Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E006: Robert Breedlove – What is Money?
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10As we prepare for the Bitcoin having and the next wave of
- 1:13global adoption of this nascent and growing asset class, we are
- 1:17halving all annual maintenance fees for clients that secure
- 1:20their wealth before the next Bitcoin epoch.
- 1:23Let's be clear. Bitcoin is an international
- 1:26asset. We are spending like drunken
- 1:29sailors. Bitcoin is the only economic
- 1:32entity where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 1:38If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert that
- 1:41currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable.
- 1:46Durable. And maintainable.
- 1:54Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 1:57the 6th episode of Scarce Assets, the show that examines
- 2:01scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets,
- 2:05and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 2:08Happy to be here with my great friend and Co host Jesse Myers
- 2:11and our guest, the great Robert Breedlove.
- 2:14Now I'm going to say a few things about Robert.
- 2:16I met Robert for the first time at the Bitcoin 2019 conference,
- 2:21which I also I almost can't believe was five years ago now,
- 2:25and we had a great conversation. I was immediately impressed by
- 2:28him and that was at a point when he was really just starting to
- 2:32hit his stride. He had recently published Money
- 2:35Bitcoin in Time, and in the subsequent few years he
- 2:38published several articles that are now must read pieces for
- 2:42understanding Bitcoin, including both Bitcoin and the #0 and
- 2:46Masters and Slaves of Money. But he then took his scholarship
- 2:49to the next level when he launched the What is Money Show,
- 2:51and it's on my personal very short list of Must Listen
- 2:55podcast. And Robert has produced
- 2:57fantastic collaborations with a lot of brilliant people,
- 3:00including Jordan Peterson and Michael Saylor, and I'm sure I'm
- 3:04missing some of his other great accomplishments.
- 3:06But I also must say that Robert has always been kind to me and I
- 3:09couldn't be happier to have him on the show.
- 3:11So Robert, how are you today? I am great Andy.
- 3:15Thank you for that very nice introduction.
- 3:18Although, if my brain is not mistaken, I think we may have
- 3:22met before the 2019 conference. Did we really?
- 3:26I remember we had lunch at one point in Santa Monica.
- 3:29Yeah, we had lunch in Santa Monica when was that, though?
- 3:31Wasn't that 2018? Maybe?
- 3:33You you might be right about that.
- 3:35I in my mind the first intro was at the conference, but I may
- 3:39have those reversed. It would not surprise me.
- 3:42Yeah, How far things have come in such a short period of time.
- 3:47A lot of water under the bridge and I'm, I'm sure we're going to
- 3:51talk about some of those topics today.
- 3:54So I. I want to piggyback Andy on on
- 3:56#0 in Bitcoin. Robert for me was actually
- 4:00probably the final nail in the coffin for me on like the
- 4:04altcoin possibility and so like that.
- 4:07That was like, that was the last piece of the puzzle that I
- 4:10didn't have like a solid answer for.
- 4:12And that took care of it. And from there it's just been,
- 4:15you know, Bitcoin Maxi for me, so.
- 4:17I appreciate. You for that.
- 4:19I'd love to hear that because that was the point of the piece,
- 4:21as you know, the opening line. And it's a hard part of Bitcoin
- 4:27to understand, right, the social layer, that it's not just a
- 4:31technology, there's a social institution aspect to it.
- 4:36And you know it. It sounds ridiculous, almost
- 4:38like, what do you mean you can just copy and paste Bitcoin, but
- 4:40there's only 21 million, so you can just copy and paste it
- 4:43forever. So to explain that is pretty
- 4:48tricky and you have to invoke a lot of kind of esoteric ideas
- 4:52like path dependence and network effects and blah, blah, blah.
- 4:55So I'm really happy to hear it had that impact on you because I
- 5:00was, yeah, really struggling to find a good historical analogy
- 5:05and I think it worked out pretty well.
- 5:08It's perfect for it and for anyone who hasn't read it.
- 5:11What the hell are you doing? Go read that.
- 5:13That's it. I've actually, I've actually
- 5:15sent clients to it because that's one of the hardest
- 5:18questions that I've had, you know, attempted to have to deal
- 5:21with is the Oh, well if you can just copy it, you know, why, Why
- 5:24can't there be, you know what's the difference between Bitcoin
- 5:27and, I don't know, Litecoin or something on that on that logic.
- 5:30And yeah, so I've leaned on your piece.
- 5:33It's, it's saved me, I think a little bit of time and you
- 5:37certainly articulated it more clearly, you know, than I ever
- 5:40could have. So yeah, we both gotten some
- 5:42good mileage out of that piece. That's great to hear.
- 5:46So definitely the fan favorite. I think of all the feedback I've
- 5:50received is that that one's the favorite.
- 5:52Yeah, yeah. Love it.
- 5:54Well, let's talk about, you know, some of your more recent
- 5:56work now. You know, I want to talk about
- 5:59some of the more timeless themes that interest you and that
- 6:03you've explored on the What is Money?
- 6:05Show this, You know, your work touches numerous different
- 6:10disciplines, how they intersect money, you know, society,
- 6:14economics, philosophy, a lot of different areas.
- 6:18I'm curious, are there any fields of study that you found
- 6:23surprisingly interesting in their intersection with money?
- 6:30It's a good question. You know a lot of people it
- 6:36would. So when people first hear the
- 6:37title of the podcast, the What is Money Show, they're like, oh,
- 6:40it's a finance show. I'm like actually not really at
- 6:42all. We talk almost nothing about
- 6:45finance. It's much more philosophical
- 6:49slash psychological. I mean, there's obviously some
- 6:52historical stuff, some economic stuff, but I have found myself
- 6:58recently obsessively reading a lot of Western philosophy.
- 7:03Before Bitcoin, I'd read Eastern philosophy.
- 7:05So this is like Sun Tzu, Musashi, some Krishnamurti.
- 7:11I was very into those philosophers.
- 7:13Those are Indian and Asian. But then in Conversations,
- 7:18obviously, Jordan Peterson was a big inspiration for me even to
- 7:21start the podcast. Through Jordan Peterson, I
- 7:24discovered the work of the likes of John Vervecki.
- 7:28He was a colleague of Jordan Peterson's at University of
- 7:31Toronto. Vervecki's been on the show a
- 7:33couple of times. He has an amazing podcast.
- 7:37Through John Vervecki I discovered the author DC
- 7:39Schindler, who wrote this book, Plato's Critique of Impure
- 7:43Reason. And it's just so damn good.
- 7:47Like, I can't. It's one of those books you
- 7:48read. And like, I can't believe a
- 7:50human wrote this, but a lot of that philosophy, like it talks
- 7:56about how things are dramatic in nature.
- 8:00So there's not, you know, we use, we typically use words and
- 8:03think that, oh, the word is the thing, but there's really
- 8:07reality is more relational than that.
- 8:09So that's why there's always context and you know, you have
- 8:11to read between the lines and what we even need things like
- 8:15language and money, right, Because action is continuous and
- 8:19complex. It's not discreet and simple.
- 8:23And so I guess to sort of answer your question, in DC Schindler's
- 8:27books, he writes often, he's writing about the work of Plato,
- 8:32Socrates, You know, Socrates is like the, the main character of
- 8:36Plato's writing. Effectively, he's kind of like
- 8:38the archetypal philosopher. So he, like, embodies his
- 8:41philosophy. But one of the ideas and a lot
- 8:45of his writing is this the idea of a mediating third, that
- 8:49between any two poles there's always a mediating 3rd between
- 8:52them. And it's it's kind of complex to
- 8:55unravel. But I just thought that was so
- 8:57fascinating is like, you get you get to the bottom of Western
- 9:00philosophy and you find this notion of like the mediating 3rd
- 9:04and I can't help but think that of money in that way, right?
- 9:07Like money is structurally similar to that.
- 9:10And that's why I think you know the show.
- 9:14We end up talking a lot about language, a lot about
- 9:16definitions, actually. Socrates said the the beginning
- 9:20of wisdom is the definition of terms.
- 9:23Ian Rand said something like definitions of the guardians of
- 9:25rationality, something that that protects US against mental
- 9:30disintegration. So very easy to forget.
