Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 5 Episode 11: Empowering Children: Healing from Domestic Abuse with Dr. Asha Patel
Transcript
- 0:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And we're back, and we're back.
- 0:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Hi, hey, there.
- 0:19David Mandel: Hey, this is Partner with Survivor.
- 0:21David Mandel: Yes, and I'm David Mandel, ceo of the Safe Retailer Institute.
- 0:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I'm Ruth Ramundo Mandel and I am the co-owner and business development officer.
- 0:29David Mandel: That's great, and we're here to do another episode of the show and we're really excited about what we have going on today talking about children impacted by domestic violence, perpetrators, behavior and the treatment of those children.
- 0:43David Mandel: And we're going to talk with leading international expert, dr Asha Patel, about that.
- 0:47David Mandel: But before we get into that, let me just acknowledge that we are coming to you from Tungsten Misako land here in the northeast part of the United States Beautiful country, though it's a little bit cold and rainy and snowy and all those things right now and just want to acknowledge this is colonized land and just acknowledging the indigenous elders, past, present and emerging who might be listening to the show.
- 1:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah.
- 1:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So today we have Dr Asha Patel, who's leading Innovating Minds, as the CEO and clinical psychologist, and her focus is on transforming access to early trauma-informed help for children and young people, and their approach hinges on sustainable, scalable models that maintain clinical integrity, and their team dedication has led to multiple awards recognizing the social enterprise for influence and growth, and the key competencies include digital transformation of services, enabling a broader impact and providing crucial hybrid training to frontline practitioners and Dr Asha Patel's leading minds.
- 1:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Innovating minds organization facilitates the Healing Together program, and the Healing Together program offers direct services to children to support their mental health and well-being.
- 2:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: The Healing Together program is a six-week trauma-informed program for children ages 6 to 16.
- 2:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It combines trauma-informed principles with relational approaches, neuroscience and attachment models, and each session helps children make the link between the mind and body and teaches simple tools children can use to help them regulate.
- 2:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: The materials are grounded in research and written by Dr Asha Patel, who's a clinical psychologist, and Jane Evans, who's a childhood trauma expert, and the program is developed by Innovating Minds as an award-winning social enterprise that supports children who are impacted by domestic abuse, and one of the important reasons we wanted to have her on this is because we sit at the crossroads between children and domestic abuse, and we were really interested in their work and in the innovations that they're bringing forward.
- 3:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I really believed, as well, that digital access is really important for the equity and access of people to get services.
- 3:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It makes it easier for them.
- 3:23Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So welcome, dr Patel.
- 3:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's really nice to have you on the show.
- 3:30Dr. Asha Patel: Thank you.
- 3:30Dr. Asha Patel: Thank you for welcoming me to your show.
- 3:34Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, we wanted to get started really with sort of understanding a little bit more about the Healing Together program and how you came about formulating that, what your motivation was in working with children, particularly who are domestic abuse victims.
- 3:56Dr. Asha Patel: Yeah, sure.
- 3:57Dr. Asha Patel: So my journey started 2016 for Innovating Minds.
- 4:02Dr. Asha Patel: Prior to that, I was a clinical psychologist working in forensic mental health services, so I worked with high-profile murderers, sex offenders, and really felt like I was working at the wrong end of the spectrum.
- 4:15Dr. Asha Patel: So I was looking around, risk assessment and supporting their rehabilitation.
- 4:20Dr. Asha Patel: But actually a lot of their journeys and their stories stem from childhood trauma.
- 4:25Dr. Asha Patel: So Innovating Minds was founded to support children and families access early, early support, early trauma-informed support.
- 4:34Dr. Asha Patel: Now, a part of that journey of startup, I came across an organization called we Are and they support mothers that are affected by domestic abuse and I remember having that meeting with them and actually by the end of the meeting I was feeling so hungry and I we'd just have talked for about six hours in terms of the work that they're doing, the need for the support for the children and a lot of their mothers, because they'd been on their journey of recovery, recognised the impact domestic abuse had on their children and were not able to access domestic abuse-informed support.
- 5:11Dr. Asha Patel: They were constantly told that their children were naughty children.
- 5:16Dr. Asha Patel: The children was at risk of being excluded from education.
- 5:19Dr. Asha Patel: They weren't able to access mainstream mental health support services because they were deemed not unwell enough in regards to not presenting with, uh, mental health difficulties or disorders, and that led that frustration and kind of that need to actually these are the children that I want to support.
- 5:38Dr. Asha Patel: How do we do that and what?
- 5:40Dr. Asha Patel: What is already out there?
- 5:41Dr. Asha Patel: And there wasn't very much out there that was evidence-based, that was domestic abuse, informed, that didn't re-traumatize children through that experience or their other parents as well.
- 5:54Dr. Asha Patel: So healing together was formed and it was always a program that pulled everybody's heartstrings.
- 5:59Dr. Asha Patel: We did it on surplus resource how could we like staff's time at the end of the day, every bit of funding we could find and children started coming to our office in Birmingham in the UK.
- 6:11Dr. Asha Patel: But it wasn't scalable.
- 6:14Dr. Asha Patel: I could only support 15 children a year.
- 6:17Dr. Asha Patel: By second session I had a waiting list of 40 children waiting to be come on to our program and that was with no marketing, no referral source or anything.
- 6:28Dr. Asha Patel: So such a high demand, but I couldn't scale it.
- 6:31Dr. Asha Patel: It wasn't an infrastructure, it wasn't something that we could keep continuously doing on that.
