Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Five-Star DT Justin Scott Decommits From Ohio State, Where Do The Buckeyes Go From Here
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony? I
- 0:13have some very exciting news for the people who watch very very closely. Behind
- 0:17me, I have new baseball cards behind me. My buddy Michael, who
- 0:21is a longtime viewer of the pod also a photographer on the on the beat,
- 0:26watches the show and we started talking about baseball cards because he saw I
- 0:28headed old sheet of nineteen eighty five tops behind me, and he said,
- 0:34you know, do you have a favorite set? And I said, I
- 0:36always love the eighty seven tops with the wood brands, and he's like,
- 0:38let me see what I can do. Let me see what I can do,
- 0:40and found a nice new sheet of nineteen eighty seven tops. So I
- 0:45have brand new baseball cards behind me. And if you're anything like me,
- 0:48you could probably went through that set often enough that you can, like without
- 0:51even squinting, just kind of like see the general outlines be like, oh
- 0:54yeah, that's a wan Sam Well, oh yeah, that's a that's a
- 0:57key Hernandez Yeah, Mike Marshall, yeah, yeah, yep. So thank
- 1:00you to Michael for updating my updating my look on the set here. I
- 1:06love it. The eighty seven was a fun one. I also had the
- 1:10the miny eighty sevens, which were like two by one or so of some
- 1:15of the star players a fantastic look back in the day. I did notice
- 1:19that I wasn't sure if it was because the camera had had widened out or
- 1:22something, but nice. Honestly, that's probably a summer show favorite. Baseball
- 1:29card years and Baseball card backs and Baseball card errors on the butts of bats.
- 1:34But for now, let's talk about other errors, I guess, and
- 1:41specifically let's start with the decommitment of Chicago five star defensive tackle Justin Scott.
- 1:48Happened on Wednesday and sort of comes out of the blue. But this is
- 1:53the time of year when things are happening. We are now three weeks a
- 2:00yeah, three weeks away yesterday on Wednesday, from the early signing day,
- 2:07and there's there's quite a bit stuck to talk about with this Justin Scott thing.
- 2:09I think the first thing that struck me with the edit from Hayes Faucet
- 2:15of the Justin Scott commitment to Miami was just a big pile of money on
- 2:23one part of this this beach theme that he's got, and I tweeted that
- 2:27out and I was like, boy, you know, college football is crazy,
- 2:29and people are responding the crazy part is that they have the CFP Championship
- 2:34Trophy and that same graphic, and it's like, oh yeah, that is
- 2:38actually the most ludicrous part in all of this. So I'll just go really
- 2:43quickly into my thing that I've said for years, and I went back on
- 2:46Twitter to see how long ago I have said this. This is not a
- 2:50recent sour grapes type of thing. My long held belief is once a player
- 2:55chooses Miami, then they no longer exists. They are no longer relevant in
- 3:01the college football world in terms of if you pay attention to Ohio State football,
- 3:07you pay attention to Alabama football or Georgia football, they're not going to
- 3:09come into your field division ever again. Basically, and also that if you
- 3:15are choosing Miami or you're choosing a USC like, if you're choosing something for
- 3:21the scene, then football isn't the most serious thing in your life, And
- 3:25not that it needs to be for all of these people, all of these
- 3:30players, but it's not serious enough. And when you're choosing the scene or
- 3:35when you're choosing the Miami bag, if you will that that tells me quite
- 3:45a bit because there are other places to go to get a bag where you
- 3:49can also win. And when you choose the Miami money or you choose Miami
- 3:53and no money, because this thought, my thought process predates It's basically,
- 4:00if you're going to Miami, you're going to Miami to be at Miami.
- 4:02You're not going to Miami to do anything else. And so certainly not changing
- 4:09that opinion now. But good get from Miami. You do have to build
- 4:13from the line of scrimmage, and they're doing that. So we'll see how
- 4:16it goes there. But I'm not going to change my pretty fairly proven thesis
- 4:25and theory on Miami and what comes from going there. Well, I think
- 4:32you want to look at just you know, if people do things. Oh,
- 4:35this is soellar grapes. I mean, first of all, I can
- 4:36assure you Tony has been saying this for literally years and lots of cases where
- 4:41it did not involve any in Ohio state in any direct sort of way.
