Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Apple Q2 2025 Business Deep Dive: Valuation and Growth
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're here to cut through the
- 0:02noise and get you the essential insights on the companies really
- 0:05shaping our world. And today, well, we're tackling
- 0:08a giant Apple Inc. They just dropped some really
- 0:12impressive earnings, underscoring their massive
- 0:15market presence. But what's really going on under
- 0:18the hood? Our mission today to pull out
- 0:20the key Nuggets from the latest financial data and analysis.
- 0:23We'll explore the fundamentals, the risks, and crucially, try to
- 0:27figure out Apple's true value, especially looking at it, you
- 0:30know, through the lens of someone like Warren Buffett.
- 0:32It's a fascinating company to analyze, Absolutely.
- 0:34Apple holds such a unique spot, doesn't it?
- 0:36And valuing something so dominant yet always evolving
- 0:40well means looking way beyond just the headlines.
- 0:42OK. So let's unpack those latest
- 0:43numbers then. Fiscal Q32025 ended June, you
- 0:47said. Impressive.
- 0:48What stood out? Right.
- 0:49They were definitely robust. Revenue came in near $94
- 0:52billion. That's a record for Q3, up a
- 0:54solid 10% year over year, beating expectations 10%.
- 0:57Wow. Yeah.
- 0:58And earnings per share also topped the forecasts.
- 1:00Stock got a nice little bump after hours, about 2%.
- 1:03So what drove that? Still the iPhone.
- 1:05Oh, absolutely. IPhone sales were huge, over $44
- 1:09billion, up 13% year over year. Seems the iPhone 16 demand was
- 1:13really strong. Apple specifically called out a
- 1:16record quarter for upgraders, which is interesting.
- 1:18Record upgraders, huh? And did they hit some massive
- 1:21iPhone milestone recently? They did just recently shipped
- 1:25their three billionth iPhone since 2007. 3 billion.
- 1:29That scale is just hard to grasp.
- 1:31It really is. And then there's services that
- 1:34continues its climb an all time high over $27 billion, also up
- 1:38around 13% and get this well over 1 billion paid
- 1:42subscriptions now across their various services.
- 1:45A billion Subs. So it's not just growth, it's
- 1:47showing how well they monetize that massive user base, right,
- 1:51even when the overall phone market might be slowing.
- 1:53Exactly. It speaks volumes about their
- 1:55resilience. And Tim Cook, the CEO, he
- 1:57touched on AI during the earnings call.
- 1:58Oh yeah. What did he say?
- 2:00Investing more there. Definitely.
- 2:01He mentioned significantly growing R&D and AI, so they're
- 2:05very open to acquisitions to speed things up.
- 2:08And he even teased a more personalized Siri may be coming
- 2:12in 2026 using on device AI. So they're clearly looking
- 2:15ahead. Right, playing the long game.
- 2:17And it all feeds back into that famous walled garden, you know,
- 2:21their hardware, software ecosystem.
- 2:24If you look at the breakdown say from FY20 23, iPhone is still
- 2:28king, about 52% of revenue. But services, that's 22% and
- 2:33it's high margin, very high margin.
- 2:35Then you've got Mac, iPad, wearables making up the rest.
- 2:38This whole interconnected system, it just breeds
- 2:41incredible customer loyalty. And that steady recurring income
- 2:44leads to, well, pretty amazing profitability.
- 2:47Think a 25% Net margin in FY20 20.
- 2:50Three, and the sheer number of devices out there.
- 2:51Over 2.35 billion active devices worldwide.
- 2:54That's the engine. That's what drives it all.
- 2:56OK, that ecosystem is clearly a powerhouse, but no companies
- 2:59invincible, right? Even Apple?
- 3:01What about the headwinds? What are the immediate
- 3:03challenges you see? Well, you always have the
- 3:04broader economy, right? Consumer demand can fluctuate
- 3:08with inflation or downturns. That's a constant, sure, and
- 3:11supply chains can still be tricky.
- 3:13Remember the COVID shutdowns hitting the iPhone 14 Pro
- 3:16supply? Things like that can pop.
- 3:17Up right external shocks. And more specifically, tariffs
- 3:21and trade policy are a direct cost.
- 3:23Apple mentioned about $800 million in tariff costs just in
- 3:26Q3 FY25. Ouch.
- 3:28Yeah, and they expect it to be even higher next quarter, maybe
- 3:31$1.1 billion. They're trying to mitigate it,
- 3:34of course, optimizing the supply chain, even exploring more US
- 3:37production options, but it's a definite drag.
