Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep15: GRD015: Should I Downsize in Retirement?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott, and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:48to your own personal situation to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: Welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate, Ed, I am fired up
- 1:06for our next episode and ready to argue.
- 1:09So tell me, Ed, what are we arguing about?
- 1:12Ed Slott: Well, here's an interesting point.
- 1:14Should I downsize my home in retirement?
- 1:17I get that question a lot from clients, especially older ones like me, and I have
- 1:21to remind our listeners, Jeff and I have a generational divide, so our point of view
- 1:26could be, uh, skewed towards that age.
- 1:29Jeff's about 30 years younger than me, so I may have a different point on that.
- 1:34Uh, as usual, we'll flip a coin to see which side of
- 1:37the debate we'll come out on.
- 1:39You ready?
- 1:39Jeffrey Levine: I will say, Ed, we're, we're finally getting to the point
- 1:41though, where we have about the same amount of hair between the two of us.
- 1:46Ed Slott: Yeah, that's why we do audio podcasts.
- 1:49Jeffrey Levine: That's all right.
- 1:49You, were headed, you know, it was kind of a weird race here, you know?
- 1:52First I had more hair than you had more hair, and now we're tied, so, yeah.
- 1:55Ed Slott: Right.
- 1:57Jeffrey Levine: Alright, well that's an interesting one, Ed,
- 1:59your topic, i'm gonna call it, I'm gonna go, uh, I'm gonna say tails.
- 2:03Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:06Tails.
- 2:07Jeffrey Levine: Tails!
- 2:08I finally win one.
- 2:09You know what?
- 2:10My natural inclination would be to argue in favor of downsizing,
- 2:13but I'm gonna go the other way.
- 2:15Um, and I'll, and I'll, and I'll say, I'm gonna go the other way
- 2:18because of a particular interaction, uh, with a client of mine.
- 2:21And that is, I'm going to say, I'm gonna argue in favor of not downsizing.
- 2:26My beginning point that I'd love to make, uh, just to kick it off, is
- 2:30when I envision myself, you know, one of the things that uh, I can
- 2:33share now is recently I've built a house, uh, that is, is meant to be a
- 2:38forever home and it's a larger house.
- 2:40Uh, you know, there's plenty of room for our family now, but also plenty of
- 2:43room for our family as our family grows.
- 2:46I'm lucky enough to have three healthy boys, God willing,
- 2:50one day they all grow up.
- 2:51I mean, the oldest right now is only eight, so it's many years from now.
- 2:54But God willing, they all grow up.
- 2:56They find, uh, you know, people that they love to spend their lives with.
- 2:59And maybe at least one or two of them, maybe all of them, uh, end up, you know,
- 3:03bringing home grandchildren one day.
- 3:05I'd love for this place to be the place where we can all gather.
- 3:10Each and every year for those important holidays, continue family traditions, etc.
- 3:14And I had a client who, who did this in retirement.
- 3:17He actually upsized because of that.
- 3:19Ed Slott: Oh boy.
- 3:19Jeffrey Levine: He wanted to have a place for his family
- 3:22to come spend in retirement.
- 3:23He said it was the best decision that he's ever made.
- 3:26And I look at all the memories that he's created in that house
- 3:28with his family, and I just want the same for myself and my family.
- 3:32Ed Slott: I can see that.
- 3:33But again, as a grandparent and say 30 years you're a senior.
- 3:37Uh, you know, I have to..
- 3:38Jeffrey Levine: Say that one more time.
- 3:39I just like to hear that.
- 3:40Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 3:40I want people to know where I'm coming from.
- 3:42It used to be the American dream was to own your own home.
- 3:45Now it's getting the kids out of it.
- 3:48Uh, I think if you have a large home now you talked about your
- 3:52three boys bringing everybody home.
- 3:55What if they're still living there?
- 3:57Uh, , you know, it's very common now.
- 4:00In today's economy, people coming back in.
- 4:02I like the idea of downsizing, just to simp again, simplify my life,
- 4:08get rid of otherwise my, my kids will end up cleaning up the mess.
- 4:12All these little things.