- 4:45Let's play a little game with the audience, Tony. We're gonna have a
- 4:48quiz what is the last time Miami won a conference championship, even a share
- 4:55of a conference championship? When is the last time that happens? Everyone takes
- 5:00second, two or two. Think back, such a storied franchise, so
- 5:03much fog, so many people holding up their hands in a U shape,
- 5:08so many, so many great players over the years. When was the last
- 5:12time they won a conference championship? Tony, Do you know the answer or
- 5:15would you like to take a guess? Oh? Well, I will take
- 5:17a guess because I do not know the answer, and I'm just trying to
- 5:21figure out when the Big East ceased to exist, and I think it still
- 5:26existed in two thousand and six and two thousand and seven, so I will
- 5:28say two thousand and five. Wrong, two thousand and three. Two thousand
- 5:36and three, they were the co champions two thousand and three. Now,
- 5:40of course, when Miami jumped over to the ACC, they split up divisions
- 5:46so that Florida State and Miami would be in opposite divisions. Because that way
- 5:49you can have a Florida State versus Miami ACC championship every single year, and
- 5:55oh boy, what a TV draw that would be. Well, first of
- 5:58all, I regret to inform you that in the whatever it's been fifteen eighteen
- 6:02years since that happened, Lauria State and Miami have never met in the conference
- 6:05championship game. Now Florida State has hauled up. They're part of the bargain
- 6:10a decent amount, Tony, would you like to guess how many times Miami
- 6:14has won the division? Miami in the Coastal Division, which is the one
- 6:16that is famously full of really crappy middling teams. So a division full of
- 6:21crappy, middling teams, Tony, would you like to guess how many times
- 6:25Miami has won that Coastal Division and appeared in the ACC Championship Game. And
- 6:29we're talking fifteen or sixteen years? Is that correct? At least? Yeah?
- 6:34I say yeah, Let's say two thousand and six, two thousand and
- 6:38seven, something like that. Yeah, okay. And given the history of
- 6:41Miami football, one of the great programs of all time, just constant winning,
- 6:46you would think in the seventeen opportunities, probably at least eight or nine.
- 6:50But I'm going to say time one. The answer is in fact one,
- 6:55at the twenty seventeen they played Clemson in the ACC Championship GM Tony,
- 6:59in the long and storied history of Miami football, would you like to guess
- 7:01how many points Miami has scored in the ACC Championship game? Well, we
- 7:05know Miami is the cradle of quarterbacks, the cradle of coaches, although that's
- 7:10a different Miami plenty of offensive firepower, defensive talent. Surely, surely,
- 7:15tom at least one touchdown, three points. They lost thirty eight to three
- 7:19to Clemson in the twenty seventeen ACC Title Game. Tony, let's talk bowl
- 7:26games. We talked about the fact that the last time the Miami Hurricanes won
- 7:31a conference championship a Sheriff Conference championship in two thousand and three. In two
- 7:35thousand and four, they played. In two thousand and three, they won
- 7:39the Orange Bowl against Florida State sixteen to fourteen. In two thousand and four,
- 7:44the two thousand and four season, they played in the Peach Bowl,
- 7:46which was not really a major bowl game back then. But we're going to
- 7:48give it to him. Since that two thousand and four Peach Bowl, December
- 7:54third, thirty first, two thousand and four, they beat Florida twenty seven
- 7:57to ten. Penty bowl game has Miami won since that game? In two
- 8:03thousand and four. End of the two thousand and four season, So we're
- 8:07talking basically nineteen seasons. How many ball games have they won in those nineteen
- 8:11seasons? Oh? Yeah, you got to figure at least half, Tom
- 8:16and they probably make a bowl game in ninety percent of their season, So
- 8:20of those nineteen seasons, there should be at least eight nine wins there.
- 8:26Okay, And before I answer that question, I'd like you to tell me
- 8:28how many Power Conference teams they've beaten in all of those bowl games they've appeared
- 8:31in since the Year of Our Lord at two thousand and four. Well,
- 8:37when did the New Year six Bowls start? When did the CFP start?
- 8:41And nose still count as well, But Miami has not been in any of
- 8:46that eleven Well, Tony, I'm going to start with twenty and sixteen.
- 8:56In the Russell Athletic Bowl, Miami beat West Virginia thirty one to fourteen.
- 9:01End of list. They also in the two thousand and six MPC Computers Bowl
- 9:07beat Nevada twenty one to twenty end of list. Of all of their bowl
- 9:11wins since two thousand and four, Tony would like NFL you NFL Miami University
- 9:22two first round picks in twenty twenty one, last time they had first round
- 9:26picks. Would you like to guess how many other first round picks they've had
- 9:30since David and Joku got wet Number one to the Browns in the first round
- 9:35to the Browns in twenty seventeen is the twenty ninth overall pick? How many?