- 9:34This open source software that we're running called language is
- 9:38not the thing itself, not the actions and the phenomenon or
- 9:41the phenomena themselves. But we, we talk as if they are,
- 9:46but they're not. So we have to remember that, you
- 9:48know, we're always kind of like mapping this territory.
- 9:50So it gets very meta and complex that you're trying to talk about
- 9:54the mapping instrument, whether that be language or whether that
- 9:58be the language of value or human action, which we call
- 10:01money. And so I think that's for me,
- 10:03that's what's really fascinating and I think that's what a lot of
- 10:05people in the audience kind of seize on to.
- 10:08It's kind of a cerebral rabbit hole ish podcast.
- 10:13Yeah, I love that the IT is fascinating and surprising.
- 10:17It certainly was surprising to me that an exploration of what
- 10:21money is can cut so deeply into our understanding of the meaning
- 10:28of the universe. Frankly, it really is quite,
- 10:32quite incisive. I certainly wish I'd I'd read
- 10:36more philosophy up to this point.
- 10:39And so I'm gonna make it make an effort to to catch up a little
- 10:44bit with you in that regard. But I highly recommend the John
- 10:48Verveke episodes. I listened to both of them.
- 10:51I thought they were tremendous and highly recommend him to to
- 10:55watch or to listeners and and viewers for sure.
- 10:58He's one of the best. I love the joke that Jordan
- 11:01Peterson is a gateway drug to John Verveke.
- 11:03Well, if you think Peterson's good, then you're going to love
- 11:07Verveke. And I would argue, maybe I
- 11:11don't. Verveke for me, was a gateway
- 11:13drug to DC Schindler, and DC Schindler's been on Verveke's
- 11:17show. And I've read two of DC
- 11:18Schindler's books. The one I mentioned previously,
- 11:22Plato's Critique of Impure Reason, and then the one I read
- 11:25recently is The Perfection of Freedom.
- 11:29That's a good book, too, man. Excellent.
- 11:34If I could speak a little bit about that.
- 11:35So this is a little bit off the deep end and I might not go for.
- 11:40It. So you pick up that book, The
- 11:43Perfection of Freedom. I have no idea what I'm getting
- 11:45into. All right, it's a 500 page
- 11:46philosophy book on the nature of freedom.
- 11:49If I may spoil the ending. It's not a fiction book, it's
- 11:53it's non fiction philosophy. Towards the end of the book, DC
- 11:57Schindler, I guess, asserts that marriage actually is the
- 12:02ultimate form of human freedom. And now you might think that's
- 12:06quite paradoxical because marriage is, you know, you're,
- 12:11you're you're giving up your options, right?
- 12:13You're giving up your freedom to commit to one person, one family
- 12:16for life till death do you part. But the an argument that he
- 12:22makes there and again, I'm I'm not going to do this justice.
- 12:25You really got to read the book. It's one of those books I found
- 12:27myself highlighting more than half the book.
- 12:29Like, it's that good. His writing is so good.
- 12:32He says marriage enables 2 forms of transcendence.
- 12:36One is a vertical transcendence where two people become one in
- 12:40the sacred union of marriage. So unlike a contract, like a
- 12:44legal contract where you and I enter into it, you know, Andy's
- 12:48on one side, he's a counterparty, Robert's the other
- 12:51counterparty. We enter into a contract.
- 12:53On the other side of that contract, we're still Andy and
- 12:55Robert, but on the other side of the contract of marriage, you're
- 12:58no longer separate beings. You're literally one unit
- 13:02basically and it's until until death do you part.
- 13:05So he gets into that. It's like you're you get you
- 13:09gain this vertical transcendence where two people are basically
- 13:12becoming one and then it enables horizontal transcendence, which
- 13:17is well, you get to have kids, right.
- 13:19You have the container for children and be you know you can
- 13:23be fruitful and multiply, as you might say.
- 13:26So marriage ends up being this like choice that you're giving
- 13:32up one form of choice, but you're gaining this other thing,
- 13:37right? You gain this union one of
- 13:39another human and you gain this container to have children and,
- 13:42you know, build a meaningful life and all of that.
- 13:44And so I'm reading this and I was just thinking how private
- 13:49property and marriage or sort of maybe have a structural
- 13:52similarity because basically private property is, well, you
- 13:55are wedded, the owner is wedded to their assets in a way, right?
- 13:59Like it's a bond between owner and asset.
- 14:02Now it's not exactly like marriage because obviously it's
- 14:04you don't marry your car for life and you know, reproduce
- 14:08with it or whatever. But one thing, a vertical form
- 14:11of transcendence that private property enables is the pricing
- 14:14system. So that we all kind of merge our
- 14:17minds into one thing. And we can see, you know, the
- 14:21total supply and the total demand for any commodity in the
- 14:25world is just data compressed into this one market price.
- 14:29So you don't need to know anyone's story, anyone's
- 14:31business, anyone's P&L. You just see everything through
- 14:34the market price. And if it goes up and you're a
- 14:37consumer, then you're incentivized to consume less or
- 14:39use substitutes. If you're a producer and the
- 14:41price goes up, then you're incentivized to produce more.
- 14:44So the market price is how we're we're alleviating scarcity in
- 14:50the world frankly which what your guys show is all about And
- 14:53then the so that would be like the vertical form of
- 14:55transcendence that you you actually mind meld through the
- 14:59pricing system. And then the horizontal form of
- 15:02transcendence which is we get the multiplication of capital
- 15:05right, we get more quantity and quality of consumer goods,
- 15:09capital goods etcetera. So anyways, bit off the deep in
- 15:13there, but it's those like those types of things like what?
- 15:17In the world? Studying money.
- 15:19You end up reading a book about Western philosophy that tells
- 15:22you marriage is the ultimate form of freedom, and then you're
- 15:24drawing parallels to private property.
- 15:27These are the kinds of explorations that I've been
- 15:30having over the years, and it's a lot of fun.
- 15:34That's the multidisciplinary approach that I love that you
- 15:39take. Robert and my wife will be very
- 15:42happy to know you know you're so you're so pro marriage and
- 15:47believe that it enhances freedom.
- 15:50Love to love to hear that Jesse, you know, Jesse recently, more
- 15:55recently bit the bullet and has also been horizontally.
- 15:59I think he's going to horizontally expand as you put
- 16:03it. I think that's coming up for him
- 16:05relatively shortly. Yep, in a couple months.
- 16:07So we got that coming down the Pike and very excited about
- 16:12that. And yeah, it's it's very
- 16:14interesting to think about those themes with regard to money and
- 16:20regard to you know that that question of what is money and
- 16:23how you're pointing out it's about intermediaries too.
- 16:26Because, you know, in our relationships and our romantic
- 16:29relationships were floating around in the marketplace until
- 16:32we decide to to commit to a single a single counterparty as
- 16:40it were and and turn that into something else like a, a, a
- 16:45life. So you're right.
- 16:46It's, it's so funny that I think I guess you're kind of at the
- 16:50forefront of this of like recognizing that explorations of
- 16:53Bitcoin is really an exploration of money and an exploration of
- 16:57money is an exploration of the world and like human nature and
- 17:02the human experience because it is the ultimately the currency
- 17:05for how we value everything that's important to us.
- 17:08Bingo. So you're doing that more than
- 17:10anybody else, which is really awesome.
- 17:12Well, I mean, yeah, I I thank you.
- 17:15I think we're all it feels like bitcoin's going to suck everyone
- 17:18into that. It's just I've been kind of
- 17:21aggressively running at it because I'm already naturally
- 17:24curious person and Bitcoin has just been this bottomless rabbit
- 17:27hole to just plunge and plunge and plunge the other thing that
- 17:31came up to me. Is You and Gigi are near the
- 17:34bottom, but neither of you have found it, huh.
- 17:36Nobody will ever find it, I don't think, because of what you
- 17:39just said, actually, if money is the language of human action,
- 17:44and this is the title of Mises's famous book, obviously, And
- 17:47human action is basically everything.
- 17:51Literally everything, right? We don't have any perception or
- 17:54observation or experience that's not a human action.
- 17:56Because guess what, it's coming through your eyes, ears, nose.
