Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Break-Up Blame, Shock Reactions, Abandoning Fathers, and Victim Shaming
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. I thought I would answer some patron emails. This
- 0:04first email is from patron Marie from Seattle. She says, I loved your
- 0:09deep dive on apologies. I wish I had been more aware of how to
- 0:14apologize at the beginning of my relationship because it might have prevented my relationship from
- 0:20becoming toxic. I feel a sense of responsibility in the sense that I could
- 0:26maybe have prevented my partner from becoming abusive toward me. In your deep dive,
- 0:32you said that victims don't need to apologize to their abusers, but I
- 0:37would love to hear more about that. My abuser can't be the only one
- 0:42responsible for the failure of our relationship, right. I wish I could find
- 0:46the extent to which I am to blame, because I don't want to be
- 0:50given a free pass and I'd like to grow from my mistakes. But where
- 0:54is the line. I listen to you a lot for about two years now,
- 0:58and you have helped me to recover end of email. Yeah, so
- 1:03difficult question to answer, obviously, But the landscape in the discourse that you
- 1:07will typically hear is that if you identify as a victim and it's believable,
- 1:14and I'm guessing that it is. Then people around you, including some therapists,
- 1:18I suppose, will refrain from ever contemplating the notion that you might have
- 1:23been quote unquote to blame for some of the relationship dynamics. By the way,
- 1:30when I said to blame, I thought of too blave. I just
- 1:34rewatched Princess Bride, and I also watched the remake that was made during the
- 1:40pandemic where all these famous people recreated various different scenes from Princess Bride. If
- 1:47you've seen it, it's on the internet YouTube. And I just love that
- 1:52movie so so much, and I love the remake. I mean some of
- 1:56it's a little slow anyway, So too blave and to blame? Okay,
- 2:01So there are two dimensions to consider, Marie. One is blame for the
- 2:07abuse, which you're never to blame for, and the other dimension is blame
- 2:13for the breakup. And there will be two These two dimensions are at play.
- 2:17Right, you broke up and there was abuse. When you talk about
- 2:22your circumstance, like I was saying earlier, a lot of people will not
- 2:28talk about you being to blame for the breakup because they really want to avoid
- 2:31blaming you for the abuse, and it's possible that the breakup was entirely due
- 2:38to the abuse. I don't know, but the way you phrase the question
- 2:43is wise, and that you're saying, I wonder if we had a better
- 2:49way of apology. Well, actually, you said you feel like maybe you
- 2:52could have been better at apologizing. So I'm guessing that the abuse that you
- 2:59went through my have oriented your mind towards a more quick to blame yourself orientation.
- 3:06I don't know that, but what I would say is that if the
- 3:09two of you had better ways of managing your attachment and your reactivity and apologizing
- 3:16to each other, there's a better chance that things would have worked out and
- 3:22the abuse would have been mitigated. But that, of course is not your
- 3:24fault, so that's mainly on your partner. But you ask like, well,
- 3:30where's the line between this, because you also ask a wise question.
- 3:36I don't want to You're basically saying, I don't want to just write off
- 3:38the whole thing in the past with this person I was with as being entirely
- 3:44their fault, and I'm not to blame for anything. You're saying that you
- 3:47want to learn from this past relationship, and you need to sift through what
- 3:53happened to determine, like, well, what am I responsible for? Because
- 3:57I don't want those kinds of things to happen again. Even if my next
- 4:00relationship is not abusive, I certainly don't want it to go as poorly as
- 4:03it did. So how do I figure out the difference between abuse and what
- 4:09was just a dynamic that was built up between the two of us that I
- 4:12can work on my side of it? And the answer to that is therapy
- 4:15because it's so complicated, and even therapy wouldn't necessarily be able to figure it
- 4:21out, but it would be much better at exploring it because it's so nuanced.
- 4:26And it depends on the way you frame it. Like if you were
- 4:30to talk with me and I detected that you were framing everything as if it
- 4:35were your fault, I would talk with you about that. Whereas if you
- 4:40were framing it as everything was always the other person's fault, then you know,
- 4:44we talk about that. So it's not just the facts on the ground,
- 4:47because the facts on the ground are completely debatable based on your lens and
- 4:51your narrative. So and also another question you can ask yourself, Marie is.
- 5:00As you're talking about the past and narrativizing it, ask yourself, if
- 5:04you heard a friend of yours that you cared about saying the same thing,
- 5:08what would you say to them? Because often for us, and particularly people
- 5:15who have been abused, they make an exception for themselves, but they don't
- 5:19make that exception for other people. For example, if you were to talk
- 5:25about the past, you're like, well, if only I had apologized better,
- 5:29maybe things wouldn't have gone down the path that it did. And then
- 5:32you imagine that you heard your friends saying that, and you think, oh,
- 5:36no, no, no, no, if you were good at apologizing,
- 5:41friend of mine, that I've externalized myself into my friend, this imaginary
- 5:45friend. You know, if you were better at apologizing that, that might
- 5:49have slowed down the abusive progression of abuse, but it wouldn't have stopped the
- 5:57abuse. I mean, your partner was determined to control you. Your partner
- 6:00had very odd attachment reactivity based on their childhood, and they refused to go
- 6:08to therapy, so it was just a matter of time. Sure, maybe
- 6:11if you apologize better, things would have been a little better, but it
- 6:14wouldn't have stopped the progression of the relationship. If anything, you know the
- 6:19fact that you weren't good at apologizing meant that it accelerated the end of the
- 6:24relationship, which you deserved to have accelerated, because the faster the better to
- 6:29get out of that thing. So you know, I don't know the situation
- 6:31as Another example, one that I often talk about with clients is delineating between
- 6:39the attachment reactivity dynamic versus the rage or abusive control or coercion that your partner
- 6:46exhibited. So let's say that you are remembering an earlier interaction in your relationship
- 6:54before things got bad, and you're recalling that you hurt their feelings, your
- 7:00partner's feelings because you didn't notice their feelings or you were upset about something else,
- 7:08and in that moment it triggered something in your partner that led down a
- 7:15flow chart of emotions for your partner and interactions between the two of you that
- 7:19eventually led to a couple days later where your partner was being say, verbally
- 7:26abusive and calling you names or something. And in so as you analyze that
- 7:32entire story, the end of that or the you know where it got to
- 7:39for your partner, you are not to blame for You're not to blame for
