Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / # 23 Total Depravity, Human Nature & Mental Health – How Does It All Fit Together? with Nathan Vella.
Transcript
- 0:14Manifesto. For too long, our culture has embraced and believed the lies of feminism,
- 0:19distorting God's design for women and leaving us burdened and unsatisfied.
- 0:24This podcast exists to confront the lies shaping our culture and boldly proclaim the truth of the gospel.
- 0:30True freedom is only found in Christ. So join us as we bring the truth of the
- 0:34gospel to light in our culture.
- 0:38Welcome back to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Today, we are getting into a
- 0:42topic that underpins a lot of problems that we are facing as a culture.
- 0:46From Islam to gentle parenting to the mental health crisis going on,
- 0:50each of these issues have a central problem in which they reject,
- 0:53and that is the depravity of human nature.
- 0:55Once this has rejected, major consequences follow.
- 0:59This year alone, we've seen the justification of the murder of three children
- 1:03under the guise of mental health, rejecting any notion of personal responsibility
- 1:07and the depravity of human nature.
- 1:09Also this year, our government has released a website supposedly seeking to
- 1:13combat child sexual attraction and the causes of it, referencing in one section
- 1:17how people struggling with this may be experiencing a form of obsessive compulsive disorder.
- 1:22The underlying premise these issues are rejecting is that man's nature is depraved
- 1:27and therefore these issues we are seeing in our culture are a result of something
- 1:31external happening to someone and not from within them.
- 1:34As we've seen, rejecting this has real consequences and it is incredibly important
- 1:38to get our theology right here.
- 1:40Theology matters. And so to help us unpack this deep theological truth,
- 1:43I've asked pastor and good friend of mine, Nathan Vela, to come on the podcast and chat about this.
- 1:48As a bit of an intro, I met Nathan 10 years ago at the church we were attending in Sydney.
- 1:53Nathan was the youth pastor there and would preach every so often.
- 1:56My husband likes to refer to him as the Australian Paul Washer,
- 2:00if you're familiar with his preaching.
- 2:02But Nathan's love for the Lord and his desire to preach the truth of God's word
- 2:06is so incredibly humbling, you cannot leave unaffected.
- 2:09My husband and I have both been immensely blessed by his ministry,
- 2:12and it was actually through one of his sermons on the holiness of God that I
- 2:16was saved out of my apathetic false conversion that I was in for seven years,
- 2:20and truly came to understand the gospel for the first time.
- 2:23Nathan is married to a beautiful wife who I'm privileged to call one of my closest
- 2:27friends. They've got five beautiful children and he pastors a church in the
- 2:31very dark state of Victoria.
- 2:33So, welcome to the podcast, Nathan. Thanks for joining me.
- 2:36Thanks for having me, Hedl. What an introduction. Can you tell us a bit more
- 2:40about yourself, your life, and how you came to the Lord?
- 2:43Yeah, well, yeah, firstly, I'm a Christian. God graciously and dramatically saved me about...
- 2:5117 years ago when I was 20, I was born into a Christian family,
- 2:56born and raised in a Pentecostal church. But it wasn't until I was about 20
- 3:00when I first heard the gospel. It was raw.
- 3:04It was intense. It was undiluted. And it really pierced my heart.
- 3:08I was halfway through it. I was devastated, crushed.
- 3:12I had to stop halfway through it. I was listening to the sermon in the car because
- 3:16I'd arrived at my girlfriend's house at the time.
- 3:18And anyway, we were to hang out that night, maybe watch a couple of movies or something.
- 3:23And I just knew I needed to get out of the house and back into the car to hear
- 3:28the rest of the sermon because I was shaken to the core.
- 3:31And it was in the second half of the sermon where the preacher shared the gospel
- 3:36and that flood of good news came into my heart.
- 3:39And it was amazing how you could have both of those feelings in the one evening
- 3:44of utter terror and shock, devastation hitting, tremendous fear.
- 3:49And then, you know, just this sweeping
- 3:52peace and assurance through the one sermon. So I praise God for that.
- 3:56So it was about 17 years ago when I was 20.
- 4:00Yeah. Secondly, I'm a husband, as you mentioned, married to Brooke.
- 4:04We've had seven kids and I say that we lost two very early in the womb,
- 4:11but we have a great confidence that we're going to see him again one day in heaven.
- 4:15But at the moment, we have five with us ranging from 11 to 2 and they are just super special.
- 4:23Love being a dad, best job in the world. They keep me on my toes.
- 4:26They've all got immense personalities.
