Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Gold Rush / Tamdhu 10 Single Malt Scotch
Transcript
- 0:00So, here's the deal everybody. We just absolutely love
- 0:03producing as much content as possible for film and whiskey
- 0:07Nation. But if our regular episodes
- 0:09aren't enough for you, then you can head on over to patreon.com
- 0:13film whiskey sign up for one of our memberships and you will get
- 0:16a slew of extra content for your listening.
- 0:19Pleasure, check us out on patreon.com film, whiskey in
- 0:251925 director and star. Charlie Chaplin gave the world,
- 0:29a rags-to-riches. Riches tale that takes the Tramp
- 0:32up to the great white North, in 2023, we strike gold in the
- 0:37speyside region of Scotland. The film is the Gold Rush.
- 0:41The whiskey is Tam do 10 more review them both, this is the
- 0:47film and whiskey podcast. Welcome to the film and whiskey
- 1:08podcast, where each week, we review a classic movie and a
- 1:11glass of whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and
- 1:15this week we keep the Charlie Chaplin train a-rollin with his
- 1:201925 comedy. The gold rush.
- 1:24Brad. I I already know that most of
- 1:26our audience will not have seen any of these movies.
- 1:30And yet, I'm still pretty sure that you know, if you were to
- 1:32hold up pictures of the stars of every movie we've ever done on
- 1:37the film and whiskey podcast, that Chaplin would still be one
- 1:40of the most recognized figures among all of them easily like
- 1:45I'm kind of struggling with like I really want her stash you
- 1:48know? I mean Hitler kind of patterned
- 1:50it after him which is a weird distinction to have You know, a
- 1:54weird badge to wear if you're Charlie Chaplin but you know
- 1:57what? I inspired.
- 2:00Yeah, we'll get to that next week when we look at The Great
- 2:02Dictator, but for this week, I guess, what?
- 2:04I'm trying to say here is this, this is one of the most popular
- 2:07movies ever made. It is the highest grossing
- 2:09silent film comedy ever. And it is probably the one that
- 2:15has the most iconic, Charlie Chaplin moments and imagery in
- 2:20it. Hmm.
- 2:21And yet it's probably like, in the Bottom-5 of movies we've
- 2:25ever done. In terms of one's people will
- 2:26have seen that. Listen to this show.
- 2:29Yeah, I mean, it's coming up on 100 years.
- 2:31Bob 100 years old, almost Brad. That like, it is crazy to me to
- 2:35look at this movie and look at how it's made and and see modern
- 2:41technique editing techniques and Camera moves and stuff like
- 2:44that. And when you think about
- 2:46something being 100 years old, you think of like this super
- 2:49archaic time that's gone by. And I think that's part of why I
- 2:52love movies so much. Is that it reminds us that a
- 2:55hundred years ago is really not that long ago at all.
- 2:57People have always been people and movies in some ways.
- 3:01I've always been movies and Chaplin films are evidence of
- 3:04that. Yeah.
- 3:05And I will say, this is a quick shout out to our listeners from
- 3:09Canada. I think that this is our first
- 3:11movie set in Canada. Yeah.
- 3:14Now, are we at Canada? Are we in Alaska in this movie?
- 3:18I'm pretty sure it is set because the the chilkoot pass,
- 3:22hmm, which it shows is in British Columbia, okay.
- 3:25So is it, she'll cut or chilkoot?
- 3:28Chilkoot. I think it's real good.
- 3:30There's two o's. So obviously should pronounce
- 3:33it. You know, improperly sure until
- 3:35cut. She'll Cooter e.
- 3:37Okay, so Cooter eboard. All right man, I'm excited to
- 3:41talk about this movie. I guess the first place to
- 3:43start, even before we get into Brad explains is to compare and
- 3:47contrast. Last week's movie City Lights.
- 3:50Now we started with that because that is kind of generally
- 3:52regarded today by critics as chaplains, best film and
- 3:57watching these two movies back to back Brad.
- 3:59The Gold Rush has never been my favorite Chaplin movie.
- 4:01I feel like even at, you know, whatever it is 85 minutes or
- 4:04whatever. There's a little bit of shag on
- 4:06it and some of the jokes go on a little too long for me and they
- 4:10take a large break in this movie from making any jokes.
- 4:13And I feel like the movie really drags in those parts, but I also
- 4:16weirdly feel like if you're just Just talking from a comedy
- 4:20standpoint. This movie definitely has higher
- 4:23highs than City Lights did. Hmm.
- 4:26I mean, I will say that the boxing scene and City Lights.
- 4:30I think might be the funniest individual chaplain sequence and
- 4:34I've seen thus far in my extensive to movie.
- 4:37Watch of him. Yep.
- 4:41But yeah. I like the boxing seen a lot.
- 4:43I think that I like gold rush overall is the film much better.
- 4:47Hmm. but I think that's mostly because It just feels a little
- 4:54more, little more self-contained, and a little
- 4:58less scatterbrained. Like it's it to me, it's much
- 5:01more focused and driving forward.
- 5:05Then City Lights was interesting.
- 5:07Yeah, I feel like if I can sum up my thoughts and City Lights,
- 5:10I really love that movie and I feel like it's, you know, it's
- 5:13probably still among like my favorite films but it's like a
- 5:16nine and a half for me on every category.
- 5:20Where is this movie? It's definitely got low.
- 5:23Lower lows for me than city lights, but it hits higher
- 5:26Heights with some of the comedy, and it's going for a different
- 5:30reaction. I think like there's dramatic
- 5:33moments, there's heart. Touch it like a heart-wrenching
- 5:35moments in this movie, but this is a straight-up comedy, whereas
- 5:39City Lights. I feel like really try to tow
- 5:41that line between comedy and drama.
- 5:43Yeah, 100%. And I think that this one works
- 5:45a little bit better than city lights.
- 5:47And that's not to say, I didn't like City Lights.
- 5:49I thought it was a great movie. I think that the gold rush just
- 5:53It just flows better. And there's so many Beautiful
- 5:57Moments in this film that, you know, you kind of get at the end
- 6:01of City Lights with that, that last moment of them falling in
- 6:04love and this one. I feel like there's a, there's a
- 6:06few moments throughout that feel really beautiful and poignant.
- 6:09And so, even though this one is more of a comedy, I found its
- 6:13have more touching moments in it.
- 6:15Alright, Brad. Well, I think we've kind of
- 6:16teased the plot of this movie a little bit and you know, we're
- 6:20only at like the 6-minute Mark here, but let's jump in.
- 6:23Into America's favorite segments.
- 6:26Brad explains rats gonna give us the movie plots with only 60
- 6:30seconds ticking on the clock. So let's go ahead and do you
- 6:33take with this little segment that we call Brad explains,
- 6:37right? Explains is the part of the
- 6:38podcast, where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 6:41has just seen often for the first time.
- 6:45We know that this is Brad's first time seeing the gold rush.
- 6:48So Brad, you've got 60 seconds on the clock to explain in a
- 6:52spoiler riff. Fashion.
- 6:54The plot of the gold rush and go.
- 6:58The Gold Rush is a film about our favorite star, the Tramp as
- 7:02he moves to Canada to be a prospector.
- 7:06He finds himself out in the middle of a massive storm
- 7:09trapped in a cabin with a man who is so hungry that he wants
- 7:12to eat, Chaplin thinking that he's a chicken.
- 7:15This man has found a wealth of gold but loses his way to it and
- 7:21an outlaw beats him in. The head and so he forgets about
- 7:25where his wealth is in the meantime.
- 7:27Charlie falls in love with a beautiful woman who dances at a
- 7:31local night club, dance hall, whatever you want to call Dad.
