Latest / DIVEBOMB Formula One Podcast / Episode 12 - Rosberg Vs Hamilton (2016 rewind episode)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to another episode of the Dive Bomb F1
- 0:02podcast. I'm Maham and I'm joined by my
- 0:05wonderful Co hosts Marie and Rohan.
- 0:07Today we'll be doing another rewind episode as we'll be
- 0:09taking a look at the 2016 F One season where famously Lewis
- 0:13Hamilton and Nico Rosberg battled it out for the
- 0:15championship until the final race of the season in Abu Dhabi.
- 0:19It was a season for the ages with headlines to last a
- 0:21lifetime, so let's get straight into it.
- 0:24Before I even begin by giving any kind of background or
- 0:26discussing anything to do with the season itself, I'm just
- 0:29curious to know if either of you were watching F1 when Hamilton
- 0:33and Rosberg competed against each other this season.
- 0:35I was, I mean, I was a lot younger nine years ago, so I
- 0:38would have been 9, I think, at the time.
- 0:41But yeah, I remember watching. It was like the earlier Sky
- 0:44days. I remember we just put the TV
- 0:45on. This is like, I remember Spain,
- 0:49like, very, very well. I remember that.
- 0:52But I was a lot, lot younger at the time.
- 0:54So yeah, I did. Yeah, I was 7, so I wasn't.
- 1:01We actually lived in China at the time.
- 1:02So I believe I went to the China Grand Prix, which is amazing and
- 1:07I love the Shanghai Grand Prix, but I wasn't like watching every
- 1:11single race and wasn't super invested.
- 1:13But I do remember like loving Nico Rosberg so.
- 1:17I'll say that. I wasn't watching F1, I was 13
- 1:19years old, I wasn't watching F1. But obviously I feel like it's
- 1:22one of those seasons that you wish you had watched and like
- 1:25you were fully aware of, because I think seeing everything unfold
- 1:29in real time would have just been incredible.
- 1:31Like I've I watched 2021 and I imagine that it would have been
- 1:35a similar kind of feeling to that, obviously just completely
- 1:38different stakes. For some background information,
- 1:40Hamilton and Rosberg were famously very close friends from
- 1:44quite early on in their karting careers.
- 1:45They raced as part of the same team and against each other
- 1:48during the Junior Formulas, and by their own admission, both of
- 1:51them spent time discussing what it would be like to race
- 1:54together in Formula One, where they hoped to win races and
- 1:56championships. The story of Bro Sadies, as
- 1:59they're affectionately known today, is one that is notorious
- 2:02throughout the paddock, and it's one that is repeatedly brought
- 2:04up even now to draw parallels between current driver pairings.
- 2:08Considering that at least I wasn't watching it and we were
- 2:12all kind of very young when it was happening.
- 2:14What do you guys know about this season before we even start
- 2:18talking about like race specifics?
- 2:20I mean, I remember the time this was like prime Mercedes
- 2:23dominance with two years into the new at the time they were
- 2:27new was 11 years ago now. So Mercedes were practically
- 2:30leaps and bounds above any other team on the field.
- 2:33I mean, it was it was practically a whole different
- 2:35sport back then because the top four teams or the top teams are
- 2:38so wealthy and the bottom teams like manner and like catering a
- 2:43few years before were struggling so much.
- 2:45So the performance was so varied across the field.
- 2:48I remember it being a different sport, I remember the whole
- 2:52approach. The media was different because
- 2:54of so it was Bernie Ecclestone's last year in control of the
- 2:57Formula One group. However you think about that and
- 3:00obviously there were a lot more restrictions on stuff like I
- 3:03just remember it being a different sport both on track
- 3:05and off track. Yeah, I mean, it was just a
- 3:08really just a championship for Nico and Lewis.
- 3:11From what I know about it, remember about it, they were so
- 3:15far ahead of everybody else that really it didn't matter to
- 3:20anybody else that everybody knew Mercedes was going to win.
- 3:23And it was just such an intense rivalry made like so much more
- 3:28intense by their history together and which also made it
- 3:31so much more interesting. You guys have kind of picked up
- 3:34on the points that I was going to say because I want a caveat
- 3:37before we begin our discussion of the 2016 season and say that
- 3:40of course, the teammate battle is one of the headlines.
- 3:42But the absolute domination presented by Mercedes, you just
- 3:45can't. I don't think you can talk about
- 3:47this season without talking about the fact that yes, it was
- 3:51a championship battle for the driver's title.
- 3:53But the constructors was effectively sealed like 4 rounds
- 3:56in when it was basically declared that Mercedes were so
- 3:59far ahead of the pack that unless something happened to
- 4:02them or something happened to their cars, there was no.
- 4:06Way on track that they could actually be challenged because
- 4:08they were just that far ahead if it wasn't.
- 4:11For the crash in Spain or Hamilton's engine failure in
- 4:14Malaysia, Mercedes is a constructor would have achieved
- 4:17the incredible feat of winning every race in a single season.
- 4:20The closest that we've gotten to this in recent years, from my
- 4:22memory, is obviously Red Bull in 2023.
- 4:25But this time it was Carlos Sainz and Ferrari whose win in
- 4:28Singapore stopped Red Bull's utter domination.
- 4:30So I think it's always important when you think about teammate
- 4:33battles because I think that constructors adds an extra
- 4:36element. It kind of changes the way that
- 4:38a team looks at how they let their drivers race, how they
- 4:41want their drivers to conduct themselves against each other,
- 4:44especially on track, which is obviously something that we've
- 4:47kind of seen in parts this season as well.
- 4:50Yeah, I think it's good to mention that because obviously
- 4:53it's very different situations. But nine years later, history
- 4:57sort of repeated itself where we've got a team that has
- 4:59supposedly been, I mean, in McLaren says this year, a far
- 5:03ahead of everyone else and you just have to let the two drivers
- 5:06race. But I think the way that
- 5:08Mercedes did it and the way the McLaren are doing it are like
- 5:11black and white. It's quite different from from
- 5:13what I remember, although I'm a bit by myself as a Mercedes fan.
- 5:17It was a different, a different approach and there wasn't any of
- 5:20these sort of issues because we had like the influence of Niki
- 5:23Lauder at the time, a non executive chairman.
- 5:26And I remember in an interview, I think he started something
- 5:29around the time about how he dealt with the crash at Spain
- 5:32and how he spoke to the drivers and stuff.
- 5:34So I think that was a major thing that was prevalent.
- 5:37So I think there are definitely parallels for sure though.
- 5:40I think it's so interesting because the influence of, of
- 5:43course Niki and Toto Wolff is so different to the influence of
- 5:47Andrea, Stella and Zac Brown. I think they're much more
- 5:50focused on like Stella and Brown, much more focused on the
- 5:53media and like the perception of the team.
- 5:55Whereas obviously Nikki doesn't care about anything but racing.
- 6:00And same with Toto Wolff. He's very business oriented, so
- 6:03of course he doesn't really care what the media is saying.
- 6:06He really cares that his drivers are doing good and that they're
- 6:09not crashing into each other as we saw in Spain.
- 6:14I think what was so interesting about Maham, your comparison of
- 6:182023 and 2020 or 2016, is that Red Ball obviously didn't win in
- 6:24Singapore that year because of pace, because the car was bad on
- 6:28the circuit. Whereas Mercedes, well, they
- 6:30lost two races, 16, they lost both races because they DNF.
- 6:34Like it wasn't a pace thing. It was like we couldn't finish
- 6:37the race, which you could argue that engine failure is a
- 6:40reliability issue, which just has stuff to do with car.
- 6:42But like, on pace, like the Mercedes is by far the fastest
- 6:47car we've seen in kind of recent history, or at least the most
- 6:50dominant. Yeah.
- 6:51And these are both points actually, that I want to come
- 6:53back to later on in the podcast episode where we talk about this
- 6:56idea of managing to #1 drivers, if you will.
- 6:59And then this idea of reliability that regardless of
- 7:02the set of regulations that we're in or regardless of what
- 7:06kind of chassis you're using or who's developing your car, all
- 7:09of these things aside, the question of reliability follows
- 7:12these teams around. All 10 soon to be 11 F one
- 7:15teams. It follows them around because
- 7:17sometimes you can be capable of being 30 seconds ahead of
- 7:21everyone else on the grid. But you just can't control the
- 7:24fact that if the engine that you have in your car is not reliable
- 7:27to the extent that you want it to be, it will simply just not
- 7:30take you where you want to be, you know?
- 7:32So yeah, these are points that I'd like to come back to later
- 7:34on in the podcast episode. The season got off to what I
- 7:37would say is a picture perfect start for Mercedes.
