Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP313: Mastering Ecommerce Operations - Secrets to Scaling Success with HighCohesion CEO Aran Kapila
Transcript
- 0:00Product data might exist in five different places completely
- 0:04differently, and probably 20 spreadsheets.
- 0:06So as soon as you move into a world where you want to
- 0:09automate, let's say product data between systems, suddenly things
- 0:13don't match and automation's impossible.
- 0:15So actually what starts off as an automation project actually
- 0:19shifts into a product data project.
- 0:23You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:26and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:29and re platform specialist James Geddon Paul Rogers.
- 0:31Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:34industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:36practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:42This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:43Got a really interesting and important topic today.
- 0:46So we're, we're going into the back office world and we're
- 0:49going to the side of the operational part of of
- 0:51e-commerce businesses, which is hugely important because you can
- 0:54put the best marks in the world out there.
- 0:56But if your operations aren't fit for purpose and able to
- 0:59scale and support like massive increases in orders or increases
- 1:02in data flows, then you end up with a lot of problems and it's
- 1:06very hard to retrospectively fix.
- 1:08So you've got a, a, a well known industry thought lead who is the
- 1:13CEO of High Cohesion, which is one of the leading integration
- 1:17platforms of fast grown brands. So warm welcome to Aaron.
- 1:19How are you doing? Hey, James, thanks for having me
- 1:22on. Yes, all good.
- 1:25I am here in sunny Barcelona. Sorry to rub it in so early at
- 1:29the beginning of the podcast, but you know, really good to
- 1:31hear, really good to be here. Yeah, that's, that's your
- 1:34gloating done. I'm not going to listen to
- 1:37anymore. It's well, I'm I'm in really
- 1:39rainy grizzly drizzly Ascot where nobody's smiling today.
- 1:43So we've got completely contract, but look, look, thanks
- 1:46for joining. So we'll get I'll let you do a
- 1:48bit of instruction in a minute, but we're going to talk about
- 1:50the operational transformation, how to plan effectively and
- 1:53minimise risk space in your size and tech maturity.
- 1:56Sounds like a mouthful, but this, this is really important
- 1:58because how you plan operation, it really is dependent on what
- 2:01size of business and where you are on your maturity growth.
- 2:03And you can be, you can be in a like fast growth brand with
- 2:07hundreds and hundreds of millions, but have a relatively
- 2:09simple tech stack or you can be a 20 to 30 million retailer,
- 2:12have a really complex tech stack and in your operational side.
- 2:15So it's really important we tease this out.
- 2:17So Aaron, do you want to give people a bit the flavour for who
- 2:20you are and where high cohesion sits in the market?
- 2:24Yeah, sure. So thanks for the introduction.
- 2:27I'm CEO, Co founder of High Cohesion.
- 2:30So we're AUK based integrations platform as a service, the
- 2:35acronym which you might have heard is ipass and we work with
- 2:40large and enterprise fast growing brands all around the
- 2:43world. Basically, we make sure that our
- 2:47brands tech stacks stay connected as they grow and also
- 2:51as they evolve the way I like to kind of frame who are we for.
- 2:57So when we're speaking to brands, if if anyone brand side,
- 3:01head of OPS, CFO, ecom director is answering yes to any of these
- 3:08questions, it probably suggests that maybe we're a good fit for
- 3:11them. So questions like you know are
- 3:15manual processors slowing down your operations today?
- 3:19Are complex requirements like tax or customs and duties
- 3:24calculations or promotions or bundles a headache when data
- 3:29moves between the systems today? Does maybe your gut tell you or
- 3:34have you got the data telling you that your team's spending
- 3:36way too much time reconciling data between platforms, let's
- 3:41say econ platform down to ERP or WMS?
- 3:45And then lastly, are you as a brand facing any challenges
- 3:51scaling processes across geographies or channels?
- 3:55You know what it is you want to do as you, as you referred to
- 3:57from it, a marketing and a front office perspective, but actually
- 4:01making that happen, operation in reality is, is a challenge.
- 4:04So typically the brands that we work with, the size they're at
- 4:10are normally answering yes probably to all of those
- 4:13questions. And that's where we come in and
- 4:16play a role in, in helping from a, a data perspective and that
- 4:21kind of connection perspective. But we've also got an amazing
- 4:25team of Ecom experts who are based all around the world.
- 4:28We're we're a remote company and we're not just taking data from
- 4:33A to B. We're also thinking about
- 4:35actually what does best practice look like from order to cash
- 4:39process for example for for a particular kind of size and type
- 4:44of brand. Yeah.
- 4:47And just lastly, the business is is 6 years old.
- 4:51We I started the business with my two Co founders Luke Hodgson
- 4:55and Andy Slater. So we have been kind of growing
- 5:01steadily over those over those six years and we and we also run
- 5:05the ECOM consultancy commerce thinking that's focused from a
- 5:10consultancy perspective, the same kind of space on, on the
- 5:13tech, tech and OPS side as well. Excellent.
- 5:17Thank you for that introduction. And let's let's get into the the
- 5:22the fun part around operational transformation and how this
- 5:27impacts brands definitely depending on size and
- 5:29complexity. So we're going to start on
- 5:30talking about established brands and then we're going to go on to
- 5:33like, I guess newer brands are fast growing.
- 5:36So when we look at an established brand, this is like
- 5:39businesses with strong operational teams, they've got
- 5:42resource there, they've got structure, they'll have decent
- 5:44tech stack maturity. But we all know that with tech
- 5:47stack maturity, you often get a lot of legacy debt into that
- 5:52bringing efficiency when they're trying to modernize, improve,
- 5:58how do they take the learnings of what's made them successful
- 6:00and gotten to where they are today, but apply those to being
- 6:03able to deliver a newer new projects faster?
- 6:06Because one of the struggles I often see in this type of
- 6:09business is speed to market. So sometimes those more mature
- 6:12tech stacks and those more robust processes can slow them
- 6:15down when they're like launching in US warehouse to support
- 6:17expansion in the US. So what, what is your approach?
- 6:20How do you help people to to get to market quicker within that
- 6:24environment? Yeah, good, good question.