- 7:36Yeah, that's all and is dragged about back out into the
- 7:41Wilderness to help the man, find his claim.
- 7:44They find the claim together, survive a falling house, become
- 7:48Millionaires, and chaplain gets the girl at the end of the day.
- 7:52The end, there's the Gold Rush. That's, that's kind of it.
- 7:56Yeah, I think I summarize not think so.
- 7:59All right, before we move into talking about the movie itself,
- 8:01I want to go back to the point. You made a bit ago, about the
- 8:04fact that this movie is now 98 years old.
- 8:08It's really weird to talk about 100 year old movie Brad.
- 8:11I mean, you know, we try to keep up with our classic films on
- 8:15this podcast, but even for that, this movie fuels old and say, I
- 8:18think 1939, we did that series of Of for is like Stagecoach
- 8:24Gone With the Wind Wizard of Oz and what was the other one, mr.
- 8:31Smith Goes to Washington, mr. Smith Goes watches.
- 8:33So I believe those would be the oldest for movies.
- 8:35We've done. Am I correct?
- 8:37Yeah, you know, I'm trying to think there's probably one or
- 8:39two scattered in there somewhere, but that's about as
- 8:41far back as we've gone so far. Yeah, so yeah this is, you know,
- 8:4414 years before it we're getting into Old territory.
- 8:49But yeah, so on that. A point in the year, 1942
- 8:54Chaplin is coming off of his most recent film, The Great
- 8:58Dictator, which came out in 1940.
- 8:59It's his first sound film and it does pretty good business and
- 9:04chaplain still a respected figure.
- 9:06But we're now 17 years on from the release of this movie, his
- 9:10most famous movie and chaplain realizes that most people, even
- 9:14though it is within, you know, a couple decades.
- 9:16Most people have never even seen a silent movie, like, kids, who
- 9:19have come up in this time. They don't remember seeing
- 9:22Silent films. And so what he does is he takes
- 9:24the Gold Rush, he takes all the intertitles out of it and he
- 9:28adds a narration to the whole movie.
- 9:30Like it's still a silent movie but he's narrating over it now.
- 9:34It's a really interesting experiment and if you get like
- 9:36the Criterion Collection Blu-ray, you can watch that
- 9:39version of it. And I actually think that that
- 9:42version of the film ends up getting nominated for a couple
- 9:45of Academy Awards because he adds a score to it and things
- 9:47like that. So it's funny when you go back
- 9:49and look at stats on the Gold Rush it's like oh is Nominated
- 9:52for Oscars. But the original version of this
- 9:54came out before the Oscars existed.
- 9:56So it's like yeah this movie has a weird history.
- 9:59We watched the silent silent silent version of this movie
- 10:02with no narration on it Brad. Can I just can I just say
- 10:06something Bob? Oh please, I turned on my first
- 10:09Charlie. Chaplin movie City Lights a week
- 10:13ago. Hmm.
- 10:14And I didn't know what to expect mmm and like I know that might
- 10:20sound silly, but I've spent my whole life.
- 10:22Being silent films called silent films.
- 10:25And I just, I knew that, you know, there would be like an
- 10:28orchestra and each movie theater that would like play that, you
- 10:31know, a little ditty to the movie.
- 10:34But I didn't know if I would just be sitting there listening
- 10:39to nothing for all of city lights all of gold rush you
- 10:43know, in our other silent films. So I was pleasantly surprised to
- 10:47hear that. It is not a silent experience if
- 10:51you get on Your HBO Max account and pop on any of the Charlie
- 10:55Chaplin's that they have on their there is music attached to
- 10:59these film. Yes.
- 11:00And I just want to clarify that because I being the complete
- 11:04Noob to silent era film. Did not know what to expect.
- 11:07No, that's I'll say I didn't want to watch these movies
- 11:11because I was like, man, if there is no sound and I'm just
- 11:15watching him, you know, pantomime across the screen.
- 11:18I don't think I'm going to enjoy it very much.
- 11:21No, that's a great point. Hey man, I think that's
- 11:23something that, you know, for someone like me, I just take it
- 11:26for granted now. So I'm really glad.
- 11:27You said that these are her not totally silent experiences.
- 11:31Even the version that I'm describing, which I just called
- 11:33silent silent. Silent is is not actually
- 11:35silent. There is an orchestral score in
- 11:37the background. There's, you know, little sound
- 11:39effects that are added in. So all that to say Brad, you
- 11:44watched a 98 year old movie. I did.
- 11:47Did it feel 98 years old? Certain elements of it did.
- 11:51Okay. It still had that little bit of
- 11:54a sped-up, feel that old Cinema has Givens.
- 11:58Hmm. And I'm sure you can explain
- 12:00that with the frame rate and, and so on, but it has that feel.
- 12:06There's definitely a, I still got the Looney Tunes vibe from
- 12:12it. We're like the slapstick comedy
- 12:14that you see in Looney Tunes? You can like see the direct T'
- 12:19through line from chaplain to loot EMS.
- 12:22So for somebody who grew up on Looney Tunes, like I still could
- 12:26feel that age to it. Hmm.
- 12:28But other than that man, like the acting in.
- 12:32This is incredible. The cinematography is Bonkers,
- 12:37good. Like I thought it was pretty
- 12:39solid and City Lights. I think it's incredible here.
- 12:42I texted you, Halfway through the film.
- 12:45And basically just said there's a shot in this movie that I
- 12:49think might be one of the most beautiful shots I've ever seen
- 12:52in a film. Yeah.
- 12:53And so funny because it's the same shot that I had written
- 12:55down to talk about. Yeah.
- 12:57And so it's stuff. Like that.
- 12:59That makes you go. Oh, at the end of the day,
- 13:02whether you have a camera from 1920, you know, 34 when he was
- 13:06filming this or a camera from 2023 2024, You still have to
- 13:13take pictures in an interesting manner for them to be good and
- 13:18Charlie. Chaplin could do that 98 years
- 13:20ago? Yeah, 100%.
- 13:22All right man, let's dive into talking about the movie itself.
- 13:25This is a very simple story as all of Chaplin's movies are, but
- 13:29this one even more. So because I feel like in movies
- 13:31like city lights, and modern times, those movies end up
- 13:35becoming more of I don't know a comedy of errors, like there's
- 13:39compounding things that happen that take the Tramp to different
- 13:42places and then in modern times, I feel like it's more of, it's
- 13:46almost like an odyssey, it's like him going across, you know,
- 13:49this industrial landscape in the 1930s, this one's more just like
- 13:53hey we Jump Right In. There's a bunch of people
- 13:56prospecting for gold and Chaplin had to this point put the Tramp
- 14:01character back in historical periods.
- 14:03A couple of times, but this is the first full-length film that
- 14:06he did that. At with, and not only that.
- 14:09But we're going back into like the 1800s with the Tramp here.
- 14:12And so he's not called the Tramp in this movie.
- 14:14He's called the lone prospector and so, you know, that he's out
- 14:17there by himself, he's just being hapless and stumbling into
- 14:20whatever he stumbles into and for the first, I don't know,
- 14:24third of the movie. It's basically just him trying
- 14:27to survive out in the elements and kind of getting mixed up
- 14:30with these two other Prospectors, one of whom is a
- 14:33wanted criminal and murderer. This is the middle third of the
- 14:36movie. Upland kind of goes into this,
- 14:39you know, Town that's been set up for the gold, miners and
- 14:43falls in love with the girl there.
- 14:44And then the last third of the movie, he goes back out into the
- 14:47frontier and things kind of wrap up but I felt like this movie
- 14:51had a very clean division of like act 1 act 2 act 3.
- 14:57Yeah and I really enjoyed that about the film.
