Latest / Ego and Other Things / Authenticity vs. Audience: The Creator’s Dilemma | Vlogs
Transcript
- William: Alright, so today I wanted to do a looser sort of vlog-like video. Partially because I don't have a lot of time this week to develop an outline and get to another subject. I'm actually doing the bicycle ride across Iowa called Rag Bride. So I'll be gone for a week doing some ⁓ bicycle riding and street preaching out there. And so don't exactly have the time this week to get into another sort of video, but I did want to make one for you guys. And I had this sort of thought that's been running through my mind, this tension that's been running through my mind lately that I thought a looser format like this would benefit from. And that is this kind of tension between creating content for consumption versus creating content, I suppose, in a more authentic way. I've had to struggle with my writing for... some time where You have two simultaneous desires as a writer. The first is to be able to faithfully represent your ideas and what you're trying to get across to people on the one hand, and on the other hand, to have readers. You want people to actually digest your work. You want people to be actually interested in looking at your work. The problem is, of course, is that you have thousands if not millions of people out there who are also creating all kinds of ⁓ work whether it's writing or videos. And so you have to give people a kind of a reason or an incentive to pay attention to what you're doing as opposed to what other people are doing. And especially if you want to turn that kind of content into something professional, something that you get paid to do, you often have to... conform your work or conform your writing to something that people want to consume. You have to try to, in the first place, package it in a way that people actually... pick up your book or click on your video. And then you have to keep them engaged enough initially to where they're going to decide to invest the time to actually, you know, watch the video all the way through or read through the either the entire book or the entire title, entire article. And so you end up having to devote a degree of energy in your craft to making things appear palatable for general audiences from the get-go, or even just the audience you're trying to achieve. You have to in some way dress up what you're doing to stand out among the crowd before you ever get to the point of presenting the I guess you could say unique perspective or unique content of what you're trying to put out there. And so you kind of end up having to market ⁓ your writings or your videos through cliches, ⁓ through... provocative titles, provocative thumbnails. You have to provide these hooks for people, right? Can you get that great opening line? Can you get that great opening hook that's going to draw somebody into work long enough for them to pay attention to it, to take it seriously, to digest what it is that you're saying? And I think in particular, modern culture tends to trend towards short form content and there is a market, there seems to be a market or cultural demand for encapsulating whatever it is that you're trying to say in a very brief video or a very brief span of time. And that makes it difficult for somebody like myself who is trying to wrangle with pretty complex concepts on the one hand, which often takes a certain amount of time, either in writing or in videos to actually lay out, explore, deliver nuance on, explain. And it also, creates difficulties for trying to present a work authentically because the Whenever you're trying to make something, whenever you're trying to make something and you know that you're going to try to market it to a wider audience, you know that you're going to try to give it to a group of people who you have to incentivize to stop and sort of look at your work, the more you recognize that fact, the more it bleeds into the actual creation of your process, right? You have to thinking, how can I... say things in the most viral sense, right? How can I express what I'm talking about in the most controversial way? How can I highlight the parts of my thoughts, my philosophies, my writing, my ideas in the way that is going to directly and immediately challenge people? so that they'll actually give my kind of content a shot. This can actually kind of change the actual content itself or it can narrow the content or it can turn it into cliches or it can turn it into an un-nuanced project. Not the actual, not actually me coming on here and sort of giving you an authentic window into a thought process that's going on around morality, around society, around government, around parenting, any of these kinds of things, but this sort of compressed version of all that. If you ever try to get advice on on you know how to present ideas to people they're always telling you to to compress it and to in one sense act more confident about it than you are, right? So I often get advice about not hedging my words and not hedging my positions, even if at the same time mentally I know that there are objections to what I'm talking about. I know that it's not exactly intellectually honest for me to present things in a black and white way when as real process of philosophy, as a real process of ideas. Quite honestly, if you arrive at a point of complete certainty about an idea, you really cease to be a philosopher. you can present your ideas in such a black and white way and in such an overly confident way, you've really ceased to be a thinker at all. When