- 7:43your partner converting all of that hurt that they felt into rage and control and
- 7:48abuse to you. That is completely not your fault. You could argue that
- 7:54it is your responsibility and this is something you can learn from in the future
- 7:59relationships. In the very beginning of that interaction, as you were not noticing
- 8:05your partner's feelings, or maybe not attuning to their feelings or not acknowledging them,
- 8:11or being threatened by your partner's feelings or something. You know. That's
- 8:16a more mundane relational dynamic that happens in all relationships, whether it's abusive or
- 8:24not abusive. In that part you can look at, but you're not responsible
- 8:26for your partner converting all that pain into abuse. I hope that's one example
- 8:33that you can look at. Also, notice how I word it. I
- 8:37don't word it like you are to blame for him being hurt. I'm saying
- 8:43you are responsible for noticing or doing your best to notice attachment reactivity and how
- 8:50you communicate and attunement in the same way that your partner was responsible for you
- 8:56in that way. Now you're not responding for your partner being hurt You're not
- 9:01to blame for them being hurt unless it was obviously hurtful. You know,
- 9:05like you just come in the house randomly one day after work and you just
- 9:09start calling your partner names or something. But that usually isn't the case,
- 9:13right, So your partner's hurt is probably mostly due to their attachment injuries earlier
- 9:22in life. A little bit of hurt probably was justified. But the amount
- 9:26of hurt that they felt, and then of course how they converted all that
- 9:31hurt into anger, that that's not your fault, but you know a little
- 9:35bit of it of it is, so that's just But again, you would
- 9:39really have to sift through this with a therapist, all right. This next
- 9:43email is from annual patron Will from Fort Wayne. He says, Hello,
- 9:50my friend Lacy Johnson and I are tremendous fans. We are both finishing our
- 9:54first semester of practicum as a therapist and would really appreciate any incur courage from
- 10:00you. Well, Will and Lacey, congratulations, Welcome to the field.
- 10:07It is a noble profession if I don't say so myself, and I can't
- 10:13imagine the amount of imposter syndrome you're going through right now, because I've never
- 10:20met a non narcissistic Well, I don't know. I'm guessing anyway. Point
- 10:26as I'm guessing your experiencing a lot of imposters job, and I hope that
- 10:30you support each other, and I hope you have a good supervisor who props
- 10:33you up. Okay, you have a question. My question for you is
- 10:37this, what do you do when a client says something shocking in session?
- 10:41What do you do when a client says something shocking in session? Do you
- 10:45conceal your reaction for fear of placing more shame on them? Do you nonverbally
- 10:50express surprise because you want to be congruent? Obviously this is circumstantial, but
- 10:54I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this from multiple perspectives. End of email.
- 11:00Yeah, I love this question because it's a very important question for therapists
- 11:05to consider, and it's very important particularly for novice clinicians. And I cannot
- 11:13summarize my entire view on this because it's so subtle and complicated and also nonverbal.
- 11:20When I talk with novice therapists about this, I have to observe them
- 11:26because we're not great at cataloging our own responses nonverbally to our clients. I,
- 11:35for example, will occasionally videotape myself in session, and I'm shocked at
- 11:41how different I look compared to what I think I am looking like. And
- 11:48so over time I have learned to change how I behave in terms of nonverbals,
- 11:54like my facial expressions, my body posture, my hand movements, this
- 12:01sort of thing, I have changed it to match what I intend. It's
- 12:05weird, right Like even with my reaction videos, I've done this when I
- 12:11first started making react you know nothing. So when I first started the podcast,
- 12:18I had never heard my voice so often, you know, whenever you
- 12:22hear your voice feel Maybe it's different now because there's so much recording going on,
- 12:26But in the past, there was so little recording audio and visual of
- 12:33people that when we all heard ourselves or saw ourselves, were like, is
- 12:37that what I look like? Is that what I sound like? That sounds
- 12:39so weird and my voice sounds so strange, And it would be it would
- 12:43create a cognitive dissonance for people that they wouldn't want to hear their voice recorded
- 12:48because of how foreign it sounded. Because to us, when we hear our
- 12:54voice, we hear not only what everyone else hears, but we also hear
- 12:58the rating of our own skull. You know, when you are talking it,
- 13:05you know propel, you know, the sound wave comes out of your
- 13:07mouth and creates this, you know, series of shock waves that go from
- 13:13my whole face. Actually our whole face radiates sound, our sinuses everything.
- 13:20And that's that sounds a certain way, you know, like when I hear
- 13:24other people on audio recordings, they sound the same to me because the microphone
- 13:30and I are hearing, you know, a very similar thing. But to
- 13:33us, we hear that, and we also hear the rattling of our own
- 13:37skull. You know, I don't know the exact term, but the point
- 13:41is is that I when I first started recording the podcast, and I edit
- 13:48these things pretty closely, I got used to my voice and I started hearing
- 13:54all these annoying quirks in my speaking voice that I a train myself out of
- 14:03because I was so annoyed with myself when I would listen back. And I
- 14:07wasn't annoyed with myself when I was talking, but I was very annoyed when
- 14:11I would listen back. Similarly with video with reaction videos, I started making
- 14:18those in Earnest a few years ago, and I edit those all pretty carefully
- 14:24as well. And when I watched myself, I look at and I was
- 14:26like, what is wrong with my hair? Why did I make that face?
- 14:33What am I doing with my hands? The shirt? That shirt looks
- 14:37like I pulled it out of the gutter. What's wrong with me? But
- 14:41before that point, I was a late forties I don't know, it was
- 14:46probably forty nine when I first started. The pandemic started, Yeah, the
- 14:50pandemic star. I was forty nine and forty nine years You'd think that I
- 14:54would know how I look and how I'm coming across, right, especially as
- 15:01a professor and as a podcaster and a therapist and as a husband. You
- 15:05know, I just think I would have some grasp of how I'm communicating and
- 15:13what I'm doing. But I was astonished at what was happening. You know.
- 15:18Even with my hair for example, I would look at myself in the
- 15:20mirror in the morning and sort of you know, as it's I would come
- 15:24out of the shower and I would just comb it back or something, and
- 15:28I would look at myself in the mirror and I'd go, yeah, it
- 15:31looks great, and I'd go on with my day, but then there's something
- 15:35different seeing it on video, because I think mirrors aren't a great representation of
- 15:43how we are as humans, because I would see this very different hair situation.
