Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #80🎙️ |Public Inquiry Growing Frustration Week Beginning 29th June 2026 Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:04Unknown: Before we begin this evening, I'd like to try
- 0:07something a little different. Over the past few months, we
- 0:11spent a lot of time talking about, amongst many other
- 0:14things, planning law, environmental statements, noise
- 0:19assessments, traffic modelling, hydrology, peatlands,
- 0:24archaeology, cultural heritage, ecology, policy documents, legal
- 0:29submissions, and procedural arguments necessary, though all
- 0:34that is, I've begun to realise that we're in danger of
- 0:37forgetting why any of us are here in the first place,
- 0:41alongside a number of others, we've been writing something
- 0:45called the Spurn's Declaration. It's a declaration of rights for
- 0:49a living landscape, rather than speaking about the Spurns, it
- 0:55speaks as the Sperns. I'm not going to read it all today.
- 1:00Instead, over the coming weeks, I'd like to share a few short
- 1:04passages. Think of them as moments to lift our eyes from
- 1:09the paperwork and the computer screens, and remember what all
- 1:13this is really about. And today's passages: I was here
- 1:19before your borders, before your roads, before your industries,
- 1:23and your maps. I am the ancient hills, the valleys, the rivers
- 1:29and streams, the peatlands, the soils, the winds, and the
- 1:34wildlife. I am the visible and the unseen, the physical and the
- 1:40spiritual, the memory of the past and the possibility of the
- 1:44future. Every week at the inquiry, we spend hours
- 1:50discussing a project that may last 20 years. The Sperans have
- 1:55been here for 1000s. Sometimes it's worth reminding ourselves
- 2:01which of those should be regarded as the permanent
- 2:04feature of this landscape. One thing I've learned over the past
- 2:10few months is that this inquiry has become much bigger than any
- 2:13one individual. Although I couldn't be there today, there
- 2:18were others in the room taking careful notes, asking questions,
- 2:22and making sure nothing was missed. Today's account is based
- 2:26on their observations. As the discussion unfolded, the
- 2:31Commissioner asked Dr. Gordon, appearing as an expert witness
- 2:34for Delraydian, about the precise location of the proposed
- 2:38explosive store. What followed was a series of references to
- 2:42different appendices and documents as the location was
- 2:45being sought. When the question was put more directly, Dr.
- 2:49Gordon apologised and offered to provide a location map of the
- 2:52explosive store. The commissioner, however, made it
- 2:56clear that she did not want any further new material being
- 2:59introduced. She said, in effect, I've asked you whether the
- 3:04explosive store is shown on the map. It's a yes or no question.
- 3:09I'm a blunt person, and I like a blunt answer. At that point, mr.
- 3:13Beatty counselled for Dalradion intervened, suggesting that it
- 3:17was not appropriate to ask such direct questions. The
- 3:21commissioner responded that the applicant had been asked several
- 3:24times already, and remarked that it was still the same story.
- 3:30Hearing about this exchange, I wondered whether the
- 3:33commissioners are beginning at long last to recognise that
- 3:36third parties have been raising since the beginning of this
- 3:40inquiry, namely the continuing flow of additional information
- 3:44and clarification being introduced by the applicant as
- 3:48the proceedings have progressed. We've made that point repeatedly
- 3:53over the past number of months from the submission of the 96
- 3:56additional files containing 1000s of pages of documentation
- 4:01after the original submission deadline through to today's
- 4:05discussion about the location of the explosive store. Whether the
- 4:10commissioners have now reached the same conclusion remains to
- 4:13be seen, but today's exchange certainly suggests a growing
- 4:18impatience with questions that, in their view, ought to have
- 4:21very straightforward answers. Eddie McCullough, 208 Crock and
- 4:26Boy Road related, how the final explosive blast in 2016 for the
- 4:34exploratory tunnel for the mine shook the whole house from top
- 4:37to bottom, cracking the walls, and that there is now evidence
- 4:41of major structural cracks in the home. Beatty replied to this
- 4:47that there had not been any claims made by Eddie McCullough
- 4:51to the company. There was also discussion around the security
- 4:55of the explosive store. Beatty had said that there will be no
- 4:59impact from the. Explosive store. The commissioner was
- 5:02quick enough to ask why. Then was there an exclusion zone in
- 5:05place around the explosive store? Carl Glass, speaking on
- 5:10behalf of Savar Spurns, said that despite the locks and
- 5:13cameras, a man was able to walk in and out of the place, saying
- 5:17that she thought it was ridiculous and that the figures
- 5:20didn't make sense. Dr.
