Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 13)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter thirteen, I think, the last
- 0:04chapter in our Dugger deep dive. Let's get into it. My name is
- 0:08doctor Kirk Conda. I'm a therapist and a professor. My name is Umbert,
- 0:13and I use my hands for important things. So let's get into a
- 0:19TI. So this is the Advanced Training Institute with an ibalp which the Duggers
- 0:24were a part of and used, and it is the homeschooling program that it
- 0:31is pretty elaborate and has some very interesting aspects to it. So let's get
- 0:36into a TI. And I think it's again, as I said earlier,
- 0:40there's nothing wrong with having a religion or a belief system, but there is
- 0:43something wrong when those beliefs or that religion harms people and particularly kids. Right
- 0:49to educate quote unquote kids in a way that is giving them false and it
- 0:55seems probably I don't know, I would imagine knowingly giving them propaganda because they
- 1:00justify it, right, they're giving them the right information. Yeah, they're
- 1:03saving their souls. They're making it so they can procreate better and survive better.
- 1:08And yeah, so it's harmful. It's harmful, it's false information.
- 1:15It is unnecessary. There plenty of Christian kids who go to public school and
- 1:21take all the regular classes. That doesn't have to threaten your religion. You
- 1:26just decided that and maybe needed to to have total control or more control over
- 1:32your people. But anyway, so ati is the homeschooling program. And the
- 1:37other thing that I just want to mention upfront is that there seems to be
- 1:42and I learned this a long time ago, that there is very little government
- 1:47monitoring of children's education. Like I grew up, I thought people said this
- 1:53that if I didn't go to school for a yeah, there's there's truant officers.
- 1:57Remember hearing about that as far as I know, And I worked with
- 2:00a lot of families who had kids who were truant and and whatnot. And
- 2:07I never met a truant officer. He just had a sense that there was
- 2:09this city, there was this guy who just roamed around in an old plymouth,
- 2:15you know, and smoke cigarettes and was just looking for truant kids that
- 2:17he could rough them up and bring him back to school. Another aspect,
- 2:21I just figured that let's say a family moved to another town and the parents,
- 2:27for whatever reason, just decide not to enroll their kids in school.
- 2:30I figured that the government or police or the truant officers or someone would come
- 2:37down on the family like a like a ton of rocks. I figured that
- 2:40there's just no way. But the first time I realized that this was not
- 2:45the case was when I started working with families and kids that were truant,
- 2:49and I would have kids that hadn't been in schools for a couple of years,
- 2:52not because the parents, but because the kid was just defying rules and
- 2:57didn't and didn't want to go to school. Because I was the thing.
- 3:00I feared that for a couple of if you didn't go to school, that
- 3:05something horrible would happen to you, right that you'd go to prison or I
- 3:07don't know, just something, or they would literally just drag you. Just
- 3:10I just figured there's got to be but no, long story short, if
- 3:15a kid really wants to not go to school, or when they're at school,
- 3:20to ditch school and not go back, they can, and some do.
- 3:25And what I would see is that once the kid would cross that threshold
- 3:28and find out that there's really no consequences and they get a you know,
- 3:34they truly get to avoid school and all all the negative things about it then
- 3:38it's really hard to get them to go back, you know what I mean.
- 3:42Anyway, they've seen through the thin veil. Yeah. And we reviewed
- 3:46a case maybe a year ago or something of a kid who was being raised
- 3:52by his abusive dad, right, and we found out through the documentary that
- 3:58the mom didn't you know, the dad stole the kid right when he was
- 4:02young, brought him to another community or state or something, and I believe
- 4:08never enrolled him in school or something, right. Yeah, And you again,
- 4:12you would just think, imagine that someone's knocking at that door, like
- 4:15there's some big database of like, hey, this kid has a birth certificate,
- 4:20but we don't see him in school. Will they hit the red button?
- 4:24The trend officers slide down the pole, Yeah, we're on our way,
- 4:28right, doesn't exist, you know. And in relation to iblp and
- 4:32Ati and the Duggers, you have whole swaths of people, millions of kids
- 4:39being homeschooled in a system that would be pretty easy to review. I mean,
- 4:43at least you could do that, right, Like you have a government
- 4:45officer just like says, hey, let me show me your program. And
- 4:47ibop and Ati it was. It was public to the point where I have
- 4:53access to it. I read a lot of it, you know what I
- 4:55mean, And you would just think that someone in the government be like,
- 4:58no, this is not a science based it's propaganda, it's culty, and
- 5:05you can't it's illegal. We we're gonna throw all you parents in prison if
- 5:11you continue there's something or you're gonna throw ati in prisoner. But no,
- 5:15you know, you could say, well, we want to live in a
- 5:17free country, so da da da, But you would think there would be
- 5:20some protections. But I just imagine if the government, if you know,
- 5:27Biden, were to support some measure that sent the jack boot booted thugs into
- 5:31homes of Christian, good Christian homes and interfered with the homeschooling. You know,
- 5:36it's there'd be a there'd be riots anyway. So I read a fair
- 5:42amount of the Wisdom booklets. So did you. These are the textbooks that
- 5:46this program uses, and there's I think there were like sixty or seventy of
- 5:51them when I found them. I sent them to you and I just thought,
- 5:56how amazing it is that we have access to this and it seems to
- 6:00progress through through age. So the first one is maybe for first graders,
- 6:03and the last one is maybe for twelfth graders or something, because it gets
- 6:06more sophisticated as the number goes higher, So maybe we start doing calculus and
- 6:11right chemistry. Yeah, well the science does get more advanced, but let's
- 6:15talk about that. So the first thing I'll say, the summary that I
- 6:19got from reading these is that there it's not so much of an educational tool
- 6:26as much as as it is propaganda for IBLP. It's not even necessarily propaganda
- 6:31for Christianity. It's really trying to indoctrinate these kids and a constant basis on
- 6:39the kind of odd beliefs that IBLP has in addition to Christianity as a whole.
- 6:46Like, for example, there, I was surprised at how much actual
- 6:49science and actual facts there are in these books. There are actual science facts
- 6:56and math facts and chemistry and biology and history, but everything, and I
- 7:01mean everything is intertwined with the cult. So for example, it's kind of
- 7:08hard to a mess like, well how do you do that? Well,
- 7:10in my opinion, it's masterful. I can see why IBLP was such a
- 7:15thing and why ATI lasted for so many decades because whoever or whatever team put
- 7:20this together, it's so slick and so convincing, especially if you had no
- 7:26outside influence. So, for example, they talk about the science of eyes.
- 7:29This is in one of the very first books, so maybe it's for
- 7:31like second third graders or something, and they're talking about sight and eyes and
- 7:36they talk about you know, lenses and photons or whatever, and the rods
- 7:42and the cones, stuff that you learn in school. But then they transition
- 7:46very I mean, to my eyes, it looks ridiculous, it's a total
- 7:49right turn. But to people that don't know, you could see how it
- 7:53just sort of it just naturally goes in and it transitions into, quote,
- 7:58how do these dis orders of sight? So they they are listing different disorders
- 8:03of sight, how do these disorders of sight apply to errors in spiritual perception?
- 8:09Brito? What do you think that makes sense? Basically, what's awesomely
- 8:16clever so horrible is that you have to give the credibility first. The credibility
- 8:24comes from like these like complex scientific bits and pieces like oh, well,
- 8:30I didn't know my eye had these little cells in them and their photons.
- 8:33Well, jeez, you learned something new every day and that preps you for
- 8:35the rest of the story, which is oh, and this helps us explain
- 8:39sin. This helps us explain right, which and you know, honestly,
- 8:45given that no one at that age or at those levels is going to have
- 8:50the ability to be like skeptical about what even photons are or whatever, it's
- 8:54so easy to be like, well, photons come directly from the heavens,
- 9:00or darkness is devoid of God's light because well, you know, and then
- 9:05yeah, but this example is indicative of a lot of the lessons that I
- 9:09saw. They don't necessarily say that that's the genius of it, because I
- 9:13think for a lot of these kids, or the authors, I think they
- 9:16knew. Look, if we could, we would just say that everything comes
- 9:20from God. But there is science, and a lot of these kids are
- 9:22going to learn about it. So how do we allow for that so that
- 9:28the cult members can say, you don't You don't want to put the cult
- 9:33member in a situation where they're easily pulled out of the cult where they're like,
- 9:35sure, but science. So they acknowledge science, but they interweave they
- 9:41always bring it back to the cult. So they talk about the science of
- 9:45the eyes, and they don't attribute it to God at all. They just
- 9:46they just they just laid out the facts. A lot of the wisdom books
- 9:50were like that, and I was really surprised by that. But very quickly,
- 9:52and I'm talking, you know, the lesson for sight might be one
- 9:56page and they're craming a lot of ship in there, and by the end
- 10:01of the page, in this you know, sort of textbooky fonts, it
- 10:05says, how do these disorders of sight apply to errors in spiritual perception?