- 4:13You know, I had this, uh, when my mom died, we're going
- 4:16through all this stuff now.
- 4:17She did downsize after my father passed away, but my
- 4:20father was more in your school.
- 4:22He loved having the house and everybody came over the house, but after he passed.
- 4:27So it may be what situation you're in, uh, as a single person, you might
- 4:32be better off downsizing because you don't have to worry about if you have
- 4:35a home cutting the lawn and doing all these chores around the house and just
- 4:39having, making life simple, less bills to pay and less things to take care of.
- 4:45I always say same thing with your investments.
- 4:46People always ask me about having all these IRAs have 50 IRAs, you
- 4:51only need one IRA, you know, . So sometime it just makes life simpler.
- 4:56If you downsize, plus you can get your money out of the house at the top
- 5:00of a market and, uh, even rent, you might not even have to buy something.
- 5:05Jeffrey Levine: Well, you know, the, those are, uh, interesting,
- 5:09interesting points, Ed.
- 5:10And I think one of the things that I would, uh, you know, that that kind of
- 5:14hits me as you talk through that, is the idea of simplifying life as you get older.
- 5:19And I understand that, and in fact, that's probably the most common
- 5:22argument I hear from folks is, I don't want to take care of this anymore.
- 5:25It's too much house for me.
- 5:27I've gotta worry about this breaking and that breaking.
- 5:29But I think one of the other things that's important to realize too,
- 5:32is that as you get older, you know, there is some benefit to routine,
- 5:36particularly for those who begin to lose, you know, cognitive abilities, etc.
- 5:41There's a lot of evidence that would show that, you know, maintaining a consistent
- 5:45routine can help improve quality of life.
- 5:49You know, think about going from one place to another and then all of a sudden not
- 5:53remembering, you know, where you know where the bathroom is or where you store,
- 5:57you know, the, the drawer that you have your brush in for the last 40 years.
- 6:01It's kind of, you know, It's just mem it, it, it's automatic for
- 6:05a lot of people at some point.
- 6:06And then to have to pick up and move into a new environment can be challenging.
- 6:10And all the gains that are made, let's say, from not having to pay
- 6:13the, you know, the lawn bill, well, so much of that today can be automated
- 6:17with auto payments and so forth.
- 6:19Or with a good power of attorney being able to take care of that for you.
- 6:23But those little things and the comfort of being in a place that you have
- 6:27known for so long is also one that I would, you know, would point out.
- 6:32Ed Slott: And you could be comfortable.
- 6:33Those are all good points and absolutely health is a big, is
- 6:38the, the big factor in all of this.
- 6:41Do you have the wherewithal?
- 6:42It depends.
- 6:43Maybe you're taking care of a spouse or maybe as I said, a
- 6:46spouse has died and you're alone.
- 6:48You might like to be in more of a community in a smaller apartment or
- 6:52condo complex where there are people around that things are taken care of.
- 6:57So it's, uh, I think health is a big thing, and lifestyle.
- 7:01Maybe you wanna travel more and you don't have to worry about locking
- 7:04up the house every time you go away.
- 7:06You just, you know, if you're in an apartment or a condo or
- 7:09co-op or something, you lock the door and you're on your way.
- 7:12You don't have to worry about any of these things.
- 7:14So again, I like the idea, uh, not me personally, but the idea of simplicity and
- 7:22not having to worry about other things.
- 7:24As you get older, people don't wanna worry about a lot of other things.
- 7:28You know, there's something to be said for a, a nice big, comfortable house,
- 7:32but you can have those same comforts, uh, in a smaller home or an apartment
- 7:36or a condo or something like that.
- 7:38And, uh, sometimes in some of these things, as you've seen, uh, I
- 7:42mean, they're all over the country.
- 7:43I was gonna say Florida, but they're all over.
- 7:46Uh, you have amenities, you have your own small unit, but you have
- 7:49access to all kinds of amenities and activities and other people, and that's
- 7:54really important if you're alone.
- 7:56Jeffrey Levine: Now I got another one for you, Ed.