- 5:23Louise Taylor commented that her own home had greater security
- 5:27than the Tel Arabian Explosive Store, that the explosive store
- 5:31was a threat to national security, and that the PSNI was
- 5:34ill-equipped to deal with it. Conditions were discussed, which
- 5:39means that if planning is received that there are
- 5:42conditions in place which theoretically will mitigate any
- 5:45problems going forward in an ideal world. When Fidelmo Kane
- 5:49was asked had she any conditions in her rebuttal, she replied
- 5:52that without prejudice she thought that the mine could not
- 5:56possibly go ahead and did not see any reason for adding in
- 5:59conditions. Her conditions were then accepted. The one thing
- 6:04about conditions, though, is who will enforce them, who has the
- 6:07budget to oversee that the conditions are carried out. I
- 6:11can't imagine Fermanagh and Oma District Council wanting to take
- 6:14this on, so therefore it has to be DFI and as their role in
- 6:18preparing information for the public inquiry, and their
- 6:22subsequent participation has been, at best, lukewarm. It does
- 6:26not exactly fill one with confidence. We, the local
- 6:30community, would be the ones living with the consequences if
- 6:34planning conditions were ever to prove ineffective or unenforced.
- 6:39Companies can change ownership, restructure, or ultimately move
- 6:42on. Communities don't have that option. We remain here long
- 6:48after the last tonne of ore has been extracted. That's why
- 6:52questions about long-term accountability matter so much.
- 6:56The end of the morning, just before lunch, I believe, about
- 6:591245 the commissioners announced that they would be breaking
- 7:02early. Some third party members thought they were going to get a
- 7:06slightly longer lunch break. To their surprise, they found out
- 7:10that the whole of Tuesday afternoon timetable was being
- 7:13abandoned, and that the PI would recombine on Wednesday morning.
- 7:19Talking afterwards to several of those who attended this morning,
- 7:23one thing struck me. Every single one of them independently
- 7:27described the same atmosphere. This spoke of a process that
- 7:31feels increasingly screwed down and tightly controlled. They
- 7:35worried that expert witnesses were finding more difficulty to
- 7:38fully explain their evidence before being moved on, they
- 7:43described the atmosphere as tense and at times
- 7:46uncomfortable. Perhaps most telling of all, several felt
- 7:51that the principle of equality of arms, so fundamental to any
- 7:55fair hearing, was beginning to feel like a distant aspiration
- 8:00rather than lived reality, whether that perception is
- 8:05justified or not is ultimately for others to decide. But when
- 8:10different people leave the room expressing remarkably similar
- 8:13concerns, I think it's something worth paying attention to. Then
- 8:18there's the timetable. These sudden changes are no longer
- 8:22just inconvenient. They are beginning to have a real impact
- 8:26on the lives of the third parties. People have arranged
- 8:29time off work, organised childcare, travelled long
- 8:33distances, rearranged family commitments, only to discover
- 8:37that hearings have been shortened or rescheduled with
- 8:41short or sometimes like today, no notice given at all. It's
- 8:46difficult not to feel that this has become a war of attrition,
- 8:50perhaps not by design, but certainly in its effects. Every
- 8:55unexpected change places another burden on ordinary members of
- 8:58the public who are trying in good faith to participate in a
- 9:02process that will shape the future of their community for
- 9:06generations to come. Thanks for listening, and see you all again
- 9:10soon.