Latest / Bloomberg Law / Anti-Woke Ban Struck, Musk Sues & $6 Billion Legal Fee
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: We fight the woke and the legislatures. We fight the
- 0:13Speaker 2: woke and the schools. We fight the woke and the corporations.
- 0:17Speaker 2: We refuse to surrender to the woke mob. This state
- 0:21Speaker 2: is where woke goes to die.
- 0:25Speaker 3: Or maybe not, despite what Governor Ron DeSantis says over
- 0:29Speaker 3: and over, actually the courts in Florida are where his
- 0:33Speaker 3: anti woke laws go to die. Many of his most
- 0:37Speaker 3: controversial laws and his declared war on woke have faced
- 0:41Speaker 3: legal roadblocks. The latest is his ban on so called
- 0:45Speaker 3: woke company training, which restricts how private employers can train
- 0:50Speaker 3: their workers. The conservative Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously
- 0:55Speaker 3: blocked that ban as unconstitutional for committing quote, the greatest
- 1:01Speaker 3: First Amendment sin penalizing speech based on viewpoints. Joining me
- 1:06Speaker 3: is First Amendment Law expert Eugene Wollick, a professor at
- 1:09Speaker 3: UCLA Law School, Eugene, can you tell us what this
- 1:13Speaker 3: particular anti woke law is about?
- 1:16Speaker 1: Sure?
- 1:17Speaker 4: So, this case involves a particular portion of the Florida
- 1:20Speaker 4: law that's called sometimes the Stop Woke Act. Doesn't deal
- 1:24Speaker 4: with other portions having to do, for example, with colleges
- 1:27Speaker 4: and universities and the like, has to do with its
- 1:30Speaker 4: restriction on employers, including private employers, and that restriction prohibits
- 1:36Speaker 4: employers from subjecting people as condition of employment to training
- 1:40Speaker 4: instruction or other such activities required activities that, among other things,
- 1:45Speaker 4: promote a certain set of beliefs. And those beliefs include
- 1:49Speaker 4: things like members of one race, color, sex, or national
- 1:51Speaker 4: origin are morally superior to others, or a person, by
- 1:56Speaker 4: virtue of his race or national origin is inherently racist, sexist,
- 2:00Speaker 4: or oppressive, or that a person's moral character or status
- 2:03Speaker 4: is privileged or oppressed is necessarily determined by race, color, sex,
- 2:07Speaker 4: and the like. So there's certain particular viewpoints that private
- 2:12Speaker 4: employers are not allowed to include or to teach as
- 2:16Speaker 4: part of compelled instruction for their employees.
- 2:18Speaker 3: What I'm conviused about, I mean, is there any private
- 2:21Speaker 3: employer teaching that one race is superior to the other
- 2:25Speaker 3: or any of the other things.
- 2:27Speaker 4: I'm not sure about the superior, but my understanding, and
- 2:30Speaker 4: I don't know the exact details, but my understanding is
- 2:32Speaker 4: that some suppose a diversity, equity and inclusion instruction does
- 2:36Speaker 4: talk about how well you know white people are privileged
- 2:39Speaker 4: whereas non whites or especially blacks are oppressed, or that
- 2:44Speaker 4: whites are inherently racist and that whites should be viewed
- 2:47Speaker 4: as oppressors. There are other things the law also includes,
- 2:51Speaker 4: like that members of particular group cannot and should not
- 2:54Speaker 4: attempt to treat others without respect to race, color, sex,
- 2:58Speaker 4: or national origin. I understanding is that some forms of
- 3:01Speaker 4: instruction do indeed say, look, it's impossible for us to
- 3:05Speaker 4: be colorblind, either in general, or it's impossible for white
- 3:08Speaker 4: to be colorblind. Another item that's covered by the law
- 3:11Speaker 4: is that they can't teach that a person there's responsibility
- 3:14Speaker 4: for or should be discriminated against because of actions committed
- 3:17Speaker 4: in the past by other members of the same race,
- 3:19Speaker 4: that's national origin and the like. Well there too, I
- 3:22Speaker 4: think some trainings do suggest that a race based affirmative
- 3:26Speaker 4: action is justified because whites in the past have oppressed blacks,
- 3:29Speaker 4: let's say, and therefore there needs to be a compensatory
- 3:33Speaker 4: preferential treatment and discrimination. Now, because of that.
- 3:36Speaker 3: The opponents of the law suit over its effects on
- 3:39Speaker 3: free speech, so basically just saying it was a free
- 3:41Speaker 3: speech violation.
- 3:43Speaker 4: Yes, that's right, And in particular, they said, look, this
- 3:45Speaker 4: law is viewpoint based. It doesn't just, for example, prohibit
- 3:50Speaker 4: employers from having mandatory education sessions that talk about politics
- 3:55Speaker 4: of any sort. Rather, it singles out particular viewpoints as
- 4:00Speaker 4: being prohibited in these kinds of education programs. And the
- 4:03Speaker 4: court says that viewpoint discrimination is the hardest to justify,
- 4:08Speaker 4: most likely unconstitutional form of speech restriction, and that the
- 4:13Speaker 4: law indeed unconstitutionally discriminated based on viewpoint and the Eleventh
- 4:17Speaker 4: Circuit panel agreed.
- 4:19Speaker 3: Florida argued that it was regulating employer's conduct, not speech,
- 4:24Speaker 3: and the court said, we reject this latest attempt to
- 4:27Speaker 3: control speech by recharacterizing it as conduct. Does that happen
- 4:31Speaker 3: often as a defense in these cases saying it's conduct?
- 4:34Speaker 4: Yeah, I think the government often tries to do this sometimes.
