Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Amazon Earnings Beat But Stock Fell,Why?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Dee Dive, the show where we take really
- 0:02dense, complex financial research and make it crystal
- 0:05clear for you. Today, we are digging into one
- 0:08of the market's most fascinating and frankly confounding
- 0:11companies, Amazon specifically. We're looking at the research
- 0:15reports that dropped right after their Q32025 earnings.
- 0:19And this moment is just, it's a perfect case study.
- 0:23You're looking at a tech giant that delivered an absolute
- 0:25blowout quarter. I mean, a huge earnings beat,
- 0:28great revenue and the cloud business AWS is firing on all
- 0:32cylinders again. It was a clean sweep on paper.
- 0:35Exactly. And yet the stock barely moved.
- 0:37In fact, it did. It dipped.
- 0:38Yeah. So that conflict, amazing
- 0:40results meeting a really nervous market.
- 0:42We're here to unpack. We're going to get into the
- 0:44earnings, the risks like regulation, that famous flywheel
- 0:46business model and of course, run some valuation scenarios to
- 0:49figure out what AMZN is truly worth right now.
- 0:52Sounds good. So before we get into the weeds,
- 0:54let's just set the table. What were the headline numbers
- 0:57from Q3 that should have had Wall Street sharing?
- 0:59Well, the top line was very strong.
- 1:01Net sales came in at about $180.2 billion.
- 1:05That's up 12% year over year, which beat what analysts were
- 1:09expecting. OK, a solid beat.
- 1:11But the real kicker was the bottom line.
- 1:14Earnings per share, or EPS hit $1.95.
- 1:19The forecast was for $1.56. Wow, that's a huge surprise.
- 1:23About 25%. A massive surprise.
- 1:25So like you said, on the surface it looks like a perfect quarter,
- 1:28but. There's always a but.
- 1:30There is, and here's the context that explains everything.
- 1:33Despite those stellar numbers, the shares fell about 3.2% in
- 1:37after hours trading. So why?
- 1:39What was the market seeing that overshadowed that huge earnings
- 1:42beat? One thing and one thing only
- 1:45really capital expenditure. CapEx investors looked right
- 1:49past the great results and focused entirely on the
- 1:52company's guidance for future spending.
- 1:55The fear of that spending just sucked all the oxygen out of the
- 1:57room. Completely.
- 1:58And that tension really defines the whole story for Amazon right
- 2:01now. OK, so that sets the stage
- 2:04perfectly. Let's get into Section 1 and
- 2:06unpack these numbers starting with the big one, the engine re
- 2:09accelerating. Let's talk about AWS, right?
- 2:13Before we do though, I think it's important to frame this.
- 2:16You know when you see a reaction like this, you have to ask if
- 2:19it's just about 1 stock or if it signals something about the
- 2:23broader market temperature. That's a great.
- 2:25Point and if you're trying to track that to see if the markets
- 2:27getting a little frothy, a great tool is the iOS app Buffett
- 2:31indicator. You can find it on the Apple App
- 2:33Store and it helps you monitor that overall market sentiment.
- 2:37Good to know. And of course, our mandatory
- 2:39disclaimer. Everything we're discussing
- 2:41today is based on publicly available sources.
- 2:43It is absolutely for educational purposes only.
- 2:46It is not investment advice. Please.
- 2:48You must do your own due diligence before making any
- 2:51decisions. All right, disclaimer done.
- 2:53Let's talk about Amazon Web Services.
- 2:55The report confirmed year over year growth of 20.2%.
- 2:59That number specifically feels like a really big deal.
- 3:02Why is that so important? Because it's a massive confirmed
- 3:05inflection point after the last couple of years.
- 3:08Anyone following the cloud space knows AWS growth was slowing
- 3:11down. Right, the cost optimization
- 3:13period. Exactly.
- 3:14Big customers were trying to trim their cloud bills, find
- 3:17efficiencies, that sort of thing.
- 3:18This 20.2% growth is the fastest they've reported in 11 quarters.
- 3:23It signals that the optimization phase is, for all intents and
- 3:26purposes, over. So customers aren't just turning
- 3:29the lights back on. This is new demand.
- 3:31It's new structural demand and it's being driven by one thing,
- 3:35generative AI. These new AI workloads are
- 3:38incredibly power hungry and they are flooding into AWS.
- 3:42It confirms their market leadership.
- 3:43I mean, the business is now on a $132 billion annualized revenue
- 3:48run rate. The scale is just immense.