- 10:11So you can the vision of my head is you have a teacher, the
- 10:13parents who are teaching this right, and they you know, it probably takes
- 10:20three to seven minutes to go over the science, and then you get to
- 10:24this question because they lay out like a blurred vision or being myopic or a
- 10:31stigmatism or something. You know, they go over those kinds of things,
- 10:33or being color blind, and then you can imagine the parents, so it
- 10:37doesn't take very long to teach that. So to speak, then you ask,
- 10:41okay, well, how do these disorders of sight, like being color
- 10:43blind or myopic apply to errors and spiritual perception? And I'm guessing that that's
- 10:50the rest of the day for school is just talking about how, oh well
- 10:56myopia is you know, being shortsighted. If that's what it is. I
- 11:00forget even though that's what I have severely. I can't even see the big
- 11:03e at the top. I'm so myopic or so nearsighted that I you know,
- 11:09they say, read the first line that you said nothing did you put
- 11:11it up? Yet I can't even so, you know, well, being
- 11:16shortsighted. That's that's like not seeing that God is the best and that Jesus
- 11:22died first since and that Dad is in control everything. You know, you
- 11:26can imagine that that those are the conversations very quickly getting away from the science
- 11:31of you. It's the same thing with like I'm sure they cover the Big
- 11:33Bang, that's one of their favorites, right and it's like, and that
- 11:37shows us that there was a beginning and then that's a whole conversation right there.
- 11:43Yeah, it's it's very interesting. It's like you present the believable,
- 11:46you know, facts, and like to your point, if they happen to
- 11:52they're not supposed to be that they happen to have a conversation with someone from
- 11:54the outside world, that they have a couple levels of depth where they can
- 11:58be like, oh, okay, well I know what I'm talking about because
- 12:01I do know, No, you're wrong. I do know about rods and
- 12:03cones. It's just what you don't know about is how that applies to your
- 12:07inner psyche and that inner psyche is your soul and blah blah blah, right,
- 12:11and how it relates to IBOP and the specifics of that, and how
- 12:16it can keep people under control. Another joy, by the way, such
- 12:20an interesting association that physical defects are related to spiritual defects. Right. You
- 12:28can imagine that they would apply this to non cult members. They would say,
- 12:35well, we have twenty twenty vision regarding spiritual matters. They don't.
- 12:41Because you saw that high school girl who was wearing a shirt where you could
- 12:46see her elbows, you know, I mean literally. Another example that I
- 12:50found was I think that this was later on, so this is more advanced,
- 12:54was they have a lesson on fiber optics and they talk about out how
- 13:01fiber optics work, and it's pretty brief, but you know, it describes
- 13:03it, and there's little illustrations, textbooky illustrations. But then they at the
- 13:09end, quote, how do fiber opics illustrate the power and accuracy of Christ's
- 13:15Sermon on the Mount? Okay, so the site disorders, as they put
- 13:20it, and equating them with errors and spiritual perception. Okay, the metaphor
- 13:26is there. It's still a problem if this is your science book, but
- 13:31this one, well, how do fiber optics illustrate the power and accuracy of
- 13:37Christ's sermon on the Mount? This is what I was saying that, like
- 13:39photons aren't just photons. They represent the light of God. And the light
- 13:45of God does not deviate, it travel, It can travel infinitely long distances
- 13:50and in a straight line. And that's the message from the Mount. It's
- 13:54cure from it. As it leaves the mouth. It doesn't get degraded at
- 13:58all, and it's right right in a straight line, directly, just like
- 14:01fiber optics. Are you saying this or am I just remembering this that or
- 14:07both? That? The whole lore around the Christ's Sermont of the Mount was
- 14:11you could be way in the back of the crowd and hear him clearly.
- 14:16I remember, at least I remember, I think I remember that being and
- 14:18so much so that you can be now in present time and still hear him
- 14:22clearly right now. I started to notice as I was nerding out on these
- 14:28books and the deep dive and I remember when I was deep diving on these
- 14:31books, it was like two in the morning, and I'm like, I
- 14:35probably should go to bed, but there's something about these books that I just
- 14:39and I'm thinking, the deep dive doesn't really require you, Kirk to read
- 14:43all these freaking things, so you know, you can get a couple of
- 14:45examples, and it's probably be representative of the whole series. But I read
- 14:50so many of them. And the reason why is because it reminded me of
- 14:54reading Dungeons and Dragons books when I was a kid. And I don't know
- 14:58what that said, that's it felt like, I guess if I dug deep.
- 15:05It felt like because with D and D when I was reading them as
- 15:09a kid, they seemed very arcane to me. It was very because Gary
- 15:13Gygax wasn't a great writer of rules of his game, and there wasn't a
- 15:20lot of playtesting us the first edition, and it was geared towards nerds that
- 15:28were forty who had a lot of time in their hands too. But wasn't
- 15:31it similar in that it was mixed? Because I remember as a kid having
- 15:33the basic book and reading and it felt to me like there was some underlying
- 15:37truths there like, well, yeah, that is how that is how I
- 15:41would level up my strength or whatever, you know, Like I just feel
- 15:45like, yeah, there was like this feeling of like there was some reality
- 15:50to it. Yeah, maybe especially to a developing kid, right that first
- 15:54there's fifth grade, and then there's sixth grade and you do more advanced math
- 15:58and with the leveling up system. Yeah, I suppose so. But also
- 16:03the illustrations kind of reminded me. I think that these books just have a
- 16:07feeling of like I said, if I dig down deep, I think it
- 16:11has a feeling of it has all the answers. And if you study this
- 16:15thing and it's hard because it's long and there's a lot of pages and there's
- 16:18a lot of details, but if you really and I've heard accounts from cult
- 16:23members of IBOP that have extracted themselves who will say this, that it felt
- 16:29like you had to know all the details, especially with IBOP because I think
- 16:34they were so homeschool ati oriented. You know that as a kid you could
- 16:37absolutely imagine I mean just imagine that your siblings and everyone around you, while
- 16:41your church members are studying this thing, and it just feels like this is
- 16:45the answer, This has all the answers and it has science in it.
- 16:48You know, it feels like this is the entirety of all the knowledge and
- 16:55if I figure it all out, then I will know God, or I
- 16:59will oh the world, or I will know me or something. You know.
- 17:02It just kind of has that that feel to it anyway. So another
- 17:04section was how to style your hair, So it's not just fiber optics and
- 17:12life. Yeah, there's there's sections on just like here's how you style your
- 17:17hair in the middle of a school textbook. And we talked about this before,
- 17:22how their prescripted hairstyle for girls was frozen the eighties, and we hypothesize
- 17:29that Bill Gothard's preference for girls frozen the eighties, you know what I mean.
- 17:33There's another section how to avoid provoking men to sexually assault you. And
- 17:41in that section, I'll save you the details, but there's there's a lot
- 17:44of details in there, and I'll say that I've got to make fun of
- 17:48it in a second. But it's pretty well written and pretty convincing, especially
- 17:52if you don't have any outside influence. Have you ever heard of the Modesty
- 17:56pamphlet? No, So this is a thing that is circulated around in Christian
- 18:03circles. And it's a literally a pamphlet and it's for women, girls to
- 18:07learn how to be modest, what to wear, what not to wear,
- 18:11all these things. And it's the same kind of thing. The whole premise
- 18:15is like, you're a fault, so here's how to prevent being a fault.
- 18:19Yeah, not great. And this material is in the homeschooling textbook.
- 18:26Yeah, it's the official educational program that is replacing things like math and science
- 18:33and other things they should be learning anyway. So in this section, some
- 18:36details which I'll highlight is they tell women, I think, but maybe people
- 18:41in general to not wink, not wink, don't wink because that's provocative,
- 18:48right yeah yeah, But well, to me, I'm thinking, when was
- 18:53the last time someone winked at someone as a flirtation when they were telling them
- 18:59not to wink? I think that's from like I love Lucy times, do
- 19:03you know what I mean? The only people I think of when I think
- 19:07of someone who winks is like a dad or a grandpa. You know,
- 19:11they'll they'll say some funny joke and they'll kind of wink at you. Right,
- 19:15So he's not supposed to wink. I understand, you can't do that.
- 19:19It's in the textbook. I'd be one thing if some random pastor had
- 19:25this weird idea. It's another thing to have it officially. It's officially inscribed.
- 19:29You can't wink today. You know, the copies of the Wisdom Books
- 19:33that we looked at, I believe are the ones that are being published and
- 19:36used today. It's not from the seventies, you know. Wait were they
- 19:40winking when they wrote that? So another section which I really want to dive
- 19:45on into, because a lot of the ex cult members that I listen to
- 19:49podcasts and heard talked about this, but to see it just in black and
- 19:53white in the Wisdom book is very disturbing. So it's a section on how
- 20:00to deal with sexual abuse, how to deal with being assaulted sexually. If
- 20:03you have been raped or assaulted, here's what you're supposed to do, essentially,
- 20:07as we say, again, now in a textbook. That's sounds so
- 20:11bad. Right to have a segment or a module in school to educate people
- 20:17about the sort of thing. Yeah, So right up. So there are
- 20:18four points that they get into that I want to highlight. The first one
- 20:25is they asked this question, which is what did the offender damage? Is
- 20:30the question? This is all quotes, what did the offender damage? What
- 20:33parts do we damage with bitterness? So it's asking the person, you know,
- 20:41presumably they're speaking directly to someone who was assaulted, who's now reading this.
