Latest / Yo Gavel Gavel! - Court TV Commentary / Suing for Stuff & Scootin into Trouble

Transcript

Suing for Stuff & Scootin into Trouble · Yo Gavel Gavel! - Court TV Commentary

0:03
This is a Bramble Jam podcast this week on Yo Gabble Gabble. If you
0:14
see your boyfriend to get your stuff back and he sues you back for literally
0:17
no reason at all, it'll be good when he has Judged Judy on his
0:20
side to kill feminism. And if you accidentally tap into someone's car, can
0:26
he permanently be put onto a scooter? Judge you know, scoots his way
0:31
into justice real people cases? Wait justice? This is your gabble gabble.
0:40
Boy, it sounds like we got a couple doozzies to Dutch a fifteen year
0:46
old Judge Judy, and nothing makes me I really want to be clear here.
0:51
This episode is fifteen years old. That's right. She she is not.
0:55
She hasn't been fifteen years old, and this episode is from fifteen years
1:00
I wanted to murder Judge Duty. She's not my homegirl. Oh no,
1:04
I wanted to murder. Would you burn the shirt? If you I would
1:07
burn it? Yes, brutal. Did you not know that Judge Judy is
1:11
the worst kind of I know that in her old age she's gotten very,
1:15
very conservative, but I've always thought that in the courtroom she was still just
1:22
Justice isn't a foreign concept, like it's not about conservative or liberal. Brand's
1:26
about doing for right exactly right, but apparently not. I got a judge,
1:30
gino, and there's security footage, and we got two good ones.
1:36
You want to flip a coin on it? Okay, let's look on heads.
1:40
It is heads. Whoh So did I get to go first? You
1:44
get to choose? I'll go first? Okay? Good. I want to
1:47
introduce you to Scott Galloway. Scott Galloway is suing Denise Murphy. This is
1:52
personal injury court, by the way, Yes, so big money is Scott
1:56
Galloway's suing who Denise Murphy? Murphy for sixty thousd for medical, forty K
2:00
for future medical expensive, thirty K for lost of income, and two hundred
2:05
and fifty thousand for pana stuff, or a total of three eighty. So
2:08
you said the numbers you said added up to for eighty No, you said
2:15
two hundred and fifty thousand for painting so high? Yep? Okay, that's
2:21
wrong. Sixty plus forty K plus thirty k right? Three? Two?
2:24
I'm wrong, My masth terrible. It's on you, is it's on me?
2:28
It's it's on me. You said it's on you. How is it
2:30
possibly on me? It's on me, Okay, it's on me. Denise
2:36
Bury U Scott Galloway is like a van driver, a shuttle driver, like
2:42
a van driver one. So he'll take groups of people to places. Yeah,
2:46
as you will. And one morning he drops off a group at the
2:51
airport and the tummy starts to growl. So he's hungry, so he goes
2:55
to his favorite diner, parks the van, goes side, gets himself a
3:00
burger, some fries, a drink, comes back to the van. He's
3:04
going to eat it in the van and then go, you know, do
3:07
his next pickup and next pick up and drop off. So he's eating his
3:14
food and then some things start to happen. I want to introduce you to
3:19
Denise Murphy. Denise is a full time student, a single mom and works
3:23
at the diner when she can to make ends meet. She's doing it working
3:29
as a as a waitress at a cocktail bar. Exactly, that's exactly right,
3:31
that's exactly what she's doing. And that day was her first her daughter's
3:38
first recital, and she had asked for it off her boss forgot kind of
3:46
crossed the wires. Put her on. So she shows up. The coworkers
3:50
came and clutched. They said, you know what, we got you covered.
3:53
We got you covered. So she leaves and she's not running late,
3:58
but she's not running early. She's trying. She's still trying to be speaks.
4:00
So she she backs out and she notices tap tap to a cary.
4:05
And but Scott, Scott is a version of this is a little bit different.