- 6:37Dr. Asha Patel: So healing together has always had a special place in innovating minds, heart and then, as we've progressed as an organization, as a social enterprise, we've been able to transform the delivery aspect and actually in the frontline practitioners that see the children on a day-to-day basis, that are in the children's safe space, by upskilling them means actually children can access early help by the people that they already know and trust in a space that they feel safe in already.
- 7:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I just want to make one linguistic point, because a lot of our audience are NGO, non-profit and government workers, and that is about the notion of scalability.
- 7:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know, social enterprises are very, very concerned with making sure that the service deliveries, the programmatic deliveries and the good practices that we are advocating for will reach as many people as possible.
- 7:34Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So when you hear the word scale, I want you all to actually hear bigger impact.
- 7:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's a one to one equation and a lot of people who do not work in the private sector do not understand that language, so I just I wanted to explain that scaling means one-to-one impact.
- 7:52Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It means a bigger impact.
- 7:53Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It means more people served.
- 7:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It means more impact for them, more access.
- 7:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So this is the language that we use.
- 8:02Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think you had a question.
- 8:02Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So this is the language that we use.
- 8:03Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think you had a question didn't you?
- 8:04David Mandel: I did have a question.
- 8:05David Mandel: I think it's amazing what you're describing and I'm not surprised.
- 8:10David Mandel: There's such a need to serve children and young people in this space.
- 8:14David Mandel: Not enough services, not enough models.
- 8:16David Mandel: So you know, when you talk about the story of the inception of the program, you talk about listening to moms and listening to their experience, and one of the things that I am concerned about, and I'm curious to hear what you think about is that people are talking more and more about children as victim survivors in their own right, and they do have their own experience.
- 8:52David Mandel: But I'm also worried about I talk a lot and colleagues with Professor Kathy Humphries and we talk a lot about children in context as child survivors and victims in context of their relationships with that, let's say, that protective parent, or even in the context of their relationship with a parent who's using violence.
- 9:08David Mandel: And I'm just wondering how you think about this idea of services to children, whether you see it in isolation or whether you see it in context or in relationship.
- 9:20Dr. Asha Patel: So I think there's a place for both.
- 9:23Dr. Asha Patel: I think definitely children need their own space and their own services for them, and that's really important because often what happens in services?
- 9:35Dr. Asha Patel: They think, ok, if we're working with a parent and supporting them, that'll have a knock on effect on the child and yes, there is that would have an effect.
- 9:43Dr. Asha Patel: But then also the children have their own needs and they have their own voice and they have their own way of how their body and brain needs to process the trauma that they've been exposed to and therefore that's why I think it's really important that children are seen as victims in their own right and therefore are given services or being able to access services that meet their needs as well.
- 10:05Dr. Asha Patel: So I don't think it's fair for the child to be assumed, actually, that they they can't access their own services that are designed specifically for them but also at the right time for them, because maybe when safe parents going through the support that they need, maybe maybe that child's not quite ready yet, maybe it's all they're ready before and they need access to that support.
- 10:29Dr. Asha Patel: So it should be individualized for the child, as opposed to always being in context of where a safe parent is.
- 10:37David Mandel: That's great.
- 10:38David Mandel: Thanks for speaking to that, because absolutely, I think one of the mistakes or one of the challenges that have been made in the domestic abuse movement over the years is this idea well, if you keep mom safe, you keep the adult survivor safe, then automatically it rolls down to the kids and that's all that needs to happen.
- 10:54David Mandel: And that hasn't translated over to the, to the real needs of children or or how child serving systems, whether it's family, court or child protection, need to understand.
- 11:04David Mandel: We're trying to understand kids' own experience of safety and well-being.
- 11:09David Mandel: So I appreciate your answer.
- 11:11David Mandel: Another question I have is really, you know, I've seen over the years people providing services to children, sometimes gatekeeping when you said something about about timing, and I would like to hear something about that, because I I've heard some people say, oh, you can't provide the service to the kids while they're still living with somebody using violence or they're they're still in contact and and and we know that most of these kids actually remain in contact.
- 11:39David Mandel: So this idea that that, oh, you wait to this magical moment where they're no longer exposed to the person using violence is my experience, is a very limiting and sort of unrealistic perspective.
- 11:53David Mandel: I'm just curious what your thoughts are about that and how you formulate your program in terms of timing, you said, and when's appropriate and when's good to do the work with kids.
- 12:04Dr. Asha Patel: So I think this is where it comes to upskilling the frontline practitioners because, like you say, there's never going to be this magic time that everything aligns and maybe all the court proceedings are over and contact no longer exists or anything like that, and therefore I think it's about upskilling the frontline practitioner to know how to safely deliver the program.
- 12:26Dr. Asha Patel: So with the healing together program, there isn't any restrictions as to if the child's having contact or no contact uh with the parent that's harming.
- 12:35Dr. Asha Patel: What we do say is actually that they might notice uh the changes.
- 12:41Dr. Asha Patel: So the adult that is harming the perpetrator might not start to notice subtle changes in how the child is responding and that's because of their uh, they're starting to be able to regulate uh themselves.
- 12:54Dr. Asha Patel: So the emotional energy they might feel, the change in that uh, which might increase risk to the child.
- 13:01Dr. Asha Patel: So that's why we ask about the for the frontline practitioner, the facilit to consider those risk factors and making sure that it's continuously to deliver, to be delivered safely.
- 13:12Dr. Asha Patel: The other thing that we talk about is actually how we communicate the Healing Together programme with Safe Parent and if the adult that harm is also having contact, that information that we're presenting to them lets them know in terms of what the program is and isn't about.
