- 37:41twenty two twenty, three dollars.
- 37:43So a few dollars cheaper. But it's a good introductory
- 37:46Rye, it's not going to hit you crazy hard.
- 37:48I'm going to go ahead and give it a seven for the value.
- 37:51I'm also going to give it a Seven.
- 37:53Because I think that most of the people listening to this podcast
- 37:56are not going to be able to get this bottle for $25.
- 37:59And so, my recommendation would be if it's any more than retail.
- 38:03You don't need to buy it but the fact is for a lot of you guys,
- 38:07that's not an option. So I do think it's worth trying,
- 38:11you know, if you go to a bar and they have it on the menu, I
- 38:13would recommend tasting it when it comes to buying a bottle,
- 38:16it's really going to be dependent on where you live in
- 38:18the United States and what the availability is.
- 38:21So I'm just going to stick at a seven and yeah, I think that's a
- 38:23fair score and that brings me out for my total to a 31.5 and
- 38:29that brings me out to a 33. So for our final scores at
- 38:34brings us out to a what would that be thirty?
- 38:37Two point two five or a 64 and a half out of 100.
- 38:42Yeah which I think is a really fair score.
- 38:44I think so too. This was a good Rye and I'm
- 38:47really starting to realize the variety of rye whiskey that
- 38:51there is. You know I was a guy that From
- 38:53the beginning of this podcast said, I don't really like Rye
- 38:55that much, but I'm finding more and more.
- 38:57That it really just depends on that Mash bill.
- 38:59It depends on the age and it just depends on your palate.
- 39:02And so, this is one that I would probably actually choose this
- 39:05over our Bulleit Rye, that we tried, because it's a little
- 39:08less harsh and I would recommend it.
- 39:10Yeah, I would recommend it to and I would agree.
- 39:12Bulleit Rye is a little bit stronger with its Rai flavor.
- 39:16Whereas this one is really smooth.
- 39:18I think that might be the defining word.
- 39:20I'm going to use is smooth. It's a nice smooth ride.
- 39:23Why? So yeah, I would definitely
- 39:24recommend Brad. What do you say?
- 39:25We keep sipping on this as we get into the back half of our
- 39:28show and finish talking about the film, The Dark Knight.
- 39:41So that was Sazerac Rye Brad and I both recommended not a
- 39:46terrible whiskey, not a great whiskey but you know, definitely
- 39:48something that if you're going to spend $25 can be on yourself.
- 39:52Yeah, it's a smooth easy sipper so I would definitely recommend
- 39:55it well for season two guys we wanted to do something new and
- 39:59add a couple different segments into the podcast.
- 40:01And the first one that we wanted to try out is something that
- 40:04we're going to call. Hot takes hot takes coming at
- 40:07you from filmin whiskey. One of our favorite podcast that
- 40:10we like to listen to Who is the insanely popular show?
- 40:13How did this get made, where they review, really, really bad
- 40:16movies. And on that podcast, they have a
- 40:18segment that they call second opinions where they find Five
- 40:21Star reviews. That people gave to these
- 40:23terrible, terrible movies. And so we thought, why not flip
- 40:26that concept on its head and so what we did is we're taking
- 40:30these Classic Movies on film and whiskey, but we're going to
- 40:33places like IMDb and Amazon and we're finding one star reviews
- 40:37that people gave to these movies.
- 40:39And boy. Oh boy, Brad, did I I find some
- 40:42really, really quality one star reviews.
- 40:44Yeah, I'm really excited for this segment.
- 40:46I think it might be the best addition to the film and whiskey
- 40:50podcast. Well, let's get into it because
- 40:51I want to hear what you think of these are first hot.
- 40:54Take comes from an IMDb user known as Tilly.
- 40:57Go mess 92 and it's titled. A disgrace of a movie I just saw
- 41:03it. This is the most horrible movie.
- 41:05I have ever seen, please don't waste your time.