- 4:38Speaker 4: For example, laws that ban sexual orientation change therapy for
- 4:43Speaker 4: children have been justified as bans on conduct, even when
- 4:47Speaker 4: the therapy involved only basically speaking to the person role
- 4:51Speaker 4: in administering drugs and the like. Likewise, some other laws
- 4:55Speaker 4: that ban supposes cyber stalking, but cyberstalking in the form
- 4:59Speaker 4: of unwanted speech about a person. There sometimes are the
- 5:02Speaker 4: laws or injunctions that say, look, stop talking about this
- 5:05Speaker 4: person have been justified as restrictions on conduct. But the
- 5:09Speaker 4: court here says that that's not going to fly because
- 5:12Speaker 4: the only conduct here is conveying certain viewpoints. If, for example,
- 5:17Speaker 4: the law said well you can or require people to
- 5:20Speaker 4: be at work before eight am, let's say, well, okay,
- 5:23Speaker 4: that would not be a speech restriction. I would be
- 5:24Speaker 4: a conduct restriction. Various kinds of laws regulating the employment
- 5:28Speaker 4: relationship are conduct restrictions. But with the law says, look,
- 5:31Speaker 4: these are particular ideas, particular opinions. You cannot teach people. Well,
- 5:37Speaker 4: that's all about the speech, all about what the employer
- 5:41Speaker 4: is communicating, and therefort's a speech restriction.
- 5:44Speaker 3: Did anything in particular in the opinions stand.
- 5:47Speaker 4: Out to you, Well, I think it was a pretty
- 5:49Speaker 4: forceful repudiation of this kind of viewpoint discriminations. I will
- 5:54Speaker 4: say there was one thing in particular that might be
- 5:56Speaker 4: relevant also for future cases. One thing that Florida said
- 5:59Speaker 4: in the same of the lawyer said, look, there are
- 6:01Speaker 4: all all of these rulings about hostile work environments, supposed
- 6:05Speaker 4: racial harassment, where employers can be hell liable for racially
- 6:10Speaker 4: offensive or sexually or religiously offensive speech, even by their employee,
- 6:15Speaker 4: and especially by the employer itself. So there have been lawsuits,
- 6:19Speaker 4: for example, over people playing offensive and supposedly misogynistic perhaps
- 6:24Speaker 4: even actually misagionistic rap lyrics, or claims that it was
- 6:28Speaker 4: a racial harassment for people to say things that are
- 6:31Speaker 4: potentially racist, even if they're kind of political expression. So
- 6:35Speaker 4: Florida's argument was, look, it's established that it's okay to
- 6:38Speaker 4: restrict that kind of speech. Well, we want a restrict
- 6:41Speaker 4: speech that may create a racially hostile environment through these
- 6:45Speaker 4: forms of mandatory training. And the court said, well, you know,
- 6:49Speaker 4: Title seven is different as a part of this broader
- 6:52Speaker 4: as a discrimination law. But beyond that, even Title seven,
- 6:56Speaker 4: even these can racial harassment and sexual harassment principle, there
- 7:00Speaker 4: are valid concerns about how they collide with the First Amendment,
- 7:04Speaker 4: and that courts therefore must exercise special caution when applying
- 7:08Speaker 4: Title seven. The matter is involving traditionally protected areas of speech.
- 7:12Speaker 4: So I do think that might be helpful for the
- 7:14Speaker 4: future when it's sort of anti woke or non woke
- 7:17Speaker 4: each that leads to a lawsuit, This may well be
- 7:19Speaker 4: cited to say that, well, you know that is protected
- 7:21Speaker 4: by the First Amendment, then the government can impose liability
- 7:24Speaker 4: for so did.
- 7:25Speaker 3: They use a strict scrutiny standard?
- 7:28Speaker 4: Right, So, the court said, look, this is content discrimination,
- 7:30Speaker 4: but even worse, it's a viewpoint discrimination. Viewpoint discrimination is
- 7:35Speaker 4: generally unconstitutional. You know, maybe it might be constitutional if
- 7:40Speaker 4: it passes this exacting standard of strict scrutiny. But it
- 7:44Speaker 4: is rare that a regulation restriction in speech, even because
- 7:47Speaker 4: of its content, much less that it's viewpoint, will ever
- 7:49Speaker 4: be permissible. The Court was saying, and the courts that
- 7:52Speaker 4: in this case, you know, it doesn't pass strict scrutiny.
- 7:54Speaker 4: There's no compelling government interest in suppressing this kind of speech.
- 7:58Speaker 3: The Press secretary for Dissand has said they're reviewing all
- 8:02Speaker 3: options for a potential appeal. One of those options would
- 8:05Speaker 3: be the Supreme Court. Do you think the Supreme Court
- 8:07Speaker 3: would want to weigh in on a case like this.
- 8:10Speaker 4: You know, it's possible. Supreme Court does take a considerable
- 8:13Speaker 4: number First Amend cases because it thinks that First Amendment
- 8:17Speaker 4: rules are particularly important. I think it's pretty unlikely, just
- 8:21Speaker 4: because even in cases where a state challenges finding that
- 8:25Speaker 4: a law is unconstitutional. The Court usually prefers to wait
- 8:29Speaker 4: until there's a split of authority in lower courts. Circuit
- 8:32Speaker 4: split or say the Eleventh Circuit strikes down some law
- 8:35Speaker 4: and say the Eighth Circuit upholds a similar law where
- 8:38Speaker 4: it uses some legal analysis as inconsistent with the Eleventh
- 8:41Speaker 4: Circuit's decision. That's sort of a signal to the court
- 8:44Speaker 4: there is an important issue. It's likely to recur lower
- 8:47Speaker 4: courts are in disagreement, usually when there's kind of a
- 8:50Speaker 4: one off state law in which there aren't really a
- 8:53Speaker 4: lot of others like it and certainly no appellate decisions
- 8:56Speaker 4: dealing with it. When that gets struck down, that doesn't
- 9:00Speaker 4: lead the Supreme Court review, but it's possible.
- 9:03Speaker 3: So now, why is the state appealing the injunction of
- 9:07Speaker 3: the university restrictions separately?
- 9:10Speaker 4: Well, like many statutes, this is again what's colloquially called
- 9:15Speaker 4: the stoppuokak involved several very different kinds of restrictions. They
- 9:19Speaker 4: have a common theme, but just that they're in the
- 9:21Speaker 4: same statue, it doesn't mean they really can effectively be challenged,
- 9:24Speaker 4: even in the same lawsuits. So this lawsuit, for example,
- 9:28Speaker 4: was brought by an employer which said, look, you're restricting
- 9:31Speaker 4: our speech, but the employer doesn't have standing to challenge
- 9:35Speaker 4: the restriction on public university professor's speech. Conversely, the public
- 9:40Speaker 4: university professors are challenging the university portion of the law,
- 9:44Speaker 4: but they don't have standing to challenge the law that
- 9:47Speaker 4: lies to private employer's mandatory education. The important point is
- 9:51Speaker 4: this is a law that has several provisions in it.