4:12
So Scott is about to take a bite out of his burger. Yeah,
4:15
and something hits the back of the van. He says, his neck
4:19
goes forward, bangs back, and his burger fell out of his hand.
4:26
Oh no, yep, it's three and eighty thousand dollars burgers exactly. That's
4:30
exactly right. And he says that. She comes and says, sorry for
4:33
hitting you. So she she says, yes, I'm sorry that I did
4:39
this. Now Denise says, here's what happened. I was close on time,
4:44
as I was pulling out, I barely tapped his van and and so
4:48
yes, I did go and say hey, I hit you, But it
4:53
was not like he was still leading burger. Yes, and he said I
4:57
was noddyting my burger, wasn't They talk a about this burger a lot.
5:02
It's not me bringing this back up. Do we have any Do we know
5:06
where the burger came from? The diner? Okay, we don't know the
5:10
name of it, just a local, he says. He says, I
5:13
was gonna go get something at the restaurant. That's what he says. And
5:16
they show a picture of a place that just says diner. So none of
5:20
those details are helpful anyways. So he then has next to him this board
5:28
of a parking lot, like an overhead with some cars that you can move
5:30
around. He wanted to show, yes, Scott does. Scott wants to
5:35
show. Scott wants to show where he was, where she was, how
5:40
it happened, So you got the van. It goes to think of an
5:43
overhead shot of a parking lot. Scott in the middle, and then right
5:47
across also middle is is Denise, and Denise backs out, and in the
5:55
process of backing out, he says, she accelerated quickly, banged him his
6:00
van, then moved forward a little. Okay, got it. But this
6:05
the the neck. What happened to the neck? Well, he's in the
6:11
brace. Okay, we'll get to it in just a second. She says
6:15
he's exaggerating or exaggerating. I barely tapped it. There were no marks.
6:21
And she says that I even tapped on his car and said, hey,
6:26
I hit you, and he seems surprised by it. Burger's still in hand,
6:32
a lot of burger talk, a lot of burger talks. Uh,
6:34
and Scott Scott says, no, no, no, my burger was on
6:40
the floor. Didn't get to eat the burger man. Denise then shows Scott's
6:46
a little pissed off he didn't get to eat that burger. Gets to ride
6:50
here, you know how it is, We've all been there. Denise then
6:54
shows pictures of both of the vehicles and there's not a scratch or a dent
6:59
on either vehicle, and Gino says it is important to note that just because
7:03
there's no apparent property damage on the outside, that doesn't mean that there couldn't
7:09
have been some sort of injury inside. It's not necessarily a one to one.
7:13
But do we have footage. We're gonna get to some footage and just
7:16
a look. Okay, okay, So Scott says, you know, I
7:21
left, I went home, and about five hour isshes later, my nex
7:27
starts to hurt and I start to not be able to move it from side
7:30
to side without some sharp pain. The next morning I couldn't even get out
7:32
of bed. So my girlfriend Gigi says, hey, you should go to
7:38
the chiropractor. So he goes to the chiropractor and the chiropractor gets some X
7:42
rays done and an MRI, which I've never been to a chiropractice. That's
7:46
a that's a full blown doctor, boy. But anyways, he says that
7:49
the test revealed that he has several bulging discs and one might have ruptured in
7:55
the neck, multiple ruptured discs in his lower back, and uh, his
8:00
ankle is out of place. Okay, so all of this, say so
8:03
doc, Yes, Denise is like, that doesn't make sense. I barely
8:07
hit him. Yeah, And he says, I have the report with me,
8:13
the meticorpor did the chiropractor do anything to him work on his back at
8:16
all? I don't know what has been I mean some sort of stuff has
8:18
been done, because he's suing for sixty thousand for medical and forty thousand for
8:24
future, so something has been done, but we don't know what that is.
8:26
But he has a brace on of sorts and he gives him the report,
8:33
and the report is pretty damning. It basically says there are elements of
8:37
him that without surgery, he'll never be back to wowl essentially. So then
8:43
he says, Judge, you know, I want I made have had a
8:46
video made up of what my neck looked like in the accident, like a
8:54
mock up animation, an animation. So he gets on it is a little
9:00
scooter. Yeah, scoots his way over. He's taking his taking his time.