- 15:50And then the pandemic happened and I couldn't go to the haircutter, and
- 15:54I was cutting my own hair, which was a disaster, and I couldn't
- 15:58cut the back of my head. So I had this very strange haircut and
- 16:02every six months, Stacy would cut the back of my head and she was
- 16:06very nervous about doing it and she didn't know what she was doing, but
- 16:11it with the pandemic, so I didn't really care. But anyway, the
- 16:12point is is that I would record myself and I would be astonished as how
- 16:18it was coming across. Long story short, One of the main things I
- 16:22learned was that I tended to have very little reactions in my face and body,
- 16:30even though I felt like I was having big, big reactions. So
- 16:34I learned I need to adopt a new pattern of how I react that's more
- 16:41accurate with what I'm trying to convey. So that's one thing to think about,
- 16:45is not only what do you do when a client says something shocking,
- 16:49like you're asking Will and Lacy, but also just know that you have to
- 16:56get to know who you are. I've thought early in my career, I
- 17:00had this realization that being a therapist is kind of like being an actor or
- 17:03a performer. You're not acting, you're not performing right. You have empathy,
- 17:11but you need to convey empathy very clearly to a wide range of humans
- 17:17with different cultural notions of communication and that sort of thing. And so especially
- 17:25for me because growing up in my family, I wasn't really required to be
- 17:32that spokesperson for the family, because you know, I had my parents who
- 17:37are both pretty talkative, my mom in particular and extroverted. My older brother
- 17:42and sister are very social. And then there was me, seven years younger,
- 17:48and I was always in my own world, partially I think because my
- 17:51older brother and sister just took up so much space, you know, verbally
- 17:55and emotionally. Not in a bad way, but I just was fine in
- 18:00my own head, I guess, and I think I neurologically developed this subdued
- 18:08reactivity. And there were reports from my aunts and uncles and other people in
- 18:15my family that would say that when I was young, like three or four
- 18:18years old, I looked like I was just observing everything quietly, and I
- 18:22think it was because I just learned that there wasn't really much point in trying
- 18:30to convey emotion on stuff because there was just a lot of chaos going around,
- 18:34not bad chaos anyway. The point is is that I think that I
- 18:38had a very subdued way of non verbalizing, and so I have to perform
- 18:48how I feel on this side on the inside, which means that I have
- 18:52to act in a way that feels a little foreign to me, and maybe
- 18:53over time I develop a new habit. For example, I'm not sure about
- 18:57this, but in my reaction videos, I was, you know, editing
- 19:02one recently and I noticed that I'm doing a lot of nonverbals in the video
- 19:07and I and I'm thinking, oh boy, it seems a little over the
- 19:11top, but so maybe I'll tone it down a little bit. But I
- 19:17think I started developing that because in my reaction videos, you only see my
- 19:26you know, my shoulders and my head, and so I have to put
- 19:30a lot of emotion into that small space or something. And as I'm trying
- 19:34to explain things, I I think I've adopted a semi gregarious way of swinging
- 19:41my arms around or something I don't know, for better or for worse.
- 19:47And I think it's because of this, of this phenomenon that I learned I
- 19:52needed to amp it up a little bit because I was actually trying to convey
- 19:56that. Also, as a professor, you're constantly trying to keep your students
- 20:02awake because our classes at Antioch are three hours long, and I have to
- 20:07stand in front of sixteen people sometimes at nine pm at night. Some classes
- 20:14were from seven to ten pm, which for some people's way past their bedtime,
- 20:18right, and it's very disheartening to watch students start to nod off.
- 20:25And so I learned I had to be very big with my movements and my
- 20:29communication, which really lent itself to being a podcaster I think. Anyway,
- 20:33getting with your question, though, what do you do when a client says
- 20:37something shocking in session? And what I'll say is that I so there's so
- 20:44many things to say. This is just my take and it's reflective of my
- 20:48style and also what I think therapists should do. But is it empirically what
- 20:53therapists should do. No, you could find another professor or supervisor who has
- 21:02a different style that works for them that would say things differently. So take
- 21:06what I say with that in mind, and for me, I tend especially
- 21:11when a client says something quote unquote shocking. Well, okay, so there's
- 21:15two categories that I'll say of shocking content. One is that a client says
- 21:19something like, so last night, I had sex with three different people,
- 21:26and you'd say, it's the first session and you don't know this client at
- 21:30all, and so for a lot of people, culturally speaking, that would
- 21:34be a very shocking thing to say. Right if you went to brunch with
- 21:38some people at work and you said, last night, I had sex with
- 21:41three people at the same time, that would be culturally shocking. But it's
- 21:45not actually a problem. Now. It could be a problem the client might
- 21:51say after that and I don't want to do that sort of stuff, but
- 21:56it's not baseline a problem that they had sex with three people last night.
- 22:00So I will try to break my superviss my trainees of having that cultural reactivity
- 22:11to clients because you could really shame people. What if they're polyamorous, What
- 22:15if they have three husbands and they say I had sex with three men last
- 22:21night while my kids were sleeping in the other room. You know at a
- 22:26brunch, you're going to get a bunch of gasps, right, But if
- 22:30you gasp as a therapist to that, you could really harm the client and
- 22:34the therapy, and that is not okay, right. You need to clamp
- 22:40down on that and stop that shit. And so it's normal to come into
- 22:45a program, into becoming trained as a therapist, to have those tendencies,
- 22:48but you gotta rein that in because there's so many cultural things that you will
- 22:55hear, especially as clients open up to us, that you cannot just go.
- 23:02It's really harmful. It'll shut a client down. I've heard so many
- 23:06stories from clients and friends of mine that will say that they said something along
- 23:11these lines and the therapist gasped, and you can't put that toothpaste back in
- 23:18the tube. Well, once you gasp, even if as a therapist you
- 23:22do everything you can to make up for it, it's always going to raise
- 23:29a question to the client as to whether or not you can be trusted as
- 23:32a safe person to say things too. So that's one category of shocking.