- 9:54Speaker 4: The provisions are savable from each other in the sense
- 9:57Speaker 4: that they could be struck down or upheld individual. A
- 10:00Speaker 4: particular lawsuit is brought by people, usually who are affected
- 10:04Speaker 4: by one provision or another, and the judge in that
- 10:06Speaker 4: case can only deal with the particular provisions that are
- 10:10Speaker 4: being challenged there.
- 10:11Speaker 3: I mean, how big a victory is this for free
- 10:13Speaker 3: speech coming from a conservative appellate court. Noteworthy?
- 10:17Speaker 4: Yeah, it is noteworthy because it's a reminder that First
- 10:20Speaker 4: Amendment provides very strong protection against viewpoint discrimination by the government,
- 10:25Speaker 4: and that applies again whether it's discrimination against woke viewpoints
- 10:29Speaker 4: or against anti woke viewpoints. That generally speaking, the government
- 10:33Speaker 4: cannot restrict speech it staate on viewpoints, even when the
- 10:36Speaker 4: viewpoints have to do it with highly controversialised matters such
- 10:39Speaker 4: as race and sex and national origin, and even when
- 10:42Speaker 4: the viewpoints are offensive to many.
- 10:44Speaker 3: Thanks so much for your insights, Eugene. As always, that's
- 10:47Speaker 3: Professor Eugene Volik of UCLA Law School. Coming up next
- 10:51Speaker 3: on the Bloomberg Law Show, the lawyers who sued over
- 10:55Speaker 3: Elon Musk's excessive fifty six billion dollar pay pack now
- 11:01Speaker 3: want six billion dollars in Tesla stock as legal fees,
- 11:05Speaker 3: and later in the show, Elon Musk sues Open Ai
- 11:10Speaker 3: and it fights back with some of his own emails.
- 11:13Speaker 3: Remember you can always get the latest in legal news
- 11:16Speaker 3: by listening to our Bloomberg Lawn podcasts. You can find
- 11:19Speaker 3: them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at Bloomberg dot com,
- 11:23Speaker 3: Slash podcast, Slash Law and attorneys looking for legal research
- 11:28Speaker 3: whether you're an in house counsel or in private practice,
- 11:31Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law gives you the edge with the latest in
- 11:34Speaker 3: AI powered legal analytics, business insights, and workflow tools. With
- 11:40Speaker 3: guidance from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in
- 11:43Speaker 3: the legal industry, helping you achieve better results for the
- 11:46Speaker 3: practice of law, the business of law, the Future of law.
- 11:50Speaker 3: Visit Bloomberg Law dot Com. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 11:53Speaker 3: listening to Bloomberg six billion dollars in legal fees? That
- 12:00Speaker 3: how much the lawyers who argued that Elon Musk's fifty
- 12:03Speaker 3: six billion dollar pay package was excessive are asking for
- 12:07Speaker 3: their efforts. Oh, and they'll take those fees in Tesla stock. Please.
- 12:12Speaker 3: Even more astounding that unprecedented six billion dollar fee may
- 12:17Speaker 3: be allowable under Delaware law. Joining me is business law
- 12:21Speaker 3: expert Eric Talley, a professor at Columbia Law School. Six
- 12:25Speaker 3: billion dollars in legal fees. That would be an hourly
- 12:29Speaker 3: rate of two hundred eighty eight thousand, eight hundred eighty
- 12:33Speaker 3: eight dollars. I mean, where are they getting that from?
- 12:38Speaker 1: Well, once again, June, you and I have chosen the
- 12:40Speaker 1: wrong professions peers. But so here's it too late? I
- 12:44Speaker 1: don't know, It's never too late. One can always dream.
- 12:46Speaker 1: But here's where they're getting from. First of all, realized
- 12:49Speaker 1: that the outcome of the case was phenomenally large as well, right,
- 12:54Speaker 1: fifty six billion dollars, you know, in terms of compensation
- 12:58Speaker 1: package that is essentially then being clawed back. And so
- 13:02Speaker 1: the way that this case gets set up as well
- 13:04Speaker 1: as pretty much all shareholders litigation is that it is
- 13:07Speaker 1: brought on a contingency fee basis, which means that the
- 13:10Speaker 1: lawyers are going to basically self finance the entire action
- 13:14Speaker 1: until they get to the finish line of either a
- 13:16Speaker 1: settlement or in this case, a judgment an outcome, and
- 13:19Speaker 1: only then are they in a position where they can
- 13:22Speaker 1: try to petition the court for an award of attorney spees.
- 13:27Speaker 1: And so essentially you can almost think of the law
- 13:29Speaker 1: firms that bring these actions as almost being like venture
- 13:33Speaker 1: capital funds, right they invest in a bunch of different
- 13:36Speaker 1: projects at different lawsuits. Many of them are going to
- 13:39Speaker 1: be losers, so many of them are going to either
- 13:41Speaker 1: settle for nothing or they'll just have to be dropped,
- 13:45Speaker 1: and then other ones will pay off. So it's kind
- 13:47Speaker 1: of a high risk, high reward thing. And so it
- 13:50Speaker 1: is often the case that when there is one of
- 13:53Speaker 1: these cases that ends up resulting in a substantial judgment
- 13:57Speaker 1: that can be monetized. And this one is one contingency fee.
- 14:01Speaker 1: It looks in hindsight like an outrageous amount of hourly compensation,
- 14:05Speaker 1: but one also has to think about how to set
- 14:08Speaker 1: that off against a bunch of other factors, including risk,
- 14:11Speaker 1: including cost, including effort, including the hard aspects of bringing
- 14:17Speaker 1: a case of this type of complexity. And so when
- 14:20Speaker 1: you sort of back those out, most of the time,
- 14:23Speaker 1: these contingency fees end up looking a little bit smaller
- 14:27Speaker 1: on an hourly up basis because you've essentially had to
- 14:30Speaker 1: control for all the high probabilities that there were going
- 14:33Speaker 1: to be nothing at the end of the rainbow here.
