Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️111 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 12 Oct. Ecology Final day Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Today was a bit out of the ordinary day for me at the public inquiry into Dalradians proposed gold mine in The Sperrins. For a start, I wasn't there for the beginning. However, I had nothing to worry about in this respect, as I knew Fedalma would be taking notes until I arrived shortly after
- 1:1511, and she is nothing if not thorough in this respect. I had settled myself in for what I expected would be another long afternoon of ecological evidence, planning conditions, environmental mitigation, and the increasingly complicated business of how deciding how much interference with nature
- 1:38might be considered acceptable, but by half past 12 it was all over, not the inquiry, unfortunately, just terrestrial ecology, which was a little surprising, because I felt there was still some important questions hanging in the air, small but not inconsequential matters such as questions about
- 2:03birds flying into electricity cables, about habitats that will have to be repeatedly cleared, about protective species whose futures depend upon conditions that are still being amended, and then there was the odd business of adding one small word to a planning condition by DFI? The word was future. There
- 2:29is a certain irony in its late arrival inserted into a planning condition to accommodate development that has already taken place without permission, while the ecological future of the very landscape these conditions are supposed to protect remains so uncertain, and finally there was the
- 2:51irrepressible Pat Houghey endeavouring to make a point about the conditions, and a commissioner who appeared increasingly determined that the discussion was finished. My morning began with the ecological impacts of the proposed electricity infrastructure, which will carry
- 3:09power to the mine. I missed the earlier exchanges, but when I arrived, the discussion was moving through the effects of construction, vegetation clearance, and the disturbance of wildlife along the power line routes. There had been suggestions that animals displaced during construction
- 3:31could move away temporarily and return once the work was completed. Niall McAllere challenged that comforting little scenario. His point was straightforward. If trees, bushes, and nesting habitats have been removed, the creatures that live there will not have anything to return to. You
- 3:52cannot cut down a hedgerow, scatter its inhabitants across the countryside, and expect them to return when the chainsaws have fallen silent. It is their home, their shelter, their feeding ground, and for some species, the place where generations have nested and raised their young. And then Dr.
- 4:14Mark Ruddock, our an independent ecology expert, brought the discussion to the birds that use the airspace around the proposed electricity lines. The applicants' consultants were keen to explain that bird surveys had been undertaken over six years, and that the scope of those surveys had been informed
- 4:37by discussions with NIEA. I wish I could say that the mention of NIEA's involvement filled me with confidence. Unfortunately, after everything we'd heard during this inquiry about the gaps in the environmental assessments and the reliance on future mitigation, I find myself wondering whether those
- 4:57discussions were about ensuring the highest. Standards of ecological protection, or simply agreeing on the minimum amount of evidence that would be considered acceptable. What do you think? Dr. Ruddock acknowledged that the breeding wader surveys had genuine strengths, but he identified a
- 5:19serious limitation in using those surveys to assess collision risk, breeding bird surveys can tell us which species are present, where they may be breeding, and something about their distribution. They cannot, without the appropriate flight activity observations, establish how frequently birds
- 5:40cross a proposed power line, the height at which they fly, or how their movements change during feeding, territorial displays, and migration. Dr. Rodock pointed out that the applicant's own preliminary ecological appraisal identified species susceptible to collision, including golden eagles, whooper
- 6:03swans, and peregrine.
