Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep4: GRD004 - Should I Buy Long Term Care Insurance or Self Fund?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement strategy
- 0:21or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to
- 0:33argue and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Jeff Levine: Well, welcome back to the great retirement debate.
- 1:05Ed.
- 1:05It's good to be with you again.
- 1:07Ed Slott: Great to be back here.
- 1:08I'm Ed Slott with Jeff Levine and you are listening to the great retirement debate.
- 1:12Jeff Levine: You know, I feel like every time you say the name, ed, it
- 1:15just, the debate becomes greater.
- 1:16I mean, it just it's good.
- 1:19It's good, ed.
- 1:20What's our, what's our topic today?
- 1:21What are we gonna be discussing?
- 1:22What are we gonna be arguing about?
- 1:23Debating
- 1:24Ed Slott: all right.
- 1:25Uh, a big, big topic, serious topic, long term care for those big expenses.
- 1:31Do you get a long term care policy or do you just try it on your own and self fund?
- 1:38Jeff Levine: All right.
- 1:39Well, let's flip the coin.
- 1:41Here we go.
- 1:44All right.
- 1:44Winner, winner, chicken dinner, ed.
- 1:45I get to pick.
- 1:47Alright.
- 1:48And I'll, uh, I'll take the side of let's buy insurance and
- 1:52you can argue for self-funding.
- 1:54Ed Slott: Okay.
- 1:55I'll argue self-funding go ahead.
- 1:57Jeff Levine: I'll kick it off and just say like, Hey, when we think
- 1:59about things that may happen in life long term care or the need for long
- 2:05term care, is really high up there.
- 2:09You know, when we think about, will you get into a car accident
- 2:11this year, ed, thankfully for most people, the answer is no.
- 2:14Will you die this year?
- 2:16Thankfully for most people, the answer is no.
- 2:19Uh, will you become disabled?
- 2:21More likely than, uh, you know, more people end up needing disability
- 2:25insurance than they do life insurance, but still the answer for most
- 2:29people is that they won't need it.
- 2:30But when we talk about long term care, long term care is one of those
- 2:35things where you are more likely to actually need it at some point.
- 2:40Then not need it, you know, thanks to our incredible medical advances
- 2:45and longevity getting pushed out.
- 2:47Uh, we now have situations where people are living a lot longer, but for many of
- 2:52those individuals, a lot more of those years require some additional form of
- 2:58care and that care can be all over, right.
- 3:00It can be whether it's just a little bit of home healthcare up to, and
- 3:03including, you know, skilled nursing facility, all of which would qualify,
- 3:08uh, as some form of long term care.
- 3:10Ed Slott: Yeah, it's just about, uh, a certainty.
- 3:13It's not if, but when, you know, if you're gonna live a, a long time, uh, these
- 3:19things are so bad now I gotta tell you over the last, I'd say about 10 years.
- 3:25It's not unusual to see tax returns that claim over a hundred thousand
- 3:30dollars of medical expenses, whether it's nurses aides, or nursing
- 3:35homes, or, uh, modifications of homes, ramps, and railings and
- 3:40chairlifts and stair lifts and, uh, bathroom and kitchen modifications..
- 3:45Jeff Levine: As you know, I'm building a house as we record this.
- 3:47And in that house is going an elevator for my, an elevator for my nonagenarian
- 3:54grandparents so that they can get around.
- 3:56Ed Slott: And these are big ticket items.
- 3:58So there's no question it has to be planned for.
- 4:01So why would I take the side of self-funding?
- 4:03Jeff Levine: Well I was just gonna ask you that.
- 4:04I'm glad you brought it up.
- 4:06Ed Slott: yeah, so I acknowledge the problem.
- 4:08And in fact, anybody that's watched any of my programs or been at
- 4:11any of my seminars, I always, uh, talk about having funds funding.
- 4:16For long term care.
- 4:18I just don't agree with the actual long term care policies.
- 4:22Not that I don't agree.