- 20:45Think of yourself out there. You're fifteen years old and you just got
- 20:48assaulted again. Trigger warning or not again, but trigger warning. If you
- 20:53are traumatized in this way, you probably don't want to go there unless you
- 20:56talk to your therapist. But if you can handle it, Just imagine your
- 20:59fifth teen You just got raped by somebody, someone in the church or something,
- 21:04and of course you go to spooking Facts. If you told your parents,
- 21:08they'd be like, read the book and one of the you know,
- 21:11this section is saying what did the offender damage? And what parts do we
- 21:18damage with bitterness? What do you think they're saying there? Bro, Yeah,
- 21:22it's so it's oh my god. There's not even a sentence in between.
- 21:26It's basically the first question is implying that, like, you know,
- 21:33how much damage was there? Really, like can you point to it?
- 21:37And number two right away, like just not even a breath, It's like,
- 21:41but what do we damage with bitterness. And this is in the context
- 21:47of having all those other lessons about how what do we see with our spirit?
- 21:49What do we see with it? So now we understand that, oh
- 21:52right, we do way more damage to ourselves being bitter about it, Like,
- 21:59like, you're right, why do I care so much? I should
- 22:02just like let it go because bitterness is surely worse than this horrible pain.
- 22:08And oh yeah, I mean the word bitter is particular, right, It
- 22:17doesn't say what parts do we damage with anger or with resentment, or being
- 22:22upset or sadness, bitter? Bitter like it? Oh you're so bitter?
- 22:30Yeah? Like I think typically that word is used Maybe it wasn't used it
- 22:34in this way here, but I think people have to use the word bitter
- 22:37as a a sort of spiteful victim mentality, mentality that's on purpose, like
- 22:45the thing you're feeling, just to give it a name. The feeling you're
- 22:48feeling right now is bitterness. Yeah. So two, this is the second
- 22:55section or another section in this in this chapter. So the question is berto,
- 23:00why did God let it happen? And then so they given they give
- 23:06an answer, But what do you think the answer is that they give?
- 23:10Why? Did God let this happen? In general, these types of why
- 23:14did God is usually well, the main thing is that God really wants us
- 23:19to have free will, and the price for our free will is that we
- 23:25are entitled to make our decisions both the person that did this to you,
- 23:29but more importantly you. So God created you, you let this happen.
- 23:36That's what I'm guessing, something like that. It's more overt than that.
- 23:40Yeah, the answer is quote, so why did God let this rape?
- 23:45Why did God let you get raped? The answer is a modest dress.
- 23:51Oh wow, Okay, they don't even couch it. They don't even couch
- 23:55it in decent exposure, being out from the protection of your parents, Oh
- 24:00my gosh, being with evil friends. Yeah, you know, this is
- 24:03fantastic in a grotesque, hideous way. Because normally, because I've watched so
- 24:10many debates over the last decade, debates, the Hitchens and stuff, I've
- 24:15watched so many hours of debates, and inevitably, when the question comes up
- 24:19about why would God let horrible things happen? The go to it's like,
- 24:23no, no, no, you got it wrong. God created us and
- 24:26gave us free will, right, that's the go to. This one not
- 24:32only do they not couch it. Not only they don't remind you of that,
- 24:34they actually say no, no, he did let it happen, but
- 24:37it's because of your faults, like it's all your fault, right, it's
- 24:41your fault. Another thing that they will say is they'll say, well,
- 24:48it's a test from God. Or another thing that they'll say is that God
- 24:53created the world and free will and wanted us to do with it what we
- 25:00will, and sometimes that results in tragedy for one person or who didn't deserve
- 25:06it, you know. And and it's what's unbelievable to me is that it
- 25:10literally says no, yes he did, and it's your fault. Right.
- 25:14The answer isn't well God didn't let it happen. No, God was basically
- 25:18there. Yeah. So third section I want to talk about they ask a
- 25:26question and they don't really give an answer, but I want you to think
- 25:30what they're trying to say with this. The question is again they're asking someone
- 25:34who's young, who was raped recently or had been in the past, and
- 25:38they ask the reader, is there any guilt? So what do you think
- 25:44they're saying? There? Yeah, they're it's basically reinforcing that point of like,
- 25:48you know, it's you know, it's you, right, right?
- 25:51Isn't there guilt? Right? It doesn't. It doesn't say is there any
- 25:53guilt? My god, do not feel guilty for being a talked No?
- 25:59No, no. It just kind of raises are you noticing that there should
- 26:02be guilt? Because there should be because hint, yeah it's you. I
- 26:07mean that is so unbelievably. Like, now this has actually changed my opinion
- 26:11about something earlier. I was talking about how, you know, I didn't
- 26:17think that on the inception of the rules making by these people that they were
- 26:22like trying to like be like whw can we get up? This makes me
- 26:26second guess that because it's like this is so egregiously like proactively, and like
- 26:33they're basically acknowledging like, look, let's be honest here, women are gonna
- 26:37be we're gonna be touching them, doing all sorts of stuff to them.
- 26:41We gotta prep so that they're okay with it, and they realized that it
- 26:45was their fault. Yeah, yeah, wow. Yeah. I can also
- 26:49see this just generating from the general cultural understanding in our culture. You know,
- 26:56the things that are being said here are of course diabolical and horrific to
- 27:02us. But we understand that you don't have to be an IBLP cult member
- 27:07as an American to have these kinds of notions, you know, even if
- 27:11you're not religious, just getting away from the God question, you know,
- 27:15bitterness and guilt, and people will do this themselves. It's natural that people
- 27:22will actually feel like, yeah, they are to blame. So it's not
- 27:26a stretch to imagine that they would also apply that blame to other victims.
- 27:30I mean, you're not wrong. I guess what makes it so much harder
- 27:33to swallow is the that it's inscribed in the homeschooling curriculum. Yeah. Yeah,
- 27:40people wrote this. And again remember that IBOP as a paternalistic, male
- 27:45centered organization, so it's probably a bunch of dudes, and they're writing this
- 27:52and reviewing it and having editors and having people review it and maybe revisions over
- 27:59time as things come out, and they're like, Yep, this is this
- 28:02is what we want to say. But I'm assuming there's at least a sister
- 28:06or brother's section that talks about what to do if you abused someone. Yeah.
- 28:11No, number four section that I want to highlight is quote and I
- 28:15don't they don't really give a response to this, but so I want you
- 28:18to tell me what you think they're getting at. If the abused was not
- 28:22at fault, so if you, as the victim, were not at fault,
- 28:26then God compensated the abuse with spiritual power. Yeah right, okay,
- 28:32yeah, yeah, do you remember hearing this? Yeah? Well, and
- 28:34this is the other version, So this one I am more familiar with.
- 28:38So, like I said, the most common one is well, God made
- 28:41us free and that's it. But the other one, which you brought up
- 28:45is it's a task. It's a thing that's going to help you grow,
- 28:48right, So that's what this one is getting at. It's essentially no,
- 28:52I don't think so. I mean it's in that direction. So basically,
- 28:56the way I'm reading it is, uh, you're, as we've already established,
- 28:59you're at fault. Let's just be clear about that. In the very
- 29:02unlikely event maybe that you weren't asterisk bottom of the page, In the very
- 29:07unlikely event that you weren't, well you benefit it spiritually. So what what
- 29:11may worry? Sweat it? And I wouldn't know this, particularly unless I
- 29:17heard from ex cult members actually talking about this, where it's a gift from
- 29:21God, because essentially the messages that if you were assaulted by someone, God
- 29:27compensates you with additional power, not that you grew wet, if you weren't
- 29:33a fault, which again you're likely fault, You're you're pure of heart.
- 29:37You were victimized, and God compensates you by giving you this extra power.
- 29:41It's not really designated as something like a like some sort of us grew spiritually
- 29:47yeah, but but it's yeah, it's spiritual power. You're you're given some
- 29:51because you've established a whole curriculum since they were little that lets you believe that
- 29:55actually that might be worth a lot. Yeah, so's that token and U.
- 30:00The analogy that I can think of in my own life is that when
- 30:04I when I was, when I grew up in my family, me and
- 30:07my siblings, we would be we frequently had spaghetti. It was always over
- 30:12a huge bed of gohan or rice, you know, edge of plate to
- 30:17edge of plate, just you know, a thick thing ice of rice.
