Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Trump Nationalizes Intel, Fed Turns Dovish & Warms the Money Printer
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing. The role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. Hey guys, thanks for tuning into
- 0:52another episode of final settlement.
- 0:54It was a fun podcast covering all things that have happened
- 0:58the past, you know, week and 1/2 in the digital asset space
- 1:02positives around Bitcoin adoption, along with all coin
- 1:05mania coming back. Quick word and exciting
- 1:08announcement. You'll be one of the first to
- 1:10hear it. We just launched On Ramp
- 1:11Guardian, really excited to get this out because we've heard
- 1:15from the market all over the board as it comes to security
- 1:18with clients of on Ramp and then prospective clients that are
- 1:21looking to leverage our solution, but have certain
- 1:24aspects of giving up what they deem as control as a negative.
- 1:28It's something that I talked to clients a lot about, if clients
- 1:30have come on from, you know, 50 to $250 million and really
- 1:35explaining this notion of a, it's not all or nothing, but
- 1:38also where we're heading to. You're going to be praying for
- 1:41giving up that control as the market starts to realize you
- 1:44don't want hundreds of millions of dollars or even 10s of
- 1:47millions of dollars in your possession.
- 1:49And So what Honor and Guardian does is effectively brings out
- 1:53withdrawal delays, deep fake protection against AI, Instant
- 1:57Three's functionality, and then obviously our Lloyds of London
- 1:59insurance. And then for private clients, it
- 2:02goes even deeper, really thinking through different
- 2:06withdrawal freezes, which has come up a lot, you know, up to
- 2:08365 days. Custom velocity controls around
- 2:12the amount of capital that can moved.
- 2:14And then a real proprietary 3FA protocol where you have to
- 2:18leverage the blockchain, specifically the Bitcoin
- 2:20blockchain to move Utxos around to prove that it's verifiably
- 2:23you in an objective manner. Really excited about this.
- 2:26If you want to learn more, if you're already a client, you
- 2:28could just, you know, activate it via the web platform.
- 2:32And then if you're looking to learn more, please feel free to
- 2:34book a consultation or shoot me a note.
- 2:36Always happy to hear from folks, Michael at honor@bitcoin.com.
- 2:39Now on to the rest of the show. All righty, welcome back to
- 2:43another episode of Final Settlement.
- 2:44Today is Monday, August 25th, 10:13 AM Eastern Time.
- 2:51I'm back in New York boys, no more pretty beach skate behind
- 2:54me. How was your weekend?
- 2:56How we doing? Big list, Big list today big.
- 2:59List I feel I'm not 100% but like 95% which last week I was
- 3:05like 60. So I feel like you know,
- 3:061,000,000 bucks. I'm excited to chat.
- 3:09I'm in Nashville right now. I woke up it was 59°, which from
- 3:12like a native Texan in you know, August to wake up 59° is pretty
- 3:17wild. So feeling good and just ready
- 3:20for the spicy takes. It's too much bullshit, too much
- 3:22things getting thrown around that the market believes to be
- 3:24true that just aren't. So I'm going to try to bring the
- 3:27heat in this one. Yeah, lots of lots of different
- 3:31topics to get into. We'll talk a little private
- 3:33equity. We'll talk a little custody
- 3:35landscape, some new research that early writers put out last
- 3:38week. Maybe, though where we're going
- 3:41to start is some news from the Trump administration.
- 3:47I'll pull up first here a a truth social tweet, Truth social
- 3:52post. I don't know what they're called
- 3:54from the dawn. It is my great honor to report
- 3:56the United States of America now fully owns and controls 10% of
- 3:59Intel, a Great American company that has an even more incredible
- 4:03future. So this made some waves over the
- 4:08past several days in what is a pretty, pretty strong departure
- 4:14from sort of the typical level of government involvement in the
- 4:19private sector and a public company like Intel.
- 4:23The government just coming out and saying, you know, now we own
- 4:2510% of that. So there's a few other links
- 4:28that I'll find for this, but what are the immediate reactions
- 4:30and thoughts around this guy's? Keep this one up for right now.
- 4:34This is, there's so much in here that we could talk about this
- 4:37for a week straight, but one of them is in the post you said the
- 4:40United States paid nothing for these shares.
- 4:42The shares are now valued at approximately $11 billion.
- 4:45That's not true. They the money comes from
- 4:48somewhere. It doesn't come from nowhere.
- 4:51So they gave significant amount of tax breaks as well as just,
- 4:56you know, they, you can also say the, the United States paid
- 5:00nothing for these, this amount of money that we printed during
- 5:03COVID and it's now worth like $5 billion or whatever amount they
- 5:08did. And it we all pay for it in
- 5:11inflation as well as taxes. In addition, to see there hurts
- 5:18it's it's difficult to see some winners and losers being picked
- 5:22when a lot of these large organizations continue to be
- 5:27able to have the ability to find out how do you monetize all the
- 5:31tax breaks as well as they can. The smaller companies just don't
- 5:35have the ability to. Jackson talked last week about a
- 5:39family Italian restaurant in his neighborhood closing after 40
- 5:43years because of the impacts of inflation.
- 5:46The while Intel, which is losing money, gets additional stake in
- 5:52an investment from the government.
- 5:55But it's when, when looking at this, it's interesting to see
- 6:00it's a, it's a departure from recent activity here in the US
- 6:04of the government not taking any stakes in companies.
- 6:07But it's actually very common when looking at the broader
- 6:11landscape of, you know, how companies benefit from or the US
- 6:17government or governments in general benefit from taking
- 6:20stakes in companies. So in the past, during world
- 6:24wars and financial crises, respectively, the US government
- 6:28took stakes in railways as well as, you know, banks and AIG, et
- 6:33cetera, during the financial crisis.
- 6:35I guess, you know, maybe we'll look back on this and say that
- 6:39we're currently in the midst of the debt crisis, which is going
- 6:42on and that's probably why they're doing this.
- 6:45But when looking at other countries and what ask or what
- 6:51stakes in government or stakes in companies that they have,
- 6:54it's pretty similar to what you would expect.
- 6:57It's there are four kind of key areas.
- 6:59One, Financial services like banks and potentially stablecoin
- 7:04issuers moving forward, defense companies in critical parts and
- 7:08then the flow of key material. So you know, I'm just looking at
- 7:14a list of other other countries and what they've taken stakes of
- 7:19the United Kingdom, coal, rail, steel industries during World
- 7:23War 2 as well as 2008. The banking sector bailouts.
- 7:28France during World War 2 was automotive and now
- 7:33telecommunications and defense. Germany, a lot of aviation.
- 7:39Italy banking and then we kind of just going through the list,
- 7:43it's a lot of energy production, oil banking, so just key
- 7:49critical parts that go into economies especially during
- 7:53times of turmoil. So, and it's really interesting
- 7:57that the they said this morning that they're going to be taking
- 8:01share of additional companies moving forward, those that
- 8:04continue to get tax credits from the government.
- 8:08So I think it's just very, it's something to watch and I would
- 8:13expect those key industries to to get some more attention
- 8:16moving forward. This makes no fucking sense.
- 8:21Yep. You didn't have a take.
- 8:23You just shared us a history on like what, what like what's
- 8:27going on? But this makes so like we it
- 8:30has, it makes zero sense. Like this is so insane.
- 8:34I don't even know what to make of it because everything feels
- 8:36like when it comes out, it's just like, oh, we throw these
- 8:38things out of God. I don't even know what's the
- 8:41most recent new insane thing. Like what was it the Trump files
- 8:45where they're like gonna release him and they're not.
- 8:47And we just like all like laughing off like these things
- 8:48get thrown out that the US government's taking 10% stake in
- 8:52a private business. And we just like, well, this was
- 8:55done before and This is why it's like this is the most bearish
- 8:59take on like humanity and like the United States specifically.
- 9:03And the reason for it is it's, it's very similar to like we've
- 9:05got super Co opted and, and our brains have got a Co-op
- 9:08different first principles thinking around the notion of
- 9:12the very often it's thought out like who will build the roads,
- 9:16right? Like we need the government to
- 9:17build the roads. It's like, no, no, that's not
- 9:19how it works. Like humans, they deliver value,
- 9:22they create value, they have moral integrity, and ultimately
- 9:25if the road around their community needs to be built,
- 9:29they will figure out how to build the roads.
- 9:31This is how all of humanity has existed.
- 9:33This is how we've like delivered value.
- 9:35He goes across and reminds me very similarly of like the TLT
- 9:38pods. When we talk to Jackson, he
- 9:39would bring up Ubi on Bitcoin. It's just like a, there's only
- 9:41like levels that we forgot to build in.
- 9:44And so going back to what this is saying is that we do not feel
- 9:47that the private market understands how to develop and
- 9:51create efficient technology. So the government is going to
- 9:55take a stake and help and influence that outcome, which we
- 9:59understand the more, the further we send our money away, the more
- 10:03inefficient the allocation of the capital.
- 10:06But then and then as that capital gets more inefficiently
- 10:10allocated, the more inefficient the outcome of the production.
- 10:14And you referenced it and and when you kicked off what you
- 10:16were sharing about nobody will pay for it.
- 10:19It goes back to like another first principle thing that I
- 10:22think we like all missed is there's I think Brad Gerstner.
- 10:25And who is it Brad Gerstner and Bill Bill Bill Gurley were
- 10:32talking about whatever the new like save a child like and all
- 10:35these things always sound good. It's like where you're going to
- 10:37give a kid like $1500 when they're first born, you're going
- 10:40to lock it up and it's going to get put into public markets is
- 10:43going to compound. It's like, well, that's
- 10:45somebody's money. Like it's not free money.
- 10:48And is there a better use for that money?
- 10:51It's like, yes, by the family that like made it and then they
- 10:53would save their own kids money or you know, child like if this
- 10:56is it's a free market endeavor, it's just ludicrous.
- 11:01But it makes sense because we're just in a weird, ludicrous world
- 11:04where the government's going to tower that from national
- 11:09security to domestic production, which brings up the other two
- 11:13parts of like, isn't this basically what like a mix
- 11:16between, you know, private and public market, like fashion
- 11:19fascism is? Where's the line when you start
- 11:22to create? Is it?