- 15:00You get him in his initial introduction to you know the
- 15:05Yukon wherever they're at. At up in Canada, maybe Alaska
- 15:10and then you have him in the city, trying to win Over Georgia
- 15:16and then you have him, finding his riches and finishing out the
- 15:20journey that he started upon to find gold and it cuts it up into
- 15:25such a nice little chunks. That for me, I was able to keep
- 15:31with the story throughout and it didn't feel like I was dragging
- 15:34on anywhere. Last week, we talked about the
- 15:36performances and city lights and kind of lead with the caveat
- 15:40that it's hard to talk about performances and yet, I don't
- 15:44know, like, I don't know how to explain it because this seems
- 15:46like the most pure distillation of a performance that we could
- 15:50talk about, like it's just it's acting without words, right?
- 15:54And so we should be able to point to like really specific
- 15:57things in these performances. But it's also really hard
- 16:00because we've only ever paired up the, you know, physical.
- 16:05With the words that are being spoken and we talked about line
- 16:08readings and, you know, we don't have that luxury here.
- 16:11So I guess I want to hear your take first of all on Chaplin,
- 16:14and do you think he's better, worse?
- 16:16Kind of the same from city lights and are there?
- 16:19Any particular things about the way he plays the character in
- 16:23this movie that stuck out to you?
- 16:25I think something I noticed in this film and this is more about
- 16:29the character that he plays more than maybe himself.
- 16:33I love the way. Way.
- 16:35He, you know, and this is famous of him.
- 16:38I love the way he keeps his feet open all the time.
- 16:41Yeah, yeah. And and Beyond the fact that
- 16:44it's comedic. There's so many moments in this
- 16:47film where he is stuck on the outside.
- 16:50Mmm, and he is looking in on other people enjoying life and
- 16:57he is, you know, being bullied by a larger more attractive
- 17:01more, masculine man than him. And For some reason, I just
- 17:07looked at his feet every single time and he has that trademark
- 17:11openness of his feet. Mmm.
- 17:13And there's something about that that I think makes the Tramp
- 17:17such a Winsome figure that he is open to whatever the world
- 17:23throws at him, that he takes it in.
- 17:26He takes into sadness, he takes him to anger, the happiness, all
- 17:30the things that gets thrown at him and just continues marching
- 17:34on. His way never giving up, always
- 17:37taking every punch that's thrown at him.
- 17:39And then there's something about that that Nuance in his acting
- 17:44performance that I think just makes the Tramp and, you know,
- 17:48the lone prospector in this film that makes him so charming and
- 17:52attractive. And like like I just want to be
- 17:55friends with that guy and I know it's not, I don't know.
- 17:58Am I crazy to say that? Like I think you're all of that
- 18:00comes down to the way he carries his body?
- 18:02Yeah, I mean, you're absolutely right.
- 18:04There is a Posture of openness with him a physical posture of
- 18:08like, I want love the same way that everyone else has love that
- 18:12I see around me and I have no one to give it to me.
- 18:15And I think there is such a heartbreak to that.
- 18:17And this movie, I think really leans in way more than City
- 18:20Lights. Did you know, in City Lights?
- 18:22He's down on his luck, and he's impoverished, and he goes to
- 18:26jail. And, you know, he is really the
- 18:28lowest of the low socially, but you never get the sense that he
- 18:31feels lonely. Like, he's pining for For and
- 18:35and really wants to be with the flower girl.
- 18:40But I don't think you ever really understand her
- 18:42experience, the kind of like social isolation of him and in
- 18:46this movie I think it's I mean they call him the loan
- 18:49prospector like that's that's the character's name and from
- 18:52there you really get this sense. I guess I want to just go ahead
- 18:55and talk about one of my favorite parts of the movie and
- 18:57it is when the film tips into, you know, melodrama there's this
- 19:01kind of contrived thing where the Dancehall girl finds That
- 19:05the Tramp likes her and sets up this whole thing where she's
- 19:09going to come dine with him at this cabin that he's overseeing
- 19:12on New Year's Eve, and bring all the dance hall girls.
- 19:14And and then she like, very obviously stands him up.
- 19:17She doesn't forget. She's screwing with him and it's
- 19:19because she's involved with this guy who's just a giant.
- 19:23And I think his name is Jack. I don't know what his name is.
- 19:25He's the worst. And I think it's R.
- 19:27It's probably Richard probably Richard.
- 19:30He's just a bully. And you know, eventually she
- 19:33realizes that this guy is just Going too far with how he
- 19:36bullies the Tramp and Des Associates from him.
- 19:38But at this point she's standing him up the Tramp falls asleep,
- 19:43dreaming about all the ways. He's going to entertain these
- 19:45girls and you get this iconic sequence which we'll talk about
- 19:49in a minute, but he wakes up from this dream, right?
- 19:51At midnight as everybody down at the dance, hall is singing Auld
- 19:55Lang Syne and chaplain does This brilliant thing where bro Auld
- 20:00Lang Syne is perhaps never sadder than it is in this movie
- 20:03which I love Auld Lang Syne As a song because it allows you to
- 20:07reflect on, I don't know the the good and bad tapestry of life
- 20:13every year and you get to some most nostalgic song is so good
- 20:17and and you get this moment of like all these Haggard looking
- 20:20people in the Klondike or wherever we are like reflecting
- 20:25on what they've done in the last year and some of them are openly
- 20:27weeping and then the song ends and they immediately go back to
- 20:30like drunken revelry and as they're reflecting on life.
- 20:35We're Cutting back to chaplain in the cabin with the door
- 20:38cracked open leaning out. Realizing that he's been
- 20:41abandoned yet again. And it's one of the few times in
- 20:44the movie where we get a legit close-up of Chaplin and his
- 20:48acting in that scene man. It is like, I legitimately
- 20:52teared up at that scene, Brad, it is heart-wrenching and the
- 20:55current one command that this guy Chaplin had on his editing
- 20:59and the way that he's able to tug at the heartstrings a
- 21:01hundred years ago. I'm like, I wish people would
- 21:04watch Listen take notes today. Yeah.
- 21:07Well and it feels like like honestly, the way that Georgia
- 21:12the dancer who's messing with him plays it, it feels like
- 21:17like, you're watching Mean Girls.
- 21:18Hmm. Like the way she's like, kind
- 21:21of, you know, tittering with her friends and like laughing and
- 21:25they know that they're kind of playing a joke on this poor
- 21:28nerdy kid. If you will, it feels like a
- 21:32modern understanding of the interaction.
- 21:35Actions between boys and girls when they're not mature enough
- 21:38to really, you know, love and sacrifice and do all the things
- 21:42that are required of people when they're in love with one
- 21:44another. Mmm and I think that he does
- 21:46such a good job of characterizing that.
- 21:48But then also his ability to use sound design to manipulate
- 21:54emotions is incredible. The way the that all Lang Syne
- 21:59is played, when the camera is on, the dance hall is upbeat and
- 22:04Lively. And a fun version of it and then
- 22:07the camera cuts to Chaplin and it immediately gets quieter a
- 22:11little bit slower and you're like, you immediately feel
- 22:15mournful and it's because chaplain has this ability to
- 22:19contrast the large Lively raucous party.
- 22:23That is the dance hall with the loneliness of a man who thought
- 22:27he had friends. And I just man that was just
- 22:31really really touching and that it's moments like that Bob like
- 22:35you. Said, we were like, this doesn't
- 22:37feel like a ninety, eight year, old movie, my heart.
- 22:40It feels like when I didn't have any friends or it feels like
- 22:44when I've struggled to, you know, how struggled with liking
- 22:48a girl? Who doesn't like me back?
- 22:50Yeah, like, like, all of that is just true to The Human
- 22:53Experience. Well and that's the thing.