- 23:36The other category of shocking is say that the client says so, and this
- 23:41is a client that say you know pretty well, and they say, oh
- 23:45my god, last night I had sex with my husband. Okay, and
- 23:52you know that they haven't had sex in two years, and they're really trying
- 23:56to, you know, spark their sexuality the marriage again and the clients,
- 24:03and you've been talking with your client a lot about sex and maybe at a
- 24:07certain point it just seemed like it was off the table that they were just
- 24:11never going to have sex again. And your clients sus down and says,
- 24:15me and my husband we had sex last night. Well, that's another category
- 24:19of shocking that might actually it would harm a client if you didn't react to
- 24:26that. Right. So in those situations, you might be serving the client
- 24:32best if you actually go with your internal shock and convey congruent shocking nonverbals and
- 24:41go oh my god, you know. And if you don't do that,
- 24:45if you're like, hmm, tell me more, then that might actually hurt
- 24:49the client because the client could walk away thinking that you don't care, or
- 24:53that you don't understand the weight of the situation, or that you're not listening
- 25:00or you're not invested or something. So there's various different types of shocking material,
- 25:06and what I find is a lot of trainees will have a really hard
- 25:11time figuring out the difference between culturally shocking and actually shocking, right, Or
- 25:19if a client were to say, oh my god, last night, you
- 25:25know, child Protective Services contacted me and said that I was accused of having
- 25:30abused my students at school, you know, say that they're a teacher.
- 25:34So that's both a culturally shocking thing and an actually shocking thing that a therapist
- 25:41should react to. I think, now, how do you react? Again?
- 25:45That's a style thing. You know, some people will be very reactive
- 25:49and some people will be more subdued. And you know, there are different
- 25:52styles of therapy towards the psychoanalytic classic psychoanalytics side where they really frame from reacting
- 26:02to more humanistic, more genuine gestalty kind of forms of therapy where congruence is
- 26:08very important, right, you know, So it really just runs the gamut.
- 26:14But it's important for therapists to really investigate for themselves when their novices and
- 26:19really throughout their career to figure out where they are in that spectrum and what
- 26:23sort of content is it that feels shocking to them but isn't actually shocking.
- 26:30Like the first example I gave of I had sex with three different men last
- 26:34night. It's not actually shocking. It's different. And if you watch my
- 26:40reaction videos, you might notice that I don't tend to react to things very
- 26:45often, even though they're reaction videos. But I don't tend to go,
- 26:49oh my god. You know, I don't clutch my pearls because I disabused
- 26:55myself of a lot of the notions of cultural shock throughout my career, and
- 26:59I I think I just have always been this way since I was young.
- 27:03The only thing I can point to is that as a half Japanese person who
- 27:08in the seventies would eat raw fish and all the white people around me would
- 27:12clutch their pearls, I would be like, what do you talk raw fish?
- 27:18It's fine, you know now. I know, for all y'all you
- 27:21probably had sushi and love it. But when I was a kid, and
- 27:26really even I'm guessing until ninety five or something, eating sushi was not only
- 27:32just an Asian thing, it was a Japanese thing. I mean, Koreans
- 27:34and Chinese people would make fun of me, although Chinese and Koreans have their
- 27:38own things that Japanese people would react to. But the point is is that.
- 27:44I think that's maybe where it comes from. But I think it's really
- 27:48important to be able to you know, if you decide to be I say
- 27:52this on a number of levels. For trainees, I say the first day
- 27:56of class, I'll tell them there was you before you enter class today,
- 28:00and now you have to adopt a new way of thinking, a new persona
- 28:07a new self. To some extent, in the past, you could have
- 28:11all these notions of shock and bias and hatred towards particular groups of people,
- 28:18whether you call it that or not. You know, before you walked in
- 28:21that door, you can hate Republicans. Now you cannot do that anymore.
- 28:26You can hate their ideals, you can hate the way that they vote,
- 28:30but you can't hate actual Republicans. You can't hate you can't even hate Republican
- 28:36politicians because they will come in your door. I myself, me Kirk,
- 28:41I have treated Republican politicians in my career and know and through those relationships,
- 28:52hour by hour, every week, month by month, year by year,
- 28:56it just realigns the bones in my toward a more open, loving, accepting
- 29:03way. I don't have room in the office just me and that person.
- 29:10It's not going to work if I'm going to continue to hate this group of
- 29:15people or have bias against them. You know, there's good and wonderfulness and
- 29:22love and glory in every human being on this planet. And once you become
- 29:30a therapist, then in my book, that is the way, to quote
- 29:34the Mandalorian, that is the way. And before you were a therapist,
- 29:40you know, you're free to be a regular human. And a part of
- 29:45this is that once you walked in that door to become a therapist, you
- 29:48cannot just free wheel your is that the phrase? You can't just be a
- 29:55free wheeling reactor of life. You can't just be shocked at whatever feels shocking
- 30:00to you. Based on how things feel to you. You have to,
- 30:04you know, investigate those things and be careful with how you react, because
- 30:10you could you could destroy someone with a gasp. All right, let's take
- 30:14a break. All right, we're back from the break. Let's do an
- 30:21opp These people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty one. These
- 30:26are all annual patrons. We have Raquel from Iceland. We have no Buco
- 30:32from Australia. We have Katie from Chicago. We got Leslie from Connecticut.