- 3:40OK. So those are the near term
- 3:42pressures. But stepping back, what about
- 3:44the bigger, maybe more structural risks, long term
- 3:47stuff? Yeah, that raises some important
- 3:49questions. First off, market saturation,
- 3:52especially in developed markets with over a billion active
- 3:55iPhones, future growth really comes from people upgrading or
- 3:58switching from Android. It's not like the early days of
- 4:01massive new user adoption. So that naturally kind of caps
- 4:05the hardware growth potential, doesn't it?
- 4:07Puts a ceiling on it, yeah. Then there's the whole
- 4:09innovation question. The perception, fair or not,
- 4:13that maybe innovation has slowed a bit under Tim Cook compared to
- 4:17the jobs era. People do talk about that is the
- 4:19next big thing coming. Exactly the Vision Pro headset
- 4:22coming soon. That's a massive test.
- 4:25Will it create a whole new platform or will it be more
- 4:29niche? If it's niche, Apple's reliance
- 4:32on the iPhone just continues, right?
- 4:35And you also hear concerns about whether Apple is keeping pace in
- 4:38areas like, say, cloud AI or generative AI compared to Google
- 4:42or Microsoft. That could matter long term.
- 4:45And regulation that seems to be heating up everywhere for Big
- 4:47Tech. Absolutely.
- 4:48Regulatory risk is huge. You've got antitrust probes,
- 4:51especially in Europe with the Digital Markets Act that's
- 4:54forcing Apple to allow third party app stores on the iPhone.
- 4:57That could really start to chip away at their services model,
- 4:59especially that 30% App Store Commission.
- 5:01That's a big profit center. Yeah, the 30% cut is legendary.
- 5:05And finally, you can't ignore the geopolitical side.
- 5:07Apple's heavy reliance on China. It's huge for manufacturing.
- 5:10Anna's market like 19% of sales in today's world.
- 5:14That concentration is a significant structural risk.
- 5:17OK, so a lot to navigate there. Yeah.
- 5:19Given all that and their massive profits, where does the money
- 5:22actually go? What are the big cost drivers
- 5:24for Apple? It's a good question and the
- 5:26cost structure tells you a lot. The biggest variable cost is
- 5:30cost of goods sold or CUDG. Yes, that's components assembly
- 5:33shipping for every iPhone, Mac, etcetera, right.
- 5:37Scales with sales. Exactly.
- 5:39It eats up over half their revenue, around 55%.
- 5:42But Even so, they maintain a really strong gross margin
- 5:45around 44. Percent.
- 5:47How do they manage that scale? Scale is huge, Yeah.
- 5:49Let's negotiate hard on component prices.
- 5:52Plus designing their own ships like the Apple Silicon.
- 5:54That reduces reliance on others and helps control costs.
- 5:57It's very smart. OK.
- 5:58So that's variable costs. What about fixed costs?
- 6:00The big one there and the fastest growing is research and
- 6:03development R&D. The innovation engine.
- 6:07Precisely. It hit over $31 billion in FY20.
- 6:1024. Just think a decade ago is
- 6:12around $6 billion. That's a massive ramp up.
- 6:15Wow, what are they spending that on?
- 6:16Future stuff. You bet.
- 6:18Things like ARVR, obviously the Vision Pro, autonomous systems,
- 6:23they're investing heavily in what's next.
- 6:25Then you have SG and a selling general and admin that's
- 6:28marketing ads, the retail stores that was around $26 billion in
- 6:322024. Still a lot, but less than R&D
- 6:35now. Right.
- 6:36And here's the thing, even with those big numbers, their total
- 6:40operating expenses are actually pretty low as a percentage of
- 6:42revenue, maybe 1415%. So very efficient operation.
- 6:46Incredibly efficient. They have amazing operational
- 6:48leverage. They really know how to turn
- 6:50revenue into profit. OK.
- 6:52So they manage costs while they're investing heavily.
- 6:55Let's talk about the people who's steering the ship and how
- 6:59are they aligned with shareholders.
- 7:01Well, the leadership team is remarkably stable, which is a
- 7:03big plus. Tim Cook, of course, has been
- 7:05CEO since 2011. And many of the key execs, Luca
- 7:09Maestri, the CFO, managing capital return, Jeff Williams,
- 7:12the COO, Craig Federigie on software, they're Apple
- 7:15veterans. Many came up under Steve Jobs.
- 7:17There's a lot of continuity there.
- 7:19And they've delivered, haven't they, under Cook?
- 7:21Absolutely. Revenue and profit have roughly
- 7:24tripled under his tenure. He's steered them to just
- 7:27unprecedented heights. Master of Operations.
- 7:30And are their interests aligned with shareholders?
- 7:32Do they own stock? Very much so.
- 7:35Executives hold significant amounts of stock.
- 7:37Tim Cook himself has something like 3.3 million shares.