- 7:58I'm gonna have to go to the financial side of this because I have a feeling
- 8:01arguing on, on, on the practical side, it's gonna be a losing battle for me.
- 8:05So I'm gonna go to the financial side of this for a moment and say, If you
- 8:09have, uh, you know, purchased a house that has gone up significantly in value,
- 8:14the, there is under current tax law, an exemption for a certain amount of gain.
- 8:19If you are a single individual, you have up to $250,000 of
- 8:22gain that can be tax free.
- 8:24If you are married and file a joint return, you can have up to $500,000.
- 8:28But as home prices continue to increase, and we've seen substantial increases
- 8:33in recent years, and as we start off with larger amounts, it takes
- 8:36a smaller percentage gain to exceed those 250 and $500,000 thresholds.
- 8:42And if you are going to go and sell your.
- 8:45And your gain exceeds those excludable amounts, that gain is actually taxable
- 8:51to you even though you're not able to like depreciate unless you're
- 8:54taking a home off this deduction, but you're not generally able to like
- 8:56depreciate your own personal home.
- 8:58And if you lose money on your house, you don't get to take a a, a loss.
- 9:03You do have to pay taxes, uh, income tax, that's capital gains tax, plus
- 9:08the 3.8% sur tax if your income exceeds certain amounts on the
- 9:12gain from the sale of your house.
- 9:15But if you hold onto that house and you enjoy it throughout your lifetime, when
- 9:20you pass away, your heirs will be able to get that house with what they refer
- 9:24to as a step up and basis, meaning..
- 9:26Ed Slott: Right.
- 9:26Jeffrey Levine: You could have bought your house for 500,000, you know, 40 years ago
- 9:31now it's worth two and a half million.
- 9:32You have $2 million of gain and that entire 2 million can escape
- 9:37taxation forever, as long as you hold onto it until you die.
- 9:42Ed Slott: Well, you know, that's true.
- 9:44And I thought about that for myself.
- 9:45Do I wanna sell the house or maybe just hold on to death
- 9:48and get the step up in basis.
- 9:51My heirs won't have to pay any tax on it, but that's more about them than me.
- 9:57Uh, it's about my lifestyle and maybe I don't want to
- 10:00keep a whole house like that.
- 10:03And first of all, uh, there's no guarantee the market, well,
- 10:07I shouldn't say there's no.
- 10:09There is no guarantee the market will always go up, even though traditionally
- 10:12for like our lives, 50 years.
- 10:15I mean, I think of it, my father bought the house, my mother sold for 16,000.
- 10:19She sold it, you know, only a few decades later for half a million dollars.
- 10:22It's crazy.
- 10:23Same house.
- 10:24Uh, so there, there is that, uh, but, the reason I was thinking of
- 10:30maybe downsizing is to aleve other people of all the record keeping, I
- 10:35was thinking of all the improvements.
- 10:37You talk about the gain, but the longer you're in a house, the, the
- 10:41more likely it is you put tens, if not hundreds of thousands into it.
- 10:45I mean, if you're in a house 30, 40, 50 years, there's certain things,
- 10:49Jeffrey Levine: New roof, new heater.
- 10:51Ed Slott: Yeah, you, it wouldn't be standing if you didn't put tens
- 10:54of thousands of dollars into it.
- 10:56So maybe this is the time to, you know, it won't de tax, your issue
- 11:00won't be as much as you think.
- 11:02First of all, a married couple.
- 11:03If you're thinking while you're married, you do get the 500,000.
- 11:07It's double.
- 11:08So, uh, that, that may cover a lot of the gain.
- 11:11Remember, the 500,000 is not off the selling price, the gain, and the gain,
- 11:16the selling price less your original cost, plus all of those improvements.
- 11:22Now, true what Jeff said, you don't need to know any of that
- 11:25if you hold it till death.
- 11:26Everybody, uh, the beneficiaries get the step up and basis, but then,
- 11:30uh, that's like I said about the beneficiaries, making it easier for
- 11:34them and a little easier for you maybe cause you don't wanna change anything.
- 11:38So you keep piling on your junk in the house for somebody else to take away.