- 4:23I don't really understand a lot of the policies.
- 4:26It seems like the, the current current policies I'm not
- 4:30talking about the back ones.
- 4:31My mother had one from 20 years ago is the best thing we ever had.
- 4:34It paid like crazy in her last years.
- 4:37But the more recent versions where the insurance companies have
- 4:41tightened up and realized, oh, we can't pay all of that amount out.
- 4:44So they've cut back.
- 4:45They've increased the costs.
- 4:47I don't see the certainty there.
- 4:48So I believe in the need.
- 4:50I think it can be done a different way, even though I'm arguing on the
- 4:54side of self-funding, I'm not really calling it self-funding in other words,
- 4:59It can be done through different means it has to be funded, but maybe where
- 5:04you are in more control, I'll give you one example, uh, life insurance.
- 5:08I have this for myself and my family, these cash value policies.
- 5:12A lot of the new ones are these hybrid type of, uh, policies
- 5:16that have long-term care riders.
- 5:18And if it's needed in its most simplest form.
- 5:22In essence, taking in advance on your life insurance.
- 5:26Yes.
- 5:26The children will get less, but they won't have to dig into their
- 5:29pockets every month for your care.
- 5:31Nobody wants that.
- 5:33So I think that might be a better way if your insurable, not
- 5:37everyone is to fund it yourself.
- 5:41Jeff Levine: Oh, it's a, it's an interesting argument.
- 5:43I give you two counters to the, to the thought of maybe purchasing a, a life
- 5:48insurance with long-term care hybrid type of policy versus a, a traditional
- 5:53type of long-term care policy.
- 5:55The first is, uh, well, It's never gonna be as good, maybe three
- 6:00reasons, a never gonna be as good.
- 6:01And, and as cost effective, if you need long-term care as a, a true long-term
- 6:07care, kind of like a, the car insurance version of long-term care, right?
- 6:10Pay your premium.
- 6:11If you need long-term care, there's a benefit.
- 6:13If you don't you've paid.
- 6:14Ed Slott: Oh, don't tell me, you're gonna say, only pay for what you need.
- 6:18Jeff Levine: Oh, no, no, , I'm not, I'm not doing one of those car commercials.
- 6:21No, no, but what I am gonna say is that you and I are tax people, right?
- 6:25We're tax nerds, uh, at, at heart.
- 6:27And there is no tax deduction for the premiums you pay for those life
- 6:31insurance with long term care policies.
- 6:33Whereas there is a federal deduction, uh, for, or at least the
- 6:38cost of a long term care policy, depending upon how old you are.
- 6:42There are different federal amounts that can be deducted each year
- 6:46as a qualified medical expense.
- 6:48So it may help you to increase your itemized deductions and thereby
- 6:51actually defer some of that cost if you're able to itemize, and if you're
- 6:55able to take those medical expense deductions, which admittedly, and I'll,
- 6:59I'll throw out one for you here, ed, I know you've gotta have more than
- 7:02seven and a half percent of your AGI.
- 7:04So some, some people may not get that, and even if they do, they may be limited
- 7:08by the overall standard deduction.
- 7:09Cause that's higher.
- 7:10But for a lot of people that can help to increase their overall deductions
- 7:15and thereby minimize the cost.
- 7:16The other thing though, and I think my bigger issue with those type
- 7:19of policies is that it actually creates a disincentive to use the
- 7:24insurance that you actually bought.
- 7:26So ed, if you were.
- 7:27Um, uh, well, let, let's share some back history here.
- 7:30I said I was building a house.
- 7:31You've built a house before, but it's the house you already had, right?
- 7:35You had to rebuild a house years ago when hurricane Sandy came in.
- 7:40Right.
- 7:40And destroyed.
- 7:41Unfortunately, uh, the house I remember going in and opening a
- 7:44draw with you and all of a sudden water came out, like one of those,
- 7:48uh, you know, one of those movies..