- 30:38Pu Ye from Hong Kong, Josh from Ontario, Canada, Frenzy from London,
- 30:45Kerrie from may Flower, Arkansas. It looks like we have Kennish from
- 30:51South Carolina, North Charleston. Is that near actual Charleston. It seems like
- 30:56Charleston's a beautiful city. Bronwyn from Michigan Bronwen, So I feel like there's
- 31:03there's a There's been a few Bronwins that I have interacted with, some more
- 31:10than others, and I feel like I just know you as Bronwyn. But
- 31:15do I know which Bronwyn it is? I feel like I should note those
- 31:18things. Emma from Olympia, Good Old Olympia, Washington, capital of Washington
- 31:23State, Lucy from San fran Tarnasa from Santa Clara, Orla from Ireland Dublin,
- 31:30Ireland, Kathleen good Ol'orla Kathleen from Georgia, and Shannon and Juliana from
- 31:37god knows where. Thank you for becoming a patron and staying at patron through
- 31:41thick and thin right sexe to emails from Annual anonymous patron, she says,
- 31:45I am curious about your thoughts on why men abandon their families only to start
- 31:49a family with someone else. Shortly after leaving about three years ago, my
- 31:53ex, the father of my sons, went for a walk one night and
- 31:57never came home again. I have been going through the divorce process for the
- 32:01last three years. He has made the process difficult, expensive, and contentious
- 32:07by filing motions and contempt charges against me. Meanwhile, throughout this ordeal,
- 32:12he has moved in with a woman who lives across the street from our sons
- 32:15and me. He just had a baby with her, his fourth child with
- 32:19his third woman. My sons and I are struggling to make sense of his
- 32:23behavior and why on earth would he start a family with someone who lives across
- 32:27the street from us. Additionally, he hasn't paid consistent support for the past
- 32:30three years, except for my rent end of email. Well, Patron,
- 32:36I am so sorry you're going through this. This is one of the worst
- 32:40things you can go through in life as a human being. You are a
- 32:45parent, you love your kids, your boys. You also were in love
- 32:51with your ex in the past, and to have your ex just walk out
- 32:59the door or abandon you, which hurts, obviously and is obviously also very
- 33:04inconvenient, you know, financially right and destructive but you know the prime directive
- 33:12of a parent is to take care of your children, and to have your
- 33:16children suffer because of what he is doing. You know, It's one thing
- 33:22for a deadbeat dad as they call them, to only show up once a
- 33:29month or every other month or something like that. It's another thing for them
- 33:32to just completely disappear and to be so callous as to move in right across
- 33:38the street where your boys can maybe see him coming and going. I mean,
- 33:45the trauma that your children are going through is just tremendous, and so
- 33:52I'm really sorry for that and all the stress that you're going through with him,
- 33:57you know, filing different legal against you. Yeah. It. I've
- 34:04been with people as they go through this. It's just a constant, you
- 34:09know, set of thorns in your side, right, It's a constant stress,
- 34:15a constant cloud hanging over you. And you're just trying to do good
- 34:20bye your boys. You're trying to move on with your life. And yeah,
- 34:25it's it's the worst. But your question is as to why some now
- 34:30you frame it as men, And of course statistically it is more men that
- 34:35do this, but women do this too, for sure. And I've had
- 34:38people in my personal life and clients who have had mothers that would just disappear
- 34:44like this. So it's people that do this. Again, many more men
- 34:49do it. But you ask, you know, why do parents do this?
- 34:52And it's there's a lot of different possible reasons. I mean, one
- 34:55we could just throw out the psychopathy angle and just say that the individual just
- 34:59does and have empathy, but that's not usually the case. My top hypothesis,
- 35:06given what you are saying without more information, of course, is you
- 35:10know, the first thing that I would investigate is that the parent who did
- 35:15the abandoning had their own massive attachment injuries when they were young, whether they
- 35:20talked about it or even knew about it consciously or not, and they're just
- 35:23recreating it. It happens all the time. There are people that are very
- 35:29hurt by parents that abandon them and abuse them when they were young, and
- 35:34then they grow up to repeat the same thing, even though they vowed they
- 35:37never would do that to anybody. So that would be the first candidate,
- 35:44and in all likelihood what happened I don't know, but the typical scenario is
- 35:50that he entered their relationship genuinely wanting to be a good husband and father,
- 35:58but given his trauma, as he was prone to being overly hurt, exaggeratedly
- 36:05hurt, but also would avoid those feelings and maybe even go into denial of
- 36:13them, turn to escapism, avoidance, maybe even drug abuse and running away.
- 36:22So you know, that's a very common story. I'm not saying you're
- 36:27supposed to have sympathy for the asshole, but I'm just saying that that's a
- 36:30possible reason as to why it would happen. Another reason worth mentioning as a
- 36:37possibility is sexism. That for many men, they are programmed to believe that
- 36:45parenting and housework and that sort of stuff is not their responsibility, and their
- 36:52slave wives are supposed to be doing all that for them, and they might
- 36:55have had that model to them, so they well, I mean, you
- 37:00know, who cares, you know, because parenting is what's so weird about
- 37:05it. Of course, you know, this patron is that how as a
- 37:08parent could you just run away from your kids? The compulsion to love and
- 37:14to be there for your children is so strong, how could someone you,
- 37:20patron, There's probably not enough money in the world that someone could pay you
- 37:24to abandon your children willingly like that, right, So it's bizarre. There's
- 37:30got to be something going on there, right, And I've treated men like
- 37:35this who deep down they are deeply ashamed and they deeply miss their children,
- 37:42but they to a much larger extent, are terrified of emotion and of vulnerability
- 37:51and of being attached and being hurt by their partner. So they would rather
- 37:57forego that need of connect to their children then face what they believe to be
- 38:05an insurmountable mountain of pain and vulnerability and emotion. And so when I work
- 38:13with them and I show them it's really the opposite, that the love in
- 38:16their heart is so big and so pronounced and their fears of vulnerability are overblown,
- 38:24then you know, things can often realign themselves, all right. A
- 38:28sex email deals with sexual assaults, not in detail, but the topic.
- 38:34So if you want to skip over that due to it being triggering to you
- 38:38regarding your traumas and distress, skip forward fifteen minutes or so. Anonymous YouTube
- 38:45member wrote in. She said, Hi, Kirk, can you talk about
- 38:47why it's a common reaction for rape and sexual abuse victims to feel guilty and
- 38:52responsible for what happened to them. I wasn't raped, but I experienced a
- 38:59sexual partner viceiling my boundaries, and then he blamed it on me. I
- 39:04felt overwhelming shame and guilt and had to sleep with the covers between my legs
- 39:07and a silly attempt to protect myself. It would be very interesting for me
- 39:13if you should alight on why victims react this way. End of email.
- 39:16Okay, So, let's sift through this email that you're saying, anonymous YouTube
- 39:21member. You say, I wasn't raped, but I experienced a sexual partner
- 39:25violating my boundaries and then he blamed me. So I don't know what that.
- 39:30I don't need to know exactly what that means. But if I were
- 39:35to answer this question in a way that was in the direction of what you're
- 39:39dealing with, I would have to know at least the I would need to
- 39:45know more information because from the way you word it, it sounds very much
- 39:50like somebody did something to you that was obviously something you didn't want to have
- 39:57happen, either delicitly or implicitly, and then you communicated that it harmed you
- 40:06or you didn't like it, and then your partner blamed you for it in
- 40:09a very unfair way, and that sounds really awful. I'm sorry that happened
- 40:15to you. That can be very damaging and traumatic. Even so, there's
- 40:21that possibility. But there's another possibility, based on the way you worded it,
- 40:23that it was some sort of boundary violation and you experienced some level of
- 40:30distress and then the communication between you and your partner didn't go that well and
- 40:37he blamed you for it. But if we had all the details, we
- 40:42would see it more as a nuanced situation. That doesn't really change my response
- 40:47that much now that I say it out loud, But the way you worded
- 40:51it, it sounds more like the former where there was an obvious boundary violation
- 40:57and he didn't care or to think about that sort of thing, or has
- 41:01been indoctrinated in a certain way and forged ahead, and then afterwards, because
- 41:08of his programming, he listens to a lot Andrew tate or he's just a
- 41:14jerk face. He blames you for something that was completely not your fault.
