Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA's Focus On Corporate Governance
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today we have a topic that we've referred to in a lot of past podcasts.
- 0:10We've referred to in a lot of discussions with credit unions and our clients.
- 0:15And I'm excited again to be back with Todd Miller and Steve Farr of
- 0:19my team and also formerly of NCUA.
- 0:22Guys, how you doing today?
- 0:24Steve Farrar: Enjoying the fall.
- 0:25Enjoying the fall.
- 0:27Treichel: Very good.
- 0:27Very good.
- 0:28And just in case we have new listeners today who are listening to With Flying
- 0:32Colors for the 1st time, why don't you give a little bit of your background?
- 0:36Todd, we'll start with you.
- 0:39Todd Miller: Okay I was with NCUA for 34 years.
- 0:43During that time, I can probably break my career into 3 pieces, about a 3rd
- 0:47of it as an examiner and a problem case officer, a 3rd of it as a regional capital
- 0:52market specialist, and a 3rd of it as a director of special actions, supervising
- 0:57problem case officers, capital market specialist, regional lending specialist.
- 1:02Very enjoyable career.
- 1:04Most of it, even my time as a capital market specialist spent a lot of it
- 1:09dealing with troubled credit unions at the heart of troubled credit
- 1:12unions is corporate governance issues.
- 1:14So today will be a fun topic to talk about.
- 1:19Treichel: Indeed.
- 1:19And Steve your background.
- 1:20Steve Farrar: Yeah, it's more specific to this topic.
- 1:24I'll address it in my career was also in 2 parts.
- 1:27The 1st, 15 years was out in the field as a problem case officer.
- 1:31And then the 2nd part was 15 years in the central office in the field,
- 1:36though, I got to work with troubled credit unions and it'd be funny.
- 1:40We'd come into the ones that.
- 1:42Poor corporate governance is why they ended up being in a problem case and
- 1:47we did have Todd and I worked together on that and we have a large number of
- 1:52credit unions We worked with that were extremely troubled that are turned
- 1:55around and are still in existence today And I think that you don't see a lot
- 2:00of those turnarounds being quite as successful today as they were then.
- 2:04So it's even more important to not end up in that situation that the ones that
- 2:10we were able to turn around happen.
- 2:13Then in the central office, I got to be involved in a lot of the policy
- 2:17development and our efforts where we would be trying to provide guidance to credit
- 2:22unions on the issues that were upcoming.
- 2:24I think that'll be helpful as we go through this subject.
- 2:28Treichel: Very good.
- 2:28Yeah.
- 2:28And, we used to be able to help credit unions before prompt corrective action
- 2:32and utilizing whether it was 208 assistance to actually allow capital
- 2:36to go negative when prompt corrective action came around that, that challenged
- 2:41the ability sometimes to work with institutions a little bit more freely.
- 2:46So while it was a rule that other banking regulators had, and it made
- 2:50sense theoretically to give it to credit unions, it did take away.
- 2:53Some of the flexibility, so well, so corporate governance, we've been
- 2:57seeing it a lot in exam reports.
- 3:00We've been talking about it in references to code for code 5
- 3:04podcast, which we recently did.
- 3:06But how would you guys define corporate governance?
- 3:09Why don't we start there?
- 3:11Todd Miller: If you Google a definition for corporate governance,
- 3:14you'll get 720, 000 results.
- 3:16So there's a lot of variations on this definition.
- 3:21I think what we'll use is the FDIC has one that is more institution specific.
- 3:28Maybe we'll use that one as a starting point from the FDIC.
- 3:33They say corporate governance is a set of processes, custom policies and
- 3:38laws affecting the way a corporation is directed, administered, controlled,
- 3:43how it manages risk, ensures compliance with laws and regulations,
- 3:47including consumer protection laws.
- 3:50And regulations and the community reinvestment act, not applicable to
- 3:54credit unions, corporate governance also includes the relationships
- 3:58among the many stakeholders involved and the corporations goals.
- 4:03It's a comprehensive 1.
- 4:05But basically, when you summarize all these definitions
- 4:08down and compare them all.
- 4:11It's basically a structure of rules, practices and processes.
- 4:14You can actually distill that down to corporate culture, which is
- 4:17really what a board is responsible for is that corporate culture.
- 4:22As we both Steve and I alluded to poor corporate governance, it often leads
- 4:28to the failure of an organization.
- 4:30I don't know how many times when we go into a problem case and.
- 4:34We'd sit down and lay out the issues for the board.
- 4:36The boards would just say, I was totally unaware.
- 4:40And along those lines, though, as Steve said, we fixed a lot of them.
- 4:43I think we should maybe throw a shout out there to all these corporate
- 4:47directors and credit union directors.
- 4:50Those men and women, they devote a lot of time.
- 4:52Most of them are unpaid with a few exceptions in a minor states.
- 4:56And by and large, they're very dedicated and they do a very good job
- 5:00of keeping our system safe and sound.
- 5:02And I was always surprised in trouble credit unions when we tell credit unions.
- 5:07Boards and they'd say, Hey, we didn't know what was going on.
- 5:11They didn't resign and walk away.
- 5:12They always stayed there to help fix it.
- 5:14And that always amazed me over my career, their dedication to restore
- 5:21their institution to good health.
