Latest / THE BEV JOHNSON SHOW / Dr. Kristen Henning
Transcript
- 0:08That just show time with this talking and home away you go, you go,
- 0:19soking Ready time show show. Let's go be john Well, make your
- 0:31dame find here on the d to listen to what to fay? You know,
- 0:40it's time for the better Fish show time show. Let's go. Good
- 0:47afternoon, and welcome back to the second half of the BEB Johnson Show here
- 0:52on w D. I A. I'm excited about my nick's guest. She
- 0:58is nationally record kick NAS legal scholar and activists and I'm sure she'll tell us
- 1:03more about that in juvenile justice reform. She is doctor Christian Henning and her
- 1:10book is called The Rage of Innocence, How America Criminalizes Black Youth. And
- 1:17want to say welcome, Welcome, Welcome to doctor Kristen Henning. How are
- 1:23you, doctor an in good, good afternoon. Thank you so much for
- 1:26having me. I'm happy to be here. I am doing well today and
- 1:30excited about the conversation. I am excited about the conversation as well. We
- 1:34heard about your book, doctor Henning, from our psychologists and mental health specialists,
- 1:41our brother doctor Warren Harper, and he talked about your book. Oh
- 1:44my goodness. We found out a lot of things but I'm excited to talk
- 1:48with you. I know you are coming to Memphis. You will be here
- 1:52July twenty fifth for the African Village Institute and slave Haven Underground Railroad Museum.
- 2:00They will host you in a very critical moment. But before we talk about
- 2:05your book, tell our listeners doctor Hemming a little bit more about doctor Kristen
- 2:09Henning. Well, I'm going to start with the fact that my family roots
- 2:15are deeply embedded in Memphis, Tennessee. So I grew up by in my
- 2:21childhood in Nashville, Tennessee, but all of my family, the Henting family,
- 2:27is rooted in Memphis. That was our home and our connection, and
- 2:32I still have extended family there and I call family in laws in the Lee
- 2:38family there as well. So that's the first. I am a Southern child
- 2:45who ultimately became a lawyer. And when I decided that I wanted to be
- 2:50a lawyer, I knew that I had a passion for children's issues. I
- 2:55come from a family of teachers and preachers, and everyone was comitted to working
- 3:00with young people. Really, I don't even like the word at risk,
- 3:06but you know, young people with promise, and so my you know,
- 3:09work in the law really is grounded in that. So that's sort of my
- 3:15first thing to consider. And then I realized that my specialty specialty should be
- 3:22in juvenile delinquency and children who are perceived to be criminal, either by way
- 3:31of prosecution in the criminal legal system or in the juvenile legal system. So
- 3:37that very much became my specialty. And you can't do this work for as
- 3:40long as I have, And I should stop and say, I've been representing
- 3:44children now for more than twenty six years. Yeah, and mostly in the
- 3:52nation's capital, but in other places. And you know, you can't do
- 3:55that work for very long without really recognizing what extraordinary racial disparities there are in
- 4:04both the juvenile and criminal legal system. Which, then, doctor Henning,
- 4:12are you yeah? I think I lost doctor Henning. I didn't it.
- 4:15Maybe her phone. Hopefully she will call me back. Let's see, doctor
- 4:25Henning. You there, No, I lost her. Maybe she will call
- 4:28me back. Oh my goodness, Oh, hopefully she'll call me back.
- 4:31It's getting good, good, and good. I'm speaking with speaking with doctor
- 4:36Christian Henning. And as you all well know that doctor Harper talked about her
- 4:41book The Rage of Innocence, How America criminalizes black youth and doctor Henning,
- 4:47I hope, I hope you called me back, and cope me called me
- 4:49back, or Norman, if you're listening, if you can get to her,
- 4:54because I don't have her telephone number. Oh goodness, but oh okay,
- 4:59okay, there you are, doctor hitting. I don't know what happened.
