Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / Cornell Jane Doe| 7 Men, Snapchat Messages & a Troubling Investigation
Transcript
- Nicholle: August twentieth, 2024. It's almost two in the morning at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. Inside a fraternity house, a 20-year-old woman is upstairs in a bedroom. She went there to meet someone she knew. She initially agreed to sexual activity with two men. But according to what she'll later tell police, that isn't where the night ends. More men begin entering the room. She describes pulling the covers over her naked body. Zalle: inside a fraternity house. A 20 year old woman was upstairs in a bed. She went there. She initially had a sexual activity. But according to what she later felt, that didn't end well. She described the open public over her naked body. Nicholle: She alleges that she was pressured to take ketamine, struck during sex, and subjected to sexual acts without her consent. Zalle: She alleges that she was pressured to take that amendment, struck during the event, and subjected to sexual acts without consent. Nicholle: Meanwhile, members of the fraternity Zalle: Meanwhile, members of the fraternity are talking about her in a sent chat. One message for everybody invited to her university. Nicholle: Are talking about her on Snapchat. One message reportedly invites other men upstairs. Then someone asks whether the shop is still open. The answer is yes. And nearly two years later, after a university investigation resulted in expulsions and suspensions, the public learned something extraordinary. The district attorney, who declined to pursue criminal charges, says he never reviewed the complete transcript of the interview in which this woman explicitly Zalle: Then someone asked, was it a shock to see him? The answer is yes. And nearly two weeks later, after the university investigated Jimmy's offer, it was exalted and suspension. The public lament simply became extraordinary. The district attorney for the crime was receiving criminal charges that he never reviewed the complete transcript of the interview in which this committee was to Nicholle: reported being raped. Zalle: be recorded in. And I'm Zalle. Today we're covering Jane Doe versus Cornell University. A case involving seven former members of the Chi Phi fraternity, allegations of sexual assault, a univer- What's a univerny? A university disciplinary investigation and a criminal investigation reopened nearly two years later. And we're going to discuss what you need to know actually to drive massive depression and sexual violence into a parking lot. There are specific outcomes involved. Nicholle: And we're going to discuss what Jane Doe actually described, not some cleaned-up version that turns allegations of sexual violence into a party that got out of hand. There are specific allegations involving forced oral sex, intercourse without consent, ketamine, and physical violence. We're going to talk about those details. Zalle: We're also going to discuss the documented Snapchat messages, what Jane Doe said in the days afterward and what Cornell's disciplinary panel found. Those findings are different for the seven men and we'll explain them. Nicholle: But we're not going to interrupt this story every few minutes to remind everybody that an allegation isn't a conviction. We'll identify the source of the information and tell you what the record's established. And then we're Zalle: And then. Nicholle: going to tell the story. Some details will be difficult to hear, so please take care while listening. Zalle: Somebody told me to look here, so please take care of us. Nicholle: If you appreciate true crime research inguesstigators make sure you're following Coffee and Crime with Mom. Let's get into it. Zalle: you appreciate that kind of true crime research, make sure you follow the camera. Let's get into Cornell University is an Ivy League institution located in Ithaca, New York. One of its fraternities was Chi-Fi, located at 107 Edgemore Lane. before the incident involving Jane Doe, there had already been a drug-related emergency at the fraternity house. According to reporting based on Cornell police reports, there was a ketamine related emergency around October 18, 2024. Then early on October 19, police made a drug related arrest at the house. Later that same day, Chi-Fi hosted another party. Nicholle: And that sequence immediately raises questions. Police had already mm police have reportedly been involved in a drug related incident at this fraternity house, and another party took place shortly afterward. What did Cornell know? Was anyone considering whether that house should be hosting another party? And what information was shared with university officials? Zalle: Those questions become relevant after Jane Doe alleged that ketamine was used During the encounter. We don't know that the earlier incident involved the same individuals or the same drugs, but it establishes that there had already been police activity involving drugs at the house. And we decided to ignore her. We're talking about a rough day in the day even before her reporting. And the nothing she does that she would actually have told me. That's something I would expect to Nicholle: And the timing is hard to ignore. We're talking about roughly a day between a reported drug related incident and the night Jane Doe says she was sexually assaulted. That's something I would expect an independent review to examine. Zalle: examine. Nicholle: Jane Doe Zalle: Jane Doe was 20 years old. She knew Matthew Ingalls, one of the fraternity members, and had arranged to meet him that night. She'd been drinking at her sorority house and later went to bars in downtown Ithaca. Around 11 that evening, she walked to Chi-Fi. Nicholle: And I want people to understand that she wasn't describing a situation where strangers abducted her. She went to see somebody she knew. She trusted him enough to go there. and that's part of what makes her account of what happened afterwards so disturbing. Zalle: According to Jane Doe's police statement, she was already intoxicated when she arrived. She rated her intoxication at approximately five out of 10. She met up with Ingles and the two spent time together. At some point he asked whether she wanted to have a threesome with him and another fraternity member, Jonathan Newell. She agreed, which there's nothing wrong with that because people have threesomes all the time. Okay. So let's not go there. And if you haven't Nicholle: Yes. So it's not the first. That's right. Zalle: done it, that's you. Nicholle: Yes. That is that should not shine any kind of dark light on her. but that fact is important. Jane Doe acknowledged agreeing to the initial sexual encounter. She described sexual activity with Ingalls and Newell that she initially wanted. But consenting to those two men wasn't an invitation to everyone else in the fraternity house. Zalle: In no way, or form. But according to the accounts collected during the investigation, the encounter involved oral and vaginal sex. At some point, Ingalls became sleepy and was described as falling asleep or passing out, and the situation began to change. Jane Doe described additional men entering the room. Nicholle: And imagine that for a moment. it just makes my chest feel tight. you're naked in a bedroom with people you've agreed to be intimate with. Then other men start walking in. According to Jane Doe, she pulled the covers over herself because