Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Moments That Matter from Cerebral Valley London
Transcript
- 0:00This episode is brought to you by Forethought.
- 0:03Most companies build their customer experience in pieces.
- 0:06Sales in one system, support in another, and onboarding
- 0:09somewhere else. Forethought brings it all
- 0:11together. Forethought is an AI system
- 0:14made-up of advanced agents that handle sales, onboarding,
- 0:17support, and retention. Each team manages its own
- 0:21agents. The customer sees one unified
- 0:23experience. Forethought powers over a
- 0:26billion interactions every month for brands like Scale AI,
- 0:29Cohere, Air Table, and Upwork. Learn more at Forethought dot
- 0:34AI. Welcome back to America.
- 0:41I'm here with Max Child and James Wilstroman.
- 0:45Hey, guys. Hello, Eric.
- 0:47Hey, Eric. We, we had a fun European
- 0:50adventure, what, couple weeks ago with this Rebel Valley AI
- 0:55summit in London. Yeah, we, we had a blast.
- 0:58I don't know what. What did you guys think about
- 1:00it? I thought it was tremendous
- 1:01experience. I mean, it really drove home how
- 1:04exciting the AI scene is in Europe, which I think you know,
- 1:08in the sort of mobile and web eras, maybe the scene a little
- 1:11bit beleaguered compared to America, but I felt like AI
- 1:14startups and and big companies are totally popping off there.
- 1:17I mean, we had granola, we had Lovable, we had Synthesia photo
- 1:21room and then you know, on the big company side, obviously we
- 1:23had Wave and Uber, which was super exciting and so.
- 1:26Well, in classic Cerebral Valley, I feel like the the
- 1:29buzzy startup founders are the real celebrities.
- 1:31You know, it's like, I mean, people are excited about Dara
- 1:34and we had Dylan Field at Figma, which, you know, what was like a
- 1:37week away from filing its S1. But yeah, I feel like the
- 1:41lovable guy and the granola guy, you know, we're definitely sort
- 1:45of people of interest at the event.
- 1:47My Spidey sense for for startup heat was was very was very
- 1:52tingly around the lovable guy. He was he was Anton.
- 1:56I interviewed him. But like, even just walking in,
- 1:57he was being surrounded by like investors and partners and other
- 2:01startups and you could just he was a look, get the vibe he's a
- 2:04little mini celebrity in the the AI scene.
- 2:07He's a He's a Unicorn now. He's a.
- 2:09Unicorn now as of like today or yesterday?
- 2:12Yeah, how how many? Like how many coding AI adjacent
- 2:16companies are unicorns now? We've got like lovable replet
- 2:20cursor windsurf. It's just like goes on and on.
- 2:24And the narrative moves so fast. Are are is is it good to be a
- 2:28coding startup now or are we already like oh man cost of
- 2:31goods sold and everything are out of control?
- 2:33And Windsurf was falling apart and luckily they were able to
- 2:36save it. I don't know, right?
- 2:38Since Cerebral Valley, though, we've had people like bouncing
- 2:41between anthropic and back and to cursor and back, and we've
- 2:45had this whole saga of windsurf getting chopped up.
- 2:49I don't know if I had to stick my finger in the air right now.
- 2:53I feel like the mood is it's good to be a model again.
- 2:56I mean, you've got a a big sentiment that anthropic and
- 3:02clawed are key to coding and you sort of rather be anthropic than
- 3:06cursor. And obviously we're recording
- 3:09this on Thursday, it's coming out on Friday.
- 3:11I mean, open AI just get a live stream about agents and seems
- 3:15like, oh, we're figuring out this agent thing.
- 3:17I don't know, you know, they're they're at once, I think they're
- 3:19trying to be supportive of MCP, you know, the sort of generic
- 3:23open source interface across agents.
- 3:25But then they're making the announcement that like, oh, that
- 3:28thing you're trying to build a company around.
- 3:29Yeah, we do. We do that too.
- 3:31So I guess my take at the moment is models back in ascendancy,
- 3:35which you'd hope so given their valuations.
- 3:39Yeah. I mean, I think obviously we've
- 3:41had this debate a million times, but I think ultimately it is
- 3:43good to be the company that has put, you know, 5 to 10 billions
- 3:48of dollars to work on something rather than the company.
- 3:52So, yeah, yeah, yeah, that that then the company that is
- 3:56slightly repackaging the thing the other guy did for five to
- 3:59$10 billion. Like, I mean, there are
- 4:01obviously I think application use cases here, but you know, in
- 4:04the sort of. Bullish on applications, yeah.
- 4:06Oh, no, I, I am bullish on applications, but I do think,
- 4:09you know, anything that's sort of close proximity to the model
- 4:12itself, which I think a lot of these coding startups are very
- 4:15close proximity to the model itself in many ways is a
- 4:18dangerous place to be because, you know, Dari, Dario and Sam
- 4:21have got their eyes on that space.
- 4:23It's like you don't want to be the most popular application
- 4:27that makes the most money because then you're square in
- 4:29the targets of the the foundation model labs.
- 4:33It's like you kind of want to be like making good money, but not
- 4:36like the number one use case of LLMS.
- 4:40We're going to get into clips so this episode is really we're
- 4:42going to engage with the key moments at this Rupal Valley AI
- 4:45summit, which I think will be fun.
- 4:46Well, you can go watch them all on YouTube, and I think they're
- 4:49all still pretty current even though AI moves fast.
- 4:52But we're bringing you our favorite clips so that if you
- 4:55don't have the time, you can get the best of what happened there.
- 4:58I wanted to say two different things.
- 5:01One on London. I think one thing I really liked
- 5:03about the event is that we took a sort of like, AI is global.
- 5:06We're not getting dragged into like, which city is the best?
- 5:09I mean, obviously London has deep mind and there are like,
- 5:11good companies in Europe, but it's like, yeah, it's a global
- 5:14world, all connected on the Internet.
- 5:15They're great people everywhere. Like, I think like half the
- 5:18audience was London and half came from elsewhere probably.
- 5:21Like, I don't know, 1/4 US and a quarter rest of Europe, I don't
- 5:25know. Yeah, decent amount of like
- 5:26France and Sweden and things like that for.
- 5:29Sure, though we had a train, yeah, Public transportation
- 5:32infrastructure, despite being like much, you know, better on
- 5:36its surface, uh, consistently we had transportation problems
- 5:40across Europe. Eurostar was in trouble from
- 5:44France, and then I had my flight deflayed out of France from an
- 5:47air traffic controller strike. So I don't know.
- 5:50They brag about public transit. There are transit and then they
- 5:53can't keep it working. It's like like their healthcare
- 5:56system or something you know works works great for most
- 6:00people most of the time and then falls apart at the at the
- 6:05limits. The other thing is we we have
- 6:07not officially committed to going back to London.
