Latest / Her Life: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Watching My Daughter Grow Into Her Own Identity | Her Life
Transcript
- I saw a woman in a cashmere sweater buying organic kale with an EBT card, and for a split second, I wanted to hide my own hands under the table. It’s not just about money; it’s about the terrifying feeling that you’re failing at being poor. Let’s start with a scene that feels like it’s pulled straight from a dystopian novel, but it’s actually just Tuesday at my local supermarket. I was standing in line behind a woman who looked like she had just stepped out of a Vogue editorial. Her coat was structured, her nails were manicured, and she carried herself with that specific kind of confidence that usually comes from having a lot of money or very little to worry about. But when she got to the register, she didn’t pull out a black Amex or tap her Apple Watch. She slid a plain white plastic card across the counter. An EBT card. Food stamps. And I watched the cashier’s face change. It wasn’t rude, exactly. It was confused. There was a micro-pause, a flicker of judgment that I know all too well because I’ve felt it in my bones. The woman didn’t flinch. She just paid for her groceries—expensive ones, by the way, lots of fresh produce—and walked out. But as she passed me, I swear I saw her shoulders tense up. That tension is what I want to talk to you about today. It’s the shame of accepting food stamps while living in what looks like luxury. Or rather, while looking like you have your life together. We need to unpack this because it’s a uniquely modern form of anxiety. For decades, poverty has been visible. It’s been associated with ragged clothes, worn-out shoes, and a general air of struggle that society can easily categorize. But we are living in an era where appearance is decoupled from reality. You can wear the uniform of success while eating off government assistance. And the shame that comes with that disconnect? It’s corrosive. It makes you feel like a fraud. Like you’re tricking the system, or worse, that you’re tricking yourself. Here’s what I’m noticing is that our culture has built this massive, exhausting theater around competence. We are expected to be perfect at everything. We are expected to have a six-figure salary, a perfectly curated Instagram feed, a thriving social life, and a healthy relationship with ourselves. If you don’t meet those criteria, you are assumed to be broken. So when you use a benefit program, even if it’s legal, even if it’s earned, even if it’s necessary, you feel like you’ve been caught breaking the rules of the play. I remember when I first started freelancing after leaving my magazine job. I had savings, but they were dwindling fast. I qualified for some emergency assistance through a local nonprofit. It wasn’t food stamps, but it was close enough in spirit. I had to go into an office and sit across from a case manager who looked tired and overworked. I tried to explain why I needed help, but every word felt like an admission of guilt. I kept saying things like, 'I really tried to make it work,' as if I needed to apologize for existing without a steady paycheck. That phrase, 'I really tried,' is the anthem of the modern professional woman. We are so afraid of being seen as incompetent that we will suffer in silence rather than admit we need support. And this is especially true for women who look like they have it figured out. We are the ones who get the side-eye. Not because we’re stealing, but because we’re disrupting the narrative that happiness and financial stability are the same thing. When you accept help while maintaining the aesthetic of success, you challenge the idea that wealth is a moral virtue. And people hate that. They hate it because it means their own struggles might not be a reflection of their character. Let’s sit with that for a second. What does 'living in luxury' actually mean? Is it owning a condo? Is it drinking wine out of crystal glasses? Or is it simply the absence of panic? Because here’s the truth: many people using food stamps are not living in squalor. They are living in precarious comfort. They might have a nice apartment because their parents helped them move in, or because they rent a room in a shared house in a trendy neighborhood. They might drive a used Honda Civic that looks fine on the outside but needs new brakes. This is the hidden middle class. The people who are one bad month away from disaster. I think about my friend Sarah, who works in tech PR. She drives a Tesla, wears designer sunglasses, and goes to yoga every morning. But last year, her company downsized, and her severance package was less than advertised. She spent three months relying on SNAP benefits while she hunted for a new role. She told me once that the hardest part wasn’t the budgeting. It was the fear that someone would recognize her at the grocery store. That someone from her old firm would see her buying discount chicken thighs and assume she’d