- 11:24You mentioned some vehicles, but what about tech companies like
- 11:27Facebook? And then we saw what happened
- 11:29with COVID and how insane the government allocates any amount
- 11:33of resources. So the whole thing's
- 11:36preposterous, basically. Yeah, I I would agree with all
- 11:39that. I I am definitely in the camp of
- 11:41this is pretty insane just in terms of a few things you
- 11:45referenced in there, like the blurring of the boundaries
- 11:48between public and private. I think this while Liam laid out
- 11:51some historical precedent for these types of things, this
- 11:55explicit of a of a blurring, you know, hasn't happened in a
- 11:59really long time, at least in sort of public markets like
- 12:03this. And so the other big thing that
- 12:05sticks out here is like this is very clearly, you know, if
- 12:07you've been listening to this administration over the past
- 12:10eight months or so that they've been in power, like they have
- 12:13somewhat forecasted or signalled this in the sense that like they
- 12:16view specific industries as national security assets.
- 12:21And so like, it's, you know, while it is a jarring move in
- 12:26terms of, you know, blurring those lines in a pretty explicit
- 12:30way, they have sort of been forecasting that like they view
- 12:33a lot of these things as almost existential to national
- 12:36security. But to your point, Michael, like
- 12:39it does like this is sort of, you know, what you would expect
- 12:43the Chinas of the world to do is just, you know, take over
- 12:46certain areas of public markets. Like it is pretty wild in that
- 12:51respect in terms of what this does.
- 12:53Like the implications of it are, you know, prices, markets get
- 12:58distorted as a as a result of these sort of capital allocation
- 13:03decisions at the government level where again, like, yeah,
- 13:06somebody's paying for it. And so that that sort of inserts
- 13:09some amount of moral hazard into markets, into these industries.
- 13:12Generally speaking, if there is a, you know, free money printer
- 13:17allocator stepping into the market and taking control of,
- 13:19of, you know, at least parts of certain industries.
- 13:22My, my two favorite parts are the notion of purchasing the
- 13:27stake in the company. You're pretty much it's, it's
- 13:32like the they're like they're just really very gas lighting
- 13:35mechanisms in the sense of if you wanted the free market to to
- 13:39out compete Intel, you basically assured with a move like this
- 13:42that they won't because imagine being an entrepreneur in any
- 13:45form in the US government and your competitor takes a stake
- 13:48like you're just, you know, what are you supposed to do there?
- 13:51This unlimited amount of capital and involvement, whether it's
- 13:53government contracts. But the other one that's fun to
- 13:57bring up is so the government's going to start buying stakes for
- 14:00national security perspectives of, you know, companies.
- 14:02Well, you know, there's a nice business over there that's
- 14:06sitting on, I don't know, the next World reserve currency,
- 14:09what is it, 550,000 BTC? That feels more than that.
- 14:13Yeah, that feels almost 700 real.
- 14:15Convenient to be able to normalize the notion of taking
- 14:19positions in businesses. So yeah, good luck with that.
- 14:23Yeah, it makes no sense at all. But I'm, and I'm not condoning
- 14:28or, or supporting this, but I'm just saying it's, it's the very
- 14:30early days and, and it's going to happen even more and more.
- 14:33And it's very difficult to see for a company like Intel because
- 14:38what do you do if you're, you're the competitor?
- 14:40It's kind of just like what Bill Gurley talks about, just like
- 14:43all this amount of crazy funding that goes into, you know, the
- 14:46Ubers versus Lyfts. And if you don't take the money,
- 14:48then you're at a disadvantage to others.
- 14:50And same with all these late stage companies who are just
- 14:53being asked and flooded with money to go develop the new AI.
- 14:57You, you. It's not a great situation if
- 15:00you're the competitor and dealing with, OK, well, the
- 15:02government has a stake in my competitor.
- 15:05What do I do now? Yeah.
- 15:09Well, times, but like Michael said, this will be forgotten
- 15:12about in a week. We just gloss over it and move
- 15:14on to the next thing, which is kind of insane.
- 15:17And yeah, I'm glad you brought up the the MSCR point, which is
- 15:22obviously where, you know, a lot of Bitcoiners took this on
- 15:24Twitter of like, you know, maybe, maybe you'll, you'll
- 15:27think a little bit more critically about proxy exposure
- 15:31to Bitcoin and not not actually owning the underlying and, and
- 15:35trusting a corporate entity to hold it.
- 15:37And also, you know, trusting layers of counterparty risk
- 15:40beneath that as well. Puts it into context that these
- 15:44things are possible. And if it's occurring with
- 15:46Intel, why couldn't it happen with MSTRI?
- 15:49Think is a is a reasonable question to be asking.
- 15:55Moving on from there, there was a few private equity related
- 16:00tweets I saw that I wanted to share.
- 16:03This first one is basically a lot of PE firms, large PE firms,
- 16:11KKRS of the world, Bain Capital, Goldman have started using
- 16:15commitments to continuation funds as collateral.
- 16:18So this is basically, you know, indicative of a few things to
- 16:23pull out of this, but basically there's a liquidity crunch in
- 16:27private equity. Generally speaking.
- 16:29Some numbers that are quoted in this Bloomberg report are are
- 16:33distributions to investors have collapsed over the past several
- 16:35years. So what was around 29% of NAB
- 16:40being distributed about a decade ago is now 11%.
- 16:44So these firms are are struggling to return cash.
- 16:46And so this is a clear sign of sort of a liquidity squeeze
- 16:49across the industry. And so they're resorting to new
- 16:51forms of financial engineering and sort of shifting risk
- 16:54around. And so to avoid sort of for
- 16:57sales at discounts, firms are now using what are called
- 17:00continuation funds to basically use those new commitments as
- 17:06collateral for new borrowing. So this is at various, some,
- 17:09some Ponzi elements to, to, to everything that's happening here
- 17:11and being described basically, you know, financial engineering,
- 17:15masking the underlying liquidity and these delays and inevitable
- 17:20markdowns that are occurring in, in the PE space more broadly.
- 17:23And so all of this is, you know, adding some success, systemic
- 17:26risk and vulnerabilities in the PE space broadly.
- 17:30And you know, marks a, a shift that we've seen over the past
- 17:34few years with, you know, exits being harder, basically masking
- 17:39over what what are probably a lot of markdowns in these
- 17:42portfolios. And so just shifting the risk,
- 17:45shifting these investments into continuation funds and then
- 17:48actually barring against those commitments as well.
- 17:51Any thoughts on this guys? I think the biggest thing is, I
- 17:58mean this is the trend we'll watch for the next 10 plus years
- 18:01is counterparty risk and the insolvencies of various funds
- 18:07and sovereigns. When it comes to all this
- 18:08misallocated capital. We the numbers get so big that
- 18:12we gloss over like when you hear billion dollar fund goes out of
- 18:18business or markdown, we talked about it a week ago, over 2
- 18:21weeks ago, the open door marked down from the billion dollar
- 18:23valuation to like $50 million. It's like that capital is
- 18:26destroyed and somebody is capital has been destroyed an
- 18:29individual, an investor in the fund.
- 18:33And this is that that reversion back to what we've been talking
- 18:36about in sound money and gold and Bitcoin that the markets
- 18:38going to wake up and realize like the risk free rate is
- 18:41whatever gold purchasing power looks like on an annualized
- 18:44basis or BTC and you don't have to go make these risky bats
- 18:48anymore. But the reality is we're going
- 18:51to play this out for so long because if you think about
- 18:53London School economics, Chicago School of Business, like these
- 18:57academics and people cannot fathom that it's as simple as
- 19:00just buying one or two assets and then just going back to
- 19:02their life and trying to produce value.
- 19:04And their whole livelihoods are built around trying to either
- 19:07outsmart or extract value from the markets.
- 19:11So I see this persisting much longer, but we're speaking to
- 19:14the individuals that kind of get it.
- 19:17And that's basically underpins a lot of our investment thesis as
- 19:19well as like who's delivering value to the world is Northstar?
- 19:22Because if you're delivering value to the world than
- 19:24individuals with value will pay, will pay for that.
- 19:27And whether it's in dollars and get swept into Bitcoin or
- 19:30whether it's in Bitcoin on ramps, a great example.
- 19:32PS People play us in Bitcoin because funny enough, one of the
- 19:36only things that are more valuable than Bitcoin is how you
- 19:38custody it. Because if you don't custody the
- 19:40right way, you might might not hold it very long.
- 19:43So yeah, I mean, a lot of this makes sense.
- 19:45It's just unfortunate because it's going to take a while to
- 19:47play out. Yeah, using leverage has been
- 19:52the prudent thing to do for these PE funds from, you know,
- 19:572009, 2010 to right up till COVID.
- 20:01And they're just going to, and they've gotten a lot of value
- 20:04that way. And so they think that it's just
- 20:05going to go on forever. But unfortunately that's, that's
- 20:10not quite as valuable as just like actually investing in real
- 20:15companies that are delivering value.
- 20:17But yeah, it's going to take a long time.
- 20:20Yeah. And then the other, the other
- 20:21link I wanted to share related to this is sort of on a a
- 20:26similar but different track and and what this chart is showing
- 20:29is revenue growth as increasingly the key value
- 20:33creation lever for PE generally speaking.
- 20:36So it's saying effectively like what was always sort of a game
- 20:39of of leverage and cutting costs isn't really working.
- 20:43And so a lot of the exits that we've seen over the past few
- 20:46years are shifting a little bit more towards just top line
- 20:49revenue growth and margin expansion as opposed to levering
- 20:53up a business cutting costs. And I think this is an
- 20:55indicative of a few things, but you know, effectively what what
- 21:00has worked is starting to not work.
- 21:02And so this is a sign of, of people in PE land having to, to
- 21:06ship their strategy a little bit and focus a little bit more on
- 21:09actually, you know, getting a company to produce value.
- 21:12I think the other take away from this could be just the onset of,
- 21:15of AI, like maybe you need less leverage and, and the cost
- 21:19cutting is, is also still a component there, but you're just
- 21:22leveraging deflationary tools in a little bit more of an
- 21:24efficient way and just driving revenues a little bit faster
- 21:28than you otherwise would have. But any any thoughts on this
- 21:30one? Well, this ties into a little
- 21:32bit of the the first conversation around.
- 21:36We never tie back directly when we see housing, but specifically
- 21:41medical care and education, because a lot of these things
- 21:45are government subsidized and you see them hit the highest
- 21:49amount of inflation and administration costs in the
- 21:51bureaucracy that sits in these organizations.
