Latest / Reformed Thinking / Unbuyable Shepherds: Why Elders Must Not Be Lovers of Money

Transcript

Unbuyable Shepherds: Why Elders Must Not Be Lovers of Money · Reformed Thinking

0:00
Welcome to Reformed Thinking. We're glad you've joined us for
0:02
this deep dive. Glad to be here.
0:04
Today we are opening up the Pastoral Epistles, specifically
0:08
First Timothy, to to really look at a qualification for church
0:12
leadership that I think often gets, well, it gets passed.
0:16
Over it? Really.
0:17
Does we talk a lot you know about the big ones.
0:19
We discuss the requirement for an elder to be the husband of
0:23
one wife for able to teach those get a lot of air time.
0:26
And for good reason. They're critical.
0:28
Absolutely. But today we're focusing on a
0:30
phrase that, as we were preparing, it felt like it acts
0:34
as a a kind of diagnostic of the soul.
0:37
That's a great way to put it. It's a phrase that if you ignore
0:40
it, it can really dismantle a ministry from the inside out
0:43
without anyone even noticing for a while.
0:45
We're talking about the requirement right there in First
0:47
Timothy chapter 3 that an overseer must be not a lover of
0:51
money. And you know, on the surface
0:54
that sounds, well, it sounds like a standard HR policy.
0:57
Right, it sounds like don't steal from the cash register or
1:00
make sure you have a clean background check.
1:02
Exactly. Yeah.
1:03
But the more we look into the sources for this, it became so
1:07
clear that this is about much, much more than that.
1:10
This isn't about credit scores. This gets to the very nature of
1:13
worship. It certainly does.
1:14
And I think we have to start where the Apostle Paul starts.
1:17
We have to look at how he frames this entire section on
1:19
qualifications. He opens with that famous
1:23
formula, Pistosos Logos. Is this saying is trustworthy?
1:27
He's putting a divine stamp on what comes next.
1:29
It's like a massive highlighter over the whole paragraph.
1:32
He calls the Office of Overseer a noble task, or in the Greek
1:37
Kalu, ergo, a beautiful work. A beautiful work.
1:40
But here's the tension, and our sources really brought this out.
1:43
Nobility in God's eyes, what God calls beautiful, often stands in
1:47
direct contradiction to what the world values.
1:49
You know that's true. We live in a culture that's just
1:52
driven by accumulation. Success is measured by your
1:55
portfolio. And Paul was writing into a very
1:57
similar situation. We can't forget the context.
2:00
Ephesus. Ephesus.
2:01
It was this massive center of trade, a port city, and what was
2:04
at the heart of its identity, the Cult of Artemis.
2:08
Which was basically religion and commerce totally fused together.
2:12
The temple was like a. Bank, it was commercialized.
2:14
Spirituality was big business. So when Paul, writing to
2:18
Timothy, who is an Ephesus, says an elder must not be a lover of
2:21
money, he is building a firewall.
2:24
A firewall. I like that this qualification
2:26
is the boundary line. It separates the true shepherd
2:30
from the hireling from the wolf. And I think the thesis we're
2:33
working with today is that greed, this love of money, it
2:37
acts as a rival worship. A rival worship.
2:40
You cannot be tethered to silver and tethered to the cross at the
2:43
same time. The ropes pull in opposite
2:45
directions. OK, let's unpack that.
2:47
I think for most of us, when we hear Lover of Money, our mind
2:50
immediately goes to, you know, a cartoon villain, Scrooge Mcduck,
2:54
someone who is actively embezzling funds.
2:57
A very overt kind of sin. Right, But the Greek text gives
3:01
us a picture that is so much more nuanced and frankly, a lot
3:04
more convicting for all of us. So let's get into the exegesis.
3:07
What is the text actually saying?
3:09
The primary term Paul uses in First Timothy 3 verse 3 is a
3:13
filler dryer, a filler gerant. It's a compound word, and like
3:16
with so many of Paul's words, breaking it down is incredibly
3:19
revealing. So you have the A at the
3:21
beginning, the alpha primitive in Greek that negates whatever
3:25
comes after it. It means not or no.
3:28
OK, so not something. Exactly.
3:30
Then you have two words fused together, filos and argueros.
3:35
And argueros, That's silver, right?