- 17:59Like it's all human action in a way.
- 18:03And also, humans. Every market in the world exists
- 18:08to serve that market. Like we would not accumulate
- 18:11goods or capital if we were not going to be making a new
- 18:14generation. So I thought about that too,
- 18:17that all these markets, all the trade, the economy and
- 18:21everything, the real point of it is the people that come after
- 18:24us, right? The legacy we leave our
- 18:26children. Because if we didn't have, we
- 18:28didn't reproduce. Well, why would we economize?
- 18:30Why would we accumulate capital? Why would we build civilization?
- 18:33Because we'd all be gone in a generation.
- 18:36We just have one big party, right?
- 18:38Call it a day, but we do all of this economization, learning,
- 18:44knowledge transfer for the kids basically.
- 18:49And I mean it's somewhat obvious to say that, but it's kind of
- 18:52interesting to think about it through a a market perspective.
- 18:56Amen. It's all for the kids.
- 18:57That's why we're doing the Scarce Assets podcast here.
- 19:00It's all, it's all for the kids. I can certainly attest to the
- 19:05fact that learning about Bitcoin has made me think longer term
- 19:08and have a longer time preference, I have to say with
- 19:10respect to the informational element, you know in the in the
- 19:13price mechanism. I I always think of some chat
- 19:18that I saw on YouTube Winces Caesaris and he really focused
- 19:22on the on the measuring stick. I mean he really focused on the
- 19:25fact that Fiat money is this measuring stick that's been
- 19:29shifting and and moving on us. And I was really not prepared to
- 19:34comprehend at the time you know that that was maybe the most
- 19:37important element of it but it certainly has has weighed
- 19:42heavier on my mind. And and I'm I'm always brought
- 19:45back to that to to that moment in time when I, when I was
- 19:48exposed to the thing wasn't quite quite ready for it.
- 19:50Which of course is true about Bitcoin generally for people and
- 19:55and how and when they fall down the rabbit hole.
- 19:58But we all take our own journey and our our own unique path in
- 20:03getting there. I have a related question for
- 20:05you Robert. You may not have a an answer for
- 20:08it, but what percentage of of people do you think so?
- 20:11You know, the whole world is going to have to come to Bitcoin
- 20:14eventually in some capacity, but what percentage of people will
- 20:18really wrestle with what Bitcoin means versus just adopt it
- 20:24because it becomes money? Yeah, it's a great question that
- 20:29I don't have a good answer to. But I think we see, I mean I
- 20:35guess bit corners in the world today by definition are the
- 20:38early adopters, right? The 1st 100 million some odd
- 20:42people. And of that 100 million some odd
- 20:46people that have adopted Bitcoin, there are a small
- 20:49percentage that are really, really going down the rabbit
- 20:56hole are either right, like you mentioned, Gigi, writing about
- 20:58it a lot, these very profound essays or talking about it on
- 21:02podcast like this. I don't know.
- 21:04But but that alone it's exciting to me that Bitcoin can inspire
- 21:09that type of inquiry, that people.
- 21:13It's strange, isn't it? Just just engaging with a new
- 21:15technology somehow inspires you to ask fundamental questions and
- 21:21lower your time preference and think more about your legacy
- 21:25etcetera. It really calls into question
- 21:30how significant incentives are. You know what, Bitcoiners.
- 21:35We disagree about a lot of things, right?
- 21:37We're very disagreeable by nature.
- 21:39That's probably 1 common personality trait among
- 21:41bitcoiners. But I think one thing most, if
- 21:44not all bitcoiners would agree upon is that incentives really
- 21:48matter. Like, a lot.
- 21:50And maybe we just haven't taken that seriously enough up until
- 21:55now. I mean obviously we, you know,
- 21:58we use proverbial carrots and sticks to try and guide human
- 22:01behavior but we haven't taken things.
- 22:06Incentives may be seriously enough in at the institutional
- 22:09level, right. The fact that a central bank or
- 22:11Fiat currency exists is a testament to that.
- 22:16We're just we're playing with what is that one there's a quote
- 22:20the the problem with people is we have primeval emotions
- 22:25medieval institutions and God like technologies.
- 22:28So it's like we're just trying to we're playing with fire in a
- 22:32way, and we have to get burnt a few times before we learn how
- 22:35important certain things are. And I think Bitcoin is probably
- 22:39going to teach us that about money slash incentives that we
- 22:42really should have just let human self organize and choose
- 22:47the best tool for the job and don't not engage in all of this
- 22:50intervention and coercion to try and treat the market as if it's
- 22:54a machine, right? Pull this lever, lower interest
- 22:56rate, increase economy, blah blah, blah.
- 22:59It's like it's not a machine, guys.
- 23:00You have the wrong metaphor. It's a complex adaptive system.
- 23:04Central bankers cannot control the economy any better than
- 23:07meteorologists can control the weather.
- 23:09So hopefully Bitcoin helps shake that tree and and wake us up to
- 23:14that reality. That's it.
- 23:16We need to dismiss the the arrogance of yeah of of those
- 23:20who believe that they can deterministically manage this
- 23:24thing bringing in the the notion of kids and marriage and all
- 23:29that good stuff. I have a so I have a three-year
- 23:30old and I see her absolutely learning you know learning about
- 23:35the world touching the stove you know falling over hurting
- 23:40yourself. I think we do that as a species.
- 23:44I guess one of the virtues of childhood is that the the stakes
- 23:48are low in the sense that you're you're tiny, you don't control
- 23:51much, you don't have those you know those God like powers.
- 23:55Prometheus. You don't have the Prometheus
- 23:58situation where you've been handed fire, although certainly
- 24:01kids will find the fire if you let them.
- 24:04So you do have to keep the keep a lid on that in the household.
- 24:07But yeah it's at the at the level of a complex adaptive
- 24:12system like the whole economy or the world.
- 24:15Certainly the stakes are are much higher, and I personally
- 24:20have taken it to heart the incentives concept.
- 24:23You know, when when dealing with my kids, it doesn't.
- 24:25It doesn't always work. And I try to be deliberate about
- 24:29it. Sometimes I get, sometimes I get
- 24:32emotional about it and my my limbic system takes over.
- 24:36But I do. We all do our best, yeah.
- 24:40Well said. The other thing that comes up
- 24:45for me about Fiat, it seems like it's very much fear based.
- 24:51You know, obviously people are complying to define Fiat, you
- 24:55know, do this because I said so or else right, like do this
- 25:00under threat of force basically. And that's not something that we
- 25:06had historically like we take it for granted now if Congress
- 25:09signs a new bill into law and we all have to abide by that or
- 25:13else, you know, we get in trouble.
- 25:15But historically, it was much more like a legal discovery
- 25:17process. You know, like Moses observed
- 25:22everyone fighting amongst themselves for a long period of
- 25:24time and then finally he writes down like, OK, here's what you
- 25:26guys have been doing. Here are the rules.
- 25:29It's not like he sat down and just wrote the rules and said
- 25:31follow these or else there was a discovery process that took
- 25:34place. So people that are complying
- 25:38with Fiat, you know, do this or else are obviously doing it out
- 25:41of fear. But I think also the people that
- 25:44are imposing or benefiting from Fiat are doing it out of fear,
- 25:48right? The fear that if you just leave
- 25:51people free to their own devices, then there will be
- 25:53anarchy and chaos and there won't be an economy and there
- 25:56won't be any goods. It's kind of this circular logic
- 26:00of of socialism in a way. It's people are greedy and evil,
- 26:05so they need so they can't be trusted.
- 26:07So they need to be governed by people who are greedy and evil.
- 26:12You know like it's it's really crazy and I hope that by getting
- 26:18some Fiat out of the world, you know by Bitcoin emerging and and
- 26:23sort of clearing hopefully Fiat out of our money, Fiat out of
- 26:27our legal system to some extent that will you know get rid of
- 26:31fear. Not not entirely of course, it's
- 26:34part of life, but I think a lot of people operate from a very
- 26:37fear based paradigm today. And what is that Bob Marley
- 26:43quote when the when the power of love overcomes the love of
- 26:49power, the world with no peace, something like that.