- 22:55I want to get back to you were talking about how Winsome of a
- 22:57character he is. And I want to just add the word
- 22:59sympathetic to that, you know, it's a yeah, obviously, a common
- 23:03word to use but the reason that we Of the Tramp so much is that
- 23:07we empathize with him and his lowest moments and he's not a
- 23:10character like mr. Bean and I think that he loved
- 23:14mr. Bean.
- 23:15You know what I mean? Those are like hilarious
- 23:16sketches, but Mr. Bean is like a Rube who comes in and messes
- 23:21stuff up and it's funny to watch a mess stuff up.
- 23:23And you know, early chaplain reels are like that.
- 23:27Like, it's just chaotic and it really funny to watch him
- 23:30pretend to be a barber and slather.
- 23:32Somebody and shaving again Three Stooges type.
- 23:34Exactly Actly. This character is not that he's
- 23:37not dumb and he's not ignorant, he's perhaps too trusting, but
- 23:41he always finds out what's going on and how he is the but of
- 23:45someone's joke, and he still chooses to keep that open
- 23:48posture to the world and to go on with his life.
- 23:51But sometimes you see him do it with a heavy sigh.
- 23:54And I think that's the key to the Tramp.
- 23:56It's not that he's ignorant or dumb.
- 24:00It's just that he's too trusting and we love him because of that.
- 24:04Yeah. Yeah, well that's that's the
- 24:06beauty of any good drama, right? That it reveals something about
- 24:10ourselves, even as we watch the drama unfold on-screen or, you
- 24:14know, on the pages of a book. And that's what you have in,
- 24:19chaplain in this film. And in a lot of his films is
- 24:22somebody that you can see yourself in.
- 24:25And like, let's be honest. Bob, there's a lot of directors
- 24:29nowadays that can't direct a movie that I would see myself
- 24:31in. That's true.
- 24:33I want to ask this, you know, we're on the performances thing,
- 24:36but before we move off of it, I think we're in a good spot to
- 24:38ask this. How has watching Chaplin movies
- 24:42and particularly like getting to know, the character of the Tramp
- 24:46Brad. How has that changed your
- 24:48preconceptions of? What the Tramp was going to be?
- 24:52Um, I think that I genuinely thought of the Tramp as a Three
- 24:57Stooges precursor. Mmm.
- 24:59And that, that was kind of it that he was a slapstick
- 25:02vaudvillian. In comedic force that people
- 25:06just really loved in the in the 20s and 30s and to spend time
- 25:11with him and modern times or sit in city lights and now, you
- 25:17know, he's called the lone prospector, but it's the trips
- 25:20the Tramp. Yeah, sure.
- 25:21Yeah. So, seeing him in now in the
- 25:24gold rush, You understand why he was so popular that that he
- 25:30really does relate to every person watching the movie?
- 25:34Yeah, I mean it, you know, this movie comes out at the height of
- 25:37the Roaring 20s and I think that's reflected like in the
- 25:39costumes of the girls at the dance hall.
- 25:41Those don't seem period-accurate to me, but what do I know?
- 25:45I was to say there's a reason that chaplain is able to, I want
- 25:50to say to milk this character, but to keep this character alive
- 25:53in the format of a silent movie. All the way through to 1936 in
- 25:58modern times when everyone's making sound pictures at that
- 26:01point. And it's because this character
- 26:03like Taps into something about the struggles of everyday life
- 26:09and that in the middle of the Great Depression, people are
- 26:12still looking to the Tramp, not just for inspiration but also as
- 26:16a reflection and an empathy that someone out there understands
- 26:21what I'm going through and someone is going through the
- 26:23same thing as me and I think that's what makes this
- 26:25character. Actor, so lasting.
- 26:28Yeah. No, I'm with you, 100%.
- 26:31I'm curious. If you have any thoughts on the
- 26:33other pieces of this all-star star-studded cast.
- 26:38I know that you are 100% familiar with them but you know,
- 26:41Max Swain as Big Jim McKay. Tom Murray is black Larson.
- 26:46Malcolm weight is Jack Cameron and Georgia.
- 26:48Hale is Georgia. You know these are big name
- 26:51actors here. Bob that everybody knows about
- 26:54sure. What did you think of their
- 26:55performance? You know, I thought it was great
- 26:57that they didn't try to overshadow, Charlie Chaplin.
- 27:00They were also much bigger than he was and they let him kind of
- 27:04Take the Lead, You know. Yeah, that's very kind of them.
- 27:07Honestly. I think the one that I want to
- 27:09talk about and they're all pretty great.
- 27:10I think. Georgia.
- 27:11Hail does a good job. Her character is a lot more
- 27:13limited than Virginia channels character last week.
- 27:18Like, in terms of screen time, the one that stuck out to me was
- 27:21Max Wayne as Big Jim McKay. I thought he didn't just a
- 27:24fantastic job. I was reading an article or an
- 27:27essay today where they talk about how the film critic James
- 27:31Agee described Max. Wayne as a hairy mushroom, that
- 27:36was not how he said that that he looked in real life and I don't
- 27:39know if I've ever heard of meaner or a more accurate
- 27:41representation of what a person looks like.
- 27:44But yeah, that's another great thing about chaplain is that he
- 27:48always found interesting faces to work with like these guys
- 27:52look like they could have been out there prospecting.
- 27:55And I think that adds a level of like, this is clearly like an
- 28:00overblown comedy, but the fact that everybody else kind of fits
- 28:04into the world at this movie is pretending to build.
- 28:08It allows the Tramp to come in there and it doesn't break the
- 28:11world apart. He's just inserted into a very
- 28:14believable situation. Yeah.
- 28:17I mean, honestly I really loved the guy who played Black Larson.
- 28:21Hmm. I think that he reminded me of
- 28:24is it Walter Huston In. Oh yeah.
- 28:26Oh good. Yeah, the prospector from
- 28:30Treasure of the Sierra Madre. Like they just have such a
- 28:34similar Vibe of their look, obviously not of their
- 28:37characters, but like they just look like they belong,
- 28:42prospecting for gold and period. And so, yeah, I think that that
- 28:47chaplain finds fascinating actors to do the things that he
- 28:51needs them to do which is like you said that like they are
- 28:55Accents on the performance. That is Charlie Chaplin.
- 28:59And I think that they, that in this movie, especially I love
- 29:04Max Wayne. And his, the way he,
- 29:09Gesticulates constantly and the way he uses his body to interact
- 29:14with Charlie Chaplin. Like he knows he's a lot bigger
- 29:18than him. And there's a lot of Comedy that
- 29:19can come from that and it's an incredible performance because
- 29:22of that Tom Murray playing Black Larson, the criminal is menacing
- 29:27and and slightly terrifying. And and it's it works for for
- 29:32how small Charlie is and the style of character that he's
- 29:36trying to play. I just I loved everybody in
- 29:39this. Movie, man.
- 29:40You know, I want to just talk real quickly about the black
- 29:42Larson character because he's only in, like the first 20
- 29:44minutes of the movie, it's like the first person that chaplain
- 29:47stumbles upon a cabin. This guy black Larson is inside
- 29:50the cabin. He is a wanted murderer on the
- 29:53lam and chaplain walks in and creates havoc.
- 29:57And then this guy, big Jim McKay also find shelter there in the
- 29:59three of them are kind of cooped up in this cabin for a while.
- 30:04When the camera goes off with black Larson on his own, I was
- 30:07really impressed at. I don't want to call it like the
- 30:09Action choreography. But those were very impressive
- 30:13scenes like he's getting. He stumbles upon to, you know,
- 30:17Marshalls that are looking for him.
- 30:19He shoots one, he beats one with a shovel.