3:36
Like the metal? Yes, argueros is silver, which
3:40
was the standard for currency. It just means money.
3:42
But the middle part, Filos, that's the absolute key to this
3:46
whole thing. What does that mean?
3:47
Filos isn't just a casual liking.
3:50
It's the word for affection. It's the word used for
3:53
friendship, for brotherly love, like in Philadelphia.
3:56
The City of Brotherly Love. Precisely.
3:58
So literally what Paul is saying is that an overseer must be a no
4:02
love Silverman or maybe even better and not a friend of
4:05
Silverman. No love silver.
4:06
Wow, that that changes everything, doesn't it?
4:09
It completely shifts the focus from the action to the
4:12
affection. It's not just asking the
4:14
question, did you steal? It's asking are you friends with
4:17
money? Do you love it?
4:19
Does it have a hold on your heart?
4:21
That is the distinction. A man might never steal a dime,
4:25
maybe because he's afraid of getting caught or because he has
4:27
a public reputation to uphold. For sure, that doesn't mean his
4:30
heart is free. He can still love it, Daydream
4:33
about it, find his security in it, be friends with it.
4:36
The text demands that the heart of the Shepherd be divorced from
4:39
that affection for wealth. He shouldn't treat Silver like a
4:43
trusted companion he loves to spend time with.
4:45
The sources we looked at also pointed out a parallel term over
4:49
the letter to Titus. Yes, in Titus 1.7.
4:52
Paul uses a different word there.
4:54
What's the significance of that? Why not just use the same word?
4:57
Well, this is Paul being a careful theologian in Titus.
5:00
The phrase is my I shrochero. OK, another compound word.
5:04
Another one, it combines a which means shameful or base, with
5:09
Kardos which means gain or profit.
5:11
So shameful gain. Not greedy for shameful gain.
5:15
The distinction here helps us build a really robust systematic
5:18
understanding of this sin. Think of it this way.
5:21
First Timothy with Apholargeron targets the internal desire, the
5:26
loving of it, the heart, attitude, the.
5:28
Want. The want exactly, but Titus with
5:32
Asia crudo targets the external method, the getting of it in a
5:36
shameful way. So that would cover things like,
5:39
I don't know, shady business deals or maybe even manipulating
5:43
the flock for donation. Precisely, it covers the how.
5:46
So you put them together and you get a complete picture.
5:49
An elder must not have a heart that loves money and he must not
5:52
use shameful methods to acquire it.
5:54
He has to be clean on both fronts, internally and
5:57
externally. And you can't miss the grammar
5:59
here either. The source is pointed out the
6:01
verb that governs all these qualifications.
6:03
The little word day. What does that mean?
6:05
It means it is necessary, or one must.
6:09
It's a word of divine necessity. Paul isn't giving suggestions
6:12
for a successful ministry. These are non negotiable.
6:14
Absolutely, and in the Greek structure, not a lover of money
6:18
is on the exact same grammatical level as husband of one wife or
6:21
super minded or able to teach. That is, that's a sobering
6:26
comparison, and I really don't think we categorize those sins
6:29
in the same way in the modern church.
6:30
I think you're right. I mean, if a pastor commits
6:32
adultery, he's removed immediately, and rightly so.
6:37
But if a pastor is ambitious, if he really loves money and is
6:40
driven by it, we tend to tolerate that.
6:43
Sometimes we even celebrate it. We call it being a good
6:45
fundraiser a visionary. Yeah, we see financial ambition
6:49
as a leadership skill, but the text here says it's a
6:52
disqualification. Structurally, you can't have a
6:56
greedy elder any more than you can have an adulterous 1.
6:58
And this all goes back to the root of the issue Paul tells
7:01
Timothy later in the letter in chapter 6, verse 10.
7:04
The famous verse the love of money is a root of all kinds of
7:07
evil. A root about the root, but a
7:09
root. Think about what a root does.
7:11
It's underground. You don't see it, but it's
7:13
feeding the whole plant. Exactly.
7:15
It's generative. So many other evils grow out of
7:18
the soil. Apostasy, as Paul mentions right
7:20
there. Doctrinal error to please
7:22
donors. All kinds of moral ruin.