- 41:08The story makes no sense. The characters are stiff like
- 41:11Frozen cucumbers, the purpose and motivations are completely
- 41:17ridiculous. This is a disgrace of a movie.
- 41:20It's as if the director wanted to create the anti Batman, oh my
- 41:24God. Oh, my Buddha wasted life, one
- 41:28star. Oh, My Buddha, huh.
- 41:32I just love that that he was covering all his bases.
- 41:34Like, this movie would have offended him in any religion.
- 41:37Yeah, for sure. I mean, who's to say what
- 41:41religion would actually accept this disgrace of a movie?
- 41:44Alright, our second hot take is coming to us from manaan Kumar
- 41:491809 1996. His review is titled.
- 41:54Okay, too slow should have shot some good daylight scenes acting
- 42:00was good. One star.
- 42:03Wait, did he actually write the words?
- 42:04One star. No, I've just his game just
- 42:07concluding with the fact that he gave it one star after saying
- 42:10acting was good. One star.
- 42:12Yeah, I feel like that take was just kind of like somebody
- 42:17scribbled notes down while they were watching the movie mellow
- 42:20acting seems good, but overall once done star, all right, we're
- 42:26moving over to Amazon for our third hot.
- 42:28Take, this is from Tortuga, the lows.
- 42:31And it's titled violence with no plot.
- 42:35There is nothing. Enticing, thrilling or
- 42:37challenging about this plot. It is all about the violence.
- 42:41The explosions and more violence.
- 42:43Please entertain my human mind. I'm inquisitive.
- 42:47Not just my animal mind with shiny lights and sounds.
- 42:51Give me something to think. To ponder, to desire to look up
- 42:55to this movie is all a bunch of modern smoke and mirrors.
- 42:59That treats me like an idiot, monkey.
- 43:02I'm sorry, I wasted two hours on it once.
- 43:05Star one star. Are you sure that Tommy was so
- 43:09didn't write that review? I'm pretty sure that if you read
- 43:12that in Tommy was those voice, its eleven times better do not
- 43:15appeal to my animal mind, appeal to my human mind.
- 43:20You're tearing me apart Batman. Yeah, I think that Tommy was so
- 43:27has a role in this movie Somewhere.
- 43:30Actually, he did a video on swear.
- 43:32He did his audition for The Joker if you ever seen it.
- 43:35No, I need to see though. As soon as we're done recording,
- 43:37you got to go to YouTube and look up.
- 43:38Tommy was those joker? I'm on it.
- 43:41All right. Our final hot take comes from
- 43:43Radio GB. And this review goes like this.
- 43:48Not enough, nudity one star. That's the whole review.
- 43:55That's the entire review. Yeah, that's it.
- 43:58Well, we all know what kind of movies he watches, right?
- 44:01Absolutely. All right, so, that has been hot
- 44:04takes. Let's get back into talking
- 44:06about the Dark Night Brad. Yeah.
- 44:08I think we need to talk about how Aaron.
- 44:10Eckhart was a frozen cucumber, but not a naked Frozen,
- 44:14cucumber. No.
- 44:15Well, clothed, it would have been so much better if you'd
- 44:18been a nude Frozen cucumber. Oh man, that's brilliant.
- 44:22And it actually, honestly, you bringing those up, makes me feel
- 44:26better about the frustrations that I have with this movie
- 44:30because it helps me understand that I'm a normal human being
- 44:34that can appreciate a movie for what it is.
- 44:36But also critique it on like a normal intellectual level.
- 44:40Like, I'm not a movie critic ready?
- 44:41I'm out. I'm not on some Roger Ebert
- 44:43level. I'm just an average Joe that can
- 44:45give an honest critique of a movie.
- 44:47Well, and that's what we appreciate about you man.