- 9:41How many have they had since between? Since? Yes, they had
- 9:43they had two and twenty one, two and twenty twenty one? How many
- 9:46others since twenty seventeen? Any position at all? Any position at all?
- 9:50Well, now you're just you're giving me any position. And this is a
- 9:52football factory that produces NFL players like Pez produces candy. I'm going to say,
- 9:58So that's that eighteen, nineteen and twenty three years an average of six
- 10:03first rounders a year. I will say tom eighteen first round picks and those
- 10:07three seasons very very close. We're going to round down from eighteen to zero.
- 10:13Other than those two, yes, and last defensive tackle to go number
- 10:18one out of Miami Vince Wulfork. Who I mean, boy, that was
- 10:20only nineteen years ago. So yeah, So when we say, you know,
- 10:26when Tony has his long held theory that if you go to Miami,
- 10:30it's great because then you basically you know, it's like falling down the Springfield
- 10:33mystery spot and we will never see you again. That's why, that's that's
- 10:37why, that's that's why there's money on the graphics, because no one knows
- 10:39what the MPC Computer's Bowl trophy looks like. So that's why they put the
- 10:43money on the graphic. Well, and the quarterback for that Miami team former
- 10:48number one overall recruit Kyle Right. People might remember from such things as being
- 10:54the number one former overall recruits and right into that the And this was something
- 11:01I tweeted out last year or this past April. So the last Miami quarterback
- 11:09to be drafted is well, they've had one since Ken Dorsey, so that
- 11:16was two thousand and three. They've had one over the last twenty years drafted.
- 11:22It may have been Kyle Right. I don't know, Tyler van Dyk
- 11:24I believe just hit hit the portal. So this is this has not been
- 11:28a great stretch of twenty years since Jim Tressel put the hammer on Miami and
- 11:33basically ended them. I don't know if this is the Montezuma's revenge of This
- 11:41is what ibis is revenge, and you start losing recruits and commits and decommits
- 11:48and and other guys that you want to Miami. That's kind of a slow
- 11:52way of doing it. I don't know if it's going to be effective enough.
- 11:56You know, sure it helps Miami and it hurts Ohio State, but
- 12:01you're gonna need a lot more then some five star defensive tackles to undo the
- 12:07damage that Jim Trussell and the Ohio State Buckeyes have done to Miami over you
- 12:11can't even say, over the over the years, over the decades, Tim,
- 12:16There's so much to be thankful for, family, friends, food,
- 12:18and NFL football all week long. Draftking Sports Book is keeping your Thanksgiving week
- 12:22full of action. New customers can bet just five bucks on the NFL action
- 12:24to score one hundred and fifty instantly in bonus bets. No matter your appetite,
- 12:28there's something for you money, aliones, parlays, props, live bets,
- 12:30and so much more. You name it and they've got it. So
- 12:31download the DraftKings Sports Book app now and use code Huddle Up. New customers
- 12:35con bet five on the NFL thanksgiving the action to score one hundred and fifty
- 12:37instantly in bonus bets only on Draftking sports Book, an official sports betting partner
- 12:41of the NFL, with code Huddle Up the Crown is yours. Gambling problem
- 12:45called tey hundred gambler in New York call eight seven seven eight Hope n Y.
- 12:48Or text Hope n Y four six seven three sixty nine West Virginia.
- 12:50Visit www dot twenty hundred gambler dot net. Please play responsibly. In Connecticut,
- 12:54help is available for problem gambling called eight at eight seven eight nine seven
- 12:58seven seven seven or visit CCPG on behalf of Boohell Casino. To resort Kansas
- 13:01must be twenty one or older in most eligible states, but age varies by
- 13:05jurisdiction. See draftgigs dot com slash Sportsbook for details and state specific responsible gamly
- 13:09resources. Eligibility and deposit restrictions apply. Bonus bets expire one hundred and sixty
- 13:13eight hours after Issueance terms at sportsbook dot draftgigs dot com slash football terms.
- 13:18Yeap Miami is just like a walking fun fact because it's like that can't possibly
- 13:22be right, and you look it up and that was I literally was not
- 13:24planning and doing any of this, and I looked up one of those things,
- 13:26I'm like, that can't be right. And then I looked up another
- 13:28thing and like that can't be right. And that gives you The last ten
- 13:33minutes or so of this show was just, Hey, that can't be right.
- 13:37Hey, toty, remember earlier in the fall when all they had to
- 13:39do is kneel the ball out and they would have won, and they would
- 13:41have beaten Georgia tech Ooh yeah, yeah, Miami football. Miami football fans
- 13:48really got on me back about twenty years ago about a column I wrote after
- 13:52the Fiesta Bowl, and it's been going great for them ever since. So
- 13:56you know, who's to say who? Who's to say who was and wrong?