- 4:30But, yeah, also tremendously privileged that we have the opportunity to homeschool.
- 4:34So my wife leads in that. She does a tremendous job. I'm so thankful for that.
- 4:39Brooke and I have been married nearly 13 years now.
- 4:42And, you know, to be married to your best friend is a pretty special thing.
- 4:48To be married to a Christian, sharing the same convictions, and we're really
- 4:53able to help each other in the race that we're in to heaven.
- 4:58And I guess just last year, as you mentioned, I'm a pastor here at the Druin
- 5:03Baptist Church in Victoria.
- 5:05Myself, Brooke, all our family, we were an extended family all from Sydney where
- 5:10we met you and your husband.
- 5:12But it wasn't until just over four years ago we kind of sensed there was a need out here.
- 5:17And it was a church that wanted to have the scriptures taught to them,
- 5:22wanted to be loved and cared for. And so we took up the call,
- 5:27left all our family behind here in Sydney and moved to Vic.
- 5:31And, you know, I can't just say there's such a special congregation here.
- 5:36They're so dear to us. We love them.
- 5:39And it's such a privilege to be on this journey with them.
- 5:43So they're just a great, great fellowship here. Yeah, that's great.
- 5:46That's great to hear from a pastor's perspective that you're enjoying your job
- 5:50and that you love your congregation because that's what you want.
- 5:55Yeah, hopefully it's mutual.
- 5:56They're amazing. Yeah. So I wanted to have a chat about this issue,
- 5:59as I've alluded to earlier, just because of the immense issues that we're seeing
- 6:04in our culture. And what I'm seeing is that they seem to have this common theme.
- 6:09But the topic of total depravity, it can come with a lot of baggage and it sounds
- 6:14a bit harsh and maybe unnecessary to talk about in such blatant terms.
- 6:20So why do you see it as an important topic for us to get the meaning of this
- 6:24right? Yeah, I think even just you mentioning that it does sound a bit harsh.
- 6:31I think it's important that the title for this doctrine is as confronting as it is, total depravity.
- 6:36I think serious matters need to be called for what they are,
- 6:40right? Abortion isn't women's health care. And adultery is not an affair.
- 6:46And sin is not a mistake. And total depravity, sometimes it's called,
- 6:52some people know it as radical depravity or total inability.
- 6:57It's a necessarily serious phrase because it's a serious condition.
- 7:01So I think that's what it is from a title perspective, getting that.
- 7:06But it's interesting, I think it's important to, when John the Baptist arrives
- 7:11on the scene as the messenger who's heralding, hey, the King is here,
- 7:15the Messiah is here, his very first words in his message is,
- 7:19repent for the kingdom is here.
- 7:21And then when the Messiah himself, the King comes, his first message everywhere
- 7:25he went is, repent for the kingdom of heaven is here.
- 7:29So the message wasn't first come, or here's what I have to offer,
- 7:33or don't be afraid, it was repent.
- 7:35And so I think getting a right and clear understanding of who God is and a right
- 7:40and clear understanding of who we are is of first importance,
- 7:44right? Get God wrong and everything goes wrong. Get us wrong.
- 7:48And then all the other doctrines that we come to love in the scriptures about
- 7:52adoption and about sanctification, you get everything wrong.
- 7:57So, this is of first importance. Yeah. Yeah, for sure. Can you take us through
- 8:02what is total depravity?
- 8:04What is the biblical reasoning for this?
- 8:07Are we really that bad? Does sin kick in at some stage of maturity or understanding
- 8:12and then we become totally depraved?
- 8:14Or where does it start? Yeah, okay.
- 8:17Well, even just recognizing that the title and the phrase total depravity can be misleading.
- 8:25And so it's always helpful to clarify that the doctrine of total depravity doesn't
- 8:30mean we are each as depraved as we could possibly be.
- 8:34Even Saddam Hussein was not as evil as he could be. Think of the worst people.
- 8:40It's trying to get at really that every part of us has been affected by sin.
- 8:46From the top of our head to the sole of our feet, we are corrupted.
- 8:50From the inner workings of our heart to the totality of our mind.
- 8:54Every aspect has been touched and affected by sin and ruined by sin.
- 9:00And so, really, it's referring to the spiritual condition of every single person born into this world.
- 9:06It reveals, and in one sense, it reveals that we're not morally free as we think
- 9:10we are, and we're not as neutral as we think we are.
- 9:14One of those in church history who was deemed a heretic, Pelagius,
- 9:19He argued the case in trying to present that human beings are born as a blank canvas.