- 5:01I'm glad to come. I can hear you beautifully. Look, did
- 5:05you there was Oh yeah, there was no break in my on your end,
- 5:09So I don't know what happened. Oh well, but I said,
- 5:12oh lord, my goodness. But anyway, continue to come. I'm so
- 5:15sorry about that. Continue your conversation. Well, I think when I heard
- 5:19you respond to my saying that I've been representing kids for about twenty six years,
- 5:24yes, um. And then my very next sentence was that, you
- 5:27know, it's really hard to do the work as long as I have,
- 5:30um, without without you know, recognizing the disproportionate impact of the juvenile and
- 5:39criminal legal system on black children in particular. And so that was where,
- 5:44um, you know, I ended before you uh um, it looked like
- 5:48I lost you. Oh I'm still here. Can you hear me? Okay?
- 5:54I can't. Yeah, I'm still here. That's it. But that
- 5:57was what I had added, was that piece about how disproportionate the impact is
- 6:01on black folks. One of the things that You've been doing this for twenty
- 6:06six years, and I'm very curious to know why did you decide to write
- 6:12this book, The Rage of Innocence. So it was precisely because I have
- 6:18been representing kids for twenty six years, and in that entire time, I
- 6:25have only represented four white children. That's it. And everybody who's listening should
- 6:30really gasp at that number, because every other child I've represented has been an
- 6:35African American child in a city that is not, you know, black by
- 6:42any stretch of the imagination. You know, look, you see it has
- 6:45been the Chocolate city. Yeah, in time past. But they But to
- 6:48be clear, there are plenty of white children in the nation's capital, and
- 6:54plenty of white children commit and engage in criminal behavior. Yet there is a
- 7:00unique way in which our system deals with response to and addresses black children who
- 7:08have engaged in misbehaviors or criminal activity, and we don't respond the same way
- 7:13to white children. And so that's why I wrote The Rage of Innocence.
- 7:16I wanted to capture some of that, I wanted to help people understand that,
- 7:21and I want to be super clear about this, BEV and to all
- 7:25your listeners. I recognize that we're all concerned about crime and public safety,
- 7:30particularly today, but we've got to make sure we get it right. We've
- 7:35got to make sure that we're intervening with the right children at the right time
- 7:40and in the right way. And so my book helps us see places in
- 7:45which we redrag we pull black children into the juvenile and criminal legal systems when
- 7:51actually they don't need to be there, and that there are other ways to
- 7:56achieve public safety short of the very harmful, stigmatizing legal system that we rely
- 8:03so heavily on whole. When you said you only represented in your work for
- 8:09white children, that's it, but it in twenty six years. But we
- 8:16know that they get in trouble too. Absolutely, And you know, we
- 8:20can look across the country, I mean, and we think about I mean,
- 8:24let's start. We can start with the low level offenses, right,
- 8:26start with things like you know, drugs and alcohol. Absolutely, children,
- 8:31middle class, wealthy children very much engaged in drug and alcohol use, and
- 8:39oftentimes to excess and with very harmful outcomes. Drinking and driving and you know,
- 8:46pulling, you know, horrible pranks on other people, sexual violence when
- 8:50intoxicated, and guess what sexual violence in white fraternities and sororities at college campuses
- 8:56are you know, abundant. Right, But all of that we treat differently
- 9:01with a black child and a white child. Also even as we think about
- 9:05more serious violent offenses that we all are afraid of. So compare the difference
- 9:13in the treatment of Kyle Rittenhouse. Everybody remembers how Rittenhouse, right, and
- 9:18the ways in which you know, everything we know about adolescence came through in
- 9:24that example. Right, We've got this seventeen year old child who is walking
- 9:28about the city in with an assault rifle in plain view. He was allowed
- 9:35to continue walking about his business for extended periods of time. And then,
- 9:39you know, and why does he go there? He goes there because of
- 9:41he's impulsive, he's responsive to his friends. His friends called him over to
- 9:50help protect businesses in a black protest matter, you know, black you know,
- 9:54lives matter protests. I mean, it's just, you know, all
- 9:58of the things that we know about adole since impulsive, reactive, not thinking
- 10:01ahead to the long term consequences. And then he gets in over his head
- 10:07and ends up taking the lives of two people and and severely enduring a third
- 10:13person. And what happens to him, Not only does he not get shot
- 10:16dead in the moment like jam or Rice right playing with a toy dad,
- 10:20but you know, he gets you know, arrested, and he and his
- 10:24mother and his defense lawyer rightfully, so at least, you know, as
- 10:28a defense lawyer wanted the world to see him as an adolescent who made a
- 10:33really bad mistake, got in over his head, right and they bought it.