- 44:49And so I do want to get back. Talking about this and I'm
- 44:52really interested to hear you said that you do have some
- 44:55nitpicks with it. So what sort of things stuck out
- 44:57to you on this viewing Brad that you had a problem with yeah,
- 45:00honestly, like the cool thing about the Joker is how
- 45:04meticulous and well-planned he is but there is something about
- 45:08his final like big climactic fight scene that just, I don't
- 45:12know, it just didn't hit the right notes for me.
- 45:16I really struggled with him hiding in this construction
- 45:18Tower while he set to face. Ferries to blow up and this
- 45:23might not be fair of me, but I think one of the reasons I
- 45:25didn't like it is because as I was watching it, I was thinking
- 45:29to myself. I'm like, man, we're at the
- 45:31climax of the movie and there's a ferry involved, and there has
- 45:36to be a choice about who's going to live or die.
- 45:39And man, I feel like I've seen this before.
- 45:42Oh, wait. I have seen it before from 2002
- 45:45Spider-Man. Like, do you think I'm crazy for
- 45:48seeing like analogies between Movie in this and I know they're
- 45:52not the exact same situation, but I really struggle because I
- 45:55was like, man, this is like a very, very similar situation as
- 45:58to another superhero movie. I just saw six years ago, I
- 46:01understand where you're getting that from.
- 46:02I obviously wasn't thinking about it and I don't think it's
- 46:04a bad comparison, but I do think that what's going on in the Dark
- 46:09Knight is a little more complicated than that because
- 46:12what the Joker's doing is he's not giving Batman.
- 46:15A decision of who to save, you know, the way that the Green
- 46:19Goblin is doing in Spider-Man What?
- 46:22I really love about that scene is that the Joker has Batman
- 46:24pinned and he's convinced that people are like him and people
- 46:29will give in to their darker side.
- 46:31When the chips are down and he is going to make Batman watch
- 46:36other people decide each other's fate and basically say you are
- 46:39powerless in the situation. Yes.
- 46:41And it shows that what the Joker's doing is, he's trying to
- 46:44crush Batman's spirit. And what I love about that is,
- 46:47you know, he tells Batman I don't ever want to kill you.
- 46:51You because you're too much fun for me to be around.
- 46:53He'd rather win in the sort of emotional mental, psychological
- 46:59way of crushing, Batman's belief in humanity, and I think that
- 47:04that's what I love about it is that the stakes are so high.
- 47:07And yet so small at the same time because Batman is Gotham's
- 47:12conscience. And the Joker knows that if you
- 47:14can destroy Gotham's conscience, then everything's going to melt
- 47:18down into Anarchy, which is what he wants.
- 47:20So all the Spider-Man stuff, kind of put to the side.
- 47:23I also just really struggled with you know, the Joker's seen
- 47:27of him being in the construction building because like the
- 47:30coolest thing about The Joker Is that even though he uses other
- 47:33people, you know, minions to accomplish his means he doesn't
- 47:37actually trust any of them and he doesn't include them in the
- 47:41plot to the point of the fact that he kills them, you know,
- 47:44the start of the movie as soon as they outlive their
- 47:46usefulness. Whereas now here at the end of
- 47:48the movie, all of a sudden, the joke Soccer is like, using dogs
- 47:52to protect himself, like the one mobster was doing and he's using
- 47:56a bunch of gangsters that are dressed up like doctors to try
- 47:59and kill the SWAT team. And it just feels like he goes
- 48:03from being this self-sufficient, maniacal brilliant, genius,
- 48:08criminal mastermind to just another ho-hum criminal that you
- 48:12know, can't do his own work by himself.
- 48:14It just felt like a really weird shift for me.
- 48:16Well, I have other reasons that I think that scene feels met,
- 48:19but before I get, There. I want to piggyback off the
- 48:21point you're making because I think this is a sign of how
- 48:24brilliant the script is, you're talking about how the Joker Goes
- 48:27from, being a guy who really only does rely on himself to by
- 48:30the end of the film. Essentially being no different
- 48:33than the Mobsters, he was trying to get rid of.