9:03
Denise is not having it that He's is like, this doesn't make sense.
9:07
This is ridiculous. He's overreacting. So we see the video, you
9:11
know, side side shot skeleton with the with the neck, the spine,
9:18
if you will, and you see it go forward back exactly how you would
9:20
imagine whiplash looking like. So then he gets back on his scooter. Uh
9:28
slowly, Uh slowly goes goes on back now while scooting back, Denise is
9:33
like, I don't understand how a tap could do this and is continuing to
9:37
just be like it doesn't make sense. Things aren't adding up. Yeah,
9:39
and Scott says, listen, I don't even know if my girlfriend Gigi's gonna
9:43
stay with me. Oh boy, Gigi's thinking about leaving. I mean,
9:48
look at me, look at me, no burger, no neck, And
9:52
Gina says where is she today? And He's like, she's supposed to be
9:56
here. She dropped me off. I don't know where she is now.
10:01
And Denise dropped him off for court and then just was like deuces. Denise
10:05
says, I I saw them walking in and he was barely using the scooter.
10:11
Oh boy. And that's when Judge Gino says, luckily we have security
10:18
cameras all around this courtroom. Oh so I'm gonna take a recess, no,
10:24
and I'm going to examine the security footage and I'll come back and I'll
10:28
let you guys know what. Does he look scared when you see when he
10:31
when Gina says that he's he's just kind of like, no, he doesn't
10:35
seem to concerned. I'm just gonna go in because there's no reason to ask
10:39
you what you think is going to happen. So uh. He comes back
10:43
out from recess wonderful time, slides the swing in some videos and he shows
10:50
two videos. The first video is Gigi helping him get out of the car.
10:54
He's in his brace, he's on his scooters, tried slowly getting on
10:56
a scooter. Sow was scooting away and Scott's like, see cee cee cee.
11:03
And then Gina says, we got one more video of the stairwell and
11:07
of the stairwell, and Scott says, I don't know what you're talking about,
11:11
and he shows the video and they get into this stairway corridor area like
11:18
of a parking garage, and he once they get into the doorway, he
11:24
takes off his his neck brace, hands at the Gigi, picks up his
11:28
scooter, walks up the stairs and these is like say, say and shut.
11:35
Gino's like, we don't have time for frosters or slimy people in this
11:41
courtroom. You wasted my time, you wasted Denise's time. You take your
11:46
scooter and you get out of here. He leaves his scooter behind and just
11:50
walks right out. No, and sut Gino's ready to rule. We don't
11:56
need to do that. Zero dollars, that's exactly right. Full. So
12:00
that's unbelievable, right, unbelievable. I didn't see it coming, brand No,
12:05
no one did. Why. I bet he ain't his burger, I
12:09
bet he did. I bet he did eat his burger. Unbelieve anybody who's
12:13
got a burger that much as evidence. Doctor, I don't know. For
12:16
him, I don't know. That's a great question. Whoots. Yeah,
12:18
that used to be. It was probably like, hey, i'll give you
12:22
a kickback from the shim we call insurance fraud, something like, well,
12:26
if you think Scott's a bad person to Judge Judy, I don't know.
12:30
Can it get worse than this? This poor well you know, single mom.
12:35
Judge Judy is going to come out in favor of domestic abuse. Oh
12:39
no, no, yeah, oh man ready for this? And this is
12:48
not the time, like this is such a serious issue and Judge Judy is
12:52
going to ream out a woman. It is brutal. Let me introduce to
13:00
April Harrington. And I want to be clear. I wouldn't no numbers.
13:05
We don't get any numbers on who's suing what for how much? Not because
13:09
it's Judge Judy. She plays by our own rules. This was two thousand
13:13
Campril Harrington is suing a fellow. She's suing Fred. What's Fred's last name?
