Latest / The Vegan Report / Breaking Free from the Tribe. With Andres Rafael Rodriguez | Ep. 62
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan and if you are vegan, let me remind you of
- 0:07how amazing that is.
- 0:10What you have done is breaking free from 16,000 years of conditioning that makes us humans
- 0:18see other animals as mere objects of exploitation.
- 0:24And by doing so, your world has grown livelier, more exciting and kinder.
- 0:32Above all else, what I admire the most in my fellow vegans is that very independent
- 0:39mindedness, that capacity to think and feel against the strong winds of normalized animal
- 0:48exploitation.
- 0:50And this is what today's episode is about.
- 0:53Staying faithful to that independence of mind, to avoid the trappings of mob mentality and
- 1:02tribalism, even when that push to conform and abandon critical thinking comes from within
- 1:10the vegan community.
- 1:12To discuss this topic, I have with me Andres.
- 1:16Andres is a long time vegan activist and a returning guest of the show.
- 1:21You might recognize him from episode 10 of the podcast titled Identifying as a Vegan
- 1:28Conservative.
- 1:30Link to that episode and more in the show notes.
- 2:00Thanks, Andres for doing
- 2:19the landing.
- 2:21but I'm gonna do what makes sense to me.
- 2:24And so growing up, I did hold more liberal values,
- 2:27but as time goes on and I learn more about history
- 2:31and culture changes and all that,
- 2:33it does seem like a lot of my views
- 2:36have landed with more conservative values.
- 2:40And what I was gonna say is that especially growing up
- 2:43in music and art and underground scenes and all that,
- 2:46it's almost expected that you would be liberal
- 2:50or leftist, but when I think about the values
- 2:56that I cherish, it seems to line up with more conservative
- 3:02and libertarian values.
- 3:04And then becoming vegan,
- 3:07I am now understanding that it doesn't require
- 3:12a certain political belief or political background
- 3:14to be vegan.
- 3:15And even though there are appeals to tradition
- 3:21with conservatism and approaching a vegan world
- 3:26is inherently progressive, right?
- 3:28We're progressing towards that vegan world.
- 3:31I still think that there are many links
- 3:33to the vegan principle and conservative values.
- 3:37So I imagine that we'll be touching on some of those today.
- 3:40Definitely, I feel the same way.
- 3:45I feel like when I was a kid,
- 3:49things that belonged on the left,
- 3:54those things I was very much engaged with.
- 3:57And then growing up, you develop critical thinking
- 4:01and you start thinking,
- 4:06why do I have this tribal mindset?
- 4:08Why do I have to accept the entire left bundle?
- 4:14Why can't I just choose ideas from the left,
- 4:17from the right, use my critical thinking skills
- 4:21and just look for the truth?
- 4:23So there's this French writer, Albert Camus,
- 4:27most people know him.
- 4:29And he once, he's quoted saying,
- 4:33I'm not on the left, I'm not on the right,
- 4:35I'm with the truth.
- 4:37And I followed the truth wherever it takes me.
- 4:40And I started feeling more and more that way.
- 4:44Maybe a concrete example of that would be,
- 4:47that intersects with veganism too, is the environment.
- 4:52There's a lot of nonsense coming from the left
- 4:57about the environment.
- 4:59Maybe a good example of that would be windmills.
- 5:03I'm against windmills, they kill so many birds.
- 5:10When you have them on the ocean floor,
- 5:14they create sound barriers that kill lots of whales
- 5:18and marine life.
- 5:20It's just a horrible idea.
- 5:23And aesthetically, it's just, it doesn't look good.
- 5:27And surprisingly, the one that criticizes windmills is now,
- 5:34Trump, you hear him talk about how it's bad
- 5:38for the environment and you think, wait, why is this,
- 5:45it's supposed to be the left talking about,
- 5:48critically about such things.
- 5:50Why is Trump talking about windmills?
- 5:53I think on the Joe Rogan experience.
- 5:55And saying what everyone knows, but doesn't say out loud.
- 6:03So you find nuggets of nonsensical positions here and there,
- 6:10and you start being more skeptical about your views
- 6:14and where you are on the political spectrum.
- 6:17And like you said, why do we have to choose a tribe?
- 6:20Yep, and you start to realize that it becomes
- 6:26so much more nuanced than what people believe
- 6:29or what people perpetuate out there
- 6:31that if you are a person who has voted
- 6:35for a particular candidate,
- 6:36you must have all these characteristics or traits about you
- 6:41and you must have all these beliefs
- 6:43as if we're not complex beings who can have nuanced takes
- 6:47on down the political spectrum talking with each topic.
- 6:55So yeah, conservatives can care about the environment
- 6:59and conservatives can want stewardship for the earth.
- 7:02And then similarly, there could be folks on the left
- 7:07who are a little bit more tight on social issues
- 7:10or folks on the left who might have a nuanced take
- 7:15on something like abortion.
- 7:17And I think we touched on this in the last podcast
- 7:20where we talked a bit about this topic,
- 7:24which of course is very controversial and contentious.
- 7:27So we don't have to go too far down it,
- 7:29but one thing that I have come to believe
- 7:33through years of thinking about politics and moral issues
- 7:39is that similar to how veganism,
- 7:42this is the theory of mine, but a firm belief
- 7:45that similar to how veganism is not tied
- 7:48to a political lane,
- 7:51I also believe that abortion should not be tied
- 7:57to a political lane or a side of the political spectrum.
- 8:01And I know that it seems kind of outlandish
- 8:03for somebody who is in the United States to believe so
- 8:05because especially with this last election,
- 8:07it was so divided where if you're voting Democrat,
- 8:11it must be that you are pro-abortion.
- 8:14If you're voting Republican,
- 8:15it must be that you're abortion.
- 8:17But I think that that's just the way
- 8:20that culturally it has come to.
- 8:24Is my connection unstable?
- 8:25Was I glitching out a second?
- 8:27So there are a few words that were lost,
- 8:30but I think we understand the overall.
- 8:32The point that I was making was that through time,
- 8:35the political parties, I believe,
- 8:37have chosen to latch onto this issue
- 8:40in order to create like a clear divide on this.
- 8:43And the left has made it like a women's rights issue
- 8:46and the right has made it a religious issue
- 8:50when my personal belief is that it's a moral issue
- 8:53and it shouldn't be tied to political parties.
- 8:56So that's just one little nugget I wanted to drop in there
- 9:01that this particular issue, similar to veganism,
- 9:04I think is more tied to morals than it is to politics.
- 9:08And just going back to what we were saying,
- 9:10it's so nuanced and it can be, and it should be,
- 9:13and we should be able to have these kinds of conversations
- 9:16without putting each other in boxes and saying that like,
- 9:20these must be all if you voted a particular way,
- 9:23or if you have a certain view economically
- 9:26on one side of the spectrum,
- 9:29it must be that all your other views
- 9:31are on that side of the spectrum.
- 9:35And it's simply not the case.
- 9:38Absolutely.
- 9:39And let me get, because I read the book recently,
- 9:45well, not recently, like a few months ago,
- 9:48called Beating Hearts,
- 9:50and it's about the intersection of abortion
- 9:53and animal rights.
- 9:55And that book really pushed me to be critical
- 10:00on my views about abortion.
- 10:04And I just want to read the introduction,
- 10:08of the book because it,
- 10:12I feel it really captures why
- 10:17this debate of abortion intersecting with animal rights
- 10:22is not that straightforward.
- 10:25So just give me a minute.
