Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.47🎙️ Public Inquiry - Absence of Habitats Regulation Assessment Week 2 Day 1
Transcript
- 0:04I opened this podcast with a quotation
- 0:06from Mary Brawley, solicitor for the third party. She cites
- 0:12Nicola Mallon, the former minister for infrastructure,
- 0:15who, on 29th of
- 0:17June 2020 announced that the dulridian gold planning
- 0:22application will be subject to an independent
- 0:25public inquiry. To
- 0:27quote, the planning application includes an assessment of the
- 0:30potential socio economic and environmental impacts by a wide
- 0:35range of expert consultees. Once I'm satisfied that all necessary
- 0:40detail and consultation responses have been provided. I
- 0:45will call a public inquiry to allow for robust scrutiny of the
- 0:49application in a public forum. Mary then went on to ask two
- 0:54questions. Number one, is the Delray and gold application now
- 0:59resting on the documents before this commission, and number
- 1:03two is the Department for
- 1:04infrastructure satisfied that the application placed before
- 1:09this commission is fit for robust scrutiny in
- 1:13light of the deficiencies already highlighted
- 1:15earlier in the inquiry,
- 1:18namely The earlier issues with trans boundary consultations and
- 1:22the absence of habitat regulations assessment. She went
- 1:27on then to query the wisdom of endeavouring to complete 150
- 1:30questions
- 1:31over the next three days.
- 1:33This would mean an average time of
- 1:34at least six to eight minutes per question. And she also
- 1:38reminded the commission that there was no allowance for
- 1:41remote evidence of experts, a situation in which only one
- 1:45party suffers. And yes, you've guessed it right, it's us again,
- 1:49the poor suckers in the so called third party. No live
- 1:52streaming, no transcripts and
- 1:54no explanation for same
- 1:57this set the scene on day one of the second week, and the
- 2:00commissioner's response to this was interesting. She remarked
- 2:06that the Commission did not have any power to refuse a PAC
- 2:11did not have the authority
- 2:13not to accept documents,
- 2:16ie, what may be deemed further environmental info during the
- 2:20public inquiry, and this is in reference to late documents been
- 2:24added to the planning portal by the applicant
- 2:27that they needed only to figure out whether
- 2:30participants were given enough time
- 2:32to read them all, and with
- 2:35that, they were satisfied that the evidence before them had
- 2:38fulfilled the conditions hard to know where to go after this. I
- 2:44have to say, the public inquiry feels stacked against us. There
- 2:48were literally 1000s of documents uploaded in March,
- 2:51just over a month before the PI started on the conflict of
- 2:57interest question that we had at the end of last week, all of
- 3:00them were fired out, except for the golden report, which was
- 3:03noted to hear more about this. Go back to podcast number 45 we
- 3:11then got started on the socio economic topics, of which the
- 3:14first title up was economic viability. And we grappled with
- 3:19a number of questions that the commissioner put to the
- 3:22applicant or to the departments, it was difficult to discern
- 3:26where one topic started and the other left off, as they were all
- 3:30woven together and interconnected to one another by
- 3:33one outstanding issue, and that was the feasibility study, or
- 3:39should I say, The Phantom feasibility study, a line from a
- 3:44certain song from the 70s, ran through my head all day, and if
- 3:48you are of an age, you may remember it, they seek him. Here
- 3:52they seek him. There was literally a game of hide and
- 3:56seek through a paper trail of documents to discern what date
- 4:01the feasibility study had first appeared in the world, when was
- 4:05it subsequently made obsolete, and how the evidence of its
- 4:10ghostly trail continues to show up and be mentioned
- 4:13in dispatches and documents to this very day,
- 4:17there is a whole economic case
- 4:19built around it. In fact, even though it technically does not
- 4:23exist, there was a mention of a spreadsheet shared with a
- 4:26government department and in the words of the applicant party to
- 4:30walk them
- 4:30through it so that they would be comfortable with it.
- 4:34I don't know about you, but having spent years in business,
- 4:37I wouldn't fancy showing up to my former bank manager and
- 4:40showing them something like this for a fairly minor business
- 4:43proposition in comparison to what has been proposed in this
- 4:46financial application. As for the third party, we found it
- 4:52impossible to determine anything with the absolute data, absolute
- 4:57data that has been used to justify job. Jobs based on
- 5:00obsolete mineral estimates from a phantom feasibility study.
- 5:06Just as an aside, mineral resources are not mineral
- 5:10reserves and do not have demonstrated economic viability,
- 5:14and there is no certainty that all or any part of the mineral
- 5:18resource will be converted into mineral reserve.
- 5:23The viability of the whole
- 5:24entire project sits on this report. And if I may draw your
- 5:28attention back to the opening lines of this podcast, when Mary
- 5:32Brawley inquired of the commissioner. Is the dalradian
- 5:35gold application now resting on the documents before this
- 5:39commission, and in particular, is the Department for
- 5:43infrastructure satisfied that the application placed before
- 5:47the commission is fit for robust scrutiny?
- 5:51Well, what do you think?
- 5:53One wonders who is misleading, who in the Phantom feasibility
- 5:58debacle? What could possibly go wrong? I asked myself, with a
- 6:02certain irony, we had a refreshing, honest account from
- 6:07marade Heaney from navan about Tara mines, how there was no
- 6:11noticeable economic Bonanza, and that even when the mine closed
- 6:15for a year, neither was there adverse effects from the
- 6:19closure, except for the mental health of the mine workers
- 6:22caught up in this boom, bust economy. She went on to talk
- 6:25about the 50 million tonnes of toxic waste that has been stored
- 6:29next door to the family farm, the 40 plus families that were
- 6:33forced to evacuate from the townland forever, the complete
- 6:38disruption of the social fabric, the 30 trucks per hour on former
- 6:43quiet country roads, the noise, the pollution, the dust,
- 6:48stakeholders and local residents been patronised and not listened
- 6:51to, and she concluded that there are no benefits to the local,
- 6:56indigenous population.
- 6:59When we got to the topic
- 7:01of trade and export, fidelmo Cain asked, How could she
- 7:05possibly say anything about trade and export when she
- 7:08doesn't know the contents of the concentrate or where the
- 7:12location of the processing is to happen? Because the economic
- 7:16modelling is based on the Phantom feasibility study, which
- 7:19is obsolete. That brought us to the end of the day with Mary
- 7:23Broly once more, raising concerns about where we are in
- 7:26relation to questions. We had made it to number 13 out of 150
- 7:34so now they tell us the timetable is to be revised.
- 7:37We'll see what happens tomorrow. You you.