- 9:25Not morally good, morally bad, but we are just, we're blank and we're neutral.
- 9:31And so, it's helpful to kind of clarify that.
- 9:35And then maybe even just a few, singing through a couple of scriptures on this.
- 9:40Jeremiah 17 says, the heart is deceitful above all things and desperately sick.
- 9:47Who can understand it? And so we normally think, okay, who's the most deceitful
- 9:50person? We probably think Satan and demons or maybe corrupt politicians.
- 9:56But it says that the human heart is deceitful above all things.
- 10:03And when the Bible talks about heart, it's not talking about the fleshly organ
- 10:08within us in the center of our chest.
- 10:10It's talking about who we are on the inside and the control center that affects
- 10:14the mind, the will, the emotions, the desires, and the actions.
- 10:19And so, the very core of who Heather is and who Nathan is born into this world
- 10:25is deceitful above all things.
- 10:28That's deeply problematic because we love to talk about people or children as,
- 10:34you know, deep down having a good heart.
- 10:36Yeah. And then that continues, right? Scriptures, Genesis 6 and 5,
- 10:41the Lord saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth,
- 10:45and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.
- 10:49And the Lord regretted that he made man on the earth, and it grieved him to his heart.
- 10:55Every intention of the heart was only evil continually.
- 10:59And God wasn't looking down at people that made a few mistakes.
- 11:03So grieved was he that man was now nothing like what he was in the garden.
- 11:09And he grieved him and he uses that strong language, regretting that he made us.
- 11:15But some people push that this is only Old Testament kind of theology and ideology.
- 11:20But Romans 3.19, there is none righteous. All have turned aside.
- 11:24There is none good, no, not one.
- 11:28And people don't get it. People in Jesus' day didn't get it.
- 11:31I think of the rich young ruler who says to Jesus, good teacher, what must I do?
- 11:36And Jesus doesn't even get into the conversation. He says, why do you call me good for?
- 11:41If we're going to have any discussion about heaven, about eternal life,
- 11:45about you, about me, let's get good right first.
- 11:49And then he links it only with God. And then as I think you mentioned there,
- 11:54what age does this kick in?
- 11:56We go straight to the man after God's own heart who said in Psalm 51,
- 12:01in sin was I born and in sin did my mother conceive me, right?
- 12:06I think every parent, maybe he listens to this podcast, every parent recognizes
- 12:11they didn't teach their children to steal, to lie, to fight, to covet, to get angry.
- 12:17They're constantly teaching them to be truth-tellers and to share and to be
- 12:22content with what they have because these things don't come to a child naturally.
- 12:27And so that important theological distinction with, we are not sinners because
- 12:32we sin, but we sin because we're sinners.
- 12:35That's what we're born as. That's the nature. And so everything that precedes
- 12:39everything we see in our children, it's coming from that nature.
- 12:42We weren't blank and became sinners.
- 12:45We keep sinning because it's who we are it's the fount of our being and if the
- 12:49fount is polluted so is the stream, right? Mm-hmm.
- 12:54Yeah, that's really helpful and helpful to make that distinction.
- 12:58You said at the beginning of being totally depraved doesn't mean that we are
- 13:02as sinful as we could be, which I think I've definitely thought that before,
- 13:06but our whole self is affected by sin. Every part, yeah.
- 13:10And that deceitfulness, we can see that in the issues that we're facing in our
- 13:14culture, but I can see that in our own hearts and why we need.
- 13:18I remember when I first became a Christian, I grew up in a Christian home and
- 13:22sung Amazing Grace all the time.
- 13:24And then when I actually became saved, I understood the words,
- 13:28I was blind, but now I see.
- 13:30Because when we are not in Christ, we are blind to our sin because our heart
- 13:34is deceitful, as you said. So yes, that's really helpful to point that out.
- 13:39What are some consequences that you can see when people get this wrong and believe
- 13:44that we are a blank state or that we are ultimately good people? Yeah.
- 13:48Look, I'd be as bold to say that,
- 13:53getting this doctrine wrong is one of the greatest stumbling blocks in society
- 13:59for people coming to faith in Christ and wanting to even consider the gospel.
- 14:04And I'd even say that it's one of the leading reasons why I think we see so
- 14:09many young people walk away from the church or walk away from Christianity.
- 14:15They don't have a robust understanding of this doctrine.
- 14:18And then what ends up happening is the gospel is not seen as incredibly precious.
- 14:26Grace, as you said, is not amazing. It's nice, but it's not amazing.
- 14:32It's not radical. It's not actually shocking. And so this is really important.