- 48:35And I think that gets to the fact that a lot of people in
- 48:40this movie are hypocrites, and Nolan doesn't just force feed it
- 48:44to you. He doesn't just call people
- 48:46Hypocrites. What he does is he lets each
- 48:48character in this movie, come I'm out and just say, boldly
- 48:51what their philosophy is and he leaves it up to the viewer to
- 48:55decide whether they're full of it or not.
- 48:57And the way we do that is by seeing whether or not they stick
- 49:00to what they say, they believe in.
- 49:02And I think back to the beginning of the movie, where
- 49:04Bruce Wayne sits at a dinner table with Harvey Dent and Dent
- 49:09starts talking about how, you know, he loves democracy, and he
- 49:12loves Doling out justice. But then he also says, I really
- 49:15like how in ancient Rome when the city was under attack they
- 49:19would Democracy. And just a point, one person to
- 49:23be the Crusader for everybody. And what that tells you is that
- 49:27Harvey Dent isn't necessarily the White Knight that we think
- 49:30he is because he's willing to break the rules.
- 49:33Even at this stage where he's still a good guy and I think for
- 49:36me that planted Little Seeds of doubt in my mind about where
- 49:40Harvey's character was going to go and you see that come to
- 49:43fruition when, you know, something goes wrong in his life
- 49:46and he completely snaps because he's not a man that really
- 49:48sticks to his principles. And I think you see the same
- 49:51thing with the Joker and the only person in the film that
- 49:54really stays consistent in what they believe and what they will,
- 49:57and will not do is Batman. And I think that's that's the
- 50:01sort of wonderful like interplay that we get is that Gotham wants
- 50:05the White Knight of Harvey Dent and at the end of the film, they
- 50:08decide that has to be the image that they project because
- 50:11Gotham's not ready for Batman yet.
- 50:13But the irony is Batman, is more of a white knight than Harvey
- 50:17Dent will ever be. So I think, And I'm saying this
- 50:21slightly facetiously but like you're missing out on the true
- 50:25White Knight of Gotham who is Alfred the butler.
- 50:29Like, when you really think about it, Michael Caine sticks,
- 50:32to his guns and his principles, throughout the movie, even when
- 50:36it seems like, Batman might compromise on his even though he
- 50:39doesn't in the end. Yeah, I think you're right, he
- 50:41definitely is the support system for Batman.
- 50:44And I think it's funny because Batman for being a guy that, you
- 50:48know, doesn't kill people. He Definitely seems to kill
- 50:51like, at least five people in this movie and he so easily.
- 50:54He throws at least eleven dogs off of a skyscraper throughout.
- 50:57That wasn't easy to those poor dogs, you know, he's throwing
- 51:01them down the the car ramp at the start of the movie and down
- 51:05a not built yet. Elevator Shaft at the end of the
- 51:08movie like those poor Rottweilers.
- 51:10What did they ever do to? Well, they did bite him.
- 51:12Yeah. And for me, the thing that
- 51:14really dragged that whole sequence down, was this really
- 51:18random subplot about surveillance?
- 51:20It's and using Sonar to, you know, to find the Joker.
- 51:25Yeah, that was a really weird thing that like it makes sense
- 51:28because in the end like I guess maybe they were trying for this
- 51:32thing where they're like, hey bats have sonar we should give
- 51:36Batman sonar but like looking back on it that has not aged
- 51:41well. So what I think, I mean
- 51:43obviously what was going on in America that time was the
- 51:46Patriot Act was still in full effect and they're making a
- 51:48commentary on that and I don't so much.
- 51:50CH mine that they did that but it's so underdeveloped.
- 51:53It just seems like all of a sudden Batman has this obsessive
- 51:56need to find the Joker that wasn't really established at any
- 51:59point prior and he just really quickly.
- 52:03And on the Fly gets access to everyone's phones in Gotham and
- 52:06makes this like Doomsday Machine.