fallen from grace. But she hadn’t fallen. She was just falling behind. And there is a difference. Society doesn’t have a category for 'temporarily challenged.' We only have categories for 'successful' and 'failed.' And when you slip into the latter, even temporarily, you carry the weight of that label. You carry the shame of not being able to sustain the performance. It’s a heavy burden to carry when you’re already exhausted from the job hunt. It’s complicated, isn’t it? The idea that if you work hard, you will succeed. It’s a myth we tell ourselves to sleep at night. But the reality is that luck plays a huge role in our financial lives. Sometimes you’re born into wealth. Sometimes you’re born into poverty. And sometimes, you’re born into the middle, where you have enough to keep up appearances but not enough to survive a crisis. When we stigmatize people who use food stamps, we are reinforcing the idea that poverty is a personal failure. We ignore the structural issues—the rising cost of housing, the stagnation of wages, the lack of affordable childcare. We blame the individual instead of the system. And this is particularly damaging for women, who are disproportionately affected by economic instability. Single mothers, divorced women, older women who have spent their careers caring for others—they are often the ones forced to rely on safety nets. And yet, they are shamed for doing so. I’ve read studies showing that stigma reduces participation in benefit programs. People who qualify for help don’t take it because they’re afraid of being judged. This is a tragedy. It means that people are going hungry, or skipping meals, or choosing between medicine and food, all to protect their dignity. Their dignity, which is worth more than any meal, becomes a barrier to survival. We need to dismantle this idea that needing help is shameful. Needing help is human. It’s part of the contract of living in a community. We support each other. We lift each other up. And when you’re down, someone should be there to catch you, not to judge your fall. So, how do we deal with this shame? How do we stop feeling like frauds when we’re just trying to survive? First, we have to recognize that the shame is not yours. It’s a projection of societal expectations that are unrealistic and unfair. You are not a fraud for using food stamps. You are a participant in a system designed to help people in need. If you qualify, you are entitled to that help. End of story. Second, we have to practice radical self-compassion. Tell yourself that it’s okay to not have it all together. Tell yourself that your worth is not tied to your bank account. Your value as a woman, as a person, is inherent. It doesn’t decrease when you use an EBT card. It doesn’t increase when you buy organic kale with a credit card. It stays the same. Third, let’s normalize the conversation. Let’s talk about our financial realities openly. Share your stories. Admit when you’re struggling. When we speak honestly, we break the isolation. We show others that they are not alone. I’ve found that when I admit my own financial anxieties, people respond with empathy, not judgment. They share their own stories. We connect. And that connection is more valuable than any amount of money. Remember the episode we did a few weeks ago about the quiet solidarity of women working late shifts? That same energy applies here. There is a hidden network of women who are keeping each other afloat. Who are sharing resources, offering advice, and providing emotional support. We are stronger together. We are not competitors. We are allies. And allies don’t judge each other for surviving. As we wrap up, I want to leave you with this thought: True wealth is not what you can afford. It’s how you treat people when you have nothing left to give. It’s the ability to ask for help without losing your sense of self. It’s the courage to be vulnerable in a world that demands perfection. If you are currently using food stamps, or any form of assistance, please hear me when I say: you are doing what you need to do to survive. You are not failing. You are adapting. You are resilient. And you deserve compassion, not criticism. If you are not using assistance, challenge yourself to look inward. Where does your judgment come from? Is it based on facts, or is it based on fear? Fear that you might end up in the same place? That fear is valid, but it shouldn’t dictate your behavior toward others. Treat everyone with kindness. Assume that everyone is fighting a battle you know nothing about. We are all just trying to figure this out. Trying to find our footing in a world that changes faster than we can keep up. And in that uncertainty, the only thing that matters is how we treat each other. Be gentle. Be honest. Be real. And let’s build a world where no one has to hide their hands under the table. Thank you for letting me into your day. I’m Ciara Stewart, and I’ll see you next time. Until then, be kind to yourself. You’re doing better than you think.