- 14:37And then it leads to a loss of confidence in the scriptures because we see things
- 14:42in there that don't seem to make sense why God would deal so severely with people in the scriptures.
- 14:48Some people seem to get away with a lot, and then at other times,
- 14:52the judgment of God immediately falls. So it causes people to have a really
- 14:58knee-jerk reaction to the Scriptures. They can't take this holy God.
- 15:02And then second, I think also coupled with that, it has an effect today because even Christians now,
- 15:09when for help and for therapy and for things like that, they're running to therapists,
- 15:16they're running to psychology, they're running to non-Christian sources and
- 15:20non-Christians to get help.
- 15:23As though this world can offer a cure for something that's going on deep down in here.
- 15:31And so, I think it's having massive, massive consequences.
- 15:35But again, I think one of the biggest ones is it's actually preventing people
- 15:39from embracing the gospel.
- 15:42Because Jesus, you know, He's kind of irrelevant. The stakes are not so high.
- 15:47The situation is not as dire.
- 15:51And I'll be able to find my own way to God eventually, right?
- 15:55As opposed to God needing to come down to us because the situation was so helpless and bad.
- 16:02Yeah, it's interesting you point that out because I was brought up in a Presbyterian
- 16:05church despite my parents being Baptist.
- 16:10And almost every single kid that I grew up with is not following the faith.
- 16:15No one is not in Christ at all.
- 16:18And one of the problems that I see with this Presbyterian theology,
- 16:21not that we're talking about that, but,
- 16:23I've seen this happen in my own life, is that people, because they were baptized
- 16:27as infants, then have this idea that they're semi-half Christians or the truth
- 16:32of, you know, I'm not quite a sinner.
- 16:35It's just blurred. I see it was blurred in their lives and the effects that it's had now.
- 16:40And yeah, as you say, because we're not being taught that we are totally depraved,
- 16:45that we are sinners from birth, there's this blurring of, okay,
- 16:49I was baptized, so where do I stand?
- 16:51Yeah. And that's the same in the Pentecostal, even though it was an infant baptism taught.
- 17:02We were not taught how serious our sin was. It was more, who wants to go to
- 17:07heaven? Who wants to accept Jesus? Don't you want to be there, right?
- 17:10And again, this affects our evangelism because the Bible uses these strong terms
- 17:15to kind of convey a total depravity that we were slaves of sin, right?
- 17:22This is a complete inability, a lack of freedom to do what is right and to come
- 17:28to the truth. It talks about us being blind.
- 17:30It talks about us being dead. in trespasses and sin. You know,
- 17:34Jeremiah 13.23, I was thinking about this one as well.
- 17:38Can the Ethiopian change his skin or the leopard he spots?
- 17:42Neither can you who are accustomed to evil do what is good. Right?
- 17:46It's using all of this inability language, even spiritual death.
- 17:51And I think this affects evangelism. Christians kind of have this mindset,
- 17:54churches have this mindset.
- 17:56Sunday school teachers have this mindset of when they're evangelizing,
- 18:00when they're witnessing, they're kind of like lifeguards on the beach.
- 18:04And people are out there and they're waving for help, seeking help,
- 18:08because they're drowning, the pictures of them drowning. But Scripture presents
- 18:12something different, not that people are drowning and waving for help,
- 18:15but that they're at the bottom of the water. They have drowned.
- 18:18They're dead. They're spiritually dead.
- 18:21And they need to be revived. And so when you're continually presenting to people
- 18:25that they have the power to change, that the situation isn't so bad,
- 18:31the grace of God is diminished in preaching.
- 18:34The sovereignty of God is diminished in preaching. The holiness of God is reduced.
- 18:39The power and effect of Christ is diminished.
- 18:43And therefore, it's as simple as signing a piece of paper, writing the date
- 18:48down when you accepted Jesus, repeating a prayer.
- 18:50And total depravity is completely diminished. You know, you conceal this in
- 18:5510 seconds while every head is bowed, every eye is closed, and no one's looking, right?
- 19:00So it has massive implications on how we're calling people to salvation.
- 19:05You know, you can just get this done over the counter. It's a quick transaction. Yeah.
- 19:10This is deeply problematic, right? And then it affects not only how we witness
- 19:14in the church, but how we witness in society and how we communicate with unbelievers
- 19:20in society. Yeah, for sure.
- 19:22So I want to take the example of the Lindsay Clancy case.
- 19:26Some people may quip back to say with everything that's happened here that Lindsay
- 19:29was suffering as a result of sin in this fallen world and acted from that rather
- 19:35than from the sin within her.