- 30:21Oh yeah, and then the spaghetti and then spaghetti. Yeah, spaghetti on
- 30:23the rice. Oh yeah. Uh. Everything Japanese Americans, every everything rice
- 30:30and lots of it. You know, it's a it's a good way to
- 30:33feed your kids. Have your rice and then and this is the spaghetti still
- 30:37with the red sauce and everything. Yeah, okay, yeah, it's Japanese
- 30:40American. You didn't know that about me? Yeah, everything, And I
- 30:42know that rice is but I just didn't know that spaghetti came into the picture.
- 30:45Yeah. I think of any dish that Javanese Americans might eat. You
- 30:51know, there's a fair amount of American food. It's always with just a
- 30:53ton of rice and not just on the side, you know, Like I
- 30:56would notice that other Americans, not happenings Americans would there be like the rice
- 31:02peel off. It would be like this tiny little thing of it. And
- 31:04I was like, huh, that's totally different from ye. For us,
- 31:07it's like essentially you have the plate and then you have rice in the food.
- 31:12It's just like and then you eat the whole thing. Anyway, so
- 31:15when we would have this meal, which was frequent, one or more of
- 31:19us would end up going, oh, bay leaf and we take the baileys.
- 31:23So so I mom, you know, bai leaf is a is an
- 31:29herb, but you're supposed to take it out. It's supposed to flavor and
- 31:32you take it out. We would go, oh, bay leaf, and
- 31:34my parents, particularly my mom would say, oh, that means you get
- 31:37good luck now, and so in our family it was like, hey,
- 31:41I got the bay leaf. Yeah. So anyway, we investigated, We
- 31:45asked my mom about it. She's like, oh, yeah, I just
- 31:48made it up because I didn't want to fish them out, you know.
- 31:49So anyway, my point is is that it's like, you got screwed.
- 31:53I'm just gonna make up this story that this is a blessing because I don't
- 31:57know what else to do except it's it's so it's it's even more like,
- 32:02you know, a mom cooks the dinner, the spaghetti for the family and
- 32:08has shards of glass randomly in there. One of the kids eats and cuts
- 32:13in the mouth is bleeding. It's like, ah, it's like, were
- 32:16you acting too hungry? You were acting too hungry, weren't you? But
- 32:21the good news is if you weren't acting too hungry, then now you get
- 32:25the lucky glass, you know, boone, because you got the glass.
- 32:30And that's what's happening with with these folks. They're basically getting told that the
- 32:37worst possible thing was their fault, and in the teeny unlikely event it wasn't
- 32:43they still got something good out of it, right, right, And I'm
- 32:45glad you point out that it would be this very unlikely asterisk that that the
- 32:51person or people evaluating them would determine that they're not at fault, because there's
- 32:54always something that you can point to, right, and it could be anything.
- 32:59Maybe that year you did everything perfect, but remember last year when you
- 33:05wore those socks that were two worldly or you know, anything, especially when
- 33:09you're in that high control environment. And I've heard, unfortunately from I mean
- 33:15I've heard from a lot of ex cult members of this cult and other cults
- 33:17that will say that the indoctrination is so complete that and the hike and the
- 33:23control is so high that you just always know that you're to blame and even
- 33:29if you can't identify it. So yeah, it's a massive asterisk for those
- 33:32people to say, like, well, if you were pure and you were
- 33:36perfect, it's actually a gift from God. That's the end of this story.
- 33:39Yeah, there's no like treatment nor understanding or because you can imagine how
- 33:45the conversation goes. If the person approaches someone they're in tears, it's like,
- 33:50well, remember what did you do right? Right? And then after
- 33:53all of that, at the end, if the persons still kind of like
- 33:55not quite agreeing, it's like, well, also keep an mind, you
- 34:00probably got some good spiritual growth out of it. Right. Well, again,
- 34:02it's not growth because there's a spiritual boon, because because growth implies there's
- 34:07a process of growing. But there's no talking some extra xp you got a
- 34:13token of God's goodwill, I think or something. Yeah, alright, let's
- 34:17take a break, we get back, let's continue looking at these books.
- 34:22What do you say, Berto, Let's do it all right, We're back
- 34:28from the break. So I want to remind people that this material is from
- 34:31the textbooks in the homeschooling program. This isn't just a pamphlet. This isn't
- 34:37some lecture given body. This is in the official teachings of this homeschool program.
- 34:44It's in black and white. I read it, and it is taught
- 34:47to literally every child by the parents. By the way, mind blowing.
- 34:52Okay, So there's a lot of other stuff, but I wanted to paraphrase
- 34:58some bits because I think it's worth it. So this is just a paraphrase.
- 35:02I'm saying as if it's written in the book. But it's really just
- 35:05by paraphrasing. Americans like to think our government is of the people, but
- 35:12that denies our biblical our biblical roots. Look at the governments of ancient Greece
- 35:19and Rome. They were based on the people also, and now they're just
- 35:23ruins. Also, look at the Soviet Union. They weren't based on God,
- 35:29which naturally leads to a tyrant Berto, what do you think about that?
- 35:32Yeah, So this is a very common argument again in the billions of
- 35:37hours of debates that I've gone through. Uh. Yeah, that essentially,
- 35:43if you don't base your government or your society on the religious principles, and
- 35:49specifically the Christian ones the Christian Bible, it will lead to ruin of your
- 35:54society. And so then they cite examples. They'll they'll cite the twentieth century
- 36:00wars, they'll site societies like the Roman society that collapse, et cetera.
- 36:04Yeah, that's a very common thing. It is. It's an easy point
- 36:09to make, I think, because easy as in you can say, hey,
- 36:14you remember how the Roman Empire felt they weren't Christians. You know,
- 36:17it's like an easy sound bite you can you can point to, yeah,
- 36:22yeah, yeah, and it's often all the you need to say, particularly
- 36:28because there's no outside influence, you know it. Oh well, that makes
- 36:31sense, and so let's move on in life. And also just that line
- 36:37of that, Americans like to think our government is of the people. That's
- 36:42a bad thing to the Ibil that government is of the people. No,
- 36:45it's not of the it's of it's it's of God, it's of the Bible.
- 36:50What are you talking about. So another paraphrase here is it's godly to
- 36:55keep things clothed like your body and the earth. God clothed the earth in
- 37:02trees, so we need to preserve the forests. In nineteen twelve, Robert
- 37:07Scott and his team of explorers died in the in the Antarctica of hypothermia.
- 37:14So Robert Scott and his fellow you know, explorers, it's kind of a
- 37:17famous case where they got ship wrecked or they their their ship got caught in
- 37:23ice in Antarctica, and it was a I think there's been a couple of
- 37:27movies about it or something. So there's a there's a whole section on them
- 37:30and some pictures of them, you know, you know. In nineteen twelve,
- 37:32Robert Scott and his team of explorers died in an Arctica of hypothermia because
- 37:37they weren't clothed enough. So not only did God clothe the earth in trees,
- 37:44and so we need to clothe ourselves sufficiently, but also Robert Scott died
- 37:49of hypothermia in ot in Antarctica. So that's a reason why you girls can't
- 37:54wear shirts that show your elbows. I mean, that's quite a leap,
- 38:00right, I mean, there's probably lots of other stories about people who were
- 38:05too hot and weren't allowed they couldn't take off their clothes and they died of
- 38:10heat exhaustion or something. You know, Like, what are you talking about,
- 38:15right, right? Yeah, So basically it's this kind of very very
- 38:20childish, simplistic presentation. Hey, trees are kind of like clothes, and
- 38:23they're all over the earth, right, so although actually, hold on,
- 38:28because I need to adjust that, because it is okay to DeForest trees and
- 38:31use all the oil, so never mind. But but you know, and
- 38:37people die of hypothermia. Therefore, I mean, even the trees thing,
- 38:42it's like, well, there are deserts and oceans, and oceans cover most
- 38:45of the earth, so but the water is the clothing, and you even
- 38:49identify Antarctica, of which there are no trees. So can we use seed
- 38:52through clothing because the water is see through? Yeah? So can I just
- 38:55put clothing on my face and then have water on the my body and some
- 39:01sand over here? What are you saying? Yeah? So another section in
- 39:07the last bit I want to point to, which is notable, is that
- 39:10the book is very much trying to brainwash the students about a lot of things.
- 39:15But one of the things that's trying to brainwash them I think this was
- 39:17in an older section, like in a teenage section. They're trying to brainwash
- 39:22the students about opinion polls. So they provided famous examples of how polls are
- 39:28wrong sometimes, and it seems pretty clear that, well, why do you
- 39:32think they'd be trying to point this out? You know, it's not like
- 39:37these research methods are more likely to get at what is likely to be representative
- 39:43of the group. It's just a whole section on how polls are are wrong
- 39:47and here are some famous cases. Why do you think they'd be doing that?
- 39:51My guess is because if you if you start looking at statistics and studies
- 39:55of what people believe and don't believe, and you think that that is supposed
- 40:00to represent truth in some way that is a major threat to the cult.
