Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Performance Improvement Plan That Actually Helps
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week that I think a lot of people have been through or at least worried about. Someone wrote in saying, 'I just got put on a performance improvement plan, a PIP. Everyone says it's just the company building a case to fire me. Is there any way to survive this?' Luna: Oof. That pit-in-your-stomach feeling. And they're not wrong that a lot of PIPs do end in termination. But not all of them. Lucas: Right. The data varies, but studies suggest somewhere between 50 and 70 percent of employees on a PIP are gone within a year—either fired or they quit. So the odds are not great. But the question is, can you improve those odds? And I think yes, but you have to treat it strategically from the moment it's brought up. Luna: And before we dive into that—I want to mention something. We put these episodes out every single day, and they stay ad-free because listeners choose to support us. If you've ever gotten useful advice from this show, a couple of dollars a month genuinely makes a difference. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Seriously, that's what keeps the lights on. Lucas: Yeah, and we really mean that. No pressure ever. But if you've shared an episode with a friend or used one of these scripts in a real meeting, that's the kind of thing that keeps us going. Okay, back to the PIP. Luna: So Lucas, what's the first move when your manager drops the PIP bomb? Lucas: First move: don't sign anything in the meeting. Say you need time to review it. Even if it feels like you have no leverage, you have the right to understand the document. Ask for 24 to 48 hours. If they push back, say, 'I want to take this seriously and give it the attention it deserves. I'll come back with thoughtful questions.' Luna: That's good. Because when you're blindsided, your brain is in fight or flight. You need space to think. Lucas: Exactly. So you take it home. And then you read it like a contract. What are the specific metrics? Are they measurable? Are they achievable in the timeframe? For example, I worked with a marketing manager at a midsize SaaS company who was told she needed to increase demo bookings by 30 percent in 90 days. But her team had been cut by two people. That's a flag. Luna: Right. So you need to look for metrics that are outside your control or based on factors you don't own. Lucas: Bingo. So the second step is to prepare a response that reframes the PIP as a development plan. You want to negotiate the terms before you sign. I'd suggest writing an email or a document that says, 'I appreciate the opportunity to improve. To set me up for success, I'd like to adjust these three things.' For example, 'The 30 percent increase assumes the same lead volume, but we're down two reps. Can we adjust the target to 15 percent or extend the timeline to five months?' Luna: That makes sense. And it's not adversarial—you're saying, help me succeed. Lucas: Right. And a good manager or HR person will see that as a sign you're engaged. If they reject every reasonable adjustment, that tells you something about their intent. But you also want to ask for weekly one-on-ones during the PIP period, not just a monthly check-in. That way you can course-correct quickly and document progress. Luna: Documentation. That's key. I've heard stories where people hit every target and still got let go because the manager claimed they 'didn't show improvement in soft skills.' Lucas: Yeah, that's the nightmare scenario. So you document everything. After every meeting, send a recap email: 'Just to confirm, we agreed I need to deliver X by Y date. I'll share a draft by Wednesday.' That creates a paper trail. And if they try to move the goalposts, you have evidence. Luna: What about the emotional side? How do you keep from spiraling? Lucas: It's hard. But I'd say treat it like a project. You're running a 90-day campaign to save your job. That means you also need to manage your energy. Don't work 12-hour days to prove a point—that burns you out. Focus on the metrics that matter, and nothing else. Also, start networking quietly. Update your LinkedIn. Talk to recruiters. Not because you're giving up, but because having options reduces the panic. Luna: That's actually the best advice. If you know you have a fallback, you negotiate from strength, not desperation. Lucas: And one more thing: if you do successfully complete the PIP and stay, great. But the relationship with your manager is often damaged. So even if you survive, I'd still keep an eye on the job market. Sometimes the PIP is a sign that the fit isn't right, and that's okay. Luna: Yeah. I think the biggest takeaway is that a PIP doesn't have to be a death sentence if you treat it actively. You have more agency than it feels like in the moment. Lucas: Exactly. The worst thing you can do is freeze and hope it goes away. So to the listener who wrote in: take the 48 hours, look at the numbers, negotiate the terms, document everything, and keep your options open. You've got this. Luna: And if you've got a career question you want us to tackle, you can always reach out. We read every message. Lucas: We do. And we'll be back tomorrow with another one.