she didn't want them seeing her naked. That is not somebody describing herself as comfortable with an audience. Zalle: That is not Every time I hear that part, my friend, I visualize my friend's face in that situation and it just so heartbreaking. She also described an incident involving Diego Sarabia. According to her civil complaint, Sarabia entered the bedroom with other men, grabbed her face and began kissing her. She says she pushed him away. I'm just confused as to why you just walked into the room and grabbed my face and started kissing me like you knew me. Nicholle: Why what made you think that was okay? And that is the specific allegation. She says he kissed her without consent and she physically rejected him. That's not a misunderstanding about whether she'd agreed to sex with somebody else. It's a separate interaction. Zalle: Jane Doe's account describes the encounter becoming increasingly chaotic as additional people entered. She alleged that the situation continued for hours and involved additional sexual acts she hadn't agreed to. And during that time, members of the fraternity were communicating through Snapchat. Okay. And this is where the story starts to piss me off because then this is where everybody's like, you can't take back and you whatever, whatever. Just hearing that and then put yourself in her shoes or imagine it being your daughter Nicholle: Let's hit here and go to the Zalle: or your sister or your mother or your grandma. And let's see if your mindset is still the same. According to Cornell's disciplinary records, Jonathan Newell sent a Snapchat message inviting other fraternity members into the bedroom where Jane Doe was undressed. And if you've seen the messages, it was so vulgar and disrespectful. But it in itself, period. But the way he did it is just. The messages reportedly describe sexual access to a woman upstairs. At approximately 1 42 in the morning, someone asked whether the shop was still open. Another participant responded affirmatively, disgusting, disgusting. Nicholle: A shot. A shot. That's the language being used to discuss a woman who was upstairs having sex. And that language matters because what it suggests is that Someone was treating her sexual availability as something he could advertise to other men. Zalle: The utter fucking gall And this wasn't simply a rumor that's like circulated around campus the snapchat conversation became part of the investigative record as it should Because you can't try to walk out of that shit, baby. It's right there. We see we see literally Nicholle: Definitely. Mm mm. Yeah. Definitely. During the list of four. Zalle: Journalists later reported on the messages and Cornell considered the communications during its disciplinary process. Nicholle: And I think we need to be direct about how ugly that is. You have a woman upstairs. You have messages being sent to fraternity members. And the language Zalle: you have a saying, the attorney in there. Nicholle: makes it sound as though people can come and go while sexual access to her remains available. But Jane Doe says she didn't agree to that. Zalle: And according to her account, additional men did enter the room. The university ultimately imposed different disciplinary sanctions on the men involved. Some were found responsible for sexual assault. Others were sanctioned for different conduct. Nicholle: is why we need to look at what each person was accused of and what Cornell actually found. But I don't want to lose sight of the basic issue here. who gave somebody permission to advertise Jane Doe to other men? According to her account, it wasn't her. Now we're going to discuss the sexual assault allegations directly. According to Jane Doe's civil complaint, the encounter escalated as additional men entered the room. She alleged that she was pressured to consume ketamine and became increasingly impaired. She described being struck during sex, and she accused several men of specific acts of sexual violence. Zalle: Jane Doe accused Jonathan Newell of striking her during intercourse hard enough to leave bruises on her buttocks. She also accused him of pressuring her to consume ketamine. According to the disciplinary records reported by the Cornell Daily Sun, Newell was expelled after Cornell found him responsible for sexual assault. I'm sorry, that just makes my chest close because to just think about, I cannot imagine, I cannot, even being somebody who's been raped, I cannot imagine the fear she felt as more people walked into Nicholle: Right. Zalle: the room for that to happen with one person. When I tell you I was, It's the most terrifying fucking thing. And then afterwards, it's a complete mind fuck because it's just like, I don't, how do I process what just happened? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: So I cannot imagine what that was like for her. Nicholle: Wow. And that's a significant finding though. Cornell's disciplinary process didn't simply conclude that Newell had sent inappropriate messages. The university found him responsible for sexual assault. Zalle: Jane Doe also accused Winston Lee of using ketamine on her body and forcing her to perform oral sex. She accused Gillio Lopez of having sexual intercourse with her without her consent. And she accused Diego Sarabia of grabbing her face and kissing her without consent before she Nicholle: Gets Glass. Zalle: pushed him off. Nicholle: those are the acts described in her complaint. Forced oral sex, intercourse without consent, unwanted physical contact, and physical violence during sex. That's what she says happened. And I don't think we should dilute those allegations into vague language about a wild night because it was much more than that. Zalle: that's what she said Yeah, especially not for these so-called men that everybody's trying to protect about, their future. What about hers? What about hers? Yeah. now you have to live with something. It's never going to Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: be what she has to live with. Her account also describes significant intoxication. Ketamine is a dissociative anesthetic. can alter perception, awareness, coordination, and memory. Combined with alcohol, can increase impairment and other health risks. Hours. Nicholle: And that matters because the question isn't simply whether Jane Doe agreed to sexual activity at eleven or midnight. The night lasted for hours. She described drinking and using ketamine. And she described her memory becoming increasingly unreliable, which makes sense. Zalle: And she described her memory being increasingly unreliable, which makes sense. In the statement discussed by the district attorney, Jane Doe described her intoxication reaching approximately eight out of 10 during the later encounter. She also described a point. when she was tired and wanted the sexual activity to stop. According to that statement, the men involved stopped when she expressed that boundary. The methods are long overdue, but it doesn't matter what happens during and after the first of your actions. Jane Doe's allegation concerning a series of other actions was always different. One moment was a kind of experience, but the final brief doesn't hint at whether another person is high on it. Nicholle: And that detail belongs in the chronology, but it doesn't tell us what happened during every earlier act. Jane Doe's allegations concern a series of interactions involving different men. One moment when somebody respected a boundary doesn't answer whether another person violated one. And I don't care that in that last moment they decided to stop. How long had they already been going, whoever that was who decided to stop? Zalle: And I don't care that in the last moment they decided to stop. How long did they work with you when you were supposed to to stop? That part. That part. It should have been nothing for you to stop. You shouldn't have been in there. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Jane Doe also alleged that she eventually lost consciousness. Her civil complaint places that at approximately 5 45 in the morning, the exact circumstances Nicholle: Game dot four. Gen full articles. What are you five and dexterity services? Zalle: and timing remain part of the disputed account. Nicholle: and when someone describes memory gaps and possible unconsciousness, that makes the other evidence even more important. What did the men say happened? What did witnesses observe? what did the Snapchat conversation reveal? And what did investigators do to reconstruct those sequences? Zalle: Let's go through the seven defendants individually because their alleged conduct and disciplinary outcomes were different. Matthew Ingalls was the person Jane Doe originally went to meet. He participated in the initial encounter and was accused of exploiting and endangering her as the night progressed. expelled him after finding him responsible for sexual assault. And let me just remind you that he is also the man that said he was too drunk and that he accused her of assaulting him. Yeah. Nicholle: Assaulting him. Yeah, that's who he is. Zalle: That's what he said. It's in no way you Nicholle: That's who he is. Jonathan Newell was also expelled. Jane Doe accused him of striking her during intercourse, pressuring her to use ketamine, and sending the Snapchat invitation. Cornell found Newell responsible for sexual assault as well. Zalle: could have seen those Snapchat messages and not. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: And not. And I just want to say you're disgusting. You're disgusting. And I hope you feel shame every day you have to look yourself in the mirror. Nicholle: Right. Even if nothing else you can come with Yeah. Zalle: even if nothing else came from it, the fact that you sent the message to begin with. Nicholle: Once the inverse Zalle: dirty. Winston Lee received a two-year suspension Nicholle: of Zalle: and disciplinary probation. Jane Doe accused him of forcing oral sex and using ketamine on her body. Gileal Lopez received a three-semester suspension and two years of probation. He was accused of intercourse without consent. Nicholle: And those are serious sanctions, but the university specific findings matter more than simply looking at the length of their suspension. A suspension tells us the school found a policy violation serious enough to warrant that penalty. It doesn't automatically establish every allegation in the civil complaint. Zalle: Diego Sorabia had graduated by the time the disciplinary process concluded. barred him from campus for three years. That's it, just three. Jane Doe accused him of forcibly kissing her after entering the room. He never should have went in there. I am so, I'm sorry. The men who were in the Snapchat thread, the group, whoever, once the message was sent, it should have been somebody with enough sense once you see that, to be like, what the, are you cool? Nicholle: What are y'all doing? Yeah. It's well just changed because it's always just Zalle: are you cool? And if you don't feel like you want to even say anything to them, you could always have said something to somebody else to stop what the fuck was going on. But none of you did. Not a one. Not a one of you. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Not a one. Not a one. Then there are Scott Norris and Scott Kretzmer. Both were accused of entering the room after the Snapchat invitation. They received no contact orders, educational requirements, and written assignments. I just want them to take that off the list. Zalle: Both were because of the care they were given after the Snippet Chat implicated. They received no contact points, educational requirements, and a degree from science. I just want them to pay for it on the first day. Nicholle: there's not a punishment. Zalle: Why would you why why I just want to know Nicholle: That's not a punishment. he's not in fifth grade and he threw a spitball across the room. That's not what happened. Zalle: Why the fuck would you feel like that would be adequate enough in any way shape or form and then when I watched the documentary on Netflix and heard from those young women about what the process was like to go through the school and to know that For one it could take long as time as you've seen that one Nicholle: Yeah. And then once Zalle: Diego had graduated by the time the process was over. Okay. And then once they have their findings, it's not like they call you in, they meet with you, have this whole meeting, they send you an email. So not only did they just get a no contact order, educational Nicholle: That's it. So not only sneak. Zalle: requirements and written assignments, but I found out about this through an email. Nicholle: Right. You didn't even there's not a letter, I didn't get a letter in the mail. Nothing. Zalle: What was the point of the process because what did you do? What did that do at all? Nicholle: But make life harder for the woman. Zalle: make a like. Yeah. Nicholle: Okay. We're down in that. Zalle: Cornell did not find them responsible for sexual assault. Kretzschmar was reportedly Nicholle: Bridgemore. Bridgemore. Bridgemore. Zalle: found responsible for attempted sexual exploitation. His attorney acknowledged his participation in the offensive Snapchat conversation, but denied that he saw Jane Doe naked or in distress. Sir, you don't feel like that's disgusting enough? And if you're a part of sexual exploitation, Nicholle: So you don't feel that's disgusting enough if they're a part of sexual exploitation. And then we're either one thing or something or two high pick up. Zalle: You were either one saying you were coming or two hyping up the other ones who did come. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Jane Doe responded that her memory was clouded too. She said everyone had been heavily intoxicated and she wrote that she didn't believe the sexual activity had been illegal. She also expressed affection for the two men she had initially been with end. Nicholle: and that is part of the evidence. But I wanna look at the whole exchange. Because in the same conversation he also said the additional men should have left. She distinguished the people she'd initially been with from the men who came into the room afterward. Zalle: Because in the state conversation he also said the additional language she distinguished the people she's additionally from the men into the afternoon. She also referred to not wanting the additional men or ketamine involved in a future encounter. And she had described the whole experience as overwhelming. Nicholle: can only imagine. my God. That's such a understatement. Zalle: Understatement and mm. Nicholle: So those early messages show a complicated picture. She expressed affection towards some of the men. She initially said she didn't believe anything illegal had happened, but she also expressed discomfort with the additional participants and described the situation as something that