- 21:54And it ties back to like private equity and I don't know, the
- 21:57trade, you know, maybe Liam can probably articulate it better,
- 22:00but you hear that talking about where private equity will buy
- 22:06like the medical facilities or or hospitals, and then they'll
- 22:08strip them of like IP or any of the goods, like sell them off
- 22:12and then they'll sell the shell to whatever, you know, other
- 22:14subsidiary that's part of the government or government
- 22:16subsidized. Point being is you've seen this
- 22:18like extraction via the system and people taking advantage of
- 22:22it. It's not good or wrong bad.
- 22:24It's just it is the incentive model of the system.
- 22:27And that's where you get these like insane, you know,
- 22:28healthcare costs and all that. But point being is like what
- 22:31happens when more of the government goes in and and you
- 22:34know, it has these misaligned incentives because the money can
- 22:37it doesn't have the discernment of allocation that a general
- 22:40private market investor would have.
- 22:42You're just going to end up with more distort distorted outcomes.
- 22:46Going back to the first point is what we're seeing here.
- 22:52We have any thoughts on this one?
- 22:55I think it's, it's difficult to tell just from this chart, but
- 23:01yeah, I think it's a little bit of a shift in terms of the types
- 23:04of businesses that they're really focused on as well as
- 23:09just the the proliferation of additional.
- 23:15These strategies are very well known and of just like, you
- 23:19know, you need to cut your costs as much as possible.
- 23:21All of these companies are looking to do that prior to
- 23:27prior to being sold to private equity companies and so they can
- 23:31get the best valuation possible. And many of these people don't
- 23:35haven't actually run a business in the past.
- 23:37And so they can go in and say you can cut costs, but they
- 23:42don't actually know how to do that.
- 23:44No, in a very reasonable way in order to drive drive potential
- 23:48returns and margin expansion for these businesses.
- 23:52Yeah. Paul said.
- 23:54Hi, guys. Thanks for listening.
- 23:55I hope you're enjoying the pod. Just wanted to give a quick word
- 23:59from on ramp and early riders. You're probably familiar with
- 24:02our venture fund we operate and we will be having some very
- 24:08exciting meeting of the minds over the next few months in
- 24:12Nashville around a few events happening at the Bitcoin Park,
- 24:16as well as in Dallas around the North American Blockchain
- 24:20Summit. We'll be having one-on-one
- 24:22meetings, private roundtable sessions discussing the status
- 24:26of the market, some of the exciting investments that we
- 24:28haven't publicly announced, as well as other ways for
- 24:31individuals to get more involved with everything we're building
- 24:34across the ecosystem. If you're interested in learning
- 24:37more, you can reach out to us directly, you can book time or
- 24:41you can just subscribe to our research.
- 24:42We're going to be publishing a lot of these dates as well as
- 24:46ways to get in touch via the Early Writers newsletter.
- 24:49You can be at our Early Writers Calm.
- 24:51We're always excited to hear from individuals.
- 24:54We have some of the most sophisticated listeners and
- 24:56clients and investors and early writers.
- 24:59And I really mean that we're working on kind of the bleeding
- 25:01edges of this space. And so it usually takes
- 25:04individuals that have had to think deeply and follow the
- 25:06space for a while to kind of pick up what we're putting down.
- 25:10But we love hearing from you folks and also hearing about
- 25:14ideas or ways to get involved. There's no shortage of really
- 25:17amazing talent out there trying to kind of either take a one
- 25:20step out of the traditional space and figure out what their
- 25:23next move is. And we love hearing from
- 25:26individuals like that because we're working on a lot of things
- 25:28and it's really our job between the Guild network on ramp and
- 25:30early writers and some of our other portfolio companies to
- 25:33figure out how to help there. So I'd encourage you to reach
- 25:36out if it's not this week, please keep it in mind as you
- 25:39navigate the space. We'd love to speak with you.
- 25:41All right, have a great rest of your week.
- 25:42And we'll be back with the last trade with a very big guest that
- 25:46we're super excited about. I don't know if Jackson will
- 25:48like that. I share it here.
- 25:50So if you want to know, tag him on Twitter and maybe he'll share
- 25:53it on Twitter. I don't want to steal his
- 25:54Thunder. All right, have a great week.
- 25:57Maybe switching gears a little bit, there are a few sort of
- 26:00just deals or announcements that we can take this in any way.
- 26:03I did want to share this one. I thought it was relatively
- 26:06interesting. Sofi becomes the first US bank
- 26:08to use Bitcoin Lightning for remittances.
- 26:10This is 3 partnership with Light Spark, which is David Marcus's
- 26:16Lightning service provider company.
- 26:19Pretty notable just in the sense of a, you know, a tradition,
- 26:22more traditional fintech seeing the vision of, of building on
- 26:25Bitcoin as opposed to all these other various block chains.
- 26:28And, and interesting in the sense that that is where the
- 26:31large sort of largest focus is in the stablecoin sphere.
- 26:34And you would expect Sofi to be thinking through use cases like
- 26:38that, but they've decided to partner with Light Spark on this
- 26:41one. So any thoughts on this?
- 26:47I think we talked about it before.
- 26:48I just don't see how this is going to at least today matter.
- 26:52I think like I think lights work has the A16Z ties.
- 26:58They're super not only well capitalized, well connected.
- 27:01And so I think the relationship similar to David Mark as being a
- 27:05PayPal like you can go to a sofa, you can tell them a story.
- 27:08Lightning been sold forever as a story, whether it's for payments
- 27:12and Blackhawk and all these things that never transpired
- 27:15with different firms and very similar here.
- 27:17And to your point, like the outcome we talked about before
- 27:19is things the same here. It's like you just put it on the
- 27:22easiest database, which is a stablepoint database, and then
- 27:24you transfer it over like that. Like thinking about the level of
- 27:27education and permissions that you have to move over.
- 27:30I just don't see it happening today.
- 27:32Now, obviously 510 years from now and for whatever reasons
- 27:35from interoperability to, you know, governance and, and
- 27:39potential, you know better from a censorship perspective and
- 27:43privacy. People would do this stuff on
- 27:45Lightning, but I don't see why they would.
- 27:47And then the amount of liquidity to make it material would happen
- 27:50there versus just on a public blockchain that is running some
- 27:54of these stable points? Yeah, it's another announcement
- 27:57of something that's coming in the future from a very large
- 27:59company. And sometimes these dealer don't
- 28:02actually end up happening on the timelines that they expected.
- 28:07And they, if you scroll up, there's something about
- 28:10implementing university money addresses too, which I don't
- 28:15know what that means and seems like it's overly complicated
- 28:20versus just using, using the typical address schema.
- 28:25So we'll see if this ends up happening.
- 28:27But if you're not already, if neither side really wants
- 28:31Bitcoin, it's a little bit of overcomplicating things in my
- 28:34view. Yeah, the fascinating thing with
- 28:37all of this, and this is happening across the world and
- 28:41we get a glimpse of it and means we're in is everyone is focused
- 28:47on these things that are sexy by whatever standards.
- 28:51And you know, the blockchain was this like in 2017 and 18 and
- 28:54STO's, and now it's real world assets.
- 28:56And then there's like payments and remittances.
- 28:58And it's not to say there's not innovation there, but it's just
- 29:00a hard thing for people to wrap their head around and then sell
- 29:03that. You want to be able to like
- 29:04house and custody this asset, store it and then when your
- 29:07client bases, I think we should transition because I think
- 29:11Brian's been a little bit like, you know, worried.
- 29:13I'm not going to go hard on him. I just want to like he's like
- 29:15all this like stuff is not news. The news is like it's all coin
- 29:18season, all coin season. If you can pull up that I love
- 29:22Brian. Brian's going to keep pillar of
- 29:24on RIP. So I'm not I don't want to, you
- 29:26know, sour relationships. I'm not going to go so hard on
- 29:29his calls around that. We're never going to see, you
- 29:33know, alts and Bitcoin dominance go below whatever.
- 29:37That's not where I'm going to go with this.
- 29:39Just want to want him to know that where I do want to go with
- 29:42it is ultimately this is going to get crazy.
- 29:46We've been saying, I've personally been saying it.
- 29:48This title says Bitcoin well wakes up after 7 years, rotates
- 29:51$270 million worth of eat. I don't know if this is true or
- 29:55not. I don't I have no reason to
- 29:58believe it's not true because in the same way people and large
- 30:01holders of public equities and other assets can manipulate
- 30:04markets. It's the same way where large
- 30:08holders, I think this is tied into some of the sell off from
- 30:11the past 24 hours that the person you know, potentially was
- 30:14manipulating the market to be able to buy back lower in the
- 30:17same format that there's large holders that play both sides of
- 30:20the market and that as the Bitcoin, you can go back and
- 30:24forth between all coins of Bitcoin, but the other, we don't
- 30:29have to pull them up, but I just had them in this channel.
- 30:31If you give me one second, I want to like rattle off just how
- 30:36wild what's what's about to happen and what's coming is So
- 30:40just, you know, read them off real quick.
- 30:41So the past, let's call it 48 business, 48 hours past two
- 30:45business days, Grayscale and Bitwise filed their amendments
- 30:48for the XRPETF. There's a former bit main exact
- 30:52launching AB and B Treasury targeting a billion dollar
- 30:56raise. Grayscale also files an S1 with
- 31:00the SEC to convert it's Avalanche trust to an AVAX ETF.
- 31:04Galaxy Jump and Multicoin seek a billion dollars to create a
- 31:06Solana treasury Vanek proposes JIT Sol ETF.
- 31:13Hold that one of your thoughts because I'll come back to that
- 31:18or maybe we'll we'll go back to like to that JIT Sol one very
- 31:24similar to I think it's like hyper liquid.
- 31:29So, so I can't help but bring up a little bit of this is where
- 31:39the fundamental discrepancy with between Brian and I were is that
- 31:42like a only 1% of the market roughly knows about any of this
- 31:46stuff. So it was kind of like insane to
- 31:49me to believe that 99% of the people were going to just bypass
- 31:51the noise was 1. 2 is the institutions love this stuff in
- 31:56the same way the individuals where they like testbed for just
- 31:59all again, the mental gymnastics around yield generation and all
- 32:02these crazy things. So they're going to parlay that
- 32:06into these frameworks of ETFs and public treasury companies
- 32:09that will generate passive yield by these other insane strategies
- 32:13that blew the market up in 2022. And and then the last part is
- 32:19crypto, including Bitcoin has been insanely historic,
- 32:24historically been insanely hard to get spot possession of,
- 32:27right? Like this is just pure why the
- 32:29ETF has had such large demand. And even like MicroStrategy,
- 32:32because if you really think about it, for anybody listening
- 32:35here, might be pretty simple to go log into an exchange and buy
- 32:37some Bitcoin, maybe figure out why you're going to custody it.
