Latest / Serves You Right / #38 Aaron Goldfarb: Inside the Underground World of Vintage Spirits
Transcript
- 0:00What if the best spirit you'll ever taste isn't some new
- 0:03bottle, but a weird old dusty bottle that's been forgotten for
- 0:07decades? This week I got to sit down and
- 0:10talk to Aaron Goldfarb. Aaron is the author of Dusty
- 0:13Boos in Search of Vintage Spirits.
- 0:16He's a long time spirits writer. He's written so much and one of
- 0:20the foremost voices on collectible ancient liquors.
- 0:24Aaron pulls the curtain back on all sorts of things that I
- 0:27didn't even know existed. A secretive world where people
- 0:29are hunting for out of production bourbon, tequila,
- 0:33rum, compari, chartreuse and beyond.
- 0:36So we get to talk about why, say, an old granddad from the
- 0:4060s may taste better than anything you could find on the
- 0:44market today. How flaws, as we would call them
- 0:48in today's age, contributed to the balance and flavour of
- 0:52ancient liqueurs and why carcinogens actually were part
- 0:57of the flavour profile back in the day.
- 0:59So super weird, but super cool conversation.
- 1:02I had a fun time. Thank you for listening.
- 1:04To Serve the Right, here's Aaron Goldfarb.
- 1:10Aaron, thanks for joining me today.
- 1:12Thanks. For having me.
- 1:13I've got my favorite passage here.
- 1:16Like when I read this, I think I laughed out loud.
- 1:19It's your section about tequila, and I'm just going to quote It's
- 1:24unlike all other spirits categories.
- 1:26Why is there so little vintage tequila?
- 1:28I asked Julio Fornejo, perhaps America's preeminent tequila
- 1:32scholar. The arrogant answer, he told me,
- 1:35is because people in Mexico actually drink them all.
- 1:38And that that was like the best way to start that chapter and a
- 1:43really cool kind of way to get into this.
- 1:48How did you get into doing research about dusty bottles and
- 1:53what led you to put together this book?
- 1:56And I thought we then we could start going through it.
- 2:00Yeah, I've kind of been a drinker and a collector and I've
- 2:07written about spirits overall for over 20 years by now.
- 2:12And I remember back in, I think it was about 2012, I was in
- 2:15Kentucky and I was at a a bar and this guy started talking to
- 2:20me about, about vintage spirits because this bar we were at had,
- 2:24had some older, older bourbons. And he said he was a dusty
- 2:29hunter. And I said, well, what's that?
- 2:30And he said, you know, I, I go around Los Angeles and I, I look
- 2:33for CD liquor stores and liquor stores off the beaten path.
- 2:38And I go in and see if they have old bottles.
- 2:39I thought, well, why do you do that?
- 2:42And he told me because old liquor is essentially a liquid
- 2:46time capsule. It doesn't it doesn't change in
- 2:48the bottle like wine or beer does.
- 2:50And so to drink an old granddad from the 60s, it tastes like it
- 2:54would have tasted like back then.
- 2:58Well, why would you want to taste a old granddad from the
- 3:011960s? Because it was made better.
- 3:03And, you know, we can get into why it tastes better or was made
- 3:07better, but that was the essential point.
- 3:09So as a spirits lover, I was, I was fascinated by that concept.
- 3:15And even back then, Dusty hunters I was talking to and
- 3:18writing about were saying, oh, it's too late, the game's over,
- 3:22you know, not worth your time. And they weren't joking around.
- 3:25They thought that. And so I thought, well, you
- 3:27know, it isn't worth my time. But, you know, people kept
- 3:29getting into it and kept finding new stuff and kept finding new
- 3:32ways to find stuff. And people tell you it's over
- 3:35now. But, you know, once a month,
- 3:36some guy finds an incredible score somewhere.
- 3:38So there's so many old bottles places, you know, you're going
- 3:43to have an old relative die one day and you're going to be
- 3:45shocked how many old bottles granny had stowed away in the
- 3:48attic. And hopefully they'll be yours
- 3:50one day. Yeah, no, you know, reading your
- 3:53book actually inspired me to do a couple quick YouTube searches
- 3:58and I, like almost instantaneously found some lady
- 4:00who when her grandmother passed away, she had like hundreds of
- 4:04bottles of minis. And it's her whole channel is
- 4:07her tasting those and asking people about like, I was like,
- 4:10I've been. On that show.
- 4:11Oh, Oh, really? Really.
- 4:12Yeah, Tammy? Yeah.
- 4:14Yeah. And I was just like, man, this
- 4:15world goes deep, doesn't it? But yeah, it's just people
- 4:21accumulate so much stuff. And, you know, it might not be
- 4:25the bottle of the, like, what is it?
- 4:28The Mona rum hidden in the restaurant.
- 4:30But just your, your grandfather has a couple of, you know,
- 4:34different whiskeys that he forgot he had in his basement.
- 4:37And yeah, that's super cool. It just who knew this world?
- 4:43You you did touch on something that I wanted to at least
- 4:47address at some point why people think these bottles are better
- 4:52and you give a couple of possible answers in the book.
- 4:56One just being kind of like nostalgia and they may not be
- 5:00evolving, but the lack of the industrial precision like So
- 5:06what what all would one look to taste with one was you know
- 5:11acquired one of these dusty old bottles what what you would
- 5:13expect. Well, you know, when we talk
- 5:17about vintage spirits in America, most people are
- 5:19focusing on bourbon and, and that's what drew me in as well.
- 5:24Other category, but that's kind of the hardest category to
- 5:26determine why things are, are better.