13:18
Bad man? No, No it's not. Fred's last name is bad
13:24
I don't think that bad man, bad man, his name's bad man,
13:28
and she's suing him for selling her belongings, and he is counter suing her
13:35
for stealing his belongings. All right, let's get into it. April says,
13:39
we lived together. I mean we were dating. We wanted to live
13:43
together. We each had dogs and my apartment only allowed for one dog in
13:48
my place, and so he begged me to move in with him, so
13:52
to which I did. I moved in with So was the original plan for
13:56
him to move in with her. They wanted to live together and she wanted
13:58
him to move This was the only way to happen. I moved in late
14:03
May. I put some of my stuff in storage. Storage unit was in
14:07
Fred's name, but I paid for the storage, got receipts paid for it.
14:11
Ever, it was a storage unit in Fred's name. I don't know
14:13
why. We never get to the bottom of that. In the storage shit
14:16
her bed frame, mattress, dressers, glass, mirror, and then toys
14:22
from childhood, including a bear collection she had from when she was a kid,
14:24
her diploma, important tax information, so everything aside from clothes. Essentially
14:30
there were clothes as well, okay, so and plates. Yes. Two
14:35
months later they got into a falling out and they separated. Why do they
14:39
separate? Well, I found out he had been cheating on me with her
14:45
and he points She points to a woman in the courtroom who never stands up
14:48
that we see her, and she's she's not just like in the audience,
14:50
right, what are you talking about? I found out he had been cheating
15:01
on me with her, and that is his baby's mother. Okay, And
15:05
in fact, he had the child before we started dating, and we at
15:09
one point were going to court to get custody of the kid over her.
15:13
And so I had already started plans on being a stepmom, like, had
15:16
bought gifts for the kid, and like, had tried, you know whatever.
15:20
And then I found out he was cheating on me when I came home
15:24
from work early. We then at this point Fred's cheating. Fred Badman is
15:31
cheating. We flash over Fred, who has a smile on his face.
15:33
Sure, smile back to April. I come in and question him, like,
15:41
how can you be doing this? Why are you cheating on me?
15:43
Blah blah blah. He shoves me into a dresser, he dislocates my finger,
15:50
and I called the police. The police told him he should leave the
15:54
apartment for three days while I got my stuff together during that time. The
15:58
next day they had a different lock on the door. He busted the lock
16:03
of the door, busted in to the apartment. Anyway, I moved out
16:07
immediately. The cops put a different lock on the door. I guess I
16:11
didn't feel safe. I left immediately, took all the things in the house
16:15
that I could, but what didn't have time to go to the storage.
16:18
Shit. The only thing I took that it belongs to him. Are some
16:22
pornography tapes. Now, she says this and stops, and Judy's like,
16:27
well, why did you take those? And she says they were buried in
16:30
a box of my movies. This is two thousand and five box of my
16:33
movies. And I felt too embarrassed to bring them back and they were disgusting,
16:37
so I just threw them away. That's what she said, But she
16:40
admits she did take those. I don't know why that's important to the story,
16:42
but she brings it up. Are the pornograph of them? I don't
16:45
know. It's just it's just on vhs, from what I understand, which
16:51
she kept underneath all of her VHL. Yeah, where he she wouldn't find
16:55
them. I don't know. I had nothing actually discovered that one day,
16:57
She says, I don't go down the VS in the what's this? I
17:03
moved out and then a couple days later I went to storage to get my
17:06
stuff. Had the key, I've been paid for it. The storage the
17:10
locks had been changed, was changed. I don't have the ability to get
17:14
in to get my stuff. Judy says, all right, let's hear from
17:15
you. So Fred starts in, Okay, when we broke up, she
17:19
was accusing me of cheating. I never admitted that I was cheating. I
17:22
remained friends with her, this girl, because we have a child together.
17:27
That's why our main friends. And then she told the police that like I
17:30
beat her up or whatever, but she didn't file a police report or anything.
17:37
Is that true? The police have a report of the incident, but
17:38
she did not refile any charges. Sure, okay, Judy says, uh.