- 41:17Obviously, Yet that's what it sounds like to me. And then you say
- 41:22you felt overwhelming shame and guilt and you're wondering why that is. Well.
- 41:27I find that a lot of people today will ask me these sorts of questions
- 41:30because they intellectually know better, you know, they're surprised. They from an
- 41:37early age, they might have absolutely known that it's not the victim's fault and
- 41:42that victim blaming is bad, and yet after an incident like this, they
- 41:46will blame themselves and they'll think, how is this happening? I knew that,
- 41:52SOW, what's going on here? How come I have all these intrusive
- 41:57thoughts. And it's one thing to intellectually understand something, it's another thing to
- 42:02be that thing. You know. You can know, for example, that
- 42:07you are worth You're a worthwhile human being, and that you deserve love and
- 42:13that you deserve to feel good about yourself, but at the same time have
- 42:16a lot of intrusive thoughts that are saying otherwise. Right. So, I
- 42:21don't know if that's what you're dealing with, but the way you worded it
- 42:24kind of sounds like maybe you're in that camp. And it's great that you
- 42:29have that intellectual foundation to be able to combat this, but it's not strange
- 42:37to me that you have this overwhelming emotion and overwhelming shame. Because we are
- 42:44not even close to being out of the woods yet as a society. When
- 42:47it comes to sexism and victim blaming and sex shaming. We have a very
- 42:57robust culture of sex shame and X negativity and victim blaming and emotion blaming.
- 43:02I guess we can add that as well. That is in our bones,
- 43:07and when we go through things like this, then all those intrusive voices,
- 43:12all those internalized voices, become intrusive thoughts, and it produces a lot of
- 43:19distress that can't be eliminated by an intellectual understanding otherwise. So I'm really sorry
- 43:27you went through that. And you know this other sentence you say, I
- 43:31feel overwhelming shame and guilt and had to sleep with the covers between my legs
- 43:36and a silly attempt to protect myself. That word silly is an internalized voice
- 43:42of some of some sort. No one resorts to that kind of behavior for
- 43:47silly reasons. You did that because your body and mind and soul needed to
- 43:52do that, and probably much more than that. But you didn't feel okay
- 43:58or safe or worthy to be able to truly get yourself to a safe situation.
- 44:05And that's one thing I just want to really emphasize is that if you
- 44:07ever, for any reason, all y'all out there. If you don't feel
- 44:12safe, you deserve to feel safe. You don't necessarily deserve to bother everyone
- 44:20around you in this situation with this member, obviously she can bother her partner
- 44:25for example, like get out of my house, or I love you,
- 44:29you know, I don't know if they're you know, it says sexual partners,
- 44:31so I don't know if they're in a relationship. But I can't sleep
- 44:37with you in this room anymore because I am in a lot of distress because
- 44:42of what happened. And blah blah blah or whatever. You know you deserve
- 44:45to. But say you walk into a grocery store and you're having a panic
- 44:51attack because of traumas that you've been through in your childhood. You don't have
- 44:57the human right to be able to shut the end tire a grocery store down
- 45:00and make everyone get out right. But you do have the right to do
- 45:07what you can to be safe. And it's such a huge oppressive notion in
- 45:15our society that if you don't feel safe, then that's on you and you're
- 45:20a cry baby, you know. A classic example of claustrophobia is sitting in
- 45:27the middle seat of an airplane or sitting in a middle seat in a row
- 45:31in the movie theater or at a play or something. And not everyone with
- 45:37laustrophobia experiences this, but they often do, and so they want to sit
- 45:43in the aisle seat. And so many people that suffer from this. Because
- 45:46I used to suffer from it, I don't anymore. I could easily slip
- 45:51back into that if I don't watch my p's and q's regarding my habituation and
- 45:59my internal cognitive therapy that I do to myself. But a lot of people
- 46:05with this will have this problem, and it's completely legit, but because of
- 46:10our society, if you were to say, hey, you know, say,
- 46:15for example, you are going on an airplane trip. That's a funny
- 46:20phrase, airplane trip, and for whatever reason, as you're getting on the
- 46:23plane, they say, oh my god, we're so sorry, we had
- 46:27to switch your seat to a middle seat, and so suddenly you're sitting in
- 46:30the middle And so many people in that situation will do anything other than ask
- 46:39for help with that. They will sit in the middle seat and just cry
- 46:45themselves the whole way on the airplane trip, or they'll just cancel the flight
- 46:50or something, Whereas what they deserve to be able to assert or ask for
- 46:55is to say, hey, I have a condition that makes it so that
- 47:00I freak out when I sit in the middle seat. I'm sorry that I
- 47:02have this condition. I'm working on it, but it'll completely give me a
- 47:07lot of emotional distress if I'm in that middle street. So is there a
- 47:10possibility that you can switch me to an aisle seat because I need that aisle
- 47:15seat, Or once you get to the row, you talk to the person
- 47:20in the aisle seat and you say, I'm so sorry. I have this
- 47:22thing called claustrophobia and if I sit in the middle seat, I know it's
- 47:25weird, but if I sit in the middle seat, I will freak out
- 47:29and I'm so sorry. Could do you mind if we switch and you sit
- 47:31in the middle I swear to God, if you've got to go to the
- 47:35bathroom, I will pop up and I'll be your best friend. Can I
- 47:38sit in the aisle? You absolutely have the right to ask for those things
- 47:43because you deserve to be safe. You deserve to take actions to be safe.
- 47:47So if you're sitting there at night with your covers between your legs,
- 47:52because you're attempting to protect yourself, because you don't know what else to do.
- 47:58That is not silly. That is your human right, my friend,
- 48:01You have the right to be able to do it you can do to make
- 48:07yourself feel safe. You did not feel safe. You did not feel safe
- 48:10for a very very good reason, even though ninety percent of our society would
- 48:15think you were being silly. But we all understand that society is not smart.
