Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 299: The Science of Influence Every Leader Must Master – Steve Martin
Transcript
- 0:00Everyone wants to be influential, but very few people actually master this skill.
- 0:04To help you become the most influential person in the room, I speak with Steve Martin.
- 0:10Steve is the author of Influenza at Work and Messengers, and he's the closest collaborator
- 0:14of Robert Chaldeini, the Godfather of Influenza.
- 0:17We cover how you can become more influential without changing people's minds, because
- 0:22that's very hard to do, how you can be trust in the age of superstars, and how you can
- 0:27become a messenger people actually want to listen to.
- 0:31So join this conversation with one of the experts in the world on Influenza at Work,
- 0:35Steve Martin.
- 0:38Why is it important to have influence at work?
- 0:41Because influence is pretty much everywhere.
- 0:44In fact, it's rare to see a job description, whether you're the CEO or you're just joining
- 0:49the organisation where the job description doesn't have the word influence or persuasion
- 0:54in some form or iteration in it.
- 0:57Of course, you don't have to take my word for it.
- 0:59I follow some surveys, principally those that are conducted by Robert Business Review
- 1:04Forbes and LinkedIn.
- 1:07They ask Oliver at the beginning of the year, what's going to be the most important
- 1:09skill that you need in your business this year?
- 1:13And they've been running these surveys for 15, 16 years now.
- 1:17And as you can imagine, the ebbs and flows of the workplace and differences in what's
- 1:22important will mean that those skills change.
- 1:25But there's one skill that never ever falls out of the top three and that's influence,
- 1:29persuasion or effective communication.
- 1:32They call them different things.
- 1:34And the latest data we have from 2024 is that it's the number one skill.
- 1:39It even beats a genty AI.
- 1:41So that's, I think, the reason why it's important.
- 1:45Totally agree, of course.
- 1:47Can it be learned though?
- 1:48Is influence something we have or have not?
- 1:50Is it something we can acquire by, for instance, you know, developing certain skills?
- 1:55I think that's a great question because oftentimes we see people that seem to have been gifted
- 2:00this ability to influence and persuade, capture their attention.
- 2:05And they seem to have been gifted this from birth.
- 2:07It's almost like a God-given skill and I think it's true that there are certain people
- 2:13that do have that capability.
- 2:16But that doesn't mean that the rest of us need to look on, obviously.
- 2:20And, you know, believe that our opportunities to influence and persuade people are always
- 2:24going to fall on stony ground.
- 2:27There are rules to how successful influence and persuasion works, often hidden under
- 2:32noticed rules.
- 2:33And if there are rules, we can learn those rules and we can apply them as well.
- 2:37So I think all of them, my response to that question is, yes, all of us can learn to be
- 2:44a little more influential, a little bit more persuasive.
- 2:47And importantly, to do so in a way that doesn't make us feel icky or requires us to kind
- 2:52of sell our soul to the devil, we can do it in perfectly moral, responsible and ethical
- 2:58ways too.
- 2:59What's the difference then between influence and manipulation?
- 3:03Well, there's a good question.
- 3:06I think, you know, for some people they would actually talk about manipulation being
- 3:11kind of morally, it's an unethical, immoral, not a particularly good approach to influence.
- 3:21But of course, manipulation can mean different things in different contexts, you know, in
- 3:25social psychology.
- 3:26If we're running experiments, we will use the word manipulate to describe how we're changing
- 3:31one environment over the other.
- 3:35So there are kind of differences, but like most things in life, they're context dependent.
- 3:40I think the really interesting thing is the difference between influence and persuasion.
- 3:47Because a lot of people, and I include myself here, we use those words influence and persuasion
- 3:52interchangeably, when in fact they're very different things, specifically influences
- 3:58about how we can have an impact on another person or a group or maybe a whole population
- 4:04of people by something that we do, a piece of information that we present to them, an
- 4:10incentive that we offer, some sort of appeal to them.
- 4:15Influences impact on an individual group that occurs from the outside.
- 4:22In contrast, persuasion is something that happens internally.
- 4:26One is largely described as inner changes that we have in our own minds that kind of
- 4:33update us, change our identity, our sense of beliefs, these kind of things as well.
- 4:38And so in that context, it's entirely possible to influence someone's behavior and not change
- 4:44their mind at all.
- 4:46That is so fascinating because I would think that I have to change someone's mind in order
- 4:51to change their behavior, and you were saying that's actually not true, those are separate.
- 4:56They are separate.
- 4:58Sometimes we do, it will be helpful to change people's minds, but it's not necessarily
- 5:03the starting point.
- 5:04It really depends on what your goal all over is in terms of the outcome you're actually
- 5:08looking for.
- 5:09And in fact, we find in study after study that we can have a pretty good effect at changing
- 5:14people's behavior in the moment.
- 5:16And minds don't change at all.
- 5:19And in some contexts in our businesses and our workplaces and our personal lives as well,
- 5:25we may not necessarily want to or need to change people's minds.
- 5:29And let's be really clear, changing people's minds is really, really hard.
- 5:33And so I think oftentimes the mistake a lot of people make in believing that in order
- 5:39to get some sort of outcome they need to change someone's mind first is that leads them
- 5:42down a particularly dangerous and often ineffective path.
- 5:46And against the wall.
- 5:47Well, yeah, you're thinking, if I'm going to change your mind, I've got to convince you.
- 5:50I'm going to like, you know, your opinion is wrong.
- 5:52Mine is right.
- 5:53See my way.
- 5:55And in those instances, we'll often go into a situation with our goal being to win the
- 6:00arguments, not necessarily to win the outcome.
- 6:03Could you do an example from maybe from business or other walks of life that exemplifies the
- 6:08difference between persuasion and influence?
- 6:10I can.
- 6:11So this is a really important one, I think.