- 5:24Treichel: Great points there, Steve, any thoughts on what Todd had to stay there?
- 5:28Steve Farrar: Yeah, I tried to what's the simplest way to break down what you're
- 5:32trying to do with corporate governance?
- 5:34And it's I came up with, being proactive, smarter risk taking and 1 that I is near
- 5:40and dear to my heart is ethical standards.
- 5:43Is Todd and I can tell you that some of the ones that where the board
- 5:47members probably weren't part of the solution were places we went into
- 5:51with really poor ethical standards.
- 5:54That was always the most frustrating 1, because it's greed takes hold in,
- 5:58in, in some of these cases, and it can make people do really poor decisions.
- 6:05Treichel: Great points by all of you there.
- 6:06I'm going to, I'm going to highlight a couple things.
- 6:08The shout out to those who serve great point Todd with the fact
- 6:13that that people don't walk away.
- 6:15A, the fact that they're there to begin with, but B, that when it
- 6:17gets tough they circle the wagons and and strive to, to make it work.
- 6:22On the ethical standards side I can think of cases where I was involved and
- 6:28I can think of client situations where, for example, there were write offs that
- 6:33had to happen whether it was accounting issues or conversion issues and What
- 6:38happens with NCUA when there's a write off like that, they're in there is, NCUA
- 6:43thinks, is there an ethical issue, right?
- 6:45Were these write offs legitimate write offs and errors or did
- 6:49somebody benefit from it?
- 6:50And we've seen that over the last couple of years, we've seen that, during our
- 6:54career where there was fraud or there was just situations because of the,
- 6:59Quality of the books and records.
- 7:01There was the opportunity for fraud and that can get into a hyper focused
- 7:06whether or not it was fraud or not.
- 7:08The fact that there's a write off gets into a really focused on what happened
- 7:12there were their ethical challenges, etc.
- 7:15And then Todd, you mentioned in that definition from the FDIC side
- 7:20Community Reinvestment Act, and it doesn't apply to credit unions.
- 7:24There are some rumblings from NCUA's Chairman Todd Harper, who
- 7:27was asking on LinkedIn if CRA should be expanded for credit unions.
- 7:33That triggered a letter from the Defense Council BCUC Trade Association
- 7:40saying, no, there shouldn't be.
- 7:41I actually, it was the first time I commented on a post by an
- 7:45NCUA board member since I left.
- 7:47I said, no, you don't need a Community Reinvestment Act because we you
- 7:52have the ability through the modest means requirement of the Federal
- 7:55Credit Union Act to do whatever you need regulatory and guidance wise.
- 7:59So I've got a podcast queued up for that topic coming out.
- 8:04And so that's just a heads up to that.
- 8:05But hopefully that doesn't get any legs because it would just be
- 8:10another burden for credit unions.
- 8:11Any comments relative to my response to where we're at on
- 8:15the definition and those things.
- 8:18Todd Miller: No, I think we'll expand on this as we go.
- 8:21Treichel: You got it.
- 8:22You got it.
- 8:23Maybe
- 8:23Todd Miller: a good place to start here now is maybe let people know where are
- 8:28some resources for partying director.
- 8:30Say you're a new director, you're a board and you've done a self
- 8:34assessment and you're trying to figure out, our way forward.
- 8:38How can we.
- 8:39Improve.
- 8:40There are various resources out there.
- 8:42In many cases, NCOA might not be your best one, but NCOA does have some resources.
- 8:48First off, they actually lay out the director's responsibility
- 8:51and the rules and regulations.
- 8:53It's in 701.
- 8:554 and just by regulations, Directors are supposed to have the general direction
- 9:01and control of the credit union.
- 9:03They may delegate a lot of operation functions.
- 9:06They let management implement a lot of the policies, but ultimate
- 9:11responsibility for each credit union's board is that they're in charge, they
- 9:18have direction, they have control of the credit union and that general
- 9:23direction and control in the regulation.
- 9:25And the regulation says that's non delegatable.
- 9:28They don't get to foster that off on their management.
- 9:32So in the regulation, it lays out some things that expects that parties carry out
- 9:36their duties as a director in good faith.
- 9:39They expect them to be fair and impartial without discrimination to any 1 group of
- 9:46members over another group of members.
- 9:48There's an expectation for some board basic financial training and regulation.
- 9:53And then there's The regulation expects them to direct the operations of the
- 9:58credit union in conformity with the law.
- 10:00The act, their bylaws, this regulation, and they have this catch all phrase in
- 10:06there, sound business practices, which they don't really define anywhere.
- 10:12So that's a somewhat interesting piece.
- 10:14When you go beyond that.
- 10:17Actually has very little specific resources for credit unions.
- 10:22They have some stuff in the exam guide that talks about a
- 10:25director's responsibilities and board and committee minutes.
- 10:29They have a flag in their exam guide that.
- 10:32There's an upcoming and under development chapter for directors at one time,
- 10:38and I used to publish a handbook for directors or board members, little
- 10:42blue handbook that doesn't exist.
- 10:46It's not on their website anymore.
- 10:47They probably haven't updated it since it was done a long time ago.
- 10:52But other than that, NCOA doesn't have a lot of specific resources
- 10:56specific to board governance.
- 10:59They do for some corporate credit unions.