- 5:28You know, for something like tequila, it's it's kind of
- 5:30self-evident. You know, they weren't rushing
- 5:33to get agave out of the ground back 40 years ago.
- 5:36So it was getting its most, you know, sugar packed and then very
- 5:41old fashioned artisan techniques were being used to harvest it
- 5:45and to to, you know, mash it and ferment it and, and distill it.
- 5:49So that kind of makes sense. Now.
- 5:51Bourbon has been one of the most regulated foods, you know,
- 5:55drinks in the world for, you know, a very, very long time.
- 6:01So it's not like we can say, well, they were, you know,
- 6:04using, you know, motor oil to make it, you know, about
- 6:06whatever they. Yeah, well, most people weren't.
- 6:09Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But.
- 6:11But since the bottle and bond act, it's been made the same way
- 6:14everywhere. There's, there was no one using
- 6:16anything else. So I think it becomes more of,
- 6:19you know, everything was being done just a little bit better.
- 6:23You know, maybe the corn was more of a, you know, heritage
- 6:28product as opposed to just grown for yield.
- 6:34You know, distilleries use computers nowaday, which is
- 6:37great for not having screw ups, but maybe you needed a human
- 6:41being's touch to just make it, you know, a little bit better.
- 6:45You know, one of the big ones is no, no ones drinking bourbon.
- 6:51So you don't have to, you know, sell it as quick as possible.
- 6:54So if you have a Wild Turkey 8 year old, maybe you're throwing
- 6:5614 year old barrels into that blend.
- 6:58Maybe you're throwing that 20 year old barrel that's sticking
- 7:00around nowadays. I'm pretty sure you know if it's
- 7:04a bottle, says 8 year old bourbon.
- 7:06Every single barrel is 8 years old and maybe a day.
- 7:10Because they would put 9 if they could, yeah.
- 7:12Right, exactly. And they weren't concerned with
- 7:14that back then. And there's there's all these
- 7:17just little things that lead to at least the best of the best
- 7:22stuff from the past being better, you know, but it's also
- 7:26a sort of winner take all things, you know, people forget
- 7:29the crappy bottle of bourbon they had from the 1960s, but
- 7:33they remember all that old granddad, all that stencil
- 7:36Weller they've had. And they go, this is better than
- 7:38anything I've had today. And it is.
- 7:40But we're the worst bottles from that era, better than the most.
- 7:44You know, the bottom shelf today is pretty good.
- 7:47You know, if you for some reason were forced to, you know, drink
- 7:52the bottom shelf stuff today, the $12.00 bottles, at least you
- 7:55know it's not going to kill you. That's that's called going to
- 7:58college. Actually that's.
- 8:00Right. That's right.
- 8:02Yeah, that's a good point. Yeah.
- 8:04If you if you're looking back in the day, the cheap stuff is
- 8:09likely the stuff that, you know, you go into a liquor store now
- 8:12and you see something on sale, 7 bucks.
- 8:15It may not be world changing, but I'll give it a shot.
- 8:17And a lot of those dusty bottles are the few more expensive ones
- 8:21that just kind of sat in the back and no one picked up for a
- 8:24while and they just kind of stayed well.
- 8:26I mean, you know, another thing you think about, you know, how
- 8:29many products does Jim Beam release a year Now, how many
- 8:31does Wild Turkey release a year? Back in the day they were
- 8:34releasing one or two products. So all the greatest barrels were
- 8:37going into their Jim Beam white label, their Wild Turkey one O
- 8:411, you know, so there there were, there wasn't, you know,
- 8:45the best barrels being saved for that special Christmas release
- 8:48that was going to be $1000. That just didn't exist.
- 8:50Everything was going into shelf products that cost, you know, a
- 8:55fair price. Sure, sure.
- 8:57Yeah. And you also point to the fact
- 8:59that a lot of the bourbon producers were fermenting in
- 9:03Redwood tanks. So there's there's slightly
- 9:05different, less hygienic methods that added to some complexity.
- 9:10Yeah, I'm a big advocate of that.
- 9:12You know, I kind of started in the beer world with open
- 9:14fermentation and and stuff like that.
- 9:17And the guys today will will claim that, you know, wooden
- 9:21tanks are are just as clean and hygienic as the same list the
- 9:25other day. But that's there's no way there
- 9:27wasn't like a house bug in the in the wood that gave it
- 9:32character if not flavor. Sure, sure.
- 9:34Yeah. I mean, it's, it's the same as
- 9:37just the environment of making bread, you know?
- 9:39Yeah, it's like you pick up things, but that's not bad.
- 9:43It's the wild east of the, that's what.
- 9:45People. Like that's that variability.
- 9:49You also point to some things that are less than savoury,
- 9:51like, well, not radioactive, but carcinogenic materials.
- 9:56And there were different allowances back then.
- 10:00Yeah. Understandings.
- 10:01Yeah, yeah. Urethane, right?
- 10:04Yeah. Yeah.
- 10:06I mean, this is, you know, one of the many theories is that
- 10:09this, you know, cancer causing material was actually somewhat
- 10:12delicious. And I think they quit using it
- 10:14around I think 85 or so. So who knows?
- 10:18You know, I think we can be have a slightly less delicious
- 10:21bourbon if we have a slightly less chance of getting cancer.
- 10:23So yeah. There's certain trade-offs that
- 10:26we're willing to make and it's kind of jumps ahead.
- 10:30We, we wonder what the future of collectible bottles will be.
- 10:35I was, I was really struck. I did not realize how little I
- 10:39knew about Campari. But your few paragraphs that you
- 10:42had about Campari actually taught me a lot.