- 3:50And that kind of growth should be translating to the bottom
- 3:53line, to profits. The reported operating income
- 3:56was $17.4 billion, which sounds good, but the research suggests
- 4:00the real number, the underlying profitability, was actually much
- 4:04stronger. Yeah, this is the key detail
- 4:07that a lot of the egg lines missed.
- 4:08That 17.4 billion number is correct, but it includes or
- 4:14rather it absorbed about $4.3 billion in special one time
- 4:19charges. So if those charges weren't
- 4:20there, the operational picture would look completely different.
- 4:24It shows the business is actually way healthier than the
- 4:27official gap results might suggest.
- 4:29OK, let's break those charges down.
- 4:30What were they? There were two main dockets.
- 4:33The biggest was a 2 1/2 billion dollar legal settlement with the
- 4:37Federal Trade Commission, the FTC.
- 4:39Right for the ongoing regulatory battles.
- 4:40Exactly. It's a huge cost, but it's not a
- 4:43core operational expense. The other chunk was severance
- 4:47costs from the big restructuring that CEO Andy Jassy has been
- 4:50doing, you know, cutting teams, shutting down unprofitable
- 4:54projects. The efficiency drive.
- 4:56The efficiency drive. So if you strip out that noise,
- 4:59that 4.3 billion, what do you get?
- 5:02What's the real number? The operational income would
- 5:05have been over $21.7 billion, and that's dramatic.
- 5:10It proves that Jassy's focus on regionalizing the fulfillment
- 5:13network and just running a tighter ship is working
- 5:16brilliantly. The margins are expanding.
- 5:19It was just hidden by these cleanup costs.
- 5:20And there was another non operating boost to the net
- 5:23income as well, right? The anthropic investment,
- 5:26correct? Net income also got a huge
- 5:28tailwind from a nine and a half billion dollar pre tax gain.
- 5:32This is from revaluing Amazon's strategic investment in
- 5:35Anthropic, the AI company. So they're not just building the
- 5:39AI infrastructure, they're also a very successful investor in
- 5:43the ecosystem. They're playing both sides and
- 5:45it's paying off big time. OK.
- 5:47This brings us perfectly to what you called the CapEx conflict.
- 5:50We have all this great operational cash flow, strategic
- 5:53gains and yet the market is scared, terrified.
- 5:56Management raised the capital expenditure guidance for 2025 to
- 6:00a staggering 125 billion dollars.
- 6:03Can you help us conceptualize that number?
- 6:05What are they buying and why does it instantly make investors
- 6:08so nervous? I mean the number is just
- 6:10monumental. Even at the peak of the pandemic
- 6:12when they were building warehouses everywhere, they
- 6:14weren't spending at this level consistently.
- 6:17So this is a new peak. A new peak, and it's almost
- 6:19entirely dedicated to winning the AI race.
- 6:22We're talking about new data centers, specialized chips like
- 6:25NVIDIA GPU's or their own custom silicon, and just all the power
- 6:30and networking needed to support this AI boom.
- 6:33OK, but why the fear? If it's for growth, shouldn't
- 6:37that be a good thing? It comes down to the simple math
- 6:39of free cash flow. Free cash flow is your cash from
- 6:42operations minus your capital expenditures.
- 6:46When that CapEx number explodes to 125 billion, it's like a
- 6:49giant vacuum sucking cash out of the company in the short term.
- 6:52So it crushes the free cash flow number.
- 6:55It crushes it. Investors are being asked to
- 6:57stomach that massive short term hit for a promise of big profits
- 7:01maybe 5 or 10 years from now. It requires an enormous amount
- 7:05of faith in management. The classic Amazon dilemma.
- 7:08Short term pain for long term dominance, but it seems like
- 7:11management isn't blinking. The Q4 forecast looked pretty
- 7:14strong. Not blinking at all, the
- 7:17guidance for the holiday quarter was extremely bullish.
- 7:20They projected sales up to $213 billion and more importantly,
- 7:25operating income between 21 and 26 billion.
- 7:28So they think they can keep expanding margins even while
- 7:31spending all this money. That's the signal.
- 7:34They're confident that the efficiency gains they've made
- 7:37can absorb a lot of these costs. They believe they can walk and
- 7:41chew gum at the same time, spend aggressively on AI while
- 7:44improving profitability. That confidence forces us to
- 7:47look at the underlying machine that generates all this cash in
- 7:50the first place. So let's move to Section 2 and
- 7:53really analyze that Amazon flywheel.