- 52:08And so there's this really weird ethics plot about is this
- 52:12ethical for us to do this. But for me, what really screws
- 52:15the whole thing up is that it's built into Batman suit and at
- 52:19some Wait, when Batman goes into that building to try to find the
- 52:23Joker, you know, Lucius Fox turns on this sonar and then
- 52:27everything we see is this weird blue Jump by.
- 52:29Looks like he's in The Matrix almost and it really pulled me
- 52:33out of the movie because I couldn't understand what was
- 52:36going on. You didn't really get a good
- 52:37sense of the geography of the building and it just was
- 52:41disorienting and it really screwed up.
- 52:43What should have been a pretty suspenseful fight scene?
- 52:46Yeah, it just felt really poorly done like that.
- 52:49Kind of Feels like one of those things that might have gotten
- 52:52thrown in last minute, or it's one of those things where in
- 52:55Christopher Nolan's head, it looked really cool and he forced
- 52:58it into the movie even though how it actually turned out was
- 53:02not that great. So, another small and this is a
- 53:05much smaller nitpick than the, you know, the fairy scene and
- 53:08that final sonar weirdness. But like, did you think it was
- 53:12weird at all that they really played up the terrorism theme
- 53:17when like Batman is like standing on the As if he was a
- 53:21firefighter on 9/11 standing on the girder, you know, of the
- 53:25world, the rubble of the World Trade Center, that's really
- 53:28interesting. I don't think that I interpreted
- 53:30that so much as like this patriotic, Nolan is a British
- 53:33guy, right? I mean, he may be an American
- 53:35citizen at this point, but I didn't take that so much as
- 53:38like, a rah-rah America thing. I do think he was trying to like
- 53:41evoke images of 9/11 and I do think that might be a little bit
- 53:47irresponsible because, like, then, what is Man you know, like
- 53:51what role is Batman playing in this metaphor that you're trying
- 53:54to design about 9/11 but yeah, I think you're right.
- 53:57It's a really weird sort of out of place shot in the movie.
- 54:00And it probably would have been better without it.
- 54:03Yeah, I think what I'm realizing as I've watched this movie, this
- 54:06is probably my sixth or seventh watch of this movie, and I'm
- 54:10starting to realize that a solid 80 to 85 percent of this movie,
- 54:16is a 10/10, like, it hits on so many different levels.
- 54:20It induces fear and anxiety, and you don't know what the Joker's
- 54:24going to do at any given moment, but there's some stuff in the
- 54:28movie that the movie could just honestly do without.
- 54:30And I really think that, you know, this movie has a two hour
- 54:34and 32 minute run time. I really think that if you cut
- 54:38out about 15 minutes of this movie, and you finished at like
- 54:41to 1:45 20, this movie could be pretty much a perfect movie.
- 54:48But unfortunately, I think, I think that Christopher Nolan
- 54:52starts grabbing it too many plot straws if you will and you see
- 54:58the seeds of the bad movie, that will come out as The Dark Knight
- 55:03Rises. So here's the thing Brad and it
- 55:06kind of segues us into our final analysis and our final thoughts
- 55:09on the movie, there are parts of this movie that hold up.
- 55:13So, well, I mean, it's only been 11 years since the movie came
- 55:15out. So it's not like it's super
- 55:17outdated, but I think when this film came out, It was so
- 55:20revolutionary. It was so unlike anything that
- 55:23we'd seen that, no one was willing or able to find fault
- 55:27with it. And now I go back and I think
- 55:29like there's two or three really great action sequences in this
- 55:32movie. I think the underground chase
- 55:34scene is just spectacular but then, like we said, there's the
- 55:38climactic action sequence in the building and its really,
- 55:42terribly done, if we're being honest.
- 55:44And so, I'm really struggling with how to evaluate this movie
- 55:48because I do think it's a Great movie.