- 6:06He explained that dedicated vantage point surveys were needed to provide the flight activity information necessary to quantify those risks. NIE's representatives disagreed that further surveys were required. They maintained that their existing survey programme and assessment had not identified a
- 6:29significant collision risk warranting that additional work, and thus where that disagreement remained. Six years of surveying sounds impressive, and it may well represent a great deal of field work, but the number of years spent gathering information tells us very little about whether the information
- 6:50collected answers the particular scientific question being asked. I was struck by the difference between recording the presence of birds in a landscape and understanding how those birds actually live and move through it. The birds, of course, have no knowledge of survey boundaries, planning
- 7:09applications, or the convenient little compartments into which human beings divide ecological assessments. They follow the landscape, the weather, and the ancient instincts that have carried their species through generations. We are the ones proposing to put wires across their flight paths. I would have
- 7:36thought that placed the responsibility for understanding the consequences firmly with us. Pat Haughty raised another issue concerning the long-term operation of the electricity infrastructure. According to the outline construction plan discussed at the inquiry, wooden electricity poles may need
- 7:56replacing every 30 to 40 years, and the decommissioning of the line is not currently envisaged. That is an interesting arrangement when you consider that the electricity infrastructure has been proposed to serve a mine with a finite operating life. The poles will remain long after the mining
- 8:18operation has ended. Pat drew attention to the ecological consequences of repeated maintenance and replacement. Vegetation will need to be managed to keep the lines clear. Access will be required for repairs. Pools will need to be removed and replaced with associated disturbances to the
- 8:42surrounding ground and habitats. Some of these activities are treated as routine maintenance. For a bird nesting in a hedgerow or a creature sheltering in the vegetation, the arrival of chainsaws and machinery is unlikely to feel particularly routine. A habitat disturbed during construction may begin to
- 9:04recover only to face further intervention when maintenance or replacement work becomes necessary. The effects will depend on the nature, timing, and location of those works, but Pat was drawing attention to the need to account for them over the lifetime of the infrastructure, it is yet
- 9:24another reminder that the environmental consequences of this development cannot be confined to the years when gold is being extracted. As the clock moved towards midday today, we had moved on to ecology planning and conditions. Commissioner McParland asked the DFI Department for Infrastructure
- 9:46how ecology condition ECOL 01 would operate in circumstances where part of the proposal involved existing unauthorised development. The room went quiet and finally. DFI asked for time to consider the matter. The commissioner seemed surprised that further instructions were needed on an issue that had been
- 10:08live throughout the inquiry. Nonetheless, we were all given a 15-minute break. When proceedings resumed, the department had found a solution. Insert the word future. The condition which had previously begun by prohibiting development activity until necessary plans had been approved would now read
- 10:31prohibiting future development activity until the necessary plans had been approved. The department proposed that the same adjustment could be made to other conditions, beginning with the words "no development. There's something almost breathtaking in the simplicity of that solution, and also
- 10:52something facile, even insulting, about the suggestion that such a complex and contentious planning issue could be addressed by inserting a single word, after years of planning controversy, extensive legal submissions, and weeks of inquiry proceedings, the department was proposing to deal
- 11:11with the difficulty in the wording of the condition by adding six letters: f u t u r e future. I am not sure if the commissioner was gobsmacked, or had just given up on DFI at this point, or maybe even struck dumb, but that's how it looked to us observers to move on. She simply emphasised that the
- 11:34discussion of conditions was taking place without prejudice to the wider issues she would have to determine. Predictably enough, the proposed amendment prompted strong objections. Pat Houghey argued that the position had changed because of the applicant's earlier statements about restoring the existing
- 11:54development.
- 11:56He challenged the logic of imposing conditions on future works while the status and restoration of existing works remained unresolved, Niall McAller also objected, describing the insertion of future as a form of facilitation enabling the application to be processed. He pointed out that
- 12:17the issue of unauthorised development had been present for years and questioned why the department still needed additional time to address it. His concern was that the planning process should not be adopted to accommodate development undertaken without permission. The commissioner
- 12:36made clear that she understood the objections and would consider the wider argument separately. The planning conditions are, after all, supposed to provide enforceable safeguards governing what happens if permission is granted. Yet here we were discussing how their wording
- 12:54should be adjusted to account for developments that had already happened without planning permission. For those of us who spent years trying to protect The Sperrins through the planning system, it was a difficult conversation to listen to. People living in the area are expected to comply with