- 19:37And whilst we can't assess her heart and exactly what's going on,
- 19:40can you elaborate on the balance of holding on the one hand bad things happening
- 19:44due to our suffering of sin
- 19:46from living in a fallen world, and the other hand that all our actions are stained
- 19:50by sin and are a result of that.
- 19:53Yeah, I hear you on that one, and I appreciate that you mentioned both sides
- 19:58there, the effects of sin and I guess the responsibility for sin.
- 20:03I think if we recognize that, even just noting that sin is not an abstract thing,
- 20:08right? Without someone committing sin, what is sin?
- 20:13Sin comes from the heart, it's enacted upon, it's thought upon,
- 20:16it's drawn upon, but sin is not something that just floats around and hits us or hits people.
- 20:23It's something that's carried out. If it's not carried out, sin is nothing, right?
- 20:27And so I think working out, where do we see that we live in a,
- 20:31how do we work out? We live in a fallen world.
- 20:34We've talked about how sin has ravaged us.
- 20:37And we talked, and even including in this conversation, original sin,
- 20:41Adam and Eve's sin has deeply affected us, right?
- 20:44They were born righteous. They were born pure. They were born with the ability
- 20:49to obey God. We're not born with that ability.
- 20:52And so now there's some different grounding there.
- 20:55So sin has deeply affected us. We didn't ask for that.
- 20:59But then how do we think through this? What do we do with the person that's
- 21:03born into poverty? Did they choose that socioeconomic status? No.
- 21:09But if they steal, should they be allowed to get away with it because they were
- 21:13born into this situation?
- 21:16What about, as we think of a biblical example, what about Peter on Jesus' trial?
- 21:20He's watching his master being assaulted, he's being abused, his master's innocent.
- 21:26He knows that Jesus' life is in danger, then Peter gets pressed.
- 21:30You're one of his followers, aren't you?
- 21:32Now, Peter's life's in jeopardy, and Peter chooses to act in a way where he
- 21:37can save his life, and he chooses to deny his master, but he's being interrogated by wicked people
- 21:43who don't care about innocence, and he tries to save his life.
- 21:46Now, is Peter innocent in that matter?
- 21:48No, it's not the case. I was thinking, and I remember when Brooke and I first,
- 21:54became parents, We were at the newborn stage. It wasn't easy.
- 21:58It's not easy for any parent. And you go without sleep.
- 22:01But I remember a medical professional first telling us about this thing called shaking.
- 22:07And I had never heard of that in my life. And they were talking about some mothers
- 22:12who, you know, when they're trying to settle their child.
- 22:15And, you know, we'll have this instinct that the rocking motion helps settle
- 22:20a child. And we all, it's inbuilt in us. We rock them and we walk around with them.
- 22:24But when that child is continually screaming in your face and you're sleep deprived
- 22:29and you're at your absolute worst, then all of a sudden you feel these desires
- 22:33to shake a little, rock a little bit harder and rock a little bit harder and
- 22:36rock a little bit harder because it's not working.
- 22:39And then hearing, you know, from this medical profession that some parents,
- 22:43whether it's the father or the mother,
- 22:45can shake so vigorously out of agitation that they cause physical harm to the
- 22:51baby that can even result in brain damage.
- 22:54You know, that was shocking to us.
- 22:58And you look at that and you say, well, is the parent responsible?
- 23:01They're being pushed to a limit here beyond what they can cope with.
- 23:07And now they've done this heinous act that they probably wasn't purely intentional
- 23:13and it didn't spring from initially bad motives.
- 23:16And I think the same as we think through, you know, Lindsay Cleancy,
- 23:20you know, is she innocent for her act?
- 23:23If she's declared innocent, what does this open up for every mother present
- 23:28and every future mother who suffers the effects of postpartum stress and anxiety?
- 23:35You know she's got three deceased children now whose lives were taken by her own hands,
- 23:42you know what what happens there and i think the distressing thing is she's
- 23:46now in court it's undeniable that she has killed them,
- 23:50that she's in court knowing what's happened and she's pleading her innocency
- 23:56or her her defense you know she's pleading not guilty to this this is This is deeply problematic.
- 24:04Yep, for sure. And so I think, you know,
- 24:08trying to work out, you know, where do we get the balance of,
- 24:11you know, this, we live in a fallen world and we live committing sins ourselves.
- 24:17We need to think through that.
- 24:19Even pre-fall, when Adam and Eve sinned, Adam blames Eve.
- 24:25Eve blames the devil, so there is this passing on responsibility.