7:25
If that root of philageria is still alive and well in an
7:28
elder's heart, it is only a matter of time before the
7:31
poisonous fruit appears in his ministry.
7:33
The elder needs to have that root severed.
7:35
It has to be dead. OK, that that sets the stage
7:40
perfectly for digging into the biblical history of this,
7:43
because this isn't some new idea that Paul just invented for the
7:46
New Testament church. Not at all.
7:48
This thread runs through the entire redemptive story, and the
7:52
sources took us all the way back to the Old Testament economy,
7:55
specifically to the Levites. Yes, and this is so key for our
7:59
covenantal understanding of ministry.
8:01
You have to remember when God brought Israel into the Promised
8:04
Land and divided it up among the tribes.
8:05
Everyone got a piece of the pie. Judah, Benjamin, all of them.
8:09
They received land and land. That world represented
8:12
everything. It was wealth, inheritance,
8:14
security, your future. But one tribe, the tribe of
8:18
Levi, the priest, the ones who served the Tabernacle, they
8:21
received no land inheritance. Just try to imagine being a
8:24
Levite in that moment. You're standing there, you're
8:26
watching all your countrymen stake out their property, their
8:29
vineyards, their fields, and you get.
8:33
It must have been a huge test of faith, but it wasn't that they
8:35
received nothing. It's that they received
8:37
something infinitely better, but something that required total,
8:41
moment by moment faith. God himself.
8:44
God Himself In Numbers 18 verse 20, God tells Aaron, I am your
8:48
portion and your inheritance among the people of Israel.
8:50
I am your portion. This structural poverty, when it
8:53
came to land, was a pedagogical tool.
8:55
It was a teaching mechanism. It taught them and it teaches us
8:58
today that the minister of God must find his security and his
9:02
his portion in Yahweh alone, not in a four O 1K, not in real
9:06
estate in God. So if a religious leader in
9:09
Israel, a priest, was greedy, he wasn't just being selfish, he
9:14
was fundamentally rejecting God's promise.
9:16
That's the deep implication, he was saying.
9:18
God, you are not enough for me. I need land, I need silver, I
9:21
need stuff to feel safe. And we see the negative examples
9:24
of this played out, don't we? Oh.
9:25
Absolutely. Think of Balaam.
9:27
The Book of Jude calls him the prototype of the mercenary
9:30
prophet. He was willing to curse God's
9:33
people because the price was right.
9:34
He was for hire. His prophetic gift was on the
9:37
market. Or I mean an even more graphic
9:39
example, the Sons of Eli in First Samuel chapter.
9:42
Two, that it's such a brutal story.
9:44
They were priests and they were treating the sacrifices.
9:47
As their personal grocery store, they were taking the choice cuts
9:52
of meat, the parts that belong to God, and they were taking it
9:55
by force with these three pronged forks.
9:57
By force. It wasn't just that they were
10:00
skimming a little off the top. No, they treated the entire
10:03
sacrificial system, the very mechanism of grace and
10:06
forgiveness for the people as a means of personal enrichment,
10:09
and the judgement against them and their house was severe.
10:13
It's a stark lesson. A leader who loves game will
10:17
inevitably end up despising the holiness of God and exploiting
10:21
the people of God. OK, so that's the Old Testament
10:24
pattern. Now, as we move into the New
10:25
Testament, there's obviously a shift.
10:27
We aren't Levites offering bulls and goats, but the principle
10:30
seems to, if anything, intensify.
10:32
It absolutely does. As Paul says in First
10:35
Corinthians 4, we are now stewards of the mysteries of
10:37
God. The stakes are even higher.
10:40
And yet the threat of filthy lucre, as the King James puts
10:44
it, it remains. And the most terrifying,
10:47
chilling example in the whole Bible has to be Judas Iscariot.
10:50
Yeah, that part of the source material, it really struck me.
10:53
The book of Acts says he was numbered among the 12.
10:56
Acts 1.17 He was there. He wasn't an outsider.
11:00
He saw the miracles, He heard the sermon on the mount from
11:03
Jesus own lips. He had his feet washed by the
11:05
Son of God. Proximity to Christ did not
11:07
immunize him against greed. That is such a critical point.
11:11
It didn't. He held the money bag and John's
11:13
gospel tells us he was a thief who used to help himself to what
11:16
was put into it. And eventually this small secret
11:19
sin festered until he sold the Lord of glory for 30 pieces of
11:23
silver. The price of a slave.
