Latest / Stories and a Cup / From Christian Roots to Embracing Islam
Transcript
- speaker-0: As-salamu alaykum. Welcome to a new episode of Stories in a Cup. Our story today begins in California and stretches across faith, family, and quiet courage. Our guest's journey began in California and Idaho in a deeply religious Christian home. She's the oldest of three sisters and she learned very early on what it means to lead to question and to carry responsibility, sometimes silently. Her journey towards Islam didn't begin with certainty. It began with curiosity, conversation, and eventually a relationship that would change the shape of her life. Through meeting her now husband, she was introduced to Islam not as a destination, but as an unfolding process. A process that required patience, inner work, and moments of fear she didn't always know how to name. For a long time, her faith journey remained private. Telling her family felt heavy, wrapped in worry, judgment, and the unknown. And yet in a quiet moment of intuition, her mom had already sensed the truth and met it not with rejection, but with unexpected support. In 2012, she married, celebrating love across Turkish culture. And then over a decade later, her story is not just about conversion, but about belonging, family bonds, and what it means to choose a path that feels true even when it's misunderstood by others. This is a story about faith that unfolds gently, about love that bridges worlds, and about finding home in places you never imagined. Let's begin our conversation today with Tara. Thank you, Tara. Hello. We're going to start our episode today about her faith journey. But before we dive into that, I would love to start with a little bit of history and context. regarding your childhood. So you were saying you grew up as the oldest of three sisters in a Christian home. So let's start there. Why don't you give us a little bit of information about your childhood, basically. speaker-1: Yeah, so I grew up with two younger sisters. We lived in California when I was first born, and then we ended up moving to Idaho when I was about seven years old. So I spent most of my childhood and teenage years there. My childhood actually was a little bit rough because ⁓ my parents got divorced ⁓ soon after we moved to Idaho. ⁓ And it was a very... kind of scary situation. There was domestic violence involved and stuff, it wasn't a good situation for us or my mom. So there was a lot of, I have a little bit of like childhood trauma around stuff like that. Biological father is no longer my life actually. He made a bunch of very bad decisions. But I basically haven't even talked to him since I was like 10. So maybe even before 10. But I think it was even through all this, these struggles that we had. My mom felt that it was very important for us to have a strong moral base. ⁓ And so I think once we got through a lot of that and tried to get back settled down, she did encourage us going to church. And eventually when I was in late elementary school and early middle school, we found a church ⁓ that we could call home and we've made a lot of friends and we started attending regularly. it was actually, it was a big part of my childhood. And I honestly, one of the things that helped shape me into who I am today. It did really give me a good support group, a good group of friends that to help keep me on a straight path, as it were. Yeah. And keep me kind of centered and out of trouble. Looking back, I mean, it was, even though I don't agree with a lot of the things anymore, it was still a good place for me at that time. And it was good for our family at that time. speaker-0: Yeah. And growing up between California and Idaho, how did those environments shape your worldview at that young age? speaker-1: I'm part Mexican, so my biological grandfather was Mexican. I mean, California's very diverse, so it's always... ⁓ We grew up, when we were there, there was a big family. Moving, it was a smaller community, more conservative area. Idaho is very conservative. But there was a lot of good people. And so I think that's something that I always remember even now and thinking about, you know, think about the political situations now. I know there's good people who are Christian. And so. and I still have family who are Christian. Allah guides who He wills. But for me, I definitely feel like there are some Christians that I believe are true believers. And maybe they haven't got to that point yet or haven't admitted it or haven't heard the right thing. But I've met Christians that had more faith than some Muslims that I've met, you know. And I believe it is true. It's, you know, they believe God and they believe they know God and they pray to God. And when you When you grow up being told and knowing something completely different too, it's hard to judge that, you know, especially if all they've heard of Islam is bad things. speaker-0: Yeah. So when did Islam first enter your life, Tara? So not the concept of Islam, but