- 26:52And Bitcoin has that kind of flavor to it.
- 26:54So yeah, I just hope we can help us.
- 26:57You're asking earlier about will everyone go down the Bitcoin
- 27:00rabbit hole? Probably not, right.
- 27:01There's going to be just a few people.
- 27:04But a few people can inspire a lot of people to stop leading a
- 27:08fear based life, even if they don't know why necessarily,
- 27:11right. Just a few courageous people
- 27:13setting an example, living out of love, etcetera.
- 27:15And I think you see that in a lot of bit corners, So I hope
- 27:18Bitcoin keeps pushing the world that way.
- 27:20And and and that goes back to your point about property
- 27:23rights. I mean, if you're living in fear
- 27:25about money, it's related to, if not primarily driven by a fear
- 27:33of like is my money mine? Am I going to get more dollars?
- 27:37The cost of everything is rising.
- 27:39How am I going to pay for my family?
- 27:41But if you shift to a a world where you have this guaranteed
- 27:45property right, because it's, you know, protected by math and
- 27:49nothing else, that shifts some of that psychology from a
- 27:55scarcity mindset of like, holy shit, how am I going to get, I
- 27:59need to get a raise because I need to keep up, and that's
- 28:03inherently fearful from that to, oh, my savings are going to grow
- 28:07in value. I'm doing pretty well.
- 28:09Exactly, exactly, yeah. And that, and we've all
- 28:14experienced, right? The lowering of your time
- 28:16preference. Almost equivalent to becoming a
- 28:19better person, right? Whatever.
- 28:21You know, Bitcoiners take a lot of different directions, but the
- 28:24commonality would be whatever, not whatever.
- 28:27But several bad things they had about themselves.
- 28:29Free Bitcoin. They start to address them post
- 28:32Bitcoin, whether that's you know, taking better physical
- 28:37care of yourself, going to church, drinking less, whatever
- 28:40it may be, saving more. Even just something as simple as
- 28:43that. And who?
- 28:46It's strange because you wouldn't think if Bitcoin
- 28:50weren't an actual thing happening, that would maybe be a
- 28:53difficult argument to sell. I mean, the Austrians have been
- 28:56making it for a long time, and not a lot of people have been
- 28:58listening, but now we see it, You know, you see people's lives
- 29:03actually changing and who knows how far that thing can go.
- 29:06And yeah, just the idea that your ability to own a thing is
- 29:12premised on other people's inability to take the thing from
- 29:15you. All right, this is very simple
- 29:19idea. But if the incentive is there
- 29:21and the opportunity is there to take it, you know, States and
- 29:26criminals have engaged in it for a long time.
- 29:28So it's almost like we needed an actual incentive or or
- 29:33technological solution to the ethical problem of of letting
- 29:37people keep what they earn. And Bitcoin, obviously, we've
- 29:40made advances along this front in many ways.
- 29:43You know the rule of law and you know English common law, things
- 29:47like that. But Bitcoin, private property,
- 29:52Bitcoins like an advancement of that idea, basically.
- 29:57But it but it's a tool plus an idea that moves us forward on
- 30:00that ethical continuum. So it's very it's fascinating.
- 30:05Yeah, it's it's got the technological element in
- 30:08addition with the sociological element and and the
- 30:12philosophical and it's and the politically scientific.
- 30:17I honestly, after studying this thing for a number of years, I
- 30:20sometimes wonder whether I could articulate it at all because
- 30:23it's so expansive and and and all-encompassing and touches
- 30:27everything, you know, getting back to the multidisciplinary
- 30:31approach with your thinking. One particular discipline is
- 30:37history of science, which touches on a few of these these
- 30:41topics. I'll say I never, I'll never
- 30:43forget taking a survey course in College in the history of
- 30:45science. And there was one professor who
- 30:48that was his specialty and unfortunately was a terrible,
- 30:50terrible class. And I think it turned me off.
- 30:53It turned me off to the discipline.
- 30:55And so it was refreshing to hear your great survey that you did
- 30:58with Michael Saylor, which launched the What is Money show.
- 31:02Have you returned to the to the History of Science concept
- 31:06recently? Does it kind of just, does it
- 31:08percolate in the back of your mind or had there been any
- 31:10recent touch points in that regard?
- 31:14You know, well yeah. First of all, the series of
- 31:17Sailor was remarkable. Remarkable.
- 31:21Agreed. I take little to no credit for
- 31:24that other than just pressing record, but the guy really
- 31:27brought it and definitely reframe my thinking about it.
- 31:32You know, I've been thinking about money as time.
- 31:33He brought in the whole energy element and then he tied in all
- 31:36this anthropology, history of technology, history of science.
- 31:40Obviously he's a great storyteller.
- 31:41It was really enjoyable, right? Almost like pushed me further
- 31:46into the rabbit hole on the history of science question.
- 31:52I am. I am very fascinated by it.
- 31:56But I've been mostly focusing in terms of science, scientific
- 32:02literature. It's been mostly economics
- 32:06focused, not entirely pre Bitcoin.
- 32:11I really liked physics and biology.
- 32:13I think they're very interesting, like the book The
- 32:17River out of Eden by Richard Dawkins.
- 32:19So I think I'm going to have on the show this year.
- 32:21Oh cool. Really impactful.
- 32:24Selfish Gene got me pretty good in college.
- 32:27Yeah, Selfish Gene is fantastic. There's a book called 7 Brief
- 32:35Lessons on Physics, I think by Carlo Carlo Ravelli.
- 32:39I hope I'm saying his name right.
- 32:40He also has like A History of Time, I think is one of his
- 32:43books. So I've always had an interest
- 32:47there. But since Bitcoin, because I
- 32:49didn't have Austrian economics prior to Bitcoin, I've been
- 32:53mostly focused on that. And people like, you know, Mises
- 32:56Rothbard, Hapa, just really, if you've ever read that stuff, you
- 33:02know, it's it's hard stuff to read, but it's really.
- 33:06Tough Mises is tough Mises is. Mises is dense.
- 33:09I I yeah it it's it's slow going.
- 33:12Repetition helps. Yes, yes.
- 33:15Repetition, backtracking. Take it easy, take it slow.
- 33:20I'm current. I just picked up A theory of
- 33:22money and credit, actually just starting that of his.
- 33:25But I read through Human Action twice and one of the points he
- 33:29makes, I think it's in Human Action that economics is the
- 33:33youngest science basically. So we're we're coming out of the
- 33:38economic dark ages, if you will. And Bitcoin is a huge piece of
- 33:42that because anywhere you have Fiat currency, which is
- 33:47everywhere, we have this very serious intervention into the
- 33:53market process, right. Like how does safety put this?
- 33:56You're almost you're going backwards.
- 33:58You're going towards barter and away from the division of Labor
- 34:01every time you, you have a a central bank or regional
- 34:04monopoly on money, right? It's you're not letting people
- 34:07exchange freely. So it's it's unwinding the
- 34:11global division of Labor, the global global civilization
- 34:14frankly raising time preference and so.
- 34:18Regressive. It's economically regressive,
- 34:20yeah. Exactly, exactly.
- 34:22And then it's interesting to think how much that plays on us
- 34:27psychologically, right? It's I think a lot of well,
- 34:31people's day-to-day decisions are economically driven, right.
- 34:36And anyone that has a full time job, I always find it funny that
- 34:39people have a full time job will say something like I don't care
- 34:42about money. It's like really why do you
- 34:45spend 40 hours out of every week doing something for money?
- 34:47Like don't it's, it's very serious.
- 34:52And you know, it's crazy to think that even what mid 1800s
- 34:57we thought that they were like particles in the universe called
- 35:00utils that gave things economic value.
- 35:03And then, you know, this pen had 65 utils in this jug of water,
- 35:08had 46 utils and that's what determine their value.
- 35:10So we're like, we're very fresh out of this economic ignorance,
- 35:16I think. And so there's a lot, there's a
- 35:19lot to be learned and that's I guess that's absorbing a lot of
- 35:25my attention. Just thinking about what what
- 35:26else are we going to figure out in economic science in the years
- 35:30ahead? Like, I have no idea, but it's
- 35:32fascinating to to think about. Thanks for tuning in.