- 40:07If, for example, there are surveys that talk about whether people think it's
- 40:12right for the man to have certain rights or if it's right for a woman
- 40:16to not this and that, and you look at that data and you believe
- 40:20it, you might start questioning like, well, wait a minute, most
- 40:22people in the world apparently don't agree with so in general, you got to
- 40:27discredit those those things that way. You can't be like pointing at them,
- 40:30or if someone brings those up, you're yeah, you can't trust those polls.
- 40:35Right. Yeah. It was again maddening to me to look at because
- 40:39I knew it was propaganda and extremely one sided and not convincing to me.
- 40:46But the way it is laid out, and considering that these kids are homeschooled
- 40:51and they can't even go on the internet, right that I would imagine it
- 40:55would be so convincing, you know. But the thing is is they're not
- 41:00saying lies. They're actually pointing to famous times when the polls and not recent
- 41:07you know, these It's not like they talked about everyone thought Donald Trump was
- 41:09gonna lose, you know, they talk about famous cases from longer ago that
- 41:14are not as politicized today. You know, it's just like things you and
- 41:15I would be like, oh yeah, there was that famous cause it's really
- 41:19both maddening and genius that they wove factual information and compelling information because it is
- 41:27a good argument. Like if you did a presentation about how you, as
- 41:32a student should interpret polls in the future, this would be a part of
- 41:37it, but it wouldn't be the only part of it. There would be
- 41:39a lot of other parts to it. So it carries with it this this
- 41:44convincing factualness of what I can't tell is if whether they're trying too hard or
- 41:50whether they succeeded. Because you see how starting in twenty fifteen, you know,
- 41:57Trump starts saying you can't trust them media. The media is always lying
- 42:00to you, can't trust the media. The media is alwayslying to you.
- 42:02And then a few years later there's a whole millions and millions, millions and
- 42:07millions of people who, when asked, like they'll say like, yeah,
- 42:09no, I can't trust the media. The media is always lying to us.
- 42:12So of course I don't believe that he's getting indicted, or if he
- 42:15is, I don't believe the reasons or if I do whatever, right,
- 42:17and that didn't require any of these clever textbooks. But I wonder if this
- 42:24and other things like it for decades have primed a lot of portion of our
- 42:30population to basically believe things like this and not trust things like that. Yeah,
- 42:37right, And I don't know if Trump and these other people know this,
- 42:40But the thing that they're tapping into, the cognitive bias they're hacking into,
- 42:45is that we are emotional creatures. So yeah, when we want to
- 42:51believe something, we figure out a way. So like for Donald Trump to
- 42:55say the presses is fake, they're all done. You know, of course
- 43:00he would privilege certain news outlets, but you could argue that he sent a
- 43:06message that it's all stupid. You can't trust anything but me. Well,
- 43:10yes, but even if he didn't say that last part did, which he
- 43:15didn't when he did. But if but if he didn't say it, you
- 43:17would think, Okay, if I'm thinking logically, well, then he's dismantling
- 43:22his own venue to communicate with the public, you know, because you could
- 43:27argue he's a Internet source, right, But what it does is when you
- 43:32dismantle the entire enterprise and you prime someone say, Okay, I reject everything
- 43:38I read on the internet. They know or they benefit from the bias of
- 43:43the person saying, but there are some things that I want to believe.
- 43:45So when you feed me the information through the news or through yourself, I'll
- 43:51believe that, even though you said all the news is stupid, but I'll
- 43:54believe it because I want to. And and you know, because of the
- 44:00total rejection, if anything comes at them that is counter to that emotionally,
- 44:05then they will, you know, like for me, they're getting away from
- 44:07politics. There are scientific notions that I adhere to, whether it's in psychology
- 44:14or physics or astronomy or something. And when new data comes out or there's
- 44:20some newsworthy study or finding and it's reported because I have an understanding of critical
- 44:28thinking and how science works, and I've been through this enough times, and
- 44:31I have to remind myself, well, just because this contradicts what you believe,
- 44:36doesn't mean you should reject it. In fact, you should actually pay
- 44:38more attention to it because it's likely that you're going to be more skeptical of
- 44:44it. So, you know, and let's look into the background. Where
- 44:45did the data come from? Who is the researcher is their follow up studies
- 44:50this kind of thing. And because I'm indoctrinated into that system, I can
- 44:54be more influenceable. You know, people, not necessarily, but I'm more
- 44:59likely because of that indoctrination. If you I'm indoctrinated into critical thinking, into
- 45:04the scientific method and to the scientific community. Now, just because a scientist
- 45:08says something, or just because science seems to be suggesting something, doesn't mean
- 45:13that I necessarily accept it, because it depends on the source and that have
- 45:16done the entirety of the data. But not that I'm not duped. Sometimes
- 45:21I absolutely am. But that's a different indoctrination. It's a different system.
- 45:24It's a system that is more interested in the truth or the data or the
- 45:29empirical science, and not as interested in a cult leader or a chrismatic leader.
- 45:34Right. So I'm saying all this to say that the further someone is
- 45:39pulled away from that, and you know that average American is already not within
- 45:43that mindset because they're not taught or they don't have the constant reminders that I
- 45:47do in my life, it's very easy to push them even further away from
- 45:52any kind of outside information. Or process or philosophy or practice that allows for
- 46:00scrutiny and questioning themselves, questioning their leaders, questioning their emotional impulses, questioning
- 46:07their emotional denial or acceptance of information, that kind of thing. But I
- 46:13right, and I am wondering more specifically about the thirty percent of the country
- 46:17that probably if they're not part of IBOP, which obviously not thirty percent of
- 46:22the country is. But if IBLP is not the only system like this,
- 46:27right, there's so many similar ones. So if for the last several many
- 46:31decades there's been a lot of these kinds of models, which we know that
- 46:37there have been, it's not that surprising that they don't have any of those
- 46:40tools that you're mentioning. And not only do they not have those tools,
- 46:44the tools they do have are specially designed to not trust anything new. Right,
- 46:52Yeah, Okay, So I want to talk about a book that is
- 46:59very prone with an IBLP that one of the patrons wanted us to talk about.
- 47:04But before we do that, let's take a break. What do you
- 47:06say? Let's do it all right, we're back from the break. So
- 47:13there were some people that wanted us to talk about this book that's very prominent
- 47:15with an IBLP about parenting, very influential book about parenting called To Train Up
- 47:22a Child published in nineteen ninety four. It was written and self published by
- 47:27two Baptists parents named Michael Pearl and Debbie Pearl, and the book was heavily
- 47:32promoted by IBLP. So I want to talk about Michael Pearl. He's the
- 47:37main figure here, born nineteen forty five, an American Baptist preacher. And
- 47:45when I look at him the way that I would describe him, if someone
- 47:47were to ask me who is that guy, I would say, well,
- 47:51Michael Pearl is a creepy old guy with a long white beard. His you
- 47:57know, it's my judgmentzel or description of him, which will make sense as
- 48:01we go through. So Michael Pearl, he became kind of well known for
- 48:06this book and his approach to parenting, and he was interviewed, for example,
- 48:09on Anderson Cooper, who really confronted him a lot. So you know,
- 48:14he's one of those figures. And his big thing is that he promotes
- 48:17corporal punishment the book. The book tells parents too, in my words,
- 48:23abused children to quote unquote break their will so that the break their will break
- 48:30the child's will is written in the book. It sounds like the Ruby gal.
- 48:35Yes, so Ruby Frankie also another very religious, isolated parents. You
- 48:42got to break that stallion. Yeah, so trig your warning. We're gonna
- 48:46get into some specifics around physical abuse, particularly some of the children of the
- 48:52parents who actually adhered to this book, which are really horrific stories. But
- 48:57so you know, some some things in here which I'm sure everyone can imagine.
- 49:00Of course, spanking is discussed pretty extensively, beating children with objects,
- 49:06that's my phrase, but that's literally what they're talking about is hitting children with
- 49:10implements with holding food from them, like Ruby Frankie was doing, Spraying children
- 49:15with a cold garden hose, using cold baths, forcing children outside in cold
- 49:22weather. And here's another really, so you know, the spanking, beating
- 49:27with objects with holding feature like, well, horrible, but you know we've
- 49:30seen that sort of thing before. Spraying children with cold garden hose, huh,
- 49:36using cold baths, forcing children outside in cold weather, Okay, But
- 49:39then here's one hitting infants when they cry out for their parents. So this
- 49:45is a this is a quote. This is a quote from the book that
- 49:50I'm gonna read. If a father is attempting to make a child eat his
- 49:53oats. If a father is attempting, I'm gonna make my child eat his
- 49:58oats. If a father is attempting to make his child make his child and
- 50:01the child cries out for his mother, you know, like I don't want
- 50:05I don't want to eat, then the mother should respond by spanking the child
- 50:10for whining for her and not eating his oats. He will then be glad
- 50:15to be dealing only with his father. Now. As a therapist who worked
- 50:19with a lot of families and inevitably I gained a lot of competence in helping
- 50:23parents with parenting for kids a very stages, particularly ten and up, but
- 50:29really of any age. Yeah, absolutely, those moments are critical for the
- 50:34parents to work out in advance how they're going to approach that, because what
- 50:37if the mom doesn't really care about the kid eating? You know, you
- 50:42got to talk about these things. Yeah, like wait, so when we've
- 50:45definitely run into especially with my younger one, but even with the older one,
- 50:49you know, twelve year old, seven year old, the twelve year
- 50:52old will sometimes but stop doing it because we would basically not respond the way
- 50:57she wanted, like ask twice, right, can I do blah? And
- 51:01then say Mom says no. Then, unbeknownst to Mom and unbeknownst to me
- 51:07that she asked, she comes downstairs and says, can I do blah?