- 7:49Ed Slott: Water, water everywhere.
- 7:50Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 7:52There was more than a drop to spare at that point, but you, you
- 7:55didn't think about whether to call your insurance company, right?
- 7:58You just did, because you paid for that insurance over the years.
- 8:02And if you didn't call you, weren't gonna get a benefit.
- 8:03Is that fair?
- 8:05Ed Slott: Yeah, that's fair.
- 8:06But that's a different kind of insurance there, right?
- 8:08Jeff Levine: Well, but if you buy the life insurance with long term
- 8:11care kind of hybrid, it almost creates a disincentive to use it.
- 8:15For instance, let's say that, uh, Let's say that you have an IRA that has a
- 8:20million dollars in it, and you also have a million dollar, uh, life insurance with
- 8:25long-term care product right associated with it, where you can use up to the
- 8:29million dollars over a period of time to cover the cost of your long-term care.
- 8:34Well, if I had a traditional long-term care policy, as soon as
- 8:37I needed care, I'd be calling the insurance company and saying, send
- 8:40me my money, because if I don't use.
- 8:42I lose it.
- 8:43Right.
- 8:44But with the life insurance and long term care policy, if I don't use it as long
- 8:48term care, it's there for life insurance.
- 8:50And so I may be even more tempted to let's say, use my IRA to take that out
- 8:55because that IRA may be, uh, you know, if I'm using, it's say for a nursing home
- 9:00and I'm paying a hundred thousand dollars a year, almost all of my distribution
- 9:04will end up being deductible and that could end up creating a situation
- 9:08where I burn down my, my livable assets during my lifetime or for a spouse,
- 9:14because I'm using my IRA because I wanna leave the tax free life insurance.
- 9:18If I don't use it for long term care, it becomes tax free life insurance.
- 9:21Where if I leave my IRA, it's taxable.
- 9:24So it almost creates this like we are disincentive to use the
- 9:28insurance that you just bought.
- 9:30Ed Slott: Oh good.
- 9:31You just made my argument for self-funding.
- 9:34Of course I would.
- 9:35If I had the IRA, I would definitely use that IRA.
- 9:39Uh, because that, I mean, you're getting the money out at, at full deductions.
- 9:44Yes.
- 9:44If the money is big enough, you will get big tax deductions and
- 9:48that's the best thing you can do.
- 9:50You're getting rid of that otherwise taxable income on money that has to
- 9:54be spent anyway for medical bills.
- 9:56So why not get a big tax benefit out of it and bring down the balance on
- 10:00those IRAs this way, the beneficiaries, if you're so worried about the
- 10:04beneficiaries, they'll get better money.
- 10:07If you don't touch the life insurance policy.
- 10:09You're right.
- 10:09There's an incentive there.
- 10:11If you have both, if you have the traditional IRA and the life insurance
- 10:16policy with the long term care rider, you're better off using the traditional
- 10:20IRA, getting the tax deductions and leaving your beneficiaries that windfall,
- 10:25they get from the full policy amount, the policy proceeds at death, which haven't
- 10:30been hit for the long term care payment.
- 10:32So they're gonna end up in a better shape, but if you are listening to this, which
- 10:36you are, if you hear me talking, uh, you should always do what's best for you.
- 10:40People ask me that all the time.
- 10:42I said, don't worry about your kids.
- 10:43They're gonna be fine.
- 10:45You have to take care of yourself first.
- 10:47So if I was their advisor, I might say to take down that IRA first, anyway,
- 10:52for the tax benefits, they might like to hear that the kids will get more,
- 10:57but then they'll keep building more of that cash value for themselves.
- 11:00And if they need it for their own care and retirement, they can take it.
- 11:04Or for other reasons, they can tap into that cash value, which is just gonna
- 11:07grow the longer they don't use it.
- 11:11Jeff Levine: Again, I think those are, are all fair arguments to make, but
- 11:14ed let's think about what happens when you actually need this cost of care.