- 6:28So I think firstly, what do we define as high cohesion as an
- 6:32established brand? I would say in kind of pure
- 6:35financial metrics, probably a brand that's 50 million GVP
- 6:40upwards. And certainly we're seeing
- 6:44brands embed technology in processes much, much more at
- 6:49that kind of stage, you know, all the way from kind of the
- 6:52people side of having a management structure, distinct
- 6:55teams, roles and responsibilities.
- 6:58But firstly, I think the things that really help an established
- 7:02brand, so #1 data tends to be good or better than a younger
- 7:09and maybe faster growing brand. So product data is solid.
- 7:13Because if it's not, then you know you're going to have a real
- 7:19challenge having got to that size in the 1st place.
- 7:21So, so data tends to be consistent across systems.
- 7:25There's not this continual scramble to to make data match
- 7:30Projects like launching AUS Warehouse, for example, are
- 7:34really kind of treated as projects, not as side hustles.
- 7:37So in a smaller brand, people are often doing projects kind of
- 7:42off the side of their desk in a bigger brands, in a bigger
- 7:45brand, they're very much more planned.
- 7:47There's actually resource carved out.
- 7:50People's time is carved out. You might even have a dedicated
- 7:53project team, I would say the providers at those largest
- 7:58brands. So the vendors or the logistic
- 8:01partners, the agencies tend to be Tier 1.
- 8:04So they are, they tend to be partners that have gone through
- 8:07the same process many, many times.
- 8:09And their ability to, you know, bring a process in and say this
- 8:14is how we're going to do it and here's where we might tweak and
- 8:17change it for your specific use case massively speeds things up.
- 8:21And I think crucially if we look at something like launching US
- 8:25warehouse and we've recently helped couple of brands, LSKD
- 8:29Australia in in Australia and Abenola in the UK go through a
- 8:34similar thing. The overall change to the
- 8:39business is incremental. So actually bringing in a new
- 8:43warehouse is a is a much, much smaller change for a brand of
- 8:48that size than a brand that's at kind of ten £15,000,000 mark.
- 8:52So the ability for the business to absorb change is much, much
- 8:56greater for a bigger business. There's a smaller business
- 9:00absorbing like a change like that is much, much more
- 9:02transformational. So I think that's what helps it
- 9:06go well at an established brand. But as you rightly called out, I
- 9:11think for established brands also, they can be very, very
- 9:16fixed to a current process. So, you know, for example, the
- 9:20whole finance department might be based around UK tax, UK
- 9:26customs and way of treating customs and duties.
- 9:30And suddenly when you've got business that's growing in the
- 9:32US and you've got AUS tax nexuses that you need to set up
- 9:36and you're hitting state thresholds for tax to completely
- 9:41shift, how a business does something like that from a
- 9:44finance perspective. Also is can be slower than a
- 9:48smaller kind of more nimble team.
- 9:52What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 9:57all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 10:01Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 10:05and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 10:08It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 10:11planet Shopify powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 10:18Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 10:22And one of the things that I see in, in large businesses and I,
- 10:26I've worked, I mean, I've worked with businesses like you of all
- 10:28different shapes and sizes from like start-ups through to a
- 10:31multi £100 million businesses. And one of the big challenges
- 10:35operationally I see is maintaining quality and
- 10:37efficiency as they scale. So they might have a process
- 10:39that works for handling refunds, for example, and then they go
- 10:43into national and they add in multiple return points and there
- 10:47might be consolidation and then actually managing that process,
- 10:51managing the SLA with customers can change and, and the impact
- 10:54on the systems can change. And one of the ways that
- 10:57sometimes people react to it is to throw more people.
- 11:01So it's OK if we put more people like new skills or more senior
- 11:05people that will improve it. And it doesn't always because
- 11:08that can slow decision making down or it can can also compound
- 11:11the problem because it might not be human 1.
- 11:13So I'd love to hear what you, you work with so many different
- 11:15businesses. What are the things you see?
- 11:17How do you help people to maintain quality and efficiency
- 11:20in their back office processes when they are going through like
- 11:23transformations that scale? Yeah, good question.
- 11:28So from our perspective, one thing we're really, really hot
- 11:33on is going in and having helping a brand or us
- 11:40understanding what is a brand's kind of standard operating
- 11:42procedures look like. And if they don't exist,
- 11:46actually we want to tease them out of people and help help them
- 11:51document them. So for our own requirements, we
- 11:54need to be obviously be aware of them.
- 11:56You know, integrations, as much as people talk about them being
- 12:01flexible and adaptable, at the end of the day, they're pretty
- 12:04kind of rigid in what's going to work in an in an integration and
- 12:08what's going to break it. So understanding the standard
- 12:12operating procedures as a business is really, really
- 12:16important. And I think as new people come
- 12:19into that business, the way they'll succeed is by business
- 12:23having great documentation. So if that doesn't exist, we're
- 12:27often seeing in brands that actually somebody comes in from,
- 12:32let's say they've come in from even from an enterprise level
- 12:36brand and they've come into a brand that's established but
- 12:39smaller than enterprise. One of the first things we're
- 12:42seeing them do it do is ask, OK, where is this, this and this
- 12:45documented? Quite often it's missing
- 12:47entirely, which you're, which you're probably familiar with
- 12:50and you know, the first six months of their role, we'll just
- 12:53be documenting the basics, which is, you know, it's, it's one of
- 12:58the benefits of having a fresh face and a face fresh mind in
- 13:02the business. Definitely.
- 13:03And that helps. Then having that in place helps
- 13:06onboarding of new people thereafter, they've actually got
- 13:09something they can reference as as the kind of baseline of how
- 13:12we do things. I think linked to that is
- 13:17spending human time and being curious.
- 13:21I think the people that I think the teams that we succeed, when
- 13:25more and more people are joining A-Team quickly is where there's
- 13:27really curious minds in each one of those new seats in, you know,
- 13:34in our world, in the world of retail, things move and change
- 13:37so quickly that if you're not curious and you just expect
- 13:41stuff to come to you, you're always going to be one step
- 13:44behind. So I think when when we see new
- 13:47team members join the brands that we work with, the ones that
- 13:51really succeed are the ones that are curious.