- 7:39Rosberg won the opening race in Australia and Hamilton followed
- 7:42up in second. Sebastian Vettel completed the
- 7:44podium on that occasion. A Rosberg Hamilton 1-2 would end
- 7:48up being quite a familiar sight over the course of the rest of
- 7:50the season, but I honestly think the only right place to start
- 7:54for 2016 is in Spain. It's in Barcelona, so arriving
- 7:57at the European part of the calendar, Rosberg had a sizable
- 8:00lead in the championship standings, having taken 4
- 8:02consecutive wins and achieving his first career Grand Slam
- 8:06prior to arriving in Barcelona. In second place in the
- 8:08championship, Hamilton was languishing after a rather
- 8:11unfortunate run of races prior prior to arriving in Europe.
- 8:14He was close behind, but he was also more of a victim to
- 8:18different hindrances during qualifying in the race compared
- 8:21to Rosberg. Now, I'm going to say this time
- 8:23and time again during this episode, but of course all of my
- 8:25questions have an element of hindsight because we know how
- 8:27the championship ended up playing out that year and what
- 8:30happened subsequently to Mercedes as a team and as well.
- 8:33But on this occasion, just humor me a little bit.
- 8:36Do you think an incident like what we saw on lap one of the
- 8:39Spanish Grand Prix was a long time coming between Rosberg and
- 8:42Hamilton? Absolutely.
- 8:43I just think it we see these kinds of incidents with close
- 8:47title fights all the time. You know, Silverstone and Monza
- 8:502021. This is it's just the thing
- 8:53that's naturally going to happen.
- 8:54I think in a, in a title fight, not just any title fight, one
- 8:58where the driver is known As for the quite well in, in junior
- 9:02falling around casting and stuff.
- 9:04So the relationships built over time and but also just, I think
- 9:07just in these situations, it's the heat of the moment thing.
- 9:10Yeah, I mean, I think it's inevitable.
- 9:11I think for every like, close championship fight, we've seen a
- 9:15crash between the two top contenders.
- 9:17I mean, you think about 2021, obviously had a few big ones,
- 9:21and I mean for 2025, you think about Canada or it was kind of
- 9:25the same situation of the driver behind just going for a gap that
- 9:29really didn't exist and these kinds of things.
- 9:32I think that there's so much pressure.
- 9:33Obviously there's so much pressure in a championship
- 9:37fighting scenario that you almost drivers almost get
- 9:41blinded of like, I have to be first, so I'll do anything to be
- 9:45ahead of the person who I'm fighting with.
- 9:47Yeah. I mean, if it didn't happen, I
- 9:51think everybody would have been very shocked if they hadn't
- 9:54collided at least once in there. I think just picking up on that
- 9:57point that you made, Marie, if they hadn't have collided, it
- 9:59would have been something that we would have been talking about
- 10:01as well. And I do think not just in the
- 10:03context of the race itself or even I would say to the season
- 10:06itself, if you think about. What was happening between the
- 10:09two as a teammate pairing in the lead up to 2016 as well?
- 10:13I think it was it almost when you read.
- 10:15About it feels like it was a situation where something was
- 10:18bound to happen and something was bound to go wrong as well
- 10:21and it just seemed this seemed to be the combination of all of
- 10:24those years not just with both drivers being an F1, but again,
- 10:28if you look back to. Their junior formula careers as
- 10:30well that karting careers as well.
- 10:31They had known each other for that amount of time, they
- 10:35instinctively almost knew. It felt like what the other was
- 10:38going to do and I. I've seen this clip so many
- 10:42times because for some reason Sky Sports loves to have this on
- 10:45broadcast every now and again of Lewis Hamilton throwing his
- 10:48steering wheel after the crash. It's right opposite from you see
- 10:52it from his perspective in his car and he throws it against the
- 10:55barriers. And I just think it's.
- 10:56For a driver. Who's we now know is very calm
- 10:59and cool and collected in, I would say 90% of situations.
- 11:03To see that kind of reaction and response from him, I think it
- 11:07just goes to show how much it was basically a long time
- 11:09coming. Yeah, I mean, I, I think we all,
- 11:11I think it represents to me that everyone just has their fuse and
- 11:14then it gets to a point where you just like, yeah, obviously,
- 11:18I mean, those steering wheels cost an absolute fortune.
- 11:21So I don't think in any other situation you'd do it with a,
- 11:24you know, thousands of pounds steering wheel.
- 11:26But I think it was justified considering what happened.
- 11:29And it represents to me that Lewis Hamilton just has a fuse,
- 11:33but that's a lot longer than most people.
- 11:35Absolutely. Especially not the thing you
- 11:37want to do when Toto is going to make you pay for it.
- 11:40But yeah, I think that season and that that like his battle
- 11:45with Nico was such a large component of him kind of like
- 11:48evolving as a driver and his him evolving into the driver we see
- 11:54today, who is very calm and kind of calculated and isn't gonna go
- 12:00for moves that don't exist and is going to know his lines and
- 12:06know kind of what he wants to do and execute it to the highest
- 12:09standard. I mean, I was going to bring
- 12:11this up later on in the episode, but this is feels like a perfect
- 12:14moment to talk about it. In 2021, just prior to the Abu
- 12:17Dhabi race, Lewis was doing an interview with Sky Sports and he
- 12:20was asked off. This is off the top of my head.
- 12:23So the question isn't completely OK or it's not completely right.
- 12:26But it was something like, are you a better driver in
- 12:29comparison to 2016, which was, in complete honesty, probably
- 12:33the last time he was pushed to that extent as a driver trying
- 12:37to defend his title. And he responded yes.
- 12:39And I'm a better teammate too. So I think it just goes to show
- 12:42every driver has a season. Or a race.
- 12:45Or a moment that changes them, makes them almost make or break.
- 12:50It either makes you a better driver and it makes you what you
- 12:53think you are capable of doing, or it just means that you
- 12:56realize that you've gotten to the extent of development that
- 12:59you can as a race car driver and you have to accept that for what
- 13:02it is. This interview like haunts me.
- 13:04Oh my gosh, I know I knew exactly what you're talking
- 13:07about. He goes no, and it's the pause.
- 13:09He goes, the interviewer is like, Louis, were you a better
- 13:12driver than you were in 16? And he goes, yes, pause and
- 13:15teammate. And then it pans straight to
- 13:17Nico. And then it like, Jensen button
- 13:20is also like on this panel of like commentators or whatever.
- 13:23And then Jensen, like Nico is just like sitting there, like
- 13:25incomplete, like, Oh my gosh, what is going on?
- 13:28And then Jensen, like, looks over to him like, Oh my gosh,
- 13:31are you OK? And it like, it's the most
- 13:33perfect piece of unscripted cinema that I think I can think
- 13:37it is in the F1 context. Oh my gosh, I know exactly what
- 13:40you're talking about. I.
- 13:41Do just want to add very briefly as we discuss the European part
- 13:44of this season in 2016 that Hamilton's first win was in
- 13:48Monaco after. To Red Bull failed to capitalize
- 13:50on Daniel Ricardo's first ever pole position.
- 13:53Having blundered in the pits, Hamilton inherited the lead from
- 13:55the Australian driver and Rosberg became the first winner
- 13:58of the European Grand Prix, but this time it was taking place in
- 14:01Baku, Azerbaijan. I just wanted to put that out
- 14:03there because I think Red Bull's involvement in this championship
- 14:07battle is something that I want to come to later on.
- 14:09So the fact that Hamilton's first win this season was an
- 14:11inherited one from a failure on Red Bull's part I think is quite
- 14:15interesting. Yeah, I mean, people complain
- 14:17about the McLaren pit stop in 2025, but people don't remember
- 14:21how bad it was nine years ago when Daniel Ricardo got shafted
- 14:24by the Red Bull pit stop team. I mean, that was just really sad
- 14:28to see. And obviously made it up a few
- 14:30years later, got reciprocated. But I think it just highlighted,
- 14:34yeah, as you're saying, the importance of the Red Bull as a
- 14:38second party, third party in the championship fight and how they
- 14:42were able to influence things as well.
- 14:43I mean, you even see it now. I would say Red Bull has a
- 14:46really big influence in the championship today.
- 14:51They're always at the scene of the crime.
- 14:52I guess. I don't know what else to say
- 14:54they have. I mean, any of the other teams
- 14:57in 2016 probably have the best seat to one of the best title
- 15:00fights, at least in recent history that we've had.