11:25
It's the ultimate warning. If it can happen to an apostle
11:28
who walked with Jesus, it can happen to a modern elder, a
11:31
modern pastor. It should make us tremble.
11:34
And this all leads to that absolute stark binary that Jesus
11:38
gives us in Matthew 6224. You cannot serve God and money.
11:42
He doesn't say you shouldn't. He doesn't say it's not a good
11:44
idea, he says you cannot. It is an ontological
11:47
impossibility. They are two different masters
11:50
demanding total rival allegiance.
11:52
You have to choose. Every day, and this plays out
11:55
even in the eschatological picture.
11:57
In Revelation 18, we see the judgement of the great
12:00
prostitute Babylon. And what is her great sin?
12:02
What does she traffic in? Gold, Silver, jewels.
12:05
All of that and it culminates in a horrifying phrase.
12:08
She traffics in human the church is the bride of Christ.
12:13
She is to be distinct from the harlot system of Babylon,
12:15
commercialism, the trading of souls for profit.
12:17
That is the mark of the world system.
12:20
The Elder, as a leader of the bride, must demonstrate by his
12:23
life that his citizenship is in the New Jerusalem, not in the
12:27
marketplace of Babylon. That is the essential contrast,
12:30
and it flows so naturally into the systematic theology of this
12:33
issue. We've see the biblical data, but
12:35
how do we categorize this sin? What box does it go in?
12:39
And the sources were crystal clear on this.
12:41
Greed is idolatry. Yeah, Colossians 3.5 Paul just
12:46
states it as a fact. Put to death, therefore, what is
12:49
earthly in you covetousness, which is idolatry.
12:53
It's not like idolatry. It is idolatry.
12:56
It is so systematically A greedy elder is a functional idolater.
13:01
He may be bowing his knee to Christ on Sunday morning, but
13:04
Monday through Saturday his heart is bowing before the altar
13:07
of Mammon. He's worshipping the creation,
13:09
the security or pleasure that money promises over the Creator.
13:13
And the Reformed tradition has always been incredibly strong
13:15
and clear on this point. I was thinking of that insight
13:17
from John Calvin on the psychology of greed.
13:19
Oh, it's brilliant, Calvin wrote.
13:21
Nothing is more uneasy to the mind of man than the desire of
13:24
getting. Uneasy to the mind.
13:25
It's a profound psychological observation.
13:28
If your mind is obsessed with getting more, it's in a state of
13:31
constant unrest, constant anxiety.
13:34
It's never content. And if your mind is restless
13:37
with greed, how can you possibly possess the sober mindedness
13:41
that First Timothy 3 requires for the cure of souls?
13:45
You can't. You can't sit there and
13:47
patiently listen to a struggling congregants spiritual crisis if
13:52
in the back of your mind you're mentally calculating your stock
13:55
portfolio or worrying about a major donor.
13:58
Your mind is somewhere else. The Puritans, men like William
14:01
Perkins or Richard Baxter, they had a name for this kind of
14:04
minister, a hireling. A.
14:06
Hireling from John chapter 10. Someone who does the job for the
14:09
wage, not out of love for the sheep.
14:11
And their logic was so simple and powerful.
14:14
It was, they argued, that if a pastor cannot trust God for his
14:18
daily bread, he has absolutely no business trying to teach his
14:21
people to trust God for their eternal salvation.
14:23
His life contradicts the core of his message.
14:26
I want to try and connect this to the Westminster standards
14:28
since that's the framework we operate from.
14:30
How does a greedy elder specifically violate the
14:32
confession? Well, at least two places come
14:35
to mind immediately. First, you have Westminster
14:37
Confession Chapter 26 of the Communion of Saints.
14:40
The confession says that Saints are bound to maintain a holy
14:44
fellowship and communion. A greedy elder completely
14:47
disrupts this communion because he can't help but introduce
14:50
transactional dynamics into the Church.
14:52
What do you mean by that? He stopped seeing the sheep as
14:56
brothers and sisters in Christ for whom he will give an
14:59
account, and he starts, maybe subconsciously, to see them as
15:03
patrons, as resources, as customers.