- 13:53They're reaching out to us. They want to spend time with us
- 13:57working out how the integrations work.
- 13:59Why did we do this project? What's out of new on maybe what
- 14:02can be improved from a tech or arts perspective in the
- 14:05business? And then I would also just add
- 14:09that that recognition from an established brand or as a brand
- 14:13starting to become established is that I guess what's got them
- 14:17there in the past isn't maybe going to be the same to get them
- 14:22where they want to go in the future.
- 14:24So they may not have had at this point lots and lots of rigour
- 14:28when they change something, they may not be kind of testing
- 14:31obsessed before they set a new process or technology live.
- 14:36They may not have any Slas for certain things.
- 14:38And now they need to because otherwise processes fall over
- 14:41and customers get annoyed and planning may have been a bit
- 14:47haphazard or last minute, let's say up until this point.
- 14:51And actually, you know, when you're an established brand, you
- 14:54actually need to get into a planning cycle.
- 14:57So although let's say we've worked on the USVPL migration
- 15:01recently, that kind of really start to finish was 4 weeks.
- 15:05It was a very, very fast for a £80 million brand.
- 15:10Actually the planning to get that going, the vendor
- 15:12selection, the commercial agreements, the putting the
- 15:15requirements in front of that three PL. happened months,
- 15:19months and months before that. Yeah, I'm glad you teased out
- 15:23the the point of ad documentation because I think
- 15:25this is something where and it's not all large businesses are
- 15:28good at least, but some especially legacy ones seems to
- 15:31be enterprising to be very, very good at having lots of lots of
- 15:34documents. They might not be necessarily
- 15:36updated frequently enough, but I think this is where SME market
- 15:39can learn massively, especially in DTC brands that are like
- 15:42really scaling quickly is the the bit that that I see really
- 15:46poorly documented business process.
- 15:48And there I mean there's space, there are hundreds if not
- 15:51thousands of processors and businesses, but it's even down
- 15:53to the minutiae. Customer notifications is a
- 15:55great one of of what triggers a notification?
- 15:58What system is sending it? What template is that?
- 16:02You know, do you have all the right notifications set up?
- 16:05Do you have all the right systemic flows set up to receive
- 16:09data points to trigger it in the right place?
- 16:12Do you have to do customisation because you don't have an event
- 16:14that's going to that's recognise in one system to trigger the
- 16:17notification you need to send out based on an update somewhere
- 16:20else. And and then you get an amazing
- 16:22amount of technical solution work that's done, but then it's
- 16:25not documented and then you've got nothing to go back to to
- 16:29say, right, OK, yeah, let's review this in 12 months.
- 16:31Are we missing something? Is this right?
- 16:33Do we need to make a change? And it's something that is
- 16:36underestimated in projects. And because I think people see
- 16:39it as a hassle and a cost. How out of interest, I when you
- 16:45get involved in these projects, to what degree of quality do you
- 16:48see process flow documentation? And is it an area that you try
- 16:53and get them to focus on more as in the client teams?
- 16:57Yeah. Well actually I was just about
- 16:58to ask you the same question of how you see, have you seen it
- 17:02done well, so we can come come on to that.
- 17:05So it varies massively. It's the minority and it's still
- 17:11a surprise and a delight when we start working with the brand.
- 17:15And you know in that even in that pre sales perspective they
- 17:19are like, OK, here's how we, here's a document on how we do
- 17:21it today and here's where we think we want to get to.
- 17:24I would say that's probably one in 20 brands we speak to have
- 17:29something like that. And when it comes along, it's
- 17:31fantastic, right, because it it saves, it moves things along
- 17:36quicker, but it also makes sure that right from the off like our
- 17:40objectives are aligned with what the business wants out out of of
- 17:44what we're doing. If that doesn't exist, then we
- 17:50will help brands with that to an extent.
- 17:53So we will help them map out how data is flowing between systems
- 17:58today and how it should be. We will tease out edge cases and
- 18:03the things that make that brand unique.
- 18:06We will tease out, you know, what tripped them over last
- 18:09Black Friday and work out ways to avoid that this year.
- 18:14So we will do that in our kind of what we call the solution
- 18:17design process, which is what we do before we go and build any
- 18:20integration at all. But also there comes a, there
- 18:25comes a ceiling right where us as a as an eye pass provider, we
- 18:29kind of have a been a bit of a blurred line of where we start
- 18:32to become kind of consultancy and advisory.
- 18:36And you probably start to have a an element of us having a little
- 18:41bit of a conflict of interest because I think what makes us do
- 18:46a good job is, is kind of that pressure and input from the
- 18:49customer. If we also become that, then
- 18:53sometimes we're kind of marking, marking our own homework a
- 18:56little bit, if that makes sense. So at that point, I think we're
- 18:59getting better at having a trigger point to going out to
- 19:03other people. So it might be, you know, a
- 19:07Shopify agency that's experts in how this part of Shopify works
- 19:11or a tech or OPS agency, you know, the the likes of commerce
- 19:17thinking, for example, or a logistics agency with, you know,
- 19:20the likes of the team at Chris Ormond and, and the for now
- 19:23team, for example. So at some point, yeah, we, I
- 19:29think we're getting much better at saying actually here's where
- 19:31we, here's probably where we need to draw the line.
- 19:34We could help and we could help a brand probably through some of
- 19:38the decision making. But actually here's experts who
- 19:41who I think will hold them accountable probably a little
- 19:43bit better than than we would. Yeah.
- 19:46What about you? I'm interested to hear your
- 19:49point of view on that as well. Yeah, I'm not sure what my
- 19:51Embrace show is of who has it locked down versus those who
- 19:55don't. I, I, I don't find many have
- 19:58really good consistent documentation.
- 20:00I think that's the starting point.
- 20:02And it's not through because people don't care, it's because
- 20:06people get distracted. So I find the document project
- 20:09documentation is normally good, and somebody does a big project,
- 20:12they'll have it documented, the scope, the requirements, the
- 20:14solution. But what doesn't happen is the
- 20:18evolution of documentation as businesses evolve and change.