- 6:09This is, it's like we need, we need a sponsor bidding war
- 6:14between New York and London, between which one we had for
- 6:19first. So if you if you have a strong
- 6:21horse in the New York versus London race, reach out about
- 6:24sponsoring. I would just say in terms of
- 6:27vibes at the event, the the London audience was dramatically
- 6:31more engaged than the New York audience.
- 6:32I would say they were excited to be there.
- 6:36They stayed for the whole event. They they engaged with the
- 6:38speakers. They wanted to chat and meet
- 6:40afterwards, whereas well. Those New Yorkers, they're
- 6:42grinding. They're like, I don't fucking
- 6:44job like. New Yorkers are like, I've got a
- 6:46happy hour at 3:45 that I've got to be at, so the 4:30 speakers
- 6:51will not be. Fully attended.
- 6:53New York invited. Before I go back to work.
- 6:55Until, yeah, you live. In New York, you're a bit of a
- 6:57booster. You did have a little bit of
- 6:59like, you know, we had Goldman, we had Snowflake, it had a
- 7:02little bit of like big company tries to like embrace AI,
- 7:06whereas I do think it turned out that Europe had some of the
- 7:10cooler up and coming startups. I mean, I think Rogo, you know,
- 7:14which we had at the fintech event is buzzy New York
- 7:17application company. I mean, there's certainly, I'm
- 7:20sure if we dig dug into like finance AI startups, we'd get
- 7:24more of the like application excitement in New York.
- 7:27I flew back from San Francisco a couple weeks ago to be on a New
- 7:34York Tech Week panel. And of course, we, you know,
- 7:37from one of the New York boosters, Julie Samuels.
- 7:40I don't know who it is. I forget what our group is these
- 7:42days, but you know, does advocacy for New York's tech
- 7:45scene was like, oh, what do you think about the New York's tech
- 7:47scene? And I gave the most like, oh,
- 7:49pro San Francisco, just like, you know, the beauty of New York
- 7:53to me is that people come through.
- 7:54It's everybody's like second favorite city no matter where
- 7:56you are. But I'm not sitting here
- 7:58claiming that New York is the center of the tech universe.
- 8:02And they're like, you are not invited to next year.
- 8:05I know, I just believe I've said this a million times, but I
- 8:10agree with Ryan Hoover, the product hunt guy who said to me
- 8:15during the pandemic, Silicon Valley is online.
- 8:17Like come on, it's like it's on the Internet.
- 8:19Like who cares where people are? All right, back to the present
- 8:23moment. A lots happened we're in now
- 8:25this like AI spending war for employees, obviously with Meta,
- 8:29which is I think the most present happening.
- 8:32Obviously scale deal just happened when we started the
- 8:35London event Yeah, let's get into clips and let's react to
- 8:39some specific lines from the most recent Cerebral Valley AI
- 8:42summit. I mean in the Uber case, I mean
- 8:44you came in, you did spin out Aurora like how did.
- 8:48You we we merge ATG into Aurora. Yeah, and then became its own
- 8:52company. How did you decide, I guess that
- 8:55self driving wasn't there in 2017 or they this shouldn't be
- 8:59something to invest in or how did you go into sort of all your
- 9:02technologists saying, oh, we're just tomorrow, just tomorrow and
- 9:06say I'm not convinced. Listen, I I think Erica was a
- 9:09really tough decision at the time.
- 9:11And one is we were deeply marked by the fact that we had an
- 9:15accident, lost life there. And so the responsibility that
- 9:21you hold in your hands when you're operating in the real
- 9:24world hit us deeply. I think the other circumstance
- 9:30that affected the ultimate judgement was that we, we ran
- 9:34ATG very separately from mainline Uber because we wanted
- 9:39the opportunity to partner with the rest of the ecosystem.
- 9:41Again, like we, we don't just work with, you know, we don't
- 9:45just have Priuses on our platform.
- 9:48We got forth, we, we want to work with the entire ecosystem.
- 9:52And when I went and talked with some of the other AV developers,
- 9:55I'd say, you know, ATG, it's in the family, but it's separate.
- 9:59We're going to treat you fairly, we're not going to share data,
- 10:00etcetera. You know, when you're having a
- 10:02conversation, actually, like I usually do with you and I'm
- 10:05saying stuff and you don't believe a fucking thing I say,
- 10:07pardon me, That's that was the response.
- 10:11Like the we were having conversations, but I think
- 10:13people didn't trust us. Yeah, because they also viewed
- 10:16us, rightly so, as a competitor, right.
- 10:18So we had a decision to make. Do we go with a proprietary kind
- 10:24of vertical strategy or do we truly partner with the industry?
- 10:29We couldn't have the best of both worlds and ultimately we've
- 10:33started that a partial model was the right model going forward
- 10:36and based on, you know, basically all of the leading
- 10:39players sans Tesla, but everyone else is open working with us,
- 10:44etcetera, I think it was the right decision to make.
- 10:46I guess I don't really buy this explanation honestly, because
- 10:52like I if you think of like Amazon today, right, they sell a
- 10:56lot of their own, you know, Amazon branded products on their
- 11:00marketplace. It pisses off their suppliers
- 11:03and they do it anyway because it's a good, a good business
- 11:05idea. Like I I just don't really buy
- 11:07that this is a good enough reason not to invest in your own
- 11:09self driving technology just because other providers on the
- 11:15marketplace won't be happy about it.
- 11:17Right. I mean, the premise of my
- 11:18question was that I thought it was skepticism on the imminence
- 11:23of the technology working and Uber's team particularly working
- 11:28and Aurora, which is what they spun off has not really
- 11:31delivered on a major successful. That might be the real answer I
- 11:35but that was. So to me, I did think like a
- 11:38call on the quality of the technology was the reason.
- 11:41But I mean, I don't know, I take him in his face.
- 11:44I mean, it's interesting to that his actual first answer was that
- 11:49they had such a negative PR situation that could they really
- 11:53do it? And I, I think it's easy to
- 11:56forget how much Dara was brought in to like clean up the PR
- 11:59situation. It's like we had the hack.
- 12:01We and they had literally, you know, launched self driving cars
- 12:05in the firestorm of their PR nightmare without the approval
- 12:10of like San Francisco. It was like just brazen.
- 12:13I mean, I do ultimately think that if Uber can sort of
- 12:16maintain it's like marketplace, you know, middle man position
- 12:20between riders and drivers, even if the there are no drivers and
- 12:24then, you know, it's just way MO's or, you know, in the case
- 12:27of Serbo Valley London, it was wave they were partnering with.
- 12:29And it's plausible that for, you know, 120 different countries
- 12:33around the world, there's going to be, you know, 60 different
- 12:35self driving companies you need to ultimately partner with, you
- 12:38know, to, to serve self driving cars to people.
- 12:41And all these different locations that Uber may
- 12:43ultimately be the sort of aggregator of this need for a
- 12:47car, whether it has a person behind the wheel or not.