- 7:41Worth what, Over $700 million? Wow.
- 7:44And their compensation is tied directly to performance metrics.
- 7:48Remember Cook took that 40% pay cut in 2023.
- 7:51That was actually after shareholder feedback shows they
- 7:53listen. Interesting.
- 7:54Who are the big outside shareholders then, besides the
- 7:57usual big funds? Well, you have the giants like
- 8:00Vanguard and BlackRock holding large stakes, but the really
- 8:03notable 1 is Berkshire Hathaway Buffett.
- 8:05Exactly. Warren Buffett's firm owns about
- 8:075.8% of Apple. And maybe more striking, Apple
- 8:11makes up something like 25% of Berkshire's entire portfolio.
- 8:13It's a huge position. Quarter of the portfolio, That's
- 8:16conviction. Do shareholders like Berkshire
- 8:18have much sway? They definitely have influence.
- 8:21While institutions often vote with the board, we've seen
- 8:23shareholder proposals gain traction.
- 8:25There was one on a civil rights audit in 2022 that passed, and
- 8:29that executive pay vote in 2023 that led to Cook's adjustment.
- 8:33So yes, shareholders can shape policy.
- 8:36OK, so management seems aligned. Big investors are watching.
- 8:39How does Apple actually give back value to shareholders?
- 8:43Besides, you know, the stock going up?
- 8:45Buybacks are a huge part of their story.
- 8:47Right. Oh, enormous.
- 8:48It's one of the defining features of Apple's capital
- 8:50return strategy. Just recently, the board
- 8:53authorized another $110 billion for share repurchases.
- 8:57Another 110 billion. That's one of the biggest ever,
- 9:00isn't it? It really is, and it signals
- 9:02tremendous confidence from the board and management in the
- 9:04company's future value. And the long term impact, how
- 9:07much have they bought back over time?
- 9:08The numbers are staggering. Over the last decade, Apple has
- 9:11repurchased over $600 billion of its own stock. 600 billion.
- 9:15Yeah, and the effect is profound.
- 9:18The number of shares outstanding has dropped by roughly 40%
- 9:21between 2014 and 2024. 40% fewer shares, so that boosts earnings
- 9:26per share automatically. Precisely.
- 9:28And it increases the ownership percentage for everyone who
- 9:31holds on to their shares. Think about Buffett's steak.
- 9:34It went from about 5.6% to 5.8% between 2022 and 2024.
- 9:41Without him buying any more shares.
- 9:42Exactly. The buybacks effectively
- 9:45increased his slice of the pie. It's a powerful mechanism.
- 9:48It shows management believes the stock is a good investment and
- 9:51they're committed to returning cash to shareholders.
- 9:54Their stated goal is to become cash neutral over time, meaning
- 9:57returning excess cash. OK.
- 9:59So that brings us to the big question for value investors.
- 10:02What is Apple really worth? Buffett calls it the best
- 10:06business I know in the world. He bought a ton of it.
- 10:09How does someone like him actually value a company like
- 10:11this? Right.
- 10:11So we try to estimate its intrinsic value.
- 10:13Buffett's preferred method, conceptually at least, is
- 10:16discounted free cash flow, or DFCF, what he sometimes calls
- 10:19owners earnings. OK, how does that work
- 10:21basically? You project the company's future
- 10:23free cash flow, the actual cash leftover for owners after
- 10:26running the business and reinvesting.
- 10:28For Apple, that was around $110 billion in F Hathgon 2024.
- 10:33Then you discount those future cash flows back to their present
- 10:36value using a discount rate. Let's use 10%, which is a common
- 10:39hurdle rate for a stable business like Apple and you run
- 10:42different growth scenarios for that cash flow.
- 10:44Got you. So what are the numbers look
- 10:45like? OK, let's run a few.
- 10:47If we're super conservative, assume 0% growth in free cash
- 10:52flow forever. The intrinsic value per share
- 10:55comes out around $84. Which is way below where it
- 10:58trades now, around 207 dollars. Exactly.
- 11:00Tells you the market expects growth.
- 11:02Now let's use a nominal growth rate, say 8% per year for 10
- 11:06years, then slower growth. That's roughly Apple's
- 11:08historical average FCF growth. That gets you an intrinsic value
- 11:11of about $156 per share. Still below the current price,
- 11:15less margin of safety then. Right now, what if we're more
- 11:18optimistic? Assume 12% annual FCF growth for
- 11:22a decade. That pushes the intrinsic value
- 11:24up to around $202.00 per share. OK.
- 11:27Now we're very close to the current market price of $207.
- 11:30We are, which suggests the market might be, you know,
- 11:34pricing for perfection or baking in quite strong consistent
- 11:37growth for years to come. So the take away on valuation.