- 7:56You have to understand the flywheel to understand the
- 7:58Amazon. It's this self reinforcing loop
- 8:00that all starts with the retail business, the online stores.
- 8:03That's the customer acquisition engine.
- 8:05It's the engine, it brings the scale, it brings the customers,
- 8:08it brings the transaction volume, and that volume is the
- 8:11fuel. Well, all that volume let's them
- 8:13build out their logistics network and lower the cost to
- 8:17ship each package. That creates a cost advantage
- 8:20and it generates this incredibly rich data on what people are
- 8:23actually buying. And that data and those
- 8:25logistics then power the other businesses.
- 8:28Exactly. They power the high margin
- 8:30businesses that sit on top of the retail platform, AWS and
- 8:34especially advertising. So the low margin retail
- 8:37business is the thing that makes the high margin profit engines
- 8:40possible. OK.
- 8:41Let's breakdown that revenue mix.
- 8:42How much comes from where? So online stores are still the
- 8:45biggest piece of the pie top line wise, about 3839% of total
- 8:50revenue. But as we all know, they run on
- 8:52razor thin margins. And the profit engines?
- 8:54AWS brings in about 17% of revenue, but a much, much bigger
- 8:58share of the profit. And then you have advertising,
- 9:00which is only about 9% of revenue, but is the fastest
- 9:03growing major segment because it's almost pure profit.
- 9:05And the third party sellers. That's the secret sauce.
- 9:09Third party seller services, that's the commissions and
- 9:12fulfillment fees make up a massive 2425% of revenue.
- 9:17This is where Amazon becomes a utility.
- 9:19It's selling access to its platform and it's an incredibly
- 9:21profitable and scalable model. It's incredible that third party
- 9:25sales are now structurally bigger than Amazon's own first
- 9:28party retail sales. It is.
- 9:30It shows the shift. The modern Amazon is a services
- 9:33platform that uses its own retail arm as a very effective,
- 9:37very large but low margin customer acquisition tool.
- 9:41And the scale of that tool is just mind boggling.
- 9:43Which brings us to prime. Yes.
- 9:45The loyalty that comes from Prime is the glue that holds it
- 9:48all together. We're talking about roughly 250
- 9:51million Prime members worldwide, and in the US, the penetration
- 9:54is insane, something like 180 million subscriptions.
- 9:58What does that captive audience enable?
- 10:00It creates enormous lock in. Prime members don't just shop
- 10:03more, they spend a lot more per year, and that guaranteed volume
- 10:08is what allows for that crucial metric.
- 10:09We see third party sellers now account for over 60% of all
- 10:13units sold on the platform. 60%. And that number is so important,
- 10:18it means Amazon is de risking its own inventory and just
- 10:21cashing in by selling its logistics network as a service.
- 10:25And it's not just shopping. You have Prime Video with nearly
- 10:29300 million users, Prime Music with 75,000,000.
- 10:33It's this sticky ecosystem that makes that annual fee feel like
- 10:36a non negotiable utility. Which brings us directly to the
- 10:39idea of an economic Moat. If they're this dominant, what
- 10:43are the actual durable advantages that keep everyone
- 10:45else out? Well, the sources describe it as
- 10:47having 4 main pillars. It's not one thing, it's a
- 10:50system. OK, what's pillar #1?
- 10:51Network effects This is the classic retail loop.
- 10:54More consumers on the platform attract more sellers.
- 10:57Which brings better selection and prices.
- 10:59Which in turn brings in even more consumers.
- 11:01It's a virtuous cycle, and that now applies to advertising too.
- 11:06More data means better ad targeting, which brings in more
- 11:09ad revenue. Right.
- 11:10And Pillar 2 is just the raw cost of entry.
- 11:13Exactly. Cost advantage.
- 11:15Amazon has spent hundreds of billions of dollars over 20
- 11:18years building out its fulfillment network.
- 11:20Warehouses, robots, planes. You just can't replicate that.
- 11:24No competitor can match it without spending a prohibitive
- 11:27amount of time and money. And they're still optimizing it
- 11:30right with the move to regionalize the network.