- 11:18Right?
- 11:18We, we said it could be pretty expensive.
- 11:21Uh, one of the, one of the insurance companies out there
- 11:23Genworth each year runs, uh, kind of an annual cost of care service.
- 11:27And we can put the link to that, uh, that site in our show notes here for folks
- 11:30the, you know, the average, the average, the, the, the monthly median cost for 2021
- 11:38for a semi-private room was about $8,000.
- 11:43Now that's about $8,000, but that includes high cost of living
- 11:47areas, low cost of living areas.
- 11:49If I take an area, let's say, uh, Where like close to your neck of the woods.
- 11:55And, and we put that in and we say, how much, you know, would that be in,
- 11:58in a particular area, like a, in a, in a New York area comparatively, right?
- 12:04That becomes just astronomical.
- 12:07We're talking about over $12,000 a month.
- 12:10That's $150,000 a year.
- 12:14Even if you've accumulated a good amount over the course of your lifetime, that
- 12:18could very quickly erode your portfolio.
- 12:20If you're married, uh, how do they have, does your spouse have enough income?
- 12:25Uh, and of course, once you need it, then it's too late to get it right.
- 12:28And so, the idea that.
- 12:31You know, and here's one other thought for you, ed, you know, some
- 12:35people may be fortunate enough.
- 12:37Well, I don't know.
- 12:38I guess you can look at that as two sides of the coin as well.
- 12:40They're fortunate enough not to need long term care for a long time because
- 12:44they go in and, and they, you know, they either they pass or much less likely
- 12:49they end up not needing long-term care.
- 12:51Right?
- 12:51Most people, once you need long-term care, you need long-term care.
- 12:54And, and that's gonna be that way forever.
- 12:56About 20%, according to recent government research.
- 13:00And we can put the link to that study in our show notes as well,
- 13:02about 20% of people will need that care for more than five years.
- 13:08So there's kind of this long tail risk where, you know, if you have, let's
- 13:12say Alzheimer's or some other cognitive decline where you know, your heart
- 13:16works great, your, you know, your, your, your bodily body, function's fine.
- 13:20But maybe it's just a situation where, you know, you need help because of cognitive
- 13:25decline or there's just a serious physical injury that is not life threatening.
- 13:29It just means you require a lot of care.
- 13:31You could end up needing long term care services.
- 13:34A decade in some cases or more.
- 13:36Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 13:36Well, I agree it has to be planned for, but I'm not sure seeing the current
- 13:41types of long term care policies out there, whether, uh, you would get all
- 13:47of that without paying a fortune and every story I see recently, I'd say
- 13:53going back the last five years, when this comes up, they're all, all the
- 13:57insurance companies are going to the state regulators to raise their premiums.
- 14:01And then it comes to a point where people are starting to say, I can't afford
- 14:04the long term care insurance anymore.
- 14:06I'll just wait.
- 14:07And, uh, that's why I would take the idea of self-funding.
- 14:13Uh, planning for it, not, not having it, but self-funding by planning in other
- 14:18ways, life insurance is one may way.
- 14:20May not be the only way building up a large IRA may be a way and if it happens,
- 14:24it happens, but you don't have to come up with the money until it happens.
- 14:29Jeff Levine: Yeah, I'll throw maybe one more out there.
- 14:31And that's the idea that if you buy certain types of insurance, you may be
- 14:35able to protect, uh, additional assets.
- 14:38So of course, if you find yourself in this situation, right where you do need
- 14:42long-term care or spouse needs long-term care, uh, in most places in most states
- 14:47and medicaid is a very complex program.
- 14:52It's a state and federal partnership.
- 14:54And so the rules vary dramatically sometimes between
- 14:57states and different locations.
- 14:58But you know, in most places you have to spend most of your own assets.
- 15:04And the assets that belong to your spouse, right?