had gone beyond what she'd expressed. And think about after hours in the room being given ketamine. Zalle: messaging show a complicated picture. She expressed affection towards some of the she initially said she didn't believe anything. But she also expressed discomfort with the additional participants and described the situation as something that had gone beyond what she expressed. And I mean think about after hours of demon being being assaulted in whatever else happened in the room. Nicholle: being assaulted and whatever else happened in that room, trying to process that information, I c I can't imagine. You don't want to that I can only imagine that feels huge that you're going to say someone raped you. Zalle: Trying to buy sense that information. I c I can't imagine you don't want the that feels I I can only imagine huge that you're going to say something right. First of all, and then you did this to me and then you had the balls enough to to text me because you clearly feel like you didn't do shit wrong. You had Nicholle: Right. Zalle: the balls to text me. First of all, my whole body, my nervous system is just survived this situation. Because Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: though he's not here. my body doesn't recognize that I recognize you as dangerous. So now I'm gonna do whatever I have to do to make sure I'm not back in that situation. I don't blame her for any of that. Because I think if Nicholle: Yeah. I don't always just see if Zalle: I had the balls, 'cause I did not to face the person who raped me afterwards, I ran. So the fact that she was able to have a whole conversation is mind blowing. And I do mean literally ran. Like ran out of a party. So it's no That doesn't mean anything. Nicholle: No. Zalle: And over the following days, her distress became more apparent. On October twenty third, she texted Ingalls about rumors circulating around campus. She said the situation was temporarily ruining her n her life and that she was spending much of her time sleeping and crying. Nicholle: that the situation everybody just Zalle: And then everybody wants to like, Well, why won't she name herself? She already went through hell after this. Nicholle: I was sleeping at night practice and Zalle: hellish experience and now you think that I owe the world the chance to put me through worse? why would I do that? Nicholle: for all the team for anything worse, but why would I do that? Because I was assaulted. Now I owe you my identity also. Absolutely not. And that adds another dimension Zalle: And that app is Nicholle: to the story. imagine having something intensely personal happen and then finding out people around campus are talking about it. she was dealing not only with what she remembered from the night, but with what other people were saying afterward. Zalle: Because it's no telling how these several several men's and anybody else who was in the message could have flipped that situation. Any of them. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: And now I have to hear about what they're saying about what happened to me. And I was already out of it, but I know something isn't right. Yeah, y'all are not thinking big picture about what that was like for her. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: by early November, Jane Doe was explicitly describing much of the sexual activity as non consensual. That was before her formal police interview. Nicholle: And that chronology matters also. Her allegation didn't first appear when she filed a civil lawsuit in 2026. She was describing non consensual activity within weeks of the incident. Zalle: On October twenty second, Jane Doe visited Cornell Health. She sought treatment for a urinary tract infection and tested for sexually transmitted infections and testing for sexually transmitted infections. According to her attorney Thomas Giuffra she told a healthcare professional that the circumstances surrounding the encounter had been traumatic. Her attorney said she wasn't promptly referred to a sexual assault forensic examination. How could you not? Nicholle: And that's a part of the institutional response I want to examine. When someone seeks medical care after a sexual encounter and describes it as traumatic, what information are they given? Are they told about forensic examination options? Are they offered confidential support? And are they given enough information to make their own decisions? Zalle: someone seeks where after your sexual economy and describes the vector, what information are they are they told about seek examination of are they offering confidential support? And are they given enough information to make their own decision? I have no personal insight on any of that because I was not as bold as Jane Doe. I did not report it I did not go to a health clinic. I didn't do any of that for a while. So I don't know. But from what it Nicholle: I just want you to know because you keep saying that, that doesn't take anything away from you. Because you weren't prepared to deal with that then. Yeah. Zalle: No. Yeah, no, I don't feel like it, but I feel like it helps shine light on how strong she was right after this for everybody trying to beat her down. Especially especially to be a woman. And then if you're a woman Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah. Zalle: who's lucky enough to have walked this earth and not have to have worried about this type of experience, for you to try to say anything, anything about how she handled that. You have no right. Jane Doe reportedly obtained a forensic examination on November seventh. Her attorney argued that the delay may have prevented the collection of useful biological evidence. We can't know what an earlier examination would have recovered, but the delay became part of this the criticism of Cornell's response. Nicholle: And it's important because a criminal investigation may later depend on what evidence is available. So what happened Zalle: So what happened? Nicholle: during that first medical visit deserves attention. On November eighth, 2024, Jane Doe reported the incident to Cornell University Police, and Cornell University Police are sworn law enforcement officers. This was not merely a report to a university administrator. Zalle: Jane Doe reported the east Cornell University please. And Cornell University leads up to the Longstreams. This was not Nicolas University, which Jane Doe participated in a lengthy police interview on November 14th and 15th. That's two days. Two days. Nicholle: Two days. Zalle: CBS later obtained the transcript. During that interview, she described the initial sexual activity she had agreed to. She also described later acts she said occurred without her consent, and she explicitly reported that she had been raped. Nicholle: And that is an extremely important point. She wasn't simply telling investigators that she'd had sex and regretted it. She was alleging sexual violence. She described Zalle: She just grown. Nicholle: the people involved, the drugs, the physical contact, and the circumstances that made her believe she'd been assaulted. Zalle: Investigators asked detailed questions about whether she verbally refused certain acts, whether she communicated discomfort, and what she remembered about her her level of intoxication. Those details became important to the legal analysis. I'm sorry, but first of all, fuck you and fuck the system that made it where that is what we're asking. Because Nicholle: Because