- 35:36If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 35:38further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 35:41a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 35:45our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 35:48you on your Bitcoin journey. Yeah, I I I've been lately
- 35:52thinking a lot about the like the geocentric model of the
- 35:57solar system and the universe I guess.
- 36:00And and how in science there's so many examples like that of
- 36:05like like you know leeches and bloodletting or you know the
- 36:08four humours model of of medicine and things that we look
- 36:13back on is like oh that was dumb of.
- 36:16Course. It just took a little bit of
- 36:18inquiry, a little bit of really thinking and pushing the the
- 36:21ball forward before civilization woke up to, Oh yeah, there's
- 36:26actually like logic and some reasonable rules that you can,
- 36:31you know, infer by studying something.
- 36:34Here, With economics, we're still in that bloodletting era.
- 36:40Yes, that's, I mean the metaphor.
- 36:43Bloodletting to Fiat currency inflation are the analogy.
- 36:48It's more than it's very close, right?
- 36:51You're talking about actual you're draining people, their
- 36:54actual vitality and energy when you drain their blood.
- 36:57And it's the same thing you're doing when you print money,
- 37:00right? People have actual lifeblood,
- 37:02purchasing power, labor stored up in that money.
- 37:05When someone else is printing it, they're basically engaging
- 37:08in like an economic bloodletting, right?
- 37:10It's very similar. And I also think it's
- 37:14interesting that philosopher David Hume said you can't get an
- 37:18ought from an is all right. So he's saying you can't take a
- 37:23description of reality and then make a prescription about what
- 37:27you should do about it. This is the domain of ethics,
- 37:29basically, right? We kind of decide collectively
- 37:31what we should do about the reality.
- 37:33Objective quote, UN quote objective realities we face.
- 37:37But when you look at something like bloodletting, there's a
- 37:40reason we have medical ethics, all right?
- 37:43It's like that the is of bloodletting.
- 37:46It kills. It doesn't help people, let's
- 37:49say get better. I'm not not a doctor.
- 37:52I don't know, maybe there's some weird Internet conspiracies that
- 37:55it does. I'm not.
- 37:56I'm just assuming that it is actually bad for you.
- 37:59So we we decide that the is of bloodletting is not good for
- 38:02humans. So the ought is let's not do
- 38:04that to each other, right? Let's create a system of medical
- 38:07ethics and stop bloodletting, guys, to kind of advance the
- 38:12human enterprise. And so we need an equivalent of
- 38:17that in the sphere of money, right?
- 38:19We need monetary ethics. And that's sort of like what
- 38:22Bitcoin is. It's just the emergence of this
- 38:25money that you can't economically bloodlet, or it's
- 38:28much more difficult to do so at least.
- 38:31And yeah, it's not enough like that.
- 38:34We all just kind of get in a big circle and say, let's not print
- 38:37money anymore. We've actually tried that.
- 38:39I can't remember. It was, it was it.
- 38:42There was a law passed in Britain.
- 38:45Fuck. This is on the Twilight of Gold
- 38:47series, probably in the 1600s, where they said this is the
- 38:50final money supply. We're never going to print money
- 38:52again. Fix money supply.
- 38:53Here we go. Everyone just trade and create
- 38:56value. We're never printing money
- 38:57again. And like six months later
- 38:59they're printing money, you know?
- 39:01So, like, we don't have the capacity as humans to make that
- 39:04to to tie ourselves to that mast and not do it.
- 39:08So we had to invent Bitcoin to prevent ourselves from
- 39:13economically bloodletting one another.
- 39:15The the siren song is too strong.
- 39:18We just we just can't help help ourselves, you know, Talk about
- 39:22the bloodletting. I'm reminded of Semmelweis the
- 39:27the Doctor Who figured out that, you know, I think it was microbe
- 39:32theory, germ theory, but specifically that it was very
- 39:35important. The doctors washed their hands
- 39:39right and purified themselves before treating their patients.
- 39:46Delivering babies for. Example.
- 39:48Yeah, exactly. Before delivering babies, the
- 39:50next generation. And nobody believed him, right?
- 39:54They. Attacked him.
- 39:55They attacked him. Yeah.
- 39:57They really said you were like the establishment.
- 39:59Attacked this guy, you know, threat.
- 40:01It was crazy. It's crazy, right?
- 40:02It's crazy. We look at that today.
- 40:03Like, are you kidding me? It's wild.
- 40:06It's wild And so it makes me think about, you know, this so
- 40:10far peaceful learning and adoption process for Bitcoin,
- 40:16the world's most scarce asset. I'm sure this is something
- 40:20you've thought about you know the possible path and and how
- 40:23this could go. It seems to be going pretty well
- 40:26so far, I would say. What are what are your thoughts
- 40:30about, you know, potential reactionary forces?
- 40:35Does this occupy a lot of your time thinking about it, or you
- 40:38do you just take it as it comes? Well, yeah.
- 40:43So I guess the the question is like what if Bitcoin does
- 40:46continue to monetize and eventually become a globe the OR
- 40:51a global monetary standard, How rocky is that transition, right?
- 40:56Will there be retaliation by the state or or what have you?
- 41:02I really have no idea. Like my it does seem to be going
- 41:05really well so far. By the way, that's a great
- 41:07point. And my view on it is that, you
- 41:14know, ultimately society is comprised of acting individuals.
- 41:17Again, it's one of these abstractions.
- 41:19We're always like, oh, what is the state going to do?
- 41:22But the state is comprised of a bunch of individuals, right?
- 41:25A bunch of individual people that are assembled into
- 41:28individual little power factions and they're all competing with
- 41:32one another, serving their own individual self-interest.
- 41:36So I've long, I don't know if it's wishful thinking or not,
- 41:41but I just thought that well, the cost of acquiring Bitcoin
- 41:48and insulating yourself or insuring yourself against its
- 41:50possible success is so low, you just buy the thing when the cost
- 41:57of attacking it is so high. It's like, how do you, you know,
- 42:01you? This is a weird paradox.
- 42:04So Bitcoin solved the Byzantine Generals problem, right?
- 42:10Which is, how do you propagate a message through a network of
- 42:15antagonistic actors in a way that the message gets through
- 42:20unchanged or undistorted, right? Passing a message with high
- 42:25fidelity through a bunch of people you can't trust.
- 42:28Basically, we didn't know how to do that prior to Bitcoin.
- 42:33Now, to attack Bitcoin, the state would need to solve the
- 42:36Byzantine Generals problem, right?
- 42:40You need coordination among states who are inherently
- 42:43distrustful of one another to really take a good shot at
- 42:47Bitcoin, right. You would need China and Russia
- 42:49and United States, etcetera to collaborate and really squash
- 42:53it. But as that collaboration, if
- 42:58that were to come together, the incentives to defect from that
- 43:01would get higher, right, If ever.
- 43:04If you did get that collaboration going on, all of a
- 43:06sudden China's like, well, if we just support it and mine it,
- 43:09then we could undercut all of these guys and make a ton of
- 43:12money, you know, blah blah, blah.
- 43:13So I've I've long thought that Bitcoin it's so asymmetrically
- 43:19advantageous for the individual that it was just going to
- 43:21dissolve centralized power structures over time that P
- 43:25individual group people and then individual groups would just
- 43:27hold this thing even if they hate it right?
- 43:31That the central bank like we hate this thing but we need to
- 43:35own put 1% of our assets in it in case it succeeds.
- 43:39Because if it succeeds it's an existential threat for our
- 43:41entire business. And so Central Bank A does that,
- 43:45They put 1% N will Central Bank BC and D say, oh, Central Bank A
- 43:49did that. We now need to put 1% in.
- 43:52And every time you put you know 1% in of, and I'm, I'm picking
- 43:55on central banks here, pick your large capital holder.
- 44:01Doesn't matter what institution it is.
- 44:03Every time someone puts purchasing power into this thing
- 44:05or buys some of it, they're actually increasing its odds for
- 44:08success. So the game theory just kind of
- 44:11ratchets up, right? Each time someone puts it in and
- 44:13they're like, well, now I need to evaluate the probability of
- 44:15its success a little bit higher and therefore put a little bit
- 44:18more of my assets to protect myself.
