Latest / AEC GrowthCast / People First, AI Forward: How AEC Firms Are Winning Talent & Tools (Ep. 8)
Transcript
- Caroline Bishop: I think we approved a $30,000 dollar check because he brought three PMs senior PMs over at one time. And it was just like, yeah. And he deserved it. And we were so happy Gregory Hart: it. Caroline Bishop: to give him that. Jo Martin: It's well worth paying that kind of an incentive to our employees to help us fill these critical roles. Gregory Hart: Hello and welcome to the AEC GrowthCast. My name is Greg Hart, president here at PSMJ Resources. The AEC GrowthCast is the show for AEC firm leaders who are interested in growing. And growing is not just about getting bigger. It's about getting better, getting smarter, getting more intentional with a firm's future. So if that sounds familiar to you, so glad to have you here. so now we're going to get into the metric of the month. This is the metric that I share with you that has something that I think is pretty relevant about where the industry is going and what you should be looking at in your own firm in terms of your strategy, your operations, maybe your financial performance, all sorts of stuff. This month we're sharing a metric that isn't specifically from any of the PSMJ research, that we have plenty of metrics that I could share. This is kind of an outside metric that I thought was kind of interesting in light of some other stuff that I'm going to share with you in just a second. Metric for this month is 11.8%. 11.8%. What does that mean? No, it's not a profit margin or anything like that. It's according to a new 2026 report from the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. Data centers could consume 11.8% of all electricity used in the US by 2030. According to the research, in 2023, data centers accounted for just 4.4%. So in less than a decade, nearly tripling in the demand or the percentage of the overall pie of electricity demand from data centers. Now, look, it's no surprise, those of you who've been in the industry for a little bit have seen the buzz all around data centers in the past few years. There's been some speculation on one hand: is this a bubble? Is it gonna peter out? There's certainly growing opposition in a lot of markets to data centers or growing push for more regulation. But the reality is a lot of research like this is very bullish on the outlook for data centers and the impact that that's gonna have on electricity demands. Now, I think the key piece of this isn't to just think about whether you're in or out of the data center market. And if you're out of it, you should jump into it. The reality is there's kind of a ripple effect. When you have this kind of demand, certainly there are the hyperscalers, and if you're specifically in the data center market, you see a lot of activity around that. But there's this lift that happens all around that in terms of water, wastewater, power generation, transmission, distribution, substations, site development, transportation, infrastructure, environmental impact, all that other stuff. Maybe most other AEC markets in these areas are getting impacted by this lift in data centers. So I guess the question to think about is what does that mean for your firm, right? If you're fitting into the data center ecosystem in some way, shape or form. And where's the opportunity for that in your strategic planning exercise? Again, it isn't just are we in data centers or not in data centers? It's what's that lift impact going to be on the markets that we are in, especially these aren't just happening in in a few major hubs in the US. When you look at maps of where data center development is happening, it's everywhere, right? Our quarterly market forecast data just came out last month and continues to show that market as a very hot market for proposal activity. If you haven't seen that report, if you're a PSMJ PRO member, just go into the portal and you'll get a copy at it. If you're not a PSMJ PRO member, we'll include a link in the show notes how to become a PSMJ PRO member. Now, if you're in one of these markets that's booming, whether it's data centers or many other markets that are quite strong, even markets that aren't, you know, kind of off the charts, if you will, you're likely grappling with some fashion or some element of needing to find top talent, right? Whether it's to expand capacity, whether it's to replace retirements, attrition, whatever the case may be, finding talent is 9.9 times out of 10 the biggest challenge that you need to overcome for long-term sustainable growth. Okay, so if that sounds familiar, if you think you might be wrestling with a talent shortage, this conversation is with you. I teed it up a little bit at the outset, but I'm giving it little more detail now. We have Jo Martin and Caroline Bishop, who are part of the internal recruiting team at a firm that has grown quite a bit, expanded quite a bit, and is finding great success with the internal recruiting function. So let's jump into our conversation, take a listen to this conversation with Jo and Caroline. All right, we have a great discussion coming up here on a topic that I think is, as long as I've been in the AEC industry, which is, I don't know, 20 plus years or something like that, has always come up and that is finding talent and finding quality talent in particular and recruiting. And that for a lot of firms, that's a real bottleneck to growth, building the pipeline of potential talent. So we have a discussion here today. We've invited Jo Martin, talent acquisition manager and Caroline Bishop, senior talent acquisition specialist at a firm called Tighe and Bond, which is 600 plus people at this point. I think 16 offices, mostly in the Northeast, but I'll let Caroline and Jo, I think, give a much more articulate description of the firm as we get into it. But first, Jo and Caroline, thanks so much for joining me here today. Caroline Bishop: Thanks, Greg. Jo Martin: Yeah, We're excited to be here. Thanks so much. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Before we get started, Jo, maybe give us a little bit of background on Tighe and Bond just to kind paint the picture a bit of the firm and kind of how you've gotten to where you are. Jo Martin: Yeah, Tighe and Bond is an employee-owned company. We're throughout the Northeast. We've got 16 offices, like you mentioned. And we do a variety of civil and environmental engineering. We also do planning, landscape architecture. We do a lot of MEP work, structural work, horizontal design, vertical design. So we're very, very broad in all of our practices. And one of the things we always like to say is that we can do something for a client. we treat that total asset. So, you know, we can do every aspect of a project. So we're especially happy to be working in the communities that we serve. So the people, you know, that work at Tighe and Bond, they get to see the projects that they work on every day. They drive by them. You know, we're part of the communities that we live in. And that's part of the hallmark of the company. We've been around for over a hundred years. And now being over 600 people, we can really touch most of the northeast and part of New York. Gregory Hart: I've started to hear we've said for years that having internal recruiters in an architecture engineering firm can be a real game changer for winning that talent acquisition game. And I think I've said it before here, but I'll say it again. A lot of times the firms that are frustrated with talent acquisition, when you really dig into it, and probe into what they're actually doing to kind of overcome that hurdle, it's usually not enough or doing a lot of the same things and not getting the results, but just continuing to kind of go down that track. So bringing on internal recruiters is something that I've heard just in the past couple of years, more and more firms beneath the mega firms doing that and making some real traction with it. So. Maybe, so you both live in recruiting day in and day out in building this 600 person plus person machine. And I just want to, if we have a CEO or a principal or a COO listening to us today, what is a day in the life of an internal recruiter? It's not just cold calling all day, right? What's a typical day look like? Maybe Caroline, you could kind of. take us through that a little bit and then we'll turn the tables Caroline Bishop: Yeah. Gregory