Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E013: Natalie Brunell & Sam Callahan – The Flywheel of Bitcoin Education
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the supply is unaffected by the demand if you want to
- 0:15preserve your wealth. You have to.
- 0:17Convert. That currency into an asset.
- 0:20That's scarce, desirable, portable, durable.
- 0:24And. Maintainable.
- 0:31Thank you for joining us for this week's episode of Scarce
- 0:33Assets, a podcast from on Ramp Media.
- 0:35On today's show, host Andy Ed Sherman, Jesse Myers sit down
- 0:38with Natalie Brunell and Sam Callahan to discuss the
- 0:41importance of education in the Bitcoin space and the challenges
- 0:43of reaching new audiences. They also touch on the shift in
- 0:46policy and politics surrounding Bitcoin, particularly with
- 0:49regards to Wall Street's recent involvement.
- 0:51Natalie and Sam emphasize the need to focus on the
- 0:54fundamentals of Bitcoin and the power of education and spreading
- 0:56awareness and adoption. They touch on the potential for
- 0:59Bitcoin to create a more fair and competitive capitalist
- 1:01system, the rise of populism due to income inequality in the role
- 1:05of journalists in questioning existing narratives.
- 1:08They also explore the themes of corporate adoption in Bitcoin
- 1:11and the potential for more institutions to follow
- 1:13Microstrategy's lead. Both Natalie and Sam emphasize
- 1:17the need for content to educate newcomers and breakdown barriers
- 1:20to entry in the Bitcoin space. And now, time for the show.
- 1:23Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 1:26the 13th episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examines
- 1:31scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets
- 1:34and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 1:38Delighted to be here with my Co host Jesse Myers and our guests
- 1:41Natalie Brunell and Sam Callahan, who are a legitimate
- 1:45Bitcoin power couple. And this makes them an
- 1:48extraordinarily scarce asset. And I have to say it's been a
- 1:52real pleasure watching them wield their formidable
- 1:55capabilities in the Bitcoin space over the years.
- 1:57And I'm happy to introduce them briefly.
- 2:00So Natalie is an award-winning journalist who applies her
- 2:04talents full time to Bitcoin. She's a frequent guest on major
- 2:08news networks, including CNBC and Fox News.
- 2:11She hosts a fantastic show called Coin Stories, where she's
- 2:14conducted interviews of the biggest names in Bitcoin and
- 2:17adjacent fields. And her weekly Coin Stories news
- 2:21block is my favorite Bitcoin news program now.
- 2:24Sam is one of the best analysts in Bitcoin, and it's been a
- 2:27personal pleasure for me to read his research and watch him
- 2:30develop over the years. He publishes research for Swan
- 2:34as its senior analyst and is also the host of the Swan Signal
- 2:38podcast, which is one of the few Bitcoin shows for which I never
- 2:40miss an episode. Anyway, in my opinion, Natalie
- 2:44and Sam are examples of exceptional talent applied to
- 2:47Bitcoin. I couldn't be happier to talk
- 2:49with both of them today. So, Natalie and Sam, welcome to
- 2:52the show and how are you? Thank you so much.
- 2:56That was such a kind introduction.
- 2:58I really appreciate it. I wish I had been on CNBC.
- 3:01That's one network that hasn't called me yet, but it's on the,
- 3:03it's on the goal list, so. No, I got it wrong.
- 3:06Maybe it was CNN. Maybe it was CNN as yeah, yeah,
- 3:10we'll make, we'll make it happen.
- 3:12Yeah, CNBC, they have to get their get their shit together.
- 3:15Yeah, Thanks for thanks for those kind words, Andy.
- 3:18I mean I got to work first hand with you and it was a pleasure
- 3:21and just excited to be here. Talk with you and Jesse to my
- 3:25favourites. Yeah, thanks guys.
- 3:28And yeah, I think Andy was touching on this a little bit in
- 3:31the intro. But you know, Bitcoin attracts
- 3:34talent that that that Bitcoin frankly shouldn't be able to
- 3:38land, you know, like it, it, it's, it's an exciting asset
- 3:42and, and space to work in and intellectually stimulating and,
- 3:46and, you know, world changing. And it pulls in people like,
- 3:49like the two of you that, you know, probably could, could have
- 3:55a a fantastically successful career in corporate finance or,
- 3:59you know, whatever for Sam and and Natalie doing any journalism
- 4:04that you decided to do. But but Bitcoin pulls people
- 4:08like the two of you in. And that is, I think you guys
- 4:11are like a microcosm of how Bitcoin wins in the long term
- 4:15because it just it, it forces you to, to just get pulled in.
- 4:21You just can't resist it, you know, or at least that's the
- 4:22case for me. And and then you apply your
- 4:26talents, considerable talents to spreading the word to the next
- 4:31Natalie and the next Sam. We're lucky to have you guys.
- 4:35Well, thank you. Yeah.
- 4:35I mean, that's something that I thought about when I was doing
- 4:38my show. I, I was so fascinated by all
- 4:40the people that I was learning from, which was kind of the
- 4:42genesis of coin stories 'cause I love hearing people's back
- 4:45stories and their origins and what, you know, what they
- 4:48overcame to achieve success. And I was like, how did all
- 4:51these people come to the same conclusion that Bitcoin is the
- 4:55solution to some of our, our world's biggest problems?
- 4:58And they come from different industries and skill sets and
- 5:00degrees and fields of expertise. And it was like, wow, all
- 5:04cumulates in this, this kind of this realization that that
- 5:10Bitcoin can be applied to so many things.
- 5:12And I was always fascinated by that.
- 5:16Yeah, it's the brain drain happens from all these different
- 5:19disciplines. And I think it's just curious
- 5:21people. I mean, everybody who's gone
- 5:22down the Bitcoin rabbit hole knows how deep it is.
- 5:25I mean, it's endless. And there's so many different
- 5:27facets of Bitcoin that you can learn about that, you know,
- 5:31nobody knows everything about Bitcoin, no matter how hard they
- 5:33try. And that's what keeps very
- 5:36curious minds just keep coming back to it, keep coming back to
- 5:39it. And there's curious minds in
- 5:40every single industry. And so when you get that bug,
- 5:43get that Bitcoin bug, I mean, it's, it's hard to shake off.
- 5:46You just keep going down and down and learning and learning
- 5:48and learning. And it really changes your world
- 5:51view, I would say. We talk about the.
- 5:54More journalists are not into Bitcoin because I can't tell you
- 5:57how much what Bitcoin solves applies to the people that I
- 6:01worked with across the board. I mean, I, I started my career
- 6:04in a tiny, tiny little news networks and made my way to
- 6:07national. And I, I think it would be so
- 6:10helpful if more journalists were not just trained to communicate
- 6:13well, but also learned how the financial system works because
- 6:16it literally applies to every single story.
- 6:18I mean, Bitcoin could have been applied to any one of the
- 6:21stories I was covering, whether it was politics and public
- 6:24corruption or the cost of education and and living going
- 6:28up and people fighting with each other over these problems.
- 6:30And it's like everything connects back to money.
- 6:34At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 6:36important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 6:39Our multi institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 6:41secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your in your
- 6:44family's possession for decades to come.
- 6:47Multi institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 6:50counterparty risk. Leveraging Bitcoin's native
- 6:52properties to eliminate single points of failure that have
- 6:55historically complicated Bitcoin ownership on ramp provides Peace
- 6:58of Mind for your Bitcoin journey.
- 7:00For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 7:04It is amazing to see how it touches literally aspects, every
- 7:08aspect of society. I like the brain drain concept.
- 7:11I like the, the human capital and the normal capital that we
- 7:17like to talk about the financial capital, the black hole sucking
- 7:21everything in And as this asset growing and growing, just the
- 7:25amount of literal monetary capital as well as physical
- 7:30capital through mining as well as human capital.
- 7:33It's just a, it's just amazing to see.
- 7:36Well, you've both now been through, I want to say probably
- 7:39roughly a full cycle in Bitcoin, maybe more.
- 7:43And as much as Bitcoin touches all those aspects of society,
- 7:50it's also a wild ride. Maybe we'll start with you,
- 7:53Natalie. What thoughts do you have since
- 7:57you pivoted your career to Bitcoin and this and this road
- 8:02that you've been on, you know, lessons learned or anything that
- 8:06our audience can benefit from? Oh gosh.
- 8:09Well, it's been the biggest blessing, the most rewarding
- 8:13work I've ever done, more challenging in many ways.
- 8:16I left one industry that was 24/7 where something crazy can
- 8:21happen at any time and bitcoins 24/7 too.
- 8:23So so I'm kind of used to that. But overall, it's just been
- 8:27really empowering being able to be my own boss and start a
- 8:31company through this podcast. And really the power of
- 8:34decentralization through communication and media and
- 8:37seeing how important it was to sort of check the gatekeepers
- 8:42that I sometimes was feeling disillusioned by when I was
- 8:46working in the industry. It's crazy to look back on my
- 8:49time as a reporter because I I often would be attracted to the
- 8:55stories that were more investigative.
- 8:56I was, I was usually an investigative reporter at my
- 8:59stations and I just wanted to root out corruption.
- 9:02I felt like the average person was getting taken advantage of.
- 9:07And I think I saw a lot of the people that I interviewed as
- 9:11sort of sort of like an example of what my parents went through
- 9:15in the great financial crisis. And I wanted to hold powerful
- 9:18people and government actors accountable.