- 51:09Now, when we hadn't caught on, I might say okay, and then
- 51:15later you know, the dots are connected. The three company episode resolves and
- 51:20it's like, wait a minute, you asked, You're already asked whole I
- 51:23no. Now, not only can you not do this, but actually,
- 51:27you know, some privileges taken or something, depending on the situation. Right,
- 51:30the seven year old, same thing, it's like, but that one
- 51:32will do it just more in our She doesn't even try to hide it.
- 51:37She'll just be like, Mama, can I do blah? No? Turn
- 51:39around, daddy, can I do blah? I'm like, no, you
- 51:42already heard from your mama. Right. So it's a very common thing from
- 51:45a child to try to play both sides, and as a parent you absolutely
- 51:47need to spank them. Really no, you need to say no, you
- 51:52know you can't play us like that. But then you don't have to add
- 51:55the physical abuse. Right right. Here's another example, and this is one
- 52:00that is really out there. During breastfeeding, So you know the child is
- 52:07an infant. During breastfeeding, if the baby bites the mother's nipple, you
- 52:10need to pull the baby's hair or pinch them or something that indicates that that
- 52:16is unpleasant. So you need to indicate to the child that you know that's
- 52:21unpleasant, but pull the hair. Yeah, So it says this in the
- 52:25book, and he talks about this too during breastfeeding. So we're not talking
- 52:30about a defiant seven year old who won't eat her oats. Okay, we're
- 52:34talking about an innocent baby who isn't biting because the child wants to be a
- 52:40dick. It's because, you know, it is a reflex and as teeth
- 52:45start to develop, Right, they don't even know they have teeth. They
- 52:50they're just continuing to gum things, you know, and I don't even know
- 52:52if they're talking about actual teeth. But during breastfeeding, if the baby bites
- 52:57the mother's nipple, you need to pull the baby hair or pinch them.
- 53:00Right, And I think they're they're thinking, is like, you need to
- 53:07send a message to that infant that they their pain that they're inflicting will be
- 53:13met with pain. Right. It completely misunderstands human development. You can't train
- 53:20a baby they're not aware. They won't connect those things. The only thing
- 53:25because the baby would have to know I'm going to now bite, I want
- 53:30to bite, right. And what's worse is that if they're depending on the
- 53:35age, if they do start connecting the dots, what they'll start connecting is
- 53:38I see this is a dangerous environment. Right, yeah, right, So
- 53:43there are lessons that they'll learn, but it won't be that, including the
- 53:47one with the oats. Ye what they look because you know, there's an
- 53:52approach that a united front, even if the other parents. It depended.
- 53:57But the thing that I taught was that, Okay, if you see your
- 54:01fellow parent, you're co parent, doing something that is egregiously wrong or beyond
- 54:07a certain threshold, and uh, and you think yourself, well, but
- 54:10I'm supposed to have a united front. There are options of stepping in gracefully
- 54:15and and having maybe a code word to your fellow parent of just like I'm
- 54:20going to take over. I'm not. I don't want to undermine you,
- 54:22but I'm going to fucking undermine you because you're you're freaking out and you're you're
- 54:27crossing some lines but those are rare hopefully, uh in most circumstances. Even
- 54:31if you're like that's not how I would do it, but you know,
- 54:36we'll talk about it later. That's what I say, is like if you
- 54:37can just table it in your mind and then you talk about it later,
- 54:42but don't intervene and that don't argue about parenting in front of the kids,
- 54:45you know what I mean. So we used to be me and my wife,
- 54:49we used to be really bad about this. Not all the time,
- 54:52but like when when especially our first child was very little man, we would
- 54:58there, we would not be good about it where it'd be like you can't
- 55:01do that. You're like literally like you can't do that, that's wrong parenting
- 55:05whatever. Like we just have like these arguments and it took us a while
- 55:08to realize that that was not healthy for anyone. But as a positive example,
- 55:15just this last weekend, my older daughter was asking for a sleepover with
- 55:20a friend. But it was on It wasn't the night before school started,
- 55:23but it was getting to where we only had one more day, so the
- 55:29mom my wife said no, no. Now in my head I was going
- 55:32like what why not let them? But you know, I let her lay
- 55:37the round rule and say no, and then I didn't you know, contravene
- 55:40that. So it was one of those cases where it's not a bad thing.
- 55:45She's saying no sleepover, but in my head, I'm like, well
- 55:47I probably would have said yes, but there's no, it doesn't benefit us
- 55:51for me to like contradict what she's doing. And that took a while to
- 55:55learn, I mean, especially in a situation like that, because say you
- 56:00talk with her, your wife behind closed doors, you're like and say you
- 56:05make your case and say she's convinced. Your wife was like, oh,
- 56:07okay, well, and then your wife can go to the kid and say,
- 56:10you know what, I changed my mind. That's a much different thing
- 56:14than you going to your kid and saying, you know what, let me
- 56:17talk to yeah. So uh so anyway, pretty often it's like spank your
- 56:23kid. But I just want to highlight that they are prescribing abusing a baby,
- 56:29an innocent, pure, little fragile baby who is just trying to get
- 56:36through the day, you know, and makes it a very innocent mistake,
- 56:40pull the hair, even a mistake, just the hair, just an innocent,
- 56:45unfortunate aspect of breastfeeding. You know that that happens. We know how
- 56:49painful pulling of the hair is, yeah, or pinching a child? What
- 56:53kind of person? You know? Okay, spanking a child. I'm not
- 56:58saying it's okay, but in terms of I guess my spectrum here, spanking
- 57:02a child for openly defying a parent and asking for the other parent not what
- 57:09not what you should do. But on the spectrum, I don't know where
- 57:13it is, but it's far below pinching and pulling the hair of an innocent
- 57:19baby who doesn't know what they're doing and clamps down right like what kind of
- 57:25monster do you have? To be? Right? And this isn't some fringe
- 57:30book. This was a book that was held up by IBLP, heavily promoted
- 57:34and influenced millions of parents, including one of our listeners. By the way,
- 57:38yeah, so by the way, I could almost see them trying to
- 57:43defend, like like, well, no, let me demonstrate what I mean,
- 57:45Like, you know, okay, so that's happening. So what I
- 57:47do is I kind of put whatever right. But even that's still not good.
- 57:52But even if they're like they're writing this book, no one's gonna interpret
- 57:57it the same way. And there's plenty of parents that will be like,
- 58:00oh, okay, plan, you know right, which is exactly what we're
- 58:06going to get into in a second. Also, the book basically claims if
- 58:12the children don't respond well to the punishments that you're giving out, the parents
- 58:15need to make the punishes, the punishments more severe until you break your child.
- 58:22Yeah, that's the Ruby thing. There is no limit in truth,
- 58:25right. This is not something that this guy made up, Michael Pearl or
- 58:32Ruby Frankie. It's something that has been in our society for a long time.