- 32:40For the majority of people, that's a very hard proposition.
- 32:42Like it's the way to either use the mental model.
- 32:44If you were to go set up a gambling account, you're going
- 32:47to go set up some like third party weird place that you're
- 32:49going to end up at. You have to move your dollar
- 32:50from your bank account. Hopefully they land over there.
- 32:52You have to buy the underline that is a magic Internet being
- 32:55and then you have to move it off into some other third party if
- 32:57you're going to like actually secure it the right way.
- 32:58That is not like easy. So these ETS provided that point
- 33:02of walking through that is when you think about hyper liquid.
- 33:05I don't even know what hyper liquid is, but and O'Brien does
- 33:07and he shared it multiple times. It's my understanding that this
- 33:10hyper liquid token is a very hard to find on any exchange.
- 33:13So if somebody's going to give you a, what they're called Dats
- 33:16now, I guess digital asset treasury company to give you
- 33:19hyper liquid exposure, they're going to generate yield.
- 33:22Think about the amount of people in your old networks that are
- 33:25going to love that thing. So anyway, all coin season is
- 33:29here. It's going to run rampant.
- 33:33And I'm sorry, Brian. No need to apologize.
- 33:37I'm I'm willing to admit I may have been overly optimistic
- 33:41about the understanding of Bitcoin being different than
- 33:45cryptic. And it's not even that.
- 33:46It's not even really the distinction.
- 33:47It's just the greed and animal spirits that still exist.
- 33:53And people see a way to make money pump these things.
- 33:56And you might be right. We might just be at the at the
- 33:59sort of beginning gates of that. And if I'm being honest about
- 34:02it, I think 50% dominance is now in question.
- 34:06And you think I will pull up BCCD?
- 34:08Just. No, I just want just for
- 34:10reference of where it was, it was around 65, it's now at 58.
- 34:15My call has always been 50%. There's a lot of resistance
- 34:17there. We'll see what happens.
- 34:19I will also point out though that the ETH BTC ratio chart
- 34:24while that's been spiking over the past month or two, it's
- 34:27still off its highs of 21. So like in Bitcoin terms,
- 34:32Ethereum hasn't made a new all time high.
- 34:34I would say alt alt season's really here.
- 34:36If and when that does happen, like if if we see this ratio
- 34:39continue to go up above its its previous all time highs, then I
- 34:42would then I would say 50% is is in jeopardy.
- 34:45Yeah, I don't. Yeah, I I mean, this is the hard
- 34:48part about where we've gone back and forth and this is like the
- 34:51thing we want versus the thing that's going to happen are
- 34:53fundamentally just different. But the IT reminded me of it.
- 34:59And this is just timely you of all people should have been on
- 35:03to this trade and how it was going to play out because a year
- 35:05ago today we are in the SALT conference in Wyoming and really
- 35:12great from a just like. Boondoggle perspective.
- 35:16Boondoggle from an environment, right like Jackson Hole and late
- 35:19August is just amazing. But remember just the amount of
- 35:24you mean you sat there, you wrote a whole piece on the noise
- 35:28that was there and that was the Canary in the coal mine and you
- 35:30can imagine. So it happened again this past
- 35:32year, heard great things from again the environment, but very
- 35:35similar when it comes to the environment from, you know, the
- 35:40signal to noise ratio around digital assets and all the
- 35:43things associated. So yeah, this is just a sadly
- 35:48sad state we're at. It's also the alpha in the
- 35:50market on just holding spot and and you know businesses that
- 35:53will occur it, but yeah, yeah. I mean, the other thing I would
- 36:00say is like probably should have known better.
- 36:03Once Trump coin happened and it became very apparent that the
- 36:08administration was not just leaning into Bitcoin, they were
- 36:10leaning into everything and that gave the air cover for
- 36:13everything. So I do think of that that's
- 36:16been a factor as well, probably would have happened regardless.
- 36:20But all of these Dats and broader institutional interest
- 36:24in all these other assets, I think is also a reflection of
- 36:27just the administration's stance.
- 36:29It's that plus it's also just the E players in the industry
- 36:34who for better or worse are looked at as like the largest in
- 36:37in the suits like the bit Wises etc that are going into and
- 36:43leading this Galaxy. Tom Lee, I think Brian Armstrong
- 36:49tweeted Belaji Coin over the weekend which had like $3000 in
- 36:53market cap or something. To that degree, all these people
- 36:57are not just interested in Bitcoin and the market perceives
- 37:01them as to be the best educated. So until that changes, we're
- 37:06we're probably going to to see all season continue.
- 37:09Yeah, maybe you can click into the other link because that ties
- 37:12directly into the rent extraction.
- 37:16Which one? There's a rent extraction link I
- 37:20think it's titled. It was right below the.
- 37:22Last. Got it.
- 37:27Yeah, the so this reminds me of this conversation that Liam just
- 37:31kicked off around the suits and and whether it's Brian, Brian
- 37:35Armstrong or Tom Lee, very similar to the gas lighting in
- 37:39the government buying a company that looked at anything any way
- 37:42positive in the same way that most individuals that were
- 37:46coming from Triadfi and even probably some listening, we
- 37:49think we're either Luddite. So there's some innovation
- 37:50happening here, but we've had 15 years to show empirically that
- 37:55there is no, there's no objective value being delivered
- 37:59by any of these block chains. And even the stablecoin aspect,
- 38:04if they really wanted to from a consortium level can adopt this.
- 38:07The banks compete with each other, but we all believe it's
- 38:10going to end up back there at some consortium level because
- 38:14even at the stablecoin level, you can seize and censor all the
- 38:17transactions. Now they do obviously offer
- 38:19innovation from like rails, but the European Union has known to
- 38:23have like great kind of like connectivity when it comes to
- 38:25banking. Like it's not as innovative to
- 38:27be able to send, you know, dollars from a bank domain.
- 38:31And so we've seen this play out. And so these tokens that are
- 38:34filling the Dats and the ETFs have no underlying value.
- 38:37Nobody's delivered delivered them.
- 38:39And at least from their architecture, we could talk
- 38:41about multiple layers on Bitcoin and where you would, you know,
- 38:43have some of the stuff derived from.
- 38:45But point being is so it's been rumored the past couple days
- 38:48that I think it was the block and then block works that 21
- 38:53shares so it looks like 21 shares ETF would invest in
- 38:56crypto Etps, features and equities.
- 38:58Active management let's us move beyond simple exposure and
- 39:01deliver strategies that adapt in real time to practically
- 39:04evolving market head of U.S. business X BlackRock.
- 39:07And if you Scroll down, it says the firm's looking to launch
- 39:11these two will be there will be a lot of crypto exposure for
- 39:15investors to choose from in the coming months between funds and
- 39:17equities. Tons of experimenting from ETF
- 39:19issuers to see where demand is. I doubt it will last.
- 39:23So it shows a 2X long DOGE ETF, a 2X long SUV ETF.
- 39:28There's discussions around Bitcoin volatility or
- 39:30concentration might be a problem for four O 1K.
- 39:33So now you're going to have mutual funds that have a basket
- 39:35of crypto currencies. We've seen Bitwise in particular
- 39:39for years have bask in the top ten.
- 39:42The fun part about talking about this is like there's actually
- 39:44receipts out there where Bitwise have launched multiple things
- 39:47like there was the metaverse ETF with multi coin that they
- 39:49scrubbed. You can still Google and find it
- 39:51online, but they scrubbed it from like their website.
- 39:53Any like, you know, the last thing, because these things,
- 39:56they're just kind of it's rent extraction.
- 39:58It's the ability to. Take individuals come into the
- 40:01space they're looking for, quote UN quote alpha, and then you
- 40:04sell on products, you take your crazy management fee, including
- 40:07in these DAT structures, and ultimately people get left
- 40:10holding a bag of effectively 0 or close to 0.
- 40:14And yeah, we're just going to see this at a much greater scale
- 40:17now that the plumbing is all opened up into these Dats.
- 40:22Yeah, this is insane. This is crazy.
- 40:26There's a bull market for noise like this is going to hurt a lot
- 40:31of people. 2X long dose, 2X long suey.
- 40:33To your point, there's no underlying value in any of these
- 40:36things. And you're layering on not only
- 40:38leverage, but counterparty risk, execution risk, all these things
- 40:43to something that doesn't even have fundamental value to begin
- 40:46with. So this is not great to see, a
- 40:50little disappointing. But to your point, this is kind
- 40:52of inevitable. And this is, this is, this is
- 40:55the world we live in now. So feel.
- 40:58Like we feel like we broke Brian.
- 41:00We're dead it. May take a long time but
- 41:05eventually this market structure will break.
- 41:07People don't really look for a basket of diversified precious
- 41:12metals. People know that gold is the
- 41:14best, and just like that they will know that Bitcoin is the
- 41:19best and only digital asset. There may or may not be a place
- 41:23for other of these that are significantly smaller than
- 41:28Bitcoin, but it's going to take a very, very long time to get
- 41:31there. Yeah, yeah, we mentioned
- 41:39Wyoming. I know Michael doesn't like when
- 41:43I read Tea leaves, but there were some heavily discussed
- 41:51words from Jerome Powell last week in Wyoming effectively with
- 41:57some people are looking at him abandoning the 2% inflation
- 42:01target. Now I think that that was a
- 42:03little overblown. But again, all of these are just
- 42:05words. They don't really matter in the
- 42:07in the grand scheme of things. But if we are to look at what he
- 42:11said, it is a bit of a departure in the sense that they're not
- 42:14really focused on inflation anymore.
- 42:17And there's various reasons for that, but they basically know
- 42:20they can't get it to their target of 2%.
- 42:22So they're sort of tacitly abandoning that target and
- 42:26instead focusing on a weakening labor market as a rationale to
- 42:30cut rates. Now, the reality baked into all
- 42:32of this is that they have to cut rates regardless of their excuse
- 42:35for it, because the interest expense on the debt is over a
- 42:38trillion dollars right now with rates where they are.
- 42:41So they have to bring down rates.
- 42:42They have to print money, and this is all just words.