- 48:21The rest of our society is not a good guide for what is wise.
- 48:24Right, So fock society and tell yourself that you deserve to be safe.
- 48:30All right, said a break? All right, back from the break,
- 48:36Let's do another opp These people started as patrons in twenty twenty one.
- 48:42We have Louise and Shaw, who are annual deserving listeners from god E,
- 48:46Nos Where we have the following annual upper tier or middle tier patrons. We
- 48:52have m from Ozone Park, New York. Ozone Park, New York.
- 48:57That sounds like something from sci Fi. We have Kim from Scottsdale, Arizona.
- 49:01Kim is that the Kim? We have Tiki from Seattle. I know
- 49:07where that is. Maria from Spokane, your militarier patron annual Maria from Spokane,
- 49:14which is where my family's from and we have Heidi from god knows where,
- 49:16and the following are monthly just regular patrons. We have Patricia from Poland,
- 49:22Shamanna from Pennsylvania, Ivy from Arkansas, Geees from Berlin, Germany,
- 49:30Amy from Boulder, Colorado, where Mark from work was from. I used
- 49:35to love that show when I was a good Luisa from Brentwood, Great Britain,
- 49:38Amy from Brentwood, California. That's funny. And Sarah from Buffalo,
- 49:44New York. Thank you for being a patron, staying a patron through thick
- 49:46and thin, all right. The sext emails from anonymous patron, She says,
- 49:51after over a decade of chronic illness as a young person, I've found
- 49:57myself extremely alone. I have severe insomnia that is very resistant to treatment with
- 50:04typical approaches focused on anxiety like CBT or ACT or mindfulness or relaxation training.
- 50:12It feels like my body just can't sleep because the level of social isolation is
- 50:16making my body feel too afraid and alone to let my guard down enough to
- 50:22sleep. For my research, it seems there are some studies finding correlations between
- 50:27loneliness and sleep issues, but not any But not yet any research on the
- 50:32directionality of that association or treatment for these issues. I'm wondering if I'm missing
- 50:38something end of email. Okay, yeah, so absolutely, And it doesn't
- 50:45take a genius to draw those connections that, especially with the way you phrase
- 50:51it right that you understand. I don't need to repeat this, but I'll
- 50:55say the topic sentence that we are social creatures, possibly one of the most
- 51:01social creatures on the planet. We biologically are designed to orient ourselves towards other
- 51:09human beings such that we need them in the same way that we need to
- 51:14have water and fiber and calories and sunlight and safety. We need other human
- 51:23beings. We need relationships, maybe even to the point where we need their
- 51:28physical warmth. We need to be near them. We need to cuddle and
- 51:32touch and feel that safety and that intimacy. So to be isolated is going
- 51:44to cause a lot of problems, not just with sleep, but all sorts
- 51:46of problems have been measured, and all those other problems that we've measured,
- 51:52like distress and depression and anxiety absolutely can affect sleep and make it difficult to
- 52:00fall asleep. You say that you suffer from social isolation, and it makes
- 52:06your body feel too afraid and too alone to let your guard down enough to
- 52:09sleep. You're in a constant state of fear because you're alone, which makes
- 52:13total sense, and you don't have to look far in the research to find
- 52:17that the problem is is that our society is so backward that not only do
- 52:23they ignore loneliness, but they also ignore sleep issues. You look online when
- 52:30you have a sleep problem, or you go to a therapist or a physician,
- 52:34the kind of advice you get, and it's not bad advice, but
- 52:37it's not universally effective. The road to insomnia. The roads to insomnia are
- 52:46in the billions. There's so many possibilities as to why someone would suffer from
- 52:52insomnia, and you're not going to get a lot of good information out there,
- 52:57right, they're going to route you towards or mindfulness or relaxation or now
- 53:04when you say it, the way you do those things are those would be
- 53:09the things I would recommend. So the fact that they haven't worked, well,
- 53:15you see you haven't really said you tried them. You have severe insomnia
- 53:19that is very resistant to treatment. Okay, well, what sort of treatment
- 53:23have you done? Have you done it with actual clinicians that know what they're
- 53:28doing or have you not. But even with that, because if even if
- 53:32you got rid of a bit of the anxiety, it wouldn't take away the
- 53:37loneliness that is fueling the anxiety, right And even if you didn't have anxiety,
- 53:42you would still feel the loneliness and the distress of that, right.
- 53:45So, and there's no amount of cognitive therapy that can take away the fact
- 53:52that you are lonely. Right, we can't sit there and say, well,
- 53:57you just have to have a lot of positive thoughts and say that everything's
- 54:01okay. It's sort of like if your house is burning down and you're having
- 54:06trouble sleeping. You can't in your mind say well, everything's going to be
- 54:10fine, because everything isn't fine. Your house is burning down, Everything isn't
- 54:15fine. You're lonely. So there's not much you can do to counteract the
- 54:21reality of that. So yeah, I and this is a general rant for
- 54:31everyone out there that suffers from sleep problems. I've worked a lot of clients
- 54:37on it. I've had my own problems with sleep over the years, And
- 54:43what I'll say is to keep working on it and don't give up and don't
- 54:47accept these simplistic explanations and treatment modalities. If they don't work, you know,
- 54:54give it a try. Relaxation can absolutely help. There's my heinfulness.