- 15:07Income is generally looked at individually, but assets are generally
- 15:10treated as though they belong to both of you and that can, you know, if you run out
- 15:15of money, if you get to the point where you are, are so low in assets, uh, and
- 15:20income that you now qualify for Medicaid, you know, in, in some places, the care
- 15:25you receive may not be as, as, as strong.
- 15:27That's the, um, One of the best things about some insurance policies.
- 15:31In some states, they have these, what are are called partnership programs, where
- 15:35if you purchase a, a qualifying long term care policy, the state will actually
- 15:40allow you to keep more of your own assets.
- 15:42In other words, you can go on Medicaid sooner, uh, with a higher level of
- 15:46assets, and that will protect more for, let's say, a surviving spouse than
- 15:52if you don't buy these long term care policies, you may have to dwindle down
- 15:55your assets to, you know, pretty, pretty.
- 16:00Slim pickings at some point,
- 16:01Ed Slott: Right, but you could be dwindling down your assets, just paying
- 16:04the premiums every month, over a long period of time when you didn't need the
- 16:08money when you didn't need the care.
- 16:10Jeff Levine: Well, that's true.
- 16:11And, but, but you know, ed, it's a, it's a, you make a great point there,
- 16:15but I, I will make the counterpoint.
- 16:17And I always, like, I talk about this with social security as well.
- 16:19People say, well, what if I die?
- 16:21Great.
- 16:22So you died and you didn't run out of money, like here.
- 16:25All right.
- 16:25So you paid like, do you walk around every year going, ah, shucks, this year,
- 16:29I didn't get into a car accident and I paid all that money for car insurance
- 16:31or, oh man, I I'm hoping for do, do you hope for another hurricane ed?
- 16:35So you have to rebuild your house again so you can call the insurance company.
- 16:38Ed Slott: Nobody wants that, but you have to look at how far your assets will go.
- 16:43And when to spend them down, I guess, is the real answer.
- 16:46Do I wanna spend them down right now, monthly payments
- 16:49while I can get the policies?
- 16:51Because if you don't do it while you're healthy, it's almost impossible.
- 16:55Once the situation occurs where you need long term care, it's going
- 16:58to be very difficult to get it.
- 17:00Even the way I'm saying through a life insurance policy.
- 17:03Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 17:04And I think maybe that's one of the best points uh, we could make is that if you're
- 17:08thinking about this, doing it while you're younger, while you're healthier, can
- 17:12be, uh, can be a pretty powerful thing.
- 17:15And, uh, you know, I, and I think while as we come to kind of the,
- 17:19the end of this debate for today, I would be remiss if we didn't.
- 17:23Even though it's to, to, to the point of maybe more self-funding, I'd be
- 17:27remiss if I didn't really hit on the issue of, uh, that, and you, you
- 17:31touched on it before of people going back to the insurance regulators.
- 17:34So as many people know, you know, insurance is kind is
- 17:38a, is a regulated thing.
- 17:39You have to follow state guidelines.
- 17:42There are some federal laws as well that can apply in certain cases.
- 17:45Uh, but when we're talking about long term care insurance, generally
- 17:49someone can't say like, You were healthy years ago when you bought
- 17:53this policy, but now you're not.
- 17:56And so now we're going to increase your premium that's general.
- 17:58Ed Slott: Oh, that's not what I was talking about.
- 18:00Jeff Levine: Correct.
- 18:00Right.
- 18:00I just wanna make sure that people understand that.
- 18:02Talking about regular cost increases because the costs are going up.
- 18:06And in most cases, insurers kind of, I don't wanna say they promise, but they
- 18:11strongly hinted that their premiums may not rise, but costs are so much,
- 18:17so insurers have kind of been hit by a, a, almost like a trifecta, right?
- 18:21People are living longer.
- 18:23Uh, we we've got costs of care that have dramatically risen
- 18:27that have outpaced inflation.
- 18:28So people needing care for more years, that care is more expensive than ever.
- 18:33And the other thing that goes into this is that interest rates have been low.