- 30:22Like it's, it's like intense action sequences leading to
- 30:28Larson. Stumbling upon Big Jim McKay has
- 30:31big find of gold and trying to flee with it.
- 30:34And then this really impressive sequence of like a cliff like a
- 30:39an ice sheet breaking off of a cliff and him falling to his
- 30:42death. And you can kind of tell that
- 30:43there's there's early not green screening but that they've
- 30:46inserted, you know, in the camera, like a person into a
- 30:51backdrop. Right?
- 30:53Yep. And I'm looking at that going
- 30:54like okay? Yeah, like I can tell what's
- 30:56going on here but this is 100 years old dude.
- 30:59Like it's, it's crazy. How well this holds up, dude, I
- 31:03have with you. I thought that as I was watching
- 31:06that shot I'm like, you can tell it's fake.
- 31:09But it's pretty damn good man. I couldn't lie.
- 31:11Could I do better in 2023? Absolutely.
- 31:14Not like I can't know shop, a still image like this is It's
- 31:19really impressive. Yeah.
- 31:21No, it really is. And like you said, the, the, the
- 31:24fight choreography in. This is honestly really good to
- 31:27the point where I'm just kind of like, you know, I feel like Tom
- 31:31Murray might have been a real criminal.
- 31:33Yeah, I'm just, he was just like, hey, just go beat these
- 31:35two people in and, and we'll call it a day and he really knew
- 31:38what he was. All right, man.
- 31:41I think we're at a good place to stop.
- 31:42Let's press pause here. Let's take a return trip to
- 31:45Scotland and try this Tam. Do what do you say dude?
- 31:48I never thought you would say that I love going to Scotland.
- 31:57Alright so today we are checking out.
- 31:59Tam do ten year. This is a single malt scotch
- 32:03whiskey from the space side region, Brad.
- 32:06Let's let's go back a little bit.
- 32:09Let's give a refresher on Scotch whiskey.
- 32:12I'm Gonna Pop Quiz. You tell me everything.
- 32:13You remember about Scotch, whiskey bread, Scotland.
- 32:16Hey, malt malted barley. Delicious.
- 32:20Mmm, it's all you need to know. Folks, that's it.
- 32:25That's it, man. Yeah, Scotch whisky, as with all
- 32:28things will start at the very Basics, all scotches whiskey,
- 32:32not all whiskey is scotch. Same way that all bourbon is
- 32:35whiskey, not all Whiskey's bourbon, Scotch is made in
- 32:38Scotland. It has to be 100%, malted barley
- 32:41and in general, you will find it in one of two varieties.
- 32:45It will either be Pete. Adorned on peated.
- 32:48Peated means that it tastes delicious.
- 32:50Non peated means that it tastes delicious.
- 32:54I think the biggest thing when you're thinking about Scotch is
- 32:57the region, that's what a lot of people get really kind of held
- 33:01up on and that's fine. Like most of your peated scotch
- 33:06is going to come as a Nyla Scotch from the islands, on the
- 33:09western sides of Scotland. The orkneys is a place where a
- 33:13few scotches come from and then you have your speyside scotches
- 33:19which are found near a river that I can't think of the name
- 33:22of Bob, is it the river spey? I'm pretty sure it's Loch
- 33:26Lomond, bread. There we go.
- 33:28Let's go Ms. Yeah, yeah. So there's space side and then
- 33:32there's Highland whiskies and I'm sure that there's more
- 33:35reasons than that. I am still a novice when it
- 33:37comes to Scotch overall. But you know, that's usually
- 33:41you'll hear people talking about space site or I'll has or things
- 33:45like that. Yeah, I mean you didn't listen
- 33:47man you did pretty good on the pop quiz here.
- 33:49I will say that not all Scotch is made.
- 33:52Made only from malted barley. You're also allowed to add
- 33:57coloration to scotch in a way that you're not allowed to do
- 33:59with things like bourbon in America.
- 34:01And in order to achieve that color, sometimes they add other
- 34:04grains into the mix. So when you look at a bottle of
- 34:07Scotch whiskey, if it says the two words, single malt on it,
- 34:11that means two things put together the word single means
- 34:15that it comes from one. Distillery one single
- 34:17Distillery, the opposite of that would be Blended.
- 34:21And then the word mulch means that it is made entirely from
- 34:24malted barley. The opposite of that would be
- 34:27grain. So you could have single malt
- 34:29single grain Blended malt or Blended grain.
- 34:33Scotch whisky what we're drinking today.
- 34:35Brad, as I said, is a single malt.
- 34:37Speyside scotch whisky has been aged for 10 years exclusively in
- 34:42Sherry casks and I'm very very excited to dive into it.
- 34:47This is clocking in at 86 proof or 43% ABV.
- 34:51Evie and we have talked long enough.
- 34:53Let's dive into this thing bread.
- 34:55Yeah, as I jumped into the nose here Bob, this is delectable.
- 35:01I got strawberry jam, I got honey, there's a bit of like, an
- 35:06orange peel Citrus zest, feel to it, and the longer I sat with
- 35:10it, the more I felt like there was like an almond extract
- 35:13nuttiness going on that. I really enjoyed.
- 35:17I give it a 9 out of 10 on the nose.
- 35:19This is an interesting note. Me Brad because we've had a few
- 35:23space eyes on the show before. I think probably the most
- 35:26predominant ones were Glenlivet and a burl hour and we talked
- 35:30about how soft and delicate and floral and fruity they are this
- 35:35one really toes the line for me between smelling like a speyside
- 35:38and smelling like a Highland. I get a lot of like like
- 35:41Glenmorangie on this to be frank.
- 35:42There's a lot more malt, a lot more spiciness and like the very
- 35:47faintest Whisper of almost like Like if you get your nose too
- 35:52close to like like gasoline and you kind of like prickles your
- 35:56nose a little bit, you know what I mean?
- 35:58Yeah, like it's not, it's not nail polish remover, but it has
- 36:01that slight. Oh, you need to take a step back
- 36:03here, you know, like Danger Danger on your nose but mixed
- 36:07with all of those lovely floral and fruity notes as well.
- 36:11It's a little bit perplexing to me because I don't know what to
- 36:14expect on the palate, but I am going to give it an 8 out of 10
- 36:17on the nose. Yeah, when I got into the
- 36:19palette Bob the almonds feel came front right to the front.
- 36:25I think I got almond slices. There was some cherry, some
- 36:29strawberry shortcake. Kind of like with like a whipped
- 36:32cream creaminess feel to it and then the, The Barley really
- 36:36started to come through on the palate, but it was soft enough
- 36:38that it didn't overwhelm any of the other stuff going on.
- 36:41I'm sticking at a 9 out of 10 on the flavor.
- 36:44Bob, I think this is a really incredible Scotch.
- 36:47Yeah, for me. It's a Darker than what you're
- 36:49describing Brad. I think if there's a fruit on it
- 36:51for me, It's almost like a luxardo cherry like it's a, it's
- 36:55a brandied dark stone fruit. And then all the barley in the
- 37:01world followed by some smokiness and it's closer to char or an
- 37:06ash, then it is a peat smoke. Definitely darker in character.
- 37:10And I would, I would say this tastes more like a Highland
- 37:13Scotch to me than it does a space.
- 37:15I'd just based on the ones we've tried so far.
- 37:18I like this a lot. It is surprising me in ways
- 37:21that, you know, I definitely we didn't expect it to.
- 37:23So I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 on the palate.
- 37:27Yeah, the Finish is really nice. It's got about a medium finish.