- 14:00Back then? If you got the list of ball games there and you
- 14:03want to take it like the twenty nineteen Independence Bowl, the Miami Hurricanes getting
- 14:09shut out fourteen nothing to Louisiana Tech. Yes, I remember that one.
- 14:15That was we were twenty nineteen, so that would have been like the first
- 14:18night we were out at the Fiesta Bowl that year, and that was on
- 14:24in the media lounge or something like that. Yeah, and they haven't played
- 14:26in a bowl game since twenty twenty. Just you go back and it's cheese
- 14:31At Bowl, Independence Bowl, Pinstripe Bowl, Orange Bowl. They lost to
- 14:33Wisconsin, Russell Athletic Bowl, sun Ball Independence Bowl, Russell Athletic Bowl,
- 14:37sun Ball, Champ Sports Bowl, Emerald Bowl, MPC Computer's Bowl. And
- 14:41now you're back to two thousand and five. Yeah. I mean, if
- 14:48you built a time machine and went back to the late nineties and told yourself
- 14:52either that you've read off that list of bowl games for Miami or told yourself
- 15:00Nebraska was gonna go on like a six year bowlless streak. I don't know
- 15:03which one would have been less believable, but I think probably the Miami one
- 15:07because they're still literally located in South Florida, Like, you have an incredible
- 15:11amount of talent, Like it takes an unbelievable amount of institutional bumbling to screw
- 15:18that up, and to screw it up for two decades is honestly genuinely impressive.
- 15:24Yeah. Now, now you got me looking at Nebraska's bowl game history
- 15:28and this is it goes. It goes dark pretty quickly because you know you've
- 15:33got you've got orange Fest, orange Festa Orange Festa, Rose Cotton Gator than
- 15:37some holiday bowls in Capitol One. That's all perfectly fine. Gator Holiday and
- 15:41then Foster Farms Music City. Nothing after twenty sixteen. But you know,
- 15:48as long as they keep their grades up and they stay at five and seven,
- 15:52eventually, Tom, they are gonna get one of those extra spots,
- 15:54like Minnesota got this year now, And really, when Minnesota has better academics
- 15:58better than you, that you should be shamed. The N on the helmets
- 16:04famously stands for knowledge, but the M on the Minnesota helmets stands for more
- 16:08knowledge, so therefore they get outranked. So now it's like, this is
- 16:15a de commitment. The commitment of Justin Scott came sort of as a surprise.
- 16:18They were obviously involved in him, but when it happened, I was
- 16:21like, whoa, hey, Justin Scott just committed. So I guess we
- 16:23shouldn't be super surprised by the de commitment looking at past decommitments. Ohio State
- 16:29has decommitments every single year. They don't necessarily have him every year on the
- 16:33defensive line. And I put a list together and I threw the sound McCall
- 16:37it in there, and he wasn't really a defensive lineman at all when he
- 16:41was being recruited. He was just an athyte who was going to end up
- 16:42somewhere. But to me, say a Delia in twenty twenty one who ended
- 16:47up at Florida and then Michigan State and has been dismissed by Michigan State in
- 16:52twenty twenty one, Brenton Cox and Andrew Chatfield in twenty eighteen, and Trell
- 16:56Lewis I e. Trell Hall in twenty sixteen. And really that's been it
- 17:02under Larry Johnson, and that's been fine four years. But it's not the
- 17:07dee commitments that are hurting them over the past few years. It hurts them
- 17:11right now, but it's leading for guys feeling really good about guys and then
- 17:17seeing those guys go to other schools the last two years with the defensive ends
- 17:21and two years prior to you this year and also this year. So go
- 17:25ahead and through the last three years. I guess if you want in terms
- 17:26of the defensive ends that you feel good about, but go elsewhere. And
- 17:33if you just land two thirds of those guys, you're feeling a lot better
- 17:36about possibly losing JT. Twuey Moloau and Jack Sawyer this year. But it's
- 17:41I think it's three different things and they're all valid. It's the negative recruiting
- 17:47in terms of Larry Johnson's age and how much longer he's going to be around.