- 10:28Sure.
- 10:30Guess there are lots of romance book called Beating Hearts.
- 10:35I typed Beating Hearts abortion animal rights,
- 10:39and it came up immediately.
- 10:40Oh, okay.
- 10:43So this is how,
- 10:45so I guess the back of the book,
- 10:47this is what you can read.
- 10:49How can someone who condemns hunting,
- 10:52animal farming and animal experimentation
- 10:55also favor legal abortion,
- 10:58which is the deliberate destruction of a human fetus?
- 11:01The authors of Beating Hearts aim to reconcile
- 11:04this apparent conflict and examine the surprisingly similar
- 11:07strategic and tactical questions faced by activists
- 11:11in the pro-life and animal rights movement.
- 11:15And I do recommend this book,
- 11:17like highly, highly recommend the book.
- 11:20It's from a lawyer called Michael C. Dorff,
- 11:24and he's his wife who
- 11:29has, is now deceased.
- 11:31But it really goes into the details of why this is,
- 11:38you know, the default view of pro-choice versus pro-life
- 11:43is not that straightforward.
- 11:44And if you are a vegan, if you believe in animal rights,
- 11:49you should look at this debate with more nuances.
- 11:54So yeah, it did make me ask the question,
- 11:58why do I support abortion when
- 12:03I don't kill mosquitoes?
- 12:08Yeah, yeah, I think, you know,
- 12:10through thinking about this over time as well,
- 12:13I have, and I guess we are going down this conversation,
- 12:16I was gonna say maybe we could touch on it,
- 12:19but not dive in, but if you wanna dive in,
- 12:22I definitely have thought about this quite a bit.
- 12:24And I see through my advocacy, you know,
- 12:27having developed a firm anti-abortion stance,
- 12:30I should be clear on that,
- 12:33and through no affiliation to politics
- 12:37and through no religious beliefs.
- 12:39I have certain particular religious beliefs.
- 12:42I'm not necessarily an atheist,
- 12:44but my views on abortion and veganism for that matter,
- 12:50are not related to politics or religion.
- 12:52It's simply a moral issue.
- 12:55And I, you know, through my advocacy,
- 12:57my anti-abortion advocacy,
- 12:59I have sensed that there are parallels
- 13:05in the reasoning that people use for being pro-abortion
- 13:09and that people use for being non-vegan.
- 13:12And just for the sake of clarity,
- 13:15I do wanna announce that I'll be using anti-abortion
- 13:18and pro-abortion for clarity,
- 13:21rather than pro-life and pro-choice.
- 13:23I feel like those are euphemisms, truthfully,
- 13:28if we're saying pro-choice,
- 13:30we're saying pro the choice to abort.
- 13:33So we can just kind of shorten it to pro-abort
- 13:36or pro-abortion and then anti-abortion,
- 13:38which is where I land.
- 13:41And yeah, as I mentioned,
- 13:44there are plenty of parallels that I see
- 13:47between pro-abortion and non-vegan arguments.
- 13:50There's a sense of devaluing each individual
- 13:57where I believe that there's a life at conception
- 14:00and a unique individual at conception.
- 14:02And so people will justify it by saying,
- 14:05well, it's just a clump of cells.
- 14:07And that's similar to what we hear non-vegans say,
- 14:10well, it's just an animal.
- 14:11It's not a worthy being.
- 14:14You know, we can assign the value to this being.
- 14:18So that's like one parallel there.
- 14:21The convenience argument is very popular with non-vegans
- 14:25and it's very popular with pro-aborts
- 14:27where they're saying it's easier for me to exploit animals
- 14:31and it's easier for me to abort this pregnancy,
- 14:35get on with my life and just wash my hands and move on.
- 14:39Cultural conditioning is big.
- 14:41Society normalizes both animal exploitation and abortion,
- 14:45especially in art and underground and music scenes
- 14:48that I run around in, it's like, it's expected.
- 14:52I think because of the framing culturally that abortion
- 14:56and being pro-abortion is a woman's rights issue.
- 15:01It's a lot of like words that are used
- 15:04to have people believe a certain thing
- 15:07when the victim in this situation would be the individual
- 15:10who has his or her life removed from them,
- 15:13robbed from them.
- 15:14The opportunity that they have to live
- 15:16has been taken from them due to somebody else's decision.
- 15:19And that's where I'm against that.
- 15:22And then just a couple more here going down the list,
- 15:25the power dynamic.
- 15:27This one I would say is maybe the biggest overlap
- 15:30is that there's a more powerful individual
- 15:33who's exploiting a vulnerable individual
- 15:36in the case of animal exploitation
- 15:38and in the case of abortion.
- 15:40And if I'm against it on one end,
- 15:44I must be against it on the other end.
- 15:46And I should add that I arrived at the anti-abortion position
- 15:51after becoming vegan
- 15:53and after understanding the vegan principle.
- 15:57And yeah, this last one was euphemism,
- 16:00which we touched on earlier.
- 16:01Euphemisms like pro-choice, like women's rights,
- 16:05and euphemisms like meat or humane slaughter
- 16:09or processing, harvesting, all these things
- 16:12that are sanitizing the act of exploiting others.
- 16:17So yeah, I've given this some thought.
- 16:21I've even thought about making content,
- 16:23talking more about how similar these issues are
- 16:26and how I believe that they are two
- 16:28of society's biggest moral blind spots.
- 16:31But again, I also similarly want to detangle
- 16:36the abortion issue from politics,
- 16:38even though it does align with conservatism,
- 16:41I don't believe that it should be such an issue
- 16:44that's tied to politics.
- 16:47Then you should definitely get the book
- 16:49because they even go into the details
- 16:51of analyzing the activism of pro, sorry, pro-life
- 17:02and animal rights activists.
- 17:05For instance, by showing the tactic,
- 17:09by talking about the tactic of showing footage
- 17:12of a fetus getting killed or aborted,
- 17:19and how animal rights activists do the same
- 17:22with animal abuse footage, which is very fascinating,
- 17:29the parallels of those two.
- 17:31Yeah, yeah, and a lot of it is street advocacy,
- 17:34sidewalk counseling outside of an abortion facility,
- 17:38and street activism with veganism.
- 17:42And for anybody who might be listening
- 17:44who is maybe firmly pro and still,
- 17:48or maybe firmly pro-abortion and still believing this
- 17:52to be something that only people who want to control women
- 17:57or exploit women or who dislike women,
- 18:01it's a misogynist act, I just want to lay the foundation
- 18:06with both activists, an animal rights activist
- 18:09and an anti-abortion activist.
- 18:11It's coming from a place of love and respect
- 18:14and wanting what's best for everyone.
- 18:16It's not that we want the woman to suffer
- 18:19and the child to succeed, we want what's best for everyone.
- 18:24It's similar with animal rights messaging.
- 18:26We don't want people to, families to suffer
- 18:31because now the farmer can't provide for his family.
- 18:33And it's like, we're not here wanting worse for people,
- 18:37we just want justice, we want fairness,
- 18:40and we want to achieve a world
- 18:42where others aren't being exploited
- 18:44based on someone else's decision.
- 18:46We don't have that right to impede
- 18:50on someone else's wellbeing.
- 18:54And that goes back to conservatism and libertarian values,
- 18:59individual freedoms to exist freely,
- 19:05to not be exploited, to not be enslaved.
- 19:08And with the abortion issue,
- 19:10I know that many people will paint the pregnant mother
- 19:13as the one who's being exploited
- 19:15or the one who's being forced into a decision,
- 19:19but it's a situation where there's another individual
- 19:23who's being affected if you go through with this operation.