- 58:37It's just promoted by this book and claimed by many of the churches that
- 58:42adhere to IBLP as the Godly Waked. Because it wasn't just like this is
- 58:46what will help you to get control of your kid. I mean that was
- 58:51you know, probably what was you know what it was sold as. But
- 58:53it's also how you're going to save your child from hell, how you're going
- 58:58to get your kid in heaven. Because it all leads up to when they're
- 59:00a teenager an adult and they start making choices. You need to be in
- 59:05total control. And I know many of you know this, but just to
- 59:07be captain obvious for a second, is that research shows that when you enact
- 59:13this kind of control parenting, but also other kinds of control, whether it's
- 59:17at work or other kinds of social environments where there's authority, it's well researched,
- 59:22well understood, found through dozens of angles that yes, you might actually
- 59:27establish control and obedience of the people that are receiving the abuse, but they're
- 59:32not following the rules because they want to. They're following the rules out of
- 59:37terrorizing fear, and as a result of that terrorizing fear, there are a
- 59:42lot of other consequences, like they never are able to feel safe in the
- 59:46world in any situation. They don't know their own feelings, they don't know
- 59:50their emotions, they're psychologically stunted in a lot of ways, or in a
- 59:55constant state of anxiety and fight or flight, or the other side, what
- 1:00:00you'll see is massive anger and rebellion because it just becomes too much for these
- 1:00:06individuals at some point in their life. So, yeah, you might temporarily
- 1:00:10if you go on a campaign to do this kind of thing, you might
- 1:00:14see in your four year old less rebellion or less annoying behaviors, but you'll
- 1:00:19also see the child shutting down. The child turning away from you. The
- 1:00:23child doesn't want to bond with you, and of course, if you have
- 1:00:28twenty kids, you might not even notice that, right. So it's really
- 1:00:34depressing to think about not only all the people that are abused in the world,
- 1:00:38and not only all the people that are abused the United States, but
- 1:00:42that it was prescribed under the charismatic leader and also all the ministers and all
- 1:00:50these various churches that it was you know that you can imagine there would be
- 1:00:53a set of parents that was not going in this direction, but then we're
- 1:00:58told they needed to and then and did it. You know, it's one
- 1:01:00thing if the parents were going to do it anyway, it's just like it's
- 1:01:04not great, but whatever. But there were probably tens of thousands, hundreds
- 1:01:07of thousands, millions of parents who would not have done this or wouldn't have
- 1:01:12been this severe, and they adopted this because it was being shoved down their
- 1:01:15throat. Yeah, it's it's it's demoralizing, you know, because for me,
- 1:01:21in my field, we start our days, our careers, our lives
- 1:01:25with trying to make the world a better place. One of things one of
- 1:01:30the things that a lot of people are putting a lot of effort into I
- 1:01:34put a lot more effort into into this in my past because I worked more
- 1:01:37with families in the beginning of my career, specifically families that were abusing their
- 1:01:40kids. CPS would actually call me and pay for me to go into the
- 1:01:44house and try to end the abuse. You know, we do it for
- 1:01:46our job, but we also are trying to stop the abuse and to have
- 1:01:52this you know, it's like trying to hold back the water from the dam
- 1:01:59by you know, there's like all these Yeah, it's just it feels like
- 1:02:06you fight and you you do what you can, and then stuff like this
- 1:02:08comes out and you hear about this, and it's just like, how are
- 1:02:12we supposed to combat this? Yeah, you're standing there and then there's a
- 1:02:15whole other dam that just broke on you're next to. Yeah, or I've
- 1:02:19been underwater the whole time, you know, like I've just been deluding myself
- 1:02:22that somehow the world is getting to be better for children. Now, empirically,
- 1:02:27the world does seem to be getting for children. But you know,
- 1:02:30a lot of these things were happening and are still to this day. There's
- 1:02:32still a lot of people who read this book and follow it actually, So
- 1:02:37to give you some an idea, there's an Amazon review that I just pulled
- 1:02:43off Amazon, someone who gave the book a five. The book on average,
- 1:02:47it's like a three and a half Stark, which isn't great. But
- 1:02:52it's all five stars and one stars, and there's a you know, I
- 1:02:54think there's a lot of people that aren't really readers of the book but know
- 1:02:59about it, leaving bad reviews. Most of the people that read the book
- 1:03:02are actually giving it five stars, and this is one of them. I'm
- 1:03:06glad that Amazon dot uk is holding up free speech and is selling this book.
- 1:03:12Michael Pearl is writing how to successfully raise a child. Our parents and
- 1:03:17generations grew up like this, and who will doubt that those generations were great
- 1:03:22generations make America great again. But look at us now today, mentally degenerated,
- 1:03:30no purpose in life, crime written, The youth is a mess,
- 1:03:34knows no boundaries, respects no one, and nearly all families are broken.
- 1:03:38Why a lack of God's word and a lack of disciplining children, not quote
- 1:03:45unquote beating them up, as the hate filled Amazon spammers suggest, but by
- 1:03:50lovingly disciplining them the way the Bible tells over and over again. Just one
- 1:03:54example from Proverbs twenty nine fifteen. Quote, the raw and reproof give wisdom.
- 1:04:02The rod and reproof give wisdom. Reproof means must be some kind of
- 1:04:08like a like a like a like a verbal punishment or something. Yeah,
- 1:04:12the rod and reproof give wisdom. But a child left to himself bringeth his
- 1:04:16mother to shame. Just just the mother, I mean. So what's interesting
- 1:04:21is the fathers and the grandfather's generation was great and they were beat you know,
- 1:04:27oh sorry, not be lovingly beat. So what happened? What happened?
- 1:04:32Because if the chain was unbroken, what happened? How did the chain
- 1:04:38break? Why is this generation not good? Were we not beat? Oh
- 1:04:43it's because we were not beat. But if we were not beating, it
- 1:04:44means our parents, who were good people, didn't beat us. Why didn't
- 1:04:47they beat us? Weren't they supposed to beat us? What happened to them
- 1:04:49that they didn't beat us? Like the logic breaks down immediately, right,
- 1:04:54It's like this, this simplistic notion, like, well, you know,
- 1:04:59the pastors always better, and I see our parents and our grandparents were better
- 1:05:02people because they were beat. But now we're not because we weren't beat by
- 1:05:06the people that I just said were better people. Yeah, I don't,
- 1:05:10doesn't make any sense. Yeah, and even the notion that the generations before
- 1:05:15us were more compliant is not born out in the data. It certainly is
- 1:05:20through rose colored glasses the way that we look at the past, maybe even
- 1:05:26those people who live the past. But it's hard to test that, right,
- 1:05:30No, No, that makes a lot of sense because the Civil War
- 1:05:33happened now, right, and the French Revolution happened now, and all the
- 1:05:39wars and all the conflict from the compliant people that didn't raise revolutions at rebellions,
- 1:05:44that was all now yeah, yeah, So now trigger warning. This
- 1:05:48is I'm going to describe in detail two of the three cases that have been
- 1:05:56reported of children dying because of parents who were followed this book specifically. So
- 1:06:00skip forward a while if you don't want to hear those details. And I
- 1:06:03apologize for the past. Some of the patrons were saying, like when I
- 1:06:08was talking about Twilight Zone and those kind of tragedies, I didn't say trigger
- 1:06:12warning, which I should have because it I think I was trying to shock
- 1:06:17you because I knew you could handle it. By the way, these were
- 1:06:20all homeschooled children. Maybe not IBLP, but very much like the IBLP kids.
- 1:06:27So the first kid is Lydia Schatz. So she was born in two
- 1:06:30thousand and two, and she was a seven year old American child from Liberia,
- 1:06:38adopted by parents in rural California. So I don't know at what age
- 1:06:43she was adopted, but at the time of her death she was seven years
- 1:06:47old. So killed in twenty ten as they were attempting to discipline her.
- 1:06:54And here's the incident. So they whipped her with a quarter inch plastic tube.
- 1:07:00By the way, this is specifically prescripted in Michael Pearl's book. He
- 1:07:04says to use a plastic tube that is a quarter of an inch wide.
- 1:07:10And on the surface, you might think, well, it's not like a
- 1:07:13bat, but just listen to the rest of this. So she was held
- 1:07:17down for nine hours by the mother while the father beat her repeatedly with the
- 1:07:25quarter inch plastic tube. And we can recall the principle that put forth by
- 1:07:31Michael Pearl that if the child continues to break the rules, you go more
- 1:07:38extremes. So if you know you're telling a kid to shut up or stop
- 1:07:42crying, or whatever. And you know, this doesn't even take into account
- 1:07:47the massive amounts of attachment trauma that this kid went through. Probably I don't
- 1:07:51know, but if the child was adopted, you know, post six months,
- 1:07:57then you know there's going to be some issues there. Potentially not always,
- 1:08:00but and the fact that the kids I think black, living in rural
- 1:08:06California, god knows. But anyway, so she was being held down for
- 1:08:13nine hours. You know, the book doesn't talk about limits, it doesn't.
- 1:08:17You know. It does try to say, don't beat your kids.
- 1:08:19There is some lip service to that, but it also says, you know,
- 1:08:24keep amp amping it up, you know. And so anyway, she
- 1:08:26was being disciplined for apparently mispronouncing a word though brutal. Yeah, so you
- 1:08:33know the you know, when you hear an issue like holding a child down
- 1:08:38for nine hours, you're not looking at a normal set of parents to begin
- 1:08:41with, right, so you would also expect that there would be discipline for
- 1:08:45things you wouldn't think a child would be disciplined for. So it seems as
- 1:08:48though these parents were bad to begin with, sadistic or psychopathic or problematic or
- 1:08:54something in some way, but the book influenced them and gave them permission or
- 1:08:59pushed them and more down that road or something, because I'm guessing the average
- 1:09:02reader of this book wouldn't have done this. But anyway, her sister,
- 1:09:06Zariyah, eleven years old, was also beaten for quote, being a liar
- 1:09:13and a bad influence on the seven year old, and she was hospitalized in
- 1:09:16critical critical condition with severe injuries. But she actually survived. So you know,
- 1:09:21when you hear critical condition, that's serious. It's not just like a
- 1:09:25broken bone or some bruises. She was near death, right, So once
- 1:09:30the child is deceased, there's an investigation, thank goodness, and the parents
- 1:09:35are charged and during the trial, the father was found guilty of second degree
- 1:09:42murder and torture and was sentenced to two concurrent life sentences with a twenty two
- 1:09:47years minimum. So you know, I normally don't condone sentencing someone to be
- 1:09:54beaten with a tube made out of plastic rubber or whatever, but this is
- 1:10:00one of those times that I would, yeah, just you know, and
- 1:10:04if and just to ask every ten minutes is this cool? Are you liking
- 1:10:09it? And if the answer is anything but yes, then you just do
- 1:10:13it more. And if the answer is yes, you do it more.