Hart: here, Jo. You can fact check Caroline a little bit. gets it right. Yeah. Jo Martin: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: Which is great. Which by the way, I have my mid-year review later today. So, you know, let's not- hope that it goes well. I like the word talent acquisition. I do. I think it's great, but I think there's a very different meaning of talent acquisition in the AEC industry versus other industries. And the reason is is because when I talk to my husband who's in, you know, medical device or other type of you know, kind of again, I guess kind of industries, it they're talking about fielding resumes, you know, looking and reviewing and just Putting people through the process, you know, whether that's the hiring process, coordinating with managers, putting job posting together, which is certainly part of my job on the day-to-day basis, I will say. But as most people know, and at least for the past couple of years, we're not getting applicants. We're not fielding resumes. I'm not here with finalists, you know, for a position. I'm here, I have Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Caroline Bishop: one person, if I'm lucky, if I get an applicant, and then we go through the the process. So I would really say what kind of makes us different compared to all the other talent acquisition peers in this industry is that we're actually really more sales. We really go proactive. We are trying to sell our company. We're trying to get people engaged. We're trying to tell them about tie and bond, who we represent, what we're all about. And we have to be the ones who are pursuing versus fielding, you know, a bunch of resumes. And with that, it's different. So when you're talking to someone who wants to invest into a talent acquisition team, it is we think of us as a salespeople. Think of us as we're we're we work with marketing, we work with employee branding, we're talking about the company, but we're also proactively reaching out. Because even if you hire someone, even if a TA person from another industry that's not used to being proactive, it's a very different process. I will say like my background is the third party recruiting. So I am so used to reaching out, you know, I had to cold call, I was, you know, texting people, I was networking, I was doing all these things and I was building, you know, my network as I was doing Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Caroline Bishop: that. but my day to day is really reaching out to people and understanding externally what their wants are, what their needs are, and timing. Everything is timing. Now there's a whole other part to it, you know, my day to day and what that looks like. I need to know internally what's going on with the business. I need to know where we're investing, I need to know where were our geography hours, where are we looking for pursuits, you know, where our clients are. I need to know, you know, kind of who's being respected by our clients, who's respected by the vendors that we use, who do our employees like working for? So there's a lot more in-depth knowledge. When we reach out to people specifically, it's intentionally, because my gosh, Jo has again great examples of reaching out to people, but before reaching out to them, knowing exactly who they are, what would make them move, what would make them want to come. In that like we have one choice. We have one choice, we have one opportunity to connect with these people. It has to be power, it has to be impactful, and it has to be different than all the other messages that they're getting from our competitors and other recruiters. I mean, there's a lot of noise that our even our own employees will be like, "I'm getting text messages at five in the morning from people from London telling me about a job!" And it's like we get it. You know, we understand there's a lot out there, but that's we haven't found that method as effective as the way that we have. And we have, we've grown past two or three years. We've hired over a hundred people each year. And so that has really, you know, been a big rate of you know, investment that the company has has taken, but we've gotten so much in return because we've been able Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: to really build and grow and and with our growth of our employees is also the growth of our revenue. And it's very interesting when we look at all of our graphs because they are really are hand in hand. The angles are the same. So it's an investment, but when you have someone advocating for you, your company specifically, that is a lot easier for me to recruit, I will say, than a third party person because they're also representing Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: multiple other companies. And you don't know what the day-to-day who the people are, you don't know the connections, you don't know who the teams are, you don't know the dynamic or the culture in the office. I'm in the office, I'm talking to them. I know the people specifically, I know their personalities, I know their family life, I know what projects they're working on, I know the type of work style they are. You know, I know all those little intricacies that really go into a successful hire. Not only a successful hire, but someone who will stay and really be embedded into the culture and embedded into the company. Jo Martin: I think part of what we do as recruiters is also just understanding the day-to-day work and what they're doing and trying to figure out with that team where that person's going to fit and how they're going to be able to contribute and complement to that team. So when we're digging into the technology and really understanding the workflow of the engineering and really getting a sense of what the work is. That's also part of our work is communicating with the teams and understanding exactly what they're going to be doing so that when we're talking to them, we can really be an educated advisor and get like sort of match what they've been working on to what we might have them be working on. And so it's much more of a higher level technical discussion. And I feel like when you are an internal recruiter, that's really important that you really understand, you know, that piece of the business. But that also is going to inform another part of a huge amount of the work that we do, which is identifying candidates. So Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: you have to really talk to the teams to understand where they are in the world. Like, am I going to find them through conference literature? Am I going to find them through public filings, am I going to find them through maybe public bids and things like that. We're going to try to dig into the work to really get a sense of who the people are in the market. A lot of times, of course, we're using LinkedIn, which is a tool that we all use, LinkedIn Recruiter. But there's other ways that we have to figure out where people are and what they're doing, because it's so specialized. So it's not just on the sales side, although that's super important in what Caroline described is exactly the way that it is, but it's also like that sourcing side, which can get really complicated and really sophisticated. And I think advice to a CEO if they were going to be hiring an internal team is, look at the cost benefit analysis and really look at how much money are you spending on external recruiters? Because Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: they're collecting between 25 and 30% of a person's salary, typically what I've seen. And so you look at how much outlay of capital you have to have in order to have an internal recruiter, and then figure out whether or not your growth strategy matches what you would want to invest in for an internal team. And I think Gregory Hart: Yeah. Yeah. Jo Martin: that internal team needs to have people that have that technical aptitude but also the ability to sell. That's kind of the sweet spot for me. Gregory Hart: A year or two ago, I remember I was having a conversation with the CEO of a structural engineering firm and he had commented to me that one of the challenges they had, it was related to outside recruiters, but that they weren't having a problem getting candidates, they were having a problem keeping them from outside recruiters. In other words, they weren't getting screened for the cultural fit or the