Zalle: though it does have some minor, you know relevance, it really doesn't mean anything because it doesn't matter how drunk she was, it doesn't matter clearly whether she verbally refused or anything. I don't understand that you don't need to you can see by somebody's face or if I'm fighting you and I don't have the strength to say words but I'm pushing you off of me, that still means no. So the questions you're asking are not the correct questions. Nicholle: Right. And and her being intoxicated only makes it worse that they ever had sex with her any from the beginning, whether Zalle: only makes it worse but yeah beginning from the beginning Nicholle: she agreed to or not. If she was intoxicated. But the interview wasn't the only document involved because the lengthy conversation was condensed into a much shorter written statement. And that statement became central to the prosecutor's decision. Zalle: Yeah. interview wasn't about back to the bottom because the lengthy conversation was condensed into a much speaker. And that statement is central to the prosecutor's decision. Jane Doe's police interview was summarized in a six page single space statement. She reviewed it, made more than twenty handwritten corrections, and signed it. The district attorney later emphasized that she had reviewed and signed the statement. And that is but the sign Nicholle: And that is a relevant fact, but the signed statement and the complete interview transcript were not identical documents. The question Zalle: The question Nicholle: is whether the summary captured the significant allegations and whether prosecutors had enough information to make their decision. Zalle: I'm sorry, but who the fuck was doing her interview that you weren't listening to what the fuck she said that she needed to correct it tw her twenty times? I need to write Nicholle: Twenty times. Zalle: over what you're saying because clearly you weren't listening to what I was telling you. You Nicholle: Right. Zalle: made twenty mistakes or left things out. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: That don't sound like off the wall. That sounds insane to me. Yeah. If this was a murder investigation, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. It is a company. Zalle: that wouldn't have been acceptable. Right. Matthew Van Houten issued a public statement explaining why his office had declined charges in 2024. He said the signed statement described voluntary sexual activity and drug use. He argued that the facts in the document did not establish the legal elements necessary for a criminal sexual offense under New York law. That man needs to be fired, jailed, and I don't even know what else, but he needs his ass. Nicholle: Cause here's here's the thing, here's the thing. That's your job, sir. It's your job to make sure that you have the information that you need Zalle: Here's here's it's that's your job. Because your job is you have that you need Nicholle: to make a decision before you make said decision. So I don't know what you thought you were accomplishing by coming out and saying you didn't have the whole statement, because that's kind of what you're paid to do, is to make sure that you have the details before you decide whether you're going to prosecute something. But Zalle: do by coming out and saying you didn't have the whole statement because that's not what you're paid to do is to make sure you have the details before you decide whether it would be the price to eat something. But That is the prosecutor's position. But Nicholle: that is the prosecutor's position. But there's something I want listeners to understand. A prosecutor deciding whether charges are supported isn't the same thing as a court deciding whether someone is guilty and the decision not to prosecute. Zalle: there's something on my list and there's something between you. A prosecutor deciding whether parties supported isn't the same thing as the court deciding somebody's guilty. And just you're not the prosecute Nicholle: prosecute isn't a finding that nothing harmful Zalle: isn't a that nothing harmful happened. Nicholle: happened. Zalle: No, because as you can see, it can just be somebody not doing their job. Yes. But Van Houten also described details from the from the statement that he believed were significant. Jane Doe had acknowledged agreeing to the initial threesome. She described voluntarily using drugs at certain points, and according to the statement, sexual activity stopped when she communicated that she wanted it to stop. He sounds like a regular degula ignorant ass man. I'm so sorry. That's what you're giving. Nicholle: So what it sounds like is that he just said, she she consented to some sex and she was drinking and doing drugs, Zalle: She's been very taking given drugs, so Nicholle: so we don't Zalle: we don't Nicholle: need to look any further into this. Those weren't facts that made him say we should probably look into this if this girl was intoxicated but because he didn't even bother to get the full report before he made the decision. I don't know how you do that. Zalle: Those weren't facts that maybe that we should probably look into this this girl was intoxicated. But because he didn't even provide it with the poor report. And I'm sorry, it's not all men, but majority of the men, especially if talking about this case, that is the first question that I get. I said s I was speaking to somebody and was like, Yeah, she went there to go meet, you know, whatever, and then it turned into a threesome but then other people came and this and h the response was Well there wasn't a gun to her head holding her there. How did they force her? Excuse me. Nicholle: That sounds like something a man would say because you don't experience life like a woman experiences life. You know? So there are all these men that different men are coming. It's not like there's a couple of guys that are raping her, which would be horrible by itself. Zalle: you don't experience women experiences So there are all these men that different men from it's not like there's a couple of guys that are raping them to be horrible by yourself. Nicholle: But she had to have not felt like she could even scream out. Because these men are coming in and out of this room. They know what's happening. Zalle: she had to have not felt like she could even scream out. Because these men are coming in and out of this room. No, different people keep coming in. People who's gonna help me if I can see y'all shuffling Nicholle: That's right. Zalle: in and out. And then on top of that, it takes one of you to overpower me. There are several of you coming in and out of here and nobody gives a fuck about what I want. So Nicholle: Mm-hmm. So Yeah, what are you expecting for me to do? But her account also included unwanted contact, additional men entering, and significant intoxication. And the longer interview contained her explicit allegation of rape, which brings us to the most troubling part of the prosecutorial review. Zalle: But our account also included unwanted contact, the additional marriage interim and significant toxication. And the long remote container split it out into the break, which brings us to the most troubling part of the prosecutor. The C Fix of Brandon, Mr. Conference, the information from the what he said are we transferred. He said yes. Nicholle: When CBS confronted District Attorney Van Houten there with information from the full police interview transcript, he