- 44:20And then the sequence goes on and on and on, and you get hyper
- 44:24bitcoinization. So I hope that's what happens.
- 44:28Might be wishful thinking. If you talk to someone like Eric
- 44:32Cason, he thinks we're all going to the gulags.
- 44:36So who knows? Useful to.
- 44:40Have useful to. Have a thought.
- 44:42So just to finish is like optionality, optionality,
- 44:45optionality. So Bitcoin's obviously a great
- 44:48form of optionality, but if you're concerned about the state
- 44:51level risk, diversify, right, get other passports, get other
- 44:55residencies, etcetera and and have backup plans.
- 45:00Yeah, that's great advice. Really well said.
- 45:04I agree with you. I think that one of my favorite
- 45:06things about Bitcoin is the bigger and bigger or higher and
- 45:10higher levels that it achieves and the larger and larger the
- 45:15capital bases as you just mentioned.
- 45:17So for every, you know, first, first it's a few cypherpunks
- 45:23playing around with it, then it's, you know, some parties
- 45:27that can't transact otherwise really need it.
- 45:30And there's these bigger, larger and larger pools of capital.
- 45:33And as you said, we're at the central bank stage at or maybe
- 45:36the sovereign government stage and and I love that there are
- 45:40certain large participants that can't even touch it until it
- 45:44gets big enough right for them to to dip their toe.
- 45:47So there's always a bigger and bigger buyer, a bigger and
- 45:51bigger pool of capital and feels like that's that's where we're
- 45:55finding ourselves these days at, you know a trillion plus market
- 45:59cap of Bitcoin and and there's still such tremendous upside to
- 46:06look forward to. It's well said.
- 46:08And the other component to that that's really important is that
- 46:12the more purchasing power that is stored in Bitcoin, the not
- 46:16only the more likely it is to succeed.
- 46:18Well, the more likely it is to succeed because it's harder to
- 46:21stop, right? The network becomes more secure
- 46:23as it grows. So you get this safe, that
- 46:28becomes harder to crack, the more treasure you have in it,
- 46:32basically. And that's crazy to think about.
- 46:35So I don't, you know it, anyone that's running that calculus
- 46:40honestly will just buy it. It's like, what what are you
- 46:42going to do to try to attack it? I don't know.
- 46:46So yeah, I think that's the way it will go.
- 46:49And then you just get states then are incentivized to deal
- 46:52with their citizens more honestly, right, Because people
- 46:57be able to move their capital more easily.
- 47:01States will have to explicitly tax people rather than print
- 47:04money. So it'll be less less of this
- 47:08surreptitious tax and more of this explicit tax and that
- 47:13people resist that right when they see the bill.
- 47:17The warrant. I was left siding the War on
- 47:18Terror as an as an example this was between 2001 and 2019 I
- 47:24think pre COVID the US printed $2.8 trillion and we spent 2.5
- 47:31trillion on the War on Terror which came out to something like
- 47:34$80,000 per US household. I might be off somewhere on
- 47:38these numbers slightly but it's in the in the if they didn't
- 47:41have the money printer and they sent each US household an
- 47:44$80,000 bill. How long do you think the war on
- 47:46Terra would have lasted? I don't think it would have made
- 47:50as far as it has. So which obviously gets into
- 47:53bitcoins whole value proposition as a peacemaking technology.
- 47:57So just stop guys. Just stop blowing each other up,
- 48:01stealing from people through money printing to go up and go
- 48:04and blow up other people and take their stuff.
- 48:05It's just we can't call ourselves rational or civilized
- 48:10animals until we stop these mass murder campaigns funded through
- 48:14money printing. And hopefully Bitcoin helps with
- 48:16that. Amen.
- 48:18One of my favorite stats about I can't remember, I think it was
- 48:21Afghanistan. It was either Afghanistan or
- 48:23Iraq was the pallets of cash that were literally lost in
- 48:29transit, right. They can't account for the IT
- 48:31was like a couple couple billion dollars worth, which ironically
- 48:35accounts for a very small percentage of the expenditure on
- 48:39those on those war efforts. As you said, trillions of
- 48:41dollars. But literally at that scale, you
- 48:45just physically lose money. Where does the money go?
- 48:48Who knows? Yeah.
- 48:50It's such a scam and it's a bit ironic that I guess I don't
- 48:57know. Most of the world maybe thinks
- 48:58Bitcoin's a scam. Still, I don't think that would
- 49:01be too much of A stretch to say more than half.
- 49:05Yet it's the only money that's absolutely not a scam.
- 49:09I mean, you guys could say physical gold, but it's just not
- 49:11practical for everyone to deal with physical gold.
- 49:14So that tipping point's coming, right?
- 49:16There's going to be a tipping point where more than half the
- 49:18world knows that Bitcoin is the only non scam money and that
- 49:24will be an interesting day. Speaking of the scam and the my
- 49:29personal view is that perhaps the single biggest reason that
- 49:33people view it that way still is, is the volatility in the you
- 49:36know, in the price or the purchasing power.
- 49:39I wonder you know, do you have any thoughts on that in general,
- 49:43I mean you know the three of us are probably comfortable with
- 49:46the fact that that's a shorter term phenomenon and the
- 49:49volatility in purchasing power has been reducing over time.
- 49:52But what do you what you know what, what thoughts do you have
- 49:55for people on getting comfortable with with that
- 49:59reality and how it's likely to play out?
- 50:02It's an excellent question. And yeah, it's so we again, if
- 50:09you don't think about what money is, then you don't realize that
- 50:14you're there's there's like a software integration into your
- 50:17mind, right. You're thinking about the world
- 50:20through dollars or in terms of dollars, right.
- 50:24And this people get so focused on the Bitcoin dollar price or,
- 50:28I'm sorry, the Bitcoin price expressed in dollars because,
- 50:32well, that's the global reserve currency.
- 50:36But you don't, I guess if you don't think about it critically,
- 50:40you'll fail to see that, well, anything can be priced in terms
- 50:43of anything, right? With money is just kind of the
- 50:44convenient common language we use.
- 50:48But you can really think about anything in terms of anything
- 50:50else. And that's what purchasing power
- 50:52is, right? You're flipping the ratio.
- 50:54Instead of saying, oh, that steak is $32, you're saying,
- 50:57well, how much steak does my unit of money buy me?
- 51:00Basically and so. A lot less than it used to, by
- 51:05the way. Yes, yeah.
- 51:07It is basically tripled in price since the pandemic started.
- 51:12The pandemic I haven't. Heard that before.
- 51:15As a frequent Beefeater, I keep a close eye on the beef price.
- 51:20So there's that. Just the whole denominator issue
- 51:26that people don't understand, you can denominate anything and
- 51:29anything, but then yeah, I guess the other piece is, it is market
- 51:36capitalization and volatility are inversely correlated, right.
- 51:41So the the bigger and more liquid an asset, the less
- 51:45volatility it's going to have in terms of both either price or
- 51:49purchasing power. It's not a deterministic law,
- 51:53but it's just what it tends to look like.
- 51:56And so, yeah, that's just not easy to communicate to people.
- 52:00Like, I've analogized, if you'd look at something like the
- 52:03Amazon stock, right, that I think Amazon crashed 94% in
- 52:07the.com bubble and then it grew, I don't know, 60,000 percent
- 52:12cents or whatever it is now. And what are the daily moves on
- 52:16Amazon now, right? It's it's much it's not 94%
- 52:20right. It's become much less volatile
- 52:22as it's grown larger and Bitcoin as you said is following a
- 52:25similar trajectory. But how do you explain that to
- 52:30people, man? It's hard.
- 52:34It's really hard. That's why.
- 52:35This is why I have 400 something episodes on what is money like.
- 52:39It's a very. It's a tricky topic and.
- 52:45Comfortable. With it, Yeah.
- 52:47I don't know if they get comfortable with it.
- 52:48I don't know. I mean, I guess you just have to
- 52:50get some skin in the game. Treat it like long term savings,
- 52:55dollar cost, average long term accumulation.
- 52:59If you're sensitive to the price and you probably own too much of
- 53:01it, right, you really shouldn't care about it that much, right?