- 15:02Whether it's the best or whether it's not the best, I think is a
- 15:05whole other podcast episode. But they had one of the best
- 15:08seats. To this championship battle, and
- 15:11I think also just going to your point that you made Rohan really
- 15:13quickly about the pit stops. It's one thing to have a slow
- 15:16pit stop in 2025 from McLaren's part, the fact that Red Bull
- 15:19didn't even have their tires ready for a pit stop, I think
- 15:22you're right. People do forget just how bad it
- 15:24can be. And this is not to say this is
- 15:27what McLaren need to start doing.
- 15:28Please do not. Forget tires for a pit stop.
- 15:31They're a very crucial part of changing tires.
- 15:34Yeah, just focusing what you said about the other teams
- 15:37having a good seat, I would probably not include manner
- 15:39because I think they've permanently found themselves on
- 15:41the a lap behind everyone else. It almost sounds like talking
- 15:45about millions. Not that's not the best.
- 15:49So they might, they would have been seeing the back of a lot of
- 15:51cars from a lap down the entire season.
- 15:54Yeah. Next I want to discuss Hungry,
- 15:57which has emerged to be a very interesting venue when you put
- 15:59it into the context of the last couple of seasons of F1 that
- 16:02we've had. If you think about the fact that
- 16:03Esteban Arcon took his first ever victory there, arguably
- 16:06it's the first emergence of papaya rules for the current
- 16:09McLaren driver lineup and the incident that I'm about to
- 16:12discuss now, then it's certainly proven to be a pivotal circuit
- 16:15for championships and headlines. Although not the most notorious
- 16:18incident in the season by far, it's where Hamilton took the
- 16:21championship lead, having steadily gained on his teammate
- 16:23prior to this moment. Having won this race, he now had
- 16:26a six point advantage over his teammate.
- 16:29I suppose my question, and again this is informed with hindsight,
- 16:32is should. Hamilton have run away with the
- 16:34championship from this point onward and avoided the option of
- 16:37even allowing Rosberg back into the fight altogether.
- 16:39I mean, should he have? Yes.
- 16:41Could he have? Probably not.
- 16:43I mean, we hear about Nico and that year and it's just anything
- 16:47that anyone could possibly think of doing that would make him
- 16:50faster. He was going to take the chance,
- 16:52like no matter if it worked or not, no matter if it was by the
- 16:54smallest of small margins. I think Nico is fighting so
- 16:58incredibly hard that it was really impossible for Lewis to
- 17:02run away with it. I think it's an interesting one
- 17:05to call obviously and the drivers finishing inverse of
- 17:08where they started on the grid really I think I think it was
- 17:11justified when he took the lead. Obviously waiting by 1.9 seconds
- 17:15is also good as well. I just want to go back to what
- 17:18Marie was saying about Rossford doing absolutely anything to try
- 17:22and be quicker. I read recently when he was
- 17:24talking about 2016, he said that he gave up cycling because he
- 17:28wanted to reduce his muscle mass because he felt that that would
- 17:30make him. Quicker in the car, there was a
- 17:32conversation at one point that the two drivers were going to
- 17:35switch, Shash sees. Because they were worried on
- 17:37both sides of the garage that there was something going on on
- 17:40the other side that was making them quicker.
- 17:42This was to the extent that and you got to say hats off to Toto
- 17:45Wolff for managing this entire situation because that's exactly
- 17:49what he had to do. It is just incredible that you
- 17:52have two drivers who are willing to literally not only put all
- 17:55cards on the table, but like even go a step beyond that and
- 17:58say there is nothing I will not do to win this title this
- 18:02season. And I think it was.
- 18:04I think it's their history that maybe spurred them on a little
- 18:06bit more as well, knowing that because they had been racing
- 18:09against each other for so long, knowing that this is exactly
- 18:12what they spoke about when they were younger.
- 18:14This is this is what they had dreamed of.
- 18:16But it also meant that I think maybe they didn't take into
- 18:18consideration for one of them to win, the other one had to lose
- 18:21as well. Yeah, I mean, it's interesting
- 18:22as well that he removed a lot of the paint from his helmet that
- 18:26year to make it black. And it's just to save 80 grams
- 18:30in weight, which the Japanese Grand Prix is coming to.
- 18:32Naughty point, naughty. 4 seconds a lap saved.
- 18:36So I think it just shows the the means to an end that Rosberg
- 18:39went just just to gain fraction of time, which obviously in this
- 18:43sport is crucial, save like even a thousandth of a second Formula
- 18:49One teams, the drivers will do. Right.
- 18:50Beginning in 2014, he ditched the yellow helmets and then
- 18:54obviously in 2016 his helmet was basically all carbon and just
- 19:00the lengths that you're able to go to.
- 19:03And I think that's something we don't, we don't really see
- 19:06nowadays or with the title contenders now.
- 19:09Like, of course, they're pushing as hard as they can, but they're
- 19:12not giving up a thing that they love like cycling because they
- 19:17need to reduce the muscle mass in their legs so that they can
- 19:20be way less and be faster. Of course, that also goes kind
- 19:23of with the new rate weight regulations.
- 19:26But they're not only eating Kellogg's Frosties because they
- 19:30are so anxious that they can't eat anything else.
- 19:36Muhammad shaking her head and has her head in her hands.
- 19:39For those who don't know, Nico and Lewis grew up eating
- 19:42Kellogg's Frosties and that's why it was the only thing that
- 19:45Nico could eat. Which is really cute.
- 19:47Yeah. Yeah, I mean, we we don't see
- 19:48this whole they're pushing the absolute limit.
- 19:51We haven't seen Lando Norris change his helmet just for
- 19:54completely void of pain and the cars are void of pain like 2023.
- 20:00I think that's an interesting point that we've raised there,
- 20:02like just how far people. The drivers at that time were
- 20:06just willing to go. I think.
- 20:07But to be. Fair.
- 20:08What I think to be fair, what I also think is interesting is on
- 20:12a given weekend, you can see Oscar in P4 in Lando and P1.
- 20:16Like it's not quite as close as I believe it was in 2016 when
- 20:20you had them finishing on the podium together.
- 20:23The majority of the races in that situation, the margins are
- 20:26so tight that you of course have to do those things to edge out
- 20:28your teammate. Whereas now, whether it be the
- 20:32car, the championship being more competitive or whatever it might
- 20:36be, for whatever reason, it's not seconds close.
- 20:39They're not one position away from each other at every single
- 20:42race. The Lando DNFS in Zanvord or
- 20:45Manza and Oscar DNFS in Baku, there's AI would say a larger
- 20:49fluctuation of points than there was in 2016.
- 20:53I think also I want to follow up to what you've just said, Marie,
- 20:55and then also maybe change it a little bit as well.
- 20:58I find it really interesting how you've there's almost been this
- 21:01really weird convergence. An F1 that, as the regulations
- 21:04have continued to. Develop technically and as the
- 21:06teams, I would say. I don't know whether this is
- 21:08right to say because the team has always built the car that
- 21:11drivers drive, but it almost feels like the hand that the
- 21:14team has in a driver's success on track.
- 21:18It feels like it's almost increased.
- 21:20So a driver needing to go to the lengths of, OK, I'm going to
- 21:23take the paint off my helmet or I'm going to give going to give
- 21:26up cycling, for example, to reduce my muscle mass for the
- 21:29sake of speed. It almost feels like they're not
- 21:31necessarily maybe as required anymore like to go to those kind
- 21:36of lengths to have that kind of success on track.
- 21:38I also think what I find especially interesting about
- 21:41Roseburg doing that kind of thing for a season like 2016,
- 21:44that Mercedes is a construction tractor was so far ahead is the
- 21:48fact that he was giving things these things up because it was
- 21:51him and Lewis in a title fight. It wasn't a case of there's six
- 21:55other drivers that I'm battling against and they're all driving
- 21:58different cars or like if there's six of us, that means
- 22:00there's three teams at the front.
- 22:02It was because he knew those were the only things that could
- 22:05make a difference. He had, regardless of what he
- 22:07and his garage felt about what was happening on Lewis's side of
- 22:10the garage, he had the exact same car.
- 22:13There was it was these small margins that were going to
- 22:16either either see him lift the title at the end of the season
- 22:19or he was going to be second. So I think I find that very
- 22:22interesting because again, it's just another added dynamic to
- 22:26this championship battle in 2016, I think.
- 22:28Yeah, I guess if he was battling perhaps Sebastian Vettel or
- 22:32Daniel Ricardo for a title, say they were, I don't know, the Red
- 22:36Bull, the Ferrari were like to that level, it might have been a
- 22:40different fight. And I think you're right to say
- 22:42that the context of it may have led to those decisions being
- 22:46made and to save this way, to give up cycling to, you know,
- 22:50those sorts of things. Absolutely.