- 42:46But as Macroscope points out here, lots of debate around the
- 42:49meeting last week. He's saying they didn't
- 42:52technically abandon it, but they are signaling basically their
- 42:55intent to abandon it at some point because they can't get it
- 42:59to 2%. And then also just shifting the
- 43:01focus from inflation to the labor market.
- 43:05Another tweet to share here from Cobia C.
- 43:11This is sort of what I was alluding to.
- 43:13They were going to blame the weak labor market.
- 43:15So they're just going to forget about CPI, which has been above
- 43:192% for 53 straight months. And so naturally this is pro
- 43:25risk assets, pro Bitcoin, pro gold, all of that.
- 43:27And it, it should be seen as as a bit of a pivot.
- 43:31They're shifting, you know, Powell also said shifting the
- 43:33balance of risks may warrant adjusting our policy stance.
- 43:37So basically that is foretelling a a likely September rate cut.
- 43:42Again, blaming the labor market as opposed to inflation which
- 43:45they can't get back down to their target.
- 43:49Maybe one other notable thing from this was just the market
- 43:53reaction to it. So right after these comments
- 43:56were released, you see gold spike and the dollar collapse.
- 44:01Thoughts on this Michael? I know you hate the Fed and tea
- 44:04leaves, but I thought I thought it was important.
- 44:07Yeah. I mean, I don't necessarily hate
- 44:09the Fed. I think, I think it's just all
- 44:11gas lighting. We talked about it a week or two
- 44:14weeks ago about the Warren Buffett like the short term
- 44:17noises, noise. I think the key thing I took
- 44:21from there is I thought for for weeks if not months, they were
- 44:24consistently saying that the job market was great.
- 44:27And we know the job market and inflation aren't great.
- 44:30It just it doesn't take a rocket scientist to go and see what it
- 44:33costs for anything or to see friends and family either not
- 44:37having jobs or being stuck. There's all these terms about
- 44:39like job hugging where people are just fearful of leaving.
- 44:41There's crazy numbers on like the amount of movement of jobs
- 44:47and like it's like a 50 year low because of there's just another,
- 44:50there's no other opportunities where people understand that
- 44:54there's very little limited opportunities.
- 44:56So yeah, I think this all like aligns right.
- 45:00It's just like, what's the the flavor of the the next Fed
- 45:02meeting on, you know, how do you spin the the narrative?
- 45:06I think the reality is we're just going to be in a much
- 45:08higher inflation than 2%. So now you have to start to
- 45:11figure out like what is that mix and goes into it to kind of get
- 45:17people familiar with how we're going to be in persistently
- 45:19higher inflation, at least in those terms.
- 45:21Whatever number they give us, you're going to be able to
- 45:23probably add 10% confidently and know that that's what real
- 45:26inflation is. Hey guys, I hope you're enjoying
- 45:28the podcast and it wasn't too doom and gloom.
- 45:32Really just try to share what's currently happening in the
- 45:34markets, how we see it. The altcoin craze is something
- 45:37that sadly will persist. But I believe if you're
- 45:40listening to this podcast, you probably understand that and
- 45:44think deeply about Bitcoin custody.
- 45:47And just a quick word from on ramp.
- 45:49I'm sure a lot of listeners know of the different offerings that
- 45:52we have, whether it's, you know, multi institution custody, the
- 45:55ability for our our trade desk lending and inheritance, and
- 46:00then the dynasty trust, which we are really excited about.
- 46:02We have no shortage of exciting things coming out this fall.
- 46:05Really I think industry shaking things that across the the
- 46:09landscape we have a lot that we've been working on.
- 46:12The one that I just want to go a little deeper on is Guardian
- 46:15that we announced today and specifically the proprietary and
- 46:18I don't even want to call it proprietary, but the 3FA3FA,
- 46:22we're really excited about that because ultimately it's
- 46:26something that suffers the Internet connection from the
- 46:29movement of your Bitcoin. So whether it is, you know,
- 46:32video verification, multiple institutions verifying that 2FA
- 46:37logic time, withdrawals, those are all put in place to protect
- 46:42client assets. But at the end of the day, they
- 46:44leverage the Internet connection specifically from a subjective
- 46:48view, how do you interact with humans in the logic?
- 46:513FA takes that a step further and really relies on public
- 46:55private key cryptography, specifically around Bitcoin
- 46:58wallets and the movement of certain UTX OS for a certain
- 47:01client specific PIN. This is something I've been
- 47:03thinking about deeply. It might be overkill for
- 47:06somebody with, call it, 1 to $10 million, even though it's still
- 47:10open for them. But for clients that we work
- 47:12with that have 10s, if not hundreds of millions of dollars,
- 47:15it's something that I think they're going to be really
- 47:16excited about. Because ultimately it takes it a
- 47:20step further and leverages either a hardware device that we
- 47:22would ship them or another way that they've generated private
- 47:25and public key. So if you want to learn more
- 47:28about that, you can look at the blog post or you can feel free
- 47:31to book a consultation if you want to talk with me directly.
- 47:33Again, Michael at honor@bitcoin.com and hope you
- 47:37enjoy the rest of the show. Yeah, I, I actually read it a
- 47:41little bit differently. I thought that they were moving
- 47:42away from the 2% inflation over time that they authored back in
- 47:46the pandemic and moving back towards the target of just 2%
- 47:50inflation, meaning that they might be a little bit more
- 47:53restrictive than than we had thought.
- 47:55I think that Powell probably wants to protect his legacy of,
- 47:59you know, running too hot on inflation.
- 48:01Then if he's not able to really tame it, then he likely will
- 48:08want to. He wants to fix it.
- 48:10Like he doesn't want to be the guy who had super hot inflation
- 48:14over his term. And but he also doesn't really
- 48:17want to crash the labor market. Labor market to your point, like
- 48:21the the job switching because that a record low new hires is
- 48:26like very very low both below pre pandemic trends.
- 48:31So they're stuck between a rock and a hard place.
- 48:36Yeah, that's all. Well said.
- 48:39Maybe one other just headline, Liam, I think you'd share this
- 48:43one, but the Philippines thinking about a strategic
- 48:47Bitcoin reserve, I don't know the likelihood of this.
- 48:50Yeah, I think, but. It's extremely low, but if you
- 48:53pull up the link there, it's interesting to see all of the
- 48:57different data points that they mentioned.
- 49:00Like in Central America, El Salvador already adopted Bitcoin
- 49:05as legal tender and began to purchase and hold and reserve.
- 49:08Brazil introduced sovereign strategic Bitcoin Reserve in the
- 49:12European Union. Switzerland is now considering
- 49:14it alongside gold in Germany. The former finance ministers
- 49:19suggested that they produce reliance on USD and consider
- 49:23Bitcoin as a way forward. Poland considering Bitcoin
- 49:26reserve. Hong Kong has advocated for it
- 49:30too. The Malaysian government has
- 49:33started to consider the use of this the in Russia, they've
- 49:37begun to use Bitcoin and other Western Digital currencies for
- 49:40international transactions as part of the strategy to bypass
- 49:44Western sanctions and reduce reliance on USD.
- 49:47And so this in itself is I doubt that the this Philippine one
- 49:54gets passed or or that this is really meaningful in itself.
- 50:00But just taking a look at this kind of laid out and how much
- 50:05the Overton window is shifted from the past two years, I think
- 50:09is just interesting to see. And regardless if they do it or
- 50:13not, I think that there are going to be a couple countries
- 50:16that do it over the next five years or so, which will just
- 50:20continue to move that window over even more.
- 50:23So just like we've seen Harvard allocate to the Bitcoin ETFs,
- 50:29we're we're just going to see it go incrementally this way.
- 50:32And it's interesting to see how they laid it all out like this
- 50:35and how far we've come. Yeah, I agree in a in a sea of
- 50:39noise as well as pessimism around the status of, you know,
- 50:45just kind of like misallocation a capital, the notion of a
- 50:49congressman in the Philippines drafting this bill and then all
- 50:53the other anecdotes Liam shared is very positive for that like
- 50:59kind of domino just next domino to fall, whether it's
- 51:03Philippines or somewhere else. And then it really ties back to
- 51:05the notion of where we shared if like the next, call it, 18
- 51:10months, you see the sovereign adoption and accumulation step
- 51:13in, things get really interesting and accelerated
- 51:17versus like the traditional markets, Our traditional Bitcoin
- 51:21markets when it comes to havings and and just cycles.
- 51:23I don't think they go away, but I think they take a completely
- 51:26different form if you have sovereigns globally that have
- 51:30access to what's effectively unlimited dollars and also
- 51:33energy to be mining step into the market.
- 51:36So do you think it's a positive direction independent of like
- 51:39the likelihood of, you know, the Philippines accumulating
- 51:41Bitcoin? Yeah.
- 51:44No tool said some signal in a in a sea of noise.
- 51:46Whether or not this gets passed, it's the it's the over Overton
- 51:49window continuing to shift with respect to to Bitcoin as a
- 51:52reserve asset that you would want on your balance sheet as a
- 51:55sovereign. Michael, there was one other
- 51:59stable coin related length that you'd shared from layer 0 labs.
- 52:03Is this the Wyoming stable coin? What was the take away from
- 52:08this? Yeah.
- 52:11So I think it's I love Wyoming and the people behind this, you
- 52:17know them consider them friends. I think it's it's cool to see
- 52:20Wyoming lead in digital assets. To my understanding, this is the
- 52:23first stable coin that's been launched on so many block
- 52:26chains, Ethereum, Solana, Avalanche.
- 52:29To my understand, it's not necessarily stablecoin.
- 52:33It's a stable token because of it being issued not by bank, but
- 52:38by the soccer state of Wyoming. The thing that what stood out to
- 52:42me, and I don't mean to be pessimistic about this, but I
- 52:44was thinking about it last week independent of the Wyoming
- 52:47launch, was that the notion of the CBD CS are here, they're
- 52:51just not called CBD CS. Because where this all goes is
- 52:56we're going to have, I think very few people that pay
- 52:58attention to digital assets and Bitcoin would say that we're not
- 53:01going to go to a digital world for for dollars in the movement
- 53:03of dollars. And they naturally have to
- 53:06become interoperable because it's just inefficient for them
- 53:08not to. So however that manifests again,
- 53:10directionally don't know. It's the same way we talked
- 53:12about the yield being generated on stable coins.