- 12:50Right. And I think if that strategy
- 12:51works, I think they're in an awesome position because kind of
- 12:54being the middle man in this massive market of personal
- 12:57transportation is, is really great.
- 13:00I think what's what's the challenge is in San Francisco,
- 13:03there's this sort of Waymo brand loyalty building among the tech
- 13:07community. I think like people like James,
- 13:10you know, are like, I basically only take Waymo's, even if
- 13:12they're take longer and they're more expensive.
- 13:14And I use the Waymo app, right? And so it's an interesting
- 13:17question. Like for someone like James, I
- 13:19would pose like if Waymo's were in Uber in any city you wanted
- 13:23to visit, and you could just instead of clicking Uber X, you
- 13:26click Waymo. Like would you just go back to
- 13:28using the Uber app because like sometimes you want to use the
- 13:32Uber X because it comes faster and sometimes you want to use
- 13:34Waymo because you like it more like, or would you be like, no,
- 13:37I'm always using the Waymo app, you know?
- 13:39I do think a lot of Uber success here depends on their ability to
- 13:43specifically convince Waymo that they should not deploy in every
- 13:47city and need to participate in the platform.
- 13:51I mean, you know, and they're running those experiments now.
- 13:54So it'll be interesting to see where Waymo thinks the power
- 13:57resides. Yeah, I think, I think I would
- 14:00that to that point, like if, if I know there's a Waymo's in
- 14:05certain cities that I can only access the Uber, it'll probably,
- 14:10you know, switch the habit back to just using Uber everywhere,
- 14:12including in San Francisco. If I can access Waymo's through
- 14:16through the Uber app. All of this though is just, you
- 14:20know, pointing back to my original point, which I just
- 14:22think Uber would still be better off if they owned something
- 14:27approximating Waymo right now. Like I just don't see a world
- 14:30where they are worse off if it's.
- 14:33Waymo Quality. If it's Waymo, sure.
- 14:36Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I who knows if they could
- 14:38have gotten there. Right, Amazon knows that they
- 14:40can deliver. You know, batteries just as well
- 14:43as Duracell or whatever, Yeah. And Costco and places they they
- 14:46pick lanes where they see where they can offer something.
- 14:50I'm not saying it was like a bad decision to spin this off
- 14:53originally, I just think disingenuous to say that he's
- 14:57only doing this for platform neutrality.
- 15:00Well. Literally like a day or two
- 15:02after the event, there was reporting in the New York Times
- 15:04that Uber might be working with Travis Kalanick to like acquire
- 15:08a Chinese self driving car startup.
- 15:10So it's, it's very possible this is on Dara's mind that we,
- 15:14they're all these Chinese startups that have actually
- 15:17caught up really well in self driving.
- 15:19And we spun off the one that wasn't succeeding and cost us a
- 15:23ton of money. Now everybody's ripping each
- 15:25other off and they're all going to catch up to each other just
- 15:28like the language models. And so then we have our white
- 15:31label version, so nobody can push us around too much Like,
- 15:35yeah, I think that's very plausible.
- 15:37And they skip a lot of the needless money losing that's
- 15:41hard to do on the public markets.
- 15:43It's like Google Pixel or something, right?
- 15:45Yeah. You want the flagship that just
- 15:47kind of shows how to do this and you want to learn even if
- 15:50you're, you know, also distributing Android to other
- 15:54phone makers. I do think, yeah, to Eric's
- 15:56point, Waymo is so head and shoulders above the field right
- 15:59now that you would just be terrified that you're going to
- 16:01lose Waymo. And so you got to balance these
- 16:02considerations of like, is it going to piss off Waymo if we
- 16:06work with this Chinese startup? Like, but what if Waymo just
- 16:09walks away tomorrow? Like we better have a backup
- 16:11plan, you know, so it's, it's a challenging place to be and.
- 16:13I think the Waymo brand is so good right now.
- 16:16You got started in like Jaguars. You have none of the baggage of
- 16:20like bad Uber rides. It's just like it's such a good.
- 16:25The MPs on Waymo has got to be like great relative for actual
- 16:29like riders. Yeah.
- 16:31Anyway, it's uh, it's, I mean, it's like a quintessential
- 16:34technology debate question, which is just like, what are the
- 16:37platform dynamics? Who actually has leverage?
- 16:39And it'll be interesting to see it play out.
- 16:41But it sounds like we all agree that it would serve Uber to have
- 16:45some credible self driving car technology of its own, at least
- 16:49to understand the fundamentals and have a little bit of a
- 16:53competitive edge against potentially bullying partners.
- 16:57All right, well, we did Uber. Let's do the other big headliner
- 17:00from the event, Dylan Field, the CEO of Figma, who literally like
- 17:05he seemed very busy when we saw him and I can see why.
- 17:10I think they literally flipped their S1 filing the next week.
- 17:14So very appreciative that he made it to London at sort of the
- 17:18busiest possible moment for a pre IPO company.
- 17:22I wanted to talk about sort of the company building piece of
- 17:24this for a second. I mean, you're, you're clearly
- 17:28sort of moving towards going public.
- 17:31I'm curious like what your decision making process has
- 17:34been. We're in this moment where
- 17:36Stripe, SpaceX, like it feels like they can stay perpetually
- 17:40private. What's sort of the impetus to
- 17:43potentially move Figma towards the public markets?
- 17:46Yeah. I mean I can talk like I told
- 17:48you about anything regarding like that process, but I think
- 17:53that just the important thing that I've been like making sure
- 17:58that I'm grounded in everyday. Whatever happens with going
- 18:02public, not going public is this is like the moment to make sure
- 18:07that we are all in on product, whether that's me, our team,
- 18:13like there is so much to build, so many workflows changing, so
- 18:16much happening and we have such opportunity to help our
- 18:19customers. So that's what we're pushing for
- 18:22every day. It's funny to hear that played
- 18:24back, like as an interviewer, him being like, I told you, I
- 18:27couldn't talk about this, like seared in my mind in a way that
- 18:31watching it was like, OK, he said that and he moved on.
- 18:34I do think he could have been slightly less defensive.
- 18:37To me, it's always better just to be like, I, they ask
- 18:40questions they feel like they have to ask and I can say
- 18:43whatever the fuck I want that you could say something totally
- 18:45different. He could have pretended like I
- 18:47didn't even ask the question, you know?
- 18:48Anyway, besides that little like bristle at, at my just doing my
- 18:53job and asking a question, it's clear that they, they feel the
- 18:56need to have like a great sort of pipeline of products heading
- 19:00into an IPO and they, they literally are presenting
- 19:03themselves as having launched what 4 fresh products after
- 19:07having four products just this year.
- 19:09My take is that he like actually believes that they're in a
- 19:15disruptive moment. We, we, we talked about in the,
- 19:18in on the podcast before where technology is changing and will
- 19:22affect them in many ways through AI.