- 13:34Dr. Asha Patel: Now that doesn't mean that we've changed the program so the child's not fully accessing what they need to access.
- 13:40Dr. Asha Patel: It's how we communicate that with both parents.
- 13:43Dr. Asha Patel: So for us it's really important that a child doesn't stop being accessed to help because everybody else outside think, doesn't think it's safe or in terms of that it doesn't align.
- 13:54Dr. Asha Patel: And we're waiting for this right moment for maybe the court system we know the family court system can go on for years and years and that the system can be used as a way to perpetrate more harm to the family.
- 14:07Dr. Asha Patel: So actually in that process, if a child is wanting to access the program, if they feel that they're ready to, and also the program's structured in a way for its flexibility so they don't need to do all of six sessions all at once, sometimes they might start, they might do three sessions, come back to it, they might recap sessions.
- 14:26Dr. Asha Patel: We know the impact of trauma on the ability to process information and therefore repetition is also key and important.
- 14:33Dr. Asha Patel: But the central of all of that is that ability to have a have that moment of co-regulation with a safe adult.
- 14:42Dr. Asha Patel: So it's not just about that program information they're accessing.
- 14:45Dr. Asha Patel: It's about that ability of having somebody, that they feel safe with somebody, that it's about that ability of having somebody that they feel safe with, somebody that their body and brain can feel safe with, that they can connect with and actually have that experience, and that shouldn't be taken away from a child yeah.
- 15:01David Mandel: So to me that's just for the listening audience that to me is a perfect example of that balance of children as victim survivors in their own right and then children in context of relationship.
- 15:12David Mandel: I think we know a lot about that.
- 15:15David Mandel: Healing happens in relationship and I think for professionals and I'm speaking to professionals that oftentimes we think of services to kids in isolation and what you're speaking to is the value of that protective pair.
- 15:31David Mandel: I mean, the research is pretty clear that some kids will heal in the context of a relationship with an important caring adult and may never need services and I hate to be sort of dissing services, you know, as we're talking to somebody who's doing an amazing service but I do really want to lift up that, the importance of that context and those relations, the familiar relationships, that it could be a teacher it doesn't need to be a protective person and it could be that therapist.
- 16:00David Mandel: But that this is healing for kids happens in context, happens in relationship.
- 16:04David Mandel: Well, for all of us adults too, it happens in relationship.
- 16:07Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well for all of us adults too.
- 16:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I want to center a little bit around access and pathways to receiving these programs because, as I understand it, this is both a program that's been used upon reporting of domestic abuse within childs in a home in certain regions in the UK, but also that it's accessible.
- 16:30Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It doesn't need to be through a court mandate or through law enforcement services, and I just want to hear a little bit about that because I think that that's really important.
- 16:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Those multiple points of access are super important for both survivors' autonomy, for safety and for not gatekeeping our ability to support our children when they've witnessed and experienced domestic abuse.
- 16:54Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And you know, I'm just I'm curious to know how that's being received in your region, how the program is being utilized, how you're experiencing those referral pathways you know, and how children are being treated as victims when they are being referred out to mental health services.
- 17:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Because there is obviously concern where we have seen survivors come into contact with mental health services when it's not domestic abuse informed and not trauma informed that any diagnoses or behavioral diagnoses often get weaponized against them.
- 17:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So we have a lot of concern for how mental health diagnoses are used and manipulated by perpetrators to try to extend their power and control post-separation.
- 17:52Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So talk to me about all those bits.
- 17:53Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I want to hear it all.
- 17:55Dr. Asha Patel: Yeah, sure, so in each region across the UK offers a very slightly different model, but they all come with a focus around this early intervention and prevention model from children needing to be referred or escalated to social care services, children and adolescent mental health services, so camp services.
- 18:17Dr. Asha Patel: So, for example, in Manchester City Council we have a great where public health are involved and public health have driven the initiative to train the early help support teams but also schools and grassroots organizations so where children and families might have that initial first contact, particularly within schools as well.
- 18:40Dr. Asha Patel: So across the UK it's been used in schools and that means that when schools have a notification that this child has been exposed to domestic abuse in the household or that there's safeguarding that have been raised regarding domestic abuse, there's somebody trained within the school to be able to access and be able to deliver the Healing Together programme In another local authority in Warrington.
- 19:07Dr. Asha Patel: What they have done is said healing together is tier one.
- 19:10Dr. Asha Patel: So children shouldn't even be escalated across through the tier services because what can happen in other local authorities is the only way to access help is to put family through the full social services and therefore that helps he can experience that process of going through social services can be traumatic in itself.
- 19:31Dr. Asha Patel: So actually provide healing together program at tier one service at early intervention point, and that is then to prevent that escalation of needing that additional support.
- 19:43Dr. Asha Patel: We've then then got other local authorities where they're saying actually every primary school should have the Healing Together programme and they've become like champions within areas where they're actually delivering it across their schools.
- 19:57Dr. Asha Patel: They've got staff that are timetabled part of their weekly timetable to plan and deliver the Healing Together programme.
- 20:05Dr. Asha Patel: So there's a real shift and a real understanding and thinking okay, how do we make it more accessible in terms of early intervention, but how do we make it more scalable and sustainable in the sense that it doesn't require ongoing commissioning.
- 20:19Dr. Asha Patel: Once somebody's trained, once they're a part of the existing workforce, that means children can access it.