more of an in-depth conversation about the opportunity and the alignment and what their company can bring to the table that might get somebody to kind of see that they're not getting that at the firm they're at now. What would it take, in other words, to leave the company that you're at now? And he found that using an internal recruiter, it wasn't that the sourcing increased dramatically, the retention got a whole lot better because he found that the Jo Martin: Yes. Gregory Hart: the candidates that they're getting were just a much better fit, intended to stick around with the organization for longer. Some of that probably implicitly comes back to what you were just saying about, you know, understanding the story, sourcing candidates from the right places. I would imagine referrals from technical staff is a huge source Jo Martin: Yeah. Gregory Hart: of candidates. Maybe talk a little bit about that. Jo Martin: next. Gregory Hart: How are these kinds of conversations that are happening every day, or do you have some system for sourcing candidates? Obviously, you know, principals and other technical folks are really busy, have a network that's probably bigger than they think in terms of potential candidates. Jo Martin: Yeah, that's a huge part of our strategy. We definitely, have regular meetings with the technical teams. I like to do them as one-offs because when I'm doing a search and I'm finding somebody, I'm trying to look at connections to see who's connected to them. Then I reach out to them and say, "Hey, I see you're connected to so-and-so. How do you know them? Let's have a quick discussion about strategy." So then we build a strategy about reaching out. Because what Caroline said is there's so few people. You only get one chance at a first impression. You have Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: to be articulate, you have to be clear, you have to talk about what's in it for them, you have to be empathetic about their point of view. I mean, even taking a call is kind of a big deal from Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: a competitor and making a change in your career is really, it's a huge deal. Exercising as much empathy and compassion that we can for the person's position, I think that's very important. But there's one other piece that when you work for a company, you know, and your- my personal why is that I'm bringing in extraordinary talent that's going to help build our company and it's going to benefit everybody here because we're employee owned. It's sort of like, Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: I feel like a responsibility to people that we hire people that are just, you know, that are really, really great for our company. I mean, that to me, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: that's, that's very important. And I have a personal stake in it. It's not like when I worked in agencies and I was making financial decisions for myself, you know, saying, "Okay, this placement is going to make me money." But here it's like, this placement is going to help be another building block to build our company. And that Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: to me is a much deeper reason to recruit somebody. Gregory Hart: And that seems to be a consistent thread with internal recruiters. And it gets back to that recruiting versus retention piece that I mentioned that, yeah, you're just more vested. Outside recruiters absolutely have a time and a place and value. It's not either or all the time. But if you're considering taking the plunge to sort of bring on an internal team, that is one of the benefits. You have a much more aligned vested interest. How did it start by the way? Do you start with just one recruiter? Is it- somebody told me once with salespeople that it's sort of like with dogs, it's best to get two at the first time because they can like entertain each other, but or in Caroline Bishop: Yeah. Gregory Hart: this case, kind of compete with each other, I guess. Jo Martin: I Caroline Bishop: Exactly. Gregory Hart: How does it start? Was it just it? Or I don't know, Jo, were you there when the first or Caroline when it- Caroline Bishop: Original. Jo was the original. So yeah, Jo, tell all the things. And then tell what we each do. Because I feel like that helps too. And also Gregory Hart: that yet yet Caroline Bishop: lets people know the day to day and all the responsibilities and all the tasks that we do and provide to the the company. Yeah. Like to Jo Martin: Yeah, I'm happy to chat about it. I I got here in 2017. I had worked for 10 years in Boston building a patent law firm. So I doubled that in size. I got here in 2017. And now we've doubled Tighe and Bond in size since I got here in about the same time frame. But in 2017, I showed up as the first recruiter. They'd never had a recruiter before. We had our first full-time HR staff a couple of years before that, and they knew they needed somebody to concentrate on recruiting. And I ran it myself until the pandemic where it got really slow and there weren't as many open positions and I was doing a bunch of different things for the firm during that time. As you know, it was just go time in 2021. And it became very obvious to me very quickly in 2021 heading into 2022 that in order for the firm to remain competitive, we needed more people to recruit. We just, there was no way we were never gonna keep up. And that great reshuffle and all the resignations and even backfilling the roles, there was just no way for the size that we were. that I could do it alone. And I had a conversation with the leadership and showed them the data. And I just said, this is an unsustainable model. There's no way that we're going to be able to continue to do that. And so I brought in Michelle who is an incredible sorcerer. She does a great job on the really super hard roles, Michelle Stevens. She's a senior recruiter and I brought her in on a temporary basis and just said, okay, I just need to bring the requisitions down, but it just kept getting harder and harder. And then when I met Caroline, it was like, oh my God, Caroline has this huge social media following. She has all these skills for recruiting. I was like, there's no way we can't hire, we have to hire Caroline. We have to have Caroline. And I was like, she's the social media front. She's the, you know, she's the face of the company. She's the salesperson. I can't live without Caroline. So I had to have Caroline. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: And then what I realized is that, you know, we were in a position where we needed somebody to do entry-level. We were just not able to do everything with the three of us, you know. It was, so we brought in Matt, who is incredible with process and technology. And he's just been amazing. You know, we upgraded all of our technology and he's been really the captain of that ship. And then we brought in Amina, who's a part-time person and she's just awesome in the, you know, entry-level and interns, and Matt is turning the corner really concentrating a lot more on the technology piece. That was a process, you know, over a couple of years to grow and build this team. But I would say that, you know, you need all of those pieces. It's really important, at least from my perspective, to have people working within their strengths and being able to shine where they shine, you know. We wouldn't be having this conversation without Caroline, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: that's for sure. Gregory Hart: So tell me a little bit about org structure. You've often said talent acquisition is different than just HR and isn't just like another one of the things that HR is responsible for. And it sounds like you've really built out kind of a dedicated team for talent acquisition. But how does it report up in there? Do you report as a subset to HR or totally separate from HR? What does that look like? Jo Martin: Yeah, so I report to the CHRO who reports to the CEO. Yep, that's how it works at Tighe and Bond. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Caroline Bishop: The HR team does help us as well. So we have like a benefits specialist, a salary expert. We have someone on the HR team that does our onboarding and our compliance and all of our, you know, whatever kind of like background checks we need to do, you know, all those other types of things. The talent position gets them in, we get them, and then once they sign the offer, then you know, the rest of our HR team helps with the onboarding and the transition and getting them set up for their IT and their desks and all that kind of good stuff. Gregory Hart: Random question on that note while we're talking, do you also place ads on things like LinkedIn or Indeed, or are those kind of like tired and old, are they still effective, or fill me in there. Jo Martin: So Indeed is the model is that you sponsor jobs. And so what we've found is that often our specialized engineering jobs, it's not as effective for us to sponsor Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: jobs on Indeed. There are some more corporate positions or other positions where it might be more effective on Indeed. But LinkedIn, we pay for job slots as part of our jobs where you can automatically see the positions that are open, but then we promote some called Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: job slots and we use those as well. We're much more reaching out to very specific people in the market. We're not going to find, you know, a senior project manager, who has, wastewater work in their background sitting on Monster, for example. They just, they're not really there, you know, that's what's challenging. Caroline Bishop: The hard to-fill jobs that we look at, you know, probably is like the five to twenty-five year PE specific technical expert. For our entry levels and for some of our corporate positions, we do get hundreds of resumes that we are looking through. And you know, that is why Matt and Amina take so much time to vet through all those resumes and do all those interviews and do the reference checks and you know put all those things together. Gregory Hart: I'm glad you touched on that, Caroline, because that'd be something I'd like to touch on a little bit more. So that mid-career, what you described exactly, is the one that a lot of firms are struggling with. there's definitely a camp, which I subscribe to, that to fix that, you really got to get more aggressive on hiring at the entry-level to kind of build those people up, to create the field Caroline Bishop: Yeah. Gregory Hart: of potential next-generation leaders. in the meantime for some of those mid-career open positions, what do you do differently there? Is it just the scouring, the technical leads, finding the people, finding the referrals? What's the secret there to tap into that market that is a very tough one for lot of firms to fill? Jo Martin: I think those individuals Caroline Bishop: Yeah. Jo Martin: are really busy. I think they're really Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: busy. They're building their life. They're often building families. They are in transition. They're doing so much. Like if you think about where you were at that time, at those years, it's like- they're really responsible for so many things. And I think we try to meet them where they are. Caroline and I and Michelle, we've all gone to professional conferences, really worked really hard to meet people personally. Having those personal one-on-one conversations, we've utilized those other individuals in the firm that are their same level and know each other to discuss why Tighe and Bond might be a great place to build a career and why our benefits might be very advantageous for them at this point in their career. You know, so we sort of try to have those conversations. I think everybody really struggles at this level because it's extremely difficult to get somebody's attention when they're very, very busy. So I think also thinking about what their experience is of you is a really Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: important part of being a good recruiter is understanding that. So, you know, using the tools that we have to figure out like what would a life, like some lifestyle things we could talk about. What are some of the opportunities for leadership that we can talk about? Maybe, you know, how we do wealth building at Tighe and Bond, like just try to meet them where they are. Caroline Bishop: I'd love to add in. Every situation is different, but there is a strategy. There is certainly a strategy. And I know what we talked about earlier, using our employees. I think that's really a big one. So I will offer, and we have resources to our employees to be the best brand ambassadors that we can possibly bring out of them. Some of them are a little bit more timid, some of them are a lot more open and welcome, you know, to approaching somebody or having those conversations. We'll definitely won't push someone to do something if they feel uncomfortable doing it, but we encourage it. And because of what Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Caroline Bishop: we talked about before, we have a really great employee referral program, you know, a bonus program, and we can talk about that more in detail. But we encourage Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Caroline Bishop: that because I can reach out to someone 10 times, you know. I've I was showing Jo like, I've reached out to this poor woman probably over 10 times the past two years and I've gotten no response. And that's totally fine. Like I I expect that. But when someone they know personally or a peer comes to them and says, "Wow, that was an amazing presentation. You really impressed me. Would you ever consider working with me?" Like that is a lot stronger of a connection. And hopefully usually we have great success with those. I really do have the support of pretty much all of my employees doing recruiting Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: as well. And they're out going networking events, they're they have their, you know, black book, you know, of contacts sort of speak, you know, with the people that they went to school with or they're on boards or they've on committees together. We do that a lot. I'm going to networking events. I'm not only talking to candidates, but I'm also talking to, you know, certain vendors. I love talking to vendors because they work with so many other companies. They're also salespeople. And I love saying, Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Yep. Caroline Bishop: like, "Well, who do you like to work with? What projects have were you excited about? What projects went Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: well? What projects were your clients happy about?" And and I love I love to get their point of view. I know we always use online databases to help us for that. We also, you know, we will go to conferences and we'll get attendee lists, you know, from from that and we'll use those as sources. But we mainly use, you know, LinkedIn as our primary tool to talk to people and to connect with them. But the the biggest I say the our biggest impact and I think is the best success stories is the ones that come from the employees and Jo was talking about a a job that we were working on for like over a year and a half. We had 11 options, but the one that we ended up hiring started last week came from employee referral. That I don't even was were they on our list? I don't even know if they were on our list. Jo Martin: Yeah, that was a crazy experience. We had been looking for somebody to head up our hydrogeology practice for a long time. And in January, I took over the search and I started to this geography and I'm looking through this area. And there was like 11 or 12 people. mean, they were even qualified for this role. And I had sourced someone for the role outside of the geography. And then I sourced another person through an employee referral. And then just at the last minute, we had an employee contact me and say, "Hey, this person's ready." And they were just perfect for the role. And so she and I were on the phone constantly, like, "What are we going to do? What's the best way to do it?" And from my perspective, just the way that I operate as a recruiter when I'm in that role, I just try to genuinely get to know the person. To me, that's just really important. And I had a lot of support from the person that referred. She let me know that he was open to it and sort of handed the process over to me. And it worked really, well. And I'll just tag one thing onto what Caroline was saying is that we do help educate and help prepare people internally for going to conferences and doing the networking. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: We let them know what the open positions are, and we ask them the ways that we need them to help. We help write emails for them sometimes if they're just feeling awkward and they don't know what to say. "Okay well how do you know the person? Let's think this through. What are what's something that you would feel like was genuine when you reach out? Like, would you actually really love to work with this person? If you would, tell them!" Gregory Hart: I think that's actually a really important part. So when we talk about that mid-career professional that everybody's trying to find, I think number one, creating brand ambassadors to create that pull-through effect. You're right, technical folks are out at conferences, at client meetings, at job sites, wherever, interacting with folks who could be candidates. But the other piece that I'd like to touch on a little bit that I think is really interesting with Tighe and Bond on the referral fee piece. So, you know, a lot of folks will say referral fees are a great resource for attracting talent and... for those hard to find positions, you're pretty bullish on what you'll pay as well. in Others might be, you know, $2,000, $5,000, but you'll go well above that for the right position. Jo Martin: It's graded from different levels. It starts at $500 and it goes up to $10,000. We would much rather have somebody come in that's vested, that somebody has a connection to, you know, that there's a reward for our employees, that we're able to fill a position because there is an opportunity cost every day that that position isn't filled, right? Like we Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: all know that. So for us, it's It's well worth paying that kind of an incentive to our employees to help us fill these critical roles. We want to make sure that those are filled. So what we learned was that we had to be really clear about the policy. We built technology around it where people go through a specific process for identifying that person and making sure that they're referred. We want to also make sure the person can know the person's work ethic, their values, make sure that their values are aligned with ours, make sure that the employee is also supporting that process, so helping the talent acquisition team and also helping the candidate navigate. Those are the requirements for a person to be able Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: to get. the employee Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: referral incentive. So it's not just one thing. It's not like, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Jo Martin: "Hey, here's a resume." It's like, "All right, here's a resume." And then, "How are you going to help us make sure that that works out and that the person is able to come on board?" So we definitely learned there was a bit of a learning curve, changing the policy to make it more clear, making sure that people felt like they were educated about what they needed to do. I felt like that was a really important thing. You know, like Caroline said, it's a huge part of our business. It's probably between maybe 20 and sometimes 25% of our hires are from employee referrals. Caroline Bishop: We hired a candidate four years ago. We had just moved into a brand new office. I had hired him. He's brought in over seven people, seven to eight people. And because of that, they've had to go to a new office. And now they're in a new office four years later because they just expanded so quickly. And he checked all the boxes for helping us and recruiting us and he was our best advocate and he brought over all of his friends and people that he knew from his previous firm and some of them actually reached out to him. And I think one time we gave him, I think we approved a $30,000 dollar check because he brought three PMs senior PMs over at one time. And it was just like, yeah. And he deserved it. And we were so happy Gregory Hart: it. Caroline Bishop: to give him that. because of Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: what the business and he put in and gave us a new offering to our clients. Like they brought in their own business. Like it really did. It was it was it was an easy check to write. And he continues Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: to be a wonderful advocate for us. He was nervous to leave his company because he didn't want to leave the people. And now he just brought the people with him. So that was great. Gregory Hart: Yeah, about the people. Jo Martin: Thank Gregory Hart: Yeah, it is it referral bonuses paid out after a period of time or how does what is that? How does that work? Jo Martin: I think it's half upfront, half after 90 days. I'm pretty sure. Gregory Hart: Yeah. So another topic I'd love to get your opinion on that I don't hear as much about anymore, but used to be the hottest topic on recruiting. And that is sourcing from competing firms. Right. That used to be a would always spark a big management team debate with people firmly planted on either side of that debate. That doesn't seem like something that's as much of a contentious issue anymore. As firms have all grown so much, it seems like that's less of an issue. Any insight or thoughts to share on somebody who's a little apprehensive about... recruiting and sourcing and reaching out to actively employed folks? Jo Martin: When I first started here in 2017, I came from a very conservative legal background, right? So when I was in Boston, recruiting in Boston and the law firms, we would never reach out to Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: anybody. So here it was really different. Engineering, I had to really adjust to the fact that we were really reaching out to people on LinkedIn, to our competitors. And I felt like there was this sort of third party site that people had agreed to be able to network on, especially there's ways that recruiters know if a person wants to hear from somebody else, et cetera. So I felt like there's a little bit of a separation. But the more we dig into different technologies, Caroline and I sat through a bunch of different demonstrations this last summer on different sourcing tools and looked at a bunch of different things. There are so many tools out there right now where, you know, you do the sourcing and then they have an email system and they're using a third party that sources people's personal emails, their work emails, their phone numbers, and they're, you know, they're reaching out directly through these software systems. We looked at everything and we know that there's gonna be an evolution going forward in what kinds of technology people are using to reach out to candidates. And we made a conscious decision to stay with what we're doing now, which is using a third party platform to reach out to candidates. So I think there's no question that people feel fine about doing that. I think the question now... it's how are we gonna reach out? Are we gonna really, are we gonna use people's personal email addresses? Are we gonna call them on their personal cell phones or text Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Jo Martin: them on their personal cell phones? So I don't think it's if, I think it's how. And we're right at the cusp, you know, like we're watching it. Like we're being very conscientious about like not overstepping the ways that we do things and trying to be, you know, very ethical about how we do it, what we're doing. But I don't know where the market's gonna go, you know? I don't know if in two years or three years, you know, it's just commonplace that people are doing that and reaching out to people that way. So it's just different. It's changed so much in the time that I've been here. Gregory Hart: Yeah, yeah, it's definitely, we see the exact same thing that it's become much less of an ethical conundrum and more commonplace. And also too, a situation where if you are able to have a conversation with that candidate, find out what they would change about that role that they're in now. And there probably are plenty of times where you say, "Well, we're not the right fit. You know, what they're looking for is not something we can provide." The downside, I guess, which is also the upside of being an internal recruiter, you've got to live with it, right? You're going to see that person at employee events and company events and holiday parties and