- 6:14And it's work that two of my colleagues, Eloise Copland and Olivia Patterson at Influence
- 6:19at Work conducted a few years ago, they ran a series of programs looking to reduce animal
- 6:24trafficking of all things.
- 6:26So the Pangolin is one of the most, I think actually the most trafficked animal in the
- 6:30world.
- 6:31They are souls for their scales for Chinese medicine and then their carcasses are sold
- 6:35to questionable restaurants as a kind of off the menu delicacy.
- 6:40And they were engaged with an NGO and a charity out in Southeast Asia to see whether or
- 6:45not we could change people's minds in terms of, you know, this is not a good thing to do
- 6:49to eat this endangered animal.
- 6:51And what they found was that they were pretty effective at reducing the consumption of
- 6:57Pangolin, the legal meat by conducting a series of, you know, little influence and impact
- 7:02strategies.
- 7:05But even when they were able to change people's behavior in the kind of post-mediation surveys
- 7:11that we typically do in studies, people's beliefs about whether it was the right thing
- 7:15or the wrong thing to do didn't change at all in that instance.
- 7:20And so oftentimes it is possible to have impact and change people's behavior as a result
- 7:26of some sort of external, as I say, information and incentive, some sort of emotional trigger
- 7:31that we pull.
- 7:33And it's often, yeah, right, it's often, other people are doing it, right?
- 7:38So when I think about the business context now, AI implementation, some people are very
- 7:44negative use of AI and think, you know, it's going to be the end of the world, makes
- 7:46it a little stupid, et cetera, yet the future of the business probably depends on the company
- 7:52introducing AI in a meaningful way so it could stay competitive.
- 7:56For that, you have to take people on this journey and what you're saying for highly interesting
- 8:00is that you probably don't have to change people's beliefs about the upsides and downsides
- 8:05of AI in order to get them to use certain tools.
- 8:09Maybe it's enough for them to give them a training or tell them that their peers are already
- 8:14using that.
- 8:15It's entirely possible.
- 8:16And it's really fascinating that you brought up the example of, you know, the application
- 8:20and the use of AI, a study I'm not entirely sure if it's actually been published yet,
- 8:26but it was posted on SSRN just a couple of days ago, which one of the co-authors includes
- 8:30Robert Chaldeini, the, you know, the, the, the, the, the, the, yeah, it's a friend
- 8:35and long-term friend.
- 8:36I trained under Bob 20 or years ago and the study looked at whether the AI is persuadable.
- 8:44You know, if the AI is trained on how humans are influenced and persuaded, can we then
- 8:53persuade that AI, that machine to behave in pretty much the same way, even when they
- 8:59have been coded not to?
- 9:03And the data shows and the paper is interesting, it's worth googling.
- 9:06It's called, call me a jerk, how to sweet talk the machine.
- 9:10And the data is, is really quite clear here, the AI is as susceptible to these human principles
- 9:20of influence and persuasion to the same extent that a human is.
- 9:24Wow.
- 9:25That's, that's kind of mind-blowing.
- 9:28In a way, it's understandable to have trained on human data in a way, but you wouldn't
- 9:33think that a machine is persuadable.
- 9:35Well, and you can start to think about the, the implications are not just the positive
- 9:39ones, there are possibly some concerns there.
- 9:43Absolutely, absolutely.
- 9:44I'll definitely check that out.
- 9:46And since you mentioned Robert Chaldeini, who is probably the most famous behavioral
- 9:50scientist and psychologist in the world who wrote influence, which make a best seller
- 9:55over decades, updated as well, so super relevant up to the state, what triggered your interest
- 10:03in the psychology of influence that you've dedicated your professional life to?
- 10:08Well, I originally contacted Bob because I thought he would be able to help us on a consulting
- 10:13job.
- 10:14I was working in a big corporation at the time and we needed some help to kind of understand
- 10:22influence and persuasion, you know, even 20 years ago, 25 years ago, it was core to our
- 10:28role then as much as it is now.
- 10:30So I called him and you know, it said, maybe you could help, do you do advisory work,
- 10:36do you do consulting work, we start out in a conversation with him and his, his post-docs.
- 10:40And then the company I was working for got taken over and I was kind of in a little bit
- 10:44of a limbo and he mentioned that he was looking for people to join him at the university
- 10:48and train under him and take the research out of the laboratory, out of the psychology department
- 10:55and into the real world.
- 10:56And I think he probably saw in me an aptitude to do that.
- 11:00I'm, you know, I've got my own position now at the Business School at Columbia, but I'm
- 11:06a rather impatient theorist and academic.
- 11:09I'm much more interested in how can we make this work and apply it in practice in meaningful
- 11:15ways.
- 11:16And so that was the starting point.
- 11:17And that was, you know, over 20 years ago and I kind of thought, well, if you didn't
- 11:21quite work out, I'll probably go back to the big corporate world and I never did.
- 11:25And it turned out to be a very lucky episode of my life.
- 11:30I ended up, you know, Bob at the time perhaps wasn't as well known and as revered as he is
- 11:34now and you're exactly right.
- 11:36He is to date now the most cited living psychologist in the world and in the field of influence
- 11:42of persuasion.
- 11:43And so I was lucky to get that opportunity to meet, to work with him and, you know, we're
- 11:49pretty dear friends and colleagues now as well.
- 11:52We've published together, we speak most weeks.
- 11:55Yeah, it was a lucky moment for me.
- 11:58Amazing.
- 11:59Yeah, I love his work on persuasion as well.
- 12:01And I think it's so relevant these days that often, especially due to, let's say, content
- 12:06being the new sales almost, that we want to be persuaded before we actually talk to someone.
- 12:12It's very hard to get people on sales calls these days or show them demos or selling
- 12:16in any capacity because there's so much noise, there's so many messages.
- 12:20What people want now as, you know, better than I do is that we want to make our own mind
- 12:25and then reach out rather than being reached out by a company that wants to sell us something
- 12:30and that's where this persuasion part through content in many cases is so valuable.