- 9:22But when I was reporting, because I had no financial
- 9:25literacy and I was not taught in school about fractional reserve
- 9:28banking and money printing and all the things you really, you
- 9:31really go down the rabbit hole through Bitcoin to understand.
- 9:36I was assigning blame on the wrong places, which is, I think
- 9:39I, I really understand when people get political and
- 9:43polarized and I'm trying to yank them out of sort of that, that
- 9:48false narrative of it's one party or the other, because it's
- 9:52really the system and the incentives that are so broken.
- 9:55It's not because the corporations are greedy or
- 9:58there's some sort of cabal that is guiding the I, I really don't
- 10:01believe that. I think it's the incentives and
- 10:03I think we're all guided by self-interest and, and Bitcoin
- 10:08makes that a good thing, flips it to the positive.
- 10:11And I just, I just want everyone to be educated because, you
- 10:14know, people are busy working so hard in all these different
- 10:17industries and they don't even know how money works.
- 10:20They interact with money every single day and their homes have
- 10:22become their savings accounts and they're desperate,
- 10:25desperately trying to, you know, afford a family in all parts of
- 10:28the country and in the world. And they don't understand that.
- 10:31Like they're literally being stolen from every single day.
- 10:34And it's something none of them voted for.
- 10:36And, and so it's made me just really appreciate the, the power
- 10:41of, of education and, and teaching people really the
- 10:45basics of our financial system. And I'm grateful that I get to
- 10:48do that through my own show. I never thought that something
- 10:51like this would be possible. It's a phenomenal blessing.
- 10:55Well, the education angle is huge.
- 10:58And Sam, I know you have you had the similar approach in that
- 11:02regard, You know, is that by coincidence?
- 11:07Are you here, you know, are we all here doing education because
- 11:11that's just the way that we bring Bitcoin to the masses?
- 11:16What What are your thoughts in that regard?
- 11:18Well, I do think education's really important because I think
- 11:23the technology's on our side. I think it's just a matter of
- 11:25it's like an ace asymmetrical opportunity right now because
- 11:29the information isn't widely distributed yet, and people just
- 11:31have to understand what this thing is.
- 11:33There's so much misinformation over the years about Bitcoin.
- 11:36I mean, if you weren't a critical thinker and you just
- 11:39read the headlines, I mean, you would have shrugged off Bitcoin
- 11:42for a scam, a Ponzi, you know, all the bad things.
- 11:44It's used for criminals. Everybody's gotten in Bitcoin
- 11:47early, multiple cycles ago. I mean, they had to be a
- 11:50critical thinker by definition because they had to look past
- 11:52the headlines and do their own work and do their own research
- 11:55to eventually come to the realization that no, this thing
- 11:58solves a real problem. And it's it solves the problem
- 12:01of the inability for us to save. I mean, it's such a huge problem
- 12:04that's faced by 8 billion people today.
- 12:06And and so once I realized like, OK, it's just people need to
- 12:10understand this. And this message has to be
- 12:11delivered to different audiences in a way that resonates with
- 12:15them. And I thought I could do that.
- 12:16I thought I had skills from my prior career and how can I help
- 12:20Bitcoin adoption? I think I could, you know, use
- 12:22those skills to help drive Bitcoin education.
- 12:25I thought that was the most important problem is that people
- 12:27just need to know more about it. So that's kind of why I went the
- 12:30education route. It just felt like I could, you
- 12:33know, thrive in that scenario and that role.
- 12:36And I thought it was the most important thing to do, which was
- 12:38just educate and multiple cycles.
- 12:41I mean, it is a roller coaster. I mean, it goes up and down and
- 12:44you just got to strap in. And I think just focus on what
- 12:47Bitcoin is and why we're here. And it's because it's, it's an
- 12:51empowering technology that allows individuals to save and
- 12:55just hit home that point over and over and over again, because
- 12:58at the same time, where we have the solution that only continues
- 13:01to grow stronger. So focusing on its adoption
- 13:03metrics and, you know, whether it's institutional adoption,
- 13:06whether it's how the protocol is developing over time and adding
- 13:10more functionality, you know, focusing on those things instead
- 13:13of the price, while at the same time looking at the traditional
- 13:16financial system and how it keeps getting worse, right?
- 13:19The debt just keeps increasing and at an exponential rate.
- 13:22And just saying, like, look, inflation's rising and this
- 13:26isn't going to get better. You need to protect yourself.
- 13:28Here's this that continues to grow stronger.
- 13:31And so I just, I think education is so important and it's why I
- 13:34focus on that. And that's what I would say to
- 13:35people like going through multiple cycles or entering
- 13:38their first cycle, Focus on the fundamentals and focus on what
- 13:42you own and why you're here in the 1st place and you'll be
- 13:44fine. It's a lot easier to hold when
- 13:47you're not staring at a price every morning or staying up at
- 13:49night checking your phone. Much easier to hold if you just
- 13:52focus on those things. I actually want to piggyback off
- 13:55that. The fundamentals are so
- 13:57important. I think when you've been in this
- 13:58space for a while, we are in sort of an echo chamber,
- 14:01especially on Bitcoin X or Twitter, whatever you want to
- 14:04call it. And sometimes you forget what it
- 14:07was like to be at that very beginning where you're asking
- 14:10the very simple questions, you know, the very early questions,
- 14:13what is a note? How does Bitcoin mining work?
- 14:16And the more that you can really hone in and articulate those
- 14:19answers, while the more effective I think you'll be.
- 14:23And it kind of builds on, on itself in layers in the same way
- 14:27that Bitcoin does. Because now, I mean, one of my
- 14:30biggest challenges as we're in this new cycle is trying to
- 14:33communicate to those total newbies who, by the way, are now
- 14:37more skeptical, some of them than ever, because of what they
- 14:40saw happen with FTX and the crypto implosions.
- 14:43And just the whole craziness of the market and the, the
- 14:47breakdown of what we're being told by media when it comes to
- 14:50the economy versus the, the economic reality people face
- 14:54today. And I really think going back to
- 14:57the basics is super, super important.
- 14:59I'm trying to do that through some scripts and, and videos
- 15:01that I'm putting together. And it's we really got to, we
- 15:04got some of us have to really go back to the basics when we're
- 15:07talking to people. Yeah, 'cause it, it's, I guess
- 15:11this is one of the things that that we don't talk enough about
- 15:14in Bitcoin, but there is like a, a certain trajectory that every
- 15:19Bitcoiner goes through of like you, you kind of stumble down
- 15:22the rabbit hole, you get really excited and you realize that
- 15:26this changes everything about your world view, about the world
- 15:29of finance, about, you know, the role of assets in a portfolio
- 15:34changes absolutely everything. And for maybe six months is
- 15:38probably the typical time frame. Like you're an absolute zealot.
- 15:42You know where this is all you want to talk about, you want at
- 15:44every BBQ, at every family gathering.
- 15:47This is you know, you're going to you're going to talk
- 15:48everybody's ears off about how Bitcoin, how they need to be all
- 15:52in on Bitcoin yesterday. And then slowly from that six,
- 15:58six month like honeymoon, you start to start to lose some of
- 16:03the the zeal or you start to get jaded or a little bit more tired
- 16:08with the the repetition of the constant FUD from everyone that
- 16:13you talk to. And it's hard to like keep in
- 16:15perspective just how world changing it is to someone who
- 16:19hasn't heard about Bitcoin and, and keep that enthusiasm.
- 16:23Do you guys feel like you've gone through that sort of
- 16:26process of, of having to of, of to a certain extent, losing some
- 16:31of that? Like, you know, you've been
- 16:35smacked over the head with with enthusiasm.
- 16:38And and then you have to find ways to, you know, remind
- 16:41yourself that this is the biggest story in journalism and
- 16:44the biggest story in finance day after day.
- 16:47How do you guys, how has that been for you and how have you
- 16:50kind of approached that? Do you?
- 16:54Want to go Nat? Sure.
- 16:57Well, yeah, I mean, I think, I think depending on the the day
- 17:01or week, you feel differently, right.
- 17:04I mean, the sentiment can change so quickly because Bitcoin is
- 17:07extremely volatile. I just for me, one of the big
- 17:11challenges is trying to make sure that my content is, is, you
- 17:16know, keeping up with the pace of the headlines.
- 17:19And it's something that is approachable to everyone if they
- 17:22don't know about Bitcoin, but also interesting enough for the
- 17:24people that are down the rabbit hole.
- 17:26You know, you don't want to repeat too many guests and too
- 17:28many topics, but at a certain point it you can't, you're
- 17:31hitting a lot of the same themes, right?
- 17:34And they're important things and I can listen to them all day
- 17:36long, but it's just, it always challenges you like what, what
- 17:39other area can you explore? And what's something that maybe
- 17:42you're not that clear on that you could go a little bit deeper
- 17:46on so that you expand your own knowledge as a host and, and
- 17:48therefore as an educator. And so it's just, it's, it's
- 17:52really been an interesting cycle though, too, because it just
- 17:55doesn't feel like the bull market back in 2021, which is
- 17:58really where I emerged as as a podcaster and I started to
- 18:02publicly share my, my takes on Bitcoin and I left my, my
- 18:05mainstream media job. It just, I know that we're in a
- 18:08bull cycle. I mean, we're up what, 100 or
- 18:11200% from from the lows, but the sentiment doesn't feel the same.