- 24:31It's interesting, the devil doesn't get out scot-free from this.
- 24:34The curse falls upon the devil.
- 24:36He had a role in this, right? There was a temptation. He was that external force
- 24:41that provoked and stimulated this sin.
- 24:44You know, God, why didn't you stop him from coming in the garden?
- 24:47Why didn't you stand between him, Eve, and the tree? Why didn't you, right?
- 24:52So, he's deemed responsible in this. But also, Eve is held responsible and a curse falls upon her.
- 25:01And Adam is held responsible and the curse falls upon him, right?
- 25:05And so, even in that we're acknowledging there's external factors here. There's a real tempter.
- 25:12There is a temptation. There's a deceiver. There is someone who is fallen already who enters the garden.
- 25:18And yet, there is responsibility there, but there is responsibility that is
- 25:23laid squarely on the feet of Adam and Eve.
- 25:25And not only that, but all of us born from Adam and Eve sharing a responsibility
- 25:33for this and are held accountable.
- 25:35And so I think even in the case with Lindsay Clancy, God established something
- 25:39very early on in Genesis when he deals with the sanctity of life.
- 25:44And I thought through Genesis 9, verse 5, God says this, and surely I will require
- 25:50a penalty for your lifeblood.
- 25:52I will require it from any animal and from any human. If someone murders a fellow
- 25:57human, I will require that person's life.
- 26:00Whoever sheds human blood by humans, their blood shall be shed. Yep, for sure.
- 26:06That's helpful to think through that from the beginning of Genesis,
- 26:09that there was that responsibility that, yes, Satan was held accountable,
- 26:14but so was each of us. And the consequences for the sin that we committed,
- 26:18or that Adam and Eve committed, that, yes, Satan was held accountable,
- 26:20They're massive. Pain in childbirth alone is a massive consequence for sin,
- 26:25and yet alone the sin of the rest of the human race.
- 26:31That's very interesting, and I've never thought of that before,
- 26:33actually. Yeah, I think it's helpful to recognize that, right?
- 26:36That God lays very clearly at the start how responsibility for sin is going to work.
- 26:45And even when you get to Leviticus and you get the establishment of the priesthood,
- 26:53and the sacrifices, and God requires different sacrifices, it's interesting
- 26:57that he has categories for intentional sin and unintentional sin,
- 27:03for willful sin and unwillful sin, right?
- 27:05And yeah, so in a sense, so even between willful and unintentional sins,
- 27:11God had a category for that and it needed to be dealt with still.
- 27:15There still needed to be a sacrifice, there still needed to be bloodshed,
- 27:18there still needed to be a payment.
- 27:20And so God always held sin, people responsible for sin. And I think we need
- 27:25to think through that even in light where there might be mental illness,
- 27:30there might be external factors, there might be pressures.
- 27:33It still needs to be account. Sin, God always holds people responsible for their sin.
- 27:39Obviously, there's degrees and we know that, but it's never completely excused as uncommitted.
- 27:48Yes, and that wording of completely excused is really relevant to this whole
- 27:52topic because this is one of the big problems that I see currently facing us
- 27:57is that we do explain away sin or completely excuse ourselves from sin because of mental health.
- 28:03Or situations that have happened to us that then make us act in a certain way.
- 28:07So there's no sin involved, but an outward circumstance happening to us that
- 28:11we have no control over. And this came up most recently when I saw the Stop
- 28:15It Now Australia website, a child abuse prevention website that I mentioned earlier.
- 28:20And in their defense, they're really acting in the best way a secular website
- 28:23can act where there is no absolute truth. There is no God. And I appreciate
- 28:27the intention behind the site.
- 28:29However, on the website, it states in one of its sections of how to combat this
- 28:35child's sexual attraction is that some people who feel distressed,
- 28:38and I quote, about sexual thoughts involving children may be experiencing a
- 28:42form of obsessive compulsive disorder.
- 28:44In these cases, the thoughts are intrusive, unwanted, and anxiety-provoking,
- 28:48and the person is not sexually aroused by them.
- 28:51Now, this goes to a deeper issue within our society, and that is within that issue of.
- 28:56Blaming that external disorder for the temptations that we face,
- 29:00which we've talked about, and show the depravity of our nature in trying to
- 29:04explain away child sexual attraction as part of OCD.
- 29:09I think the majority of people listening to this podcast would reject that notion,
- 29:13but what I want to point out here is that if we say to the mum who's struggling
- 29:17with ex-mental health issue, rather than let's look at what sin could be going on in your heart
- 29:22and instead justify her actions and treatment due to that mental health issue,
- 29:27To be consistent, then, do we not need to apply the same reasoning to the person
- 29:32struggling with child sexual attraction?