- 20:21So you then get to the next project cycle and you are you've
- 20:24just got processed debt and tech solution debt everywhere because
- 20:27it's it's not In Sync. And then you're almost like
- 20:30starting from scratch again because you don't know where
- 20:33your starting point is without sitting down and going through
- 20:35it. So I think that's that's what I
- 20:37find in terms of when it's done well, it's done well when
- 20:41somebody's willing to pay for a resource in a project to address
- 20:44this. And that needs someone with ABA
- 20:46mindset, a business analyst, because traditional PMS cannot
- 20:52add their weight in gold to projects by coordinating,
- 20:54distilling, adding value and advice.
- 20:57But they often don't have the, the BAE skill set of being able
- 21:00to, you know, scrutinize an in depth process and map it and
- 21:04document it because visualizing process flows is actually quite
- 21:08challenging. I know there are tools out there
- 21:10that help you do. I'm definitely not good at it.
- 21:13I, what I do though, is I, you know, I guess I provide an
- 21:16interim thing. So I will help clients, I will
- 21:19map. So I've mapped out like
- 21:20processes for creation and uploading the products and it's
- 21:24very basic. I'm not, I'm not an advanced
- 21:26flow builder in the way that a true BA would be to make it a
- 21:29really seamless process map. But I'll do something like
- 21:32Google Slides and I'll just go right here you go.
- 21:35This is a process where we agree these are the principles.
- 21:38So I guess I come in it from a if you've got nothing, you don't
- 21:40have that resource, then it's least to get the principles
- 21:43sound and have some level of visualisation.
- 21:46Because when you're in a functional workshop and you're
- 21:50trying to sign off on what you need, I just find without any
- 21:54visual, it's really difficult for a lot of people to
- 21:56conceptualise because I say that sounds good.
- 21:59But actually they're not thinking about, they're not
- 22:01thinking about it in terms of how that flow plays out.
- 22:04They're just thinking of that sounds functioning OK when
- 22:07you've got it drawn out again, right?
- 22:08And we're now here and this is what's happening and this is the
- 22:10customer impact and this is what you've got to do in a system.
- 22:13And this is now going to impact this other third party over here
- 22:16for that campaign. Then they stop and go, oh, oh
- 22:19man, that's not how we need it to work.
- 22:21So yeah, I guess that's probably my rambling answer.
- 22:25Yeah, yeah, no, that, that makes sense.
- 22:26And I think that's what it comes down to a lot of the time,
- 22:30right, is that if at least you in your project is about
- 22:33decision making and can you align everyone to a single
- 22:37decision. And yeah, something spoken or
- 22:40written is one thing, but visualizing it, yeah,
- 22:43definitely, definitely really powerful.
- 22:45Yeah, well, I'm just going through a process with a client
- 22:46of mine at the moment and doing a re platforming and helping
- 22:49them and and it's about one one thing's come up is what's the
- 22:53final set of notifications? Because we're trying to simplify
- 22:56and actually what we're doing is I'm going to put a little map
- 22:58together on Monday, which is here's all the ones that I've
- 23:00understood from all the workshops.
- 23:02Here's what I think's driving systemically.
- 23:04This is triggers, this is the number of templates we need and
- 23:08this is a customer touch points. What are we missing?
- 23:10Because it's so much easier than people trying to relate to six
- 23:14workshops set of notes and going have we got it all covered.
- 23:16So well, let's move on to we've talked about like larger brands
- 23:20or established brands. Let's talk about fast growth
- 23:22because a lot of our audience on this podcast is more in that
- 23:27DTCSME space, several million up to, you know, maybe 30 to 50
- 23:33million. And some of them this last year
- 23:36has been all about international expansion and we will know what
- 23:39fun that's been with the US and tariffs.
- 23:41For others, it's about expansion into B to B and consolidating B
- 23:45to B&B to C on the same platform.
- 23:47And then looking at what the impact is to the back office
- 23:50flows and the fulfilment and the challenges and the logistics
- 23:53around that. So there's lots of different
- 23:56dynamics that then suddenly take somebody out of their core
- 23:59comfort zone to, oh, we've got bigger problems to solve.
- 24:01How do we do this? I'd love to hear from you when
- 24:04you're working with these Fast Coast brands.
- 24:06They might have lots of manual processes, some some
- 24:09alterations. What are the key challenges you
- 24:11see and what is your advice? How do you help them try and
- 24:14future pre? Yeah, great.
- 24:18Great question. So I think one of the key things
- 24:23versus the larger brands where stuff is maybe documented or
- 24:28visible somewhere like what we were just talking about in
- 24:32smaller brands, you have people that have maybe been there since
- 24:36the beginning. They are the experts on how a
- 24:40certain system or process or supplier relationship or
- 24:44whatever it is works, which is great.
- 24:49You know, they're the better kind of powerhouses that have
- 24:51grown these brands, but stuff is in those people's heads.
- 24:55So you have this single person risk where if you need to
- 24:59communicate something to a new team member or a new supplier or
- 25:04you're looking at, OK, this is broken, how do we then fix it?
- 25:08You've got to extricate that from, from, from people's heads.
- 25:12And those people are busy, right?
- 25:13They're flat out probably doing 5 rolls.
- 25:16So I think that's, that's one of the, one of the tough things is
- 25:20that versus a bigger business where there are more people who
- 25:23kind of have a have an understanding of the same thing
- 25:27and a smaller business, it's that kind of single person rest
- 25:29stuff is in, in people's heads. A massive, massive 1 is data
- 25:35tends to be messier in the smaller, fast growing brands.
- 25:40So product data might exist in five different places completely
- 25:46differently and probably 20 spreadsheets.
- 25:50So as soon as you move into a world where you want to
- 25:52automate, let's save product data between systems, suddenly
- 25:56things don't match and automation is impossible.
- 25:59So actually what starts off as an automation project actually
- 26:03shifts into a product data project.