- 22:52Because I also think when it becomes with two different
- 22:54teams, it becomes much more about the car.
- 22:57It's where even if you couldn't have nowhere left to kind of
- 23:01develop the car, it's always, well, how can we set up the car
- 23:05differently or change it or whatever it might be to make it
- 23:08faster than the other team? When it's your teammate and you
- 23:11know that the car is the same, then there's nothing you can do
- 23:14but to go to those other measures.
- 23:17As we are comparing now 2025 to 2016, I think it's so
- 23:22interesting how both sides of the garage were so split and of
- 23:26course wanted to beat each other so badly, which is obviously
- 23:29something we're not really seeing now.
- 23:31We're trying kind of seeing Oscar and Lando wanting to beat
- 23:34each other really, really badly and then the rest of McLaren
- 23:37trying to like be like, oh, we're a happy family, we all
- 23:40love each other, yay, formula what?
- 23:43You know what I mean? Like, it's not quite.
- 23:45It doesn't feel quite as cut throat as the Mercedes garage,
- 23:49which was so split down the middle between Rosberg and
- 23:52Hamilton. Yeah, it was very different.
- 23:55They didn't really have this happy go lucky attitude to
- 23:57racing where we'll forgive the driver and then I don't know, 2
- 24:01races down the line say, Oh well, the the wherever he got in
- 24:05trouble for doesn't matter anymore.
- 24:06Let's go race guys kind of attitude.
- 24:08Just as I think I was alluding to earlier, the the way that
- 24:12Mercedes 9 years ago approached it to McLaren today, it's just
- 24:15very different. We'd love to know how the
- 24:17conversation would have gone down had Toto Wolff tried to sit
- 24:20Nico Rosberg and Lewis Hamilton down post Barcelona and said,
- 24:24OK, well we're giving repercussions to one of you, so
- 24:27let's flip a coin and see how this goes.
- 24:28I think that would have been, I would have paid to have been a
- 24:31family on that wall, had that kind of conversation.
- 24:34Happened. I think it was still different,
- 24:35obviously the influence of Nikki Lauder as well, who was far more
- 24:39focused on racing and calling presence then focused on
- 24:42anything else but including sponsorship and what have you.
- 24:45So I think even that conversation would have gone
- 24:48differently to a degree. So then I agree.
- 24:51Is it an issue of McLaren not having a kind of big racing
- 24:55influence? Obviously we saw Jill
- 24:57unfortunately pass away a few years ago.
- 24:59They don't really have a key member of the team who was a
- 25:03historic racing driver kind of guiding their move.
- 25:06And of course Zach and Andrea have been in Formula One for a
- 25:09long time and know a lot about it, but they don't have that
- 25:12kind of sort of driver mentality of being a Formula One driver.
- 25:15Is that what McLaren is missing, perhaps?
- 25:20How old will their problems fall?
- 25:24They just needed. I think it's just in the way
- 25:26they've dealt with what's called this this season.
- 25:29But even that nine years ago is alluding to that is really just
- 25:34a model of how you can deal with it when it's not about the car
- 25:37against another team. It's between two drivers.
- 25:40I think it is a model, not the perfect one of seeing how
- 25:44another team dealt with it and how their model works and how
- 25:48their rules guided the season and their perspective.
- 25:51I want to turn to Asia next and discuss Malaysia from a team
- 25:54perspective. Before getting into that though,
- 25:57I just want to say that Singapore is when Rosberg retook
- 25:59the championship lead as he turned A2 point deficit into an
- 26:028 point lead. Now on to Malaysia where the 10
- 26:05race win streak came to an end. For Mercedes.
- 26:08Like I mentioned earlier in this episode, there is only one.
- 26:10This is only one of two races that was not won by Mercedes in
- 26:13this season and at this time it wasn't a collision which turned
- 26:16out which turned to change the final outcome of the race, but
- 26:20instead it was a critical engine failure for Hamilton which saw
- 26:23him DNF ING from the lead of the race.
- 26:25Now, like I mentioned before, the question of reliability is
- 26:28one that follows F1 teams around regardless of regulations,
- 26:31regardless of who your chief engineer is, regardless of
- 26:34anything whatsoever. Is reliability something that
- 26:37has improved steadily? Obviously, we're talking about
- 26:39nine years in the past compared to now.
- 26:41Or is this still something? Is it still a dark shadow
- 26:44effectively that hangs over the heads of F1 teams, especially
- 26:47when you're in a championship battle, regardless of whether
- 26:50that's the constructors championship or the drivers
- 26:52championship? I think it's almost worse now
- 26:54when you have something like an engine failure like we saw for
- 26:57Orlando and Zenver because it's less common.
- 27:00I mean, of course it didn't happen all of the time in 2016,
- 27:03but if you had a championship contender who had an engine
- 27:06failure, it wasn't necessarily like the end of the world.
- 27:09And of course it hasn't been for Lando either.
- 27:12But that's the kind of thing where because the cars are so
- 27:14reliable now, you start to question it a bit, or at least
- 27:17some of the team or some of the fans do question kind of the
- 27:21difference in the two cars. The situation arriving into Abu
- 27:24Dhabi was clear and relatively simple, I think from a
- 27:26mathematical perspective. Rosberg LED Hamilton in the
- 27:29standings by 12 points, so even if Hamilton won the race,
- 27:32Rosberg only needed to finish P3 in order to clinch his first
- 27:35ever world title. Despite ups and downs in the
- 27:37race itself, with Sebastian Vettel also bringing himself
- 27:40back into contention for the win, it was a Mercedes 1-2 to
- 27:43finish off the season and Rosberg secured the points
- 27:45needed for his first and what would.
- 27:47Be his only title in the context of the season that we're
- 27:50currently seeing unfold. Between Lando Norris and Oscar
- 27:52Piastri and the countless discussions that have been had
- 27:55about Mclarens management of them of both drivers and their
- 27:58commitment to having no #1 driver, what could be said about
- 28:01Mercedes or specifically Toto Wolff management?
- 28:04Of these two drivers. I just think, I can't remember
- 28:07as well at the time that you just took it literally just
- 28:10race, no strings attached, just race kind of attitude to more of
- 28:15a degree than McLaren have, rather than a more micromanaged
- 28:18one-size-fits-all the approach they've taken.
- 28:21And I think it's represented just everything just works
- 28:24better to a of it to a degree. But it wasn't perfect, but it
- 28:28worked and I think it was significantly better than how
- 28:31McClaren have so far managed their racing on track and off
- 28:35track, right. It wasn't perfect, but both of
- 28:38the drivers finished P1 and P2 in the World Drivers
- 28:42Championship and the team won the Constructors Championship.
- 28:44Really. I mean, what more can you ask
- 28:46for? And they didn't, whether it be
- 28:48the kind of competitiveness of the car or the management, they
- 28:52didn't have someone knocking on the door as we see in Max
- 28:55Verstappen of of challenging this title fight, possibly
- 29:00because of some of the mismanaged race situations.
- 29:03I agree. I mean, apart from of course,
- 29:05Spain, the team was on the podium every single weekend.
- 29:08And at the start of the season with the dominance of the
- 29:11McLaren, that's what we would have really kind of expected.
- 29:14But obviously it's not what has happened this season.
- 29:17I think, I think Zach and under I need to attend 1 of Toto's
- 29:22Harvard Business School classes because I don't know, just their
- 29:26management of it. I think they're so caught up in
- 29:28the image of the team and Orlando and Oscar need to be
- 29:32best friends. Like they need to respect each
- 29:34other, but they don't need to be best friends.
- 29:36And like, that's OK. They're colleagues.
- 29:38They're not. They're not besties for life,
- 29:41right? Like it's OK.
- 29:44And of course they both, it's very evident that they both have
- 29:48a lot of respect for each other. So I think they really, I mean,
- 29:51we've said this whole season, but they really just need to not
- 29:54overcomplicated it and be like, you can't collide, but you can
- 29:58race. And as long as damage is done,
- 30:01it's fine by us. Yeah, I think compared to them,
- 30:05a lot of McLaren's pitfalls apart from like Lando Norris
- 30:07retiring due to an engine failure and that's a related
- 30:10issue, which obviously wasn't their fault, just been in their
- 30:12management of it, where Mercedes pitfalls was just how the
- 30:15drivers drove on track, which wasn't really in their controls.
- 30:19Obviously that that it just worked for them.