like as a lived experience. speaker-1: That was when I was in college. I moved to Albany, New York for college and lived there for about four years. And within the first year of being there, actually, I met my husband and he was my first boyfriend. And so he was my first experience with Islam. I met him and got to know him. And like you said, first lived experience. Of course, I'd heard things and wasn't that open-minded at that time. But I think as a lot of people do when you go to college, you do start opening your mind to different things and you meet new people. I went to a college before I went to Albany. I went to a two-year women's school with girls from all over the country and all over the world even. Like they were international students. And so I had gotten to be friends with a lot of different girls. Actually, some of them were Muslim, but we didn't really talk about faith at all. There wasn't much. Like it was kind of like back in my head, I know they're Muslim, but it wasn't something we ever talked about or never that I really observed or anything. So my first really up close encounter with Islam was my husband. speaker-0: And was there a moment when curiosity shifted into something deeper? Or was it like a slow unfolding? speaker-1: I think for the most part it was a slow unfolding. think there was one thing that always kept me really curious and trying to understand and struggling with, which is that you always heard that Muslims were bad people, but he wasn't. And so I was trying to kind of reconcile this with, you know, what people are telling me and then this isn't what I'm seeing and there's something there. Like what is, why would people think that? And so I think that sparked this curiosity and trying to understand more about Islam and Muslims and, I mean, of course, ultimately understanding that there was nothing to be afraid of, you know. ⁓ speaker-0: in general, is that what you were hearing? speaker-1: think it was more kind of in general that ⁓ Muslims believed dangerous things and were scary people and ⁓ there's different aspects of that. There's ⁓ the aspects of you heard in the news and 9-11. ⁓ yeah. Because I was in, I think it was my senior year in high school when 9-11 happened. that wasn't that far, you know, distant from that. But also Growing up Christian, and like I said, I was very heavily involved in the church and I was in the youth group and I was on the youth leadership team. And so we had conversations at points about other religions, including Islam. And I remember the things, I mean, we were told that we were told reasons why Islam was wrong and why like theologically that we shouldn't believe it began Christian was right and Islam was wrong. And then we were told, I mean, you know, the typical stereotypical bad things they tell you. that why Islam is bad. Many of them lies or misunderstandings or incorrect translations of the Quran or taking things out of context, you know, things about the Prophet, things about Aisha, you know, those kinds of things. And so I had all this in the back of my mind too, which was making me confused. ⁓ speaker-0: I can imagine, of course. speaker-1: told that this, this, and this, and then it's not lining up kind of. But that also was a driving thing in wanting me to learn and get more information about what exactly Islam was instead of just the talking points that Christians have about why it's bad. speaker-0: And I'm just imagining, so you were raised in a conservative Christian family and meeting your now husband and your initial experience of being close to somebody who's Muslim. When and how did that shape how things changed for you? speaker-1: Yeah, so at first when we were dating, we didn't talk too much about religion. I think we were both, I knew he was Muslim, he knew I was Christian, and we didn't push the issue too much. But then as we had been together for longer and we started getting more serious, of course it's something that you have to start thinking about and talking about. When we first started actually having conversations about it, there was a lot of arguments. had studied a lot, I knew the Bible a lot, I'd read a lot of it. And as Christians, we were told, ⁓ basically you have to believe the Bible, it is God's word. And so whatever the Bible says, you have to believe. It's not a choice, it's not something to think about or consider. It's difficult to argue with someone who doesn't... agree with that. And I think I'd never really been in a situation like that where you have to try to defend what you believe because somebody else believes something differently. And so at some point we both kind of agreed to just agree to disagree and we're not gonna talk about it because it would get us nowhere. know, we just go in circles. The primary thing that we would argue about, well, is Jesus God and no, he's not God or yes, he is God and how could he be God's son? And my husband tried. But honestly, I think that I struggled with the way he was