15:05
And you can't have Holy Communion with a customer you're
15:07
trying to upsell. It totally changes the
15:09
relational dynamic. It poisons it.
15:11
And secondly, there's chapter 19 on the law of God.
15:15
The three uses of the law. Exactly.
15:18
We talked about the third use of the law, which is how the law
15:20
acts as a guide for the believer in their life of gratitude and
15:23
obedience. The command do not love.
15:26
Money isn't just a heavy burden or a restriction for the
15:29
regenerate man. It's a guide to freedom.
15:31
It's a guide to the joy of stewardship.
15:33
It shows him how to live free from the slavery of Mammon,
15:36
which is where real joy is found.
15:38
And then, of course, there's the ecclesiological danger, the sin
15:42
of simony. Named after Simon Magus in Acts
15:45
chapter 8, who tried to buy the power of the Holy Spirit with
15:48
money, right? Simony broadly is the buying or
15:51
selling of ecclesiastical office or privilege.
15:54
And if an elder loves money, he essentially rewrites the
15:57
ownership deed of the Church. He starts to treat God's house
16:00
as his own business. He treats God's things, the
16:03
pulpit, the sacraments, the counseling room, as his own
16:06
opportunities for personal gain. OK, so we've got the theology
16:10
laid out. Now let's get really practical.
16:13
The sources use a helpful phrase, a pastoral diagnosis.
16:17
How does greed actually show up in ministry?
16:20
Because it rarely stands up and announces itself.
16:23
It doesn't wear a sign that says I am greedy.
16:25
No, it's far more subtle. The sources use this concept of
16:28
the bend. The bend, yeah.
16:30
Greed acts like a subtle, constant gravitational pull that
16:33
bends everything in ministry towards itself.
16:36
It acts as a filter on every decision, and it doesn't whisper
16:39
its own name. It whispers words like prudence,
16:41
stability, wisdom or growing the platform.
16:44
It disguises itself as good stewardship.
16:46
Very often. So let's talk about the first
16:48
area bending the pulpit. How does a love of money change
16:52
a sermon? It fundamentally changes the
16:55
internal calculus of the preacher.
16:57
Before he preaches on a difficult text, before he calls
17:00
out a culturally acceptable sin, he starts asking himself a
17:04
different question. Not what does this text say?
17:07
No, he starts asking, what will this sermon cost me?
17:11
Wow. He starts to wonder, if I preach
17:12
on this passage about greed, will the wealthiest family in
17:16
the church stop their generous giving?
17:18
Or if I talk about sexual ethics, will we miss our budget
17:22
goal this quarter? So the result is you just soften
17:25
things. You soften sin, you blur the
17:27
sharp edges of the call to repentance, you start trimming
17:31
off the costly, offensive doctrines of the faith, you
17:34
start preaching the whole council of God, and you start
17:36
preaching the safe, financially solvent counsel of God.
17:39
The fear of God gets replaced by the fear of financial loss.
17:41
That's it in a sentence. That is terrifying to think
17:44
about. What about pastoral care?
17:46
How does greed bend one-on-one ministry?
17:48
It inevitably turns care into customer service, and this is
17:52
where James chapter 2 on the sin of partiality becomes so
17:56
painfully relevant. Right giving the rich person the
17:59
best seat. If an elder has a left for
18:01
money, the wealthy and influential members of the
18:04
congregation get VIP treatment. It's just a fact.
18:07
They get the quick appointments. Their calls get returned first.
18:10
They receive the gentlest, most deferential correction, if any
18:14
at all. But the poor member.
18:16
The poor member, or the member who is just not seen as useful
18:19
to the institution, They face delays.
18:22
They might even face suspicion. They are seeing, maybe not even
18:25
consciously, as a drain on resources rather than a precious
18:28
soul for whom Christ died. People become means to an end.
18:32
The flock becomes a resource to be leveraged and not a family to
18:35
be loved. You've got it.
18:37
The Force has also made a powerful point about bending
18:39
discipline and governance. Yeah, and this is where things
18:42
can get very dark in a church. If a big giver becomes
18:45
untouchable, if their sin is consistently overlooked because
18:48
of their financial contribution, then church is a complete sham.
