Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Women Invest Better!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're here to take that stack of
- 0:03reading. You send us all the articles,
- 0:04the complex research, the data and boil it down into something
- 0:07that really sticks with you. And today we're getting into a
- 0:10really big one, a huge disparity that just won't go away in our
- 0:14economy. The massive gender gap in
- 0:16finance, both in, you know, engagement and in actual wealth.
- 0:20Right. And you always hear that one
- 0:22sort of simplistic question. It's something like, why do men
- 0:26seem to care more about investing in finance than women?
- 0:30But that whole premise, as your sources just immediately show
- 0:33us, is completely flawed. It's just the wrong question to
- 0:36be asking. Exactly.
- 0:37We have to just smash that idea right from the start.
- 0:40The gap we're seeing, it's not about who cares more or some
- 0:44innate ability. It's systemic.
- 0:46Woven through history, through how we're socialized, through,
- 0:49well, straight up economic factors.
- 0:51So our mission today is to get way beyond that simple question.
- 0:54We want to give you an evidence based look at what's really
- 0:57going on and. We want to show you the the
- 0:59surprising paradox that's really at the heart of all this.
- 1:02OK, so let's unpack it. We're going to take a journey
- 1:04from, you know, centuries old legal barriers that built the
- 1:09world we live in now all the way to the psychology of confidence
- 1:12versus actual skill. And then we land on the big
- 1:16reveal, the surprising truth about which gender is actually
- 1:20the more disciplined and therefore the more effective
- 1:24long term investor. So if you're looking for a few
- 1:28AHA moments, you're definitely in the right place.
- 1:31But before we jump in, just a quick word.
- 1:33We really want to thank you for sending these sources over and
- 1:35trusting us with them. Our goal, as always, is purely
- 1:37educational. And we do have to give the
- 1:39required disclaimer. All of our analysis is based on
- 1:42publicly available sources. The content is just for
- 1:44educational purposes. It is not investment advice.
- 1:47So please do your own due diligence before making any
- 1:50decisions. That's right.
- 1:51And on that note, if you do want to track the total market
- 1:54temperature, you can search for and download our iOS App Buffett
- 1:57Indicator right from the Apple App Store.
- 1:59And for more advanced content, you should we check out our Deep
- 2:01Value Club membership. OK, let's start at the
- 2:04beginning, because you really can't understand today's
- 2:06financial behaviors without seeing how recently women were
- 2:10just legally shut out of the economy.
- 2:13Yeah, the foundations of this gap are much more recent than I
- 2:16think most people realize. So when we look back, what did
- 2:19that legal landscape actually look like?
- 2:22Well, for centuries the main legal principle was something
- 2:25called curvature. Coverture.
- 2:27OK, that sounds pretty old school.
- 2:29What did that mean in like, practical terms for a woman?
- 2:32It meant that when a woman got married, her legal and economic
- 2:35identity was basically just absorbed by her husband.
- 2:39So she just vanished, legally speaking.
- 2:41Pretty much. She couldn't own property on her
- 2:43own, couldn't sign contracts, couldn't even control the money
- 2:46she earned. This was the law.
- 2:48It wasn't just the social norm. And it wasn't until around 1900
- 2:51that all states finally passed laws allowing married women to
- 2:55own property in their own name. 1900.
- 2:58Exactly. And even then, just owning
- 3:00property wasn't enough. You still had to be able to use
- 3:02the financial system. Right.
- 3:04Which brings us to something that is well within living
- 3:07memory for a lot of. People accessing credit think
- 3:10about something as basic as getting a bank loan or a credit
- 3:13card. A woman couldn't do that on her
- 3:16own without her husband's permission until the Equal
- 3:19Credit Opportunity Act of 1974. 1974 that's that's staggering to
- 3:27think about. For almost all of American
- 3:29history, women were legally blocked from being independent
- 3:33financial actors. And that deep, long standing
- 3:35exclusion created a kind of division of Labor in the home
- 3:39that you still see today. Even in dual income households,
- 3:42right? The habits just stick.
- 3:43It's the long shadow of it all. The sources you sent show men
- 3:46typically take the lead on the quote UN quote major decisions.
- 3:50So the investments, pensions, insurance, the long term stuff.
- 3:54Yeah, while women are often left to manage the routine, things
- 3:57like the day-to-day budget, paying the bills, that kind of
- 3:59thing. And that might seem, I don't
- 4:00know, efficient on the surface, but when you look at what
- 4:02happens during big life changes, you see how incredibly dangerous
- 4:06that setup is for women. It's a setup for acute financial
- 4:09vulnerability. The data is so clear on this 90%
- 4:14of women will be solely responsible for their finances
- 4:17at some point. Usually after a divorce or when
- 4:20they're widowed. Exactly.
- 4:22And they're often totally unprepared.
- 4:24Over 70% of divorced women and widows report these awful
- 4:28financial surprises. Things like hidden debts or
- 4:31finding out the investment accounts are way smaller than
- 4:34they thought. Yeah.
- 4:35And that 70% number is startling.
- 4:37But the actual financial hit is just brutal.