- 20:24Dr. Asha Patel: So it doesn't mean that on a year-to-year basis at risk of being decommissioned, but then also it comes a part of the system, because then the rest of the team around those people that are trained start to get excited about it, start to want to know more, they start to co-facilitate the program.
- 20:42Dr. Asha Patel: We've also got it in children's homes as well.
- 20:46Dr. Asha Patel: So salute and care and education.
- 20:48Dr. Asha Patel: They work with support, children in care, children that often come from families of children being exposed to domestic abuse, children that have been neglected.
- 20:58Dr. Asha Patel: So creating that whole system approach to trauma informed and domestic abuse informed.
- 21:05Dr. Asha Patel: Then changes every day-to-day language the way that they start to see behavior as a form of communication.
- 21:11Dr. Asha Patel: So it goes beyond the six weeks, six sessions program.
- 21:15Dr. Asha Patel: It actually starts to infiltrate into the environment, into everybody's day-to-day practice.
- 21:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's great.
- 21:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's great and I also think it's really a key point that this is very behaviorally focused.
- 21:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Children learn patterns of behaviors and strategies for control from their parents and we know that in cases of femicide, that there's a certain set of the population of women who are killed by their children, and that domestic violence was in the home prevalently prior to that femicide.
- 21:56Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So it's really important that we work with children and give them tools for regulation, for behavioral modification, that we acknowledge their experiences and that we acknowledge that the behaviors that they experienced were harmful and that we give them other behaviors.
- 22:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We model to them other ways of relating, resolving conflict and dealing with their fear and anxiety about loss of power and control.
- 22:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I'm excited to hear that there's so many different entry points for access, because we do have a bit of a global problem in that many services are only accessible if you use the main access points, which is usually law enforcement, and that those access points are very limiting and that they themselves, being the main access point, limit people engaging for help.
- 23:01Ruth Reymundo Mandel: People will avoid that.
- 23:04Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I love that you're highly accessible, that your language is seeping in um and that there's a lot of behavioral emphasis and the thing that's a real emphasis is actually seen as life persevering behaviors.
- 23:20Dr. Asha Patel: So, in response to the trauma the children have experienced, their body is operating a way of safety, survival.
- 23:28Dr. Asha Patel: Their brain is operating a way.
- 23:29Dr. Asha Patel: So often we can think, okay, is it learned behavior, is it based on what they're seeing?
- 23:34Dr. Asha Patel: But actually as well, it's their body and brain's mechanism to keep themselves alive as well to keep themselves safe, that they're functioning in safety, survival mode constantly, that meerkat mode that actually is behaviors that are presenting to protect themselves.
- 23:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, I always tell people you used strategies that may not have been beneficial in the long run, but in the short term they saved your life and that's amazing, because you're amazing.
- 24:04David Mandel: So I'm going to pick your brain as an expert in children and domestic abuse, not just as somebody who's created this innovative program and the social enterprise and scaling it.
- 24:16David Mandel: One of the things that I think about a lot and written about is one of the chapters in my book I talked about the myth of the child witness and also another chapter of the myth of trauma-informed practice, and it was both chapters to kind of explore lots of different things like the impact of domestic violence perpetrators behavior on kids and the how far it's beyond just seeing and hearing, and also explore the idea that that that sometimes there's this uh gap in the way we talk or think or practice and I'm kind of curious what you think about this, which is the concept of trauma, is historically been very centered on physical violence and kind of threats to bodily integrity, sense of self, loved one.
- 25:03David Mandel: But coercive control is a much more complex set of behaviors that, from my perspective, don't neatly fall into the trauma box, at least the way it's been practiced by many people, that so many things that domestic violence perpetrators do as part of coercive control, whether it's financial control, whether it's making false allegations to child protection, whether it's targeting professionals to manipulate or get them to collude, you know, or using culture.
- 25:30David Mandel: These things don't, in my experience, don't always line up with the trauma box.
- 25:34David Mandel: So can you talk a little bit out of your experience about what perpetrators do to impact kids?
- 25:39David Mandel: But this whole conversation about?
- 25:40David Mandel: Is it all about trauma or are the pathways more complex and varied?
- 25:50Dr. Asha Patel: Coercive control is trauma in the sense that, yes, okay, it's not a physical act, but the emotional act coming out of coercive control, the impact it has on the body in the sense that it'll be sensing danger, that constant feeling of eggshells or having to is this, this, they're nice because of something that's going to happen, but I still need to do xyz or we need to behave in this specific way will heighten a sense of anxiety in us in that there's a perceived threat and in this situation there's actual threat that is constantly there.
- 26:25Dr. Asha Patel: So it is traumatic for the child to experience the uh constantly living in coercive control and being exposed to that.
- 26:34Dr. Asha Patel: Even if they're no longer living uh with the abusive parent, there still acts of coercive control that takes place, but also those pathways that are formed neurologically and that there's a certain way that things have been for so long.
- 26:48Dr. Asha Patel: So there's this expectation that harm is going to come to them, that their body will be constantly reacting to that and responding to that.
- 26:59Dr. Asha Patel: So when we think about trauma and trauma-informed practice, we shouldn't put this hierarchy in place in terms of what form, what domestic abuse have they been subjected to?
- 27:11Dr. Asha Patel: Is it physical violence?
- 27:12Dr. Asha Patel: Is a sexual violence taking place.
- 27:14Dr. Asha Patel: Is it coercive control?
- 27:16Dr. Asha Patel: Is it through the internet?
- 27:18Dr. Asha Patel: Is it financial abuse?
- 27:19Dr. Asha Patel: Because actually all of those will have an effect on somebody's body and brain, how they, how it responds and how they're safe they're.