- 17:51It's the fact that Larry Johnson is an older coach and how much longer
- 17:55is he going to be around? So the negative recruiting is fact you recruiting
- 18:00in that sense. And then also nil is a huge reality in all of
- 18:03this, and as I said before, some programs have to pay a lot
- 18:07to kind of build Ohio State isn't necessarily in that situation, which frustrates people
- 18:12when your collective has the money. In theory, there's money around that you
- 18:18know you won't match what a Texas A and M or a Miami or a
- 18:25USC or Texas will do, and so you don't even bother getting involved in
- 18:29them. But those three things are going to continue to impact the defensive line
- 18:33recruiting at Ohio State until something is done. And it feels like I don't
- 18:41know if this was the last straw, but there aren't many more straws that
- 18:45can be put on this camel. If you will, Yeah, it does
- 18:49feel like at some point the you know, I mean Larry Johnson is not
- 18:55going to coach forever. That is not how you know anything works. And
- 19:00you know, there have been rumors back when Joey Bosa was a recruit at
- 19:03Ohio State. You know, I think it, or at least Nick Bosa,
- 19:07how much longer can Larry Johnson possibly coach was sort of one of the
- 19:11recurring storylines of his thing. And boy, will he be around for you
- 19:15know, the end of Joey Bosa's career. Will be around for the end
- 19:18of Nick Bosa's career. Will he be around for the end of Chase Young's
- 19:21career? Will he be around for the end of Zach Harrison's career? Will
- 19:25he be around for the end of j T. Twey Moloaw's career? And
- 19:29you know twey Moloow is draft eligible this year. We'll see if he ends
- 19:33up turning pro or not. But you know, Larry Johnson has been there
- 19:36for three years of his career, and you know, they have had a
- 19:40couple classes in a row where they haven't gotten the five star guys. Last
- 19:45year there were three guys who were in the top fifty nationally top six overall
- 19:51at the edge position that Ohio State was considered to be in decent shape or
- 19:53good shape for at various times. Key On Keeley he ended up going to
- 19:57Alabama, Damon Wilson, he ended up going to Georgia. Butteyo Ujungle Away,
- 20:02he ended up going to to Oregon, and they ended up going oh
- 20:06for three And now you know, you lose Justin Scott, you know,
- 20:10they they missed out on Marquis Lightfoot, who also went out to what went
- 20:15to Miami, and there was some talk that maybe Ohioso could flip him,
- 20:18and that has not happened yet. And you know, you keeping Larry Johnson
- 20:23around is based on you know, reputation, based on his history, and
- 20:29based on the fact that he brings in guys that you don't have to just
- 20:33this is not Texas A and M where you're just like throwing a bag at
- 20:36people like guys come because he's the guy who coached the Bosa's and he's the
- 20:38guy who coached Chase Young. The production hasn't really been there from the defensive
- 20:44line for the last couple of years, and the recruiting hasn't really been there
- 20:48for the defensive line in the last couple of years, and you know,
- 20:51you do wonder. I think there's been, you know, some questions about
- 20:55exactly how well he meshes with Jim Knowles and what Jim Knowles wants to do
- 20:57on defense, and how well what Larry Johnson does on the defensive line meshes
- 21:02with what Jim Knowles wants to do, and is there enough flexibility there?
- 21:06And I think there's probably going to be a lot of examination. If Ohio
- 21:11State does miss the playoffs this year, then this will be three years in
- 21:15a row where they didn't beat Michigan, didn't win the Big Ten, didn't
- 21:17win the national championship, And I think there's probably time for some self examination
- 21:22and is this is this the time to make some kind of a change there.
- 21:26And even if it's just a small change in role and someone younger comes
- 21:30in and he stays on in some other role whatever, that's fine, But
- 21:33it does feel like you're getting to the play where that conversation, mate,
- 21:37conversation may at least be you know, be being considered. Yeah, in
- 21:41the past, it's been like, well, you don't want to make a
- 21:45move because you could lose the defensive line class and right now you don't have
- 21:48enough guys necessarily into class to really concern yourself about losing them. Obviously,
- 21:53you've got guys committed that you want to keep, edarck Houston, Houston,
- 21:57Eric Mensa, guys like that. But you can't let the fear of what
- 22:03could happen continue to alter or affect your decision making and what is happening,
- 22:10because stuff is happening as we speak in terms of the defensive line, production,
- 22:15development, all of these things, and at some point it's an inevit
- 22:21evitability. At some point something needs to be done. So do you do
- 22:23it now? Do you do it later? And this all maybe also depends
- 22:29on what happens with Jim Knowles, which you we'll get to in a bit.
- 22:32But so in terms of this losing Justin Scott, what does it do?