- 11:00If you dig through some old corporate letters but in general, you have to
- 11:06infer what NCOA's expectation for board members are from that regulation.
- 11:11And from their bodies and letters to credit unions,
- 11:14which covers specific topics.
- 11:16There's not really one out there that talks about general door governance.
- 11:21So what I would suggest for credit unions is you go look at the
- 11:24FDIC and the other regulators.
- 11:26The FDIC does have a pocket guide for directors.
- 11:30It's six, seven pages, maybe a little bit shorter, depending on
- 11:34how big of a font you make your Internet page when you print it out.
- 11:37They keep it updated.
- 11:38It's done very well.
- 11:40Back in 2016, they did a supervisory insight.
- 11:44So they did a really longer commentary on that supervisory guide or on
- 11:48that pocket guide for directors.
- 11:50It's actually really good.
- 11:51It's not a very long read either, only 10, 15 pages.
- 11:56And then something unusual, and we'll let Steve talk about this
- 11:59because he's an expert on it.
- 12:01The FDIC actually has proposed guidance.
- 12:04I don't know if the comment period is closed on it or not on corporate
- 12:08governance for larger institutions, so as you start getting more complex,
- 12:13if you look through all the corporate governance literature, it will always
- 12:16say your systems should be commensurate with your size and complexity.
- 12:21You don't need to be perfect thing in a small credit union, but as you get
- 12:25larger and more complex the duties of your directors become more involved
- 12:30and those internal controls and those.
- 12:33Risk management structures and that strategic planning.
- 12:36It all has to change as you grow in size, but this proposed guidance that the
- 12:41FDIC is issued for larger institutions.
- 12:45It's a good guidance to give you an idea of where you might want to be as you grow
- 12:52larger and expand and size and complexity.
- 12:57Steve Farrar: One other tool that I mentioned that came across as
- 12:59we were doing research on this that FDIC has out there is.
- 13:02They have a youtube video that's on corporate governance.
- 13:06So you just go into youtube and type fdic corporate governance They'll bring it up.
- 13:09It's a good introduction I would say for a board member in a half hour brings
- 13:16them through You know a an overview Of corporate governance and it might be
- 13:21something that somebody after listening to this podcast might want to look at Because
- 13:26they give you a half hour some more tools.
- 13:28So you want to take if you're going to You Discuss it with
- 13:30your board members, but one more resource that was unique out there
- 13:35Treichel: and I'll put links to all of those.
- 13:37Sadly, most of the links will be to FDIC as Todd kind of summarize.
- 13:41There's not a lot out there from N.
- 13:43C.
- 13:43U.
- 13:43A.
- 13:44And by the way, Steve, I did see you sent me that YouTube video.
- 13:48I've converted that into a podcast for the sister podcast, the credit union guidance,
- 13:53and I put FDIC guidance on there as well.
- 13:56I downloaded that turn it into an MP3 and it'll come out I think next month on
- 14:01that, on our other podcast credit union regulatory guidance in the voice of NC
- 14:07with an intro from Samantha shares and in the voice of of those folks on NCOA.
- 14:12So if someone likes audio book style, that'll be out there soon.
- 14:16It's interesting with it, it may be not interesting, might
- 14:19not be the best word, but it's.
- 14:22With the frequency that we're seeing corporate governance referred to in our
- 14:27conversations with credit unions that they're having with NCUA, for there to
- 14:32be this big blind spot in guidance from NCUA, because, as we've talked about, if
- 14:39you have a problem in topic A, B, C, D, E, F, Z, it seems to be linked to corporate
- 14:46governance from NCUA these days, and it it's an area where hopefully they'll
- 14:51catch up with the FDIC and have have some guidance coming out relative to that,
- 14:57but that's more of an editorial comment.
- 15:00As far as the best document that's out, there seems to be this FDIC proposed
- 15:04rule, which I think if I remember, the comments are due to FDIC by December.
- 15:09So they're still taking comments on that.
- 15:10Steve Farrar: It was probably December of last year.
- 15:12'cause it came out one year ago in October of 2013.
- 15:16So I think your chancellor comment is well passed on that.
- 15:20Very good.
- 15:21They still haven't approved it yet, so they haven't moved forward on it.
- 15:25And, I think, that's being affected by, things that not necessarily
- 15:29related to the policy itself.
- 15:32Treichel: Got it.
- 15:33Very good.
- 15:33And Steve, with that, you you've read this guidance from FDIC.
- 15:37I think much more than Todd and I have.
- 15:40We've made reference to it.
- 15:41But why don't you give us our take on the pros of that guidance
- 15:46from FDIC and what credit unions might be able to take from it?
- 15:50Steve Farrar: Yeah, I get Todd accuses me of carrying this around in my back pocket
- 15:54because it's a, I refer to it pretty constantly and while it is just proposed.
- 16:00Guidance for credit unions over 10 billion or more.
- 16:05It is a great document.
- 16:06It outlines and we'll go through the outline all the parts of of a good.
- 16:13Corporate management and explains, we talked about that it's important
- 16:17because of failures, but they note in this proposed rule that this failure of
- 16:23signature bank found that the root cause of failure was poor management without
- 16:27adequate risk management practices and controls and the same as silicone bank.
- 16:33They're big losses, they directly attributed to this
- 16:36poor corporate governance.