- 37:32It doesn't last crazy long, but it sticks with you for a little
- 37:35bit. For me, I got into the darker
- 37:38fruit territory on the Finish. Blackberries Plum, the Almond
- 37:43stuck around and then it had a nice vanilla Spritz at the end
- 37:48that was intriguing. I give it an eight and a half on
- 37:52the Finish. Yeah I think vanilla is a good
- 37:54call here. I was trying to pinpoint other
- 37:56something sweet that I normally get on American whiskeys and it
- 37:58wasn't caramel and it's definitely vanilla.
- 38:01It's really good man. I will say that this is a little
- 38:05spicier than I thought it would be like, it's definitely not
- 38:08alcohol forward. It's not prickly in that way,
- 38:12but it's got some black pepper on it, which is really, really
- 38:14nice. It's this is like, almost
- 38:16reminiscent of it's like the Rye Whiskey of the speyside region.
- 38:21That makes sense. Yeah, and I like it a lot.
- 38:23I'm gonna give it a seven point five on the finish.
- 38:26I'll jump right in with balance. I think that this is a very well
- 38:29balanced whiskey. I don't think that there was
- 38:31much on the nose that Teased something that wasn't there on
- 38:35the taste or finish. It definitely feels.
- 38:39I don't want to say out of place but just different from the
- 38:41space sides. We've tried so far but that
- 38:44difference was Apparent from the get-go.
- 38:47And so I think it is a really consistent product, I'll give it
- 38:51an 8 out of 10. I give it a 9 and a half on
- 38:54balance. I think that there's a
- 38:56complexity of flavor mixed with a really nice experience that
- 39:01that isn't a roller coaster. I think that this was a very
- 39:06well balanced whiskey that is. Nine and a half Brad, I don't
- 39:11know what the price on this is right now.
- 39:13I think they stopped selling it in the state of Ohio.
- 39:15I'm like 99% certain that this was part of one of my OHL Q last
- 39:21call runs that I did for the show.
- 39:23So I picked this up at a bit of a discount but I don't know what
- 39:25it typically retails for. What have you found the best I
- 39:30can tell is that it's around a fifty dollar, Whiskey in the
- 39:34state's, I think this is a great value for 50 bucks.
- 39:38Like is it my favorite Scotch at $50?
- 39:41No but it's a 10-year Scotch that has a very unique flavor
- 39:46profile. You know, according to the
- 39:48region that it's from and 50 bucks, I'll give it a 9 out of
- 39:5310 man. Yeah, that's exactly what I gave
- 39:55it. I think that you know, if this
- 39:57was like anything under 50 it be a 10 out of 10. $50 is like
- 40:01right where it should be if not a little higher.
- 40:03This could be a 60 dollar bottle of whiskey and I'd be like yeah
- 40:06that makes sense. So yeah. $50.
- 40:09This is a nine out of ten value. Bob I am coming out to a very
- 40:12high and I think it's going to be a little bit higher than
- 40:15yours 45 out of 50 Brad. I'm at a 40 out of 50 and I will
- 40:21add the caveat that I like this less than you.
- 40:24And the reason I'm at a 40 is because I gave it a 9 out of 10
- 40:27on value, it would be a 31 out of 40 on just the tasting
- 40:32experience, which is still good, very good.
- 40:35But this is not like in my upper echelon of scotch.
- 40:38Is that we've tried for this show but it sounds like it's
- 40:40really checking all the boxes for you.
- 40:43Yeah, I mean, I believe that would put me at a 36 out of 40.
- 40:47So yes, I very much. So enjoy this whiskey.
- 40:52I think that it's very easily worth a buy or a try.
- 40:56If you find it out in the wild, I'll agree with that.
- 40:59And we're coming out to an average of a 42.5 or an 85 out
- 41:03of 100. Darn good, whiskey, Brad.
- 41:06And I think that, yeah, you know, if they Had this in the
- 41:09chilkoot pass back in the day. It really would have helped them
- 41:12warm their cockles, as they prospected for the gold, the
- 41:16cockles of their soul. Bob, let's get back to talking
- 41:20about the cockles of Charlie Chaplin's.
- 41:22So, what say you? Yeah, I don't want to talk about
- 41:25cockles on anyone, but that sounds good man.
- 41:27Let's do it. All right, everybody, that was
- 41:35Tam. Do 10 a whiskey that we as you
- 41:38said at the start start of the episode Bob struggled with, we
- 41:42sure did 450 bucks, man. Yeah, that's what I'm saying,
- 41:45dude, it's good whiskey. This almost would have been a
- 41:48bargain back in 1800 something. Whenever this movie set Well,
- 41:53whether or not it's a bargain, we are going to move into
- 41:56Canada's favorite segments to fax in a falsehood, is gonna try
- 42:01to stop you by all right? And what is wrong?
- 42:08Two facts in a faucet to facts in a falsehood is the part of
- 42:12the show where Brad presents three items to me, as fact about
- 42:15the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 42:19And I have to guess, which one is the LIE, Bradley.
- 42:22As, you know, I have checked 12 books out of the library, on
- 42:26Charles Chaplin. As we get into his films here
- 42:29and I have read zero of them in preparation for this episode.
- 42:34I will tell you what I have done for this episode so that you
- 42:36don't get mad. I glanced at the Wikipedia
- 42:40article mostly for specs on how long the movie was, and I read
- 42:45an essay in the Criterion Collection, which I sent to you
- 42:49before we start, we started recording.
- 42:51So that's literally To the extent of my prep for this
- 42:53episode. If you're going to pull one over
- 42:55on me, now is the time man. Yeah, I'm absolutely ready.
- 43:00I'm prepared to take the victory home today.
- 43:03Let's do this, I will say I'm at 500 now last week you also
- 43:07episode 10 on the season, I am five and five.
- 43:10So this is really, you know, this is the Crux of the thing
- 43:13right now, A Clash of Titans, if you will.
- 43:17Fact number one, an actual American black bear was used for
- 43:21the scene, where the lone prospector encounters the Beast,
- 43:24which was quite unusual for the time when it was very normal for
- 43:27large. Phony looking costume men to
- 43:30play Animals fact, number two, Chaplin originally envisioned
- 43:35this film to take place in San Francisco, California.
- 43:39But was convinced by milk gross that the Yukon had more
- 43:42potential for isolating. Its main character due to its
- 43:46inclement weather, Weather. Fact, number three, this movie
- 43:49May feature the earliest born actor in any major film born in
- 43:531828 in modern-day Brownsville. Texas, pop Taylor appears in
- 43:58this movie as the ancient dancing prospector, he was 70
- 44:02years old at the time of the actual Klondike Gold Rush of
- 44:051898. Wow, well that's cool.
- 44:09I'm going to go ahead and assume three is true.
- 44:11I don't remember the ancient dancing prospector but sure,
- 44:14we'll just say it's true. One and two are interesting and
- 44:18I'll start with number two. I don't know if chaplain wanted
- 44:22to set this movie in San Francisco.
- 44:25Or where did you say? You said San Francisco, right?
- 44:27Yeah, yep, the gold rush in San Francisco.
- 44:29I don't know if he wanted to set it in San Francisco.
- 44:31I know he wanted to film on location and had to fill most of
- 44:36it in California, which I mean, that makes sense.
- 44:40So I know the difficulty know the, the pull between going to
- 44:43like Alaska or staying in California.
- 44:45Nia was a thing. I don't know if it had anything
- 44:47to do with the setting of the movie.
- 44:50Number one is interesting because if you watch that scene
- 44:53where the black bear comes in the cabin, there's very
- 44:56obviously a real bear in some of these scenes.
- 44:58And then when it starts beating people up, it's very obviously,
- 45:01a person in a fake bear suit. So I'm struggling with the way
- 45:06that one's worded because it's clearly a both and like there's
- 45:09definitely a bear. There's definitely also a person
- 45:13in a suit I think I'm going to say one, is the falsehood, just
- 45:20by the way, it was written. But I think one or two could be
- 45:23false and if it's three then I had no chance.