said he hadn't seen it. He had reviewed the signed six page statement, but he hadn't reviewed the complete interview containing Jane Doe's explicit allegation of rape. Tell me how you make a decision. I I don't understand how you made that decision. Zalle: He had the signs with the page down. But he had to be the complete interview. I don't understand how your ignorant ass felt confident enough to stand in front of anybody's interview and say that out loud. That's right. Nicholle: That's right. You didn't need it. Zalle: You didn't even come up with a lie. You just told her she I didn't do my job. And I just came up with a decision because she agreed. So once she agreed initially, she can't take back consent. Yeah, let's throw this Nicholle: And Zalle: out. Nicholle: let's not let's not ruin these young men's lives. Some young people need their lives Zalle: Some young people neither Nicholle: ruined, otherwise they just keep doing the same atrocious shit over and over and over again. Zalle: And then they just turn out to be horrible ass people in positions of power or controlling other I mean I don't know I don't know anybody like that that's in the public eye. Nicholle: You don't think you can name anyone? Zalle: I mean nobody in power comes to mind, not the president. I mean, Nicholle: No? Zalle: nobody that just got kicked out in the vote. since we went blue. Nicholle: Herein Texas Zalle: I can I can't think of anybody because that doesn't sound like a trend. Like that's happening in our culture and our society right now. I've never heard of that. Nicholle: Absolutely. Zalle: And that became a major part of the public controversy because the district attorney's original decision was based on a a narrower document than the complete interview. And I'm assuming that's the t the one that had the twenty handwritten corrections on it. Yeah. He didn't even bother to look at the handwriting. Exactly. You should have been questioning issues that follows in your Nicholle: Yeah. Exactly. You should have been questioning it or suspicious of it with all those handwritten corrections. Zalle: I'm assuming that's not the one he got. I'm assuming that's the one that got summarized was the one with the handwritten corrections. Yeah, the summarized. What is the pointwritten correction? it was okay. yeah, he definitely didn't do his job. You didn't even look at Nicholle: No, I I yeah, the summarized was the one with the correction. She signed it. That's what he kept saying. She signed it. She read it and signed it. Yeah, he didn't. Zalle: the all you had to do was read the side notes. even if you wanna look at the overall picture, the side notes would have been fine. Nicholle: Hm. And I wanna know why. I wanna know why that wasn't done. Why wasn't the full transcript requested? Did the prosecutor know it existed? Did they ask whether the written summary contained every significant allegation? And if they didn't, why not? Zalle: Did the prosecutor know it? Did they ask whether you written someone who made every significant allegation? If they did call up? They clearly didn't, but so why? There's another important detail. According to ABC's reporting, Cornell police investigator Jeffrey Northrup contacted the DA's office on November twenty five twenty-five. November twenty fifth, two thousand twenty four. He reportedly informed prosecutors that additional interviews had been conducted. The DA's beautiful office did not request those materials before maintaining its decision to not move forward with charges. Nicholle: That's right. And that is extremely difficult to understand. We're talking about a case involving multiple people, disputed consent, intoxication, and Snapchat messages. Additional witness interviews could have helped clarify what happened. why wouldn't they want to examine them? Zalle: difficult to understand. We're talking about a case involved from multiple people, disminuted control intoxication and not chat means. Additional we just could have helped clarify we have why would name things be examined? Why? Mr Van Houten? Vanhouten's position was that the signed statement didn't establish a crime under New York law, even assuming the facts in that statement were true. Assuming. His office maintained that the original decision was legally correct based on what it reviewed. It was not. I mean, you're kind of giving bullshit because you didn't review anything. Yeah, you just reviewed the sample the thing that made you walk away from to walk away from it. Nicholle: Because you didn't review. Yeah, you just reviewed the simplest the thing that made it easy for you to walk away from it because you didn't want to be bothered with it. But that's exactly the distinction right there based on what it reviewed. Zalle: But that exactly the pressure. Right there, based on what a The question is whether that review was sufficient. Nicholle: The question is whether that review was sufficient. Zalle: And I think that's a legitimate question, especially look later on that the prosecutor hadn't seen the complete interview. Nicholle: And I think that's a legitimate question, especially when we later learned that the prosecutor hadn't seen the complete interview. Zalle: The criminal investigation was reopened in September 2026 after the civil lawsuit and additional reportings brought renewed attention to the case. Nicholle: Nearly two years after Jane Doe first reported what happened. Zalle: Jane Doe reported what happened. Two years. On September 16, 2026, Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit against the seven former fraternity members, Cornell University, Chi Fi and other defendants. Nicholle: Yes, yes. Zalle: Hats off to you, sis. Do that. Do that. Stand on it. Make them make them eat what they did to you. you thought you were gonna get away with that shit? Yeah. No. Yeah. The lawsuit described the alleged sexual violence and criticized the university's handling of the incident. It also brought renewed attention to the evidence gathered during Cornell's disciplinary investigation. Nicholle: And that investigation had resulted in two expulsions for sexual assault, suspensions, and other sanctions. So people understandably began asking how the university had reached those findings while the original criminal investigation had ended without charges. Zalle: So people understand the PP and how they can further reach those findings while they criminal investigation without charges. Without charges, and t at least two of those people were found responsible for r*pe Exactly. Nicholle: Exactly. Zalle: Those processes have different standards and procedures, and some of Cornell's evidence Nicholle: Both processes have fixed some of Zalle: was developed after the prosecutor's original decision. But the question about additional police interviews available in November 2024 remains. Nicholle: Exactly. We're not suggesting prosecutors could have reviewed evidence Zalle: Exactly. Where does it pass with the evidence? Nicholle: that hadn't been collected yet. We're asking about evidence that reportedly already existed and whether the original investigation followed those leads, which it did not. Zalle: And whether the original investigation followed those leads, which it did not. On September 28, 2026, District Attorney Van Houghton announced that the investigation had been reopened. New York Governor Kathy Houchell subsequently appointed Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor. That