- 53:14We don't know how it's going to happen, but we just know market
- 53:16forces will determine it or require it.
- 53:19And similar to like Coinbase doing whatever they're doing in
- 53:22their arbitrage from like marketing dollars to pay people
- 53:25back for using it. So it's not yield by a circle
- 53:29point being is everyone's friendly until the draconian
- 53:33measures come in and it goes back to the state private public
- 53:37partnership. We saw this happen again during
- 53:40COVID. It's not about being
- 53:41conspiratorial. It's just the reality of when
- 53:44you have government, you know, sanctions and forces and policy
- 53:49for the greater good, whatever the greater good is marketed at
- 53:51the current time, you will naturally be able to now
- 53:56effectively like just halt any movement of capital.
- 53:59And so you're starting to see this.
- 54:02And again, it's marketed, it's spun as a positive where what's
- 54:05the recent knowledge around like HSAS and Maha and like, OK, so
- 54:09you're going to get like your HSA and then maybe that's going
- 54:11to be digitized, but you can't like buy, you know, Coca-Cola or
- 54:14sugary stuff, right? Well, like, that's how it
- 54:16starts. But ultimately, you're basically
- 54:17saying with a click of a button, you can programmatically
- 54:20determine what people are going to buy or not buy.
- 54:23So again, it's going to look like a positive for the
- 54:25industry. It's going to be.
- 54:26I think it's positive for Bitcoin because more capital is
- 54:28going to come in because, you know, you have a digital dollar
- 54:30and you can just eat. It's more interoperable with
- 54:33BTC. But I can't help but see this is
- 54:35just kind of like, you know, not going to play out very well for
- 54:39a lot of people long term. Yeah.
- 54:43I would agree. I think that Tether and Circle
- 54:46are pretty much just like half a step removed as well-being
- 54:50overseen by Congress as well. It's pretty much just all the
- 54:54same thing and using we've already started to see this with
- 54:59choke point 1.0 with the restriction on guns, payday
- 55:04loans, etcetera and de banking of those types of businesses.
- 55:12The the flow of funds and and tracking that and as well as
- 55:15just the then permitting what you can and can't buy will will
- 55:20probably continue to heat up moving forward.
- 55:24Yeah, it's a slippery slope for sure.
- 55:27They'll be positioned as innovative and necessary, but
- 55:33there are some seriously negative potential externalities
- 55:37from all this continuing to flow this direction.
- 55:41Let me switch gears a little bit here to some research that early
- 55:46riders put out last week. Michael, I'm going to pull up
- 55:48your tweet 1st and maybe you can speak to sort of high level what
- 55:53we're trying to accomplish this with this report and then I'll
- 55:55pull up the report. Yeah, I think at the core, I've
- 55:59been hesitant to say this, but I feel a lot more confident we'll
- 56:04still be polarizing as we're so early to Bitcoin.
- 56:06We hadn't even figured out custody yet.
- 56:10The tweet, I know Bill Ackman gets a lot of crap on Bitcoin
- 56:13Twitter, but it's a really apartment quote that he had
- 56:16which says institutions cannot self custody without severe
- 56:19regulatory issues. And that's just one issue, not
- 56:21just regulatory. Most of individuals would prefer
- 56:24not to self custody. Crypto will remain a sport for
- 56:26hobbyists until this is fixed. And so this is something that
- 56:30we've been talking about, thinking about really the notion
- 56:33of how do you get access to Bitcoin without the trade-offs,
- 56:35you know, a third party custodian and all the other
- 56:38layers of intermediation between an ETF or Bitcoin or a treasury
- 56:41company. But then also again, the reality
- 56:44is, yes, it's very easy for anyone on the planet Earth to
- 56:47put a 10 bucks or $1000 into twelve boards or a hardware
- 56:51device, But it gets really hard for somebody to put all of their
- 56:54wealth. And I think that's the big gap
- 56:56that most people have been missing is again, a Bitcoin
- 56:58speculative asset and people want to play around.
- 57:01It's very easy to put a little bit of percentage in any of the
- 57:03existing custody solutions, whether it's a hardware device,
- 57:07collaborative custody, an ETF, Coinbase, etcetera, etcetera.
- 57:12But if you're going to think about Bitcoin permeating in
- 57:15everyone's lives and every aspect of society in the same
- 57:19way that the Internet did, you have to bring standardization
- 57:22across the board. And so this piece breaks it down
- 57:25and it references different formats like the SSL of Bitcoin
- 57:28time back to encryption and how if you if anybody old enough
- 57:33remembers, you know, or your parents trying to buy anything
- 57:36online, they would never put their credit card information
- 57:38online. And now that's looked at is
- 57:40standard via encryption. That's based online Linux very
- 57:44example very similar similar an open standard for building
- 57:48blocks on top of different, you know, software hardware.
- 57:51Very nice piece of the early writers team put out and I think
- 57:54it's worth a read to kind of see how this goes.
- 57:57The iPhone is something that gets loosely thrown around a lot
- 58:00iPhone moment, but there's good examples of once you have, you
- 58:04know, a product that kind of collapses and disintermediates a
- 58:06lot of either physical or software into like one unique
- 58:12kind of construct, you can start to really innovate and bring
- 58:17things. And so an iphone's a great
- 58:18example where GPS being included in your pocket now started to
- 58:22allow it for you to hail an Uber, a car that, you know,
- 58:25historically taxi cabs were like 110th or one 100th of the amount
- 58:28of demand for for rides because you didn't have the technology
- 58:31to manage. And that's just a small example.
- 58:34So I think very, very good read and then also gives a good lens
- 58:37of not only how we look at the market, but the opportunity that
- 58:40we invest in. For if we're so early that
- 58:43custody hadn't been figured out, then there's a wide open
- 58:46opportunity to bring standardization and then bring a
- 58:49lot more, a lot more effectively capital and users into Bitcoin.
- 58:57And that goes from individuals all the way to whether it's
- 58:59credit unions, credit funds that are allocating to the space that
- 59:03need a more redundant resilient architecture when you're doing
- 59:05Bitcoin back lending to insurance products.
- 59:08So I highly encourage the rate if anybody's interested.
- 59:13Yeah, go ahead, Lynn. I was just going to say,
- 59:15building off that, yeah, I mean, like we're we're still in such
- 59:20early days. I couldn't help thinking of
- 59:23Steve Jobs initially trying to sell computers, not not actually
- 59:28built to retailers and allowing them to build it themselves.
- 59:31And they and he didn't even understand that that's not
- 59:34necessarily what they wanted. Forcing people or not not quite
- 59:38forcing people, but just like telling people to if they want
- 59:42Bitcoin exposure to become hobbyists and figure out how to
- 59:46figure out how to manage all their wealth in hardware devices
- 59:51or however they want to custody their funds is just not
- 59:54something that is super interesting to a lot of people.
- 59:56And there's always specialization because that is
- 1:00:01just how the world works. It's just allows people to be
- 1:00:04more efficient with whatever they're doing.
- 1:00:06And so rather than just trying to convince everybody to be a
- 1:00:10hobbyist when they're. Potentially going to lose
- 1:00:13significant funds if they don't manage it correctly or, you
- 1:00:17know, keep them out of the market is just probably not how
- 1:00:20the entire world is going to work moving forward.
- 1:00:23So yeah, I would highly encourage people to to read
- 1:00:27this. It's kind of just goes over the
- 1:00:28historical arcs of other technology and how this is kind
- 1:00:32of applying to Bitcoin today, yeah.
- 1:00:36Really great piece, I think would stood out to me or you
- 1:00:39know, at a very high level. It does a great job sort of
- 1:00:42walking through, you know, what has traditionally happened with
- 1:00:46emergent technologies. They go through these various
- 1:00:48phases where you know, initially the hobbyist phase, there's a
- 1:00:54ton of friction embedded in using the new technology.
- 1:00:56So whether that was PCs, some of the earliest cell phones or
- 1:01:02Internet protocols, there was a, there was a stage there where it
- 1:01:05was very difficult to use. There was a lot of friction, a
- 1:01:06lot of learning. And effectively, that's where we
- 1:01:09are with Bitcoin custody because we have to your point, you know,
- 1:01:14people for the last 15 years have figured out self custody
- 1:01:16because they knew the alternative was probably
- 1:01:18suboptimal, IE trusting a single custodian.
- 1:01:21So they were forced into this niche hobbyist endeavour of
- 1:01:25figuring out how to secure their their you know, in a lot of
- 1:01:29instances, the majority of their net worth be a cryptographic
- 1:01:32material hardware devices. And there really hasn't been a
- 1:01:38way outside of single custodians to broaden the access reduce the
- 1:01:43frictions associated withholding this asset in a risk mitigated
- 1:01:47way. And so in our view, you know,
- 1:01:50multi institution custody pioneer by honor.
- 1:01:52It really is that break breakthrough for Bitcoin for
- 1:01:54Bitcoin custody in the sense that it's it distributes the
- 1:01:59counterparty risk, it's risk mitigated sort of at at the base
- 1:02:03layer, at the protocol layer using Bitcoin native multi sig.
- 1:02:07But importantly, it abstracts away the friction of the end
- 1:02:09user in terms of securing key material themselves.
- 1:02:12And so it's this really elegant infrastructure approach that I
- 1:02:16think opens opens the door to just a lot more innovation on
- 1:02:22top of that standard, but also just more adoption of the asset
- 1:02:25because it's simpler, reduce friction for someone to onboard
- 1:02:30only underlying in a risk mitigated way where they don't
- 1:02:32have to do it themselves and be that niche hobbyist.
- 1:02:35So this this walks through the various examples at at length.
- 1:02:39And the other thing I would point out too, to just note here
- 1:02:41is like the stakes are different when we're talking about Bitcoin
- 1:02:46custody relative to these other technologies that emerge and
- 1:02:49went through these phases in the sense that, you know, if you
- 1:02:52were early edition of some cell phone craps out doesn't work or,
- 1:02:56you know, you can't log onto the Internet for whatever reason,
- 1:02:59you're not losing your assets, you're not losing your net
- 1:03:02worth. So there's, there's obviously
- 1:03:04negatives and it was clunky to use these different
- 1:03:06technologies, but Bitcoin and Bitcoin custody is a different,
- 1:03:10it's a different level of, of stakes and, and what's at risk
- 1:03:13for things going wrong. And so that's why I would say
- 1:03:17this sort of infrastructure breakthrough is even more
- 1:03:19important than some of these ones that we're making parallels
- 1:03:22or analogs to in the sense that the stakes are just much higher.