- 10:35And the jury, you know, he gets acquitted. He's now got
- 10:39social media profile, you know, spewing you know, you know, you
- 10:45know hatred if you will or you know, and so I mean, but
- 10:48that's my point here is all the way from normal adolescent behaviors, all the
- 10:54way up to the most serious violent behaviors. We treat black children differently,
- 11:00more harshly, in ways that are not effective, in ways that don't you
- 11:05know, support them, promote them, redirect them, provide them with vocational
- 11:09services and mental health services. We do none of that, you know when
- 11:13it comes to black children. Instead, we arrest them, we prosecute them,
- 11:18we remove them, from their homes, We put them into tension facilities,
- 11:20and when they commit the most serious offenses, we prosecute them as if
- 11:26they were adults. Right, We impose solitary confinement, severe life sentences like
- 11:33life without the possibility of parole, when all of the research shows that even
- 11:37for the most violent offenders, even for the most repeat offenders, there are
- 11:43more humane, more effective, and more rehabilitative responses that we can use even
- 11:50with that population. But we don't do that with black children. Someone is
- 11:56listening, doctor Henning, and heard you say that. In probably we would
- 12:00say, well, if if black youth are continuing to commit all these heinous
- 12:07crimes, and why not charge them as an adult? What would you say
- 12:13to that? So the research is really clear that we do more harm than
- 12:20good than with prosecuting children as adults. Okay, And you know the motto
- 12:26is you're exactly right. There's no doubt somebody is listening and thinking exactly what
- 12:30you said. You know, you do the crime, you got to do
- 12:31the time, and without real life. That's just a mantra. And you
- 12:35know what that is. It's also it's responding to, you know, the
- 12:39political moment. It's responding to fear it's not responding to science. Science tells
- 12:45us that the adolescent brain is radically different than the adult brain, which means
- 12:50several things. One, it means that adolescents are more amenable to change.
- 12:56So if you introduce the most appropriate interventions, everything from mental health services,
- 13:05vocational services, you name it, cognitive therapy. All kinds of interventions wrap
- 13:15around services that touch the child at every segment of their lives, at school,
- 13:18at work, at family. You can turn a kid around in those
- 13:22adolescent years. That's one of the main reasons that transferring children to adult court
- 13:28is really bad. A second reason is that adolescents are less culpable because their
- 13:35brains are not as formed as an adult there is. So the research shows
- 13:41that all the things I just talked about with Kyle Rittenhouse, they're impulsive,
- 13:45reactive, they don't think ahead to the long term consequences, their sensation seekers,
- 13:50risk takers. Well, guess what. People are shocked to learn that
- 13:54those features of adolescence people naturally grow out of that into adulthood. So there's
- 14:01this phenomena called natural desistence that an adolescent who does the stupidest thing that unfortunately
- 14:09has a tragic outcome maybe hurts another person will actually grow out of it.
- 14:13It is the rare case. People do not believe this. It is the
- 14:16rare case that children are are you know, antisocial, you know, intentionally
- 14:24trying to hurt another person very often. And I want to be careful about
- 14:31that because, yes, there are kids who hurt other people and know that
- 14:35they're hurting other people, but they're doing so in the broader context of like
- 14:41social environments that have really abused them, right, have neglected them, who
- 14:48have not given them what they need in school, or they've been hurt themselves
- 14:52in some ways, or they're trying to show off for peers and things got
- 14:58of control. So it's just people could see for example, Kyle rittenhouse in
- 15:03African American skin right, all the things. You know, we're just absurd,
- 15:07like you know, So I just say that to say, you know,
- 15:11there's less reduced culpability because of all of the social environments there is.