things like that. So, you you want to make sure it's the right fit and you're not selling something that the company can't deliver. Nobody wants to you know, kind of get somebody to leave a job and then kind of fail to deliver because of a promise that was made that couldn't be kept. Caroline Bishop: I will say all every time I call, it's like I just "If you're happy, that's great. But if you're Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Caroline Bishop: not, let me tell you about what's here and maybe if that's an improvement for you, let's talk more. Like let me have you talk Gregory Hart: You bet. Caroline Bishop: to more people." You know, acceptance or a decline. We're like, it's okay. You know, we leave the door open, even with people that leave us. We always have closing, you know, kind of like exit interviews to be like, "You can come back," if it's, you know, someone in good standing. You know, and actually that's happening to me right now. I literally have an interview with someone, you know, in this afternoon who left two years ago and was like, "In my exit interview, my team leader said I'd be welcome to come back if I wanted to." And we were! We were more than happy to have that conversation again. We've Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Caroline Bishop: had those boomerang employees come back. So I think it's it's Gregory Hart: You bet. Caroline Bishop: very much about that experience, but it's about what's best for them. And the timing may not be right or the salary might be not right at the time or the project or an opportunity. but everyone is a person. I mean that's the difference. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: What I'm as a TA person, I'm looking at them as a person versus I'm a third party recruiter, I'm looking them as a dollar sign. And that's all that it is. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: So it's it's very different Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: because I have to work with these people afterwards and then I get to know their families and I know their personal lives and you know, like you get close with them. So and that's even if I don't hire them, if even if I'm just having an interview process with someone, I do get close with them and I share with them and because it's a very as we said before, a very big decision also impacts everything in your life. Everything in your life, you know, what you do, you're engaged and then your family life and all those other things. So Gregory Hart: You bet. Caroline Bishop: I think all those things are are part of it. So we kind of give them this white glove service, we like to say, you know, we just like how can we be most accommodating? How can we make the experience the most beneficial for the team to understand them, but also for them to have a great experience being not ghosting them, you know, being responsive, but we expect the same thing in return. I expect people to not ghost me and to be responsive, have a, you know, a good communication there and a good working relationship. And we will! We'll have conversations with the candidate at some point and maybe we decide, maybe they're not a right fit for us. Even if technically they're right, maybe it there's not a cultural fit. And we Gregory Hart: Yeah. Caroline Bishop: get to those conversations because we get the trust of the candidate. Gregory Hart: Well, there's so much more we can cover, but we should probably leave it there. I'd love to at some point we can get into cultural fit and how you determine that and all that. So we'll have to bring you back sometime, but we'll leave it there for now. Caroline, Jo, thanks so much for joining me here today. Caroline Bishop: Pleasure. Jo Martin: Thank you so much for having us. Such a blast! We loved it. Gregory Hart: You that awesome. All right. It's Caroline Bishop: Such a blast. Gregory Hart: Okay, so I hope you got something out of that. Now, another people issue that we're hearing about quite a bit in all sorts of different perspectives, but it ties back to the same issue. I'm going to call it the bucket of accountability. The root issue that's that's causing kind of subpar performance is accountability. It's not the people, it's not the process, it's not the practices, it's accountability in the organization. And again, that scales up and down the org chart. We spend a lot of time in meetings these days, right? It's become so easy to set up a meeting, a virtual meeting in particular, that the meetings, meetings, meetings, and meetings are getting bigger, bigger, bigger, right? Because people can be remote, they can be in person. You can just press a few clicks in Outlook and Microsoft Teams and you get yourself a meeting. So they're everywhere. So what ends up happening is we we have a lot of discussion, but not a lot of decision, right? There isn't the true outcome with the accountability of three basic questions. Number one, what did we decide? Okay, what's the specific action outcome of any sort of discussion, particularly meetings. Don't assume that everybody heard the same thing. State the decision explicitly. Wrap it up with a very explicit, succinct. articulation of what we decided. Number two, who owns what, right? So whatever we decided, every action item should have one and only one person accountable for what happens. Shouldn't be the marketing team, shouldn't be the operations team. There could be support from other people, of course, but there should be one individual accountable for it. Number three, the other piece that you gotta have is by when, right? If there's no sense of urgency to it, things don't get done. An action item without a deadline is kind of just a suggestion, really, right? It's not really an action item. You ask those three questions at the end of every meeting. Wow. You will see a dramatic increase in productivity and a dramatic decrease in frustration of "What did we decide at that last meeting? Wait, I thought you were doing that." "No, that's not what I agreed to." So that's our five minute fix. What do we decide by who and by when? Take it with you. Let me know how it goes. We haven't talked about AI in kind of a hot minute in this podcast. And that's a topic, of course, changing quite a bit. We had our AEC INNOVATE conference earlier this summer. All sorts of stuff going on. But I want to just drop in another quick perspective. I had a great conversation with the Director of AEC Marketing Innovation at OpenAsset, about AI, what she sees, particularly from OpenAsset's perspective. Okay, here we are with Rachelle Ray, the Head of AEC Innovation at OpenAsset, the digital asset management platform for AEC firms. I think she has one of the coolest titles that I've heard as of late. So we're going to talk about that a little bit, but also talk a bit about AI. I know it sometimes seems like we're just talking about AI so much and in so many different dimensions, but it's that big of a deal. And there's a lot that can go right and a lot that can go wrong. One of the early areas where we started hearing about generative AI and the use cases associated with it was in marketing and business development, right? In proposal writing and things like that. So we're going to talk with Rachelle a bit about AI, the rights, the wrongs, specifically with respect to the hidden risks in using it for marketing and what firm leaders need to do to protect their quality, reputation, and their bottom line. Rachelle, thanks for joining me here today. Rachelle Ray: Thank you so much. I'm excited to be here. Gregory Hart: Yeah, all right. All right. So maybe first just give us a little bit of background, a little bit of intro, how you ended up at OpenAsset, how you got that cool title, and maybe tell us a little bit more what exactly, for those of you not familiar with OpenAsset, maybe just tell us a little bit more about what the digital asset management means. Rachelle Ray: Absolutely, absolutely. So I have been an AEC marketer for over 15 years. I've done my time in the proposal trenches, interviews, decks, brochures, anything you possibly need communicated in your firm. I've done it at the small firm level, at the large international firm level. And then I started a consulting business to support marketers who needed a little bit of help when we get overflow, right? So was trying to rescue all of my marketers from 10 proposals due it once plus two