framing it. The way he framed it to me was, God doesn't need a son. And so he doesn't have a son. Why would he need a son? But for me, that argument didn't make sense because God is God. And if he wants something to happen, he can make it happen. So I never really fell for that. Like it wasn't something that I was like, okay, that makes sense. For me, it doesn't make sense. know, God can make things be whatever way he wants it to be. So, like I said, eventually we were just like, okay, forget it. We're not gonna talk about this anymore. It's causing too much arguments. Yeah, we're just gonna drop it. But it was in that space of deciding to not talk about it with each other anymore that it gave me more... freedom, think, and more peace to be able to learn about it more myself. And so ⁓ I went on this spiritual journey. ⁓ It was, I read a bunch of different books basically. And there are several books that were pivotal in that journey. But basically, know, learning more about Islam, what is Islam, what people believe, things like that. Stories about converts. So experiences of, I think that was kind of later, a little bit later in the journey, experience of converts and what had led them to Islam. historical books. like actual like histories written by historians of like what is true? What are the things that aren't really up for debate? What is the facts of the situation? And I was trying to read things that were balanced too from both sides. I read other books too that weren't specifically about religion but still were part of my journey. Like eventually I got to the point where I realized that there were a lot of similarities obviously between Christianity and Islam and that was making it even more confusing. Yeah, I imagine. But at some point you have to get to the point where it's like speaker-0: Thank you. speaker-1: In order to be a Christian, basically have to believe that the Bible is true. And being a Muslim means you believe the Quran is true. And so that's what I would say that comes down to the core of it. And because I think I had already kind of learned from the stuff that I read about Islam, that there is that belief that it is unchanged, that what we read today in Arabic is the exact same thing that was revealed to the prophet. Peace be upon speaker-0: peace be speaker-1: So then I just needed to better understand where the Bible comes from. And when you go down that road, it's not very clear. There's a very confusing, you look at the Old Testament and there's a lot of different things that could have been or not been included. When you look at the history of the New Testament and where it came and how it got together, I learned that there was actually at one point a lot of different writings. that were produced around the same time by people who were disciples of Jesus or who had listened to his message, things like that. So it had put a lot of doubt. speaker-0: Yeah, it looks like it really took a long time for you. A lot of research, a lot of digging, a lot of trying to understand and make sense. And I'm thinking about you, so you were in your 20s? Yeah. Yeah, and did you have any support? Did you have any friends that you could talk to about this or were you kind of just doing this on your own? speaker-1: I most, I was doing it on my own. I didn't talk to very many people about it. I think I, at one point I tried to reach out to my old youth pastor and ask him some things, but he never responded. And I think he was upset about. the question even, because we were taught that you don't question things, right? Which is quite different from Islam, because you are encouraged to question and to think and to have this, you know, knowledge to understand what you believe. I know I talked to my sister a little bit about it, not much, that I was just, I was looking at it and researching. But yeah, for the most part, it was just on my own. I was always a big reader. I want to say am, but with kids in a business, it's not. I don't have much time for reading anymore, but I used to read a lot and I love to read and so at that time in my life that's what I was reading. Just a lot of different books about Islam and Christianity and yeah. speaker-0: I'm just thinking about, you know, your 20 plus self that is going through all of this turmoil and you must have had like fears and worries that came up about even telling your mom or your siblings, you know, that you're going through this. speaker-1: Yeah, I did. I was scared. And that's why I think even when I was just researching it, I only had told one of my sisters we were close. I think she lived here at the time too. And so I think she was the only family member that I had even mentioned that I was thinking about it. Because I, know, growing up in a Christian house and I had assumptions about what my family would think and... that they'd probably be upset and they wouldn't like it and how would they react and how would they treat me differently and yeah, so it was scary. speaker-0: And then around when did that moment happen where you were like, okay, think this is starting to make sense. speaker-1: So I think it was 2010. So it be almost 16 years then. I do want to say first. After all the reading I had done, I had read about everything that I could think that would be useful for me to read and all this stuff about history and everything. And I finally got to the point I said, okay, I need to read the actual Quran now. You know, I've put it off long enough. Let me open it and see what it's actually saying. And I opened it and I read Fatiha and I started crying. because Fatiha is exactly the prayer I had been praying for years. speaker-0: Subhanallah. speaker-1: Because throughout my journey, I just, I kept praying, asking God to please show me what is right. Let me know what is the path I should take, what I'm supposed to believe, show me your truth, you know. I believed in God. I just wasn't sure which, you know, was the path of truth and what I was supposed to believe about God. And so I was constantly praying to ask for guidance and to ask to be shown what was that path. So when I saw that and I was like, ⁓ my God, this is, you know, exactly. I think at that moment, in my heart, I knew that this was right. And it just, it felt so true and authentic and correct. so, but it took my mind a little longer. So ⁓ I continued reading and trying to understand and learning. it probably wasn't too much longer. I don't remember exact timeframe, but one night it was in Ramadan. speaker-0: Panalas, panalaya. speaker-1: It was my first Ramadan that I was fasting. I was fasting with my husband. One night we were reading the together. We were each reading and I'm sitting there and I just stopped and said to him, I realized that now when I'm reading the Quran, I'm not reading it anymore, trying to understand is this true or not? That I'd gotten to a point where I knew it was true. And I was just reading it just to try to understand what it was saying. it wasn't a judgmental thing anymore, if is this right or not. Yeah. Yeah. So I realized that there was that shift in me. And my husband said, well, I think that means you're Muslim then. And I was like, huh, I think you're right. And so we talked about it. speaker-0: there was a shift. speaker-1: you know, a little bit and then I decided to take my Shahadah with him that night. And later he told me that that night actually happened to be the night that the scholars believe most likely is Laylat al-Qadr. So I didn't even know. But Subhanallah, was ⁓ amazing to like look back and think about that. Yeah. speaker-0: Subhanallah. So, how did you navigate moments of like, concern and judgment or fear from your loved ones after sharing that there was a shift and that you were ready to revert? speaker-1: So after I became Muslim, I didn't still tell anyone for a while. I think I felt safer to just, and none of my family lives here, so it wasn't hard to like not tell them because we didn't get to see each other very often and so it was just something I could keep to myself for a while. So eventually, I think I told my sister first and she was like, yeah, I'm not surprised. I thought that's probably what would happen. So I was like, okay. And it was like, not a big deal. I had visited my mom a little bit after that. I think it was probably within a year. And I got up the nerve to tell her too. And she was so kind and I was just so, I was shocked actually. Because I was expecting that she might be upset. When I first started dating my husband, she was upset. But I think in that time period of, it had been several years, you know, and she'd gotten to know him and to see who he was and what kind of person he was. And there's nothing to be scared of, you know? And so when I told her, she was also kind of like, I was wondering if that might happen, you know? She was expecting it. was kind of expecting it. And she said, and I told her I was scared to tell you, and she had said, I don't really care if what you've decided to believe what your religion is. I just wanted you to be able to choose that for yourself and that she didn't raise us Christian just so that we could stay in that. And it wasn't the kind of thing that was meant to be like, you need to do this. It was more of, like I said, just for some moral guidance. And she wanted us to be, you know, have good people around us and to not get in trouble. Yeah, it was a huge relief because I just like, oh, I've been worried for nothing, you know? I think after I telling her, I slowly told other people in my family and at least I told all the people that were closer to me. And I think they took care of telling more extended family. So, the word spread. I didn't have to. speaker-0: I'm sure that was a relief. travels very fast speaker-1: to have that conversation with every single person. But yeah, it was a relief that she was very supportive about it, yeah. speaker-0: So you've been Muslim now for... speaker-1: Almost 16 years. speaker-0: Masha'Allah. And as an American revert of Mexican slash European descent, correct? Would you say that your sense of identity evolved all through the last 15, 16 years after you reverted to Islam? speaker-1: Yes, definitely. think because I think a big part of one's identity is their religion, especially when you're in with something that like Islam where it is a way of life. Some people take religion, even Muslims, as more of a I'm born into it, I'm Muslim or I'm Christian, you know. We call them Sunday Christians or, know, Ramadan Muslims. So, ⁓ but. for those who live their faith, which is more of a daily kind of thing, which I did as a Christian as well, or I tried to do. I think it really does shape your identity, and so there was definitely struggle in the beginning of trying to shape a new identity while still staying the same person. Of course you're not still the same exact person because, you know, things have changed but at the core you're still the same. My husband likes to tell me he thinks that I was always Muslim kind of but I didn't know it. Yeah. Because I was always... I guess the odd one out with friends even like I didn't really drink very much. you know, I always tried to be a good person and to not get involved with sins or anything. I did my best to behave and be a good person. So he told me, you have that heart that you were probably always a Muslim. You just hadn't found it yet. ⁓ But in the beginning, ⁓ there was still that struggle with identity of trying to... speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: figure out how to move forward. And a lot of it had to do more with people's perception of me. I know one of the biggest struggles in the beginning was clothes. ⁓ yeah. speaker-0: ⁓ yes, yes, of course. And we have to talk about that, because I guess that's what led you to your whole business idea. speaker-1: is because I... that it was such a struggle. Because also I didn't want to suddenly start... I felt it wasn't good for myself to just suddenly overnight start dressing completely differently. So it was a gradual shift. Just trying to, okay, maybe I'm not gonna wear tank tops anymore. Let's wear short sleeve but make sure that's high neck, you know? So the the pant legs and the arm like... Lengths started getting longer slowly, you over time until eventually I was completely covered, but people still might not know it because I, it wasn't loose or it wasn't typical like what you'd think a Muslim would wear. I didn't start wearing hijab at first either. So it was a, I want to say probably, three or four year time period that it took for me to like start dressing more modestly and wearing hijab. And even when we opened our business, didn't wear hijab at first. I felt guilty about that because I'm like, I'm selling hijabs, but I don't wear hijab. But I didn't want that to be the reason I started wearing hijab either. I... I just, had to give myself the time to get there until I was ready. Yeah, I think one of the big things that I struggled with in trying to dress more modestly was that most of the modest clothes available in the U.S. are geared towards older generation. And so they're not the clothes that I necessarily want to wear. And, but then a lot of the traditional Muslim clothes that I would find if I tried to go look somewhere or online. weren't me either. And so there was, it was kind of like, I don't know what to wear. I have nothing to wear. Or like if it's, you stock up in the fall and winter on stuff, but then in Texas, I you're going to cook if you wear that stuff in the, in the summers. My husband, he's Turkish. So the first time I went to Turkey, I was in awe. speaker-0: The summer of f***ing my goomies. speaker-1: with the clothes because I was like, this is what I've been missing. This is what I need. Because I felt like Turkish clothing had that blend of it was modest, but it was still fashionable. And it was still stuff that I could see myself wearing. So it was this kind of styles that I like to wear just cut more modestly. And so I really resonated with me and I felt like there must be other women that feel the same way, you know? Whether they're converts or not, like, I'm sure there's other women out there who would like these clothes too. speaker-0: ⁓ absolutely, we love your store. Ever since this store started a while back and you know, I hear everybody saying at least there is somebody thinking about us. speaker-1: Yeah. So when we first started this business, we didn't have clothes at first because clothes are, hard to get into. So when we founded it, it was in 2011, we knew that we were going to have clothes at some point. That was the goal. That was the end goal. We just had to build up to get there. So we started out with hijabs. We thought this is an easy thing to start with, you know, and then slowly worked up to the clothes. Yeah. speaker-0: So from your experience and journey, Tara, what would you want families to know when a loved one chooses a journey that they