- 4:41We're talking about married women's finances declining by a
- 4:44staggering 41% after a divorce. 21%.
- 4:47That is more than double the 21% decline that men experience.
- 4:51And, you know, that's not just a number that's losing your home,
- 4:54that's not being able to afford healthcare.
- 4:56It's a total loss of security. So the problem isn't that women
- 4:58don't care, it's that the system basically encourages them not to
- 5:02engage until a crisis hits. And by then, they're scrambling
- 5:06to learn from a place of huge disadvantage.
- 5:09Which brings us to how this whole thing gets reinforced
- 5:12today, not just through history, but through education and
- 5:16socialization. OK, let's shift gears to that
- 5:19because it seems like financial education starts out gendered
- 5:22right from childhood. It really does.
- 5:24Survey after survey shows that boys are just way more likely to
- 5:29get financial advice from their parents and they get it earlier.
- 5:32A 2021 survey found something like 10.2 million more adult
- 5:37women than men missed out on those basic financial lessons at
- 5:40home. And the data points to 1 main
- 5:42source for that gap. Fathers.
- 5:45They're three times more likely to talk to their sons about it
- 5:48than their daughters. So we're basically passing down
- 5:51the same old expectation. Men handle the serious money,
- 5:54women handle the spending. Which leads us straight into
- 5:57what the research calls the confidence chasm.
- 5:59Right, This is work. It's really interesting.
- 6:01On financial literacy tests, women consistently score lower
- 6:04than men. But that's not the whole story,
- 6:06is it? Not at all.
- 6:07When you dig into how they answer, the picture completely
- 6:11changes. The lower scores are almost
- 6:13entirely a confidence problem, not a knowledge problem.
- 6:16Because women are way more likely to pick the I don't know,
- 6:19option. Vastly more likely on one
- 6:22question about diversification, 63% of women chose.
- 6:25I don't know that created this huge 20 point gap with men,
- 6:29which you know at first glance looks like a massive knowledge
- 6:32deficit. But then the Federal Reserve did
- 6:33this fantastic experiment. They just took away that I don't
- 6:36know option and forced everyone to guess what happened then.
- 6:40The gap disappeared, that massive 20 point gap and correct
- 6:43answers just, you know, it vanished.
- 6:46It shrank to A1 percentage point difference, which is
- 6:49statistically nothing. Wow, so the knowledge was there
- 6:52all along, it was just hidden behind a reluctance two guests
- 6:56to be wrong. You could almost call it
- 6:58epistemic humility. It's a low risk learned response
- 7:02for women who've been told this isn't their area.
- 7:05Opting out feel safer than being wrong.
- 7:07Which is the total opposite of the male socialist tendency to
- 7:10just take a swing, take a guess, overconfident.
- 7:12Exactly. And that difference, prudence
- 7:15versus overconfidence, is what leads us to the biggest aha
- 7:19moment of this whole deep dive. The performance paradox.
- 7:22The performance paradox Despite lower confidence, despite lower
- 7:26participation, women are statistically better long term
- 7:30investors. OK.
- 7:31The data here is just so compelling.
- 7:32Give us some of the numbers A. Huge Fidelity study looking at
- 7:36millions of accounts found women outperformed men by 0.4%
- 7:42annually now. .4% might not sound like a lot.
- 7:44But over 30 years of investing, that's a massive amount of
- 7:47money. The power of compounding makes
- 7:49that small edge turn into potentially hundreds of
- 7:52thousands of dollars. And there was another study from
- 7:54Warwick Business School that was even more dramatic.
- 7:56It was. It showed women outperformed the
- 7:58Footsie 100 index by 1.94%, while men only beat it by .14%.
- 8:04That's a colossal difference. So what are they doing?
- 8:06What's the secret? It's all about behavior.
- 8:09The outperformance comes from avoiding the cost of
- 8:11overtrading. There's a famous study called
- 8:13Boys Will be Boys. Right, I remember that one.
- 8:16And it showed that men trade 45% more often than women, and
- 8:20single man, the most confident of all, trades 67% more.
- 8:24And all that hyperactivity just kills your returns transaction
- 8:27costs, bad timing, interrupting the magic of compounding.
- 8:31That's the whole thing. The study quantified it.
- 8:34Men's overconfidence and hyperactivity cost them 2.65% in
- 8:38net returns every year. For women it was only 1.72%.
- 8:43So women's patients, their lower turnover, it's perfectly aligned
- 8:47with classic value investing. Just sit still and avoid what
- 8:50Buffett calls unforced errors. Exactly.
- 8:52Prudence just beats bravado. But is there anything deeper
- 8:55going on here, maybe biologically?
- 8:58Well, there's a growing field of neural economics that suggests
- 9:00there is. Research has linked higher
- 9:02levels of testosterone to well over optimism and a bigger
- 9:06appetite for high risk immediate rewards.
- 9:09So the impulse to chase a hot stock or jump into a market
- 9:11bubble might actually have a hormonal component.
- 9:14It seems so. In experiments where traders
- 9:16were given testosterone, they generated much bigger and more
- 9:19pronounced price bubbles. It aligns perfectly with men's
- 9:23tendency to chase momentum regardless of an asset's real
- 9:27value. And you see this playing out
- 9:28right now in the most speculative parts of the market.