- 26:06Must say that's a fast growth brands, you know, we still, we
- 26:09actually see the same thing at brands that are doing hundreds
- 26:12of million as well. So, you know, as soon as data
- 26:15sets are different, it's tough. But typically, typically that
- 26:21tends to be more of a problem at smaller brands, I would say,
- 26:25where stuff is moved from a non joined up world to a wants to
- 26:30move to a joined up world. And I guess on that point is
- 26:36that systems, processes, people even don't tend to be as joined
- 26:40up in in smaller brands. So that that means that there's
- 26:46always this element of manual process, whether you're moving
- 26:50data or whatever it is, that always will take up a chunk of
- 26:55time until you've automated it. So actually scaling is always
- 26:58then a little bit linear because you as you scale, you need more
- 27:03hours in the day or more people in the team to move data.
- 27:08So that's one thing I would say that we're also seeing small
- 27:15projects, even small projects when you Add all that up would
- 27:18seem like a bit of a mountain to climb to smaller brands.
- 27:23And you can get into this kind of decision paralysis vicious
- 27:28cycle where actually every project seems too big.
- 27:31So we'll just keep going how we're going.
- 27:33We know it's kind of broken, but actually versus committing 2
- 27:38months to this when we've got, you know, two months that we
- 27:43could dedicate to something else become is a tricky decision.
- 27:46And I think that prioritization is, is really important.
- 27:50At some point, somebody's just got to make the decision and
- 27:52just say, look, guys, we're going to if we don't fix this,
- 27:55we're going to hit ceiling. So yeah, I would, I would say
- 28:00all of those things sounds a bit doom and gloom, but all of those
- 28:03things added together I would say are the kind of key
- 28:05challenges we see in the in that kind of 5 to 15, five to 20
- 28:09million range. Yeah, that that completely
- 28:12resonates for me. Question for you actually on
- 28:14this, because in those, those businesses you typically you do
- 28:18not have experienced project management resource, right.
- 28:21PMO stuff doesn't exist. That's larger businesses.
- 28:25We will have like some, some, you know, consistent resource
- 28:28and therefore people are running projects, but they're not
- 28:33potentially structured project managers who have full PMO
- 28:36expertise running races, risk chart as governance.
- 28:40When you get into this business now going to the next step and
- 28:42it's got a transformation and that's got lots of dependencies
- 28:46and systems decisions, etcetera. How do you find that many of
- 28:52them are are then at the point where they go, yes, OK, we're
- 28:55willing to have APM. Or do you find yourselves having
- 28:59to go in and try and like educate people about perhaps?
- 29:02No, you need to bring APM to run this?
- 29:04For you much more the the latter.
- 29:10So I would say, you know, even even at larger brands the the
- 29:14kind of PM role is is rare. And I would see normally what
- 29:22happens what we see is that it becomes somebody in the team's
- 29:25role to kind of I'm going to manage this project.
- 29:28They're not project managers. They are fantastic head of
- 29:32operations. They are fast, fantastic econ
- 29:34managers. Sometimes it can you know, even
- 29:38be Acfos become the project manager for a, for a project and
- 29:43you know, there's, it doesn't quite add up.
- 29:46So more often than not that is the case.
- 29:50We are seeing though AI would say a small but growing number
- 29:55of independent project managers in the brands that we work with.
- 29:59So we work with some some great people.
- 30:02So recently worked on a project at Ancient and Brave, the
- 30:07supplements brand massively fast growing.
- 30:12I've put in new systems, expanded to new markets.
- 30:15And we worked with Emma Forward, who I think you know, and she,
- 30:20she was the project manager slash business analysts slash a
- 30:26couple of other roles in, in the work we did with them.
- 30:29But yeah, a really important go between, between us, the other
- 30:33vendors in the mix and then the ancient and brave team
- 30:36themselves. And I think without her, they
- 30:38that would have been really, really challenging.
- 30:41And yeah, we're seeing a couple of other people now increasingly
- 30:44play that role. And it's been great for us
- 30:47because we now have this small but growing pool of people that
- 30:50we can, we can see a project needs it and we can say to a
- 30:55brand. Look, guys, we've done this now
- 30:5810s hundreds of times. The role missing here is this,
- 31:01the here are the roles and responsibilities.
- 31:04Can you tell me somebody in the business has this against their
- 31:07job description for the next 6 months?
- 31:10If they don't, there's a gap and we know from experience this is
- 31:14going to fall over. I think, yeah, being able to do
- 31:18that now through our past experience, but also then say we
- 31:22can recommend these fantastic people who can help fill that
- 31:25gap is has been really strong. Yeah, it's it's such an
- 31:28important discipline is to, is you start with your racey.
- 31:31That's the critical that you need your, your project roles
- 31:34and responsibilities and you map people to them.
- 31:36And if you don't have the right skill or you don't have somebody
- 31:39who can fill those roles, it's a risk that then increases the
- 31:43risk profile. And it's, it's amazing actually
- 31:47how you can change the dynamic because when I've had this
- 31:50conversation with people before and I think in my early days, I
- 31:52probably didn't couch it the right way.
- 31:54And it's like you need a project manager, it's going to cost X
- 31:57people turn off, you turn around and go, here's your product
- 31:59racy, here's the responsibilities.
- 32:01These are the four roles that you do not have covered.
- 32:03And this is the risk of the project.
- 32:04And this is a potential risk to you commercially if you don't
- 32:07have an adequate cover for it. And all of a sudden you flip
- 32:09that conversation. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 32:13And I think that needs to be somebody independent or they
- 32:18need to be brand side. You know, we, we will manage a
- 32:22project, an ERP provider will manage a project, a Shopify
- 32:25agency will manage a project. But the end of the day, we
- 32:29can't, one of those partners can't manage a hot an entire
- 32:34migration, you know, econ migration or ERP implementation.
- 32:40Because you know, kind of what I said earlier, you kind of
- 32:42marking your own homework at the end of the day, somebody needs
- 32:45to be responsible who's independent of the the third
- 32:48parties in the mix, right? Yeah, I think that's, I think
- 32:51that's Sound of Ice. And also, I think that's that
- 32:54actually helps like critical strategic partners like
- 32:58yourselves be more effective because you don't then you're
- 33:01focusing on delivery and collaboration and you know that
- 33:06there's a trusted person who's going to ensure that you get the
- 33:09inputs you need to deliver and that if there's any change, it's
- 33:12managed effectively so that you're not constantly having to
- 33:15handhold a client on top of delivery.