- 15:16They're more amenable to change. And then the third and final reason that we
- 15:20don't want to be trying and prosecuting children with adults is because you know,
- 15:26guess what, just because you do a crime doesn't mean you wake up the
- 15:28next day, and you're an adult, you know, and in fact,
- 15:31when you go to a jail or to a prison with adults, you're a
- 15:33subject far more subject as a child to rape, physical abuse by guards,
- 15:39physical abuse by children, all of you know, all of the harms,
- 15:45psychological harms that are associated with incarcerating children with other adults. So they come
- 15:52out worse. They go and you do prison, you learn all the bad
- 15:54habits of the adults. So those are the reasons why. Okay? And
- 16:00so doctor Henny, what do you say that a lot of the young black
- 16:10youth who who met crimes and do things like that. So we need to
- 16:14look at first it's psychological? Well is that is that a good word to
- 16:19say? I don't know if it's psychological or environmental? Okay, So,
- 16:26so I think there are you know, a couple of different things. I
- 16:27think part of what I'm trying to say is that the brain is not yet
- 16:33fully developed. Okay, right, And so all of the reasons think about
- 16:37this, like we don't let kids drive cars, we don't let kids vote,
- 16:41we don't let all the things that we don't let them do because they're
- 16:44not mature enough yet committing a crime does not make them any more mature,
- 16:49right, They're still impulsive and reactive in all of these things. So my
- 16:55only point here is because the brain is not yet formed, they're not equally
- 17:00culpable to an adult who does the exact same activity. So there is an
- 17:04element of psychology to that, but it's more cognitive development and psychological development.
- 17:11That's part one, Part two. I was mentioning all of the causes,
- 17:15what are the root causes of crime in our city? And you know,
- 17:21and Memphis is no different, right, it's you know, poverty, and
- 17:26you know, you know, abuse, neglect, you know, deficits in
- 17:30our educational system or educational system that is not uniquely tailored to the kids.
- 17:37The fact that so many children today suffer from trauma right in some form or
- 17:41another, whether they've witnessed violence in their lives or something like that. So
- 17:47there's trauma, there's depression at higher rates than ever before. And so those
- 17:52are some of the root causes of crime. And so what one has to
- 17:55ask is, well, Okay, do I punish somebody who's had a terrible,
- 18:00you know, or a harmful or painful upbringing, or do I help
- 18:03them? Do I rehabilitate them? Do I support them, And so my
- 18:07answer is the latter, and that there is evidence that if we introduce the
- 18:14right interventions, that we can indeed turn a child around, even after something
- 18:19as severe and serious and dangerous as murder. And I just want to tell
- 18:25you, like I work with young people. I work with many young people
- 18:27who are now young adults, who are teenagers where they committed heinous crimes and
- 18:33are doing beautifully now. And so that's what I think people forget. And
- 18:37the difference and the reason why I raised this as a race question is we
- 18:41are more way more likely to let a white child, even who's committed murder,
- 18:45get a second chance, right and have the right. We fund it,
- 18:49We send them to residential facilities, hospitals, mental health facilities, we
- 18:55provide we throw money at them, you know, to turn their lives around
- 18:57and give them another chance. And my what I'm saying is we don't do
- 19:02that, certainly not at the same rates as we do for We don't do
- 19:06that for black kids at the same rates as we do that for white kids.
- 19:10Okay, I got it, I got it. Hold on for a
- 19:11second, doctor Henning, I'll take this break, and I have another question
- 19:17for you. If you've just tuned in this afternoon, good information. I
- 19:22love this. I am talking with doctor Christian Henning. She is the author
- 19:27of the book The Rage of Innocence, How America Criminalizes Black Youth. We're
- 19:34talking. She is coming to Memphis, by the way, so you'll be
- 19:37able to meet her in person. Will tell you about that and real quickly.
- 19:42If you do have a question or two or four doctor Henning, we
- 19:45invite you to call five three five nine three four two five three five nine
- 19:52three four two will get you in to us. You're listening to w d
- 19:59I A. You're listening to the heart and soul of Memphis. So bev
- 20:08Johnson Show exclusively on w d IA. For seventy five years, w DA
- 20:25has been the musical fabric of Memphis. Hi, this is Mishiba. Pots
- 20:29right, your blues recording artists, let me give you my personal message in
- 20:33memory of WDIA. I'll never forget when I first put out the song he
- 20:37had lipstick on his pants, My God, j Michael Davis, Ruthus Thomas,
- 20:42Oh, we laughed till we cried at that song. Because one of
- 20:47those guys actually had that experience. I will not tell you who but it
- 20:51was so funny, hilarious. They went straight to Bobby oj we miss you,
- 20:56We miss all three of them. Oh my god. They went to
- 20:57him and the song became a major hit with w DA. You will forever
- 21:03be our good will and good Time station. AM ten seventy WDIA love it.