- 55:51But I also wonder sometimes like when I've seen a movie as many
- 55:55times as I've seen The Dark Knight and I love a movie as
- 55:57much as I love The Dark Knight. Am I just trying to find things
- 56:00to nitpick or is this actually a movie that has a few more flaws
- 56:04than we just wanted to admit ten years ago?
- 56:07Yeah, I don't think it's a bad thing at all to recognize that
- 56:11there's some faults. In this movie, there's some fat
- 56:13on the movie that needs to be trimmed off.
- 56:15And it's interesting because, you know, when I watch the
- 56:18original Batman of this, Gee Batman Begins, that movie is
- 56:22extremely tightly wound. It moves quickly from scene to
- 56:27scene, and you don't have all these extraneous, you know, plot
- 56:31lines that you need to follow. And so, unfortunately, I think
- 56:35you see how this movie leads you to the Dark Knight Rises where
- 56:38there's just so much going on, that it ends up being a pretty
- 56:42bad movie because of everything that's happening.
- 56:45And so while I definitely like the Dark Knight, more than
- 56:48Batman Begins, and I think the Dark Knight Is a better movie
- 56:51than Batman Begins? I think the Batman Begins had
- 56:53some elements that probably should have stayed in the second
- 56:56movie. Yeah.
- 56:58I definitely still prefer this one to the dark, or to Batman
- 57:01Begins. Just because this one has more
- 57:03to say, and I feel like, Batman Begins is just a pretty standard
- 57:05like origin story. One of the things I've also
- 57:08found myself really struggling. With this time around is, how
- 57:12much am I holding the Dark Knight responsible for all of
- 57:16the crappy? Quote-unquote, dark movies that
- 57:18came out after it. Because it was so influential,
- 57:22and I felt like, movie studios really misread what the public
- 57:26loved about this movie, and they just thought they needed to make
- 57:28everything gritty and dark. And for a long time, now we've
- 57:32been stuck in this rut of like the gritty dark superhero movie
- 57:37and even the MCU movies that are kind of lighter, fare, you know.
- 57:41I actually just watched another DC movie the other day.
- 57:44I watched Shazam. And that movie was kind of a
- 57:46mess because part of it, was this really happy go.
- 57:49Lucky, Why you know, story about a 13 year old who becomes a
- 57:53superhero? And then the other part of it
- 57:54was like about these demons that would eat people's heads off.
- 57:57And it was just weird. It was this weird jumble of
- 58:00like, does everything have to be dark now and, you know, I don't
- 58:05think we should blame the dark night for that, but at the end
- 58:08of the day, if it wasn't for this movie being so successful.
- 58:11I don't think we'd have all these crappy.
- 58:13Rip offs that we have either. Well, yeah, and even on top of
- 58:16that, not only like bad, not very Rip offs, but even certain
- 58:22things in media have been ripped off that are done really.
- 58:25Well maybe would have been better if they weren't direct
- 58:28ripoffs of, you know, the Dark Knight.
- 58:30And what I'm thinking of is the TV shows Sherlock.
- 58:33And Bob, you are the one who first pointed this out to me
- 58:35that, you know, the character of Moriarty in Sherlock is in a lot
- 58:41of thematic ways. A pretty clothes, rip off of the
- 58:45Joker, you know, performed by Heath Ledger.
- 58:48And so I look at that and I go was His performance was
- 58:51Moriarty. Amazing.
- 58:52Yes was Sherlock. One of the best TV shows I've
- 58:54ever watched. Yes, was it dark and gritty and
- 58:57real? Yes.
- 58:59But could, they have gone a different Direction with their
- 59:01main big villain? Moriarty than to make him this
- 59:04Anarchist, psychotic criminal mastermind.
- 59:08They probably could have and it might have been better off
- 59:10because of it. Yeah, I think that's a really
- 59:12good point. I didn't even think about how
- 59:13the Dark Knight may have influenced that TV show, but you
- 59:16can see the footprints are are the Fingerprints of this movie
- 59:19everywhere? And I mean it even in a
- 59:22roundabout way changed the course of Oscar history.