- 27:28Dr. Asha Patel: So I think us as professionals sometimes often put this hierarchy in place and think, okay, this person's probably more traumatized because they've experienced X, y, z, but actually it's about that individual's experience of that trauma.
- 27:42Dr. Asha Patel: That is the most important and most thing that we need to keep at the central of this, and we don't focus on the act itself but the impact it's had on the child or on the family as a whole.
- 27:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, that's interesting because I think that highlights a little bit some of the differences between trauma-informed and domestic abuse informed.
- 28:03Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I believe they're supportive of each other.
- 28:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We believe they're supportive of each other, they're just not the same, and that is that the focus on the impact is very important for being able to clinically support somebody, to properly clinically support them in the long term for the trauma that they've been given.
- 28:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And in domestic abuse informed, there is a focus on the perpetrator's pattern of behaviors as a parent, so that we can hold them responsible, and also documenting the adult survivors' strengths and protective capacities so we can also highlight how they've had to struggle under these conditions to support their child and themselves and keep themselves safe, often in ways that official systems don't recognize, especially if that victim survivor is from a marginalized community and is resistant to coming into contact with law enforcement or child protective services because of the context and the history of the thing, or child protective services because of the context and the history of the thing.
- 29:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So it's really important for us to understand where one methodology ends and the other one begins in order for us to know that we're actually doing two different actions that are supportive of each other, and one is very focused on healing and therapy and supporting a person through those those predictable physiological, biological, hormonal responses to trauma.
- 29:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And and one of the things that I think that you're doing it sounds like that'll that many people fail to do when they're trauma-informed is to accommodate for the reality that there is going to be ongoing contact and trauma from a person who either has continued and unresolved coercive behaviors or continued and unresolved violent behaviors, because collectively we're failing to hold that person behavioral, behaviorally accountable so I can I add something and then I'd love to hear dr patel's view on this.
- 30:20David Mandel: You know which is.
- 30:20David Mandel: You know, when I hear you talking ruth, I think about sort of as a clinician, somebody you know trained from a mental health perspective.
- 30:28David Mandel: You know, listening to colleagues for decades really kind of talk about trauma and being trauma-informed and oftentimes my frustration that the conversation throws all different sources of trauma into one bucket and then boils them down to the symptoms of the biological response and say, well, the way we need to treat that is all the same.
- 30:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So a car crash is the same as the parents sexually assaulting you.
- 30:54David Mandel: A car crash versus a refugee experience versus a community violence watching somebody be knifed on the street, and what you're bringing out I think Dr Patel, you're talking about is children in context of these relationships where the course of control has continued access.
- 31:09David Mandel: So I'm curious what your thoughts are about this wider discussion about trauma-informed versus domestic abuse-informed and how the unique situations of children in domestic abuse may differ than somebody who experienced war trauma in another country.
- 31:26David Mandel: You know, which is real but may have a very different context or constellation of factors around it.
- 31:34David Mandel: Does that make sense to that question?
- 31:36Dr. Asha Patel: Yeah, so I think the underlying principles of trauma-informed practice apply.
- 31:41David Mandel: Yeah.
- 31:43Dr. Asha Patel: Where we're talking around children being affected by domestic abuse, there's something long-term in the sense that they still might be having contact uh with them or even forced contact uh through the court system.
- 31:56Dr. Asha Patel: Uh also even where there I've seen it myself where there's been um, a court order of no contact, but then social media contact can be authorized or letter writing is authorised and then asking a safe parent to mediate that contact and to monitor it.
- 32:16Dr. Asha Patel: So not acknowledging that safe parent is actually evicting themselves of domestic abuse and being affected by coercive control and other forms of domestic abuse.
- 32:25Dr. Asha Patel: But then children are also continuously exposed to that and also the lifestyle changes because they might be in financial hardship, they might have had to move schools, they might have had to relocate or live in refuges, they might have lost contact with the family that they used to have.
- 32:40Dr. Asha Patel: From the other parent's side.
- 32:50Dr. Asha Patel: Domestic abuse informed clinicians, I think sometimes they they struggle to see actually the long-term underlying ongoing difficulties that this child has been exposed to and for the prolonged period as well.
- 32:58Dr. Asha Patel: So often babies as well are affected by domestic abuse and they've gone through their development so all the way through from those critical a thousand and one days of experienced trauma.
- 33:10Dr. Asha Patel: They've experienced trauma in the wound, they've then gone on into their adolescent development, et cetera, and that is all being hindered by the exposure to the trauma of domestic abuse.
- 33:21Dr. Asha Patel: So often when they come into contact with mental health services and you spoke before about being diagnosed so often they can then lead to a diagnosis of something like adhd autism and there's that cross.
- 33:35Dr. Asha Patel: The presentation between the two in terms of the symptoms or the the.
- 33:41Dr. Asha Patel: What they're looking out for can often be misrepresented because of the how trauma is presenting, so it comes across as if it's autism as adhd and that's because of how trauma is presenting, so it comes across as if it's autism as ADHD.
- 33:52Dr. Asha Patel: And that's because of clinicians are not always domestic abuse informed and haven't seen that relational approach in terms of actually this is trauma presenting from the domestic abuse when often the Healing Together programme is being used with asylum seekers, refugees, and is being used with asylum seekers, refugees, and is being translated into other languages.