- 30:22Obviously that that car advantage, it just everything
- 30:26clicked into place. How the drivers drove on track
- 30:28was how it was. That's I think the way I see it
- 30:31compared to. I think one thing also that I
- 30:34find really interesting if you were to start comparing Mercedes
- 30:37in 2016 versus McLaren in 2025, is this is going to sound very
- 30:42strange, but I will explain this, the longevity of their
- 30:44memory as well. I've famously had that post
- 30:48Barcelona in 2016, but a Wolf had the two of them write
- 30:51apology letters to each other, which he then read out to the
- 30:55other one as well. And it was kind of a, OK, this
- 30:58incident has happened. We've lost the points that we've
- 31:00lost. Obviously we've lost the record
- 31:02that we've had so, so far winning every single race up
- 31:04until this point, but we're going to move on and this is
- 31:07going to be it and just don't do this again.
- 31:09And I think obviously a lot of that is probably to do with the
- 31:12racing influence that Nikki Lauda brought and then also
- 31:15Total Wolves management of the team as both a business but also
- 31:19a team. I think in comparison, McLaren
- 31:21this year seemed very much focused on these are going to be
- 31:25pivotal moments of the season. Things like Canada, things like
- 31:29Singapore, things like turn one in the Sprint at the Circuit of
- 31:32the Americas. But they're going to be pivotal
- 31:35to the point that even when management, so Zac Brown and
- 31:38Andrea Stella are talked about, are asked about them in the
- 31:41media, they're still going to be brought up regardless of how
- 31:44long it's been since those incidents actually occurring.
- 31:47I find that very interesting because I think they, as
- 31:49incidents for McLaren, overhang and then influence future
- 31:53decisions that don't necessarily have anything to do do with what
- 31:58has already happened. Because those points are gone,
- 32:00they can't come back. You can make them up in further
- 32:03races, but it's not like winning once somewhere else is going to
- 32:06get you 50 points all of a sudden, which will wipe out
- 32:09Canada completely, you know? Yeah, I think that's what I
- 32:12think. I mean, as I said this, this
- 32:14one-size-fits-all approach McLaren are taking just doesn't
- 32:17work when you know like the Singapore.
- 32:20I would personally say that was a racing incident.
- 32:23I wouldn't say it was influenced anything like off track.
- 32:26I mean at the start of a race you've got so much adrenaline,
- 32:29you're not thinking about that kind of thing, you just want to
- 32:31make it through the corner. But yeah, I just think the
- 32:33Mercedes way was a better way of managing the increased tensions
- 32:37that title fire into team title fight can bring.
- 32:40Whilst the McLaren way has worked and obviously there's
- 32:43still, they've run the constructors and everything, I
- 32:46just think there were significantly more flaws or
- 32:49they're both ways are flawed. The Mercedes will evidently work
- 32:52better in practice. No, I like what you you're
- 32:55saying because I you agree they need to have a shorter memory.
- 32:59When we're talking about McLaren, we often reference
- 33:02Hungary of 2024 or Monza of 2024.
- 33:06I mean, there's a multitude of races that we come back to
- 33:10really. I think it's because the team
- 33:12hasn't forgotten them and they haven't moved on, which allows
- 33:16kind of the media to keep being what about this, oh, this
- 33:19happened, what about that? Well, in this situation, you
- 33:21said this, that happened, OK, it probably, knowing McLaren, it
- 33:26probably wasn't a good decision. Let's move on.
- 33:28Like it's not, as you said, in Spain, they dealt with the
- 33:32situation and then they moved on and it didn't hinder them any
- 33:35further. Really.
- 33:36McLaren is just every single situation that they can make
- 33:39complicated. They will.
- 33:41And it's so frustrating to see because I agree.
- 33:44They need to just accept the situation as it is, say we're
- 33:48sorry to anybody who feels hindered or hurt or whatever by
- 33:52this, and then move on and just focus on winning the next race.
- 33:57Because really in Formula One, no, everybody remembers your
- 34:01last race. Nobody remembers the race two
- 34:04years ago where you because of a pit stop discrepancy, you had to
- 34:08like, no, move on. I think the fact that they're
- 34:11mentioning Hungary 2024 and Monza 2025 is an interesting
- 34:16one. I mean just keep calm and carry
- 34:18on. As the posters usually say, just
- 34:20think. Focus on then here and now
- 34:22rather than what happened in the past and what you did.
- 34:25Just learn one from what you did and move on.
- 34:27Again, I think McLaren should probably just hire us because I
- 34:30think we've solved about 90% of the problems that they seem to
- 34:33have been having this year. Very famously, after winning the
- 34:35title, Rosberg announced his retirement from the sport and in
- 34:38doing so he became the first reigning world champion to
- 34:41retire since Alan Prost in 1993. Having won 23 races, standing on
- 34:46the podium 57 times with 30 pole positions and 20 fastest laps,
- 34:50Rosberg was undoubtedly a success in the era that he drove
- 34:54in. I know that we don't deal with
- 34:55hypotheticals too often on this podcast, but I feel compelled
- 34:58that I have to ask this anyway. Do you think that he would have
- 35:01had it in him to compete against Lewis in 27 and beyond for
- 35:04another potential World Championship title?
- 35:07I think hypothetically yes. In practice if it happened, it's
- 35:11hard to say. I mean, Mercedes going into
- 35:132017, they still have the car advantage, although through
- 35:17those regulations that was progressively undercut.
- 35:20I, I think it's kind of hard to say because the reason he
- 35:23retired is because he dedicated so much time and effort both
- 35:26physically and mentally into this championship and it kind of
- 35:30just took the wind out of the sails by the end of the seasons.
- 35:32Theoretically yes, but in practice it's for me it's harder
- 35:35to call. Right.
- 35:36I think he would have had it in him to put together a
- 35:39competitive season and to race Lewis in a tight battle.
- 35:44Obviously, as we as we've said, it took so much out of him and
- 35:48it took so much for him to win and he put so much effort into
- 35:53it that it really just burnt him out hard.
- 35:56And especially when you have a wife and kids and whatever else,
- 36:01like that's not necessarily something you want to be doing
- 36:04every single year, which is obviously why he retired.
- 36:06But I think he could have done it, but it would have been to
- 36:10his detriment because he would have been even more burnt out
- 36:13really. I think we're all going to end
- 36:15up with the same answer that hypothetically, yes, he could
- 36:17have done it, but in practice whether they would have worked
- 36:20out the way that he would have hoped or not, I think is
- 36:23probably more up for debate and I would learn more towards.
- 36:26No, I think also like we've kind of episode discussing whether
- 36:30Rosberg would have had anything else to give for a subsequent
- 36:33championship battle. I think it was earlier this
- 36:36season. Nico Rosberg was part of the
- 36:38commentating team at Sky Sports, as often is on occasion, and I
- 36:42can't remember what track it was, but he said Lewis would
- 36:45have been holding his breath for the entirety of that lap.
- 36:48And I can't even remember if this was in practice or in
- 36:50qualifying or what weekend it was.
- 36:52But that intuition that I think they both had about each other,
- 36:55which is why they knew how to race each other just so well, I
- 36:59think that would have been the unsustainable part, at least for
- 37:03Nico himself to move forward to do that all over again in
- 37:06another championship battle, knowing that obviously by that
- 37:09point Lewis Hamilton was also a world champion.
- 37:12Rosberg being a world champion as well.
- 37:14I think that battle itself would have been completely different.
- 37:17Nico no longer would have felt, if he had felt this at all to
- 37:20begin with, He still had to prove the fact that they he had
- 37:24to achieve the dream that they both collectively had when they
- 37:27were in the junior formulas. They were both on equal
- 37:29grounding. They both had titles.
- 37:31How many is maybe less of an important point, but they both
- 37:34were world champions. They knew exactly what it felt
- 37:36like to be the fastest man on track.
- 37:39So yeah, hypothetically I think it would have been possible.
- 37:43I think he would have been able to do it even with obviously,
- 37:46like you said, Roman, the undercut of the car advantage
- 37:49that they had. Regardless of that, I think he
- 37:51would have been able to do it. But if he actually had anything
- 37:54else to give in practice, I think is probably less likely.
- 37:58In the entirety of the 2016 season there were only three
- 38:01drivers who qualified on pole, Lewis Hamilton, Nico Rosberg and
- 38:04Daniel Ricardo, and four drivers who won a race.
- 38:07Lewis Hamilton, Nico Rosberg, Daniel Ricardo and Max
- 38:10Verstappen when he won in Barcelona and he became the
- 38:13youngest ever race winner in the history of Formula One.
- 38:15Was this the point? Where the rivalry between Red
- 38:17Bull and Mercedes truly emerged, the culmination of which we saw
- 38:21back in 2021 between Hamilton and Verstappen.
- 38:24I think it was the very, very early stages.