- 22:36What do they do now? They've got three star Carlin Jones visiting on
- 22:41December eighth, was committed to Nebraska, decommitted from there, and so he's
- 22:48visiting and people feel pretty confident that he's going to end up there. You've
- 22:52got Marris Williams who is committed to Miami, who is a flip candidate at
- 22:59this point, but just waiting for that to happen. He is the uh,
- 23:03the uh. I'm just scrolling through here looking for him. Number eleven
- 23:07defensive lineman in the in the class, number forty six overall out of North
- 23:11Carolina. He's listened at six three two seventy So is he a is he
- 23:15a three four end? Is he a defensive tackle? Stuff like that needs
- 23:18to be figured out. But again, you need bodies. And of course
- 23:22there is the portal. They just offered Middle Tennessee graduate transfer Marley Cook who
- 23:27U grad transfers can announce their transferring and announce their offers. At this point,
- 23:33you don't need to They don't need to wait till Monday. They can
- 23:34do what they want. They've done, they've got enough book learning in them,
- 23:37they've studied, they've earned their degrees. They don't need to wait around
- 23:41like kids. So with with with the portal, Tom, you also don't
- 23:48need to necessarily worry about losing a class because you can. You can kind
- 23:53of make up for it and grab some guys who have experienced I just I
- 23:59just don't think you can continue to and I don't know if that happen,
- 24:03But coach scared in terms of your coaches, if you know what I'm saying,
- 24:11Yeah, you have to you have to take I think a little bit
- 24:12of a long view on some of this stuff. And you know, if
- 24:15you were going to make a change, you don't have a huge class this
- 24:19year that you're super worried about losing. And I think part of the question
- 24:25also is who would you bring in as a replacement and can you bring in
- 24:29someone who would be a draw as well. I don't think this is you
- 24:33know, Rhinde has done a lot of internal hiring and internal promotions. I
- 24:37don't think this is an internal promotion position. I think you got to go
- 24:41out and get a name, get someone with a reputation, and bring someone
- 24:45in who you know is sort of established and is not just you know,
- 24:49an internal guy who you don't want to lose. I think that's not a
- 24:53great way to make make decisions on a you know, repeated basis. And
- 25:00Mars Williams the Florida commit, you know, he's a top fifty guy,
- 25:03He's someone who they could you know that that would be a real significant addition.
- 25:07And Edrick Houston is kind of the same way where he's you know,
- 25:12he's not a two hundred and thirty pound, two hundred and forty pound guy.
- 25:15Those are to Mars Williams six three two seventy EDWCK. Houston I think
- 25:18is somewhere in that like two seventy two seventy five kind of range. Those
- 25:22are bigger defensive ends, and that's something that would be a little bit out
- 25:26of the ordinary for Larry Johnson. So we'll see, you know, if
- 25:30they end up. Houston sounds like he's gonna end up as an edge,
- 25:33Amrs Williams, like you said, could be an edge, could maybe a
- 25:36three tech something like that. But you know, and Marley Cook from from
- 25:41Middle Tennessee, as you said, is you know it possibility as well.
- 25:45He has not put up huge numbers at Middle Tennessee's. That might be more
- 25:49of a depth play than anything else. But you can you can sort of
- 25:53patch holes through the portal, and that's something that you know, you've seen
- 25:59good teams do that you can't build to the portal. You do need to
- 26:03still hit on your recruiting because the portal play a lot of times is a
- 26:08one or two year thing. And that's fine if you're bringing in a guy
- 26:12to fill a spot. You know, Josh Simmons this year, like great,
- 26:15that worked out really well for Ohio State at left tackle. You can't
- 26:19just build an offensive line through the portal. That's what it sounds like Deon
- 26:22Sanders is kind of trying to do at Colorado. And I was reading something
- 26:26that basically, there are maybe thirty Power five caliber offensive linemen in the portal
- 26:33during any given year, and there are sixty something Power five teams and they
- 26:37probably all would love to add one. So on average, you're going to
- 26:41add about half of one every year. So you can't. You can't just
- 26:44and that's probably true of defensive tackle, that's probably true of edges as well.