- 16:38I'll just go through and hit the, kind of the outline of the of the rule under
- 16:43corporate governance, I'd like that it starts with the board of directors,
- 16:46general obligations, as Todd talked about, that the, the board is ultimately
- 16:51responsible for complying with, as Todd pointed out, governing laws, And here's an
- 16:56issue that we've discussed about it about you have to look at the board composition
- 17:02and the, it is important as your credit union is a bigger and, maybe your field
- 17:08of membership becomes more broad that the board is looking at what kind of
- 17:13skills are they looking for and need.
- 17:16To have a well rounded board with the right professional knowledge to be able
- 17:22to work through all of these issues.
- 17:24And I think that's an issue that's passed on a lot.
- 17:27I'll ask if you guys have, any comments on, the importance
- 17:30of that board composition.
- 17:32Treichel: I have some thoughts, but Todd, let's hear what, if you have any first, I
- 17:35Steve Farrar: have
- 17:35Todd Miller: a good story about that.
- 17:37It's interesting.
- 17:38You mentioned signature bank, but if you look at postmortems, there are almost
- 17:42all for governance and board failures to, but in board composition, it's important
- 17:47that you have diversity of skills on there and diversity of backgrounds.
- 17:51I had a troubled credit union one time in California.
- 17:55But every director was a retired teacher in their 60s or 70s, and you start
- 18:03looking at their services and it's just, there's, that's another thing you find
- 18:07in trouble cardians is you're generally a breakdown and services and you start
- 18:11mentioning things to the board that.
- 18:14Really, the way you guys are offering services to your members, it doesn't
- 18:18fit your membership demographic.
- 18:20Basically, all the policies fees, everything were skewed to retired people
- 18:25and it never hit home for the board.
- 18:27They said that wasn't applicable to us.
- 18:29They yelled at me when I told him that, but we come back 3 months
- 18:32later, and the director just says, hey, thanks for bringing it up.
- 18:35He said, I asked my open accounts for all my grandkids and they all closed
- 18:39them because our service was terrible.
- 18:41And it took that to get the directors to get off their stools.
- 18:46But you do just need to be aware of that diversity amongst
- 18:50your directors is a strength.
- 18:52You can create blind spots in your board.
- 18:56If everyone is from that same exact demographic and in background.
- 19:01So those skills are necessary, but.
- 19:04Very demographics and different points of view are important
- 19:08to be on that board as well.
- 19:10Treichel: That's a great comment.
- 19:11That reminds me of one of my favorite books, The Wisdom of Crowds,
- 19:14which I've referred to here a lot.
- 19:15But you have those blind spots if you don't have the diversity of thought.
- 19:18Todd, you said the diversity of skills.
- 19:21And then, of course, just the diversity for different minority groups.
- 19:24And I'll take this as an opportunity to refer to NCUA's proposed rule on
- 19:30succession planning, which requires Many things which will likely require many
- 19:37things as it relates to key positions and succession planning, including
- 19:42diversity, they actually tiptoe into the diversity and they include the board
- 19:46as key positions, which makes sense.
- 19:48And now, of course, we wrote a comment letter on that, and all 3 of us
- 19:52believe that guidance would be more appropriate than regulations, but.
- 19:55Be that as it may, I think by the end of the year, NCOA will probably have
- 19:59that rule in place, and credit unions should should watch that and look to
- 20:04see what the diversity requirements are there, and it does make sense to have a
- 20:08diverse board in all of those areas so that you don't have those blind spots.
- 20:13Any other thoughts on that, or do we want to jump to the next major category of this
- 20:17Steve Farrar: proposed guidance?
- 20:19I'll go ahead and move us forward.
- 20:20The next one is a big area here.
- 20:22It talks about and lays out that has it sees in terms of corporate
- 20:26governance, the duties of the board.
- 20:28And number one is great set an appropriate tone, that corporate culture is a big deal
- 20:34I mean we taught and we've talked about the problems and the ones that failed It
- 20:38did start at the top and resonated through so Yeah, we all probably have things
- 20:44that we could mention real quickly about that setting appropriate tone you know
- 20:50more and how did any of our Places change from the inappropriate tone at the top
- 20:57to correct, corrected corporate culture
- 21:01Treichel: thoughts on what Steve had to say there.
- 21:04Todd Miller: That tone from the top, it, it starts from the directors.
- 21:08A lot of times it gets heavily influenced by executive management.
- 21:13I don't want to take Steve's thunder away that, the biggest responsibility
- 21:18of a board is to pick their management team, their CEO And they need to
- 21:25keep that whole culture in mind and not pick a CEO that's going to
- 21:29dominate and determine that culture.
- 21:31It needs to come from the board.
- 21:33And this is 1 of those things where the board is independent.
- 21:35They still have to work very cooperatively with their management team, but
- 21:40they got to keep that independence.
- 21:42And it's important that board set the tone and a lot of boards just, yeah.
- 21:49Some are really good at it, and some just do it informally, and they don't
- 21:52even realize that they're doing it.
- 21:55And that's when you get those breakdowns.
- 21:58Treichel: Now that's a great point.
- 21:59I think about, my time at NCUA and different boards
- 22:02that set the tone differently.
- 22:04And of course, I had the ability as executive director or deputy
- 22:07executive director to set my own tone in my conversations with staff.
- 22:11And I look back to when I was deputy executive director.