- 34:13Dr. Asha Patel: It's that around the resettlement, but also processing the trauma that I've experienced in terms of war, being affected by the war, being living in fear, but then also moving to a new country and thinking about what safety feels like again on that journey I think there's something so, um, powerfully impactful about having a person who is supposed to nurture and protect you be the the source of your harm, sort of as a primary, fundamental, you know, concrete trauma that children are experiencing.
- 34:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is different.
- 34:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is different than experiencing displacement, war and forced migration, as well as other traumas like car accidents so on and so forth.
- 35:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That betrayal, that fundamental betrayal is, is so harmful to children and their ability to healthily attach to other people.
- 35:22David Mandel: You know, and I I really feel like we need to say that out loud and and and to add to that the, the intimate knowledge, so the betrayal of the trust yeah the intimate knowledge I have, an access I have to you, you know, and then the legal entitlements that I may be given or have or be reinforced, and I've even seen courts um enforce, courts enforce or support access of non-biologically related kids of perpetrators who manipulate systems.
- 35:56David Mandel: There's one case where he was the stepfather, he had no legal rights to the child and he was the perpetrator of the violence and the court placed the child with him or supported his keeping the child from the mom because they had kind of put her in this really negative box, probably because of mental health diagnosis.
- 36:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's right.
- 36:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's right.
- 36:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's right After he abused her.
- 36:18David Mandel: I think it's really, you know, I think this both and approach.
- 36:21David Mandel: You know, I think one of the themes here is this both and approach to this conversation.
- 36:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's just the limitations of diagnoses.
- 36:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Diagnoses are meant for treatment protocols.
- 36:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: They aren't meant to document patterns of perpetration or give evidence for who the person who's harming is.
- 36:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But at the same time, because our documentation is often used in legal settings, we have to be complete about who's causing the harm, who is the ongoing threat to the child and what their impact is.
- 36:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is absolutely important and we also have to because this is a child who lives in a relational setting, who's completely dependent upon their parent figures.
- 37:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We also have to really map the way that the adult survivor is protecting and supporting them, because even a small amount of protection and support and acknowledgement that those behaviors are not acceptable, that they're harmful and hurtful, can help to preserve the dignity and mental well-being of a child.
- 37:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: One of the most damaging things for a child in those situations is to feel like nobody is saying that it's wrong.
- 37:42Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Everybody's afraid to name it as being a behavior that is not acceptable because a parent is perpetrating it and there's some weird belief that naming abuse as a problem is undermining somebody's parenting.
- 38:02David Mandel: So can I flick that to you as a question, Dr Patel, which is sort of you know again, whether it's about the program or just about your expert kind of thoughts about this, which is just sort of kids and their relationship with that person using violence to the perpetrator is, I think, is an interesting area that people don't talk about enough.
- 38:24David Mandel: I think there's sometimes a simplistic view sort of that this person's quote-unquote bad, the answer is to separate the kids and then we're done talking about the kid's relationship with a parent using violence or control.
- 38:39David Mandel: We know that kids' experience is much more complex, much more layered, much more diverse across the range of kids.
- 38:45David Mandel: We know that many kids want to remain in contact.
- 38:48David Mandel: Their survivor parents want that kid to remain in contact if it's safe and sometimes contact is forced.
- 38:54David Mandel: I mean just so, can you just talk a little bit about your the program or your your experience of kids and their relationships with that person using violence or control?
- 39:04Dr. Asha Patel: yeah.
- 39:05Dr. Asha Patel: So the healing together program is very much focused on understanding how their body and brain works, what happens when they're feeling safe and unsafe, and being able to use some discrete strategies to help their body to feel safe again so it can send messages to the brain.
- 39:21Dr. Asha Patel: So there's nothing in there that starts to unpick about their experiences, direct experiences of domestic abuse and that is because we don't want to go through the re-traumatization of retelling their story.
- 39:32Dr. Asha Patel: And that happens within the system, happens when they come in contact with professionals.
- 39:36Dr. Asha Patel: They have to keep retelling their story and often they don't want to.
- 39:41Dr. Asha Patel: Now, in terms of their contact and it varies for every child that I've come into contact with because the relationship has been so complex I've seen children that never want anything to do with them again and actually want the system to put that in place for them.
- 40:00Dr. Asha Patel: So, but then the system keeps saying, oh, we need to get child's voice, we need to hear it again, because then it's being contested, and then the same Well, well, actually the child's not old enough and well, almost the child is now 16 or 18, so actually then we still need to ask for it.
- 40:16Dr. Asha Patel: So they're desperate for somebody to say no, no more contact and that needs to be a legal process because the system around that family isn't been able to do that for them.
- 40:28Dr. Asha Patel: I've also then seen children that are really angry at mum, at safe parent, because you're the one that's made this happen.
- 40:36Dr. Asha Patel: I want to see dad, I don't know why you've done this, and look at our life now it's a mess and they're desperate to have contact and mum and the support around mum is saying no, it's not safe for that child.
- 40:53Dr. Asha Patel: So they're really struggling and that's maybe the younger children and often as well when children have been used as pawns within this process or placing children in a role within the household that actually maybe child is used by the perpetrator to spy on mum or kind of keep control of contacts on mum etc.
- 41:17Dr. Asha Patel: But then I've also seen it play out in siblings where one sibling is treated different to the other.
- 41:24Dr. Asha Patel: One is favouritised and gifted and kind of love bombed and the other sibling ignored.
- 41:31Dr. Asha Patel: So I feel it's an individual for each child in terms of their experience and where they're at, with whether they want contact, what that contact looks like.
- 41:42Dr. Asha Patel: Sometimes it's not in hope that something's going to change.