- 38:27I think after that through 2016, the regulations that followed
- 38:30Red Bull as a team just got better and better until Daniel
- 38:34Ricardo left and that they'd struggled with, you know, drive
- 38:37second seat syndrome, which they still, which is still prevents
- 38:41this day. So I would say it was the start
- 38:44of it. Yeah, this was the start of
- 38:46Total Wolf having a very love hate relationship with Christian
- 38:49Horner and him just always kind of throwing a wrench and their
- 38:53plans. But yeah, I mean, they were so
- 38:54far ahead. Does it really matter?
- 38:56Did Total really pay any attention to it?
- 38:59Probably not a terrible amount for sure.
- 39:01The first incidents in a long rivalry.
- 39:05Just as a final question to round off our discussion of the
- 39:072016 season in this ever famous rivalry, F1 has seen so many
- 39:11different driver pairings over the course of its 75 years of
- 39:14existence. Some have been incredibly
- 39:16successful and others have been disastrous, and yet there are
- 39:19comparisons to be made between perhaps every single one of
- 39:22those pairings. So my question to you both is,
- 39:26do you think we could ever have another driver pairing like
- 39:28Hamilton, Rosberg or do you think we've already had one?
- 39:31Or is it simply just not possible to get 2 drivers like
- 39:35this again? I don't know if you wouldn't,
- 39:37you can't like copy. I wouldn't say you can like you
- 39:38get a copy and paste exactly the same relationship because I mean
- 39:43a lot of the drivers on the grid now did go through the junior
- 39:46formulas at the same time, competed against each other,
- 39:49etcetera. But I don't think in the way
- 39:51that it was they were in, I don't think you get rivalry in
- 39:55the current grade that is very similar to what they have.
- 39:58The current grade, No, I don't think.
- 40:01I mean, as Rohan was saying, to know someone since you were 14
- 40:04years old and then to become kind of like enemies.
- 40:07I mean pretty much enemies is so interesting and it makes the
- 40:10title so interesting. So if there's 214 year olds out
- 40:14there right now who are battling it out and are best friends,
- 40:18then and both of them make it to Formula One possibly.
- 40:21So I think it's only possible to.
- 40:22See, not the same situation, but a very similar one, but of the
- 40:27current grid. I don't think there's any anyone
- 40:30who could recreate that kind of rivalry.
- 40:33I was. Thinking very long and hard
- 40:34about my answer to this question, even though it's my
- 40:36question that I came up with and I kind of decided that you can't
- 40:41replicate exactly what Mika Rosberg and Lewis Hamilton said.
- 40:45I don't think that that's possible because I think also
- 40:48knowing what their individual parts into Formula One were as
- 40:52well, there's too many different characteristics.
- 40:55But also at the same time, I do think that there is a potential
- 40:58for a very similar situation on the current grid.
- 41:01And I'm going to say it's if George Russell and Alex Albon
- 41:04ever had the chance to be as part of the same team.
- 41:07Because I think obviously the 2019 rookies, which are Orlando
- 41:11Norris, George Russell and Alex Albon came into F1 together.
- 41:15Obviously Alex Albon lost a season when he was demoted from
- 41:18Red Bull and then rejoined. And funnily enough, Lando Norris
- 41:22and George Russell will be celebrating their Hundred and
- 41:24Grand Prix in Las Vegas later on this week.
- 41:26But I think George Russell and Alex Album being on the same
- 41:28team would be a similar situation to Rosberg Hamilton.
- 41:34And I think that because like I said, they went through the
- 41:36junior formulas together, there is mutual admiration from both
- 41:40drivers about the other driver. I mean, George Russell to the
- 41:44extent saying that obviously when I'm departing Williams, I
- 41:46want Alex Album to come and replace me.
- 41:49Them being support to each other throughout about the junior
- 41:51formulas, obviously the tumultuous relationships that
- 41:54they had throughout the junior formulas as well, despite the
- 41:57success that they had, I think there could potentially be
- 42:00potential there. I'm not putting this out into
- 42:03the world. I would not like that to happen.
- 42:05I really like the 2019 rookies, but also at the same time, if I
- 42:09ever had to pick a pairing I would have my eye on the two of
- 42:11them. I like it, I agree.
- 42:13Like I mentioned at the start of the episode, the 2016 season was
- 42:16certainly one for the ages and as much as there's still so much
- 42:18to say about it, I'd like to turn back to F1 in 2025 as we've
- 42:22had some headlines of our own in the last week.
- 42:25Both of my Co hosts are smiling for all the wrong reasons
- 42:28because they know exactly where I'm turning to 1st.
- 42:30So the place I'd like to start today is something that I've had
- 42:33many conversations about over the last week and that is with
- 42:36Sky Sports Halo. In case you missed it, Sky
- 42:39Sports launched A, and I'm doing this in quotation marks little
- 42:43CIS channel for women, for female sports and for female
- 42:48fans of sports as well, with very interesting marketing and
- 42:52headlines and just at all around very question marked approach to
- 42:58marketing. So I'm not going to say much
- 43:01more because both of my Co hosts I know have a lot to say about
- 43:04this topic so I'm going to hand over to them.
- 43:06I feel like I'm going to walk on egg shells when I say this.
- 43:08I think the idea is to highlight the fact that, you know, women
- 43:11as an audience group are obviously a growing part.
- 43:14Like growing fan base in sports is important thing.
- 43:18I don't want to like offend anyone.
- 43:20I say I think because obviously it's true women in, you know,
- 43:23our growing group is, you know, part of the sports fandom
- 43:26generally, not just in motorsport and stuff.
- 43:28But apart from that, I don't know what the hell they were
- 43:30doing. I mean, first of all, you've got
- 43:32an account on TikTok that already has 4.5 million
- 43:36followers and gets good engagement and stuff like that.
- 43:39So why are you making a separate one now?
- 43:41Second of all, why are you calling it a little cyst?
- 43:44I said quotations because that is a bit is it?
- 43:48I think the words patronizing, you know, why isn't it equal?
- 43:51Why are you making a separate one anyways?
- 43:53And also the fact that I mean, I don't know what not sharing all
- 43:57this like, you know, this stuff is, but I feel like that's just
- 43:59a bit stereotypical and you're I just don't get what the hell
- 44:04they were thinking in the amount of work that goes into social
- 44:07media strategy and stuff like I don't know what they're thinking
- 44:10like. And also the content just felt a
- 44:13bit weird. Why are you posting a random
- 44:15Earling Harling goal with like, what was it like hot girl Walker
- 44:19something? I say that again in quotation
- 44:20and exhausting that I don't what the hell they were thinking.
- 44:23I just think it's the worst thing that Sky Sports have done
- 44:25in a while since they raised my subscription price.
- 44:28I mean, I'm just so grateful because I can't understand
- 44:33sports if there isn't pink lettering.
- 44:35And even though I have a we have a podcast about Formula One
- 44:38where I give my takes every single week.
- 44:40I and edit articles about it. I just have no idea what's going
- 44:44on and to have someone explain it to me in such a patronizing
- 44:48manner is so helpful. Be so for real.
- 44:51Come on, like who signed off on this?
- 44:54Who? Because I'm ready to throw hands
- 44:57like I under. Not really.
- 45:00I see what they were going for in that they want to highlight
- 45:04women's sports. That said, the fact that you
- 45:06feel the need to create a new account to highlight women's
- 45:11sports says enough about it as it is.
- 45:13The fact that you don't feel comfortable putting women's
- 45:16sports in a highlighted position or women in sports highlighted
- 45:20on your main page says enough as it is without the complete
- 45:24disaster that that account was. I'm just like, I'm fuming.
- 45:28Clearly like women who play and watch sports deserve better than
- 45:33a senseless idea designed to make us feel inferior.
- 45:36I, I mean, my whole life as a female sports fan and someone
- 45:41who plays sports, obviously you feel the difference in women's
- 45:45sports compared to men's sports. And I do believe it's getting
- 45:48better. But it's things like these that
- 45:50set us back. And I mean, I just, I can't
- 45:54even, I mean, even if the account was genuinely showing
- 45:58women's sports and genuinely painting them in a normal light,
- 46:02it still wouldn't be a good account.
- 46:04Because the fact, as I said, the fact that you feel the need to
- 46:07create a new account to talk about women's sports says enough
- 46:11as it is, without marketing it as as well, the little sis of
- 46:15the main account. What are we doing?
- 46:17It just feels like the worst possible decision from a
- 46:20marketing perspective I could have come up with in my head.
- 46:24This is still 150,000 times worse than that.