17:45
She has April's complaint and she reads from it and says, April says,
17:51
I came home from work to talk to Fred. He was sleeping.
17:55
She said, so you woke him up. She says, yes, I
17:59
woke him up. And she said, okay, Uh, well, you
18:06
woke up a guy, and you think that he dislocated and broke your finger.
18:11
I don't think so that didn't happen. I don't think it happened.
18:15
I'm sure you. I'm sure your finger got broken or dislocated. I don't
18:18
think he did it. What does him being asleep have to do with any
18:21
of that? Just wait, April goes judge. He admits he broke the
18:26
finger in the report. So then she goes back to the report. She
18:32
goes. She goes to Fred. Fred says, I she continued to poke
18:36
me over and over again, to talk about this poke me, poked me.
18:40
She was punching the walls, and so finally I wanted to leave me
18:42
alone. I turned around, I squeezed her, I grabbed her hand.
18:47
She started crying and her finger had been injured in the report. Judge Judy
18:52
said, so you're poking him non stop. You're just poking him, poking
18:57
him. No, you can't put your hands on somebody and expect them to
19:02
do nothing. She says that to this woman. No, she says it
19:07
to it. April says, your honor, if you keep reading, you'll
19:11
see that he pushed me off the bed and kicked me. And Judy interrupts
19:15
again and says you put your hands on him. And April says, so
19:21
that makes all of that okay, and Judy goes, listen to me,
19:26
you can't put your hands on someone and expect them not to do anything.
19:30
Oh my god, Yeah, I am losing my mind right now. Dang
19:38
boy. It mits she he shoved her. Itmits, squeeze your hand,
19:45
broke her finger. Judy is on team abuse her. But to be clear
19:52
here, even if you go down, like, even if you get to
19:56
the point where you're like Judy's right, well, here's the thing is if
20:00
you are poking. April was saying, I'm I wasn't angry. I was
20:03
crying and I'm trying to wake him up because I want to talk about this.
20:07
That is her take. But all I'm saying is, even if you
20:11
are on team Judy, here where you're like an I for an eye or
20:14
a finger for a finger here, finger for a finger. Okay, That's
20:18
what all I'm saying is. He then went further, yes, like it's
20:22
no longer an eye for an eye at that according to Judy, she started
20:26
it. So if if you poke somebody, if you want to go down
20:29
the trap of hill, regardless of if it's uh anybody, if I'm poking
20:33
you, that then gives you the right to kick the living tar. Apparently
20:38
so and Judy is. I was like, okay, tell me about what
20:41
happened with the stuff in the storage unit. He said, well, I,
20:45
uh held on to the stuff in the storage unit for six months.
20:49
I took it back to my aunt's place. Uh. And why did he
20:52
do that? I want I didn't want to pay for the storage unit anymore.
20:56
A and then b I wanted my stuff back before she could have her
21:02
stuff back, and Judy said, what stuff of yours did she take?
21:06
He says, an entertainment stand, a bunch of movies, a tent,
21:12
and a few other things. And I've got pictures. None of the movies.
21:17
Judy asked for it. The entertainment stand looks awful. She goes,
21:21
what is this? Like sixty nine bucks? Like did you put it together?
21:25
And he said no, you're on hers like three hundred dollars. She
21:26
said, do you have a re seat? He says no. She said,
21:30
she asked, April, did you take the TV stand? He gave
21:33
me the TV stand. I did not take the tent. I don't know
21:34
what he's talking about Okay, what else did she take? He said,
21:40
she took some of my daughter's clothing and some of her toys and my tackle
21:44
box. April says, I didn't take the tackle box. I took the
21:48
clothing and toys because I bought them thinking we were going to raise a child.