- 33:17Because I don't think that's a fair expectation on a third
- 33:20party either. I think it just blurs the
- 33:22boundaries too much. Yeah, Yeah, absolutely.
- 33:25And the other thing I would add is what we're talking about here
- 33:29is all kind of project and free go live.
- 33:32I think it's also really important to consider what
- 33:34happens post go live. Let's so let's say yeah and
- 33:38ipass is going in, going into a brand, high cohesion is going
- 33:42into a brand or an ERP is going into the brand for the first
- 33:45time. The project is one thing, but
- 33:47who is going to run, manage, monitor, fix, tweak, improve
- 33:52those systems once they've gone live as well?
- 33:56Again, you know, will it be something off the side of
- 33:58somebody's desk maybe for smaller systems that if you're
- 34:03putting in an ERP for the first time or you are, you know,
- 34:10putting in a WMS for the first time where maybe previously
- 34:14you've been using the back of Shopify or or something else,
- 34:19you need to have somebody who's who knows how to use that system
- 34:24effectively. So I think we're also seeing
- 34:26like the kind of systems admin, systems manager role become
- 34:30really important in businesses as they kind of learn more and
- 34:36more on tech to do these things. Yeah, let's talk about
- 34:40transformation processes as well, because typically when a
- 34:46brand is growing, it's it's involves multiple partners.
- 34:50It could, they could have, they could have an ERP partner on top
- 34:54of an integration partner like yourselves.
- 34:57They could have a separate person like handling other parts
- 35:01of techs that they could have a third party consultant in on
- 35:04that. Who knows how many different
- 35:07parties there might be from tech and processing consultancy?
- 35:11Imagine that it's a challenge and you've obviously been
- 35:13working with lots of different businesses across different
- 35:15sizes on different levels of projects a lot to know how what
- 35:19is the advice and what have you learnt about how do you how do
- 35:22you manage these processes across multiple partners to make
- 35:25sure that you get, you know, good cohesion?
- 35:30Yeah. It's interesting because that
- 35:34starts rearing its head in the sales process.
- 35:38Like we go in, let's say we have a two page MSA, we have a state,
- 35:44a short statement of work. Somebody like a NetSuite goes
- 35:47in, they've got 80 page T's and C's.
- 35:50The statement of work is another 100 pages, so on and so on.
- 35:55So that actually, you know, immediately you've got this
- 35:58mismatch between how different partners and providers, two
- 36:02things simply, you know, even at that very early stage.
- 36:05So there's a couple of things that I think have really helped
- 36:08us. 1 is really, really early alignment on what's the overall
- 36:15business outcome here? Why the hell are we doing this
- 36:18thing in the 1st place? And what's that single, what's
- 36:21that single point we're aiming towards on how we define whether
- 36:25this has all been a success or not and keep revisiting that all
- 36:30the time. Just say actually, you know, if
- 36:33we're going off on this tangent or somebody's got this really
- 36:35rigorous and slightly tiring process, is this actually
- 36:40feeding into getting us, getting us as a collective where we want
- 36:43to go? So I think that constant
- 36:45alignment of why why you're here is important.
- 36:50I think being transparent early on and everyone actually in
- 36:55what's been really powerful for us is in pre sales and ERP
- 36:58projects, for example, we now kind of mandate that we're
- 37:01spending a whole day aligning with the brand and with the
- 37:06other partners in a room together on what does that
- 37:10process look like, What does our project management look like,
- 37:12what does our governance look like.
- 37:14And saying actually you will get this from us, you won't get this
- 37:18from us, you will get this from these guys, you won't get this
- 37:21from these guys. And just everyone being aware
- 37:24upfront before we start and he thinks there's no surprises.
- 37:28So I think that like spending time, human time in person,
- 37:31talking through, that's important.
- 37:34But fundamentally one of the things I'm proud of, I think
- 37:37most is that we are normally the most flexible in the room.
- 37:42So if we need to rise up or suppress something down or
- 37:46change something or meet somebody else's way of working,
- 37:50then we will be flexible. That's I think one of the things
- 37:54that makes our projects happen and succeed rather than kind of
- 37:59hitting a wall and failing time and time again is that at some
- 38:03point we'll say, look, we can see that somebody needs to be
- 38:06flexible here. And we, we will take that on.
- 38:09And I think having somebody in the mix, if it's, you know,
- 38:14having somebody in the mix that can be the most flexible in the
- 38:16room is important as well. They they tend to be the partner
- 38:19or the OR the team that becomes a glue and hold holds everything
- 38:23together. Yeah, and it's, I guess it's,
- 38:27it's quite nice given the product positioning.
- 38:29That's essentially what you're doing technically.
- 38:31So yeah, it makes a lot of sense.
- 38:33One of the things that that that always comes up is that people
- 38:38don't know what they don't know. And I get this conversation a
- 38:41lot where I'm with a client and I do a lot of, I guess I do, I
- 38:44do. I've done some projects similar
- 38:46to to Emma, who's a brilliant consultant as well.
- 38:48So anyone listening, she's well worth having on your books to,
- 38:51to reach out to. And yeah, a lot of the, the
- 38:55questions we all get as independent consultants are OK,
- 38:58What, what, what are the things we need to think about?
- 39:00What don't we know, which is always a hard one to, to know
- 39:03how you concisely do it. So let's talk about how you
- 39:06help, what you've learned and how you help customers plan
- 39:09around like potential issues, like what are the common issues
- 39:12that you see in these, in the types of projects you work on?
- 39:16And what can client teams do to better prepare?
- 39:21Yeah. So common, common issue.
- 39:24So let's say integrations are up and running between systems.
- 39:27They're kind of day-to-day successful.
- 39:31What comes along and breaks them?
- 39:34Many things we could be here all day talking about that, but I
- 39:37think if we were to group them, so I think 11 is business
- 39:42events. So what do I mean by that peak?
- 39:45So Black Friday or a for a kind of more of a hype based brand, a
- 39:50new drop or AVIP sale or whatever it is.
- 39:56But where you get these kind of peak events and peak volumes and
- 40:01actually what's worked 364 days of the year suddenly breaks when
- 40:06you've got 100 times the volume going through it.