- 19:27And we already disagree with affecting the fetus
- 19:31by drinking, smoking, or doing drugs.
- 19:34So it should just extend that we also want what's best
- 19:38for the individual to not unnecessarily rob his only chance
- 19:44at being born or at existing.
- 19:49Yes, definitely.
- 19:50And that's the shift that happened to me.
- 19:53I think I had the wrong perception
- 19:57and I had some prejudices on what it meant to be pro-life.
- 20:02And I felt like this was a misguided position
- 20:07based on all patriarchal values.
- 20:12And then I discovered through reading, beating hearts,
- 20:15that there is actually a very convincing case
- 20:18for being pro-life, which made me respect that position.
- 20:23I don't think I became pro-life.
- 20:28I think I'm still pro-abortion, pro-choice,
- 20:34but within asterisks.
- 20:36Now it's not as black and white as I used to be.
- 20:41For instance, here in Quebec, where I live in Canada,
- 20:46there is no, I think so, I looked it up,
- 20:53and I think there is no limit for abortion.
- 20:56So you can have abortion at any time.
- 20:59And I find this to be just horrific morally.
- 21:05I think that if your child can be brought to life
- 21:10and sustain itself without the help of the mother,
- 21:19why do you have to kill that child?
- 21:24But it does happen.
- 21:29So yeah.
- 21:30Yeah, and that brings me to another parallel
- 21:33that I can think of, which reflects a breakthrough
- 21:38that I've had with my ideas on veganism
- 21:41and understanding veganism a little bit more,
- 21:44which we can go into in a bit,
- 21:46but I do wanna identify this other parallel
- 21:49that I thought of now, which has come to me before.
- 21:52But when we're talking about abortion happening
- 21:59at some point between conception and the nine months,
- 22:01you do hear many people who might be a little bit
- 22:03more moderate on the topic saying,
- 22:06well, I think I should have a choice to abort the fetus,
- 22:10but not after a certain amount of time,
- 22:13because at that point it becomes cruel.
- 22:16At that point, it's a little bit worse than the other case.
- 22:20And it might be worse because the child might have
- 22:23a more developed sense of sentience
- 22:27and a more developed sense of consciousness.
- 22:29It might be worse because there is actually a viable way
- 22:34for this child to be delivered
- 22:36and kept alive outside of the womb.
- 22:39So people will categorize that in their minds as saying,
- 22:42this is better welfare for the individual
- 22:46than this over here.
- 22:48So I'm against this kind of late-term abortion,
- 22:51but I'm pro earlier term abortion.
- 22:55And that brings me to like welfareism
- 22:57with animal exploitation, where we're saying,
- 23:01like these certain practices I'm really against.
- 23:04I'm really against the factory farming and all that,
- 23:06but small local farms or other forms of exploitation
- 23:10are okay when my stance on both topics
- 23:14are that at conception, there's a unique individual
- 23:17who has his or her own DNA,
- 23:19who will continue existing unless there's some interruption.
- 23:23And so interrupting that after the child has been conceived
- 23:28is morally wrong and similar to with exploitation.
- 23:31Like the vegan objective is to rid the exploitation
- 23:37of animals by humans.
- 23:39So it doesn't matter the scale, the level of suffering,
- 23:44the abuse versus use, it's simply that there's an individual
- 23:50who's having his or her autonomy taken from them
- 23:54and is being used for someone else's benefit.
- 23:57That's the line that's drawn.
- 24:00It's a stance against exploitation.
- 24:02So that's just another thing that came to me
- 24:06that I'm thinking that like, it's more of a hard cut.
- 24:09If you're into philosophy, it's like a deontological decision
- 24:14or deontological decision-making
- 24:17rather than a utilitarian thing about maximizing pleasure
- 24:21and reducing suffering.
- 24:23It's more like principally this is wrong.
- 24:26And so regardless of consequences,
- 24:28this is where I draw the line.
- 24:31Yes, on that, I think I have more of the Peter Singer
- 24:36position, which is the degree of sentience
- 24:40and basically the degree of suffering
- 24:43that that being would experience
- 24:47and having to balance that with the degree of suffering
- 24:52that the mother or ex-person would have to go through.
- 24:59Yes, definitely.
- 25:00I mean, I do have this more Peter Singer-esque.
- 25:06Where there's like a range of suffering
- 25:10and you can make a calculation and balance it out.
- 25:14Yeah, I understand that for some people it's more on that.
- 25:17I think through my own reflection
- 25:19and thinking and reading, it's become more
- 25:22of like that principle-based.
- 25:25But I understand your own.
- 25:28Would you say that it also is reflected in that way
- 25:32with veganism as far as like a reduction of suffering
- 25:38as opposed to a clear stance against exploitation?
- 25:43Yes, now that gets tricky.
- 25:46I want an abolition.
- 25:50I want, I think that there is nothing wrong
- 25:52with being idealistic in your advocacy
- 25:56and asking for the moon.
- 25:59But do I think, does the pragmatic in me think
- 26:03that we will arrive at a point where there is no suffering
- 26:09in exploitation of animals?
- 26:11I don't believe that.
- 26:12I think we should definitely go for the moon,
- 26:17but we will not reach that.
- 26:20And I think that with some audiences,
- 26:24you have to be a welfarist.
- 26:28They are not ready to hear the abolitionist message.
- 26:33They're just not there.
- 26:34Maybe if we had that conversation in like 50 years,
- 26:39hopefully less, but realistically in a hundred years,
- 26:45my answer would have been different.
- 26:47But I think for now, I see the world
- 26:51and I think that the abolition of all animal exploitation
- 26:56is not something that most people in the world
- 27:00would be receptive of because of cultural differences,
- 27:04because of religious beliefs, and the list goes on.
- 27:08So have you tried, because we can talk a bit
- 27:12about this breakthrough that I've had
- 27:14in the last year or so,
- 27:17and it's great that you had Ben Mazaya on recently,
- 27:22because he is certainly an influence on me.
- 27:26And there are a group of other activists online
- 27:29who have helped me make a connection
- 27:33to the vegan objective, the vegan principle,
- 27:36and just the way that it should be represented
- 27:41in ways that like completely went against
- 27:46what I was doing before,
- 27:47and the things that I believed before.
- 27:49And so what they are talking about, of course,
- 27:53is the original definition developed by Leslie Cross.
- 27:57And I know that you and Ben had a conversation about that,
- 28:00and how the vegan objective, as I mentioned earlier,
- 28:04is to rid the exploitation of animals by humans.
- 28:09And I began understanding veganism more as,
- 28:12rather than like adopting a set of beliefs,
- 28:15or even adopting a set of practices,
- 28:19it became something where I'm believing it to be
- 28:23that we're unlearning biases that society has imposed on us.
- 28:28And we're recognizing the individual in other animals.
- 28:34And I think that that's a message
- 28:36that simplifies the whole conversation,
- 28:41and makes it something that anyone can accept,
- 28:46going back to anyone on the political spectrum,
- 28:48religious or secular, adult or child.
- 28:52I believe that if we're telling people
- 28:54that animals exist for their own purposes,
- 28:58rather than to serve humans,
- 29:02conversations about veganism can go totally differently.
- 29:07If we're talking about symptoms,
- 29:11ways that animals are being exploited,
- 29:14we're talking about the state of the world,
- 29:17and we're just for that,
- 29:19people hear that and say,
- 29:21oh, okay, you're giving me something to think about.