- 53:05If you really intend to treat it like savings, the way savings is
- 53:08intended to be, well, savings is intended to be saved and only
- 53:12used in case of emergency sort of thing, or to build your
- 53:16dreams or something like that. But the more you're treating
- 53:19Bitcoin like checking, I think the more you're going to get
- 53:22shocked by the volatility, But the more you treat it like
- 53:25savings, the more you're buffered from that shock.
- 53:29So I hope that's helpful for people.
- 53:33Yeah, that's it. I know you've got some thoughts
- 53:34on on that. You've been you've been
- 53:36communicating that Jesse to to friends, colleagues, clients,
- 53:42family for a long time. How do you get how do you get
- 53:45him comfortable with the ball? Yeah, I I mean, Robert's right.
- 53:50It's it's it's kind of impossible.
- 53:52It's an impossible question. But it's like it's a journey
- 53:54that everybody has to go through.
- 53:56And I think going back to what Robert was saying of, you know,
- 54:01the the vast majority of people think that Bitcoin is the scam.
- 54:05But you know, once you go through the looking glass, then
- 54:09you have a totally different perspective and then you
- 54:11appreciate Bitcoin for what it is.
- 54:13And you realize that Bitcoin is the the one thing that is not a
- 54:15scam and everything on the other side of the looking class that
- 54:18was the scam. And so I think, I think that I
- 54:23mean you guys have probably experienced this too, that the
- 54:26people in my life that I have managed, the few, the few people
- 54:30in my life that I have managed to bring into Bitcoin, had to
- 54:36just take that leap, you know, had to dip a toe and then learn
- 54:39more and then increase their allocation until they got
- 54:42comfortable with Bitcoin on its own terms.
- 54:46And that's that's just an uncomfortable and hard process.
- 54:49And I, you know, that's part of me wondering how many people
- 54:53will do that. But the other reality is like,
- 54:56if people choose not to make that leap, Bitcoin will make the
- 55:00leap for them. Bitcoin is going to keep
- 55:02encroaching on all territory until you know you.
- 55:06Pretty soon everybody's four O 1K is going to include Bitcoin
- 55:09because they have micro strategy and S&P.
- 55:11Yeah, and and so it grows. That's it.
- 55:15That's it. Well, let's, yeah, let's
- 55:17continue to look to the future a little bit, Robert.
- 55:20If you think about allocating your time, which you understand
- 55:23better than anyone, is the truly scarce resource, do you imagine
- 55:29spending more of your time thinking about policy issues, or
- 55:32is that not so much of interest to you?
- 55:35Do you prefer the fundamentals to the to the layer to the human
- 55:39layer? To the very flawed human layer
- 55:41with all its busted incentives? Yeah, if I could respond to
- 55:49something, Jesse said. Then I will answer that
- 55:50question. The looking This is the thing
- 55:54about studying money like you're looking at the looking glass.
- 55:58John Vervecki actually has this great example where he's talking
- 56:01about human rationality. It's like whatever frame of
- 56:05reference you're using, it's almost implied and you you take
- 56:08it for granted. And he uses glasses like
- 56:11eyeglasses as an example. It's like you're looking through
- 56:15the lens and you're seeing the image as it appears to you
- 56:17through that lens. But how often do you take off
- 56:20the glasses and examine the actual glasses?
- 56:23Right. The frame of reference is
- 56:24implied. And this is the thing about
- 56:28studying money is like, you have to do that meta cognitive leap.
- 56:30It's like, wait, whoa, what am I thinking through that is causing
- 56:34my thoughts to be distorted in a certain way.
- 56:38And that's the whole unplug the dollar, you know, plug in the
- 56:40SAT's thing. And I I agree.
- 56:43Like, you can't, I don't know. It's one of those things you
- 56:46can't just read in a book and get it.
- 56:48You almost have to have some Bitcoin, basically.
- 56:53And I think everyone has some amount of money they can put
- 56:55into Bitcoin. Like whatever it is, I don't
- 56:57know, whatever amount of money you can stand to literally lose,
- 57:01right? It could be a dollar, whatever.
- 57:05But where your money goes, your mind will follow.
- 57:07Like once you have some of it, you'll just start paying more
- 57:09attention. You'll probably start listening
- 57:11to podcasts, maybe you'll read a book and you you should probably
- 57:17do that. I I don't like the word should,
- 57:20but I will say it here because again, and we're talking about
- 57:24again a dollar or whatever, the amount of money you can totally
- 57:26stand to lose is because if you don't Start learning about it,
- 57:31it's like you either take the orange pill or the orange
- 57:33Suppository as someone said, right.
- 57:34You can take it voluntarily now or involuntarily later.
- 57:39And it's. I don't know.
- 57:41It's. I think it's the most important
- 57:43question of our time, right. Like what is well what is
- 57:46Bitcoin? Bitcoin is money.
- 57:47Well what is money? You better start figuring it
- 57:49out. Otherwise you're going to be
- 57:50figuring it out under duress soon.
- 57:53So on the question of policy issues, it bores me.
- 58:01Frankly, it bores me. Suppositories Not an interest,
- 58:06not a topic of interest for you. It's just, I don't know.
- 58:09I went on a few of these podcasts where, you know, people
- 58:13can be very. It seems to me like a lot of
- 58:15people really love being political, right?
- 58:17They love, and this is part of the state's game, by the way,
- 58:21right, that you can rotate in this politician, put Biden in
- 58:24there and everyone's directing all that animosity at him.
- 58:27And then you just pull out that puppet, put in another 1-8 years
- 58:31later and they direct all the animosity at him.
- 58:33But it's like you never get any systemic change because
- 58:36everyone's animosity is pointed at an individual.
- 58:39And it's like, has anyone ever thought that maybe, you know,
- 58:42one ape to rule 330 million apes is just bad math?
- 58:45Like we should just systemically doesn't work.
- 58:48You can be mad at Trump, or mad at Biden or mad at whoever, but
- 58:51it's just never going to work, frankly.
- 58:53So that's why we're politics in the Fiat world we're currently
- 58:58in really bores me. Now back to DC Schindler.
- 59:01I am reading some of his book now about the traditional sense
- 59:06of politics, right? Is like the the distributed
- 59:10ethics. Like the if the marketplace is
- 59:13distributed cognition politics is supposed to be like
- 59:15distributed ethics. Like we were saying like how do
- 59:18we ethically Orient ourselves towards the good collectively.
- 59:22There's a lot of dangerous socialist words in here, as you
- 59:24may have noticed. But I that's intriguing to me,
- 59:27but I don't know much about it. I'm just learning.
- 59:31But the idea of like going to Washington or like trying to
- 59:36campaign for money and go fight that leviathan in in the belly
- 59:39just sounds horrible to me. Much more interested in being a
- 59:45student and being an entrepreneur.
- 59:49Yeah, that's probably probably time better spent for you.
- 59:53So on the entrepreneurial front, is there anything you know that
- 59:56is of interest that you want to talk about with us today?
- 1:00:00Well, the show is my main focus and I may have some other
- 1:00:08interests coming up, but the show has been really my main
- 1:00:14focus the past three years and there's a lot to it.
- 1:00:19Actually, it doesn't. I mean, well, you guys know,
- 1:00:23setting up a studio here. I just moved to Miami, so I'm
- 1:00:25setting up a studio here in my home.
- 1:00:27So I'm trying to do a lot more interviews in person, and
- 1:00:32there's just a lot of moving pieces.
- 1:00:33So I hope to get that really dialed in and then maybe I'll
- 1:00:37have more to say on the entrepreneurial front after
- 1:00:39that. Well, as a fan of the show, I
- 1:00:42can attest that it shows in terms of the the input to the
- 1:00:46output. It's definitely, it's definitely
- 1:00:48on the must listen category and people should understand.
- 1:00:52I mean obviously it's like it's like with buying Bitcoin, like,
- 1:00:55you know, just go try it if you haven't already.