- 22:16And versus, 15, 20 years later when I was the executive director and, just
- 22:21the importance of when you meet people on the elevator and instilling in them
- 22:27the confidence of what's going on.
- 22:30And I might have been having a bad day on the 7th floor at N.
- 22:33C.
- 22:33U.
- 22:33A.
- 22:34But it was important for that to stay on the 7th floor and for the discussions
- 22:39with staff to be focused and be positive and be ethically driven, which we're
- 22:44going to get to, et cetera, et cetera.
- 22:45But, yeah, the tone from the top.
- 22:47It's easy to lose sight of that as you're busy getting things done, but it
- 22:51really needs to be ever present in the mind of the board and the mind of the
- 22:55executives and the mind of the tellers as they're dealing, because it trickles
- 22:59down while they're not at the top.
- 23:01It trickles from the top to the middle, to the front line, and to the members,
- 23:06which is why it's so important.
- 23:08Steve Farrar: Yeah, and 1 other way that NCOA can dramatically
- 23:12change the tone that's at the top is through conservatorship.
- 23:16I was involved in a large crediting in New York that NCOA conserved and it was really
- 23:21because of poor corporate governance and that we brought in a huge new management
- 23:27team and that was our number 1 goal is to, change the tone that the employees
- 23:31are getting from the top, that it was not going to be, the business was not
- 23:35going to be done as it had been before.
- 23:38All right, and then the other important one moving on is approve a strategic
- 23:42plan for the covered institution.
- 23:45That's the strategic plan is if you start working with us 1st
- 23:51thing, 1 of the 1st things we'll ask for is your strategic plan.
- 23:55So we want to know where you think you're going and what tool you're going
- 23:59to use to hold management accountable.
- 24:01It has some points in here for strategic PAN, articulate an overall mission
- 24:06statement and strategic objectives to contain a comprehensive assessment
- 24:12of risks that currently affect the covered institution, explain how the
- 24:17covered institution will update as necessary, its risk management program,
- 24:21and explain how the covered program will review, update, And approve
- 24:26the strategic plan as necessary.
- 24:28So that's just a, that's just a drop in the bucket on strategic
- 24:32plan which is, could be a whole topic for a whole separate podcast.
- 24:37But just to how that affects corporate governance.
- 24:40I'll throw that out there.
- 24:42I can
- 24:42Todd Miller: break that down into 3 questions.
- 24:45Where are we now?
- 24:46Where do we want to be?
- 24:48How do we get there?
- 24:50I always thought it was interesting in really high performing credit unions, you
- 24:55could go talk to the little tellers in the lobby and the loan officers and they
- 24:59had a pretty good idea exactly what was in that strategic plan and their roles in it.
- 25:05And it's just something you notice in high performing credit unions, that whole.
- 25:09Culture and that whole plan is communicated all the way down from
- 25:13the board to management to staff, executing it on a day to day basis.
- 25:18You just see that over and high performing organizations
- 25:22Treichel: and I can think of some client conversations we've had where was
- 25:26critical of their strategic plan and what.
- 25:29What seemed to have been driving it in most instances was.
- 25:33The strategic plan said, we're going to do a, B and C.
- 25:37And then what they did was be.
- 25:39X and Y, and there was not a lot of discussion about that pivot.
- 25:44So the credit union had what they perceived to be.
- 25:49A good opportunity that wasn't in the strategic plan, and it may, which may have
- 25:53may or may not have been the case, but there was not a lot of indications in the
- 25:59credit unions records that was something that was fully vetted with the board.
- 26:03And it was, there wasn't an addendum to the strategic plan.
- 26:06There wasn't a big discussion in the board minutes, et cetera, which goes
- 26:09back to, The board being ultimately responsible, and we've seen some
- 26:14situations where pivots were made from the strategic plan that weren't properly.
- 26:22At least documented in, in.
- 26:24In making sure that it was clear that the board wanted to go in that
- 26:29direction and the board saying it after the fact doesn't cut muster
- 26:32within because they view that as.
- 26:35As cleaning up the record, as opposed to establishing a record,
- 26:39Steve Farrar: we have experienced some disagreements between credit
- 26:42unions and NC way as to what kind of a, how long of an outlook.
- 26:46So the strategic plan have most of our research has come up with 3 to 5
- 26:52years is the general recommendation on the length of time it should
- 26:57be doing your strategic plan.
- 26:59Treichel: That's a great point.
- 27:00And if you look at how NCUA does it, it's a five year strategic plan, which
- 27:04may be updated sooner than that if there's a change in the presidency
- 27:08of the United States, because that means there's a change At the board
- 27:11level, but they also then do an annual plan that pivots a little bit.
- 27:15So here's the big strategic plan, and then annually they'll revisit it.
- 27:19And I always thought that was a pretty good way for nnc a to do it.
- 27:22And if a credit union has a three to five year strategic plan, they should
- 27:25be looking at it obviously annually when they're doing their budget, et cetera.
- 27:29Maybe tweak it a little bit, but it doesn't necessarily have
- 27:31to go back to that bigger plan.
- 27:33Todd Miller: I had one credit union, a very troubled one that became a very
- 27:38high performer under new management.
- 27:41They actually had a policy on these kind of one off things like this.
- 27:44These new opportunities come up and it dictated.