- 11:32Yes, moving from a national system to these smaller regional
- 11:35delivery zones to cut down on shipping distances and costs
- 11:39even further. It's a relentless drive for
- 11:41efficiency. OK, Pillar 3 takes us back to
- 11:44the cloud. It does switching costs
- 11:46specifically with AWS. Once a company builds its entire
- 11:50digital infrastructure on AWS, moving it is incredibly costly,
- 11:54complex, and risky. You're essentially locked in.
- 11:57You are, and that creates this wonderfully predictable high
- 12:00margin recurring revenue. And the new AI investments make
- 12:04that lock in even stronger. Once you can make the training
- 12:07your models on their custom chips, moving becomes even
- 12:10harder. And the final pillar.
- 12:12Intangible assets. This is brand trust, of course,
- 12:15but more importantly, it's the proprietary purchase data.
- 12:18What people buy, not just what they search for.
- 12:20Exactly. Unlike Google or Meta, Amazon
- 12:23knows your purchase history. That data is an invaluable asset
- 12:28for advertising for product development.
- 12:30It's a Moat that's almost impossible for anyone else to
- 12:32cross. So even with a Moat that wide,
- 12:34there have to be pressures. Let's move to Section 3 and talk
- 12:38about the headwinds and the regulatory battles.
- 12:40What are the short term economic issues?
- 12:42Well, the macro environment is still a bit of a drag.
- 12:45You still have inflation pushing some consumers to trade down to
- 12:48cheaper options or delay bigger purchases.
- 12:50That puts pressure on retail margins.
- 12:52And as a global company, currency fluctuations.
- 12:55Right. A strong U.S.
- 12:56Dollar hurts the value of their international sales, but
- 13:00honestly the biggest single financial headwind is the one we
- 13:03started with. The 125 billion in CapEx.
- 13:06That's the one we have to be clear, that's cash that's not
- 13:09going to shareholders or paying down debt.
- 13:12It's being reinvested. And the sheer size of that
- 13:15reinvestment is what's driving all the investor anxiety right
- 13:18now. OK, let's shift to the longer
- 13:21term, more structural threat. The researcher identifies the
- 13:24regulatory risk as potentially existential.
- 13:28Let's unpack that FTC lawsuit. Yeah, this is a big one.
- 13:31This isn't just about a fine. It's a battle over the very
- 13:34structure of the company. The FTC, along with 17 states,
- 13:38has filed this massive lawsuit alleging that Amazon is an
- 13:42illegal monopoly. And what are the specific claims
- 13:44they're making? There are a few big ones.
- 13:45One is the claim that Amazon used deceptive dark patterns to
- 13:48get people to sign up for Prime and then make it incredibly
- 13:51difficult to cancel. This was apparently known
- 13:54internally as Project Gilead. So tricking users into staying
- 13:57locked in the ecosystem. That's the allegation.
- 14:00The other major claim is that Amazon essentially forces third
- 14:05party sellers to use its Fulfillment by Amazon service
- 14:08FBA and to buy ads if they want their products to be visible.
- 14:12Coercion. Basically the.
- 14:13FTC argues it's coercion and if that's proven it could really
- 14:17damage that very profitable third party seller services
- 14:20business. And we're already seeing the
- 14:22financial impact of this, right, the $2.5 billion charge from Q3.
- 14:26Exactly. That charge was to settle a part
- 14:29of these claims. It proves this isn't some
- 14:30abstract future risk, it's a material cost hitting the books
- 14:34right now, and the worst case scenario for Amazon would be a
- 14:37forced breakup like separating AWS from the retail business.
- 14:41That would completely change the investment thesis.
- 14:43OK, let's look at the internal cost structure.
- 14:46How do they manage fulfillment costs when they seem to be
- 14:48constantly rising? They're relentless.
- 14:50Fuel, labor, everything goes up. Amazon's strategy is pretty
- 14:54straightforward. They use their market power to
- 14:56pass those costs on to the third party sellers who depend on
- 14:59them. By raising fees.
- 15:00By raising fees. For example, they announced an
- 15:03average fee hike of $0.08 per unit for 2026.
- 15:07It doesn't sound like much, but when you're selling billions of
- 15:10units, it adds up. They're using their Moat to
- 15:12protect their own margins. Which frees up more cash for
- 15:15that big CapEx plan? Precisely, they're shoring up
- 15:18operational profits with pricing power so they can feel more
- 15:22comfortable deploying that 125 billion into AI.
- 15:25And of course, there's labor, the single biggest variable,
- 15:28cost. It is.