- 1:03:25This is people's money. In many cases, it's, you know, a
- 1:03:29large percentage of their net worth, and they can't afford to
- 1:03:32have those frictions that ultimately could end up in a
- 1:03:36catastrophic permanent loss. And so it is just different in
- 1:03:40that sense. But go ahead, Mike.
- 1:03:41Yeah, it's well said and I think it ties.
- 1:03:43Back to there's a lot of historical precedences and
- 1:03:47influences to where we're at and why it hasn't been done as
- 1:03:50simply because again, we're so early.
- 1:03:52But when you look back at again, there are multiple disciplines.
- 1:03:56But when you look back at the, the mainframe computers and what
- 1:04:00had to go into effectively like a mathematician or an account,
- 1:04:05somebody that's managing accounting to code up with the
- 1:04:08logic would be, there's great references on where you'd have
- 1:04:12to like not only build the logic, but then you would hand
- 1:04:15it off to somebody that would go and like punch these cards that
- 1:04:17almost look like like folders or like an envelope that would be
- 1:04:20plastic. And you'd have to like get the
- 1:04:22holes in the correct way. And if you messed it up and
- 1:04:23there were stacks of them, depending on how complicated the
- 1:04:27formula was. And then you'd have to put that
- 1:04:29into the mainframe computer. It's like there's a lot of like
- 1:04:32precedents to look at. Well, OK, that was used by
- 1:04:34certain individuals, but overtime you have to democratize
- 1:04:37that access. But then on the complete other
- 1:04:39side of it, when you think about Goldsmiths and the notion of
- 1:04:43like gold monetizing in real time, the reason we're a lot of
- 1:04:46this stuff is still taboo and why there's a lot of opportunity
- 1:04:49for us is because in Bitcoins 1st 15 years, the logical way to
- 1:04:54custody, it wasn't self custody, A, because this didn't exist,
- 1:04:57but really B, the asset was so small.
- 1:04:59So there wasn't really the significant losses that you had
- 1:05:01at stake. Now that a Bitcoin is 112,000 or
- 1:05:04whatever it is. And then what you need also when
- 1:05:07you think about like dynasty trust or insurance or these
- 1:05:10other products and services that are out there.
- 1:05:12So for 15 years, it was the thing to do is self custody
- 1:05:15because third party custody, ultimately you couldn't trust
- 1:05:18it. Still make the case.
- 1:05:19You still can't because it's just code.
- 1:05:21It's just pick one private keys. They're just data.
- 1:05:25And at the end of the day, all data will eventually get leaked
- 1:05:27in some capacity. We've seen this historically.
- 1:05:30And so when you look at the historical presidents, it's very
- 1:05:32similar to gold where a bunch of times people would leave their
- 1:05:35gold buried in their backyard or, or in their on their land.
- 1:05:38They give it up to the church or a third party family member.
- 1:05:41But all those things don't have, you know, congruence,
- 1:05:44accountability. They miss a lot of the natural
- 1:05:46functions for, for coordinating economic activity.
- 1:05:52And that's where the Goldsmiths were introduced.
- 1:05:54And then we obviously went away from the Goldsmith as you
- 1:05:56created notes and you know, the different, you know, claims on
- 1:05:59it, but very similar here where it's just thought of as a second
- 1:06:04order. Like custody has been figured
- 1:06:06out because we figured out how to hold, you know, the private
- 1:06:08keys on a hardware device or trust a third party ETF when for
- 1:06:1115 years it's been proven that it hasn't worked.
- 1:06:14Because we know that for everyone person that gets
- 1:06:16kidnapped, hacked, loses their money in a wildfire or all the
- 1:06:19things associated, there's a hundred others that haven't come
- 1:06:22forward for a number of reasons. And then again, the last big
- 1:06:26blow up was only three years ago.
- 1:06:28And that's where the market completely delevered because of
- 1:06:30the lack of transparency and all the things associated with
- 1:06:34centralized custody, let alone hacks.
- 1:06:36And so it's just something that the, the world, the market works
- 1:06:39in a very 2D fashion. And so it's like what all that
- 1:06:42we've been given is what we assume will be there.
- 1:06:44But that's the definition of like, what's obvious is
- 1:06:46obviously wrong. And so I think this piece does a
- 1:06:49good job of it. But we'll, we'll continue to do
- 1:06:51more because when you look back, you know, history doesn't, it
- 1:06:55often rhymes. And when you look at computers,
- 1:06:58when you look at banking, like the notion that we're all going
- 1:07:00to just be our own bank, it's not even technically that it's
- 1:07:03impossible because it is for every, you know, 8 billion
- 1:07:06humans to hold their own Utxos. It's actually from a socio
- 1:07:09economic perspective. Nobody wants to be their own
- 1:07:12bank. Even the people that scream the
- 1:07:13loudest about self custody, I can guarantee they go to sleep
- 1:07:17at night not feeling the greatest that all their wealth
- 1:07:19is held on 12 words. That God forbid they get hit by
- 1:07:21a bus and they haven't set up the total protocol for their
- 1:07:23family to get it. And again, it's not an either or
- 1:07:26thing is the beauty. It's the same thing as money is.
- 1:07:29If we don't hold all of our cash in the bank, like you may take
- 1:07:32some home, you may have some in a rainy day fund, you may have
- 1:07:34these different options. It's just explaining the
- 1:07:36standardized process for the vast majority of wealth will end
- 1:07:39up going down this trajectory. Yeah, very well said.
- 1:07:44So we'll link to that in the show notes.
- 1:07:46Check out that report in a related item, Just thinking
- 1:07:50through custody risks, there was a report from last week of a
- 1:07:57social engineering attack. We've been seeing these
- 1:07:58increasingly over the past really almost two years now, I
- 1:08:02feel like have we've been seeing increased.
- 1:08:06News items other than social. Engineering or physical attacks
- 1:08:09in the crypto space so this happened to be a social
- 1:08:11engineering attack, a victim losing almost 100 million in
- 1:08:16Bitcoin. They were using what it seems
- 1:08:19like is a some some hardware wallet that then there was an
- 1:08:23attacker posing as a support agent for said hardware wallet,
- 1:08:28getting them to effectively unveil a certain amount of their
- 1:08:33cryptographic materials or passwords or logins to the point
- 1:08:37where they could then siphon funds.
- 1:08:40And so this is, you know, a continuation of trend that we've
- 1:08:42seen. You know, on one hand, multi
- 1:08:45institution custody, broadly speaking, defends against these.
- 1:08:48But I want to pull up a announcement from on ramp.
- 1:08:53Just this morning we went live with what we call on ramp
- 1:08:58Guardian, which is basically even further protection.
- 1:09:01So going beyond the custody layer and thinking through how
- 1:09:05do you defend against basically the unauthorized movement of
- 1:09:09your Bitcoin? And so sort of the first defense
- 1:09:11against that is just superior trust, minimize custody through
- 1:09:16multi institution. But basically wrapping around
- 1:09:18that various elements of basically just, you know, the
- 1:09:24ability to slow down the process, the ability to put in
- 1:09:27enhance identity checks, time delays, velocity limits and
- 1:09:31enhance fraud detection as well. So using AI to combat AI
- 1:09:35deepfakes potentially and really just doing everything in our
- 1:09:38power to add an additional layer of security around what we
- 1:09:42believe is is sort of best in class custody.
- 1:09:44But Michael, anything to add on on on Ramp Guardian?
- 1:09:48Yeah, I think the spoofing. Stuff.
- 1:09:50Randomly I had a dream about spoofing.
- 1:09:53I was thinking about pitching Sailor if if yeah, we won't go
- 1:09:58far sailors actions and intent, but sailor pitching him on MIC.
- 1:10:04And it was this notion of spoofing because what Brian was
- 1:10:06alluding to, there's a lot of already, you know, value and
- 1:10:10assurances and security with multi institution 1 specifically
- 1:10:14is around the notion of even if a key signer was somehow spoofed
- 1:10:17by multiple versions, that would take, you know, different levels
- 1:10:20of an organization's coordination.
- 1:10:22The beauty of multi sig is that because it's interoperable and
- 1:10:25because the signatures happen in a segregated fashion, one
- 1:10:30address or one signing is it completely independent from the
- 1:10:33second one. So you can't manipulate the
- 1:10:35second signer to sign up a malicious transaction if it
- 1:10:37wasn't authenticated via the person.
- 1:10:41But that so there's a lot there with video verification to go
- 1:10:43into multi institution. But to take it a step further,
- 1:10:46given not only the physical attacks that have been
- 1:10:49occurring, but also the social engineering that is increased,
- 1:10:54there's a number of levels from whether it's a lot of folks
- 1:10:57concerned with AI and the deep fake protection to leverage AI
- 1:11:00to combat AI by using the ability to tell if somebody is
- 1:11:04actually there or not. It's a real human.
- 1:11:07The withdrawal delays have been something that clients have been
- 1:11:10asking and using already because depending on markets.
- 1:11:13And also this goes back to just market understanding that if you
- 1:11:16know that you're an honoring client and it's going to take
- 1:11:18either days, if not weeks, if not longer to move the assets,
- 1:11:21you're automatically because there's certain aspects of this
- 1:11:25that doesn't matter, gets thrown out a lot.
- 1:11:27Well, if somebody has a gun to somebody's head, they are just
- 1:11:29going to tell them to move the money.
- 1:11:30It's like it doesn't work like that in banking wire in the same
- 1:11:32way doesn't work with on ramp, like there is a SLA in process
- 1:11:35independent of what's happening. And that's also why you may want
- 1:11:38some form of self custody because you may want to give
- 1:11:41them something. But then layered on top of that,
- 1:11:44there's obviously the insurance, there's freezes in case there's
- 1:11:47the ability for somebody to get access to your account.
- 1:11:50But then there is a new F3FA protocol which effectively
- 1:11:54severs the Internet connection to objectively prove that it is
- 1:11:57you with a certain amount of Satoshi's wanting to move from
- 1:12:00one wall to another. That's limited to private
- 1:12:03clients for now, but we can talk more about it if you ever want
- 1:12:05to book a consultation. But I'm personally really
- 1:12:08excited for that because we have clients that hold, you know,
- 1:12:10quarter billion plus in assets and significant wealth is stored
- 1:12:14with us. And there's a notion of at the
- 1:12:16end of the day, a lot of things end up subjective, whether it's
- 1:12:20passwords or can be manipulated, spoof video verification, that
- 1:12:25certain holders will want to sever that Internet connection
- 1:12:27and have a objective opportunity to show via the blockchain.