- 18:16It doesn't feel the excitement is not there.
- 18:18I've seen charts where people even going to Bitcoin podcasts
- 18:22or YouTube channels is nowhere at the level that it was during
- 18:26the 2021 bull run. And so I'm wondering like, where
- 18:29is that interest and what will spark it?
- 18:31And is it just number go up? Because obviously people at that
- 18:34point are just full mowing and, and wanting to to get on board
- 18:38and learn a little bit more. So yeah, I, I mean, my thoughts
- 18:41kind of change day-to-day on this and I just try to find ways
- 18:46to, to produce meaningful, valuable content for the newbies
- 18:50and the the hardcore orange pilled people.
- 18:55You face the same challenge, Sam.
- 18:57I mean, you're doing in depth analysis on, you know, maybe not
- 19:02so much a daily basis, but at least a weekly and monthly
- 19:05basis, right? And then also day-to-day you're
- 19:09talking, you know, you're talking, having conversations
- 19:12with Bitcoiners, you know, for the benefit of both experts and
- 19:16and noobs. Does it feel the same same way
- 19:20to you where we are in the cycle right now in terms of mainstream
- 19:25participation and interest? Yeah, I think I think it's still
- 19:29really early in this bull cycle if I had to pick, because we're
- 19:32just we haven't seen that like new renewed retail interest.
- 19:36I would say like I haven't gotten like a ton of texts from
- 19:38friends and you just really haven't seen that like FOMO.
- 19:42Same thing with like the comments and videos and things
- 19:44like that. Like it seems like there's
- 19:46either existing Bitcoin holders or there's like more
- 19:49institutional interest like I quote UN quote the smart money.
- 19:53I would say, you know, I don't, I like that term, but I, I would
- 19:57agree, I agree with her. And I think that's the challenge
- 19:59of educators is like, specifically like you have a
- 20:03experienced audience and a, and a, and a not so experienced
- 20:06audience. And how do you keep the content
- 20:07fresh while providing content that attracts both audiences?
- 20:12I mean, that's that's tricky because I can go really in the
- 20:14weeds with a certain podcast with somebody about really
- 20:18technical stuff or more advanced topics in Bitcoin, but that's
- 20:21not going to be really helpful for somebody who's coming at it
- 20:24for the first time. And then it could kind of feel
- 20:26repetitive on my side to just go back to Bitcoin one O 1 stuff.
- 20:28But as Natalie said, it's extremely crucial to remember
- 20:31that people are coming at this for the first time and you have
- 20:34to be the deliverer of that message, no matter how many
- 20:36times you've given that message before.
- 20:38And so just how do you give it in like a fresh way that keeps
- 20:41yourself interested, but also keeps is really helpful for a
- 20:45beginner? I think that's really important.
- 20:47And yeah, it's just I'm human too.
- 20:50Like I get if there's like this, the typical FUD we've heard so
- 20:54many times before that's so easily debunked.
- 20:57I mean, I just have a list of basically articles that other
- 21:00Bitcoiners have wrote that like I have in my pocket that I just
- 21:03throw out to them. And at this point, if I don't
- 21:05feel like arguing it myself, hey, just read these, do your
- 21:07own work, come up to with your own conclusions.
- 21:09If I feel like they're genuine, then I'll I'll, I'll talk with
- 21:13them and I'll kind of walk them through, hold their hand a
- 21:14little bit. But if I feel like they're not
- 21:16genuine, then I say like, look, you can read these articles.
- 21:19You know, this has been readily debunked over the years.
- 21:21But as Bitcoin adoption has grown, I have seen like the
- 21:26conversations change a little bit.
- 21:27Like you don't really hear the Tulip bubble, you know, FUD as
- 21:30much anymore. And, and now obviously, like the
- 21:33China Fud's gone. You know, it's, it's, it's the
- 21:35FUD has changed a little bit. I think we still need better
- 21:38critics personally, but it's become a little bit more
- 21:41advanced and and now there's like this acceptance amongst
- 21:44investors that Bitcoin's not going away at this point.
- 21:47So I think that just shows progress.
- 21:50I have two other observations that Sam made me think of.
- 21:53I feel like so many people right now are distracted by the
- 21:56election and all the political narratives.
- 21:58Like I'm being called on on the news outlets a little bit less
- 22:01because I know that their focus is on the election and I've made
- 22:04it a point not to not to go into that.
- 22:06I don't. I don't, I don't want Bitcoin to
- 22:08become police sized. I don't want it to be something
- 22:11that is right wing or left wing. I, I, I, it's bipartisan.
- 22:14It just is, it's neutral. It's a neutral technology which
- 22:17we need so badly right now to hopefully help unify people.
- 22:20But even the algorithms like on, on Twitter, I noticed that
- 22:23everything kind of ticks up and, and floats to the surface.
- 22:27That is about these politically charged divisive issues.
- 22:30And I, I hope that that changes cause in 2021 we were all at
- 22:37home and I think it was just, we were, we were dealing with the
- 22:40pandemic and everything was closed and everyone was just
- 22:43kind of focused on the market in a weird way.
- 22:45And there wasn't this kind of divisiveness yet.
- 22:48It, it bubbled up in the pandemic.
- 22:51But I'm just, I'm seeing people really distracted by politics
- 22:55right now. And Sam and I are actually
- 22:57trying to, well, we are, we're planning a, a very special event
- 23:00here because we're passionate about orange peeling our local
- 23:03community. I think everyone should do that.
- 23:06Everyone who's passionate about Bitcoin should try to orange
- 23:08peel their friend groups, their family, their local communities.
- 23:12And just, even, I mean, it's, we don't want an event where we're
- 23:16just talking to Bitcoiners, right?
- 23:17And, and a lot of the conferences that we go to, it's
- 23:19a room full of people that believe what we believe.
- 23:23But how do you get the new people in to educate them and
- 23:25give them that 101 And it has been challenging in ways that I
- 23:29did not expect here in Missouri. There is, there's a lot of
- 23:33wealth, mostly real estate wealth.
- 23:35And so they don't see the problem of broken money.
- 23:38They don't see Bitcoin as something they absolutely need
- 23:41to have in their portfolio and something that they would take a
- 23:44Saturday to learn about the history of money.
- 23:47Which again, like, I think all that is so exciting and I think
- 23:49most of us do because we've been down the rabbit hole and we
- 23:52loved that educational knowledge journey.
- 23:55But it's really hard to reach new people and get them wanting
- 23:59to take the time out of their busy schedules and say, look,
- 24:02you really need to learn about this.
- 24:03This is super important if you want to preserve or generate
- 24:06wealth. And, and depending on the the
- 24:09group or depending on their level of wealth already, it's
- 24:14sometimes harder than I, I expected it to be.
- 24:17So yeah, it's it's coming up with trying to figure out how to
- 24:22distract people away from the politics to focus on Bitcoin,
- 24:26but also generate local interest in our community about Bitcoin
- 24:30and and learning about it. Yes, certainly.
- 24:33You know, we focus on scarce assets here and I have to wonder
- 24:37if if I have to wonder if how much of it is just driven by the
- 24:43pain of the scarcity of whatever asset you save your money is, as
- 24:47you just pointed out, bunch of real estate owners, you know,
- 24:52their asset, their primary asset, it's pretty scarce on the
- 24:56spectrum of asset scarcity. It's pretty good.
- 24:59And yeah, I spoke to a group of Realtors a couple months ago.
- 25:06I was actually surprised at the level of engagement and
- 25:09interest. I thought they would Boo me off
- 25:12the stage when I started to explain how Bitcoin was going to
- 25:15take a bite out of their most cherished asset class, which is
- 25:19real estate. But actually they were quite,
- 25:21they were quite attentive. So maybe we've turned over a new
- 25:25leaf with respect to the real estate crowd.
- 25:27But yeah, it seems like it it might take some time.
- 25:31Yeah. And, and in Missouri, I
- 25:34probably, I don't think I've mentioned this to, to either of
- 25:37you, but so the family farm is in Iowa, so have some Midwest
- 25:40connection. And you know, farmers have
- 25:45farmland has been a good asset class in terms of inflation
- 25:48protection because it has that, that dual connection of, of if
- 25:53it's generating commodities. And so, you know, the commodity
- 25:57kind of sets its own price based on all the inputs and what the
- 26:01market will support. And then of course, real estate
- 26:04like, you know, so, so you, you're generating a little yield
- 26:07every year. But, but over the last few
- 26:10decades, the, the big net worth growing side of it has been the
- 26:17value appreciation of the land itself rather than the little
- 26:20yield that you get every year from peace and crops.
- 26:23And you know, if if that's a big part of the culture, the
- 26:25investing landscape of your local region, that's a pretty
- 26:30darn good asset to protect yourself against inflation and
- 26:35to ride the wave of real estate value appreciation as that asset
- 26:39class has been monetized increasingly over the last 40
- 26:42years since the inflation peaked in in 1981, interest rates
- 26:46peaked in 1981. So, you know, that might be part
- 26:49of the uphill battle that you guys face with getting the
- 26:53Midwest to to realize that Bitcoin needs to be a part of
- 26:56the 21st century portfolio. So we we promised we wouldn't
- 27:02talk politics or Natalie probably she wouldn't.