- 29:24And they might, but it doesn't inspire change
- 29:29as if you ask somebody,
- 29:32why do you believe that animals exist to serve humans?
- 29:35Or if you ask somebody,
- 29:36do you believe that animals have interests in living freely?
- 29:40Like rather than talking about the suffering,
- 29:45rather than talking about the ways that they are being used,
- 29:49it's talking that they're being used,
- 29:52that they're being exploited and viewed
- 29:55as a resource by humans.
- 29:58And that has kind of shaped my advocacy over the last,
- 30:01I'm gonna say like six months
- 30:03since I've seen these Leslie Cross promoting activists
- 30:07start coming out online.
- 30:08And Ryan, I'll just ask you,
- 30:10have you seen these people,
- 30:12that they're going after people in comment sections,
- 30:15and they're going after some of the big time activists,
- 30:18and it's a small network, but they're pretty loud.
- 30:22Have you come across them?
- 30:24Absolutely not.
- 30:25People need to understand I'm not on social media.
- 30:28I'm not a social media person.
- 30:29I actually actively avoid them.
- 30:32If it was not for this podcast,
- 30:34I would not be on Instagram, I would not be on X.
- 30:37I would be like off the radar.
- 30:41Yeah, yeah, well, I can just give you a quick summary.
- 30:44They are some activists who are promoting
- 30:48the original definition of veganism,
- 30:51which has been mentioned,
- 30:52and I imagine has been mentioned on other times
- 30:56in this podcast, veganism is the doctrine
- 30:59that humans should live without exploiting animals.
- 31:02Some people have tuned it up to say veganism
- 31:04is the principle that humans should live
- 31:06without exploiting animals.
- 31:08And I think that that summarizes it very efficiently,
- 31:12very easily, and you won't have conversations
- 31:15about various things, about lifestyle,
- 31:20about diet, about like a personal choice.
- 31:25If you're framing it as a principle
- 31:28that is a moral obligation,
- 31:32a principle that is rooted in justice,
- 31:35that will skip past, it's kind of like a fast pass
- 31:39on an amusement ride or something.
- 31:40It's like, it skips past all these other points
- 31:44that people are going to be making about welfarism,
- 31:47about reducing suffering, about crop deaths,
- 31:50about diet, personal response, personal choice.
- 31:54All these things kind of get flattened out
- 31:57when you introduce it in that way.
- 32:01And I think that that's a very simple thing
- 32:03to communicate to people.
- 32:05And you may have heard people say that if every vegan,
- 32:11everybody who has a plant-based diet
- 32:12became a vegan activist,
- 32:14we would achieve a vegan world quicker.
- 32:17I think if every vegan activist began reframing
- 32:22their activism as focusing on exploitation
- 32:27and why animals as individuals deserve respect
- 32:32and deserve to live freely,
- 32:35if we reframed our conversation
- 32:37around the exploitation of animals
- 32:40rather than the suffering of animals,
- 32:42my theory is that we would have a vegan world much quicker.
- 32:46It would cut through the fluff
- 32:48and all the distortion that's out there.
- 32:51And there are several activists that maybe I can point you to
- 32:55and have on the channel
- 32:56because I think that they're spreading
- 32:57a lot of great information that worked on me.
- 33:01As soon as I started reading what they were writing,
- 33:03I said, I've been representing this all wrong
- 33:07the whole way, the whole time.
- 33:08You know, I've been misunderstanding this the whole time.
- 33:11And I reframed my advocacy.
- 33:14And now when I do cubes of truth
- 33:16or I'm just talking with anyone about the vegan principle,
- 33:19again, I frame it as a principle
- 33:22and it can really cut through a lot of the fluff.
- 33:26Interesting.
- 33:28You know, my conversation with Ben
- 33:29was one of my most thought provoking conversation
- 33:33on this show.
- 33:37And I'm still digesting everything that was said,
- 33:41but something I brought up to him was
- 33:43you don't have the legitimacy to make this argument
- 33:49to certain crowds of people.
- 33:52And maybe a good example of that would be religious people.
- 33:57You know, you're not a rabbi, you're not an imam,
- 34:00you're not a priest.
- 34:01And you're talking about moral principles
- 34:05to people who don't see you as a figure,
- 34:11a leader in their community
- 34:13or that is able to talk about those things.
- 34:22And then we talked about how there was a lack of advocacy
- 34:27directed to religious communities and religious leaders.
- 34:31But the problem remained, you know,
- 34:34you can't go to a Muslim majority country
- 34:38and be the westerner or the guy with Western ideas
- 34:45who talk about animals being individuals.
- 34:49You need to be one of them to make the case for,
- 34:53or talk about people like El-Mahri,
- 34:56who I had an episode on,
- 35:00on this Arab Syrian vegan dinker
- 35:04who lived hundreds of years ago
- 35:07and who wrote about animals having feelings
- 35:10and sentience and all of that.
- 35:13So it's touchy like that.
- 35:17I think there is, which is beautiful,
- 35:20there is in the West this culture of free speech
- 35:23and we're much less tribal than in the rest of the world,
- 35:28where tribalism is alive and well,
- 35:31and you need to be part of the crowd
- 35:34and you need to conform and there is no such thing
- 35:38as a culture of free speech.
- 35:41Yeah, yeah, I think that you're right.
- 35:44If I was going into a Muslim majority country,
- 35:47the customs are totally different
- 35:48and the habits and traditions are different.
- 35:54So it would be more challenging,
- 35:57but I think anything less than rooting this conversation
- 36:02as a conversation about justice
- 36:05is selling the animals short,
- 36:08selling the victims short here.
- 36:10And I think that I've learned
- 36:13that a lot of it comes from avoidance.
- 36:16Vegans want to avoid,
- 36:17so they think that by appealing to the customs
- 36:22and the beliefs that the non-vegan has
- 36:24will bring them over into the idea a little bit better.
- 36:29I agree with that and I don't.
- 36:31I think that the way that we communicate it can be nuanced,
- 36:35but the bottom line should be the root of the issue.
- 36:40And the root of the issue is that humans
- 36:43have been conditioned to believe
- 36:45that exploiting animals is acceptable.
- 36:48And that's the genesis of all the side effects.
- 36:53That's the genesis of all the symptoms
- 36:56of animal exploitation is that belief
- 36:59that animals exist to serve humans.
- 37:01So however you wanna get that message across
- 37:05is where the nuance can lie,
- 37:06but the message needs to be that,
- 37:08that animals are individuals
- 37:12and it doesn't take any moral authority
- 37:18or any science to understand that.
- 37:22I think if we spend time with animals,
- 37:24we can see that there are personalities in them.
- 37:28And anyone with a personality is a person,
- 37:31and I think that that's just a really simple message
- 37:33that most people can get.
- 37:35Of course, there are people who are set in their ways
- 37:37and there are people who are not going to
- 37:39and trenched in whatever their customs are.
- 37:42But I don't think that now distorting the vegan message
- 37:46is going to get them on any quicker.
- 37:49I think we can refocus a target
- 37:52and go to someone else who might be more willing
- 37:55to hear this justice rooted message
- 37:59rather than trying to distort it in a way
- 38:02that will have them accept it easier.
- 38:05And I think that there's just too much distortion
- 38:07in vegan activism right now,
- 38:11painting it as something where it's like a journey
- 38:14or something that you come to
- 38:18rather than something that you unlearn
- 38:21and you apply a principle in your life.