- 1:00:57Although I suspect a large percentage of our audience will
- 1:01:00already be involved but but it does touch so many aspects it's
- 1:01:05it's much broader I would say than than almost any other
- 1:01:09Bitcoin related show out there. So highly recommend highly
- 1:01:15recommend. Well, you've been you've been
- 1:01:19very generous with your time. Robert want to give you an
- 1:01:22opportunity though, to touch on any topics that we haven't
- 1:01:26covered up to this point. You know, including in addition
- 1:01:30to the What is Money? Show you know where else can
- 1:01:32people learn more about your thoughts and find you?
- 1:01:35Sure. Well, I had a little thing I
- 1:01:39wanted to say about scarcity since this is the title of your
- 1:01:42guys podcast. Please, please do.
- 1:01:43Let's do it. So, you know, what do we think
- 1:01:48here? Most people, I guess when you
- 1:01:49use that word, scarcity, I think most people think that it's just
- 1:01:54a supply thing, right? Like, there's just not enough of
- 1:01:56the thing, which is sort of true in a sense, but in a in a strict
- 1:02:02economic sense, scarce scarcity is not purely a function of
- 1:02:07supply, right? There's well, it's wherever
- 1:02:10demand exceeds supply. And so it's also not necessarily
- 1:02:16related to value or significance, because if you're
- 1:02:20talking about something like oxygen, right, that's very
- 1:02:23important, very essential to human life.
- 1:02:26But it's so super abundant that the supply exceeds the demand.
- 1:02:30We don't have a price for it, right.
- 1:02:32We don't have to ration it. The supply so far out sees it
- 1:02:35exceeds the demand, it's not scarce, whereas something
- 1:02:40unessential like the Mona Lisa painting, right, can have an
- 1:02:43extremely high price because well, there's only one, but
- 1:02:46there's a lot of demand. So I think that's just an, I
- 1:02:53don't know if you guys would agree with that, but like seems
- 1:02:55like most people think it's just a supply thing, but it's not,
- 1:02:57it's supply and demand and then we often and Andy you know I've
- 1:03:01talked about this a lot in your book.
- 1:03:04I think you have 14 properties of money, was that right?
- 1:03:07That's it. That's it.
- 1:03:08I wish there were fewer. I wish there were less of them.
- 1:03:10Well, I, I narrow it down to five, right, to try and make it
- 1:03:13and this is, I'm lifting this from Gary North.
- 1:03:17And one of them, you know is divisibility, durability,
- 1:03:20recognizability, portability and the last one's scarcity.
- 1:03:24So you might ask yourself like what?
- 1:03:25Why if scarcity is And by the way, I should have should have
- 1:03:30said this earlier, scarcity is the starting point of all
- 1:03:32economics, right. It's the point of all economics.
- 1:03:35It's let's collaborate so that we can create more supply per
- 1:03:39unit of effort to satisfy all that demand anywhere demand
- 1:03:43exceeds supply and The thing is scarce, right.
- 1:03:46So we're creating more stuff, more solutions to problems,
- 1:03:49whether this be goods, services, etcetera.
- 1:03:53So you might think, well, if scarcity is what we're trying to
- 1:03:57overcome in economics, why is scarcity a a good property of
- 1:04:01money? It's almost like a counter
- 1:04:02intuitive thing and maybe it's a bad word.
- 1:04:07It's like a lot of people have argued that like you don't need,
- 1:04:09it's just a bad word, it's confusing people.
- 1:04:11You could go with something like supply integrity or
- 1:04:14predictability perhaps. But the way I like to think
- 1:04:19about it is and and safety goes into this in his book, right?
- 1:04:24Like ultimately and you said this earlier, it's all a
- 1:04:27function of human time. Ultimately that's the only thing
- 1:04:29that's actually practically scarce.
- 1:04:32Like if we point enough human time at anything, we can get
- 1:04:34more of the thing right to satisfy maybe not all the demand
- 1:04:38but a lot of it. And so really it's it's our time
- 1:04:42that's scarce. And so if money is this and
- 1:04:47obviously all goods and services require time to produce, so
- 1:04:51therefore goods and services are scarce by extension.
- 1:04:54So if money is this tool we use to acquire goods and services,
- 1:05:00and goods and services are scarce, you might be able.
- 1:05:04If you follow that line of reasoning, you might be able to
- 1:05:07intuitively grasp why non scarce money would be a problem because
- 1:05:12you have the money that represents something that is
- 1:05:15scarce. But if it's if it itself is not
- 1:05:18scarce and someone can just artificially expand the supply,
- 1:05:22then they can use that to steal the actually scarce stuff from
- 1:05:27the people that can't print the money.
- 1:05:31So. So it's kind of a maybe it's
- 1:05:33confusing people more. You can just dispense with this
- 1:05:35whole argument if it is, but it for me it it was kind of
- 1:05:38intuitive in a way. It's like, and Jeff Booth sums
- 1:05:41us up, right, if you have scarce money, you have abundant goods.
- 1:05:43If you have abundant money, you have scarce goods.
- 1:05:45Basically you need, we need something that represents the
- 1:05:49scarcity of human time. That's, you know, if you
- 1:05:51consider money to be a tool for trading human time, you need
- 1:05:54something that reflects that scarcity.
- 1:05:57And This is why Bitcoin is so perfect.
- 1:06:00I mean, I think I'll use that word perfect, right?
- 1:06:02It's absolutely scarce, right? It has a perfectly fixed supply,
- 1:06:07just like your lifetime, just like the human time.
- 1:06:10That money is intended to be an emblem for, and so you know,
- 1:06:17scarce assets. Podcast good name might be scary
- 1:06:21for some people, but scarcity is a very important topic and if
- 1:06:26you get your cognitive grip on that, I think you'll get a
- 1:06:30cognitive grip on on at least to some extent, on Bitcoin.
- 1:06:34And hopefully that's really useful in your life and in your
- 1:06:37family's life and your future family's life, etcetera.
- 1:06:42I love that. I love that insight, Robert.
- 1:06:45Sorry. Go ahead.
- 1:06:46I cut you off, Jesse. No, no, that was it.
- 1:06:48That's why I spiel on scarcity. I wanted to bring that one to
- 1:06:50your guys show and see you fitting.
- 1:06:52It's it's perfect. You encapsulated it.
- 1:06:56It's exactly, that's the whole story.
- 1:06:57The whole story of Bitcoin is that, you know for all of our
- 1:07:00lives we've had a form of money that is incompatible with what
- 1:07:05it represents. And and now Bitcoin is like to
- 1:07:09like with what it is intended to value, which is our time
- 1:07:14ultimately. And you know, and that kind of
- 1:07:17ties it back to the through the looking glass analogy of like
- 1:07:22everybody's been living in bizarro world thinking that
- 1:07:26infinite Ponzi units are a fair representation, a fair measuring
- 1:07:32stick for how we value our our finite time.
- 1:07:38And now you go through the looking glass and you have a
- 1:07:43different perspective that is more in tune with, you know, the
- 1:07:46the alignment of those two things.
- 1:07:49It's very well said and here, welcome to the Bitcoin rabbit
- 1:07:53hole. Right is radical and you could
- 1:07:56in many way. I I think Bitcoin is basically
- 1:07:59the invention of money, right? Or at least the invention of
- 1:08:01pure money. We've never had anything that's
- 1:08:04100% monetary premium. It has no other use case, right?
- 1:08:07Yeah, gold has other uses. Everything has other uses but
- 1:08:11the. Invention of the #0 the
- 1:08:13invention of money. It's the same thing.
- 1:08:15Exactly. So.
- 1:08:16It's a singular, idiosyncratic event, right?
- 1:08:19It's never going to happen again, It's not repeatable.
- 1:08:22And all this sounds ridiculous. Maybe at first blush, but I
- 1:08:26don't know. Welcome to the rabbit hole.
- 1:08:27Come disprove it. That's it.
- 1:08:30Well, Robert, I really want to thank you for sharing or
- 1:08:35spending some of your scarce time with us.
- 1:08:38It's been a pleasure falling down the rabbit hole, learning
- 1:08:41from you, with you and from you about Bitcoin over these many
- 1:08:45years. I hope we have a chance to do it
- 1:08:48again with you. And yeah, on behalf of our
- 1:08:52audience, this has been scarce assets.
- 1:08:55Thanks guys.