- 27:05So maybe I'll push this one to Sam, at least to start, which
- 27:08is, you know, you've been you've been, of course, covering what's
- 27:13been going on on Capitol Hill lately and the events of the
- 27:17last month. Do you see a shift in policy and
- 27:24the politics with respect to this, you know, historically
- 27:29controversial asset? I mean, I think it's undeniable
- 27:34at this point the the shift happened in the Biden
- 27:38administration. I feel like because it's
- 27:39extremely obvious that Biden has been hostile towards the broader
- 27:44crypto industry. Let's just say, I mean, pretty
- 27:46much every single thing he said or done hasn't been favorable
- 27:50towards this industry. I mean, that's just kind of a
- 27:52fact. I mean, from the executive order
- 27:55ordering different agencies to do research into it and then
- 27:59saying like, hey, we have to stop illicit activity from
- 28:01happening with this new industry.
- 28:03To the illegal data collection on Bitcoin miners that after the
- 28:09Texas boxing associated Suitum was found to be unlawful.
- 28:12To his budget proposal that says he's going to tax Bitcoin miners
- 28:16by 30%. You know, it's really, this is a
- 28:20countless list. And then he appointed Gary
- 28:22Gensler, who has been, you know, got dragged kicking and
- 28:25screaming after losing a lawsuit to finally approve the spot
- 28:29Bitcoin ETFs. He still hasn't approved the
- 28:31options on the spot Bitcoin ETFs.
- 28:34He did that rule for SAP 121 that turned out to be, again,
- 28:39didn't do any kind of congressional review.
- 28:41He just slapped down this rule. There was no kind of comment
- 28:44period. The Government Accountability
- 28:47Office came out and said, hey, actually this needs a
- 28:49congressional review. And then it hits the Congress
- 28:52floor and they overturn it. And then Biden says he's going
- 28:55to veto it. And then it goes to the Senate.
- 28:58And some of these Democrats go against party lines, passes the
- 29:02Senate with bipartisan support. And then Trump does his thing.
- 29:05And then Trump suddenly goes, hey, I'm pro crypto.
- 29:08And then the Biden administration's like, oh, OK.
- 29:11And then they start calling people, and then they actually
- 29:13follow through with the veto, which is interesting, right?
- 29:17Which I think there was a mistake, but maybe it's because
- 29:19of this other stuff that's happening with Trump.
- 29:20They feel like, OK, we don't have to be totally pro crypto
- 29:23yet. But honestly, like, if you look
- 29:26at it, there has been this shift generally and now there's like
- 29:30kind of more bipartisan support. There's more acknowledgement of
- 29:33some of the benefits that Bitcoin can bring.
- 29:35I mean, you have people like Lummis who have been banging the
- 29:38table. Tom Emmer, you have, you know,
- 29:42Warren Davidson, who's in a leadership position.
- 29:45He's, you know, the head of the the House Committee of Financial
- 29:47Services. And so there are advocates in
- 29:51Congress for this industry. And now their voices are just
- 29:54finally being heard, I feel like.
- 29:56And so we'll see if this continues.
- 29:58There is momentum. And obviously having a leading
- 30:01presidential candidate coming out and accepting lightning
- 30:03donations and saying he's pro crypto and he's going to build a
- 30:07pro crypto army. I mean, it's hard to say that
- 30:09that's not positive for Bitcoin adoption.
- 30:12I do agree with Natalie, though. It's like you don't want this
- 30:15thing to become a political issue, but we'll kind of see
- 30:19what the other party does. I mean, there's reasons for both
- 30:21parties to embrace Bitcoin for different reasons.
- 30:25So it doesn't have to be like that, but we'll see how it plays
- 30:27out. But I think the shift is there.
- 30:29I think it's very, very evident for those, you know, keeping a
- 30:31close track of these things. And it, it would be such a shame
- 30:35if it does get politicized and, and becomes a partisan issue.
- 30:38And because effectively 1/2 of the country would be locking
- 30:42themselves out of exploring Bitcoin and, and benefiting from
- 30:46its, you know, savings technology properties for, for
- 30:49some amount of time. For, you know, maybe that takes
- 30:51four years or eight years or 10 years for the, the
- 30:54politicization to be undone eventually from the economic
- 30:58reality playing out. But Sam, I was surprised by the
- 31:01veto going through because it sure felt like it sure felt like
- 31:06the Democrats realized that they can't afford to lose the crypto
- 31:11vote in, in coming into the election and that they, you
- 31:15know, sent out some memo at the highest level and overnight they
- 31:18were going to be pro crypto as well.
- 31:20It felt like that was what was happening.
- 31:22And then the veto goes through. So you're, you're more plugged
- 31:26into this than than any of us. What do you think?
- 31:28Where do you think that leaves the partisan nature of crypto
- 31:33right now? And where do you think that's
- 31:35heading into the election? And we want people get Natalie
- 31:39on the record for that. But I.
- 31:41Think maybe we will. Yeah, I just think he had to go
- 31:44through with the veto and how to do it.
- 31:46Credibility issue. You know, he made a public
- 31:49statement saying it, but I think Wall Street wants this thing
- 31:53overturned. Wall Street wants the ability to
- 31:56custody Bitcoin on behalf of their clients.
- 31:59I mean, they've seen this thing rock it up and they've seen
- 32:02other crypto native firms benefit from being able to do
- 32:05it, but they haven't been able to do it because of this silly
- 32:07rule that was kind of implemented bypassing
- 32:11congressional review. I mean, it wasn't normal
- 32:13procedures. And BNY Mellon State Street were
- 32:16building out their custody solutions for their clients.
- 32:19And because of this random rule, all that was thrown to the
- 32:21wayside. They had to basically fire a
- 32:23bunch of staff. I mean, all that stuff was being
- 32:25developed for years. And then the SEC came out and
- 32:27did that. So I say that because the Wall
- 32:30Street lobby wants this. The American Bankers Association
- 32:33wrote Biden a letter hours before he vetoed it saying like,
- 32:37hey, this is wrong and we want this actually, you're going to,
- 32:41you know, be this is harmful for financial stability.
- 32:44This is harmful for investors. You're preventing the most well
- 32:48regulated financial institutions for custody in these assets on
- 32:52behalf of, you know, their clients for the Bitcoin.
- 32:55And so, I mean, it makes no sense, but I think it was just a
- 32:59credibility issue. And I think when you have Chuck
- 33:01Schumer and major Democratic senators supporting it, I just
- 33:05think it's a matter of time. Maybe it needs an administration
- 33:08change for this to get overturned.
- 33:09Maybe somebody new at the SEC to kind of remove this rule.
- 33:13But it will get overturned because Wall Street wants this.
- 33:16And what Wall Street wants, Wall Street gets.
- 33:18I mean, it's one of the most powerful lobbies in Washington,
- 33:20DC. So maybe it just needs a a
- 33:22change in in leadership before this actually gets through.
- 33:25But I think it's inevitable. Well, and if you just follow the
- 33:28money, I mean, the Democratic senators that broke rank, if you
- 33:30look at where they where they get their donations, a lot of
- 33:34them obviously sided with the Wall Street and banking lobby
- 33:37that support their election campaigns.
- 33:40And so it was really interesting because for the first time, it
- 33:42was like the crypto industry was on the same side as the Wall
- 33:45Street lobby and it wasn't enough for for Biden to veto it.
- 33:51But I do think if you're going to try to come from the other
- 33:54side and and ask the question of, well, why, why maybe would
- 33:58they not want this yet There are some that would defend Gensler
- 34:03in saying that maybe they don't want the transition to happen so
- 34:07quickly because this asset class as it eats into everything else.
- 34:11We want the transition to be as controlled as as possible.
- 34:15And so maybe they're just trying to figure out ways to really
- 34:19implement and integrate this into the traditional system,
- 34:22which obviously is inevitable, but they're trying to, you know,
- 34:25slow those, those those those tremors that come with any sort
- 34:29of transition, especially one that could be this this sizable.
- 34:35So Natalie, you mentioned earlier that one of your
- 34:37inspirations to journalism was holding Wall Street accountable
- 34:43for things that happened, I think, in the global financial
- 34:45crisis. So you've watched this movie
- 34:48play out and we've come full circle to yeah, to Wall Street
- 34:52lobbying in favor what, you know, analysis.
- 34:56I'd love to hear your analysis. We kind of have a little bit,
- 34:58but I, I'd also love to hear your, your feelings about that.
- 35:02About what? About Wall Street coming.
- 35:04About, yeah, about the about Wall Street coming around to to
- 35:07Bitcoin? Yes, exactly.
- 35:08Well, I do, I do. I do think that it, it is
- 35:11inevitable and I'm a huge proponent of free markets and
- 35:13one of the saddest things that I think we have is crony
- 35:18capitalism as opposed to real capitalism.
- 35:20I feel like the, the value and the quality of goods and
- 35:23services, which would be much, much better, much higher if we
- 35:27had real capitalism and, and things that didn't work were
- 35:29actually allowed to fail instead of bailed out.
- 35:31And as I, as I learned more about the history of money and
- 35:35how we became global reserve currency and the Triffin dilemma
- 35:38that comes with that, I, I see why we've become so
- 35:40financialized and, and why bankers and Wall Street makes so
- 35:44much money. And so again, it's like you go
- 35:46down to the, to the very core and drill down to the sand and
- 35:49it's the, it's the money and the incentive system that's
- 35:51completely broken. I, I just, I think that you have
- 35:55to the incentives, Dr. the outcomes.