- 15:29You're talking about a workforce that fluctuates around 1.51
- 15:33point 6 million people, so even a tiny increase in the average
- 15:36hourly wage translates into billions of dollars in new
- 15:40annual expenses. And the unionization efforts are
- 15:43still a long term risk. A long term risk, yes.
- 15:46If a large part of that workforce were to unionize, it
- 15:49could fundamentally change their cost structure and really eat
- 15:52into those retail margins. So it's a double whammy from
- 15:54inflation. It is it hits them with higher
- 15:56fuel costs for delivery and higher wage demands from their
- 15:59workforce. The pressure is constant.
- 16:02All right, let's zoom out. We've looked at the quarter,
- 16:04we've looked at the risks in Section 4.
- 16:06Let's look at the long term trend.
- 16:08What does the 10 year picture tell us?
- 16:10It tells a story of incredible transformation.
- 16:13The Amazon of 2016 is not the Amazon of 2025.
- 16:17How so? The margin expansion has been
- 16:19profound. If you look at gross margins,
- 16:22they've gone from around 35% in 2016 to over 50% in the trailing
- 16:2712 months of 2025. 50% gross margin for a company with that
- 16:31much retail is unheard of. It is, and it's driven almost
- 16:34entirely by the makeshift. As higher margin businesses like
- 16:38AWS and advertising become a bigger piece of the pie, the
- 16:41overall company margin just gets richer and richer.
- 16:44The operating margin is basically doubled to around 11%.
- 16:47And let's revisit CapEx over that decade.
- 16:49It went from under 7 billion in 2016 to this projection of 125
- 16:54billion. Just shows you their core
- 16:56philosophy. They're always willing to invest
- 16:58far far ahead of demand. The spending focus just shifts.
- 17:02A few years ago it was all logistics, now it's all AI.
- 17:05That's how they build and defend the Moat.
- 17:06And all that spending makes the free cash flow number really
- 17:10volatile. Very volatile.
- 17:11It went negative during the big logistics build out in 2021 and
- 17:152022. But the number you really want
- 17:17to watch is operating cash flow, which is the cash the business
- 17:20generates before those big investments.
- 17:22That's still strong. Incredibly strong, over $130
- 17:26billion in the last 12 months. It shows the engine itself is
- 17:30perfectly healthy, even if management chooses to reinvest
- 17:34every penny it generates. Let's talk about that management
- 17:36CEO Andy Jassy. His background is building AWS.
- 17:40Is he the right guy for this AI pivot?
- 17:43I mean, you couldn't pick a better person really.
- 17:45He's a builder, he's deeply technical, he understands
- 17:48infrastructure. So his focus on high margin
- 17:50services and this aggressive AI build out makes perfect sense.
- 17:55He's also been ruthless about cutting unprofitable side
- 17:57projects, which was a necessary clean up.
- 17:59And the alignment with shareholders, is it still there?
- 18:01It's exceptionally strong. Jeff Bezos still owns 9 or 10%
- 18:06of the company. His wealth is tied to the stock
- 18:09and Jassy's pay is heavily weighted to stock units that
- 18:12vest over a decade. His incentives are tied directly
- 18:16to that long term cash flow per share mantra from the original
- 18:211997 shareholder letter. But they're still very
- 18:24conservative on returning capital to shareholders.
- 18:27No big buybacks or dividends. No, that's strategic.
- 18:30They have a small $10 billion buyback program, but it's mostly
- 18:34just to offset dilution from employee stock compensation.
- 18:37They prioritize having a fortress balance sheet so they
- 18:39have the flexibility to fund these massive investment cycles
- 18:43like the one we're in now. And this split in philosophy is
- 18:45really reflected in what the big institutional investors were
- 18:48doing last quarter. Absolutely.
- 18:50The 13 F filings show a clear split.
- 18:52Yeah, growth focused funds like Tiger Global and .72
- 18:56aggressively buying more shares. They're betting on the AWS
- 18:59reacceleration and the AI payoff.
- 19:01They're betting that the 125 billion is a great investment,
- 19:04but on the other side you had someone like David Tepper's
- 19:06Appaloosa management trimming their position.
- 19:08Signaling concern over the risk, the FCF compression, the
- 19:12regulatory threat. Exactly.
- 19:14Of course, Business himself continues his pre planned sales
- 19:17for Philanthropy and Blue Origin, so the smart money is
- 19:20clearly divided on how this big AI bet is going to play out.