- 12:36I think you're right about that in two ways actually.
- 12:39One of the questions that I am often asked by businesses with the CEOs, people working
- 12:45in organizations, governments is, is how do I know if I'm influential?
- 12:50How do I know if people see me as such a good question?
- 12:53Persuasive.
- 12:54And my answer typically is, you'll know if you have influence, if more people come to you
- 13:01than vice versa.
- 13:04So, if you find your day cold messaging people and you've got to sell your services,
- 13:10you're probably not very influential.
- 13:13And then you're in the domain of persuasion, okay?
- 13:16If you're lucky enough to have credibility, a position, a status, some notoriety, that
- 13:23people come to you because of your best selling books or your insights to whatever case may
- 13:27be, that's clearly true influence.
- 13:32So your point about persuasion I think is a valuable one as well, so this was back in
- 13:362016 that the book in the series of books that I'm part of the team of published came
- 13:43up with this at first, somewhat kind of outrageous idea that it's entirely possible to arrange
- 13:50for an individual or an audience of yours to be potentially receptive to your message
- 13:57before they've even heard it.
- 14:00And it sounds like some sort of mind-reading, mind-bending trick, but it's not, as you rightfully
- 14:08have pointed out, if people are kind of minded to be receptive to a certain type of message,
- 14:14we can think about that in our communications, in our, I mean, there's got lots of applications
- 14:20in digital advertising, online advertising, for example, even, you know, it's surprising
- 14:25to me how many people that appetise, for example, online in magazines don't really think
- 14:29about this, you know, if you're a consumer and you're reading an article about the cost
- 14:36of living crisis online, probably doesn't make sense that the next ad you see is for a
- 14:40Rolex watch, right?
- 14:42It's, you're thinking about, well, the cost of living and how tight, you know, money and
- 14:46budgets are and everything, so a high-end wristwatch is probably not the right thing.
- 14:51So often asking the question, if I'm going to deliver a message or place an ad online,
- 14:57what is the person that's going to see this?
- 14:59What have they been reading in the moment before they see my ad?
- 15:03And is that optimal from a mindset perspective?
- 15:08Are they in the kind of frame of mind that is conducive to my message?
- 15:13And oftentimes they're not, so save your money, choose another time, you know, often influence
- 15:18some persuasions, successful influence of persuasion is a function of good timing,
- 15:23not just a good message, and how the audience has primed, right?
- 15:27Right.
- 15:28Can you explain the difference between priming and framing?
- 15:31Yeah, I can, I can.
- 15:34So priming is essentially this idea that we induce a positive or somewhat helpful frame
- 15:44of mind, mindset in someone that they are going to be more inclined to be receptive to
- 15:49our message.
- 15:50For example, there was some famous studies done a number of years ago, I think back in
- 15:56the 90s now where they found that the music that was played in wine stores had an influence
- 16:02over the type of wine that people were likely to choose.
- 16:06So when French wine was played, the French wine sales, sorry, when French music was played,
- 16:13the sale of French wine would have.
- 16:15And then when they changed the music to German music, then sales of rising would rise in
- 16:20these instances.
- 16:21And so what we've got here is essentially an environmental trigger of sorts, largely
- 16:30sensual in this instance, so it could be a sound, a sight, a smell that primes a certain
- 16:38frame of mind or a mindset.
- 16:41And then a message that is conducive or an alignment with that arguably might be more inclined
- 16:46to be kind of receptive.
- 16:48Another example in online sales, for example, one furniture store found that if they had
- 16:55clouds in the back of their landing page on their website, people searched for more features
- 17:01of furniture related to comfort and softness.
- 17:04So if there were coins in the background, they went straight to how much is this?
- 17:08So there's another example of an online business.
- 17:12It's kind of positive.
- 17:13It's kind of positive.
- 17:14Yeah.
- 17:15Yeah.
- 17:16Expensive, that sort of thing.
- 17:17And I think one of the business presentation contexts, for instance, do a start by
- 17:20outlining problem or a negative, you know, the nightmare scenario or do a talk about,
- 17:25you know, the brighter horizons, the opportunities at the end of the rainbow, that sort of thing.
- 17:30Indeed.
- 17:31And then depending on those kind of emotional reactions that you actually trigger, people
- 17:34do actually have a different perspective in terms of their decision-making.
- 17:39So, you know, when people are feeling angry or kind of, you know, quite visibly emotive
- 17:45about something, they think much quicker, they are interested in just winning, they don't
- 17:49pay attention so much to the detail, the opposite is true in kind of counter emotions.
- 17:55So that's the kind of priming element.
- 17:56Framing is more, I think, setting up the right psychological contrast for the message
- 18:01you're about to present.
- 18:04You know, for example, you know, thinking about the order in which, you know, which just
- 18:07talks about wines in a wine store, thinking about the order of wines on a wine list.
- 18:12You know, if we put the cheapest at the top and the most expensive at the bottom, people
- 18:15choose a different wine than if we simply reverse the order.
- 18:18So in that instance, what we are doing is we are making a conscious decision about the
- 18:23way in which our options are actually framed.
- 18:25And this makes really good sense because, you know, you mentioned a few months ago that
- 18:29we're just like almost inundated with information and data from the moment we wake up in the
- 18:34morning to the moment we retire in the evening.
- 18:37And these are ways in which we can make efficient quick shortcuts because the idea that people
- 18:46calculate answers is, I think, a naive one.
- 18:50Humans aren't calculating machines.
- 18:53Humans are comparing machines.
- 18:57They're more.
- 18:58So I think it's not just, let's give more evidence.
- 19:03Let's give more data so that they can do the math in their head and see that I'm right.
- 19:09The way that we get through life is not to calculate the right response, but to compare
- 19:13amongst other things.
- 19:16You know, so when we look at a list, the first thing we see creates a frame of reference
- 19:20for our evaluation of everything else.