- 10:45So Campari originally colored with essentially beetles, if I
- 10:49understood correctly, which I had heard before, just
- 10:52anecdotally. But the fact that they bottle at
- 10:55a different proofs through different countries, like I
- 10:59just, I guess I've never had a Campari in another country.
- 11:01I never thought to check, you know.
- 11:04Yeah, and I, I joke that I can't believe American restaurants
- 11:08don't sell Mexican Campari like they sell Mexican Coke because
- 11:11Mexican Campari is, I believe, higher proof and it's made with,
- 11:15with the, you know, bugs as opposed to just a red food dye.
- 11:19Yeah, well, I I brought it up because, you know, in those
- 11:22countries that dye is not allowed.
- 11:24So there's there's a feature where maybe we'll wake up and it
- 11:29too will be banned and all of a sudden people will be looking
- 11:31for the artificial dyed Campari out there.
- 11:34So you never know, you know? RFK Junior might attack the the
- 11:38red dye next in our Campari, who knows.
- 11:41You heard it here first. So going back just, you know,
- 11:48kind of follow the evolution of the book.
- 11:51We kind of started with bourbon and whiskey is kind of the big
- 11:54deal. And I felt like the core of the
- 11:57story. How, how does one go about these
- 12:02days finding more rare vintage bottles?
- 12:06You kind of mentioned that all the like easily accessible ones
- 12:09have been snatched up and you hear more and more, there's no
- 12:13unicorns out there. We've got Howard Hughes, we've
- 12:16got some some private stashes like that.
- 12:19But is there anything else that people are now excited about or
- 12:24like? Well, you got to get clever.
- 12:26I mean, I tell the story in the book of this guy who finds
- 12:29himself on a farm auction website that's mainly auctioning
- 12:33off, you know, dead farmers. John Deere's and it just so
- 12:36happened one of these dead farmers owned a liquor store 30
- 12:39years ago and and that was part of this farm auction.
- 12:42So he buys the entire liquor store that hasn't been opened in
- 12:4530 years. It's like King Tut's tomb of old
- 12:47bottles. And he makes a, a world class
- 12:49score. So, you know, the more clever
- 12:54guys are figuring out ways to to find other bottles, whether it's
- 12:59going, going to weird countries that haven't yet, you know, been
- 13:02fully picked over. Because the other thing is, you
- 13:05know, if grandma dies and you know nothing about alcohol and
- 13:08you go to her, her basement or wherever, sell her and she's got
- 13:12a ton of bottles and you go, this kind of looks old.
- 13:14You can quickly Google it and find out.
- 13:16Oh wow, this is valuable too. So this is all happy.
- 13:19OK, there's. Not a yeah, there's not a lot of
- 13:21suckers in the world anymore that you can pull a fast one
- 13:25with, especially with bourbon because it's so written about.
- 13:29So most people at least kind of know the market price of their
- 13:33old bottles. It's been a bad thing too
- 13:36because they think the market price is the highest absolute
- 13:39price they will find of a bottle listed on the Internet, which is
- 13:41obviously not the case. One guy one day paid for it once
- 13:46and all of a sudden that's the market price.
- 13:48Not even paid for it. One guy asked for this price one
- 13:51day and it's still being asked for on the Internet, and so
- 13:53other people don't think that's a market price.
- 13:56But yeah, if I knew, if I knew these great secret ways to find
- 14:00bottles, I'd be doing it myself. You'd.
- 14:02Really. Just be talking to me, yeah.
- 14:04I mean, for a lot of guys, it's their full time job just trying
- 14:07to figure out how they can find bottles, getting tips and
- 14:10driving for 10 hours on the pure chance that this guy really has
- 14:15incredible bottles in his basement or, or whatnot.
- 14:17And, and, and going from there, it's a real hunt.
- 14:21These are real hunters for sure. Sure, yeah.
- 14:24And I think that, you know, the way you said by chance kind of
- 14:28leads me into something I did want to ask you about.
- 14:30And so I'm I'm more, I'm more versed and more experienced in
- 14:35the wine world. And so the billionaire's
- 14:37vinegar, the story of the counterfeit Lafitte that you
- 14:40actually mentioned in the book, It's it's incredible.
- 14:46I can only imagine that there must be a ton of people
- 14:51refilling and fakes and you you kind of mentioned that and it's
- 14:55kind of a one of those like anytime there's second hand
- 14:58markets, beware buyer. I like I like that you had the
- 15:04suggestion. I don't know if it was yours or
- 15:05if it's big in the dusty bottle world of breaking your bottles
- 15:10after you get done drinking them, but.
- 15:12Yeah, that's, that's been a thing.
- 15:14You know, the, there's never been as big of fraud as, as in
- 15:20the wine world because there's also not a lot of $100,000
- 15:23bottles, $1,000,000 bottles out there in the, in the bourbon
- 15:26world just yet. But there have been refilling
- 15:29cases quite often with, with Pappy, which are being more and
- 15:35more combated as, as people figure out ways to authenticate
- 15:38better. I still don't think it's a huge
- 15:41problem, especially with, with vintage stuff.
- 15:45You're going to set up a whole operation just to sell, you
- 15:48know, $2000 bottles to a very small select group of people
- 15:52that like old bottles maybe. And it happens occasionally, but
- 15:56I don't think there's a guy with, with fake aging or
- 16:00Fitzgerald labels from the 30s sitting in his basement.
- 16:03I could be wrong. Maybe that, maybe I'm a sucker,
- 16:05but I'm not buying these bottles right now, so.
- 16:07Sure, Yeah, but that famous counterfeiter, Rudy, there's no
- 16:13like comparable thing that well, that makes sense.