- 26:48I'm sure that's true of quarterbacks. There are just not that the demand
- 26:52significantly outstrips to supply there. So you've got to be able to continue to
- 26:57bring guys in from the high school ranks and continue filling, you know,
- 27:02keep that pipeline fill full, because it is not that easy to just like,
- 27:07oh, lell, we'll plug a hole like you. Maybe you can
- 27:08plug one hole, you're not going to plug three. Well, and when
- 27:15you are doing what Deon Sanders is doing and trying to basically rebuild your offensive
- 27:19line every year or whatever. You're you're not going to get the first five
- 27:23draft picks in the offensive line class of the Portal. And you know,
- 27:27I know one former Buckeye was offered like kind of like five grand to go
- 27:34to Colorado, and it's like, why you know there are other places to
- 27:40go that yeah, are more collegial. I don't know, just it feels
- 27:47more like college football and there's more chance to win. And really, if
- 27:49they could have put frozen time after about the first three weeks of the season,
- 27:53then everybody's going to be talking about Colorado. But when I think they
- 27:56lose eight of nine and and you see the at least one player lashing out
- 28:03about the selfish nature of the team, that's something that we have talked about
- 28:07for a long time that you can't build a championship through nil. You have
- 28:11to build it with culture. Now you supplement it, you can build upon
- 28:15it, but you can't. The foundation can't be transfer portal and NIL because
- 28:22it's you're building the foundation on a foundation of sand, as they say,
- 28:26and it's not going to hold up to any kind of adversity, scrutiny,
- 28:32windy day type of stuff. And I think you're seeing that it does get
- 28:37windy in College Station, Texas, if that is any kind of indication.
- 28:41And you know, you go back through the recruiting class that they had a
- 28:45couple of years ago, and you know, the games are won and lost
- 28:47along along the offense and defensive lines. Absolutely one hundred percent through Texas A
- 28:52and M brought in one of the greatest defensive line classes in the history of
- 28:56the sport and just fired their coat two years after two years after bringing in
- 29:00one of the greatest defensive line you know, you've got the most expensive coach
- 29:03in the history of the sport, You've got the most expensive recruiting class in
- 29:07the history of the sport, and you fire your coach, and you know,
- 29:11there's a lot of the stuff happening that has happened at Texas A and
- 29:15M the last couple of years is a lot of the same stuff that you
- 29:17see happening at places like Miami, where it's like, you know, you
- 29:19got to you kind of have to. Culture is one of those things that
- 29:23everyone talks about, and it's not really something that everyone has built. And
- 29:30even the places that you think you've built it, sometimes it isn't quite as
- 29:33strong as you think it is. It's one of those things that I think
- 29:37people have rolled their eyes at, but it is something that kind of matters.
- 29:38And you know, in the wake of Ohio States lost to Michigan,
- 29:44I think you have a lot of people examining the culture at Ohio State and
- 29:47is the culture at Ohio State exactly what they say it is and all that
- 29:49kind of stuff, And you know, are you having that same conversation if
- 29:53they complete one more pass? You know, if if you know, what
- 29:57does that one more pass do? Or you know for the culture at Ohio
- 30:02State, if Marvin Harrison catches it instead of Rod More and you know that
- 30:06that's I think there's a there's a big gap between Put it this way,
- 30:11I think there's a much bigger gap between Ohio State and Texas A and m
- 30:14or Ohio State in Miami than there is between Ohio State and Michigan, or
- 30:18Ohio State in Georgia or whoever else you'd want to compare that to completely agree
- 30:22and last thing, Tom before we get out of here. Reports on Wednesday
- 30:27from I believe Nicole Arbach from the Athletics saying that Jim Knowles has spoken with
- 30:34Duke about their open head coaching position. This is year two of a three
- 30:41year contract with Jim Knowles, and I guess, on one hand, you
- 30:45want your coordinators to be looked at as possible head coaches, future head coaches,
- 30:49things like that, and if you go and talk to a school,
- 30:52clearly you are interested in that job. I don't. I don't necessarily think
- 31:00that he's leaving or that that he would be the choice. You know,
- 31:03he has been an assistant there for almost a decade, so he understands the
- 31:08culture and what it takes and what you can and can't do there, and
- 31:11I think Duke likes that aspect of the the reality, the knowledge of the
- 31:17reality. And obviously what Jim Knowles has done at Ohio State this year has
- 31:21been very good. Number two scoring defense, number three, total defense,
- 31:23number three or four or five pass efficiency defense. So you know, I
- 31:30think it's obviously something to monitor until I hear more. Though I expect him
- 31:36well, I expect him back. I expect him. I expect Duke to
- 31:40maybe go in a different direction until we hear something more or that this is
- 31:45heating up, But just to know that he's looking around when you kind of
- 31:48figured he would be around for as long as you wanted him. I wonder
- 31:52what Ryan Day's reaction to this is, or if this is also Ryan Day
- 31:56saying, hey, go look around. Well, I don't know that he's
- 32:01getting chased out. This might be a little bit like when Brian Hartline had
- 32:06his name in with what was the Cincinnati job last year or something like that,
- 32:09where he was at least in sort of theoretically, it may be a
- 32:15go ahead and take a look, and if you want to be a head
- 32:16coach at some point, okay, take a look and see what you see,
- 32:21what you want to do. Noles coached at his alma mater, Cornell
- 32:22from four through two thousand and nine, and had one season above five hundred
- 32:29and hasn't been a head coach in since two thousand and nine, so I'm
- 32:32not expecting him to be the one who gets the job at Duke. I
- 32:37know many Diaz was one of the other names that was in there, and
- 32:39many Diaz has been a head coach more recently and not tremendously successful as a
- 32:45head coach. He was circling back to Miami. The Many Diaz era at
- 32:50Miami was not a disaster, but it wasn't a huge success. Either,
- 32:53so now you're going to go work at Duke and have less resources and be
- 32:58in the same conference. You know, maybe okay, but and many Dias
- 33:02is a lot like Jim Knowles, where he had you know, had a
- 33:06very good defense this year in the Big Ten East and played, you know,
- 33:09played pretty well, but is in a spot where they, you know,
- 33:13the fan base is probably not thrilled because they lost the wrong games.