don't necessarily understand? speaker-1: I that... I know... I always try to put myself in the other person's shoes and think about what they might be going through, so... It can be hard when you are on the other side of that. I do know people who have come to Islam and their families weren't supportive because they felt that it was a betrayal. That you're denying the things that I gave you and I raised you with this and you're telling me that that's wrong. And I feel like people sometimes take it really personally and they think it's more of an affront to themselves or a betrayal of that. But I think it's understanding that that's not what it is. It doesn't have to do with the other person at all. I think it's more about, you know, someone finding what is true for them and what they believe. And so while it can be hard to watch someone, you know, turning away from what you believe, I think still showing them love and support and trying to be there for them, it goes a long way. And it can definitely keep the bond strong and keep you together through that. speaker-0: Yeah. How's the bond between you and your mom today? speaker-1: Yeah, it's good, Alhamdulillah. I think we're pretty close. think even, I mean, closer than I say we were, you know, before Islam. speaker-0: It's a panel line. speaker-1: I think there's a lot of things that have changed that and not necessarily Islam. Becoming a mom was, I think for a lot of women, it opens your eyes to realize, wow, this is what my mom went through. I'm sorry, mom. I forgive you whenever struggles you have because it's hard. And then of course, Faith teaches us that our mom is the most important person in our life, besides Allah. That it's very important to keep that bond with your mom and to take care of your mom and support her. And so that's what I've tried to do. So we're good. Even though she doesn't live here, unfortunately, she lives in Arizona. But she is... trying to move here, inshallah. ⁓ that's wonderful. Yeah. I think that she's been able to see over the years that, you know, at my core, I still am the same person, even though I may dress differently and my faith is different, that underneath I'm still her daughter, I'm still the same person. So. ⁓ speaker-0: Beautiful. Yeah. So if you could speak to Tara in her 20s right now, what would you tell her today? speaker-1: I would say that Allah has some very special plans for you and not to worry because Allah is going to take care of you. speaker-0: Today, when Tara feels stressed or like needing grounding or comfort, what do you gravitate towards? speaker-1: I want to say peace and quiet. speaker-0: Mmm, your office. Mashallah, very peaceful here. speaker-1: Thank you. I'm a bit of a loner. And so sometimes things get too chaotic and stressful and you just need a minute, you know? But I want to say to... having those like. heartfelt prayers and duas to Allah. I don't do it enough right now, I think. But it does really. It can be very soothing when you just kind of open up and release, you know, to Allah what your fears and worries and stresses are. I think that's something that I learned more in Christianity that I think that has carried through. It's more trying to have more of a personal connection. God knows what... He knows what you need. and he knows what you should ask for, but he wants to hear you sometimes telling him and coming to him. And so it can be very comforting to have those moments where you just open up. And I think whenever I have, if I look back at the times, whenever I was at my darkest hours or most difficult times in my life, and I had those times where I had those heartfelt conversations reaching out to God, trying to connect, they were always answered. Even with my husband. Before I met him, it's one of the things I told him later. I prayed for him, actually. Because when I had first moved to Albany, I was so lonely. And I prayed to God, please bring me someone, you know? And it wasn't that long after that, you know, that I met him. I see you. speaker-0: a very special connection with prayers. speaker-1: Yes, prayer. Yeah. Like I said, I don't do it enough now. ⁓ I think like all Muslims, I've gone through ups and downs in my faith. I struggled a lot after I had kids, but Alhamdulillah, I've been slowly making my way back to that, having a closer connection with Allah, inshallah. speaker-0: Inshallah. Thank you so much, Tara. Thank you for sharing your beautiful journey with us and for the beautiful inspiration that you have given to other people who may want to start this kind of journey and who may be afraid. Your message is powerful. I truly appreciate this. Thank you. speaker-1: Yes, thank you and thank you for inviting me. think I don't do this type of thing very often, but ⁓ so it is a little bit scary to like put yourself out there, but inshallah it does help other people going through similar things or struggling, know, so inshallah. speaker-0: May you be rewarded, inshallah. Thank you. speaker-1: you