- 16:15And you know, you, you pointed to something I hadn't considered
- 16:17there because in my head I just kind of thought, you know,
- 16:21expensive product invites counterfeiters, invites people
- 16:25who are going to cheat the system.
- 16:26But there is that cap. Like you sure you do have the
- 16:30off bottle of like $100,000 Cognacs and like weird like
- 16:36auction stuff, but usually it's like the two to three, not the
- 16:4010,020 thousand. Yeah, it's like counterfeiting
- 16:43$1.00 bills. Like you can make a little
- 16:46money, but are you really going to do it?
- 16:47You know you're going to swing for something bigger and and
- 16:50that's still the wine world. Yeah.
- 16:52OK. So in the wine world, likewise
- 16:55you can. Get away with, you know, Oh no,
- 16:58this $200 bottle tastes like crap, but we kind of expected it
- 17:01to have gone bad. You know bourbon is a lot more
- 17:05Hardy, so you expect it to taste good.
- 17:09But yeah, you also expect if you were to refill a bottle of Pappy
- 17:14with, you know, even like makers or, you know, some we did
- 17:17something, yes, you, you would know, although you you would be
- 17:21surprised how much expectations cloud your tasting judgments.
- 17:25And sure, you know, sure. Yeah.
- 17:29There's just so, you know, compared to like Lafitte
- 17:32bottles, there's just so much Pappy out there that you know,
- 17:35is legit and you can buy and so many people that have tasted it,
- 17:39it's it would be very hard to pull a fast 1.
- 17:42You know, I'm sure there's some bars out there that refill their
- 17:44Pappy with Weller and sell it to the, you know, drunk suckers on
- 17:49a, you know, expense account coming in to have it and get
- 17:52away with it. But I just don't think it's a
- 17:54very big crime in in the bourbon world right now.
- 17:57Fair enough, fair enough. And just to make sure that's
- 18:00clear, that is not my my restaurant too.
- 18:02Just throw that out there. Yeah, we're we're going down a
- 18:05dark hole here. Let's let's turn.
- 18:08Let's talk about Cognacs. The gentleman the what was it
- 18:12the dawn of. Oh man, I'm planking up
- 18:16Salvatore calibration. Yes, yes, yes.
- 18:20So this gentleman, he shows up a couple times in the book, you
- 18:25know, those listening. Who is this gentleman and why
- 18:27did he want to collect so many old bottles?
- 18:30What? What was his You?
- 18:31Know he he's so far ahead of the game.
- 18:33You know, I kind of cite the beginning of dusty hunting in
- 18:38the US around, I don't know, 2008 to 2010 with bourbon.
- 18:44He's in England in 1985 and he's a bartender at Duke's Hotel,
- 18:50Duke's Hotel Bar, which is still a fantastic bar in, in London.
- 18:54And he has some sort of deal where he his salary is based on
- 19:00how much he's selling per night. Well, this is an era back when
- 19:04you can only spend so much. Even, you know, if Paul
- 19:08McCartney's coming into his restaurant, who would?
- 19:11There just is not like McAllen bottles that are worth
- 19:14$1,000,000 back then. So he figures, well, I can't,
- 19:18you know, I can only sell so many martinis.
- 19:20Maybe I can start selling rarer products and his ideas.
- 19:25I'm going to start selling vintage products.
- 19:27And he loved cognac, which was not huge at the time in in the
- 19:33UK from what I understand. So he started pursuing vintage
- 19:38bottles with his thinking being, I could tell a story.
- 19:42I could say, you know, when were you born Paul McCartney?
- 19:44Well, I got a bottle of cognac from that year, you know, you
- 19:47know, American citizens, who would you like this bottle that
- 19:50was distilled, you know, when Abe Lincoln was shot, etcetera,
- 19:53etcetera. It took him over 2 years to find
- 19:55a single vintage cognac that someone would sell him because
- 19:59even back then people thought, well, you know, this bottle's
- 20:02100 years old, this is poison. I'm not going to sell it to you.
- 20:06How do you want the old stuff? What's wrong with it?
- 20:07Right. Yeah.
- 20:08You know, it seems like a weird angle, but he eventually by by,
- 20:13you know, the, the, the mid to to late 80s started building a
- 20:16collection of vintage cognacs and army yaks and Calvados.
- 20:20And you know, he, he wasn't selling them for what we would
- 20:23consider expensive today. You know, maybe 20 or 30 lbs of
- 20:27pour, but that was a a, a fortune back then for a single
- 20:32glass of something. And he's a very charismatic guy.
- 20:35And he would he would tell these stories about, you know, what
- 20:38were you doing when this bottle was made, when it was distilled.
- 20:41And you know, anyone would be seduced by him.
- 20:44And this is a very well to do bar.
- 20:45And he started selling a lot of vintage spirits.
- 20:48Now, this didn't necessarily start a sensation across Europe
- 20:51and certainly not in the USA. Few other bars dipped into it.
- 20:54It was very hard to source these bottles back then.
- 20:57So you couldn't, you couldn't build a collection.
- 21:00Salvatore's in his 70s now and he spent the last 40 plus years
- 21:04running bar programs in in, in the UK and, and beyond,
- 21:09continuing to source vintage bottles from all categories.
- 21:14You know, the products to make a legitimate James Bond Vesper
- 21:19martini from from 1960 is one of his favorite things to put
- 21:23together. He's still a big name on the
- 21:24scene. You know, I kind of stole this
- 21:27story for the book a bit. But you know, he said he'll get
- 21:31on a Zoom and and you'll be saying I got to go pick up my
- 21:33kids Salvatore and he'll keep talking and keep talking.