- 38:25Now, I will say that it wasn't that way for me.
- 38:29I adopted the plant-based diet,
- 38:32and then after having adopted it,
- 38:33I came to the vegan principle.
- 38:36So, and I think Ben touched on this as well.
- 38:39It's hard to determine what's more effective
- 38:44talking about diet and getting people to adopt practices
- 38:47and later come to the principle.
- 38:49But I think that that's, again, that's distorting the message
- 38:52and that it's not practical than if we're just clear
- 38:56about what the objective is, about what the definition is,
- 38:59and about it being a moral obligation rooted in justice
- 39:04and about unlearning bias.
- 39:07But I can see how people are a little hesitant to adopt this.
- 39:12You know, some vegan activists might say,
- 39:14well, we need to have a variety of tactics.
- 39:18I think that plant-based influencers
- 39:20will exist, health and diet influencers will still exist,
- 39:24and they can handle that.
- 39:26Environmental people can handle those kinds of messaging,
- 39:29but I don't think they should be using the word vegan,
- 39:31which was developed to distinguish itself
- 39:35from welfarism and from vegetarianism
- 39:38as more of a principle that goes across the board
- 39:42with any form of animal exploitation,
- 39:43any form of animal use.
- 39:46Hearing it framed that way, that it's,
- 39:47oh, we're against using animals for any purpose?
- 39:51Oh, okay, that's way simpler.
- 39:53We're just against using animals as a means to our ends.
- 39:57Okay, well, now that I understand it that way,
- 39:59I can advocate easier and people can understand it easier,
- 40:03even if they don't adopt the principle,
- 40:06they're understanding it.
- 40:07And these objections and excuses go by the wayside
- 40:12if they're understanding it as a stance against exploitation.
- 40:18Yes, your optimism is contagious.
- 40:23Because, yes, I am thinking there are kind people everywhere.
- 40:26There are empathic people everywhere,
- 40:31and they deserve to hear that argument being made,
- 40:37whatever the religion or culture is.
- 40:42Whatever the state of freedom of speech in their country.
- 40:47And they might be receptive to that.
- 40:51And we should, I'm thinking about success stories
- 40:56of spreading ideas and things like global religions.
- 41:08I don't think they had the same hesitancy,
- 41:11you know, those missionaries, those Christian missionaries
- 41:13going into alien cultures and spreading the good word.
- 41:18I think they were convinced by what they were preaching,
- 41:24and they were driven, and that's how they obtained result.
- 41:29They believed in the simplicity of the message.
- 41:33Not to say that that message is simple,
- 41:35but they probably had it in their heads,
- 41:37that it's a very simple thing to understand,
- 41:39and that it's rooted in truth for them.
- 41:42And so with that conviction, they go out and they spread it.
- 41:48I think that, yes, simplifying that message is really the key,
- 41:54and vegan education is really a key.
- 41:58I can point you to a few of these activists
- 42:00who are very firm against sending a welfare message.
- 42:08So what is a welfare message?
- 42:10Well, a welfare message is one that says,
- 42:13we are against animal abuse, because abuse and torture
- 42:18and high levels of suffering are wrong.
- 42:21But animal use, if there is no suffering or torture or abuse,
- 42:26if we're just using them, then that's acceptable.
- 42:30So using words like suffering and using words like abuse
- 42:35actually sends the opposite message of what veganism
- 42:39seeks to achieve.
- 42:41And I think because there's all this distortion,
- 42:44even some vegans will believe that it's too optimistic
- 42:49to be sending such a simple message.
- 42:51But I think that that paradigm shift among vegan activists
- 42:56needs to happen so that we're unified against all
- 43:01the opposition that we encounter,
- 43:03and that we're unified against all the different avenues
- 43:08that people are attacking a plant-based diet from
- 43:12and all these sorts of things and calling it
- 43:14some globalist agenda.
- 43:18Going back to politics a little bit,
- 43:20this is rooted in injustice.
- 43:23And I think that that can appeal to many conservatives who
- 43:28are based on principle, who do have values like personal
- 43:34responsibility and ethical consistency and all that.
- 43:38So just to bring it back to the conservatives there,
- 43:43it's something that, regardless of your background,
- 43:48if we're framing it in that way against a suffering-focused
- 43:53message and more of the exploitation-focused message,
- 43:56that's my optimism.
- 43:58And many of the writings of these,
- 44:01I call them crossians.
- 44:02They're like Leslie Cross advocates.
- 44:04They're crossians.
- 44:06But they've gotten themselves in a lot of trouble.
- 44:08I'll give you just a little summary here,
- 44:11since I know you're not so much on social media.
- 44:13But they are going on podcasts, a lot of infighting.
- 44:17They're calling out activists.
- 44:19And they're saying that you're making this seem way too much
- 44:22of a diet thing.
- 44:23You're making this seem way too much
- 44:24as a reduction of suffering, where
- 44:28you're making a calculation as opposed to a hard cut,
- 44:32a line in the sand that says, we need
- 44:35to unlearn what society has conditioned us to believe.
- 44:40And we need to focus on the root of the issue
- 44:43rather than factory farms and all these symptoms
- 44:47of animal exploitation.
- 44:49And a lot of that does come down to language.
- 44:52Former English teacher, I'm thinking
- 44:54about language a lot.
- 44:55And I know Ben mentioned that on his appearance here as well.
- 45:01But little differences that if everybody applied them,
- 45:04I'm not saying I have all the answers.
- 45:06But if we are going to be true to the objective
- 45:10of the movement in the 1940s and 50s, as this definition,
- 45:15as this term was even coined, all other movements
- 45:19respect the foundations of their movement.
- 45:21All other justice movements will read the founders
- 45:25and promote the values of the founders.
- 45:28And it seems like with veganism, for some reason,
- 45:31I think due to the avoidance, they
- 45:34want to package it in ways that will be more appealing.
- 45:36Hey, let me send my mom this article
- 45:38about how a plant-based diet reduces risk of heart disease.
- 45:43Let me send my environmentalist cousin this thing
- 45:45about a plant-based diet.
- 45:46And we're getting way too distracted.
- 45:50It can lead someone to a plant-based diet.
- 45:53But then they're going to be one of the worst advocates
- 45:55for the vegan principle, which is rooted in justice, which
- 45:59is against exploitation.
- 46:01They're going to be talking about it
- 46:02as an environmental stance, as a diet, as a personal choice,
- 46:06a lifestyle, rather than something
- 46:08that needs to happen as a moral emergency.
- 46:13Those are my thoughts on that.
- 46:16That's impressive.
- 46:19I love those kinds of conversations.
- 46:21And that's what makes me so glad to have created this podcast.
- 46:27And at first, I thought the goal of this podcast
- 46:30would be to encourage people to do more activism
- 46:33and encourage myself to also do more activism for animals.
- 46:42But then I find myself having debates and conversations
- 46:47about what's the best way of doing activism.
- 46:50And I'm discovering how it's not that straightforward.
- 46:54And those debates and conversations,
- 46:57we're not having them.
- 46:58And yeah, it's truly fascinating.
- 47:02And I don't know how I found myself in this situation.
- 47:08But yeah, especially when you have some of these crossians
- 47:11coming out.
- 47:12And they are a bit aggressive with the vegan activists
- 47:17who they disagree with.
- 47:19Because their position is that these vegan activists
- 47:24are diluting the message and actively harming the message.
- 47:29So if you want to encourage a plant-based diet,
- 47:32you can do that.
- 47:32If you want to send a different message, you can do that.