- 33:15And so I think those are those guys are probably fairly similar. Noles is
- 33:21in his late fifties, I think Diaz in his maybe late forties something like
- 33:23that, So, you know, similar, similar kinds of profiles. But
- 33:29well, we'll see where this one goes. But you know Nole's with the
- 33:32connection there, you know, it's worth it's worth poking around if that's something
- 33:37you think you want to want to, uh maybe do again. At some
- 33:39point, Tom, I'm going to throw a number out at you over under
- 33:45on coaching staff changes for Ohio State this year. I should go but we
- 33:49should go back and look at what we said last year, because I'm almost
- 33:52certain we did this last year as well, and we've probably done it every
- 33:55year. But if I set the over under in terms of the number of
- 34:00changes of the top of the ten assistant coaches, Tom, I am going
- 34:05to set that number at two and a half. See, I was thinking
- 34:12you were going to say one and a half because I think one is almost
- 34:15certain, and then you know, I don't. I think I could get
- 34:22to two and three is three is probably someone leaving who you're not expecting to
- 34:31leave. I'm going to take the under on that. I think I think
- 34:38two would be if I'm just laying out you know, the order of probability,
- 34:44Two is probably the most likely scenario to me, followed maybe by one
- 34:52and then three and then zero. But I'm you know, I'm not.
- 34:57I don't have a super high degree of confidence here because you could have one
- 35:01guy get a head coaching job, and I mean like Kevin Wilton got a
- 35:05head coaching job last year and took a bunch of lower level staffers to Tulsa
- 35:08with him. So you know, if someone gets a Power five gig,
- 35:12did they take you know, a position coach with them to go be a
- 35:15coordinator? Maybe? Well, And that's why I setting the number at one
- 35:21and a half is a pretty easy over for me, A more easy over
- 35:28than what the two and a half would be whether you want to go under
- 35:31or over that I've at this point I would probably This is why I ask
- 35:38you, so I wouldn't have to do it. I think this early on,
- 35:44maybe you just go over just because it might be a better bet in
- 35:49terms of the payout if we're talking actual dollars. Not that I'm expecting any
- 35:54particular person, but shoot, maybe maybe a position coach gets an opportunity to
- 36:00go be a DC somewhere, because again, this has been a very good
- 36:04defense, it's been a very good secondary. You've got two secondary coaches.
- 36:07Is this something where one of them gets an opportunity? You know, something
- 36:14like that. I think the obviously the there's going to be we would both
- 36:17agree there's going to be at least one and quite possibly two. The question
- 36:22is is there going to be a third? And that's one thing we'll be
- 36:25watching all December long, maybe into January as well, and coaching changes.
- 36:34It's a part of the game. Happens every year, and the speculation will
- 36:37never stop, and we'll try to keep up on all of that, the
- 36:42possibilities and the probabilities throughout. Tom, you got anything else, No,
- 36:45I think we're good for now, and then who knows. Maybe between transfers
- 36:51and the BOWLD drama over the weekend and conference championship games and coaching changes,
- 36:59I suspect there will be plenty of stuff for us to talk about starting next
- 37:01week. Yeah, and daily previews of Louisville versus Ohio State and the Orange
- 37:07Bowl. Maybe maybe let's not start getting grumbly just yet. There's plenty of
- 37:15time, so that will do it. If you are watching this video on
- 37:19YouTube, please go ahead and like it. I should have said that earlier.
- 37:21That's my fault. I apologize for that. Also, please find us
- 37:23at bucke huddle dot com. If you're not yet a member, now is
- 37:27a great time. Trust me, it's still a good time to become a
- 37:30member. You can find us there. It is also a great way to
- 37:31support what we do. So we want to thank you for tuning in and
- 37:35we will talk to you guys later