- 59:25This movie won two Oscars for Heath Ledger as best supporting
- 59:29actor and it won for best sound editing, but it was nominated
- 59:33for six more. But they were all in, what we
- 59:36would call the technical categories.
- 59:37It was, you know, cinematography sound mixing, things like that
- 59:41visual effects, and it was pretty conspicuously not
- 59:45nominated for best picture. Now it was super highly regarded
- 59:48by critics. It was obviously loved by
- 59:50audiences. It was the highest grossing
- 59:52movie of 2008. The next closest movie was Iron
- 59:55Man and it made like 200 million dollars less.
- 59:58This was a runaway smash that changed the course of Cinema
- 1:00:01history and yet it didn't get nominated for best picture and
- 1:00:05what the academy did as a result instead of nominating a movie.
- 1:00:10Every once in a while that is a cultural Touchstone.
- 1:00:13What they decided was know. What we need to do is just
- 1:00:16nominate more movies every year and so their response to the
- 1:00:19Dark Knight. Being snubbed was to then,
- 1:00:22expand the field of Best Picture nominees from 5 to 10.
- 1:00:26But what they've ended up doing is basically, they still don't
- 1:00:29nominate the movies. People go to see, they just
- 1:00:31nominate five more movies. That no one has ever heard of.
- 1:00:33And I think that's, that's part of the problem with how the
- 1:00:37academy has responded to The Dark Knight is they, you know,
- 1:00:40in theory? Yes.
- 1:00:41You can put more quote, unquote, popcorn movies on that list.
- 1:00:45Now of Best Picture nominees, but there's only been one
- 1:00:48superhero movie. That's got Mated and that was
- 1:00:50Black Panther and so I don't think they've solved the
- 1:00:53problem, but it is really interesting to see how the
- 1:00:56backlash from The Dark Knight has changed things even up to
- 1:00:59the level of the Oscars. But yeah, it is interesting to
- 1:01:02look back and see how a movie like The Dark Knight can change
- 1:01:07the way that the academy does things, even if it doesn't
- 1:01:11actually change the end results of what the academy choose rice.
- 1:01:15We all know it was the best film of 2008.
- 1:01:18Well, what did, when best picture that?
- 1:01:20Year, that was the year. I believe that Slumdog
- 1:01:23Millionaire won best picture. Oh, I mean, that was a pretty
- 1:01:26good movie. That's a good movie.
- 1:01:28You know, whatever. I'd still think it should be the
- 1:01:30Dark Knight. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:31I mean, I don't think Slumdog Millionaire deserves the best
- 1:01:35picture over Dark Knight, but whatever.
- 1:01:37Well, Brad, I think we've said about everything there is to say
- 1:01:39about this movie. You know, it's been such a huge
- 1:01:42part of our lives and I'm anxious to see what your score
- 1:01:46would be for this film. And would you recommend it?
- 1:01:48This is an extremely hard, right?
- 1:01:50Thing for me, because in a lot of different ways, I think that
- 1:01:53this movie deserves a 10/10 even with the flaws that we talked
- 1:01:58about and the struggles that I have with it, I just, I don't
- 1:02:02know, but I also want to give it a nine and a half because of all
- 1:02:04the flaws that we talked about how to Bob.
- 1:02:08This is tough. I this is a really hard.
- 1:02:11This might be one of the hardest scores I've had to give out.
- 1:02:13Well, can I jump in then? Yeah, go right ahead.
- 1:02:16I'm in the exact same place you are.
- 1:02:18And, you know, I feel like every time That I come down on the
- 1:02:21more critical side when I'm debating between two scores.
- 1:02:26I feel like a snob you know and I think that if you had asked me
- 1:02:29when I was 18, like is this a 10 out of 10?