- 11:41At today's price around 277, using that 10% discount rate,
- 11:44Apple looks fully valued, maybe even a touch overvalued.
- 11:47The implied return you might expect buying today if it grows
- 11:50around that 8% historical rate is probably closer to 8.5% or
- 11:549%, not the 10% we used as a. Hurdle.
- 11:56Interesting. So if it's not obviously cheap
- 11:58now, how does Apple stack up against Buffett's famous
- 12:01checklist? The rules for a great company
- 12:04separate from price. The checklist.
- 12:06This is where it gets really revealing about why Buffett
- 12:09likely made an exception on price.
- 12:11Let's run through it. OK, first valuation discipline.
- 12:14Classic Buffet. Like PE under 15, PB under 1.5.
- 12:18Apple's PE is 31, PB is 55. Clear fail on the strict
- 12:22numbers. No, 25% margin of safety at this
- 12:25price. But he bought it anyway, so
- 12:27quality trumped price. It seems so.
- 12:29He likely saw the business quality as justifying paying up,
- 12:32something he's increasingly done for exceptional companies.
- 12:34OK, next. Cash generation and allocation.
- 12:37Huge pass here. Consistently massive free cash
- 12:40flow. FCF margins well over 2528%.
- 12:43Excellent returns on retained capital.
- 12:46Apple is a cash machine and returns tons via buybacks.
- 12:50Total buffet territory. Right growth.
- 12:52Growth in predictability, earnings per share generally
- 12:55rising, but not every single year without fail.
- 12:57So maybe a partial pass book value per share has actually
- 13:00gone down. Right down isn't that bad.
- 13:02Not necessarily here. It's because of the huge
- 13:04buybacks, shrinking the equity base.
- 13:06It's intentional, boosts EPS and ownership.
- 13:09So context matters. Owners earnings are strongly
- 13:11positive pass, but the free cash flow yield FCF relative to
- 13:15market cap is only about 3.5% below Buffett's ideal 10% fail.
- 13:20OK. Nuanced picture on growth?
- 13:21What about safety balance sheet? Balance sheet safety.
- 13:24Formally the debt to equity ratio is high, around 1.7, way
- 13:27above Buffett's .5 rule fail. Yeah, the reason the equity is
- 13:32low is the buybacks and their ability to cover interest
- 13:35payments is incredibly strong. Like 30-40 times earnings pass.
- 13:39They have tons of cash and liquidity, so while it fails the
- 13:42ratio, the substance is very safe.
- 13:44It's about capital structure optimization, not distress.
- 13:47Gotcha. Context again.
- 13:49Finally, profitability. Profitability and efficiency.
- 13:51This is where Apple just knocks it out of the park.
- 13:54Gross margin consistently over 40% pass.
- 13:57Net profit margin around 25% Pass.
- 13:59Return on equity is over 100%. Return on invested capital
- 14:03around 46%, vastly above typical thresholds.
- 14:06Pass with flying colors. Low depreciation relative to
- 14:09profit to pass. This is the definition of a
- 14:12wonderful business in Buffett's terms.
- 14:14So summing up the Buffett lens, an absolutely stellar business,
- 14:17but maybe not a bargain stock price right now.
- 14:19That's a great way to put it. Apple the business A+ stack
- 14:23checks almost all the quality boxes spectacularly well.
- 14:25Mote, profitability, cash generation.
- 14:28Apple the stock. At a $3 trillion market cap,
- 14:31it's priced such that future returns for new investors might
- 14:34be more modest. Not the kind of returns Buffett
- 14:36got buying back in 20/16/2018 when it was much cheaper
- 14:40relative to earnings. And the fact he's holding, not
- 14:42selling. Exactly.
- 14:44It implies he's very comfortable holding this incredible business
- 14:47for the long haul given its durable Moat.
- 14:49Even if he's not adding aggressively at these prices.
- 14:51He found a wonderful business at a fair price back then.
- 14:54Today, it's arguably a wonderful business at a full price.
- 14:57It really is a fascinating paradox, isn't it?
- 15:00Exceptional quality often commands that premium price.
- 15:03It does, and it leaves you, the listener, with a question to
- 15:06ponder right as you look at Apple's future.
- 15:09Where does the true value lie? Is it in nailing the price you
- 15:13pay for future growth? Or is it in the enduring power
- 15:16of a business so fundamentally strong it can shower
- 15:18shareholders with cash while pouring billions into its next
- 15:20potential game changer? Like personalized AI for Siri,
- 15:23it really challenges that traditional deep value playbook.
- 15:26It'll be fascinating to watch how Apple continues to navigate
- 15:29saturation, competition, regulation, all while trying to
- 15:32invent the future.