- 21:37He's got a lot. Of guys, yes.
- 21:40As an author, you're grateful. You want to tell me all this
- 21:42stuff. Thank you very much.
- 21:43But he he's probably been the most significant name for
- 21:47vintage spirits appreciation across the globe, for sure.
- 21:50Yeah, no. And I, I really admired, you
- 21:53know, how early on in the game, I remember I, I forget the base
- 21:58level, but I remember he took cells some something like 5 or
- 22:01609 to like 10,000. You said like out of nowhere.
- 22:05And it's like, you know, reading about he's telling people that
- 22:10this was distilled before World War One.
- 22:12This was distilled. Like he had one gentleman, I
- 22:15believe, crying because he was drinking the last of the bottle
- 22:18and said no one else will ever try this.
- 22:20And like it's like, I think that, you know, it was good to
- 22:25have him so early because that story that the tears over the
- 22:29last of this liquid did kind of reappear throughout the book.
- 22:34Kind of a theme of to drink or to hold that you always hear in
- 22:38wine just we have these bottles and it's history and it's a very
- 22:43much non renewable source that we have questions about how much
- 22:46there is. And the truth is, there's still
- 22:49old bottles out there to find, but there are a limited number
- 22:53of bottles. And there will be a day when the
- 22:55last bottle of Chinaco is opened and there's the last bottle of
- 22:59Pappy and. Yeah, I mean, I I would say it's
- 23:02the only collectible in the world that its own collectors
- 23:06willingly deplete. Yeah.
- 23:08You know, passionately, ardently.
- 23:12Yeah. No, it's so it's one of those
- 23:16things where, yeah, there's there's no getting past that,
- 23:19that tension like it's going away.
- 23:23But yeah, I don't, I don't know. It's it's something that I
- 23:25thought about as I was reading the book more and more.
- 23:27Just so where do you, where do you stand on that?
- 23:31Are you going to gift some bottles to your future, your
- 23:34your progeny, or or is yours going with you?
- 23:40You know, I always imagine myself on my deathbed going,
- 23:42damn, I didn't open that one bottle.
- 23:43Bring. Bring it to me.
- 23:45Bring it to me. Yeah.
- 23:47No, I, you know, I don't know if my kids will want this
- 23:49collection behind me. They got quite a few years to
- 23:52go. I'm sure by the time they're
- 23:54grown and they've lived around all these bottles for their
- 23:57entire childhoods, they'll not even want to look at this stuff.
- 23:59And they'll they'll join some religious faith that doesn't
- 24:03allow alcohol or whatnot. And.
- 24:05And talk badly about that. But no, I hope if you look
- 24:08behind me, I open most of my bottles because for me, I, I
- 24:13need to know what things taste like.
- 24:14So, you know, even if I have a very expensive bottle, if I
- 24:17don't, if I've never tasted it, the, the I'm just haunted by
- 24:21what it tastes like more than I'm haunted by depleting its
- 24:24value. So I, I'm a, I'm a collector of
- 24:29tastes and drinking more than I am of the actual bottles.
- 24:32Having said that, I don't like to fully kill bottles.
- 24:35Yeah, yeah. Especially ones that are rare
- 24:37that you can't get anymore. It's it's like that's, that's
- 24:40the end of the game there. Yeah.
- 24:43OK. Moving, moving through the book,
- 24:45if I remember correctly, chronologically through it.
- 24:48The next thing you hit that I thought was awesome was but is
- 24:52it legal? And this was something that it
- 24:54was ringing through my head while I was reading it because
- 24:57I, I grew up in Texas, but I spent a large part of my
- 25:01bartending career in New Mexico. And it's one of those states
- 25:04that it's like, there's not even corkage.
- 25:07You can't bring anything in. And so like, as I'm reading you
- 25:11like these people that are offering these dusty vintage
- 25:16spirits, I'm like, I know in New Mexico, this would not fly like
- 25:19you would. You would just straight be
- 25:21arrested. So I I was really glad that you
- 25:24touched on like, is this legal? Yeah.
- 25:27Because I. Mean there's been more you know,
- 25:30there's been strict states where places have open bars.
- 25:34I mean, yeah, you know, there's a lot of guys that have millions
- 25:40of dollars in bottles tied up in vintage bottles that are just on
- 25:43the shelves and. And I don't know, they're kind
- 25:46of trusting that that, you know, the, the ATP is not going to
- 25:54bust them or doesn't know what a a 1960s bottle of old granddad
- 25:58looks like compared to the modern one.
- 25:59But yeah, there's really never been a case as far as I know, of
- 26:06a bar getting in trouble for selling vintage.
- 26:10Is is New Mexico control state? No, no.
- 26:14So OK, yeah, you don't have to go to like a liquor store or
- 26:17something like I think Pennsylvania where it's like
- 26:19real intense. Yeah.
- 26:21Because the. Most most of the control states
- 26:23do not have vintage stores. But then again, North Carolina
- 26:26is a control state and, and Gary Crumkelton, a bar owner there,
- 26:30fought for laws to to sell it and, and so North Carolina's one
- 26:34of the only states where you can sell it.
- 26:38Yeah, I don't know. I think a lot of places have,
- 26:41you know, I, I, I think you'd be surprised the states where
- 26:44places have a, you know, perhaps a very small vintage menu.
- 26:47Maybe they don't advertise it online, but you know, maybe they
- 26:50pass it along with the dessert menu or to more valued customers
- 26:54and and sell them hush. Tones in the back rooms, yeah.