- 45:28Well Bob fact, number two was the false lot man.
- 45:33Fact number one is the truth, according to IMDb.
- 45:36All right. Well, I'm pretty sure there was
- 45:39a guy in a bear suit in in those scenes.
- 45:41I don't know. What's your take on that Fred?
- 45:44I mean, On the wording of the, the truth, or just the, whether
- 45:48or not there was a real person, I guess both.
- 45:51But yeah, was there, it seems like they enter cut a trained
- 45:56bear with a guy Charlie. Chaplin is fighting in a suit.
- 46:00Yes, 100%, I'm with you. All right, well I want half a
- 46:03victory, then this is ridiculous.
- 46:07So you are still at 500 with five-and-a-half wins and five
- 46:10and a half glasses. All right Magill Ace will take
- 46:14my L, but This is one of those moments where it's like IMDb not
- 46:19trustworthy. I mean I think the focus was
- 46:23more on the fact that they had a bear at all right.
- 46:26More than the fact that there was a guy in a suit for some of
- 46:29it, I feel it. All right, so I think that was
- 46:31the the point of the fact what you really should have said was
- 46:35they got a giant six-foot chicken to be in this movie one
- 46:38of the rarest chickens in the world and not a Charlie Chaplin
- 46:42dressed as a chicken. Yeah.
- 46:44Which actually It was supposed to be somebody else.
- 46:46Stresses the chicken, but chaplain got so frustrated with
- 46:49him that he just put the suit on himself and did it.
- 46:53I love that man. Yeah.
- 46:55Like I think I can be a better chicken than this guy committed.
- 46:57The auteur Charlie Chaplin dressing as a chicken because
- 47:01the other guy dresses, the chicken wasn't doing a good
- 47:03enough job. All right, man, where do you
- 47:06want to go from here? I feel like we've had a really
- 47:08good conversation about why? Chaplain is an indelible figure
- 47:13and an endearing figure. I feel like we've had a good
- 47:16conversation about some of the directorial choices.
- 47:18He made in this movie, may be the best place to start Brad.
- 47:22If I could kind of steer us somewhere, is like what gags
- 47:25worked for you best what, sequences from the movie?
- 47:27Do you remember the most aside from the Old Lang?
- 47:30Syne one that we've talked about already.
- 47:32I think the shot that I referred to earlier, there's this moment
- 47:37where Charlie goes into the dance hall for the first time
- 47:41and he, you know, he has the, The Boy Meets Girl, you know,
- 47:46when he sees Georgia and Falls immediately in love.
- 47:49And there's this shot where he is like standing underneath, you
- 47:55know, kind of an overhang and a ton of people around him just
- 47:58talking and then the band strikes up and you know, it's
- 48:01time to dance. And the camera just sits behind
- 48:05Charles like a little bit lower than his waist, height kind of
- 48:10looking up on him a tiny bit and he's like perfectly silhouetted
- 48:14by the ceiling above him. And you just watch as every
- 48:20human being in the dance. Hall finds a partner and starts
- 48:25dancing or talking or engaging with someone and he just stands
- 48:32there. They're open feet, taking it all
- 48:36in lonely, as I've ever seen a human being on a, on in a movie,
- 48:43and the camera just sits there for a solid ten seconds, which
- 48:48is a long time in. When you think about movies,
- 48:50especially where they're cut in a lot of films with how quick
- 48:54they go, it's just a solid 10 to 15 seconds on him standing
- 48:59there. He kind of leans on his Cane a
- 49:01little bit and And you just feel just from his back, the
- 49:06loneliness that this character is feeling and I'm just like,
- 49:10sitting there going. Oh, this is a perfect movie
- 49:14scene. A perfect movie shot.
- 49:17Yep. And I just, I don't know, man.
- 49:19I it was mind-boggling. And in that moment, I was like,
- 49:23oh, I get it, like, I understand why people love, Charlie
- 49:28Chaplin. It's stuff like this that I'm
- 49:32like Yep. This is why he remains relevant
- 49:34to 100 years later, it is like a mind-bogglingly beautiful shot.
- 49:38And it's one of those things where You almost got to hit
- 49:42pause on it and kind of take in, why it's working.
- 49:44So, well, it's the framing, it's how big chaplain is in the
- 49:48frame, compared to the people who are dancing physically away
- 49:51from him. It's the way that the lens is
- 49:54kind of putting those people further.
- 49:56And further out of focus, the farther they get away from him,
- 49:59it's the lighting. And it's a really great example
- 50:02of using, like, multiple points of light to accentuate, or like,
- 50:06I don't know, D accentuate, other areas.
- 50:09It's the kind of smokiness of that.
- 50:11It's all in the way, the lights catching that.
- 50:12It is just a perfect shot. I don't like.
- 50:16Yeah, and it's really rare that we spend more than 20 seconds,
- 50:19talking about how beautiful it specific shot is in a movie, but
- 50:23the framing of the Tramp, looking on, at the rest of the
- 50:27world having fun without him is perhaps the like it's the most
- 50:32iconic image I can think of of the Tramp.
- 50:34And I think that for me it makes me think about Spielberg and the
- 50:40way he talks about About John Ford and, you know, like the
- 50:43famous meeting that he had when he was a little kid.
- 50:46Yeah, or a teenager when he met John Ford and John Ford's
- 50:49talking about how to frame a shot.
- 50:51That's what I was thinking about.
- 50:53As I watched this shot, like I thought about how people talk
- 50:57about Ford that he didn't have to move the camera because he
- 51:00just shot a beautiful shot. Like, you don't need to move the
- 51:03camera if it's in the perfectly right spot.
- 51:06And I like that's what I was thinking about.
- 51:08As I watched this, this All seen that I was just like, yeah.
- 51:12Like you don't need to move the camera when it's in the perfect
- 51:15spot like Charles knew what he was doing here and it's just
- 51:19incredible. And I couldn't walk away from
- 51:21this episode, without talking about it.
- 51:24I think the two most famous kind of gags in this movie, I don't
- 51:28know. If I want to call him gags, but
- 51:30like, famous comedy bits are first, the cooking and eating of
- 51:34the shoe really funny. And at, like it's really great,
- 51:39it's big, Jim McKay. Okay, and the Tramp are in this
- 51:42cabin and they've been starving for days and days and days.
- 51:45While black Larson is out shooting people and running off
- 51:47and dying and they have no idea where he is and Chaplin Cooks,
- 51:52one of his shoes and they decide to eat it and and Big Jim takes
- 51:56the the top part of the shoe and leaves the Tramp, the heel of
- 52:01the shoe with Nails in it and watching them both eat this
- 52:05thing. Like apparently the shoe was
- 52:06made out of black licorice, I think they do a really good job
- 52:09of selling that. It is just cooked leather.
- 52:11Yep. Watching the Tramp, take each of
- 52:14these little nails and put them in his mouth and like, pick
- 52:17every bit of meat off of the bone again.
- 52:19Like, he's eating chicken wings or like a rib or something.
- 52:23Yeah, it's such a great moment, man, dude.
- 52:26The the whole opening scene with the way he like gets backed off
- 52:30by the gun and they're like, backing around the room.
- 52:33And the way that they eat, the, the shoe that that whole
- 52:37sequence between him and Big, Jim Jim is comedy gold.
- 52:43Oh yeah. And I don't know if this is the
- 52:45other set piece but I'm going to point it out the whole house
- 52:48falling off the edge of the cliff.