21:52
And then it is this point that Judy hops back in to lecture her
21:56
again on what a gift is good? Gosh, woman like, just stop,
22:07
okay, so hey, Judy says, it's a gift. It doesn't
22:10
matter, It doesn't matter who you bought, if you bought him or not,
22:11
as soon as you gave him to the kid, even if the kids
22:15
won it their hers blah blah blahlah blah. So Fred then says, I
22:19
gave three bags of her things away to the Salvation Army. I gave a
22:25
bag of clothes, a bag of dishes, and some Teddy Bears away to
22:29
the Salvation Army. Wait, can I stop you right real quick? So
22:30
she didn't try to get the stuff out of those stores. She did for
22:33
six months, locks changed, So he changed. Why did he do that
22:38
to make sure she couldn't get him until he had his stuff back, which
22:41
once again she claims a stand he gave her I got, I got nothing,
22:45
yes, right, So then he took all of her stuff. He
22:48
didn't want to pay for it anymore. To this his aunt's barn. It's
22:52
been outside in a barn. The rest of the stuff he has pictures.
22:53
He's like a cow to a dress her. It's sitting in a barn outside.
22:57
Right. He said, I kept her her furniture, I kept her
23:00
diploma, I kept her tax stuff. Uh why didn't you give it back
23:04
to her? Says Judy. Fred says, because she didn't give me my
23:07
stuff back. Uh. And uh she And then Judy says, well,
23:10
you're a baby. She does call him a baby. I want to be
23:12
clear that it is not April. She does call him a bait. And
23:18
I think that's and April said, you're on her. This is six months
23:22
later. My stuff is in a barn covered in feces, over a dozen
23:25
cats living there. Uh, like this is I don't want that, Like
23:30
I don't want the stuff. I wanted the stuff back when I could use
23:33
the stuff. And is at this point that Judy is ready to rule.
23:38
Remind me of the finances there isn't. I can't because they don't ever mention,
23:45
but he has the stuff he gave away. We're clothes, dishes,
23:48
Teddy Bear collection. The stuff he kept was furniture, mirror, dresser,
23:56
bed, diploma attack stuff. My guess. My guess is that Judy will
24:03
give her the amount of money equal to what he gave away. So let's
24:11
call it two hundred bucks. Yes, but it's a thousand, okay.
24:15
She gives her a thousand and then says, you, within the next five
24:18
days, he is required to give you all the stuff out of the barn
24:22
back, okay. And that's the end of the case. Sure, one
24:26
of the more utterly just depressing cases I've ever watched. Yeah, that's tough.
24:32
I don't want to post the link for other people to watch it.
24:33
But I also am just gobsmacked as Judy lectures this woman on getting this on
24:38
the YouTube. It's on the YouTube, or to the comments, saying I
24:41
did not look because it's on this string of like three hours worth of Judge
24:45
Judy. But I can look it up. I say, it is patently
24:48
absurd. I can't believe it's a real case. I wanted I wanted to
24:52
punch Judy in the face. Just full disclosure well, you'd have to wait
24:55
for her in this scenario to poke that's that's right, and then fair gas.
25:00
Yeah, I really want to punch you. Do you want to be?
25:03
She's not my homegirl. I can tell you that right now. No,
25:04
no, no, we did, We did everybody. I would implore
25:07
everybody to watch as much judge, you know, as possible. U.
25:11
There is what I've been going back to is there's a four hour clip of
25:15
four hours worth of episodes on a Facebook somewhere. Come on. I don't
25:19
know whose Facebook it is, but God bless them for doing the Lord.
25:23
I went back in two weeks next week with the Bayside and tell them,
25:26
man, we'll be the first to wish you in all ris Yo. Gabble
25:33
Gabbles a Bramble Jam podcast recorded live in Greenville, South Carolina, at the
25:37
Bramble Jam Podcast Network Studios. It's produced by Brandon Gray. For more information,
25:42
you can go to Bramblejam podcast dot com slash gabble. You're about to
25:55
hear some ads that helped keep the lights on here in the old studio.
26:00
Thanks for listening or don't listen. It's really up to you at this point.
26:03
It is at the end of the show. I mean, you're listening
26:07
to me Hi. But here they come. I promised they're coming. Yep,
26:10
here they are. Happy Day.