- 26:58Bar owners have always told me that that paying your taxes is
- 27:01number 1. And if you're paying your taxes,
- 27:05they're going to be a little less concerned about, you know,
- 27:07why. Why is that pre prohibition
- 27:10bought on the shelf? Well, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm
- 27:12making the state $1000 every time I, I finish one of them.
- 27:16So I don't know. Yeah, no, I think that is a
- 27:20good, a good point. It's there's this constant
- 27:23tension that exists in the bar and restaurant world of, you
- 27:28know, we're running a valuable service that people really
- 27:31appreciate and noticed when COVID was closed.
- 27:34But we are actually selling legally, you know, addictive
- 27:38drugs. And so like, it is a heavily
- 27:40regulated industry, for better or worse.
- 27:42Didn't. Yeah, you've gone up against
- 27:44that. The bar and.
- 27:45Restaurant world, especially in a place like New York, is always
- 27:49just very closely skirting the law.
- 27:52And you know, that's how it's worked since the beginning of
- 27:55time. So it.
- 27:56Is yeah, it's going to. Continue working that way.
- 28:03If you're enjoying this so far, please take a moment, hit like
- 28:06subscribe, share it with someone that you know would enjoy it.
- 28:10It mean the world to me. And it really does help this
- 28:12show grow. All right, back to it till the
- 28:20end of time. OK, Before, I would be really
- 28:26remorse if I didn't ask you about the rum section.
- 28:29So, yeah, I thought, you know, one of my favorite sections, I
- 28:34thought it was great to have sort of a nod to the fact that
- 28:38not all historical aspects of these products might be viewed
- 28:43in the best of light. Rum was definitely one that some
- 28:47of the history is a little more nuanced, if you will.
- 28:52And yeah, I mean, just all over the place.
- 28:54So writing, writing rum, what was that?
- 28:59Talk to me about rum. Yeah, I mean, so initially I had
- 29:05thought, well, I can write an entire book about vintage
- 29:09bourbon hunters that that was my expertise.
- 29:12And at a certain point I thought, well, that's not going
- 29:14to fill 400 pages and and the book's getting a little boring.
- 29:19So, you know, I started tackling each spirits category with rum.
- 29:24You know, I, through my previous work, I had a relationship with
- 29:27Martin Cate, who's the pre eminent tiki and rum connoisseur
- 29:31at Smuggler's Cove in, in San Francisco.
- 29:34Got on the phone with him and he, you know, after a 2 hour
- 29:38phone call, I, you know, it was so concise.
- 29:41I knew everything I thought I needed to know about vintage
- 29:43rummy. It was incredible in a way.
- 29:45I joke that Martin wrote that, that the, the rum chapter for
- 29:48me, rum is by far the hardest vintage category.
- 29:54It's still the one I probably know the least about because
- 29:57unlike the other other categories, it's made in in just
- 30:01about every country on earth. Tequila's made in in one place
- 30:04in one country. Bourbons made in in one country,
- 30:07and was mostly made in one state till recently.
- 30:09Scotch one country, etcetera etcetera.
- 30:11Rum's made everywhere. Literally everywhere, and they
- 30:15all have their own rules, yeah. They all have their own rules.
- 30:19A lot of a lot of name brand rums haven't made it to the
- 30:24present like bourbon. You know, these bourbon brands
- 30:26are have been around forever. So it's not very hard to go.
- 30:30You know, you find a bottle that says old Overholt on it from the
- 30:33past. Well, that's probably going to
- 30:34be pretty good because I've heard of that before.
- 30:36But there are rums from the past that will knock your socks off.
- 30:40And you've never heard of this brand in your life.
- 30:42You know you can, you can find a, a opening, opening day menu
- 30:47from Trader Vic's whenever the first Trader Vic's opened in
- 30:501937 or whatever and look at their rum menu and you know
- 30:56you'll, you will see the various prices.
- 30:58I think the highest you know most rums cost like 15 cents or
- 31:011/4 for a pour. You listed some as like the top
- 31:05end is like $0.85 I think, right?
- 31:07Exactly. That's it.
- 31:08Yeah. But.
- 31:09But, you know, you don't even have to have heard of these rums
- 31:11or do the conversion to the present to go, holy shit, there
- 31:15was a 30 year old rum for sale in 1937.
- 31:18Wow. There was a, you know, you're
- 31:20going, this stuff doesn't exist at any bar in New York City
- 31:24right now. Doesn't exist in any bar I've
- 31:25been to in America right now. So why was there so much
- 31:28incredible rum? And that, you know, was because
- 31:31during Prohibition, America rum's biggest customer was not
- 31:37drinking rum. So all these island nations were
- 31:40just aging their rum. Likewise, a lot of this great
- 31:45rum never went to stores. So unlike bourbon, you're not
- 31:49going to go into an old liquor store and find a lot of really
- 31:53old rum because it never made it to stores.
- 31:55It was going to this new wave of tiki bars opening in the 30s
- 32:00that were, you know, plowing through bottles of Ray and
- 32:03Nephew, you know, eighteen, 1718 year old back in the 30s.
- 32:09So, so rum's one of the hardest categories to be kind of a
- 32:13vintage expert on because there's just so much.
- 32:15You also need to know a lot of political, you know, stuff about
- 32:18when the Bacardi family had to flee Castro and start making
- 32:21their run in Puerto Rico. You know, I always joke like you
- 32:25don't even have to really like spirits or even drink to like my
- 32:28book. You will learn a lot about, you
- 32:30know, world events through reading it because alcohol in a
- 32:34way, is, is a reflection of what was going on in the world.
- 32:41Yeah. So I, I haven't even tasted a
- 32:42lot of vintage rum, quite frankly.