- 19:25And then also, you know, he it's a message to his team to say
- 19:29like, you know, even though we are going public and this is an
- 19:32amazing milestone for the company, like don't get
- 19:35distracted because we actually have to fight those battles and
- 19:39build product. Yeah.
- 19:42I think it's interesting given our experience with these vibe
- 19:46coding tools over the last couple months, James that like
- 19:49to me it increasingly seems like the bottleneck for vibe coding
- 19:53or AI assisted coding or whatever you want to call it is
- 19:56the quality of the design. I would say that like the
- 19:59designs you get out of these tools, whether it's like.
- 20:03Cursor or lovable or Claude code or whatever or just garbage like
- 20:07really bad. And it's a sort of interesting
- 20:10question if like Figma is extremely well positioned in
- 20:13that case, because they have all the designers, like all the good
- 20:17designers in, you know, in software, essentially use Figma.
- 20:21And they can actually convert this sort of group of people who
- 20:24actually know how to make things that look and feel really great
- 20:27and polished into becoming creators and developers.
- 20:30Or if you go the other way, which is say like, Oh no,
- 20:33everyone else is going to like actually grab these designers
- 20:37and they're going to start understanding how to use cursor
- 20:39and Claude code. And then once cursor and Claude
- 20:41code level up on their quality of design by either training on
- 20:45new data or just something else, then all these designers are
- 20:48just going to be using Claude code or cursor, which is kind of
- 20:51what we experienced in the company in the last few weeks
- 20:53when we trained everyone on Claude code.
- 20:54It's like all of a sudden every every person in the company,
- 20:56whether in design or product or data or marketing can can now
- 20:59build apps. They all just look like garbage
- 21:02because the models aren't there yet.
- 21:03I I think Figma is in a funny situation launching Figma make,
- 21:08which is their sort of lovable, you know what have you vibe code
- 21:13platform, vibe code platform is that what?
- 21:16We're calling the category. I mean, I don't know what
- 21:17they're calling it, but that's what I'm calling it.
- 21:19Yeah, I mean. It puts them in a weird position
- 21:21where they have to sort of defend the category, which I, I
- 21:25think is still like messy and broken.
- 21:27I, I think they, they created like Figma.
- 21:30I mean, a lot of what Figma is doing is like sort of you're a
- 21:33marketer or you're a website builder.
- 21:36We're going to give you sort of a lightweight version of Figma.
- 21:38So it's easier for you to get in and do what you want.
- 21:41And so they created Figma sites for web creation and that has
- 21:45like a Figma make integration. And in some ways I think that
- 21:50makes more sense with Figma's like long term plan where it's
- 21:54like deeply integrated with their design elements.
- 21:57And Figma make feels a little bit like, all right, there's
- 22:01this sexy thing that everybody has.
- 22:02It's just sort of like a wrapper over models.
- 22:05If there's going to be so much zeitgeist around it, let's have
- 22:08it too. But I agree that the real
- 22:10opportunity for Figma is that like they have all your design
- 22:13assets. They have all your design
- 22:15assets. It's a moment when context is
- 22:18seen as like extremely important and Figma has all your context
- 22:22on how you design things. And so clearly the more they can
- 22:26make this make thing much more like related to the actual
- 22:29design tools and assets that Figma has, it'll be much more
- 22:34valuable. And then it'll be truly
- 22:35differentiated from Lovable and everybody.
- 22:38Else, I mean, for the record, like I don't know if they're
- 22:40gonna do this, if they have the talent to do this or if there's
- 22:42it's a focus of theirs, but they have this tremendous opportunity
- 22:46to essentially like trained as a, you know, the first good
- 22:50model in terms of design for, you know, for vibe coding or for
- 22:55creating software, right? I mean they have again basically
- 22:59every like good design of software you know is on Figma
- 23:04for the last like I. Don't know they can actually use
- 23:06that data to train, but yeah. I mean, they should, I don't
- 23:09know. They should.
- 23:10Their lawyers should try to find some loopholes on this.
- 23:12Yeah, I guess. What?
- 23:13Would you be outputting? You'd just be outputting the
- 23:15layers themselves, not the code you're saying like.
- 23:18I don't know how it would work exactly.
- 23:20Maybe you create your own version of Claude code.
- 23:22Maybe you create your own version of, you know, a super
- 23:24enhanced version of love of lovable that just makes really
- 23:26nice looking websites instead of pretty crappy looking websites
- 23:29like. But I'm just saying, you know,
- 23:31to Eric's point about like context is king, you know, IE
- 23:34like the data on how people, you know, use these tools or create
- 23:37things with these tools. Like Figma has the greatest
- 23:40goldmine of design context like in the world.
- 23:43And I don't know how they capture that or if they're
- 23:45thinking about it. But to me, it feels like this,
- 23:47this massive upside opportunity to be the the creation tool that
- 23:51actually makes things that look nice and work.
- 23:53Well, the, the other thing Dylan bristled at me about was that I
- 23:57said, you know, oh, when I use these like tools, I just like
- 24:01fucking copy and paste, you know, sub stack or whatever and
- 24:04say like, build me sub stack. And he's like, well, you're, I
- 24:08don't know, it's sort of like you're lazy.
- 24:09Not everybody else does that. I don't know.
- 24:11But I do think like a lot of what works about these is you
- 24:15start with some visual design that you like and sort of
- 24:19replicate it. I don't.
- 24:20Know no, I, I, I'm fully on your team here.
- 24:23I feel like most design is most design is, is remixing, you
- 24:27know, to sort of the remixing is the kind of like generous
- 24:30version and I think the ungenerous version would be a
- 24:32lot of copies. Design.
- 24:34I think Figma is a tool where you're trying to build it up on
- 24:36the pixel level, but a lot of these like text based almost.
- 24:40It's either you're asking the thing to just arbitrarily come
- 24:45up with something you don't know how, or sort of like copy and
- 24:48pasting, putting things in. I, I realize you can put in your
- 24:50own stuff, but I, I do think there's a lot of like copying
- 24:54that's going on. I think a lot of this is take
- 24:57right now is going to age like milk and in a year we're going
- 25:00to be looking back on this in a world where the foundation
- 25:03models have just chosen to train more on on good design.
- 25:07You know, it won't be like Eric having to cut, copy paste
- 25:11pictures of so stack to like copy it.
- 25:13It'll just come out with better looking designs when you vibe
- 25:15good, and I think that that's the future.
- 25:18You can feel the AGI today, James.
- 25:21Yeah, Yeah. I just, I just think the models
- 25:23haven't like, you know, trained like the coding models haven't
- 25:28focused on this yet and they will like it's just a matter of,
- 25:31you know. Actually like a super short
- 25:34figma case then I mean I'm just. Saying like.
- 25:36I guess that's why. I'm saying they should be in
- 25:37that race like I'm saying like they've got this goldmine.