interviews plus a brochure, and also Gary needs who knows what for his conference. I was trying to be the solution for that. And so I did that. I worked with A, E and C and everything in between your specialties, your geotech, your interiors, all that good stuff for many, many years. And then yes, AI showed up and everyone was like, "Whoops. That's going to do marketing for us!" And I had Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: this like personal crisis. I was like, "Great, AI is going to take my job. I don't know what I'm going to do. Maybe I'll go back to school for engineering." And then I remembered that I hate math and that's why I'm a marketer. I like words and pictures and graphic design and communication and story. And so I kind of the hidden figures approach to things and decided that I would not just let AI market for me. I was going to learn this technology. And so I went down the rabbit hole and ended up like doing workshops and teaching and talking to OpenAsset about AI and how it was kind of a natural fit and extension of their digital asset management. And they brought me on to be the head of AEC marketing innovation, which I tell people is just a really fancy title for, "I'm old and I've been doing this a long time." And now we're plugging my brain into our Shred.ai project. So yeah, that's where I got started. OpenAsset is our, you know, kind of our content engine. It's where all of your gorgeous photography and your information about your projects lives. It's where your employee resumes live, kind of your source of truth. And then Shred.ai works together with your OpenAsset and it helps automate your proposals. Where I live is on the Shred side, helping to download my brain and my years of experience and pack all of those best practices into AI solutions to help other marketers do better, do faster, do more efficient, do better quality and maybe save us from some burnout. Gregory Hart: AEC marketers have always been a bunch that they're working against deadlines in kind of a hundred different directions and have sort of more work than there's hours in the day. So it seems to me, you know, the early use cases of, "Let's use it to help write bios," and things like that were great, but it seems like it's advancing to a place where it can really be a force multiplier for overworked marketing teams. But still, you know, whenever I'm out and about speaking at events and talking to folks, I still hear it from marketers. Even while the broader economy is showing some signs of uncertainty and instability, a lot of AEC firms are still just absolutely slammed, and that means marketing teams are absolutely slammed. You got their attention with ways to use AI to work smarter and do more. Maybe to start, let's just talk a little bit. What are some of the dangerous misconceptions that firm leaders have right now about how their teams are actually using AI? I know there is obviously, you know, there's all those age-old concerns about privacy and hallucinations and all that kind of stuff. But is the fix training and development or you think it's deeper than that? It's sort of a cultural change management exercise. Yeah. Rachelle Ray: I think it's both. The thing that I saw a lot of from AI tools, especially AI proposal tools when they were first starting to roll out was this messaging around, "You can do more faster," and no AEC marketer wants to hear that they can do more proposals. And so there was some resistance there like, "Great, you're handing me this thing when I need something that's going to make it easier for me to lift the five, 10 proposals I already have. And you're giving me this thing that's telling you I can do 20 now." So there was some resistance to it. There I think is some hesitation if it hallucinates, if it goes wrong, there's instant distrust and leadership doesn't always see that if somebody doesn't use it. We hear it all the time when I go to conferences, somebody's like, "Yeah, we just bought this thing and it did something dumb. So I just switched back to what I was doing before." Like, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: maybe we need to try again or like troubleshoot or figure out. So I think there's a lot of enablement that needs to happen with that training and understanding and working through. Like unlike a lot of other tools, there is no one right way to use AI. So maybe you found the wrong way and you do need to do some work with your team, some sharing of lessons learned and best practices to find the right ways. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: Yes. Gregory Hart: Are you starting to almost see a divide of the firms that really get it and are doing all the things right, whether it's change management, training and development, and are really kind of amplifying their output with AI versus there's probably a bucket that are playing around with it, you know, trying to figure it out, having some of those issues. And then there's probably a bucket that's just like still doing it the old fashioned way. Is there like a growing divide you think of the firms that are just like getting it and are starting to really take off or tell me a little bit about what you're seeing on that front. Rachelle Ray: I think we're on the cusp of seeing that. I expected Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: to see it a lot sooner, but we're not quite there yet because I think we're still in that like adopting phase. You know, Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: two years ago, we like, "If you're not using ChatGPT right now, then you are behind! Your firm's going to disappear like you're going to sink." But we are historically slow to adopt new technology industry. It took us like 20 Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: years for Revit to become the standard. And now you can't imagine life without it. So I think in the next five years, that rift will be significant. And you will Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: definitely see that difference between the firms that have adopted these tools and have adopted them well, have implemented that change management, have really woven it into the fabric of their company. And the ones that are either still kind of poking around and playing with it, or the ones that said, "You know, this is too risky, this is too dangerous, we're not going to touch it." Gregory Hart: We've been talking about this in the past couple episodes that a lot of data, both from PSMJ and other sources, it's an industry that has a lot of potential with AI, but there hasn't been a lot of adoption. See that as a strength, weakness, opportunity, threat, however you may look at it, but, there is still kind of that early adoption phase that a lot of firms are in. Who ultimately pays the price? Like if we're making, what can be some pretty significant investments in some of these tools and they're not getting used and not getting adopted at a rate that maybe even leadership thinks they are within the organization, who pays the price for that? And how does that risk kind of ultimately flow up to the leadership in the firm? Rachelle Ray: I was talking to another proposal manager and they, in like the last six months or so rolled out a AI proposal automation tool. I will not name the tool, but it is like the Cadillac of proposal automation tools, and it essentially has like a magic button that auto answers all of your questions for you and then you're supposed to check the outputs. And this particular company does a lot of questionnaires. So it's a lot of yes, no answers. Do you provide the service? Yes or no? Move on. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Rachelle Ray: Well, when the AI answers those questions, it doesn't do yes or no. It does kind of that AI bloat thing where it's like, "Ah yes, we offer this service and it's blah, blah, helpful and blah, blah, blah, blah." Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: So they're kind of chunky answers and they weren't being edited down by either the technical staff or the marketing staff. And a client reached out to one of the teams that had turned in these proposals and said, Hey, you might want to check your AI. And so leadership found out at that point, which was bad, and had to send out a memo to the entire company saying, "Hey, you have this great tool. It's amazing. Please review what it's putting out because this Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: is a problem." So it affects everybody. Gregory Hart: Marketing teams just have always, as long as I've been in the industry, they have to work hard and they got a lot going on and a lot of balls in the air. And I could see that temptation to think these tools can kind of, allow them to take their eye off a couple of things, but yeah, I'm sure that that sort of thing, just one, you know, granted it's not a technical design flaw that led to a claim and all that kind of stuff, but certainly could do some huge brand damage for future work, which is one little instance like that. Rachelle Ray: Exactly. Gregory Hart: Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about AI governance. You know, a lot of smaller firms may not even have a real dedicated IT team and they may be using the outsource resources for that. But what are you seeing in terms of kind of responsible AI governance in kind of the typical mid-size firms that exist in a lot of corners of the industry? What are you seeing for governance models to make sure stuff like that doesn't happen? Rachelle Ray: This does not belong solely in IT. It doesn't belong in marketing just because marketing was the low hanging fruit in Gregory Hart: Sure. Yep. Rachelle Ray: the beginning. AI is such a fascinating new technology. It's unlike anything we've seen before. It touches every facet of your business. So I think the firms that we're seeing are most successful in that change management, that implementation and training. are governing it in a 360 way. So they have AI committees or review panels that are made up of representation from all corners of their firms. You get marketing in there, you have leadership in there, you have IT in there, right? It has to be cross functional, cross evaluated. And leadership has to be an active participant in that. I think in the past, you know, it was kind of, "We trust each department to argue for the need of whatever tools they need," and leadership signs off on the checks. But they have to understand now how that tool interacts with their firm data and their staff workflows and how one flows from the other. You construction is a really big one, right? Because Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: estimating and marketing flow together so closely on pursuits and they have different softwares and those have to play well together now, especially with AI that can cross all these ways. And so you really need to understand what that blend is, what the interaction is. And everyone needs to come together to define what those guardrails are. What can Gregory Hart: Okay. Rachelle Ray: the AI access and who is authorized to use it and what review processes exist before that AI generated content goes out the door. Gregory Hart: How do you kind of build this culture, that really embraces AI and, doesn't hide potential issues or ignore them either, but leans in, leans forward, embraces the power of it and flags failures and looks for ways to make them better and looks at it as a tool, as a resource to help become a force multiplier for the marketing team. Are you seeing some cases where firms are getting that culture piece right? Rachelle Ray: I think that change management piece is absolutely non-negotiable with AI. Like you can't just hand this tool to your team, expect them to figure it out on their own. I think AI gets personified a lot. Like we call Shred our marketing intern, right? And we try to level it up to coordinator, manager, stuff like that. So if you were thinking about AI because of how quote unquote smart it is as an extension of your team rather than a tool, you almost need to treat it that way as well and like do lessons learned on it and make sure that you are normalizing like, "This didn't work. Let's figure out how to fix it." You know, we used to do that in kind of our postmortems on proposals; what went well, what didn't. And there were all people things, right? Like project manager had a submittal due the same day as the proposal. So we planned that poorly because he didn't let me know. Like we had a discussion about what went wrong. You have to do the same thing, I think, with AI. Like have that conversation about I didn't use the tool wrong. Sometimes the tool does things you don't expect because it's not predictable. That's just the nature of generative AI. And so we have to normalize that conversation around this didn't work and create feedback loop so that problems surface early and not after the proposal has been submitted. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: And definitely frame it as something that needs human judgment. It's not a magic button. It's not a silver bullet. Kind of just set those healthy expectations from the start. So like, I see success when you are healthily skeptical about the AI. Gregory Hart: I'll put you on the spot a little bit here, I guess. Given all this AI, all this stuff that's going on, what do you think the marketing team of the future in five or maybe 10 years looks like? Is it going to continue to sort of radically transform the way work is won, work is delivered, the business model of AEC, or I don't know, what do you see the marketing team of the future looking like given all this technology that's coming onto the scene? Rachelle Ray: I love this question. I spend a lot of time thinking about this and trying to anticipate what marketing will look like in one, two, five, ten years. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: And some days I'm like, well, the magic button is going to be magical enough to do all the things. But where I tend to actually land is someone the other day said something very profound to me. She said, "I no longer write proposals, I produce them." And I think that is such an amazing way of thinking about AI because you're still involved, but you are directing the creation of the proposal. You're not directly involved in the crafting of that, but you're still in it. And I think that like that way of thinking opens us up to some really incredible opportunities for being creative. Like granted, we are at the mercy of how a client works their RFP and what they ask for. But I think we can do some really cool things in our general marketing, in our conferencing. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: AI just opens us up to some amazing opportunities and strategy as well, and understanding market trends, and finding best fit experience. So I'm really, really optimistic that the team of the future is just going to be super empowered with incredible insight, because all of their scattered data is going to come together, not be so burdened by kind of that administrative tasks of like hunting and pecking and we call it dumpster diving, right? Going into the archives to find something. That we'll Gregory Hart: Yeah. Rachelle Ray: have that time and space to really think through like, "What's a cool thing we can do? What's an experience we can provide for someone reading our marketing materials or talking to our people?" So I'm optimistic about the marketing team of the future. Gregory Hart: It's probably a really darn exciting time to be in the AEC marketing world, you know, in terms of, Rachelle Ray: It really is. Gregory Hart: it hasn't changed much in like 50 years. And then in like five years, it's so much is happening that's changing kind of the way it looks and the way it works. So it's awesome. Yeah. Cool, well Rachelle, thanks so much for joining me. Really, really enjoyed catching up. Rachelle Ray: Yeah, thank you for having me. This is a fantastic conversation. I love it. Gregory Hart: You bet. All right. Thanks. Well, that's it. That's another episode of the AEC Growth Cast. Hope you got some tips, ideas, and inside secrets to be more successful, to grow, whether it's getting better, getting smarter, or getting more intentional. If you're not a PSMJ PRO member, you'll see a link in the show notes to become a PSMJ PRO member to access that quarterly market forecast report that I mentioned. If you have any questions, comments, suggestions, ideas, requests of what you want us to cover in a future episode: aecgrowthcast@psmj.com. aecgrowthcast@psmj.com. Praise, criticism, whatever the case may be, we want to hear from you. And be sure to also like, subscribe, and follow us wherever you get your podcasts. Until next time, thanks everybody. Take care.