- 9:31Oh absolutely. Look at crypto.
- 9:33Men make up 61% of global crypto owners, and during the whole
- 9:38meme stock frenzy, a staggering 86% of those trades were made by
- 9:43men. By staying away from assets with
- 9:45no intrinsic value, women are implicitly following the rules
- 9:49of smart long term investing. It's a powerful conclusion.
- 9:52If you want better long term results, you should be copying
- 9:55the behaviors of the average female investor.
- 9:57OK, but that raises a huge question.
- 9:59If women are better investors, why is the overall wealth gap
- 10:02still so enormous? We have to go back to the
- 10:05structural roadblocks because no amount of investing skill can
- 10:08make up for a fundamental lack of capital.
- 10:10It all starts with the pay gap. The foundational barrier?
- 10:13Women working full time still only make about 83 to $0.85 for
- 10:18every dollar a man earns, and that number has barely moved
- 10:21since 2002. That is such a critical point.
- 10:24It's not a care deficit, it's a capital deficit.
- 10:27It's hard to get excited about investing when you have
- 10:29systematically less money leftover at the end of the
- 10:32month. And that lower income stream
- 10:34directly creates a massive gap in accumulation.
- 10:36Isolated wealth. The wealth gap is just
- 10:39staggering. For every dollar of wealth a man
- 10:41owns in the USA, woman owns just $0.32. $0.32 That's the
- 10:46accumulated cost of decades of lower pay, career interruptions
- 10:50for caregiving. And it all comes to a head in
- 10:52retirement, which for many older women is a full blown crisis.
- 10:56What do those numbers look like? Women have 30 to 32% less income
- 10:59in retirement and they have to make a much smaller nest egg, a
- 11:02median of $50,000 versus 157,000 for men, and last for a longer
- 11:08lifespan. It's a recipe for poverty in old
- 11:10age. Just an incredible amount of
- 11:11pressure. It is, but the sources you sent
- 11:14also point to a huge demographic shift on the horizon that could
- 11:18force the entire industry to change.
- 11:20You're talking about the great wealth transfer.
- 11:22The Great Ralph Transfer, An estimated $30 trillion in
- 11:26financial assets is projected to shift into the hands of American
- 11:30women by about 20-30 to 2045. Mostly through inheritance.
- 11:34Yes, and this isn't just a trend, it's a seismic event.
- 11:38It will force wealth managers, brokerage firms, everyone to
- 11:42finally change their culture and their products to serve what
- 11:46will become their dominant client base.
- 11:48So, given that this problem is so deeply rooted, what are the
- 11:51big recommendations for change? Well, on a policy level, you
- 11:55have to fix the capital deficit first.
- 11:57That means serious legislation to close the pay gap, like the
- 12:00Paycheck Fairness Act, and it means supporting caregivers.
- 12:03Paid family leave, Affordable childcare.
- 12:06Things that prevent those career interruptions that are the
- 12:09primary driver of lower lifetime earnings for women.
- 12:12And what's the take away for individuals if you're a woman
- 12:15listening to this and feeling that confidence?
- 12:17Gap The message from the data is clear.
- 12:19Just get in the game. Commit to participating.
- 12:22You don't have to be a confident guesser, you just have to be an
- 12:24informed participant and build that knowledge on top of the
- 12:27discipline you already have. And for men, the take away is to
- 12:30be an ally to really challenge these biases and make sure
- 12:34financial responsibilities, both the bills and the long term
- 12:37strategy, are truly shared. Absolutely.
- 12:40So we started with this idea of why men seem to care more, and
- 12:45we've ended up with this powerful evidence based
- 12:47conclusion that the gap has nothing to do with caring or
- 12:51ability. It's about systemic barriers.
- 12:53And in fact, the data shows the empirically superior strategy.
- 12:57Patience, prudence, low turnover is the one that's traditionally
- 13:01associated with women. Which leaves us with a really
- 13:03important thought to reflect on. Yes, the future of successful
- 13:07finance really seems to depend on adopting this female model of
- 13:11investing, which values endurance over excitement.
- 13:15So the question for you to think about is this.
- 13:18How might the entire financial world look different if patience
- 13:21and discipline, the very traits that generate superior returns,
- 13:25were celebrated as the ultimate signs of financial
- 13:28sophistication instead of aggressive, hyperactive trading?
- 13:33That is a challenging and an incredibly hopeful thought to
- 13:37end on. We hope this deep dive has given
- 13:39you a much clearer view of this critical topic.
- 13:41And remember the disclaimer, all this analysis is based on
- 13:44publicly available sources and is for educational purposes
- 13:47only. It is not investment advice.
- 13:49Please conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 13:51investment decisions. And if you do want to listen to
- 13:53our full deep dive on this or access more advanced content,
- 13:57you can join our Deep Value Club membership.
- 13:58Or you can subscribe to us on Apple and Spotify Podcasts.
- 14:02The channel is deep value investing.
- 14:04Thanks for joining us for this deep dive.
- 14:05We'll catch you on the next one.