- 35:57And so I don't think that there are necessarily a bunch of evil
- 36:01people who are running corporations and these Wall
- 36:03Street firms. It's just they're benefiting
- 36:05from a system that allows them to take advantage of it and, and
- 36:08be bailed out if something goes wrong.
- 36:11So I hope Bitcoin at the at the core will fix that.
- 36:15I think that it's a good thing. It's a creative that we have
- 36:17investment vehicles like the ATF so that pension funds and
- 36:20traditional, you know, mom and pop and Busters and Ras can, can
- 36:25move in to start to adopt. But I, I obviously think that
- 36:27it's better to learn how to own spot Bitcoin and self custody
- 36:31and do multi sig custody because why would you, why would you pay
- 36:35these? I mean, they're not high fees
- 36:37right now, they're all competing.
- 36:38But ultimately you're trusting an intermediary, you're
- 36:41introducing counterparty risk and they take a slice of it.
- 36:44So it's not real Bitcoin. But overall, I think it's good
- 36:48that we've gotten to a point of legitimization and I think it's
- 36:51understandable why the black rocks and, and many more firms
- 36:54that are going to follow are going to want to be big Bitcoin
- 36:57holders. So I, I tend to see things as
- 37:01all like, everything's good for Bitcoin and the more
- 37:04corporations on a big and small level that adopt it, the better.
- 37:07I hope that in the far future, I don't think this is going to
- 37:10happen overnight or maybe not even in my lifetime, but I hope
- 37:13we do move to a Bitcoin standard where the money is universal and
- 37:17fair and can reinstate a system of capitalism that creates more
- 37:21competition and allows for again, like real value to
- 37:27surface as opposed to encouraging monopolization.
- 37:30I think what companies do today is just it's horrible.
- 37:33But again, it's, it's not any individual CEO that's evil
- 37:37that's doing this. It's the system that they're
- 37:38taking advantage of to be able to take on cheap corporate debt,
- 37:42buyback shares of stock that boost executive salaries, while
- 37:45meanwhile the products and and services that they offer
- 37:49continually deteriorate and the average workers making like 200
- 37:52times less than a CEO. You can imagine you can
- 37:55understand why populism is on the rise and the workers feel
- 37:58disenfranchised 'cause they are. And so if you had a system that
- 38:02disincentivize things like that and people had to actually
- 38:05compete based on real value and you couldn't just take on all
- 38:08this debt and leverage and re hypothecate, maybe, maybe we
- 38:12would have a better system. Maybe we would have things that
- 38:14we don't even, you know, we can't even imagine now.
- 38:16Maybe we would have faster planes and, and at cooler cars
- 38:20and things that got blocked by, by regulations and, and and got,
- 38:26I don't know. I just, I, I imagine a more
- 38:29abundant and better world with with Bitcoin, but I don't know
- 38:33how long it will take for us to be on the Bitcoin standard.
- 38:37That was awesome. That was, that was the war cry
- 38:39of Bitcoin evangelism right there.
- 38:41Like you brought it back to the, you know, the true north of this
- 38:45makes everything better and, and, and breaks the, the drag
- 38:51that the economy has suffered from for the Fiat era.
- 38:55And it can return us to an era of innovation and abundance
- 39:00through abundance, through scarcity.
- 39:01Ironically, you know, like that's if you have scarcity in
- 39:04the money, you have abundance in, in, in economic innovation.
- 39:08It, it seems, at least looking at the, the, the 150 years
- 39:12between the American Revolution and the advent of central
- 39:14banking in in 1913. So yeah, Hell yeah, Natalie.
- 39:19I was. I was loving that.
- 39:20That was a great rant. Yeah.
- 39:21That was a great rant. Well, I do.
- 39:23I think about it a lot. I mean, I think most of us do,
- 39:26especially when we travel. Even people who don't understand
- 39:28Bitcoin, it's like why? Why are planes?
- 39:31They feel smaller. The food isn't as good as it
- 39:34used to be. The nothing's as clean as it
- 39:37used to be. My my meal at the store is more
- 39:40expensive, but it's smaller and the ingredients are awful.
- 39:43For me it's like just follow the money, follow why this is
- 39:46happening because they have to continue to get X amount, you
- 39:49know, increase in, in the amount of size and profit every single
- 39:53year. And how are you going to, how
- 39:54are you going to do that without sacrificing the quality while
- 39:57you're paying your CEO, you know, $5,000,000 a year?
- 40:00I all of this, that's why I totally, I totally get why
- 40:04people are like, we need a higher minimum wage.
- 40:06I don't believe in it anymore because of the economic studies
- 40:09I've done. But it's like, I get why the
- 40:11cries are there because everyone recognizes the problem.
- 40:15They just can't figure out how to properly identify the cause
- 40:19and what the solution is. Whether you've been buying
- 40:22Bitcoin for years or just getting started on your journey,
- 40:25our Multi Institution Custody solution is the safest and
- 40:28easiest way to custody your Bitcoin.
- 40:30With On Ramp and our partners at Bitco and Coincover, you can
- 40:33sleep soundly at night knowing that your Bitcoin is safe from
- 40:35exchange failures, the loss of seed phrases, and broken
- 40:38hardware devices. On Ramps Multi Institution
- 40:41Custody Solution eliminates any single point of failure,
- 40:44distributes counterparty risk, and minimizes required trust,
- 40:47all while providing greater assurances that a client's
- 40:50Bitcoin is secure and auditable on chain.
- 40:53As a client of On Ramp, your assets live in a multi save
- 40:55vault controlled by three distinct entities, none of which
- 40:58have unilateral control. On Ramp provides products and
- 41:01services that honor our clients ownership and control of the
- 41:04underlying asset. To learn more about Multi
- 41:07Institution Custody, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 41:11When, when you're, when you're talking about this, it sounds
- 41:13like it sounds like pure journalism to me.
- 41:15Like I just keeping struck by like this is a journalist's
- 41:18curiosity and intellectual curiosity digging into the core
- 41:22problem here. And, and it brings it back to
- 41:24what you said earlier, Natalie, like I'm curious to get your
- 41:28opinion on this. Why haven't more journalists
- 41:30figured out that this this is the thing that they should be
- 41:34focused on? Yeah, I've wondered that because
- 41:37I, first of all, you know, it's funny.
- 41:39A lot of people think that news is very glamorous, so you're on
- 41:42TV, so you must make a ton of money.
- 41:44And what a great lifestyle. It's really tough.
- 41:47You start out and you're out. My first job was paying like
- 41:50$28,000 a year when I had student loan debt.
- 41:53And my first internship in high school paid more than my first
- 41:57real job with a master's degree in news.
- 42:00And it's a tough grind. You work weekends, you work
- 42:02nights, You're sent on some of the most dangerous stories and
- 42:06settings and environments. But what I realized is that I I
- 42:10think one of the reasons I appreciated Bitcoin more and
- 42:14faster than my colleagues seem to be is I had a pain point.
- 42:18And that pain point was my families financial loss and
- 42:22crisis. And the, the two of them, my
- 42:24parents, I grew up with the stories of them growing up under
- 42:26communism and how this total government control of the
- 42:30economy was a way to create poverty and of the black market
- 42:35is where people transacted in value.
- 42:37And, and there was real price discovery.
- 42:40I, I didn't actually learn until very recently that my gram, the
- 42:44reason that my parents were able to have an apartment in Poland
- 42:47because everyone got like a small government apartment.
- 42:49But the reason my parents were able to to actually upgrade
- 42:52theirs was because my grandma sold meat on the black market.
- 42:57She was a cook for government police and she sold extra meat,
- 43:01risked her, you know, her life and her livelihood by selling it
- 43:05on the black market and was able to accumulate enough cash that
- 43:08they were able to get a bigger apartment in Poland before they
- 43:11came to the United States. And everything was transacted in
- 43:14that way. And and there was just no social
- 43:18mobility or, or economic hope that you were going to be able
- 43:22to achieve, you know, something great in life.
- 43:24And my parents always wanted to come here, especially my mom.
- 43:27She looked at the United States as a beacon of hope and
- 43:30opportunity that no matter where you come from, you could come
- 43:32from the deepest levels of poverty.
- 43:35If you work hard and you get an education like you can do and be
- 43:39whatever you want. It's like a level playing field
- 43:41of opportunity and you, you determine it.
- 43:44It's your it's your work that determines your success.
- 43:47And I think a lot of people hope for that.
- 43:50It's like the American dream became a universal dream.
- 43:54It tapped into these universal human desires that we all have.
- 43:59And I, I think that Bitcoin will help us maybe revive some of
- 44:04that because you're right. I mean, when I was a journalist,
- 44:07I just, I felt like a lot of people are getting sucked into
- 44:10the narrative of whatever these government agencies were telling
- 44:15them without doing some more critical thinking and
- 44:17questioning things. But because of my mom, I
- 44:20questioned everything. I mean, we would put out
- 44:21studies. And I'm like, I don't think that
- 44:23this is like, what's the other side of this and why aren't we
- 44:26sharing it? And, and so I grew up with a
- 44:29very skeptical mind because of my parents and what they went
- 44:32through where they couldn't trust their media and my
- 44:35friends, for the most part, they grew up in that like golden era
- 44:40of, of America. The I mean, 80s and 90s was
- 44:44amazing. I think it was like the best era
- 44:46to grow up in technology was like enough to make your life
- 44:51more interesting and easy and efficient, but not too much
- 44:54where you're just like sitting on your, you know, phone all day
- 44:56and have a different version of yourself via online
- 44:59personalities. It was just, it was like a very
- 45:02prosperous time, I think in in America's legacy and history.