- 25:40They've got to get in here with these other models like, you
- 25:43know, they could. They could be the leader.
- 25:45I don't agree with the goldmine because they don't actually have
- 25:49the connectivity to the code like at some point.
- 25:53Like the way that clod code works, is it like generates
- 25:56actual front end, you know, CSS? Yeah.
- 26:00So I just think, you know, they, they have like a goldmine of
- 26:05great looking imagery. All right, well, breaking news.
- 26:08James's short Figma. James James's Shorting Figma I.
- 26:12Predicted at the start of this episode that we would be high on
- 26:15models today and that's that's bearing out.
- 26:18All right Next up we've got Harry Stebbins, the only VC we
- 26:23trusted to interview somebody. It helps that he has a podcast
- 26:27of his own, so he knows what he's doing.
- 26:29He interviewed the Granola CEO, Christopher Pedro Gall.
- 26:33Here's the clip. My favorite quote is like will
- 26:35the incumbent gain innovation before you know the innovator or
- 26:39the startup gains distribution? How do you think about that
- 26:42today, if you think about kind of an open AI's ability?
- 26:45To do what? You do in some respects and have
- 26:47distribution versus your ability to move fast.
- 26:50Be very nimble, innovate. Yeah, I think my my view here is
- 26:57that we are in you know, when the iPhone came out and you had
- 27:00like the beer drinking apps and the lighter apps like I still
- 27:04think we're in that stage of AI, which might sound ridiculous
- 27:07because whatever ChatGPT has 500 million users and is clearly
- 27:10useful, but I really think that is the case I don't think AI is
- 27:14that useful. I think it's today and I think
- 27:17it's mostly masquerading is useful, but you end up spending
- 27:20a lot of time like rewriting or redoing it.
- 27:23Another way to put that is it's going to be so much more useful
- 27:26in one to two years. And and I think we have yet to
- 27:31see truly AI native like interfaces and and products come
- 27:36out. And I think that's the whole
- 27:38question. Like I think the the it's not
- 27:41about the products that exist today.
- 27:43Those are. It's still like.
- 27:45It's like the caveman days now. It's like who can get to the
- 27:49truly AI native experiences and whoever builds those first and
- 27:54gets distribution on that. That's that's my view.
- 27:57And I think we're all everybody in the industry is pre that
- 28:00right now. I basically agree with that, but
- 28:03I'm not sure that means like bet on granola.
- 28:05I don't know, it's like a little bit like I sort of
- 28:07philosophically agree with him that there's a lot, you know, of
- 28:11kind of latching AI onto existing products and workflows.
- 28:15And even granola arguably, you know, is essentially just
- 28:17latching voice AI onto a Zoom call essentially.
- 28:22And the interface is, you know, not innovative.
- 28:24It's like a notes app essentially with some folders.
- 28:27It's a great product. For the record, I freaking love
- 28:29granola, but I don't know if the the idea that like, oh, we're in
- 28:34the beer drinking iPhone phase, so like air go, just wait one or
- 28:39two years and then we'll see where the chips fall necessarily
- 28:41makes me believe in someone other than opening eye, I guess.
- 28:45I mean, it's a great. Fundraising posture because it's
- 28:47like, it's cool now. Like, think about what?
- 28:50Wait till next year. Really.
- 28:52Yeah. I mean, I feel like yeah, the
- 28:54the missing, yeah, the missing piece for me was the the
- 28:56explanation of what the evolved version of his product looks
- 29:00like, which maybe he doesn't want to say would have made to
- 29:02that me that argument a lot more, right.
- 29:04Yeah. I mean, it reminds me of like
- 29:06the early social media days where, you know, first you have
- 29:10all of these media companies just put their products on the
- 29:12Internet, and then it turns out that the form factor that
- 29:17succeeds dramatically is is Facebook or Twitter or
- 29:20something, right? That's just like a totally
- 29:23different product. But if we had interviewed the
- 29:25Myspace CEO in 2003 and he had said, you know, we're not really
- 29:29at the final form of social media, like, you know, it's
- 29:32coming. And and then we're going to
- 29:34really like unlock the value you get out of social media and
- 29:37you'd be like, this dude's totally right.
- 29:38But like, does that mean Myspace is going to win?
- 29:40I mean, I don't know, it just it's sort of in, I feel like it
- 29:43was a little bit of that kind of comment where it was like, so
- 29:45you're saying like nobody's figured it out.
- 29:47So ergo, like we're all just kind of killing time until the
- 29:50models get better for. A year but but wouldn't the
- 29:52wasn't Myspace like we're hot shit like I don't know.
- 29:55I'm, I'm, I'm for the record, I'm not saying that Myspace CEO
- 29:58would have said that. I'm just like.
- 29:59Right. I'm just saying you'd prefer the
- 30:00CEO who at least is like a realist about where we are if
- 30:04he's correct. I guess if the Myspace CEO did
- 30:07say that, they would be directionally correct in that
- 30:10like, you know, most newspapers didn't win like incumbents,
- 30:15right? But I guess you can argue like
- 30:17this is where it gets to be like a tricky argument like open AI.
- 30:20Are they really the incumbent or are they also just the, you
- 30:23know, another startup that is, you know, in the game as much as
- 30:29granola? I just don't get the I want.
- 30:32I mean, I have a I want transcripts and I know they give
- 30:35it to you, but like I don't want to query it for general
- 30:38takeaways. Like I want it to give me
- 30:41specific lines out of the conversation.
- 30:43And so the whole thing sort of annoys me because it does the
- 30:47opposite of what I want, which is you could give me a gloss
- 30:50you. It shows you the whole
- 30:52transcript, but I want it to deliver like here are the five
- 30:54best quotes or like give me the specific verbatim thing that was
- 30:58said and it's always trying to approximate sort of what was
- 31:01said. I think the way that Harry asked
- 31:04the question was like, how do you think of incumbents getting
- 31:07to, you know, the product versus the innovator?
- 31:11But like in this case, we're not, we're calling Open AI an
- 31:14incumbent, not an innovator. I don't know.
- 31:15They're innovating. That's funny.
- 31:17I mean, that's sort of the role Figma played where it's like,
- 31:19oh, you're the incumbent executor now, like right.
- 31:21And Notion is a similar one. There's this whole set of
- 31:25companies that like, oh, in any normal sense, you'd be like,
- 31:28this is my innovator moment to be on the public markets.
- 31:32And now it's like, no, you're, you're already the incumbent.
- 31:34There's a new wave. I think that was like a big meta
- 31:37theme of the event. Right.
- 31:39And I'm just saying we need to be a little bit more precise
- 31:41with the definitions here, like who are the incumbents?
- 31:44I don't know. Incumbents, anyone who are they
- 31:47thought they knew what their company was pre catching you 3
- 31:51and everybody you know the the upstarts are people who said oh
- 31:56man, I have to invent my company with catchy BT in mind.