moved responsibility for the renewed criminal investigation to the state attorney general's office. Thank you. Please do not put his ignite ass back on the case. Nicholle: And Cornell's response also expanded. Former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates was brought in to conduct an independent review of the university's handling of sexual misconduct complaints. Thank Zalle: General Stalin was brought into you was brought in the independent review of the university's handling of sexual this. Thank you. Nicholle: you. Zalle: Thank you for bringing these women in who are actually gonna look into the shit and make some shit shake because this is unacceptable. And it's also unacceptable but that it took all of this and you're only doing Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: this because Jane Doe made this case against you and now you have national coverage. Nicholle: That's So Zalle: Cornell also announced Nicholle: yeah, also Zalle: an arrangement under which New York State Police would generally investigate further sexual offense complaints that otherwise would have been handled by Cornell police, subjected to the reporting person's choice of agency. I do think that that is I have mixed f emotions about that because clearly you see w how that the police handle the situation. This situation. Nicholle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Okay. So it's no telling how it's handled the other situations before this one or Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: how what's coming after it. However, Cornell police did that job thoroughly. Enough that they reached out and called and was like, Hey, we got interviews, you need that is my only thing. But I feel like it's good because now once it's they're found responsible, it's no longer, you're expelled, your ass is going to Nicholle: Right. Zalle: jail, prison, etcetera. Yeah, because can take Nicholle: Yeah, because in this case you can be mad at Cornell because of the way that they handled this and you should be, because there are a lot of places where they dropped the ball for this young lady and I'm sure many other women. And many other victims, period. Zalle: A mini curve. It's very good. Nicholle: Men or women, it doesn't matter. But at least their police department actually investigated. Cornell did what they could. They're not the police. That is a university. So they use the policies that they have. Zalle: But every department actually investigated. Cornell with what they could. They were not the police at the university, so they use the policies that they have conclusions that they get about human creation. I can tell you that they didn't technical job, but I Nicholle: come to the conclusions that they did about these boys. Now that's more than we can say for the DA's office. I can't tell you that they did an impeccable job, but I can tell you that the DA did nothing. But this is a significant institutional change. And I want to know what the independent review finds about the response to Jane Doe's report, not just the criminal investigation. I want the medical response, the university's internal procedures Zalle: Some that we had nothing. Yeah. But this is an institutional challenge. And want to know what the finds about the response to Joseport, not just the criminal investigation. I want the medical university's internal procedure, and the way implementation particularly different part of this. Nicholle: And the way information moved between different departments. Zalle: There were also legal challenges concerning the reopened investigation. Gilea Lopez sought to disqualify Attorney General Latitia James as special prosecutor, raising concerns about her public statements. He's mad because she's a woman and he knows his ass is grass. As of the latest Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. And with the list. Zalle: hearing included in our research, the challenge had not resulted in her removal, and it probably will not. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. And now we wait to see what the renewed Zalle: Okay. Nicholle: investigation establishes. Because there are still questions about the events of that night and about the way the original report was handled. A lot of questions. Zalle: There's still questions about the invits of the night and about the way the original report has handled. A lot of questions. Nicholle: When I look at this case, three things stand out. First, Jane Doe described a sexual encounter Zalle: When I look at this thing, I was date, over the section one count. Nicholle: that began with her consent and then, according to her allegations, changed dramatically. She described additional men entering unwanted sexual contact, ketamine, physical violence, and sexual acts she didn't Zalle: At beginning with her content and then according to her allegations changed dramatically. She described the mischievous marriage featuring unwanted sexual content. That'd be physical violence sexual act she didn't agree Nicholle: agree to. Zalle: to. Second is definitely the Snapchat conversation because those messages document fraternity members discussing sexual access to a woman upstairs like she was just what do they call The electric bulls up here. Just come come come take a turn. I cannot. Nicholle: Right. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: This is just disgraceful. And then Cornell's investigation, did examine those messages alongside the allegations about the men entering the room. Nicholle: And third, the response after Jane Doe reported what happened. The police interview, The six-page statement, the additional interviews, and the district attorney saying almost two years later that he hadn't reviewed the complete transcript. That sets my insides on fire every time I want him to never say that to anybody again. Zalle: The sixth range they can review shop and reviews and the different references saying almost two years later that have reviewed the transcript. That sets my ease of my time. Yes, because at no point during these last two years did you think maybe I should do that. Nicholle: Because imagine going to work, anybody who has a job and you messed up something and your boss says, Well, what happened? And you basically say, Well, I just didn't do my job. I just didn't finish. And yeah, I just said, what would happen to you? You that's crazy. Zalle: And you basically say well I didn't I didn't do it. And then didn't go back and try to correct it. Yeah, I just asked What would happen to you? You would that's very simple. And the university's disciplinary findings are part of that story too. Cornell expelled two men after finding them responsible for sexual assault. Other men received suspensions or different sanctions. The university didn't reach the same conclusion about every defendant, but they reached a conclusion and made something happen. Nicholle: That's right. And we don't need to exaggerate those findings. We can tell people exactly what Cornell concluded. The facts are serious enough. Zalle: The same is true for Jane Doe's account. We can describe what she alleged directly. we don't have to replace forced oral sex with vague language. We don't have to describe unwanted intercourse as simply a sexual encounter. And we don't have to ignore the Snapchat messages and we're not going to. Because telling the story actually looks Nicholle: That's right. Because telling this story accurately means telling