presenting an idea, you're never really presenting something finished. You're presenting something you ought to present it as a moment in a process of understanding or discovery because you never really get to the absolute certain truth of anything because There's always criticisms and always places where it could be pushed forward There's always nuances that haven't been addressed are always things that you're going to run into in the future that are going to Come into conflict with what you're thinking and what you presented so far And not only that, but I think when you're trying to strip your work of what is superfluous for it, from it, you take out a lot of the human reflection. I get the sense just from reading old works, and I think you get this more even in theology than you do necessarily in philosophy. ⁓ Some of the better works of the past have been works which incorporate that kind of personalistic element, that almost autobiographical process of development happening in real time in relationship to ideas which are, you know, significantly important to the people who are writing about them or talking about them. And in the modern culture, you are not only taught but incentivized to strip out the personalistic elements that relate to an idea or a philosophy. And it ends up being rather, the end product ends up being rather sterile and abstract, or you have to present your stories in a way that are, or have a clean relationship to the ideas that you're talking about. Development, the exposure of development and the authentic process of actually developing an idea are relatively rare. think the last time I read a philosophical work that actually involved that was when I read Robert Piercig's Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, there was a work that was philosophical and presented a position, but it was ⁓ embedded in a kind of story, right? It was embedded in a kind of autobiographical retelling of the development of the ideas, which was actually engaging and interesting. And of course, it was able to success. But I think that kind of success is relatively rare, mostly because people who are looking for the ideas don't have the patience for, I don't know if I can say they don't have the patience for it. Maybe that's ⁓ going a little bit far. They don't have a taste for it in one sense. I feel as though a lot of ⁓ nonfiction work today is, it's about clarity, right? It's about stripping away as much of the author as, you can to present the bare ideas because you know time is money and we don't have the time to get into the actual world of the person who is creating these ideas we just want to get to the ideas themselves and see whether or not they are valuable but the truth is that any idea any concept any philosophy any presentation of ideas is in reality, a process of a person's story, a process of their autobiography, a process of life lived that can be expressed in real time. At the same time, which is not incredibly marketable, there is when you you are trying again, when you are trying to give out a work or create a video or something like that, you have to, well, you don't have to, but there, you have a great incentive to market it towards consumption, market it towards. not necessarily the lowest common denominator, but market it in a way where it is going to sell market in a way in which it is going to have a broad appeal or a broad enough appeal to to matter, right? It almost seems as though the value of a word is not so much in its inherent qualities or its honesty or its vulnerability or its forthrightness or even in the quality of its ideas, but whether or not it gets picked up in a mass way, whether or not it gets picked up by the culture itself and in one sense can can survive the culture ⁓ either ideologically or I guess in terms of making money, right? The product can't make, if a video or a book on philosophy can't make money and can't get this sort of mass appeal in an immediate way, then there is this subtle pressure to continue to try to package it in a way that people will pick it up. And sort of like, it's almost like you're trying to sneak in the real idea underneath an attractive package, right? Underneath an attractive. outline or attractive cover or And sometimes it feels like creating an intervention for somebody, right? You sort of lie about them like, oh, we're gonna go have this birthday party for a friend of mine, you're invited, right? But of course the real intention is for you to confront you with the fact that you're an alcoholic or something like that, right? And so you walk into, you're all excited to go into it and then it's actually. you know, something in depth. It's something that's going to confront you. It's something that's going to challenge you. It's something that's going to, that you're probably going to be uncomfortable with and want to turn away from. And I feel like the most valuable philosophy is the kind of philosophy that actually makes you uncomfortable. The most important idea that the ones that challenge you, and challenge your way of thinking about the world. And I'm not necessarily saying, you know, my ideas are... any of that inherently, more that, you know, just in a broader way, it feels as though we have to fool people into actually ⁓ giving a crap about... deeper issues, I guess, by making them entertaining, right? There is a market demand for entertainment and there is a market demand to package ideas and philosophies and... things like that into something that is at the same time entertaining. And so people don't