Latest / Culture Project: Creativity, art & storytelling / The Courage to Submit: Why Rejection Letters Are Part of the Art | Culture Project
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that lives in your inbox after you hit send on a submission, and it’s heavier than any rejection letter ever could be. It’s the moment where you hand over the only thing you have left of yourself and realize you can’t control what happens next. Let’s talk about that pause. You know the one. The five seconds between clicking 'submit' and the screen finally confirming receipt. Your heart does this little flutter, like a bird trapped in a ribcage, hoping against hope that maybe this time, they’ll see it. Maybe this time, it’s enough. I’ve been there, Leona here, sitting in my kitchen with cold tea going cold, watching the progress bar creep forward as if it’s moving through molasses. And then, the relief washes over you, but so does this terrifying vulnerability. Because once it’s gone, it’s not yours anymore. It belongs to the editors, the readers, the algorithm of chance. You are no longer the creator; you are the candidate. And being a candidate feels awful, doesn’t it? It feels small. It feels like standing naked in a gallery full of strangers who might just walk past without glancing twice. I used to work in an archive in London, restoring old books. Do you know what it’s like to hold a page that was written three hundred years ago? The ink has faded, the paper is brittle, but the words still burn with intent. Those writers didn’t know if their books would survive, let alone be read. They sent their words into the void, trusting that someone, someday, would care enough to pick them up. Today, we have competitive journals. Literary magazines. Online platforms. They promise connection, but they often deliver judgment. I remember reading a submission guideline once that said, 'We are looking for voices that challenge the status quo.' But how do you challenge the status quo when you’re terrified of being deleted from existence? We polish our sentences until they shine, we check the rhythm, we make sure every comma is doing its job, all while wondering if the editor even cares about commas or just wants something loud and new. Beauty is messy, isn’t it? The messiness of hoping too much is part of the price we pay for being heard. Remember that episode about drawing comics about houseplants? We talked about the freedom of creating without an audience. There’s a strange irony in that. When we create for ourselves, for the leaves, for the quiet corner of the room, we are free. But submission demands an audience before the work is ready. It asks us to perform empathy for people we haven’t met yet. We start writing with the ghost of the editor in the room. We imagine her sighing, imagining him scrolling past. This anxiety changes the texture of the prose. It becomes defensive. It tries too hard to be clever, too eager to please. And that’s when the art suffers. I’ve seen brilliant writers choke themselves with expectations. They write what they think the journal wants instead of what only they can say. Let’s look closer at that impulse. Why do we want their approval more than we want to tell the truth? Is it because we’re afraid that if they don’t like it, we aren’t good enough? Or is it because we’ve forgotten that the act of creation is the victory, not the acceptance? Then comes the email. Or the lack thereof. Six weeks pass. Then twelve. Then a generic form letter that says, 'While we enjoyed reading your piece, it wasn’t quite right for us.' It’s polite. It’s kind. And it cuts deeper than any insult ever could. Because it implies you were almost there. So close. But not quite. I used to keep those letters in a box. A physical box, heavy with guilt. I’d take them out on rainy Sundays and read them like horoscopes, searching for meaning in the vague feedback. 'Needs more punch,' one said. 'Too lyrical for our taste,' said another. But here’s the thing I learned slowly, painfully: rejection is rarely about the quality of the work. It’s about fit. It’s about timing. It’s about whether the editor is hungry for that specific flavor today. Your poem might be perfect, but if they’re looking for essays this month, it’s a failure of logistics, not art. Yet, our brains don’t process it that way. They hear 'not right' and translate it to 'not me.' That translation is the lie we have to unlearn. So what do we do with the ache? How do we keep creating when the door keeps closing? We treat the rejection like a collaborator. Not a harsh critic, but a distant friend who loves you enough to tell you the truth. I started viewing each 'no' as a data point, not a verdict. One journal said my narrative voice was too unreliable. Another said it was too controlled. Which is it? Well, it’s both. It’s complex. And that complexity is exactly why I should keep writing. The anxiety of submitting fades when you realize that every great writer has a graveyard of unpublished stories. Sylvia Plath had rejections. Raymond Carver had rejections. They didn’t stop. They revised. They submitted again. They understood that submission is part of the craft, not separate from it. It’s the bridge between the private self and the public world. And bridges are supposed to bear weight. If it doesn’t feel heavy, you’re probably not building anything worth crossing. Maybe it’s time to redefine success. Not as the acceptance letter, but as the courage to send the piece out. That tiny click of the mouse is an act of bravery. It’s you saying, 'I believe this matters.' Even if no one else agrees, you believed it. That belief is the seed. Without it, there is no tree. I think about the hands that held those old books in the archive. Did they care if the book was famous? Probably not. They cared if the story helped them get through the winter. That’s what we need to return to. The intimacy of the exchange. The desire to connect, not to conquer. When you submit, you are casting a net into the ocean. Most days, you catch nothing. But sometimes, you catch a whale. And even if you don’t, you are still fishing. You are still participating in the ancient human ritual of sharing our inner lives with the outer world. Don’t let the fear of empty hands stop you from reaching out. Keep your pen sharp and your heart soft. I’m rooting for you, always. Until next time, keep creating, even when it’s scary. Love, Leona.