- 19:23That division makes this the perfect time to stress test
- 19:26Amazon against some classic value investing principles.
- 19:30Let's move to Section 5 and run it through a Buffett style
- 19:32quality checklist. OK, so let's start with the
- 19:35strict valuation tests. PE PB How does it look?
- 19:40On those pure deep value metrics, Amazon fails pretty
- 19:43spectacularly actually. the PE ratio is around 31, way above
- 19:47the traditional benchmark of 15. Price book is over 6 when you'd
- 19:51want to see something closer to 1.5.
- 19:52Which is typical for a tech company where the assets are
- 19:55intangible. It is the brand, the data, the
- 19:58network effects. That stuff doesn't live on the
- 20:00balance sheet. But, and this is a huge but,
- 20:03there's the growth exception where it passes.
- 20:05The PEG ratio. The PEG ratio, you take that
- 20:08high PE and you divide it by the expected earnings growth rate.
- 20:12With EPS growth projected around 33%, the PEG ratio is between
- 20:160.86 and 1.0. That's the definition of growth
- 20:21at a reasonable price or GARP. So the high price is justified
- 20:25because the growth is so explosive.
- 20:27That's the argument. It qualifies as a GARP stock.
- 20:29OK. So what about the quality and
- 20:31safety checks? Cash generation?
- 20:34That's a convincing pass. The free cash flow has recovered
- 20:37strongly, over 38 billion in 2024 and more importantly, their
- 20:42return on retained earnings is exceptional.
- 20:45For decades they've proven they can reinvest cash back into the
- 20:48business and generate returns that are far higher than their
- 20:51cost of capital. That is the hallmark of a
- 20:54quality compounder. And the balance sheet, is it
- 20:56strong enough to handle this huge CapEx cycle?
- 20:59A clear pass there too. It's a fortress.
- 21:02Debt is very low relative to their cash generation and their
- 21:05interest coverage is over 25 times.
- 21:07There's absolutely zero financial distress risk here.
- 21:10OK, but there is one quirky metric on the balance sheet, the
- 21:15current ratio. It's low around 1:00, which
- 21:18would normally be a red flag. Why isn't it for Amazon?
- 21:22This is one of my favorite things about Amazon's model.
- 21:25It's a sign of extreme efficiency and power.
- 21:28It's because of their negative cash conversion cycle.
- 21:31OK, break that down for us in simple terms.
- 21:33Sure, when you buy something on Amazon, they take your cash
- 21:35immediately the second you click buy all right.
- 21:37But because of their power over their suppliers and 3rd party
- 21:40sellers, they don't have to pay them for 3045, sometimes even 60
- 21:44days. So they're using other people's
- 21:47money as interest free working capital.
- 21:50Billions and billions of dollars of it.
- 21:52It's a massive float because they have this system perfected.
- 21:55They don't need a big pile of cash sitting around for
- 21:57liquidity, which is what a high current ratio would show for
- 22:01Amazon. A low current ratio is actually
- 22:03a sign of incredible strength. That's a fantastic explanation.
- 22:06So if we pull this all together, what's the final verdict from
- 22:09the Graham and Buffett checklist?
- 22:11Amazon passes all the quality, growth, and safety tests with
- 22:14flying colors. It fails the deep value price
- 22:17tests, but it qualifies as a GARP stock.
- 22:21So the conclusion is pretty clear.
- 22:23This isn't a fair company at a wonderful price.
- 22:25It is a wonderful company at a fair price.
- 22:28And the next obvious question is what is that fair price?
- 22:31Exactly. Which brings us to our final and
- 22:34most important section, trying to determine the intrinsic value
- 22:38using a discounted cash flow model.
- 22:40This is where we try to put a number on all these competing
- 22:42narratives, right? So let's quickly review the
- 22:44assumptions we're using. We have a weighted average cost
- 22:47of capital or discount rate of 9.5%, a terminal growth rate of
- 22:513%. And critically, we're using a
- 22:53normalized free cash flow base of $45 billion.
- 22:57Right. And that 45 billion is our
- 22:59estimate of the company's true earnings power.
- 23:01If they weren't reinvesting so heavily for growth, we're
- 23:04crediting back some of that discretionary growth CapEx.
- 23:07OK, so let's run the scenarios. Let's start with scenario A, the
- 23:10stagnation case. This is the floor.
- 23:12What if AI is a bust and FCF just stays flat forever?
- 23:16In that scenario, the calculated value per share is about $43.65.