- 47:35But these activists are really firm
- 47:37about reclaiming this word vegan for its original definition
- 47:42developed by Leslie Cross.
- 47:44And they can be a bit antagonistic and aggressive
- 47:51to ways where now a lot of the, it seems like infighting.
- 47:55And a lot of these activists are now
- 47:59digging their heels in against the Leslie Cross definition
- 48:04and saying, no, no, no.
- 48:05I have it right.
- 48:05And then it's becoming this contentious thing.
- 48:08I'm grateful that it wasn't something
- 48:10where I was called out in an aggressive way.
- 48:12Because if I was, it's just human psychology.
- 48:15I might have rejected this message even further
- 48:17and said, no, I'm good.
- 48:19I got this.
- 48:20I don't need to read the factors.
- 48:22So I'm grateful that it came to me
- 48:24in a way that was easy to understand.
- 48:26And my ego didn't get in the way.
- 48:29But I think that we should be having conversations
- 48:32like this about how to improve the efficiency of this movement
- 48:39and hold each other accountable too.
- 48:41Like, hey, actually, these words and phrases that you're using
- 48:45are sending the opposite message and are actively
- 48:48harming the message.
- 48:50This one's kind of interesting.
- 48:52We can go down this a bit.
- 48:55But these individuals who promote Leslie Cross's
- 48:59definition also are against single issue campaigns.
- 49:04And I know that that's not a super novel issue or topic
- 49:09with vegans.
- 49:10You either have your radical reform
- 49:14or your gradual increases.
- 49:18But with single issue campaigns, the message
- 49:21that we might be sending out is, hey, this level of torture
- 49:26is really wrong.
- 49:27This level of abuse is wrong.
- 49:30Other forms of animal exploitation are fine.
- 49:33But this one here, I really disagree with this one.
- 49:35Let's all be really loud.
- 49:37And then what you find is that non-vegans will even chime in
- 49:41and say, yeah, I disagree with foie gras.
- 49:44That's really cruel.
- 49:45That's really torturous.
- 49:46I'm still going to continue exploiting animals.
- 49:48I'll still continue using them and viewing them
- 49:50as objects and resources.
- 49:52My mindset hasn't changed, the non-vegan says.
- 49:55Like my perception of animals as objects and resources for me
- 50:00to use is still there.
- 50:01But I feel better about having joined that anti-fouagra
- 50:05protest.
- 50:06And nothing changes.
- 50:09And it kind of keeps perpetuating the ideas.
- 50:13In a pragmatic way, does it help small little achievements?
- 50:17In a pragmatic way, does it help people feel like, OK,
- 50:20we're getting small wins.
- 50:21We're moving towards something.
- 50:23Is it a win for the ducks who are no longer having pipes
- 50:27shoved down their throats?
- 50:28Well, what I've heard is actually
- 50:30that these industries will still continue breeding
- 50:33ducks into existence, but using them for down
- 50:37or using them in other ways.
- 50:39Duck fat and other ways that we can exploit these animals
- 50:44won't be force feeding them to make their livers
- 50:49diseased as a delicacy and sell it as a delicacy.
- 50:51But it will still continue.
- 50:54And it's like, we feel like we're
- 50:56making wins with these single issue campaigns.
- 50:58But the prevailing mindset that animals are objects
- 51:02and resources for humans to use, that hasn't been changed.
- 51:05That hasn't been challenged.
- 51:06And that hasn't moved at all.
- 51:08The needle hasn't been moved.
- 51:10So it has convinced me.
- 51:13I'm fully Leslie Cross-pilled, as the internet says.
- 51:17I've taken the pill.
- 51:18I fully believe in it.
- 51:19And I think that there needs to be,
- 51:21in a way that doesn't cause too much infighting,
- 51:24I think that there really could be a shift in the messages
- 51:28that we put out and in the tactics as activists.
- 51:32So I want my podcast to be the home of different voices,
- 51:37even opinions that contradict themselves and people
- 51:40from all walks of life.
- 51:42And I try to do the same in my personal life.
- 51:45I listen to podcasts from all over the political spectrum,
- 51:49including right-leaning podcasts.
- 51:51And recently, I was listening to a right-leaning podcast
- 51:57with the host talking about how she received letters
- 52:02from animal rights organizations,
- 52:06criticizing her for wearing fur or for talking about foie gras
- 52:13and how she loved that foie gras.
- 52:18And then she said something like,
- 52:20I understand how it's bad and all of that,
- 52:25but I am on the top of the food pyramid.
- 52:29And why is it bad to wear fur and eat foie gras,
- 52:35but it's not bad to drink milk and have hamburgers?
- 52:43And that really connects with what you're saying,
- 52:51because no one made the case to her of animal exploitation
- 52:59being bad, full stop.
- 53:05We made the case that foie gras was bad
- 53:07and that wearing fur was bad.
- 53:10But she did not understand the whole thing, the philosophy.
- 53:16And we lost her because of that.
- 53:19And she's just confused now.
- 53:21And the questions she's raising, that host,
- 53:25are pertinent questions.
- 53:29I mean, of course, what about the...
- 53:32But what surprises me is why no one has made her the case,
- 53:38like the entire vegan case?
- 53:39Why are we just targeting those things she said or did,
- 53:45the small instances of promoting animal abuse?
- 53:51So yeah, definitely, I think that this example illustrates
- 53:57well why we do need to follow the principles advocated
- 54:04by the Leslie Cross people.
- 54:07Yeah, yeah.
- 54:08And that was totally eye-opening.
- 54:13Another example that I heard from these actors,
- 54:15because I would engage with them and sometimes even send them
- 54:19direct message and say, well, help me understand
- 54:22this a little bit better.
- 54:23And well, OK, but I can still see how maybe a single issue
- 54:27campaign is good, though, because it does represent a win
- 54:32and all that.
- 54:32And I was trying to understand it.
- 54:34And another example that was given to me
- 54:36was about bullfighting in Colombia,
- 54:40where I believe that one president in the previous term
- 54:46received a lot of support against bullfighting,
- 54:50support to abolish the bullfighting tradition
- 54:53in Colombia.
- 54:54And it did go through.
- 54:55It passed.
- 54:56And bullfighting was outlawed completely in the country
- 54:59during that president's term.
- 55:02And then a new president came in who
- 55:06might have some more exploitative traditions and habits.
- 55:10And that rule was overturned.
- 55:12And so we feel a temporary victory,
- 55:15but culture will just keep a tug of war between one way
- 55:20or the other rather than targeting the root.
- 55:24And if everyone who was at those protests,
- 55:28whether it's foie gras, fur, bullfighting,
- 55:32all these single issue campaigns,
- 55:33if everybody was instead targeting
- 55:36the root of speciesism, targeting the mentality that
- 55:40is so prevalent in society, this bias against other animals
- 55:45and viewing them as objects, resources, or slaves, tools,
- 55:48commodities, we're not challenging that.
- 55:52It's going to keep going unchallenged.
- 55:54And it's not going to significantly change.
- 55:58And people will continue making arguments about crop deaths
- 56:01and diet and other excuses that are all distractions rather
- 56:09than that root issue.
- 56:12So it has really revolutionized my thinking.
- 56:16And I hope that you explore it more on your own,
- 56:20on this podcast, through reading some of the writings.
- 56:25I could shout out a few here.
- 56:27There's one account called Humanify.
- 56:31She's a psychologist.
- 56:33So a lot of her writing deals with the human psychology,
- 56:37the cognitive bias, the dominant bias in society,
- 56:43and ways to unlearn this conditioning.