the uncomfortable parts, not making them disappear. Zalle: What stands out to me is how much attention has been paid to Jane Doe initially agreeing to sexual activity. Because that fact doesn't answer what happened during the rest of the night. No means no. Yes. Cause since one person is independent to everyone, we all know that. Because one act it is sent at the beginning of the encounter doesn't often have to be continued for hours. Remember you just for hours. Nicholle: Exactly. It doesn't yes. Consent to one person isn't consent to everyone. And we all know that. Consent to one act isn't consent to every act. And consent at the beginning of an encounter doesn't automatically continue for hours. Remember this was hours, Zalle: Good time. Nicholle: regardless of what happens afterwards. Zalle: Yeah, this wasn't just a wham bam, thank you, ma'am. It was hours hours from like eleven something to five something. And Jane Doe's early Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: messages don't erase the allegations she later reported. We've already discussed that. They are Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: part of the evidence, but so are the Snapchat c Snapchat. Snapchat communications, witness accounts, Nicholle: And Zalle: and university findings. Nicholle: I think the biggest unresolved question is whether Zalle: Well. Nicholle: the original criminal investigation examined the evidence thoroughly enough. Because a prosecutor can decide not to bring charges, but that decision should come after an adequate investigation. Yes. Zalle: We can decide that's what the charges. But that's the change we found after an adequate. After. Adequate. Yes. Is the word. Adequate. As of our research cutoff, the renewed criminal investigation, civil litigation, and independent review were ongoing. Nicholle: So before we close, there's something want to make clear. We've spent this epis episode, we've spent this episode discussing what Jane Dell reported, the evidence that came to light, and how the people and institutions involved responded. But behind every case like Zalle: But behind it, it's Nicholle: this is a real person. And for people who've experienced sexual violence themselves, these stories can be deeply personal. Zay, I'm giving you Zalle: And for people who are experienced sexual violence and those these stories good personally. Zay, I'm giving you. Nicholle: the floor. Zalle: I'm sorry, my whole chest just tightened up. Who Nicholle: You don't have to do it. Zalle: It's okay. So my experience is very similar to Jane Doe's in many ways. Many ways. I was locked out of the apartment I stayed on campus. And I had a friend who stayed around the corner. And so I was I called him, asked if I could go over there till, you know, my roommate could come and unlock the door. And then he was like, Yeah. So I went over there. And this is my friend. I trusted him. I went there and I Everything was cool. And then it turned into like then I was into women. I did not do men whatsoever. So then it turned into a, you know, well, let I wanna do this, I wanna do that. And it was always no, like I'm not interested in that. And he messed with one of my f well, somebody who I thought was my friend at the time. And so that was always a no. You mess with even if I did like men, you talk to my friends, you slept with my friends, that'll never happen. And he didn't like that answer. And so, yeah, he just raped me. And in the middle of that, in the middle of me screaming and telling him no, fighting to keep my clothes on, I remember hearing his roommate open his bedroom door, walk out of the apartment, and leave. And it was just mind blowing to me. One, I didn't know you were in here. Two, you left me here. You can hear me. And you just walked out. And I remember once it was done, he got up and left the room. And I kind of just got up, grabbed my stuff and just stood there. Like, looked around. Like what happened? And as soon as he came back in, then like the shock kind of like went away. And I just remember I got dressed and I just left. And I walked. To the busiest street on campus where all the bars are, and I just sat on the sidewalk. And I had somebody come get me, and they told me that they didn't believe me because they felt like I was lying. So I didn't look like a hoe for sleeping with somebody that my friend was sleeping with. And yeah, so I never reported it after that or, you know, said anything to anybody for a long time. And that's why I say you can't. Everybody's reaction is different because mine was just shock. It wa I'm happy that at least regardless what her friend said, she had somebody she could talk to where it didn't come out to be the same result. But I just sat on the bench and waited and just watched and made sure that he didn't follow me. And I just felt like well, I'm gonna sit on the busiest spot in campus. So even if he does come for me, there are people around and maybe somebody will help me because at that point I couldn't do anything. At least one of these people, maybe somebody won't leave. And yeah, it it's different for everybody. It's hard to talk about. I was nineteen when that happened. Twenty. I am nineteen, yeah. I am thirty now. And it still makes my chest close and it's hard to talk about. It still plays in your head. And so Nicholle: Mm-hmm. But Zalle: For anybody trying to shame Jane Doe or any other woman who's been through that experience, especially for the women to be like, well, you gave consent and then you can't take it away. Y your no always means no. And I'm sorry that nobody taught you that. But your no always means no. Nicholle: anyway, you're not. Mm-hmm. But you're not. Well, Zaili, thank you so much for sharing that. I know that it wasn't easy, especially considering this is this is the second time that we have done this episode because we couldn't hear you on the first one. So thank you. I know that's not easy. And to Zalle: Yeah. So thank you for Nicholle: anyone listening who has experienced sexual violence, you deserve to be heard, treated with dignity and supported. Zalle: And whatever your story looks like, you get to decide when, how, and whether you share it. It it's never easy. It doesn't it's not gonna be easy, but you can give yourself back that power. It's okay not to be afraid. It's okay to take your voice back in that situation and and remember like though they took that piece of you that did not take you. And so you don't have to feel ashamed in what happened to you because you're not the problem. Nicholle: Right. Well, investigators, thank you for being here with us for this conversation. What stood out to you most about Jane Doe's case? The Snapchat messages, Cornell's disciplinary findings, or the fact that the district attorney said he never reviewed the complete Zalle: The Snapchat Matispids or the disciplinary parties or the parents that you never view the computer. Nicholle: police report. Let us know your thoughts and please keep the conversation respectful if you appreciate the research and stories Zalle: Let me put the conversation on appreciation present stories. Nicholle: we bring to Coffee and Crime with Mom. Follow the show, leave us a review and share this episode. Zalle: Follow the development equally share it from. And we'll continue following Jane Doe's case for meaningful developments. Nicholle: Until next time, investigators, stay curious, stay informed, and keep asking questions. Bye. Zalle: Bye.