- 31:59I just say I, I basically what I'm seeing is that companies
- 32:02like Notion and Figma are very much like a, like live players
- 32:06in this game. And they're they're really
- 32:07trying to avoid these disruptions from from below.
- 32:11Our next clip is from the first panel of the day with
- 32:15Microsoft's Bonnie Croft and Hugging faces.
- 32:18Thomas Wolfe. I, I introduced it saying this
- 32:21was my smart people panel. It was the question of whether
- 32:24we'll find novelty in AI and where where true discoveries lie
- 32:30with the AI systems of the day. Let's hear what they had to say.
- 32:33So Thomas, you, you, you know, you wrote this great essay,
- 32:35basically, you know, asking the question of will AI produce a
- 32:41Nobel Prize? Will it create an Einstein?
- 32:43Like what? What was your conclusion there?
- 32:46How optimistic or not are you about the ability of the current
- 32:49paradigm to produce a true revolutionary idea?
- 32:54Yeah, I'm not super optimistic on this right now.
- 32:57Not optimistic. You almost whispered it.
- 33:01You're like, this is in the crowd to admit it.
- 33:05In most part, I'm usually the optimist because I think there's
- 33:07a lot of great stuff you can do with AI.
- 33:10And as I mean, probably you got right, you got the idea right
- 33:13here, which is you have two, two things with AI.
- 33:15So you have the assistant that's really getting amazing.
- 33:18And I think, I think training DfT models, training A4, these
- 33:22are amazing assistants and they will definitely lead to some
- 33:25interesting. Discovery, like we were
- 33:27discussing yesterday where we started to talk about this panel
- 33:30discovery, this discovery will come from still from this part
- 33:33of creativity of a human saying I'm going to use alpha fault to
- 33:36explore these proteins and that will be the thing.
- 33:39And then Alpha Fault helps you find how it works.
- 33:42And then you have the other thing which is taking this
- 33:44trillion parameters model and ask them.
- 33:47Invent something now invent something new.
- 33:49We want to travel faster than light.
- 33:51How should we do? Right?
- 33:52If you ask that to chat DPT nowadays, the answer we get are
- 33:55pretty bad. Well, I don't really.
- 33:56I don't really understand his take away exactly.
- 33:59Would it count if a scientist used ChatGPT or ChatGPT 5 to
- 34:05like win a Nobel Prize? I mean, I think he's saying that
- 34:08that is clearly going to happen. I think both panelists were
- 34:11bullish on AI models expanding like the search space for
- 34:15discovery or being like, we're going to be able to like I'm an
- 34:19expert in material X and it will consider material Y, but it
- 34:24doesn't think this sort of like contrarian, like think outside
- 34:28the box, reinvent core premises that AI is capable of doing
- 34:33that. I mean, I think he's saying like
- 34:35if you just ask the big model like right off the shelf, go
- 34:38invent something for me, it's not very good at that.
- 34:41I agree with that. That could change, but that is
- 34:43the current case. I guess that doesn't really
- 34:46matter. I mean, like, we're gonna have
- 34:48if, if, even if it's just, you know, humans have to like, tell
- 34:52it to do something that's adjacent to their own research.
- 34:54Like that would still be revolutionary.
- 34:57Yeah, I'm definitely with jams here.
- 34:59I mean, you can't just walk to a random human scientist and be
- 35:02like, oh, go figure out, you know, the nature of the universe
- 35:04or whatever. I mean, like they're it's like,
- 35:06OK, well, give me 50 years and I'm gonna go do research and dig
- 35:09into things, right? He's saying we're training these
- 35:11models on the boring rule followers, which are him.
- 35:15He includes himself in this and the vast majority of us.
- 35:18But he's saying that the true novel discoveries are created by
- 35:21independent thinkers, and that we are not training AI to be
- 35:26that sort of revolutionary. I mean, I just don't believe
- 35:28this. So obviously none of us are
- 35:30scientists, but I do think don't.
- 35:32Believe that there's this persona of.
- 35:36Of course, I believe that being an independent thinker is
- 35:39incredibly important to making novel discoveries.
- 35:41But I think so much of the way novel discoveries come about is,
- 35:44is not just this personality, but it's, it's searching the
- 35:47sort of frontiers of, of what we know and, and being aware of,
- 35:52you know, to go Rumsfeld here, like, what are the known
- 35:54unknowns? What are the unknown unknowns?
- 35:56You know, and, and even in that protein folding example, you
- 35:59know, you could say, OK, well, here's like, you know, 10,000
- 36:03proteins that, you know, I think might be interesting in terms of
- 36:06like being an agonist for this receptor.
- 36:09Like what are the top 100 you think I should look at or
- 36:11whatever? And, and like, even just
- 36:13narrowing down that list from 10,000 to 100, you know, using a
- 36:16genius AI is like 100 X improvement in the efficiency of
- 36:20this search space where you're trying to discover, you know,
- 36:23new science, right? So like, I just don't, I don't
- 36:26really believe that Like, you know, dude, sitting alone, like,
- 36:29you know, coming up with crazy ideas is, is how most scientific
- 36:33discovery happens. I think a lot of it's searching
- 36:36these efficient frontiers that we've discovered so far and, and
- 36:39trying to continue to push them forward in interesting ways.
- 36:41And being 100X efficient is filtering ideas or remixing
- 36:45ideas or sort of creating slight tweaks on what we know so far
- 36:48is, is so much of I think discovery, which I think AI
- 36:51would be tremendous at. Yeah.
- 36:53Connecting ideas across disciplines, right?
- 36:56Like you know, you, you know a lot about both biology and
- 36:59chemistry and physics or something, right?
- 37:01Which I think the models are clearly best in the world at in
- 37:05terms of depth of knowledge in every scientific discipline.
- 37:08So I think if we believe that connecting the dots across these
- 37:13fields is important to discovery like I think we're, you know,
- 37:16tracking in a great way there for for the models.
- 37:19I think the defense is 1 like the models are pretty capable
- 37:23now and like even in the sort of like, OK, we're not
- 37:26revolutionary thinkers, like find the cool stuff.
- 37:28I feel like it's a little underwhelming.
- 37:30I mean, I I still don't think it's like delivering me scoops.
- 37:33So, but, but putting putting that aside, I, I think we're all
- 37:36somewhat optimistic that like sort of rule follower, consensus
- 37:41associative thinker, we'll be able to find a bunch of stuff
- 37:44that we just haven't put together and there'll be this
- 37:46period of a lot of value. To sum up my point here, models
- 37:50are sycophants. Sycophants don't win Nobel
- 37:54Prizes. You know, I think every great
- 37:57man story in history is about sort of like rejecting the
- 37:59consensus, I think. But my point is, yeah, they're
- 38:02they're sycophants. The models are.
- 38:04And like academics, you know, need to be free thinkers.
- 38:08And until we can figure out how to train a model to really
- 38:11resist core premises, we're reinforcing the status quo.