- 1:02:31I would have no. Hesitation said yes, right?
- 1:02:34I do think with, you know, a decade plus of distance between
- 1:02:37me and the time this movie came out that there are elements of
- 1:02:41this movie that could be better. And there are elements of this
- 1:02:43movie that I think even other superhero movies have taken and
- 1:02:47improved on. So it's not a perfect film.
- 1:02:50Umm, and at the end of the day, I think I am going to give this
- 1:02:53movie a nine and a half and I'm okay with that because it's one
- 1:02:57of the most famous, most popular, most beloved movies
- 1:02:59ever, made me, giving it a 9 and a half is not going to really
- 1:03:02change anyone's opinion on it, or make it less watched.
- 1:03:06We all know and we all love the dark night and I think giving it
- 1:03:09a 9.5 or like a 95. Out of 100 is not taking
- 1:03:13anything away from it. It's still a phenomenal movie.
- 1:03:17It deserves to be seen and watched and reviewed and Apart
- 1:03:20forever. Yeah, this and this is one of
- 1:03:22those situations where like we are limited by the constraints
- 1:03:25that we put on ourselves, but I would imagine that if we did a
- 1:03:29full, you know, 100 scale. You might give this like a 97 or
- 1:03:3298 out of 100. Sure.
- 1:03:34But we are limited by the constraints we've made for
- 1:03:37ourselves. So we go by .5 increments and
- 1:03:40I'm going to give this movie a 10 out of 10, all right?
- 1:03:43Yeah. I I just I keep coming back to
- 1:03:46it and I just keep thinking to myself, man, this movie He has
- 1:03:50too many good things for the few bad things to keep me from
- 1:03:54saying this is a, this is a 10/10.
- 1:03:57It's a truly great movie and Brad, I'm glad you gave it a 10
- 1:03:59because I think you're right, you balanced it out to the point
- 1:04:02where I think we'd both be comfortable seeing this movie at
- 1:04:05a 97 and a half. Yes.
- 1:04:10Because he's the hero Gotham deserves but not the one it
- 1:04:14needs right now, so we'll hunt him.
- 1:04:21Because he can take it. Because he's not a hero.
- 1:04:33He's a silent guardian and watchful protector.
- 1:04:45Well, there you have it, folks. We both recommend.
- 1:04:47We both give it incredibly high scores.
- 1:04:49If you haven't seen the Dark Knight.
- 1:04:50First of all, where have you been living under a rock?
- 1:04:52For the last 10 years? Yeah.
- 1:04:54Are you one of those reviewers that wasn't wrote one of those
- 1:04:56stupid reviews? Not enough.
- 1:04:58Nudity one out of ten or you could give us a call on our call
- 1:05:02in line. Leave us a voicemail we'd love
- 1:05:04to play it interact with it on air.
- 1:05:05Our number is two one, six eight hundred five nine, two, three
- 1:05:10once again, that number is two one six eight hundred five nine
- 1:05:14two three. We want you guys to tune in this
- 1:05:16Thursday, we have a special bonus episode with Josh Larson,
- 1:05:21host of the insanely popular podcast film spotting.
- 1:05:25He's going to be joining us to talk about his book movies, our
- 1:05:27prayers and we have a whole list of questions to ask him as well.
- 1:05:31Brad. I'm so excited to do this
- 1:05:32interview. Yeah, this interview is going to
- 1:05:34be fantastic. Josh is such an amazing guy and
- 1:05:38we're so excited to bring him to film and whiskey Nation.
- 1:05:42Next Monday, we'll be back with another regular episode.
- 1:05:44It's going to Halloween special. We're bringing in our regular
- 1:05:47guest host, gentle hours. And we're going to be looking at
- 1:05:50Ridley, Scott's 1979, classic alien for the film and whiskey
- 1:05:56podcast. I'm Bob book, I am Brad.
- 1:05:58She will see you next time.