- 14:36Speaker 1: So that's one of the factors that really controls in
- 14:39Speaker 1: any situation where there's a contingency fee award, when it's
- 14:42Speaker 1: not structured as an hourly rate. Pretty much all of
- 14:45Speaker 1: these plaintive shareholder litigation fees are based on some type
- 14:49Speaker 1: of a contingency arrangement.
- 14:51Speaker 3: And how have the Delaware courts been viewing these contingency
- 14:55Speaker 3: fees in stockholder actions Over.
- 14:58Speaker 1: The years, the courts have come up with sort of
- 15:01Speaker 1: a formula for thinking about when and under what circumstances
- 15:06Speaker 1: a contingency fee should be awarded, and how high it
- 15:09Speaker 1: should be, what percentage of the total award should be
- 15:12Speaker 1: paid over to the attorneys, and there the Delaware Courts
- 15:17Speaker 1: of you know, there's a long standing line of cases
- 15:19Speaker 1: and they're actually pretty current. They go back a long time,
- 15:21Speaker 1: but the most recent ones are within the last couple
- 15:23Speaker 1: of years. That basically say, look, there's several factors that
- 15:26Speaker 1: we look at. One of the factors we look at is,
- 15:29Speaker 1: you know, the value that is created for shareholders, and
- 15:33Speaker 1: you know, I guess one lens of this, you can say, well,
- 15:35Speaker 1: this was fifty six billion dollars worth of value that
- 15:37Speaker 1: was created to shareholders because those Tesla shareholders were able
- 15:41Speaker 1: to claw back a fifty six billion dollar stock award
- 15:44Speaker 1: payment that they would have had to share and now
- 15:47Speaker 1: they don't have to share it any A couple of
- 15:48Speaker 1: the other factors that go into it is you know,
- 15:51Speaker 1: how risky was it, how costly was it? What's the
- 15:54Speaker 1: reputation of the firms that are bringing this. Are they
- 15:57Speaker 1: kind of ambulance chaser type firms? Are they sophisticated sort
- 16:00Speaker 1: of firms. The thing that was kind of odd about
- 16:02Speaker 1: the case is that when you went down these factors,
- 16:05Speaker 1: the factors all seemed to point in the plaintiff's direction. Right,
- 16:10Speaker 1: this was a fairly substantial award, it was risky, it
- 16:13Speaker 1: was costly. Burnstein Lidewiz, who has lead counsel on. This
- 16:16Speaker 1: is one of probably the most sophisticated and high reputation
- 16:20Speaker 1: Planet off firms in the country. And so typically what
- 16:24Speaker 1: that would mean is that when you get to the
- 16:26Speaker 1: end of these factors, which the petition for fees went
- 16:29Speaker 1: through them one by one, if you check all the boxes,
- 16:32Speaker 1: make it to the very finish line, then the typical
- 16:36Speaker 1: norm in Delaware is to award something like thirty three percent,
- 16:40Speaker 1: like a third of the award the attorneys. Now that
- 16:43Speaker 1: would have been about that would have been about eighteen
- 16:46Speaker 1: billion dollars, and so I think that the attorneys when
- 16:49Speaker 1: they're drafting this sort of said, Okay, that's just a
- 16:51Speaker 1: big number, and so they kind of make a point
- 16:54Speaker 1: to saying, look, we're going to articulate all these factors.
- 16:56Speaker 1: We're going to say that that under existing law would
- 16:59Speaker 1: entitle us to a third, We're going to take a
- 17:01Speaker 1: third of a third or eleven percent. And that's what
- 17:04Speaker 1: they ended up at their five point eight or five
- 17:06Speaker 1: point nine billion dollar request.
- 17:08Speaker 3: But does it not seem ironic that they argued that
- 17:13Speaker 3: Musk's pay package was excessive and now they want a
- 17:16Speaker 3: chunk of it also excessive.
- 17:19Speaker 1: Yeah, it's kind of an interesting thing. I mean, I
- 17:20Speaker 1: guess you could run this in multiple directions.
- 17:23Speaker 3: Right.
- 17:23Speaker 1: One is to say that paypackage was so excessive that
- 17:28Speaker 1: when we prevailed. This is what the plaintiff attorneys would
- 17:31Speaker 1: argue that when we prevailed on having it nullified, we
- 17:34Speaker 1: created an excessive benefit to shareholders. And we can point
- 17:38Speaker 1: to that benefit, that fifty six billion dollar benefit that
- 17:42Speaker 1: inured to the non Elon Musk shareholders. So had the
- 17:46Speaker 1: pay package not been as exorbitant, then our fee would
- 17:50Speaker 1: not be as large. And we are then once again
- 17:54Speaker 1: doubling back and saying, and guess what, We're going to
- 17:57Speaker 1: take only a third of the fee that under the
- 18:00Speaker 1: sort of a cookie cutter approach we would presumptively be
- 18:03Speaker 1: entitled to. The fact of the matter, though, is you're
- 18:05Speaker 1: right too. And this is a gargantuan award. It's very,
- 18:09Speaker 1: very large. A lot of times you'll see big fights
- 18:11Speaker 1: over attorney spees that are in the hundreds of millions
- 18:13Speaker 1: of dollars, you know, three hundred four hundred million dollars.
- 18:16Speaker 1: Those are the ones that have generated the biggest fights
- 18:19Speaker 1: over whether those fees should go through or whether they
- 18:21Speaker 1: should be shaped down. But one of the big challenges
- 18:24Speaker 1: in this case is that the fifty six billion dollar
- 18:27Speaker 1: award is kind of the denominator against which all this
- 18:30Speaker 1: other stuff is measured, right, and we just haven't seen
- 18:33Speaker 1: a fifty six billion dollar award that has put itself
- 18:37Speaker 1: in this position where we're trying to figure out what's
- 18:38Speaker 1: the value of the attorney speed. And you know, there
- 18:41Speaker 1: are cases recently that have tried to contend with this
- 18:44Speaker 1: question of, you know, as the award gets bigger, should
- 18:46Speaker 1: the percentage go down? And the Delaware courts have generally
- 18:50Speaker 1: resisted that thus far, but that could be a factor
- 18:53Speaker 1: that factors into Chancellor McCormick's assessment of the fee request.