- 11:42And at some point, I think I'd like to just simplify and, uh, you know, get a,
- 11:48a smaller place and maybe there might be some tax to pay, but it all depends
- 11:53on how much you put into the house, but then it's, it's a lot simpler.
- 11:57You don't have to worry about all these things.
- 11:59And a lot of the things I said before about, uh, especially if
- 12:03a spouse has died or you are, you don't have a spouse and, you just
- 12:07wanna be active with people there.
- 12:09You know, you, you know, these places here, the villages in Florida,
- 12:13these people love that stuff.
- 12:15Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 12:15They love a lot of things, ed.
- 12:16Uh, I mean, I'm sure you've seen the reports that it is the, uh, you know,
- 12:20Ed Slott: Yeah, yeah, don't even go there..
- 12:21Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 12:21Right.
- 12:21Yeah, go ahead and Google the Villages folks.
- 12:24If you don't know what I'm talking about.
- 12:25Ed Slott: All what Jeff is talking about is that they love life.
- 12:29Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, they love love, yes.
- 12:31Yeah.
- 12:33Yeah, that's, uh, it's an interesting place.
- 12:35Uh, you know, I would also say, Ed, you know, one other thing on, on the,
- 12:39the, the financial side of this is that, you know, most people when you
- 12:43think about retirement, they've got a tremendous amount of assets, or, or at
- 12:47least a lot of people who are probably listening to this type of podcast
- 12:49have a, a significant portion of their assets tied up in financial assets.
- 12:54Things like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, etc.
- 12:59And if you sell your house and you walk away with a boatload
- 13:02of cash, what are you gonna do?
- 13:03You're probably gonna go and invest it in stocks, bonds, mutual funds,
- 13:08ETFs, your house while you own it, is effectively a, a non correlated asset
- 13:13with the market, with stocks and bonds.
- 13:15In other words, it's a, it's a diversifier to your portfolio.
- 13:18And while someone listening may say, yeah, but I can't spend my kitchen.
- 13:23You can in a way, right?
- 13:24There are home equity loans, there are reverse mortgages, which,
- 13:29uh, are much, much more cost affiction and much more regulated
- 13:33than they were in previous years.
- 13:35Not advocating for it today, maybe on a future podcast, I'll have to, uh, but you
- 13:39know, there are all these things that come up from time to time and, and ultimately,
- 13:44you know, that is, your house is an asset.
- 13:46There is a way to access the value in your house.
- 13:50While you are still there, and even if the market, the stock market that is, is down
- 13:55the real estate market, your house may still be valuable enough that you can take
- 13:59a loan from that of substantial amounts.
- 14:01And in fact, sometimes you may even want to access the money in your house as
- 14:06a loan to avoid selling when the stock market is down to give it time to recover
- 14:11before you sell those financial assets.
- 14:14Ed Slott: Right.
- 14:14Uh, that's, that is a good financial argument that you can
- 14:17tap the funds, but you still have to deal with maintaining the home.
- 14:22And I know some people tell me they keep the home because they
- 14:25wanna leave it to their kids.
- 14:26At 90, uh, I heard this is not a statistic, it's just something
- 14:30somebody said, but it makes,
- 14:31Jeffrey Levine: It's just something you made up, but it
- 14:32sounds good for the podcast.
- 14:34Ed Slott: Somebody else made up.
- 14:35He was talking about reverse mortgages, that's what
- 14:37reminded me when you said that.
- 14:38He said, and there's probably some truth to it.
- 14:4199% of homeowners, parents, uh, think their kids want the house when they die.
- 14:4899% of kids don't want the house.
- 14:50They want the money.
- 14:52Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, I would agree with that.
- 14:53And I mean, forget about that.
- 14:55What if you differ in opinion?
- 14:56Right?
- 14:56I mean that's, uh, you know, that is one that, uh, you know, you'll notice that I
- 15:00definitely didn't use that as an argument.
- 15:02That it's what the kids want.
- 15:03Ed Slott: What do you mean different opinion with the two spouses?
- 15:05Jeffrey Levine: No, the two kids.