- 29:34Can you talk to that for a minute? Well, I think you've hit the nail on the
- 29:37head, right, for consistency. And that's what we're seeing.
- 29:41So, even with that website that you're quoting, right, the floodgates are now
- 29:44open, right? And it's only going to get worse because there needs to be consistency there.
- 29:50And so if a certain mental illness person is a victim to that and they're not
- 29:57culpable for that and their behaviors, the same is going to be now for child sexual attraction.
- 30:05This is something that comes upon a person. They're not to blame for it.
- 30:10And now this is going to be consistent. So it's going to come out with all sorts of things here.
- 30:16Whereas I think the biblical doctrine and the theology of this is,
- 30:19hey, we're acknowledging that we are now born into a world where we are corrupted,
- 30:26and our desires are corrupted.
- 30:29We don't live forever in our bodies anymore. Our bodies wear out. Our minds are clouded.
- 30:35Our desires are corrupt. I mean, it touches everything, right?
- 30:39And so even with this now child sexual attraction and just distinguishing,
- 30:45look, they're not acting out those desires.
- 30:48They might not be aroused by it, needs to be acknowledged from biblical worldview
- 30:53here that this is a perverse attraction.
- 30:55This is Romans 1 talks about even when it talks about homosexuality.
- 31:00Men now, because they've suppressed the truth and because they're depraved,
- 31:04they now desire or have an attraction for men and women now being attracted
- 31:09to women, contrary to nature, contrary to God's original design.
- 31:15These are now fallen instincts that are inbuilt to us. Now, because we have
- 31:20these desires, now does that mean that they're okay because I've had these for
- 31:24as long as I can think, so it must be just who I am?
- 31:27No, no, these fallen, perverse, and depraved desires, and that's why we—and
- 31:33I have no problem even with some people saying, well, I was born this way,
- 31:37or I was born with these kind of things.
- 31:39Well, the Bible says you need to be born again, you need a new heart,
- 31:44you need a new birth, you need new desires, and on top of that,
- 31:47you need the Holy Spirit inside of you.
- 31:49Right? And so we can argue, look, this is who I am, this is my mental state, da-da-da-da.
- 31:56The Bible says you need to be made a new creation.
- 31:59And whoever comes to Christ is a new creation from the inside out,
- 32:03and He's working in us, right?
- 32:06And so, the world's got no answers for this. They're trying to put in categories.
- 32:11They're trying to medicate these things.
- 32:15We need the good and great physician, don't we, to reach into the place that
- 32:20the therapists, psychologists, politicians, new legislation,
- 32:25they can't touch this area of us.
- 32:28Yeah, for sure. And it's really helpful to actually look into this and to follow
- 32:32the logic of where our thoughts are coming from, because this is the logical conclusion.
- 32:39And whilst that is confronting, and I think we'll be confronting to a lot of
- 32:42women, because there's a lot of women who we all fall prey to this idea.
- 32:47And it's because this is so prevalent in our culture at the moment.
- 32:50But to come back to, okay, what is the truth of God's word? What does he have
- 32:54to say on this and not just go from our feelings and whatever we feel then determines what is right.
- 33:01So, yeah, to actually dig into where is this coming from? Where does it lead to?
- 33:06What is the truth of the gospel here? Yeah, that's key.
- 33:09Good point. That's key. This whole topic of total depravity,
- 33:13it can seem depressing in one sense because maybe even a bit dark because we're
- 33:18looking at, okay, we are sinners. We're affected by sin, the entirety of us.
- 33:22If we are left in that state, then it is depressing.
- 33:25But what hope can you give us? Is there any hope in this topic when we have
- 33:29come to understand the depths of who we are before a holy God? Yeah.
- 33:34Yeah, no, good question. I mean, what we call the gospel means good news.
- 33:39And good news is good news as when we know what the bad news is, right?
- 33:44Good news shines brighter in
- 33:45that. And so I think if we can embrace what the Bible says to us, right?
- 33:50Like the person, the cancer patient who doesn't want to see the test results
- 33:56and the doctor's pleading and saying, hey, this is a diagnosis.
- 33:59This is the size of the tumor.
- 34:01This is where it's spread. And like the person who says, I don't want to hear
- 34:03it. I don't want to hear it. It can't be true. It can't be true.