- 38:15And so it might discover things that we would have already
- 38:18concluded, but to really reject human thinking it, it feels like
- 38:22that's that's not how it's trained.
- 38:23That's that's how I see the argument.
- 38:25I don't know if I totally agree with that.
- 38:27Moving on to what I think will be our last clip of the day,
- 38:31perhaps the most provocative, we have a great line from the CEO
- 38:35of Synthesia, Victor RIP. Our belly definitely designed
- 38:38for peak spice. Give it a listen.
- 38:41I guess, you know, last question for you, Victor, like within a
- 38:43company similarly, like what percentage, you know, how many
- 38:47times a day am I going to be watching an AI generated video
- 38:50that's explaining something to me like 5 years from now?
- 38:53Is it daily, hourly, you know, every 5 minutes, everything I
- 38:56do? Like what percentage of
- 38:57corporate, the corporate experience is going to be
- 39:00consuming AI generated video, you know, five years down the
- 39:02road? I think I'll probably mirror
- 39:04your personal life, right. So, I mean, I don't know, don't
- 39:06know that well, but when my own like media mix of like what I
- 39:09consume, yeah, I consume mostly podcasts, YouTube videos.
- 39:12Sure. Tick tock videos, Instagram
- 39:14reels, Instagram photos. I also do read, but way less
- 39:17than I did five years ago. And I think that'll be kind of
- 39:19mirrored in the workplace. It could be hard to imagine
- 39:21exactly what it's going to look like, but I truly think that
- 39:23that is clearly what people prefer when no one just tells
- 39:26them what to do. And so I think that's what we
- 39:28want to kind of see in the in the in the workplace as well.
- 39:30And I have this, you know, often very provocative to people idea
- 39:33that, you know, your kids, kids are not going to be reading and
- 39:35writing. They're going to be watching and
- 39:36listening almost exclusively. And I think that is going to
- 39:38happen. I'm teaching my daughter to read
- 39:40right now. But I think at some point I
- 39:43think text will just feel a bit like vinyls or something, right?
- 39:47Or like, we'll do it sometimes because it's like a fun
- 39:48nostalgic thing, but for actual information dissemination, it's
- 39:53going to be like a very low bandwidth compared to those.
- 39:55Where's Paul Graham? That's that's my first reaction.
- 39:57Paul Graham has been beating the drum.
- 39:59Writing is thinking. And so I guess my biggest
- 40:02defense of writing and why this terrifies me the most is less
- 40:05that like everybody, I mean, it's good.
- 40:08Reading is how you learn to write and writing is how we
- 40:11think. And so if we don't have reading
- 40:12and writing. Human intelligence as we know it
- 40:14today collapses. That's not necessarily defense
- 40:17to the lure of video, which I agree is very strong, but
- 40:21definitely this vision is to me one of much stupider human
- 40:26beings. Well.
- 40:27Do you feel like right now in this podcast, you're not
- 40:30thinking, you're not learning like I do?
- 40:32I feel like I have to like, you know, think about what you guys
- 40:34are saying and concoct my, you know, responses like on the fly.
- 40:39I just think like, if, if I could constantly talk to other
- 40:43humans, you know, whether they're actually AI's or not,
- 40:48like, I don't, I think I'd still be learning, right?
- 40:50Like, so I guess I kind of understand what he's saying.
- 40:53Especially does both podcasts are in an intellectually lazy
- 40:56medium compared to writing. Writing you really have to
- 40:59figure out your argument. Like, I could just be I'm most
- 41:01fun on a podcast being loud, boisterous, disagreeing,
- 41:04slipping around. Like the All in guys have the
- 41:06most popular podcasts in the world.
- 41:08Writing requires you actually, like, organize your thoughts.
- 41:10Somebody could breakdown an argument.
- 41:12No, no, I Yeah. I think podcasting is a much
- 41:16lazier way to engage with ideas than writing.
- 41:20What about like a one-on-one tutor?
- 41:22Just chatting, You know, one-on-one with mean?
- 41:24Socratic, you know, if you really push it, but it's just so
- 41:27easy. Conversation lends itself to
- 41:31mean social and like slipping to the next thing.
- 41:33And like This is why this whole, you know, there's a whole
- 41:36Silicon Valley way of, you know, argumentation that's sort of
- 41:39like we, we're following each other's ideas and like jumping
- 41:41around. That's that's not how you would
- 41:43write like a proof. And like, I just think if you
- 41:46want, you know, argument and reasoning in sort of like proof
- 41:50form writing is much better than talking.
- 41:53Yeah, I just think we're talking, we're basically talking
- 41:55about like the average person growing up in America, like how
- 41:59will they learn in 12 to 15 years?
- 42:02Like I definitely think there will be a lot more like
- 42:05personalized tutoring that basically feels more like
- 42:09working one-on-one with a human, you know, assistant, right.
- 42:14And, and so less, less writing. I, I agree with that.
- 42:17I don't know if it means no writing, but.
- 42:19But is this fatalist? I I, I sort of agree with that
- 42:22we are going to be pulled to less writing.
- 42:24I'm just saying, do you think we'll be Dumber if we write
- 42:26less? I don't know, man.
- 42:28I think the percentage of Americans that like writes and
- 42:33at all like, you know, essentially like rounds to 0
- 42:36for, I would argue probably 98% of the population like.
- 42:40And so I would sort of argue like you're already there in
- 42:43this dystopia if you believe this is a dystopia.
- 42:46And then on the other hand, yeah, I'm kind of more team
- 42:48James here, which is I agree, writing is a form of thinking.
- 42:52And I think having to prepare your thoughts in written format
- 42:55allows you to distill and improve them.
- 42:57But I also don't think it is the only way to think.
- 43:01I mean, like thinking is thinking as well.
- 43:03I mean, there is a whole, yeah, there's a whole genre of, you
- 43:06know, shower thoughts, right? I mean, like Elon Musk always
- 43:09says he comes up with his best rocket ideas while he's
- 43:12showering and stuff. Like, is he writing them down on
- 43:14the, you know, the squeegee, like, you know, on the wall of
- 43:17the shower? I mean, like, it is pot.
- 43:19I have always thought like, my best thoughts came from like,
- 43:21exercising or like walking around or something.
- 43:24You know, it's not writing, right?
- 43:25And so I'm just not sure IA believe like, first of all, that
- 43:29nearest makes no difference. Basically nobody writes in, you
- 43:32know, the United States, I would argue and then BI think there
- 43:35are other ways to think. So I, I sort of believe Victor's
- 43:38thesis and I, I think it's a little bit less dystopian, but,
- 43:41you know, you guys are both, I think better writers than I am,
- 43:43so that you might find more. But you write company memos.
- 43:47You can, Yeah, but things and but I don't.
- 43:48Necessarily think that's the my best thinking.