- 55:00But what I do with clients in this area is, and I do this
- 55:05for myself, is what are you thinking about? What are the patterns of
- 55:09thinking that you have throughout the day, but also when your head hits the
- 55:13pillow, because if your pattern of thinking engages certain aspects of your mind,
- 55:20it will make it very difficult to fall asleep. Whereas if you allow those
- 55:23areas of your mind to relax a little bit, you know, like for
- 55:29me right now, Stacy and I were taking these pottery classes, and last
- 55:34night I found that if I thought about the next pottery project I wanted to
- 55:40work on, I fell asleep very quickly, Whereas if I thought about other
- 55:45things, it would kind of keep my mind a buzz such that I wouldn't
- 55:47fall asleep. And I noticed last night that I did it several times,
- 55:52because you know, I'd wake up and then I would start thinking about something,
- 55:57and then I'd okay, go back to my pottery thing, and then
- 56:00I would fall asleep. I almost immediate. I could feel myself as I'm
- 56:04thinking about pottery fall. And then the morning I woke up and I thought,
- 56:07you know, I thought about pottery like three or four times last night,
- 56:12but I think I only got to like step two in the in the
- 56:15project before my mind fell asleep. Now, I'm not saying that thinking about
- 56:20pottery is gonna cure your insomnia, but there's just a lot of different angles
- 56:24to it, and it can be complicated, and just saying to yourself that
- 56:30you're not going to think about distressing things is easier said than done for a
- 56:36lot of people, right, so it could be quite comprehensive in terms of
- 56:38the amount of things that you're tackling. So anyway, my point is is
- 56:43that for everyone out there who have sleep problems is to value yourself. You
- 56:49deserve to sleep. You deserve to have people value how important it is to
- 56:54sleep. You deserve to have someone there or everyone to reflect to you just
- 57:00how horrible it is to not be able to sleep. I feel like we
- 57:06have I don't know if it's derived from when we're younger and we can get
- 57:09by unless sleep at times, but I think that's a myth as well in
- 57:15my society and mainstream American society. I just feel like sleep is this thing
- 57:20that's seen as weak, you know, Like there are times when I really
- 57:25want to sleep in in the morning because I just really want to be able
- 57:30to sleep. And I have found that some people react to that as if
- 57:35I'm being lazy or something, and I'm just like, am I a lazy
- 57:38person? Do I look lazy to you? I'm not. People don't usually
- 57:43think of me as lazy, right, And yet I love to sleep and
- 57:46value it greatly and need it right and consider it to be a very nourishing
- 57:52thing. And I've even organized my life right now such that I don't have
- 57:57an alarm anymore. I don't schedule anything for the morning because I want to
- 58:01be able to wake up when I wake up, and that has really improved
- 58:05my life to now. When I do have an appointment, like our pottery
- 58:09class, which is in the morning, I have to set my alarm,
- 58:14which can kind of screw me up for the day. Not always, But
- 58:16the point is that you deserve to sleep. You deserve to have people value
- 58:23your sleep. You deserve to have people say, oh my god, like
- 58:27you're not sleeping, well, how are you managing? That's so horrible?
- 58:30Because it is it's horrible. It's a you could argue it's more important than
- 58:35eating, Like you can go without eating for a while. I don't recommend
- 58:39it, but from what I understand, you can go without eating for a
- 58:43while. You can't go without sleeping for a while. You'll start to lose
- 58:46your mind. You'll start to hallucinate, you won't be able to think straight,
- 58:50you won't be able to do anything, you won't even be able to
- 58:52get food right. You'll your entire process will shut down, and you'll be
- 58:58dead in no time, right as freak people out. But sleep is very,
- 59:02very very important, and not only just sleep, but good sleep,
- 59:07because if you take medications to sleep, sometimes yeah you'll be unconscious, but
- 59:12you won't actually be going into the necessary rhythms of sleep that actually nourish the
- 59:20mind and the body. So uh, you know, when I when I
- 59:24hear when I read your email, it just gets me upset that what I
- 59:30think is happening to you is you're running into the very typical well maybe there's
- 59:35three levels to it. They're often the first dumb layer in people's responses or
- 59:40the way the internet will react, will give very trite advice, like you
- 59:45know, make sure your room is quiet. It's like, well, no,
- 59:46duh, but some people need to be told that, right, you
- 59:51know, very simplistic sleep hygiene kind of things. And then the next layer,
- 59:57if you're lucky, someone will start recommending more in depth treatment to things
- 1:00:00like CBT and mindfulness and stuff. But even that, it's like hard to
- 1:00:05know if they know what they're doing. And that's great, but it's not
- 1:00:08the end of the deal. The next layer where I'm at in my life
- 1:00:13is and when people come to me, is I sit down, I say,
- 1:00:16well, first off, let me just validate your feelings, because it's
- 1:00:21horrible to have these kinds of issues. And also, I'm here to tell
- 1:00:25you that we'll start with these easy things, but we might find ourselves going
- 1:00:34down hundreds of different roads to figure out if something's going to work for you.
- 1:00:38There's so many things that can get in the way. And when I
- 1:00:43talk to people about it, they all have their own solution because that's what
- 1:00:46works for them, and they think that that works for everybody. But in
- 1:00:50my experience, any particular solution is not likely to work for the next person
- 1:00:55because everyone's road to insomnia or sleep deprivation is different or is at least potentially
- 1:01:04different, and everyone's road to recovery is also potentially different. So I just
- 1:01:09feel bad for you. But the thing to do is to just keep working
- 1:01:15on it. Is what I want to tell everyone is, don't give up.
- 1:01:19And if one physician or one therapist, or one website or one treatment
- 1:01:24thing that you're trying isn't working, don't stop there. Just keep going down
- 1:01:30all the roads, keep asking more physicians, more second opinions, reading research,
- 1:01:37experimenting with different things for yourself, because there might be a set of
- 1:01:43solutions out there that are not typical to people, and thus you need to
- 1:01:49uncover a lot of rocks before you get there. All right, Well that
- 1:01:52does it for that episode in which I read Patreon emails. If you want
- 1:01:58to submit an email, you want to go to the website and fill out
- 1:02:00the form there. And remember that's the vast majority of emails I never get
- 1:02:07to. So I deeply, deeply apologize for that. I am actually contemplating.
- 1:02:15I don't know if you heard the episode where I talked about AI,
- 1:02:19and it's possible that I might be able to you know, sometimes people will
- 1:02:22ask, you, know, Kirk, what what would if you could clone
- 1:02:27yourself. What would you have your clone? Do you know, like,
- 1:02:30what would you wish you could get done if you had a clone? And
- 1:02:35one of the clones that I would love to give them a full time job
- 1:02:39is to respond to all the emails because I feel guilty when I don't,
- 1:02:46and I also really just love reading all the emails. So I one of
- 1:02:52the ways of getting a clone is maybe to have an AI version of me,
- 1:02:57which sounds like ridiculous and un ethic, pot possibly, and of course
- 1:03:00I'm going to consider all those angles, but I am tempted. If it
- 1:03:05works right and it is ethical and it is something that is accurate, I
- 1:03:09think, you know, it could be something that would make it so I
- 1:03:15could sleep better at night. Speaking of and everyone out there, please take
- 1:03:19care of yourself because you deserve it, You really really do.