- 45:07And then all of a sudden we realized that we've burdened
- 45:09that entire generation and they're now trying to pay the
- 45:11tab and they can afford anything.
- 45:13None of my generation can afford their own house without parental
- 45:16help. And so a lot of the people that
- 45:17I worked with, they did, I mean, they grew up in really great
- 45:21middle, upper middle class homes.
- 45:23They had enough to get by. They weren't worried.
- 45:25And they assumed that their job would only help them accelerate
- 45:28in life and do even better than their parents.
- 45:30Only to, you know, find themselves in their mid 30s now
- 45:33being like, why am I still working super hard and can't
- 45:36accumulate, can't buy a house or can't start a family.
- 45:40And so that's why I hope more of them learn about Bitcoin.
- 45:42But I also think the people that reach Bitcoin sooner are the
- 45:45ones that have like a pain point or something that they
- 45:47experience where they're like, wait a second, there is a real
- 45:50problem and hopefully there's something to address it.
- 45:54I love that analysis and and the focus on questioning,
- 45:59questioning the party line, questioning the existing
- 46:02edifice, you know, the narrative essentially.
- 46:05That's fantastic, Sam. I'd love to get your take a
- 46:09little bit from from an analysis perspective.
- 46:12You've been analyzing Bitcoin and everything it touches for
- 46:17years now. What are some of the more
- 46:20interesting or maybe counterintuitive elements that
- 46:25you've come across in your analysis or maybe analysis that
- 46:29might violate some of the narratives either with respect
- 46:33to Bitcoin or its value or or anything it touches?
- 46:37Yeah, I'd say, you know, one is that, you know, all these ETF
- 46:42inflows and it's just, it's been interesting to see the price
- 46:46just go completely sideways. You had the big run up up until
- 46:51March, and then it's just kind of chopped around sideways for a
- 46:55few months now. And people are like, well,
- 46:56what's going on? These ETFs are gobbling up all
- 46:59these Bitcoin and there's only so much Bitcoin being mined
- 47:02after having the, you know, where's the supply shock?
- 47:05Whereas all the demand's still there and they're wondering why
- 47:07they're selling, but it's actually the long term holders
- 47:09that are selling right now. So those those like that metric
- 47:12that everybody pointed to all the time was like, oh, 7070%
- 47:17plus of Bitcoin. UTXOS haven't moved in greater
- 47:19than a year. You know, people are holding,
- 47:22but what you see in previous cycles of when the price gets
- 47:27back up to previous all time highs, you typically see churn
- 47:31there. And that's kind of what we're
- 47:32seeing now. So it's actually spot selling
- 47:35that I think is causing some of the sideways price action or why
- 47:38Bitcoins not going to the moon or going to 80K or 90K right
- 47:42now. People, if you if you think
- 47:44about UTXOS, just because people held for a year or two doesn't
- 47:48mean technically that they are convicted hodlers.
- 47:51It could be somebody who bought the last top who's basically
- 47:54stared at Bitcoin and hated it for the last two years because
- 47:57it's been underwater and they're like, man, this thing sucks.
- 47:59Everyone told me it was going to be great.
- 48:01They don't understand what they own.
- 48:02They don't have a long term mindset, but they didn't want to
- 48:04sell at a loss during the bear market.
- 48:06Maybe they're smart enough to know that.
- 48:07So once it got up to their previous entry point, which is
- 48:10probably around the previous all time high, they finally sell
- 48:13after breaking even or they're maybe they're a little bit in
- 48:15profit. So I think that's part of the
- 48:17reason why you see churn around previous all time highs and I
- 48:19think that's what we're experiencing.
- 48:21So people are wondering why it's selling and it's actually these
- 48:24long term like convicted hodlers that are starting to sell.
- 48:29And I think I think that's temporary though, because I
- 48:31think everyone on this call would probably agree that now
- 48:33would probably not be a good time to sell.
- 48:36I think it's actually a good time to accumulate because you
- 48:38typically see this in the early stages of bull markets.
- 48:42Usually there's a bit of a chop around the previous all time
- 48:45high. It takes a couple of times to
- 48:46breakthrough with momentum and then there's a lot of price
- 48:48discovery afterwards. And so I think that's ahead of
- 48:51us. And I think there's a lot of,
- 48:53you know, institutional investors that are still doing
- 48:56their due diligence with this thing.
- 48:58And I think that's still coming. You saw that from Fidelity, you
- 49:01saw that from BlackRock, Vanek. They all said the same thing as
- 49:05that primarily the early the 1st wave of ETF buying was primarily
- 49:09retail investors. It wasn't the institutional
- 49:11investors with all the money. It was retail because it just
- 49:14takes time for these large institutions to pull a trigger
- 49:18on a new asset. Some of them actually can't even
- 49:20do it before a certain amount of time if there's a new investment
- 49:23vehicle to invest in. So all that to say, right now
- 49:28there's some long term holders that are selling.
- 49:31I think that's temporary. I think this is a period of
- 49:34accumulation that's occurring. And I think this is the early
- 49:37stage of the bull cycle. And I think you're going to see
- 49:40a lot of these institutional investors, a lot of these big
- 49:42names. I think it's going to be the
- 49:44next SEC filings next quarter. I think you're going to continue
- 49:48to see really interesting names pop up, different types of
- 49:51institutional investors that are getting their feet wet here.
- 49:54And with each, with each one of those, it just gets the market
- 49:56excited. You know, another pension fund,
- 49:58another big company, you know, another really prominent
- 50:03investor, you know, all those are like white swan events that
- 50:06will just compound it on a on another and get more people to
- 50:09open their eyes and maybe take a look at this Bitcoin thing
- 50:11again. I'm beyond shocked that we're
- 50:14not at 90 or 100K yet. Beyond shocked, especially with
- 50:19the equities and indexes getting to new all time highs.
- 50:23I'm, I'm, I'm really surprised and I think maybe we'll wake up
- 50:27one day with a massive green candle, but I'm really surprised
- 50:33we haven't gotten there yet. Yeah, I was looking at this
- 50:36recently, last cycle. So, you know, in 2020 we got
- 50:40stuck at prior all time high for five weeks and in 2016, so then
- 50:472017 when we got stuck at prior all time high, we were there for
- 50:501515 weeks. And right now it's been 12-13
- 50:54weeks stuck at prior all time high.
- 50:56So it is boring as it has been. It's par for the course.
- 51:00And I think you're right, Sam, I think the the snowball of good
- 51:03news is, is is going to happen, you know, as as the halving
- 51:08continues to play out is planning to be.
- 51:12Yeah. One more thing I'd say is that I
- 51:14love this report that Fidelity put out looking at Bitcoins
- 51:17volatility. I don't know if you guys caught
- 51:19that one, but and Hoffa, the CIO at Swan, he recently did some
- 51:25research on this too. It's basically we're at a
- 51:27historic low period of volatility from Bitcoin over
- 51:30like the last year. And typically that occurs at the
- 51:32end of bear markets and you can think of it as like a coiled
- 51:35spring. And usually there's a lot of
- 51:38apathy with the price. And then there's really a lot of
- 51:43outperformance that occurs after periods of very low volatility,
- 51:46which is what we're in right now.
- 51:48And so that's another reason to get excited, I'd say.
- 51:50And, and I would just go check out that report from Fidelity.
- 51:53I think it's one of my favorite pieces that they put out in a
- 51:56while. So go check that out, Chris
- 51:58Kuiper over there. And the team did a really good
- 52:00job with it. There's a related dynamic there
- 52:04perhaps I think Sam, which you highlighted with, you know,
- 52:08price sort of bumping up against prior all time high and maybe
- 52:13those one year holders, you know, reducing their holdings.
- 52:18And we've kind of the prices hit and it's tested once, I don't
- 52:21know, we're on like the 4th or 5th in a retest of that 70 ish
- 52:27$1000 level. And perhaps, yeah, perhaps once
- 52:31those should we call them medium term holders?
- 52:35You know, once we grind, grind through their supply, you know,
- 52:38there might be, there might be an opportunity for, for upward
- 52:42movement there. I'm curious, Natalie, you, I
- 52:45mean, your channel is substantial and you're doing,
- 52:50you know, relevant news content, you know, week to week, but
- 52:54you're also interviewing experts in the field.
- 52:58And then I heard you say you're, you know, you're working on some
- 53:00more basic content or as well. Are you seeing any patterns in
- 53:06interest in different kinds of content on your channel that
- 53:11gives you any insight about what people are interested in and
- 53:15what and what's going on? Yes, fascinating insight.
- 53:20My most popular episodes are with Colonel Douglas McGregor
- 53:25and Whitney Webb and both of them are, I mean, Bitcoin is a
- 53:30tiny portion of those interviews.
- 53:32They're really talking about the ideas of the new world order and
- 53:36de dollarization and things like geopolitics changing and
- 53:41corruption on on a deep level and people really respond to
- 53:46that. I did another show recently with
- 53:48Ed Dowd. We talked about sort of also
- 53:51that he investigates like the deep state and the the
- 53:54consolidation of big banks. And is there kind of like a
- 53:58banking implosion on the way where we're going to have even
- 54:00fewer too big to fail banks and we're going to move to a CBDC
- 54:04that got a lot of views and listen.