- 18:36So the insurance companies, right years ago, when they bought these,
- 18:40you know, when they, when they took in these dollars and said, Hey,
- 18:43we've gotta save these dollars and grow them for the future amounts.
- 18:47We'll have to pay out.
- 18:48They assumed that they were going to be actually generating some
- 18:51sort of real interest on them.
- 18:53And for a really long time, interest rates have been pretty low.
- 18:58And so insurance companies in, in large respects, haven't made near the
- 19:01returns that they were counting on for years and so we do see that a lot
- 19:06of times where they go back and will be able to increase for everyone in
- 19:10a certain class, like all 45 years..
- 19:12Ed Slott: If you don't have stability in your monthly expenses, I guess that's,
- 19:15what's bothering me about paying it out monthly, but the bottom line with
- 19:19all of this, I think we both agree it has to be planned for and prepared
- 19:24for, because at some point it, it could be a likely thing in your life.
- 19:28So however you prepare, whether it's the self funding through IRAs or
- 19:32life insurance, or actually going out and researching a long term
- 19:35care policy, something should be done while you're healthy enough.
- 19:39Like hopefully right now to do it.
- 19:41Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 19:41I, I agree.
- 19:42I, I think, uh, without a doubt, when you create your retirement plan, It's
- 19:48understanding what the impact would be if there's a long term care event
- 19:52or need and how that might impact look, if, if you I'll make the extreme
- 19:57example, if you've got a hundred million dollars in the bank and you
- 19:59wanna, self-insure like, okay, fine.
- 20:03Uh, that would be just fine.
- 20:04But if you have a scenario where, you know, you've got
- 20:07a million dollars or so, and.
- 20:10You know, having that long term care need could mean a spouse goes from
- 20:13living in a really nice apartment to living in a, not so nice apartment or
- 20:17from driving their nice car to never having another car again, you know,
- 20:22that's something you wanna be aware of.
- 20:24And so just running the numbers, crunching the numbers.
- 20:26I, I, I think is probably the, the critical element here and just
- 20:29understand how that would impact you.
- 20:32And then from there, Whether you decide to insure, self-insure, whatever
- 20:36it is there it's up to you agreed?
- 20:39Ed Slott: That's right.
- 20:39That's all.
- 20:40Jeff Levine: So we actually agree on something in this debate.
- 20:43That's fantastic.
- 20:44Uh, and, and with that, ed, this is obviously a huge topic because most
- 20:48people are likely to need long-term care at some point in their life,
- 20:52especially if they're fortunate enough to live those long lifetimes.
- 20:55Right.
- 20:55If they, if they don't pass away early, which certainly we would hope.
- 20:59Um, alright, well, ed, you know, there are two sides to every coin.
- 21:03Your life and retirement decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 21:08And that's why one thing that you and I always agree on is making sure
- 21:12that you're talking through any big decision like this with a knowledgeable
- 21:16financial advisor or tax professional, so that you could weigh the pros and
- 21:19the cons of different options against your specific goals and objectives.
- 21:23If you'd like to continue the discussion with Ed and I we'd love to hear from
- 21:26you, you can reach out to Ed on Twitter using the handle @TheSlottReport, that's
- 21:31at the Slott report with two T's and slot, or you can reach out to me using
- 21:35the handle @CPAPlanner . Uh, if you think we missed something or you think a
- 21:38particular side of the issue is, is more important, or you just like to suggest a
- 21:42topic for a future debate, let us know, let us hear from you and until then,
- 21:47uh, ed always fun, always educational.
- 21:50I know every time we chat, I learn something new in myself.
- 21:53So, uh, thanks and look forward to our next debate!
- 21:57Ed Slott: OK, Jeff, I'll see you on the next great retirement debate.
- 22:01OUTRO: Jeffrey levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham wealth partners.
- 22:04This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 22:07not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 22:11Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 22:14which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 22:16Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's.
- 22:20And completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 22:21The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 22:24and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.