- 27:47Here's the business case that we're going to make and present to the board when
- 27:51these opportunities come up that we didn't think about in their strategic plan.
- 27:55And it was a whole risk assessment and a formal.
- 27:58It was a formal listing of here's what you bring to the board if we're going
- 28:02to do something that's outside our plan, because we have a new opportunity
- 28:06that comes up, the world changes, business condition changes, but they
- 28:09had a formal process to deal with those one offs and get them before the board
- 28:14and to make modifications as business opportunities presented themselves.
- 28:19Treichel: I like that.
- 28:20I like that.
- 28:21Steve Farrar: What's next?
- 28:22Steve 1 that we probably don't need to spend much time on because it's
- 28:27pretty self expanded approved policies.
- 28:29The board is responsible for establishing and improving the
- 28:32policies that govern and guide the operations of the covered institution.
- 28:37In accordance with its risk profile and as required by law and regulation.
- 28:42I think that topic is Pretty self explanatory.
- 28:45We all have experience with good policy And lackadaisical
- 28:50policies for lack of a better word
- 28:52Treichel: You know on that topic ncua Here's a kudos to ncua which which I
- 28:57don't always give out As frequently as saying something's missing like
- 29:02not having good corporate governance You They do have a page that lists
- 29:07what policies are recommended, what policies are required with references
- 29:12to to those citations, et cetera.
- 29:15And that was one of the over the last year and a half, one of the better things
- 29:18I saw into a put out on their website.
- 29:20I think I turned it into a PDF and I'll put that in the, a link to
- 29:24that in the show notes as well.
- 29:27Todd Miller: It also gives, does a good job of saying how
- 29:29often boards should review 'em.
- 29:31General guidance to boards is review as necessary, but in most of the financial
- 29:36regulators, there's various policies that are required to be reviewed annually.
- 29:42Others not so much in that resource page that you mentioned, it does
- 29:46actually list out which ones are required by law to be reviewed annually.
- 29:50So good resource for your board calendar.
- 29:54Treichel: Very good.
- 29:55Very good.
- 29:56Steve Farrar: All
- 29:56Treichel: right,
- 29:57Steve Farrar: next
- 29:57Treichel: up number
- 29:58Steve Farrar: 4, establish a code of ethics.
- 30:01The board should establish a written code of ethics for a covered institution,
- 30:04covering directors, management employees, and then, addressing conflicts
- 30:09of interest, self dealing how to report illegal and unethical prepare
- 30:13behavior, and so employees know who it is that they would need to go to.
- 30:19Having just, a platform there.
- 30:22So employees know that there is a program there and that it's found
- 30:26to be important by both the board of directors and senior management
- 30:31Treichel: thought.
- 30:31Steve Farrar: Any
- 30:32Treichel: thoughts on that?
- 30:33Todd Miller: It's just super important.
- 30:34A lot of the bonding companies actually require you have FARD.
- 30:38Fraud policies and ethics policies for employees and directors.
- 30:42It's something that every organization needs.
- 30:45Now you just need that enforcement mechanism.
- 30:49Cause like Steve said, people that operate outside those bounds of ethics
- 30:54create problems more often than not.
- 30:57Treichel: As we're talking through this one and how to
- 31:00report it, a light bulb went on.
- 31:01I think we all had this situation when we were.
- 31:04Examiners where, we did our loan sample and we said, we want these 25 loans.
- 31:09And then when the stack came, there weren't 25, there were 27, right?
- 31:14And there were 2 other loans that they thought we should look at.
- 31:18You recall any any situations there?
- 31:20And of course, there's a direct link to ethics.
- 31:23Probably if they're saying you might want to look at these, there
- 31:26might be some ethical situations.
- 31:28It could have been a board member that got favoritism.
- 31:30It could have been a staff member.
- 31:32Or it could have been in some instances fraud, right?
- 31:36Todd Miller: Yeah, I had a similar thing happen in Ukraine.
- 31:38And it's so they were missing a lot of loans on their commercial loan
- 31:41appraisals, they were missing appraisals.
- 31:44And, an employee just comes in and puts a junk drive on our desk.
- 31:47It's you might want to see this and it's appraisals for all these properties
- 31:51that they tell us they don't have.
- 31:52And of course they're significantly valued under the loan balance.
- 31:56Decorating ended up in conservatorship.
- 31:59Treichel: Wonderful.
- 31:59Yeah, those conservative, those conservatorship war stories
- 32:02tend to pop back into your mind.
- 32:04In good and bad ways as we think back on the history of our time at NCUA.
- 32:08Very good.
- 32:09What's what's up next, Steve?
- 32:11Steve Farrar: Provide active oversight of management.
- 32:13The board should hold management accountable for adhering the strategic
- 32:16plan and approved policies and procedures to ensure the covered
- 32:21institution's compliance with safe and sound banking practices and all
- 32:25applicable laws and regulations.
- 32:27Now, this is the one that, we've been seeing a bit as comments on unhappiness
- 32:32with the evaluation process that the board's doing with senior management.
- 32:37The, you need to have that strategic plan so that they know what you're holding
- 32:42their feet to, but, you need to hold professional management accountable and
- 32:46that strategic plan and those directions that you provide, allow you to do that.
- 32:50But you need to make this process.
- 32:54Appropriately rigorous.