- 46:28It just, and it's like what you said, Marie, knowing that
- 46:31obviously, especially in recent years, female involvement in
- 46:34sports, whether that's as athletes or whether that's as
- 46:36spectators and fans has exponentially increased.
- 46:39And there's so many different reasons for that.
- 46:41As someone who's been a sports fan for a very long time,
- 46:43obviously I watch F1, I watch football as well, Knowing that
- 46:46whenever I tell someone new about that, I'm often asked
- 46:50questions like, well, can you explain the offside rule?
- 46:52OK, what's DRS? Questions like this, marketing
- 46:55strategies like this reinforce this idea that women almost have
- 47:00to women almost have to be bigger fans to be able to
- 47:04justify why they are interested. And it's not.
- 47:06This isn't a small platform. This is not a small broadcasting
- 47:10team. This is Sky Sports.
- 47:11They have rights to almost every single sport that's out there.
- 47:15And to have this kind of rhetoric come from a
- 47:17broadcasting team like this, I think it's just so, so
- 47:20disappointing, So incredibly disappointing.
- 47:22Because again, it's just, it's this reinforcement time and time
- 47:26again for anyone who watches who feels like, who has ever been
- 47:30tested about why they're interested in something or why
- 47:32they deserve quote UN quote to be a fan of a sport.
- 47:36Yeah. I mean, the fact that I mean
- 47:38already before this, we have so many good, you know, female
- 47:43content creators talk about sports like Motorsport Diaries
- 47:47or this person I watch on TikTok called Tony, who explains like
- 47:53the tech and politics of F1. If anyone's ever yet she's
- 47:55really good. The Bernie, Bernie Collins's
- 47:59grid walk when she went to go and talk to all the a lot the
- 48:02women on the grid doing, you know, whether a part of the team
- 48:05or guest or whatever. There's so many.
- 48:07That was Sky Sports itself. You know, there's so many all
- 48:12established and of concurring people who are talking about
- 48:16women sports fans and sports and etc.
- 48:20I just think it's a really patronizing, tone deaf thing
- 48:23from a major media organization. I just I can't even I think the
- 48:27only thing careful when I say is interesting that there's so many
- 48:30accounts that just come to take the big out Sky Sports.
- 48:34So like there's an interesting one where someone set up an
- 48:37account. I don't know what it's called.
- 48:39It's just making like jokes about it and see other people's
- 48:42reactions to it like other like content creators and people
- 48:47online are saying that it's definitely interesting one.
- 48:49Or even ESPN has a very similar thing.
- 48:51They have an account called like, ESPNW, but I mean, they
- 48:55genuinely showcase women's sports and don't put glitter
- 48:59pink texts all over them. And it's like genuinely a good
- 49:01account which has had good reception and is established.
- 49:05And I mean, also shout out Bernie.
- 49:07Her book is also very good. Everybody should read it.
- 49:09But yeah, I think it's very much one thing if you have a small
- 49:13creator doing this or some random guy with a podcast.
- 49:16I mean, I say this as we have a podcast, but some random guy
- 49:19with a podcast and saying bad things about women's sports, I
- 49:22mean, that's one thing. But to have, as you said, Mahama
- 49:25major broadcasting organization that is gigantic throughout the
- 49:29globe, putting something out like this, it's just so tone
- 49:33deaf. And I was very thankful for my
- 49:36F1 TV subscriptions. Yeah, I just think Sky Sports
- 49:40the right thing. They've apologized, move on and
- 49:43literally never do anything like this for the rest of eternity.
- 49:49And, you know, don't screw up like this.
- 49:51And you know, it's, I feel like I'm talking to a child or
- 49:54something. Don't mess up.
- 49:56Don't rate the rules. Don't do something you shouldn't
- 49:58do. I mean, just don't screw up.
- 50:01Don't find people like this. I just find it shocking knowing
- 50:04that what kind of teams, and again, I watch football and I
- 50:07watch F1 on through Sky Sports, so I can speak for the
- 50:09broadcasting teams for that. But I know, like I said, there's
- 50:12countless different sports that Sky has the right to through Sky
- 50:15Sports, knowing what kind of commentators and broadcast
- 50:18journalists they have as part of their teams, specifically in
- 50:22those female broadcast journalists, female presenters,
- 50:24female commentators, knowing the kind of women that work within
- 50:28these spaces to then also have this rhetoric at the same time,
- 50:31it just feels like all the hard work that these teams do to put
- 50:35representation out there, the two steps, for example, that
- 50:38they might have taken forward accounts like this, rhetoric's
- 50:41like this, take them 15 steps back.
- 50:43And it's kind of like this is very counterintuitive,
- 50:46incredibly counterintuitive. And it's the word that
- 50:49everyone's been using to talk about this.
- 50:51It's just patronizing. It's to give the impression that
- 50:54sport is honour level that cannot be understood by certain
- 50:58audiences unless it's given to them in specific ways.
- 51:02And I just think that that's just not OK in any context that
- 51:05is not OK. But turning to better female
- 51:07representation Motorsports, it was announced that the
- 51:10partnership between Formula One and F1 Academy would be
- 51:13extending with all the teams on the current grid recommitting to
- 51:16FIA F1 Academies running their liveries next season and beyond.
- 51:21With even better news, Cadillac ahead of their arrival on the
- 51:24grid next season and has also committed to a team running
- 51:27their livery as part of the series.
- 51:29Can I get your thoughts on the future of F1 Academy, what this
- 51:31means for potentially a female F1 driver in the future, and
- 51:35just this exciting new venture that Susie Wolf has really taken
- 51:39to the top? I mean, I was watching her in
- 51:41through the High Performance podcast the other day and she
- 51:43was explaining about how like there were so many challenges in
- 51:47setting this up and there was pushback.
- 51:48And so, but it's great to see in the long term how it's
- 51:51succeeding now and how the F1 teams are so focused on helping
- 51:55these people on, you know, working with the teams and
- 51:58stuff. It's great to see Cadillac as
- 51:59well doing that. I think in the long term of
- 52:02seeing a female of 1 driver, I think it's in the long term,
- 52:06yeah, absolutely possible. I mean, I think anybody in
- 52:09motorsport, you know, an ideal world would have, should have
- 52:13the same chances of getting to Formula One or another senior
- 52:16level of motorsport rather than gender and ETC.
- 52:21So it's great to see that this commitment is being renewed for
- 52:24the future and helping women rise up the round sport rounds.
- 52:28Right. And that it's grown so much so
- 52:30quickly. You think back to 2023 when the
- 52:33series first started and you couldn't even watch the races
- 52:37really anywhere. They didn't broadcast them.
- 52:39It wasn't synced with the Formula One calendar.
- 52:41It was kind of just like its own thing.
- 52:43It's in its own world. And now because of Susie, it's a
- 52:47huge thing. And obviously they have a really
- 52:50tight title, title battle going into Las Vegas this weekend and
- 52:53they're synced with the Formula One calendar and they have all
- 52:55this kind of partnership with Formula One teams that really,
- 52:58really helps drivers under. I mean, the world of Motorsports
- 53:02is so difficult to understand, so difficult to make your way
- 53:05through. So to have partnerships with
- 53:06Formula One teams or at least big brands that can get you
- 53:10sponsorships and get you to certain series is so important
- 53:15and is so necessary to help to help these people get to where
- 53:20they want to be, whether that be Formula One or as you said,
- 53:24Rohan, another high level Motorsports series.
- 53:28And I think also one of the best in the long term of things like
- 53:31F1 Academy, helping to get names out there so that they can be
- 53:35linked with the driver development programs or driver
- 53:38academies is also just so incredibly important as well.
- 53:41McLaren released a statement to say that they have added two
- 53:44drivers to their development program and now they have 3
- 53:48Ellas driving for them as part of the development program,
- 53:51which I think is super cool. And obviously they're having a
- 53:53blast with their marketing with Ella Squared.
- 53:55But funnily enough, one of the Ellas that has joined the team
- 53:58is the daughter of Mika Hakanen, who was obviously a very famous
- 54:01driver for McLaren. So it just goes to show that
- 54:04it's series like these don't exist in a bubble and having
- 54:08sponsorships from F1 teams is not maybe to a certain extent
- 54:11it's F1 teams just saying, Oh, well, we can do this because it
- 54:13looks great for us from a marketing perspective.
- 54:16But also in the long term for these athletes that are involved
- 54:19in series like these, it can make a really huge difference
- 54:23just knowing that you almost, you have a foot in the door
- 54:26because you're already driving one of their cars, so to speak.
- 54:29So I think the future of the series I think looks really
- 54:32good. I think Susie Wolf is absolutely
- 54:35incredible. She's been a pioneer for women
- 54:37in Motorsports for so many years now, whether it was as a driver,
- 54:40now on the management. Side as well.