- 41:45Dr. Asha Patel: Like you said, it is their father.
- 41:47Dr. Asha Patel: There's kind of this belief that, well, you're my parents, it should be this way.
- 41:52Dr. Asha Patel: This is kind of what society tells us.
- 41:54Dr. Asha Patel: They go to school, they see parents at the gates, they see family events taking place and start to question why is my family not like that?
- 42:02Dr. Asha Patel: Or could it be like that?
- 42:04Dr. Asha Patel: So that experience for the children, I think is very difficult for us to navigate as a system and think that there's going to be a one size fits all approach, and that's why it's so important that frontline practitioners are domestic abuse informed so they can actually start to think about these differences in relationships and their experiences.
- 42:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, yes, not all relationships are the same.
- 42:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: This is very real and victim survivors respond differently to the perpetration and there's definitely no one size fits all and builds on the Safe and Together model and is compatible and supportive of domestic abuse-informed practice, which is a little bit more centered on obviously mapping perpetrators' patterns of behaviors as a parent, their impact on child and family functioning, the impact on the adult survivor and also mapping and supporting the protective efforts and strengths of the victim survivors.
- 43:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So talk to us a little bit about how our programs are kind of supporting each other in the environment, what you're experiencing, maybe of even professionals, some who are domestic abuse informed, some who are not.
- 43:26Dr. Asha Patel: Yeah, so I think from the and correct me if I'm wrong the Safe and Together model is looking at the systemic, the ways in terms of the system looks in terms of respond to domestic abuse, how they support the victim, survivor, how they support children, young peoples, but then holding perpetrators too accountable as well, and from a trauma-informed, from a domestic abuse informed lens.
- 43:50Dr. Asha Patel: So really thinking around the language, the documentation, the processes, the interviewing type, questions and upskilling the frontline practitioners that are having that contact with the families.
- 44:03Dr. Asha Patel: Now where I feel healing together program dovetails really nicely is the safe and together model, that holistic, systemic approach.
- 44:12Dr. Asha Patel: Work is taking place.
- 44:14Dr. Asha Patel: The healing together program now enables the children to have that direct intervention, that direct piece of work with those frontline practitioners that are also gone through the safe and together model.
- 44:27Dr. Asha Patel: So not only systemically are children benefiting their own, they're also benefiting from being directly being able to access the support and all of that gives a positive help seeking experience, which then leads to future help seeking experiences that we're trying to take these families away from, these negative help seeking experiences that they've had from professionals, which makes them more reluctant to go and seek help when they need it and, as we know the children are going to need the same long term.
- 44:57Dr. Asha Patel: So actually, if we can give those them and we've seen it play out where then families have come back and said do you have anything else to offer?
- 45:05Dr. Asha Patel: Actually, they've never engaged like this before.
- 45:07Dr. Asha Patel: What else can our family engage in?
- 45:09Dr. Asha Patel: Or a child's gone back into school, there's a reduction in child to parent violence, there's an increase in relationships, in the sibling relationships, and that there's how to feel safe again.
- 45:22Dr. Asha Patel: So I think that's where it dovetails and it fits really nicely.
- 45:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think about how we often have a very adult focus when we're speaking about engagement and documentation, and one of the foundational concepts of the model is the partnering concept, which means really acknowledging and affirming the experience of harm that the pattern of behaviors of the perpetrator have caused, and that includes acknowledging and affirming children's experiences.
- 46:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is something that is incredibly powerful, incredibly healing.
- 46:06Ruth Reymundo Mandel: To have a professional look at you and say you did not deserve to be treated that way.
- 46:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is not the way that a parent should engage with a child.
- 46:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Those are not behaviors that are supporting your well-being or your behavioral health.
- 46:23Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Those are not good behaviors for a parent to model to you.
- 46:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Those are behaviors which destroy your family and your connections and your relationships.
- 46:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Those are behaviors which destroy your family and your connections and your relationships.
- 46:35Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That was not your fault.
- 46:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You did not choose that by you saying no to your parents.
- 46:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That was a normal childhood behavior.
- 46:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Them responding with violence and abuse is a harmful behavior.
- 46:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: All of those affirming statements should be a routine part of everybody's practice, especially if they're interviewing children.
- 46:56Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It doesn't matter if you are a mental health practitioner or not.
- 47:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's basic, fundamental partnering to affirm the reality that somebody's behaviors have deeply impacted that child and have harmed them.
- 47:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So we do that with the adult survivor them.
- 47:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So we do that with the adult survivor.
- 47:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We need to do that with the child survivor as well.
- 47:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That needs to be very much the way that we approach children, rather than approaching them from a place where they feel very threatened, they feel responsible, they feel unheard and they feel potentially like nothing is going to be done to help them because they've seen nothing be done to help them.
- 47:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I love how you describe the dovetailing of the two models and the language seeping in.
- 47:44Dr. Asha Patel: Yeah, I also think as well.
- 47:46Dr. Asha Patel: There's something here around.
- 47:48Dr. Asha Patel: We talk about these affirmations, but this is really cognitively heavy and we can't process trauma cognitively.
- 47:55Dr. Asha Patel: So until we feel it, then that's when we start to actually accept it.
- 48:02Dr. Asha Patel: So it's a bit like when we tell ourselves stop being stupid.
- 48:05Dr. Asha Patel: So if I was coming on today, I was.
- 48:06Dr. Asha Patel: I'm feeling really anxious.
- 48:07Dr. Asha Patel: What if I don't?