- 19:23You know, I have this saying that, you know, if you want to appear tall, you know,
- 19:27tall in a bar, go out with short friends, yeah, there's a comparison, you know, there's
- 19:34a comparison.
- 19:35Yeah.
- 19:36You have to be right about the cheap and the expensive and obviously in marketing and sales
- 19:39and, you know, a lot of what we do in business, we take this implicitly explicitly into account,
- 19:44but often more because we learned it this way without necessarily understanding the neurology
- 19:48and psychology behind it.
- 19:49Well, let me be even more forthright than that, even.
- 19:53I will go so far now as to say that if you're the sort of individual organization that uses
- 19:59data and evidence to convince an audience to sell an idea to get people behind a project
- 20:06or a program, remember this, it's never the evidence by itself that does the influencing
- 20:12in the persuading.
- 20:14It's never the evidence by itself.
- 20:16It's what you compare that evidence to that does the persuading.
- 20:21Right.
- 20:22It's the comparison too, not the evidence itself.
- 20:26There's no evidence, I forgive the irony here, to suggest that evidence alone is a good
- 20:31source of data and information.
- 20:33It might be in a law of court of law, you know, where everything is probative, but otherwise,
- 20:39it's all about the comparison.
- 20:41It's all about the comparisons.
- 20:43We are not calculating the things.
- 20:44It's such an important insight and before we present the evidence, we should obviously
- 20:48talk about, or we should ideally get past the emotional gatekeepers in our audience's
- 20:55minds.
- 20:56Right.
- 20:57Yeah.
- 20:58Increasingly we're seeing, you know, for those that are really interested in it, I can
- 21:01absolutely commend the work of Jennifer Loner over a Harvard who have had the good fortune
- 21:06to work with recently, in fact, and this idea that we are increasingly in our lives all
- 21:15over faced with hard to answer questions.
- 21:20Generally, particularly if you're the CEO, you're faced with questions about what's going
- 21:24to happen in the future.
- 21:25Now, none of us have looking glasses, none of us have that crystal ball.
- 21:30So we're largely, you know, making a future bet on the available evidence that's with us.
- 21:35But notice something that we all do when we are faced with a hard to answer question.
- 21:42The answer an easier one that no one asked.
- 21:47That is true.
- 21:48We don't answer the question, what is the right thing to do here?
- 21:52Because we don't know what the right thing to do is.
- 21:54So we replace that question with what feels like the right thing to do here.
- 22:00And in that context, our feelings become the predominant data.
- 22:08Right.
- 22:09And then we rationalize it, presumably.
- 22:11We rationalize it, we will rationalize it, depending on clearly the outcome.
- 22:15If it works well and everything is great, then didn't we do a great job if things didn't
- 22:20work so well, then it was probably something else that caused it.
- 22:23Yeah.
- 22:24And we started this conversation by thinking about how can we be more influential?
- 22:29And essentially everything we talked about so far, just understanding this, these points
- 22:34you were making, they help us become more influential.
- 22:37Right.
- 22:38And also curious to hear your thoughts about messaging and how we can make our messaging
- 22:42more effective in the book of this sort of ace acronym, which I quite like.
- 22:47So could you speak to that as well?
- 22:48Yeah.
- 22:49So in the book, this is the latest book, the economist book, you're talking about here,
- 22:53right?
- 22:54Yes.
- 22:55Yeah, we make the case that almost all successful influence and persuasion, whether it's
- 23:03a proposal, a project, a presentation, a request, a simple, you know, ask for compliance,
- 23:11they gain their success by being able to trigger or satisfy one of just three fundamental
- 23:20human motivations, the first being accuracy.
- 23:23You know, people want to do the right thing, not necessarily the perfect thing, but the
- 23:29thing that is the most accurate given the constraints and the limitations they have,
- 23:34you know, and there's lots of, you know, implications if we don't do the right thing,
- 23:38you know, we might lose money, we might lose face, we might make a bad decision, these
- 23:41kind of things.
- 23:42So we are under pressure to make as quick and as efficient a decision as we possibly
- 23:47can, but in an accurate way.
- 23:49And in those instances, this is where these comparisons and, you know, do, you know, our
- 23:56other people doing this, that might be a good source of, you know, that, you know, if
- 24:01everyone else is doing it, it's not just me joining this kind of, it's a good proxy for
- 24:04a decision.
- 24:05Yeah, we're doing it.
- 24:06And there are similar decisions to me.
- 24:07It's probably, that seems like probably an accurate thing to do, but sometimes we do
- 24:11things because it's the connected thing to do.
- 24:14You know, we are all social creatures at the end of the day and sometimes our decisions
- 24:19and our actions allow us to kind of satisfy that fundamental motivation of, of connection.
- 24:25If I do this, Oliver will spend more time with me, we'll deepen our connection, our
- 24:32relationship.
- 24:33If I do this for a client, okay, it might not necessarily make me money today, but it
- 24:37keeps that connection and that relationship going.
- 24:40So perhaps I'm willing to pay the price of accuracy for that deeper connection that,
- 24:44you know, will be helpful over the long term.
- 24:47And in some instances, we just want to do things because it allows us to feel good about
- 24:51ourselves.
- 24:52It allows to live up to our self-escribed traits, our values, the commitments we've
- 24:56actually made.
- 24:57And so invariably, there's always this dynamic where when people are making decisions,
- 25:03when they're acting in certain ways, they're satisfying one or a combination of those
- 25:08fundamental motivations and the job of the influencer, the communicator is to figure
- 25:13out what might be the most salient one.
- 25:15And to also recognize that sometimes they conflict, you know, sometimes we want to be
- 25:19part of the crowd, at other times we want to stand out from the crowd.
- 25:23In fact, in some instances, we want to be part of the crowd and stand out from the crowd
- 25:27at the same time.
- 25:29So it's complicated, but I think it's a kind of neat way to think about the fundamental
- 25:36human motivations that underpin most successful influence and persuasion strategies.