approach the ideas for themselves. They don't approach the ideas for the potential for them to be valuable. They approach the ideas in terms of whether or not it can. keep them occupied for a certain amount of time. and Yeah, it's in a sense in Whistler there is a disconnect between whether something can be marketed and whether or not, whether something can be marketed, whether it can be produced as content for consumption and the values of the ideas in and of themselves. Something I was thinking about was something like book publishing, If you go to publish a book, particularly a nonfiction book, there is this... most publishers or most agent more more so agents more most agents that you're going to to try to work with are going to ask for some version of social proof right so this is like talking about social media followers on on instagram on youtube on facebook or whatever right some massive social presence that you that you already have ⁓ they're gonna want evidence of social proof so that they know that if they take on your book and publish it and market it, that there is already an audience there that is interested in those ideas and wants to push them out, right? So unless you have built an audience, there is already, there is not much of a chance of your book getting published and... pushed out to the sort of wider view, right? And that seems to make sense from a business that does make sense from a business perspective, because of course the agent and publisher, they want to be able to make money off the content. They don't care so much about the actual ideas themselves. They care about whether or not people will buy the book and whether or not they're going to make a profit from producing your book and putting it out there. And so, The consumption process puts aside the intrinsic value of the ideas themselves, intrinsic value of the ideas and or the philosophy or whatever, in favor of whether or not people will buy the book. And So if you want your book or your ideas or your philosophies to reach a wider audience, you have to package your ideas in such a way that they will have this sort of broader or mass appeal. packaging your ideas in this way forces you to kind of, again, simplify it and cut out the autobiographical and authentic process that goes into it. to make it directly relevant to people's lives and or directly relevant to ⁓ the individual consumer. rather than be faithful to the ideas themselves and rather than be faithful to the complexities and the nuances, the difficulties and the ongoing process of discovering any kind of idea at all. And guess the question I often have for myself is like, to what degree or the other am I willing to engage in that, that compromise, right? Because so much of my own process, so much of my own project relies on authenticity itself, right? It relies on the exposure of a process. It relies on the, the complexity of the ideas itself, the development of the philosophy over time, rather than a finished product, which I can just you know, create a clickbait thumbnail to and then push out into the world. And in the process of making YouTube's own videos on YouTube, I've run into this. I've been experimenting with different ways. I I can be, you know, you won't watch any of my videos and see me try to experiment with different processes. For instance, I found something like outlining to actually be really helpful because I can kind of keep track of the ideas and maybe present them. I can still be faithful to the ideas while presenting them in a more organized way. I get, when it comes to putting out thumbnails or something like that, I go back and forth in my mind on it. If I can create thumbnails that are directly relevant to the kind of ideas that I am talking about in the book and maybe peak a certain curiosity, then I'm fine with that. The hooks, I don't know. I've tried to compromise with the hooks where I'm taking the hooks from the video themselves and then putting it at the beginning so that it stays true to the actual content inside. And also this could just be a process of impatience, right? Like... even if I did the entire process, like even if I socially engineered my own videos to sort of the broader mass appeal, this wouldn't mean that the channel would sort of explode, right? And in fact, I've gained a number of subscribers. I'm sort of surprised that the number of subscribers have gone so far. So it's kind of interesting to me just to see the growth happening either way. but there's a lot of experimentation with the videos and the experimentation with the videos comes straight down to how much am I gonna keep this as authentic process in the moment and how much am I going to... contour this to appeal in a broader way. like even the degree of taking like a second take. I've done a process recently where I will record a video and then I'll go over the video, take out the strongest points from the first recording, use that to create an outline and then... ⁓ do a second take from there. And that's like a very common practice, I think, on YouTube. And there's a degree to which is just helpful in organizing my ideas anyway. I often will just take that unless I'm doing something like this, where it's just kind of a vlog, And you're just going right off the top of your head. Doing a process like that helps me to organize the ideas and is part of that practice of articulating. the ideas and just getting better at talking about my own philosophy and ideas. But it's also a question of like, okay, how much does that leave out the process, right? How