- 54:08So people are really interested in these very kind of triggering
- 54:13and sometimes outright negative themes and topics, which is, I
- 54:20understand, but I, I'm sick. I'm a really positive person.
- 54:26Like I, I really don't believe that there are evil people that
- 54:30are in control, guiding us and trying to create this controlled
- 54:33demolition. At least I hope not.
- 54:34But I, in my core, I don't believe that.
- 54:36I think that the system, it's, it's just so broken.
- 54:40And individual actors who are at different levels of power and
- 54:43influence are just taking advantage of it as best they can
- 54:46for themselves and for their families.
- 54:48And it's a lot of just, they want to survive and they want
- 54:51their organizations and groups of power and structures to
- 54:54survive. So I think we have to strike at
- 54:57the heart of all of it in a very sly, roundabout way, which is
- 55:01Bitcoin. It's not, it's not a war, it's
- 55:03not violent. It's not like coming at them
- 55:06aggressively and and forcing anything down anyone's throat.
- 55:10It's like this peaceful opt out into a beautiful new system
- 55:13because it's so hard to reform a very corrupted system and try to
- 55:17battle all the people who have much at stake.
- 55:21It's, I think it's easier to create a new one and then get
- 55:23people to see like this one's a lot better.
- 55:25You should go over to this world.
- 55:27And so I think that new technologies always win.
- 55:30It just takes some time and sometimes the old guard has to
- 55:33has to move on from this world and that'll happen with Bitcoin.
- 55:38But I just, it's been interesting to see that like
- 55:41when I bring on guests that are of sort of, you know, wanting to
- 55:44talk about the New World Order and the the, the forces that are
- 55:49enacting more control and limiting all of our freedoms,
- 55:53that gets a lot, a lot of attention.
- 55:57I want to under score the Colonel McGregor episodes.
- 55:59I really enjoyed those. And he has, well, first of all,
- 56:04he's very articulate, but also he has such a command and
- 56:08knowledge base of geopolitics and, and obviously military
- 56:12dynamics and understanding about power structures.
- 56:17And yeah, it is a nice, it is a nice juxtaposition though.
- 56:21You're always so positive. Bitcoin gives you hope.
- 56:24It gives me hope too. It gives all of us, all of us
- 56:27hope. I think it would be a darker
- 56:29world that we live in today in the absence of Bitcoin's
- 56:34existence for sure. Yeah, well, a funny story about
- 56:37Colonel Two. I, I didn't know he was a
- 56:39bitcoiner. I was really trying to better
- 56:41understand the, the geopolitical conflicts that are impacting the
- 56:45global economy. And I thought he was very smart
- 56:47about everything that's happening with, with the shifts
- 56:50globally and the risks right now when it comes to the dollar and
- 56:54our status as like a global leader.
- 56:57And, and then he just came on and he was like, I, I own
- 57:02Bitcoin. This is awesome.
- 57:05Now I understand why you said yes to my show.
- 57:07He's great. He's fascinating.
- 57:10To see it. What about you, Sam?
- 57:12Are you, you know, are there any guests you've had on Swan Signal
- 57:15lately that have surprised you or that have gotten surprising
- 57:20amount of traction in terms of the audience?
- 57:24No, I mean, it's kind of been the typical, the macro guys that
- 57:27usually do well. People love macro.
- 57:29I mean, I think we all know that.
- 57:31So like the Luke Romans of the world, James Lavish I, I brought
- 57:35up Chris Kiper. I really enjoyed that episode
- 57:38that I had with Chris because you know, when he he came on and
- 57:42we really delved into proof of work for his proof of stake.
- 57:45And I think that's actually going to be a topic that's going
- 57:48to come back in full force here with the approval of the spot
- 57:52Ethereum ETFs. You know, why is proof of work
- 57:54so important? You know, why can't we do this
- 57:58by being quote UN quote, 99% more energy efficient with proof
- 58:01of stake? What are the trade-offs?
- 58:03And I think he does a really good job of laying it all out
- 58:07and, and the benefits of proof of work.
- 58:09And so I really enjoyed that episode.
- 58:11I got really good reviews and comments.
- 58:14And he said that he's never, he's been on a lot of shows and
- 58:16he, nobody ever asked him about that research paper that he
- 58:20wrote. And he says it's one, it's his
- 58:21favorite one that he's written. So that was that was probably
- 58:24the my favorite recent guest that I've had on.
- 58:28It's interesting for for both of you.
- 58:30It's not really like Bitcoin specific topics that that have
- 58:34been popular or gotten more traction for you recently.
- 58:38I, I sort of wonder if that's just a, a symptom of, of an
- 58:42outcome of where we are in the cycle and that there's not a lot
- 58:45of fresh interest right now, not a lot of people Googling Bitcoin
- 58:49for the first time at this point in time.
- 58:51But historically that happens first, you know, six months,
- 58:56maybe a year, every four years. And we're kind of coming up on
- 59:00that time when that would would typically start to happen.
- 59:04So maybe that will flip for you guys in, in the, in the coming
- 59:08year at some point where suddenly people, you know,
- 59:11there's a wave of, of new listeners who just want to learn
- 59:14about Bitcoin because price keeps going up and they need to
- 59:17know why. Well, I definitely think there's
- 59:20an appetite for one O 1 content because earlier this year we put
- 59:25out a a course. I hosted it for Swan and it's
- 59:29totally just 101 and really approachable bite size, like
- 59:33less than 10 minute clips. Oh, sorry.
- 59:35And and it's just talking about what is Bitcoin at the very at
- 59:39the very fundamental level. And that got a lot of traction
- 59:42and a lot of views to the point that I was even like, wow.
- 59:45I mean, there's clearly a lot of people who are just starting at
- 59:47the beginning who need more content like this.
- 59:51Yeah, that's awesome. There's so much better Evergreen
- 59:53content now than than there was. And before 20/18 it was like
- 59:57there kind of wasn't anything like truly Evergreen like before
- 1:00:01bullish case for Bitcoin, Bitcoin standard.
- 1:00:03It was like Andreas videos. And since then it's it's all the
- 1:00:07great stuff that Swan's putting out all these awesome podcasts.
- 1:00:11Natalie, yours, your stuff is just the most accessible for for
- 1:00:15someone who's who's new to Bitcoin.
- 1:00:18That's actually I, I, I point people of all, of all the
- 1:00:21interviews that the podcast that, that I've been on, I point
- 1:00:24people to the one that I did with you as, as like, you know,
- 1:00:28the my go to because it's such an accessible format.
- 1:00:32And you know, thank goodness that that stuff exists.
- 1:00:35And, and again, this, this feels like this is how Bitcoin wins
- 1:00:38because of the, the inevitable virality of the, the content
- 1:00:43propagated by more and more capable people as we move
- 1:00:47through the adoption curve and win more talent.
- 1:00:49It it's it's great to see. Well, I'm excited that you're
- 1:00:54both doing one-on-one content as well as, you know, deep in the
- 1:00:58weeds coverage. Natalie, I wonder this may be
- 1:01:02speculation. I mean, we can talk about what
- 1:01:05you're working on now or what stories interest you the most,
- 1:01:08but I'm curious what you think is likely to, you know, to be of
- 1:01:14interest to you, not just to your audience, but to you
- 1:01:18specifically with respect to this whole wild and wooly space.
- 1:01:24I mean, what, what do you think you're gonna be most intrigued
- 1:01:27about getting into the details on going forward?
- 1:01:30Well, to be honest, my focus is really 101 information and
- 1:01:35content right now. I feel like there are so many
- 1:01:38people that we need to reach who we haven't yet.
- 1:01:41And I'm trying to just really put myself in that mindset that
- 1:01:45I had back in 2017 where I was first investing in Bitcoin.
- 1:01:49Was totally skeptical, terrified that I was going to lose all my
- 1:01:52money, not sure what I was doing and and intimidated frankly, by
- 1:01:56the space because so many people come from an engineering or
- 1:02:00finance or computer science background.
- 1:02:02It was a lot of men. I just felt like I didn't really
- 1:02:04fit in and I didn't have the expertise that was needed in
- 1:02:08order to get involved in the space.
- 1:02:10And I realized that I, I mean, everyone, we need everyone.
- 1:02:14Bitcoin is for everyone. And so I'm focusing on that.
- 1:02:16I'm focusing on, on, like I said, writing scripts to help
- 1:02:20teach people, working on some special videos that will
- 1:02:22hopefully come out in the coming months.
- 1:02:25And just just get people to really understand at a
- 1:02:28fundamental level why this is such an important opportunity.
- 1:02:31And maybe like bring together all of these great analysis and
- 1:02:36themes that so many people have written on everything from the
- 1:02:40fundamental of how Bitcoin mining works to the human rights
- 1:02:43angle to the energy angle. And like, really, how do you
- 1:02:45break that down? Simply because I've always been
- 1:02:47someone who I speak to a mainstream audience and I don't
- 1:02:51know what their level of expertise is.
- 1:02:53And perhaps I assume that they have maybe no financial literacy
- 1:02:56at all like I did when I started out.
- 1:02:58And it's like, how do you make something interesting and
- 1:03:00approachable and easy to digest? Because if you can, if you
- 1:03:04really understand something, you can, you can share it simply.