- 23:22Wow, OK, The implication there is staggering.
- 23:26If Amazon stops growing today, it is massively overvalued.
- 23:29Completely. It just confirms that almost all
- 23:31of the stocks current value is based on the expectation of
- 23:34future growth. If that growth story dies, the
- 23:38stock collapses. OK, let's get a bit more
- 23:40realistic. Scenario B, The conservative or
- 23:43bear case. This is where the fears come
- 23:45true. AI disappoints.
- 23:47Competition eats into AWS margins.
- 23:49The FTC wins. Let's say FCF grows at just 5% a
- 23:53year. In that bear case, the model
- 23:54gives us an intrinsic value of about $115.20 per share.
- 23:58And this is where the risk becomes very real At today's
- 24:01price. If that happens, the stock is
- 24:03overvalued by nearly 50%. This is the scenario that's
- 24:06driving that tepid market reaction.
- 24:09It embodies the fear about the $125 billion CapEx gamble.
- 24:13But I have to challenge this even regulatory risk.
- 24:16We just talked about the FTC potentially wanting to break up
- 24:18the company. Doesn't that make this $115.00
- 24:22scenario even more likely? If they were forced to split AWS
- 24:26from retail, where would the growth come from?
- 24:28That is the critical risk factor, yes.
- 24:31If the absolute worst case regulatory outcome happens and
- 24:34they are forced to separate, the synergies that justify the
- 24:37higher valuations just evaporate.
- 24:39The $115.00 case assumes AWS growth slows if a breakup
- 24:45happens. You're right, even 5% growth
- 24:48might be optimistic for the standalone retail business.
- 24:51For now, the market seems to be betting that a full breakup is a
- 24:54low probability event. OK, which brings us to the final
- 24:57case, Scenario C, the nominal or base case.
- 25:00This is a management vision. AWS growth stays strong.
- 25:03The AI investments pay off big. We'll assume FCF grows at 15%
- 25:07for five years, then slows to 10%.
- 25:09Running those numbers, the model produces a final intrinsic value
- 25:12of about $260.80 per share. And the implication there?
- 25:16The implication is that if you believe in that base case, which
- 25:20is supported by the Q3 results, then the stock is currently
- 25:23undervalued by about 13 or 14%. It suggests today's price is a
- 25:28reasonable entry point for a long term investor who believes
- 25:32management can execute. So there's the range, a disaster
- 25:35scenario at 115 and a successful execution around 260.
- 25:40The market has priced the stock right in the middle of that
- 25:43range, reflecting both the quality of the business and the
- 25:46huge execution risk. That's a perfect summary of
- 25:49where things stand. OK, let's synthesize this for
- 25:51you, the learner as we wrap up this deep dive.
- 25:53The core conflict with Amazon right now is this monumental
- 25:56trade off. They are knowingly sacrificing
- 25:59short term free cash flow with that staggering $125 billion
- 26:03CapEx plan for what they believe will be a dominant long term
- 26:07structural win in the AI cloud war.
- 26:10Classic Bezos style bet. It is.
- 26:12The key takeaways from Q3 were that the underlying business is
- 26:16much healthier than the headline suggested because those one time
- 26:19charges mask the real profitability and that AWS
- 26:22reacceleration is very real. But the market only cared about
- 26:26the CapEx. Exactly.
- 26:27The market saw that growth engine turning into a short term
- 26:30cash strain and chose caution over optimism.
- 26:34So here's the final provocative thought for you to chew on.
- 26:38Given our DCF analysis, which points to a value of around $260
- 26:43if they succeed, is this CapEx surge just the necessary cost of
- 26:48doing business to achieve that value?
- 26:50Or is the sheer size of this bet a reckless gamble that could
- 26:54drive the stock closer to that conservative $115.00 valuation
- 26:59if the AI boom doesn't pay off as expected?
- 27:01That's the billion dollar attention in Amazon stock today.
- 27:04A great way to frame it, and just a final reminder from my
- 27:07end, all of this analysis is for educational purposes only, based
- 27:10on public information. Please do your own rigorous due
- 27:13diligence. Absolutely.
- 27:15And hey, if you find these market dynamics fascinating and
- 27:18want to keep an eye on the bigger picture, don't forget to
- 27:20check out that app we mentioned earlier, Buffett Indicator over
- 27:22on the Apple App Store. It's a great tool for tracking
- 27:24market sentiment.