- 32:44I've, I've, I've tasted Cuban rum back when it was considered
- 32:48elite before Castro nationalized all the distilleries.
- 32:51I've tasted some, some vintage Jamaican from the past.
- 32:55But there's a ton of incredible rum out there, mostly in private
- 32:59collectors hands that who knows if they'll ever get back into
- 33:05the general public to taste. But rum?
- 33:08Rum's a category I'd definitely like to to taste more of the
- 33:11vintage spirits for sure. I feel like rum is actually one
- 33:15of those things that, unlike the kind of saturated bourbon
- 33:19market, you could actually have a chance because you don't have
- 33:22these people following these cult classics.
- 33:24If they're all closed and you just have a bunch of bottles and
- 33:28you could actually stand a chance to find some real gems if
- 33:31you're willing to put in some of the legwork, you know?
- 33:34Yeah, I mean, you know, pretty much any category but bourbon.
- 33:37Tequila has its own kind of nuts.
- 33:40But, you know, vintage cognac is still remarkably underpriced in
- 33:44my opinion. And you know, rum for sure.
- 33:48Sure, sure. I'm, you know, kind of taking us
- 33:53from one huge I'll defined category to the next Liqueurs.
- 33:59I thought, yeah, of course you're going.
- 34:01To head that way, yeah, again, you know, there's so much
- 34:08vintage liqueurs out there. If we just look at Italian
- 34:10tomorrow, you know, I think it was up until about World War 2,
- 34:17from what I, I've been told, Italians treated Amaro kind of
- 34:21just like, you know, Benadryl, like a cough medicine.
- 34:24So it wasn't really collected. It wasn't kept in bars.
- 34:27And likewise there was no massive players.
- 34:31Campari was around, of course, but just about every little town
- 34:36and just about all these, all these mom and pop shops were
- 34:38making their own Amaro. Because you don't, you don't
- 34:41need a still, you just need some alcohol and, and local herbs
- 34:46and, and what not. So you know, you'll you'll
- 34:51sometimes discover vintage Amaro or vintage liqueurs from Europe
- 34:56and you'll have never heard of them.
- 34:57They never made it to the present.
- 34:58They never got big, but they're incredible.
- 35:01Doesn't mean they're all incredible.
- 35:04The few that have made it, the Chartreuse's of the world,
- 35:07Campari, Benedictine, etcetera. Those are phenomenal as well.
- 35:10But there's there's lots of very minor mom and pop liqueurs from
- 35:14the past that you can't even find any anything written about
- 35:18them. No one remembers what it is.
- 35:21It's just, yeah, random bottle #2 yeah.
- 35:25Yeah, I mean, I, I found vintage Amaro in, in, in Rome because
- 35:29from what I understand, Italians don't really care for old Amaro.
- 35:36And you know, you, you can't find any information about this,
- 35:39this vintage Amaro and it, it tastes, tastes fantastic.
- 35:43One of the things that I was fascinated by and like
- 35:47transparently I've never had the chance to try old liqueurs the
- 35:53way you described their flavor changes.
- 35:56There were some of the ones where the flavor does actually
- 35:59evolve, it seems like, and the crystallization of the sugars.
- 36:03And so like, what does that even taste like?
- 36:05Do you actually, is it, does it become gritty or does it just
- 36:08change the mouth fill? How does How does that work?
- 36:11Yeah, yes. So because of the lower proof of
- 36:14most liqueurs and the sugar content, they will change in the
- 36:19bottle and, and the botanicals, certain botanicals will fall
- 36:22out, others might rise. You know, I've, I've talked to
- 36:26people who have, you know, vintage chartreuse collectors
- 36:30and they might buy an entire case of a year of chartreuse and
- 36:351 bottle tastes, you know, human heavy or something.
- 36:39And the next bottle tastes saffron heavy and the next
- 36:42taste. So just magical weird things
- 36:45happen in the bottle. In terms of the crystallization
- 36:50I've noticed with old chartreuse, kind of like the
- 36:55rock candy texture starts building up in, in, in the neck
- 36:59of the bottles. The the the actual liquid remain
- 37:05remains kind of like syrupy and oily.
- 37:09It doesn't I wouldn't describe it as gritty.
- 37:12The the crystalline build up is more like in the neck or in the
- 37:15in the the bottom of of the bottle.
- 37:17But it's really, really cool to look at and and old old
- 37:22chartreuse is about as good as it gets.
- 37:24So, I mean, it kind of serves as an unmistakable indication of
- 37:29age, but it's not so much that you're drinking it.
- 37:33Yeah, I mean, I, you know, I actually Bros, you could stick a
- 37:36knife in and break it up and. I mean, that's exactly what I
- 37:39want to. I want to try chartreuse, like
- 37:42rock candy. Yeah, that'd be pretty good,
- 37:45yeah. I I've only seen other people's
- 37:47bottles with the crystallization.
- 37:49I've never had my own so old that it's done that.
- 37:51But yeah, you know, I, I would like to taste that as well.
- 37:54Yeah. I also, I also think, you know,
- 37:57is it just that Chartreuse is such a strange liqueur having so
- 38:03many ingredients. They have the story where they
- 38:05got kicked out of France. So you have this transition to a
- 38:08different country and the secrecy around it.
- 38:11Like, so you have all these different elements to where,
- 38:14like, it's everything that you could think to put together for
- 38:17a cult classic all in one brand. Kind of, yeah.
- 38:20They say, they say there's only two monks that know all.
- 38:23I think it's 72 or three ingredients.
- 38:27You know, you can kind of guess a few of them, I suppose.
- 38:29But yeah, no one knows the ingredients.