much does that break away from this whole project of authenticity to begin with? ⁓ And I don't know, I don't know what the answer to that is. Again, I think I'm sort of trying to emphasize it myself anyway, that's... I'm leaning on this side of authenticity. I'm leaning on this ⁓ side of being faithful to the ideas themselves, being faithful to the process and allowing that to mean slower kind of growth in general. It's more difficult for me to decide that in terms of book publishing. I'm in the midst of writing a book right now and the book. would probably be like 90 % finished in about six months or so. the question continually comes up of, you know, am I going to go the self publishing route or am I going to go the traditional publishing route? And if I go to the traditional publishing route, they're going to want me to contour the book more towards this kind of mass appeal, more towards what's going to sell and what's going to sell in the culture is not necessarily going to be the authentic or autobiographical presentation of the ideas that I'm writing, but rather something which is going to be intrinsically accepted by the culture to begin with, like, at what point do you accept obscurity for authenticity, I guess is is kind of the tension that I'm drawing out here. And I don't I don't really have an answer for you guys. I'm just kind of wanting to lay out the the tension that going back and forth my mind if you guys have ways that you you've dealt with this, I would be more than happy to hear them. So put them down in the comments if you have ways that you've really overcome this. I don't think there's really an overcoming of the tension. I think it's kind of a negotiation and a sense of patience, a sense of you can't judge the value of your ideas or your philosophy based on whether or not other people are interested in it or take it seriously. There's a sense in which there's an intrinsic value to ideas, an intrinsic value to the process itself that has to be self-related, that you have to be faithful to, that you have to be willing to stand up for, even if nobody cares or nobody interacts with your with your kind of stuff. At the same time, you know, creating just a total private language and and giving the middle finger to the audience and not caring about whether people can understand what you're saying or whether it's relevant to them is is also not exactly the right way to go and guarantees that kind of obscurity. I mean, you can't you can't on the one, at least in myself, I can't on the one hand deny that I want people to engage with my content and my writing. And at the same time, I can't deny that I want to be faithful and authentic to the work itself. And the only compromise I've been able to come up with so far is this sense of, like put it out somewhere public, make it somewhere, right? So that people can interact with it. ⁓ But recently I think You know, with trying to focus so much on the hooks and trying to focus so much on the thumbnails and trying to focus on, you know, crafting the content so precisely in this attempt to reach broader people, I think this has taken something out of the sense of or the importance of what I've been trying to do or the intention of the project in the first place. And so you might see me in the future kind of pulling back a little bit from this. I think there are elements again that have been useful, like the outline, you know, doing double takes. the thumbnails to a certain degree, but in the spirit of trying to keep it authentic, I think I'm gonna end up pulling back just a little bit on crafting it, which may make the videos seem more disorganized and again, maybe they won't reach as much of a broader audience or maybe the growth is gonna be slower. Whatever. I think it's probably too early for me to even judge the efficacy of what I was doing before because it's not like I've made all that many videos and I've really only been active for... a little over a month and a half. So I'm not sure you can squarely judge the value of it in that short of a time, but just I'm almost anticipating the structure that's been coming out in myself. And I want to stay true to the process. I want to stay true to the idea of keeping it nuanced, keeping it, keeping the process as a part of it and not being consumed by contouring the content towards what I think might have broader appeal. I would rather be obscure than be inauthentic is essentially the stake I'm taking here. It doesn't mean it has to be black and white like that. But I think I'm just sort of reestablishing in myself this more primary value of authenticity compared to broader appeal, broader viewership, making money and creating content that is purely for consumption. I'd rather speak to an audience that has the patience to endure ⁓ long form content and the nuances and the process and the discovery of ideas in real time. That's the kind of content that I want to produce and that's the kind of audience that I want for my content. But anyway, this is just my thoughts. Just a short video for you guys, a little peek behind the scenes here. But if you guys have any thoughts about this, if you have any ways that you've overcome this distinction in yourself, I'd be really grateful if you just put those down in the comments so that I can read them. And if you like this video, please like it. If you think that somebody else would get some value out of this, then please share it with them. And if you want more videos like this, then please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for listening.