- 56:46I mean, it's super interesting to me to read these posts.
- 56:50David C. Arenas is another one.
- 56:52He's the Colombian who was talking about the Colombian
- 56:55bullfighting.
- 56:57There's another one named Vicente,
- 56:58who I saw on a debate with folks from the Allied Scholars
- 57:03for Animal Protection, which is Dr. Faraaz
- 57:06Harseini's nonprofit being lab-grown meat or cell-based
- 57:12meat.
- 57:13And absolutely, cell-based meat is a utilitarian solution.
- 57:18But absolutely not does it align with veganism,
- 57:21because it perpetuates the idea that animals are to be used,
- 57:25that it's OK to exploit animals to be used by humans,
- 57:30to benefit humans.
- 57:32So all these little awakenings that I've
- 57:36had from this very small but unified group of activists
- 57:40that I think it's kind of spreading.
- 57:43They're making enemies along the way.
- 57:45They are burning bridges along the way.
- 57:47But I think if their ideas spread, as it did for me,
- 57:50a lot of things clicked into place for me
- 57:53in my understanding.
- 57:55And if it happened for me, it can certainly
- 57:57happen for any bystander who can hear this message
- 58:01and understand it if they're open and ready
- 58:04to accept that message.
- 58:06I mean, you don't even have to go into it
- 58:10with the idea of accepting it or being attracted to it.
- 58:16But just educating yourself or exposing your current views
- 58:20to other views, alternative views, opposing views,
- 58:27and just having a reflection, sparking
- 58:32a reflection around that.
- 58:34I know that I remembered something
- 58:40from my conversation with Ben.
- 58:41He said veganism is not the goal.
- 58:46The end of animal exploitation is not the goal.
- 58:49We want a utopia, a better world.
- 58:52And the end of animal exploitation
- 58:55is part of that, of making that better world.
- 59:01So yeah, it's an ambitious worldview
- 59:06that does deserve some attention from people,
- 59:13and not just disregard.
- 59:14And I don't care about fighting.
- 59:17Fight it out with words, of course,
- 59:19not with actual violence, physical violence.
- 59:23And let's stay within the boundaries of civility.
- 59:31But what's the harm of debating, which is the better way
- 59:37to advocate for veganism?
- 59:40I don't find the harm in it.
- 59:41And actually, I find that it's good.
- 59:44And we should not be ideologues.
- 59:47So I started this conversation talking
- 59:50about how I loved the idea of being an idealist
- 59:57and going for the moon.
- 59:59But there is a difference between idealism and ideology
- 1:00:04and being an ideologue and being dogmatic in what you think.
- 1:00:10So yeah, definitely.
- 1:00:12And I think it does play well in the theme of our conversation,
- 1:00:18which is just liberate yourself from the labels
- 1:00:23and the tribes and just gain some independence
- 1:00:29and critical thinking.
- 1:00:31It's truly freeing.
- 1:00:35OK, I want to say a few words about the left versus right
- 1:00:40debate, and we know that Trump integration is coming up.
- 1:00:48I really don't understand why we don't reach out
- 1:00:55to more conservative crowds.
- 1:00:57And we close ourselves into, no, I'm not talking about you
- 1:01:03directly, but overall, into this left-leading space.
- 1:01:14Why do you think it's the case?
- 1:01:17I don't think we covered that in our last conversation.
- 1:01:24But looking at it, it's just nonsensical.
- 1:01:29I feel it's one of those downfalls of the current activism.
- 1:01:35And that I'm truly convinced of.
- 1:01:37The Leslie thing, I'm still not sure where to lean on that.
- 1:01:43But not being partisan in our activism, I think it's key.
- 1:01:49I think we should.
- 1:01:50And I'm ready to die on that hill.
- 1:01:56So do you have any idea of why?
- 1:02:00Yeah, I think a lot of it has to do with, again,
- 1:02:03the representation of veganism as something that it's not.
- 1:02:12So the first thing I'll say is that people
- 1:02:16do tie it in with an emotional appeal, which maybe can
- 1:02:24reflect more liberal values, I would say, rather than it
- 1:02:29being an objective, moral decision that's
- 1:02:34rooted in justice for other individuals
- 1:02:37and that's rooted in wanting to promote freedom for others.
- 1:02:43And animals count as others.
- 1:02:47So just that view of veganism being something that's
- 1:02:52rooted in something emotional, the view of veganism
- 1:02:57being as something to do with environment.
- 1:03:01Liberals and progressives might have
- 1:03:03more environmental protections and might have more priority
- 1:03:08to environment.
- 1:03:09So it gets conflated with that.
- 1:03:13This one is another, and this is only a modern phenomenon
- 1:03:17of the last 10 years or so.
- 1:03:19But I have seen a growing movement of people
- 1:03:22who believe that by not being vegan,
- 1:03:26by continuing to eat animals, by continuing to view animals
- 1:03:31as objects and resources, they are actually
- 1:03:35rejecting the mainstream narrative.
- 1:03:38And they are anti-establishment by being non-vegan.
- 1:03:43And again, this is more of the last 10 years or so,
- 1:03:46but they see that plant-based solutions are being offered
- 1:03:51as a way to combat environmental damage.
- 1:03:55And so they say, I'm removing myself
- 1:03:57from all this mumbo jumbo with the environment
- 1:04:00and climate change and all that.
- 1:04:01I am anti-establishment.
- 1:04:03I get my meat from animals.
- 1:04:05I use animals.
- 1:04:08And again, I think it's all cultural.
- 1:04:10It's all the way that it's being represented.
- 1:04:14So if we did talk about it in ways
- 1:04:17that were a bit more objective, that animals
- 1:04:20exist for their own purposes, not to serve humans,
- 1:04:24that is something that can be adopted by anyone.
- 1:04:27So I would say that my answer to why it leans more left
- 1:04:31has to do entirely with the way that it's represented.
- 1:04:35This whole movement, the objective of this movement
- 1:04:38is being misrepresented.
- 1:04:40And if it was explained to a conservative who
- 1:04:44does value personal freedoms, who does value a libertarian
- 1:04:50values what's called the non-aggression principle,
- 1:04:53which is you don't initiate harm or exploitation
- 1:04:57against someone else.
- 1:04:58You don't take anything from anyone without consent.
- 1:05:03You live freely and you allow others to live freely.
- 1:05:07That's one of the central tenets of libertarianism
- 1:05:11called the non-aggression principle.
- 1:05:12I mean, they align so well with the vegan principle.
- 1:05:18Now, if we move away from the vegan principle
- 1:05:20for just a moment and talk about plant-based diets,
- 1:05:24I also think that there are appeals to conservatives.
- 1:05:28When you think about the billions of dollars
- 1:05:30that the government taxes from citizens
- 1:05:34to allow the meat, dairy, and egg, and honey industries
- 1:05:40to compete in the free market, if you're a conservative,
- 1:05:44you value it.
- 1:05:45You want there to be minimal government restrictions,
- 1:05:48minimal regulations, and minimal artificial price
- 1:05:53leveling.
- 1:05:55If we paid what it actually costs for eggs, meat, dairy,
- 1:06:01it would be way, way more expensive.
- 1:06:03But we have these artificial calculations
- 1:06:07that come from taxes.
- 1:06:08And any conservative would want less taxes.
- 1:06:12Any libertarian would want less taxes.