- 25:41And as a messenger, I need to really understand these.
- 25:43So just for me to recap, accuracy is, you know, oh, this feels like the right thing to do
- 25:47in the situation.
- 25:49Connection is, oh, this brings me closer to other humans, which I would like because
- 25:52connectors as a human desire.
- 25:54And ego is, oh, this is good for me.
- 25:57And that way we end up with the acronym 8, accuracy, connection, ego.
- 26:02Can you, for example, allow that how we can bring this to life in a message in a business
- 26:06context?
- 26:07Well, actually, there's a business that has been built these last 15 years that has done
- 26:12a pretty good job of actually fundamentally satisfying all three of those fundamental
- 26:17motivations of accuracy, connection, and ego.
- 26:20And it's Uber.
- 26:21Oh, you know, in the past, you know, when we needed a taxi, we would not be sure of how
- 26:26long we'd be standing outside in the rain, waiting for it now.
- 26:29It's on our app.
- 26:30We see a nice little picture of a car.
- 26:32It tells us exactly when it's going to be arriving.
- 26:34It even tells us how much the ride is going to cost and we can decide from the outset.
- 26:38So there's, there's accuracy taken care of.
- 26:41There's connection there as well, because one of the things that Uber does is it connects
- 26:44you to the driver.
- 26:45It gives you information about the driver.
- 26:47It tells you information about what other people have said about this driver.
- 26:50So you can feel like it's the connected thing to do as well.
- 26:53And I realized that this is a little bit of a stretch, but even the ego motivation is
- 26:58actually taken care of.
- 26:59And I'm not just talking about the number of, you know, points or stars or your rating
- 27:03that drivers give to you.
- 27:04I mean, that could make you feel good about yourself or not so good.
- 27:08If you time your exit from the pub at just the right amount of time as the car is pulling
- 27:13up, who knows?
- 27:14You might even be able to kind of feel like a little bit of an a-lister for a moment or
- 27:18two as well.
- 27:19So there's an example of a business that is actually built its whole model around these
- 27:23fundamental motivations.
- 27:25Absolutely.
- 27:26And there being be and many others come to mind, right?
- 27:28It's a new approach.
- 27:29So yeah, I can totally see this.
- 27:31This is very helpful.
- 27:33And if you, I guess the more of these three, you can cover the more persuasive, your
- 27:40message will become potentially potentially potentially, okay.
- 27:46What about the influence equation?
- 27:49Yes.
- 27:50Now, somewhat different and it requires a little bit of an explanation, because a few
- 27:56years ago, I was approached by the economist who wrote this book and I really didn't want
- 28:03to write it.
- 28:04Okay.
- 28:05And there's a couple of reasons why I didn't want to write it.
- 28:07The first is, is that, and you've written a few books yourself, hold on.
- 28:12It's not an enjoyable experience.
- 28:14It's bloody hard.
- 28:15It's really hard.
- 28:16It's really hard.
- 28:17And, you know, we, you know, I see posts on, you know, online media or LinkedIn and
- 28:22the people that have just decided to write my first book, I'm so excited.
- 28:26And I feel very excited and sorry for the mini-core measure, because I'm thinking, right,
- 28:30well, that's about the most it's ever going to be in terms of rewarding until you've
- 28:33finished it.
- 28:34Yes.
- 28:35Who's it that said, I enjoy having written a book?
- 28:38Yeah.
- 28:39Or writers.
- 28:40Or writers, I think.
- 28:41Whereas musicians say, you know, I love to play, but writers like to have written for
- 28:46sure.
- 28:47So, you know, I'd already written with the Chaldeini and Noah and the like in the
- 28:51part side and Joe too.
- 28:53So I had no desires to write this book.
- 28:56And the second reason was that I didn't really know if I had anything to write about.
- 29:01You know, we, influence have been published first back in 1984.
- 29:05We had its 40th anniversary last year and then, you know, the collection of us, we wrote
- 29:09yes.
- 29:10It wasn't really the follow-up, it was more a practical guide to influence, but it was
- 29:13seen as the follow-up to the influence book and that got published in 2008.
- 29:18And then we did the small big and then we did messengers back in 2020.
- 29:21I didn't really feel like I had anything else to say about influence, but then I kind
- 29:27of thought about it.
- 29:29And I'm kind of thinking it is the economist, right?
- 29:31And why would I want to say no to the economist?
- 29:34And so I started to think about, well, typically the work that we have been doing in the psychology
- 29:39of influence and persuasion is, it's been all about how do you effectively communicate
- 29:44your message, connect with people, convince people to act beyond the economics and the evidence.
- 29:51So you know, soon you have a good case to make and the economics make sense.
- 29:56How do you differentiate your case based on the social aspects of influence?
- 30:00That's been our work to date.
- 30:02And so I kind of figured, is there a way of kind of broadening that out a bit?
- 30:07And I came up with this idea that successful influence, if you want to be a good communicator,
- 30:15a good persuader, it can be really helpful to think about successful influence and persuasion
- 30:23in the same way that an artist thinks about color.
- 30:28And so, you know, I guess a lot of us will remember back to art class at school where we
- 30:35found out that we could mix various combinations and quantities of the three primary colors of
- 30:41red, yellow and blue, and we could make, marry out other colors, okay, from those three basic
- 30:47ingredients.
- 30:48And I believe to a certain extent the same is true when it comes to successful influence,
- 30:54persuasion, communication and change.
- 30:56All of us can create a compelling case based on the right combination of evidence, economics
- 31:04and emotion or put another way when we think about influence and persuasion, think about
- 31:10what is the right percentage or proportion of facts, finances and feelings that we put
- 31:15into our case.
- 31:17And that proportion will be dependent on the context of our case.
- 31:21So that gives us our equation.
- 31:22So influence essentially is successful influence is a function of the right amount of evidence,
- 31:28economics and emotion.