- 21:08We're still your station of goodwill and good times, celebrating seventy five years
- 21:14on the radio, ten seventy w d I. A who has been jamming
- 21:19with w d I. A. Hey, this is Jeffrey Osborne, and
- 21:22I want to congratulate AM ten seventy w DIA on your seventy fifth radio anniversary.
- 21:29You've been there for me since the beginning of my career. Thank you
- 21:32for allowing my music to be heard all throughout Memphis. You will forever be
- 21:36our goodwill and good Time station. Celebrating seventy five years of black radio with
- 21:41a heart and soul of Memphis. Ten seventy w d IA. You're listening
- 22:11to the Bev Johnson Show. Here's Bev Johnson, and I'm talking with my
- 22:15very special guest, doctor Christian Henning, who is the author of the book
- 22:19The Rage of Innocence, How America Criminalizes black youth. She is also a
- 22:26Bloom Professor of Law and director of the Juvenile Justice Clinic and Initiative at Georgetown.
- 22:33Doctor Henning one of my callers who didn't want to say on the line
- 22:36and ask what to ask about when we hear about serial criminals and killers?
- 22:45Do we see a lot of that in black youth as they grow up?
- 22:49How does that begins as a youth and go into adulthood. Oh, that's
- 22:56a great question, and I should say that I don't know the exact statistics
- 23:02on the racial breakdown of serial killers and cereal. Um, but if that's
- 23:07what the caller is referring to. But you know from the media that so
- 23:11many of like you think of you know, um uh laumer right, Like,
- 23:17yeah, you think about those they have been historically not been black people.
- 23:23Um. That's not to say that there are no black serial killers,
- 23:26but um, that's that's one thing. Another example. You think about mass
- 23:32shootings at schools, right, those also historically have not been black children.
- 23:38Um. So to the extent that that's what, um, the caller is
- 23:42asking about, that's an interesting question. Um. The if the question is
- 23:48a little more subtle than that, which is the notion that some children of
- 23:56all races and classes do become repeat offenders a couple of things. I want
- 24:02to say, that is pretty rare. You will have a child who can
- 24:07go through a season of their life, maybe you know, a stretch of
- 24:11years in which they are engaged in rapid and repeated criminal behavior, maybe for
- 24:18example, you know, associated with you know, a gang, or maybe
- 24:22it's you know, they get caught up after something really bad or traumatic or
- 24:30devastating happens in their lives, and then they turn to crime as a way
- 24:34to cope. But you know, I think part of the message that I
- 24:40like folks to have is that is that really we need to be careful about
- 24:47how we respond to the whole. In other words, we often criminalize the
- 24:52whole, all of black children, for the sins of the two percent or
- 24:57the sins of the nine percent. And the data across the country has shown
- 25:02that really very few children of all races and classes are engaged in those most
- 25:10extreme violent behaviors that we worry about the most, and that we need to
- 25:15tailor our resources to those children, those nine percent of the population who are
- 25:21engaged in serious violent behavior. And then, and you know, and offer
- 25:25the gamut of resources to them as well as to other children. But we
- 25:29need to make sure we're not criminalizing or becoming so afraid of other Black children
- 25:34because of the sins of the two percent or even the nine percent. I
- 25:38like that. I like that you've given us a good highlight. I want
- 25:42don't want it to spoil it for our folks and Memphis, because you will
- 25:47be here on I want to make sure. On Tuesday, July twenty fifth,
- 25:52the African Village Institute and Slave Haven is bringing doctor Hinting to Memphis to
- 25:57talk about her book The Age of Innocence, How America Criminalizes Black Youth,
- 26:03and you will be here. This last question, Doctor Henning, I want
- 26:07to say, should we be when you talk about the Rage of Innocence?