- 32:56Treichel: Appropriately rigorous.
- 32:57I like that.
- 32:58Todd, any thoughts on this?
- 33:00Todd Miller: It's a huge one.
- 33:01So many times we get into trouble with credit unions.
- 33:04Directors need to be independent, but they still need to work
- 33:07cooperatively with management.
- 33:09And often what is they let management take over that supervision of
- 33:14management isn't there that.
- 33:16Appraisal of management isn't there.
- 33:19Management reporting leaves the board in the dark.
- 33:22So the crediting board hasn't set up appropriate controls.
- 33:26It's especially issues.
- 33:28It seems like in smaller rural areas where rather than the board hiring
- 33:33the CEO, you have the CEO recording.
- 33:36Recruiting all the directors and there's nothing wrong with that.
- 33:40But sometimes that whole relationship gets skewed and that's quite
- 33:45often can lead to problems.
- 33:47So I think probably the most important role of board has is hiring appropriate
- 33:55management to carry out the day to day operations of the credit union.
- 33:59And.
- 34:00Supervise them appropriately.
- 34:01And that means a very rigorous, as Steve said, appraisal process.
- 34:06And, this is probably a topic for a separate podcast, but it requires a
- 34:11reporting process where management is demonstrating compliance with all
- 34:15those board directives and policies.
- 34:18Treichel: Great point.
- 34:19And it also reminds me of when it goes awry, sometimes you'll see NCUA
- 34:23ask for an organizational review.
- 34:25We recently.
- 34:27At a podcast on what to do if NCOA requires an organizational review and
- 34:32I believe that might have actually been this week, this past Monday's episode
- 34:36but that can be something when NCOA is not comfortable with how involved the
- 34:42board is, how they're appraising staff, et cetera, that you might get that
- 34:45dropped into your examination report.
- 34:48Steve Farrar: Which is actually, so we've already covered the next topic
- 34:51which is good, because it's selecting a point that qualified executive officers.
- 34:56And so we've got that 1 covered quite well.
- 34:59And we understand the importance of that.
- 35:02Very good next on that is provide ongoing training to directors and I think that's,
- 35:08isn't is important because things.
- 35:11Things move pretty fast.
- 35:12So it's, it is a challenge because, people are now developing,
- 35:16enterprise risk management things.
- 35:18And it's what is your board properly, have enough background to where they could
- 35:23evaluate and be a participant in that.
- 35:26So those types of issues are coming up.
- 35:29Todd Miller: I think an important piece of that too is good boards are going to
- 35:32do a self assessment of where they're at and figure out that training plan.
- 35:36Now, let's go back to something we said in the beginning and regulation
- 35:40actually has a bullet point on board training in the regulation.
- 35:46It's directed for new board members, but the ongoing training is super
- 35:50important in this day and age
- 35:54Treichel: and there's a Podcast from a couple of years ago where
- 35:57I interviewed the CEO of Quantum Governance, who does a lot of training
- 36:01for America's credit unions and other groups, other trade associations.
- 36:05And I've seen their work at some credit unions and they're very passionate
- 36:09about this whole governance topic.
- 36:11So that if you're a board looking to do some of that training and you're looking
- 36:14for somebody who might be able to do it.
- 36:16You might want to listen to that podcast.
- 36:17See if they're a good fit for you.
- 36:19All right, Steve, what's next?
- 36:20Steve Farrar: Self assessment, the board should conduct an annual self assessment,
- 36:24evaluating its effectiveness and meeting the standards of the guidelines that
- 36:28are in their risk management program.
- 36:32That's pretty
- 36:32Treichel: self explanatory.
- 36:33Todd, any thoughts to add on that?
- 36:35Todd Miller: I already mentioned it, and I didn't mean to take Steve's thunder away.
- 36:38I don't have the document open.
- 36:40It was just a comment.
- 36:42I threw out there just in line with the board training.
- 36:45But, yes, it is important and high performing boards
- 36:48Steve Farrar: Do that.
- 36:50Treichel: Very good
- 36:51Steve Farrar: and the last item under board responsibilities and
- 36:53this is a big 1 is a compensation and performance management programs.
- 36:59Compensation is a big issue and how that's structured one thing that has to always
- 37:04be taken in place is your compensation structure resulting in changing your
- 37:10risk profile because it's focused too much on growth or it's focused too much
- 37:17on a growth in a particular type of loan and so in trying to meet that part of
- 37:22what's put in the strategic plan, is that causing you to, To deviate from your
- 37:27risk appetite that you think you have.
- 37:29The structure of your compensation program is something that
- 37:32needs to be done with care.
- 37:34Great point, God, any thoughts on that?
- 37:361?
- 37:37Todd Miller: Part of that is also your performance management.
- 37:40So it's not only important for the board to be doing that.
- 37:46Performance appraisal that CEO, it's important that they have a
- 37:49good system in place for that.
- 37:51So that occurs throughout the organization.
- 37:55Does have specific regulations on compensation.
- 37:59Lending people specifically.
- 38:02Don't get incentives to increase risk.
- 38:05It doesn't come up very often and see why it does have a regulation buried away
- 38:09that if you're a troubled credit, you can't be changing your golden parachutes.
- 38:14Compensation is a difficult thing for directors because you want to pay
- 38:18your executives fairly to retain good talent, but you also don't want to get.