- 43:51You know, I'm not like looking back on my company memos and
- 43:53being like, oh, those are much better thinking than when I have
- 43:55a good conversation with James. I mean, this is a, this is a
- 43:57deep sort of question, but I think about a fair bit.
- 44:01I, I, and I'm a pretty auditory person, like love audiobooks and
- 44:06everything. But I think in terms of writing,
- 44:09you can have great ideas in the shower, great ideas on a
- 44:11podcast, But like, what's unique about writing is the emphasis on
- 44:16revision. And I think what writing has is
- 44:19that you have to sort of go back and say, Oh, does that sort of
- 44:22make sense? And so, you know, I think, you
- 44:25know, smart people, you know, like the sort of like first
- 44:30burst of like this great idea and like that is like really fun
- 44:33on a podcast and like a first draft of writing.
- 44:36But I think like a tight argument is often in revision
- 44:39and writing is unique there where you have to sort of face
- 44:43your ideas and and sort of beat them down and reform them and
- 44:46make them work. Back to Polygram, you know Y
- 44:50Combinator has basically a two phase application process, right
- 44:53The first is super writing heavy you you answer all these
- 44:58questions about your company I think Max and I found that to be
- 45:01a very helpful process in some ways where it kind of forces you
- 45:05to like refine your startup idea.
- 45:07But the actual like interview process is 10 minutes of them
- 45:11asking you questions in a conversation, right?
- 45:13And I also found that to be like a, a very thought provoking
- 45:17experience. So I don't know what whether you
- 45:20need both or not, but they it seems like we're definitely
- 45:23gravitating to a world where conversation is gonna be more
- 45:28prominent and and you'll be able to do that like sort of Socratic
- 45:32style of. Pushing.
- 45:33I agree, I think this like Socratic dialogue is definitely
- 45:36another sort of valid and interrogating line of thought
- 45:39that is a little different than podcast scene in podcasting.
- 45:42I think there's often an agreeableness and it's sort of
- 45:45like we're all going in the same place and like sort of like
- 45:47improv or something, whereas like we're a true like interview
- 45:51Socratic dialogue. And that's I think where
- 45:53teaching can fit in where you're really like challenging that
- 45:58that can help. The last thing I'll say is like,
- 45:59you know, you can write with Chachi BT.
- 46:01So I, I don't know that I necessarily think what's
- 46:04happening with AI is going to totally hurt writing.
- 46:07It's making a great writing tool that really, you know,
- 46:10interrogates you much, much more available.
- 46:13Yeah, it does seem like people are probably writing more than
- 46:15they were in the past now with ChatGPT, because you have to
- 46:19write full sentences, you know, you know, Google was just about
- 46:21keywords. You end up in these longer
- 46:23dialogues. So I wouldn't be surprised if
- 46:25like we're on like a slight uptick in in writing.
- 46:28But I think the elites are probably in a downward trend.
- 46:31I don't know. You read old, old like famous
- 46:34people letters to their friends. I mean, I just feel like they're
- 46:37like these long sort of reflections and some of these.
- 46:40Right. But but I mean to come back to
- 46:42the the overall point like was the quality of their thinking
- 46:45like superior to ours? I just don't believe that.
- 46:47Like, I think that if you look at any metric you can measure
- 46:50overtime, you know, there's this concept of like, the Flynn
- 46:52effect, which is that IQ keeps going up on, you know, on
- 46:55average over the decades, right? So like, yeah, sure.
- 46:58I mean, John Adams and, like, Abigail Adams, like, wrote some
- 47:01amazing letters. But like the, you know, the at
- 47:03least the average IQ in their society was much lower than
- 47:06today, even though, you know, the elites were all writing much
- 47:09more. So I'm just not kidding the
- 47:10elites. Are way less literary today.
- 47:13I mean you. Sure, that for sure.
- 47:14Of course, because that was kind of the only medium for
- 47:18expression right now. Yeah, and we're going to movies.
- 47:21Yeah, Yeah, Movies contain a lot of information, but I I remain,
- 47:27you know. Pessimistic about the world,
- 47:29basically. You remain, I know I think AI is
- 47:33going to democratize a lot of tools.
- 47:35I think we're still in this period where this is allowing
- 47:38much more people to get access to education than before.
- 47:42So I think it'll be net good, but I think it's encouraging
- 47:45some of us, like super elites, to be lazier than we should be.
- 47:50Writing is a good way to think. This is a super elite podcast
- 47:54for the record. Obviously I mean super elites,
- 47:57yes. I just admit it.
- 48:01Like nobody wants to see their elite.
- 48:02Anymore like I plan to be a Davos this year with my fellow
- 48:06super elites. Oh my God, I'm not trying to be
- 48:09indulgent. I'm just trying to be honest
- 48:11that we don't reflect like, you know, the average reading
- 48:14writing consumption Max, you know, you're, you're teaching
- 48:18your daughter to read. That's sort of an inspirational
- 48:20story. What is your?
- 48:21What's your? What the method to teaching or
- 48:23display? Oh, I mean, this is this is the
- 48:25beauty of it is it's an iPad game.
- 48:28It's an interactive iPad game that's actually made by a
- 48:31startup in up in Seattle. I believe it's called Mentava.
- 48:36And this is not a. Paid ad This is not a.
- 48:38Paid ad and IT. Costs a fortune you're somehow
- 48:40getting it for. Free.
- 48:41I think getting it for free because my daughter is becoming
- 48:43an influencer, which is also an important skill, they're making
- 48:46videos of her playing the app. But yeah, I mean, it's awesome
- 48:51because I think the screen time has become such a meme among
- 48:55parents that it's sort of objectively bad to have any
- 48:58screens in your kids life, especially in the Super elite
- 49:01circles that I roll in. And this app is teaching my
- 49:06daughter to read it at, you know, years ahead of when she
- 49:09would be learning these things in school.
- 49:10And so I think it's just evidence to come back to the
- 49:12more optimistic perspective on software and AI in general that,
- 49:16you know, interactive experiences, even if they're
- 49:19sort of purely educational, can be a really positive thing for
- 49:23for kids on screens and using software.
- 49:26And so I actually think that makes me get very long like AI
- 49:29education and sort of software driven human improvement or
- 49:33augmentation or whatever you want to call it, because she's,
- 49:36you know, making progress at just a crazy rate compared to
- 49:38school. So whether or not, you know,
- 49:41videos or games are the way she learns how to read or learns
- 49:44math eventually, I think there's clearly much better ways for
- 49:48kids to learn things and, and in my opinion, a lot of it involves
- 49:51software and AI. That's a much happier note to
- 49:55end on. Thank you very much.
- 49:56Alright. Well, we'll see you guys ahead
- 49:58of the next Cerebral Valley AI Summit.
- 50:01It'll be in San Francisco on November 12th.
- 50:04Sure, we'll have a lot to catch up on in late October or
- 50:07November. Alright, we'll see you later.