- 1:10:16Yeah. I mean the sad thing, as I say that in reality is
- 1:10:19that, you know, it's just it's quite possible. I mean that maybe
- 1:10:25that person was a psychopath out of nowhere, but it's quite possible they were
- 1:10:28severely beat as well when they were kids. Who knows what damage they had
- 1:10:32in their head. The whole thing is such a tragedy, but the fact
- 1:10:36is that something influenced them on top of whatever they already had going. Right.
- 1:10:43Uh. Yeah. The mother was found guilty of voluntary manslaughter and infliction
- 1:10:48of unlawful corporal punishment and was sentenced to thirteen years. Michael Pearl was attacked
- 1:10:55by the media and people saying that you influenced this, right, because they
- 1:11:00there was a lot of criticism about the book anyway, and then this happens,
- 1:11:02and he responded to the news about Lydia dying. He argued that him
- 1:11:10being a factor in the murder of Lydia was not objectionable because because his children
- 1:11:18became quote unquote his children, his children, his own children became quote entrepreneurs
- 1:11:25that pay the taxes your children will receive in entitlements. But wait, wait,
- 1:11:30hold on. We were driving down a road and now we just veered
- 1:11:33off into the ditch and I don't understand where which way we're facing. So
- 1:11:38he's speaking to the people that were attacking him, I know, right,
- 1:11:41So the people attacking him say that your book, your book is is preaching
- 1:11:45abusive children. The fact that my book is mentioned here is not a bad
- 1:11:49thing, right, because my kids pay taxes, right and your your lazy
- 1:11:57ass will receive entitlements, will welfare because your government payouts likely black and you're
- 1:12:03poor or you're liberal or something. I'm sure there's racism and that statement,
- 1:12:09yeah, yeah, yeah, he's the little girl was apparently not white,
- 1:12:12right, right, right. I hadn't thought about that that they're wow,
- 1:12:15yeah, no, just wonderful, wonderful around. Yeah, that's his public
- 1:12:19statement. Yeah, but but that was on top of the empathy about the
- 1:12:26victim. And I mean maybe, but it's hard to imagine that the empathy
- 1:12:31goes very deep, given that he would say that sort of thing, you
- 1:12:34know. Anyway, So the second child I want to talk about. Her
- 1:12:40name is Hannah Williams, born in nineteen ninety seven, another adopted child,
- 1:12:45this child from Ethiopia by an American family living in Segro Wooly, Washington.
- 1:12:53You know where Siegrow Williams. No. I think it's north of Seattle.
- 1:12:57It's a small town and Washington state. And she died in twenty eleven of
- 1:13:03hypothermia. So, just as Michael Pearl recommends, Hannah was regularly spanked,
- 1:13:12locked in a closet, denied food is punishment, not allowed to wear clothes,
- 1:13:15forced to sleep in a barn, and take showers with a garden hose.
- 1:13:20And you know, I want to remind people that time she died,
- 1:13:24she would have been twelve or thirteen or something. So the amount of years
- 1:13:28that she went through being spanked and beaten and locked in a closet, denied
- 1:13:31food, not allowed to wear clothes, forced to sleep in a barn,
- 1:13:34taking showers with a garden hose. Okay, So the mother was convicted of
- 1:13:39homicide by abuse, homicide by abuse, and first degree assault of a child
- 1:13:44and was sentenced to thirty seven years in prison. The father was convicted of
- 1:13:46first degree manslaughter and first degree assault of a child and was sentenced to twenty
- 1:13:51seven years in prison. And how is it a limit on that sentence.
- 1:13:57I don't understand, by the way, twenty seven year but when they get
- 1:14:00out, they've lost their license to have kids. Right. Yeah, the
- 1:14:03description here in the news reporting is so much more graphic, right, I
- 1:14:10mean, and so heartbreaking, like I don't understand. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:14:15it's just like what drives me insane about this is it's likely likely the same
- 1:14:24crowds that are going crazy over Q and on and how children are getting harmed
- 1:14:29all over the world and all this stuff. Yeah. Now, I'm sure
- 1:14:32the vast majority of children who were raised by parents influenced by this book,
- 1:14:38you know, they didn't die, right, But so these are the this
- 1:14:41is the tip of the tip of the iceberg. Right. The kids that
- 1:14:44die are the ones that the abuse was severe enough or in a way that
- 1:14:48was such that it resulted in the murdering of a child. But just think
- 1:14:53about all the millions of other kids who are being treated this way and it
- 1:14:57didn't result in death, because you know, you can imagine the kinds of
- 1:15:00things that are severe abuse still severe damage physical emotional everything, torture. Yeah,
- 1:15:05there's a pretty good chance that with Lydia that the parents had held her
- 1:15:10down before and beaten her before for maybe eight hours at a time or something,
- 1:15:15And and think about all the other kids who have been through that sort
- 1:15:18of parenting and been through that sort of abuse and torture, and then you
- 1:15:21know that's horrible. It's another thing, or it's further painful and torturous to
- 1:15:28know that this is coming from a book that's kind of mainstream in your community
- 1:15:31and from a pastor right that it's considered to be a wonderful book, and
- 1:15:38the parents are saying, look, I'm doing what's in here. It's so
- 1:15:42horrible. Like, there's few things more horrible than seeing hearing about like these
- 1:15:49tortures of little children inspired by a pastor writing a book about torturing children.
- 1:15:58Yeah, also to rub salt in our wounds. Burdough, is that his
- 1:16:04publishing house or whatever his organization, because he also is hired to do a
- 1:16:09lot of speaking. It's a nonprofit organization, so they don't pay federal taxes,
- 1:16:14of course they don't. Yeah, Yeah, what about at least putting
- 1:16:16warnings or having to like link books that contradict the material or like, well,
- 1:16:23what I would hope is that a book like this would not be popular
- 1:16:27to begin with, because if you did get rid of this book, it's
- 1:16:30not like the practices would go away right right, But since it since it's
- 1:16:34you know, impossible to control sometimes while it gets popular, I still think
- 1:16:39like there should be some responsibility on the side of the publishing companies as well
- 1:16:43as the distributing companies to offer more information to people. Yeah, like why
- 1:16:48not do you have the book? Say, and by the way, there
- 1:16:50are three deaths associated with you know, yeah, like what would I do?
- 1:16:56I would one just not have it on my site. But think another
- 1:17:00thing you could do is you could mention that, but you could also mention
- 1:17:02more detailed information about the research on using corporal punishment and this kind of torture
- 1:17:09on kids like it, because that's the more salient points, like the idea
- 1:17:13of this book is actually not in service of what you want. You're trying
- 1:17:16to do offer books that contradict the thing because or data, because sites have
- 1:17:21had to do this for things like when you go on YouTube or or Facebook
- 1:17:26or whatever. Sometimes they have to say, hey, these are not facts,
- 1:17:29like Joe Rogan having to have a disclaimer that he doesn't know what he's
- 1:17:32talking about when he talks about vaccines and science and stuff. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:17:38well, on that depressing note, burto let's take a break and we
- 1:17:42get back this let's adjourn chapter thirteen of the Duggert Deep Dive. This will
- 1:17:45be our final chapter and the final chapters, final chapter, and in the
- 1:17:54patron zone, we're going to go over the allegations of I'm in a Summer,
- 1:18:00the allegations against IBLP and Bill Gothard. The documentary Shiny Appie people went
- 1:18:04into a little bit of it, but didn't go into enough of it.
- 1:18:08In fact, we talked about in an earlier chapter about yeah, and it
- 1:18:12was unconvincing to me for the most part. I remember right, it was
- 1:18:15like he did something, yeah, And then there were some specifics that were
- 1:18:19identified by some of the victims. But when you learn the actual accounts and
- 1:18:25the court documents, you know people that are stating these allegations for the record,
- 1:18:30it's way worse than the documentary made it seem to me anyway. So
- 1:18:35we're gonna do that, and then we're also going to talk about We're going
- 1:18:39to answer the question is IBLP a cult? Because I have over the years
- 1:18:43developed my own criteria based on other systems of evaluating cults, because we often
- 1:18:48talk about it, and I have been identifying it as a cult. But
- 1:18:51is it really a cult? Can it be categorized that way? You know,
- 1:18:55we can't just throw that word around willy nilly, So let's get into
- 1:18:59that and the page own and so become a patron if you want to hear
- 1:19:01the rest of this, and if you don't want to become a patron,
- 1:19:04that's also fine with me. Hurts me a little bit, but but no,
- 1:19:09no, it's fine. Especially you know, money is tight right now,
- 1:19:13so beyond a patron if you want to hear the rest of this,
- 1:19:15and otherwise, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.