- 31:30And that proportion is dependent on the context you find yourself in.
- 31:34So one thing I can absolutely say with some confidence now, having been writing about
- 31:39this for the last few years is that those proportions are never the same.
- 31:44It's never 33, 33, 33 or 30s.
- 31:48And there's something quite nice about the primary color metaphor.
- 31:53I don't know what color, did you know what color you get if you mix equal quantities
- 31:57of red, yellow and blue, purple?
- 32:00No, you get a really kind of dark shitty brown color.
- 32:04Oh, okay.
- 32:05Which is beautiful.
- 32:06Ready?
- 32:07Because that's not influence at all, either.
- 32:09So that's essentially the influence equation and then what we talk about then is when it
- 32:17comes to presenting evidence, when it comes to making a case purely on economics or when
- 32:21it comes to an emotional case, what are the three most important things that you should
- 32:27always do?
- 32:28Not other 50 things that you could do, but what are the three things that are always
- 32:31going to be the most important when you are trying to persuade people using evidence
- 32:36or economics or emotions, and then that helps you build your case.
- 32:42Just to clarify, evidence and economics, how are they different?
- 32:45Because you could argue that economics should be based on evidence.
- 32:48Yeah, I think what I'm talking about here is primarily financial incentives.
- 32:52Got it.
- 32:53You know, I can inform you into change.
- 32:55I can kind of like convince you through an emotional story.
- 32:58I could just say, you know, Oliver, I want you to do this.
- 33:00I'm going to pay you.
- 33:01Yeah.
- 33:02Got it.
- 33:03Okay.
- 33:04I understand.
- 33:05Amazing.
- 33:06So that's very helpful because these three ingredients are usually part of messaging and
- 33:08it depends on the audience and the context I presume, which one I want to focus on.
- 33:13So if I speak at an economist economics conference, I may want to focus a bit more on the evidence
- 33:18economics side.
- 33:19If I speak at a tech conference, I'll probably focus more on the emotional side because
- 33:24even if they're sort of similar people in the audience, the context different, the expectations
- 33:28are different.
- 33:29So I need to be quite mindful.
- 33:30And what I always do is ask myself, what do I want the audience to know, feel and do?
- 33:35Not just to know, because that's the easy part, but also to feel and to do.
- 33:38And that usually helps me to, you know, as a compass when I think about persuasion.
- 33:42That makes good sense to me, yeah.
- 33:45How important is the messenger?
- 33:47And the reason I'm asking is obviously, for a long time, it has been said, based on
- 33:51famous book from the 1960s, the medium is the message.
- 33:55You wrote a book, co-authored the message.
- 33:56Not sure what Cluen, yeah.
- 33:57Of course, the Canadian.
- 33:58Yes, exactly.
- 33:59Exactly.
- 34:00So medium is the message.
- 34:01That was the big thing for decades.
- 34:03You came out five years ago with a co-authored Joseph Marx saying, no, actually it's the messenger's.
- 34:09And I tend to agree with you, but I'd love to hear from you while you think that the messenger
- 34:14is now the most important factor when it comes to getting the message across.
- 34:18Well, I think there's a whole array of reasons that, you know, it's easy to look in the
- 34:24rearview mirror and explain after something's happened, why it's actually happened, and
- 34:28why we are where we are in the world today.
- 34:30But let me see if I can pull a couple of points together to make this point.
- 34:34So the first is that we see it every single day.
- 34:38Okay, I don't need to present evidence or data.
- 34:41We, all of us, not just the people that are listening to this cast today, but all of us
- 34:47in everyday life, see this phenomena playing out.
- 34:52We are in the most stimulant saturated information overloaded environment that has ever existed,
- 34:59and it gets worse tomorrow and the next day and the next day and the next day.
- 35:03We cannot possibly have the cognitive bandwidth, the time, the energy, the resources, the motivation
- 35:13to listen to everything that's being said.
- 35:15And to make a decision about is this the right decision, it's the right thing to do, the
- 35:19wrong thing.
- 35:21And so one of the things that we have noticed, and it's always been there, it's just it seems
- 35:26to have been amplified, particularly in recent years, Oliver, is that rather than asking,
- 35:34what should I decide here?
- 35:37People are instead saying, who should I listen to here?
- 35:43Yeah, okay.
- 35:45And as a result, the messenger becomes the message in that context.
- 35:53Now it's always been there, okay?
- 35:55It's always been there.
- 35:56If we have a challenge with our health, we go see a doctor, there's a good messenger,
- 36:01if we've got a challenge with our car, we go see a mechanic, you know, we've typically
- 36:04thought about these people that we rely on and listen to the because of who they are,
- 36:09not necessarily because of what they say, because they have what psychologists call instrumental
- 36:15value.
- 36:16And that's how a good society should actually operate, right?
- 36:19That's the reason why we have plumbers and doctors and we have technicians and we have
- 36:22nurses and we have, you know, builders and we have, you know, computer scientists, you
- 36:27know, we can't all be expert at these kind of things.
- 36:30But what's actually happened as knowledge and information has become democratized and we
- 36:35have increasingly found ourselves in a situation where we don't know who to pay attention
- 36:42to now because we don't know whether something is true or not.
- 36:46Right.
- 36:47The message has almost become an irrelevance in this instance and it is now the messenger.
- 36:52We're not being asked to decide anymore, we're being asked to choose a side and the manifestation
- 36:57of that now and where we are is the fact that, you know, we have people that will hawk
- 37:03false facts online.
- 37:05We have politicians that will lie and we trust them more often as a result of that because
- 37:10we're choosing a side.
- 37:12And so we started to see this back in 2016, 2017 and we, Joe and I, Joe was working with
- 37:18me at the time, Dr. Joe now, Dr. Joe Martin, of course, he's now finished his PhD and
- 37:22the like, we started to ask ourselves a question, well, what are the reliable factors that
- 37:28incline people to listen to certain messages, regardless of the truth or wisdom of what
- 37:33they're saying?