18:52
It creates A2 tiered system of justice, one for the rich and
18:56
one for everyone else. Which is an abomination to God,
19:00
and furthermore it almost always leads to a culture of secrecy.
19:03
Money loving leaders hate transparency.
19:06
Why is that? Because transparency is a threat
19:09
to their control, they become incredibly defensive about the
19:13
budget, about compensation, about designated funds.
19:16
They start treating basic financial information like it's
19:19
a state secret because control of the information protects
19:22
their income stream and their power.
19:24
And the sources mentioned emotional instability as well,
19:27
which I found interesting. Yes, because money can't truly
19:30
secure you. It's a false God.
19:33
Loving it creates a deep, abiding anxiety, and this
19:36
anxiety manifests in the pastor's temperament.
19:38
He's either harsh and defensive, snapping at anyone who questions
19:42
the spending, or he's a flatterer, constantly praising
19:45
his patrons to keep them happy. It destroys the gentle, stable,
19:48
not quarrelsome temperament that First Timothy 3 explicitly
19:52
requires. It makes it impossible.
19:53
OK, we absolutely have to make some careful distinctions here,
19:56
because it'll be easy to hear all this and swing to an
19:58
extreme. We're not saying money is evil
20:01
or that pastors shouldn't be paid.
20:02
So this brings us to the polemic section.
20:05
We need to fight off the errors on both sides of this road.
20:08
Correct. On one side of the ditch, you
20:10
have the prosperity gospel. Which is rampant.
20:13
It is. This is the explicit belief that
20:16
godliness is a means of financial gain, which is almost
20:20
a direct quote of what First Timothy 6.5 condemns in false
20:24
teachers. Yeah, it's a gross confusion of
20:26
the biblical covenants. They take the Old Testament land
20:29
and wealth promises which were for national Israel under the
20:32
Mosaic covenant, and they miss apply them to the New Testament
20:36
believer. But the New Testament calls
20:37
totally different. It's take up your cross and
20:39
follow me. Exactly.
20:40
It's a fundamental Christological error.
20:43
It presents a Jesus who died primarily to make us wealthy and
20:46
healthy, rather than a Jesus who died to make us holy.
20:49
It's a different gospel. Then there's the other ditch on
20:51
the other side of the road. Right asceticism or some forms
20:55
of the social Gospel? This is the view that private
20:57
property is itself evil, or that poverty is inherently holy.
21:01
And we have to be just as clear here, the text says.
21:04
An elder must be not a lover of money, not one with no money.
21:10
The story of Ananias and Sapphira in Acts 5 is so clear
21:14
on this, isn't it? It's the perfect proof text.
21:17
What did Peter say to Ananias? While it remained unsold, did it
21:21
not remain your own? And after it was sold, was it
21:23
not at your disposal? Their sin wasn't owning the
21:26
land, it was lying to God about their giving.
21:29
Precisely. Scripture affirms private
21:31
property, and the classic Reformed view, rooted in the
21:34
Westminster Confession, chapter 5 on Providence, is that wealth
21:37
is a tool. It's a stewardship given by God.
21:39
It's to be used for His glory, to support your family, to
21:42
relieve the poor, and to advance the Kingdom.
21:45
The sin is in the affection, not the possession.
21:48
So we need to find the balance, the biblical balance, between
21:50
rightful support and shameful gain.
21:52
That is the crucial distinct for every church to make.
21:55
Let's talk about rightful support first.
21:57
The Bible is not silent on this. Not at all.
22:00
First Timothy 5.17 says elders who rule well are worthy of
22:04
double honor, which in context certainly includes financial
22:08
remuneration. First Corinthians 9 Paul's great
22:11
defense of his apostleship. He says you shall not muzzle an
22:14
ox when it treads out the grain. The pastor should be paid.
22:18
A church has a duty not to starve its pastor.
22:21
A church should pay its pastor generously enough that he can
22:24
work without worldly anxiety about providing for his family.
22:27
That's good and right. But shameful game I sure could
22:30
ease That's a different animal A.
22:32
Totally different animal. It's all about the motive and
22:34
the method. The motive is serving for the
22:37
money. The money is the reason you're
22:38
in ministry. The method is manipulation,
22:41
secrecy, conflicts of interest. Peter commands the elders to
22:44
shepherd eagerly, not for shameful gain.