- 1:03:08And that's truly the greatest challenge to know it that well,
- 1:03:11that you can explain it in, in 30 seconds in a way A5 year old
- 1:03:14can understand. So I'm constantly on that
- 1:03:17journey of bettering myself when it comes to explaining Bitcoin
- 1:03:20simply. Yeah.
- 1:03:23And you've clearly achieved that with respect to your, you know,
- 1:03:26mainstream news show appearances.
- 1:03:30That's one of my favorite things that you do.
- 1:03:32But I'm glad that you're also applying yourself with respect
- 1:03:35to talking to talking to noobs, talking to people that are just
- 1:03:39approaching Bitcoin for the first time.
- 1:03:41We're getting up on time here, but I wanna ask you the same
- 1:03:45kind of the same, the same question.
- 1:03:46What do you think's gonna what interests you most at the
- 1:03:49moment? Or what do you think is gonna
- 1:03:51interest you with respect to analysis or what's going on in
- 1:03:55Bitcoin in the coming months? Well, I think, I think corporate
- 1:03:59adoption of Bitcoin is really interesting right now.
- 1:04:02I mean, we saw similar scientific come out and
- 1:04:05basically implement the micro strategy, you know, strategy,
- 1:04:08Bitcoin treasury strategy. And I think it's very, very
- 1:04:11early days there. And it's just fascinating to see
- 1:04:15them basically use the financial system to raise debt or raise
- 1:04:20capital in any way they can to acquire this harder asset.
- 1:04:23I mean, it is that Pierre Rochard speculative attack in
- 1:04:26action right now and corporations just have this
- 1:04:29access to capital markets that an individual just doesn't have.
- 1:04:34And so it's extremely exciting. And it's really not just these
- 1:04:37public companies. You know, any, any business
- 1:04:39that's like a cash flowing business can find creative ways
- 1:04:43to incorporate Bitcoin into their organizations.
- 1:04:46And I think you're going to see that really develop because some
- 1:04:49of these barriers that have prevented them in the past, like
- 1:04:51the, you know, the FASB accounting rules, etcetera.
- 1:04:54You know, they've come down and now we have a proof of concept.
- 1:04:57I mean, you can't look at micro strategy stock and not say it's
- 1:05:00been a massive success since they've adopted a bitcoins
- 1:05:03treasury strategy. And when similar scientific
- 1:05:06announces it, their stock goes up 25%.
- 1:05:08I mean, the market likes it, the market really likes it.
- 1:05:11And now you have, you know, Dylan over in Japan and you
- 1:05:14know, this is all just getting started.
- 1:05:17And, and so I think that's something that I'm really
- 1:05:19excited about kind of looking at how these organizations are
- 1:05:24going about it. What is their strategy?
- 1:05:26I think it's, you have these pioneers, it's such a deviation
- 1:05:30to how these CFOs typically think about treasury management
- 1:05:33for a corporation. So it is going to take time for
- 1:05:36these corporations to get their head around it.
- 1:05:38But the the proof of concepts there.
- 1:05:40I mean, even just look at Peter McCormick and what he's done.
- 1:05:43I mean, it's amazing what he's done with that, you know,
- 1:05:45football, soccer, organization, what do you want to call it?
- 1:05:48And you know, he's done. It's like what the, what a
- 1:05:51Bitcoin standard does to an organization.
- 1:05:53I mean, it's probably even there's some intangible stuff
- 1:05:56there that that we talk about at individual level, what it does
- 1:05:59at the corporate level. So that's something that I'm
- 1:06:02really focused on, really interested in keeping track of.
- 1:06:05And so when when another similar scientific comes out, I'm all
- 1:06:08over it. And I just think it's very, very
- 1:06:10early days there. Yeah, it's so awesome what what
- 1:06:13Peter's dealing with, with Bedford going from the 9th tier
- 1:06:16and with the with the stated goal of getting to the Premier
- 1:06:19League and with the tailwind of Bitcoin like that might actually
- 1:06:22happen, you know, if that becomes.
- 1:06:24So cool, that's a documentary. It's unbelievable.
- 1:06:27And you're right that you're right that I think that we
- 1:06:31collectively got lulled to sleep a bit on corporate treasury
- 1:06:35adoption of Bitcoin, that the micro strategy playbook, because
- 1:06:39micro strategy came out with that they're buying Bitcoin,
- 1:06:42they're doing this. And it felt like, OK, the next
- 1:06:44domino is going to happen any month.
- 1:06:46And it was years with, with nobody else following suit,
- 1:06:49right? And I still, so I think that
- 1:06:51collectively we Bitcoiners sort of feel like that's not going to
- 1:06:55happen because it hasn't been happening in the last few years.
- 1:06:58But you're right that like the, the proof of concept is there
- 1:07:01and then the FASB rules the, the thing that Michael Saylor said,
- 1:07:04this is one of the three biggest developments that could happen
- 1:07:07for Bitcoin. The FASB rules went through and
- 1:07:09now it's possible for assembler or any other public company to
- 1:07:15book profits on their quarterly reports from marking up their
- 1:07:19Bitcoin. And that becomes a much more
- 1:07:22attractive reason to adopt the the micro strategy playbook.
- 1:07:25And now it's happening. So it really is like, you know,
- 1:07:28we had to wait. We had to wait for the proof of
- 1:07:29concept to play out, but now it's time to actually get
- 1:07:32excited about that playbook. I think you're right, Sam.
- 1:07:34Yeah, I think there's one one other thing is just like the SAB
- 1:07:37121 one seconds overturn. If you have a corporation and
- 1:07:41your existing banking partners can finally just help you out,
- 1:07:45you don't have to get another bank and go find like the coin
- 1:07:48basis of the world, whoever it is to to hold have a whole
- 1:07:50nother custody situation. Your existing banking partner
- 1:07:53that you do all the business with that you've been with for
- 1:07:551015 years now they can just make it easy to custody on your
- 1:07:59behalf because institutions are different, right?
- 1:08:01They're completely different. That's going to open the doors
- 1:08:03as well. Anything that like reduces the
- 1:08:05barrier of entry for these CFOs and CEOs is going to be helpful
- 1:08:10for corporate adoption. So I expect I think that's one
- 1:08:13thing Saylor said as well. He just, you need to break down
- 1:08:16the barrier for Wall Street institutions and large financial
- 1:08:19institutions to be able to custody these assets as well.
- 1:08:22And I know we always talk about self custody and how it's
- 1:08:25important, but institutions are kind of different, right?
- 1:08:27They, they have different regulations that they need to
- 1:08:29adhere to. And so that's just another thing
- 1:08:32that I'm looking for that's going to just be, you know,
- 1:08:35tailwind to all corporate adoption in the future.
- 1:08:37And I think it's inevitable, like I said earlier.
- 1:08:40Well, you have both been doing a tremendous job over the years of
- 1:08:44breaking down barriers with respect to knowledge and
- 1:08:46education about Bitcoin. So I thank you both.
- 1:08:49This has been a tremendous conversation.
- 1:08:52Of course, highly recommend people check out both your
- 1:08:56channel, Natalie and your Sam, all of your content and your
- 1:09:00shows. And as we close here, just kick
- 1:09:03it to you, Sam, any anything else you want to give someone as
- 1:09:07a handoff and then Natalie, you can close.
- 1:09:11Yeah, no, you can just follow me on X at at Sam Cala S AM CALLAH.
- 1:09:16You can find some of my work on the Swan Signal blog as well as
- 1:09:19Swan Signal Live. I do the podcast and Natalie
- 1:09:21mentioned the event we're throwing in our hometown.
- 1:09:24You can check that out at bitcoinhyphenlunch.com.
- 1:09:27If you're interested in in sending fans from friends or
- 1:09:31family, or if you live in the area, come check it out.
- 1:09:34Will there be chairs at the event?
- 1:09:37There will be chairs. They're literally fixated.
- 1:09:39You know, it's an auditorium, so there will be chairs.
- 1:09:42Good to. Know Good to know, Natalie,
- 1:09:45close this out. Yeah, it's in a nice venue.
- 1:09:47I hope. I hope to Orange help orange
- 1:09:49Pelt Missouri. No, I'm just, I'm just really
- 1:09:51grateful. This work is challenging in the
- 1:09:54most rewarding way, and I just can't wait to see the next wave.
- 1:09:58I really think a lot of millennial women are going to on
- 1:10:00board next. A lot of my peer group who I'm
- 1:10:03really excited for because they need it.
- 1:10:05They need it so much and I'm just really inspired by the
- 1:10:09people I've met in this space. And I can't wait for in the next
- 1:10:12year, the turnarounds, the big companies, the big, the
- 1:10:15legendary names that were against Bitcoin who are coming
- 1:10:18around to our our side because really it doesn't benefit anyone
- 1:10:21to be against Bitcoin. This is Bitcoin, It helps
- 1:10:25everyone in every way possible. So I can't wait to see to see
- 1:10:30how this bull cycle shapes up. We've got a long way to go.
- 1:10:34That's it. And we're looking forward to
- 1:10:37enjoying that ride. Well, thank you, Natalie.
- 1:10:39Thank you, Sam. And this has been another
- 1:10:41episode of Scarce Assets. Thank you.
- 1:10:45Thank you. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:10:47week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:10:49valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:10:51rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:10:54All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:10:56notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:10:59reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:11:01entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:11:04investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:11:07your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:11:10Visit onrampbitcoin.com. Contact Schedule a consultation
- 1:11:14with one of our private client advisors.