- 15:07Right.
- 15:07Like what if
- 15:07Ed Slott: Oh, the kids.
- 15:08But I, I, when you said that, I was thinking of my parents,
- 15:10they did differ in opinions.
- 15:12My father wanted to stay in the house.
- 15:14He was just like, your first argument, this is my palace.
- 15:16This is where everybody comes.
- 15:18I'm not moving.
- 15:19But he died early, , and it didn't take a year or two.
- 15:22My mother said, I'm outta here.
- 15:23I'm doing what I always wanted to do, get my little apartment.
- 15:26She sold the house and she didn't even buy anything else.
- 15:29She just rented and it worked out great.
- 15:31The money lasted up for the rest of her life.
- 15:34Jeffrey Levine: Sounds like a win.
- 15:36Ed, I don't know.
- 15:37It's a good discussion.
- 15:38I, I don't have, I have I convinced you, are you rethinking selling your house now
- 15:42or do you still think you'll downsize?
- 15:44I think that may be the ultimate judge of how we debate.
- 15:46Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 15:47I still would like to downsize cause I'd like to do it on my terms, see what goes
- 15:52and, you know, take care of everything.
- 15:54So I don't leave other people a problem, but there's another side to that.
- 15:58Leave them the problem.
- 15:59Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 15:59That's what I'm gonna do.
- 16:00Ed Slott: A step up and basis.
- 16:01They can hire accountants and attorneys.
- 16:03They'll have plenty more money.
- 16:05Yeah,
- 16:05Jeffrey Levine: I've got probably 30, 40 years before I have to make that decision.
- 16:07But that's my, that's where I'm leaning at least for right now.
- 16:10Ed Slott: All right.
- 16:11Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 16:11There we go.
- 16:12Well, you know, another, another fun, uh, discussion Ed, and, you know, certainly
- 16:16two sides to this coin, as there are with, uh, most everything in life, but..
- 16:20Ed Slott: This is very practical.
- 16:21This is a lot of people, uh, are grappling with this now.
- 16:24Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, yeah.
- 16:25But, but our listeners, you know, their life and their retirement
- 16:28decisions are too important to leave up to that coin flip.
- 16:31So, you know, that's why the one thing Ed you and I always agree on
- 16:34is making sure that, uh, people are talking with a knowledgeable financial
- 16:39advisor or tax professional when it comes to any sort of big decision.
- 16:43This way they can weigh the pros and the cons of different options against their
- 16:47specific set of goals and objectives.
- 16:49As a reminder, if you'd like to continue the discussion with Ed
- 16:52and I, we love to hear from you.
- 16:54Uh, we always look forward, uh, to seeing what's coming through
- 16:57in our inboxes or on Twitter.
- 16:58You can reach out to Ed on Twitter using the handle @TheSlottReport.
- 17:01That's with two ts, @TheSlottReport.
- 17:05Or you can reach out to me using the handle @CPAPlanner.
- 17:09Once again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 17:12Uh, and we would love to hear from you.
- 17:14Let us know what you thought.
- 17:15You think you're gonna downsize, you're gonna stay in your current home.
- 17:18Why?
- 17:18And if you have a topic for us for a future episode, we'd love to know.
- 17:23Ed Slott: Well, I think it's important we hit good topics, uh, good points on
- 17:27this, but one of the big points, I just wanna reiterate the point you made, you
- 17:31have to really have some good records.
- 17:33I mean, you have to know what you paid.
- 17:35You talked about the gain.
- 17:37You have to know what you paid, and a lifetime's worth could be
- 17:40decades worth of improvements.
- 17:42You know, pe sometimes people don't keep records.
- 17:44This is one area where you've had to keep these records
- 17:47forever, as long as you own that.
- 17:49Because everything you can prove will increase your basis and may get you to
- 17:54the point that you can sell with that $500,000 exclusion and have no tax.
- 17:59Anyway, something to think about and we'll see you next time on
- 18:02the Great Retirement Debate.
- 18:06Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 18:09This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 18:12not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 18:15Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 18:18which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 18:21Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 18:24completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 18:26The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 18:29and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.