- 1:06:14So that's another way to appeal to conservatives
- 1:06:17by talking about a plant-based diet,
- 1:06:20not about the vegan principle, but about a plant-based diet.
- 1:06:24Things like voluntary exchange, that's
- 1:06:27another libertarian value, consensual interactions,
- 1:06:30free from coercion.
- 1:06:33There are so many things that line up.
- 1:06:36And I think that we can be promoting it more.
- 1:06:39I gave you the names of a couple of conservative vegans
- 1:06:42that I see online.
- 1:06:43And they're talking about these things.
- 1:06:45And when I see it, I give it a like.
- 1:06:48And I keep it in the memory bank in case
- 1:06:51I encounter another conservative.
- 1:06:54And those are the ways, Ryan, that I
- 1:06:55think that we can modify and adapt our messaging.
- 1:07:00So if we understand the other person's values,
- 1:07:02we can talk about it in ways that would appeal to them more
- 1:07:07while still remaining true to the core of the vegan principle
- 1:07:14without distorting it or diluting it.
- 1:07:18Beautiful.
- 1:07:19It's as simple as that, people.
- 1:07:21Listen to that.
- 1:07:23It's so clarifying.
- 1:07:25OK, one last thing I want to have your take on.
- 1:07:29Something else that was a mindfuck,
- 1:07:34sorry for my language, but in the last election
- 1:07:38was to compare how in the American election,
- 1:07:44to see them, the Democratic Party,
- 1:07:49pushing for a VP candidate who likes pheasant hunting.
- 1:07:56And there are videos of him promoting himself
- 1:08:04with videos of him feeding cows in a dairy farm.
- 1:08:10And that whole image of I'm with the farmers,
- 1:08:14and I'm a hunter, and this is what being a man means.
- 1:08:21And then you had the presidential candidate
- 1:08:27talking about how she puts almond mink in her coffee
- 1:08:32in the morning, like if this was a great appeal to vegans.
- 1:08:37And then on the right side of the political spectrum,
- 1:08:41you had Vivek Ramaswamy, who is an ethical vegetarian,
- 1:08:45describes himself as ethical vegetarian,
- 1:08:48and talks about how animals should become
- 1:08:52a core concern of conservatives.
- 1:08:54You have Tulsi Gabbard, who is a vegan, again,
- 1:09:00for ethical reasons.
- 1:09:03And you had that whole thing with the squirrel.
- 1:09:10And I was thinking, just like with the windmills,
- 1:09:14this feels like a reversal of values.
- 1:09:19The left should be the party of Pinot de Squirrel
- 1:09:24and the ethical vegans.
- 1:09:26And why are we complete?
- 1:09:30Yeah, well, Tulsi is very inspiring,
- 1:09:32because she actually started on the Democratic Party,
- 1:09:37and then through time, through evaluating her positions,
- 1:09:42and through seeing where the culture is shifting
- 1:09:44politically, she's saying, well, conservative values actually
- 1:09:48make more sense to me now, at least where they are currently.
- 1:09:52And that is something that I think we're seeing.
- 1:09:56We're seeing people leaving the left
- 1:10:00and adopting more conservative values.
- 1:10:03And I welcome it.
- 1:10:06It happened to me.
- 1:10:07I mean, it happened to me in the last decade or so.
- 1:10:10A decade ago, I was firmly in the Democratic Party,
- 1:10:16a liberal, and then just evaluating my values
- 1:10:20and priorities.
- 1:10:21I started learning about libertarianism
- 1:10:23and viewing these two political parties
- 1:10:28and what they cherish and appreciate in society.
- 1:10:32And it just started making more sense to me to shift right.
- 1:10:37And there are some topics that I'm not
- 1:10:39super firm on that are core tenets of conservatism,
- 1:10:44things like Second Amendment, things like immigration.
- 1:10:47Personally, they don't jump out to me
- 1:10:52as things that I am fully determined on
- 1:10:55or have a full solution on.
- 1:10:58And that's what it's all about, right, Ryan?
- 1:11:00We were saying, you can have, just
- 1:11:02because you fall on certain issues on this lane,
- 1:11:07politically doesn't mean that all the other ones
- 1:11:09have to be checked off in identically the same way.
- 1:11:14So yeah, I think that people are nuanced.
- 1:11:17And even as we age, our priorities shift
- 1:11:21and our values shift.
- 1:11:22And we learn more about history.
- 1:11:23And we see more examples in history, even in real time.
- 1:11:26Like, hey, this is happening in this country.
- 1:11:28And that's affecting what I believe
- 1:11:29will help society the most.
- 1:11:32So that malleability, I think, is missing in a lot of people
- 1:11:40in society, where they are not malleable.
- 1:11:43And they believe that if you're on the opposite end
- 1:11:46of the spectrum, you must be a bad person.
- 1:11:49You embody values that are bad.
- 1:11:52And that's like an evilness that people
- 1:11:54believe that other people on the political spectrum have.
- 1:11:59It's just not rooted in truth.
- 1:12:01It's not evil to have differing political values.
- 1:12:05And there's just too much of that going around.
- 1:12:09Yes, and I feel dumb for saying that to vegans.
- 1:12:13Because 10 years ago, I was eating dead corpses.
- 1:12:19And now I'm not.
- 1:12:22Talk about a change.
- 1:12:25So we're not our views.
- 1:12:27We're not our opinions.
- 1:12:30We're not our political positions.
- 1:12:31We're more than that.
- 1:12:35So let's not judge people according
- 1:12:40to their views or opinions.
- 1:12:42Let's look at them and not their views and confirm that.
- 1:12:48Yeah, and it also reflects in my own life.
- 1:12:53I have these ideas, but I haven't had too much
- 1:12:56of a platform to talk about them.
- 1:12:58I have had one-on-one conversations with friends.
- 1:13:01And I have surprised a few of them who just believe,
- 1:13:04oh, you're into art, music.
- 1:13:07You're in the underground scene.
- 1:13:09You're vegan.
- 1:13:10It must be.
- 1:13:12It has to be that you believe these certain political values.
- 1:13:16And it's not the case.
- 1:13:18So if I can inspire anyone to break free
- 1:13:23from whatever the political box that you're in
- 1:13:26tells you to believe, please do.
- 1:13:27Because we are so much more than that.
- 1:13:31And we have the potential to really align with what
- 1:13:33we believe to be true.
- 1:13:35And the more we do that, the more fulfillment
- 1:13:38there is in our own lives.
- 1:13:40And the more we can structure society
- 1:13:43in ways that feel right and true to ourselves.
- 1:13:48What a wonderful way to end this conversation,
- 1:13:52to wonderful message.
- 1:13:55Thank you so much, Andres.
- 1:13:56Thank you for having stopped by.
- 1:13:58And I was really happy to catch up with you.
- 1:14:03Cool.
- 1:14:03Always a good time, Ryan.
- 1:14:04And I'll hop back on any time.
- 1:14:07Yes.
- 1:14:07And just a quick thing.
- 1:14:11Andres did one of the voiceovers in the Psycho.
- 1:14:18What's the name?
- 1:14:19The psychedelic episode I did.
- 1:14:24So yeah, go check that episode.
- 1:14:26And you will recognize his voice in the intro.
- 1:14:30Awesome.
- 1:14:32Awesome.
- 1:14:32Thanks, Ryan.
- 1:14:33Keep up the podcast, because we need more conversations
- 1:14:35like this.
- 1:14:36Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:14:38I kindly invite you to share this podcast
- 1:14:41with the vegans you know.
- 1:14:42Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:14:46Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:14:48And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.