- 37:34And that's what spawned the book, messages who we listen to, who we don't and why and,
- 37:40you know, we, we explored that and we, we explored the types of messages in today's society
- 37:44that are more likely to be listened to or less likely to be listened to on the basis of
- 37:49who they are, not on the basis of what they say.
- 37:54So fascinating.
- 37:55And obviously a lot has changed as the book came out five years ago.
- 37:58In particular, AI, and I totally agree, the trend is beginning for at least 10 years
- 38:03or if not, if not more.
- 38:05Today, when you think about elections in recent years, it doesn't matter which country
- 38:09you look at.
- 38:10We look at podcasts.
- 38:11Why a podcast is so influential is because people decide that they are messages they trust,
- 38:17they tend to go back to the same podcast and almost doesn't really matter what the topic
- 38:21of the day is or who they talk to, they just like the show, they like the messenger and
- 38:26the other messages they invite.
- 38:28And now that we see more deep fakes, more AI-gerated content, it makes it very hard to
- 38:33turn what's actually true and what's false.
- 38:35So in a way, for own mental sanity, we choose these shortcuts and say, I trust A, B and
- 38:42C messages and I will trust that they curate the world for me and help me make sense
- 38:47of a very complex, very confusing world.
- 38:50And therefore, I look towards messages rather than messages or the medium, essentially.
- 38:56I think you're right about that.
- 38:57There's another point I would add specifically about the audio podcast.
- 39:04It has a feature that I think is particularly persuasive, which is that it's the most
- 39:14intimate of communication channels.
- 39:18When you're listening to a podcast, you'll typically listen to your podcast with your
- 39:23headphones or your earbuds, the noise, a basement system that it has on it as well.
- 39:30So it feels like they're only talking to you.
- 39:34It's the most personal, the most intimate, and that has an impact as well.
- 39:44There's a broader implication, of course, to this and where we've gotten to, and this
- 39:49is where the focus of pretty much most of the day job is for me now, is that we have
- 39:57spawned a new type of consumer, a new type of citizen in the world.
- 40:04They're growing in number.
- 40:05There's a significant number of them.
- 40:07Typically, psychologists will look at individuals and look at how they trust others.
- 40:14On a basis of, are they high-trust people or are they low-trust people, high-trust
- 40:17people or the kind of people that are willing to listen and trust and give everyone an
- 40:21opportunity?
- 40:22Low-trust people tend to be the kind of people that think, well, you prove to me that
- 40:26you're trustworthy, and then once you've done that, then I'll start to trust you and we
- 40:30can start to engage.
- 40:32There's a new group now that we are finding significant and compelling evidence for, and
- 40:40they are growing population.
- 40:43These are people, they're not high-trust, they're not low-trust.
- 40:46Their starting point, Oliver, is to distrust everyone and everything.
- 40:54And the implications for this are crazy because trust is the social contract in a society
- 41:04that keeps us, and there's very many reasons, I think, that this group of, we call them,
- 41:10the rise of the super-distrusters.
- 41:12By the way, this is not a UK thing, it's not a German thing, it's a westernised, individualised
- 41:18cultural thing, so we'll see it in the US, we'll see it in Germany, we'll see it in Ireland,
- 41:21we'll see it, you know, these kind of things.
- 41:24We think we're seeing it in Southeast Asia, it's just that people don't talk about it that
- 41:26much because of the cultural consequences of actually doing that, but if we are now
- 41:33in a situation where are a significant proportion, and in the UK our data is it's close to three
- 41:40and ten working adults, whose defaults to distrust everything, that's problematic, particularly
- 41:48for business, because in low-trust societies, what typically happens is governments tend
- 41:54to overreach, and they start to put more regulations in place, it makes business harder
- 42:00to get, it takes longer to sign things, if there's more regulation, that just stifles
- 42:06innovation, it's stifles, technological advancements, these kind of things, it's bad for everyone
- 42:12concerned.
- 42:13Lots of friction in everyday life, indeed, across the board, indeed, and what's really
- 42:18interesting about these super-distrusters is they defy every lazy stereotype, so they're
- 42:22not like middle-aged men who've voted for Brexit and that are right-wing and that don't
- 42:26have college degrees, they're more likely to be zoomers than they are boomers, they're
- 42:30younger, they're educated, they're mobile, they're smart, and they're pretty angry with
- 42:36life as well, because a lot of things they've been promised these last ten, fifteen years
- 42:39haven't come true, and there's a case to be made that they probably have a right to
- 42:44fill the way that they actually do, but that's the group I'm watching now and how we reconnect
- 42:49an influence and engage with them because they are a significant part of our society now,
- 42:54so that's the implication of technology and the democratisation of not just facts but
- 43:00falsehoods as well, and the implication is actually having on social contracts and trust,
- 43:06it's fascinating and I think if there's one message that I'm giving out to businesses
- 43:11and institutions and governments at this moment in time is you need to pay attention to
- 43:15this group and you need to start thinking about how you essentially align and come up
- 43:21with strategies for managing, dealing, engaging with them, they are not a problem to be fixed,
- 43:29they are a group that needs a good listening to and a good sense of understanding, and
- 43:34so our basic tenets of influence and persuasion are going to be really important tools there.