- 18:57Speaker 3: But Elon Musk may not be getting that fifty six
- 19:01Speaker 3: billion dollar pay package, but they have to redo his
- 19:04Speaker 3: pay package, right, so Tesla won't be keeping all of
- 19:08Speaker 3: that fifty six.
- 19:09Speaker 1: Billion Well, that I think really is the fifty six
- 19:12Speaker 1: billion dollar question too. The pay package itself was nullified,
- 19:18Speaker 1: which basically means that mister Musk was working maybe not
- 19:23Speaker 1: quite for free, because remember he owned twenty two percent
- 19:26Speaker 1: of the company, so any you know, ten billion dollar
- 19:28Speaker 1: increase in the value of the company is going to
- 19:31Speaker 1: get him two billion dollars worth of value that he
- 19:33Speaker 1: has already pocketed. But one of the things that I
- 19:36Speaker 1: think is one area where you know, one could sort
- 19:40Speaker 1: of kick this case around and try to think, you know, what,
- 19:42Speaker 1: where are the ways that it might have come out differently.
- 19:44Speaker 1: I think one area that it might have come out
- 19:46Speaker 1: differently is exactly on this point about whether if the
- 19:49Speaker 1: pay package is being nullified, does that mean that he's
- 19:53Speaker 1: entitled to nothing for the services that he provided to
- 19:58Speaker 1: Tesla over these years under the presumption that he was
- 20:02Speaker 1: going to be paid from this executive compensation package. And
- 20:05Speaker 1: so that itself is a type of a claim that
- 20:08Speaker 1: you will often see in cases where a contract gets nullified,
- 20:12Speaker 1: to say, look, if you're not going to let me
- 20:14Speaker 1: collect pursuant to the contract, let me at least make
- 20:17Speaker 1: out a claim of what was the benefit that I
- 20:20Speaker 1: conferred on the other side, and we can come up
- 20:24Speaker 1: with the fair terms. And so that argument, for example,
- 20:27Speaker 1: might end up culminating in finding with the fair value
- 20:30Speaker 1: of what Musk created for Tesla was you know, thirty
- 20:34Speaker 1: billion dollars or something like that, And so that would
- 20:37Speaker 1: then be kind of an offset that you often will
- 20:40Speaker 1: see in contrast cases at the end this case was
- 20:44Speaker 1: a little odd because you know, a lot of the
- 20:46Speaker 1: litigation gets compressed into a short amount of time and
- 20:49Speaker 1: people have to argue about all the different parts of
- 20:51Speaker 1: the case. And so the Tesla attorneys in this case,
- 20:54Speaker 1: mister Musk's attorneys in this case or sort of in
- 20:57Speaker 1: an odd position of sort of saying, hey, listen, pay
- 21:00Speaker 1: packages one hundred percent fair. You know, it was highly incentivized,
- 21:04Speaker 1: but that was exactly what the design was, and look
- 21:06Speaker 1: how well it paid off. It would be hard at
- 21:09Speaker 1: the same time to say, oh, by the way, this
- 21:12Speaker 1: was the fair and the unfair part. Right, It's kind
- 21:14Speaker 1: of hard to argue that the thing was entirely fair,
- 21:17Speaker 1: and at the same time you can distinguish between the
- 21:20Speaker 1: fair part and the unfair part. And so I think
- 21:22Speaker 1: the defense attorneys in this case sort of understandably decided
- 21:26Speaker 1: to make a strategic choice, but not even offering you know,
- 21:29Speaker 1: some alternative valuation that's less than fifty six billion dollars
- 21:34Speaker 1: of what the fair value of mister Musk services was.
- 21:37Speaker 1: But that ended up, you know, creating big problems for
- 21:40Speaker 1: them once liability was done, because there was no alternative
- 21:42Speaker 1: theory about what some sort of an offset should be
- 21:45Speaker 1: for the for the fair value of musk services. So
- 21:48Speaker 1: you know, it's conceivable that the Supreme Court of Delaware,
- 21:52Speaker 1: if this goes up on appeal to the Supreme Court,
- 21:54Speaker 1: which I suspect it will, will say, hey, hey, hey,
- 21:56Speaker 1: I know we want to send this back because we
- 21:58Speaker 1: want to hear a trial on this. It's called restitution, right,
- 22:01Speaker 1: This restitution theory a possibility, and realize that that bears
- 22:06Speaker 1: on these factors. One of the factors is how much
- 22:08Speaker 1: value that you create for stockholders. Well, right now we're
- 22:12Speaker 1: sitting at fifty six billion dollars worth of value that
- 22:14Speaker 1: got created to stockholders. But if say half of that
- 22:17Speaker 1: is going to be carved off an offset because of
- 22:20Speaker 1: a I don't know, a restitutionary claim, then maybe it's
- 22:23Speaker 1: only twenty eight billion dollars that you created for stockholders
- 22:26Speaker 1: or maybe even less. And so we don't really know
- 22:29Speaker 1: the answer that question, or the answer that question as
- 22:31Speaker 1: of now is there is no restitutionary offset and will.
- 22:36Speaker 3: There definitely be a restitutionary process.
- 22:39Speaker 1: This whole idea of sort of saying Okay, we're not
- 22:42Speaker 1: going to enforce the contract, but we'll let you make
- 22:45Speaker 1: a claim for your restitution of whatever benefits you did confer.
- 22:50Speaker 1: That's a highly judgment oriented determination. It is really left
- 22:55Speaker 1: up to the discretion of the judge, and there is
- 22:58Speaker 1: at least historically some precedent out there for judges saying, hey, hey,
- 23:04Speaker 1: I'm willing to let this, you know, go forward and
- 23:07Speaker 1: let you make your arguments about you know, your your
- 23:10Speaker 1: restitutionary interest, but I won't do it if you have
- 23:14Speaker 1: uncleaned hands, if you have been a naughty actor before,
- 23:17Speaker 1: and if you read the front you know, one hundred
- 23:20Speaker 1: and eighty pages of Chancellor McCormick's opinion, you know, one
- 23:23Speaker 1: could read that as saying Elon Musk and the board
- 23:26Speaker 1: members were naughty actors, so I'm not going to afford
- 23:28Speaker 1: them now the chance for a mulligan, essentially to try
- 23:31Speaker 1: to claim what their restitutionary interest is. Now, there are
- 23:34Speaker 1: cases that go both ways, and so, you know, I
- 23:36Speaker 1: think that's a little bit more of an issue of
- 23:39Speaker 1: law that one could imagine the Delaware Supreme Court disagreeing on.