- 1:12:32And Satoshi's, you know, UTX has moved that.
- 1:12:35It is then verifiably proving that they are moving this amount
- 1:12:39of assets. And if they don't, then then the
- 1:12:41account naturally will go into a freeze.
- 1:12:44Really excited about Guardian and just really adding to the
- 1:12:47value. Again, this is similar to
- 1:12:49insurance and the other products we've launched.
- 1:12:50There's no additional cost for this, which is something that is
- 1:12:54important for us, that the idea is we're not just a custodian,
- 1:12:56we're a private bank for bitcoiners.
- 1:12:59And you want to be able to deliver as much value as
- 1:13:02possible, whether it's trust planning, estate planning,
- 1:13:04inheritance, or the just ability for your friends and family and
- 1:13:09bad actors to know that you can't just take somebody's
- 1:13:11assets independent if you show up to their house or not.
- 1:13:15Yep, very well said. We'll link to that in the show
- 1:13:19notes as well if you want to learn more or reach out to any
- 1:13:21one of us one other before we wrap.
- 1:13:26I know we're we're up on time, but there was one other headline
- 1:13:30related to all of this related to custody risk, particularly at
- 1:13:34the corporate Bitcoin treasury level.
- 1:13:37Michael, you'd share this one. Corporate Bitcoin treasuries
- 1:13:39could raise credit risks. Morningstar says regulatory
- 1:13:43uncertainty, volatility and liquidity challenges could all
- 1:13:45elevate the credit risk profile firms adopting a crypto treasury
- 1:13:49strategy. So basically my understanding of
- 1:13:51this was Morningstar and other credit rating agencies are
- 1:13:54looking at a lot of these Bitcoin treasury companies and
- 1:13:57Dats and saying, you know, effectively calling out custody
- 1:14:01as a really important risk to consider.
- 1:14:03Something that we've talked a lot about on their show seems to
- 1:14:07be impacting or at least, you know, entering the mind of
- 1:14:12credit agencies looking at these these companies.
- 1:14:16Yeah. I think this ties back to
- 1:14:17everything we talked about with the standardization.
- 1:14:20If you're a corporate rating agency, you're looking at a
- 1:14:23public equity, whether it's a, let's forget about digital asset
- 1:14:27treasury company, just a traditional market public listed
- 1:14:32company that holds a significant amount of BTC in its balance
- 1:14:35sheet. Figma is a great example.
- 1:14:36It's in Coinbase's ETF, but if nothing happens to Coinbase,
- 1:14:41what part of the credit rating starts to take a hit?
- 1:14:43If Coinbase is holding trillions of dollars and there's no form
- 1:14:46of insurance that will provide, you know, insurance for that,
- 1:14:50let alone, well, what's the strategy like?
- 1:14:52Is it in cold storage? Is a verifiable chain?
- 1:14:54Are they lending against it, doing other things?
- 1:14:57Now, these might not seem like a big deal today, but as the asset
- 1:15:00appreciates because we're again only at 112 K, so two 2 1/2
- 1:15:04trillion dollar market cap. But what happens at 5 trillion,
- 1:15:0710 trillion? And these risks come back
- 1:15:10because they will like it's again, we've never, we're in the
- 1:15:13Wild West. We've never had a digital bearer
- 1:15:14asset worth this amount of capital online.
- 1:15:17There will just be increase in volatility when it comes to
- 1:15:19counterparty risk. Like I can hang my head on that.
- 1:15:22And if that's true, then there will naturally need to be
- 1:15:25standardization, not only the the ratings of who's holding it,
- 1:15:29but then how are they holding it?
- 1:15:30How is it verifiable? And insurance is one of my
- 1:15:33favorite ones to bring up because I don't think I'm very
- 1:15:36confident insurance in this industry has not been solved yet
- 1:15:39and simply because most insurance companies are
- 1:15:43insolvent. We all know this.
- 1:15:45And so you should never rely on your custody arrangement because
- 1:15:48it's insured. Sure, we offer insurance and I
- 1:15:50look it as a cherry on top, but the best form of insurance and I
- 1:15:53can explain why ours is different.
- 1:15:54But at the end of the day, the best form of insurance is the
- 1:15:56way cryptographic materials held.
- 1:15:58And so I'm convinced that over time you'll be able to create
- 1:16:03these. We've talked to firms about
- 1:16:04these these mutuals, these insurance products where you can
- 1:16:06hold them in multi institution custody.
- 1:16:09It'll be natural for institutions to participate in
- 1:16:12this that already have Bitcoin exposure because they've already
- 1:16:14had to underwrite the, you know, notion of multi institution for
- 1:16:18their own holdings. That'll propagate over into them
- 1:16:20participating into some of these mutuals.
- 1:16:22And now you can start to really develop robust Bitcoin
- 1:16:25denominated insurance markets, which will naturally also fill
- 1:16:29into this credit rating. So I think we're just very
- 1:16:32early, but it's an important thing that's been brought up
- 1:16:34that the credit problem is a, or the credit rating problem will
- 1:16:38only increase as a, as a natural point of friction as the market
- 1:16:41grows 100%. I think it's a definitely a.
- 1:16:46Positive signal that you know, at least we're talking about
- 1:16:48this stuff more. I think for a while the sort of
- 1:16:53concentration risk, particularly as it relates to Coinbase being
- 1:16:57the custodian of nine out of the 11 ETFs is something that's just
- 1:17:01generally not spoken about. Like everyone recognizes it as a
- 1:17:05really important risk, but it's really not talked about.
- 1:17:08And so the rating agencies talking about this in the
- 1:17:12context of treasury companies, I think just blows through to all
- 1:17:16elements of custody and and people recognizing that, you
- 1:17:20know, these proxy exposures come with real risks.
- 1:17:23And so you have to you have to consider those as you're making
- 1:17:27your allocation to the asset. How do you actually want to hold
- 1:17:29it? Do you want to do it through a
- 1:17:30proxy where there's layers of counterparty risk and potential
- 1:17:35credit related insolvencies at the underlying level or do you
- 1:17:37want a more direct exposure where you have greater
- 1:17:40assurances of your ownership? Yeah.
- 1:17:43And the the crazy part is that you can see.
- 1:17:45It playing out this way from a very simplistic view of it's
- 1:17:48already kind of happening where nobody ever gets fired to go
- 1:17:51into Coinbase and maybe a little bit of Fidelity.
- 1:17:54So if you just look at this, you just need one treasury company
- 1:17:59or one large custodian to mess up and then you're back.
- 1:18:03So like it can be again, like the treasury company is an
- 1:18:07easier example because it can be a small amount of BTC, but at a
- 1:18:11public treasury company that's well known as influencers,
- 1:18:13whatever. And then now everyone starts to
- 1:18:15just think which they already should have of like, how are
- 1:18:18they custody and are they trying to generate yield from it?
- 1:18:21But if you take it a step further, well, that naturally
- 1:18:24starts to move the market to where it's already going of
- 1:18:26like, OK, well it needs to go at Coinbase because of XY and Z
- 1:18:29reason. But that in itself is it's this
- 1:18:32natural paradox of the more successful Coinbase is, the more
- 1:18:34likely they are to fail. And a from a just pure first
- 1:18:38principle perspective, this is how gold fell.
- 1:18:40Because ultimately, if you end up with a centralized asset, you
- 1:18:42end up with too many claims on it and then you can't actually
- 1:18:44audit it. You end up in a whole slew of
- 1:18:46other problems. But the other side of it is just
- 1:18:49the ROI starts to grow for the honeypot for that asset.
- 1:18:54And so there's just multiple forces that will like naturally
- 1:18:59push people in this direction. And it ties back to the war
- 1:19:02Buffettism of the whole notion of the definition of like risk
- 1:19:06management is, you know, just like it's such a great, like
- 1:19:10it's a crude example, but he references if you're going to
- 1:19:13get off him a billion dollars, but he has to play Russian
- 1:19:17roulette. But here's the kicker.
- 1:19:17It's like 1000 bullets. You can make up whatever number
- 1:19:20of or not bullets, but 1000 spins in the chamber, but you
- 1:19:24have one bullet. Well, you would never take like
- 1:19:26no rational person would take that chance because if you click
- 1:19:29the wrong, you know, trigger once you pull the trigger, once
- 1:19:33wrong, you're out of the game. And it's very similar with
- 1:19:35custody. It just takes one time and you
- 1:19:37lose all the money. And so this is just, again,
- 1:19:40we're so early and they're still so small allocations that nobody
- 1:19:44talks or discusses this. But as the price rises, the
- 1:19:47allocation becomes greater and then the confidence and
- 1:19:49conviction of the education becomes greater.
- 1:19:51That this is just the rational outcome for market participants.
- 1:19:57Paul said. All right, boys.
- 1:20:01We got through a lot. I think we got through all the
- 1:20:02links, got through the reports. We'll put those in the in the
- 1:20:06show notes. Anything else before we wrap?
- 1:20:08No, I think we're going to be out on the road.
- 1:20:10Hosting events. So if anybody's interested in
- 1:20:13meeting the guys or the team US one-on-one, we're going to be
- 1:20:17hosting some private dinners and some other round table events,
- 1:20:21please reach out either. You could shoot all of our names
- 1:20:25at earlyriders.com or schedule time with the on ramp team and
- 1:20:30and let them know that you're interested in joining.
- 1:20:32There'll be some stuff in Nashville next month and then
- 1:20:34Dallas in October, but I think it's going to be a busy 18
- 1:20:38months. So, you know, reach out.
- 1:20:39We always want to connect. And then I think we'll be taking
- 1:20:42better logs of kind of who's in certain markets as we're around
- 1:20:45the the country and actually outside of the country.
- 1:20:47Try to set up more round tables and things where we can all
- 1:20:50connect with listeners and clients that are, you know,
- 1:20:53partnering with us. Sounds good.
- 1:20:57All right, boys. See you next, guys.
- 1:20:59Thanks, guys. Thanks for listening to this.
- 1:21:01Week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:21:04valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:21:06rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:21:08All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:21:10notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:21:13reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:21:15entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:21:18investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:21:21your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:21:24Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:21:28one of our private client advisors.