- 43:38Right, and do you think they could then change their position and come around and become
- 43:43at least medium-middle-level trusting, are they gone, are they just, that's the mindset
- 43:49for ever? No, I don't think it's the mindset for ever, but I do think that there's a piece
- 43:53of a compromise here that needs to take place. These aren't crazy conspiracy theorists, they're
- 43:58smart people, I know some super distrusters, they have PhDs, they're clever, they're smart people,
- 44:06they're not wrong, they're disenfranchised, they become disillusioned, they've been sold,
- 44:13the story of, improve your life, go to college, do these things, you'll earn more than everyone
- 44:20else, and it's not worked out for them, COVID was a disaster for them, the financial crisis was a
- 44:25disaster for them, and they're looking for meaning for why are the things that I have worked so hard
- 44:33for and that I have promised, not coming true, and when they compare to their previous generations,
- 44:38their parents, their grandparents, it's a very, very different story, so they become dissolutions,
- 44:42but they represent 30% of our populations in Westernized individual countries, so they can,
- 44:48they can basically, you know, they can shake elections, they can shake new governments. Absolutely,
- 44:54they can be, wow, that's so important. And would you say from, in your book, you make the
- 44:59distinctly in hard messages, soft and hard, essentially, one more, essentially from a position
- 45:06of authority, one more from position of influence, what's the more effective messenger in this day
- 45:13and age? Well, I don't think there's necessarily a certain messenger that's going to be effective
- 45:20all the time, in the same way as I will, I will start any, whether I'm teaching the university,
- 45:24whether I'm giving a talk at a kind of conference for leaders, salespeople, it doesn't really matter,
- 45:29I will always start out by saying, if you've come here to learn the thing that's going to get you
- 45:35to persuade 100% of the people are 100% of the time, you're in the wrong place, it just doesn't
- 45:40exist. And anyone that claims that they do have that secret, you just need to kick them out
- 45:45in the room. So it's not the case that there's going to be a certain type of messenger that is
- 45:50always going to be most effective. But I think it's helpful to think about messengers in those
- 45:54hard and soft terms. So briefly, you know, in some instances, hard messengers and a hard messenger
- 45:59essentially is defined as a communicator who is seen by the audience to have some status over
- 46:08that audience. You know, they're richer or more famous than they are, they've got elevated
- 46:15expertise. Maybe they're more attractive. Or in some instances, they're just
- 46:20dispositionally more dominant. And in some instances, they don't sound necessarily a
- 46:26particularly compelling lot. But people do seek them out in certain instances.
- 46:31Whereas in other instances, people are more inclined to be persuaded by the softer message.
- 46:35And the softer messenger is someone who's defined as they don't have status over their audience.
- 46:40They have a connection with their audience. They're seen as warm, trustworthy, vulnerable. Or in
- 46:47some instances, charismatic. So they create connections. Now, what is important here is the
- 46:52circumstances in which we find ourselves in. So typically, what we find is is that if audiences are
- 46:58uncertain, they are anxious, they are worried, they're concerned about things. They have a tendency
- 47:06to listen more and follow the advice of the harder status-driven messenger.
- 47:13Now, there's probably a few of your listeners now that are thinking, oh, hello, this suddenly
- 47:18makes quite a lot of sense. And explains, in some degree, the rise of the hard dominant
- 47:26leader and politician. Because their strategy often will be to create that distrust and anxiety.
- 47:35So that their dispositionally dominant personality is the place to go. They are creating the environment
- 47:43for their dominant messenger status to exist. They are persuading.
- 47:49That's right. And there's method to the madness, right? There is, for the untrained eye to
- 47:55ask the looks like there's absolutely a strategy behind this. And it turns out that it's not just
- 48:00a political or a societal thing. It's a corporate thing as well. There's good data that show that when
- 48:07a business is looking to replace a leader, particularly a high ranking leader, say on the ex-committee
- 48:14and executive committee, a CEO, chief financial officer, whatever it may be. If that business is
- 48:20currently not doing very well, if it's lost its way, if it's strategy is failing, if it's share prices
- 48:24low, boards will typically recruit a much more dominant, hard, orientated messenger in those instances.
- 48:33But if things are going well, the strategy is going well, the share prices going well, there's
- 48:38high degrees of psychological safety. That same board will in those instances promote or appoint
- 48:45a much softer messenger in that instance. So it's very easy sometimes, I think, to commentate
- 48:51what's actually happening in the world. But these same principles are actually happening in our
- 48:55businesses too. That is true. I could talk to you for hours. Hopefully we get to do part two
- 49:02at some point. And I want to bring this home to London. Ask him, there's always my final question.
- 49:06What's your best piece of communications advice? Be more human. Be more human in the age of AI.
- 49:14Indeed. Same all. Well, I think one of the things that we maybe have lost sight of is the fact that
- 49:25influence, persuasion, communication, relationships, convincing others is primarily a human affair.
- 49:33And we've got all these tools, these new ways of working, these apps, these robots,
- 49:39these, you know, agentic AIs and all these kind of things that seem to be doing a lot of things,
- 49:45that, you know, allow us to be a little bit more efficient, allow us arguably to free up time.
- 49:51I'm not sure they do that at all. I've never been busier. At the expense of our humanity,
- 49:57at the end of our program at Columbia, I've got a couple of brilliant colleagues in
- 50:01Stefan Meyer and Oded, Netso who run the behavioral science program at Columbia with me at the
- 50:06business school. And we do this round kind of table panel thing at the end and we get various people
- 50:12into kind of talk. And he very be the question that comes up is, is an AI going to steal my job?
- 50:21That's the big question. And one of the ways we respond to that is to ask people to consider
- 50:27their hands at the end of the day. If you have to wash your hands at the end of the day,
- 50:39you're probably going to be okay because robots are good at making things. They're not
- 50:46especially good at least not yet at repairing things. So that's the first thing. Here's the other one.
- 50:54Count how many times your hand has shaken someone else's hand.
- 51:01Because a robot can't do that. So that is the essence behind my, if there's one thing to leave
- 51:09you with today, it's be more human. Amen to that. I'm so in agreement with you. As I said,
- 51:18Supercomputer Disney Supercommunicators and you help us be and become Supercommunicator Steve,
- 51:24I'd so appreciate everything you've shared with us today. All the work you're doing, please check
- 51:29out the books, messengers and our influence at works. Highly recommended. Thank you. It's better
- 51:35pleasure. I really enjoyed it. Thank you. Likewise.