- 23:43Speaker 1: But if that were to happen, if there were some
- 23:46Speaker 1: sort of an offset to the fifty six billion dollars
- 23:48Speaker 1: that's been returned to Tesla stockholders and Musk is able
- 23:51Speaker 1: to claw back some fraction of that in restitution, that's
- 23:54Speaker 1: going to cause the benefit of the stockholders to go
- 23:57Speaker 1: much further down that in principle than would have an
- 24:00Speaker 1: effect on the dollar value of the percentage that the
- 24:03Speaker 1: plaintiff's attorneys are trying to ask for.
- 24:06Speaker 3: It is unusual, is it not? For the legal team
- 24:09Speaker 3: is seeking to be paid by taking part of what
- 24:13Speaker 3: Musk is giving up, so testless stock.
- 24:17Speaker 1: It is definitely an unconventional request. It was not surprising
- 24:21Speaker 1: to me that they made a request of testleas stock
- 24:24Speaker 1: rather than money, in part because that is the very
- 24:28Speaker 1: remedy that they were seeking. You know, they were seeking
- 24:30Speaker 1: the return of stock. And if you then want to
- 24:33Speaker 1: translate that into what is eleven percent of the value
- 24:36Speaker 1: of that, well then you get another set of headaches
- 24:38Speaker 1: about how do you on what date do you value it?
- 24:41Speaker 1: And how do you value some of these you know,
- 24:44Speaker 1: options that haven't been fully vested yet and you know,
- 24:48Speaker 1: maybe underwater or at the money or you know, in
- 24:52Speaker 1: the money and so forth. So that ends up setting
- 24:54Speaker 1: up a huge number of valuation challenges that I think
- 24:58Speaker 1: on some level the plaintiffs said, you know, we don't
- 25:00Speaker 1: have to go there on the valuation challenges. If we
- 25:03Speaker 1: had petitioned for the return of money, then we'd want
- 25:05Speaker 1: eleven percent of the money. Repetition for the return of
- 25:08Speaker 1: a bunch of shares, we want eleven percent of the shares. Now,
- 25:11Speaker 1: on some level that makes sense. I think it might
- 25:13Speaker 1: also make sense from the business positioning right now of Tesla.
- 25:18Speaker 1: It's still very, very valuable company obviously, but you know,
- 25:21Speaker 1: the headwinds in the EV industry are now, you know,
- 25:24Speaker 1: definitely strong, and so you know, having the corporate sort
- 25:28Speaker 1: of till invaded by a cash award that has to
- 25:32Speaker 1: go out to planet's attorneys, that's a little bit harder still.
- 25:35Speaker 1: You know, Tesla could in principle to sell more stock
- 25:38Speaker 1: and pay for it that way. But you know, on
- 25:40Speaker 1: some level, even though it's unconventional, it just didn't surprise
- 25:44Speaker 1: me to see that the request was being made for stock,
- 25:47Speaker 1: which is the very thing that the planets were asking
- 25:50Speaker 1: for the return of, rather than cash. Now, it does
- 25:53Speaker 1: put kind of an interesting twist on what do you
- 25:56Speaker 1: do if you were a plaintiff side firm who just
- 25:59Speaker 1: has received a bunch of stock in a defendant that
- 26:02Speaker 1: you just sued and you're trying to you know, maybe
- 26:05Speaker 1: like build more business in the future, and some of
- 26:07Speaker 1: that business might be now suing that same company for
- 26:10Speaker 1: other things in the future. Well, now you're a big
- 26:13Speaker 1: stockholder of that company, do you really want to win,
- 26:16Speaker 1: because now it's going to hurt you in the pocketbook
- 26:18Speaker 1: with respect to the stock that you own. So my
- 26:20Speaker 1: sense is that even you know, if an award of
- 26:23Speaker 1: stock is approved and is effectively executed on the plane's
- 26:28Speaker 1: attorneys are probably going to be well advised to try
- 26:32Speaker 1: to unwind that position through sort of progressive sales of
- 26:37Speaker 1: those stocks out into the market so they are no
- 26:39Speaker 1: longer basically you know, big stockholders of the company that
- 26:42Speaker 1: they may end up suing again, you know, possibly for
- 26:46Speaker 1: how the company responds to this very judgment.
- 26:49Speaker 3: Stay with me, Eric, Coming up next on the Bloomberg
- 26:52Speaker 3: Law Show, I'll continue this conversation with Columbia Law School
- 26:55Speaker 3: professor Eric Talley, and we're going to be talking about
- 26:58Speaker 3: another lawsuit, this one brought by Musk against open AI.
- 27:03Speaker 3: The lawsuit's kind of iffy, and open AI is fighting
- 27:07Speaker 3: back with some of Musk's own emails. I'm June Grosso
- 27:11Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg, there's some chance that is
- 27:14Speaker 3: above zero that AI will kill us. Well, I think
- 27:16Speaker 3: it's low.
- 27:18Speaker 1: Chance.
- 27:19Speaker 3: What do you what's your first take on this lawsuit?
- 27:22Speaker 3: Elon Musk has always been among the most outspoken about
- 27:26Speaker 3: the dangers of AI, and now he's suing Open Ai
- 27:31Speaker 3: and it's CEO Sam Altman, alleging they violated the Artificial
- 27:35Speaker 3: intelligence startups founding mission by putting profit ahead of benefiting humanity.
- 27:42Speaker 3: I've been talking to Professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School.
- 27:46Speaker 3: Eric Musk is apparently suing for Humanity for breach of contract,
- 27:51Speaker 3: breach of fiduciary duty, and claims of unfair business practices.
- 27:56Speaker 3: What's your first take on this lawsuit?