- 40:09I mean, we work, we work with some brands that maybe do let's
- 40:13say 1000 orders a day and then at peak moments they might do
- 40:19two 300,000 and you get this. Massive delta between what's
- 40:23normal and then what's kind of this more not anomalous because
- 40:26they are planned events, but those kind of peak events.
- 40:30So things can break at peak and building that robustly into
- 40:36integrations is hard. So you kind of take two
- 40:39approaches. You either build for that kind
- 40:42of one off event and the rest of the year is just kind of
- 40:48massively over specked as it were or you spend time more
- 40:53closely with the brands. And this is I think what we're
- 40:55doing more and more of. So Rd. mapping and working out
- 40:59actually what does a marketing calendar look like?
- 41:02But also Rd. mapping around what does your business change look
- 41:05like? Are you planning a new system?
- 41:07Are you thinking of changing returns providers?
- 41:10Are you going to a new geography or channel And us understanding
- 41:14that in advance means that we can actually proactively suggest
- 41:19how the integrations should change and adapt to to meet how
- 41:23the business is changing and adapting.
- 41:25So I think that kind of yeah, Rd. mapping and understanding
- 41:28things in advance around Peak this year, we've from each of
- 41:33our brands got pretty detailed forecasts of what they're
- 41:36expecting through peak and when. So again that we've taken that
- 41:40and gone and checked every integration set up and said
- 41:43actually is what's set up for the brand today going to meet
- 41:47this kind of forecast calendar that we've got and obviously
- 41:50have some buffer in it as well. I think also one of the things
- 41:56called very common problems is that there can be changes in one
- 42:00part of the system that brands don't always think through end
- 42:04to end. So classic example came up
- 42:08actually earlier this week. We work with a really fast
- 42:11growing jewellery provider and they do personalization on their
- 42:16jewelry and they wanted to just change how that personalization
- 42:21was kind of captured on the front end.
- 42:23But you can imagine personalization for a piece of
- 42:25jewelry needs a very exact like format to be then sent to the
- 42:29warehouse when they engrave it on this tiny piece of jewelry,
- 42:33that change on the front end. And then suddenly the warehouse
- 42:36was just getting either no personalization or the incorrect
- 42:39personalization on their orders. Customers started flagging that,
- 42:46you know, either my necklace has not come through engraved or
- 42:50that it's missing. And you know, when we spoke to
- 42:54the brand, they, you know, they said, Oh yeah, we didn't even
- 42:57think about how that would impact anything downstream.
- 43:01It just felt like an innocent enough front end change.
- 43:03I think those small changes not thought through when everything
- 43:08is integrated and automated can have that end to end impact.
- 43:13And then lastly, I would probably say the other bucket is
- 43:17the kind of time to value can differ massively across
- 43:22different types of let's say softwares or providers.
- 43:25So order editing app at the moment, those guys can onboard a
- 43:31brand super quickly. Fantastic team, great app.
- 43:35That can happen very quickly, but sometimes it might be that a
- 43:42a mirrors change needs to happen in the OMS or in the three PL.
- 43:46or the ERP and order editing might be able to make the change
- 43:50in 5 minutes. But with one of those providers,
- 43:54you need to raise a ticket, somebody that needs to resource
- 43:56that ticket, come back and clarify what's on that ticket,
- 43:59schedule the change in the test environment, then deploy in
- 44:03production and that time to value between, you know, one app
- 44:08is selling, we can make this happen in 5 minutes.
- 44:10Absolutely they can. But actually sometimes how that
- 44:13then has a knock on effect in other systems can be much, much
- 44:17slower. So I think for brands need to be
- 44:20realistic about changes and you know, you can't plan everything
- 44:25in advance, but just think about actually as you grow to a bigger
- 44:29brand, you've got a bigger tech stack, you've got more processes
- 44:32that things will just take take longer.
- 44:36Yeah. I, I think that's such an
- 44:38important one to pull out the knock on implications of of
- 44:40changes. And I, I see this on many
- 44:44occasions in ecom where somebody wants to make a decision, but
- 44:49that decision then has an say, for example, they want to change
- 44:52something function in the front end, but that then impacts
- 44:55product data model, for example. And that product data model
- 44:58needs to be reworked. Therefore, you've got to think
- 45:00about, does that rework into the product data model have an
- 45:03impact on other systems that dependent on the data ID and
- 45:07where's that data mastered? And does that therefore need to
- 45:10be changed at that source? And, and it's just, I think
- 45:12sometimes people underestimate, don't they that and it's yeah,
- 45:15it's not criticism. It's just if you haven't gone
- 45:17through that process, you don't know that this could happen.
- 45:19Is a is, is the, is the iceberg thing, the surface is grey, but
- 45:25what's underneath that's going to cause you massive problems?
- 45:27And and then coming back to that point, you said about, you know,
- 45:30the roles of an in bank. So like Emma in a project,
- 45:32having somebody where you, you somebody can take the time to
- 45:35stop and go, right. Let me look at what the impact
- 45:38is and come back and say, like, OK, do we need to have involved
- 45:42other third parties in this conversation or can we just go
- 45:44ahead and execute that? I think that's where having that
- 45:47structured like project, project management, whatever you want to
- 45:50call it, resource and skill is massively valuable.
- 45:54Yeah, yeah, 100%. Let's then let's flip to talk
- 45:58about your your technology, your platform.
- 46:00You know, Yeah, you're, you're an ipaas provider.
- 46:03You work with lots of different brands.
- 46:04You're constantly evolving your, your, your, your proposition.
- 46:07I'd love to hear where's high cohesion headed strategically
- 46:10and then I guess from a a functionality, a feature wise
- 46:13what you what are you concentrating on?
- 46:15Because I know you've been building out strategic
- 46:17partnerships and you've you've allowed the loop partnership
- 46:19relatively recently. So yeah, just don't talk.
- 46:22Talk over on three right where you're headed.
- 46:26Yeah, the big question. So I think, let me start with
- 46:31partnerships. So why are partnerships
- 46:34important to us? Well, probably consistent
- 46:37message with every partnership, but we do not have a like a
- 46:42strong outbound growth strategy in place at the moment.
- 46:48A lot of our growth is partnership oriented.