- 48:07Dr. Asha Patel: And I say stop being stupid, asha, I still feel inside extremely anxious.
- 48:13Dr. Asha Patel: So, as much as I can tell myself cognitively, if you're feeling that way and you're feeling unsafe, it still doesn't connect with you and that's the whole thing around the connection with somebody and feeling it.
- 48:27Dr. Asha Patel: So feeling that safety, that then you can start to start to think actually that wasn't okay, this isn't okay, they are my mum, that, my dad, uh, whoever's perpetrating the harm, but actually it still doesn't feel safe.
- 48:40Dr. Asha Patel: But they can be open to that because as much as somebody cognitively tells them that and it's a cognitive process it doesn't process because that's not how our bodies and brains work right I love that.
- 48:54David Mandel: It's um that your work is is got this embodied gestalt element to it.
- 49:00David Mandel: You know, I I trained in body-centered gestalt therapy for a number of years and and there was so much work about the body experience of trauma, how the body locks.
- 49:09David Mandel: You know those, those experiences in the physical body, and how the healing needs to happen in that physical body and in relationship.
- 49:19David Mandel: You know, and those words, those connections, those looks, those gestures, those transmit safety or unsafety.
- 49:27David Mandel: They transmit love, they transmit validation, they transmit, you know, a sense of it's okay for you to feel the way you're feeling.
- 49:34David Mandel: And I love what you said earlier about professionals really need to respect the diversity of kids' experiences and not impose our view on that.
- 49:44David Mandel: So, you know, I think it's a great approach.
- 49:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, we have been jabbering here for about an hour, I think.
- 49:54Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I mean, we really got into it, I think one of the.
- 49:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Just to start wrapping up, what would you say to professionals about the importance of trauma-informed mental health services dovetailing with domestic abuse-informed practices, specifically for child victims of domestic abuse?
- 50:14Dr. Asha Patel: I would say be curious and think about the system that you're working in and have a look at it from a lens of trauma-informed, domestic abuse-informed, and find somebody within your organization that gets it.
- 50:29Dr. Asha Patel: That's really critical.
- 50:30Dr. Asha Patel: Not everybody does.
- 50:31Dr. Asha Patel: Everybody does.
- 50:31Dr. Asha Patel: For us it feels like common sense, for others that's not the case.
- 50:35Dr. Asha Patel: Find something in your organization that gets it and see how you can champion to start changing some of these practices.
- 50:43Dr. Asha Patel: Thinking about your own practice.
- 50:45Dr. Asha Patel: So not everybody has the ability to make change systemically, but you are the key resource.
- 50:52Dr. Asha Patel: So start looking for that magic wand, that magic intervention.
- 50:56Dr. Asha Patel: Actually focus on yourself and think about how you conduct the training, whether it's the healing, together training, the safe and together institute training to inform your practice, because their work, their connection with children and families will go way beyond and might not even ever know the impact it's had on these families and these children.
- 51:16Dr. Asha Patel: Sometimes they come back 10 years later and say remember that thing that you said to me, or that thing that you did, or you used to say hello or you smiled at me.
- 51:25Dr. Asha Patel: That's the thing that's going to make the difference.
- 51:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's great.
- 51:29Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And then I want to let you know that we actually have a lot of kids that listen to this podcast.
- 51:35Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We have found that out, that there's a lot of adult survivors who listen with their children.
- 51:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So what would you say to survivors?
- 51:55Dr. Asha Patel: try to focus on being with your child, and when I say being with, it's about being in that present moment with them.
- 51:57Dr. Asha Patel: So how you spend your time with them, you might be feeling guilty that you can't do loads of different activities with them.
- 52:03Dr. Asha Patel: External activities it's either expensive, you're not able to, but actually those moments of being with them, of connecting with them, even if you're washing up the dishes, there's so many sensory based activities that you can do in the household that can help your child's body to feel safe, but also for you to connect with them and reconnect with them, that'll go such a long way in their journey of healing and recovery.
- 52:29Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And what would you say to child survivors as well?
- 52:40Dr. Asha Patel: Well, the child survivors.
- 52:41Dr. Asha Patel: It's very much thinking about what you need and it's okay to put yourself first.
- 52:44Dr. Asha Patel: Often I work with children who blame themselves for it.
- 52:47Dr. Asha Patel: He thinks things could have been different.
- 52:49Dr. Asha Patel: But knowing that actually you're important, your needs are important and it's okay to put yourself first and really listen to what your body is telling you.
- 53:00Dr. Asha Patel: Probably for a long time you've pushed away the feelings, your gut feeling that your body's been telling you, but maybe now's the time to start listening to your body, to help you in places, whether it's school, whether it's at home, whether it's thinking about getting back into school, being around your friends again.
- 53:19Dr. Asha Patel: Use your body to help you because that's a little uh coping mechanism, a little superhero that you've got that you might not recognize.
- 53:26Dr. Asha Patel: That's great well.
- 53:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Dr asha patel, we are really happy that you joined us today and thank you for all the work that you're doing to support children who have experienced domestic abuse, and we are partnered with a survivor.
- 53:44David Mandel: And I'm still David Mandel, the CEO of the Save it Together Institute.
- 53:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I'm still Ruth Ramundo and you can do some low-cost domestic abuse-informed training on our virtual academy at academysafeandtogetherinstitutecom, and we will put the resources for Innovating Minds and also for the Healing Together program in this podcast episode notes so that you can take a check at their program and their offerings.
- 54:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So thank you very much, dr Patel, and I hope you're well and I hope your work flourishes and helps lots of kids and we are out, thank you.