- 26:12Should we be outraged about how America does our Black youth and what can we
- 26:19do about it? Yes? I love that absolutely. I In fact,
- 26:26the title of my book is in part you know, just that we should
- 26:30all be outraged by the ways in which we fail to allow Black children to
- 26:38be children. And that is from childhood all the way up through those adolescent
- 26:44years. How critically important is it to just play and laugh and frolic and
- 26:51go to a park and shoot basketball hoops. Right to do all of those
- 26:56things is a part of you know, social development, men, it's a
- 27:00part of cognitive brain development, it's a part of you know, of physical
- 27:06development. And yet we deprive black children of those opportunities far, far,
- 27:10far too often. So yes, we should be outraged. And one of
- 27:12the ways in which we deprive children of the opportunity to be children is by
- 27:18criminalizing them for normal adolescent behaviors, those behaviors that all of us did when
- 27:23we were kids, and we came out just fine. And also, you
- 27:27know, all the things that other kids do, testing limits, pushing the
- 27:33boundaries, talking back sometimes right, even experimenting with drug sex and alcohol.
- 27:38And I'm not you know, of course, you know, we as an
- 27:41adults, we get a lot of high courses forgetting that each and every one
- 27:45of us, you know, you know, at some point, you know,
- 27:47the different degrees of course, has pushed those boundaries and tested you know,
- 27:52you know, the limits, you know, during their childhood. And
- 27:56it's precisely because we were able to test limits and even try things that were
- 28:00you know, maybe even illegal, is what made us successful. You know,
- 28:04we had courage to push beyond, and we had the wherewithal to figure
- 28:08out what our limits work. Right, So at some point, you know,
- 28:12maybe those of us who do drink alcohol, you know, maybe push
- 28:15that limit too far. And we figured out what was too far for each
- 28:18of us and we pulled back. That's a part of growing up and evolving.
- 28:22So yes, I love it. I love it. Well. We
- 28:26thank you, doctor Henning, and thank you so much for just giving us
- 28:30a tab. We are looking so forward to having you in Memphis, Tennessee.
- 28:33And by the way, your cousin called earlier, Charles, and he
- 28:37said, told me tell you hello. Indeed he said when he said,
- 28:41when you get here, he'll be in Arizona. But he just wanted to
- 28:45say, he wanted to say hi. And we feel a whole lot of
- 28:48love. I'll have to call it. I hate I'm gonna miss him again.
- 28:52Yeah, well, I hope I get to meet you maybe bad YEA
- 28:56hope I get to meet you as well. Thank you so much, have
- 29:00a beautiful day today, and we look for you having you in Memphis,
- 29:06Tennessee. All right, thanks so much, Thank you, great day too.
- 29:11You two bye bye. That's doctor Kristin Henning. She is coming to
- 29:15Memphis. Yeah, her book is The Rage of Innocence, How America criminalizes
- 29:22Black youth. If you want to get the book and read it before she
- 29:26gets here, Norman says they have a hundred copies over there at the African
- 29:33Village. Call Norman at nine zero one eight five nine sixteen eighty nine nine
- 29:40zero one eight five nine sixteen eighty nine to get your book before doctor Henning
- 29:45gets here next week on the twenty fifth. That's gonna be great. You
- 29:51get her to sign your book. And also don't forget y'all because you know
- 29:55it costs, and they're looking for, you know, asking just for thirty
- 30:00yall a donation which will include a copy of her book. So yeah,
- 30:03thirty dollars refreshments, gonna be a wonderful experience. It's happening at the Benjamin
- 30:08L. Hook's Central Library, thirty thirty Popular add the new Yeah, it's
- 30:15gonna be good. In the afternoon. If you need more information, called
- 30:18Norman Redwing. That's gonna be good. So love talking with her, arhon
- 30:22God roots right here in Memphis, Tennessee. Love that love that love that.
- 30:30I want to say, thank you callers thank you listeners this day on
- 30:34the Bev Johnson Show, we do, we really do appreciate you, so
- 30:41until tomorrow, please be saved. Keep a cool ahead, y'all, and
- 30:48don't let anyone steal your joy. Until tomorrow, I'm Dev Johnson and y'all
- 30:53keep the faith. The views and opinions discussed on the Bev Johnson Show are
- 31:02that of the host and callers and not those of the staff and sponsors of
- 31:07w d I a