- 54:41I'm really looking forward to seeing what she continues to do
- 54:44with the series. And yes, it was a very that was
- 54:47a very welcome piece of news in comparison to everything that
- 54:50was going on with Sky Sports Halo.
- 54:51Now I think that I've saved this topic for last because this team
- 54:54in particular have been the topic of many of our
- 54:56conversations on the podcast since we started running it.
- 54:59The three of us, however, I'm like normal I'm not going to be
- 55:02discussing their on track performance or lack thereof, and
- 55:06instead I'm going to pivot and look at their management
- 55:08instead. Recently, in response to Lewis
- 55:10Hamilton and Charles Leclerc discussing the lack of
- 55:12performance in their Ferrari this season, John Elkin turned
- 55:15to the media and said that his drivers, quote, need to focus on
- 55:19driving and talk less. End Quote.
- 55:21Now I know I have a lot to say on this topic so I'm going to
- 55:24hand. Over to you both 1st and just
- 55:25say what are your thoughts on this state I.
- 55:27Think it's also a bit more interesting he's defending the
- 55:29engineers. I don't where that's coming
- 55:32from. I mean, I just don't think
- 55:33publicly criticizing any member of your team is really a smart
- 55:38thing to do. I mean, Formula One is a team
- 55:41sport. I don't think singling out agree
- 55:42whether it be the drivers, the engineers or and another part
- 55:47member of the team or of the team achieves anything apart
- 55:50from like to me feeling naming and shaming.
- 55:53Like, I just think it's a bit of a weird thing for someone's sake
- 55:57of his stature to say in public. How about you talk less and
- 56:01focus on management more? That was my reaction.
- 56:04We'd be docking the dog and not walking the walk.
- 56:06Like, come on. Yeah.
- 56:08I mean, if you had a driver that was outwardly saying to the
- 56:11media every single weekend, our team is terrible, I'm never
- 56:14going to win anything. This is horrible.
- 56:16I can't believe the team is abysmal.
- 56:19Like, OK, fine. Then you can say that.
- 56:21How about you pay? How about you pay the fine that
- 56:24they get if they don't complete their media duties so that they
- 56:26can have more time in the debrief?
- 56:28That was my other reaction. Because you say you want them to
- 56:31talk less. Well, they're literally
- 56:32obligated to talk to the media. Like, I don't know what you want
- 56:35from them. It's not like they're popping
- 56:37went out of their house and saying hey guys, I got dirt on
- 56:40Ferrari. No, they're giving their honest
- 56:42reactions, which are very, very polite considering the place of
- 56:46the team at the moment to the media because they are literally
- 56:48obligated to or they will get fined.
- 56:50Like, this is not a, this is not a situation where you have
- 56:54drivers who hate the team and are bad mouthing them at every
- 57:00opportunity. They're two drivers who are
- 57:02incredibly loyal to the team and incredibly devoted for the sake
- 57:06of their own careers to the future of the team.
- 57:09So to have someone say something like that is just, I mean, if I
- 57:13was Charlotte Claire and Lewis Hamilton, I'd be like, what do
- 57:15you want from me? Like I, I'd be appalled
- 57:19genuinely. And yeah, especially when you
- 57:21have two drivers who we know are so good and you have a car that
- 57:27is slower than a tractor. I don't think the drivers are
- 57:30the issue. But anyways I.
- 57:31Want to pick up on what both of you have said.
- 57:33I'm going to start with Rohan's comments about it being very
- 57:36driver focused. I think this is a rhetoric that
- 57:38we've seen time and time again from Ferrari and obviously their
- 57:41last drivers title was Kimi Raikkonen in 2007.
- 57:45So that says everything it needs to be.
- 57:47It has always been the drivers that have been focused on by
- 57:50higher management in terms of looking at why the team is not
- 57:53successful. Now they've changed drivers.
- 57:55We've had, that's Sebastian Vettel, we've had Felipe Massa,
- 57:57we've had Kimi Raikkonen, we've had Fernando Alonso.
- 58:00Now we have Charles Leclerc and we have Lewis Hamilton.
- 58:03Of all the names I have listed, you have multiple world
- 58:05champions in that list and not just one title, 247 titles in
- 58:12order with Fernando Alonso, Sebastian Vettel and Lewis
- 58:15Hamilton. So you've changed the drivers,
- 58:17that hasn't changed anything. You've changed team principles
- 58:19and that also hasn't changed anything.
- 58:21The only thing that has not changed, which each driver that
- 58:24I've listed has was alluded to in one way or another, has been
- 58:28the engineering department has been the team that guide the
- 58:31development of the car. I don't think that you can get 2
- 58:34drivers more committed to Ferrari than what you already
- 58:37have. Charles Leclerc I'm pretty sure
- 58:39bleeds prancing horses as opposed to as opposed to just
- 58:42red blood. And Lewis Hamilton gave up a
- 58:45very comfortable existence and F1 experience at Mercedes to
- 58:49jump ship to join a Ferrari project that he believed in.
- 58:52I do honestly believe that's why he joined the team.
- 58:55And yet Despite that, to go into the media and say they need to
- 58:58focus on driving and talk less. Honestly, if you look through
- 59:01the media that they've actually been doing and what they've been
- 59:04saying about the car, I don't think anything is as horrific as
- 59:07what it could be considering, like you said, Marie, the car
- 59:09that they're actually driving and the pace that they're able
- 59:11to produce them. So I don't know, maybe Ferrari
- 59:14need to have a good long look in the mirror over the winter break
- 59:18ahead of next year's regulation changes and see if there's
- 59:22something major that they haven't looked at that could be
- 59:25change that could give them the speed and the titles that they
- 59:28want. Right.
- 59:29And I think, I mean, I know you said earlier people need to have
- 59:32a shorter memory in this situation.
- 59:34People need to have a longer memory because I believe it was
- 59:37four years until Michael Schumacher won a championship
- 59:40with Ferrari. I mean, of course, Michael
- 59:42Schumacher, one of the best drivers in the history of
- 59:45Formula One, it took him four years as a team to be
- 59:48comfortable there enough and to develop the car enough to have a
- 59:52championship winning car. So for Lewis to not even have
- 59:56completed his first season and they're already ringing alarm
- 1:00:01bells. I think is it's a little early
- 1:00:03and they kind of need to look at history and say, OK, well, maybe
- 1:00:07it's going to take longer than two races for someone to get
- 1:00:10caught up with a car and develop it exactly how they want it to
- 1:00:12be. Sean Todd also like a phenomenal
- 1:00:15team principal who led the team to multiple World Championships.
- 1:00:20The exact year is escaping me, but again, took him multiple
- 1:00:23years. I.
- 1:00:24I almost believe it was 7 or something close seven years at
- 1:00:28the team to be comfortable enough there and to have a car
- 1:00:31that he, you know, has developed and to have drivers and whatever
- 1:00:35it might be. So Fred Vesser obviously only
- 1:00:38joined the team in 2020, second, third year.
- 1:00:41So just the team in terms of its core of the team principal and
- 1:00:45the driver have they're so new and they really understand so
- 1:00:52little of the car at this point in time that it's just
- 1:00:59completely unrealistic that you expect these people to be at the
- 1:01:03very, very top fighting a fighting for a championship.
- 1:01:06Just give them a little, cut them a little slack and get some
- 1:01:09more engineers because them talking about the situation at
- 1:01:14the team candidly yet extremely politely is not the issue.
- 1:01:19Yeah, I'm really interested to see how this is going to
- 1:01:22translate out obviously into the final three races of this season
- 1:01:25and then moving forward into the next set of regulations.
- 1:01:27I have my eye on Ferrari for 2020 and beyond.
- 1:01:31I have my eye on a lot of teams but Ferrari specifically, I want
- 1:01:35to see what they have planned and what they have in store and
- 1:01:38I'm going to reserve all judgements until I see the
- 1:01:42lights go out in Australia and we're racing for the first time.
- 1:01:46That's all from us for our rewind episode looking at the
- 1:01:482016 season and the infamous rivalry between Lewis Hamilton
- 1:01:51and Nico Rosberg. On behalf of myself and my
- 1:01:53wonderful Co host, thank you so much for listening and we hope
- 1:01:56that you enjoyed the episode. If you enjoyed the episode and
- 1:01:58would like to hear more dive on podcasts then please do check
- 1:02:01out the Formula E and IndyCar podcasts also hosted by
- 1:02:04incredible teams. Join us next time where we will
- 1:02:06be discussing the final of three American races on the calendar,
- 1:02:09the Las Vegas Grand Prix.