- 52:50Just feels like the best slap, the best of slapstick comedy,
- 52:55you know, and I love the house teetering on the edge of the
- 52:58cliff, but I almost love earlier in the movie, every time the
- 53:01door gets opened and there's like a big gust of wind and
- 53:03their load, he's trying to kick trap out of the house and
- 53:06chaplains like running Against the Wind and not going anywhere.
- 53:09Mmm. The other really Famous sequence
- 53:11Brad and you might not know it because I feel like it gets
- 53:14buried under. These bigger set pieces is this
- 53:17bit where chaplains dreaming? And he does this little dance
- 53:21with the dinner rolls at where he like, he puts two roles on a
- 53:24fork and you pop them out. Like it is his feet and he does
- 53:27a dance on the table with honey. It's really funny but I feel
- 53:31like I've never understood why that is the like literally Brad.
- 53:35It's the most iconic thing chaplain has ever done.
- 53:38And apparently, I was just reading in this essay today.
- 53:41When they premiered the movie in Berlin, now again, we keep
- 53:45getting circling back to Berlin on these things.
- 53:47But pre Nazi Berlin. They premiered this movie and
- 53:51that bit killed so much that they stopped the movie, and ran
- 53:55it back like during the premiere of the movie.
- 53:59No. It's, it's that iconic.
- 54:01And I feel like I'm pooh-poohing like one of the most famous
- 54:05scenes in history. It's a funny bit.
- 54:07I don't know if I've ever understood.
- 54:08Why it became the most iconic chapters.
- 54:11When bit, but I do think it does a really good job of showing his
- 54:15physicality like it. He looks like a small man doing
- 54:19a dance on a table with dinner rolls for feet.
- 54:22And I think it works really well.
- 54:24I think the reason it works and it kills so much is that he is
- 54:30just so incredibly smooth, like the, the way he uses his hands
- 54:37and the way he flips these dinner rolls around like It's so
- 54:42much looks like a real Can-Can that it's I'm about to do it.
- 54:47It's uncanny. Hey how much it looks like he's
- 54:50actually doing it and you're I feel like it's almost man.
- 54:54I'm just I'm on a roll here. Bob it's almost an uncanny
- 54:58valley. Mmm of like it is so smooth and
- 55:02looks so much like an actual Can-Can and yet it's just dinner
- 55:06rolls on Forks. Yeah.
- 55:07And the I was losing it when I was watching it.
- 55:11Do it. I thought that was an incredibly
- 55:12funny scene. I would agree with you though
- 55:14that. I don't know why that would be
- 55:16the funniest. All right man.
- 55:19I think we're at a good spot to segue into our last segment of
- 55:23the day which we call, let's make it a double we near the end
- 55:27of the episode. So thanks for listening to the
- 55:30film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 55:32this one. Even if it's struggle, it's a
- 55:34final section of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 55:37Let's make it. A double is the part of the
- 55:38show, where we pick a movie to pair up with this one to make
- 55:42the perfect double feature Brad. I didn't really have one coming
- 55:45into this episode and I feel like you've given me the
- 55:47inspiration. Eration to just say, it's
- 55:50Treasure of the Sierra Madre, like it's that's about Perry.
- 55:53I could possibly think of two great movies about prospecting
- 55:56for gold, and they go in wildly, different directions.
- 56:01Yeah, 100%. And I think that Treasure of the
- 56:03Sierra Madre Works especially because of the Ridiculousness of
- 56:08that movie and yet, how grounded it remains.
- 56:12And I think that in a similar way like the, you know, the Gold
- 56:15Rush is a ridiculous movie with slapstick.
- 56:18The end yet. It somehow stays grounded in the
- 56:21real experience of loneliness that pretty much every human has
- 56:24felt. So I think that's a really good
- 56:26pairing Bob. Is that your parent?
- 56:29No, I think I want to get it out of the way and I think it works
- 56:33here because of how much slapstick comedy occurs in this
- 56:36film. I don't know if I'm gonna
- 56:38partner with a movie. I'm just going to partner with
- 56:41the Three Stooges. Mmm, like, you know, because as
- 56:45best as I can remember, I don't know if They made a
- 56:48feature-length movie but they had a lot of like half hour
- 56:52comedy specials that were truly incredible.
- 56:57And so I would say just go watch, you know, three or four
- 57:01episodes of The Three Stooges and pair it with the gold rush
- 57:05and you'll have an absolutely entertaining evening.
- 57:09I think that's a great pairing and this is the one that I would
- 57:12do that pairing for because among the four films like
- 57:15there's definitely slapstick bits and there's a Out of bits
- 57:18where he's interacting with a second person and doing
- 57:20pratfalls, but this is the most Three Stooges e of the four
- 57:25movies. We're going to watch.
- 57:27Yeah. That's that's kind of what I
- 57:28felt and so I was like, I think this is a good space for that.
- 57:32All right, Brad, it's time for final scores.
- 57:35I really like this movie, I just don't think it hits the heights
- 57:39of City Lights. Well, that's not true.
- 57:41It exceeds the comedic Heights of city lights, but we're City
- 57:45Lights is like a 9.5 for me on every Single category, I think
- 57:50this movie. The second act, especially
- 57:52really drags for me. The ongoing thing about that
- 57:56bully and his interactions with Georgia.
- 57:59I feel like the scenes where it's just the two of them
- 58:01talking about like what they're going to do together and whether
- 58:04or not he likes her, I could care less get me back to the
- 58:07Tramp. I think the the way the movie
- 58:10ends is really really funny. It's almost like a Shakespeare
- 58:12comedy where, you know, everyone gets married at the end.
- 58:15But the the way that they go from like, This guy is a
- 58:19stowaway. Let's put him in jail to like
- 58:21no, he's not, he's a millionaire and then he goes and this is my
- 58:24wife and she's like, all right, cool, let's get married.
- 58:27Yeah, really kind of whiplash on that relationship.
- 58:31So I think that there's flaws to this movie.
- 58:33It's still an 8.5 out of 10 for me.
- 58:37I like this one a lot more than I liked city lights and I like
- 58:42City Lights. This was a 9 out of 10 for me.
- 58:44Bob, I think that the Comedy Works the, the slapstick
- 58:49elements, the dramatic elements. I love a lot of the camera work
- 58:53and I like the setting a little bit better.
- 58:55So yeah, 9 out of 10 for me. All right, we're coming out to
- 58:58an eight point seven five out of ten but we would like to know
- 59:02what you think. Maybe I'm completely wrong about
- 59:04how many people out there have watched Chaplin's films and
- 59:07you're all going to rake me over the coals and say that I called
- 59:10you all Rubes. But I would like you to do that
- 59:13in the form of a message on our social media accounts.
- 59:16So you can reach out to me and Brad to congratulate him on
- 59:19being smarter, than me, Facebook Twitter, Instagram, and
- 59:23Tick-Tock at film whiskey, or you can jump onto our Discord.
- 59:27Discord is a beautiful place where we get to talk about all
- 59:30things film, and whiskey and Beyond, we should call our
- 59:33Discord film, whiskey and Beyond.
- 59:35That's an idea. Right there, I love it.
- 59:38Come, join us. We're talking about all sorts of
- 59:40things all the time. You can find a link to our
- 59:42Discord at the end of every single one of our show notes
- 59:45next week, Brad, we are throwing it all the way forward to 1940.
- 59:49So this is chronologically the last movie in our set of for its
- 59:52chaplains. First sound film and he uses it
- 59:56to Great extent. It's also going to be the
- 59:57longest one we watch from. Chaplain at just a little over
- 1:00:00two hours. It's called The Great Dictator.
- 1:00:02So, we're watch that one next week.
- 1:00:04But until then, I'm Bob book. I'm Brad G and we'll see you
- 1:00:08next time.