- 13:11planning rules. They are told that procedures must be followed, that permissions matter, and that developments simply cannot proceed because somebody wishes it to. Those expectations should carry equal weight when the development is a major industrial project. There was another important
- 13:29contribution from Dr. Ruddock. He reminded the commission that the third party's primary position remained that adequate, up-to-date ecological information should be available before a planning decision is made. He distinguished between information needed to assess environmental effects and the
- 13:49detailed information that can legitimately be required later to implement mitigation. This has been one of the recurring concerns right through the ecology evidence, planning conditions can govern how agreed protection measures are carried out. However, they cannot necessarily compensate for an
- 14:11assessment that has failed to establish the likely environmental consequences in the first place. He argued that if further ecological surveys were to be deferred. The conditions would need a mechanism to prevent development proceedings where those surveys revealed effects that had not
- 14:30previously been assessed. Later in the session, he returned to the wording of individual conditions. He queried why certain references to protective buffers around watercourses and refuelling activities appear to have been deleted from NIE's proposed amendments. NIE explained that refuelling and
- 14:53fuel storage would take place off-site, and that pollution prevention arrangements would cover the relevant. Following discussion, there was agreement that an explicit prohibition on refuelling and fuel storage on site could usefully be incorporated into the pollution prevention plan. Two other
- 15:14provisions, G and H of ECO L 01, had also disappeared from the amended wording. We were told that this was an error and that they were intended to remain. There were further discussions about nesting birds, peat storage, and the protection of lizard and newts. Dr. Rodock suggested that common lizards
- 15:37and smooth newts should be specifically considered within protected species management condition, given the evidence discussed during the week, the precise wording of these conditions will determine what an operator must do, what is prohibited, and how environmental safeguards are
- 15:55enforced. And yet, even at this advanced stage of the inquiry, provisions were being restored, additions suggested, and the wording of safeguards clarified. Then came the exchange of Pat Hoy. Pat had been following the discussion of the conditions and wanted to raise additional concerns about their adequacy.
- 16:16The commissioner explained that participants had already been given opportunity to submit their proposed amendments in writing, she was not prepared to accept further evidence or revise conditions during the session. Pat tried to explain that he wished to comment on DFI's conditions and on matters
- 16:34he felt had not been adequately addressed. The discussion became increasingly strained. The commissioner maintained that the commission had reviewed the written submissions and had no further questions on those points. Pat argued that having submitted written material should not exclude him from
- 16:53participating in the discussion taking place in the hearing room. Eventually, the commissioner made clear she was not reopening the matter. Now I understand that this inquiry has been running for a long time. I understand that the commission has to manage proceedings, avoid endless repetition, and ensure
- 17:10that the examination of evidence eventually reaches a conclusion. There have been extensive opportunities for written submissions, and the commissioner was entitled to explain the procedure she was following. All the same, I was uncomfortable watching this exchange.
- 17:26Pat has spent an enormous amount of time examining the application, identifying issues, preparing submissions, and very often comes up with detail missed by almost everyone else. He was trying to engage with conditions that were still being discussed and had just been amended in the room. A little
- 17:45later, when the applicant's representative clarified further amendments, Pat drew attention to what he saw as an inconsistency in the opportunities being afforded to different parties. There may be procedural distinctions between clarifying an existing submission and introducing a new
- 18:02proposal, and these are distinctions that matter, but they are not always easy to recognise from the public gallery. And after all this time, it is still frustrating to see a local art protector struggling to get his concerns heard. And so, at approximately half past 12, the commissioner
- 18:20announced that the terrestrial ecology session was concluded. We would return tomorrow for air quality. I confess, I was taken by surprise. After so many long days, so many detailed exchanges, and so much argument over ecological evidence, we had reached the end of this part of the inquiry before lunchtime.
- 18:43Today's proceedings left me thinking about the yawning chasm between the world of planning conditions and the living landscape, who those conditions are intended to protect. The protection of all the living beings in this threatened landscape depend on the quality of the evidence, the strength of
- 19:00the safeguards and the willingness of those making the decisions to recognise the limits of what has been established. I understand the growing impatience to bring this long inquiry to a close, but the duty to scrutinise the evidence does not diminish as the finishing line approaches. If
- 19:17anything, those final days demand even greater care, because the consequences of getting it wrong will endure in perpetuity. The inquiry may be drawing towards its conclusion, but our responsibility to protect this place will never end. And I leave it here for now. See you all tomorrow.
- 19:38You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in
- 19:56the show notes. Please take a moment to share this. Podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our
- 20:15voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.