- 46:51So we put a lot of time and effort into partnerships and
- 46:56understanding how can we solve the pain for our partners, what
- 47:01can we take away from them to enable them to do their job
- 47:05better and make them look better in the eyes of the customer,
- 47:09frankly and also enable them the quicker kind of time to value or
- 47:14or go to market as well. So yeah, working with the likes
- 47:19of Loop, we're also doing more and more work with SWAT, another
- 47:24returns provider. We have a growing number of
- 47:30partnerships with a number of consultancies, agencies, other
- 47:33software providers where they want to focus on what makes
- 47:38their software great. They don't want to focus on
- 47:41integrating that software into every ERP or WMS or ECOM
- 47:45platform. So we're kind of moving more and
- 47:49more into what helping those partners solve integration
- 47:53challenges. So we will understand the nuts
- 47:57and bolts of their system and help them integrate quickly into
- 48:03the kind of core systems that or most common systems that their
- 48:07that their customers have. So we're doing more and more of
- 48:10that with partners. If it's the logistics partner,
- 48:14we're working out OK, how can we help you on board a brand
- 48:18quicker that's like really deep rooted into their existing WMS
- 48:22or three PL. and they want to now expand into a new market
- 48:25quickly. So we're basically saying new 3
- 48:29PL. you don't need to really worry about how the brand does
- 48:32tech and integrations brand side.
- 48:35We'll just focus on how we can make that work with you as the
- 48:38as the new 3 PL. for example. So partnerships really important
- 48:43strategically also we're thinking about new channels and
- 48:47new markets. So I think we've predominantly
- 48:51worked with Shopify brands today.
- 48:53We see that centre Stockholm based ecom platform matches our
- 49:02ICP really, really well and we are spending an increasing
- 49:07amount of time with them working out again how can we help solve
- 49:12these integrations, especially at the more kind of complex end
- 49:14of things, new markets. So most of Avran still today are
- 49:19UK based brands. We have an increasing number in
- 49:22the US, Australia and New Zealand and we see those as two
- 49:26growing markets and also Northern Europe as well.
- 49:31And then I would say lastly, we want to shrink our time to value
- 49:37for customers. So our projects are they take on
- 49:43the complex stuff that we see brands wanting to be more
- 49:48reactive than kind of what we can offer today.
- 49:52So we're thinking really hard and making changes on how can we
- 49:55shrink time to value for customers that will want to
- 49:57react to tariff changes or this suddenly sudden opportunity in a
- 50:02new channel. They want to do that kind of in
- 50:05hours or days rather than weeks or months.
- 50:07So I think shrinking that time to value is is a big focus for
- 50:10for the coming year as well. Yeah, I, I, I just think that's
- 50:13such a broad broader trend in the market generally is people
- 50:17under lots of pressures. It's it's still tough trading
- 50:20conditions and there's so much volatility like the macro level,
- 50:23isn't there like crazy people around the world?
- 50:27So. I think that's time to value is
- 50:30I'd, I'd see so much, so many conversations now shifting a bit
- 50:34more away from cost. Make cost is still important
- 50:36because you have budgets and you can't just suddenly like add
- 50:39another 50 grand to your cost line.
- 50:42But yeah, that how quickly can you get value and what is the
- 50:45value to find out? Because the value could be to
- 50:46find out improving efficiency in the business so that it, it
- 50:50takes you half an hour to do a task rather than an hour and
- 50:53that's your value and you can get there in the next three
- 50:56months. So yeah, I that results a lot of
- 50:58me and not the conversations I'm having.
- 51:00And, and also, are you trying how I try and like talk people
- 51:04through, especially at the senior leisure team level about
- 51:07the benefit of new systems, you know, not trying to evangelize
- 51:11them and say they're perfect because they're not.
- 51:14But why, what, what can you do? And what's the business value?
- 51:17Yeah, yeah, exactly, exactly. I could carry on asking you
- 51:23questions for for hours because I'm just one of those annoying
- 51:26consultants, Aaron, but I know you have a very busy day ahead
- 51:29of you as well. So I'll stop there.
- 51:31But if if somebody, somebody wants to discuss a potential
- 51:34project and wants to find out a bit more, I guess technically,
- 51:36operationally, how I ICO sits within the wider systems
- 51:40architecture, how do they reach out?
- 51:43How do they get more? Info so obviously go on to our
- 51:48website, hikehusen.com. Feel free to reach out to me on
- 51:53LinkedIn or or by e-mail. We love talking to people.
- 51:57So, you know, just a chat. Maybe you've got a problem that
- 52:00you're looking to solve and it might not be directly
- 52:03integration related, but we've, we've seen a lot of problems
- 52:08across a lot of a lot of brands. So if we don't know the answer,
- 52:11we can probably point you in the direction of somebody who will.
- 52:16But yeah, that's, that's what I'd recommend definitely is it's
- 52:19just having a chat with us and we're very open to, you know,
- 52:23putting you in touch with, with other customers of ours as well
- 52:27who may have gone through similar kind of challenges and,
- 52:31and to maybe talk through how we've helped them.
- 52:33But yeah, that's what I say is just we're we're absolutely here
- 52:37to chat really kind of hot on that kind of human time.
- 52:40So reach out. Jason and Aaron's contact
- 52:44details are on the landing page for podcasts on our website and
- 52:47inside commerce dot FM so you can find his LinkedIn profile
- 52:50there. Aaron always love chatting to
- 52:52you or really enjoying watching high occasions story and success
- 52:58and the brands you're working with.
- 52:59So that thanks, thanks for joining today.
- 53:01Thanks for making the time James, and have a good rest of
- 53:04the day. Cheers.
- 53:05Yeah, and thanks to everyone for listening.
- 53:06Take care everyone. Until next week, you're
- 53:11listening to the Insidecommerce podcast.
- 53:12Hosted by experienced consultants James Gert and Paul
- 53:15Rogers. Insidecommerce is your fast
- 53:17track to digital knowledge feature in interviews with
- 53:20leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 53:23C-Suite key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 53:25strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 53:28Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 53:31advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 53:33strategy and tech. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 53:37out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 53:39project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 53:41episode.