- 38:32The, the monks have literal vows of silence, so they're not
- 38:35talking to you. You have to really go out into
- 38:38the Alps if you want to visit. And yeah, there's lots of weird
- 38:43bottlings over the years, both in Spain, as you mentioned, when
- 38:46they escaped, and in France. And most all of it's pretty,
- 38:50pretty damn good. Yeah.
- 38:52That's cool. And expensive.
- 38:54And expensive it is. Even the intro models are
- 38:57getting up there in Nebraska at least.
- 39:00Who knows? OK, is there anything that we
- 39:05haven't really touched on? I know we hit most of the major
- 39:10categories. Anything that I missed in the
- 39:12book that someone listening, you'd want them to a little
- 39:15teaser. They might might be sad that
- 39:18they never heard. Well, you know, a lot of people
- 39:21get excited. I'm going to start dusty on it
- 39:23and I'm like, slow down. Just find a vintage store and
- 39:26maybe maybe try a few pores at a a a price and see if you
- 39:31actually like the old stuff. Before you drop a couple
- 39:34thousand, yeah, OK, right. I think vintage cocktails is
- 39:39probably the next, the future of vintage is, is a lot of great
- 39:43bottles disappear and people want to start using up the their
- 39:47vintage vodkas and gins that no one's kind of buying by
- 39:50themselves. And I think you're starting to
- 39:52see more, more bars selling vintage cocktails because it's
- 39:57easier to clear those off the shelf and $1000 pours of, of, of
- 40:01whatnot. Sure, sure.
- 40:03Yeah, that is the future, isn't it?
- 40:06And you know, you mentioned their vodka.
- 40:08We didn't really talk about vodka, but you, you didn't
- 40:10really either. There's not a lot of vintage
- 40:13vodka out there, is there? Well, there's a lot of vintage
- 40:15vodka out there. There's just not really
- 40:17collectors, Yeah. But.
- 40:20They're, you know, my friend Seth Weinberg, who's one of the
- 40:24top collectors and he's written about heavily in the book.
- 40:28He does collect vintage vodka. And he told me, well, you know,
- 40:31one day when I, you know, have my bar where I'm, when I'm
- 40:34selling vintage gin martinis and and great pours of old bourbon,
- 40:40that one friend's going to come on who only drinks vodka.
- 40:42Well, OK, I got a vintage vodka for you then.
- 40:44So. Yeah, I, I, yeah, I should
- 40:50should have been clear. It's not that you don't talk
- 40:52about vodka at all. It's just compared to the other
- 40:55categories, it's pretty toned down.
- 40:57Yeah. So yeah.
- 40:59I mean, you know, even even with vintage gin, which a lot of
- 41:03people don't like because they think that Juniper falls out, I
- 41:06don't necessarily agree with that.
- 41:09There are collectors and there's tons of tons of people who have
- 41:13a urge for vintage martinis, vintage Negronis, etcetera.
- 41:17There's just not, you know, the kind of person who only drinks
- 41:21vodka is probably not the kind of person who's also pursuing
- 41:25weird old bottles of it. As I mentioned, the vintage
- 41:28Vespers a a bit of a a vintage cocktail favorite and that needs
- 41:32vodka too, so. Sure, sure.
- 41:34I mean, you get the the King of the lay is really the start
- 41:36there, I feel. But.
- 41:38That's right. No, you're right.
- 41:39Yeah. Awesome.
- 41:41Yeah, I think it's probably time for us to go make a vintage
- 41:45cocktail. Celebrate.
- 41:48Celebrate your awesome book, Aaron.
- 41:50Where? Where could someone who's
- 41:51listening find out more about you and find some more of your
- 41:54books? And where?
- 41:55Where should people follow you online?
- 41:57You know, you can follow me on Instagram, Aaron Goldfarb.
- 42:00I do not post a ton, but you can see what I'm drinking.
- 42:05And yeah, my books are wherever books are sold.
- 42:08And I, I, I, I write stories too, for Vine pair and other
- 42:13places. And yeah, I'm all over the
- 42:15Internet. Awesome, awesome.
- 42:17Yeah, and go pick up Dusty Boos in search of vintage spirits is
- 42:22super fun book, lot of cool history.
- 42:25And then we didn't really touch on specific brands, but there's
- 42:28also brands in each section that kind of tell you the must, must
- 42:32search and then kind of the extra goodies, so.
- 42:36It's a bit of a CHEAT SHEET, yeah.
- 42:37It's a Hunter's Yeah, got a collectible Pokémon of vintage
- 42:43spirits right there. Yeah.
- 42:44Well, my biggest fear was, you know, the book came out a year
- 42:47ago. I thought all those brands will
- 42:50be, you know, shifted to other brands by the time that book
- 42:53comes out. But they've they've kind of
- 42:55remained the same. So yeah, there's a good little
- 42:56CHEAT SHEET in there for you. Yeah, if you, if you name
- 43:00quality, quality doesn't shift that quickly.
- 43:02You know, it's true. These are still the high end
- 43:04brands that people are looking for and awesome.
- 43:07Well, hi, thanks for taking a moment to talk to us today and
- 43:10appreciate it. All right, that's the end of the
- 43:15show. Thank you for listening to
- 43:17Serves You Right. My name is Andrew.
- 43:20If you have not, please hit like subscribe, send to a friend.
- 43:24The more listeners we get, the more subscribers, the more cool
- 43:27guests we can get and the more cool things we can do.
- 43:31All right, that's it. Episodes of this podcast come
- 43:35out every Tuesday and Thursday and we'll see you soon.
- 43:39Thanks.