22:48
That eagerness must come from a love for Christ and his sheep.
22:51
They cannot be tied to the size of the paycheck.
22:53
And here's a hard question every elder in church should ask.
22:56
Would this man still shepherd these people if his pay was cut
22:59
in half or cut entirely? If the honest answer is no, he
23:02
might be a hireling. He just might be.
23:04
This brings us to the absolute heart of the matter.
23:07
We can't just moralize about this.
23:09
We can't just say don't be greedy and leave it there.
23:11
That's just law. It is.
23:12
We have to ground this qualification in the person and
23:15
work of Christ. How does being not a lover of
23:19
money testify to the gospel itself?
23:21
This is the Christ centered proclamation.
23:24
This is where the power to change is found and you have to
23:26
start with the incarnation. Second Corinthians 8.9.
23:29
It's one of the most beautiful verses in the Bible.
23:32
For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though
23:35
he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that you by
23:38
his poverty might become rich. The kenosis, the great self
23:42
emptying. Think about his life on earth,
23:45
the creator of the universe who owns the cattle on 1000 hills.
23:49
He was born in a borrowed Manger.
23:51
He preached his greatest sermons from a borrowed boat.
23:53
He rode into Jerusalem to die on a borrowed donkey.
23:56
And he was buried in a borrowed tomb.
23:58
He had nowhere to lay his head. So an elder who is grasping for
24:02
silver, who is focused on accumulating wealth, he is
24:05
living in a way that directly contradicts the master he claims
24:08
to represent. He is acting in direct
24:11
opposition to the Spirit of Christ.
24:13
And it gets even darker when you look at the Passion.
24:16
What specific role did Filler Juria, the Love of Money, play
24:21
in the death of Jesus? It was the engine of the
24:23
betrayal. It was the specific sin that
24:25
sold the Son of God for 30 pieces of silver.
24:28
Judas traded the bread of life. He exchanged eternal treasure
24:32
for pocket change. When an elder flirts with greed,
24:35
when he compromises for cash, he's standing in the shadow of
24:38
Judas, not the shadow of Jesus. That thought should terrify us
24:43
into holiness. But there is a solution, and
24:46
it's not just gritting your teeth and trying harder with
24:48
willpower. No, that will never work.
24:50
The solution is what the old Scottish preacher Thomas
24:53
Chalmers called the expulsive power of a new affection.
24:56
The expulsive power of a new affection.
24:58
Explain that. You don't stop loving money just
25:00
by telling yourself stop it. You stop loving money by finding
25:04
a superior treasure. You have to fall in love with
25:06
something better. The treasure hidden in the
25:08
field. Matthew 13.44 The man who finds
25:11
a treasure hidden in a field, what does he do?
25:14
He goes and with joy, sells everything he has to buy that
25:17
field. It wasn't a burden to sell his
25:19
old stuff. It was a joy because he had
25:21
found something of infinitely greater value.
25:23
And Christ is that treasure. Christ is that treasure.
25:26
Our inheritance, as First Peter 1.4 tells us, is imperishable,
25:31
undefiled, and unfading. It's kept in heaven for you.
25:34
It's not in a bank that can fail or a market that can crash.
25:38
When an elder truly, deeply believes that in his bones, the
25:41
glitter of gold starts to look like cheap dust.
25:44
OK, so let's land this plane. Let's get into some very direct
25:47
application. The sources gave us that helpful
25:50
head, heart and hands framework. Let's start with the head.
25:53
What do we need to believe differently?
25:55
1st we have to consciously reject the cultural lie that net
25:58
worth equals spiritual worth. That's a big one.
26:01
We have to reconstruct our whole view of success.
26:04
We have to understand that often the very skills that make a man
26:09
a successful CEO in the corporate world, a focus on the
26:12
bottom line, profit over people, ruthless efficiency, self
26:16
promotion are often the exact opposite of the skills needed
26:19
for shepherding. So just because a man is a
26:22
successful businessman, that doesn't automatically mean he's
26:25
qualified to be an elder. In fact, it might mean he has a
26:27
whole set of habits and instincts that need to be
26:30
unlearned and repented of before he's qualified.
26:32
OK, that's the head. What about the heart?