- 34:06Right? They're cutting themselves off from any remedy. And I think it's once
- 34:10we embrace the situation and the diagnosis that the Bible brings,
- 34:15I think that is the pathway to life, that is the pathway to cure.
- 34:21And I think we can take heart in that, because the good news reaches to us in that state.
- 34:27Jesus Christ coming to us, comes to us in that state.
- 34:32Romans 5, while we were still weak, while we were still helpless.
- 34:37That's in our complete fallen state, with all our mental disabilities,
- 34:42with all of our frailty, with all the horrible upbringings that we might have
- 34:46had, with all the environmental factors around us,
- 34:49while we were still weak and powerless, Christ died for the ungodly.
- 34:53One will scarcely die for a righteous person. Maybe one will die for a good person.
- 34:58But God shows his own love for us in that while we were still sinners,
- 35:03you know, total depravity, Christ died for us.
- 35:07And I think that's just really important. That's where the hope comes.
- 35:10And this is why we're going back to what we said earlier.
- 35:13When we reject total depravity, when we shy away from this, When we water that
- 35:18down, we're cutting people off from the hope that really we've been entrusted
- 35:25to bring to people this good news.
- 35:27The gospel is not good news. Grace is not amazing.
- 35:30But I've often found it's the people that have come, the Christians that have
- 35:35come to realize how serious their sickness and disease was of sin.
- 35:40They're the most grateful in their Christian walk. They're the most joyful.
- 35:45They're the most evangelistic.
- 35:47And they're the most passionate about seeing the lost saved.
- 35:51And they're the most thankful for Christ because they've understood what they've
- 35:54been saved from. So there is great hope in this, right?
- 35:58It's not a bleak doctrine in and of itself because it's tied now to the gospel.
- 36:03It's inextricably linked to the gospel.
- 36:05100%. Yeah, I'm reminded of Romans 7 that I was reflecting on this a lot just
- 36:10prior to my conversion, where Paul is wrestling with the, I do what I don't
- 36:14want to do and wrestling with his flesh.
- 36:16And then he comes to the end of Romans 7. He says, wretched man that I am,
- 36:20who will deliver me from this body of death?
- 36:22Thanks be to God in Christ Jesus, my Lord. And then you've got Romans 8 starting
- 36:26off. There is no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.
- 36:30Like the beauty of the gospel, we see it when we see our own wretchedness.
- 36:33And yeah, so thank you for shedding some light on this.
- 36:38If people want to look into this topic more, is there places you can direct
- 36:42them to to gain more of an understanding of this or to help them understand,
- 36:46you know, the wrestle of this whole issue?
- 36:48Yeah, I think just from a, I think first place would be go straight to the scriptures
- 36:55and spend some time studying Romans 1 to 3. That is one of the clearest words.
- 37:01Paul's treatise on the doctrine of total depravity, and he's really seeking to gather—he's,
- 37:07got a mission before him because he's trying to convince Jews,
- 37:11that they're just as sinful as pagan Gentiles, those who've had the covenants,
- 37:17those who've had the Scriptures, and he argues a massive case of total depravity, that it's universal.
- 37:22So spend some time with just some careful and honest study of Romans 1-3.
- 37:29As far as some other resources outside of the Scripture, Michael Horton,
- 37:34maybe you could put a link to it, he has a great book called Putting Amazing Back Into Grace.
- 37:40It's just a fantastic book, Michael Horton, Putting Amazing Back Into Grace.
- 37:45There's a great, there's a free three-part video series on YouTube called Amazing
- 37:52Grace, and it's called The History and theology of Calvinism.
- 37:58And the reason why I recommend this is because it's the Calvinistic doctrine
- 38:02and system of beliefs that gets into total depravity the most and the most helpfully.
- 38:07So Amazing Grace, The History and Theology of Calvinism, it's a three-part series on YouTube.
- 38:14That's fantastic as well.
- 38:16And anything from Ligonier Ministries, R.C. Sproul, on what is Reformed theology
- 38:22of total depravity, just great resources there.
- 38:25Thank you so much. And thank you, Nathan, for coming on.
- 38:28You know, when I was thinking through who could I interview on this topic,
- 38:31I was trying to think through who's the most totally depraved person I can...
- 38:35And they weren't available. And so you called me. No.
- 38:40But yeah, no, I appreciate your thoughts on this. It's been very helpful. We've been just...
- 38:44For me thinking I've understood this doctrine, but having you explain it again
- 38:47is really, really helpful. We need the truth of God's word to be taught to us.
- 38:51So thank you, Nathan. Oh, it's an absolute privilege. Thanks for...