- 27:59Speaker 1: It's very creepy, creative June. It's a very creative lawsuit,
- 28:03Speaker 1: possibly so creative that it's hard to find law to
- 28:07Speaker 1: back it up. So here's part of the problem. And
- 28:11Speaker 1: you know, I teach contracts as well, and the key
- 28:13Speaker 1: ingredients to a breach of contracts suit is you have
- 28:15Speaker 1: to have a contract with the other side. The other
- 28:17Speaker 1: side then has to have breached the contract, and then
- 28:19Speaker 1: you have to be able to show damage it and
- 28:21Speaker 1: if any of those fail, you don't have a lawsuit.
- 28:24Speaker 1: And there's an argument that maybe all three are very
- 28:28Speaker 1: dodgy here, at least two of the three are very
- 28:31Speaker 1: dodgy here. So the first is like is there a contract? Well,
- 28:35Speaker 1: you know, in the complaint that was filed by mister Musk,
- 28:38Speaker 1: there certainly doesn't seem to be any document that says
- 28:41Speaker 1: here is the investment agreement, and here's the promises that
- 28:44Speaker 1: open ai are making, you know, but the exhibits that
- 28:48Speaker 1: were attached to the agreement that are supposed to, you know,
- 28:51Speaker 1: memorialize the existence of the contract, where like a bunch
- 28:54Speaker 1: of text message or email exchanges that you know, seemed
- 28:58Speaker 1: very preliminary and a little bit flat, dash and informal,
- 29:02Speaker 1: followed by basically a reproduction of the charter of open Ai,
- 29:06Speaker 1: which does have a purpose provision. And you know, there
- 29:10Speaker 1: is a set of interpretations out legal interpretation out there
- 29:13Speaker 1: says the charter of a company is in some ways
- 29:15Speaker 1: like a contract between the stockholders and the company itself.
- 29:20Speaker 1: But that's going to have to carry a heavy load
- 29:22Speaker 1: here because those preliminary email exchanges, that's kind of classic
- 29:27Speaker 1: example of a non contract, right, that kind of preliminary
- 29:31Speaker 1: language just isn't filled out enough to put any specificity
- 29:35Speaker 1: on what the underlying contract if there is one. Looks
- 29:39Speaker 1: like second thing is if there is a contract, who
- 29:42Speaker 1: would enforce that contract? Is this a contract that is,
- 29:45Speaker 1: you know, that is enforceable by one of the people
- 29:48Speaker 1: that basically paid money to a nonprofit, So they weren't
- 29:51Speaker 1: getting like stock stock or anything. Right, non profits don't
- 29:54Speaker 1: have stockholtures. So would it be sort of humanity that
- 29:58Speaker 1: if anyone has a cause of action here, it should
- 30:00Speaker 1: be humanity versus open AI. And Elon Musk is now
- 30:05Speaker 1: sort of appointing himself as a representative of humanity, I guess,
- 30:10Speaker 1: but you know, I think he's got to turn this
- 30:11Speaker 1: into know, this was a contract with me for me
- 30:14Speaker 1: to give you money under the expectation that you weren't
- 30:18Speaker 1: going to go out and I don't know, do profitable
- 30:21Speaker 1: things with it. And so so it's really hard to determine,
- 30:25Speaker 1: even if there is a contract, whether he's not standing too.
- 30:29Speaker 1: If he does, how do we know that open AI
- 30:33Speaker 1: hasn't done stuff for the good of humanity? Right? The
- 30:36Speaker 1: fact of the matter is, yes, when you were out
- 30:39Speaker 1: there as a nonprofit per se, you probably have to
- 30:43Speaker 1: engage in various types of transactions and relationships with other
- 30:48Speaker 1: players who are not nonprofit. That happens all the time, right,
- 30:51Speaker 1: And so if I agree that you invest money in
- 30:54Speaker 1: your nonprofit that's supposed to feed the homeless in Central Park,
- 30:58Speaker 1: I don't really have a complaint when you decide to
- 31:02Speaker 1: buy food from McDonald's, which is a poor profit company,
- 31:06Speaker 1: in order to execute on that. And so there is
- 31:08Speaker 1: a sort of a sense in which it's not even
- 31:11Speaker 1: clear that, you know, dealing with companies like Microsoft is
- 31:14Speaker 1: necessarily inconsistent with what that mission is, because the mission
- 31:19Speaker 1: that's in the charter is actually crafted pretty broadly to
- 31:23Speaker 1: give a lot of discretion on what to do. And
- 31:25Speaker 1: then you know, open Ai has recently posted a blog
- 31:28Speaker 1: post that basically said that Musk himself was kind of
- 31:31Speaker 1: needling them throughout before he departed the company to try
- 31:34Speaker 1: to get them to move in a more monetized direction,
- 31:37Speaker 1: including a potential merger with Tesla that he was pushing.
- 31:40Speaker 1: So there's almost a sense in which his own words
- 31:43Speaker 1: are likely to be used against him as to whether
- 31:46Speaker 1: anyone really understood this to be the type of contractual
- 31:50Speaker 1: obligation to be sort of the mother Teresa of data
- 31:53Speaker 1: that doesn't look like he even believed so long as
- 31:56Speaker 1: you know, there was a chance that Tesla might be
- 31:58Speaker 1: able to acquire Open AI.
- 32:00Speaker 3: So to put it in legal terms, the lawsuit is iffy.
- 32:03Speaker 3: And also, I mean you have the fact that he
- 32:06Speaker 3: has founded his own AI startup x of course he
- 32:11Speaker 3: loves the x XAI, and that's a for profit entity.
- 32:15Speaker 3: I don't know where that fits in just as another irony.