- 38:25To the point where you're overcompensating them and being overly generous either.
- 38:30So it's a big challenge for directors.
- 38:32A lot of them use outside consultants to guide them along that process.
- 38:37If they don't have directors with specific experience in that area,
- 38:42because it's very important.
- 38:44It's part of that corporate culture.
- 38:46Treichel: Great point and as you're walking through that, it reminds
- 38:49me of a succession planning.
- 38:53Rule the presentations they've made the comments they've made
- 38:56relative to that where they're talking about looking forward.
- 39:00You're you may see that smaller institutions.
- 39:05Aren't compensating their staff enough for what actually needs to happen.
- 39:09How however, the pivot from that is attacking their ability to
- 39:14continue to utilize appropriate.
- 39:16In my opinion, what are appropriate fee structures.
- 39:19So while the same time they're saying you need to do succession planning
- 39:23and look at compensation and make sure they're compensated enough they're
- 39:26putting these smaller institutions that are already having difficulty
- 39:31making a profit in harm's way by.
- 39:33Making it more challenging to have some levels of fees which I think is going to
- 39:39lead to increased mergers in that arena.
- 39:42But I digress.
- 39:44All right.
- 39:44Wow.
- 39:45Anything else?
- 39:46Anything we missed here?
- 39:48Relative the obvious.
- 39:49There's a lot we missed because like we said, you could take a month
- 39:52long class on corporate governance, but any, anything else we want to
- 39:55highlight here today, gentlemen?
- 39:58Steve Farrar: I think 1 thing that we're not going to go into on here
- 40:00that is in this proposed rule of it has a lot of focus on the role of
- 40:06audit and internal audit, which for us, I think makes it appropriate for a
- 40:10separate podcast subject, but you can't.
- 40:12That is a tool that the board of directors has their ability to make
- 40:17sure that in helping hold professional management accountable, provided that
- 40:22they appropriately control that function.
- 40:25And you said, but
- 40:26Treichel: I think you meant FDIC, the proposed rule.
- 40:29Yeah.
- 40:29Yeah.
- 40:30Okay.
- 40:31Or at least I thought I heard that.
- 40:32And, as you mentioned that 1 thing that popped into my head
- 40:36was the 3 lines of defense.
- 40:37As it relates to this any thoughts on the three lines of defense relative
- 40:42to what we've seen where NCOA has been dealing with, internal audit
- 40:47and enterprise risk management in some of the bigger institutions
- 40:50that, that we've been associated with or any general thoughts on that.
- 40:54Steve Farrar: Go through
- 40:55Treichel: how you're defining
- 40:56Steve Farrar: the three lines of defense there, Mark.
- 40:59Treichel: So the frontline units who are responsible for managing
- 41:02risk in their business areas.
- 41:04Independent risk management, which would be overseeing risk taking activities
- 41:09across the credit union and then internal audit, which ensures compliance
- 41:12with the risk management program.
- 41:15Todd Miller: Okay.
- 41:15Outside it's interesting.
- 41:18This goes back to guidance.
- 41:20I don't know what year it was.
- 41:21Miss mass was a chairman.
- 41:22They wrote a letter to credit unions isn't required this whole 2nd line
- 41:27of defense chief risk officer that actually is under the whole realm
- 41:31of enterprise risk management.
- 41:33Just by definition we're seeing that more and they require it
- 41:38of ones type credit unions.
- 41:40It's requirement for corporate credit unions.
- 41:42There is a letter to corporate credit unions about it, but it's not required
- 41:47for many credit unions that said, when I was a director of special actions,
- 41:51I got a troubled credit union over a billion dollars assigned to me.
- 41:54They weren't leaving me until they were down the road to implementing an
- 41:58enterprise risk management program.
- 42:01I've just seen real world successes through the last recession, the natural
- 42:05person credit unions in the Sand States and California and stuff, they performed
- 42:10admirably through that last recession.
- 42:12I know these enterprise risk management systems are extremely effective.
- 42:17There are probably a topic for another podcast, but like me,
- 42:21there was never guidance that said accrediting had to do it.
- 42:24I just as a supervisor said, you're going to do it because that's where
- 42:27sound business practice takes you.
- 42:29But we're seeing that from other examiners at to even.
- 42:33Though there's not a requirement for it in these credeins outside of WANs
- 42:38and outside the corporate credeins, we are seeing examiners put doors in place
- 42:43at much, much smaller organizations that says, this is what you need.
- 42:47And realistically, for directors, you start crossing that billion dollar path,
- 42:52you need to go down that road to ERM.
- 42:55It's going to become a business necessity.
- 42:58And you will have blind spots in your organization and your performance will
- 43:02suffer if you don't put those types of risk management tools in place.
- 43:07That's one person's opinion.
- 43:09Treichel: Great.
- 43:09I would agree with that.
- 43:11That's a great summary and a great point.
- 43:12All right, guys.
- 43:13As always this is, this was fun.
- 43:15It brought up some past war stories.
- 43:17I think there's a lot to unpack here.
- 43:19And I think we referred to other subcategories that we might put
- 43:22on our list for future podcasts.
- 43:24Thanks so much for your time today, guys.
- 43:27Take care.
- 43:28And listeners, I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 43:31I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 43:33This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying ColorS.