26:34
The affections. Here we need to ask ourselves
26:37
some sharp diagnostic questions. Does the loss of money cause me
26:41
to despair? Does financial gain make me
26:43
giddy with joy? The answer to those questions
26:45
reveals your functional God. It reveals where your treasure
26:48
really is. Yes, we have to confront the
26:50
idol of security and control that money promises but can
26:53
never deliver. And for the people in the pews,
26:56
this text should be a great comfort.
26:58
If you are poor, this text tells you that you are safe in this
27:01
church. Your value here is not your
27:03
tithe. You are not a number on a
27:05
spreadsheet. And for the wealthy?
27:07
For the wealthy, this is a call to find your deepest joy, not an
27:11
accumulation, but in radical, joyful generosity to become a
27:15
conduit of God's grace, not a reservoir of his resources.
27:19
And finally, the hands. This is the practical rubber
27:23
meets the road part, especially for search committees and elder
27:26
boards. How do we vet for this?
27:28
You can't just look at the resume and listen to a sermon.
27:30
You have to carefully and wisely look at the man's life.
27:34
You you mean his finances? In a sense, I would propose 2
27:37
simple checks. 1st, the giving check.
27:40
Does this man give generously, sacrificially and regularly to
27:44
his local church? If a man wants to lead a
27:46
ministry but doesn't financially invest his own money in that
27:49
mission, he doesn't actually believe in it.
27:51
That's a great point. And the second check.
27:52
The debt check Proverbs 22.7 says the borrower is slave to
27:57
the lender. Is this man drowning in consumer
27:59
debt because of a lavish lifestyle?
28:01
If he is enslaved to creditors, he is desperately vulnerable to
28:04
financial compromise. He's not a freeman.
28:06
And. His reputation outside the
28:08
church. Absolutely.
28:09
First Timothy 3.7 says an elder must be well thought of by
28:13
outsiders. So ask them talk to his former
28:16
employees, his vendors, people in his community.
28:19
Is he known as shrewd in a way that borders on dishonest?
28:23
Or is he known as a man of impeccable integrity?
28:25
What about safeguards for the church as a whole?
28:28
How can a church structure itself to protect against this?
28:32
Plurality is essential. No single elder or pastor should
28:36
ever have sole authority to write checks or control the
28:39
financial results. That is a recipe for disaster.
28:42
Hand balances. Yes, transparency is vital.
28:45
Regular, clear financial reporting to the congregation
28:48
and having clear policies for things like love offerings or
28:51
gifts to the pastor is so important.
28:53
You have to avoid that habit of powerful members slipping cash
28:56
directly to leaders, because that breeds a culture of
28:58
patronage and kills accountability.
29:00
And finally, you said it before, but it's worth repeating.
29:02
Pay your pastor well, support him and his family so that he
29:06
isn't needlessly tempted by poverty, but ensure through the
29:08
vetting process that you have a man who has content in Christ,
29:11
whether he has little or much. This has been a heavy, but I
29:14
think an incredibly necessary deep dive.
29:17
As we wrap up, how would you summarize the core take away
29:21
here? What's the one thing you want
29:22
people to walk away with? The qualification not a lover of
29:25
money is not a throwaway line. It is a guardian of the Gospel
29:29
itself. A man who loves silver
29:31
ultimately loves himself more than the flock.
29:34
He is by definition using the sheep to feed himself, not
29:39
feeding the sheep. I have a final provocative
29:41
thought I want to leave with you, our listener.
29:44
Consider the witness to the outside world we live in, a
29:46
world that is completely enslaved by a Mammon, a world
29:50
where everyone and everything has a price.
29:52
That's. True, when a local church is led
29:54
by a plurality of men who are clearly, demonstrably unbiable
29:58
men whose integrity cannot be purchased, whose convictions are
30:01
not for sale, that serves as an undeniable countercultural
30:04
testimony. It's a powerful apologetic and.
30:06
Proves to a watching world that our God is a generous, life
30:09
giving father, not a demanding taskmaster who can be bought
30:13
off. Generosity and contentment in
30:15
our leaders might just be the ultimate apologetic against the
30:18
world enslaved by money. Thank you for listening to
30:21
Reform Thinking. We hope this has challenged you
30:24
and encouraged you, whether you are a leader, an aspiring elder,
30:27
or a member of Christ's flock. Until next time.