- 32:19Speaker 1: Perhaps, yeah, it probably dusted in as like sort of
- 32:21Speaker 1: additional evidence that mister Musk himself sort of had the
- 32:25Speaker 1: big use case view of generative AI as being part
- 32:29Speaker 1: of a profit generating enterprise that also coincidentally and simultaneously
- 32:35Speaker 1: would be creating benefits for humanity. And those things are
- 32:38Speaker 1: not always inconsistent with one another. But it does sort
- 32:42Speaker 1: of suggest that his mindset throughout this period of time,
- 32:46Speaker 1: including what he's doing now, seems to be very much
- 32:49Speaker 1: a mindset of harnessing these tools for purposes of generating
- 32:55Speaker 1: net revenues. And so to then sort of file this
- 32:58Speaker 1: lawsuit against AI for doing exactly that, it's somewhat reminiscent
- 33:03Speaker 1: of Casablanca character to Captain Renault, who proclaims that he
- 33:07Speaker 1: is shocked, shocked that there's gambling going on in this establishment, right,
- 33:10Speaker 1: It's just seems unlikely to be the case. Now, you know,
- 33:14Speaker 1: if open ai was formed as a nonprofit, so there's
- 33:17Speaker 1: a little bit more grab that to that argument, sort
- 33:20Speaker 1: of say, hey, no, no, I formed x as a
- 33:23Speaker 1: for profit. You formed this as a nonprofit. But does
- 33:25Speaker 1: that mean anything? And so you know, it's not like
- 33:27Speaker 1: there are no arguments, but boy, do you have to
- 33:29Speaker 1: reach deep into the pocket to find the types of
- 33:32Speaker 1: arguments that we conventionally go into a standard contract claim.
- 33:36Speaker 1: And by the way, we haven't even gotten to damages.
- 33:38Speaker 3: Right if oh the damages are crazy.
- 33:41Speaker 1: And who gets them?
- 33:41Speaker 4: Right?
- 33:42Speaker 1: Does humanity get the damages?
- 33:43Speaker 3: Apparently?
- 33:44Speaker 1: You must?
- 33:45Speaker 3: Apparently because open ai has to make its research and
- 33:48Speaker 3: technology open to the public prevent anyone, including Microsoft, which
- 33:53Speaker 3: by the way, has invested billions in open ai, from
- 33:56Speaker 3: benefiting financially from its technology. And also the Altman has
- 34:00Speaker 3: to give up all the money he's earned. But I mean,
- 34:03Speaker 3: this is like drama, drama, drama, that boardroom drama where
- 34:08Speaker 3: the company directors ousted Altman and then he was reinstated.
- 34:13Speaker 1: There is a lot of drama the dramas are not
- 34:15Speaker 1: completely separate, right. A lot of times when you you know,
- 34:17Speaker 1: sort of, you know, thinking about the various things that
- 34:19Speaker 1: Elon Bust does, it's it's kind of like that they
- 34:22Speaker 1: could be completely random, you know, sort of parapatetic things
- 34:25Speaker 1: that he's up to. But these are actually a little
- 34:26Speaker 1: bit more connected because the earlier drama with open Ai
- 34:30Speaker 1: was a little bit about a kind of an existential
- 34:33Speaker 1: crisis on exactly what the weight that the company was
- 34:36Speaker 1: going to place on, you know, doing business with for
- 34:38Speaker 1: profit entities versus essentially just being a big basket of
- 34:43Speaker 1: public goods. And so, you know, on some level, one
- 34:46Speaker 1: can view this lawsuit as kind of a reaction to
- 34:50Speaker 1: the internal reaction in open Ai, when you know, Altman
- 34:54Speaker 1: was kind of unceremoniously shown the door because some board
- 34:57Speaker 1: members sort of thought that the company had gone to
- 35:00Speaker 1: far in the direction of commercialization. But then so much
- 35:03Speaker 1: employee unrest and unrest generally ensued that you know, caused
- 35:07Speaker 1: him to basically come right back in and effectively, having
- 35:10Speaker 1: now won that internal skirmish, mister Musk has now decided
- 35:14Speaker 1: to turn it into an external skirmish. It's just not
- 35:17Speaker 1: clear that he has standing to do so, and so
- 35:19Speaker 1: it's just just an odd situation. My guess is his
- 35:22Speaker 1: best claim for damages is just the return of his
- 35:25Speaker 1: forty five million dollars, right, which is yet another kind
- 35:29Speaker 1: of restitutionary claim that that he can make. That's something
- 35:32Speaker 1: you can at least quantify in and stuff that he
- 35:34Speaker 1: paid in. But even that, you know, was he paying
- 35:36Speaker 1: it in under the assumption that there would never be
- 35:39Speaker 1: any involvement five big players like Microsoft. When you've got
- 35:42Speaker 1: these emails from him at the time he's making the investment,
- 35:45Speaker 1: the investment saying you can't just do this with one
- 35:49Speaker 1: hundred million dollars. You're going to need dollar denominations to
- 35:52Speaker 1: start with a B, and you're going to need to
- 35:54Speaker 1: get big players in to help you out here if
- 35:56Speaker 1: you have any chance of competing against Google. But who
- 35:59Speaker 1: are those big players are going to be? He suggested Tesla,
- 36:02Speaker 1: but Microsoft is definitely another one. And so you know,
- 36:05Speaker 1: the optic of the lawsuit as well also raise at
- 36:08Speaker 1: least the possibility that you know, we have this person
- 36:11Speaker 1: who is trying to you know, make a mark. Now,
- 36:14Speaker 1: I guess using X to be a big player in
- 36:17Speaker 1: generative AI, if you're trying to create some elbow room
- 36:20Speaker 1: at that table. It's always good if you can elbow
- 36:23Speaker 1: a couple of the big competitors in the face. And
- 36:25Speaker 1: maybe that's part of what's going on here as well. Like,
- 36:27Speaker 1: you know, maybe this was deemed to be worth a
- 36:30Speaker 1: shot because it would essentially, you know, mecap Microsoft's stability
- 36:35Speaker 1: to compete effectively in the generative AI space, leaving you
- 36:40Speaker 1: a smaller number of the Fang firm working on the
- 36:42Speaker 1: same project, and maybe creating a little bit more elbow
- 36:45Speaker 1: room for mister Musk to scoot up to the generative
- 36:48Speaker 1: AI table.
- 36:49Speaker 3: Sounds a lot more realistic than benefiting humanity. I always
- 36:53Speaker 3: enjoy our conversations, Eric, thanks so much for taking the time.
- 36:57Speaker 3: That's Professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School. And that's
- 37:00Speaker 3: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember
- 37:03Speaker 3: you can always get the latest legal news by subscribing
- 37:06Speaker 3: and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and
- 37:10Speaker 3: at Bloomberg dot com, Slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June
- 37:14Speaker 3: Grosso and this is Bloomberg